Upload
others
View
1
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
THERE’S NO SUCH THING AS SUSTAINABILITY…AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT
ASU Lodestar Center2015 Annual Conference on Sustainability StrategiesOctober 15
Strategy + Action/Philanthropy www.strategyplusaction.com
There’s no such thing as sustainability?!?!
STRATEGY + ACTION/PHILANTHROPY 2
Tip of the hat
ASU Lodestar Center
Vu Le, Blogger, Nonprofit With Balls (and E.D. of Rainier Valley Corps, Seattle)
STRATEGY + ACTION/PHILANTHROPY 3
Caveats
“Leadership is the art of disappointing people at a rate they can stand.”*
*John Ortberg
STRATEGY + ACTION/PHILANTHROPY 4
Caveats
Nonprofits: You’ll be disappointed if you’re looking for the secret sauce
Funders: You’re not going to like what I’m going to say
STRATEGY + ACTION/PHILANTHROPY 5
Caveats
STRATEGY + ACTION/PHILANTHROPY 6
So why do I do care about this?Reviewed of hundreds of proposalsWorked with thousands of grantseekersRecommended 10s of millions of dollars in fundingDeveloped grant strategies and evaluationsPartnered with family foundations, community
foundations, corporate funders, public entities
And through it all….the illusion of sustainability persists!*
*And I’ve been guilty of this too!
STRATEGY + ACTION/PHILANTHROPY 7
Sustainability isn’t a natural state
STRATEGY + ACTION/PHILANTHROPY 8
Sustainability doesn’t exist
Average life span of Fortune 500 company is 40 years*
Only 44% of small businesses survive 4 years or more**
*Ron Mattocks, The Zone of Insolvency: How Nonprofits Avoid Hidden Liabilities and Build Financial Strength (Wiley, 2008)
**Maureen Farrell, “Risky business: 44% of small firms reach Year 4,” Forbes.com article for MSNBC, 2007, www.msnbc.msn.com/id/16872553/
STRATEGY + ACTION/PHILANTHROPY 9
Why is this conversation important?
Change – real change – takes time, a long time
STRATEGY + ACTION/PHILANTHROPY 10
Real change takes time
US Poverty Rate stuck at 12% for 40 years*
*Dan Pallotta, TEDX Talk, March 2013
STRATEGY + ACTION/PHILANTHROPY 11
Real change takes timePrichard Committee for Academic Excellence:
Statewide effort began in 1980 to move Kentucky from bottom tier of states
By the 2000’s Kentucky in mid-tier on some measures
Now aiming for top-tier by 2020 on 20 education measures
STRATEGY + ACTION/PHILANTHROPY 12
Real change takes time
RAND Corporation study:
Making long-lasting, significant change in a single school building takes 3 to 5 years
STRATEGY + ACTION/PHILANTHROPY 13
So what’s the challenge?
We face long “arcs” of work to tackle problems
The illusion of the sustainability conversation hampers the work
And here’s how that happens…
STRATEGY + ACTION/PHILANTHROPY 14
So what’s the challenge?Philanthropic policy and practice
Unsolicited proposals not acceptedNo funding for start-upsNo multi-year grantsLengthy proposal review processConstrictive grant application rulesOnly one grant at any one timeGrantee must wait a year to re-apply after receiving a grantLimitations on types of support (ex: no gen op, no capital, no
advocacy, etc.)
STRATEGY + ACTION/PHILANTHROPY 15
So what’s the challenge?The “question” from funder to recipient:
How will you continue/sustain the project/program/organization after our funding?
The “answer” from recipient to funder:
We’ll do x, y and z!
Actual result: Funder A passes off recipient to Funder B
STRATEGY + ACTION/PHILANTHROPY 16
So what’s the challenge?Change in interest and direction
Intel began sponsorship of Science Talent Search in 1998; will end sponsorship in 2017 (NY Times, 9-9-15)
Bonfils-Stanton Foundation (Denver) shifts all funding from science, health, human services, arts to focus just on arts (Chronicle of Philanthropy, 8-12-15)
STRATEGY + ACTION/PHILANTHROPY 17
So what’s the challenge?Change in interest and direction
For every 100 new donors gained in 2014, nonprofits lost 103. (Chronicle of Philanthropy, 10-2-15)
Public funding: See Planned Parenthood and First Things First
STRATEGY + ACTION/PHILANTHROPY 18
So what’s the challenge?Change in leadership
Ford Foundation (Darren Walker): Focus on 6 “thematic areas” to address global inequality. “…will result in fewer grants, and, most likely, fewer grant recipients.” (7-23-15 post)
MacArthur Foundation (Julia Stasch): Focus on impact investing. Ending 20 years in juvenile justice and 15 years in affordable housing. (Chronicle of Philanthropy, 8-13-15)
STRATEGY + ACTION/PHILANTHROPY 19
So what’s the challenge?Change in leadership
Nathan Cummings Foundation (Simon Greer): Focus on reducing income inequality and fighting climate change; fired in 2014. New president, Sharon Albert, starts in November…stay tuned.
Raymond John Wean Foundation (Jeff Glebocki): Focus on larger grants, reframed approach to early childhood, sharpened attention on economic development and education
STRATEGY + ACTION/PHILANTHROPY 20
So what’s the challenge?Donor fatigue
Foundation’s ADD – provide support for 1 to 3 years, then…well….???
“We’ve been funding the same thing for awhile, they do good work, but…”*
“Are we making a difference?”
*Actual quote from funders
STRATEGY + ACTION/PHILANTHROPY 21
What to do about it?
How about a honest conversation between funders/donors/foundations and nonprofits?
STRATEGY + ACTION/PHILANTHROPY 22
What to do about it?Darren Walker, new president, Ford Foundation
“…our aim is to ask not, ‘How do we make this grant successful?’ but rather, ‘How do we make this organization successful?’”
7-23-15 post
STRATEGY + ACTION/PHILANTHROPY 23
What to do about it?
In ecology, sustainability is the capacity to endure
Wikipedia, “Sustainability,” 10-15
STRATEGY + ACTION/PHILANTHROPY 24
What to do about it?Funders:
Focus on the long-term context and arc of real problem-solving
Change the dialogue with grant recipients and partners
STRATEGY + ACTION/PHILANTHROPY 25
What to do about it?Funders:
Explore the many options of how to build the endurance of your grantees to really solve problems
Transcend the limitations of application guidelines and procedures
STRATEGY + ACTION/PHILANTHROPY 26
What to do about it?In the meantime….what can nonprofits do?
Be aware of The Golden Rule* but question it when possible!
Reframe your story - dream big, shoot for the stars, expand the possibilities
Organize, organize, organize
*the other Golden Rule
STRATEGY + ACTION/PHILANTHROPY 27
What to do about it?In the meantime….what can nonprofits do?
Diversify your funding streams
Don’t chase the money, but do analyze and prioritize new funding opportunities and techniques that work for you
Envision, plan and work in the long-range – and bring your supporters along (manage up!)
STRATEGY + ACTION/PHILANTHROPY 28
Jeff GlebockiStrategy + Action/[email protected]
480.794.0871
www.strategyplusaction.com
STRATEGY + ACTION/PHILANTHROPY 29