73
Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV Zebulon Corporate Limits and Extraterritorial Jurisdiction Wake County, North Carolina New South Associates, Inc.

Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV Zebulon Corporate Limits and Extraterritorial JurisdictionWake County, North Carolina

New South Associates, Inc.

Page 2: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

Intentionally Left Blank

Page 3: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV Zebulon Corporate Limits and Extraterritorial Jurisdiction

Wake County, North Carolina

Report submitted to: North Carolina SHPO • 4617 Mail Service Center • Raleigh, North Carolina 27699

Report prepared by: New South Associates • 6150 East Ponce de Leon Avenue • Stone Mountain, Georgia 30083

Mary Beth Reed– Principal Investigator

Jennifer B. Langdale– Historian

November 20, 2018 • Final Report New South Associates Technical Report 2883

Page 4: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

Intentionally Left Blank

Page 5: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WAKE COUNTY ARCHITECTURAL SURVEY UPDATE, PHASE IV (ZEBULON)

i

TABLE OF CONTENTS

TABLE OF CONTENTS ............................................................................................................ iLIST OF FIGURES ................................................................................................................... iiLIST OF TABLES ..................................................................................................................... ii

I. INTRODUCTION ..................................................................................................................1

II. WAKE COUNTY ARCHITECTURAL SURVEY HISTORY ...............................................3COUNTYWIDE SURVEYS ....................................................................................................3CHANGES IN LANDSCAPE OF NORTHEASTERN WAKE COUNTY ...............................4

III. SCOPE OF WORK AND METHODOLOGY .......................................................................7TASKS/ACCOMPLISHMENTS .............................................................................................7METHODS ..............................................................................................................................8NRHP CRITERIA FOR EVALUATION ............................................................................... 12LOCAL HISTORIC LANDMARK DESIGNATION CRITERIA .......................................... 18

IV. SURVEY RESULTS .......................................................................................................... 19

V. RECOMMENDATIONS ...................................................................................................... 20

VI. PRODUCTS ....................................................................................................................... 22

REFERENCES CITED ............................................................................................................. 25

APPENDIX A: PROPOSED ZEBULON NRHP DISTRICTAPPENDIX B: PROPERTIES SURVEYED OUTSIDE OF PROPOSED NRHP DISTRICTAPPENDIX C: MAP OF PROPOSED ZEBULON NRHP DISTRICT WITH SITE FILE

NUMBERS

Page 6: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

ii

LIST OF FIGURES

Figure 1. Map of Project Area ....................................................................................................2 Figure 2. Map of Proposed Zebulon NRHP District ....................................................................9 Figure 3. Examples of Property Types in the Proposed NRHP District, 1 of 2 .......................... 10 Figure 4. Examples of Property Types in the Proposed NRHP District, 2 of 2 .......................... 11 Figure 5. Individually Recommended Properties, 1 of 2 ........................................................... 14 Figure 6. Individually Recommended Properties ...................................................................... 15 Figure 7. Potential Study List Property, C.V. Whitley House (324 W. Gannon Avenue) ........... 16

LIST OF TABLES

Table 1. Population of Zebulon by Decade .................................................................................4 Table 2. Recommendations for Study List, Potential Study List, and/or Local Historic

Landmark Designation ................................................................................................ 17

Page 7: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WAKE COUNTY ARCHITECTURAL SURVEY UPDATE, PHASE IV (ZEBULON)

1

I. INTRODUCTION

This report summarizes the findings of the Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV

(Zebulon). This survey, conducted in 2018, is the fourth phase of a multi-phase project designed

to update the survey of the entire area within the jurisdiction of the Wake County Historic

Preservation Commission (HPC). The corporate city limits and extraterritorial jurisdictions (ETJ)

of Zebulon were included in this phase (Figure 1).

The project was funded by Wake County (County) with a federal matching grant from the Historic

Preservation Fund (HPF) administered by the North Carolina State Historic Preservation Office

(HPO). The total cost of the project was $22,500. The current project area was last surveyed

comprehensively during the 1988-1991 Wake County architectural survey.

New South Associates, Inc. (New South) was awarded the contract for the survey update of

Zebulon in March 2018. Mary Beth Reed served as Principal Investigator and Jennifer Langdale

and Ellen Turco served as Architectural Historians. Gary Roth, staff for the Wake County HPC;

Claudia Brown, Survey and National Register Branch Supervisor and Architectural Survey

Coordinator for the HPO; and Elizabeth King, Architectural Survey Coordinator for the HPO

supervised the project. Work was conducted between June and August 2018.

This report summarizes the findings of the survey update, which documented approximately 430

resources. The primary goals of the project were to document resources within a proposed

National Register of Historic Places (NRHP) Study List District in the town of Zebulon, to record

changes (such as demolitions, additions, and other alterations) that have occurred to previously

documented resources since 2005, and to document any previously unrecorded properties from

any time period more than 50 years ago that now merit documentation. This update of the

architectural survey will support future planning efforts and identify areas and resources

potentially eligible for listing in the NRHP, local historic landmark designation, or other

preservation measures.

Page 8: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

2

Figure 1.Map of Project Area

64

64

264

39

97

96

97

64

Source: NC Spatial Download (2018), iMAPS (2018)

Zebulon Corporate Limits

Planning Jurisdiction

0 1 20.5 Miles

0 1.5 30.75 Kilometers

Wake

Page 9: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WAKE COUNTY ARCHITECTURAL SURVEY UPDATE, PHASE IV (ZEBULON)

3

II. WAKE COUNTY ARCHITECTURAL SURVEY HISTORY

COUNTYWIDE SURVEYS

The Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV (Zebulon) builds on Wake County’s

past architectural inventories. The county’s first comprehensive architectural survey was

conducted in 1988-1991 by Kelly A. Lally and Todd Johnson and resulted in the book, The Historic

Architecture of Wake County, North Carolina (Lally and Johnson 1994). The comprehensive

architectural survey encompassed all of the rural areas, small communities, and municipalities

outside Raleigh’s 1988 city limits. One product of this survey was a NRHP Multiple Property

Documentation Form (MPDF), “The Historic and Architectural Resources of Wake County, North

Carolina (ca. 1770-1941).”

A two-phase, HPF-funded survey update to Lally and Johnson’s work was conducted in 2005- 2006 by Edwards-Pitman Environmental, Inc. (EPEI), the results of which were summarized in a report, “Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phases I and II” (2007).1

Phase II revised the

records for previously surveyed properties, excluding those within the 2005 corporate limits of Raleigh and Wake Forest; identified resources that had reached 50 years of age since 1991; and identified resources missed or omitted from the Lally and Johnson survey. In Phase II, significant or worthy resources identified for the first time in Phase I were intensively recorded. The EPEI survey produced a draft historic context entitled, Context 5: Wake County in the Post-World War II Era: Rural Life Transformed (1942-1960). The context included the property types, “Word War II and Post World War II House Types (1942-1960)” and “Post World War II Farm Complexes (1946-1960).” The draft context was not submitted to the National Park Service and, therefore, has not been formally added to the MPDF at this time.

In 2017, Phase III of the HPF-funded survey update to Lally and Johnson’s work was conducted by hmwPreservation. This phase encompassed historic resources in the long- and short-range urban service areas of Apex, Holly Springs, and Fuquay-Varina, the Apex Non-Urban Service area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were summarized in the report, “Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase III” (2017).2

1 A copy of this report is available online at http://www.hpo.ncdcr.gov/surveyreports/WakeCountySurveyUpdatePhI&II-2007.pdf

2 A copy of this report is available online at http://www.hpo.ncdcr.gov/surveyreports/WakeCountySurveyUpdate-2017.pdf

Page 10: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

4

CHANGES IN LANDSCAPE OF NORTHEASTERN WAKE COUNTY

Wake County has experienced explosive growth in past 30 years, rising from a population of 423,380 in 1990 to an estimate of 1,072,203 in 2017 (Wake County Government 2018). With that growth came unprecedented suburbanization since the last architectural survey update was completed in 2006. While much of Wake County has transformed from a twentieth-century landscape of farms and small towns to a twenty-first-century suburban landscape, the area around Zebulon has managed, so far, to retain much of its rural character. There are still numerous tobacco farms and agricultural acreage along the roads leading into the town. The city itself retains a small-town atmosphere and does not appear to have experienced the loss of historic housing and neighborhoods that has occurred in other communities in Wake County. Its estimated population growth between 2010 and 2017, however, has already exceeded the growth seen between the previous census years of 2000 and 2010 (see Table 1). As Raleigh and Wake County continue to grow, Zebulon is primed for the same pattern. There have already been several new neighborhoods constructed, such as Taryn Meadows and Weaver Pond, and several more are in the early stages of development along Old Bunn Road. New commercial enterprises have also appeared along the outskirts of Zebulon, particularly on N.C. Highway 96. This trend renders the surviving early-twentieth-century core of Zebulon, as well as surrounding farmsteads, agricultural buildings, and rural landscapes, precious and worthy of preservation. Additionally, the public’s awareness of mid-twentieth-century resources has also been elevated over time.

Table 1. Population of Zebulon by Decade

1990 2000 2010 2014 (est.) 2017 (est.)

3,173 4,046 4,433 4,750 5,268

Source: U.S. Census Bureau Wake County has the state’s highest median household income (Wake County Government 2018). This creates demand for residential subdivisions composed of single-family houses and townhouses and the concomitant construction of schools, medical facilities, strip shopping centers, big box stores, and office parks. Development propels local and state road improvement projects, as well as the construction of entirely new roads. However, the 2008 recession was reflected in Wake County’s construction sector. Between 2007 and 2009, the number of permitted units fell by 71 percent, from 14,221 to 4,117. Permits remained suppressed between 2009 and 2011, but have since rebounded. In 2012, nearly 12,000 housing construction permits were issued in Wake County, and by 2017, there were 11,335 housing units built in the county (Wake County Government 2018).

Typically, historic downtowns, such as Zebulon’s, are somewhat insulated from development pressure, perhaps because these areas were fully built out by the 1960s. In fact, the suburbanization of other areas of Wake County have spurred revitalization projects in historic downtowns.

Page 11: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WAKE COUNTY ARCHITECTURAL SURVEY UPDATE, PHASE IV (ZEBULON)

5

Programs such as North Carolina Main Street and Downtown Associate Community Program, established in May 2015, provide “eligible communities interested in downtown revitalization with the tools to build a sustainable organizational foundation that will strengthen their downtown development efforts,” which are centered around the context of historic preservation (North Carolina Department of Commerce 2018). Federal and state historic preservation tax credits have also been extensively used in Wake County to restore and reuse historic buildings. These opportunities also exist for Zebulon.

Page 12: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

6

Intentionally Left Blank

Page 13: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WAKE COUNTY ARCHITECTURAL SURVEY UPDATE, PHASE IV (ZEBULON)

7

III. SCOPE OF WORK AND METHODOLOGY

The update of the architectural survey will support future planning and identify areas and resources

potentially eligible for NRHP listing, local historic landmark designation, or other preservation

measures. All work was conducted according to the guidelines in the HPO’s 2008 publication,

Architectural Survey Manual: Practical Advice for Recording Historic Resources.

TASKS/ACCOMPLISHMENTS

The major tasks of the Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV (Zebulon) are

presented in the bulleted list below. The actual number of survey database entries created as a

result of a completed task is in italics.

• Document properties in a proposed NRHP district through digital photography, mapping,

and full population of database records including a written description sufficient for a NRHP

inventory list. New South documented 340 properties and created 316 site files. (Two site

files contain numerous examples of similar building types and were recorded onto one form.)

• Revisit and update survey records (including the database entry, mapping, and

photography) of approximately 70 previously surveyed properties within the corporate

limits and ETJs of Zebulon, but outside of the proposed NRHP district. New South

updated survey records for 64 properties.

• Do reconnaissance survey fieldwork and create new database records for pre-1960 resources

outside of the proposed NRHP district that possess sufficient integrity and architectural

quality and have not been surveyed previously. New South created 27 new records.

• Prepare a list of properties recommended for the state Study List and local landmark

designation (see Table 2).

• Prepare text for a press release to be issued by Wake County Public Affairs outlining the

purposes and goals of the project.

• Conduct up to two public presentations about the survey (Zebulon Commissioners’ Meeting,

August 22, 2018 and Wake County HPC, November 20, 2018).

Page 14: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

8

• Present a PowerPoint of recommended Study List properties to the National Register

Advisory Committee (October 11, 2018).

• Prepare a brief report on the results of the survey.

METHODS

Prior to fieldwork, New South obtained tax parcel data from Wake County and a copy of the

Access survey database, populated with limited information on previously surveyed resources

from the HPO. New South staff visited the offices of HPO to obtain hard copies of the survey

files. The typed descriptive entries contained within the paper files were scanned into the database.

The project began with touring local historic sites with New South staff and members of

Preservation Zebulon. New South staff also met with Zebulon town planning director, Mark A.

Hetrick, during the survey process.

The intensive architectural survey portion of the project began with documentation of the proposed

NRHP district (Figure 2). During this phase, 316 sites were recorded and/or updated.3 Each

property was visited and digitally photographed to capture its overall appearance, physical context

and setting, and significant architectural details. Alteration and demolition that had occurred since

the last survey were documented and noted in the survey database, and narrative descriptions were

revised with new information. Examples of property types in the proposed NRHP district are

shown in Figures 3 and 4. For a list of all the properties, see Appendix A. For a map of the

proposed NRHP district with site numbers, see Appendix C.

Of the 316 resources identified for the proposed NRHP district, approximately 140 had been

recorded within paper “block files” containing multiple resources. Individual survey database

records were made for the block file resources. Previously undocumented buildings in the

proposed NRHP district were recorded no matter their age, condition, or integrity, so that all

properties in the potential district, whether contributing or non-contributing to the district, are

already documented as required for an NRHP application.

Once the proposed NRHP district was documented, fieldwork progressed to updating previously

recorded sites outside of the district and adding 27 new resources that had not been recorded in

1991 or 2005. For a list of the properties surveyed outside of the proposed NRHP district, see

Appendix B.

3In two instances, multiple properties within the proposed district were documented on one form as the houses in these two areas are very similar in style and form, in good condition, and constructed at the same time. These were WA8433, which includes six ranch houses on W. Lee Street, and WA8400, which includes 19 ranch houses on E. Lee, N. Lee, and E. Franklin Streets.

Page 15: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

9WAKE COUNTY ARCHITECTURAL SURVEY UPDATE, PHASE IV (ZEBULON)

Figure 2.Map of Proposed Zebulon NRHP District

New Bern Ave

N Arendell Ave

N Church St

N Wakefield St

W Franklin St

W Horton St

W Gannon Ave

N Poplar St

E North St

W Barbee St

W Judd St

W Sycamore St

W North St

E Horton St

N G

ill St

S Arendell Ave

Shepard School Rd

E Vance St

E Gannon Ave

Wakelon St

E Judd St

W Glenn St

W Lee St

N Whitley St

W Vance St

N Lee St

W McIver St Cem

etar

y Rd

E Barbee AveStratford D

r

S Wakefield St

E Sycamore St

N Pitt St

Primrose Pl

US Hwy 264

E McIver St

Apothecary Dr

N P

rivet

te S

t

W Oak St

E Lee St

E Stronach Ave

E Franklin St

Mack Todd Rd

Silver St

N Rotary DrN Rotary St

W B

arbe

e St E

xd

Parkside Pl

Lakeside Cir

N Flowers AveE Glenn St

US Hwy 264New Bern Ave

E Glenn St

Source: NC Spatial Download (2018)

Proposed Zebulon NationalRegister Historic District

0 600 1,200300 Feet

0 250 500125 Meters

Page 16: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

10

Figure 3.Examples of Property Types in the Proposed NRHP District, 1 of 2

100 E. Vance Street

212 W. Sycamore Street

214 E. Sycamore Street

Page 17: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

11WAKE COUNTY ARCHITECTURAL SURVEY UPDATE, PHASE IV (ZEBULON)

Figure 4.Examples of Property Types in the Proposed NRHP District, 2 of 2

Hales House,805 N. Church Street

108 E. Franklin Street

219 W. Franklin Street

Page 18: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

12

NRHP CRITERIA FOR EVALUATION

Each of the surveyed properties was evaluated for its potential eligibility for listing in the NRHP and as a local historic landmark. Neighborhoods, landscapes, and groups of properties were evaluated for their potential as historic districts. Cultural resources were evaluated based on criteria for NRHP eligibility specified in the Department of Interior Regulations 36 CFR Part 60: National Register of Historic Places. Cultural resources can be defined as significant if they “possess integrity of location, design, setting, materials, workmanship, feeling, and association and if they are 50 years of age or older” and:

A) Are associated with events that have made a significant contribution to the broad

patterns of our history (history); or

B) Are associated with the lives of persons significant in our past (person); or

C) Embody the distinctive characteristic of a type, period, or method of construction or that

represent the work of a master, or that possess high artistic values, or that components may

lack individual distinction (architecture); or

D) Have yielded, or may be likely to yield, information important in prehistory or history

(archaeology).

Cemeteries, birthplaces or graves of historical figures, properties owned by religious institutions

or used for religious purposes, buildings that have been moved from their original locations,

reconstructed historic buildings, properties primarily commemorative in nature, and properties that

have achieved significance within the past 50 years are not generally considered eligible for the

NRHP. However, such properties will qualify if they are integral parts of historic districts that

meet the criteria or if they fall within the following categories:

Criteria Consideration A: a religious property deriving primary significance from

architectural or artistic distinction or historical importance; or

Criteria Consideration B: a building or structure removed from its original location but

which is significant primarily for architectural value, or which is the surviving structure

most importantly associated with a historic person or event; or

Criteria Consideration C: a birthplace or grave of a historical figure of outstanding

importance if there is no other appropriate site or building directly associated with his or

her productive life; or

Page 19: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WAKE COUNTY ARCHITECTURAL SURVEY UPDATE, PHASE IV (ZEBULON)

13

Criteria Consideration D: a cemetery which derives its primary significance from graves

or persons of transcendent importance, from age, from distinctive design features, or from

association with historic events; or

Criteria Consideration E: a reconstructed building when accurately executed in a suitable

environment and presented in a dignified manner as part of a restoration master plan, and

when no other building or structure with the same association has survived; or

Criteria Consideration F: a property primarily commemorative in intent if design, age,

tradition, or symbolic value has invested it with its own historical significance; or

Criteria Consideration G: a property achieving significance within the past 50 years if it is

of exceptional importance.

In North Carolina, a property must be placed on the state Study List before it can be nominated to

the NRHP. The Study List is a preliminary step in the review of nominations to the NRHP. The

list serves as an early screening mechanism to remove from consideration properties that are

clearly not eligible for the NRHP. Not all properties placed on the Study List will ultimately be

eligible for NRHP listing. Placement on the Study List simply means that the properties appear to

be potentially eligible based on a preliminary assessment and merit additional research to make a

determination. Properties recommended for placement on the Study List are indicated in Table 2.

Photographs of the individually recommended properties are shown in Figures 5 and 6. Table 2

also lists properties in Zebulon that are already on the state Study List, as well as properties that

have already been determined eligible (DOE) to the NRHP through a previous environmental

review process or some other study.

Individual properties cannot be placed on the Study List without knowledge that the interiors retain

integrity. While New South staff and Preservation Zebulon members attempted to gain access to

some properties in order to examine the interior, property owners were sometimes not agreeable.

Therefore, a number of properties were identified that appear to be potential candidates for the

Study List based on exterior examination but merit further investigation of interiors. Properties

which fall into the category of “potential study list properties” are also indicated in Table 2. The

properties on this list are shown in Figure 7.

Page 20: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

14

Figure 5. E.C. Daniel House (205 E. Sycamore Street)

B. The cover of Life, April 30, 1956 Showing the Son and Daughter-In-

Law of E.C. Daniel

A. E.C. Daniel House (205 E. Sycamore Street)

Page 21: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

15WAKE COUNTY ARCHITECTURAL SURVEY UPDATE, PHASE IV (ZEBULON)

Figure 6.Individually Recommended Properties

Wakefield Missionary Baptist Church and Cemetery

Mt. Pisgah Prince Hall Lodge No. 65

Wakefield Missionary Baptist Cemetery (809 Proctor Street)

Page 22: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

16

Figure 7.Potential Study List Property, C.V. Whitley House (324 W. Gannon Avenue)

Page 23: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WAKE COUNTY ARCHITECTURAL SURVEY UPDATE, PHASE IV (ZEBULON)

17

Table 2. Recommendations for Study List, Potential Study List, and/or Local Historic Landmark Designation

Survey Site Number

Name Address Description Current Status

Study List Potential Study List

Local Designation

WA0048 Wakelon School 1003 N. Arendell Ave.

1908 School NRHP Listed

X

WA2110 Dr. G.M. Bell House

301 Proctor Road

2-story traditional/ vernacular

Study Listed

X

WA2111 J.A. Kemp House 102 Pearces Road

2-story traditional/ vernacular

DOE/SL X

WA2114 Horton-Kimball House

502 Pearces Road

2-story traditional/ vernacular

Study Listed

X

WA2116 Stringfield-Pippin House

601 Pearces Road

2-story traditional/ vernacular

Study Listed

X

WA2117 Starkey-Hoyle House

613 Pearces Road

2-story traditional/ vernacular

Study Listed

X

WA2121 House 1009 Pearces Road

2-story Queen Anne/Colonial Revival

Study Listed

X

WA2122 Stringfield-Massey House

1017 Magnum Street

2-story Queen Anne/Craftsman

Study Listed

X

WA2123 Wakefield Missionary Bapt. Church and Cemetery and Mt. Pisgah Prince Hall Lodge No. 65

809 Proctor St.

Church, Cemetery, Fraternal Building

Surveyed X X

WA2184 Horton Farm 406 S. Arendell Street

1-story Queen Anne/Colonial Revival

Determined Eligible

X

WA2213 E. C. Daniel House

205 E. Sycamore St.

Craftsman Foursquare

Surveyed X X

WA2234 George and Neva Barbee House

216 W. Gannon Avenue

Craftsman Foursquare

NRHP Listed

X

WA2238 C.V. Whitley House

324 W. Gannon Ave.

Mediterranean Revival

Surveyed X X

WA2242 (former) Zebulon Elem. School

900 Shepard School Road

Rosenwald School Study Listed

X

WA3194 (former) Zebulon Town Hall

100 N. Arendell Ave.

Commercial Building

Determined Eligible

WA4066 N. Arendell/W. Gannon HD

Study Listed

Page 24: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

18

Table 2. Recommendations for Study List, Potential Study List, and/or Local Historic Landmark Designation

Survey Site Number

Name Address Description Current Status

Study List Potential Study List

Local Designation

WA4067 Horton/Sycamore St. HD

Study Listed

WA4068 Zebulon Commercial District HD

Study Listed

WA4850 Pearce Farm 401 Moss Road

early 19th-c. farmhouse

Surveyed X

WA8498 Jones House 119 W. Glenn Street

Modernist ranch house

Surveyed X

WA8688 Zebulon HD Surveyed X

LOCAL HISTORIC LANDMARK DESIGNATION CRITERIA

The Wake County HPC recommends local historic landmarks to the local governing boards. The

Criteria for Designation are established in the Wake County Historic Preservation Ordinance, as

amended, Section 3.2, Criteria for Designation:

In order for any building, structure, site, area, or object to be designated in

an ordinance as a historic landmark, the Commission must find that the

property is of special significance in terms of its history, prehistory,

architecture, archaeology and/or cultural importance, and that it possesses

integrity of design, setting, workmanship, materials, feeling and/or

association.

While the landmark designation criteria are very similar to those used in evaluating resources for

NRHP eligibility, local landmarks generally do not place as strong an emphasis on interior integrity

since, in most cases, only the exterior of a building is subject to the landmark ordinance. For

properties recommended for local historic landmark designation, see Table 2.

Page 25: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WAKE COUNTY ARCHITECTURAL SURVEY UPDATE, PHASE IV (ZEBULON)

19

IV. SURVEY RESULTS

Results of the 2018 Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV (Zebulon) are as

follows:

• Total number of properties surveyed: 431

• Primary resources documented during the 1988-1991 comprehensive survey that have

since been demolished: 12

• Number of resources recommended for the state Study List: 3

• Number of resources that may qualify for the State Study List but merit further

investigation of the interiors: 1

• Number of resources recommended for local landmark designation: 16

Page 26: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

20

Intentionally Left Blank

Page 27: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WAKE COUNTY ARCHITECTURAL SURVEY UPDATE, PHASE IV (ZEBULON)

21

V. RECOMMENDATIONS

• Properties listed in Table 2. Recommendations for Study List, Potential Study List, and/or

Local Historic Landmark Designation are recommended for placement or potential

placement on the Study List or for designation as local historic landmarks.

• Property owners of “Potential Study List properties” should be contacted to educate them

about the NRHP and request interior access.

• Phase V of the Wake County Architectural Survey Update can proceed to include the

outlying areas of eastern Wake County.

Page 28: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

22

Intentionally Left Blank

Page 29: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WAKE COUNTY ARCHITECTURAL SURVEY UPDATE, PHASE IV (ZEBULON)

23

VI. PRODUCTS

• Access Database containing updated survey records and new records.

• Hard copy survey files printed from the database and labeled photo contact sheets and

property location maps (2 sets, one to HPO and one to Wake County HPC).

• CDs of photographs (2).

• Summary Report describing methodology, findings, and recommendations for future work

and identifying properties potentially eligible for the National Register and/or local

landmark designation.

Page 30: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

24

Intentionally Left Blank

Page 31: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WAKE COUNTY ARCHITECTURAL SURVEY UPDATE, PHASE IV (ZEBULON)

25

REFERENCES CITED

Edwards-Pitman Environmental, Inc.

2007 Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phases I and II.

Lally, Kelly and Todd Johnson

1994 The Historic Architecture of Wake County, North Carolina. Wake County

Goverment, Raleigh, North Carolina.

North Carolina Department of Commerce

2018 North Carolina Main Street Program. N.C. Department of Commerce, Rural

Development.

Slane, Heather (hmwPreservation)

2017 Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase III.

Wake County Government

2018 Wake County By the Numbers. www.wakegov.com

Page 32: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

26

Intentionally Left Blank

Page 33: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

APPENDIX A: PROPOSED ZEBULON NRHP DISTRICT

Page 34: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

Intentionally Left Blank

Page 35: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

Appendix A: Proposed Zebulon National Register Historic DistrictSite File Number Street Adress Property Name

WA0048 1003 N. Arendell Avenue Wakelon School

WA2189 130 N. Arendell Avenue (former) Zebulon Drugstore

WA2194 107 W. Horton Street (former) Farmers’ Tobacco Warehouse

WA2204 214 E. Horton Street John Finch House

WA2210 104 E. Sycamore Street Strickland-Temple House

WA2211 116 E. Sycamore Street R.J. Whitley House

WA2212 111 E. Sycamore Street J.A. Hunt House

WA2213 205 E Sycamore Street E.C. Daniel House

WA2216 111 W. North Street Pittman-Stell House

WA2217 108 W. North Street Millard Chamblee House

WA2219 913 N. Arendell Avenue Marvin Bunn House (Massey Funeral Home)

WA2221 503 N. Wakefield Street Charles A. Flowers House

WA2222 500 N. Wakefield Street Dr. Charles E. Flowers House

WA2225 115 W. Gannon Avenue Zebulon Methodist Church

WA2228 201 W. Gannon Avenue Dawson House

WA2229 209 W. Gannon Avenue McGuire House

WA2230 213 W. Gannon Avenue F.E. Bunn House

WA2231 223 W. Gannon Avenue Talton-Moser House

WA2232 224 W. Gannon Avenue Strickland-Harper-Gill House

WA2233 220 W. Gannon Avenue Wilber Campen House

WA2234 216 W. Gannon Avenue George and Neva Barbee House

WA2235 212 W. Gannon Avenue Pitts House

WA2236 208 W. Gannon Avenue Chamblee House

WA2237 200 W. Gannon Avenue Horton-Massey House

WA2238 324 W. Gannon Avenue C.V. Whitley House

WA2239 310 W. Gannon Avenue J.K. Barrow House

WA3194 100 N. Arendell Avenue (former) Zebulon Town Hall

WA8367 311 E. Horton Street house

WA8368 309 E. Horton Street house

WA8369 306 E. Horton Street house

WA8370 304 E. Horton Street house

Site File Number

�1

Page 36: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WA8371 302 E. Horton Street house

WA8372 305 E. Horton Street J.R. Sawyer House

WA8373 300 E. Horton Street Bunn House

WA8374 804 N. Church Street house

WA8375 212 E. Horton Street house

WA8376 215 E. Horton Street house

WA8377 209 E. Horton Street house

WA8378 208 E. Horton Street house

WA8379 206 E. Horton Street house

WA8380 204 E. Horton Street house

WA8381 202 E. Horton Street house

WA8382 205 E. Horton Street house

WA8383 203 E. Horton Street house

WA8384 201 E. Horton Street house

WA8385 200 E. Horton Street house

WA8386 124 E. Horton Street house

WA8387 122 E. Horton Street house

WA8388 116 E. Horton Street house

WA8389 112 E. Horton Street house

WA8390 111 E. Horton Street A.F. & A.M. Lodge

WA8391 805 N. Church Street Thomas E. Hales House

WA8392 113 E. Horton Street house

WA8393 115 E. Horton Street house

WA8394 306 E. Sycamore Street house

WA8395 304 E. Sycamore Street house

WA8396 302 E. Sycamore Street house

WA8397 216 E. Sycamore Street house

WA8398 215 E. Sycamore Street house

WA8399 214 E. Sycamore Street house

WA8400 19 houses N. and E. Lee and N. Franklin Streets (111 and 117 E. Lee Street, 703 and 705 N. Lee Street, and 103-117 E. Franklin Street)

houses

WA8401 210 E. Sycamore Street Lattie J. Massey House

Street Adress Property NameSite File Number

�2

Page 37: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WA8402 207 E. Sycamore Street house

WA8403 211 E. Sycamore Street house

WA8404 308 N. Gill Street house

WA8405 309 N. Gill Street house

WA8406 310 N. Gill Street house

WA8407 313 N. Gill Street house

WA8408 221 W. Franklin Street house

WA8409 204 E. Sycamore Street Ora Gay House

WA8410 202 E. Sycamore Street duplex

WA8411 200 E. Sycamore Street house

WA8412 403 N. Wakefield Street Creech House

WA8413 201 N. Poplar Street house

WA8414 201 E. Sycamore Street house

WA8415 119 E. Sycamore Street house

WA8416 115 E. Sycamore Street house

WA8417 113 E. Sycamore Street house

WA8418 116 W. Glenn Street A.C. Lowery House

WA8419 309 W. Glenn Street Zebulon Swimming Pool

WA8420 108 E. Sycamore Street house

WA8421 112 E. Sycamore Street house

WA8422 208 E. Sycamore Street Phillip F. and Louis M. Massey House

WA8423 201 N. Whitley Street duplex

WA8424 202 N. Whitley Street house

WA8425 203 N. Whitley Street house

WA8426 306 N. Poplar Street house

WA8433 200 block W. Lee Street (209, 210, 211, 216, 217, 218, and 219 W. Lee Street)

houses

WA8434 112 W. Lee Street Allman House

WA8435 110 W. Lee Street house

WA8436 108 W. Lee Street house

WA8437 107 W. Lee Street house

WA8438 109 W. Lee Street house

WA8439 115 W. Lee Street house

Street Adress Property NameSite File Number

�3

Page 38: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WA8440 100-109 W. Judd Street multiple buildings

WA8441 115-117 W. Judd Street duplex

WA8442 119 W. Judd Street house

WA8443 911 N. Church Street Tant-Lee House

WA8444 908 N. Church Street Irby and Barbara Liggins House

WA8445 906 N. Church Street house

WA8446 901 N. Church Street Hepler House

WA8447 900 N. Church Street Debnam House

WA8448 204 W. McIver Street Nathaniel Grogan House

WA8449 208 W. McIver Street Willie and Patricia Griswold House

WA8451 219 W. McIver Street Crofton and Ruby Hudson House

WA8452 217 W. McIver Street house

WA8453 215 W. McIver Street Lawrence and Jean Liles House

WA8454 207 W. McIver Street house

WA8455 116 W. McIver Street house

WA8456 114 W. McIver Street house

WA8457 110 W. McIver Street house

WA8458 801 N. Wakefield Street Zebulon Baptist Parsonage

WA8459 109-111 W. McIver Street duplex

WA8460 115 W. McIver Street house

WA8461 117 W. McIver Street house

WA8462 808 N. Wakefield Street Bowling House

WA8463 804 N. Wakefield Street Garland and Maebelle Richardson House

WA8464 802 N. Wakefield Street Joyner House

WA8465 811 N. Church Street house

WA8466 813 N. Church Street duplex

WA8467 812 N. Church Street J. Thurman and Elizabeth Murray House

WA8468 808 N. Church Street Ashley and Virma Murphy House

WA8469 800 N. Church Street Wilbert T. Debnam House

WA8470 715 N. Wakefield Street W. Horace and Margaret B. Gay House

WA8471 307 W. Franklin Street George F. and Frances A. Tucker House

WA8472 302 W. Franklin Street Narvil and Sue Gill House

WA8473 223 W. Franklin Street Willie M. and Jane R. Brannan House

Street Adress Property NameSite File Number

�4

Page 39: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WA8474 224 W. Franklin Street Claude Everton Pearce House

WA8475 220 W. Franklin Street George R. Massey House

WA8476 219 W. Franklin Street Massey-Jordan-Morton House

WA8477 216 W. Franklin Street Ronald and Ruby Perry House

WA8478 215 W. Franklin Street house

WA8479 112 W. Franklin Street Vinson House

WA8480 115 W. Franklin Street Herman and Rebecca Jones House

WA8481 110 W. Franklin Street house

WA8482 111 W. Franklin Street Herbert C. Perry House

WA8483 712 N. Church Street Charles P. and Lucile Olive House

WA8484 109 W. Franklin Street house

WA8485 700 N. Church Street house

WA8486 715 N. Church Street George and Mary Temple House

WA8487 612 N. Church Street house

WA8488 709 N. Church Street house

WA8489 613 N. Church Street W. Ray and Annie Goodwin House

WA8490 701 N. Church Street Max and Wilma Williams House

WA8491 708 N. Wakefield Street house

WA8492 707 N. Wakefield Street house

WA8493 704 N. Wakefield Street Harold and Peggy Debnam House

WA8494 701 N. Wakefield Street house

WA8495 700 N. Wakefield Street Wayne and Patsy Davis House

WA8496 689 N. Wakefield Street C.V. Whitley Memorial Park

WA8497 612 N. Wakefield Street Beck House

WA8498 119 W. Glenn Street Haywood and Gladys Jones House

WA8499 600 N. Wakefield Street J.R. and Roslyn Alford House

WA8500 211 W. Glenn Street house

WA8501 209 W. Glenn Street house

WA8502 502 Flowers Avenue Berry and Eleanor Williams House

WA8503 207 W. Glenn Street house

WA8504 205 W. Glenn Street Dawson House

WA8505 202 W. Glenn Street house

WA8506 204 W. Glenn Street Zebulon Methodist Parsonage

Street Adress Property NameSite File Number

�5

Page 40: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WA8507 208 W. Glenn Street house

WA8508 115 W. Glenn Street house

WA8509 108 W. Glenn Street Wood House

WA8510 111 W. Glenn Street house

WA8511 112 W. Glenn Street house

WA8512 109 W. Glenn Street house

WA8513 110 W. Glenn Street house

WA8514 107 W. Glenn Street house

WA8515 104 W. Glenn Street house

WA8516 611 N. Church Street Zyba K. Massey House

WA8517 112 W. North Street house

WA8518 607 N. Church Street Thomas and Hazel Monk House

WA8519 116 W. North Street house

WA8520 513 N. Church Street house

WA8521 120 W. North Street Braswell House

WA8522 509 N. Church Street Roger and Rebecca Baker House

WA8523 200 W. North Street house

WA8524 113 W. North Street house

WA8525 204 W. North Street house

WA8526 117 W. North Street house

WA8527 206 W. North Street house

WA8528 121 W. North Street house

WA8529 208 W. North Street house

WA8530 201 W. North Street house

WA8531 221 W. North Street Campen House

WA8532 209 W. North Street house

WA8533 512 N. Wakefield Street Francis and Jean Wall House

WA8534 213 W. North Street duplex

WA8535 506 N. Wakefield Street Davis House

WA8536 217 W. North Street duplex

WA8537 406 N. Wakefield Street house

WA8538 300 W. North Street house

WA8539 405 N. Wakefield Street house

Street Adress Property NameSite File Number

�6

Page 41: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WA8540 309 W. North Street Oden and Julia Spivey House

WA8541 112 W. Gannon Avenue house

WA8542 407 N. Wakefield Street Robertson House

WA8543 120 W. Gannon Avenue house

WA8544 205 W. Gannon Avenue Elwood and Cleo Perry House

WA8545 204 W. Gannon Avenue McNabb House

WA8546 107 W. Sycamore Street house

WA8547 108 W. Sycamore Street house

WA8548 109 W. Sycamore Street house

WA8549 110 W. Sycamore Street house

WA8550 111 W. Sycamore Street house

WA8551 114 W. Sycamore Street house

WA8552 113 W. Sycamore Street J.C. and Hazel Debnam House

WA8553 118 W. Sycamore Street house

WA8554 115 W. Sycamore Street Duke Earl House

WA8555 303 N. Church Street house

WA8556 117 W. Sycamore Street house

WA8557 301 N. Church Street house

WA8558 119 W. Sycamore Street house

WA8559 204 W. Sycamore Street house

WA8560 201 W. Sycamore Street Pearce House

WA8561 206 W. Sycamore Street house

WA8562 205 W. Sycamore Street house

WA8563 208 W. Sycamore Street house

WA8564 207 W. Sycamore Street J. Massey House

WA8565 210 W. Sycamore Street house

WA8566 209 W. Sycamore Street house

WA8567 212 W. Sycamore Street house

WA8568 211 W. Sycamore Street house

WA8569 214 W. Sycamore Street house

WA8570 213 W. Sycamore Street W.M. Strickland House

WA8571 223 W. Sycamore Street Richard Scarboro House

WA8572 215 W. Sycamore Street house

Street Adress Property NameSite File Number

�7

Page 42: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WA8573 221 W. Sycamore Street house

WA8574 217 W. Sycamore Street house

WA8575 301 N. Wakefield Street Jenkins House

WA8576 219 W. Sycamore Street Charles D. Collins House

WA8577 305 N. Wakefield Street Robert Hobgood Jenkins House

WA8578 301 W. Sycamore Street Norman and Helen Screws House

WA8579 300 W. Gannon Avenue house

WA8580 304 N. Wakefield Street Randolph S. Hendricks House

WA8581 304 W. Gannon Avenue house

WA8582 221 W. Gannon Avenue house

WA8583 308 W. Gannon Avenue Mann House

WA8584 301 W. Gannon Avenue Kannon House

WA8585 402 W. Gannon Avenue house

WA8586 303 W. Gannon Avenue E.T. Jones House

WA8587 310 W. North Street duplex

WA8588 309 W. Gannon Avenue house

WA8589 111 W. Judd Street apartments

WA8590 313 W. Gannon Avenue house

WA8591 101 W. Vance Street Zebulon Supply Company

WA8592 113 W. Vance Street commercial building

WA8593 115 W. Vance Street commercial building

WA8594 117 W. Vance Street commercial building

WA8595 121 W. Vance Street commercial building

WA8596 116 W. Vance Street commercial building

WA8597 120 W. Vance Street commercial building

WA8598 124 W. Vance Street commercial building

WA8599 105 S. Arendell Avenue commercial building

WA8600 100 E. Vance Street commercial building

WA8601 103 N. Arendell Avenue Kannon’s Cafe

WA8602 111 N. Arendell Avenue Antone’s Department Store

WA8603 104 W. Horton Street commercial building

WA8604 106 W. Horton Street commercial building

WA8605 109 S. Arendell Avenue commercial building

Street Adress Property NameSite File Number

�8

Page 43: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WA8606 118 E. Lee Street Zebulon Lion’s Club

WA8607 110 E. Horton Street commercial building

WA8608 109 E. Horton Street Zebulon Community Library

WA8609 107 E. Horton Street commercial building

WA8610 103 E. Horton Street commercial building

WA8611 101 E. Horton Street commercial building

WA8612 104 E. Horton Street commercial building

WA8613 203 N. Arendell Avenue commercial building

WA8614 207 N. Arendell Avenue commercial building

WA8615 209 N. Arendell Avenue commercial building

WA8616 215 N. Arendell Avenue commercial building

WA8617 217 N. Ardendell Avenue commercial building

WA8618 219 N. Arendell Avenue commercial building

WA8619 221 N. Arendell Avenue commercial building

WA8620 225 N. Arendell Avenue commercial building

WA8621 229 N. Arendell Avenue commercial building

WA8622 109 E. Lee Street Winstead House

WA8623 105 E. Lee Street house

WA8624 114 E. Lee Street Strickland House

WA8625 110 E. Lee Street house

WA8626 106 E. Lee Street Eugene Privette House

WA8627 700 N. Arendell Avenue house

WA8628 713 N. Arendell Avenue Carter House

WA8629 709 N. Arendell Avenue house

WA8630 705 N. Arendell Avenue Hopkins House

WA8631 701 N. Ardendell Avenue Hocut House

WA8632 128 N. Ardendell Avenue commercial building

WA8633 124 N. Arendell Avenue commercial building

WA8634 122 N. Arendell Avenue Caviness Building

WA8635 120 N. Arendell Avenue Caviness Building

WA8636 114 N. Arendell Avenue commercial building

WA8637 110 N. Arendell Avenue commercial building

WA8638 108 N. Arendell Avenue commercial building

Street Adress Property NameSite File Number

�9

Page 44: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WA8639 104 N. Arendell Avenue commercial building

WA8641 113 N. Arendell Avenue commercial building

WA8642 115 N. Arendell Avenue commercial building

WA8643 117 N. Arendell Avenue Debnam Hardware

WA8644 407 N. Arendell Avenue house

WA8645 107 E. North Street house

WA8646 501 N. Arendell Avenue house

WA8647 500 N. Arendell Avenue house

WA8648 505 N. Arendell Avenue house

WA8649 504 N. Arendell Avenue Ellington House

WA8650 509 N. Arendell Avenue house

WA8651 510 N. Arendell Avenue Privette House

WA8652 607 N. Arendell Avenue house

WA8653 606-608 N. Arendell Avenue duplex

WA8654 609 N. Arendell Avenue house

WA8655 614 N. Arendell Avenue house

WA8656 611 N. Arendell Avenue house

WA8657 613 N. Arendell Avenue Bridges House

WA8658 103 E. Glenn Street duplex

WA8667 200 N. Arendell Avenue commercial building

WA8668 202 N. Arendell Avenue commercial building

WA8669 204 N. Arendell Avenue commercial building

WA8670 208 N. Arendell Avenue (former)Central Carolina Bank and Trust

WA8671 214 N. Arendell Avenue (former)First Federal Savings and Loan

Street Adress Property NameSite File Number

�10

Page 45: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

APPENDIX B: PROPERTIES SURVEYED OUTSIDE OF PROPOSED NRHP DISTRICT

Page 46: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

Intentionally Left Blank

Page 47: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

Appendix B. Properties Surveyed Outside of Proposed NR District, incl. Multiple Property Forms and Destroyed Properties

Site Number

Address Name Status

WA2068 2225 Zebulon Road Rowland Farm DESTROYED

WA2069 2024 Zebulon Road Theodore Clifton Pippin House

WA2074 1914 Shepard Road Massey-Tippet House

WA2076 10124 Debnam Road Farm complex

WA2077 1300 Old Bunn Road house

WA2078 1709 N. Arendell Ave. Jones-Olive Store

WA2079 Green-Pace Road Herbert Winston House DESTROYED

WA2080 308 Green Pace Road Pace Farm

WA2081 1313 Shepard School Rd. Massey House and Store

WA2082 713 Green-Pace Road house

WA2083 1001 Water Plant Road Parrish House

WA2094 825 E. Horton Street house

WA2095 Highway 96 farm complex DESTROYED

WA2096 321 Perry Curtis Road house

WA2097 240 Perry Curtis Road house

WA2099 500 S. Wakefield Street Horton House

WA2104 113 Proctor Road Sherron House

WA2105 200 Proctor Street Nolan House

WA2106 214 Proctor Street Foster Proctor House

WA2107 212 Proctor Street Foster Proctor House DESTROYED

WA2108 302 Foster Street White Stone Masonic Lodge

WA2109 Stringfield-Ferrell Memorial

WA2110 301 Proctor Street Dr. G.M. Bell House

WA2111 300 Pearces Road J.A. Kemp House

WA2112 204 Pearces Road David Sanford Joyner House DESTROYED

WA2113 102 Pearces Road John Kemp House DESTROYED

WA2114 502 Pearces Road Horton-Kimball House

WA2115 511 Pearces Road house

WA2116 601 Pearces Road Stringfield-Pippin House

WA2117 613 Pearces Road Starkey-Hoyle House

WA2118 701 Pearces Road Earlie-Green House

WA2119 728 Pearces Road Bunn-Tant House DESTROYED

WA2120 no address, cemetery Wakefield Cemetery

WA2121 1009 Pearces Road house

WA2122 1017 Magnum Road Stringfield-Massey House

Site Number

�1

Page 48: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WA2123 809 Proctor Street Wakefield Missionary Baptist Church, Mt. Pigsah Lodge and Cemetery

WA2124 Wakefield Multiple Property File

WA2183 300-500 Blk. S. Arendell Ave. MULTIPLE PROPERTIES FORM

WA2184 406 S. Arendell Avenue John D. Horton Farm

WA2185 100 Blk. N. Arendell Ave., E. Side MULTIPLE PROPERTIES FORM

WA2186 200 Blk. N. Arendell Ave., E. side MULTIPLE PROPERTIES FORM

WA2187 200 Blk. N. Arendell Ave., W. side

MULTIPLE PROPERTIES FORM

WA2188 100 Blk. N. Arendell Ave., W. Side

MULTIPLE PROPERTIES FORM

WA2190 100 Blk. W. Vance St. MULTIPLE PROPERTIES FORM

WA2192 100 Blk. E. Horton St. MULTIPLE PROPERTIES FORM

WA2193 100 Blk. W. Horton St. MULTIPLE PROPERTIES FORM

WA2195 S. Wakefield Street Zebulon Cotton Gin DESTROYED

WA2196 323. W. Barbee Street house

WA2197 204 S. Wakefield St. house

WA2199 219 W. Barbee St. house

WA2200 202 E. Vance St. Zebulon Lighting and Water Works

WA2201 201 E. Vance St. Davis House DESTROYED

WA2202 300 Blk. E. Horton St. MULTIPLE PROPERTIES FORM

WA2203 100/200 Blk. E. Horton St. MULTIPLE PROPERTIES FORM

WA2206 200 Blk. W. Sycamore St. MULTIPLE PROPERTIES FORM

WA2207 100 Blk. W. Sycamore MULTIPLE PROPERTIES FORM

WA2208 100 Blk. E. Sycamore MULTIPLE PROPERTIES FORM

WA2209 200 Blk. E. Sycamore MULTIPLE PROPERTIES FORM

WA2214 400 N. Arendell Ave. Zebulon Baptist Church DESTROYED

WA2215 400 Blk. N. Arendell Ave. MULTIPLE PROPERTIES FORM

WA2218 600/700 Blk. N. Arendell Ave. MULTIPLE PROPERTIES FORM

WA2223 100 Blk. N. Glenn Street MULTIPLE PROPERTIES FORM

WA2224 105 W. Gannon Avenue Gill Motor Co. DESTROYED

WA2226 100/200 Blk. W. Gannon Avenue MULTIPLE PROPERTIES FORM

WA2227 300 Blk. W. Gannon Avenue MULTIPLE PROPERTIES FORM

WA2240 100/200 Blk. W. North Street MULTIPLE PROPERTIES FORM

WA2241 1000 Shepard School Road Zebulon Middle school DESTROYED

WA2242 900 Shepard School Road (former Zebulon Elementary School

WA2243 600 N. Privette Street Zebulon Town Cemetery

WA2245 327 E. Stronach Avenue Mt. Holiness Church

Address Name StatusSite Number

�2

Page 49: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WA3699 801 Mack Todd Road (former) Zebulon Depot MOVED

WA3700 S.R. 2351 Corbet House DESTROYED

WA4419 301 S. Arendell Avenue National Guard Armory

WA4765 1216 Shepard School Road house

WA4766 148 E. Vance Street Colonial Frozen Foods

WA4831 916 S. Arendell Ave. Rochelle and Luther Long House DESTROYED

WA4832 729 S. Arendell Ave. house DESTROYED

WA4834 Shepard School Road Dr. Luther Massey Barn DESTROYED

WA4835 1311 Old Bunn Road Joyner Family farm

WA4850 401 Moss Road Pearce Farm

WA8427 300 S. Arendell Avenue house

WA8428 308 S. Arendell Avenue house

WA8429 314 S. Arendell Avenue Corbett House

WA8430 307 S. Arendell Avenue Chamblee House

WA8431 402 S. Arendell Avenue house

WA8432 510 S. Arendell Avenue house

WA8450 210 W. McIver Street house

WA8640 1309 Old Bunn Road house

WA8659 200 Blk. W. Barbee St. houses

WA8660 308 Proctor Street Wakefield Central Baptist Church

WA8661 405 S. Arendell Avenue house

WA8662 407 S. Arendell Avenue house

WA8663 409 S. Arendell Avenue Rebecca Horton House

WA8664 310 E. Gannon Avenue house

WA8665 400 E. Gannon Avenue Devil Dog Dungarees

WA8666 411 E. Stronach Avenue house

WA8672 120 E. Gannon Avenue house

WA8673 122 E. Gannon Avenue house

WA8674 124 E. Gannon Avenue house

WA8675 113 Proctor Street house

WA8676 808 W. Barbee Street house

WA8677 2500 Rosinburg Rd. house DESTROYED

WA8678 E. Horton Street outbuildings DESTROYED

WA8679 E. Horton Street Farm complex DESTROYED

WA8680 333 Perry Curtis Road house

WA8681 1624 Old Bunn Road house

WA8682 1729 N. Arendell Ave. Brannan Auto Repair

Address Name StatusSite Number

�3

Page 50: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WA8683 0 Morphus Bridge Rd Pleasant Grove Bapt. Ch. Cem

WA8684 813 Moss Road house

WA8685 1319 Pulley-Gordon Rd Paul #1 Church of Christ

WA8686 2132 Morphus Bridge Rd Moss House

WA8687 0 S. Wakefield St Horton Family Cemetery

WA8688 Zebulon Historic District

Address Name StatusSite Number

�4

Page 51: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

APPENDIX C: MAP OF PROPOSED ZEBULON NRHP DISTRICT WITH SITE FILE NUMBERS

Page 52: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

Intentionally Left Blank

Page 53: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WA8585

W Gannon Ave

Stratford Dr

Mack Todd Rd

W Franklin St

0 100 200 Feet

0 25 50 Meters

Proposed ZebulonHistoric District Boundary

Resources

Page 1 of 21

Page 54: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WA2239

WA2238

WA8585

WA8588

WA8583

WA8590

WA8586

WA8581WA8579

WA8577

WA8575WA8475

WA8584

WA8540

W Gannon Ave

W Sycamore St

N Rotary Dr

N Rotary St

N Liberty St

0 100 200 Feet

0 25 50 Meters

Proposed ZebulonHistoric District Boundary

Resources

Page 2 of 21

Page 55: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WA8582

WA8475WA8575

WA2230

WA8577

WA2231

WA8571

WA8563

WA8584 WA8567

WA8565

WA8561

WA8569

WA8580

WA8572

WA8573

WA8576

WA8568

WA8574

WA8570

WA8566

WA8559

WA8578

WA8588

WA8586

WA8557

WA8564

WA8579WA8555WA2229WA2232

N Wakefield St

W Horton St

W Sycamore St

W Gannon Ave

0 100 200 Feet

0 25 50 Meters

Proposed ZebulonHistoric District Boundary

Resources

Page 3 of 21

Page 56: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WA8557

WA8562

WA8560

WA8558

WA8564

WA8556

WA8552WA8554

WA8597

WA8566

WA8615

WA8550 WA8616

WA2194

WA8598

WA8617

WA8604WA8603

WA8559

WA8596

WA8548

WA8568

WA8618WA8553WA8555

WA8614

W Horton St

W Vance St

N Church St

W Sycamore St

0 100 200 Feet

0 25 50 Meters

Proposed ZebulonHistoric District Boundary

Resources

Page 4 of 21

Page 57: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WA8605

WA8388

WA8591

WA8607WA8389

WA8597

WA8643

WA8615

WA8633

WA8611

WA8387WA8669

WA2194

WA8596

WA8593WA8592

WA8594

WA3194

WA8667

WA8610

WA8595

WA8632

WA8634

WA8600

WA2189WA8612

WA8642

WA8601

WA8641

WA8599

WA8603

WA8635

WA8614

WA8637

WA8613

WA8668WA8616

WA8636

WA8638

WA8609

WA8639

WA8598

WA8604

E Vance St

S Arendell Ave

N Arendell AveW Vance St

E Horton St

E Barbee Ave

W Horton St

W Barbee St

0 100 200 Feet

0 25 50 Meters

Proposed ZebulonHistoric District Boundary

Resources

Page 5 of 21

Page 58: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WA8605

E Barbee Ave

E Vance St

N Poplar St

0 100 200 Feet

0 25 50 Meters

Proposed ZebulonHistoric District Boundary

Resources

Page 6 of 21

Page 59: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WA8496

WA8419

WA2239

WA8496

WA8535

WA2221

WA8540

WA2222

WA8537

WA8499

WA8500

WA8533

WA8587

WA8542

WA8583

WA8538

WA8539

WA8581WA8579

WA8412

WA8507

WA8529

WA2232

WA8501

WA8531

WA2238

W North St

N Wakefield St

W Glenn St

N Flowers Ave

0 100 200 Feet

0 25 50 Meters

Proposed ZebulonHistoric District Boundary

Resources

Page 7 of 21

Page 60: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WA2230

WA2232

WA2236

WA2233

WA2234

WA2235

WA8522

WA2229

WA2237

WA8545

WA8525

WA8544

WA8528

WA8526

WA2228

WA8543

WA8530

WA8582

WA8534

WA8521

WA8529

WA8537

WA8527

WA8536

WA8531

WA8532

WA8519

WA8501

WA8502 WA8523

WA8503

WA8555

WA8524

WA8559

WA8517

WA8561

WA8504

WA8563 WA8557WA2231

WA2222

WA2225

WA8500

WA8579

WA8565

WA8498

WA8535

WA2216

W North St

N Church St

W Gannon Ave

N Flowers Ave

N Wakefield St

0 100 200 Feet

0 25 50 Meters

Proposed ZebulonHistoric District Boundary

Resources

Page 8 of 21

Page 61: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WA8541

WA2225

WA2216

WA8524

WA8549

WA8551

WA8547

WA8644

WA8620

WA8557

WA8550

WA8555WA8553

WA8552

WA8548

WA8546

WA8543

WA2228

WA8526

WA8554

WA8621

WA8615WA8556

WA2217

WA8616

WA8617WA8618

WA8619

WA8671

WA8517

WA8558WA8559

N Arendell Ave

W Sycamore St

W Gannon Ave

N Church St

E Gannon Ave

W North St

E Sycamore St

0 100 200 Feet

0 25 50 Meters

Proposed ZebulonHistoric District Boundary

Resources

Page 9 of 21

Page 62: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WA8414

WA2213

WA8388

WA8670

WA2210

WA2211

WA2212

WA8393

WA8671

WA8426

WA8413

WA8422

WA8415

WA8417

WA8416

WA8402

WA8420

WA8421

WA8405

WA8411

WA8384

WA8383

WA8410

WA8409

WA8386

WA8387

WA8382

WA8390

WA8385

WA8669WA8668

WA8404

WA8611 WA8389WA8607

WA8615

WA8392

WA8610

WA8667

WA8608

WA8616WA8609

WA8407

WA8617

WA8669WA8668

WA8618

WA8401

WA8619

WA8614

WA8620 N Poplar St

E Sycamore St

E Horton St

N G

ill St

E Gannon Ave

N Arendell Ave

0 100 200 Feet

0 25 50 Meters

Proposed ZebulonHistoric District Boundary

Resources

Page 10 of 21

Page 63: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WA8367

WA8376

WA8368

WA8372

WA2204

WA8385

WA8422

WA8423WA8369

WA8398

WA8377

WA8401

WA8399

WA8370

WA8371

WA8373

WA8402

WA8381

WA8404

WA8382

WA8380

WA8378

WA8379

WA8375

WA8396

WA8394

WA8395

WA8424

WA8397

WA8425

WA8403

WA8383

WA8409

WA8406

WA8386

E Horton St

N Whitley St

E Vance St

E Sycamore St

N Poplar St

0 100 200 Feet

0 25 50 Meters

Proposed ZebulonHistoric District Boundary

Resources

Page 11 of 21

Page 64: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WA8433

WA8433

WA8496

WA8488

WA8507

WA8478

WA8497

WA8499

WA8494

WA8506

WA8408

WA8486WA8475

WA8476

WA8474

WA8477

WA8490

WA8505

WA8473

WA8495

WA8493

WA8491

WA8492

WA8464

WA8483

WA8489

WA8451

WA8470

WA8463

WA8501

WA8516

WA8391

WA8485

WA8452

WA8500

W Lee St

W Franklin St

N Wakefield St

N Church St

W Glenn St

0 100 200 Feet

0 25 50 Meters

Proposed ZebulonHistoric District Boundary

Resources

Page 12 of 21

Page 65: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WA8485

WA8439

WA8518

WA8487

WA8505

WA8498

WA8511

WA8510

WA8418

WA8513

WA8508

WA8434

WA8509

WA8483

WA8519

WA8517

WA2217

WA8657

WA8438

WA8522

WA8489

WA8655

WA8631

WA8516

WA8656

WA8650

WA8504

WA8520

WA8654

WA8652

WA8503WA8521

WA8480

WA8648

WA8490

WA8501

WA8653

WA8515

WA8512WA8514

WA8437

WA8435WA8436

WA8433

WA8506

WA8482 WA8630

WA8488

WA8627

WA8646

W Lee St

W Glenn StN Church St

N Arendell AveE Lee St

0 100 200 Feet

0 25 50 Meters

Proposed ZebulonHistoric District Boundary

Resources

Page 13 of 21

Page 66: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WA8651

WA8646

WA8658

WA8653

WA8626

WA8606

WA2217

WA8647

WA8648

WA8655

WA8645

WA8625

WA8650

WA8649

WA8624

WA2216

WA8517

WA8652

WA8644

WA8514

N Arendell Ave

E North St

N Poplar St

W North St

E Glenn St

W Glenn St

E Glenn St

0 100 200 Feet

0 25 50 Meters

Proposed ZebulonHistoric District Boundary

Resources

Page 14 of 21

Page 67: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WA8407

WA8426

WA8405 WA8404

WA8406

WA2213 WA8402

N G

ill St

N Pitt St

E North StN Poplar St

E Gannon Ave

Shepard School Rd

E Stronach Ave

E Glenn St

0 100 200 Feet

0 25 50 Meters

Proposed ZebulonHistoric District Boundary

Resources

Page 15 of 21

Page 68: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WA8406

WA8404WA8398 WA8394WA8402 WA8367

N W

hitle

y St

E North St

N G

ill St

E Gannon Ave

E Sycamore St

E Stronach Ave

0 100 200 Feet

0 25 50 Meters

Proposed ZebulonHistoric District Boundary

Resources

Page 16 of 21

Page 69: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WA8449

WA8451

WA8462

WA8463

WA8448

WA8452

WA8464

W Judd St

N Wakefield St

W McIver St

0 100 200 Feet

0 25 50 Meters

Proposed ZebulonHistoric District Boundary

Resources

Page 17 of 21

Page 70: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WA8446

WA8391

WA8448

WA8374

WA8447

WA8441

WA8465

WA8468

WA8454

WA8453

WA8466

WA8456

WA8452

WA8457

WA8460

WA8589

WA8443

WA8451

WA8467

WA8449

WA8469

WA8444

WA8483

WA8445

WA8440

WA8442

WA8477

WA0048 WA2219

WA8475

WA8479

WA8486

WA8455

WA8459

WA8461

WA8463WA8464

N Church St

W McIver St

W Judd St

W Franklin St

0 100 200 Feet

0 25 50 Meters

Proposed ZebulonHistoric District Boundary

Resources

Page 18 of 21

Page 71: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WA8629

WA8481

WA8479

WA8480

WA8627

WA8483

WA8628

WA8484

WA8630WA8482

WA8631

WA8460

WA2219

WA8623

WA8655WA8434

WA8459

WA8374

WA8436WA8435

WA8469

WA8457

WA8485

N Arendell Ave

E McIver St

W Franklin St

E Franklin St

W McIver St

E Lee St

0 100 200 Feet

0 25 50 Meters

Proposed ZebulonHistoric District Boundary

Resources

Page 19 of 21

Page 72: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WA8606

WA8623

WA8622

WA8624

WA8625WA8626

WA8627

WA8655

N Lee St

E Lee St

E Franklin St

N Poplar St

E McIver St Shepard School Rd

0 100 200 Feet

0 25 50 Meters

Proposed ZebulonHistoric District Boundary

Resources

Page 20 of 21

Page 73: Wake County Architectural Survey Update, Phase IV...area, and the Falls Lake Water Supply Watershed of Northwest Wake County. The results were ... landscape of farms and small towns

WA0048

WA2219

WA8440WA8589

WA8441WA8442

N Arendell Ave

W Judd St

Apothecary Dr

Wakelon St

0 100 200 Feet

0 25 50 Meters

Proposed ZebulonHistoric District Boundary

Resources

Page 21 of 21