Upload
others
View
2
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Title 〈論文〉ヒュームの自然主義と因果推論の正当化問題
Author(s) 澤田, 和範
Citation 哲学論叢 (2014), 41: 35-46
Issue Date 2014-11
URL http://hdl.handle.net/2433/200734
Right
Type Departmental Bulletin Paper
Textversion publisher
Kyoto University
- 35 -
clvh2Dzƚ�Ǫ,æŵŏȝ2ƃĠÄãɞ
ƗƪÞǕ
��������
� �Ēǚŏȝ2ƃĠÄ�/ą�DĺưȝHţƾ.�Š+Őǀ�$�Ɲ�"�18~ǙWS\
_ms`2àüǭ^LtK\`uclvh+�D���E��Ǥƴ.clvhȉɅ+�'
$������2ȉɅHǧŅ�D23ǖÆ+3. , ��,��Ȼ�,> 1980ĕ�/3
clvhƽNJǭ2Ɍ+ė�IJȠ�EDA�/.'$,ĮGED��ǤƴȉɅ�ł�Dȟã
ɞ2�&>',>ţƳ.23�clvh�ĒǚŏȝHDzȯ2àüōNJƌ,�*ŌƩ�*
D�,+�D��E3ģ2�ǻ��ɌŲįȝ2Te[L_o��ÿɡƴŏƤƌHǘǂ2
ȟãɞ/ć�DȒ;�+�D�,�B>ţB�+�D�ɣclvh3�Ēǚŏȝ��Ǣɡ
�E$ąȣ�BǢɡ�E$�,2. ąȣ72ŏȝ��3�8*æŵŏȝ+�D,Ǭ�*
$��ƃ� �æŵŏȝ2Šƌ�ÿɡƴŏƤƌ+�D�ɤĒǚŏȝHÚþ�$�Ɲ�DzB
2àüōNJ2Šƌ/ÿɡƴŏƤƌHŌƩ�D,36(�Ǭ�BE. 2+3. ��
� ô�2ȉɅǭ$&3�clvh�Ēǚ/ɍ�DĺưȝHČɋ�$,�E*�$Ǔľ2ȡ
ȝ2²ȉɅ/A'*�clvh�ÿɔ/3Ēǚ/ɍ�DĺưȝHŐ´�.�'$,�Ğ�
* D�.�+>ŭȱ�qLWuqve(Loeb, 2006, 2008)��clvh3óë�Ǫ2ȈƘ
�BæŵŏȝH¡ɝį�Ǫ/A'*ȕȠƴ/ƃĠÄ�$,ȝ�*�ƎƶHɖ=* D(1)�
qve2ȉɅ3�E:+Ǝƶ�E*�.�'$ȝƘHÛ;ǵÜƔ >2+�D�����
×Ŧ/ãɞ>ł�* D,ĮGED��2ş� ȉɅ/ą�*ŀ·ƴ/ŻȋH¾�D�,
/A'*�clvh2àüōNJ/( *ŗ=*Ǭ�Ʒ��,�+�D+�F��"E�Ų
ȝ2�ɞ+�D��{+3:��ȱĕ2ȟȉɅ�BPkp\_2ȗHǟ���"E/ą�
Dqve2ŀ·,qveDzȯ2ȗHȗţ�Dɣ2ǔɤ�"2�,�Ųȝ2�ĞHŗ=*ƾȕ
��"2ɔ/Ųȝ 4ǔ�ɏ2ȡȝ2Ȅȶ�Hȳ8D�,/�Dɣ3ǔɤ�
�������+1�
� �Ǥƴ.ȉɅHǖÆ/��B �D$=/�clvh2æŵȝ,�*�ACƎƶHɖ=
*�$� G@D�Ēǚ/ɍ�Dĺưȝ�(T 1.3.6)H²ŽĻ�D�,�Bù=A��
A) Ǣɡ�E$�,2. ąȣ72ŏȝ3�Dzƚ2Ŝwį2ÉƤ���.G&�Ǣɡ�E
- 36 -
$�,2. ��3Ǣɡ�E$��,ɟ��D�, �ÉƤ/ï) * D�
B) �2ÉƤ�Ƥįƴ/ƃĠÄ�ED.B4�"E3ȝȐƴȡȝ/ï)��Ǽƚƴȡȝ/
ï)��2-&B�+�D�
C) �2ÉƤ3ȝȐƴȡȝ/A'*3Ȑţ�E. �, �23��2ÉƤ�Ļnj�.
�,Hı©Óǰ+�C�@�/�2ÉƤ2|Ļnj3ȝƤƴ/Óǰ%�B+�D�
D) �2ÉƤ3Ǽƚƴȡȝ/A'*>Ȑţ�E. �, �23��2ÉƤHȐţ�A�
,�DǼƚƴŏȝ"EDz���2ÉƤH»Ő�Dĩƥȝƌ/ɒD�B+�D�
E) �$�'*��Dzƚ2Ŝwį�3Ƥįƴ/ƃĠÄ�E. �
F) �$�'*�Ēǚŏȝ3Ƥįƴ/ƃĠÄ�E. �
clvh2ȡȝH�2A�/Ƥȉ�D�,/9,I-2ƽNJǭ3Îą�. ,ĮGED�
ȉɅz2�Ƙ,.'* D23�<�F�2ȡȝ/A'*clvh��HIJé�$2��
,CG�clvh�Ēǚ/ɍ�DĺưȝHIJé�$2�-��+�D�
� �Ǥƴ.ȉɅ/AE4�clvh3�2ȡȝ/A'*ĒǚŏȝHý®/ŋŝ�$�Ēǚ
ŏȝ/A'*ħBE$,ĮGE* D¡ĭ3ȝȐƴ.ƾÿįHŅ$. ��B/�ļ�3
|ƾÿ.ȟ¡ĭ/( *��E�E29��ACƾ�B� , �Ǽƚƴ·ŞH{�$=
2Ƥįƴ.Ÿń��:'$�Ņ$. �
� ����clvhDzȯ�ĒǚŏȝHƩ $àüōNJHǽ'* D�,/ư 2�ì3.
�"�+�2ȡȝH¸2�Š+ȉɅ�8� �(�2Őź�.�E*�$�$,�4�
`suPkp\_(Garrett, 1997, pp. 94-5; cf. �Ǘũ, 2005, Ǐ 3Ǎ)/AE4��2ȡȝ3ȕ
Ƞȝ/��DƃĠÄ2śDZ+3.��clvhƒ2ȕƼĪƤü/��DǘǂiNaXh2
ōNJ, �śDZ+Ƥȉ�ED8�.2%, ��ÿɔ�clvh2ȝȳHƃƾ/Ș=4�
ļ�2æŵŏȝ2Éæ�ƷŎ2ãɞ,�E* $�,�µ�D�
Èȣ�BȈĭ72ǘǂ2LJǽɧɦæŵŏȝɨ��ȽÊ2Ǣɡ��.G&"EB2ąȣ
2İēƴɓ�2ȌĹ/ï) * D�,�ţB�+�D�B�Ɓ2ãɞ3�Ǣɡ��
2ɧąȣ2ɨȈĭHɧǘǂ2�&/ɨƧ;´�23�Ƽį/AD2��"E,>ı©
½/AD2�, ��,��.G&�ļ�H�*"2LJǽHǽ�A�/Ɗþ�D23�
Ƥį+�D2��"E,>Ƽȇ2�B�2ȸÖ,ɍ�+�D2�, ��,+�D�
(T 1.3.6.4)
clvh2ƺIJ3æŵŏȝ/ɍGDǘǂiNaXhHţB�/�D�,+�D�"�%,
clvh2Dzƚ�Ǫ,æŵŏȝ2ƃĠÄãɞ
- 37 -
�E4��æŵŏȝ3Ƥį/A'*ƃĠÄ�E. �, �ȡȝ3�ǣĊ2,�F�æŵŏ
ȝ2Éæ�Ƥį+3.�ı©½�(:C�ǫĵ��.G&ȸÖ2ÉƤ�(T 1.3.7.7)+�D,
�ĪƤüƴ.�ÿHǀ�$=2>2+�D��2ȉɅ3�.!clvhDzȯ�ãɞ2ȡ
ȝ2�»>�ĥ>ĒǚH� Ǧ�.�B�"2�,HŕȢ�Dţǀƴ.ȡȝHŐǀ�.
2�Hȗţ�*�ED�Pkp\_2A�/clvhæŵȝHwlj2ȌȳĪƤü,�*ȉ
Ʌ�D.B4�clvh2IJé3Ēǚ/ɍ�DĺưȝHŐ´�D�,+3.�'$,Ȋ�
�,3+�D�
� ���ŭȱ�qve(Loeb, 2008, pp. 112-4)�Pkp\_2ȉɅHŀ·�*�ACɇĪƴ.
ȉɅHČɋ�* D�ģ3clvhæŵȝHȌȳĪƤü,�*ȉɅ�D�,/ƦI�. �
"E-�F��ģ�xlj2]OW_ƴȐńHň�*ȝ�D,�F/AE4�clvhæŵ
ȝ3ȕȠȝƴōNJ+�C���>�clvh3Ēǚŏȝ�ƃĠÄ�E* D,Ǭ�* D�
2+�D�qve2ň�D]OW_ƴȐń3�clvh�wɃ2Ēǚŏȝ/Ǯþƴ.ȕȠ
ƴȑ�H}�* D, ��,HţB�/�* D�,�/ɆȂ.>2HÏC´ 4�:
�clvh3���2ɧÉæ,ǣŵ2ɨɍ�3�ļ���Dąȣ�B¸2ąȣ72ƃ� ŏ
ȝɣjust inferenceɤH"E/ï)�D�,�+�Dâw2ɍ�+�D�(T 1.3.6.7),ȳ8*
D�:$��ɚàüƴǼƚį�H�àüƴǼƚį�,ąƇƴ/ȝ��»ǭH�¤Ȅ�2ƕ
,�DwŠ�ĥǭ/( *3��¡ĭ,IJȄ2ÖƤƴ.ïƿɣreasonable foundationsɤ+�
D,ȕ=BE* D�(T 1.3.13.1),Ȋ���B/��Éæ,ǣŵH"E/A'*·þ�D$
=2ȅº�(T 1.3.15)Hþ=* D��$�'*�clvh3ļ�2Ēǚŏȝ72wƁ2S
g\_is_2ÉæHĪƤüƴ/ōƉ�* D%�%�, �Pkp\_2ȉɅ3ƾ�/
ƙƤ��D(Cf. Loeb, 2006, p. 326)�
� ����>&FIqve2A�/�clvh3Ēǚŏȝ�ƃĠÄ�E* D,Ǭ�*
D�,�Ğ�D23"�ǖÆ+3. �æŵŏȝ2ïƿHƤį+3.�ȈĭȸÖ2ÉƤ/
��clvh2æŵȝ3�ǣĊ2,�F�Ēǚŏȝ2ɚÖƤ�ǪHć * DA�/ĮG
ED�B+�D�ãɞ,.D23�ĒǚŏƤ/( *2ɚÖƤ�Ǫƴ/;�Dȡȝ,��
Dlj2ĒǚŏƤH�ƃ� �,Ȅ.��Ğ,�� �/�*ŚÖ�* D2�, ��,
+�D�
� qve2ȉɅ2ȂȞ,.'* D23�ȡȝ2ǯĥ/ɕE* DƼȠȈ?ȕȠƴƃĠÄ
/ɍ�Dclvh2Ǭ�/( *2�ģ2ŇĽƴ.Ƥȉ+�D(Loeb , 2006, p. 333ff.; 2008, p.
115ff.)�qve/AE4�clvh2æŵȝ�ĺưȝ/Į�D23�ļ��clvh2ȡ
ȝH±ë�Ǫƴ.»Ő2>,+Ƥȉ�*�:��B+�D�Dzƚ2ŜwįHŖŅ�DƤį
ƴ.ȡȝ�. , ��,�B�Ēǚƴ.¡ĭ3ƃĠÄ�E. , �ǣȝHć�/3�
- 38 -
±ë�Ǫƴ.»ŐHclvh�ȕ=* .�E4.B. �(:C�ȕȠƴƃĠÄ/3�
¡ĭ�ƺ+�D,Ǭ�D$=2ƤƫH�¡ĭHŅ(���Dzȇ�* DīȂ��D, �
»Ő+�D�����clvh�±ë�Ǫ+3.��¡ɝį�Ǫ��D 3"E/ɟ�$
óë�Ǫƴ.ƼȠȈHŅ'* $,�E4-�+�F���¡ɝį�Ǫ�ƃĠÄ/ą�*
ȂƉ�D23�ǖÆ/Ȋ'*�¡ĭHƧ;´�$fqYW��"2¡ĭ�ƺ+�DĀȈƴ
.ȄȰ;Hŵ/Ņ$ DA�.¡ɝ+�DfqYW+�D�,+�D�"�*��2nj
ð�óë�Ǫ+�D23�¡ĭ�ƃĠÄ�ED$=/�"2¡ĭ2��Dzȯ�ãɞ,.'
* D¡ɝÓǰį/( *2ȕƼƴ.JQYWHŅ'* DīȂ�. �B+�D�őȊ
�E4����Dzµ2¡ĭ3ƺ+�D,Ǭ�D$=2ƤƫH:'$�Ņ'* .�*>�
"2¡ĭ3ȕȠƴ/ƃĠÄ�EħD�qve/AE4�ĒǚŏƤ3"E�ǫĵ, �¡ɝ
+�DfqYW/A'*ƨ;´�ED�@�/ƃĠÄ�ED,clvh3Ǭ�$2+�D�
���!.����0.�
� Ųȝ3qve2ȉɅ/Ł�*�clvhHóë�Ǫǭ,ȉɅ�DīȂ3. ,ȝ�D�
ȂƘH«/ȳ8*����qve3�clvh�ÿɡƴŏƤƌHŌƩ�* D�,�B�
��/ÿɡƴŏƤƌ�ƃĠÄ�E* D,Ɗ=*��'* D�ģ/AE4���ɌŲį2
ü3Ēǚŏȝ�ƃĠÄ�E* D,»Ő�*�C��-2A�/ƃĠÄ�E* D�Hȗţ
�D�,�"�clvhæŵȝ2Țɞ.2+�D(Loeb, 2006, p. 321)�>�ƃĠÄ�E*
D>2/A'*àüōNJHù=.�*3.B. 2+�E4��2ȉɅ3clvhHwlj
2ïƿ���Ǫǭ/�*�:�%F��"E/ą�*�Ųȝ3clvh2àüōNJHɚï
ƿ���Ǫƴ.Dzƚ�ǪƴōNJ%,Ƥȉ�D8�%,ȝ�D��ɌŲį2ü3�ļ��ƣ
/Ēǚŏȝ/A'*¡ĭHġĻ�* D, ���ÿ��B´Ʊ�D2+�C�"E@��
ļ�2ĒǚŏȝHƩ D�ɌŲį2ü/A'*�ļ�2Ēǚŏȝ�ÿɔ/ƃĠÄ�ED�
-�����$�'*�ɌŲį2ü�ƃĠÄ�ED�-����3űƊãɞ.2+�D�
� ȓ��3ĥȳ�DA�/�ǃ3qve2ȉɅ/3ƙƤHij��DHħ. �,3 ��
�2ȉɅ��HȉƊ�A�,�*Őź�E$2�HƤȉ�D�,3ɆȂ+�D�qve�
ȉƊ�A�,�$ȉɅz2çəHȉƊ�D 3ȉƓ+�. ȉɅ3�">">÷Ź%�B
+�D�"2çə,3Ɓ2A�.>2+�'$�clvh3�Dzƚ2Ŝwį2ÉƤ��Ƥ
įƴ/ƃĠÄ+�. ,ȝ�D,×Ŧ/ĒǚŏȝHƩ * D���>ļ��æŵŏȝH
�G�DHħ. , ��ÿH�Ğ�* D%�+3.���Dlj2Ēǚŏȝ/ȕȠƴȅ
ǕįHȕ=*DzB2ōNJŠƌ,�*ŌƩ�* D��2|Óȉ�HȉƊ�D$=/�qv
e3Ēǚŏȝ2óë�ǪƴƃĠÄ, �ȉɅHŐ´�D�,/.'$2+�D�
clvh2Dzƚ�Ǫ,æŵŏȝ2ƃĠÄãɞ
- 39 -
� �$�'*��E�BŲȝ3�{2A�/ȹ<�:�clvhHDzƚ�Ǫǭ,�*Ƥȉ
�D�,/A'*zȳ�$ȉɅz2çəHåɁ+�D�,Hǀ�ɣ4ǔɤ��B/qve�
Ǝƶ�D�ƃ� ŏȝ�, �clvh2Ȁƣ3�ī��>�ƃĠÄ�E$ŏȝ�2�,
%,ȉɅ�DīȂ3.��¸2�Š+ƤȉÓǰ+�D�,Hȝ�Dɣ5ǔɤ�ŭĥ/clv
h�óë�Ǫǭ+�'$, �ȉɅ�-E9-2¡ĸįHŅ(2�HŻȋ�Dɣ6ǔɤ�
����2'�&#�������*$�)�
� :�ƾȕ�$ 23�æŵŏȝ2ïƿ�Ƥį+3.�ǫĵ/�D�,Hǀ�$clvh
2ȡȝ2IJǪ+�D�clvh�ȗţ�$æŵŏȝiNaXh���2Îƹǰ½,ƙɍ�
+�D�,3>&FIƙȆ+�. �
Éæ,ǣŵ/ɍ�Dļ�2·Ş3�ǫĵ,Ǣɡ,�BƧ�D2+�C�ļ��w(2
ąȣ�¸2ąȣ/ǣ5( * D2HȄD�,/ĵED,�ļ�2ı©½3�Ǐw2
ąȣ�BǏ�2ąȣ7,�Dzƚ.LJǽ/A'*LJD2+�D��2LJǽ3�Îƹ/«����
nj'*�C�����
�Îƹ/A'*ɎƂ+�. �(T 1.3.13.8ɧ¦ƘěƩǭɨ)
clvh/AE4��2æŵŏȝiNaXhHŅ'* D�,�"��ļ��Dzƚ2Ŝw
į2ÉƤH�»Ő��* D, ��,2IJÜ.2+�D�
�űŴ�ȽÊ/ɟ��D�, �ıþ3� �.Dljɟ2ȡȝ/ï) * D2+>
.��:'$�ǫĵ�BƧ�D2+�D,Ȋ'*A �ǫĵ/A'*�ļ�3�Ȅĵ
E* D2,×�ąȣ2ȸɊHűŴ/>ůĤ�DA�/Ɗþ�ED2+�D�(T
1.3.12.9)
"E@���2ÉƤ3� �.DȐţ>:'$�ȍ���:$�ļ�� �.DȐţ>.
�/�Ġƚ2�,,Ȅ.�*�:'* DƘ�(A 14)+�D�
� ǨCȲ���clvh3æŵŏȝ2ïƿ�ǫĵ/Ƚ�. , ��,�B���/Ēǚ
ŏȝ/ȕȠƴ�£�. ,3ȊG.�'$�clvhDzȯ3�ãɞ2ȡȝ�Ʋð�D�»
/>Ʋð�$ĥ/>�ĒǚŏȝHƸòGB�� Ǧ�* D�clvh3�2Ƙ/ɍ�*
�Ǫƴ.ĴĚHŌ'* DA�/Ȅ�D�-�Ǭ�D8�%F���
� ÿ3Pkp\_2Ȍȳ�ɆȂ.ǀáH}�*�ED�
- 40 -
ɧclvhɨ3�ļ���+/Ēǚƴ.ĮǬH�Dǭ+. ɐC�ļ�HÂ���,
2+�D"� '$ȡȝ3ûë�. , �:'$�ŵ.Ÿń/ï) *�$%
ļ�3ĒǚHŖŅ�DȡȝHƤȉ�D�,/A'*ĒǚŏȝH.�2+3. ,
��,%�Hǣȝ�$2+�D�(Garrett, 1997, p. 92)
Ēǚŏȝ2ÖƤįHļ��NJżƴ/ǚħ+�. 23��Dzƚ2Ŝwį2ÉƤ�HȐţ�D
Ƥįƴȡȝ�. �z�Ēǚŏȝ��:�ǽ�,¡�DƤƫ�.���$�'*"2ÿȭ
3Ƥįƴ/ƃĠÄ�E. �B+�D�"�+clvh3�Dzƚ.æŵŏȝ�ƃĠÄ,3
ɍ�.��Â�Dļ�2ÂƝƴŲǰ2wlj+�C�"2�,Dz���Dzƚ2Ŝwį2ÉƤ�
Hıþ�D�,/9�.B. ,�Ğ�D�ɆȂ.23��Dzƚ2Ŝwį2ÉƤ�H"2A
�/»Ő�$z+�E4��$,�"2»ŐDz�3ƃĠÄ�E.�,>(2) �� G4"
2±¥�B�-2A�.Ēǚŏȝ�ACÖƤƴ+�D�Hȝ�D�,3+�D, ��,
+�D(Cf. T 1.3.13.7)�
� (:C��+/���
ĒǚŏȝHǽ�ǭ+�Dclvh3�zȌ2IJÜ+�Dzƚ2Ŝwį2É
Ƥ�H»Ő�*�C����$CĒǚ/A'*ħBE$¡ĭH¡ɝ�D,�F�B�ģ2
ōNJHù=* D2+�D�ÿɔ�Dzƚƴ.Ųǰ�ó/Ēǚŏȝ2ïƿ�Ȅ % . ,
�ƱȄDz�/>�Ēǚ/A'*ħBE$¡ĭ�wĢȥ'* D�,3Ǝƶ/£�D�$
,�4�clvh3��DȽÊ2Èȣ2Æ.DÎĨ�B3�"E�ƙɐå2ÎĨ+�'*
>�īƚƴǣÖ2Ȉĭ2A�.ş� Ÿƕƴ.Ȉĭ3�'�*Ƨ�. +�F��(T
1.3.6.3),ȝ�* D���2�ĞDz�3�+/ĒǚH»Ő,�*ħBE$clvh2Ǣɡ
ƴ�ȗ�� G@DSdvÉƤ(T 1.1.1.7)��/�ń�* D�Ȃ�D/�clvh3^N
o_ƴ.ïƿ���Ǫǭ+3.���Dlj2ĩƥH">">2ù=�Bȕ=$z+àüō
NJHȹ=A�,�DDzƚ�Ǫǭ.2+�D(3) (4)�
� clvh2æŵȝ3�Ēǚŏȝ/ï) *�Ɍ2ǘǂƀŽ/ɍ�DǢɡƴ�ȗH�C�
"2�ȗ/ï) *Ēǚŏȝ/ɍGD�Ɍ2ǘǂƀŽHȉţ�D, �>2+�D�(:
C��Ɍ/Dzƚƴ/ǡ;Ȱ:E* Dæŵŏȝ2iNaXhHæŵŏȝ/A'*Îƹ��
æŵŏȝHě�Ȩ��ǘǂƀŽ��Â�D$=2ȟų�HƏ ´"�, �Ȓ;+�D�
clvh3�"��*�Ɍ/6�G� ŏȝŠƌ��Éæ,ǣŵH·þ�D$=2ȅº�H
ţB�/��"EH�ÿɡƴŏƤƌ�,�*Œ�*��Ɍǘǂ2�B/ȓǞ.ȉţ7ȹI
+ǽ��,�D���/3ţB�/Dzƚ�Ǫƴ.ĩƥŽȷ��D�
clvh2Dzƚ�Ǫ,æŵŏȝ2ƃĠÄãɞ
- 41 -
���" ��.��*$�)'+1�
� qve3�clvhæŵȝ�Æ.DȌȳĪƤü+3.���Dlj2ȅǕƴ�ĞH��ȕ
Ƞȝ+�'$�,Hņœ�$Ƙ+ƃ��'$�����clvh2�ƃ� ŏȝ�, �
Ȁƣ3�ŲĠ/ƣ�2ȕȠȝ+ȊGED�ȕȠƴ/ƃĠÄ�E$�ŏȝ, �IJÜ+Ƥȉ
�8�%F��(5)�>�"�%,�E4�ƾ�/clvh�óë�ǪƴƃĠÄ/ȏ�$Ó
ǰįHƺ¼/Ǭķ�.�E4.B. %F��������+>¸2ȉɅ�Óǰ+�D�
� qve3�æŵŏȝ2ïƿ�Ƥį+3.�ǫĵ/�D�,Hǀ�ȡȝ�Ʋð�DśDZ/
9,I-ƎIJHĿ'* . ��"2$=/�DȝƘHȄȵ�* D�clvh3��ȳ
8* $����"B��ŭĥ/3�ŏƤ�īƚƴǣÖ/�û�D2+3.�*�īƚƴ
ǣÖ�ŏƤ/�û�D, ��,�ţB�/.D+�F��(T 1.3.6.3)�clvhæŵȝ2
öɃµ3īƚƴǣÖ2Ȉĭ2ōǝ/Ȧ?�E* D2+�D�ÿHȊ�4��2Ƙ�qv
e2ȉɅ/,'*ǴÝƴ+�D,ĮGED�clvh/AE4��ƃ��ŏȝ�D�,3�
ŏȝ�ɍGDȈĭHý®/Ƥȉ�D�,.�/3|Óǰ�(T 1.3.2.4).2+�D��>�c
lvh�óë�Ǫǭ+�D,�E4�"2ģ�-��*Ȉĭ2ÙÜ2īȂHȏ�* D2
�HƤȉ�D�,3çə/.D+�F�(6)�qveDzȯ3�clvh2]OW_�B2ö
Ɉ2ěƩ/A'*�ƃ� ŏȝ�.-2ȊǺ/ƎIJH �* DwŠ+�|Óȉ.�,/
Ȉĭ2ÙÜ/ɍ�*3ȊÌ���* . �
� ,>�E�Ųȝ2ȉɅ/,'*ɆȂ.23�īƚƴǣÖɣ2Ȉĭɤ��+. ��,�Ğ�
E* $�+�D(7)�ɆȂ.ɃµH]OW_�BěƩ�A��
�2A�/�*�ǣĊ2,�F�ļ���ACªE$Ųį2>2ɧǂɨ+�E�AC
¿'$Ųį2>2ɧȁȷƝɨ+�E��Dûëǭ/( *��B�2ǣŵ/Ƈ��$
½ǰ:$3½H�}�E* D>2,�*ȖD,��:$ļ��ąȣɌ2īƚƴǣÖ
/( *ȖC��2ǣÖ�"EB2ąȣ2-E�/�}�E* DÁ½:$3Ɛ½
/�ń�* D>2,�*ıþ�D,��"2A�/�Ʃ�E$�EB�8*2Ȁƣ
/� *�ļ�3�ÿɔ/3�B·ţ.IJÜHŅ'*�B��$%ŧȶ2ȖH�B2
ţŨ+ƾþ�$Ȉĭ>Ņ$�/�Ʃ�* D%�+�D�,ŏƤ�D�,�+�D�
>�E. ������EB2Ȁƣ3��B2IJÜ>Ņ'* . , �AC>�Ɍ
ȿ'*�Ʃ�E$�,/A'*���+"2ŲŴ2IJÜH÷'* D, ��,�A
C�C"�.�,+�Dɧɩɩɩɨ�(T 1.3.14.14)
��+clvh�ȳ8* D23�ąȣ�Ņ(,�ED½ǰ�"�*"E/�û�Dīƚ
- 42 -
ƴǣÖ/( *�ļ�3ƙƼ.2%, ��,+�D�clvh3�DǓľ+�efficacy,
agency, power, force, energy, necessity, connexion, productive quality�(T 1.3.14.4).-3�8*
×ǪȖ+�D,Ȗ'* D���EB2Ȗ+IJÜ�ED>23�8*�"2Ȉĭ�æŵŏ
ƤHƤįƴ/Ŗ�D>2,�*Ġ¶3ıþ�E* $�(:C�Ƥį/A'*>Ǣɡ/A
'*>ƱȄ�E. īƚƴǣÖ2Ȉĭ3���Dąȣ a �B b 7,ŏȝ�Dɔ/�a 2û
ë� b 2ûëHÛIJ�D�,Hļ�/ř�*�EDA�.Ȉĭ�,�*Ɍȿ'*ıþ�E
* $>2.2+�D��E3ÖƤ�Ǫƴ.ıþ,Ȋ�D�ÖƤ�Ǫƴ.æŵŏȝ2Ƥȝ
3Ɓ2A�/�Ğ�D%F���ļ�3īƚƴǣÖ2ȈĭHú�/�D�,/A'*�ą
ȣ a 2Èȣ�Bąȣ b 2ȈĭHƤįƴ/ŏȝ�* D,�
� clvhæŵȝ2ſƴ3�2A�.ıþ+�D�
ļ�3�DÉæH"E2ǣŵ�BƷŎ/ŏȝ�D2+�C��2ŏȝ3ɧɩɩɩɨ�ǎ
2ȈĭHǣ5(�D$=/�2ȈĭH�ë� D,�AC>�ACȗħƴ.2+�D�
(T 1.3.7.5. n. 20)
clvhæŵȝ�ÿɡƴŏƤƌ2ƾnj2$=2ȡȝ+�D�,3�+/ƾȕ�$��"2
>',>ɆȂ.ȝƘ3�ļ�3īƚƴǣÖ2ȈĭHŅ(�,.�/æŵŏȝ�Óǰ+�D
, ��Ğ/�D�ÿɡƴŏƤƌ2ïƿ3�ļ��Éæ,ǣŵ2Ɍ/�DǣÖÉƤHƼD
�,/�D2+3. �Ţ�>��ɌŲįȝ2�Ęȝ�/3Ɓ2A�.āȊ��D�
ǘǂ2Ųȧ3�óƴƝ�2Ųȧ,×���ļ�/3ƼBE. 2+�ǘǂ� �.D
ǰ½,įȧHŮ�D�HƼD�,3�óƴƝ�/( *,מ/�ƎIJƔ ƃƾ.ÿ
ɡ,�Ư.Dų�?ƟƋ�BƧ�D¢�2ǣŵ2ȈĄ,/AD2+.�E4�|Óǰ
+�D�,3ţB�+�D�,ǃɧclvhɨ/3ĮGED�:$�Óǰ.ɐĚ:+
ÿɡ/A'*ȴƉ���8*2ǣŵHŭ>ÆǛ+ŭ>ŧȼƴ.>2/�DA�À½�
.�E4.B. ��"E+>�ļ��ǢɡHȩ�*3ȹ;ħ. �,3��ƚ,�
*ƾÿ.2+�D�"E@���ɌŲį2NJżƴÉƤHţB�/�D,dž�Dȗ3
�E>�Į z�'$Njı,�*�ŭ¶�Bŝ�BE14.B. �(T intro. 8)
clvh3�ļ��æŵɍ�HĻCnj$ * DÉƤHƤȉ�* .�*>�Ǣɡ,ȈĄ
/A'*ƣȣȝƴ.àüōNJHȺǽ+�D� ?<�F�ļ�3æŵɍ�2ÉƤHƤȉ+
�. �@�/"2A�.�Š+àüōNJHȺǽ�D9�. �,�Ğ�$2+�D�
clvh2Dzƚ�Ǫ,æŵŏȝ2ƃĠÄãɞ
- 43 -
� ��+�Dzƚ�ǪƴȕȠȝ/( *2cmnvuSvsenW(Kornblith, 1994, pp. 1-3)
/ADȗţHě�Ö /´�*����ãɞ3Ɓ2yljɟ2ã 2ɍ�+�D�
A) ļ�3-2A�/�*¡ĭ/¹Ⱦ�8���
B) ļ�3-2A�/�*¡ĭ/¹Ⱦ�* D��
C) ļ��"E/A'*¡ĭ/¹Ⱦ�* DfqYW3�ļ��"E/A'*¡ĭ/¹Ⱦ
�8�fqYW,wǴ�* D��
��Ǥƴ.Ȅȉ�/AE4�àüǭ3ɣAɤ2ã /ĆĪ�E4A��ɣBɤ2ã /ǒ�
D23ĪƤüǭ2��+�D�àüǭ,ĪƤüǭ3Ơnj/��HǠ�*�B�ÍŠ2ǣŵ
HŅ&ă'*ɣCɤ2ã /ÏCǡ=4A , �G�+�D�"2Ȅȉ/ą�*A�Ƽ
BE* D23�ȝś�DzƚÄ�E$ȕȠȝ�+QrLs�ɣAɤ2ȕȠȝƴã HɣBɤ
2ĪƤüƴã /ǩ�ő�D8�%,�Ğ�$�,%F�����SvsenW/AE4�
Dzƚ�ǪƴȕȠȝ3>',ė�Ŋ�BE*Ƿ ���ɣAɤ2ã /ą�*ɣBɤ2ã ,
3Ơnj/ǒ�D�,3+�. �, �2�Dzƚ�ǪƴȕȠȝ2ŭĈɐ2þǪ+�D��
2IJÜ+>�clvh2æŵȝ3Dzƚ�ǪƴȕȠȝ2w��%,ȄD�,�+�D�
� clvh�ģ2æŵȝ+ƶņ�$23��2A�.�Š+ÿɡƴŏƤƌ2ÿȧHţB�
/�D�,+�'$�ļ��Ɍ2ȕƼǰ½/3ɐƬ��D�z�ɚ�Ɍƴ.æŵŏȝ�+
�D,Į ȰI+ōNJHǽ��,�D23Ǒȿ +�F��"E,ąƇƴ/��ƎIJƔ ƃ
ƾ.ÿɡ,�Ư.Dų�?ƟƋ�BƧ�D¢�2ǣŵ2ȈĄ,/AD�æŵŏȝ��ļ�
�Ɍ�ŌƩ�8��ƃ� ŏȝ�%,ȊGE* D2+�D�
�
���" ��.��-/'"��354�
� clvh2Ȋ��ƃ� ŏȝ�Hzȳ2A�/Ƥȉ+�D,�D,�ɆȂ.�,3��
Ɍƴ.�ƃ� ŏȝ��ȕȠƴ/ƃĠÄ�ED�-���(:C�2�ƃ� ŏȝ��ļ�
H9I,�/ƺƤ7,ć *�ED,Ǭ�DƤƫ��D�-��3�ŻȋHȂ�Dãɞ�
�D 3�ĉ.�,>Żȋ�EDÓǰį2�Dãɞ%, ��,+�D�clvh�ÿɔ
/�2ãɞ/Ʒɛ�DǓľ2w(��Ƥį/ɍ�Dĺưȝ�(T 1.4.1)2ȡȝ3�Ɓ2A�.
>2+�D�
� �+/ȝ�$A�/�Dzƚ�Ǫǭclvh3���$C�����
Ēǚ/A'*ħBE$¡ĭH¡
ɝ�D,�F�Bģ2ōNJHȹ=D�����%�B,Ȋ'*�ļ�3Dzµ� :¡�*
D�,HŲĠ/¡�D8��-��ư Hł��,3. �, ��,/3.B. +
- 44 -
�F��ļ�2Ēǚŏȝ�|ƾÿ+�D�,H�ļ�3Ǣɡ�B����
ƼD�B+�D��2ư
/ą³�D2/�ļ�3-��ȩȪȝƴ.ȆƘ�B�ļ�2Ēǚŏȝ�~Ƭ2�CŠ,
ąĬ�$ƺ.D¡ĭHƃ��Ƨ;´�$�-��Hƾȕ�*;D�,3+�. �"E@
�� :2¡ĭ�ƺ+�D�-��3�ļ�2Ēǚŏȝ2ǰ½2ƃ��/( *��E:
$ļ�2Ǣɡ/ï) $Ēǚŏȝ+·Ş�D9�. ����*�ļ�2Ēǚŏȝ2ǰ½
�DzĐÙÜHɆ1�"2ƃ��/( *ƺ¼/Żȋ�E4�ļ�2ŏȝ3�DzBHý®/
ȃ��àü/��D>2+�E�šēƧƐ/��D>2+�E� �.DÝɞ/>�>'
,>� LjĚ2ţȐį��Ƅ�. �(T 1.4.7.7; cf. T 1.4.1.6)�clvh3"��Ğ�D�
� ��+ȝ�BE* D23�>�ļ�2ŏȝH¡ɝ�D.B4���������������
�"2ŏȝ3DzB�:'
$�¡ɝ/£�. ,ȐȊ�D, �bm`OUNo.�Ĵ+�D(8)��G=*ǖƖ/Ȋ
�4���ɌŲįȝǏwđ3�ļ�3ļ��¡�* D�,H-2A�/¡�* D2�
HōNJ�D�,�Bù=�"2ǣŵ,�*�ļ���2A�.�Š+¡ĭHŅ(2%,�
E4�ļ��¡ĭHŅ(8�Ƥįƴ.Ÿń3. , �ĺưȝ7,dzD>2+�D�ǣĊ
2,�F�clvh3��Ɍƴ.�ƃ� ŏȝ��ļ�H9I,�/ƺƤ7,ć *�E
D>2+�D�-��, �ã /ą�*�Ǯþƴ/3ǒ�. 2+�D�
�z/ȳ8*�$�,�BȘǭ3ĂŤ/Ȅ*ÏEDA�/�Ųūɧ��ɌŲįȝɨ/
Û:E* Dàü3�G=*ĺưƴ+�C��ɌƼį�|ý®+�ơ Ǖè/��Ì
4. >2%, �Ǭ�H�ļ�/}�A�,�$>2+�D�ɧɩɩɩɨļ�2ǻǭɧc
lvhɨ3�2 �(�2ĺưƴ�ɞH�Ğ�*�C�®�,�*�ļ��Dzµ$&
2ǰ½/×IJ��Dzµ$&2ƤįH�Ʃ�D23�Æ/"� �DHħ. �B/Ƚ
�. ,ǣȝ�* D�Dzƚ��2àü/ąŁ�D%�2½HŅ$.�'$,�E4�
àü/A'*�ļ�3ý®.dlqs�Ǫǭ/�E*�:'* $+�F��(A 27)
�E���ɌŲįȝ2ǣȝ+�D��ļ�3¡��DHħ. �B¡�* D/Ƚ�.
, �2+�D(9)�
� qve3�æŵŏȝ2óë�ǪƴƃĠÄH�Ğ�$,�EDclvh��-��*�2
A�.żǎ.ĺưȝ7,ɒD�,/.D,Ǭ�$2�Hȗţ�D�,�+�D%F���
¡ɝį�Ǫ/�Ȁ�EDóë�Ǫƴ.ȉɅ/,'*ãɞ.23�Ƥį2¡ɝį/( *2
Ƥį/ADDzĐÙÜ, ��2ȡȝ2±ë�Ǫƴ.įŹ+�D�"E3clvh, ��
Ɍ�ǽ�ȕȠfqYWHóƴȆƘ�B�ș�¸��ŷþ�A�,�D>2+3. ��2
ȡȝ3��Ɍ2ǘǂƀŽ2ȉţ, �àüƴōNJHǽ'*�$�ǃɧclvhɨ�(T 1.4.1.6;
clvh2Dzƚ�Ǫ,æŵŏȝ2ƃĠÄãɞ
- 45 -
T 1.4.7 passim)��"2ĻŵHȮ:��ŗ=*ōNJ�D��+�D,�F2DzB2ȕȠǰ½
/( *DzĐÎƹH�*A�,�$>2+�D���/3�ōNJHȒ;D��3DzB2ȕ
Ƞ2ǰ½/( *DzB�ƼB.�E4.B. , �ȂȜ�¨ * D2+�D�
� ,�F+�qve3��ŭȱ2óë�Ǫ2ŖŅǭ$&2Âƀ2w(��Ė¬?��Ɍ+3
. ÂƝ2ƼȠHȗţ�D�,��Hĉ.�,>¯Ů�* DƘ+�clvh3óë�Ǫ
2«ɠǭ%'$�(Loeb, 2008, p.116),ǀá�* D�ŭĥ/��2Ƥȉ>ưG� �,H
ņœ�*��$ �Ǐw/�ģ�ň�D]OW_�T 1.3.1.62[L_o��ÂƝ2Ƥį/
( *�+�D�,�B>µ�DA�/�clvh�ȝ�* D23ÂƝ2�ƼȠ�+3
.��Ƥį�+�D�>&FIclvh�^No_�Ǫǭ/Ł�*�Ɍ2Ƽį,ÂƝ2"
E,2ȸǦįHğț�$�,3Ɍȿ . ������Ɍ2ĒǚŏȝiNaXhHȗţ�
DDzµ2�ȗ�ÂƝ2Ƥį/( *>ɀƩ+�D,clvh�"�+�Ğ�* D,��
ƼȠ?"2ƃĠÄ�ȡȝ2�ɞ/.'* D,ȉɅ�D23ǜƷ.Ș;Š,3Ȋ�: �
Ǐ�/��2ǓľHƣ�2óë�Ǫ2«ɠƴ�Ğ,�*ȉɅ�D23�àüÔƴ/Ȅ*>
ȗħ½�. A�/ĮGED�clvh�ƠDz2JpsVH¾�* D,3 ��Ƣɟ�
�Ɍ,×�A�.ŏȝǰ½H§�* D, ��ɞ3�<�FYQW_W?js]val
/>ȄBEDĺưƑ2�Ǥ/č�D>2+�D(10)�
��(.�
� Ųȝ3�clvh2æŵȝ�æŵŏȝ2óë�ǪƴƃĠÄ2«ɠƴȒ;+�D,�Dŭ
ȱ2ȉɅHſƴ/�$�Ųȝ3�ĦŴ2ȉɅ+3ȗţ+�. ,�E$ȉɅz2çə�ó
ë�Ǫ/ADȉɅ+.�,>ŵ/ȗţ�ED,ȝ��clvhHɚïƿ���ǪƴDzƚ
�Ǫǭ,�*ȉɅ�ħD�,Hǀ�$��Š�óë�Ǫ+3ȗţ�ə Ƙ��D,ņœ�
D�,/A'*�clvh2àüōNJ�B��"B�^No_ƴ.ãɞIJȠHÐ�ǥ %
±ë�Ǫƴ.ȈƘHƓ�ÊD�,3+�. �,>ţB�/�$�ȱĕ2Dzƚ�ǪƴȕȠ
ȝ3�¡ɝį�Ǫ�"2°î+�DA�/�y�dž2ȆƘ�BȕȠHã��,�ŧȶ+�
D�"E/ą�*�clvh/,'*ȕȠȝ2Ųȧ3��:+>��.B0DzµDzȯ�ȕ
Ƞ�Dǭ+�D, �Dzȇ2>,/�w�džƴ.ã /ǒ�D�,%'$2+�D� ,�
(1) ê±+3�ɢƆĶ(2013)?ǸċÇä(2013)��qve2Ȅȉ/ƻƶ�$z+�ɣ"E#E2�Š+qve,2ȬɘHÏC.�Bɤclvh3æŵŏȝHóë�Ǫƴ/ƃĠÄ�$,ȉɅ�* D� (2) Ƥįƴ.ïƿ�. %�+"EHư�8�%,�E4�"EDz��ïƿ)��Ǫƴ.Ʊı+�F�� (3) ,�/clvh/ɍ�*3���ɌŲį�/A'*ļ��ł��DH�. A�.¡ĭ� G@D�Dz
- 46 -
ƚƴ¡ĭ���D2%, �ģ2�ĞHŊ�*��clvh2Dzƚ�Ǫ�,ȊGED�,�ô �����
��+Ȋ�Dzƚ�Ǫ3"E,3Ư.D�,/ƎIJ�E$ � (4) �2Ƙ/( *��B/ȓǞ.ȡȝ3�Ǘ(2005, ǏyǍ)HËƛ2�,�$%���Ǘ3�Dzƚ2Ŝwį�óƬûë��D 3�Ź2×wįǐ2šēƴŶǡ;/º'*�šēƴ¡ĭ2ġĻiNaXhHȗţ�
D�,3ĩƥȝƌ+3. �(2005, 66ɜ),>ȳ8* D�ǃ3�2A�.ȗţ�.!ĩƥ+3. 2�µ�B. �<�Fclvh3ĩƥHě�Ð�* D,Ȋ�8�+3. %F��� (5) ɢƆ(2013, 75ɜ)3�2Óǰį/ȊÌ�* D��ÿȧƴ.Żȋ3ǽ'* . � (6) >&FI�wǶ/óë�Ǫǭ.BȈĭ2ÙÜHīȂ,�. 3�%,:+�Ğ�D(>C3. � (7) īƚƴǣÖ2Ȉĭ��+�D2�/( *3�Ńȝ(2011)HËƛ2�,� (8) �E3QrLs/ą�DW_mM`2ŇĽHĮ Ȩ�� D�ĺưȝǭ�Džü/ą�DDzB2ư HŐ
Ȩ�D2/DžüHƩ D23Dzƫ%,QrLs3ȕ=D�"�%,�D,QrLs3Ɓ2A�.ĺưȝ2
ÓǰįHě�Ð�.�E4.B. ,W_mM`3ȝ�$���Džü3ƺ+�C�ļ�/ƼȠH}�*�
ED>2+�D���D 3"�+3. �2-&B�+�D�>�Džü�ƺ+. ,�E4�ƝƤƴ~
Ƭ/( *ļ��¡�* D�,3-E>ƼȠ/3ƸĠ�. +�F������>�Džü�ƣ/ļ�/
ƼȠH>$B�*�ED,�*>�Ƽȇ�* Dŭ�/ļ�2ijȇɛ/Ȩ�* DȤĝ.ǿŔ/( *Dž
ü�ř�*�ED�,�B�E4�óƬ�ŲĠ/ļ�2Ƽȇ�* D,�C2>2+�D�-��3Ɗ�
*µ�B. , ��,H�ļ�3Ȅ*ÏD�,�+�D��(Stroud, 1984, p. 228ɧŃȎɨ) (9) �2®ɛƴĺưȝ2ȫÃ?Ǐ�đuǏyđ,2ɍ�3>&FIãɞ/.D�"2�,Hȝ�DƩIJ3�D��"E/( *3¸2ƀ�HĤ$.�E4.B. � (10) �2Ƙ3�ɉĎĜĔ(2003, 81-2ɜ)>ņœ�* D�clvh�wȄ�G=*ƣ�ƴ/Ȅ�D,��ģ�<�F^No_�»2�ǤHě * D�,�"2Ƥƫ+�D�,>�4�4�DA�/ĮGED� %�
Hume, D. (2000). A Treatise of Human Nature, David Fate Norton & Mary J. Norton (Eds.), New York: Oxford University Press. (1995, ŰŬøǰȎ, ��ɌŲįȝ� Ǐwđ��Ƽį/( *, ƌŘöü´ƜĊ.)
��� (2000). An Abstract of a Book lately Published; Entitled A Treatise of Human Nature, & c., in Hume (2000). ɣěƩ/ɔ�*3�"E#E T�A,ƭȌ��T3đ.Ƀ.ǔ.ƅǹ�A3ƅǹ2ƮÕHǀ��Ȏ´3ɂȎHËǬ/�$��ȡȝ2ɄÖ/ÖG *ȎHòŪ�$Ǔľ>�D�ɤ Garrett, D. (1997). Cognition and Commitment in Hume’s Philosophy, New York: Oxford University Press. ɉĎĜĔ (2003).�ƼȠ,ĺư�Ò�,ȱƣ���ZQm]W,clvh�DzB2Ī2±/ȈĄ�$
>2�, �àü, Ǐ 54Õ, 71-91ɜ. Kornblith, H. (1994). ‘Introduction: What is Naturalized Epistemology?’ Naturalizing Epistemology, Second
Edition, Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press. �Ǘũ (2005). �clvh2ĺưȝ, ďƍūę. Loeb, L. E. (2006). ‘Psychology, Epistemology, and Skepticism in Hume’s Argument about
Induction’, Synthese, 152, 3, 321-338. ��� (2008). ‘Inductive Inference in Hume’s Philosophy’, in E. S. Radcliffe (Ed.), A Companion to Hume
(pp. 106-25), Oxford: Blackwell. ƗƪÞǕ (2011).�clvh2æŵȝ/��Dīƚį2Ȉĭ/( *�, �àüȝÑ, Ǐ 38Õ, 61-72
ɜ. Stroud, B. (1984). The Significance of Scepticism, New York: Oxford University Press. (2006, ƈ�íƵȎ,
�Ø3 :õHȄ* . ,-��*Ȋ�D2���àüƴĺưȝ2IJǪ, ťDŽǁ.) ɢƆĶ (2013).�clvh2¡ɝį�Ǫ�, �JoRv, Ǐ 21Õ, 73-85ɜ. ǸċÇä (2013).�clvh/��Dæŵŏȝ2ƃĠÄ�, �àüɗȔ, Ǐ 128đǏ 800Õ, 194-215
ɜ.
�ɄöüöüɑÇñȚLjuàüɥšŲüǾʼnǵ�ƞ¸ƽNJß�