The Years Since 9/11: What Hath Our Rulers Wrought?

7/30/2019 The Years Since 9/11: What Hath Our Rulers Wrought?

1/21

12

Te Journal Of

Peace, Prosperity & Freedom

Cris Leitner

T Y S Sb , :

Wh Hh O R Wgh?

L J Ch, T P P, wh h w, whh hw bh h hg whh T h gv j, gv w ghg g h h h bg h.

O T wh k w h h h, bg

h g . R h h h w v g k T hj.

- C Pbg H1

Introduction

A h I M b Nbg g 45-4, Ag-A bj h hh Ah H hg bg w . I h I v,M, Ah Eh (wh g h S W W managed themass deportation of Jews to extermination camps) Ag h I.H 5 hg, g g h w , h x I v b v .

Y M , h U.S. Gv v h g h w. I, x h O b L (wh, g h hg, h

P Dg W,My Prayer Book, C Pbhg H, 5.
http://www.wise-pdf-tools.com/?product-split-demo


2/21

126

Journal of Peace, Prosperity and Freedom Summer 2012

kg x , Sb , ). I b k h, wh h hv k? T wh g bw

j vg w g v h , whh NS I , v b h v j,

b b h h h v g h hg wh w . I w k h w h bv h w. B w h g h vb bv h w.2

O gh hv h P Bk Ob, g Hv Lw Sh,w b w h g b L wh . B h k h :

L Ag, kg wk b g , I wb b b L A , wk, I h w

h gh g k , hz g O bL bg h j..., , h U S h g g [] Abbb, Pk A gh,h k O b L k h b.

[A]-Q h gh M , g w. S h h b w b wh bv hg[O]n nights like this one, we can say to those families who have lost lovedones to al-Qaedas terror: Justice has been done.3

M A h h .4 Ag A P M JG, b L h v j h v h wh Sb.5 Mwh P K w Te Australian h

Sv Gh, B A IS P S, Rv ; G Gw, A P A h Gwg Sv S, Rv . Rk b h P O B L, Rv .4 I : R Jk hv h g vg. N

vg h h h O b L gg h b h b h , Sv, h v. I g. W h h , h h h h , M h S h. T h h Sb , , k Nw Yk. H w A h W C h . O h hg M wh kg Te Australian w h h h hjk wh k h h h h g. I h g wh w h , h h h w g hg g G.T w v , h . M w b L h b k hh b , b h hk w h I M vw b L -Q g h hg h I h. I hg b b h v h. U, v h h

b w hg wh M, h (L Shh Mh Ow,F V F Shk Owgh R, Te Australian, M ).5 P Ob, B L Dh I J V: PM, Te Sydney Morning Herald, M .


3/21

127

Cris Leitner e Years Since Septemer 11, 2001

T kg O b L v g h h US.6 A M 5 h w :

J h w w g h hz w h w -v k v [M]h h g b Lh k g []h g wh w b wh b L vvg g h w hv g v v b L w hv v gg g Agh h , b g h v. A whv b h w b h kg kghg A, A W, k h v. I hg w h w, h b -kg hgh w, g j hg h b L .7

I b L h j? O kh h gv g h h w gv h g ? Tkb h h h W w o wg v vh whh hv b vh b W g. Mv, h W A hv, , whh h U.S. Gv h w bj. I h , k h h wg h w h w b g:

Te events of 9/11 were a temporary deviation (outlier) rather than a permanent shi:h b v k; h hg k h h. I, h M E Sh A, h k h b g h . Ev g h /, x g k h A W ( I). I g k k h U.S., h h /, h k A w b h h k h b, h . h hg h h h h h h.8

It is very dicult for terrorists to obtain much less deploy chemical, biological or w, v h h g h w k b wh g. Ev h WMD k wh h w h /, h k w b v .

J D B F Dv, Te Australian, 4 M . D C O b L, Te Australian, 5 M . I 5, -h A w h h h b k b

v hgh h w , v hgh k h (, h , 5). T v v x h b b, h k h whh k k.


4/21

128


I. What Is Terrorism?

Ahgh h x v g g bg w , h v k hv g, g . B h , hh v wk g h v g. P g whW gv b b gg ggh v. I h h bj B H h b,g h :

has political or ideological motives and aims;

is violent (or threatens violence);

seeks a far-reaching psychological impact beyond its immediate victim or target, usuallyb g h g b;

is conducted by an organisation with an identiable chain of command or conspiratorial ;

is perpetrated by a sub-national group or non-state entity(h ).9

H v x w. Y h g x h , gv h h v b h gz gz h ? S A g W O, h-g wh w D h N S A R Rg hv k kwg h h U.S. Gv h g , hv h h h h v h .10

I h w H w h bk W g b ghb ? 11 Sv h v w h Ag-A v Iq Mh w ?12 I gh h v h w

B H, Inside errorism, Cb Uv P, , . 4. IAmerican Hegemony: How to Use It, How to Lose It, O w: A hv , . I . B h U S h g g g , h g w k h U Sk h h h w. S MS MS M Williamson, Terrorism, War and International Law: The Legality ofThe Use of Force against Afghanistan in 2001, Ashgate Publishing, 2009, p. 38. S AxP. Schmid, The Denition of Terrorism, The Routledge Handbook of Terrorism Research,Rg, . . A w g b b h b

A h Ch h I M b (IM). I h h SW W, h gv h Bg F (.., h U.S.A., Sv U, B F) bhh IM h N S G . T b Ch,


5/21

129


w h b , g b h bw - A,Bh A h v gg q h g,, wgg w gg h , h w . Nh S H h Iq b h

W ; h S h hv h h k /.13 T v b , wh hDwgS M, Lw (S) Lbb h , v b h h v h w v h h b x w bj.

Ag, b h Nbg, h g v-hgg b, g h v Iq x b.14 T bh b A B Nbg 4 h : v h h h h h k

whh h v kw wh h x h v g . I h w, whh wg b Nz -vv, -v w w . T h bw S H w v h (H Bx h ) wh kh w b WMD Iq k v b h W w g h xb j.

bh Ag 45, A : T wg , h, gwh h j h b whh h h b v b: Crimes against Peace: , g, , wgg w gg, w v , g , C P C h h h gg. War Crimes: , v h w w. Sh v h , b b , , - v b h v

, - w h , kg hg, b v , w , w, vg, v j b S J R, T Lg G, Rv .4 T Nbg b x hbtu quoque( !) h ,gv h v j. T g w gh b h v hg h w h v , w w h , h b h w h h H hh. T hb b . S j, wh h , b , ? T , h v P w g wh A H hgh-kg

G x , h h v Iq, wh b Gg W. Bh, B, Jh Hw h b, g ?


6/21

130


b : S R V W D Agg

SNb Iq Cv Dh Abb hAg-A Iv O

F Mh

Iq B C

,4 ,4 v h Egh-gg (g Ab Egh) J

O RhB v

,, v h (g 4, ,,) h Ag

Iq HhM v

5, v h (g 4, ,) 4, x h w J

L v , v h 54,5 x h J

Mv, g gh h b v vb b , h A Bh ( bg h ) hv v h w w g . . . v , - w... b v , w , w, vg, v j b .A h h Fj,Hh,Mh,S,k,hAb Ghb P h .

A. War on Terror or a War of Terror?

I g h , w g h ? Ahghh U.S. Gv hv , kwg, x k h q,h h gg h Sb h hv bh w. T b k whh w g w h . T w w. T w q v. F k, Gg W. Bh Sb .

Ag Wk, h W g bh U S h U Kg wh h h Nh A Og (NAO) w -NAO . Og, h g w wgg -Q h gz wh h g h.T h h W h v v- -v, h h v hh v vg. I h hv g g, h w gv q.

O Sb , Gg W. Bh h h w . O Sb, g v j Cg, h h : O

w bg wh -Q, b h. I w v g gb h h b , . Bk Ob h


7/21

131


h h, b h g J h : O w, g -hg wk v h. I Mh h q h A v h h , h h h h Ov Cg O.15

Gv h h w b w b, h hv h b b q , ,hv w hv h h w v.16I B, h D Pb P h h Cw PSv, K MD, h h h h h J 5 bbg L b w, b q wh h j h j.17 O Sb ,h RAND C h U S H A Sv Ch hv Deeating errorist Groups. I b

h v g g g g h b h g v, whh w b h % [] g . RAND h h h g bg w b M wh k .

Oh , h F Fk, hv h W O g hh: b b , w b v bw h w h b wb. A thelinguist George Lakoff has argued, terror is an abstract noun (concept).18 Therefore a war on

terror is a logical impossibility and strong evidence of its proponents woolly thinking.

Wars on bh, kg g k, g h , g, g g b , g g bvg, . k, kw, b, v k, g,vg, , q ghb. Lakoff concludes:Terror cannot be destroyed by weapons or signing a peace treaty. A war on terror has no

end. Dg v h U.S. J , h Bh P M G Bw h h bg wh h h W g b.

Gg W. Bh h v h h W w b h wb. N hw hw g xgh, h h hw g w . I Ag 5, h Ox Rh

5 S S W A K, Gb W I Gv Nw N, Te Washington Post, 5Mh . S, x, Richissin, War on Terror Difcult to Dene, The BaltimoreSun, 2 September 2004.

T I N W h UK, DPP, Te imes, 4 J War on Terror, Rest in Peace, Retrieved from .


8/21

132


G -Q v v, wh g b hgh k h b / F wg hw , h Gg W. Bh g h g v -A. Ag, ( Bh )

h h w w v g gb h h b, h w v .

T w g h g h w g h h h g h j gb: h h, k h h w h h W Dg W Pv, w b. T W on h b w o.

B. What Does Al-Qaeda Want?

I Szg U h Nw -Dw B L, D V N, J. w:Wh O b L w? T vxg q g g wkwh h whh h -Q b kg.O , h h Db [4] k g h U S C J, S Ab, g h g h S .

T h b L h v h g v h S h w h h gh b wh, whh h v A g h M E,

h h A h Ab P h P h.19

Wh k h W? N b w h, b b h v h. g h W b wW, b b , , h, bb hw h k ( h M E) v b h gv hv .

O Mh 5, Al-Quds Al-Arabi x S -A

Al-Qaedas Strategy to the Year 2020. T g v g:

. Pvk h U S h v M .

. I h g .

Te New York imes, Db 4. S h bk b Ch Jh. T S h bk b Ch Jh. T Blowback: Te Costs and

Consequences o American Empire (H Pbk, 4); h Te Sorrows oEmpire: Militarism, Secrecy, and the End o the Republic (M Bk, 4); h h Nemesis: Te Last Days o the American Republic (M Bk, ).


9/21

133


. Ex h ghbg , gg h U.S. g w w .

4. Dv -Q g g h b h h wh qg ; v h h k g h U.S. ( ) h whw h .

5. B h U.S. ( h h wh U S) v h h gg ; g hww whh h g h U.S. g gb b, whh w g bg gb jh b A-Q Whhb Ch w h b

h w.21

Rgg h h U.S., Ab B Aw: I h -h, bg h h [g]v b h w h Sv U.22

A bk b Rb P h Uv Chg Dying to Win: Te StrategicLogic o Suicide errorism h hh v b. B v kw (5 k g), P h h bw I , h w g Rh, wh k hv

g g: whw h h b h h. T , h g; x g b.4 P hh x g gg -Q h S Lk g. Nb,h b gwg b h h h j vh bkg, b h hv g g v .

Ag Mh Sh (Imperial Hubris: Why the West is Losing the War on error, P Bk,4) O b L h h h U.S. k v hg g : ) I; ) whw h Ab P M ; ) vv Agh Iq; v) U.S. h M Ch, R,I wh; v) M h I w g h b M. A xh h U.S.-bk g h M w wh I , bh xh h M .

Te Secret History o Al-Qaeda, Uv C P, , . .Dying to Win: The Strategic Logic of Suicide Terrorism,p. 4.4 Ib.pp. 79-80.


10/21


11/21

13


I 5, h U.S. Gv q h K.. Bg E.D. J h LwLv N Lb hv h RAND-MIP b.26 Bg J h, h k g h k b , h w h b v w : h S

I Evwh E. I I, h gP, h I v bgg h. I I, h h j h hgh v g bw .% % -- whh hgh gh h h w kw wh h b j, k, k. B h h w, h k j h bw , . C h A k bg k b ghg ( ,4), bg k b v ( ,), wg bhb ( ,), g ( ) g h ( 4). Bg J bv h h k b w b-hh x, w wh h g h

g de minimis Egh, .

A. But Youre Ignoring the Existential Treat o WMDs!

Fw W , g h , h bv g. H h j h h k W. I, h h h g h k .T h h j k w v

S Rk M Mb Ww : 4,S Rk M Mb Ww : 4, Rk M Mb Ww : 4,Rk M Mb Ww : 4, Risk Analysis, :,Fb , . 45-5.


12/21

136


k v. T g k h w h h w v. T h / w

v k , bb w w g h, , v. T h : b

w (WMD), h h w h v h h h , v wk! T k, h , ; g, h h h k v x v h. T x k one which has the potential to destroy, ordrastically restrict, human civilisation. Ag Mh Ig:

C h q j k h U S h g bb, h, w- v h k bw. A h v h, v h w k / k . A h

k, g, h, g w hg v b g.

A k h h b. T kg w h I, h q vb h gh .D v b k, b k vhg h ,, hx w h h . Ag bg vz, w h w h k, w b . S. , h,w v k. W hv h b h x .27

A v w h g , w k Ih j . I h, h I hv gv vg. F h w w h wh h xv h h S I h bj h. T hh h M, h hv g j hh M E h h h g h Z b k . A I h v k b wh WMD.T g h gg g h w

hk w hv bv.

I , b v, w h k bkk; , hwv, h h J B v w kg h . b WMD h h w w k I hU.S. . B h hh g h v h h b h h h k w v, h h w qk b bb h b I v .

S S Lesser Evils, The New York Times Magazine, 2 May 2004.


13/21

137


Ah g : O b L w b K Jg I I . I h w h hg b , v h g h w g , h h G C.28 T hv

v g wh , h bg w.T v h D-I-Y . M k h Ig h WMD b wh h g g, hk h I h gg. I , hG C:

T h b kg v w b h g. T g h bg h

g b jg kg v b h g v h h. T h g - w b kg h, h h h q v v g h , bb b h h q , h b g g w v, h v v . [T b h h] , w, b b h h h v j x gz b bh -.

S, Weapons o Mass Destruction the errorist Treat b hCg Rh Sv :

b b WMD b gwg k hg h Sv U h hg . Hwv, WMD g h b h wh h h bb b h h g. T C Ig Ag bv

h k h w h v xv vWMD.

T b wh I h jg: h W hv gh h g z b WMD bg h J

T U.S. S D, wh h A G, h S Eg, hT U.S. S D, wh h A G, h S Eg, hT U.S. S D, wh h A G, h S Eg, hS Hh H Sv h D h F Eg Mg Ag wh h RAND N D Rh I (NDRI), bh h Av

P A D R Cb Ivvg W M D.C kw h G C h G C, h Db .


14/21

138


A Shk.

L b Shk Ah, A w x h g - k h kg w. A w b. A k, h b bh , A, G, R h U.S. I h v h h, h h $ b . A h hgh k b: A w h b v J ggv g bg, h, h gg. A gv h h q b. A , bh wkg bg w, h vg h w. A gh w, v h 5,- h A wh h J wh, g h G C, g h hg w v w-g .

I R, h g bgh g q kw hv b h k v w, h k, j gh, -- kh v w.

I h, A vk wk hv. Wh Ob bk h Eb v A, Shk Ah 4 h w h g wh w g h . Ow bv A h v b - J. T .

T w h A . T kw b- k vv hg b x h x b h b h k g h A v b, , J h I P. N g k; , b v kw h h bk h h w v h . Ah b k J . T h, h hx k . I , A h wh w h b w. Tk . I h v A wh v h b g v h hg g

h b.

H h wh h w v g. H, A wh b , g b q g, , VX h w bg g h v g. Wh A 5, h gh k 4. . D h ? Q h : h . A, h w h w k , whh h h bbw h w h w h b g

j h. A A still h.

O J 4, A b v v g k


15/21

139


ghbh M, J. I, v - h h q v bw h wh . T w w , w gg h w ww h w gh . Sv h 4 j. O

Mh 5, A h v h. Fv b b g b b v h h k-w bw . I , h bg wh .Pg h bg h , h k h h wh h b h . T h bg . T h gh gh 5 . A h q , v v . wv .Fv w j b vv. Ah w v j,wh 4 .

J h, b A ,

v h . Wh h v h. D h v , b, q h gh h k, h h wh w hg h. I h g w : wh bg gh h h , , x q b, -gh v - . A A k wh h bg w k w v h h wh Okh C wh h MVgh g bb -g .

T G C :

A x gg hwv -v b h g hg b - g wz h bg w v.

C h , h C , h h wh b : A , h b g , b v b k jg. F

wh , h v gg; x h , h h . A-Q h I v w A vg. T k h , q, h h b v . M , h hv h -Q h h b h , whh h h hv v hw v A h h.

A x h h bb - kg h bg w g h z, b h zh . qk h g b

h w h h. T g wh v h h h hv k bb b , h h w


16/21

10


k h, bx k.

O , h hg wh w g . Ph h w hv bona fde w b w, wh G C. A k w b b gbh, h h h vb g gh vw hgh bb. B bb w g whk, h k. B h bgg k h h : wh -kg z. I w h h v g bb h , wh W Mg-A k W w w h v, b gb-gg wh h . B v vb w ,q gh, h h w b h bb x b

h g w h. W hg h h ; h , w h g z b . T h h b bgh b wh .

B. How Likely Is the Mushroom Cloud? What Damage Might It Cause?

The problem here, Condoleeza Rice said, is that there will always be some uncertainty

about how quickly [Saddam] can acquire nuclear weapons. But we dont want the smoking

gun to be a mushroom cloud. Similarly, Obama has identied nuclear terrorism as a

threat that rises above all others in urgency There is no graver danger to global security

than the threat of nuclear terrorism and no more immediate task for the internationalcommunity than to address that threat. Wh h bb h h k h ? I b . Wh ? B hv h h h b h. I h b , w k h b h vb w k jg .

T G C j h. I b g h, h w h v g h , h h Sv U h

x-Sv k h bk k. I , h R k w g wh . I v, h v qg, hgh h xv . Ev g R g bb, h b w hv h jb ggg g h bg b v hv - h g v h .

A DIY, h h hg h h vg gk h vg bb gg. Bg v b g

H hg v wh w- h g, h G C w. I h


17/21

11


, S H Iq v - g.B b h G W h v g w. Ah ShA b , b k g w whh b h g- (h

bb).A , hwv k b , h. Wh h? B , b w k h , . Gv h h , h h - Abg k h x w b .%, ,. A h v k, h , h h h b A k h bb 5, gh q h b A v h. S b v, k w b g b .

A k w v g, b h h h Gg h w h A xgg. Ag, hb h h - . T k w h , , b h h h U.S., h v bg A hg h.Sk k g b wh 4 h DJIA v Sb.A x , h v b, hgh h

v gb gh $ $. w b v h k v bq $ 5.T A w v w gb v. Ah h Ag 5, wh H K bhh v g Nw O. M h ,5 , h .T wh k x, b A w h b. T hv b $ b.Nh h h h A .

C.All the Groundless Fear Mongering, All the Bloody ime

W h k Sb k . I5, -h A w h h h gh b k b v h w higherh w , vhgh k h . A h v v x h b b, h k whh k k.

T g w w h h h k b. B wh A ? h, w v Sb Gg W. Bh h h v

h v w h . T w w F k. B h w h h w


18/21

12


: w kw h h w, h , g h h bg v w . T h h wghb /. Ag , w wh hg h bx- g k: w v h w, h

h h .Hw b hw? A, , h g w b h E H h Wh W W; w, h h b h, h h k, T Ib N. A b -A , Ob h, hv -A : hw b. Ag, hh h h k w g-g w b h A x; h hg h w A bg hv .H h h B h Bgh: h k Sb

w hb v h ; h w w x k h g h h w w .

T v / hv b v w, b Gg W. Bh vh gb h bw gh h v .T vz w g, h h S h UA J . U w v , w wv , vvg h w v w, A , h PNational Strategy or Homeland Securityw . I hg b v b k , , wh v w. I h S h U , Bh h ghg w h gg g H, , , h g, h h bw w , w h . I , h WhH wb h / k w g h U S, hgh h w, h v b h g. Mh h, Bh h h h h.

T g h h Bh w h w w h

h k h wh b h g h . R Sk, h h Te One Percent Doctrine: DeepInside Americas Pursuit o Its Enemies Since 9/11 traces this mentality to Bushs Vice-President Dick Cheney. According to Suskind, immediately after 11 September 2001

Cheney directed that if there was even a one percent chance of terrorists getting a weapon

of mass destruction and there has been a small probability of such an occurrence for

some time the United States must now act as if that were a certainty.

H h h I. A Sb, bb g h w gv

xv v v g w h w . I Doublespeak and the War on errorism, h Lh


19/21

13


x h . Ag h b $5, -bbh k Nwk, Nw J $, h Mh V,Mh. I hb hh I kw wh w gg , b w g . N-Gv Og hv

h h bw. G h g w h k xg , h h w w h k h b h h .N b g, h Wwh I g g Bg Ag hg h .29

III. The Score After A Decade: Al Qaeda - 5, Western Democracies - 1

, w B Mh Jk, h v h , whh w xgg hgh h h h h . Y notb. I h w, h b . I h wk h h h gh whh h v w vb h.Sghper se hgh k v bw h . B g g , wh Wgv v hv h ; , , gg h(v) h, h, w v h . F gh v h W , h v h v b h .

I h , Gg W. Bh hk, k h whh Ob L . T b h h g h -Q h b . O b L h h k Sb w h A whw h M w Av M . I h A b h M E, h - h Eg S Ab w b wk. I hA v M , h w b L h h w kg I. I w w h h U.S. wh h h Sv U h h , b . F h vw, h k Sb w h - .

I h , b L g w h U.S., b B C wg h. A h bb A b K z, k A h h h Ab P, O wh,b h h wh h h q b h g v M wh wh h gv

S, .g., T B Y Bg, Rv .


20/21

1


b w h. Wh Bh h O w x h hU.S., h gv O x h w h v. I h , h G gv h R Bg g v; Sb ,h U.S. Gv v v v h x b

L -Q w .C h g Te Daily elegraph:

T A w Iq Agh, h Pk, x $4 h h h h b Cg h h / k. T ggg g w b h Iv- g Bw Uv hv h $. C H h gbg. I h Pg , bw

h w, h $4 b hv b h w , h wh bw $. $. .

A v hgh h w w wg w, g bv h kg v, b hw h b w b wh bw $. $4.4 Uk A v , Iq Agh hv b b bw h b .

T h . T h , bw5, 5, hv h w. O h , US k h b , ,. T v h Iq 5, (h h h ) 4, Agh. F Pk, b b .

Hw h -Q g g h ? Hw h h U.S. Gv?C h gh h :

. A-Q h vk h U S h v M . P : -Q ( h Agh Iq), U.S. .

. A-Q h h g .P : -Q 4 ( h Agh Iq), U.S. .

. A-Q h x h ghbg , gg h U.S. g w w . P :

L, J .


21/21

1


-Q 5 ( Pk), U.S. .

4. A-Q h h g g h b h h h Y S wh qg ; v h h k g h U.S. h whw h . P :-Q 5 ( h ), U.S. ( gv h h b h b h w v whwh).

5. A-Q h b h U.S. h . W h h gg ? P : -Q 5 ( ), U.S. .

Eh v h k Sb , , gv

k gv. F h k h w , W h gv h wh h h k Sb . W bggv h g W M ,gg I S Ab h 4 v h Ab w .

Documents

The Years Since 9/11: What Hath Our Rulers Wrought?