TRANSCRIPTS OF CRIMINAL CASES IN NEW YORK CITY

Shorthand minutes are taken during the course of t r i a l proceedings by a

court stenographer. In the past th is was done by hand in stenographic notebooks,

but a t the present t ime minutes are ususally created through the use of

stenotype machines. Transcripts of the minutes are made for the use of the court

or the attorneys involved in the case only under certain circumstances. A t

t r ia ls of class A and class B felonies, the judge may order the stenographer t o

transcribe proceedings daily as the t r i a l i s progressing. Stenographers a1 ternate

in the court room and spend the time out of court typing the transcrlpts. This i s

called "daily copy." Court reporters are not required t o transcribe their minutes

i f not requested t o do so by the judge or by the defense attorney.

When a criminal case i s decided in a defendant's favor, no appeal w i l l be

made. No need exists in such cases for a transcript of the t r i a l proceedings. In

cases in which daily copy was produced, the reporter may destroy the copy i f he

wishes, or he may retain i t in his fi les.

When the defendant i s found guilty, hls case may be appealed. In that

case, the judge w i l l usually order a transcript of the trial t o be made for use in

the appeals hearing. The defense attorney may purchase a copy of the transcript,

and the prosecuting attorney w i l l also receive one. In cases where the defense

cannot afford t o purchase a transcript, the court must make provision for a copy

for the defense. Court reporters are always paid f o r producing trancripts.

The courts are required by law t o keep the minutes, Le. the stenotype

tapes. In fact, since 1971, a program t o microf i lm a l l court reporters' minutes

has been underway in New York City. Reporters are supposed t o send their tapes

t o the microfi lming unit. The potential fo r loss i s great since adequate storage

f a c i l i t i e s do not exist fo r the court reporters and t h e microfi lming project i s

several years behind. Access t o the minutes i s by court reporter's name. A

complete record of which reporters cover what t r ia ls is kept by the court

reporters' off ice in the Criminal Court. I f the record of a particular trial i s

needed, the reporter of record i s determined, and a request fo r the minutes he

took on the dates o f the t r i a l i s sent t o the microf i lm unit. The microf i lm i s then

made available t o the stenographer t o transcribe in the event of a reopening of a

trial, or a future appeal. Should the original reporter no longer be available t o do

the transcript, another w i l l be hired for the job. Again, the reporter w i l l be paid

for producing the transcript.

Cases from the New York City Criminal Court (lesser offenses) and cases

from the Supreme Court, Criminal Branch (felonies) are usually f i r s t appealed t o

the Appellate Division o f the Supreme Court. When a case goes t o the appeals

court, a l l of the paperwork connected w i th the case i s compiled by the Appeals

Bureau. Transcripts of size, usually over 100 pages, are treated as separate

documents and are given numbers by the Appeals Bureau. This number,

colloquially known as the "stenographic o r steno number," i s stamped or wr i t ten

on the cover of the transcript. A t present, as a money-saving effort, the daily

copy, i f available, i s used by the court as the copy of record. The transcript

remains w i th the court documents throughout the appeals process; a t the

conclusion, the transcript i s sent directly t o the Criminal Court Library, where it

is kept, arranged by steno number. Transcripts of fewer than 100 pages are not

treated as separate documents. They are f i led with other t r i a l records by the

Appeals Bureau. Most transcripts are more than 100 pages long.

I t i s not clear when the system o f numbering t r i a l transcripts in the

Appeals Bureau began; nor i s i t certain when they began t o be stored in the

Criminal Court Library. The Appellate Division of the Supreme Court was created

by a court reform ac t in 1894 and began i t s work in 1896. However, cases from

the Court of General Sessions were appealed t o similar appeals bodies prior t o

that time. There i s an almost complete series o f transcripts in existence w i t h

steno numbers start ing at 1 and continuing to the present day (approximately

*10900). In fact, record books l is t ing these transcripts are kept in the Appeals

Bureau. The f i r s t book contains an alphabetical l is t ing of defendants w i t h

accompanying steno numbers through the year 1929 (approximately steno number

4800). From an examination of the transcripts, i t i s clear that the numbers do

not form a s t r ic t chronological sequence: " 1 i s a t r i a l in 1908, while numbers in

the 2000's are t r ia ls that took place in the 1880's and 1890's. However, there i s

a single complete numerical sequence, and after the beginning o f the 20003, the

numbers do become more or less chronological. I t i s a reasonable speculation

that the system o f assigning steno numbers began in 1908 (perhaps that i s when

the record book was started) and that numbers were retrospectively assigned t o

court reporters' works as they were entered into the record book. Once the

backlog had been numbered, the numbering system seems to ref lect a

chronological l is t ing o f cases sent t o the Appellate Division.

In 1972, the transcripts wi th steno numbers from 1-3666 were offered t o

the John Jay College Library. The reasons for this are not clear, although i t i s

probable that crowded conditions in the Appeals Bureau o r the Criminal Court

Library necessitated the removal of some records. A request was made o f John

Jay t o produce a catalog of what had been received, but lack o f s taf f and money

made this impossible at the time. Exactly what th is collection contained was

not understood when i t was sent to John Jay. Over the years, personnel changes

both i n the Criminal Court and at John Jay lead t o confusion over what was in

the John Jay collection. However, i t was obvious that i t had historical

significance and that the collection was in a deteriorating condition. As a

result, John Jay applied for and received a grant from the National Endowment

3

for the Humanities t o microf i lm the collection. This was carried out in 1983-4.

An index t o this set of transcripts i s now in preparation which w i l l include

access t o these transcripts by type o f offense, defendant's name and other

factors. Unfortunately, because the significance of the steno numbers was not

understood a t the t ime of microfilming, the cases were renumbered to put them

in chronological order by the date of the t r ia l . The steno numbers were retained

and l isted as "old numbers."

In 1975, as part o f a reorganization of the records keeping of the City o f

New York, a large number of the transcripts in the Criminal Court Library were

moved t o storage. These were packed in boxes, and sent t o the Municipal Records

Center. The Records Center inventory shows a gap in the steno numbers which

are i n storage. Again, personnel changes were responsible for the fact that no

one realized a t that t ime that the f i r s t 3666 numbered transcripts had been sent

t o John Jay. There i s now an established procedure by which transcripts are

tranferred t o the Records Center for storage when the Criminal Court Library

becomes too crowded.

At present, items w i t h steno numbers from 3667 t o 8000 are stored by

the Municipal Records Office, while the more recent transcripts are housed in

the Criminal Court Library. A card index, arranged by defendant's name, for a l l

transcripts i s available in the Criminal Court Library. Anyone wishing t o use an

item in storage must apply a t the Criminal Court Library. The transcripts w i l l

usually be sent t o the Criminal Court Library from the Records Office within a

week's time. A copy of the microf i lm and the John Jay index w i l l also be made

available t o the Criminal Court Library, so that anyone doing research into

transcripts there w i l l have access t o the complete set

4

Following are a number of l i s t s which add information t o the John Jay Index.

They were created through a study of both the index f i l e of the New York City

Criminal Court, and the f i r s t record book from the Appeals Bureau which covers

cases sent on appeal from the beginning of the sequence o f stenographic numbers

through the year 1929.

The f i r s t l i s t f i l l s in stenographic numbers for cases in the John Jay

collection for which an "old number" had not been found on the transcript. The

f i r s t l i s t is arranged by John Jay number. The second list i s a rearrangement of

the f i r s t l i s t by defendant name.

The third l i s t consists o f stenographic numbers for transcripts which appear

to be missing from the collection a t John Jay. The names were found through a

search of the Appeals Bureau record book by matching names t o numbers which

were missing in the "old number" f i l e of the John Jay index. In many cases the

John Jay collection has transcripts of t r ia ls for these defendants which may form

only part of the record, or are combined transcripts from which the numbers may

have been missing. In cases where the recod book indicates more than one number

for a particular defendant, these are included. I f the John Jay collection contains

transcripts for the particular defendant although the number in question i s

missing, the related numbers are indicated. These are always steno numbers o r

"old numbers" as they are called in the John Jay index. No attempt has been made

t o l i s t the corresponding John Jay numbers which can be found by looking in the

John Jay Index. In many cases due t o i l legib i l i ty and spelling peculiarities in the

transcription of ora l testimony, errors were made which result in numbers being

assigned twice, or t o the wrong people. The notes indicate such errors when

5

possible The fourth l i s t i s a rearrangement o f the missing case l i s t by defendant

name

After a diligent search, I have determlned that some numbers are completely

missing. There is no record of them in the record book and one can only conclude

that they were lost pr ior t o entry into the record book or that for some reason

those numbers were erroneously omitted when numbers were being assigned to

the transcripts.

Finally, there are some miscellaneous problems and errors which seemed

important enough t o mention. This does not exhaust the many problems which

were found during my search through the record book and card f i le . Nor does i t

include the many names of defendants not l isted in the John Jay Index, but who

nevertheless appear as co-defendants in the record book. There were likewise,

co-defendants l isted in the John Jay Index who were not included in the record

book. Anyone using the collection should at least be aware that these problems

exist, and should therefore proceed w i t h caution in any analysis of the cases,

s tat is t ica l or otherwise. -9

El ysabe th Kleinhans

Reference Librarian,

John Jay College of Criminal Justice

May, 1985

6

CASES L A C K I N G STENOGRAPHIC N U M B E R S

JOHN JAY * STENO 0 E F E Ii D A NT ' 4; N A I1 E N CIT E 5

27 64 97

109 114 1 I ? 121.1 125.1 162 169 204 206 278 294 302 318 326 353 363 372 414 437 482 515 520 529

565 572

SEr1.1 566 594 61 1 fl54

tC7 -1 J J

CASES L A C K I N G STENOGRAPHIC NUMBERS

NOT E 5

659 €163 673 716 816 825 844 864 836.1 980

1075 1136 1 OR0 1167 1185 1203 1274 1376 1377 1547 1564 15?4 1612 1652 1653 1655. 1 1714

1719 1725 1771 1805 191? 2142

2?7i1

, } .-- { 7 l Z i I .-)&I

535 825 540 2 1 Ei 932

48 2 354

68 67

1137 266

1216 1209 1166 1352 1542 1520 1764

1788 1853 1605 1541

( 1860) 1960

19-75 1 g45

2050 2322 2 E, 8 E,

'I) ', ;j ;;; 7.-1fJ 1

-7-

L, -

i -

He q e rrs o t i , ,I ohn H. E d w 8 r d s ~ Tho r-rl B s Owi t z, Lctui s Ellis, Arc f i i t i a ld Berkciwi t z , C : t w l e s H Rutsetis, F red Ward, P e t e r DeC:reir-le, Turiy Kuveke, F red Dorrchin, Meyer Schwart z, Sernuel Ormnnd, John S c hmi d t , C: h fir1 e s A m i c :o , Gospare Dwyer, Erving (and n C:arnpri ni ~ Ph i 1 i p Psrrclt t ,, Hat-vi 11 Hclf f man, ,lacoh Schsefer, Emma Gangel clsi ~ Hosar io FurccIlo, Hal ph Delgr f jc iu , John Schultz, A l f r e d Pyer, ,Ioht-i Pl. Vcln Esc:her, Mark Sal orr-ictrt., C:t-larl E;

Ncl t i n tlclctk

Spell ed Keutlens 1 n ticrctk Not i rt t m o k

In index f i le, no t i n hook!!

See SlSCl CJteno 1060 Inquiry into conduct

t h e r s rmt l i s t e d i n ttclol:)

Not i n t m k

C A S E S LACKING STENOGRAPHIC NUMBERS

JOHN , I N 5TENO DE F E Id 0 ANT '5 N A P I E NOTEE;

C A S E S L A C K I N G STENOGRAPHIC NUMBERS

DE F E N 0 ANT N AHE

Raker, M6ry Harc:I ay, Robert B a r r o w , George B e r k c r w i tz, C h a r l e s H. El1 clclrfr, I SBBC

f i rand t, Wo1 f Brunr ter t , Thecidcire

h g g i at-IO, Koc:c:o Csl deraro, Gui seppe C:emprini, P h i l i p C:srrst tzo, Guiseppe Chip, F rank Ci srarr te l lo, A1 1 emndrc i Considine, M ichae l

DeCre i ne, T c m y Del grac i 0, John Dot-ict-tin, Meyer Durriann, C a r r i e D w y e r , Erving (and o t h e r s ) Dyer, John M.

Edwards, T t-torflas E l 1 i s , A r c h i tis1 d

Gangel os i , K o s a r i o Garcia,, Plar ia Gerlact-1, George ,It-

121El

130? 2322

160 218

1725 225; 21 1

€103

1166 1945 905 453 45 1

482 I788

68 49 1

1209 1605

535 540

909 547

1764

3333

515

654 97

1203 1725 553 117

864 15-74 980 554

1185 1652

663 7 1 El

553 3149 1564

1547 1771 282f,

Spell ed Gaggi arto i n tmtk Not l i s t e d i n ttocik

Olsly orre S t * l is ted i n book

Ott-ier d e f e n d a n t s n o t l i s t e d

CASES L A C K I N G STENOGRAPHIC NlJMBERS

Hot-rei 1, Ben i a m i 1-1 Ha r-ri s,, ,lotin H o r t- i 5; ~ S B t-r'li~ e 1 Hegemsrr, Jllrtsrs R. H ct f f rrt a rt , ,I 6 c: o tl

,I 6 c k s CI rr , t l CI s e s ,Io t-1 t-I 5; CI t-I, F red E! r i c: k

K e i 1 ey, ,lohn Ke l l s rd , Mary Klein, Gussie K1 e i rrberg, Hart-l l K r a k 6 ti E! r, Ab r B h B t n

Kregsl, Ahrsham Kuveke, Fred

LaGa tu t t s , P ie t r c l Langi n, ,lotin LarsorI, H a r r y Law1 ess, E d w a r d L e f E:ovi tz, A d l o p h Levy, Of iv id find Ller l r~i E!

L eilt y , P ti i 1 i p

O'B e i t-t-I e ,, Pl 6 1 6 c: h !../

462 326

569 114 125.1

3305 165 353 896.1

Orl ly one St# l is ted i n t m

In index f i l e , n o t i n t r c ~ l k

1 7 14 2142

162 414 121.1 206 302

O'Dc1nne11 st-ml d tie S t # 1 Xi 1

C A S E S L A C K f N G STENOGRAPHIC NUMRERS

Fjat-ro t t , t-larvi t-t Pe c: k rt e 4, E uge n e Poi ndex t er, Lercly Pcdykrcrnis, Peter-

Satti, Tony Sol c~tnctr~, t:t-mrI es Sc:haef er , Emma Schmidt, Char les Sc :hu l t z, A1 f r e d Sc:hwart z, Ssrriuel 5 t-t i rt-ct, T ho r i d s Soe j i t-m, T r o a i [:hi S t egl er, R i cha rd E;tilwell, Stephen

Tahar-, Sheik H a d j i

1068 1860 1520 266

1653 67

19-75 329 1 2885 19-79

588 165g.1 1377 1080 1612 107s See also St# 1060 1719 2770 30 17 322[>

Only c l n S t # l i s ted i n t m k

O n l y one St* l i s t e d i n ticmk

1541 1653

STENOGRAPHIC NUMBERS MISSING FROM THE JOHN J A Y COLLECTION

STENli * OEFENDANT NkNE NOT E 5

3 14 17 31

33 34 37

41 43 44 45 46 44 5 0 56 58 77 78 79 80 96

100 1 04 1 06 11s

116 127 129 140

146 158

1 46

STENOGRAPHIC NUMBERS MISSING FROM THE JOHN J A Y COLLECTION

STENO * DEFENDANT N A t l E N CIT E 5

161 164 171 204 253 260 264 273 277 262 283 285 29-7 299

30 1 303 328 338 367 37 1 386 42 1 422 43 1 432 44 1 446 448 450 460 486 SO 1 51 1

536

Eiursdi, George Healy, Jcisept-i Also "€179 W d trnan, W i 11 i art1 H1 ake, Llohrl Ackcwi tz, Lecrpol t Bat t ag l i s , Sal vatc1t-e Brunswi ck, Rcrtter? Berkrriarl., I s rae l i: our t IS e q, Tho rfl B s Robert on, Jat-r~es Katie, Patr ick Ma t erscm, Jart ies J. Kshn, Max Fer i ~ ,Icdirr Pol 1 i no, F rank Jorilon, Char1 es J e f fcl, Jirri Koerii g, Ado1 ph Anderson, Chsrl es J o h 1-1 E; o ri , The c! d o r e Jenni rigs, Msry

Not Rr 1 16 as listed

Not # 177 6s listed

Also *378

A1 SO *356

A I SO *278

STENOGRAPHIC NUMBERS MISSING FROM THE JOHN JAY COLLECTION

STENO * OEFENCMNT NAME NOTES

55 1 556 56 1 60s 608 62 1 633 6 45 653 665 668 67 1 693 717 722 73 1 753 755 765 784

803 604 815 83 1 840 843 845 E355

865 868 865 872 885 889

Fucar-i ncl, Gse t atw Flyr-In, Jsmes Fanrti rig, H e r q C:. G u l o t t a , Ar i thor iq J. Glrstof ~ n , Frank Go cldrr-t B n ~ S B n-1 11 e 1 Go1 dsmi t h , Freder i ck Honrii riqrsn, J o h n ,-I. ti 6 t-ri p t o t-t , B v i d H o t-i e ri tr E r-g , R e rri ir r d Hendr i cltson, John Hallett , Herlry R . Lewis, Mart in

Len tz, 'v/i 11 i mi Limcrnte, Felipi Mc:Lauqhlin, Frank Murphy, Jo tin Mulligen, P s t r i c k J. Hunter, I s ~ s c M i 1 es, Samuel mi ]en, ~~1sept - t Mart i ti, C)iirwcicd M urp 11 y L 6 PY r e ti c: e

STENOGRAPHIC NUMBERS MISSING FROM THE JOHN J A Y COLLECTION

85 1 PI i t t, Hbr-t-i s 906 R i bel 1 o, John 907 K i c h s r d E; ., N o s t-I 314 Rerrii go, Marcci t 1111 i s 420 Rose, Ni c:hcd as 923 RUSSCI, Joseph 330 Roach, Williat-r-1 J. 935 Wetler, Ct-mrl e s A. 447 Wa l te r , Alexander 55 1 Wheel er, Osrnor Ei. 958 Wsde., Ger t rude 985 V ia fo ro , P ie t r c l 588 Val en t i ,, TOTTIBSSCI 989 V i ta le , C'srrrsine 99 1 Hclml in, F r e d e r i c:k 9% & 997 Torr-tpkins, Cha r l es ,I. 5194 Thomm,, Nicholas

1001 Thorr-IpsoH, C h a r l e s 8 . i 1302 1006 Taylor, Ella 1007 1008 Taorney, Mary 1009 1010 T i ghe, M a r t i n 1012 Smi th, h h t - ~ 1013 1014 Trebi, P1ar-c:o 102 1 1022 Sh ie lds , C:harl e s ,-I. 1024 S c h r w S a S , , R i cha rd 1026 Sperrcer, W i 11 i srrl 1026 Stef fsnct , Bise1 1 i 1 S B 1-1 d s , ,I B t-ri E! E;

1045 S t a h l , Hat-t-g 1052 S;teele, C:/jar-le:; E . (Ei ' 7 )

1058

T o b i n , T h o rrl6 E;

Townsend, Hal s t ed

Srrli t h, C:harl e s

4; o r cl h B Is , ,I it TI e 5;

5; w e e rr e y ., ,I o t-I rl

klsc1 "661

:v .

STENOGRAPHIC NUMBERS MI'SSING FROM THE JOHN JAY COLLECTION

ST E N 0 * D E F E N C) A NT F I A Pl E I1 CIT E 5

1101 1107 1108 1 1 13 1114 1 1 18 1122 1127 1136 I138 1148 1155 1159 1163 1 tb5 1184 116'6 1188 1189 1130

1196 1201 1202 1209 1226 1226

1243

1246 1257 12ty 1273 1 3 1:) 5 1312

5 c h l esse], Na t hsn E. Korrrf el d, t'ltm Krakauer, Max Jsmmes, A1 b e r t i J B s r l e t , Herman Schre iber , W i l l i a m 5. Eci gel CIW., C:1 aude 'dei r, Gust- aili R CI s E! 1 1 i ., A rl t o rl i o C o 1 1 i n s , C! E! rr n i s Del iliec:c:t-li o, Char-1 es Oeci cc i O, Errti 1 i o Amsbi 1 e, A I phcinse Doe, Jcihrr, e t a1 r i a l 61-8, ria t t Frsnke l , Max Plsri f 0, Joseph P l o f f e t t , Paul H. Merks, Msrshsl A r o n i n, Hclbert W i 11 i a r m , ,ioseph Lust ig, Mclrr i s Cf laur i ce?) Mat7 f 0, Jiiseph Arctns, L e w i s Dwyer, E r v i rig E;:. ott-rers Si arm, Leopcll d c ~ I anria, G i c ~ ~ a t - ~ n i Sfri r ie l 1 i , Ph i 11 i p c ~ Er; F t-frnc:exo c; 0 f f , ,I 0 PI rl 'PI.

\ - I '

STENOGRAPHIC NUMBERS MISSING FROM THE JOHN JAY COLLECTION

ST E N O .tt D E F E N Cl A NT N A I-1 E NCITES

132? 1331 1336 1367 140 1 1420 1460 1461 1480 1514 1518 1522 1550 1559 1579 1586 1599

1613

1624 1638 1643 1653 1667 1674 1689 1691 1692

16c13 1fIq7

Also * 146 I

STENOGRAPHIC N U M B E R S MISSING FROM THE JOHN J A Y COLLECTION

STENO * DEFENDANT NAPIE N [IT E 5

1703 1710 1712 1714 1715 tP18 1722 1724 IT741 1 750 1 7 m 1813 1816 1638 1854 1865 1866 1891 1905 15112 191s 1 w o 1955 1961 1935

3 1974 1481 1992 19YEi 2006 2007

C c w t ney, Thornas Alsc t "277, 425, 440 & 1728 K i n rr o r i , F 1-0 rr k , ,It-. S i rc l ta , Rutlirr H i r s o h k o w i t z , C h a r l e s Ford, George L. DeVeau, Edgar E. Dut t ctt-I, St epherr A . K i t i s 1 er, Joseph A1 de rd i ce,, L1ames Eel 1 er, claC:clti P c w e r s , P e t e r Rossi, C:harl es Dunrie, I l w y Mi 11 er, Mcir r i E;

I m p e r a t o , Gaetarm MI= E en rr a ~ J CI s e p h J. A1 SO * 1837 H e t t l e r , Human & Rusk A i so 1850

Alr;c1 * 1358 A1 so 19E lO

Alsc1 Yxi

Not *I739 as l i s t e d

F 1 tis 5; , PI e t e rl K 6 u f r-n B rl , S B rri

Sari t ago t a, E d w a r d Guhi t osi, Gbe t arm

8i 11 i ngs, George R o g u l , A b r a h a h S t a f f a, R o s a r i o Oci rrfr 6 rt ., \*i i 1 1 i firri F . T o d i ria, F r m k A l s o 12651 Uhee, Err1trIa Si rig, Ong Tssh j i mi., A r m W h i t e Slave T r a d e (Grand JWU) I rl Re 766 P.L. (Gr-and J u r y I tsvesti ys t i ari) U'C)orrnell I Wsl t e r Baker, A l t l e r t P E ! ~ c : o c : ~ , 01 i v e r

A I w YES 1

L i s t e d 0:; #'1961:i

1 '3

STENOGRAPHIC NUMBERS MISSING FROM THE JOHN J A Y COLLECT; OF!:

STENO DEFENDANT NAME NOT E S

2038 2040 2047 2057 2060 2065 2067 206'3 2074 2080 208 1 2082 2085 2 w 5 2055

2 1 00 2101

2 103 2109 21 12 2120

Zeimet-) Herlry Alscr #'203 1 Sc-hmi d t, Hans C: o IS c: ii ~ A t i t o t i i o Camparre1 1 i I '4. S u l l i vm, Mi chael J, McC:ahi 11 ., Henry Schc r r , I S B B C :

St o v a l 1, At-chi E!

Eiweeney, Dan ie l Wo l f , Sad ie Dempsey, T i rrio t tiy S p r a g u e , G e o r g e. Wsde, G e r t r u d e Voskow, Meyer Parerr t i, W i 11 i arrr Tore1 1 i, Angel o T a l 1 on, M i c:hael M c E l hi tirrey, Har r i so r r H . Seton, Char l es A. W al dron, Rober t H. Sul 1 i vm, C:crrnel i us Curci o, Fratic:i sccl Ray, James P a r-k s, S B rr-1 u E! 1

A k c I 9 2 10 & 245 1

A l so 1094

2 125 K, 2 128 Pesrsall, Thclrrtas 2137 Eirecco, A I phcinse 2141 K i err; t ed, C h e r l es

Lclng, M i c:hseI r i i t o t w 1, c : ~ ar -et -m Ct'Rri en, Pa t t - i c:k

2152 Gal bet-t ,, Georqe 2154 61 ennon, Edward G. 2160 Ple t r -cqol i t at-I 5 t . RR 2161 Meyers, Percy A . 2178 Fort imat o,, Pl i cl-lael 2 179 L u t Fig., E d t-d

STENOGRAPHIC NUMBERS M I S S I N G FROM THE JOHN JAY COLLECTION

STENO DEFENCMNT NAME NOTES

2255

9968 L L

2269 22?3 2274 2283 2287 2292 2236 2300 2304 2320

2326

232cJ 2340

"Thfiw" (Grand J u r y ) Brad1 y, A1 f r e d R u w s r t h , A1 exarlder- Giambruno, Fj ietrcl L evfils t i ncl, A n t on i o Kerlrredy, Darli e1 K e rt n E! d y , ,I ct 11 ri Kclerrler, W i 11 i a m J. Becket-, Char l es Tunnel D i s f i s t e r W 61 den, A m i e Bshb, Jfic:ttl

Krserner, W i 11 ism J. 'Irlhi t e , W a l t e r P a t errm s t r o, J a m e s Daw, George W i 1 E; o rt , T h o t-rl6 s A. Brusci, Pietrcl Furmera, N i V B

Thomas, Ben j owti n Schiff, H e r m a n H. Singer., H a r r y A r t i s, A r t ernas F'. Rmdazzci.l Eresi ede t t.cl E l i f f mi ,, Char l es M i lone, Pasqua1 e

A l s o * 3 17 & 2273

A1 SO 9 3 1 E; Not *234 BE; listed

A lso *237€1, n o t V 8 7 h

STENOGRAPHIC WMBERS MISSING FROM THE JOHN J A Y COLLECTION

STENO DEFENDANT NAME NClTES

2413 2419

2423 2460

2475

2482 2485 2497

253 1 2567 26139

2643

2654 2660 2672

2674 26% 2680 2733 2757 2799 2637 2840 28-;72

2645

Pezzulo, A I b e r t A c e n ~ , V i r1c:Errizci 8; K a t e r i ria Eircwm, John PI CI s k U I ,I CI 11 n Rei 1 1 y , T e r e n c e

C:annel1s, Kclssr i o DerIrlel et-, C:harl es UeV i 11 ers, Yves

La Marit ia, S a l i v a r e Gat to , Caudelaro Arbarno, F rank Carbone, C:armi ne Marigfin, 'di 11 i awl F . L i etlrnsn, Hyrrlari Rot hman, At i raharf i

L

A r i c h i el 1 ci, Gui seppcl Rot t-lschi 1 d , Henry Rothrnan, At i rsharn Demorest , Horace E . Hai ken, Jacot l Truc:kerrnan, Lciui s Carrisval e., Rocco A lexander , Dsv id D i Muro, Sal m t c t r e P i t-rcirie, Thornos 'dt-ri te , ~ o u c l t Rkmc:k?) G i tiscir-1, E;tst- tky R e rl o 1 d s ~ T t-I o rr5 6 :;

Kaufman, F r e d e r i c k R i c: c: o ti o t-1 CI I I? i CI v a rt rr i rl Rcise, t-lairri c:e G i cit-dot-lo, Ange l o ri 6 t- t- i t-1 E! z I Iq E! p o t-1 IJ 1:. e 1-1 CI

A l s o #E84

STENOGRAPHIC NUMBERS MlSSfNG FROM THE JOHN J A Y COLLECTfON

STENrlr DEFENCrANT NAME NOT E S

8nCk, /%x H o r r i s, I S B B C

Er ur-k e, ,I ci s e ph Ni zrti k, S t epherl Kapl an, I rvi ng 0 o e ., ,I o h rl

R e f e r s tct the Tr i a r i g l e S h i r t w a i s t F i r e

Not *22fi9 8s 1i:;ted

A I S O * 3 175 ( re Bu f f )

A l s o * 3 169, not 3 158

STENOGRAPHIC NUMBERS MISSING FROM THE JOHN J A Y COLLECTION

STENO OE F E N C ) A NT N AP1 E NOT E 5;

STENOGRAPHIC NUMBERS HISSING FROM THE JOHN J A Y COLLECTION

Cj E F E N 0 ANT N A P1 E ST E NO * NOT E 5

Ac:erdo, Sol v a t o r e 33

A c k o v i t z , Lecrpcrldo 253 Adron ja , Guiseype 34 A I derdi IX., Jf j rnes 722 A I exonder-, D a v i d 2 J f , Arnabi 1 E!, A1 p h ~ r t s ~ !

Art lano, F r a n k 2497 Arqenz i arIo, Lui g i 1460 A r i chi el 1 o, Gui seppo Arorrin, Rober t 1 / 9 0 A r u m , Lewis 1202 A r t i s , A r t e r n u s P. 2350

Ac:ena, V i ncenzct Px. K a t e r i rta 24 1 3

1159 7 - 4 - Anderson, C:tim-l E!:; w 4, '- ci

2643

A u t omcttri 1 e T r s f f i c I n v e s t i g a t i o n 3443

Babb, Jacob Baker , A1 hert Baksa, E l i z a b e t h Ha l dassare, Rocxci Bsr l et , Herrnan R a t t a g l i a , S a l v a t o r e Beck, L o u i s Erecker, C h s r l e s Bel 1 i rrg, W i 11 i a m H. Eierkrr'rsr-t, I :;rad Ber t rawl,, 'di 11 i a m H i gel ow, C1 aude B i l l i n g s , George 61 Uke, Jclhrt Hl ar-lck, PI6X

Eclqul, Atlrat-lar-r-1

STENOGRAPHIC NUMBERS MISSING F R O M THE JOHN J A Y COLLECTION

D E F E ND ANT NAME

H o ri B r-1 rt CI , P4 i c CI 1 B

Bowen, Jot i r i Jr. Bclyd , W i 11 i err1 Brac:c:o, A1 phonse Brad1 ey, A l f r e d Brandt , Clarertce Erand t , Fo lke E. Hrcrwn, J o h n Brown, ,Iot~n Jr. B r u n s w i c k , Rober t B rusc i , P i e t r o Erundi, Gearge Huono, Antoriicr Burke, Joseph B u r r a w s , A i f r e d

Campi orre, Thomas Canriel 1 a, R o s a r i o C8rbOm3, C a r m i n e Carnevale, Rocco Cascone, Ra f f a1 e Casson, Theodore Chapman, W i 11 i a m H Chee, Ernrrla Cioffi, Kaphaele C i t r on , Satnuel C:ohen, E l i Coco, P e t e r M. Co11 ins, Deni s C:crl 1 i ns , [)on 8. Ccmway, B e r n a r d C:. C:cincs, A n t on i no c: 0 1-1 t l CI I-s ~ R 0 tl e I- t Cour t neg, T h c ~ m a s

STENO

14 1327 3134 2137 2249 3134

51 1 2419 1327 264

2326 161

2385 3269 3358

3354 2460 2497 2674

432 8c 446 44 1

349 1 1966

106 422

415 1653 1138 3359 359fl 2 0 47

448

NOTES

Not * 1 16 BE; l i s t e d ; see also Noto

N o t "2269 es l i s t e d ; see a l s u Kennedy

A l s o "2675 A h *I240 & 1241 A1 SO "464 A l s o *3552

Not *464 as l i s t e d

STENOGRAPHIC NUMBERS MISSING FROM THE JOHN J A Y COLLECTION

Ci E F E I4 C> A NT N A I-1 E

Cow art, A r t tiur Cozzens, Henry H. C r i s a f u l l i ~ Urwf ri cl C r o t t y , P e t e r C:unni ngham, ,tarries Cushi ng, W i 11 i a m C i n i o, F r -ami sco

D' A c i e r n 0 , F r B 1-1 c e 5; c o Do i l y , Merrlie D'Angelo, S a l v a t o r e Darry, Rube Daw, Eeorge F. Dec i c:ci 0, Errti 1 i o C)eFortaro, C a r l o DeFoulke, L a w r e n c e Delvecchio, Char les OeMe~i, A1 e>c,aridet- Derrtorest, Horace E. Dempsey, T i m o t h y Denrteker, J o h n Denneler , C h a r l e s DePre t i s , James N. D e v i 11 ers, Yves D i f f oni , Char1 es DiMuro, Selv&tar-e D i nser , Gust ev Doe, John n 0 e, J 0 h n Orurrt, Phi 11 i p Oumcmd, George 5. D iirl ne, M a r y C) 11 t t o n ., S t e p t-1 e rl A . D i ~ V e a i ~ , Edqar E.

A l i a s N o r m a n P r i n c e 9 5 7 3

A l s o *5 1 E; L i s t e d " e t a l " H e Buff A l s o *2 1 EiEi

S T E N O G R A P H I C N U M B E R S MISSING FROPl T H E JOHN JAY COLLECTION

DEFENDANT NAME STEN0 # NOT E El

Ea t ori, C:cldwell J. Edwards, L e s l i e E rrre r E; o rr , Herr ru Enea, V i r1c:enzo

Farmi rig,, Henry E.

Fer-i, John F i t z p a t r i c k , W a l t e r F1 sriagan, Frank F l u s , N e t e n Flynn, J a m e s Ford, George 1. F o r t u n a t o, M i chae l Frartkel , Max Fucarina, Gaetano Funnera, Nova

Gal b e r t , George Galgano, Dominick Galvani, Jose C. Gangi, G i ovanni Gardiner, M a t t e r crf Gat to , Caudo ls ro Gaut hi er, Eugene G'i arr~ t~runci, P i e t r c l G i trsorr, S t ari l ey G i 1 mctre, John C;. G i c r d a m , Ange l o G i t 1 ow, Ben j a m i rr Glennciri, Edward 6. Gclf f ~ L ~ ~ ~ P r r l w. Go1 dberg, ,Ioseph

536 A l s o 1 129 1566 ,7494 7?

249 115 A l s o Y3?

3334 1865 A l s o 1958 556 A l ~ l *25ErO

1712 2178 1 w 4

2326

A lso "3 l6rJ tiut r io t 3 158

55 1 A l s o *571

STENOGRAPHIC NUMBERS MISSING FROM THE JOHN J A Y COLLECTION

DE F EN C1 ANT N APlE

Go ldsmi th , F reder ick : Gorrmn, W i 1 1 i erri F. Grend Jury Inv. He T 6 6 P L Grarrd Jury "T tiaw" Greentlerg, Sarrtiel Gusstelo, Angelo Gutii t o s i , Gset mo Gustst son, Frsrrk

Hai ken, Jacob H a l l e t t , Henry R. Ham1 i 1'1, F r e d e r i c k Hamp t on, f ) w i d Hsnni gan, clohn J. Hart-i s, I s m c

Het t ri ck, Jc~hn T. H i r sc :hkow i t z , C:harl e$; Hahenberg, H e r n 8 r d Hiin t et-, I saac:

Kahn, Max

STENO * NOTES

2672 67 1 99 1 653 645

1599 kE 3261

349 1 1710 665 784

1228 1816 1461

A l ~ l "267 1 A h *267 Also %6 1 A l so *639 A l s o "2164 L a t t e r r e f e r s t o t h e T r i s n q l e E ; h i r t w a i s t

F i t-e A1 so *3552

STENOGRAPHIC NUMBERS MISSING FROM THE ,JOI-CN J A Y COLLECTION

0 E F E N A NT Id A Pl E

Ksne, P o t r i c k K a ra ti en , C B E; p a I- K s U f rri8fi, F r e d e r i c k KBlJffTl8~i, sarf'71 Kaplsn, I r v i n g Kell et-, JaCOtl Kennedy, Dan ie l 1: en r-I E! d y , ,I ci t-I rl K i e r s t ed,, C:harl e s K i l r o e , Edwiri P. K i nsl et-, Joseph Koerri g, Ado1 LI t-1

Koerr ier , W i 11 i mi J. Korr l f el d, Max Krskeuer , Plax

L a l l a n t i a, 581 i { ia re Lentz , \~/i l l iarrl Lerned, C:harl es Lesc:hi de, Ti Levont i rm, Antonio Lewis, Martin L i e bmsn, Hyman Limonte, F e l i p i Loetl, Max Long, M i chfiel Lus t i g , M c r r i s (Maur i ce? ) L u t hy , Edwar-d L u t t re1 1, Jot-in J.

STENO *

283 1367 2840 1866 32fiE; 1724 2266 L L 3 'y&

2141 3526 1718 328

2273 tK22'36 1107 1108

11 CiT E 51

A l s o # 179

A1 SO 9 ' 5 1 A l s o * I 110 A l s o *31? A l s o "383 N o t 367 os l i s t e d

Not *369 B S l i s t e d

STENOGRAPHIC NUMBERS MISSING FROM THE JOHN J A Y COLLECTION

DE F E N 0 ANT N A PI E STENO # NOTES

Mar t in, Dorwocld H. t-lert irrez, Ne(jcrnuc:eno Mor t oges i an, Levon t Pl. Mss t ersort, Js t r~es J. Mc:C:ahi 11, Henry M c E l hi nney, H o r r i sclrr H 11 r: K e n rl B , ,I o s E! p t-1 ,I. Mclaugh l in , Frank Me1 i rre, C:harl e s Met rclpcll i t 81-1 S t . RR Meyers, Perctd A . M i 11 er, Morri s Mi lone, Fjasqual e tvli t che l l , C1areric:e M o f f a t t , Paul E. Mclrel lo, Henry

Mu1 1 HI, Jciseph Mu1 1 i gfin, P a t ri ck J. Murphy, John Mut-phy, John Murphy , L s w r e n c e

rioska, J O F ~ ~

Napol i , O i a c c i no Ni zni k, E; t ephen Nctrrriari, M a r t i ri N. Nclrri s, George C:. Nclrt cm, Hart-y No t o, Carr i ie l CI

O'Brien, P a t r i c k O'C)cm-iell, Mi c:t-isel Cl'Dorlnell, Walt et-

E; 0 4 2960

140 285

2065 2101 1 ti38 753

1312 1305 & 2 160 21ht 1813 2368 2141 1188 1257 2419

603 765 755

1238 815

845 3284

41 37

643 116

A h *8 14

Not l i s t e d w i th o t h e r Murphy cfises No Wm. Howe in bock

A l s o *Ei 1 1 , 1424, 1875

ST EN 0 GRAPH I C

DEFENDANT NAME

NUMBERS MISSING F R O M THE JOHN JAY COLLECTION

STENO * NOT E E;

P a l imtm, h h r i Parr ipi r le l lo , P e t ro Parer i t i ni, W i 11 i arrl P a r i rl t i , W i 1 1 i arn P a r I( s, E; a rrlu e 1 Pasquriell i, U1 i sse Ptdernc ls t ro, JarrieS P a t t erscri , Nan R. Peacock, 01 i v e r P e s r s a l l , T t-icir'nas Per ie l l i , Joseph ine Persce, Gui seppe Pet re1 lo , M i c:hael Pezzulo, Alber t P i ro r r i o l l i ., A reange l o P i r rone , Tharriss P i sc i a t a, G i acorrm P l i t t , H a r r i s Pcdaro, F i l ippc i P o l 1 i na, Frank Powers, P e t e r s Pr-arm, James P r e n t i s , Herirg 1.

864; 868

1317 2099 2120 1401 2304

869 1998 2125KC 2128 A l s o T 1 2 3 3615

46 872

2403 1638 2733

885 85 1

79 299

1741 88Sr

37

STENOGRAPHIC NUMBERS M I S S I N G FROM THE JOHN J A Y COLLECTION

D E F E N 0 A NT N A t l E

R i chords, Noat-I R i t tct, Eugeni o Roach, W i 11 i ~ r r i J. R o tr i n I ,I B c: k Romana, Selvstcrt-e Rose, Maur i (:e Rose, N icho las Koselli, A n t o n i o Rctsertwasser, Ju1 i 11s Rctsscl, M i ct-iel o Hot hmm, At j reham Rot hschi 1 d, Heriry R o t o h , Nic:oicl Kowarth, Alexandet- R u s s 0, ,I 0 s e p h Ryan, Clarii el R y s n , Gecirge

Sands, Jsrnes Santsgats, Edward Schiff , Herrr isn H. Schkssel, N ~ t h 8 n 8. Schrni d t ~ Hans SChrioims, K i c h a r d Sc:t-torr, I safic: Sc:hrei ber, \ V i 11 i o m J Eichrei timan, ,-I~ccib 5churen, Arncll d 5;. Situ 1 1 i n, A u s t i rr Seton, Ct-iarl es A . Eihields, C:harles J. Shillitoni, CIrestci 5 i B n o ,, 1 e ci p o 1 d o S i t-t g ~ 0 rig

go7 1643 930

1624 291 I & 2914 920

1136 3586 1480 2639 ti 2654 2645 2379 2243

1248 t m 2

3 5 (1 CJ

31 & 923

A ~ X I V 6 4 9 ti 2653 A lso "2644

Not *65 1 A1 so 1249

A1 so "28 Not *234 A1 so * 1086 A l s o *22 10 8E 245 1

STENOGRAPHIC NUMBERS MISSING FROH THE JOHN JAY COLLECTION

Singer-, Harry 2340 S i ro ta , Kubirr 1703 S w ~ i th, C:t-iarles 1 i>og Srr-ri th, Herber t 349 1 Srni t h, ,Io hn Srnuc:kl et-, I smc : Sokcit i n s k i , Lou i 5;

f; ora t-ia rt ~ ,I ~ t r i e 5;

Spsul di rig, Eim j m - l i t-t

S p e r m r , 'di 11 i arrl

1012

L) 1 1013

3-7 1 WE1

cc J tl 7

Spinelli, Ph i l l i ppc i 8; Ft-mc:esc:i 1228 S p r B g u e, 13 eo r g e S t a f f a , Rasarics S t ahl , H e r r 4 Steele, Char les E. (Ei.'?) S t e f f aria, Bi s e l l i S t ovs11, A r c h i e Stuve, L o u i s Sull ivan, Ccirt-Iel i us S u l l i v m , M i chsel ,I, War t s , Lciuis E. Sweeney, Dsn i e l

Sweeney, Thomes M. s w e et-l e y , ,I 0 hn

Alscl*l1814& 1815

A l s o "87

STENOGRAPHIC NUMBERS MISSING F R O M THE JOHN LJAY COLLECTION

OEFEND A NT NAME 5T E N 0 NOT E E;

T o h i rr , T /-I o t-rr B E;

Tcldi r q Ft-ark Tcin-ipki ns, Char l e:; J. Toomey, Mary Tore1 1 i, Ange l o Tou rb i 11 on, A r t hut- Townsend, Halst etjd Trehi, M a r m Truckermar i , Lcwi s Truon, W i 11 i a m A. Tunrrel D i s a s t e r " 1882"

V a l en t i, Tomasso 988 V s l l e, C;i cwmrri 100 V ia fo ro , P i e t r o 585 V i t a1 e, Carmi n e 48Y

Waxmsn, I s i do r Weher-, Char-1 e s A . W e i r, G IJ s t 8 ir

Weis, Edwiri A . iu' e 1 1 t-1 fi u s e ri ,, J CI h 1-1

Wheeler , CIsrr-wIor E. hi h i t E!, B CI 11 C: k ( E; CI t i c: k '? ) 'dtii t e, Wal t et- W i 11 i arris,, Josept-~ Id i 1 so Is, T t-1 o rr~ fi 5; A 'di t t ent lerq, 'IsIli 11 i 8r1-1 R

STENOGRAPHIC NUMBERS M I S S I N G FROM THE JOHN JAY COLL-ECTlON

DE F E N C> A NT N A H E ST E 1\10 # NUT E 5

Ze i mer, Henry Zer-i 11 o, Frat-rk

MISCELLANEOUS PROBLEMS

John Kol inowski should be *353 not *354

Fred Kuveke should be *354 (steno number missing).

Dennis 0. Lesry (‘854) listed os O’Lesry i n book.

Mart in Lewis should be *693 not *369.

Michsel O”Donne1l should be *855 not #842; Michsel O’Donovan is l i s ted as *842 i n

book.

Joseph Russo should be * 3 1 and #923 not “85 1 .

Herman H. Sch i f f should be *2340 not *234.

Isaac Smuckler should be “56 not ’32.

William F. W e l tmsn shou ld be 17 1 not * 177.

Josef Zimienske (*1308) i s spelled Simianske i n book.