Upload
max-matthaeus
View
217
Download
1
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Comparing two typeface designers
Citation preview
O t l A i c h e r
Post World War 2 Typography in Germany and the USA
Herb Lubalin
O t l A i c h e r
Post World War 2 Typography in Germany and the USA
His work was a lot more experimental, and playful. He used letters as images, and the way com-bined them and how the interacted with each other allowed from much greater variety in his work.
Typography by: Herb Lubalin & Otl Aicher
Post World War 2 Typography in Germany and the USA
Once the war was over, in 1946,
he went to the Akademie der Bil-
denden Künste in Munich to study
sculpture. In 1947 he started his
own studio back in his home city
of Ulm. At his studio he worked
with Braun Electric, Lufthansa, the
Westdeutsche Landesbank, and
the ZDF as his clients. In 1953 he
started a school for design in Ulm
along with Max Bill, and his wife
Inge Scholl. In 1972 he was hired
as lead designer for the Munich
Olympic games, where he create
signage using stylized stick figures
to represent the different activities,
which would
A S
hort
Ove
rvie
w Otl Aicher was born on May 23rd , 1922 in Ulm,
Germany. During his youth he was arrested multiple times for
refusing to join the Hitler youth, and later deserted from the
German army. He hid with his friend Werner Scholl, who’s
two siblings were executed by the Nazi party for being part
of the White Rose, a resistance movement against the Nazis.
later carry over to other signs in
the public, He later created the
Traffic font for the Munich transport
services and in 1989 created Rotis
after the town he moved his studio
to. He also designed the logo for
the Munich airport. In 1991 he died
after being in a traffic accident.
During his design career Otl experi-
enced many different technological
advancements in his field from the
letterpress, to phototypesetting, to
finally the computer. He was able
to use and master all of them, even
making his Rotis font on the comput-
er. His designs had been influenced
heavily by his heritage, even after
the turmoil of the World War, there
was a very strong influence that
the German design history had on
Otl’s deign sense, pushing him into
certain styles.
Herb Lubalin was born in 1918 in
New York. At age 17 in 1936 he
began studying at Cooper Union
where he gained his interest in
typography. After graduating in
1939 he became the art director
for Deutsch & Shea Advertising in
1941, then for Fairchild Publica-
tions in 1942 and Riess Advertis-
ing in 1943. For twenty years he
worked for Sulder & Hennessey.
In 1964 he created his own studio
call Herb Lubain Inc. In 1970 he
creates the International Type-
face Corporation. He died in 1981
in New York.
Like Otl, Herb also was able to use multiple generations of type creating technolo-
gies, however for creating his fonts he used photo type, and not the comput-
er. For his work Otl created his work using a very minimalist style. When looking
at his Lufthansa work, he created a very simple design. The timetable he created
for them, it uses simple outlined shapes, with the logo in the middle, and small
text explaining what the pamphlet is in three languages. The logo he created
for them is a heavily stylized bird that mimics the shape of a plane. The bird is
Lufthansa’s mascot, a crane, and it is portrayed in the logo flying in front of a
circle that can be seen as representing the sun, as the warm yellow he used for
branding gives the feeling of the
colors of a setting sun. The name
‘Lufthansa’ is shown very clearly
at the top of the page, with that
being the primary focus.
If one looks inside, the design
stays simple. Using only black
and white, with map of the world
taking over most of the page, but
not being overwhelming, Otl split
the page up so that it was clear
where the information that one
was looking for was.
The timetable at the side is simple,
and is clear to follow, something
that is important when people are
in a hurry. The image of the plane
at the bottom gives the viewer
some idea in what kind of plane they will be flying in. The local
flight plan has a heavily stylized
map on it, showing the relation
of all of the airports in Germany,
Austria and Switzerland. It uses
the same basic layout of the general flight plan, only replac-
ing the logo in the center with
the map. This serves to give the
viewer an idea of which airports
are listed in the timetable. The
timetable also keeps Lufthansa’s
name and the warm yellow on
the cover, only revering the color relationship with the
black/brownish color, so that the yellow is the back-
ground color, and the brown is the color of the lines.
RondaAaBbCcDdEe
FfGgHhIi
NnOoppQq
RrSsTtUu
VvWwXxYyZz
JjKkLl
Mm
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N
O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z
a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o
p q r s t u v w x y z
A B C D E F G
H I J K L M N
O P Q R S T
U V W X Y Z
a b c d e f g
h i j k l m n o
p q r s t u v
w x y z
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0
Herb Lubalin has a more Post-Modernist approach to his work.
He also used type a lot more expressively, and created entire pieces purely
out of type, as seen in the way he depicted his school’s name. He used the
forms of type to create new and exciting forms that broke up the way we
usually see type.
The way he combined the ‘H’ and
the ‘E’ in ‘THE’, makes the viewer at
first glance still recognize the indi-
vidual letters, as the forms are still
clear, but when looking at it again
one sees how the crossbar of the
‘H’ runs into the middle arm of the
‘E’ creating one letter. He does the
same with the ‘C’ and ‘T’, creating
a new letter, but till keeping the
piece understandable.Wo
rks
by
Lub
alin
The main thing one notices in
this piece is how the ‘O’ interlock,
and how the ampersand fills both
lines, making up for the break-
ing of the word ‘Architecture’,
allowing the entire piece to from
a solid block. The same goes for
how he spelled out ‘The Bible’
even though it is in a block it
still has a lot of motion with in it,
allowing the viewer’s eyes to flow
around it.
Otl Aicher was heavily influenced
Being from a region that has such a
rich history of typographic design Otl
was somewhat forced into pre-existing
styles. In his designs he created, he
used the skills he learned at school,
where the emphasis was to stay within,
that which had already been estab-
lished by previous designers.
by the typographic styles of the Swiss and
German designers, such as Jan Tschichold,
Joseph Müller-Brockman, Armin Hoffman, etc.
Herb Lubalin on the other hand had much more freedom to design
as he pleased. His work was a lot
more experimental, and playful.
He used letters as images, and the
way combined them and how the
interacted with each other allowed from much greater va-
riety in his work. Sometimes his
work was a bit hard to read,
but that mostly happened in cov-
ers, or in the title, where the mes-
sage, was not as important as how
the piece looked, and even if the viewer did not understand
the work at first glance,
it was easy to figure out, the
way that he had combined
the letters made sense,
and were easily deciphered,
when looked at for longer.
A a B b C c D d E e F f
G g H h I i J j K k L l M m
N n O o P p Q q R r S s
T t U u V v W w X x Y y Z z
Avant
A a B b C c D d E e F f G g H h I i J j K k L l M m
Garde
N n O o P p Q q R r S s T t U u V v W w X x Y y Z z
A a B b C c D d E e F f G g
H h I i J j K k L l M m N n O o
P p Q q R r S s T t U u V v
W w X x Y y Z z ( & . , ! ? )
Garde
The main type face Otl created was Rotis it was a sans-serif
type face that could be used as a body text or for header. The
use of modern technology allowed Aicher to create a clean
and simple font that has a wide variety of weights to it.
Also allowed him to make a semi-serif
version of this that adds a serif at the
top of the stem of letters. The Swiss
design that he used was made easier
through the precision of the computer.
Photo type allowed Lubalin to make
very intricate fonts that have a lot of
detail to them, such as the relationship
of the stem to the bowl in the ‘R’s of
Ronda, or how the curves in Serif Goth-
ic were created.
Rotis
Avant Garde
There are some quirks with it
such as the way the tail of the ‘Q’
comes out flat with the baseline or
how the ‘O’ is much taller than it is
wide. Overall it is solid, and seems
stable. Herb Lubalin created four
typefaces, with his most famous
being Avant Garde. It has a
great variety in weights. It is a lot
heavier than Rotis, at regular, and
is also wider, with the ‘O’ being
almost a perfect circle. He also
created a Lubalin Graph, which is
block serif version of Avant Garde,
and is also somewhat thinner than
Avant Garde. His third font is
Ronda which is overall thicker,
and who’s spurs are a lot more
triangular. It also seems to have
a bit of a left slant to it and also
seems to have a bit of Futura in it.
Lubalin’s final font is Serif Gothic.
Lubalin Gragh
Ronda
Serif Gothic
He was heavily influenced by oth-
er designers of his time, and the
general design culture that existed
in Germany and Switzerland at
the time. The technology chang-
es also helped refine his work,
and allowed for greater precision
when working with Swiss Design.
Otl Aicher used Swiss Design to create
a very clean typeface t h a t h a s
a n e x t r a o r d i n a r y n u m b e r o f
w e i g h t s t o i t , a n d u s e d t h i s
s t y l e i n h i s d e s i g n w o r k .
L i k e h i s d e s i g n s L u b a l i n c r e a t e d f o n t s l i k e R o n d a a n d
S e r i f G o t h i c t h a t w e r e s o m e w h a t o u t o f t h e o r d i n a r y t o
b e u s e d f o r t i t l e s , o r s p a r i n g l y a c r o s s o n e s w o r k .
He also made very clean and
simple typefaces l ike Avant
Garde and Lubalin Graph,
which have wider application.
AaBbCcDdEeFfGgHhIiJjKkLlMmN
Serif Gothic Light
ITC Serif
Serif Gothic Black
Gothic
nOoPpQqRrSsTtUuVvWwXxYyZz
If one looks inside, the design stays sim-ple. Using only black and white, with map of the world taking over most of the page, but not being overwhelm-ing, Otl split the page up so that it was clear where the information that one was looking for was. nOoPpQqRrSsTtUuVvWwXxYyZz
Designer: Max MatthaeusTypefaces: Ronda , R o t i s , A van t Ga r de , L uba l i n G r aph , S e r i f Go t h i cCourse: Typography 3Faculty: Francheska Guerrero
Herb LubalinHerb Lubalin
Herb LubalinHerb LubalinSe r i f Go th i c
Luba l in Graph
Ronda
R o t i s
Avan t Ga rde
O