Upload
others
View
5
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Spring 2012
_________
Vol. III No. 2
UIC Bioengineering Student Journal
UBSJ
University of
Illinois at Chicago
Bioengineering Student Journal
Spring 2012 Vol. III No. 2
CHIEF EDITOR
Carson Ingo
EDITORS Cierra M. Hall
Benjamin L. Schwartz
REVIEWERS Lara Ansari
Helen Ashaye Aimee Bobko
Nikhil Bommakanti Rudhram Gajendran
Mina Khalil Noman A. Khan
Andre Paredes Rachna Parwani
Dan Yu Julia Zelenakova
COVER ARTIST Lara Ansari
FACULTY ADVISOR Professor Richard L. Magin
Contact: [email protected]
phone: (312) 996 – 2335 fax: (312) 996 - 5921 UIC Bioengineering Student Journal
Department of Bioengineering, University of Illinois at Chicago, Science & Engineering Offices (SEO), Room 218 (M/C 063)
UBSJ IS A UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS AT CHICAGO BIOENGINEERING
STUDENT PUBLICATION
UIC Bioengineering Student Journal Spring 2012
Vol. III No.2
Contents
Foreword
i
TAILORING THE RF PULSE: A SURVEY OF PULSE SHAPE EFFECTS
ON MAGNETIZATION WITH FOCUS ON RECT AND SINC PULSES
Lara Ansari
1
THE ROLE AND IMPACT OF ULTRASOUND GUIDED
TECHNOLOGY FOR REGIONAL ANESTHESIA PLACEMENT
Aimee Bobko
6
A REVIEW OF APPLICATIONS USING CURRENT MRI TECHNOLOGIES
Noman Ali Khan
12
BASICS OF MAGNETOENCEPHALOGRAPHY AND ITS
APPLICATIONS AS AN EXPERIMENTAL TOOL
Vu Nguyen
17
MEDICAL SIMULATIONS OF INTRATHECAL MORPHINE
FOR PAIN CONTROL AND MANAGEMENT
Jamie M. Stewart
21
APPLICATION OF NUCLEAR MAGNETIC
RESONANCE IN POROUS MEDIA
Dan Yu
26
VIEWING INTERVERTEBRAL DISC PROPERTIES OF
RODENT ANIMALS THROUGH MORPHOLOGY AND MRI
Julia Zelenakova
32
Call For Papers
37
Image Credits 38
i
Foreword
I am very lucky to have been a part of the editorial board of this journal, a wholly student-driven
publication that demonstrates the caliber of instruction and atmosphere of cooperation within the
department of Bioengineering at the University of Illinois at Chicago. Publications in peer-
reviewed journals are the coin of the realm in Academia, so it behooves bioengineering students
to hone this craft just as they would, e.g. mathematical analysis. The rigorous review process
each author must navigate—and which each reviewer must exact—has made for invaluable
practice in both scientific writing and the critiquing thereof. To my knowledge, a publication of
this nature is rare among engineering programs in American universities, highlighting the role
UIC has played in leading the charge of bringing the discipline of bioengineering the formal
recognition it now enjoys globally. It is my wish that our work—writing, editing, reviewing—
will inspire students to contribute their time and effort to future issues of this journal that it may
become an even brighter example of the good science we do here. Finally, I hope that this
journal serves, in part, as the face of UIC Bioengineering. Prospective students will see not only
the vast ocean of knowledge open to them, but that their learning and growth as engineers is
recognized and celebrated by our community. Prospective faculty, by reading the UBSJ, will see
a department that engenders cooperation among researchers, instructors, and students, alike. My
deep thanks go to all the students who have helped to make this issue a reality. We are all now
part of something larger than ourselves and our sum.
Benjamin L. Schwartz
Editor
1
TAILORING THE RF PULSE: A SURVEY OF PULSE SHAPE EFFECTS
ON MAGNETIZATION WITH FOCUS ON RECT AND SINC PULSES Lara Ansari
Abstract Radiofrequency (RF) pulse design is an active research focus for many engineers and scientists
studying MRI and its advancement. Particularly, the shape of the RF pulse is of vast importance to
the reconstruction of images in k-space using Fourier Tansforms (FT), as well as the optimization
of signal transduction and correction of magnetic field inhomogeneities for high-field applications.
In this paper, a brief overview of the different types of RF pulses and algorithms commonly used
today are introduced, highlighting the RECT and SINC pulse shapes in both their physical
interactions with the magnetization vector, as well as their respective mathematical descriptions.
An overview of the basic factors influencing RF pulse design and the considerations taken when
concerned with high magnetic field applications is also presented here. The concept of Specific
Absorption Rate (SAR) is addressed as a clinical example of the importance of diversity in RF
pulse tailoring methods, as certain design algorithms such as the Shinnar-LeRoux (SLR)
algorithm for arbitrary tip angles and the design of more specific pulse shapes can influence SAR.
Programming applications such as MATLAB are discussed in their relevance to the advancement
of the field, and reference to Amir Stricker’s work in designing an RF pulse design toolkit for
MATLAB is presented. This paper is predominantly concerned with basic RF pulse shape effects
on magnetization of spins due to the variable characteristics of the pulse shape itself—and thus
the basis for customized tailoring of RF pulses with SLR, though the discussion here is not
concerned with the explanation of the SLR algorithm or other means of shaping RF pulses beyond
the RECT or SINC forms.
Keywords: RF Pulses, pulse sequences, SLR Algorithm, SINC, RECT, pulse shaping, SAR,
MATLAB, nuclear induction, frequency profiling, FWHM
1. Introduction
When a patient is subjected to a homogeneous,
constant magnetic field, B0, the net magnetization of
the protons aligned in his body lies upon the z-axis in
the direction of the field (assuming the +z-axis points
head-to-toe of the patient, the +x-axis left-to-right,
and the +y-axis back-to-front).
In order to communicate with these protons in
precession and generate a response in the form of an
―echo‖ capable of being detected by the receiving
radiofrequency coil, a pulsed magnetic field must be
applied in order to perturb the proton spins such that
they are forced out of their equilibrium state at the
precessing (Larmor) frequency. Due to this
perturbation, the protons are forced to return to
equilibrium while releasing the energy absorbed
during their original deflection from the z-axis. This
energy in the form of a radiofrequency wave can then
be received by the detecting radiofrequency coil.
If energy in the radiofrequency region of the
electromagnetic spectrum is released as the protons
are returned to equilibrium, the communicating
pulsed magnetic field must be carried by a
radiofrequency pulse.
A radiofrequency (RF) pulse can be described by the
following characteristics [4]:
(1) Its pulse amplitude – A1(t)
(2) Its pulse envelope – E1(t)
(3) The pulse carrier frequency – ω1
(4) The pulse duration – τ
Each RF pulse characteristic is vital to the
communication of information that allows one to
manipulate the net magnetization of multiple nuclei
precessing in a constant magnetic field, such as that
within the patient previously mentioned.
The RF Envelope is a slowly varying function in the
time domain with respect to the carrier frequency,
and comprises the shape of the radiofrequency pulse
[1]. It is a result of filtering the RF waveform in order
Tailoring the RF Pulse: A Survey of Pulse Shape Effects on Magnetization—L. Ansari
2
to restrict its effective bandwidth between two
frequency boundaries.
The RF pulsed waveform generated by the actual RF
coil of the MRI hardware is a higher-frequency
―carrier‖ waveform that modulates (or multiplies) the
RF envelope waveform. This RF carrier frequency is
what is set to the proton’s Larmor frequency, with an
offset of ±Δf, the pulse bandwidth, and is what allows
only select protons comprising a specific slice
location to respond to the RF pulse. The pulse
duration can be described as the pulse width, and is
measured in units of seconds.
Another parameter that may characterize an RF pulse
is in terms of the flip angle (α) it is capable of
inducing in the net magnetization vector from
equilibrium [2]. Flip angle is also a parameter
affected by the RF pulse shape, as it can be calculated
as the area contained beneath the RF pulse envelope.
Equation 1, below, illustrates this in terms of E1(t)
(the pulse envelope), A1(t) (the pulse amplitude), τ
(the pulse duration), and a constant, γ, known as the
gyromagnetic ratio [1,3]:
α = γ = γ A1(t) (1)
The flip angle is represented as the integral of the RF
envelope over a pulse duration of d , multiplied by
the gyromagnetic ratio. From equation 1 it is evident
that the amplitude, A1(t)—or the magnitude of the
pulsed magnetic field at time t for small
approximations of α and , also written as B1(t)—
varies the flip angle directly. This is another manner
in which the shape of an RF pulse determines the
manipulations of the magnetization vector,
illustrating the importance of proper RF pulse
selection and RF pulse design.
The basis and need for RF pulse ―tailoring‖, or
customization, such as by means of methods like the
Shinnar-Leigh-LeRoux (SLR) algorithm, are
presented in this paper through the explanation of
basic RECT and SINC pulse applications and effects
on image characteristics in MRI, as well as through
the acknowledgement of more clinical considerations
such as SAR, and corrections in high-field
applications.
2. Basic Pulses
RF Pulse shaping, tailoring, and manipulating all
simply refer to designing the RF pulse envelope in
such a way as to allow the RF pulse to selectively
excite spins [4] in an effective and anticipated
manner.
Basic pulse shapes include the RECT and SINC
waveforms, SINC being the more commonly used as
opposed to RECT. For applications not requiring
customizability of RF pulses, such as in imaging in
low-fields (clinical field ranges up to 3T), selection
of a common RF pulse such as SINC, Gaussian, or
truncated-SINC can be sufficient to invoke a proper
image for diagnostic purposes.
However, more advanced methods that are intended
for optimizing an RF pulse under highly specific or
more unique cases (such as for field inhomogeneities)
might require design algorithms such as SLR.
The following sections introduce the RECT and
SINC pulses.
2.1 RECT Pulse
The RECT pulse is simply a hard RF pulse with few
practical applications on its own in diagnostic
imaging. Figure 1, below, shows a basic RECT pulse.
Often it is replaced with other ―windowed‖ pulse
shapes such as a half-sine pulse, or even a simple
ramp-shaped RF pulse such as the TRAP pulse, in
order to compensate for waveform discontinuities
often resulting in low-fidelity signals from RF
amplifiers in MRI or other electronic hardware [1].
Figure 1. Representation of a RECT pulse in the time
domain; although it may also be represented in the
frequency domain with preservation of rectangular form.
Aside from the discontinuities dictated by the
mathematical characterization of the RECT pulse, it
is also an infrequently used RF pulse in diagnostic
imaging due to its deficiencies in spatial and spectral
selectivity, arising from its mathematical description.
Yet despite the RECT pulse’s limited use in MRI, it
is often employed in NMR for assessment of
chemical structure. Because RECT RF pulses often
Tailoring the RF Pulse: A Survey of Pulse Shape Effects on Magnetization—L. Ansari
3
interact with the magnetization vector in the absence
of a gradient magnetic field, and because of their
possibility of being applied with exceedingly short
pulse durations (and thus very broad bandwidth in the
frequency domain), multiple spins with varying
resonance frequencies may be influenced—a trait that
is exploited in NMR of chemical structures [3].
2.1.1 Mathematical Description
Equation 2 [1], below, is the mathematical
representation of the RECT function, for which it can
be seen that for time values of t less than half the
pulse width in the time domain (T), RECT is equal to
1—corresponding to an ―on‖ edge pulse—and for t
greater than half the pulse width in the time domain,
RECT is equal to 0—corresponding to an ―off‖ edge
pulse.
(2)
The frequency-domain representation of the RECT
pulse is the SINC pulse, meaning that the SINC pulse
is thus the Fourier Transform (FT) of the RECT pulse.
The frequency-domain representation of the RECT
pulse is shown below in equation 3 [1].
(3)
It is now understood why the excitation bandwidth of
the RECT pulse is so broad for very small pulse
widths; for example, in NMR, in order to yield
quantitative data for chemical structures of interest, it
is important to have as uniform an excitation profile
as possible elicited from the species under study. This
means that as much of the full frequency bandwidth
(or pulse width, T) of the RECT pulse must be able to
fit within the central peak of the SINC profile in the
frequency domain as possible. The only way to
accomplish this is with shorter pulse widths in the
time domain.
2.2 SINC Pulse
Much more applicable to a variety of applications
than the RECT pulse, the SINC--or sin(x)/(x)--pulse
is a soft pulse form consisting of one large central
peak, bounded by a series of smaller decreasing lobes
on either side. A SINC function is shown in Figure 2.
The central peak of the SINC pulse is always twice as
wide as all other lobes and much higher in amplitude
[1].
Figure 2. A SINC pulse in the time domain, with central
peak and two negative and two positive neighboring lobes.
SINC pulses are particularly convenient to use for
small flip angle excitation (α < 90o), as the slice
profile for a small-angle SINC pulse is more
approximately uniform, and is thus considered more
selective using the small-angle approximation than
when trying to use a SINC pulse for α greater than
90o.
2.2.1 Mathematical Description
The shape (RF envelope, E1(t) or B1(t)), of the RF
SINC pulse is given below in Equation 4 [1]:
(
4)
Where: A = Peak amplitude at t = 0
t0 = Width of each side lobe
NL = Number of zeros toward -∞
NR = Number of zeros toward +∞
Because the Fourier Transform of the SINC pulse is
the RECT pulse, this implies that the most uniform
slice profile (or representation in the frequency
domain) can be achieved for a SINC function with
infinitely many ―zeros‖ on the plot of the SINC
function versus time (infinite values of NL and NR).
This is represented in the mathematical description of
the SINC pulse if one notes the domain over which
the nonzero portion of the function is defined.
Time (ms)
B1
Tailoring the RF Pulse: A Survey of Pulse Shape Effects on Magnetization—L. Ansari
4
Simply, the greater the number of lobes on the SINC
pulse function, the more ideal the rendered slice
profile becomes, and thus the more spatially selective
the RF pulse for a particular slice.
Physically, this corresponds to unrealistically long
pulse duration, however, resulting in impractically
long echo (TE) and repetition (TR) times. Normally a
SINC pulse is truncated when used in the clinical
setting, and this is achieved by only allowing the
SINC peak and several neighboring lobes remain to
form the RF envelope [1,3]. Truncating the
neighboring lobes from the positive side of the SINC
function results in shorter TE.
3. Design Considerations
A study conducted by Wang et al. [7] observed that
different RF pulse shapes do have an impact on
certain factors such as flip angle, spatial uniformity,
and slice profile. The authors of the study also
mention the importance of matching the RF pulse
profile with the particular field mapping (flip-angle
mapping) procedure of interest.
RF pulse shaping is important for being able to
correct for inhomogeneities in the static magnetic
fields of high-field (5T-7T) applications. A SINC
pulse is not necessarily always the most ideal
waveform to use, particularly concerning large flip-
angle purposes for angles greater than 90o, since
varying flip angles are more likely to occur on a
greater scale for the same slice under this condition.
Specific Absorption Rate (SAR) is also of concern in
the clinical environment, as RF pulses contribute to
the irradiation of patients due to heat given off by the
RF coil. Because it is the RF transmitting coil that is
exposing the patient to dissipated heat, SAR doses
are administered anywhere that is in range of the RF
coil, and in quantities proportional to the amplitude
of the transmitted RF pulse [2].
SLR-based MRI systems have replaced most SINC
systems [1], since the flexibility and tailoring
capabilities allow SLR to correct for field
inhomogeneities, adjust peak RF pulse amplitudes to
better prevent SAR, and generate more ideal
waveforms designed to excite slice profiles unique to
a specific application.
4. Pulse Modeling and MATLAB Simulating and designing RF pulses in MATLAB is
an indispensible activity for anyone interested in the
generation of novel RF pulse design; whether it is for
the pursuit of improved models and algorithms, or
simply just out of personal interest in the field.
A project published by Amir Stricker [7] shares the
code for producing one’s own RF pulse design and
simulation toolkit for MATLAB. Note that Amir
Stricker’s work was published in 2001, likely for the
2001 version of MATLAB, and thus special attention
must be given to commands which may require to be
modified for later versions of MATLAB.
Amir Stricker’s function toolkit implements the SLR
algorithm to design pulses, and does not provide
―template‖ pulses such as for Gaussian, SINC, or
RECT functions of the common type.
The reader is referred to [7] for demonstrations of the
toolkit’s capabilities. They are not presented in this
paper, as it would require an explanation of the SLR
algorithm, which is not fully within the context of the
discussion presented here.
5. Conclusion
Characteristics of the RF pulse waveform directly
influence the excitation profiles of the irradiated
slices of interest. RF pulses can be described by four
distinct characteristics; A1(t), the pulse amplitude;
E1(t), the pulse envelope; ω1, the pulse carrier
frequency; and τ , the pulse width. These essential
components of a pulsed signal manipulate the
interactions between MRI technician and proton
spins, therefore providing a means by which to
communicate with—and receive cooperation from –
the magnetized protons subjected to uniform
magnetic fields.
For this reason, RF pulse design and simulation is a
viable field, producing such mechanisms as the SLR
Algorithm for tailoring the RF pulse to better suit any
signaling application. Analysis of the slice profiles
for RECT and SINC pulse forms reveal the spectral
and spatial excitations that the pulse is capable of,
however, these two basic pulses are hardly as flexible
as more rigorous pulse shaping methods such as SLR.
MATLAB is a useful tool in aiding in the
visualization of multiple pulse forms with highly
variable properties. In the future, the author would
like to contribute another paper detailing more
personal experiences with user-defined MATLAB
functions and the publication of her own updated RF
design toolkit, much like Amir Stricker’s work
presented here.
Tailoring the RF Pulse: A Survey of Pulse Shape Effects on Magnetization—L. Ansari
5
6. References
1. Bernstein, Matt A., Kevin Franklin. King, and
Xiaohong Joe. Zhou. Handbook of MRI Pulse
Sequences. Amsterdam: Academic, 2004. Print.
2. Bottomley, P. A., Redington, R. W., Edelstein,
W. A., and Schenck, J. F. 1985. Estimating
radiofrequency power deposition in body NMR
imaging. Magn. Reson. Med. 2:336-349. Print.
3. Claridge, Timothy D. W. High Resolution NMR
Techniques in Organic Chemistry. Amsterdam
[u.a.: Elsevier, 2006. Print.
4. Epstein, Charles L. "A Lecture on Selective RF-
pulses in MRI." University of Pennsylvania,
Philadelphia. Reading.
5. Gershenzon, Naum I., David F. Miller, and
Thomas E. Skinner. "The Design of Excitation
Pulses for Spin Systems Using Optimal Control
Theory: With Application to NMR
Spectroscopy." Optimal Control Applications
and Methods 30.5 (2009): 463-75. Print.
6. Khalifa, A. A., AB M. Youssef, and Y. M.
Kadah. "Optimal Design of RF Pulses with
Arbitrary Profiles in Magnetic Resonance
Imaging." Engineering in Medicine and Biology
Society, 2001 3: 2296-299. Print.
7. MATLAB Tools for RF Pulse Design and
Simulations:
http://amirschricker.org/pubs/proj_rfpulse.pdf
8. Smith, Nadine, and Andrew Webb. Introduction
to Medical Imaging: Physics, Engineering and
Clinical Applications. Cambridge, UK:
Cambridge UP, 2011. Print.
9. Wang, Jinghua, Weihua Mao, Maolin Qiu,
Michael B. Smith, and R. Todd Constable.
"Factors Influencing Flip Angle Mapping in
MRI: RF Pulse Shape, Slice-select Gradients,
Off-resonance Excitation, AndB0
Inhomogeneities." Magnetic Resonance in
Medicine 56.2 (2006): 463-68. Print.
6
THE ROLE AND IMPACE OF ULTRASOUND GUIDED TECHNOLOGY
FOR REGIONAL ANESTHESIA PLACEMENT Aimee Bobko
Abstract Regional anesthesia is used to decrease pain observed near a specific surgical site. By placing the
anesthetics near nerves responsible for the sensory information of the desired area, temporary
sensory loss can occur; this is called an anesthetic block [4]. In order for the anesthetic to be
injected and placed, locating the correct nerve is essential. Initially, it was required for the block
to be placed in blindly which introduces a higher risk for nerve damage to the patient and
increases the chance for block failure [3]. In the late 1970s, ultrasound technology was applied to
this procedure to allow for real time imaging [2]. The main purpose of using ultrasound for this
procedure was for improved nerve identification and localization. Studies have shown that
ultrasound guided anesthetic blocks typically have a 94% success rate of sensory loss in the right
area compared to the 79% success rate of sensory loss with the blind technique [1]. Using
ultrasound includes other advantages such as less pain medication consumption and fewer needle
insertions into the body [1]. As a result, this technology has revolutionized the field of regional
anesthesia and has become a common practice throughout surgical units across the country [4].
This technique is a great example of advancing medical care through the use of real time imaging
to improve treatment. This application also emphasizes that patient specific treatments are
becoming more favorable as it is now better understood that each person’s anatomy is slightly
different [4]. Taking this fact into consideration produces more successful care as physicians can
tailor specified patient plans. Medicine can become more exact and certain. The ultrasound
guided technology with regional anesthesia placement serves an important role in healthcare
today and is continuing to advance patient care.
Keywords: Ultrasound, Anesthesia, Medical Imaging
1. Introduction
The interest in the use of regional anesthesia began in
1884 with the discovery of local anesthetic properties
in cocaine [2]. As more anesthetics were discovered
and improved, there was an increasing trend to move
towards the use of regional anesthetics blocks in
conjugation with certain surgical procedures such as
foot or ankle surgery. Blocks started to gain rapid
popularity in the 1970s and 1980s when there was a
large concern about analgesia, pain experienced after
undergoing surgery [2]. A regional anesthetic block
consists of incremental doses of an anesthetic through
a perineural catheter [1]. This catheter is placed near
nerves close to or leading towards the surgical site.
By placing the anesthetics near nerves responsible for
the sensory information of the desired area,
temporary sensory loss can occur; this is called an
anesthetic block [4]. The purpose of regional
anesthesia is to decrease the pain observed near the
surgical site and in some cases, to avoid the use of
general anesthesia.
The most important aspect of implementing this
application is placing the anesthetic in the proper
location to ensure proper function while avoiding
nerve damage. Traditionally, this procedure was
performed blindly without visualization of the nerve
for anesthetic placement, and usually, only with the
help of electrical stimulation technology, which
produces an indirect indication of location through
muscle twitches around the desired area. Hence, this
produced a problem with respect to the inability to
confidently receive the precise nerve location [4].
Figure 1. This figure shows a typical set-up of an
ultrasound guided regional anesthesia block with a
computer screen nearby for the clinician to get a good
visualization of the region underneath the transducer on the
patient’s body prior to needle insertion [6].
The Role and Impact of Ultrasound Guided Technology for Regional Anesthesia Placement—A. Bobko
7
Due to its ability to produce a real-time image of
identifiable structures below the skin, ultrasound
technology has been applied to fulfill this role to
assist clinicians in their placements of regional nerve
blocks, as seen in Figure 1. The images give an
accurate idea of the location and direction of the
nerves [4]. This is especially useful in accounting for
the varied anatomy of each individual patient [4]. By
having a more accurate guide for anesthetic
placement, more precise movements and control of
the needle during the procedure are obtained, as seen
in Figure 2 [8]. The spread of the anesthetic
throughout the visualized region can also be assessed
for accuracy [8]. This leads to more properly placed
blocks which will reduce pain greater more
effectively than a block placement with electrical
stimulation. With less pain experienced, patients do
not have to use as much pain medication and their
overall satisfaction is greater.
Common areas in which ultrasound has been found to
be useful include procedures involving venous
access, epidural space identification, and
identification of nerve plexuses for nerve blocks [4].
Ultrasound guided regional anesthesia placement in
particular is an excellent example of the results
obtained through the use of a combination of
technology.
2. Evolution of Technology
2.1 Electrical Stimulation
Prior to the 1970s, electrical stimulation was the
major form of guidance utilized for peripheral nerve
blocks [2]. The electrical stimulation technology
utilizes an electrical current for short intervals to
induce a muscular twitch response [1]. In order to
first locate the desired nerve, a needle is inserted into
the body, which will subsequently be replaced by the
catheter. In order to ensure the needle is in the
appropriate location and near the correct nerves,
electrical stimulation elicits a response from the
muscles which the needle is currently affecting. For
example, if a block for ankle surgery is desired,
twitches of the surrounding ankle muscles would be
needed to ensure the anesthesia would travel to the
correct location. Often, there is a large distance from
the block placement to the affected surgical area. As
a result, it is essential for a clinician to have through
knowledge of the anatomy of these regions [8].
This method is associated with several risks. Since
this procedure offers the clinician no visual
assistance, the needle insertion is performed almost
blind creating a situation where uncertainty plays a
role in a block placement. As a result, even when
used by experienced clinicians, electrical stimulation
outcomes cannot be reliable [4]. Without the
assistance of visual cues, there can also be a higher
risk of punctured blood vessels and nerve damage
[8]. Furthermore, specific structural landmarks that
may be relied on with electrical stimulation can be
skewed by factors such as obesity or varying patient
anatomy, resulting in a more difficult block
placement. This method illustrates a less than ideal
environment for the placement of regional
anesthetics.
2.2 Ultrasound
Figure 2. Shows a close up view of the approach a clinician
takes to make the needle insertion as part of the procedure
for regional anesthesia placement. The clinician has placed
the transducer over the site where they predict a desired
nerve plexus is located. The clinician will be able to see
this plexus as they guide the needle into the correct position
[7].
As mentioned previously, ultrasound offers an
opportunity to obtain some visual guidance as a way
for clinicians to place blocks with more success.
Thomas Bendtsen demonstrated this claim in a study
where sensory blockade success, pain medication
consumption, needle passes (the number of times the
needle was inserted and withdrawn from the body)
and patient satisfaction where measured in 100
patients [1]. This study found that the patients who
received the ultrasound guided nerve block had a
success rate of 94% which is much higher compared
to that of the electrical stimulation group with a
success rate of only 79% [1]. This demonstrates that
greater sensory blocks can be obtained with the use
of an ultrasound guide. Bendtsen was looking at
nerve blocks specifically with the popliteal sciatic
nerve and considered sensory block to be achieved
when there was sensory loss in both the tibial and
common peroneal regions [1]. In addition to the
success rate of the ultrasound guided block, this study
The Role and Impact of Ultrasound Guided Technology for Regional Anesthesia Placement—A. Bobko
8
proved that the ultrasound treatment group had a
reduced need for morphine pain medication
consumption. This group required a median of 18mg
compared to the median 34mg of the electrical
stimulation treatment group [1]. The decreased
amount of pain medication indicates a larger effect of
the block in terms of successfully decreasing the
amount of pain in the surgical area. In terms of
needle passes, where the needle may need to be
withdrawn from the body and reinserted due to
misplacement, there was also a difference between
the two groups. In the ultrasound group, there was a
median of one pass versus a median of two passes for
the electrical stimulation group [1]. Fewer needle
passes means less chance of nerve damage as well as
quicker and more accurate needle placement. Patient
satisfaction was also measured on a scale of 1-10 in
this study. In the ultrasound group, there was a
median patient satisfaction number of 9. The
electrical stimulation group had a median patient
satisfaction number of 8 [1]. The slight difference in
patient satisfaction shows that patients in the
ultrasound category felt happier with the outcomes of
their overall treatment. In this study, the ultrasound
procedure fared better in each degree of
measurement.
N.S. Sandhu also conducted a similar study with 126
patients who underwent ultrasound guided
infraclavicular brachial plexus blocks [8]. His results
indicated that 90.4% of the block only procedures did
not require any additional anesthetic [8]. This high
success rate gives insight into the decreased degree of
speculation and subsequent failure associated with
the ultrasound guided procedure.
A combination of ultrasound technology and
electrical stimulation can be used to further ensure
the location of the needle in relation to desired nerves
[3]. The electrical stimulation confirms the proper
needle placement that was determined through
ultrasound use. This can lead to an even higher
success rate for the blocks. The specific technique of
the ultrasound method will be discussed in the
following section.
3. Technique and Image Quality
The technique of an ultrasound guided regional
anesthesia block begins with the insertion of a needle
and the tip being led towards the appropriate
neurovascular bundle, which can be seen on an
adjacent ultrasound imaging screen. The image is
generated through sound transmission and reflection
through the transducer. Sound is able to pass through
the fluids which make up the soft tissues [4]. This is
why fluids are displayed in black color on the
resulting image [4]. The materials composing the
actual soft tissue reflect a portion of the sound back
towards the transducer, making them a lighter color.
Once the needle is in place, test injections of the local
anesthetic can be conducted. These injections should
only be 1-2ml, just to see if the spread of the
anesthesia is occurring in the correct direction [3]. If
not, the needle will need to be moved [4]. Once in the
correct position, the appropriate dose of local
anesthesia can be injected and visualized.
An essential component of this procedure is the need
for needle visibility on the ultrasound image screen,
as seen in Figure 3. The visibility depends on the
echogenicity of the needle in comparison to the
echogenicity of the surrounding tissue [5].
Echogenicity refers to the ability to reflect a portion
of the ultrasound wave back [5]. If there is only a
small difference between the echogenicities, the
visibility will be poor [5].
Figure 3. This image is a short axis ultrasound scan of the
musculocutaneous nerve in the axilla. The needle tip can be
visualized along with the local anesthetic that has just been
injected (arrowheads). After the injection, the needle can be
seen displaced from the nerve [3].
Human tissue has a high echogenicity, resulting in a
less than ideal needle visibility [5]. The needle’s
echogenicity is determined by its angle of insertion to
the ultrasound beam, quality of the needle, and
needle gauge [3]. The needle begins to become less
visible at steep angles and more visible with larger
gauged needles. The larger needle can be seen more
easily due to its size and stiffness. [3]
The nerve viewing planes are also important to
ensure correct needle and anesthetic spread images.
The needle is better seen in comparison with the
surrounding tissues in the transverse direction [4].
Also, these blocks are usually performed by short
axis imaging [3]. This allows for good visualization
The Role and Impact of Ultrasound Guided Technology for Regional Anesthesia Placement—A. Bobko
9
of nerves and resolution of surrounding barriers [3].
Also, if the transducer moves somewhat, the nerves
will still be visible [3]. It is imperative to ensure the
clearest combination of needle and tissue structures
in the resulting image.
Frequency of the ultrasound beam is also another
aspect of the image affecting the quality. The
frequency is decided based on the needed range of
depth and resolution [4]. The general trend is that
high frequencies will only allow short tissue depths
and produce high resolution, which is seen in Figure
4. Inversely, low frequencies waves will allow for
deep tissue penetration but produce low resolution.
Common needed nerve depth is between 3-7cm,
which can be reached with high frequency ultrasound
waves with decent image quality [3]. However, there
have been current advances in technology that have
been able to distinguish between nerves and other
various structures at low frequencies [3].
The most efficient mode of ultrasound for this
procedure is cross-sectional B-mode, since images
show a slice of tissue and are the easiest to interpret
for clinicians [4]. As a result, in real time, the needle
location and any local structures can be seen.
Figure 4. This figure shows ultrasound scans of the median
nerve of the forearm, which is labeled by the yellow arrow,
at five different depths. As the depth increases, the nerve
becomes visually smaller and more difficult to see. This
illustrates the importance of choosing appropriate image
settings with ultrasound for a desired nerve [9].
Usually, a built-in caliper allows for measurements
such as the depth and length of various structures
such as nerves to be measured [3]. A lot of these
aspects contribute to creating an image that will be
most helpful to guide clinicians as they look to ensure
they have achieved the correct position to insert
anesthetics into the body. Although ultrasound does
not allow for a clear direct image, the reflection of
the sound waves creates a good enough visual aid
with low safety risks that is able to serve the needed
role well enough.
4. Advantages and Disadvantages
4.1 Advantages
There are many advantages to the ultrasound guided
method which is why it has become increasingly
popular in its use. As discussed earlier, there has been
evidence from studies which show that higher
success rates can be achieved from the use of
ultrasound in regional anesthetic placement [1]. This
can be concluded from measurements of the high
degree of sensory loss, lower pain medication
consumption, fewer needle passes, and higher patient
satisfaction, specifically in comparison to the
electrical stimulation technique [1]. In addition, one
of the most advantageous features of ultrasound
technology in this application is being able to move
and relocate the needle after the initial dispersion of
anesthetic without necessarily removing or
withdrawing the needle from the body [3]. By being
able to recognize and correct the misplacement on the
ultrasound image screen, this greatly helps avoid
complications [4]. It allows for faster placement and
less risk of nerve damage or block failure.
Furthermore, something electrical stimulation is
incapable of achieving but ultrasound can is able to
perform a successful block on patients with
amputated distal upper extremities [8]. It is important
that this treatment protocol offers the opportunity to
better reach patient populations that were not able to
be accessible before.
In terms of image visualization, ultrasound is more
useful than other medical imaging modalities.
Ultrasound equipment is smaller and more easily
transported compared to other imaging technology
available in addition to creating acceptable
resolution, depth distance, and structure identification
[4]. Nerves are identified by moving the image along
the path of the nerve which is often in a slanted
direction. This is difficult to achieve with other
imaging technologies such as medical resonance
The Role and Impact of Ultrasound Guided Technology for Regional Anesthesia Placement—A. Bobko
10
imaging (MRI) [3]. Thus, ultrasound has many
factors that contribute to its success in this role.
4.2 Disadvantages
However, along with the many advantages of the
technology, there are also several disadvantages with
the technique as well. First there is a definite need for
more training to be able to utilize and perform the
technique successfully. It is important for clinicians
to understand not only how to operate the machinery
but also how to work with ultrasound and anesthetics
in combination to recognize correct nerves and
proper placement. In order to be able to make these
recognitions, clinicians often have to fight the less
than perfect needle visibility produced by the
technology. Since living human tissue has high
background echogenicity, the needle can be difficult
to identify [5]. This problem must be treated with
care because not being able to correctly see the
needle can lead to mistakenly puncturing structures
and causing damage. In addition, another factor to
consider is that the nerves can be displaced from their
usual positions. This displacement that moves nerves
can be caused by light pressure from the ultrasound
probe, needle advancement through the tissues, or
even the anesthetic as it distributes in the body [3].
The correct identification of nerves is needed
throughout the entire procedure in order to produce a
successful block in the right area.
Since image quality is such a high priority, it is
necessary to avoid any factors that may distort the
image through items such as shadows. As a result, air
bubbles which cause shadowing have to be evaded as
well as bicarbonate containing solutions since they
can produce carbon dioxide which would disrupt the
image clarity [4]. Another factor in image quality is
the resolution and the ability to distinguish between
structural components. Currently, there is a limit to
the resolution of the image due in part to nerve size.
At this time, the smallest nerves that can be
distinguished in an image are 2mm in diameter [3].
Most nerves for regional blocks can be seen in the
generated image; however, if this limit could be
lowered, success in the procedure would most likely
increase further.
Low image quality prevents accurate interpretation
by clinicians. These interpretations are on an
individual scale and can vary between clinicians [4].
As a result, there is still a portion of this procedure
that requires educated guessing and decision making.
Another limiting factor that needs to be considered is
the time and intensity of exposure of the body to the
ultrasound waves. Despite the increased safety of
ultrasound’s non-ionizing radiation, these waves can
have a high enough energy to cause heating and
damage to tissues [4]. In order to avoid this, the
clinician must have knowledge about the settings for
ultrasounds as well as the effects the waves can have
under certain circumstances.
Futhermore, other limiting factors of the ultrasound
technology include space and cost. There is the high
cost of the ultrasound equipment which could deter
performing the procedure. However, this would be a
onetime cost that could become very cost effective
with the amount of patients who could utilize this
treatment as well as the time that could be saved by
investing in a more precise method [8]. In addition to
the cost of the equipment, space in hospitals is also
needed in order to perform this procedure. Specific
rooms need to be allocated in hospitals as ―block
rooms‖ where the necessary equipment could be
permanently situated [3]. This could be a problem if a
hospital does not have any additional space to make
available.
Other disadvantages that may be in the realm of this
method’s protocol include that in some cases, it may
be easier to give general anesthesia rather than
regional anesthesia, there may lack of anatomical
knowledge by clinicians needed for this technique,
and there could also be a lack of knowledge by the
clinicians regarding the benefits and uses of regional
anesthesia [3]. These disadvantages emphasize the
need for extensive training in order to combat these
typical limiting factors of this procedure.
5. Conclusion
Ultrasound guided regional anesthesia placement has
revolutionized the field of regional anesthesia by
allowing for clinicians to be able to see a real time
image of their anesthetic placement. Being able to
have this picture greatly alleviates much of the
guesswork that previously went into this application.
This can be seen in the difference of success rates of
sensory blocks with 94% for the ultrasound group
and 79% for the electrical stimulation group. These
differences as well as the differences in pain
medication consumption, number of needle passes,
and degree of patient satisfaction, show how
ultrasound has advanced the medical treatment of this
procedure. The ultrasound guided blocks are
achieving their purpose by decreasing the amount of
pain experienced by a patient post-operatively.
Since the late 1970’s, ultrasound has been utilized in
this procedure, and now, it has become a rather
The Role and Impact of Ultrasound Guided Technology for Regional Anesthesia Placement—A. Bobko
11
routine component with the procedure in surgical
units across the country [4]. As a result of its high
use, it would not be surprising to see ultrasound
machines being incorporated as a key component on
anesthesia machines in operating rooms in the future
[3]. This demonstrates the increasing role medical
imaging is playing in health care today. There is a
growing need for clinicians to be able to have a real
time image of what is going on beneath the skin, and
ultrasound is becoming the preferred imaging
modality to do so. With real time imaging, medicine
is achieving a higher degree of precision and
confidence.
Currently, clinicians are finding the procedure to be
particularly useful in patients with different and
difficult anatomies [3]. The integration of this
technique into their practice is allowing them to gain
a better sense of how to approach the treatment of
these patients and to gain a better idea of how to
move forward with a treatment plan. Clinicians have
also been finding this procedure to be useful with
children who share a high degree of anatomic
variation among one another [4]. This procedure is
also very useful since a child’s nerves are rather
superficial, making them easy to access through this
technique [4]. These examples illustrate the
importance of the new trend of individualized
medicine. Since each person’s anatomy is slightly
varied, ultrasound is allowing clinicians to account
for this by displaying images that demonstrate that
not every individual’s nerve plexuses are in the exact
same location [4]. Individualized medicine is
allowing for the treatment of each patient more
successfully because clinicians are working a plan
that is specified to the structures within the anatomy
of a specific patient, which is ultimately leading to
better results.
There are many current research investigations that
are hoping to improve ultrasound technology for
regional anesthesia placements further in the future.
It is hoped that one day this technique could be used
to access traditionally difficult nerves or nerves that
cannot be easily located [4]. There is also a goal to
achieve clearer imaging of smaller and deeper nerves
[3]. Another aspect being tested is the use of color
encoded echoes which could lead to better image
visibility. This could assist with the identification of
the needle, structural components, and anesthetic [3].
Additionally, the improvement of needle
echogenicity is being examined to see if the effects of
material modifications through the use of procedures
such coating can attain better visibility [3]. All of
these factors could eventually lead to large advances
in the field of regional anesthesia as well as the
medical field as a whole.
Ultrasound guided regional anesthesia placement is a
good example of a time when imaging can be used in
a functional role to assist with procedures. It has had
a large impact thus far and will continue to do so.
6. References 1. Bendtsen, Thomas, Thomas Nielsen, Claus
Rohde, Kristian Kibak, and Frank Linde.
Ultrasound Guidance Improves a Continuous
Popliteal Sciatic Nerve Block When Compared
With Nerve Stimulation. Regional Anesthesia
and Pain Medicine. 36.2: 181-184, 2011.
2. Brown, T.C.K. History of Pediatric Regional
Anesthesia. Pediatric Anesthesia. 22.1: 3-9,
2011.
3. Gray, Andrew. Ultrasound-guided Regional
Anesthesia: Current State of the Art.
Anesthesiology. 104: 68-73, 2006.
4. Gupta, Prashant, Kumkum Gupta, Amit
Dwivedi, and Manish Jain. Potential Role of
Ultrasound in Anesthesia and Intensive Care.
Anesthesia Essays and Researches. 5.1: 11-19,
2011.
5. Hocking, Graham. Simon Hebard, and
Christopher Mitchell. A Review of the Benefts
and Pitfalls of Phantoms in Ultrasound-Guided
Regional Anesthesia. Regional Anesthesia and
Pain Medicine. 36.2: 162-170, 2011.
6. Philips. 2011. Regional Anesthesia and Pain
Medication Products. 21 Nov. 2011. <http://ww
w.healthcare.philips.com/de_de/products/ultraso
und/categories/regional_anesthesia.wpd.>.
7. Romdhane, Kamel, Adel Zorkani, Maizar
Khalaf, and Safwan Jandali. Introduction to the
Ultrasound Guided Regional Anesthesia. The
Internet Journal of Health. 5:2, 2007.
8. Sandhu, N.S. and L.M. Capan. Ultrasound-
guided infraclavicular brachial plexus block.
British Journal of Anasthesia. 89.2: 254-259,
2002.
9. USRA. Scanning Technique – Machine Settings.
20008. Ultrasound for Regional Anesthesia. 21
Nov. 2011 <http://ww w.usra.ca/ugt_st_ms_io>.
12
A REVIEW OF APPLICATIONS USING CURRENT MRI TECHNOLOGY Noman Ali Khan [email protected]
Abstract Magnetic Resonance Imaging is one of the most informative diagnostic imaging tools. Since the
scanning process does not expose the patient to ionizing radiation it is one of the safest imaging
technologies, which should be taken advantage of. One of the future benefits of MRI is the ability
to monitor intracellular drug delivery. Another future application of MRI is to examine metabolic
function of the brain. Not only is the number of MRI applications evolving but the method for
capturing these images is evolving as well. Structural and functional MRI’s are being integrated.
Spatial resolution of obtained images has greatly increased with MRI. With other imaging
techniques which are used for diagnostics, there are not many quantative functions. However
there are new research studies which evaluate the possibility of quantitative functional MRI. Not
only is MRI being used in medical applications it is also being used in lie detection and even
marketing. This article will not only explain these applications and processes but also assess the
validity of these technologies and provide an insight on the usefulness of each application.
Keywords: MRI, UIC, Bioengineering, Lie Detection, Future Technologies, fMRI, marketing
1. Background
Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) is a diagnostic
tool mainly used by radiologists and other
professionals in the medical field. There are many
more applications for MRI, which are discussed later
in this paper. The first one-dimensional magnetic
resonance image was reported by Herman Carr in the
1950‟s. Later on, Paul Lauterbur developed a
technique to construct two and three-dimensional
MRI images. The first MRI cross sectional image of
a mouse brain was documented in 1974. Peter
Mansfield enhanced MRI technology to reduce the
amount of time it took in order to generate an image
as well as increase the quality of the image. Both
Lauterbur and Mansfield won the 2003 Nobel Prize
for their “discoveries concerning magnetic resonance
imaging” [3].
Figure 1. An image of a typical MRI machine with coils
inside the “MRI ring” and a table for the patient to lie on
during the exam [7].
According to Textbook of Medical Physiology, the
human body consists of approximately 57% water
[1]. Since each water molecule contains two protons
in the form of hydrogen, MRI takes advantage of that
by applying a magnetic field to these molecules and
aligning them with the magnetic field direction. An
RF pulse is initiated temporarily to create an
electromagnetic field. The photons of this field move
according to the resonance or Larmour frequency,
which allows them to be absorbed by the protons that
in return will flip its spinning direction. When the
field is turned off the energy absorbing protons
subsequently return to their original states releasing
energy, which is detected by the scanner as an
electromagnetic signal. The image itself is
determined by applying more gradient fields to the
scan. Through solenoids a current is passed which
will vary the magnetic field according to the position
of the patient. This position can be predicted using
the inverse Fourier transform. The Fourier transform
converts the mathematical results into an image,
which can be later used for diagnostic purposes [3].
There are some major advantages of MRI: no
ionizing radiation, images can be captured in any 2-D
or 3-D plane, very good soft tissue contrast, images
are produced with inconsequential penetration
effects, and a spatial resolution of 1mm can be
acquired. There are also some disadvantages of MRI
which includes: time to acquire an MR image is
longer than x-ray or ultrasound images, patients with
certain metallic implants are unable to undergo a
scan, and it is relatively more expensive than x-ray or
ultrasound [7]. Since MRI is so expensive, most
A Review of Applications Using Current MRI Technology—N. Ali Khan
13
hospitals are not able to afford as many MRI
machines as x-ray machines, which means that more
people may need to wait on a waiting list to receive a
scan. MRI already takes a long time to obtain, and
with the lack of machinery it could affect the patient,
who will be the one that pays for it, in time and
money. Although this is an unfortunate drawback the
spatial resolution and safety of MRI overcomes the
cost, which may be why there are over 10 million
MRI‟s prescribed every year [7].
2. Current MRI Applications
There are several companies, which manufacturing
MRI machines. The machines these companies
produce are mainly used in hospital or clinical
settings. Some of these companies include: Fonar,
General Electric Healthcare, Hitachi Medical
Systems, Odin Medical Technologies, Philips
Medical Systems, Siemens, and Toshiba.
One of the current supremacies of MRI technology is
the ability to see more clearly into musculoskeletal
tissues. Because of the high spatial resolution of
MRI, even fine details in the structure are easily
displayed. For example, MRI may be used to detect
symptoms of rheumatoid arthritis in the wrists and
knees [7].
Another current use of MRI is to diagnose diseases in
soft tissues. One example is the diagnosis of liver
cancer using MRI. Using a contrast agent,
metastases, which are the most common form liver
tumors, may be visible. Other diseases that may be
diagnosed because of MRI include cirrhosis,
haemochromatosis and haemolytic anemia, hepatic
adenoma, as well as other focal and diffuse liver
diseases [7].
There are quite a few neurological applications for
MRI. Some of the diseases that are diagnosed
through MRI include: meningioma, lymphoma,
schwannoma, astrocytoma, glioblastomas, and
vasogenic or cytotoxic edema. One of the main
neurological diseases that are diagnosed through
MRI is a stroke. Strokes occur when there is a
blood clot in one of the blood vessels in the brain.
This blood clot leads to the failure of a
sodium/potassium pump which will cause
cytotoxic edema. Since certain therapies must be
administered after a stroke, an early detection is
essential. Alzheimer‟s and Huntington‟s diseases
may also be diagnosed using MRI. However, they are much more difficult to diagnose since the
symptoms of these two diseases lead to white
matter lesions similar to that of normal aging [7].
MRI angiography is essential in observing the
blood flow through the body and its organs. Using
this technique, fine details of the blood vessel
structure in the brain can be detected. The images
of blood vessels from MRI can be used to evaluate
a stenosis or aneurysms. Another use for MRI
angiography is in the cardiac tissue, specifically
the heart. The heart can be imaged to show the
four stages of the cardiac cycle. Abnormalities
such as left anterior descending coronary artery
disease, which is the most common cause of heart
attacks, may be detected using MRI angiography.
Figure 2. On the left shows the MRI angiogram of the brain
with maximum intensity. The left image shows the details
acquired using MRI angiogram [7].
Functional MRI (fMRI) is used in order to examine,
which parts of the brain are used for certain activities.
Oxygenation of certain parts of the brain during these
tasks such as speech, sensory motion, and other tasks
allows fMRI to display them. Although fMRI is used
in research more than in clinical applications, it is
used in some clinical applications such as the pre-
surgical planning. Here a surgery may be planned
using fMRI in order to avoid critical areas of the
brain, which may be necessary for tasks such as
speaking and sensory motion [7].
3. Diagnostic MRI Enhancements
In order to diagnose amyotrophic lateral sclerosis
(ALS) a team of researchers at Oxford used a
combined fMRI as well as structural MRI to see if it
would have any diagnostic value. Twenty-Five
patients who were diagnosed with sporadic ALS were
chosen for the study as well as fifteen control
subjects. Images were taken using a 3T Siemens Trio
scanner. This scanner includes a twelve channel head
coil and has met guidelines set by the 2010
Neuroimaging Symposium in ALS. The subjects
A Review of Applications Using Current MRI Technology—N. Ali Khan
14
went through a T1-weighted, diffusion weighted and
resting state fMRI. A three-dimensional whole brain
T1-weighted MRI scan was also acquired with
specific time/echo, flip angle, and spatial resolution.
Subjects were kept awake for the scans but were
instructed to keep their eyes closed [8].
Figure 3. A diagram of structural and fMRI overlaid each
other which shows white matter damage commonly
associated with ALS [8].
The results for this study showed that by using this
novel approach to integrate structural and functional
MRI the researchers found connectivity between the
two in ALS subjects which was not found in the
control group. This connectivity is essentially an
“ALS cerebral signature” which could be a potential
method for early detection of ALS. There were a few
drawbacks to this study including not being able to
image “mild cognitive impairment”; however, there
is great potential in combining structural and
functional MRI and this study has displayed some of
that potential [8].
Another diagnostic MRI enhancement is the study
involving using fMRI as a quantative diagnostic tool.
FMRI has greatly increased the potential of MRI, by
allowing researchers to qualitatively asses brain
function. However, it has not been able to give
quantative results that may be used for diagnostic
purposes. This research paper shows that fMRI can
be quantified into showing cerebral blood flow,
cerebral blood volume, and oxygen metabolism in the
brain as a quantative result. Quantative fMRI has
already shown a linear relationship between cerebral
blood flow and oxygen metabolism in the brain. One
of the main challenges for fMRI to be used in a
clinical setting is the lack of adoption in
pharmacological research studies, and individual
patient evaluations. If there were an accurate
methodology for interpreting the results of an fMRI
so that it may be used for these types of uses, it could
have a plethora of clinical applications [6].
4. Future MRI Applications
One of the future applications of MRI is the
possibility of specific drug delivery imaging. The
goal of this specific study is to “strengthen future
nanomedicine research by improving our ability to
design sensitive „targeted cell-shuttle‟ type nano-
probes for monitoring drug delivery and therapy”.
The way MRI fits in this study is that it is used to
capture the images of the cells. These cells receive
this drug and the researcher evaluates whether the
MRI is able to accurately image the nano-probes and
specific drugs that are being introduced into the cells.
The study uses a 14T magnetic field strength using a
10mm micro-imaging coil. This study proves that
MRI is able to image this nanoparticle system. In the
future this discovery could lead to more
breakthroughs in cancer biology and drug delivery
[5].
The use of magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS)
has a great deal of useful applications. It is able to
show the amount of a substance in an MR image. For
example it can determine the amount of lactate or
lipids within a certain organ such as the brain. It can
also be used to determine the metabolic profiles of
tumors. One of the main uses of MRS is to diagnose
various disorders including: brain tumors,
neurodegenerative disorders, metabolic
encephalopathy, ischemia, hypoxia, and white matter
diseases. Another possible use of MRS is to diagnose
Parkinson‟s disease. By investing the metabolic
profiles of patients with Parkinson‟s it is able to
detect pathogenic markers of the disease which could
help in early diagnosis. Because of the great clinical
potential of MRS and especially its effect on
evaluating metabolic processes it is a future
breakthrough in MRI applications [2].
Figure 4. An MRS image which shows the image as well as
the amount of each compound, slightly increased lactate
and lipids are present here [2].
A Review of Applications Using Current MRI Technology—N. Ali Khan
15
5. Non-Medical MRI Applications
Aside from clinical uses of MRI there are many other
uses including marketing research as well as possible
lie detection.
In marketing, MRI is being used in order to
determine whether a consumer is interested in a
product. This product is placed with other products,
ideas, and pictures in order to stimulate a response
from the consumer‟s brain directly using fMRI.
Below is a graph which shows how attentive
someone is when they are shown pictures of different
things. There is a very noticeable change when the
person is shown a plant versus a bottle of Coca-Cola.
Figure 5. A chart which displays the attention index during
a series of advertisements shown to members of this study
group [9]. The peaks indicate increased attention and
troughs are decreased attention.
Although this research is controversial it is difficult
to say that it has no value as research at all. There is
some basis to say that it does provide useful
information to potential product manufacturers. For
example, there is a direct correlation to using EEG or
MEG to determine if an advertisement has been
remembered or not, which would be of great value to
marketing companies. However, it is difficult to
gauge whether a consumer had a specific emotional
response. More research is necessary, and the
researchers of this particular study stated that
companies which employ this method of marketing
need to publish their results. However, this may be
difficult due to the competition, which would also
have the results as well [9].
Another application for MRI may be lie detection. In
a recent study published by the journal of Behavioral
Sceience and the Law, 333 undergraduate students
served as “jurors” in a mock trial where they had to
evaluate fMRI as a possible lie detection criterion in
a court case. The following chart shows that most
jurors did believe that fMRI is accurate in lie
detection.
Figure 6. A graph of jurors‟ guilty responses when each
method of lie detection was claimed to asses the guilt of the
defendant. FMRI has the highest validity of guilt prediction
[4].
Although this research study is quite thorough in
determining the value of fMRI in the minds of many
jurors, it did not assess the validity of fMRI as lie
detection technology itself. More research studies are
needed in order to determine whether MRI
technology is an accurate method in detecting lies.
However, this research proves that if fMRI results are
ever admitted into court as evidence it will most
likely have a very influential impact in the minds of
jurors [4].
6. References
1. Guyton, Arthur C. (1991). Textbook of Medical
Physiology (8th ed.). Philadelphia: W.B.
Saunders. p. 274. ISBN 0-7216-3994-11.
2. Hall, Hélène, Sandra Baena, Carina Dahlberg,
René Zandt, Vladimir Denisov, and Deniz Kirik.
"Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopic Methods for
the Assessment of Metabolic Functions in the
Diseased Brain." Current Topics in Behavioral
Neuroscience (2011): 1-30. 11 Nov.2011
3. "Magnetic Resonance Imaging." Wikipedia, the
Free Encyclopedia. Web. 05 Dec. 2011.
<http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetic_resonan
ce_imaging>.
4. McCabe, David P., Alan D. Castel, and Matthew
G. Rhodes. "The Influence of FMRI Lie
Detection Evidence on Juror Decision-making."
Behavioral Sciences and the Law 29 (2011):
566-77. 29 July 2011. Web.2011.
A Review of Applications Using Current MRI Technology—N. Ali Khan
16
5. Mitra, Rajendra N., Mona Doshi, Xiaolei Zhang,
Jessica C. Tyus, Niclas Bengtsson, Steven
Fletcher, Brent Page, James Turkson, Andre J.
Gesquiere, Patrick T. Gunning, Glenn A. Walter,
and Swadeshmukul Santra. "An Activatable
Multimodal/multifunctional Nanoprobe for
Direct Imaging of Intracellular Drug Delivery."
Biomaterial (2011): 1-9. 24 Oct. 2011.
Web.2011
6. Pike, G. B. "Quantitative Functional MRI:
Concepts, Issues and Future Challenges."
NeuroImage (2011): 1-7. Print.
7. Smith, Nadine, and Andrew Webb. "Magnetic
Resonance Imaging (MRI)." Introduction to
Medical Imaging: Physics, Engineering and
Clinical Applications. Cambridge, UK:
Cambridge UP, 2011. 204-73. Print.
8. Turner, Martin R., Gwenaëlle Douaud, Nicola
Filippini, Steven Knight, and Kevin Talbot.
"Integration of Structural and Functional
Magnetic Resonance Imaging in Amyotrophic
Lateral Sclerosis." Brain (2011): 1-10. 10 Nov.
2011. Web.2011.
9. Vecchiato, Giovanni, Laura Astolf, Fabrizio V.
Fallani, Jlenia Toppi, Fabio Aloise, Francesco
Bez, Daming Wei, Wanzeng Kong, Jounging
Dai, Febo Cincotti, Donatella Mattia, and Fabio
Babiloni. "On the Use of EEG or MEG Brain
Imaging Tools in Neuromarketing Research."
Computational Intelligence and N (2011): 1-12.
28 June 2011. Web.2011.
17
BASICS OF MAGNETOENCEPHALOGRAPHY AND ITS
APPLICATIONS AS AN EXPERIMENTAL TOOL Vu Nguyen
Abstract Magnetoencephalography (MEG) is a new novel noninvasive method used to measure the magnetic flux
associated with the electrical current occurring naturally in the brain. The location of the magnetic flux is
caused by the action potential of neurons during synaptic transmission. By locating the sites of the active
neurons, MEG is able to identify and visualize brain activity with superior temporal and spatial resolution
compared to functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI). MEG imaging technique can be used to study
many properties of the working human brain, including spontaneous activity and signal processing after
stimulation. Also, MEG the only imaging technique today that can record brain function in millisecond
interval provides doctors and researchers real time information on brain activities. This paper provides a
survey of this current technology assessing the basic physical theories behind the technology. Sections in
this paper include the description of instrumentations including the construction of the main detector in
MEG, the superconducting quantum interference devices (SQUIDs), data analysis and interpretation.
Finally, several current experiments on brain functions using MEG method and its future applications in
clinical settings are discussed.
Keywords: Magnetoencephalography, SQUID, Electroencephalography
1. Introduction
The human brain is the most complex structure
known to man consisting of more than 10 billion
neurons in a vast network of signaling that handles
hundreds of billions of synapses [1]. During brain
activity, the intracellular currents are produced within
the network creating a weak magnetic field that
forms regular distributions on the surface of the head
where they can be recorded by sensitive
magnetometers.
Magnetoencephalography is a novel noninvasive
method of functional brain imaging. The
technology’s functions are to record the magnetic
flux across the head surface, estimate the locations of
neuronal activity, and project the signals onto an MRI
image of the brain.
The magnitude of the magnetic field that a MEG
measurement is in the range of pico-Tesla which is
millions times smaller than the magnetic field
generated by the Earth [5]. The only detector capable
of such a small field is the superconducting quantum
interference devices (SQUID). A SQUID
magnetometer is coupled to the brain magnetic fields
by combinations of superconducting coils called flux
transformer. The MEG signals are detected by the
magnetometer and converted into information on the
current distribution of the brain through series of
mathematical models which are briefly discussed in
later section.
Along with MEG imaging technique, many imaging
methods of the human brain are available today [3].
Methods such as X-ray imaging, single-photon-
emission computed tomography (SPECT), positron-
emission tomography (PET), and MRI provide
precise anatomical structures of the brain without
opening the skull, but exposed the subjects to
ionizing radiation, x-rays, and strong magnetic fields
[1]. Electroencephalography (EEG) is a
complimentary noninvasive imaging method with
MEG that similarly measures the neuronal activity of
the brain with the resolution of milliseconds.
Present studies and experiments have explored vast
knowledge of how the brain functions, yet the
fundamental questions of how the brain processes
information still remain unclear [1]. MEG technique,
as a result, can be used to investigate changes in brain
reaction to external stimuli and localize brain regions
involved with language functions [4]. In this review,
the physiology of the brain and the mathematical
aspect are being accessed along with the SQUID
instrumentation. Finally, the paper will survey the
current experiments and developments of clinical
applications using MEG.
2. Physiological basics of the neuronal
signals
Glial cells and neurons are the building blocks of the
brain. The glial cells are used for structural support
and neurons are the information processing units
Basics of Magnetoencephalography and its Applications as an Experimental Tool—V. Nguyen
18
which are the main focus in this section. A neuron
(Fig. 1) consists of a cell body as a controlling center,
dendrites to receive signals from other cells, and the
axon which carries the signal from the cell body to
other cells. The MEG signals are caused by
synapses from by the firing of an action potential at
the axon hillock [1]. As a consequence, the ion
pumps are activated resulting in the flow of charged
K+, Na
+, and Cl
- ions that would change the
membrane potential.
Figure 1. A neuron with its soma (body) with dendrites and
axons used to receive and carry signal from and toward the
soma. The three types of synapses during the firing of an
action potential [1].
The strength of the signal across neurons is
dependent on the permeability of the membrane to K+
and Na+
ions. An action potential is initiated when
voltage at the axon hillock reaches the firing
threshold. The change in potential triggers the
neighboring neurons like a domino effect. The
synaptic current flow is the source of the EEG and
MEG signals.
3. Mathematical Model of the
Electromagnetic Fields
This section briefly discusses about the origin of the
magnetic field being measure and the mathematical
model used to interpret the phenomenon. The MEG
signals measured can be fully described by a model
of simple current dipole in which the magnetic field
arose from (Fig 2).
On the macroscopic scale, the Maxwell’s equations
(Equation 1-4) and the continuity equation (Equation
5) can be used to calculate the electric field E and the
magnetic field B:
Figure 2: Current contours of the human head with the
magnetic flux flowing in and out of the head which are
indicated by the ―-‖ and ―+‖, respectively [3].
0
E (1)
t
BE
(2)
0 B (3)
t
EJB 0
0
(4)
tJ
(5)
where J is the total current density and ρ is the charge
density. The detailed derivation can be obtained
from Hamalainen.M et al [1].
The model of the current dipole is described as the
forward problem where as the magnetic field can be
easily calculated provided the knowledge of current
dipole and a realistic volume conductor model is
present. On the other hand, in a realistic research
case, the locations and strength of the currents in the
brain have to be estimated given the magnetic. This
inverse problem has no unique solution since each
magnetic field has an infinite number of possible
interpretations which was proven by German
physicist Helmholtz. Several methods using
probabilistic approach to estimate the location of the
brain currents can be further explored from
Hamalainen et al [2].
4. MEG Signal Detector and
Instrumentations
This section reviews in detail the instrumentations
necessary in MEG imaging including the mechanism
of the SQUID detector, noise reduction, and signal
processing. MEG is composed of a complex network
Basics of Magnetoencephalography and its Applications as an Experimental Tool—V. Nguyen
19
of many devices used to detect and analyze the
magnetic flux signal. A complete schematic of MEG
instrumentation system is shown in Fig 3:
Figure 3: Schematic of the entire MEG instrumentation [5].
4.1 Environmental Noises and Solutions
In the laboratory environment where MEG machines
are usually located, there are many sources of
magnetic noise with the magnitude several times
stronger than the biomagnetic signals to be measured
[1]. Magnetic noises are generated from electric
equipments, biological artifacts generated from the
smallest source of movements inside the subject’s
body such as blinking, muscle contractions, and
cardiac activity.
As a result, all devices and materials that may
interfere with the MEG have to be removed from the
environment and the subject. The most effective way
to reduce external disturbances is to measure MEG
signals in a magnetically shielded room. There are
currently four different methods that are used to
insulate a room from the external magnetic
disturbances: ferromagnetic shielding, eddy-current
shielding, active compensation, and the recently
introduced high temperature superconducting
shielding. Another method used in conjunction with
the shielded room is the flux transformer
configurations shown in Fig 4. A more detailed
description of how these configuration works can be
further explained by Hamalainen.M et al [1].
Figure 4: Several arrangements of the flux transformers. (a)
magnetometer; (b) series planar gradiometer; (c) parallel
planar gradiometer; (d) symmetric series axial gradiometer;
(e) asymmetric series axial gradiometer; (f) symmetric
parallel axial gradiometer; and (g) second-order series axial
gradiometer [1].
4.2 Superconducting Quantum Interference Devices
The only sensor on the market today sensitive enough
to detect the minute MEG signals is the SQUID [5].
The most popular types of SQUID are direct current
(dc) and radio frequency (rf) SQUID. Most modern
MEG instrumentations use dc SQUID due to more
sensitive detections and simpler electronic readouts
[5]. The dc SQUID is made up of a thin film of
superconducting loop, interrupted by two Josephson
junctions (Fig 5). Modern SQUIDs use materials
made up from the refractory metals due to their
outstanding resistance to heat and wear.
Figure 5: Simplified structure of a planar thin film dc
SQUID [1].
The rate of mapping the magnetic field can be
increased by integrating a multi-channel
magnetometer into the MEG system. The review by
Hamalainen.M et al [1] provides several examples of
multi-channel SQUID system used in experimental
applications.
4.3 Signal Analysis
The goals of MEG are to enhance the signal-to-noise
ration of the electrophysiological signals and to
locate the incoming signal. The detected signal is
averaged to enhance the signal-to-noise ratio.
Several quantitative methods are designed to analyze
the MEG signals, such as, time-amplitude analysis,
coherence analysis, forward and inverse solutions [5].
A typical result includes the bypassed filtered data,
the magnetic field distribution, and most importantly,
the estimated solution of the inverse problem. Proper
design of the MEG software is of equal importance
that has to display the analyzed data in such a way
that can be observed by the operating personnel.
Basics of Magnetoencephalography and its Applications as an Experimental Tool—V. Nguyen
20
5. Compliments Systems of MEG
MRI imaging system provides accurate images of the
brain anatomy. When used concurrently with MEG,
the locations of the magnetic field sources can be
compared with actual anatomical structure (Fig 6).
Figure 6. The combination of MEG and MRI imaging
techniques on a patient’s skull. The white dot shows the
location of the current dipole superimposed on an MRI
image [1].
Additionally, electroencephalography (EEG) has the
same working mechanism as MEG but provide
complimentary information regarding the volume
current of the brain. Consequently, the combination
of EEG and MEG can create significant
improvements in modeling the conductivity of the
brain.
6. MEG Imaging in Experimental
Research
MEG is one of the preferred methods used to
investigate how the brain reacts to various stimuli. It
is also the only imaging method that can reveal brain
function within milliseconds intervals; study by
Wheeles, J et al [4] has shown that MEG can be used
to localize brain areas involved in key language
functions. Using data obtained from MEG signals,
the team investigates the validity and reliability of
various tasks that can be used to identify the frontal
lobe areas involved in expressing language functions.
Several other studies at Helsinki University examines
how the human brain, specifically the auditory and
visual cortex reacts when evoked by different
external stimuli.
7. Conclusion
The human brain is the most complex structure
known to man consists of billions of neurons with an
equivalent number of synapses. MEG is one of the
emerging imaging techniques that are capable of
providing accurate location of the magnetic field
generated during brain activity. This paper has
surveyed the functional and structural make-up of the
MEG system. Even though there are many obstacles
in localizing brain activity based on the magnetic
field, better estimations in the future can minimize
this effect greatly. Many experiments and research
have shown the practicality and reliability of MEG as
an experimental tool assisting researchers to study
many aspects of how the brain works. In the near
future, MEG imaging has a great potential to be used
in many clinical applications.
8. References
1. Hamalainen.M et al. Magnetoencephalography-
theory, instrumentation, and applications to
noninvasive studies of the working human brain.
Rev. Mod. Phys., Vol. 65, No. 2: 413-497. 1993.
2. Hamalainen, M. S., H. Haario, and M. S.
Lehtinen."Interferences about sources of
neuromagnetic fields using Bayesian parameter
estimation‖ Technical Report TKK-F-A620.
1987
3. Lutken, B. Magnetoencephalography and its
Achilles’ heel. Journal of Physiology - Paris
97:641-658. 2003.
4. Wheeles, J et al. Assessing normal brain
function with magnetoencephalograph.
International Congress Series 1232. 519–534.
2002.
5. Vrba, J, and Robinson, S. Signal Processing in
Magnetoencephalography. METHODS 25, 249–
271. 2001.
21
MEDICAL SIMULATIONS OF INTRATHECAL MORPHINE FOR PAIN
CONTROL AND MANAGEMENT Jaimie M. Stewart [email protected]
Abstract Intrathecal drug delivery is used for administering drugs to the central nervous system by
injecting into the cerebrospinal fluid. It is more efficient than oral and intravenous because it
requires less of the drug and allows drugs composed of macromolecules to bypass the blood brain
barrier. Additionally, certain drugs have greater therapeutic effect when administered
intrathecally because they are able to reach their specific binding site in the brain and spinal
canal. The infusion, distribution, and binding of morphine to the μ-opioid receptors were
investigated. The purpose of morphine is to treat chronic pain. Current treatments with morphine
are not patient specific and either result in over dosage or repeated dosage to achieve the desired
therapeutic effect. First, the intrathecal injection of morphine in the spine using a 3-dimensional
computational model created from patient images of the spine investigated the species transport of
morphine. Second, the intrathecal injection of morphine in an axial section of the lumbar region of
the spinal cord and spinal canal using a 2-dimensional computation model also created from a
patient image investigated binding, reaction rates, and kinetics of morphine.
Keywords: Morphine, Intrathecal, Spinal Cord, Spinal Canal, μ-opioid Receptors,
Cerebrospinal Fluid
1. Introduction
1.1 The μ-opioid Receptors
The typical μ-opioid receptor agonist is the opium
alkaloid morphine; μ (mu) refers to morphine. These
receptors can exist either presynaptically or
postsynaptically depending upon the cell types. The
μ-opioid receptors exist generally presynaptically in
the gray matter, and in the superficial dorsal horn of
the spinal cord, more specifically in the laminae I-III
[7]. μ-opioid receptors are found in numerous areas
throughout the body such as the external plexiform
layer of the olfactory bulb, the nucleus accumbens, in
numerous layers of the cerebral cortex, in certain
nuclei of the amygdala, and in the intestinal tract
[9,17].
1.2 Morphine
Morphine is a potent opioid analgesic used to relieve
severe pain. Morphine can be administered into the
body in various ways such as orally, rectally,
subcutaneously, intravenously, epidurally, and
intrathecally [3]. Toxicity of morphine can occur if
the patient has either an allergic reaction or has
overdosed. Symptoms that may allude to morphine
toxicity include respiratory depression, hypotension,
circulatory failure, comatose, and death [3]. Pain is
eliminated by morphine binding to receptors located
on neuronal cell membranes. This binding activates
the presynaptic action of opioids. Ca++ channels
reduce Ca++ entry, or indirectly by increasing the
outward K+ current, thus shortening repolarization
time and the duration of the action potential and
inhibiting neurotransmitter release. This inhibits pain
signals to be sent to the brain and allows the flow of
dopamine [6]. Figure 2 displays this action.
Figure 2. Morphine binding action [6]
Figure 1. Autoradiograms of axial sections of lumbar
regions (L2 and L4) that represent a distribution of
opiate receptors (light spaces) [7]
Medical Simulations of Intrathecal Morphine for Pain Control and Management—J. Stewart
22
Figure 4. 3D mesh of spine created from MRI data [13]
1.3 Intrathecal delivery
Intrathecal delivery of morphine is the best method of
drug transport in comparison to the other ways
morphine can be distributed. For example, if
morphine was taken orally only 40% to 50% of the
dose would reach the central nervous system.
Therefore, more of the drug would have to be
administered orally to obtain the same level of effect,
as a smaller dose of intrathecal delivery would
transport. This chronic administration increases the
chances of the patient overdosing. Additionally,
morphine crosses the blood-brain barrier, but it does
not cross it easily due to poor lipid solubility, protein
binding, fast conjoinment with glucuronic acid, and
ionization. Intrathecal delivery also allows for a drug
to pass the blood-brain barrier, therefore making
morphine’s bypass through the barrier easier than is
administered in an alternate way [17].
1.4 Computation of Morphine Binding Drug
Action
It is assumed that morphine reaction kinetics is a
second order reversible reaction, which agrees with
the following equation [16].
This equation presents the theory that there are a
limited number of receptors that morphine can bind
to and that this reaction is reversible allowing the
morphine to unbind from the receptor. The reaction
constants ka and kb govern the rate at which this
occurs. From this, a two second order curves are
expected as shown in figure 3.
2. Methods
2.1 Transport Model
2.1.1 Literature Data for Species Transport
Five patients, 3 males and 2 females with intractable
pain due to cancer were treated with 2 mg morphine
hydrochloride in 2ml of saline solution, both isobaric
and hyperbaric solutions were administered in
different patients, this paper will focus on isobaric
solutions. The isobaric solution was injected slowly
for 1 minute into the subarachnoid space (L5-S1) via
spinal needle. The CSF samples were collected at the
T10 level and measured using high performance
liquid chromatography analysis [5].
2.1.2 Three-Dimensional Spine
A computational mesh of the spine was created from
actual patient magnetic resonance imaging (MRI),
shown in figure 4. The mesh of the spinal canal was
created in Ansys [2]. The mesh is discretized into
633790 cells and is scaled at a length of 0.71 meters,
which is the average length of the male vertebral
column [11]. The spinal cord is not included in this
mesh, because this model is solely investigating
species transport in the CSF and CSF velocity.
Figure 3. Graphical representation of morphine
binding action, governed by constants ka and
kb
Medical Simulations of Intrathecal Morphine for Pain Control and Management—J. Stewart
23
Figure 6. Velocity at Ventral C4
2.1.3 Species Transport
In this model, a finite volume method integrating the
Navier Stokes, continuity, and the species transport
equations were used to conduct simulations. Water,
the bulk fluid, is assumed to be a Newtonian fluid,
because it resists compression and retains constant
viscosity. For the species transport, it is assumed that
there are no reactions, no radiation, and no heat
production. Additionally the size of the needle used
for injection is assumed to be 1 mm in diameter.
For the investigation of the species of drug transport
a three-dimensional simulation is selected. The
velocity of injection was calculated to be 1.0452e-05
m/s of 2.0 ml of mixture at a constant velocity over 1
minute.
2.1.4 Equations and Numerical Methods
The commercial software, Fluent [3], is used to
conduct the simulations. Fluent utilizes the Navier
Stokes equation (2), the continuity equation (3) and
the species transport equation (4). The Navier Stokes
equation describes the motion of fluid, the continuity
equation is a conservation equation for
incompressible flow, and the species transport
equation is a diffusion equation.
Equations (2)-(4) are solved using the finite volume
method in Fluent. It utilizes the numerical algorithm,
Semi-Implicit Method for Pressure-Linked equations
(SIMPLE) algorithm [15]. The algorithm initially
guesses for the pressure field, and then solves the
Navier Stokes equation for a velocity field. The
pressure and velocity gradients are used to compute
mass fluxes at each face, using the continuity
equation. The algorithm updates the pressure fields
and then corrects the previously computed mass
fluxes. This process is repeated iteratively until the
solution attained is within the specified convergence
criteria [14]
.
2.2 Binding Model
2.2.1 Lumbar Axial Section of Spinal Cord
and Spinal Canal
In this study, a finite volume method integrating the
Navier Stokes, continuity, species transport
equations, and reaction kinetics was used to conduct
first order steady state simulations by directing
variables of a species distribution in reactive zones in
an experimental setup which serves as a simplified
model for an axial lumbar section of the spinal cord
and canal. The mesh of the axial section of the
lumbar spinal cord and canal is discretized into
38782 cells. The sites of reaction in the right and left
dorsal horns were meshed finer for higher accuracy
of simulation results. In figure 5 the mesh is
displayed.
3. Results
3.1 Simulation of Three-Dimensional Spine
In figure 6 the velocity at the C4 ventral section was
measured and plotted. This data presented a
sinusoidal wave. This is representative of one cardiac
cycle for 1 second.
Figure 5. Mesh of axial lumbar section of spinal cord and
canal derived from actual patient image [4,14]
Medical Simulations of Intrathecal Morphine for Pain Control and Management—J. Stewart
24
Figure 8. Morphine distribution along the spine
for 15, 30, and 60 seconds [1]
Figure 7. Morphine distributions over time in the spine
at L2 over 1.65 seconds in the CSF [3]
Morphine was injected at L5-S1 of the spine. In figure
7 the distribution of morphine in the spine at L2 is
shown in the time span of 1.65 seconds.
Figure 8 displays the percentage of morphine
distributed along the spinal cord for 15, 30 and 60
seconds. Morphine peaks at approximately 20% of
morphine after length of injection.
3.2 Simulation of Lumbar Axial Section of
Spinal Cord and Spinal Canal
An initial mass fraction of morphine was set to be a
fixed value. This was repeated for five steady state
simulations with initial mass fractions of morphine of
0.01, 0.05, 0.1, 0.15, and 0.2. The right and left
dorsal horns were set as reactive zones to display
morphine binding. Figure 9 displays the mass
fraction of bound morphine vs. the initial fixed mass
fraction of morphine from the steady state simulation.
This graph shows the amount of bound morphine
found in the right and left dorsal horns depending on
the amount of morphine that is in the CSF. Figure 10
illustrates the contours of the mass fraction morphine
and bound morphine. The volume-average of bound
morphine for the left dorsal horn was 3.6987942e-05
and was 6.005871e-05 for the right dorsal horn.
4. Discussion
The morphine distribution displayed over time at L2
does not change drastically due to the short amount
distribution time, and the fact that the mesh is 3-
dimensional, fewer incidences of dispersion is
expected. Literature states that only 3.8% of
morphine enters the spinal cord when adminstered
intrathecally [12]. The data in figure 10 is
approximately this amount until a mass fraction of
0.2 is injected, this validates that amounts over 0.2
mass fraction are toxic and a physican would not
adminster this amount. The velocity plot shown in
figure 6 is the convective CSF flow field. The flow
dynamics of CSF flow were accounted for by
pulsations that were set by boundary conditions. The
Figure 10. Fixed Mass Fraction of Morphine 0.01:
Contours of the Mass Fraction Morphine (a) and the
Contours of “Morx” (Bound Morphine) (b) [3]
Figure 9. Mass Fraction of Bound Morphine
VS. Fixed Mass Fraction of Bound Morphine
Medical Simulations of Intrathecal Morphine for Pain Control and Management—J. Stewart
25
curve is 10 times larger than clinical data, but this
error can be accounted for in scaling.
5. Conclusion
Pulsatile flow affects the CSF flow field and the
dispersion of morphine in the spinal canal. Receptor
kinetics plays an important role in the uptake of
morphine. The initial concentration of morphine in
the system will determine the amount of morphine
that will bind to the receptors, however, there are not
unlimited receptors in the dorsal horns, and therefore
saturation of the receptors is expected to occur.
Future work includes building a global model that
would compute infusion, distribution, binding, and
downstream cellular events. More specific modeling
conditions including permeability of tissues in the
spine such as the pia membrane, and approximation
of μ-opioid receptors in the cord.
6. Acknowledgements
This work was supported by the Laboratory for
Product and Process Design. The author would like
express her deepest gratitude to Ying Hsu and Dr.
Andreas Linninger for their invaluable guidance,
support, and time in making this project possible.
7. References
1. A.D.A.M. The Anatomy of the Spine.
Photograph. Http://www.adamimages.com/.
2011.
2. ANSYS® Academic Research, Release 13.0,
Help System, Coupled Field Analysis Guide,
ANSYS, Inc.
3. ANSYS® Fluent, Release 6.3.26, Help System,
2ddp, ANSYS, Inc
4. ANSYS® Gambit, Release 2.3.16, Help System,
ANSYS, Inc.
5. Caute, B., B. Monsarrat, C. Gouarderes, J.C.
Verdie, Y. Lazorthes, J. Cros, and R. Bastide.
Csf morphine levels after lumbar intrathecal
administration of isobaric and hyperbaric
solutions for cancer pain. Pain. 141-46. 1988.
6. Chahl, L.A., Opioids: mechanism of action.
Australian Prescriber. 19:63-65. 1996.
7. Faull, R., and J. Villiger. Opiate receptors in the
spinal cord: a detailed anatomical study
comparing the autoradiographic localization of
[3H] diprenorphine binding sites with the
laminar pattern of substance P, myelin and nissl
staining. Neuroscience. 395-407. 1987.
8. DeCasteo L., Meynadier J., and Zenz M.
Regional Opioid Analgesia. The Netherlands:
Kluwer Academic Publishers. 23-26. 1991.
9. GetData Graph Digitizer. Digitize Graphs and
Plots. Vers. 2.24. 2011.
10. Gray, H. Anatomy of the Human
Body. Philadelphia; Lea & Febiger, 2000, 1396
pp.
11. Hanna, M. H., S. J. Peat, M. Woodham, A.
Knibb, and C. Fung. "Analgesic efficacy and csf
Pharmacokinetics of intrathecal morphine-6-
glucuronide: comparison with morphine. British
Journal of Anesthesia. 547-50. 1990.
12. Manx Pain Clinic. Spine01-MRI for Website.
Photograph. Http://www.manxpainclinic.com/us
erimages/spine01-MRI%20for%20website.jpg.
2010.
13. Overney, G. Exploration of human brain tissue.
Micscape Magazine. 84. 2002.
14. Pantakar, S.V., Numerical heat transfer and fluid
flow, Hemisphere Publishing Corporation,
United States, p126-p135. 1980.
15. Raffa, R.B., Porreca, F., Cowan, A., Tallarida,
R.J., Morphine-receptor dissociation constant
and the stimulus-effect relation for inhibition of
gastrointestinal transit in the rat. European
Journal of Pharmacology. 11-16. 1982.
16. Schreiter, A., Gore C., Roques, B.P., Stein, H,
and Machelska, H. Pain control by prevention of
opioid peptide degradation in peripheral
inflamed tissue. European Journal of Pain 13.
89. 2009.
17. Smith, H.S., Deer, T.R., Taats, P.S., Singh, V.,
Sehgal, N., Cordner, H.. Intrathecal drug
delivery. Pain Physician. 89-104. 2008.
26
APPLICATION OF NUCLEAR MAGNETIC RESONANCE IN POROUS
MEDIA Dan Yu
Abstract Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) is now widely used as a tool to study the structure of porous
media system, molecular dynamics, and fluid transport and various processes occurring in them.
There are many types of such systems and an understanding of the spatial distribution of fluids
and their diffusion and flow with these structures is important in a variety of contexts. Examples
can be found in the reservoir rocks and aquifers of the oil and water industries, in biological
tissues and in many other naturally occurring or man-made systems. Typically the measured NMR
properties of molecules in the probed fluid reflect the internal dimensions and geometries of these
structures. This technique can determine characteristics such as the porosity and pore size
distribution, the permeability, the water saturation, the wettability, etc. This paper introduces the
basic theory in the process of using NMR to study porous media, and also a novel method called
NMR Cryoporometry which is developed to determine media pore size and pore size distributions
of porous materials. An application of NMR in porous media is also presented in this paper, which
is the development of the NMR well logging device for measuring nuclear magnetic properties of
fluids in underground porous sediments. NMR is an effective and quantitative method to monitor
the distribution of fluids and flow in porous media, particularly helpful in fields such as well
logging in which it is hardly accessible to sampling.
Keywords: NMR, porous media, permeability, NMR Cryoporometry, well logging
1. Introduction
Flow of fluids through porous media is involved in
many processes in biological and geological areas,
including microscopic and macroscopic researches.
For example, the transfer of gases to blood within the
lung and through organ tissues occurs in porous
media. As another example in a larger scale process,
the flow of water and the flow of petroleum in
underground geological formation are closely
associated with properties of porous media, too. This
is important to help extract petroleum. Even though
these processes are quite different, they share many
characteristics. They involve large expanses in
porous material, which are commonly hard to access
by direct sampling. These processes are considered
important, so researchers strive to design and control
of these flow processes in porous media [11].
1.1 Advantage of Nuclear Magnetic
Resonance
Various of methods used to gain information of
properties and fluid states in the porous media, such
as optical, ultrasonic, and x-ray methods. They all
can be used to visualize fluid saturations and flow
patterns and provide useful information. But all of
these methods have obvious limitations. Nuclear
magnetic resonance provides many exciting new and
effective opportunities for probing fluid states and
flows within porous media to obtain quantitative
information. It is not only an effective method but
also a non-invasive method which is sensitive to
molecular-level events within fluids, and with nuclear
magnetic resonance imaging, fluid states and
properties can be spatially resolved.
1.2 The Basic Idea and Limits of NMR Used
in Porous Media
It is often desired to simulate the flow of fluids in
porous media to design and control processes. Such
simulations require suitable mathematic models that
can describe various fluid states, and various porous
media properties within the models [5].
Many of the issues in modeling flow in porous media
are basically the same in different applications,
except that the terminology is often different.
By detecting the signals from the fluid phase, NMR
imaging is used to acquire information of properties
of flow in porous material. Protons are most
commonly nuclei chosen to be observed. The primary
challenge of NMR imaging in fluid-saturated porous
systems is that the transverse relaxation is too fast.
When the transverse relaxation time is smaller than
the minimum time needed to acquire image data from
Application of Nuclear Magnetic Resonance in Porous Media—D. Yu
27
excitation of the spin system, some relaxation will
have occurred before data are acquired, which will
cause difficulty in quantification of porosity and fluid
saturation. Furthermore, some fluid may not be
observed by NMR, due to its small pore size. This
means NMR has its limitation in detecting fluids that
reside in extremely small pores [5].
1.3 NMR Imaging in Underground Geological
Formations
The essential challenge for successfully applying
NMR in porous media is how to explicate the signals
measured by NMR. That means it is important to find
out the useful properties, which describes the storage
and flow in porous media, from the NMR
measurements [11].
There are a lot of porous media that are studied by
researchers. For example, NMR experiments can be
conducted in well pores to obtain information about
underground geological formations, which has
further increased interest in using NMR to
characterize fluids and flow in porous media. A
considerable effort has been made to study on these
porous media, but it is limited by the lack of means
for observing fluid states within porous media. In this
paper I will elaborate on those methods which are
applied to underground geological formations.
2. Methods
There are are basically two relaxation processes for
fluids in porous media. The first one is called T1
relaxation, which describes the decay of the excited
nuclear spin system associated with the fluid
molecules to thermal equilibrium with its
surroundings (the lattice). Experimentally, this spin-
lattice relaxation process, is the return of the
macroscopic nuclear magnetization to its equilibrium
after a perturbation. The second process is called T2
relaxation, which describes the decay of the spin
system to internal equilibrium. Experimentally, this
spin-spin relaxation process involves the decay to
zero of the magnetization perpendicular to the
external magnetic field [11].
Below I choose some of the most important processes
occurring in porous media when using NMR to
measure and study the properties of the porous media.
2.1 Relaxation Process
Through the modification of the relaxation properties
of the fluid inside the solid phase, we can obtain
physicochemical information on porous media, such
as pore size, wettability, permeability or surface
properties. Moreover, NMR can also use pulsed
gradient techniques to measure and visualize the
diffusion and flow in porous media. The
susceptibility contrast between the fluid and the solid
phases, however, is usually very strong in rocks, and
consequently a significant line-broadening is
observed. Thus, spin-echo methods must be used, and
in some cases more specialized solid-state methods
are necessary [6].
2.2 Diffusion in Porous Media
There are two basic models used in porous media,
which are called microscopic model and macroscopic
model. In this case, microscopic models are chosen.
Because microscopic models can be used to display
the relationship between pore structural features and
responses measured by nuclear magnetic resonance
experiments.
No matter which mechanism of relaxation is
considered, the enhanced relaxation associated with
surfaces is commonly modeled by giving a different
relaxation rate to the region near the solid surfaces
than to the bulk fluid. As a result, the signal
measured by NMR turns out to be proportional to the
total spin magnetization throughout the sample. This
depends on many factors, and the most essential one
is the interaction of molecular diffusion of the spins
with the geometry of the porous media [11].
2.3 Surface-Limited and Diffusion-Limited
Regimes
The relaxation will be enhanced in the pore-grain
interface in porous media. If the magnetic relaxation
occurs at the surface, the nuclear magnetization in a
pore is uniform. In this case, the magnetization decay
in the pore depending on the surface-to-volume ratio
of the pore instead of depending on the pore shape.
This is called the 'fast diffusion' or 'surface-limited'
regime [8].
In the opposite, if the magnetic relaxation occurs at
the grain surface, when pores are large or surface
relaxation is strong. In this case, the magnetization
decay depends on the shape of the pore and the
magnetization in the pore is not uniform. This is
called 'slow diffusion' or 'diffusion-limited' regime
[8].
Application of Nuclear Magnetic Resonance in Porous Media—D. Yu
28
2.4 Line Broadening
As we know, the NMR spectrum for fluid regarding
to one signal resonance frequency is Lorentzian in
shape, and has a width of few hertz. However, when
fluids in porous media interact with solid surfaces,
the line widths will rise, which is ranging from 102 to
104 Hz. Also the transverse relation rate will be faster
[11].
The spectrum also has relationships with some
properties in porous media. It has been observed that
the transverse relaxation time decreases as the fluid
saturation is lowered. Another experiment shows that
the spectral width increases with decreasing water
saturation. In fact, the inhomogeneous line
broadening in porous media (rocks) is mainly due to
the variations of magnetic susceptibility [11].
However, this line-broadening dependence result in
limitation of resolution in NMR, because the
resolution cannot exceed this fundamental parameter.
Moreover, the line broadening can also be used to
detect fractures in porous media. If there are fractures,
it will lead to significantly broadened line shapes,
because resonance frequencies of the fractures and
porous matrix are shifted by different amounts [11].
3. Results Using NMR in porous media, we can obtain
quantitative information, about pore size,
permeability and wettability. In this section, several
essential properties of porous media associated with
well logging are discussed in the first part. Also a
new NMR technique for measuring pore size is
briefly introduced. Lastly, the application to well
logging and the recent progress in this field are
briefly discussed.
3.1 NMR Permeability
Permeability is a very important property which is
essential in research and also industry associated with
porous media, such as well logging. Permeability is
the ability of fluids to flow through the rocks. The
higher the permeability, the easier it is to extract oil
and gas from the well.
NMR is typically used to measure permeability for
fluid typing and to obtain formation porosity. The
common approach is based on the model proposed by
Brownstein and Tarr [4]. They have shown that, in
the fast diffusion limit, given by the expression:
(1)
where ρ is the surface relaxivity of pore wall
material, r is the radius of the spherical pore and D is
the bulk diffusivity.
For a single pore, the magnetic decay as a function of
time is described by a single exponential:
(2)
where M0 is the initial magnetization and the
transverse relaxation time T2 is given by:
(3)
S / V is the surface-to-volume ratio of the pore, T2b is
bulk relaxation time of the fluid that fills the pore
space, and ρis the surface relaxation strength. When
the pores are small or the ρ is large, the bulk
relaxation time is small and the equation can be
simplified by:
(4)
In fact, real rocks should contain different types of
pores which have different sizes. These pores are
connected with narrow and small pore "throats"
which restrict interpore diffusion. But if we neglect
the influence of these "throats", we can consider
every pore as a distinct and independent pore and the
magnetization with each pore decays independently.
The decay can be represented by:
(5)
where ai is the volume fraction of pores of size i that
decays with relaxation time T2.
3.2 Wettability
The wettability conditions contain two or more
different fluid phases, which determine the
microscopic fluid distribution in pore network.
Nuclear magnetic resonance is effective and sensitive
to wettability, because the solid surface has strong
Application of Nuclear Magnetic Resonance in Porous Media—D. Yu
29
effect on promoting magnetic relaxation of the
saturating fluid.
There has been a long history of researchers
measuring wettability. The idea of using NMR to
measure wettability was first presented by Brown and
Fatt in 1956 [3]. Their theory is built on a hypothesis
that the movements of molecules are slower in bulk
liquid than at the solid-liquid interface. In this solid-
liquid interface the diffusion coefficient is reduced,
corresponding to a zone of higher viscosity. In this
higher viscosity zone, the magnetically aligned
protons can more easily transfer their energy to their
surroundings. Thus, the magnitude of this effect
depends upon the wettability characteristics of the
solid with respect to the liquid in contact with the
surface [7].
3.3 NMR Cryoporometry
NMR Cryoporometry (NMRC) is a recent technique
for measuring total porosity and pore size
distributions. It is based on the Gibbs-Thomson effect:
small crystals of a liquid in the pores melt at a lower
temperature than the bulk liquid. The melting point
depression is inversely proportional to the pore size.
This technique is well connected with gas adsorption
to measure pore sizes [9].
In a Cryoporometry measurement, some amount of
liquid is imbibed into the porous media (sample), and
the sample cools until all the liquid is frozen. Then it
warms slowly while measuring the quantity of the
liquid that has melted. This process is similar to DSC
thermoporosimetry, except that it has a higher
resolution. Because the signal detection does not rely
on transient heat flows, and the measurement can be
made discretionarily slowly. It is especially suitable
for those pores whose diameters range from 2 nm-2
µm.
As the fact that in many cases, the T2 relaxation time
in a frozen material is much shorter than that in
mobile material, Nuclear Magnetic Resonance is
suitable for using as a convenient method of
measuring the quantity of liquid that has melted, as a
function of time.
This technique is also suitable to experiment on
structural resolution in spatially dependent pore size
distribution [10], and dynamic information of the
liquid [1].
3.4 Application in Well Logging
Well logging measurements are always considered to
be quite complicated. But it is widely admitted that
the main target is the measurement of geophysical
properties under the surface of rocks. There are many
properties useful for well logging, such as
permeability, porosity and fluid content.
To introduce the definition of these properties,
porosity is the proportion of fluid-filled space within
rocks. It is this space which contains the oil and gas.
Permeability is the ability of fluids to flow through
rocks. The higher the porosity, the higher the possible
oil and gas content of rocks. The higher the
permeability, the easier for the oil and gas to flow
toward the well bore.
Beyond just the porosity and permeability, various
logging measurements allow the interpretation of
what kinds of fluids are in the pores—oil, gas, brine.
Moreover, the logging measurements can also be
used to study the mechanical properties of the rock
formations. These researches are important, because
these properties can be used to determine what kind
of damage (such as erosion) will possibly happen
during oil and gas production.
3.4.1 Small-scale instrumentation for nuclear
magnetic resonance of porous media
Researchers have been making an effort to design
instruments that can be used in porous media for a
long time, and develop small-scale nuclear magnetic
resonance instruments that are mobile and can be
moved into the site of the object, such as well pore of
an oil well. The analysis was originally restricted by
the inferior homogeneity of the magnets. But today
portable and mobile magnets are available for all
kinds of NMR measurements, including relaxometry,
imaging and spectroscopy in two types of geometries
(figure 1) [2].
These small-scale instruments are built with
permanent magnets, so the magnetic field strengths
are low. These low-field instruments come with
closed magnets and open magnets. The former
surrounds the sample, and the latter one is exposed to
the object and acquires NMR signal from a sensitive
volume outside the magnet and inside the object.
Currently these small-scale NMR instruments are
used for porosity analysis, describing of diesel
particulate filters, the determination of the moisture
content from grey concrete, and also new approaches
to analyze the pore space and moisture migration in
soil [2].
Application of Nuclear Magnetic Resonance in Porous Media—D. Yu
30
Figure 1. Instruments for small-scale NMR and for large-scale NMR [2].
This principle has been pioneered in well-logging
NMR and become popular for materials testing
with the invention of the NMR-MOUSE [2].
4. Discussion
Flows in the porous media are important in many
biological and geological processes. But sometimes
the sample is not accessible, so researchers make
much effort to design such instruments and in order
to measure and control the processes happened in
these media.
NMR in porous media is based on microscopic and
macroscopic mathematical models. It measures
several main properties of porous media to reflect
internal properties so we can predict what kind of
process (or sometimes damage) will happen during
industrial processes, such as production of oil and gas
from reservoir rocks. This greatly helps in specific
industry fields.
5. Conclusion
This paper briefly describes the process of using
nuclear magnetic resonance as a tool to study the
structure of porous media systems. Compared to
other techniques, such as sonic or x-ray, NMR turns
out to be an effective and quantitative method to
monitor the distribution of fluids and flow in porous
media, even though NMR also has its limitations, like
resolution.
NMR provides a suitable way to measure the porous
media that is hardly accessible for sampling. This
makes NMR widely applied in fields such as
measuring oil and gas in reservoir rocks. During the
experiment, researchers put NMR instruments in the
sample instead of taking the sample to the NMR
instruments, which is a revolutionary method in
measuring and monitoring properties in porous media.
6. References
1. Alnaimi, S.M. Binary liquid mixtures in porous
solids. Journal of Chemical Physics. 120 (5):
2075-2077, 2004
2. Blümich, F. C., M. D. et al. Small scale-
instrumentation for nuclear magnetic resonance
of porous media. New Journal of Physics.13
(2011) 015003 (15pp)
3. Brown, Fatt. Measurements of fractional
wettability of oil fields' rocks by the nuclear
magnetic relaxation method. Society of
Petroleum Engineers. Fall Meeting of the
Petroleum Branch of AIME, 14-17 October
1956, Los Angeles, California
Application of Nuclear Magnetic Resonance in Porous Media—D. Yu
31
4. Brownstein K.R., Tarr C.E. Importance of
classical diffusion in NMR studies of water in
biological cells. Physical Review A. 19 (6): 2446,
1979
5. Chang, A.T. Watson. NMR imaging of fluids
and flow in porous media. Experimental
Methods in the Physcial Sciences. 35: 387-423
6. Guillot. MRI of oil/water in rocks. Encyclopedia
of Spectroscopy and Spectrometry. p. 1380-1387,
1999
7. Howard J.J. Quantitative estimates of porous
media wettability from proton NMR, Magnetic
resonance imaging. 16 (5–6): 529, 1998
8. Kleinberg. Well logging. Encyclopedia of
Magnetic Resonance. 2007.
9. Mitchell J, Webber J. B. W., Strange J. H.
Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Cryoporometry,
Physics Reports, 461 (1): 1–36, 2008
10. Strange, J.H. Spatially resolved pore size
distributions by NMR. Measurement Science
and Technology. 8 (5): 555-561, 1997
11. Watson, C. T. Philip Chang. Characterizing
porous media with NMR methods. Progress in
Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy. 31:
343-386, 1997
32
VIEWING INTERVERTEBRAL DISC PROPERTIES OF RODENT
ANIMALS THROUGH MORPHOLOGY AND MRI Julia Zelenakova [email protected]
Abstract Rodents are popular laboratory animals used for investigation of intervertebral disc disease and
other spine related disabilities. Rodents have well-characterized skeleton, although it possesses a
smaller cancellous bone to total bone mass ratio, when compared to human skeleton. Similarly,
the rodent intervertebral disc consists of the nucleus pulposus (NP) surrounded by the annulus
fibrosus (AF). Disc provides acceptable resemblance in terms of morphology, cellularity,
biochemistry and biomechanical properties. It is possible to observe the changes in signal
intensity when comparing a control group of animals with a group that shows signs of disc
degeneration. Nevertheless, different stages of disc degeneration and the structures of the
intervertebral disc itself can be recognized using fast spin echo sequences. T1 and T2 relaxation
times are recorded to distinguish between regions of the spine motion segment. Structures such us
the nucleus pulposus, annulus fibrosus, cartilaginous endplates and the vertebral bodies are able
to be displayed with excellent soft tissue contrast and high spatial resolution. It is more difficult to
acquire diffusion tensor imaging data to quantify variations in water diffusion, due to microscopic
structures of collagen fibers and the overall size of the disc. It is necessary to understand the
animal disc features and use previously obtained knowledge as a foundation for diagnostics of the
degenerative disc disease pathways and its progression in humans.
Keywords: Intervertebral Disc, MRI, Rodent, Disc Degeneration Disease, Nucleus Pulposus,
Annulus Fibrosus
1. Introduction
Rodents have interacted with the human population
for decades and are mostly known for disease
spreading and crop destruction. Although their
reputation among the general public has not
improved over the years, they have become very
popular in the research society. Small animal rodent
models are widely used to conduct physiological and
biochemical research studies. Rats have been
domesticated as first mammals for being tireless,
their compact size, breeding habits, short lifespan,
and their personality features. Rodents become
addicted to drugs, alcohol and other substances
similarly as humans, and their system can absorb and
eliminate several drugs at comparable rates. The
Food and Drug Administration usually requires
rodent animal studies as a foundation to preclinical
investigation. Rodents comprise up to 95% of all
laboratory animals used for research purposes. [1, 2]
Orthopaedic research is among the many fields that
have adopted rodent mammals as its research model
for biochemical, morphological and biomechanical
analysis. Several hundred papers have fully examined
the properties of specific bones and cooperation of
musculature within the whole skeleton. Particularly
large interest has been given to the investigation of
the spine [1,2,4,7]. Both skeletally immature and
mature animal models are used for specific aims,
such as whether examined changes are related to
adolescent bone growth, or if they are related to fully
mature bone. However, animal models are not limited
to only the investigation of bone properties, but also
soft tissue components. Using animal models is
necessary in order to gain insight in elementary
mechanisms and to evaluate new treatment strategies.
They have shown importance particularly in
investigation of intervertebral disc degeneration
disease. Several requirements must be met in order to
proceed with animal models, such as inducing the
degeneration of the disc. In order to mimic the state
of progression as it occurs in humans, the animal
intervertebral disc model should be validated in terms
of morphology, cellularity, biochemistry and
biomechanical properties. Nevertheless, animals
studied for specific findings need to possess the same
characteristics in their group to avoid any other
influences on the studied matter. Comparison of the
animal intervertebral disc model to the human
intervertebral disc needs to be properly optimized in
order to draw conclusions for our findings.
Spontaneous recovery should not occur while the
evaluation of our tested animal models is ongoing,
and all treatments to the intervertebral disc need to be
reproducible and reliable during modeling procedures
for inducing animal disc degeneration.
Viewing Intervertebral Disc Properties of Rodent Animals through Morphology and MRI—J. Zelenakova
33
2. Similarities and Deviations between
Rodent and Human IVD Anatomy
Reversal of disc degeneration disease has yet to be
discovered. Rodent animal models are widely used to
study the role of therapeutic treatment and surgical
procedures in order to halt the occurrence of
degenerative disc disease. Animal species are
evaluated, measured and compared with each other in
order to find a valuable animal model for exploration
of intervertebral disc chronic disorder.
Figure 1. Representative axial cross section from human,
rat tail and lumbar and mouse tail and lumbar intervertebral
disc. [5]
The human intervertebral disc consists of the annulus
fibrosus and the nucleus pulposus, and it is connected
to adjacent vertebral bodies with cartilagenous
endplates. This basic morphological structure of the
intervertebral disc is shared with most other animal
species. It is reasonable to suggest that establishing
animal models for examining the intervertebral disc
would be a great opportunity to learn about how to
preserve the function of the human disc and possibly
how to treat degenerative disc disorders, which occur
in the majority of the global adult population.
However, the availability of the tissue, the decreased
variability between subjects compared with humans,
and the feasibility to perform in vivo experiments is
relevant for successful study, as the animal models
are often criticized for being irrelevant to the human
situation.
2.1 Cellular Composition of Rodent and
Human Intervertebral Disc
All animals that model disc degeneration have
insufficiencies in their comparability to humans. One
of them is the difference in size of the intervertebral
disc, where the small size of the rodent disc affects
the diffusion process important for oxygenation and
nutrient supply of cartilage. The human intervertebral
disc lacks notochordal cells at the age of skeletal
maturity, whereas in the animal disc the notochordal
cells are present, even during the post-adolescent
period of their lifespan. This is a crucial difference
between the human and animal disc because it is
affects the progression of degeneration and
regeneration of the disc. Notochordal cells are
believed to modify disc matrix synthesis, and their
presence influences the cell viability and nutrition of
the disc and affects proteoglycan content in the
nucleus pulposus. Proteoglycan fragmentation is
usually the starting indication of human disc
degeneration and it can be mimicked by injections of
different degrading enzymes that affect
proteoglycans. This is one of the methods of how disc
degeneration can be induced in the rodent animal
model. When the nucleus pulposus starts to lose
proteoglycans, it is losing its water binding capacity,
and changes in the mechanical properties are
followed by alterations of biochemical factors.
Similarly with humans, a common pathway of
increasing intervertebral disc degeneration takes
place, where alterations in the nucleus pulposus and
the anulus fibrosus occur.
Other signs of degenerative disc disease are loss of
disc height and signal intensity on T2-weighted
magnetic resonace images, histologic and
macroscopic changes, and biochemical and gene
expression pattern modifications. Researchers are
trying to induce these cascades in the rodent animal
models as well as in other animal species to learn
about the progression of the disc diseases, by
attempting to follow the pathways of its progression.
2.2 Morphological Composition of Rodent
and Human Intervertebral Disc
Several disc types were investigated in comparison to
the human disc in terms of cost, availability, and time
constraints. Lumbar disc geometry for the rat and
mouse were evaluated, as well as tail disc geometry
for both rodent species. Their geometrical properties
were normalized and compared with humans. The
representative axial cross section of the rat tail, rat
lumbar, mouse tail and lumbar intervertebral disc is
shown on the Figure 1.[5]. The human intervertebral
disc is noted for its kidney-like shape, and both
rodent species differ from this shape.
The tail intervertebral disc of both species has a
circular cross-section and its shape is unlike the
human one. Tail disc models have been often used
Viewing Intervertebral Disc Properties of Rodent Animals through Morphology and MRI—J. Zelenakova
34
because of its excellent when surgical procedures are
required in the studies. Tail models are also preferred
when biomechanical loads are applied on the
intervertebral disc to measure mechanical properties
of both healthy and degenerative disc. Numerous in
vivo studies use external fixators that can easily be
attached to the tails of both rodent species. Future
investigations are needed to confirm that using the
rodent tail disc provides a valid comparison to the
anatomy and function of the human disc.
Unfortunately, there is still a general lack of
comparative data with respect to the human disc.
Analog animal models are evaluated by vertebral
body anatomy, biomechanics, size, cost, disc
geometry, biochemistry, cellularity and others.
Table 1. Normalized Parameters of the Disc to the Area, as
well as to the Lateral and Antero-Posterior Width [5]
Height Lateral
width
AP
Width
Area
Human 0.202 1.0 0.665 0.553
Rat L 0.161 1.0 0.753 0.609
Mouse L 0.169 1.0 0.674 0.535
Rat T 0.288 1.0 1.067 0.834
Mouse T 0.198 1.0 1.083 0.813
One of these studies focused on the comparison of
disc anatomies across animal species and compared
the rat lumbar and tail anatomy as well as mouse
lumbar and tail anatomy. It showed a comprehensive
evaluation of rodent disc geometry, axial cross
sections, shape and position of the nucleus pulposus.
Relative disc height for the rodent species has been
also collected. All obtained parameters were
normalized and compared with human lumbar disc
geometry, see Figure 2. The scaled dimensions
collected are summarized for the rodent species in the
Table 1 [5] and can further be used for mechanical
testing protocols and finite element models.
The geometry of the animal disc must be taken into
consideration when analyzing collected mechanical
data. Interesting findings show that the mouse tail
normalized disc height is the only species within 10%
of the human disc. The normalized disc height is
larger in the rat tail than the human, and the rest of
the species seems to have a smaller normalized disc
height. Human lumbar disc anterior-posterior width is
most closely matched within 10 to 15% by the mouse
and rat lumbar discs. The mouse and rat tail discs
have a large normalized anterior-posterior width
when compared to human disc, because of the
circular shape of the intervertebral discs in the tail.
[3, 6] Validation for the mouse and rat disc as an
animal model of the human disc provides correlations
between lumbar spine properties and rodent lumbar
spine models. The differences between lumbar and
tail intervertebral disc need additional examination in
order to select the appropriate model for the human
disc.
Figure 2. Schematic view of IVD cross-section, defining
geometric parameters of IVD. Disc LW and Disc AP-W are
disc width in lateral and antero-posterior direction,
respectively. Nucleus LW and Nucleus AP-W are nucleus
pulposus lateral and antero-posterior widths, respectively.
After normalizing parameters across the rodent
species, several ratios were taken into account: the
disc height scaled by lateral width, the AP width
scaled by lateral width, and the nucleus pulposus area
scaled by disc area. Overall deviation from human
geometry for these parameters is the following:
mouse lumbar (12%), rat lumbar (15%), mouse tail
(18%) and rat tail (46%) [3]. It can be noted that
using the rat tail disc model for comparison with the
human disc might not be the best idea.
2.3 Posture Differences between Rodent and
Human Intervertebral Disc
Another limitation of using rodent animal disc
models is that most of the animals used for spine
research are quadruped. Whether the horizontal
position of the animal spine can be an adequate
model of the vertical human spine position from the
biomechanical point of view can be questioned.
Because of the horizontal vs. vertical positions of the
spine, there is subsequently a difference in terms of
mechanical load that animal and human spine
experience. It can be seen in the behavior of the
animal bone, and it corresponds morphologically to
the different directions of trabeculae formation as in
humans. Bone needs to withstand the physiological
and mechanical loads that are necessary to control the
posture of either a quadruped or bipedal spine, so as a
consequence its structure will be affected. This
phenomenon is described by Wolff’s law. Due to
additional tensile forces from muscles and ligaments,
quadrupeds experience more axial compression on
their spine. [8]
Viewing Intervertebral Disc Properties of Rodent Animals through Morphology and MRI—J. Zelenakova
35
Figure 3. Rat Skeleton [10]
In order to direct the quadruped posture, the rodent
spine is mainly loaded by axial compression. This is
why trabeculae in a rodent’s vertebral body are found
to be in the horizontal direction between the superior
and inferior endplates. Differences in bipedal and
quadruped posture of humans and rodents
respectively are causing differences in the bone
structures of the vertebrae between the species. The
density of the vertebrae of humans is lower than that
of rodent vertebrae, signifying that the quadruped
posture has to sustain higher axial compression
stresses than the upright human posture. As a result,
the rodent vertebrae will absorb most of the axial
compression and its intervertebral disc will
experience a smaller amount of compression force.
Figure 4. Human Skeleton [11]
Rodent vertebral bodies are longer when compared to
human ones, so this results in a smaller rodent disc
height when normalized and compared to humans.
Therefore, there are some restrictions on the
transferability of the outcome from rodent animal
experiments to the human situation. The rodent
skeleton consists of 6 lumbar vertebrae and 12 caudal
(tail) vertebrae (see Figure 3). And the shape of
rodent vertebra resembles human vertebral bodies,
though posterior spine elements differ in angle
orientation as well as in size and shape. Even if it is
accepted that quadruped animal spines are
experiencing different loads from those in the upright
human spine (see Figure 4), several studies show
remarkable resemblance in geometry, demonstrating
that quadruped and bipedal spines must be loaded in
a similar way.
3. Monitoring Rodent IVD through
Magnetic Resonance Imaging
It is possible to observe the changes in signal
intensity when comparing a control group of animals
with a group that shows signs of disc degeneration.
Nevertheless, different stages of disc degeneration
and the structures of the intervertebral disc itself can
be recognized using fast spin echo sequences [6,9].T1
and T2 relaxation times are recorded to distinguish
between regions of the spine motion segment.
Structures such us the nucleus pulposus, annulus
fibrosus, cartilaginous endplates and the vertebral
bodies are able to be displayed with excellent soft
tissue contrast and high spatial resolution.
Figure 5. Cross-section of the rat IVD using 9.4T magnet at
UIC, using 5mm coil
The T2-weighted image in Figure 5 represents a
cross-sectional area of rat lumbar L2 healthy disc. It
is displaying different structures of the rodent
intervertebral disc; such as annulus fibrosus and
nucleus pulposus using 9.4T magnet at the NMR
facility of UIC. In this image you can clearly
distinguish these structures of the disc. Along the
perimeter of the disc are fiber layers that form the
annulus fibrosus. Near the middle of the disc, the
Viewing Intervertebral Disc Properties of Rodent Animals through Morphology and MRI—J. Zelenakova
36
fibers are being replaced by gellous structures in the
transitional zone. The center of the rat disc is formed
by the nucleus pulposus, and it has approximately
80% to 95% content of the water. It is a gel-like
substance and it acts as a shock absorber for the
spine. Traces in the green color are representing
annulus fibrosus portions of the disc, the yellow trace
located in the center, is the representative of the
nucleus pulposus. Special preparation of the rat disc
specimen was done by carefully dissecting the rat
intervertebral disc from the spinal column, cutting off
posterior elements and dissecting vertebral bodies in
order to fit the disc into a 5mm coil used for
Magnetic Resonance Imaging. It is more difficult to
acquire diffusion tensor imaging data to quantify
variations in water diffusion, due to microscopic
structures of collagen fibers and the overall size of
the disc.
4. Conclusion
Rodents are popular laboratory animals used for
investigation of intervertebral disc disease and other
spine related disabilities. Rodents have well-
characterized skeleton, although it possesses a
smaller cancellous bone to total bone mass ratio,
when compared to human skeleton. Similarly, the
rodent intervertebral disc consists of the nucleus
pulposus surrounded by the annulus fibrosus, and
provides acceptable resemblance in terms of
morphology, cellularity, biochemistry and
biomechanical properties. Choosing appropriate
methods to fully explore the properties of the rodent
intervertebral disc, will give us a powerful tool for
future analysis of human disc pathologies.
Limitations for radiological data collections
presented in this paper include the size of the imaged
structures, where both rodent species are quite small.
This paper reviews deviations in morphology
structures between human and rodent intervertebral
discs, and demonstrates the close similarities between
the two. The process of disc degeneration involves
alterations in structural proteins within the
extracellular matrix including collagens and
proteoglycans, which can be displayed radiologically
as well as histologically. Previous studies have used
animal models to mimic human degenerative disc
disease, and this trend will continue in the future,
especially due to cost effectiveness, vailability and
lifespan of the animal. Immunohistochemical,
biomechanical and radiological analysis will help
explore the animal intervertebral disc, so it can be a
better tool for future investigation of human disc
degeneration disease.
5. References
1. Clause, B. T. The Wistar Rat as a Right Choice:
Establishing Mammalian Standards and the Ideal
of a Standardized Mammal. J. Hist. Biol,, 26(2):
329-349, 1993
2. Trull F. L., B. Rich. More Regulation of
Rodents., Science 284(5419):1463, 1999
3. Elliott, D. M. and Sarver J. J. Young Investigator
Award Winner: Validation of the Mouse and Rat
Disc as Mechanical Models of the Human
Lumbar Disc. Spine 29 (7): 713–72, 2004
4. Gruber H. et al. The Sand Rat Model for Disc
Degeneration: Radiologic Characterization of
Age-Related Changes. Spine 27(3):230–234,
2002
5. O’Connell, G. et al. Comparison of Animals
Used in Disc Research to Human Lumbar Disc
Geometry. Spine 32(3): 328-333, 2007
6. Pfirrmann, C. W., A. Metzdorf, M. Zanetti, J.
Hodler, and N. Boos. Magnetic Resonance
Classification of Lumbar Intervertebral Disc
Degeneration. Spine 26(17): 1873-1878, 2001
7. Singh, K. et al. Animal models for human disc
degeneration. The Spine Journal 5:267S–279,
2005
8. Smit, T. H. The use of a quadruped as an in vivo
model for the study of the spine - biomechanical
considerations. Eur Spine J 11 :137–144, 2002
9. Sobajima, S. et al. A Slowly Progressive and
Reproducible Animal Model of Intervertebral
Disc Degeneration Characterized by MRI, X-
Ray, and Histology. Spine 30(1):15-24, 2005
10. ―Rat Skeleton.‖ Carolina Biological Supply
Company. Web. February 2012.
<http://www.carolina.com/text/pdf/owls/ratskelet
on.pdf>
11. ―Vertebral Column.‖ Spineuniverse. Web. 20
Sept. 2011.
<http://www.spineuniverse.com/anatomy/vertebr
al-column>.
37
CALL FOR ARTICLES - FALL 2012
Mission The mission of the journal is to develop the art of scientific writing among students.
Students may submit articles that discuss original research or review research published
elsewhere. This allows students to hone their writing skills without being limited by a
lack of a data to present. The journal also provides students with an opportunity to be
involved as editors and reviewers. This gives students an overall appreciation of the
processes involved in disseminating scientific findings. The journal finally serves to
expose the reader to current trends in the bioengineering spectrum.
Scope Completed research projects are not necessary for publication. Articles are intended to
document research accomplishments to date. It is expected that many of the articles that
appear in the journal will later be expanded to full-length studies and published
elsewhere. Publication in the UBSJ will not preclude later publication of the results in a
more complete presentation. Submissions can range from original research articles and
technical reviews to book reviews relevant to bioengineering. Letters to the editor are
also welcome.
Submission Process & Guidelines
We have setup a Bioengineering Student Journal Blackboard site to streamline
submissions and make the process as transparent as possible.
1. Single author.
2. The student must be a current UIC Bioengineering undergraduate/graduate student.
3. Only review and research articles may be submitted.
4. Appropriate credit must be cited and permission must be given when applicable.
5. Papers are typically around 4-6 pages long and must be formatted according the
template available on Blackboard.
6. The criteria of acceptance shall be based on volume of papers received, relevance,
subject mastery, organization, appropriate documentation etc.
7. Please refrain from submitting any material that might involve copyright restrictions.
This journal is for learning purposes only. Papers already submitted elsewhere, in-press,
or already published may not be resubmitted here.
8. All submissions will be peer reviewed and the author will be informed in advance if
their article is selected for publication.
9. Submissions are to be made as both .doc and .pdf files. The files shall be named in the
following format:
AuthorName_AuthorLastName_AbbreviatedArticleTitle_VersionMonthDate
If you have any questions please contact:
38
FRONT
“Broken Knee, X-ray”. Image courtesy of © Zephyr/Science Photo Library/Corbis (royalty-
free, license obtained).
SEM of a Neuron Cell. Image courtesy of ACM at the University of Illinois at Urbana-
Champaign, part of the Sigbio group project. URL:
<http://www.acm.uiuc.edu/sigbio/project/nervous/micro_info/ct_neuron.html>.
Gene Sequencing Plot. Image courtesy of M. F McDermott, et. al., from “Germline Mutations
in the Extracellular Domains of the 55 kDa TNF Receptor, TNFR1, Define a Family of
Dominantly Inherited Autoinflammatory Syndromes.” Cell 97 (1999): 133-144.
Action Potential Plot. Image courtesy of Sharanya Arcot Desai et. al., from “Improving
impedance of implantable microwire multi-electrode arrays by ultrasonic electroplating of
durable platinum black.” Frontiers in Neuroengineering 3 (2010).
BACK
Cell-Stained Images a-f. Image courtesy of W. Boesmans, et. al., from ”Brain-derived
neurotrophic factor amplifies neurotransmitter responses and promotes synaptic communication
in the enteric nervous system.” Neurogastroenterology 57 (2007): 314-322.
Protein Subunits 3D Image. Image courtesy of the University of Texas Health Science Center
at San Antonio.
Blood Flow Dynamics in Vessels. Image courtesy of Fernando Calamante, et. al., from
“Estimation of bolus dispersion effects in perfusion MRI using image-based computational fluid
dynamics”.
bioe.uic.edu