14
Hon. Irene Ovonji-Odida, Member AU/ UNECA High Level Panel on IFFs from Africa, Outgoing Chair ActionAid Int., CEO FIDA-Uganda.

Untitled

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • Hon. Irene Ovonji-Odida, Member AU/ UNECA High Level Panel on IFFs from Africa, Outgoing Chair ActionAid Int., CEO FIDA-Uganda.

  • Background & ConceptHLP on IFFs from Africa set up Feb. 2012 by AU/ECA Ministers of Finance, Planning & Economic Development. ToR: to establish IFF nature, patterns, scale & effects on development, sensitize stakeholders including governments, & make proposals to reverse it.Chair H.E. Thabo Mbeki & 9 members.

  • Method: ECA study on trade mispricing, 2 visits, sub-regional & global consultations, IEC/ advocacy, 6 country studies. Algeria, DRC, Kenya, Liberia, Mozambique, Nigeria.GFI definition: money illegally earned, transferred or used ie illicit in origin, movement or use. Means: commercial, criminal & corruption by govt officials

  • Commercial mainly by MNEs eg aggressive tax avoidance schemes, concessionary agreements, cash smuggling, capital transfers through services or intangibles like IPRs, trade mispricing, tax evasion, money laundering is 60% of IFF.

  • Criminal- trafficking, counterfeiting, contraband, terrorist financing is 35%.Government corruption-bribery, abuse of office constitutes 5%. However government corruption enables other practices contributing to IFFs.

  • 1: IFFs from Africa large & increasing $20 billion in 2001 $60 billion in 2010.Scale: per ECA study its now ~$60bn p.a. IFF is est. at btw 3x ODA (OECD) to 10x ODA (Tax Justice Network).Policy implicn: impacts on devt incl.lost tax rev.,savings, econ. investment, & DRM for ODA gap.

  • The pol. econ of IFFs core to ending it v. powerful actors/interests & harmful gov. effects. Polit.commitment key to action.3: Transparency key to all aspects of IFFEg decl. of profits in financ. Secrecy jurisd/ use of low tax jurisd; opaque MNC in-hse trading of inputs, IP, outputs, services;

  • Commerc mispricing in trade imports & exports thru transp. in fin. reporting incl. country-by-country account of sales, profits & taxes paid by MNEs. Tax avoid/ evasn declaration of benef. ownership in comm. entities, incl. banking & securities accts & cross-border exch of tax info.

  • MNEs under-declare export quantities of oil, gas, minerals, agric gds eg timber, fish. But no global regime for comm IFF drivers.5: Afr states dependence on natural resource extraction increases vulnerability to IFFs. Extractv sector major area: poorly structured kts reduce/ eliminate legit. royalty/ tax earnings. 6: New, innovative means of IFF bring new, increasing challenges to stop it.

  • Corruptn key driver of tax incentvs like tax holidays-no relatn btw FDI/ tax incentives FDI idue to pol. stability, cost of biznss.Higher tax burden on SMEs due to MNE tax abuse; yet small domestic firms boost employt more than MNCs. 8: Corruption, abuse of pwr a cont. concern IFFs kill state institutions, rule of law, state capacities, undo public confid. & divert public money to private uses -> skew income distribution, linked to inequality.

  • IFF primarily go to ext destinations tradit. & new incl. tax havens (old & emerging). Tunisia post-MENA uprising shows role of banks, acctg firms, lawyers to enable MNE practices & outdo govt cap OECD BEPS process ->asset recov. for OECD states! 10: Money laundering continues to require attentionHarmonized crim. laws reqd. MNEs misprice imports/ exports to avoid duties or transfer monies esp. foreign exch abroad ~ Liberia challenge worse w USD as legal tender. De-regulatn, liberalizn ->hard to stem laundering

  • Af. Govts lack funds for public services ~ health, educ, infrast.-direct cost esp. on poor citizens.IFF weaken fin. sector, tax collecn, mkt reguln, integty of public fin. systems, stability & security. Liberalized & de-regulated econ enable IFFs cut regulatory cap.eg customs to stop trade mis-pricing; ensure negot of gd kts in extractives & monitor resource exploitation.Strong neg cap. req to shape global architectureATAF initiatives relevant for cap. bldg

  • Uneven/ missing inst. global architecture - UNCAC ~ corruption, crime but not MNEs.13: Financial secrecy jurisd req closer scrutiny Transpcy, uncovering secrecy & information, collaboration, cooperation key challenges.Tax havens & fin. secrecy jurisds ease regn & enable corporate SPVs & nominal owners (fronts) to mask beneficial owners.

  • Global initiatives but many not univ. applic & dont cover Africa eg OECD BEPs.Coop of OECD, G8, G20 reqd~richest states & IFF destination to close global gov gaps on means of IFFs.15: IFFs esp comm. MNC transactns shd be incl. in UN f/works eg SDGs, FFDs.Conclusion: IFFs linked to DRM & FfD: Req. polit. will & technic cap re. powerful interests & complexity.