63
The LoneStar Project This project was supported by Grant No. 2014-MU-CX-0111 awarded by the National Institute of Justice, Office of Justice Programs, U.S. Department of Justice, and was made possible with the assistance of the Texas Department of Criminal Justice. Opinions, findings, and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this publication are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect those of the U.S. Department of Justice or the Texas Department of Criminal Justice. What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the LoneStar Project David C. Pyrooz, Ph.D. Department of Sociology Institute of Behavioral Science University of Colorado Boulder A Presentation to the UTEP Center for Law & Human Behavior Email: [email protected] Phone: (303) 492-3241 Twitter: @dpyrooz

What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

The LoneStar Project

This project was supported by Grant No. 2014-MU-CX-0111 awarded by the National Institute of Justice, Office of Justice Programs, U.S. Department of Justice,and was made possible with the assistance of the Texas Department of Criminal Justice. Opinions, findings, and conclusions or recommendations expressed inthis publication are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect those of the U.S. Department of Justice or the Texas Department of Criminal Justice.

What have we learned about prison gangs?Findings from the LoneStar Project

David C. Pyrooz, Ph.D.Department of Sociology

Institute of Behavioral ScienceUniversity of Colorado Boulder

A Presentation to the UTEP Center for Law & Human Behavior

Email: [email protected]: (303) 492-3241

Twitter: @dpyrooz

Page 2: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

The LoneStar Project

SCHEDULEUnderstanding prison gangs

1. The problem of prison gangs

2. The LoneStar Project

3. Characteristics of prison gangs/gang members

4. Power and control on the inside

5. Q & A

Responding to gangs

1. Joining/leaving in prison

2. Criminal and gang recidivism

3. Renouncement and disassociation

4. Policy/program implications

5. Q & A

Page 3: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

The problem of prison gangs

Page 4: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics
Page 5: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics
Page 6: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics
Page 7: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics
Page 8: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

Camp & Camp

(1985)

3% N=23

Wells et al.

(2002)

10% N=39

Hill

(2009)

12%, N=38

Winterdyk & Ruddell

(2010)

19% N=37

NGIC

(2011)

15% N=N/A

Pyrooz & Mitchell

(2018)

15% N=38

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

1984 2002 2008 2009 2011 2016

% o

f P

riso

n P

op

ula

tion

, G

an

g A

ffil

iate

d

Page 9: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

The LoneStar Project

SOME INCONCLUSIVE “FACTS”

• Misconduct, particularly violence

• Orchestration of riots and uprisings

• The control and distribution of contraband

• At the core of the prison social order

• Symbiosis between prison and street gangs

• Consequences for inmate recidivism

Page 10: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

The LoneStar Project

Individuals, Groups, and Inference

0

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

6000

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

1900 1923 1930 1946 1951 1956 1961 1966 1971 1976 1981 1986 1991 1996 2001 2006 2011

Nu

mb

er o

f P

ub

lica

tio

ns

Years

Total

Yearly

Research on Gangs (through 2014)

Source: Pyrooz and Mitchell (2015)

Page 11: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

The LoneStar Project

CHALLENGES OF PRISON GANG RESEARCH

Robert Fong and Salvador Buentello (1991)

• Official documentation on gangs is underdeveloped

• Prison administration is reluctant to grant access to researchers

• Gangs are secretive and prohibit the sharing of information

Page 12: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

The LoneStar Project

Page 13: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

The LoneStar Project

WHAT IS THE LONESTAR PROJECT?

• National Institute of Justice • Research on Gangs and Gang Violence FY14

• “Gangs on the Street, Gangs in Prison: Their Nature, Interrelationship, Control and Reentry”

Texas Study of Trajectories, Associations, and Reentry

Page 14: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

The LoneStar Project

Page 15: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

The LoneStar Project

Texas, Prisons, and Gangs

Page 16: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

The LoneStar Project

Baseline Wave 2 Wave 3

• Start: 4/18/2016

• End: 12/10/2016

• Retention: ---

• Constructs: 62

• Items: 1,190

• Start: 5/30/2016

• End: 5/9/2017

• Retention: 66.3%

• Constructs: 51

• Items: 1,126/1,508

• Start: 2/7/2017

• End: 2/26/2018

• Retention: 64.2%

• Constructs: 52

• Items: 1,180/1,552

THE LONESTAR PROJECT

16

Population:

Huntsville Unit

N=15,644

Sample:

Huntsville & Estelle Units

n=802

Disproportionate random sampling

Population:

Gang: 1,596 (10.2%);

Non-Gang: 14,048 (89.8%)

Response rate: 61%

Participation rate: 94%

Sample:

Gang: 368 (45.9%);

Non-Gang: 434 (54.1%)

Page 17: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

Legend

Number of Respondents

Houston (n = 91)

Dallas (n = 171) San Antonio (n = 71)

Page 18: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

82.5%

N=660

17.5%

N=140

35.8%

N=286

46.8%

N=374

10.0%

N=807.5%

N=60

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

Concordance Discordance Admin (yes),

Survey (yes)

Admin (no),

Survey (no)

Admin (yes),

Survey (no)

Admin (no),

Survey (yes)

Page 19: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

The Characteristics of Prison Gangs and Gang

Members

Page 20: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

The LoneStar Project

Gang Members and Gangs in the LoneStar Project

20

Persons (N=441) Person-Gangs (N*G=477)

1. Tangos – all (5 sets) members:

2. Crips – all (4 sets):

3. Bloods – all (4 sets):

4. Aryan Brotherhood:

5. Mexican Mafia:

6. Aryan Circle:

7. Texas Syndicate:

8. Gangster Disciples:

9. Peckerwood:

10. Barrio Azteca:

11. Texas Chicano Brotherhood:

12. La Raza Unida:

13. Hermanos Pistoleros Latinos:

14. Surenos – all (2 sets):

15. Black Disciples:

16. - 8 gangs>1 N-G

G=34 gangs, N*G (>1 NG) =

+ 36 gangs = 1 N-G

109

66

57

34

25

16

18

11

10

9

8

7

5

5

3

36

405

441

1. Tangos – all (5 sets) members:

2. Crips – all (4 sets):

3. Bloods – all (4 sets):

4. Aryan Brotherhood:

5. Mexican Mafia:

6. Aryan Circle:

7. Texas Syndicate:

8. Gangster Disciples:

9. Peckerwood:

10. Barrio Azteca:

11. Texas Chicano Brotherhood:

12. La Raza Unida:

13. Hermanos Pistoleros Latinos:

14. Surenos – all (2 sets):

15. Black Disciples:

16. - 13 gangs>1 N-G

G=39 gangs, N*G (>1 NG) =

+ 33 gangs = 1 N-G

111

70

59

34

25

17

18

12

10

9

8

7

5

10

3

36

434

477

Page 21: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

DIFFERENCES SIMILARITIESNon-Gang, (N=454)

Mean/% (SD)Gang, (N=346)Mean/% (SD)

Non-Gang, (N=454)Mean/% (SD)

Gang, (N=346)Mean/% (SD)

Demographic/IndividualAge in years 41.64 (10.40) 34.55 (13.67) * Black 28.7% 21.3%Latino 27.8% 41.3% * Married 13.9% 14.8%White 35.7% 22.4% * In a relationship 15.6% 19.0%Education 11.74 (1.65) 10.95 (2.27) * Single 70.6% 66.2%

Low self-control 1.33 (0.63) 1.56 (1.11) * Father 67.6% 72.1%Military veteran 10.9% 5.5%IQ 93.33 (10.88) 91.96 17.71)

EnvironmentalInformal social control 2.90 (0.79) 2.55 (1.45) * Prison social control 1.79 (0.78) 1.71 (1.26)Good place to live 74.8% 63.2% * Unstructured routines 2.24 (3.40) 2.36 (5.17)Gangs in neighborhood 44.8% 73.4% *Disorder in the prison 7.32 (1.87) 8.66 (2.57) *

HealthStress 0.80 (0.49) 0.96 (0.84) * BMI 27.69 (4.40) 27.66 (8.01)Self-rated health 2.01 (0.70) 2.23 (1.16) * Self-esteem 2.13 (0.44) 2.09 (0.80)Exposure to violence 1.60 (0.87) 2.26 (1.39) * Projected age of death 86.21 (15.85) 87.52 (32.03)

Social ConnectionsEmbeddedness in gangs -0.44 (0.54) 0.73 (1.59) * Social distance 1.03 (0.42) 1.09 (0.72)

Family social support 2.36 (0.65) 2.50 (1.02) * Friend social support 1.86 (0.79) 1.87 (1.34)Criminal peers 0.65 (0.59) 0.97 (1.17) *

Attitudes and BeliefsCode of the street 1.88 (0.70) 2.42 (1.14) * Ethnic ID—cultural 3.07 (0.49) 3.20 (0.86)Convict code 2.47 (0.48) 2.80 (0.78) * Spirituality/religiosity 3.07 (0.78) 2.93 (1.27)Legitimacy 1.59 (0.43) 1.37 (0.74) *Procedural justice 1.14 (0.50) 0.99 (0.77) *Ethnic ID—social 3.18 (0.53) 3.01 (1.13) *

Criminal Justice SystemAge at first arrest 21.05 (6.87) 18.09 (8.73) * Number of arrests 8.47 (5.04) 9.08 (8.53)

Prison stints 1.87 (1.08) 1.73 (1.43)Years incarcerated 4.33 (4.63) 4.78 (7.31)Violent offender 38.4% 43.7%

Page 22: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

2%

6%

9%

21%

25%26%

35%

54%

48%

64%

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

Group 1:

2-8 RFs

(N=97)

Group 2:

9-10 RFs

(N=87)

Group 3:

11-12 RFs

(N=124)

Group 4:

13 RFs

(N=79)

Group 5:

14 RFs

(N=87)

Group 6:

15 RFs

(N=71)

Group 7:

16 RFs

(N=74)

Group 8:

17 RFs

(N=54)

Group 9:

18 RFs

(N=49)

Group 10:

19-23 RFs

(N=80)

% G

an

g-I

nv

olv

ed i

n P

riso

n

RFs=Number of Risk Factors

Page 23: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

The LoneStar Project 23

Prison Gang Street Gang

Race/ethnicity Single race or ethnicity Mostly single race or ethnicity

Age Concentrated in mid-20s, with members 30s-40s Average age in upper teens

Organizational Structure Hierarchical Situational/Hierarchical

Sources of violence Symbolic and instrumental; Core activitySymbolic;

Core activity

Offending style Entrepreneurial Cafeteria style

Visibility of Behavior Covert Overt

Drug traffickingMajor activity;

Organized, collective

Varies;

Mostly individualistic

Loyalty to gang Absolute Weak bonds

Key to membershipUnqualified fidelity; Abide by gang rules;

Willingness to engage in violence

Real or perceived fidelity; Abide by street rules;

Hanging out

Key psychological attributes Oppositional to Correctional Authorities;

Intimidation; Control; Manipulation

Oppositional to authority; Intimidation;

Camaraderie

Page 24: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

The LoneStar Project 24

Street

only

Prison

only

Street/

PrisonTotal

Any

Street

Any

Prison

f f f f % %

STG: admin. segregated

Aryan Brotherhood 0 0 34 34 100% 100%

Aryan Circle 0 0 17 17 100% 100%

Barrio Azteca 0 0 9 9 100% 100%

Hermanos Pistoleros Latinos 0 0 5 5 100% 100%

Mexican Mafia 0 0 25 25 100% 100%

Raza Unida 0 0 7 7 100% 100%

Texas Syndicate 0 2 16 18 89% 100%

Gang Type Total 0 2 113 115 98% 100%

STG: no admin. segregated

Bloods (all) 7 0 52 59 100% 88%

Crips (all) 6 0 64 70 100% 91%

Partido Revolucionario Mex. 0 1 3 4 75% 100%

Texas Chicano Brotherhood 0 0 8 8 100% 100%

Texas Mafia 0 1 3 4 75% 100%

Gang Type Total 13 2 130 145 99% 91%

Street

only

Prison

only

Street/

PrisonTotal

Any

Street

Any

Prison

f f f f % %

Prison-oriented

Mandingo Warriors 0 2 0 2 0% 100%

Mexicles 0 2 2 4 50% 100%

Peckerwood 0 6 4 10 40% 100%

Tangos 1 63 47 111 43% 99%

Single-rep. gangs 0 2 0 2 0% 100%

Gang Type Total 1 75 53 129 42% 99%

Street-oriented

18th street – other 4 0 1 5 100% 20%

Aryan Nation 0 0 2 2 100% 100%

Bad Boys 2 0 0 2 100% 0%

Black Disciples 0 0 3 3 100% 100%

Black Widows 2 0 0 2 100% 0%

Gangster Disciples 2 0 10 12 100% 83%

Latin Kings 2 0 2 4 100% 50%

Northsiders 4 0 0 4 100% 0%

Surenos – all 9 0 4 13 100% 31%

Vice Lords 0 0 3 3 100% 100%

Single-rep. gangs 32 0 6 38 100% 16%

Gang Type Total 57 0 31 88 100% 35%

Dichotomy of Street and Prison Gangs?

Page 25: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

The LoneStar Project

Group-Level Characteristics

25

Instrumental Expressive Profit-Generation Communication

Page 26: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

The LoneStar Project

THE CHARACTERISTICS OF GANGS: COMPOSITION

0 1 2 3 4

Vice LordsSurenos - GeneralSurenos - Eastside

Party of Mexican RevolutionNorthsidersLatin Kings

Gangster DisciplesBlack Widows

Black DisciplesBad Boys

Aryan NationAmbrose Folk Nation

18th Street - Vagos18th Street

Tango - West TexasTango - VallucoTango - Orejon

Tango - HoustoneTango - General

PeckerwoodMexicles

Mandingo Warriors

Texas MafiaTexas Chicano Brotherhood

Crips - Rollin 60sCrips - General

Crips - GangsterCrips - 52 Hoover

Bloods - Tree Top PiruBloods - General

Bloods - Bounty Hunter

Texas SyndicateMexican MafiaLa Raza Unida

Hermanos Pistoleros LatinosBarrio AztecaAryan Circle

Aryan Brotherhood

Str

eet-

ori

ente

dP

riso

n-o

rien

ted

ST

G—

not

segre

gat

edS

TG

—se

gre

gat

edInstrumental

0 1 2 3 4

Expressive

0 1 2 3 4

Profit-Generation

0 1 2 3 4

Communication

Page 27: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

The LoneStar Project

THE CHARACTERISTICS OF GANGS: COMPOSITION

0 1 2 3 4

Vice LordsSurenos - GeneralSurenos - Eastside

Party of Mexican RevolutionNorthsidersLatin Kings

Gangster DisciplesBlack Widows

Black DisciplesBad Boys

Aryan NationAmbrose Folk Nation

18th Street - Vagos18th Street

Tango - West TexasTango - VallucoTango - Orejon

Tango - HoustoneTango - General

PeckerwoodMexicles

Mandingo Warriors

Texas MafiaTexas Chicano Brotherhood

Crips - Rollin 60sCrips - General

Crips - GangsterCrips - 52 Hoover

Bloods - Tree Top PiruBloods - General

Bloods - Bounty Hunter

Texas SyndicateMexican MafiaLa Raza Unida

Hermanos Pistoleros LatinosBarrio AztecaAryan Circle

Aryan Brotherhood

Str

eet-

ori

ente

dP

riso

n-o

rien

ted

ST

G—

not

segre

gat

edS

TG

—se

gre

gat

edInstrumental

0 1 2 3 4

Expressive

0 1 2 3 4

Profit-Generation

0 1 2 3 4

Communication

Page 28: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

The LoneStar Project

THE CHARACTERISTICS OF GANGS: COMPOSITION

0 1 2 3 4

Vice LordsSurenos - GeneralSurenos - Eastside

Party of Mexican RevolutionNorthsidersLatin Kings

Gangster DisciplesBlack Widows

Black DisciplesBad Boys

Aryan NationAmbrose Folk Nation

18th Street - Vagos18th Street

Tango - West TexasTango - VallucoTango - Orejon

Tango - HoustoneTango - General

PeckerwoodMexicles

Mandingo Warriors

Texas MafiaTexas Chicano Brotherhood

Crips - Rollin 60sCrips - General

Crips - GangsterCrips - 52 Hoover

Bloods - Tree Top PiruBloods - General

Bloods - Bounty Hunter

Texas SyndicateMexican MafiaLa Raza Unida

Hermanos Pistoleros LatinosBarrio AztecaAryan Circle

Aryan Brotherhood

Str

eet-

ori

ente

dP

riso

n-o

rien

ted

ST

G—

not

segre

gat

edS

TG

—se

gre

gat

edInstrumental

0 1 2 3 4

Expressive

0 1 2 3 4

Profit-Generation

0 1 2 3 4

Communication

Page 29: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

The LoneStar Project

THE CHARACTERISTICS OF GANGS: COMPOSITION

0 1 2 3 4

Vice LordsSurenos - GeneralSurenos - Eastside

Party of Mexican RevolutionNorthsidersLatin Kings

Gangster DisciplesBlack Widows

Black DisciplesBad Boys

Aryan NationAmbrose Folk Nation

18th Street - Vagos18th Street

Tango - West TexasTango - VallucoTango - Orejon

Tango - HoustoneTango - General

PeckerwoodMexicles

Mandingo Warriors

Texas MafiaTexas Chicano Brotherhood

Crips - Rollin 60sCrips - General

Crips - GangsterCrips - 52 Hoover

Bloods - Tree Top PiruBloods - General

Bloods - Bounty Hunter

Texas SyndicateMexican MafiaLa Raza Unida

Hermanos Pistoleros LatinosBarrio AztecaAryan Circle

Aryan Brotherhood

Str

eet-

ori

ente

dP

riso

n-o

rien

ted

ST

G—

not

segre

gat

edS

TG

—se

gre

gat

edInstrumental

0 1 2 3 4

Expressive

0 1 2 3 4

Profit-Generation

0 1 2 3 4

Communication

Page 30: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

Power and Control

Page 31: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics
Page 32: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

The LoneStar Project

Who “Runs” Prisons?

32

Non-Gang Members(N=454)

Gang Members(N=346) Diff.

Rules% Agree % Agree

It is more important to follow the rules:

. . . gangs set than prisoners set 15.7% 44.5% Large

. . . gangs set than the prison staff 17.7% 40.8% Large

. . . prisoners set than the prison staff 30.4% 47.7% Medium

How fearful of punishment for violating:

% Very or Somewhat

Fearful

% Very or Somewhat

Fearful

. . . the rules that prisoners set 6.8% 12.7% Small

. . . the rules that gangs set 16.2% 23.5% Medium

. . . the rules that prison staff set 13.4% 9.0% Medium

Non-Gang Members(N=454)

Gang Members(N=346) Diff.

Order % Agree % Agree

Prisons would be more violent w/o gangs 18.5% 34.1% Medium

Gangs help maintain order in prisons 34.2% 65.6% Large

Gangs fix problems better than COs 28.1% 60.7% Large

Prison suffers when gangs have problems 81.9% 80.9% None

COs must talk to gangs to make changes 36.4% 48.3% Medium

Gangs make you feel safer in prison 6.2% 14.8% Medium

Non-gang inmates have hard time 25.9% 29.5% Small

I trust gangs to fix my problems, not COs 15.0% 38.7% Large

Control % Agree % Agree

Approval of gangs is required for selling:. . . drugs 28.8% 46.4% Medium. . . cell phones 24.2% 41.8% Medium. . . other contraband 20.7% 37.1% Medium

Gangs get a cut of contraband profits 20.8% 31.7% Medium

Page 33: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

33

Nuances of Gangs and Power

• Changes in prison gangs

“Everything has gotten watered

down, calmed down. It is not as

violent as it used to be. It’s a new

generation, younger, that doesn’t

necessarily have the same morals as

what the older generation does.”

“Less violence now. More inner strife

within the family itself. You don’t

really see opposite gangs go at each

other.”

“Prison is washed up. It is not what it

used to be. It used to be more

disciplined and gangs meant

something. Now the gangs don’t

mean anything”

• Rules and social order“you can find a way to do both [inmate

code and gang rules] but it is most

important to follow the gang”

• Control of contraband

“If you’re not in the gang, you’re not

going to sell nothing.”

“Only if you are affiliated with them

[prison gangs] – they have guidelines.

If they want to get something dropped

out they get a “basketball” (literally)

which is full of cellphones, drugs, etc.

Once the people [gang members] get it

they are supposed to split it between

the person and their family [gang].

That is why you get so much at one

time.

• Street/prison symbiosis

“If they was having trouble with

someone in the street or somebody

snitched on them, then that person

comes to prison, then they send word to

prison we take care of it here.”

“If there’s a war going on in the world,

in the penitentiary, the same rival gang,

there’s a war, whatever goes on the

outside goes on inside, it works outside-

in.”

“The inside pretty much controls the

outside. So they didn’t really do much

on the outside if the inside didn’t let

them.”

Page 34: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

Joining and Leaving Gangs in Prison

Page 35: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

Sample Street Prison

N=799

Pre-prison:

- 18% Gang

- 82% Non-gang

N=231

Street Importation

N=151

Street Only

N=80

N=5

N=3

Street Importation

N=151

N=36

Prison Origination

N=209

N=3

(8%)

(12%)

N=359

(70%)

Never

Gang

Street

Only

Prison

Origination

(10%) Street

Importation

Page 36: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

WHY DO THEY JOIN?

Pushes (external to the gang) and Pulls (internal to the gang)

Joining on the street

• Normative influence (50%)

• Belonging (29%)

• Economic (12%)

• Status (11%)

• Ideology (8%)

• Adjustment/guidance (5%)

• Protection (4%)

Joining in prison

• Normative influence (30%)

• Belonging (25%)

• Ideology (25%)

• Protection (21%)

• Status (13%)

• Adjustment/guidance (8%)

• Economic (7%)

Page 37: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

HOW DO THEY JOIN?

Passive and Active

Joining on the street

• Jumped in (59%)

• Prospected (12%)

• Other violence (12%)

• Nothing (10%)

• Attacked rivals/exes (9%)

• Other non-violence (7%)

• Gang ties (5%)

Joining in prison

• Jumped in (48%)

• Prospected (20%)

• Other violence (18%)

• Nothing (15%)

• Attacked rivals/exes (7%)

• Other non-violence (6%)

• Gang ties (2%)

Page 38: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics
Page 39: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

WHY DO THEY LEAVE?

Pushes (internal to the gang) and Pulls (external to the gang)

Left on the street

• Disillusionment (76%)

• Family (38%)

• Triggering events (29%)

• Positive influences (13%)

• CJ involvement (10%)

• Gang structure (2%)

• Work (2%)

• Religion (2%)

Left in prison

• Disillusionment (79%)

• Family (36%)

• CJ involvement (26%)

• Triggering events (12%)

• Religion (10%)

• Positive influences (6%)

• Gang structure (5%)

• Work (1%)

Page 40: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

HOW DO THEY LEAVE?

Passive and Active

Left on the street

• Nothing (40%)

• Stopped associating (24%)

• Giving notice (18%)

• Jumped out (16%)

• Moved (8%)

• Permission/meeting (3%)

• Intervention (2%)

Left in prison

• Giving notice (34%)

• Nothing (27%)

• Jumped out (14%)

• Intervention (12%)

• Stopped associating (12%)

• Permission/meeting (7%)

• Moved (4%)

Page 41: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

Criminal Justice

Rival Gangs

Family

Gang

POST-EXIT VALIDATION

Self

Page 42: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

Criminal and Gang Recidivism

Page 43: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

REARREST

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

30%

35%

40%

45%

50%

55%

60%

65%

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24

Perc

en

t A

rrest

ed

Months Post-Release

Everyone Non-Gang Active Gang Former Gang

Page 44: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

RECONVICTION

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

30%

35%

40%

45%

50%

55%

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24P

erc

en

t R

eco

nvi

cte

dMonths Post-Release

Everyone Non-Gang Active Gang Former Gang

Page 45: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

REINCARCERATION

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

30%

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16P

erc

en

t R

ein

carc

era

ted

Months Post-Release

Everyone Non-Gang Active Gang Former Gang

Page 46: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

GANG CONTINUITY AND CHANGE

Page 47: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

Gang Renouncement and Disassociation

Page 48: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

WHAT IS GRAD?Stage

Disassociation Investigation

Phase I: Normalization

Phase II: Socialization

Phase III: Reintegration

Unit Administrative segregation

Ramsey or Ellis “GRAD wing”Red wristbands

Ramsey or Ellis "GRAD wing" Orange wristbands

Ramsey or Ellis “gen pop”Blue wristbands

Time 12 months 2 months 4 months 3 months

Contact None Limited contact Single-celled; First month, solo rec time; Second month, double rec

Expanded contact Double-cell with inmate from

historical rival (race, gang); Group-based programming

Standard contact General population

interaction

Privileges None Limited privileges

More in-and-out of cell privileges;

One visit per weekend

Phase I, plus: Different clothing (2-piece

rather than white jumper); More programming and

movement

Phase II, plus: Regular visitation; Phone calls; Commissary; Work assignments; GRAD completion ceremony

Programming NoneSTG office investigates sincerity/commitment, conflicts, and eligibility* Informants and state's witnesses can bypass this phase

Stabilizing programming

In-cell videotaped lessons Substance abuse Domestic violence "Thinking errors“

Counselor meetings

Classroom programming

Cognitive intervention (180 hours), journaling

68 hours of substance abuse, anger management, and criminal addictive behaviors

Role playing, group activities

Vocational opportunities

When educational classes are not in session, comparable to GP inmates

Page 49: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

WHO PARTICIPATES IN GRAD?All (N=117) Non-GRAD (N=64) GRAD (N=53)

Mean/% (SD) Mean/% (SD) Mean/% (SD) Different?

Age (in years) 43.61 (8.77) 42.00 (9.24) 45.56 (7.83) YesLatino 49.6% 48.4% 50.9% NoWhite 40.2% 39.1% 41.5% No

Multi-racial 10.3% 12.5% 7.5% No

Skin color (0-10) 1.83 (1.00) 1.97 (0.99) 1.66 (0.99) No

Married 14.5% 14.1% 15.1% No

In a relationship 10.3% 6.3% 15.1% No

Single 75.2% 79.7% 69.8% No

Father 69.2% 68.8% 69.8% No

TDCJ stints 3.09 (1.68) 3.00 (1.55) 3.19 (1.84) No

Prior arrests count 11.50 (6.56) 11.11 (6.93) 11.96 (6.12) No

Violent offender 37.6% 40.6% 34.0% No

Eligible gangs N N NAryan Brotherhood 31 18 13Aryan Circle 15 5 10Barrio Azteca 8 4 4Hermanos Pistoleros Latinos 6 3 3Mexican Mafia 23 13 10Raza Unida 8 3 5Texas Mafia 4 3 1Texas Syndicate 22 15 7

Page 50: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

GANG MEMBERSHIP

21%

73%

56%

44%

3%

95%

9%

91%

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

Survey:

Current gang

Survey:

Former gang

Official:

Current gang

Official:

Former gang

Non-GRAD GRAD

Page 51: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

GANG EMBEDDEDNESS

0.28 0.28

0.21

0.02

0.15

0.33

0.15

-0.34 -0.33

-0.25

-0.03

-0.18

-0.40

-0.18

-0.60

-0.50

-0.40

-0.30

-0.20

-0.10

0.00

0.10

0.20

0.30

0.40

0.50

0.60

Gang embedded Position

in gang

Importance

of gang

Gang

fights

Influence

on gang

Contact

w/ gang

Friends in

gang

zsc

ore

Non-GRAD GRAD

Page 52: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

MISCONDUCT AND VICTIMIZATION

44%

20%

39%

25%

18%

40%

14%

34%

24%20%

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

Survey:

Any

Misconduct

Survey:

Violent

Misconduct

Official:

Any

Misconduct

Survey:

Any

Victimization

Survey:

Violent

Victimization

Non-GRAD GRAD

Page 53: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

Implications for Policy and Practice

Page 54: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

1. Mass incarceration and gangs

2. Gang-oriented programming

3. Group intervention in prison

4. The grip of the gang

5. Prison as a turning point

6. Gang variation

7. Housing gang members

8. Multiple methods for understanding gangs

9. Preparing gang members for reentry

Page 55: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

1. Mass incarceration and gangs

2. Gang-oriented programming

3. Group intervention in prison

4. The grip of the gang

5. Prison as a turning point

6. Gang variation

7. Housing gang members

8. Multiple methods for understanding gangs

9. Preparing gang members for reentry

Page 56: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

1. Mass incarceration and gangs

2. Gang-oriented programming

3. Group intervention in prison

4. The grip of the gang

5. Prison as a turning point

6. Gang variation

7. Housing gang members

8. Multiple methods for understanding gangs

9. Preparing gang members for reentry

Page 57: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

1. Mass incarceration and gangs

2. Gang-oriented programming

3. Group intervention in prison

4. The grip of the gang

5. Prison as a turning point

6. Gang variation

7. Housing gang members

8. Multiple methods for understanding gangs

9. Preparing gang members for reentry

Page 58: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

1. Mass incarceration and gangs

2. Gang-oriented programming

3. Group intervention in prison

4. The grip of the gang

5. Prison as a turning point

6. Gang variation

7. Housing gang members

8. Multiple methods for understanding gangs

9. Preparing gang members for reentry

Page 59: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

1. Mass incarceration and gangs

2. Gang-oriented programming

3. Group intervention in prison

4. The grip of the gang

5. Prison as a turning point

6. Gang variation

7. Housing gang members

8. Multiple methods for understanding gangs

9. Preparing gang members for reentry

Page 60: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

1. Mass incarceration and gangs

2. Gang-oriented programming

3. Group intervention in prison

4. The grip of the gang

5. Prison as a turning point

6. Gang variation

7. Housing gang members

8. Multiple methods for understanding gangs

9. Preparing gang members for reentry

Page 61: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

1. Mass incarceration and gangs

2. Gang-oriented programming

3. Group intervention in prison

4. The grip of the gang

5. Prison as a turning point

6. Gang variation

7. Housing gang members

8. Multiple methods for understanding gangs

9. Preparing gang members for reentry

Page 62: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

1. Mass incarceration and gangs

2. Gang-oriented programming

3. Group intervention in prison

4. The grip of the gang

5. Prison as a turning point

6. Gang variation

7. Housing gang members

8. Multiple methods for understanding gangs

9. Preparing gang members for reentry

Page 63: What have we learned about prison gangs? Findings from the … · 2020-02-20 · Understanding prison gangs 1. The problem of prison gangs 2. The LoneStar Project 3. Characteristics

Thank you

[email protected]

@dpyrooz

Department of Sociology

Institute of Behavioral Science

483 UCB

Boulder, CO 80309

303-492-3241

This project was supported by Grant No. 2014-MU-CX-0111 awarded by the National Institute of Justice, Office of Justice

Programs, U.S. Department of Justice. The research contained in this document was coordinated in part by the Texas Department of

Criminal Justice (723-AR15). The contents of this article, including its opinions, findings, and conclusions, are those of the authors

and do not necessarily reflect the views or policies of the U.S. Department of Justice or the Texas Department of Criminal Justice.