UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT ... of Dismissal of Appeal... · UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT MARK S. ANNIS; et al., ... Salvatierra,

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT

MARK S. ANNIS; et al.,

Plaintiffs - Appellants,

v.

MICHAEL AGUIRRE; et al.,

Defendants -Appellees.

___________________________________

SABIN M. ABRAMS; et al.,

Plaintiffs - Appellants,

v.

MICHAEL AGUIRRE; et al.,

Defendants - Appellees.

__________________________________

)))))))))))))))))))))))))

CASE NO: 08-56653

D.C. No. 3:06-cv-01451-H-PORSouthern District of California,San Diego

STIPULATION OF DISMISSAL OF APPEAL WITHPREJUDICE

(CONSOLIDATED APPEAL NO. 08-56691)

CASE NO. 08-56691

D.C. No. 3:06-cv-01451-H-PORSouthern District of California,San Diego

The following Appellants (“Appellants”):

Adair, Larry

Adams, Lori M.

Adams, Robert Heath

1

Case: 08-56653 04/26/2010 Page: 1 of 28 ID: 7315363 DktEntry: 80-1

Agnew, Laurie

Aguirre, Edward R.

Aiken, Michael

Albertsen, Sandra Rapalee

Albrecht, Leslie

Albright, Daniel T.

Ambito, Albert I.

Ammon, Kevin

Anderson, Peggy

Andrews, Thomas J.

Anschick, Robert W.

Armenta, Oscar A.

Ashcraft, Wesley R.

Asher, Michael R.

Atwood, Jennifer (formerly Perea)

Atwood, Robert

Austin, John

Bailey, John B.

Baird, Robert M., Jr.

Barnes, Scott T.

Bassett, Tina

2


Bassett, Tod E.

Beamesderfer, Michael A.

Beard, Jana M.

Beathard, David W.

Becker, Edward Lee

Behrendt, Steven M.

Benavides, Joe A.

Bernier, Steve

Bernstein, Meryl

Binkero, Victoria M.

Bisesto, Gregory R.

Bittner, Richard A.

Bixel, Lynn

Black, Carlton E.

Blackford, Jeffrey

Blagg, Brian R.

Boerom, Thomas M. J.

Bolen, James R.

Borrelli, Nick

Bourasa, Steven B.

Bowman, Roger E.

3


Boyd, James W.

Bozarth, Phillip Kent

Brady, Cindy Lea

Breitenstein, Glenn A.

Bressler, Robert R.

Brinkerhoff, Paul

Bristol, Russell T.

Brogdon, Michael

Browder, Neal N.

Brown, Ronald O.

Brown, Tim R.

Brown, William M.

Brugman, Joy Marie

Burgess, Randy P.

Burke, David W.

Burkett, Brett

Buxton, Christopher G.

Cairncross, Laurie

Calloway, Jene L.

Caneron, Christen M.

Campbell, Janet M.

4


Campbell, William H.

Carignan, Theodore

Carlson, Mark A.

Carlyon, Thomas J.

Carpenter, John D.

Carter, Tony B.

Carter, William

Caruso, Peter J.

Castro, Nydia M.

Cavada, Arthur H.

Cedrun, Misty

Cerar, Daniel

Chaney, John

Chiles, James H.

Chione, Jeffrey W.

Cimmarrusti, Raphael

Clark, James

Clark, Joseph

Clem, James H.

Cloniger, C.J.

Cole, Rex A., Jr.

5


Collier, Douglas M.

Collier, Kimberly

Collins, Garry

Colon, Bernie T.

Conley, Paul D.

Council, Carol V.

Coyle, Timothy S.

Cranston, Meghan

Cueva, Celso G.

Culligan, James P.

Cunanain, Rolito

Dare, Robert W.

Darrow, Darby Lee

Daun, Robert

Davies, Lisa L.

Davis, Charles R.

Davis, William T., Jr.

Day, William G.

De Armas, Alexander

Decastro, Conrado V.

Dela Cruz, Charles

6


Dela Pena, Susan

Deloach, John

Derning, Patrick R.

Devone, Edward A.

Diaz, Derek

Didelot, John “Jack” R.

Dobbs, Matthew

Dodd, Dorinda K.

Dolezal, Donald J.

Doremus, Dennis P.

Doshibr, Wilbert A.

Dougherty, Marianne L.

Dougherty, Ronald H.

Douglas, David F.

Downs, James E.

Dragi, Julie M.

Drilling, Eric

Dunbar, John G.

Dupree, Anthony L.

Eastep, Donna R.

Eichmann, Randal W.

7


El-Assis, Antoine

Elkins, Roland

Ellithorpe, Shari L.

Ellsworth, Philip

Elmore, Stanley A.

English, James D.

Epperson, Julie

Epperson, Steve

Ericson, Cassie

Escalante, Manuel, III

Escuaero, Christopher C.

Fabregas, Robert C.

Farrar, Debra Lance

Farrar, James W.

Farrell, Mary V.

Faubel, Tim

Fay, Paul J.

Fellows, Andrew L.

Filley, James D.

Filley, Robert

Finch, Robert

8


Fischer, Rodney W.

Flanagan, Michael F.

Flores, Riter

Ford Yankovich, Anna M.

Fowler, Robert M.

Fragoso, Alan R.

Freitas, John W.

Fune, John Patrick

Furst, Andrea S.

Garcia, David A.

Garcia, David D.

Garcia, Ivan

Garlow, Justin

Gasteiger, Mark

Gault, Ryan P.

Gerke, Frederick R.

Gilmore, Cory E.

Glazewski, Dewayne F.

Gobbi, Marcos

Goldberg, Brian

Gollehon, Gary L.

9


Gomez, Edward R.

Gonzalez, Tristan

Gonzalez-Reed, Hilda

Goodman, Gregg

Goodner, Derrel

Gore, Larry K.

Graham, William M.

Graves, James E., III

Greenwood, Scott

Gressel, Mary K.

Groff, Michael D.

Gross, Jeffrey George

Grubbs, Daniel L.

Grubbs, Jennifer

Haley, Michael A.

Hall, David A.

Hall, Patrick

Hansen, Richard A.

Harbin, Levi

Harris, Paul A.

Hart, Shannon W.

10


Hartman, M.A.

Hastings, Michael R.

Hastings, Ramona R.

Hattler, Daniel C.

Havin, Jess R.

Hays, Eric

Head, George A.

Headley, David M.

Heims, Robert

Henderson, Scott

Henry, Shaun P.

Hentigan, Michael

Heppell, James K.

Herrera, Victor M.

Hershman, Carlton R.

Hesselgesser, Larry R.

Hibshman, Byron

Hicks, Matthew P.

Higdon, Daniel

Highsmith, David F.

Hill, Gary W.

11


Hodges, Diana

Hodges, Kenneth Paul, Sr.

Hodges, Mark

Hoerman, Frank J.

Hoff, Lloyd

Hoffman, Andrew T.

Holden, Mike D.

Hollister, Dan

Holmes, William B.

Holmstrom, Richard E.

Holt, Chris

Hone, Natalie M.

Hoolihan, John P.

Horvath, John

Hoyte, Hector E.

Hubbs, Kenneth

Hubbs, Phillip D.

Hudson, Edward

Hurley, Michael P.

Hustad, David J.

Isbell, Craig E.

12


Jackson, Brian A.

Jacobsen, Jane E.

Jarvis, Lynda E.

Jarvis, Philip T.

Jennings, David E.

Joaquin, Jerome O.

Johnson, Anthony K.

Johnson, Buddy L.

Johnson, Jeffrey M.

Johnson, Jeffrey M.

Johnson, Sarah

Johnson, Tim Daniel

Johnston, Scott W.

Jones, David H.

Jones, Edward V.

Jones, Randal L.

Karsh, Daniel

Kay, Charles Q.

Keating, Timothy J.

Keene, Jonny F.

Keelsing, David

13


Kelbaugh, Nicolas I.

Kennedy, James L.

Kenney, Francis L.

Kern, Jacob

Kilby, Christopher W.

Kitts, Dale

Knish, Jack

Kolender, William B.

Kook, Lloyd E.

Korenkov, Andrew

Kral, Franklin, Jr.

Kremer, Denny K.

Kriebel, Jerry, II

Krosch, Calvin L.

Krouss, Joseph

Kulinski, Nancy

Labo, John G.

LaChapelle, Sandra

Landman, David L.

Lange, Terry A.

Lara, Charles

14


Larmour, Ronald P.

Lasher, Daniel P.

Lawson, Brooke Pamela

Leds, Alberto H.

Lemaster, Ronald W.

Lemahan, B.

Leribeus, Brian J.

Levan, John Brian

Lewak, Kazimierz P.

Lewis, Robert L.

Little, Darrell K.

Livesey, James R.

Lobel, Henry J.

Lofftus, Mel

Long, James W.

Long, Timoth M.

Loucks, Gene C.

Lozano, Alfred

Lucchesi, Brian

Lucchesi, Mark

Luce, Chris M.

15


Luth, Christopher

Luth, Daniel D.

Lyall, Charles David

Maggi, Louis John, Jr.

Maglaras, George

Maley, David

Marcos, Mark

Margetts, Stephen G.

Martinez, Chrissy

Martinez, Rudy

Martz, Philip, Jr.

Maschmeier, Michael W.

Mauzy, Kathleen M.

Mauzy, Ralph C.

McCarvel, Roger W.

McClain, Terry L.

McElfresh, Noel

McElroy, Guy

McGhee, James

McGowan Minto, Laura

McGuire, Ed

16


McLellan, Scott D.

McLoed, Michael D.

McMillen, Steve L.

McMurrin, Joel

McNair, Sharon K.

McNamara, Kevin Dean

McQuien, Robert M.

Meisner, Robert N.

Melhorn, Skip

Mendez, Michael J.

Mensior, Kerry A.

Metz, Richard D., Jr.

Michalek, David R.

Michalek, Debra S.

Miles, Carmi D.

Miller, Douglas D.

Miller, Jeffrey L.

Miller, Thomas P., III

Mills, Peter R.

Minton, Robert D.

Mitrovich, Gary E.

17


Molinoski, Joseph W.

Mondesir, Gary F.

Montierth, Charles

Moore, James G.

Mora, Robert

Morales, Miguel P.

Morales, Ray A.

Morris, David L.

Morrison, Cynthia

Morrison, James D.

Morrison, Scott A.

Moser, Jay

Mosteller, Jacob

Munoz, Cynthia L.

Muren, George Timothy

Myers, Gregory J.

Navarn-Moran, Angelica

Needham, James

Nelson, Kenneth E.

Nezgodinsky, Alexander

Newquist, Robert L.

18


Nikkola, Gordon

Nisleit, David

Nobbs, Robert H.

Norton, Lee

Norton, Regina

Nalton, John R.

O’Hanlon, Richard M.

Oliver, Gene F.

Olson, Barney C., III

Olson, Shelly K.

O’Neill, James

O’Neill, Michael

Oplinger, Sandra

Orden, Thomas A.

Packer, Thomas R.

Page, Denise D.

Papenhausen, Billy J.

Parpart, Richard C.

Parrella, Richard

Patrick, Kevin

Perez, Marco

19


Perkins, Curtis E.

Perez, Jose Paul

Petersen, Jeffrey P.

Petrick, Edward K.

Pettitt, Duane E.

Phelps, Bradley L.

Pickett, Douglas L.

Pinarelli, Greg A.

Pino-Jarvis, Marisela

Pitucci, Marc A.

Plein, Dan R.

Powers, Jason

Prutzman, Bob

Prutzman, Michael J.

Pudgil, Duane

Pursel, Dalana Sue

Queen, Corinne

Queen, John

Rabell, Michael J.

Ramsay, Michael

Randolph, Matt

20


Rausis, Kevin C.

Redding, Robert M., Jr.

Reece, Dwight P.

Reif, John J.

Reno, Wendy S.

Rey, Robert L.

Rhodes, Thomas M.

Ricardez, Rolanda M.

Richmond, Brenda T.

Ries, Darin

Righthouse, Bret A.

Righthouse, Susan M.

Robertson, Todd J.

Robinson, Steve

Rodriguez, Elias

Rojorquez, Eugene H.

Rollins, Bobby D.

Roman, Daniel G.

Ronquillo, Carlos

Root, David L.

Rorrison, Paul R.

21


Rosales, Jorge

Rosario, Angel D.

Rosenbloom, Steven

Rude, Robert

Ruvido, Joseph

Rydalch, Lynn D.

Salas, Paul H.

Salinas, Jeffrey

Salvatierra, Alfonso

Sanchez, Juan

Santos, Alejandrino Cruz, III

Sarot, Christopher M.

Schaeffer, Jack D.

Seiter, Eric

Sells, Gaylon W.

Shanley, Patrick J.

Sharki, Adam T.

Shaw, Marvin L.

Shiraishi, Michael S.

Shockley, Dale T., Sr.

Shumaker, Benjamin

22


Sidhu, Amalia

Simms, John W.

Simonds, Thomas G.

Sinclair, Lori A.

Smith, James

Smith, James F.

Smith, Larry H.

Smith, Robert W.

Smith, Timothy M.

Snarponis, Joseph G.

Snow, Ronald

Spear, Andrew

Speck, David

Spetter, Howard W.

Stacy, Michael L.

Stadler, John

Staley, Leroy

Stephens, Norman O.

Stewart, Gary G.

Stewart, Kenneth P.

Stewart, Leslie W.

23


Stiasny, Elliot S.

Stratton, Jerry G.

Stricklin, John Jay

Stutz, William F.

Sullivan, Mark C.

Sullivan, Thomas A.

Surwilo, David

Swadener, Arturo

Swanson, Michael Joseph

Szakara, John

Szymczak, Charles M.

Tamagni, Louis A.

Tate, John H.

Taylor, Dana D.

Terhaar, Philip J.

Thach, Alvin

Thompson, Scott A.

Toneck, Daniel D.

Tos, David

Truderung, Robert

Trumper, Ernie

24


Underwood, Timothy L.

Updike, Bernard P., Jr.

Valencia, Janis E.

Valentin, Ramon

Valentin, Wendy J.

Van Abel, Mark A.

Vandiver, Rodney L.

VanHorn, Dale L.

Vanlaningham, Edward F.

Van Proyen, Joel

Varonfakis, James G.

Vega, Danny

Verdone, Kenneth J.

Vile, Daniel R.

Vittek, Robert

Vollmar, Timothy

Voss, Duane A.

Voss, Gary R.

Wallawer, Gerard M.

Wade, Sylvester, Jr.

Wadhams, Kevin L.

25


Wagner, Elyse S.

Wagner, Thomas

Wahl, Michael D.

Walb, Kristopher

Wallace, Mitchell B.

Ward, Dick L.

Warrick, Deanna M.

Watkins, Donald E.

Watkins, Victoria D.

Way, Dean

Weathersby, Sedonia

Weaver, Michael W.

Weeden, Larry W.

Wegson, Adrian

Wendell, Diane

Wetter, Raymond

Whitfield, David L.

Wilkins, Larry

Wilkinson, Scott

Williams, Brent

Williams, Donna L.

26


Williams, Tina M.

Wilson, Lawrence

Witt, Steven

Wolfe, Dawn

Woods, William H.

Worden, David M.

Worthington, Phillip

Wright, Stephen W.

Wuemler, Jeffrey J.

Yu, Dave C.

Zaitz, Mathew

Zeljeznjak, Anthony

Zepeda, Monica

Zetterlund, Timothy P.

Ziegler, Jeffrey P.

and Appellees, City of San Diego, Scott Peters, Jim Madaffer, Ralph Inzunza, Toni

Atkins, Tony Young, Brian Maienschein, Donna Frye, Michael Zucchet, Cathy Lexin,

Mary Vattimo, Terri Webster, Ed Ryan, P. Lamont Ewell, Michael Uberuaga, and Bruce

Herring (collectively “Stipulating Appellees”), by counsel, pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P.

41(a)(1)(ii) stipulate to the dismissal with prejudice of Appellants’ appeal against

27


Stipulating Appellees, each party to bear its own costs and attorney’s fees.

Respectfully submitted,

DATED: April 26, 2010 LAW OFFICE OF MICHAEL A. CONGER

/s/ Michael A. Conger Specially appearing for dismissing appellants tofacilitate dismissal pursuant to written authorityfrom dismissing appellantsE-Mail: [email protected]

DATED: April 26, 2010 LATHAM & WATKINS, LLP

/s/ Colleen C. Smith Attorneys for Appellees City of San Diego, Scott Peters, Jim Madaffer,Ralph Inzunza, Toni Atkins, Tony Young, BrianMaienschein, Donna Frye, Michael Zucchet,Cathy Lexin, Mary Vattimo, Terri Webster, EdRyan, P. Lamont Ewell, Michael Uberuaga, andBruce Herring E-Mail: [email protected]

28


Documents

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT ... of Dismissal of Appeal... · UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT MARK S. ANNIS; et al., ... Salvatierra,