Upload
renna-alyassini
View
212
Download
0
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
UPMC Center for Quality Improvement & Innovation
Citation preview
team catharsisca•thar•sis: a purifying or figurative cleansing of the emotions.A release of emotional tension, as after an overwhelming experience, that restores or refreshes the spirit.
Design for Service Fall 2007 Renna Alyassini • Christina Payne • Reina Takahashi • Diana Yu UPMC Cath Lab
Team Catharsis is a group of 4 students from Carnegie Mellon University School of Design. As part of a service design project and an introduction through UPMC’s Quality Improvement, the team was assigned to design a better experience for those involved with the CHA through research, prototyping and ideation. We wanted to connect to the Cath Holding Area on an emotional level and found “catharsis” an appropriate, euphonic term.
4
The Cardiac Catheterization Holding Area (CHA) at UPMC Presbyterian is located on the third floor. It services Catheterization patients (Cath), Trans-esophageal patients (TEE), Electrophysiology patients (EP) and emergency patients as a pre- and post-procedure holding area.
The procedure is outpatient, although some patients may be admitted for observation
overnight. Additionally, the CHA will hold inpatients when there is an overflow.
There are 14 bed spaces and a central nurses station. Each bed space has three walls with a front curtain, television and chair. The nurses’ station is rather cluttered with computers and files. There is a linen cart in plain view; however there are plans to build a closet.
ABOUT THE CATH LAB
cath•eter•izationthe operation
of introducing a catheter into
the body.
5
The waiting area is down the hall from the CHA and also primarily serves Gastrointestinal patients. There is a reception desk where CHA patients
must check-in. A private room labeled “Consult 1” is at the other end. There is another sign and door labeled “Consult 2”, however that is blocked off.
ABOUT THE CATH LAB
The Check-in
6
PATIENT TOUCHPOINTS
Based on our first visit and information provided by the UPMC Quality Improvement team, the patient’s touchpoints and stakeholders through the CHA experience are identified and diagrammed.
touch•point: the point of contact,
especially when products or services
come in contact with a customer.
MD
Patie
nt P
athw
ay
Diagnosed/Referred to UPMC
ContactScheduler
Arrive in Oakland
NavigateHallways & Find MPU
Enter CHAPre Procedure Tasks
Enter CHAPre Procedure Tasks
Enter CHAPre Procedure Tasks
Check-In & Consult
UPMC ›
CHA ›
Home Pittsburgh
Taken to Lab
Discharged or admitted tohospital
Return to CHAPost Procedure Tasks
MD Office Check-Up
SendMaterialsPre Procedure Call
EP Lab CATH Lab TEE Lab
UPM
C Ac
tions
7
CATH LAB STAKEHOLDERS
stake•hold•er: someone who has a share or an interest in an organization.
tee
patient
hospital care
techniciandoctor
nursepractitioner
admin
check-inreceptionist
consult room
pre-visitcontact
referring doctornurse caller
lab work nurse/tech
parking (valet)poha
appointmentreceptionist
family &friends
upmc
patient
emergency
patient
cath
patient
ep
patient
nurse
8
KEY STAKEHOLDERS
Key StakeholdersThe primary stakeholders that affect the CHA everyday are separated into quadrants.
CHA StaffUPMC
PatientsFamily & Friends
10
OBSERVATIONAL RESEARCH
After our preliminary visit, we began the research phase for the CHA. We spent several hours observing all of the key touchpoints at UPMC.
Observation: We walked through the physical touchpoints that the patients experience when they arrive at UPMC. We observed the signs used for wayfinding and where it might be confusing for patients and family.
way•find•ing: signs, maps and other graphic or
audible methods to convey directions
to travelers.
11
OBSERVATIONAL RESEARCH
Storytelling and InterviewingWe sat in the waiting area and spoke to patients and families who were there for the CHA. We asked questions about their morning before arriving and if they had concerns about the day. We observed the interactions of the patients and families waiting; did they read, watch television, sleep? Were they bored, frustrated and confused, or comfortable, relaxed and aware?
We went the CHA and observed the actions of the staff during a morning shift on a Thursday, the day typically with the most patients scheduled. When they had a moment between patients, the nurses told us how the CHA works and what tools they use.
Document CollectionWe wanted to understand what written communication was exchanged between stakeholders. We requested and received all the documents that are sent to CHA patients from the time their appointments are scheduled. We also collected the paperwork used by the nurses for post-procedure.
Exploratory ResearchIn addition to the research in the CHA, we looked at other ser-vice environments. We researched the amenities available in luxury hospitals and high-end hotels and brainstormed about what might be appreciated by CHA patients.
12
Exploratory Research (cont’d)We discovered a publication written for and by other hospitals’ CHA staff, called Cath Lab Digest. We researched some of the problems other Cath labs were facing, including patient flow and equipment shortage, and what improvements they made.
Later in our research phase, we discovered the special surgery center at UPMC Montefiore. We were very surprised to find that many ideas developed in our first brainstorming session were already implemented. Not only were many of our ideas already in place, they were right across the bridge at Montefiore. We observed and documented the touchpoints for the surgery patients and compared and contrasted them with the CHA patients. From many of the design improvements already in place, patients there had a much different experience from patients at the Cath Lab.
OBSERVATIONAL RESEARCH
13
in•ter•ac•tive: involving the communication or collaboration of people or things
To gain a true understanding of the CHA experience, it was essential for us to involve the key stakeholders and gain their trust and insight. We focused on our primary stakeholders in the CHA: staff, patients and family.
In the waiting area, we used an existing bulletin board space to put up an interactive bulletin board for patients, staff, family and friends. With lightbulb-shaped and speech-bubble shaped notes, and pens and tacks, we encouraged everyone in the waiting area to “tell us what you think.”
We designed and distributed journal cards for patients, so they could write about how they feel throughout the process in the CHA.
IDEAS
Please Circle One: GI or CHA
CHA Patient Input Card
On this card, please tell us your suggestions.
_______ would make me feel more comfortable during my stay here.(for example: warm blankets, less noise, reading material...)
It was helpful that UPMC told me about _______ before I came today. (for example: information about my procedure, food restrictions...)
I wish I also knew _______ before I came here today.(for example: lab work needed, better directions to UPMC...)
I’d like to receive information about today in the following ways:(circle as many as you’d like)
internet website email phone call mail from my referral doc other____________
please tell us more a
INTERACTIVE RESEARCH
14
For the staff, we designed cards for them to record their actual day in the CHA and the ideal day.
INTERACTIVE RESEARCH
Bef
ore
my
shift
Dur
ing
my
shift
Afte
r m
y sh
ift
On an ideal day: On a typical day:
15
We also gave staff feedback cards with topics such as “Work-Life Balance” and “Access to Clean Linens” and asked them to rate these topics according to their importance.
INTERACTIVE RESEARCH
16
PROTOTYPE
Towards the end of our research phase, we began brainstorming idea solutions for the CHA. We created an Information Brochure for patients which included what to expect, the patient process, and where to find hospital amenities. We received very positive feedback from staff and staff suggestions, and decided to develop the content further.
Prototyping
Cath Procedure Patient & Family
INFORMATION SHEET
Where can I find...Food ServicesThe UPMC Presbyterian Cafeteria is located on the 11th floor
Daily: 6:30am–2:30pm For a recording of the daily menu call 412.647.4328
The UPMC Montefiore Coffee Shop is located on their 7th floor in front of the Main Elevators
Weekday: 7am–8pm Weekend: 8am–5pmSee front of brochure for directions
Gist ShopsThe UPMC Presbyterian Gist Shop is located on the lobby level.
Weekday: 9:30am–6pm Weekend: 11am–4pm
The UPMC Montefiore Gist Shop is a larger store and located on their 7th floor in front of the Main Elevators.
Weekday: 7am–8pm Weekend: 8am–5pmSee front of brochure for directions
BankingATMs are located in the following areas:
• 11th floor near the cafeteria• Lobby level near the cashier• Ground level walkway near the Falk end
Walkway to MontefioreFrom the CHA waiting room, exit toward the main hall, follow the walkway signs to Montefiore Hospital. You will arrive on the 6th floor of the Montefiore Hospital. Take the Main Elevators up to the 7th floor.
GardensThe UPMC Presbyterian provides the Spinola Garden, a restful outdoor haven located on the Unit 3E balcony. From the CHA waiting room exit toward the main hall and follow signs to Unit 3E.
UMPC Montefiore provides the Blair Crawford Courtyard Garden located on the 7th floor, near the coffee and gist shops. Enjoy an outdoor gazebo and a heated solarium. See Walkway to Montefiore for directions.
PharmacyThe Pharmacy will fill any prescription your loved one is given at the time of discharge. Payment may be made by cash, check or credit card.
To fill a prescription, call the UPMC Presbyterian Pharmacy at 412.648.3123
Overnight LodgingShould your loved on need to be admitted into the hospital overnight, the following are nearby accommodations for you:
Family House 412.647.7777Holiday Inn 412.682.6200Hampton Inn 412.681.1000Quality Inn 412.683.6100Wyndham Garden Hotel 412.683.2040
Parking ValidationDiscounts are available for parking 7 to 24 hours. Present your parking ticket at the Information Desk at UPMC Presbyterian on the first floor to see if you qualify.
What to ExpectArriving at the CHA• For those visitors new to Pittsburgh or
UPMC, the back of this guide provides some information on where to find
conveniences during your visit.• It can be confusing navigating through
the building. Do not hesitate to pick up a tan-colored phone in the hallways, where someone will help direct you if you are lost.
• Upon arriving, patients will need to register, and check in with the Consult nurse.
• The waiting room serves both Gastrointestinal and CHA patients, so both
will be called for their procedures.
Before the Procedure• Patients may need to have lab work done if
it has not been done prior to arriving. This may delay the procedure.
• There can be long wait times up to several hours to accommodate scheduling and patient demand.
• The CHA itself may become very busy, especially in the morning when there are the most patients. The CHA can become loud, please try and keep your voice down in the CHA to allow patients to rest.
During the Procedure• The procedure will take about an
hour or so.
Aster the Procedure• Patients will need several hours or more to
rest and recover aster the procedure.• There is a chance patients may be admitted
into the hospital overnight.
The patient process on the day of the procedure: Please note the times are an estimated average and may vary depending on patient status.
arrive at UPMC,check-in at reception
5-10 minutes
wait to speak with consult
15-30 minutes
speak with consult to verify information
10–20 minutes
post-procedure observation and recovery in CHA
60 + minutes
pre-procedure prep in CHA
30-60 minutes
procedure and tests
60-120 minutes
discharge or admit toinpatient bed
pro•to•typ•ing: the creation of
a model and the simulation of all
aspects of a product or concept.
18
ty•pol•o•gy: a systematic
classification of types that have
characteristics or traits in common
and that is used to create personas.
PATIENT TYPOLOGIES
While intending to learn more about the patient experience in the CHA, we found valuable feedback from the staff. We created typologies
of common profiles we saw, addressing similar patterns and varied situations in each persona.
Dan, 74
Retired auto mechanic
At CHA for his third cardiac catheterization; first at UPMC
Has had all of his lab work done prior to today
Drove four hours with his wife from rural New York
Dan and his wife use the internet at home
Lee, 63
Small business owner
Pacemaker needs replacing immediately
Taken directly to the EP lab
Requires extra attention in Cardio Care bed
Lives 40 minutes outside of Pittsburgh
Uses the Internet at home
Alice, 39
HR Executive
At the CHA for first EP procedure and possibly an ICD
Allergic to IV dye; has not received IV prep work
No lab work done prior to procedure
Lives within twenty minutes
Uses the Internet at home
19
STAFF TYPOLOGIES
Carol, 42
Registered Nurse
Has worked at UPMC for 14 years
Has worked at the CHA for 2 years
Needs access to clean linens and proper equipment daily
Has two young children, likes to be home for dinner when possible
Jim, 63
Advanced Patient Care Tech
Has worked at UPMC for 35 years
Has worked at the CHA for 2.5 years
Work space is too crowded, CHA is too noisy and overstimulating
Would like to get off work in time to go running
We also found it important to profile staff typologies as well, in order to understand the personas of those that work at the CHA.
20
SignageWe went to UPMC Presbyterian and put ourselves in the patient’s shoes to see what their first impressions might be. In navigating through the system of buildings, we had a difficult time finding the CHA, and found the signs used for wayfinding to be confusing and inconsistent.
WebsiteWhen searching the UPMC website, we had a hard time finding the information we were looking for, such as what to expect, details about the procedure, and other details.
KEY FINDINGS: PATIENTS
21
“I wish I knew the procedure better before I came here today.”
- CHA Patient
Waiting/Check-in AreaIn our observations, we found that the waiting area is shared by GI patients which often confuses and frustrates CHA patients. Patients do not know which door to enter, which receptionist to talk to, or who will be calling them for their appointment.
Knowledge of the ProcedureFrom patient interviews and patient feedback cards, we found that patients are often anxious or frustrated for various reasons. They do not know what’s next, do not know much about their procedure, do not know beforehand that they may stay overnight, and incur long unexpected wait times before and after the procedure.
KEY FINDINGS: PATIENTS
22
KEY FINDINGS: PATIENTS
CHA ›
UPMC ›Home Pittsburgh
SendMaterialsPre Procedure Call
EP Lab CATH Lab
UPM
CAc
tions
Emot
ions
NoisyOverstimulatingNoisyOverstimulating
Brea
kdow
nsPa
tient
Path
way Diagnosed/
Referred to UPMC
ContactScheduler
Arrive in Oakland
NavigateHallways & Find MPU
Enter CHAPre Procedure Tasks
Check-In & Consult
Return to CHAPost Procedure Tasks
MD
Discharged or admitted tohospital
Over-book daySent inconsistent information
Pittsburgh intimidating to non-locals
Poor signage NoisyOverstimulatingLong wait timesShortage ofequipment
Shared w/ GIConfusingUnwelcoming
NoisyOverstimulatingLong wait timesShortage ofequipment
Lab work not prescribed prior to procedure appointment
MD Office Check-Up
Taken to Lab
TEE Lab
We mapped our overall findings of the patient journey with emotions they were experiencing in the Patient Emotion Blueprint.
23
Area and Facility InformationAfter interviewing families and gathering comments from the bulletin board in the waiting area, we found that families and patients from out of town often find it intimidating to arrive in Pittsburgh for the first time. Families are often frustrated by the unexpected long wait times with limited places to go during this time. Many wished they were better informed about the process and what to expect.
Please Circle One: GI or CHA
Family & Friends: �ell �s ��a� �o� ��in�Ha�e an i�ea or s���es�ion� � ell �s a�o�� i� �sin� ��e li��� ��l��
“Getting here was easy. Finding parking—not
so easy.”
KEY FINDINGS: FAMILIES & FRIENDS
24
KEY FINDINGS: STAFF
Core Competencies From our observations, interviews, and interactive research, we discovered a consistent message that the core competency of the CHA is its people.
core com•pe•ten•cy:
Effective coordination of
skills benefiting patients
upmc cha’s strength lies in the people
STRONG TEAM WORKNurses, technicians and nurse practitioners regularly meet throughout the day to coordinate tasks and review patients.
PRIDE IN THEIR EFFORT
CHA employees take great pride in their flexibility and accommodation of patients and their families.
PATIENT CARE
CHA employees take extra measures to comfort patients and their families.
25
Non-Medical TasksCHA staff face daily common issues that hamper them in doing their jobs. We analyzed the feedback we received from staff in listing their ideal day and their actual day, and interviewed and observed them.
We found that staff must spend much time requesting and acquiring more supplies and linens. Equipment must often be borrowed from other areas of the hospital. Staff also spend much time dealing with upset families because the procedures took longer than families expected.
They often deal with many ill-tempered patients because their lab work is not done, delaying their procedure. Hospital beds often are not accessible, and they must stay with patients until beds are made available.
KEY FINDINGS: STAFF
26
KEY FINDINGS: STAFF
Ideal Day
Typical Day
Before Shift During Shift After ShiftLinens stocked
Inadequate amounts of linens, calls made to restock
Hospital beds available within an hour of check-in
CHA is quite and calm. Only necessary people in area.
Cha has too many non essential people, is disorganized and loud
Patients often wait hours for hospital beds when checked-in
Shift ends on time at 7:30pm Patients in respectful mood with labs completed
Beds made by hospital staff
Beds made by nurses at end of shift
Rarely end on time. Often end as late as 11:30pm
Families informed about process; understand requirements if patient is checked inNo need to overflow to other areas
Clean space available to work
Rooms clean and stocked
Supplies in rooms usually low
Families don’t know what to expect. Ask the same questions repeatedly
Floor clean
Floors sticky and dirty
Often have to overflow patients
Workslpace is disorganized
No in-patients
Not enough equipment available. Must check out equipment
Patients arrive ill-tempered and rude without lab work done.
Supplies stocked
In-patients in the CHA. Requires extra work to get into hospital beds such as fax orders, etc.
27
From the staff feedback cards, we found that staff most needed the following resources to help them provide quality care: accessible hospital resources,
a manageable workload, and work-life balance. Staff also rated appreciation by management as one of their most important elements.
Staff Needs
KEY FINDINGS: STAFF
Accessible Hospital Resources Patient Happiness
Manageable Workload
Appreciated by Management
Functional Workspace
Positive Atmosphere
Supportive Co-Workers
Enjoyment of Work
Downtime
Work-Life Balance
Manageable Stress Level
Pay
Staff
1
Staff
2
Staff
3
Staff
4
Staff
5
Staff
6
Most Important itemsas Ranked by Staff unimportant
somewhat important
moderately important
important
extremely important
28
KEY FINDINGS: STAFF
In analyzing our findings and feedback from staff, we found that common process breakdowns increased negative emotions such as anxiety and frustration. We mapped these findings of the staff journey into the Staff Emotion Blueprint.
CHA ›
UPMC ›Home Pittsburgh
SendMaterialsPre Procedure Call
UPM
CAc
tions
Emot
ions
Lots of traffic getting into Oakland
Fax orders Make calls Physically take them
NoisyOverstimulating
NoisyOverstimulatingNoisyOverstimulating
Linens, supplies and equipment always inadequate
NoisyOverstimulatingLong wait timesShortage ofequipment
Less staff toward end of day. Navigate extra beds stored in CHA. Clean. End lateB
reak
dow
ns Long wait timesToo many non essential peopleAnswer repeated questions
Staff
Path
way Get family
out the door
Arrive in Oakland
Find hospital beds for in-patients
Begin pre-procedure. Overflow when needed
Call for linens, restock supplies, checkout equipment
Begin post- procedure
Checkout or admit patients, Manage in-patients, Clean
Equipment Room
Work around in-patients. Take CHA patients to hospital bedsEP
LabCATH Lab
TEE Lab
Take to lab. Answer family’s repeated questions
29
KEY FINDINGS: STAFF
CHAStaff
UPMC
In-Patient BedsLinensSuppliesEquipment RentalJanitorialFood ServiceOver Flow Areas
Family &
Friends
Transport PatientAsk QuestionsAccompany Patientto CHA & Home
Patients
Make AppointmentCheck-InLab WorkPre ProcedureProcedurePost ProcedureCheckout/Admit
Enter Medical InfoLab WorkPre Procedure PrepPost Procedure CarePost Procedure FormsCheckout/Admit PatientsPrep For Next Day
The majority of communication flow filters through the staff, both for treating patients, and communicating with other parts of UPMC to request supplies or other necessities. The key issue is a balance of communication.
32
In a brainstorming session, we considered all possible solutions to enhance the CHA experience, from immediate to long-term. However, our focus is on the areas affected by communication. We also kept our focus within high-value, low cost solutions that can more easily become implemented.
PROPOSED SOLUTIONS: UPMC
Focus
staff
patient
family
wireless internet
new magazines for waiting room
comfort amenities
coffeestation
upmc greeterlinen supply
more equipment
cha receptionist
new info pdfs on siteconsistent signage
cha style guide
ambient lighting
ambient sound
noise pads
welcome sign
video of upmc visit
library cart
cha coordinator
information for patient comfortable waiting room chairs
hotlinestaff masseuse
33
PROPOSED SOLUTIONS: STAFF
high valuelow value
cost effective
cost prohibitive
computer lab
wireless internet
new magazines for waiting room
dvd players in holding areas
light music patient amenities
extra equipment on hand
good coffeestation
upmc greeter
staff masseuse linen supply
2nd bathroomin cha with shower
cha receptionist
new info sheets on website
staff suggestionforum consistent
signage
cha style guide
ambient lighting
ambient sound
welcome signvideo of upmc visit
emmi on tvs
library cart
cha coordinator
nurse in consult
info/flow chart booklet for patient
compatible epic system
check-inkiosk
med-info card
digital touchscreen
upmc brandconsulting
comfortable waiting room chairs
1-800 hotline
34
The Cath Lab can greatly benefit from having a consistent brand and style. This key communication concept would be essential in giving the CHA its own identity not only with patients and visitors, but also within UPMC. This brand can be applied
to wayfinding, the UPMC website, and written documents. Based on the standards from UPMC Corporate Communications, we have suggested a style guide to implement this vision and establish a consistent identity for the Cath Lab.
Style Guide
PROPOSED SOLUTIONS: UPMC
LOGO
cath labHOLDING AREA Helvetica Neue Regular,
Smallcaps
Pantone 193 Black 45%
Janson RegularHelvetica Neue Regular
TYPEFACES
cath lab Janson Regular
Janson Regular
Use this version of the Cath Lab logo when information pertains to the Catheterization Lab as a whole
Use this version of the Cath Lab logo when information pertains to a specific section of the Catheterization Lab.
Headings in Helvetica Neue RegularBody text should be set in Janson Text Regular. Te eummod eu faciliquat. Dui esto etumsan ea feugue core facilit irilluptatio corem amet vel iure vel dolobor eetuerat velit nim in essim volor amet, consequi tat.
Pantone 294 Black 100%
TEXT
Headings of bodies of text should be set in Helvetica Neue Regular, in the UPMC trademark blue (Pantone 294).
Bodies of text should be set in Janson Regular.
35
PROPOSED SOLUTIONS: UPMC
The Cath Lab brand would also be the driver for consistent signage throughout the building. Since navigation through the building is often a visitor’s first experience with UPMC Presbyterian, consistent signs will greatly help patients and visitors find the Cath Lab and lessen emotions of
feeling lost or overwhelmed. Consistent signage would also display a concrete identity of the Cath Lab to visitors and staff alike at UPMC. To develop this further, the Cath Lab logo could be implemented as a branch for an overall identity of all cardiac areas.
Signage
cath labCHECK-IN
cath labPATIENT & FAMILY ROOM
cath labPARKING
cath labHOLDING AREA
Logo is labeled underneath with the appropriate sections of the Cath Lab.
LOGO VARIATIONS SIGNAGE EXAMPLES
cath labPATIENT & FAMILY ROOM
COLOR VARIATION
In some cases, the logo will be shown on a dark background. In these instances, the logo should be reversed, in white.
Signage should be labeled clearly with the logo denoting the appropriate Catheterization Lab section.
36
PROPOSED SOLUTIONS: PATIENTS & FAMILIES
Many issues patients and families faced during their experience was due to the lack of information provided to them. They did not know what to expect next in the process, how long they would wait, where families could go during their wait, or what steps the procedure actually entailed. We propose using CHA Information cards as a solution to directly addresses these issues. The cards we have designed can provide
consistent written information to patients and families so that they can feel more at ease throughout their experience. Designed as a color-coded set of six with various information on each, the cards should be displayed near the check-in area in an acrylic literature holder. They can be posted on the wall in the waiting area for patients and families to choose based on their medical and personal needs.
CHA Information Cards
37
Our feedback showed that many patients and families were interested in accessing information about the CHA online. We had to search through multiple pages on different parts of the website to find this information. We also found that the information was structured in a format that
was hard to follow. As a new website design for the CHA, we propose that the information on the Cardiac Catheterization page is organized by content and colors consistent with the CHA Information Cards, putting key information all in one place and making it easier to find.
Website
PROPOSED SOLUTIONS: PATIENTS & FAMILIES
38
PROPOSED SOLUTIONS: PATIENTS & FAMILIES
Once patients arrive at UPMC Presbyterian and find the CHA waiting area, the check-in process is one of the key touchpoints with the CHA, and streamlining the efficiency is crucial. Because the CHA patients share the current waiting room with GI patients, CHA patients should be directed to the second door, utilizing the the Cath Lab brand and signage. A kiosk can be installed by the consult room where CHA patients can sign in and confirm information. This process
was already in place and being used at UPMC Montefiore, where patients had a much easier time checking in.
The proposed solutions are for temporary implementation until the new waiting room is built. We recommend that the CHA patients are separate from the GI patients, regardless of which room they eventually check-in.
CHA Check-in Process
SEPARATE ENTRANCES EXTEND THE BRANDING STREAMLINE CHECK-IN
39
PROPOSED SOLUTIONS: STAFF
We found many opportunities in which communication could be facilitated for UPMC, CHA staff, patients, and visitors (our key stakeholders.) The CHA staff is often overwhelmed with their primary responsibilities in addition to communicating between
stakeholders. Introducing a CHA Coordinator role will provide the support needed by the CHA staff so they can focus on providing quality care for their patients. The CHA Coordinator position is integral to improving the CHA experience for all stakeholders involved.
CHA Coordinator
Patients do not have a consistent experience of UPMC Presbyterian.
CHA Staff has to answer the repeated non-medical questions of family and friends.
CHA Staff has to continuously interact with UPMC services throughout the day to make sure their unit is properly prepared for patient care.
Opportunity:
CHAStaff
CHAStaff
UPMC
UPMC
Family &
Friends
Patients
40
The CHA Coordinator will assume most of the non-medical responsibilities currently being handled by the CHA staff. This includes ensuring supplies and equipment for the CHA, assigning
in-patient beds during patient overflow, admitting and checking out patients, and answering questions posed from family and friends.
CHA Coordinator (cont’d)
PROPOSED SOLUTIONS: STAFF
UPMCCHAStaff
Family &
FriendsPatients
In-Patient BedsLinensSuppliesEquipment RentalJanitorialFood ServiceOver Flow Areas
Ask QuestionsTransport PatientAccompany Patientto CHA & Home
Checkout/AdmitMake AppointmentCheck-In
Communicate with coordinatorEnter Medical InfoLab WorkPre Procedure PrepPost Procedure CarePost Procedure Forms
CHACoordinator
41
CHA Coordinator (cont’d)We have listed some of the main job responsibilities of the CHA Coordinator, most of which are being handled currently by the CHA nurses:
PROPOSED SOLUTIONS: STAFF
Act as primary non-medical liaison to patients, family and friends.
Greet them and attend to their overall comfort. Direct them to hospital amenities. Provide them with applicable resources.
Coordinate and work with scheduler, consult, and CHA staff to manage the smooth operation of the unit.
Manage daily schedules of linens, supplies, cleaning and food service.
Manage daily equipment rental and coordination with over-flow areas.
Coordinate overnight patients move to hospital beds. Handle all paperwork and transportation of patients to correct hospital units and beds.
UPMC
Family & Friends
CHA Coordinator
CHA Staff
Patients
42
From our staff feedback cards and interviews, we discovered that staff has many valuable ideas on how to improve the CHA experience. In dealing with the daily responsiblities and knowing the varied situations in the CHA, the staff is in a credible position to propose solutions. However, we also found that they did not have a platform to allow their issues to be heard and therefore, sometimes felt unappreciated by management. We created the CHA Ideas Forum as a structure for CHA staff to propose ideas to upper management. CHA staff can post ideas and rate them on different dimensions, such as benefit to patients, benefit to staff, high value, low cost and staff favorite. The Ideas Forum can be a means to show which solutions are most important or relevant to the CHA.
Ideas Forum
PROPOSED SOLUTIONS: STAFF
43
We found the core competency of the CHA to be its people, and this is a strength that should be externalized. CHA gear such as shirts, sweatshirts, or nametags emblazoned with the CHA logo can be a tangible symbol of the staff ’s strong teamwork, as well as indicate to patients the personalization of care provided.
CHA Gear
PROPOSED SOLUTIONS: STAFF
46
FUTURE IDEAL SCNEARIO
Pre-ArrivalDan has been scheduled for his first catheterization procedure at UPMC Presbyterian. He is a bit nervous so he wants to find out more about the procedure before arriving. He visits the UPMC website and reads about the Cath Lab to gain a better understanding of what to expect. He finds that having his lab work done prior to arrival is rather important, and contacts his physician to ensure all his labs are in order.
ArrivalDan and his wife drive four hours to Pittsburgh from their home. Upon arriving at UPMC, they use the valet service that they read about from the website. From the main entrance, they ask the greeter how to get to the CHA. They take the elevators to the third floor and follow the Cath Lab signs. Dan and his wife see the sign above the second door of the waiting room for Cath Lab patients.
Check-inThey enter the waiting room and check in at the kiosk. The CHA Coordinator helps them to check in and answers questions. She tells them about the cards on the wall to help them during their visit. They pick out the “What to expect,” “Cath,” and “Amenities” cards and learn that the entire wait time throughout the procedure may be several hours or more. In the waiting room they see rocking chairs, updated magazines, and games. A video outlining the UPMC visit is on TV.
47
FUTURE IDEAL SCENARIO
Cath Holding AreaThe CHA Coordinator brings Dan and his wife to the CHA, which is busy but quiet. Dan’s wife receives a pager, which allows her to be contacted in the building once the procedure is over. In the CHA, Dan gets changed and prepared for the procedure. He is anxious but is glad he knows more about the procedure itself from the UPMC website and from the “cath” card.
ProcedureDuring the procedure, Dan’s wife decides to visit the UPMC café and gardens mentioned in the cards. After several hours, she is alerted by the pager and returns to the CHA. After the post-procedure recovery is completed, Dan’s is discharged and they return home the same day.
48
FUTURE STEPS
We have discovered that even minor changes can make a large difference to improving the experience for UPMC Presbyterian CHA stakeholders. In this book, we have focused on solutions that enhance communication flow and that can be implemented straightaway. In our ideal scenario, we illustrate other amenities that would be appreciated by patients and visitors. After researching in other UPMC hospitals, we have seen that these design solutions are feasible, effective and already in use.
As UPMC grows, we feel it is essential to take the time now to perform an internal audit of all of the facilities. This will not only indicate areas in need of improvement, but perhaps more importantly provide key information for what are effective practices already implemented.
50
Thank You
We would like to give a warm thanks to the wonderful staff of the CHA. In addition, we would like to thank Rose for all of her stellar support and feedback. You went above and beyond in giving us access to the holding area as well as answered so many of our questions outside of work hours!
Thank you to Judy, Gail and all the folks we worked with at the Center for Quality Improvement and Innovation. This has been a truly eye-opening experience and a pleasure to work with such dedicated people.
Lastly, thank you to Shelley for being a fantastic teacher. Truly.