1
THE TIMES OF INDIA, NEW DELHI WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 21, 2015 9 TIMES CITY New Delhi: Two days after law- yer Gaurav Rana and his dog were electrocuted by a live wire left unguarded at a park in northwest Delhi, North Delhi Municipal Corporation on Tuesday accepted that neglect on its part led to the tragedy even as angry residents of the area said they planned to sue the civic body. The corporation has or- dered a probe and indicated that an electrician or an engineer may be suspended for “callous- ness”. “We have ordered an in- quiry and the report will come by Wednesday. We haven’t sus- pended any official. Depending on the report, we will take ac- tion. But it was the corpora- tion’s responsibility to see that live wire wasn’t kept in the park,” said P K Gupta, commis- sioner, North Delhi Municipal Corporation. Residents of Vaishali, the colony where the electrocution took place, said they would take the agency to task. “We must sue the corporation. We will protest. Why should residents face the consequences of such negligence?” asked Shikha Seh- rawat, a resident. Locals gathered at the park said the lights there were not working for over a year. “A fam- ily had even complained that the lights are not working. The police don’t know how to deal with such cases. Why weren’t they carrying wooden logs? They were looking for sticks in the park after they reached here,” said Jyoti Khatri, anoth- er resident. However, civic body officials are also probing whether the dog had dug up the live wire which caused the electrocution. “Some zonal level officials indicate the dog might have dug up the portion which led to the live wire getting exposed. Even so, our maintenance staff should’ve checked,” he added. Officials have been instruct- ed to inspect all parks and non- functional fancy lights have to be replaced. “Our officials are drawing up a list and within two days, all parks in North Delhi will be inspected and bulbs re- placed.” But the residents say that they didn’t see any official inspecting the park where the mishap took place. TOI found rusty wire meshes jutting out of most light poles in the park. Residents of other colonies said no official had visited their neighbourhood to inspect parks and repair non-functional lights. “These fancy lights go off after some months. People are getting killed and corporations are squarely to be blamed. The contractor/officials do a shod- dy job by giving multiple elec- tric connections and people have to pay through their lives. They must compensate the fam- ily,” said Ashok Bhasin, presi- dent, North Delhi Residents Welfare Forum. North Delhi mayor, Yogen- der Chandolia, said a commit- tee had been formed to probe the matter. “Either the electri- cian or junior engineer will be suspended. It is sheer callous- ness on officials’ part. Our par- ty members met the family and strict action will be taken.” Meanwhile, Congress and AAP latched on to the opportu- nity, claiming that the accident betrayed the BJP-ruled corpo- ration’s “lack of governance” and “misrule”. “This is a very unfortunate incident and shows total lack of governance. How can a live wire be left in the park? Immediate action must be taken against those respon- sible in the administration,” said Congress leader Haroon Yusuf. AAP lashed out at BJP for ‘misrule’ in the corpora- tions. “The incident highlights the sorry state of governance. It’s been seven years that they are ruling the corporations and yet the situation is so pathetic,” said AAP spokesperson, Atishi. Lawyer’s neighbours may sue corpn Agency Orders Inquiry Into Park Tragedy, Hints At Suspending Those Responsible IN GRIEF: Sister Vandana Kohar Photos: Vipin New Delhi: Gaurav Rana, the 26-year-old lawyer and resi- dent of Pitampura who was electrocuted by a live wire in the colony park while walking his dog on Sunday night, was known for going out of his way to help people and friends. His elder sister, Vandana Kohar, describes him as dildar—someone with a big heart. On Tuesday, Gau- rav’s house was filled with tearful friends and family mourning his sudden death and remembering him to be a very jovial and caring per- son. Rana booked a car as a surprise gift for his father on Saturday which is yet to ar- rive. On Sunday, he went out for his daily stroll with his dog and was speaking to friends on the phone when his pet Caesar strayed into the park. Rana went after him before both were electrocuted by a live wire from a lamp post in the park. “Gaurav was an ideal brother. He was also an ideal friend. Ask his friends. Last night a boy came knocking on our door at 11.30pm calling Gaurav. It was his friend who came all the way from London after hearing about his death. His friends loved him,” said Vandana. The fam- ily was looking for a match for Gaurav. Gaurav’s neigh- bour Smita Chaud- hury recalls how during Holi last year Gaurav poured five buckets of colour on her. “I asked why you are pouring so much colour and he said each bucket is on behalf of differ- ent people who have moved out of the colony now. He was very jovial. He regarded me as an elder sister and was also ve- ry close to his two sisters,” said Smita. Gaurav studied in Army Public School till Class X and Lancer Convent for classes XI and XII and completed his LLB from Amity University. “Gaurav aspired to be a poli- tician. Our father is a member of the Bar Council of India. He wanted to be influential like dad,” recalls Vandana. Gaurav’s friends had gath- ered, some in front of the park. “It’s criminal negligence. The corporation should be booked. Also, police should have called the CATS ambulance which is equipped to deal with such emergencies. It’s a huge loss to us,” Ajit Singh, a friend, said. Tears for ‘ideal brother’, ‘big-hearted friend’ SHOCKING NEGLECT Jan 2015 Two linemen are electrocuted while shifting high-tension cables to underground fixtures in Noida. The incident happened when the line they were working on became ‘live’ Jul 2014 A 10-year-old boy was killed after he fell on a high-ten- sion wire from the terrace of his house in Swaroop Nagar, northwest Delhi Jul 2013 A documentary filmmaker, Anand Bhaskar Morla (33), is electrocuted when his car’s door brushed an iron gate that was in contact with a live wire from a split AC in Green Park area Oct: A 40-year-old man & his son (20) are killed after they came in contact with a live wire hanging from a trans- former in northeast Delhi’s Harsh Vihar Aug: A 35-year-old man is electrocuted after he came in contact with a wire hanging from an overhead electricity meter in Holambi Kalan of northwest Delhi TIMES NEWS NETWORK New Delhi: Not all schools are dealing responsibly with the autonomy given to them to set nursery admission gui- delines. At least one school’s web- site showed a change in reg- istration dates—from Janu- ary 20 to January 15. Authorities at The Banyan Tree, Lodhi Institutional Ar- ea, claim “technical error” but parents are suspicious. A parent has also complained that he was asked to submit two demand drafts while tak- ing admission without being told what he was paying for. Jasdeep Kaur had planned to submit the appli- cation at The Banyan Tree on January 17 as the sched- ule first uploaded on the website said the last date for registration was January 20. When she checked again, she found that the last date was January 15. “Forms were accepted till January 20,” says Chetna Saini, prin- cipal, The Banyan Tree, “there was no change of schedule. May be there was some error. As for the list, it was probably the one for par- ents to see if they’ve filled all the details correctly.” The parents, however, are suspi- cious and have mailed a com- plaint to Action Committee for Unaided Recognized Pri- vate Schools. Another parent, Pratik Jain, has written that when he went to admit his daugh- ter to a Dayanand Vihar school, one of a large chain, he was asked to pay two DDs. “One was for Rs 25,000 and another for Rs 30,000,” says Jain. When he posted his ex- perience on a social network- ing site, another applicant responded saying he was asked for donation by the Vi- kaspuri branch. A third parent said the East of Kailash branch asked for a hefty amount to teach “a poor kid whose par- ents had died.” Jain has emailed the Directorate of Education officials. Complaints of donation, date change pour in Greater Noida: Motorists using the Yamuna express- way will now have to shell out more money as toll. More than two years after it was opened for commuters, the expressway concessionaire has hiked the toll charges. The new rates have come into effect on January 19. The new toll rate for four- wheelers is Rs 330, up by Rs 10, while it is Rs 165 for two- wheelers, up by Rs 15, for a one-way trip to Agra from Greater Noida. Tax for other vehicles—commercial and large—has also been hiked by up to 10%. Buses and trucks will pay Rs 1,150, minibuses and other light commercial vehicles Rs 550, and other multi-axle vehicles Rs 1,765. The concessionaire, Jay- pee Infratech, said that the toll hike was notified by the UP government earlier this month and endorsed by the Yamuna Expressway Indus- trial Development Authority. According to the new rates, expressway users will have to pay Rs 2.20 per km for light motor vehicles like cars and jeeps, Rs 3.45 per km for medi- um heavy vehicles and light commercial vehicles like minibuses, and Rs 7 per km for buses and trucks. Heavy construction machinery or earth moving equipment will be charged Rs 10.75 per km and multi-axle heavy vehicles will be charged Rs 13.75 per km, officials said. “Commuters travelling to Jewar are charged toll for 0 to 48 km. However, the rate for this section of the express- way has not been increased for two-wheelers and four- wheelers like cars, jeep or light motor vehicles. It re- mains at Rs 50 and Rs 100, re- spectively,” said a Jaypee spokesperson. Yamuna e-way toll up, but Jewar ride costs same Vandana.Keelor @timesgroup.com FIRST HIKE Ghaziabad: Around 600 SIM cards, 25 modem hubs, two CPUs and a laptop, among other electronic items, were reco- vered from the possession of a person, purportedly a resident of Delhi's Mukherjee Nagar, from a house in Ghaziabad on Monday night. His father, Rajiv Sapra, who also lived with him managed to escape. The accused, Chirag Sapra, was nabbed from a house in Radheshyam Colony Phase I in Mu- radnagar. Cops are trying to find out why Sapra had amassed the huge cache of communication devices. He failed to pro- vide relevant documents too. TNN 600 SIMs seized from house AGRA TRIP TO COST JUST 10 MORE Category of vehicle Jewar Mathura Agra Total OF RF OF RF OF RF OF RF 2/3 wheelers 50 50 50 65 50 50 150 165 Car/jeep/van 100 100 120 130 100 100 320 330 LCV 150 160 200 210 150 180 500 550 Truck/bus 300 335 400 430 350 385 1,050 1,150 MAV 450 515 600 660 550 590 1,600 1,765 Oversized vehicles 600 660 800 845 700 755 2,100 2,260 OF (Old fee) RF (Revised fee) in( ) NURSERY ADMISSIONS T his newspaper has consistently held that we must establish a system for pinning individual responsibility for this sort of criminal negligence. We have also argued that there must be appropriate compensation for those dying or injured in accidents caused by the negligence of civic agencies. This must include three components. First, compensation for the loss of potential earnings for the victim’s household. The second should be for the trauma suffered by the family. While no monetary value can be placed on this, the figure should be at least Rs 10 lakh. A third component should be a punitive fine imposed on the agency that has been negligent. This again should be no less than Rs 10 lakh. For a young person, like in this case, these would add up to well over a crore of rupees. At least 1% of the compensation amount should be recovered from the official held directly accountable for the negligence. Only such a system can act as a real deterrent to such callous negligence. Times View Noida: The National Human Rights Commission on Tuesday asked the UP government and the GB Nagar administration to submit reports on the electrocution of two linemen in Noida within two weeks. Taking suo motu cognizance of reports in TOI, the rights panel issued notices to UP’s principal secretary (power) and the district magistrate and police chief of Gautam Budh Nagar. The two linemen, Mohammad Hasan and Saddam Hussein, were charred to death on January 11 while working on a high-tension line that suddenly went live. TNN NHRC notice on linemen deaths Gaurav Rana Maria.Akram@timesgroup.com TIMES NEWS NETWORK

THE TIMES OF INDIA, NEW DELHI WEDNESDAY, JANUARY …epaperbeta.timesofindia.com/NasData/PUBLICATIONS/THETIMESOFINDIA/... · rawat, a resident. ... in Holambi Kalan of northwest Delhi

  • Upload
    vonhu

  • View
    214

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

THE TIMES OF INDIA, NEW DELHI WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 21, 2015 9TIMES CITY

New Delhi: Two days after law-yer Gaurav Rana and his dogwere electrocuted by a live wireleft unguarded at a park innorthwest Delhi, North DelhiMunicipal Corporation onTuesday accepted that neglecton its part led to the tragedyeven as angry residents of thearea said they planned to suethe civic body.

The corporation has or-dered a probe and indicated thatan electrician or an engineermay be suspended for “callous-ness”. “We have ordered an in-quiry and the report will comeby Wednesday. We haven’t sus-pended any official. Dependingon the report, we will take ac-tion. But it was the corpora-tion’s responsibility to see thatlive wire wasn’t kept in thepark,” said P K Gupta, commis-sioner, North Delhi MunicipalCorporation.

Residents of Vaishali, thecolony where the electrocutiontook place, said they would takethe agency to task. “We mustsue the corporation. We willprotest. Why should residentsface the consequences of such

negligence?” asked Shikha Seh-rawat, a resident.

Locals gathered at the parksaid the lights there were notworking for over a year. “A fam-ily had even complained thatthe lights are not working. Thepolice don’t know how to dealwith such cases. Why weren’tthey carrying wooden logs?They were looking for sticks inthe park after they reachedhere,” said Jyoti Khatri, anoth-er resident.

However, civic body officialsare also probing whether the

dog had dug up the live wirewhich caused the electrocution.

“Some zonal level officialsindicate the dog might have dugup the portion which led to thelive wire getting exposed. Evenso, our maintenance staffshould’ve checked,” he added.

Officials have been instruct-ed to inspect all parks and non-functional fancy lights have tobe replaced. “Our officials aredrawing up a list and within twodays, all parks in North Delhiwill be inspected and bulbs re-placed.” But the residents say

that they didn’t see any officialinspecting the park where themishap took place. TOI foundrusty wire meshes jutting outof most light poles in the park.

Residents of other coloniessaid no official had visited theirneighbourhood to inspect parksand repair non-functionallights. “These fancy lights go offafter some months. People aregetting killed and corporationsare squarely to be blamed. Thecontractor/officials do a shod-dy job by giving multiple elec-tric connections and people

have to pay through their lives.They must compensate the fam-ily,” said Ashok Bhasin, presi-dent, North Delhi ResidentsWelfare Forum.

North Delhi mayor, Yogen-der Chandolia, said a commit-tee had been formed to probethe matter. “Either the electri-cian or junior engineer will besuspended. It is sheer callous-ness on officials’ part. Our par-ty members met the family andstrict action will be taken.”

Meanwhile, Congress andAAP latched on to the opportu-nity, claiming that the accidentbetrayed the BJP-ruled corpo-ration’s “lack of governance”and “misrule”. “This is a veryunfortunate incident andshows total lack of governance.How can a live wire be left in thepark? Immediate action mustbe taken against those respon-sible in the administration,”said Congress leader HaroonYusuf. AAP lashed out at BJPfor ‘misrule’ in the corpora-tions. “The incident highlightsthe sorry state of governance.It’s been seven years that theyare ruling the corporations andyet the situation is so pathetic,”said AAP spokesperson, Atishi.

Lawyer’s neighbours may sue corpnAgency Orders Inquiry Into Park Tragedy, Hints At Suspending Those Responsible

IN GRIEF: Sister Vandana Kohar

Photos: Vipin

New Delhi: Gaurav Rana, the26-year-old lawyer and resi-dent of Pitampura who waselectrocuted by a live wire inthe colony park while walkinghis dog on Sunday night, wasknown for going out of his wayto help people and friends. Hiselder sister, VandanaKohar, describes himas dildar—someonewith a big heart.

On Tuesday, Gau-rav’s house was filledwith tearful friendsand family mourninghis sudden death andremembering him tobe a very jovial and caring per-son. Rana booked a car as asurprise gift for his father onSaturday which is yet to ar-rive.

On Sunday, he went out forhis daily stroll with his dogand was speaking to friends onthe phone when his pet Caesarstrayed into the park. Rana

went after him before bothwere electrocuted by a livewire from a lamp post in thepark.

“Gaurav was an idealbrother. He was also an idealfriend. Ask his friends. Lastnight a boy came knocking onour door at 11.30pm callingGaurav. It was his friend who

came all the wayfrom London afterhearing about hisdeath. His friendsloved him,” saidVandana. The fam-ily was looking for amatch for Gaurav.

Gaurav’s neigh-bour Smita Chaud-

hury recalls how during Holilast year Gaurav poured fivebuckets of colour on her. “Iasked why you are pouring somuch colour and he said eachbucket is on behalf of differ-ent people who have movedout of the colony now. He wasvery jovial. He regarded me asan elder sister and was also ve-

ry close to his two sisters,”said Smita.

Gaurav studied in ArmyPublic School till Class X andLancer Convent for classes XIand XII and completed hisLLB from Amity University.

“Gaurav aspired to be a poli-tician. Our father is a memberof the Bar Council of India. Hewanted to be influential likedad,” recalls Vandana.

Gaurav’s friends had gath-ered, some in front of the park.

“It’s criminal negligence. Thecorporation should be booked.Also, police should have calledthe CATS ambulance which isequipped to deal with suchemergencies. It’s a huge loss tous,” Ajit Singh, a friend, said.

Tears for ‘ideal brother’, ‘big-hearted friend’SHOCKING NEGLECT

Jan2015

Two linemen are electrocuted while shifting high-tension cables to underground fixtures in

Noida. The incident happened when the line they were working on became ‘live’

Jul2014

A 10-year-old boy was killed after he fell on a high-ten-

sion wire from the terrace of his house in Swaroop Nagar, northwest Delhi

Jul2013

A documentary filmmaker, Anand Bhaskar Morla (33), is electrocuted when his

car’s door brushed an iron gate that was in contact with a live wire from a split AC in Green Park area

Oct: A 40-year-old man & his son (20) are killed after they came in contact with a live wire hanging from a trans-former in northeast Delhi’s Harsh Vihar

Aug: A 35-year-old man is electrocuted after he came in contact with a wire hanging from an overhead electricity meter in Holambi Kalan of northwest Delhi

TIMES NEWS NETWORK

New Delhi: Not all schoolsare dealing responsibly withthe autonomy given to themto set nursery admission gui-delines.

At least one school’s web-site showed a change in reg-istration dates—from Janu-ary 20 to January 15.Authorities at The BanyanTree, Lodhi Institutional Ar-ea, claim “technical error”but parents are suspicious. Aparent has also complainedthat he was asked to submittwo demand drafts while tak-ing admission without beingtold what he was paying for.

Jasdeep Kaur hadplanned to submit the appli-cation at The Banyan Treeon January 17 as the sched-ule first uploaded on thewebsite said the last date forregistration was January 20.When she checked again,she found that the last date

was January 15. “Formswere accepted till January20,” says Chetna Saini, prin-cipal, The Banyan Tree,“there was no change ofschedule. May be there wassome error. As for the list, itwas probably the one for par-ents to see if they’ve filled allthe details correctly.” Theparents, however, are suspi-cious and have mailed a com-plaint to Action Committeefor Unaided Recognized Pri-vate Schools.

Another parent, PratikJain, has written that whenhe went to admit his daugh-ter to a Dayanand Viharschool, one of a large chain,he was asked to pay two DDs.“One was for Rs 25,000 andanother for Rs 30,000,” saysJain. When he posted his ex-perience on a social network-ing site, another applicantresponded saying he wasasked for donation by the Vi-kaspuri branch.

A third parent said theEast of Kailash branchasked for a hefty amount toteach “a poor kid whose par-ents had died.” Jain hasemailed the Directorate ofEducation officials.

Complaintsof donation,date change

pour in

Greater Noida: Motoristsusing the Yamuna express-way will now have to shell outmore money as toll. Morethan two years after it wasopened for commuters, theexpressway concessionairehas hiked the toll charges.The new rates have come intoeffect on January 19.

The new toll rate for four-wheelers is Rs 330, up by Rs 10,while it is Rs 165 for two-wheelers, up by Rs 15, for aone-way trip to Agra fromGreater Noida. Tax for othervehicles—commercial andlarge—has also been hiked byup to 10%. Buses and truckswill pay Rs 1,150, minibusesand other light commercialvehicles Rs 550, and othermulti-axle vehicles Rs 1,765.

The concessionaire, Jay-pee Infratech, said that thetoll hike was notified by theUP government earlier thismonth and endorsed by the

Yamuna Expressway Indus-trial Development Authority.According to the new rates,expressway users will have topay Rs 2.20 per km for lightmotor vehicles like cars andjeeps, Rs 3.45 per km for medi-um heavy vehicles and lightcommercial vehicles likeminibuses, and Rs 7 per kmfor buses and trucks. Heavyconstruction machinery orearth moving equipment will

be charged Rs 10.75 per kmand multi-axle heavy vehicleswill be charged Rs 13.75 perkm, officials said.

“Commuters travelling toJewar are charged toll for 0 to48 km. However, the rate forthis section of the express-way has not been increasedfor two-wheelers and four-wheelers like cars, jeep orlight motor vehicles. It re-mains at Rs 50 and Rs 100, re-spectively,” said a Jaypee spokesperson.

Yamuna e-waytoll up, but Jewarride costs same

[email protected]

FIRST HIKE

Ghaziabad: Around 600 SIM cards, 25 modem hubs, twoCPUs and a laptop, among other electronic items, were reco-vered from the possession of a person, purportedly a residentof Delhi's Mukherjee Nagar, from a house in Ghaziabad onMonday night. His father, Rajiv Sapra, who also lived withhim managed to escape. The accused, Chirag Sapra, wasnabbed from a house in Radheshyam Colony Phase I in Mu-radnagar. Cops are trying to find out why Sapra had amassedthe huge cache of communication devices. He failed to pro-vide relevant documents too. TNN

600 SIMs seized from house

AGRA TRIP TO COST JUST 10 MORE

Category of vehicle

Jewar Mathura Agra Total

OF RF OF RF OF RF OF RF2/3 wheelers 50 50 50 65 50 50 150 165

Car/jeep/van 100 100 120 130 100 100 320 330

LCV 150 160 200 210 150 180 500 550

Truck/bus 300 335 400 430 350 385 1,050 1,150

MAV 450 515 600 660 550 590 1,600 1,765

Oversized vehicles 600 660 800 845 700 755 2,100 2,260

OF (Old fee) RF (Revised fee) in( )

NURSERYADMISSIONS

This newspaper has consistently held that we must establish asystem for pinning individual responsibility for this sort of

criminal negligence. We have also argued that there must beappropriate compensation for those dying or injured in accidentscaused by the negligence of civic agencies. This must include threecomponents. First, compensation for the loss of potential earningsfor the victim’s household. The second should be for the traumasuffered by the family. While no monetary value can be placed onthis, the figure should be at least Rs 10 lakh. A third componentshould be a punitive fine imposed on the agency that has beennegligent. This again should be no less than Rs 10 lakh. For a youngperson, like in this case, these would add up to well over a crore ofrupees. At least 1% of the compensation amount should be recoveredfrom the official held directly accountable for the negligence. Onlysuch a system can act as a real deterrent to such callous negligence.

Times View

Noida: The National HumanRights Commission on Tuesdayasked the UP government andthe GB Nagar administration tosubmit reports on theelectrocution of two linemen inNoida within two weeks. Takingsuo motu cognizance of reportsin TOI, the rights panel issuednotices to UP’s principalsecretary (power) and thedistrict magistrate and policechief of Gautam Budh Nagar. Thetwo linemen, Mohammad Hasanand Saddam Hussein, werecharred to death on January 11while working on a high-tensionline that suddenly went live. TNN

NHRC notice onlinemen deaths

Gaurav Rana

[email protected]

TIMES NEWS NETWORK