Upload
nafee-mahatab
View
265
Download
1
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
1/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan1
Ulama Freedom Struggle and
Concept of Pakistan
Mohammed Anwer Hussain
The advent of nineteenth century saw the East India Company
emerge as the major political power in India. Not only was the
power of the Mughal Empire broken but also most of theindependent principalities that had come in to existence as a
result of its disintegration were subjugated by the British. In1799 Tipu Sultan (1750-99) was defeated and killed and his
territory annexed. Bengal, Bihar and Urissa and a major part of
the United Province had already passed in to the hand of theforeigners. Awadh was a British allay and Hyderabad was
virtually ruled by a British Resident. The Maratha though
divided and fighting among themselve, remain the only sourceof anxiety and danger for the British. But in the second Marathawar (1803-1805) the British authority successfully manoeuvred
to remove this obstacle in their way to aggrandizement on theirrefusal to come into the fold of subsidiary alliance on Britishcondition was declared against them and they were defeated in
the various engagement and were forced to come to terms
dictated by the British interest. Of these battles, the crushing
defeat of Sindhia of Gowaliar at the battle of Delhi in 1803 wasthe most significant and had far-reaching political
consequences. It laid to the British protection of the Moghal
Emperor Shah Alam, now a miserable blind old man of eighty-three seated under a small tattered canopy. The British forces
marched in to the city and by show of their strength convince
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
2/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan2
the imperial seat that from Calcutta to Delhi they were real rulerof India (PE Roberts. History of British India Oxford University
Press London 1952 P.P. 257) In the North-West of the country
the Sikh feudatories were getting exhausted by internecine warsto be united and ruled by Sikh statesman, Ranjit Singh (1780-
1839) who concluded a peace treaty with company. And on the
whole the Muslim supremacy had come to an end.
Under these circumstances Shah Abdul Aziz (1746-1824) the
illustrious son of Shah Waliullah Dehlawi (1703-62) issued thefamous Fatwa in 1803 declaring that India had ceased to be aDarul Islam. This Fatwa from religion-politico point of view
was a landmark in the history of India in general and in that
Muslim of India in particular. It amounted to a call to religiousconscientious Muslims to mobilize them in the absence of a
powerful Muslim rular, under whose popular leadership they
would rise in defense of foreign power. The original Fatwa,which is in Persian, say, "in this city (Delhi) the Imamul
Muslimeen (The spritual head of the Muslim community)
wields no authority. The real power rests with the Christians
Officers. There is no check on them: and promulgation of thecommand of the Kufr (Infiedelity) means that in administration
and justice in matters of law and order, in the domain of trade
finance and collection of revenue everywhere the Kuffars(infidels) are in power. Yes there are certain Islamic rituals e.g.
Friday and Id (Muslim festival) prayers, Azan Prayers call) and
cow slaughter with which they had no objection. But the veryroot of these rituals was of no value to them. They demolished
mosque without the least hesitation and no Muslim or any
Dhimmi (Non- Muslim citizens of Islamic State) can enter intothe city or its Suburbs without their permision. It is in their own
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
3/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan3
interest if they do not object to the traveler and traders to visitthe city. On the other hand, distinguish persons like Sujaul
Mulk and Wilayat Begam can not dare visit the city without
their permision. From here (Delhi) to Calcutta the Christians arein complete control there is no doubt that in principalities like
Haydarabad, Rampur and Lucknow etc. they have left
administration in the hand of local authorities. But it is becausethey have accepted their leadership and have submitted to their
authority".
Thus after analyzing the existing situations and referring to theestablished legal positions on the point and instances from the
early period of Islamic history, Shah Abdul Aziz, gave his
opinion that India was no more a land of peace and securityboth for Muslims and Dhimmies. W.W. Hunter, summaries this
Fatwa in his own words when he quoted Shah s.b declaring
"when infidel get hold of Muhamdan country and it becomeimpossible for the Muslim of the country, and of the people of
neighboring district to drive them away or to retain reasonable
hope of ever doing so, and the power of infidels increasing to
such an extend that they can abolish or retain the ordinance ofIslam according to their pleasure, and no one is strong enough
to cease on the revenue of the country without the permision of
infidels. And the Muslim inhabitant does no longer live sosecure as before. Such a country is politically a country of the
enemy (Darul Harb) (W.W. Hunter the Indian Musalman. The
comrade publishers Calcutta 1945.
2 Shah Abdul Aziz Fataw Azizi Matbah Mujtaba Delhi 1311
A.H. P. 17.
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
4/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan4
With the gradual consolidations of the British power, thedecision of the doctors became more and more distinct as to
India being Darul Harb (enemy country) Shah s.b and other
Ulama who gave the decision to that effect were consciencekeeper of the Muslim community bewildered by the rapidity of
British expansion. It founded the ground sleeping from their
feet and in the time of its bewilderment and distress it lookedtowards the religious leaders for guidance.
However it is significant to note that during the period (1782-1803) when the Maratha Chief wielded suzerainty over Delhiand Mughal emperor, a mere figure head was under their
protection, no Fatwa as to India being Darul Harb (enemy
territory) was given. Shah s.b was in Delhi and his very eyes theNon Muslim Maratha soldiers were perpetrating all sorts of high
handedness on the peaceful citizen of Delhi and its suburbs, yet
he did not come out with a declaration that India has ceased tobe a Darul Islam (land of peace) for the Muslim. One possible
interpretation that can be put forward is that inspite of Shah s.b
bitter criticism of Maratha's ruthless behavior and the general
spread of chaos and confusion due to their tyrannical exactionof (chawth) (three fourth) from all who fall a victim to their
greed and lust He had no consideration that Muslim supremacy
had come to an end. He might have interpreted the rise ofMaratha power as a rebellion and have thought that it was a
temporary phase, perhaps he believe that some Ahmed Shah
Abdali would again appear and drive the unuly Maharashtrianout of Delhi. In hisFatwa he use the word Dhimmi, not Hindu
not Non-Muslims which indicated that he did not interpreted the
situation which tantamount to final collapse of the Muslimsadministration in India. To him it still existed. It needed
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
5/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan5
rejuvenation. The Maratha have no doubt weakened it but theyhave not replaced or shown any desire to replace it by any new
set-up. On the other hand in the ascendancy of East India
Company, he certainly saw the seed of total disintegration of theMuslim society and the final decline of the Muslim authority
beyond any hope of recovery. He was a man of keen insight. He
was fully aware of British doing in Mysure, Bengal, Awadh andthe land of Ruhila's. He fully realized the danger that lay in the
new situation. Hence theFatwa and call for resistance.
Shah s.b was not content only with the pronouncement ofFatwa. He went futuree and gave lead in organizing the
resistance moment. As he was too old to participate in it
actively he asked his spiritual disciples, Sayyed Ahmed Barelwi(1786-1831) to go to the camp of Ameer Ali Khan in Rajputana
who in collaboration with the Jaswantrao Holker, a Maratha
chieftain, who was putting up a stubborn resistance to theBritish. Sayyed. Ahmed Baralwi was a man of strong moral
character, a perfect activist and a born leader of man. His
mystique training had given him a unique spiritual position
among the Ulama trained in Waliullahi tradition. Shah s.b wasso impressed by his spiritual attainments that he commanded his
whole family, relatives and friends to swear fealty to him and
accept his leadership.
Sayyed Ahmed lived in Rajputana for seven years, preaching to
the soldier of Amir Ali Khan, giving advise in organizationaland strategically matters and even fighting sword in hand
against the British forces. W.W. Hunter, partly because of his
ignorance and partly due to his prejudices, refers to his activitiesin Rajputana in the following words "he began his life as a
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
6/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan6
horse soldier in the service of a celebrated freebooter (Amir AliKhan) and for many a year harried the rich opium growing
village of Malva". W.W. Hunter, O.P. Cit-Pu.
However in 1817 when Amir Ali Khan decided to sign a peace
treaty with the British, Sayyed Ahmed left his camp and came
to Delhi where he was received by Shah s.b. with the submisionof Amir Ali Khan to the enemy the last ray of hope for
resistance under the banner of warlord had vanished. Now the
Jihad was to be continued through popular support. In order topopularize the cause and to enlist support in man and moneySayyed Ahmed with the blessing of Shah s.b toured the country.
His success was tremendous and within a short spans of time he
turned the land between Delhi and Calcutta in to a rebelliouscamp. In 1822 he made a religious journey to Makka and in
1824 made his appearance among the wild mountains of the
Peshawar Frontier preaching a holy war against the rich Sikhtown of Panjab.
Sayyed Ahmed and his followers have been charged with
making of frantic endeavor to establish an Islamic state in India.It is said that they were revivalist and strove to bring back the
vanished glory of pristine Islam but this allegation was not true.
Thus it is clearly evident that before the formation of Indiannational Congress Hajrat Shah Abdul Aziz and his colleagues
had already formed an organization which had started liberation
struggle against the British Government. It is also interesting tonote that Hindu too was participating in the struggle with the
Muslim. But leadership lay in the hand of Muslim community.
Shah Abdul Aziz R.A. and his disciple wrote that Muslims were
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
7/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan7
torch bearer of freedom struggle in India. (Naqshe Hayat P. 8-M.P.K)
Hazrat SayyadAhmedShah and his movement
The revolutionary political party formed by the Shah Waliullah
and Shah Abdul Aziz have rendered valuable contribution in thefreedom movement in the beginning of the nineteenth century
Sayyed s.b and his colleagues had influence the mind of
common Indian masses to oust the British government from theIndian soil. He had burning zeal to see Indian Muslim live withdignity therefore he had entered in to effective alliance with the
Hindus.
It was sheer bad luck for India that Sayyed Ahmed Shaheed had
to fight with the Sikhk rulers in the initial phase of his freedom
struggle and unfortunately was killed by Sikh solddiers atBalakote in 1831.His sad demice was great relief for the
British.If he would have lived for few more years the political
scenario in early19th century India could have been quite
different. The British rulers were quite apprehensive of hisintention and had remained under constant fearpsychosis. That
is why the British ruler had sigh of relief when Sayyed Ahmed
Shaheed had turned his struggle against Sikh instead of BritishGovernment.
However, the real intention of Sayyed Ahmed Shaheed wasdistruction of British Empire that had caused unprecedented
socio-economics havoc for Hindu and Muslim. To achieve this
sole objective he affected alliance with the Hindus to oust theBritish from this land This was soul reason that he had invited
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
8/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan8
Hindus and told them in clear term that British was their deadlyenemy and their ouster from this country was only solution to
their degradation. But the question of who will rule this country
would be decided amicably and whosoever will be capable ofruling would rule. For this purpose the letter written by him to
the Maharaja of Gawaliar Daulat Rai Sindhia and his brother
Hindu Rao is worth reading. His letter to these brothers clearlydefines his vision for this country. The letter reads as follows.
The following letter have been copied from Musalmanoke
Tanazzul Se Dunya ko Kiya Nuqsan Hua by Sayyed AbulHassan Ali Nadwi (P. 274-276)
Your Excellency! You are well aware of the fact that British
ruler who are originaly traders have now become ruling powerin our country. They have disgracefully trampled under feet the
dignity and respect of many great rulers of this country. Those
who are capable to rule this country are sitting on the fence andhave become idle therefore, few poor and people without any
recourses at their command had come in forefront to save their
religion. They have abandoned their home only for Allah. They
did not aspire for material gain. The moment British will leavefrom this country we will fullfill our mision. Those who intend
to rule this country would be given maximum opportunity to
rule and those who seek power will get it. It will strengthen ourcountry. We humbly request the rulers (custodian) of various
states to start their struggle under the banner of Islam and
remain the ruling power of this country. (Naqshe Hayat P. 14)His letter to a Muslim official in the state of Gualiar is also
worth reading he wrote.
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
9/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan9
"Under this circumstances it appear quite appropriate that youbrought the kind attention of the Raja Hindu Rao to this matter
that large chunk of Indian Territory has fallen into the hand of
foreigners. Everywhere they are perpetrating atrocities to theindigenous peopulation. The power of Indian rulers has become
ineffective and now they are completely under foreign
domination. Therefore, few people without any resourse at theircommand have taken the difficult task of over throwing alien
rulers from this land. It is prime duty of those who have been
ruling this land for long time to lend their helping hand for thiscause because it will certainly strengthen their rule.
It was quite evident from above two letters written by Sayyad
Ahmed Shaheed that his intention was not to impose pristineform of Islam but his main target of attack was British
Government.Sayyad Ahmed Shaheed had to confront with the
sikh rulers in his initial phase of political struggle and wastragically killed at Balakote.With his sad demice his moment
suffered severe setback. His army got dispersed and division
crept into the rank and file of his army. However after his death
the Mujahidin had established their headquarter at Sittan(Sihan) in the Swat valley in the frontier from there they had
continued their fight with the help they received form
Hindustan.
Role ofUlama in the revolt of 1857
"If one read through the official and the British records of 1857
one gathers the vague impression that the Muslim revivalistgroup and the Wahabis in particular had something to do with
it. There are casual call for Jihad (Holy war) in almost all the
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
10/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan10
places, toFatwa (religious decree) of Maulavi, to the display ofgreen flag in important rebel center- all of which suggest a
certain Muslim revivalist coloring to the event of 1857." (K.M.
Ashraf Ahyae Islam Ke Hami Awar 1857 Ka Inqilab P. 86.Teanslated from Urdu)
Now the question is why the Muslim theologians' in particularand general Muslim masses were so active during the revolt of
1857. These factors need detailed discussion.
Religious causes for revolt- the rumors about the BritishGovernment. Secrete design of promotinge conversion to
Christianity had inflamed the heart and mind of the sepoy. The
Government-misionary nexus gave credence to the rumour forwhich Indian masses had become sensitive to this issue. In
some cantonments misionary were permitted to preach openly
about Christianity and their diatribe against other religions v.i.zHinduism and Islam was welknown that had anger the sepoys.
The reports about the mixing of pig fat in the flour and the
introduction of enfilled rifes had increased the sepoy growing
disaffection with the Government.
The reforming zeal of British officers under the influence of
utilitarianism had rose considerable suspicion, resentment anddiscontentment. The orthodox Muslim feared that by
government patronage and through social legislation the British
rulers were trying to destroy the religion and culture of theIndian. Moreover they believed that legislation was under taken
to aid the misionaries in their quest for evangelization. The
orthodox and religious therefore arrayed against the British.Particularly the Muslim theologians who had concern for their
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
11/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan11
religion, were seeing before their eyes that Islamic granduerwas losing its vitality. The last Mughal Emperor Bahadur Shah
Zafar was sadly watching the destruction of grand Mughal
Empire. The situation has come to such a sorry state of affairethat between Asar (late afternoon prayer) and Maghrib (evening
prayer) the Christian misionary Finder usesd to deliver speeches
about the Christianity at the gate of Jama Masjid Delhij. In hisspeech he was severally criticizing Islam and Islamic principle
(this is an excerpt from the report of Madarsa-e Saulatia Hind
Nidae A'am 1357 A.H.
In fact misionary Findar was not alone in his mision
topropagate Christianity but he had a band of Christian
misionary with him who were trying to convert entire Indiansubcontinent into Christiandom. This process represents the
unique mixture of religion and politics of which Muslims were
most sufferers.
To counter the growing influence of Christianity Maulana
Rahmatullah Usmani Kiranawi who was a prominent Isslamic
scholar aaand aaaalso descendent of Makhdum JalaluddinPanipati was in forefront to counter misionary Finder and his
missionary activities.
Maulana Kiranawi had started correspondence with misionary
Finder to assess his intellectual capability. Afterward he had
started religious debate with him in which respected Hindu,Muslim and Christian were invited as audience and also as a
judge.
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
12/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan12
The first Christian Muslim debate was held between MaulanaKiranawi and misionary Finder on 1270 A.H.By the blessing of
Allah Maulana Rahmatullah Kiranawi spoke for three days
against the latest Bible and human interpolation in it. He provedby citing nuemerous examples in his speech that latest Bible of
which entire Christians were proud of was completely
interpolated by the human agency.
The hapless misionary was helpless and had to submit before
Maulana Kiranawi's argument against Christianity. After facingthis humiliating defeat at the hand of Maulana Kiranawimisionary Findar was not seen again in India. The next debate
scheduled to be held could not be undertaken due to non-arrival
of missionary finder at debating table, therefore entire audiencegave their pronouncement against Christianity. (Ulama-e Haque
P. 33-34-35)
A respected rich Muslim from Agra published the entire
proceeding of this religious debater in a book form. The
Christian misionary bought this book on massive scale and tried
to dump it to ennsure that no single record of this proceedingcould be available to succeeding generationof the Muslum
ccommunity. However some copy of this precious book could
be found in many educated Muslim family of India.
To furthere counter the nefarious influence of Christianity
MaulanaRahmatullah kairanwi had writtene many books V.I.Z.Izharul Haque, Izalatul Awham, Izalatu-l Shukuk, Ejaze Iswi,
(Miracle of Jesus) Asahul Hadith Fi Ibtali-l Taslis, Baruqul
Amea etc.
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
13/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan13
Educational policy pursued by the British Government and
its effect on Muslim community
While Christianity was being spread freely during the Britishperiod, educational system too was also organized in such a
manner, which were detrimental to Muslim and Islam.
It should be noted that Lord Macauley while presiding over theeducational commity on 7 March 1835 had emphasized the need
for imparting education in English language. The main thrust of
educational policy formulated and persued by the BritishGopvernment in India was as follows "we should create agroup of educated people who would be channel of
communication between the British Government. and thousands
of coror of indigenous Indian masses. These educated peoplewould be Indian by colour but British by test (Ulama-e Haque
awar Unke Mujahidana Karname (P. 38-39)
The Muslims
Community was apprehensive that with the spread of English
education in India, Islamic education will received sever
setback because Chistianity and Islam was poles a part and nomeeting of mind between the two waring ideologies was
possible. In comparisoin to Hindu community, the Muslim
community was not mentally prepare to let their children remainunder the misionary influence under the garb of new
educational policy, because already Muslim were gradually
pushed backward. The British government was vehementlypushing ahead their educational agenda that can be summarised
as follows:
1- To create the hardened supporter of British Raj.
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
14/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan14
2- If Muslim would follow Quranic injuction, it was impossiblefor themto remain liyalto the British Raj. Therefore massive
effort was made by way of education to make Muslim
irreligious.3 The syllabus of education should be devised in such a fashion
that its readers would become an obedient slave of the British
Government. As a result respect for religion, and Ulama
(Muslim theologian) sense of nationalism and mutual co-
operation between the Hindus and the Muslim would acquire
secondary importance. The effect of this policy would be thatpeople would fight together. Thus divide between the Hindusand Muslim divide would become more eminent and British
would continue their policy of divide and rule.
The ill effect of British educational system was imminent
during the short span of time in all parts of the country. The
union jack was unfurled every where in the country. TheChristian misionary increased their activities on massive scale.
The destruction of Indian educational system and replacement
of it by the British system had disastrous consequences on the
young impriosonable mind of the Indian.
Taking into consideration the events described and discussed in
the preceding page, the general atmosphere of discontentmentthat prevailed during the first half of the 19 century and the
policy of annexation and exploitation carried on by the British
through that period, on can only conclude that the rebellion of1857 was accumulative effect of various social economic and
political causes. . The presence of foreign power which was
considered responsible for all these social upheavals hadawakened a sense of Muslimness in the Muslim community. As
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
15/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan15
a logical corolary to their sentiment. Muslim Ulama hadmobilized the public opinion for arousing anti-British feeling in
the name of religion and culture to which the Muslim masses
are most sensitive.
As for the Muslim, the rising of Indian Muslim in Vellor (1806)
the revolt of Faraidise in 1804 the peasants riots organized bythe Dudu Mian in the thirties and forties of the nineteenth
century, the movement led by Sayyed Ahmed Beralawi and the
activities of Mujahidin after him- all these happenings suggestthe deep suspicion, frustration and discontent. Among themwhose leadership went mainly into the hand of religious
reformer. Therefore we find a religious string also in the final
attempt in 1857 to drive the British out of India, and also largebody of Ulama who lead the masses and at various places
actually fought against the British forces and led the masses to
and all out war against the British Government. Therefore afterthe war the main targets of the British attack were the Muslim
and therefore many of them were publicly hanged and
prosecuted.
The tradition established by Sayyed Ahmed Shahid in (1781-
1831) of course with the blessings of Shah Abdul Aziz were
taken up and followed by their successors and those who werereligiously and politically oriented to them. In Delhi the famous
Fatwa declaring Jehad against the infidel foreigners signed by
the many Alim of repute and authority stirred a large number ofpeople to fulfill the obligation enjoined therein. In 1858 at
Lacknow the welknown trial of Allama Fadhle Haque
Khairabadi a very learned Alim educated at the feet of ShahAbdul Qadir (1826) the younger brother of Shah Abdul Aziz in
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
16/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan16
connection of his Fatwa suggest the magnitude of influence aFatwa could wield on the minds of discontent Muslims. In
Lucknow the famous Maulvi of Faizabad from all account can
legitimately claim to be brain and the hand of conspiracy. It canbe asserted with confidence that he was working in close co-
operations with the Wahabi group and the folower of Sayyed
Ahmed Beralawi (Ashraf Op. Cit. P. 87)
The Wahabi sentiment had permeated the heart and mind of
rugged soldiers like Bakht Khan who was the dominating figureof the revolt and the leader of central Government. at Delhi(Ibid Ashraf) he arrived in Delhi with a bend of Wahabi and
appointed his spiritual guide Maulavi Sarfraz Ali (Ashraf O. P.
C. I. T 98) as the Imam of the contingent of religious warriors(Mujahidin) numbering several thousands (Ashraf OPCIT P.
87)
Intizamullah Shihabi in his two treatises Ghadar Ke Chand
Ulama (Naya Kitab Ghar Delhi) East India Company Aur Baghi
Ulama gives a list ofUlama who were very active in the days of
1857 and played a prominent rule in providing the rebellion aconsistent anti British- ideology altogether with a religious
fervor which had sometime led people to read a revivalist trend
in this great Musslim upprising.
The founder ofDarul Uloom Deobandactively participated in
the rebellion and had organize the masses out side Delhi torevolt and for a while had succeeded in ousting the British
authority form the area where the were working.
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
17/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan17
Jehade Shamli (introductions)
Jehade Shamli and Thana Bhawan is an important milestone in
our freedom struggle. It was a major effort on behalf ofUlamaof Deoband to oust the foreign yoke from Indian soil. But
unfortunately there is non-availability of any authentic
document and reliables source material on this grand chapter ofMuslim historiography. Few books for instance (Tazkiratul
Rashid, i.e biographies ofMaulana Rashid Ahmed Ganguhi and
Maulan Ashique Elahi Mirathi, Sawaneh Qasmi i.e (biographiesof Qasim nanotwi) Hazrat Maulana Qasim Nanatawi byMaulana Monazir Ahsan Ghilani, Ulamae Hind ka Shandar
Mazi by Muhammad Mian and few books by Sayyed Ahmed
Khan and by some book written by English writers, we findsome reference about the Jehad of Shamli, but detail account of
this Jehad is not available to the readers of history. Among the
few prominent Ulama and Mujahidin who had written on thismonumental event, the name of Shaikh Muhammad Thanwi
who was an outstanding Alim and writer find special mention
among galaxy of writers.
By intellectual reasoning Maulana Thanwi was not mentally
prepared to jump in this war, but he had the company ofUlama
like Qasim Nanatawi before him whose decision to wage Jehad(holly war) against the British Government had been hailed by
the majority of Ulama who were gathered to deliberate upon
how to initiate the decisive holly war against the British forces(Jahade Shamli wa Thanabhawon P.3)
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
18/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan18
Background
The main inspiration behind Jehade Shamli and ThanaBhawanwas Qazi Enayat Ali Rais (feudal lord) of ThanaBhawan. When
the British Government publicly hanged his innocent younger
brothers and many friends of him. He had become furious andwas adamant to wage war against the British Government. His
voice was echoed by the Ulama of Waliullahi order, who had
already psychological hang over of Jehad in their mindstherefore were unanimous on the pronouncement that this war
would be regarded as full fledge Jehad, because atrocities on the
indigenous Indian population had reached to an intolerable
scale. Hence Haji Imdadullah Mahajire Makki and Hafiz ZaminAli led the Jehad in which thousands of their followers have
participated.
Qazi Inayat Ali, Haji Imdadullah Mahajire Makki and Hafiz
Zamin Ali belong to the Faruqi clan who have played
pioneering rule in initiating the revival of Islamic cultures andtraditions in the region of Thana Bhawan. His illustrous
ancestor, Qazi Nasrullah had come to settle here and acquiredprestigious positions during reign of Akbar the great. His family
had produced many outstanding scholars in academic field. LikeTaqiul Ulama (Pious Muslim theologian) Muhammad Sabir,
Qazi Muhammad Ali Thanawi and Muhammad Mukarram were
an authority on commentary on the Holly Qura'an. Few of themwere outstanding spritual personalities like Haji Imdadullah
Makki and Hafiz Zamin Ali Shahid, and few were highly
talented in administrative fields like Shaik Ahmed Faruqi, QaziKutbuddin and Qazi Nijabat Ali.
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
19/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan19
Due to extraordinary talent, the Mughal rulers appointed themembers of his family from very beginning on high positions.
In majority of cases judge and accountant were appointed from
this respectable family alone. A part from this, Mughal rulershad given them huge portion of land therefore they were
regarded among few big landlords of the country. Mughal rulers
had also conferred upon them with numerous titles. It isinteresting to note that during the decline of Mughal rulers this
family continued to be prosperous and respected one.
Till 1803 this family was associated with Mughal Empire. Butsoon after the decline of Moghal ruler, Lord Leak had
established his rule in the Doaba region and this family had
came under the influence of British Government. When Britishhad sway over this region Qazi Kutbuddin was the guardian of
this family. He immediately declared his loyalty to the British
Government. Which has resulted into status quo as far as hisprestigious position was concerned. Many top British officials
trusted him and sought his help. And within one year he was so
much trusted by the British Government. That when (Halkar
Deck) was escaping from Bharatpur battle ground and washeading toward Panjab to seek some help, in the way he was
chased by lord. At this critical juncture he had sought logistic
support from Qazi Kutbuddin in 1805. Maulana ShaikhMuhammad Muhaddis narrates this story in the following
words. "When in 1803 governor Gen. Leak s.b established
suzerainty of British Government. By defeating and oustingMaratha Jaswant Raw, he issued a Farman (decree) to Qazi
Kutbuddin that there was shortage of logistic support therefore
his prompt assistence was needed at this critical moment Inresponse to this request Qazi had sent him massive material
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
20/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan20
support. Governor Leak was very happy for this timelyassistance and had conferred him rewards and titles."
Due to his family assistance to Lord leak, East India Companyhad lavishly rewarded Qazi Kutbuddin s.b. After the capture of
Doaba by company Bahadur, Qazi Kutbuddin remain loyal to
the British Government. till his last breath. East India companyhad also recognized his loyalty and had conferred him various
titles. During the life time of Qazi Kutbuddin the relation
between Qazi Nijabat Ali (younger brother of Qazi Kutbuddin)and company Bahadur had been firmly established.
After this brief introduction it is apparent that till the occupation
of Doaba (Beasts of earth) region by the Britsh Government. In1803, the friendly and mutual cordial relations between Faruqi
family of Thanabhavan and British had continued until
1857,and there was no single small incident by one party whichhave caused rupture of this agreement. To our surprise when
great rebellion of 1857 had started on 10th of May 1857 from
Meerut, its effect was felt in nearby cities and region. But
Thanabhavon was quite peaceful till August 1857. Feudal lordof village Thanabhavon Qazi Inayat Ali by exerting his
influence had created complete social harmony and did not
allowed single disturbing incident to take place which wouldhave led to social chaos. Business of life was going on as usual
and all credit for this could be attributed to Raiees of
Thanabhavan Qazi Enayat Ali.
Keeping in the mind such peaceful situation in Thanabhavan
every body could be amazed why suddenly every body in thevillage suddenly set a side all previous agreement turned hostile
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
21/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan21
to the British Government. . That too when strength of theMujahidin was getting weaker and in Delhi and the British
Government. was getting upper hand. Even resident of Shamli
was feeling helpless. If people of Shamli had any intention tojump in the war they would have started during the initial phase
of the revolt. In order to understand the sudden out break of
Shamli against the British Government. We should delve deepto know the causes and also we have to see who firstly violated
the agreement. It was Ulama orBritish Government?
In order to understand this great upheaval in proper perspectivewe have to understand the geographical contiguity among
Delhi, Thanabhavan and Saharanpur. The centrality of
Saharanpur, it's administrative and on going revolt in the nearbyareas should be kept in mind.
Presently Delhi is national capital of India and also an
autonomous state. Meerut, Thanabhavan, Shamli and
Saharanpur are important cities of U.P. Meerut was the
headquarter of all these commisionaries and has two district
v.i.z Saharanpur and Muzaffarnaghar. Thanabhavan and Shamliare two important villages of Muzaffarnaghar district, which are
located on the main railway line between Saharanpur andShehadra. There is also many important and famous villages
located on this line viz Rampur, Minharan, Nanota and
Jalalabaad. Before the outbreak of revolt in 1857 scenario wasquite different. Uttar Pradesh had no existence and all the cities
and villages were part of Delhi. Saharanpur was like an
autonomous state. There were thirty-six Mahal in it. Among
them was one Thanabhavan. This geopolitical setup hadcontinued from the reine of Akbar the Great. That was the
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
22/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan22
reason we find detail description of this village in themagnumopus book: Ainae Akbari: written by celebrated wrier
Abul Fazal. But the name of Thanabhavan in this book has been
written (Thanabhim). Before the outbreak of war in 1857 therewas no railway track that was reasion why Saharanpur, Rampur,
Thanabhavan, Shamli and Muzaffarnaghar were connected by
Grand National highway grant trunk road built by great Bihariruler Sher Shah Suri. This road was only means of
transportation by Vehicle, horse and other means of
transportation. Saharanpur was adjacent to Punjab therefore ithad acquired the status of military cantonment. All the armyrecruited at Punjab were stationed at Saharanpur and were
dispatched to the various places whenever situation demanded.
The collector of Saharanpur had wide-ranging military powertherefore naturally he has become an arrogant dictator.
When revolt had started on 10th
of May 1857 at Meerut thisnews had reached to Saharanpur on 12th of May 1857. Next day
all the children and women of the British officials were sent to
Dehradun as precautionary measure. After that the news of
revolt had reached to Delhi. Gozars and Ranghrod had takenfull advantage of the situation and had started looting in the
rural areas. Following this incident the security of the
Saharanpur was tightened and massive forces were deployed on21 of May 1857. The Gozars and Ranghord had assembled at
south of the Pargana Saharanpur and had looted British treasury
at Halni too. To counter the growing deterioration the Britishofficials along with massive military force had arrived at the
scene. The magistrate had with him twenty police and 39th
regiment when Gozar (name of martial cast of this sub-continent) and Ranghord saw these massive British forces they
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
23/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan23
had started running away and had thrown out all their booty onroads and fields. By that time all the prisoners at Meerut who
were fleeing from prison cell were arrested at Saharanpur.
Before this incident the British Magistrate had ask for help fromcommisioner of Ambala Here he found assistant commisioner
Mr. William Chechli who had come to Joghedhri. By that time
he had arranged some military forces and crossed the JamunaRiver. On 30th of May 1857 the Magistrate of Saharanpur along
with Mr. Plodon, Mr. Trench, Mr. Edward, Mr. Ravarts, Captan
Eed and Captan Gristan had launched a massive attack onvillage Mangnore. Gozars inhabited this village, and Umrawsiwas their village head. When the British forces had launched
attack all the villagers had run away due to fare. The British
forces had set a blaze entire village on fire. After that they hadarrested some villagers.
When bloody war was going on in the adjoining areas ofSaharanpur, Shamli and Thanabhavan was quite peaceful.
About the Shamli we can speculate that relation between its
Zamindar Mahars singh and Tahsildar Ibrahim Khan was not
cordial and doubt was expressed that former was havingcorrespondence with the king of Delhi. However this story may
had been fabricated by Ibrahim Khan as he was hostile to
Meharsi singh, and if we accept this story as true this was apersonal affairs of Raees of Shamli and it had nothing to do
with the Raees of Thanabhavan Qazi Enayat Ali. Thanabhavan
was itself very peaceful due to personal effort of Qazi EnayatAli. The reluctance of Qazi Enayat Ali to fight with the British
Government could not be presumed that he was pro-British and
loyal to British authority therefore he had no religious zeal dueto his inherent weakness. But we can say that when he had
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
24/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan24
raised the banner of revolt against the British authority theentire world was surprised at his religious zeal and sense of
nationalism. He not only compelled the British authority to eat
humble pie at Thanabhavan and Shamli but had also giventough fight to the British forces at Bijnor. No body could drive
wrong meaning by this sudden outbreak of Qazi Enayat Ali
against the British government that his action was dictated byself-interest. Because before entering into war against the
British Government. he had maintained peace in the
Thanabhavan and Shamli on four grounds.
1. The elder brother of Qazi Enayat Ali's grand father andgrand father Qazi Nijabat Ali had agreement with the British
government for the last fifty years that they would remainloyal to the British goveernment.
2. And only due to this agreement both these two persons hadeasy access in the British Darbar (court) and were frequently
conferred with honor and titles.
3. The father of Qazi Enayat Ali Qazi Saadat Ali had renewedhis loyalty to British government in 1856. He had also beenemployed as judge by Company Bahadur of Deoband.
4. After the death of his father, Qazi Enayat Ali had keptintact his agreement with the British intact.
5. After the death of his father, Qazi Enayat Ali had kept oncarrying the agreement reached by his father and the British
Government.
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
25/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan25
Those who understand the important of agreement in Islamwould have certainly hailed Qazi Enayat Ali for his attitude
towards the British Government. It was his sheer devotion to
Islam, which Islam by which guided him. In fact he wasemulating prophet Muhamad (pbuh) in this matter. As we now
that prophet had entered into the agreement with the Jews of
Madina and had kept his agreement intact until aagreement wasviolated by Jews themselve.
After the war of Badar, (Battle of Badr) Banu Qainqa (Tribe ofBanu Qainqa) had misbehaved with our prophet as well as otherMuslims. And when prophet had made conciliatory effort with
them the Jews had not only misbehaved with the prophet but
also were adamant to wage war against the Muslim. Thisincident had resulted into war of Banu Qainqa during the period
of second Hizri.And after the war had ended the prophet had
kept the previous agreement with Banu Nasir. And also tried torenewed his previous agreement. But Jews kept on carrying out
their ancient and traditional rivalry with the Muslim and Islam.
On one hand they had kept the prophet engage in formulating
agreement, on the other hand they were hatching conspiracy toassassinate him. Therefor due to these entire treachery prophet
was compeled to wage war against the Jews and war driven
them away from Madina. In the affaire of Banu Quraiza samething had happened. Initially agreement was sign between Banu
Quraiza and Muslim, that if Madina was attack they would be
party along with the Muslim to defend it. But during the war ofGhazwae Ahzab (Battle of Ahzab) in fifth A.H. they had
clandestinely entered into alliance with the invading forces and
had put the Muslim under unprecedented danger. By that timetheir conspiracy had met with failure due to war strategic tactic
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
26/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan26
and wisdom of Prophet Muhammad (pbuh). However after warthe prophet following with the commandment of Allah, had
surrounded entire village of Banu Quraiza and all the people of
their tribe were killed for violating agreement with the Muslims.Prophet Muhammad had followed the same method with the
idolater of Makka after the treaty of Sulhe Hudaibia. (The treaty
of Hiudaibiya)
Keeping in mind the Sunnah of Prophet Muhammad, (Religious
rite ordained by the Holy Prophet) Qazi Enayat Ali fullyadhered to the agreement made with the British officials. Hetried his best to maintained peace in those areas, which were
under his sphere of influence. And due to his personal influence
not a single violent incident had taken place against the Britishofficials. Though fierse fighting was ensuing in adjacent area of
Thanabhaon. Also the inhabitant of Thanabhaon were
completely unaware that in their region war was going on andeven the king of Delhi was participating in it. In the village, life
was normal and marriages and other social program was being
celebrated without any disturbance. Even the Aqiqa (Party
thrown on seventh day of after new birth in the family)programme of newly born child of Qazi Enayat Ali's younger
brother Qazi Abdur Rahim was being celebrated with religious
fervor. No body could anticipate that this happy celebrationwould turn into a tragic one. The villagers were celebrating
birth of newborn child of Abdur Rahim at Thanabhaon and in
Saharanpur child fathers the British officials were executingQazi Abdur Rahim. The moment the news of his execution had
reached to Qazi Enayat Ali that his younger brother had been
publicly hanged he lost his sense and had become like mad.And this was quite natural because he had already lost his two
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
27/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan27
brothers and even his father had died one year ago. This was hisonly brother who was his right hand for him, but sadly British
forces had killed him mercilessly. The news of his killing had
spread to his village and all the members of his family werewailing and lamenting. But Qazi Enayat Ali's condition was
most critical. He was repeatedly saying that I would avenge the
killing of my brother. The entire family members of him wereadvising him to exercise restrain. Particularly his Uncle Qazi
Muhabbat Ali advised him not to play with the fire. But Qazi
Enayat Ali was adamant to fight with the British Government.Therefore he had angrily declared "I would not tolerate theatrocities of the British Government even for one minute I
would fight with them till my last breath. Either I would finish
them or they would finish me. Some elderly people of thatregion had narrated to Shamsul Haque Siddiqi, the author of
Jehade Shamli and Thanabhaon that Robert Spinsky had come
to know that few innocent peoples had been killed by the Britishforces and that Qazi Enayat Ali was adamant to revenge against
the killing of his innocent younger brother. Therefore he had
tendered his apology in order to preclude him from undertaking
war against the British government. For this purpose he hadsent massage to Qazi Enayat Ali which was as follows "I have
unintentionally killed your younger brother and I am sorry for
that. You keep patience and do not take any step, which woulddisturb the peaceful situatione. You keep quite I will gave you
enormous property and also accept you as a Nawab of
Thanabhaon".
But Qazi Enayat Ali had firmly decided not to step back. Haji
Imdadullah Mahajir Makki and his colleges who were inspiredby the great warrior like Sayyed Ahmed Shahid and Shah Ismail
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
28/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan28
Shahid had motivated and encouraged Qazi Enayat Ali toinitiate war against the British government. To deliberate upon
how to start war against the British government. they had
convened a meeting of Ulama at Thanabhaon in which allprominent Ulama of surrounding region had assembled. Few
outstanding Ulama who had attended this meeting were v.i.z
Haji Imdadullah Mahajir Makki, Hazrat Hafiz Zamin AliShahid, Hazrat Maulana Shaikh Muhammad Muhaddis, HazratMaulana Qasim Nanatwi, Hazrat Maulana Rashid Ahmed
Gangohi, Hazrat Maulana Muhamad Ihsan, Hazrat MaulanaMuhammad Ahsan and Hazrat Maulana Mazhar etc.
At the meeting of Majlise Shura two important issue came up
for discussion i.e.1 To start a full fledged war against with the British government
and
2 Weather this war would be regarded as fledged Jehad (HollyWar) or not.
During the deliberation upon these two crucial issues minor
differences have cropped up among the Ulama. Since fewUlama had express concern over the meager availability of
resources (war material, logistic support). They though that the
power of the British Government. Had expanded to such anextent that much powerful Government. (Principality
feudatories) were helpless before them. The British forces had
human resources as well as logistic support. And as far as warexperience was concerned they have no paralell. Under this
situation, to jump in the war at mere assurance given by some
feudal lord that they would extend their help during war was nota wise act. Because Muslim were armless and defeat was
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
29/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan29
imminent. This was the first objection raised. And according toMaulana Ashiq Elahi Meeruthi Maulana Shaikh Muhammad
Muhaddis had raised this objection (P 32 Jehade Shamli wa
Thanabhawan).
Who so ever had raised this objection, Maulana Qasim Nanatwi
had replied this objection in the following words "do we haveless power and war materials than Ashabe Badar (fighters in the
battle of Badar)" this sentiment of Maulana Qasim Nanatawi
obviously meant that a Muslim Should not rely upon theavailability of resources only (war material and logisticsupport).
In fact Maulana Qasim Nanotwi had silenced all dissentingvoice by this comprehensive one line sentence. After settling
first issue the second issue came up for deliberation was,
weather this war would be regarded as Jehad or not? On thiscontroversial issue Maulan Shaikh Muhammad Muhaddis
expresses his opinion in the light of Islamic teaching and said,
"we kept quite until Muslims in different regions were fighting
against British Government. to save Muslim and Islam. Nowthe British forces had killed some people and we were sseeking
revenge (though it is inevitable) then how we can term it as a
Jehad. Maulana Ashiq Elahi had not given any reference aboutthe objection raised by Maulana Shaikh Muhammad neither he
had hinted at who were other participant in the Majlise Shura
who had out rightly rejected his view. Also there is notavailable reliable historical record to refer what answer was
given to Maulana Shaikh Muhammad Khan. However we can
only anticipate that Maulana Qasim Nanatwi would havereplied as follows. "In stark violation of all previous agreement
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
30/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan30
the British Government. had executed many innocent Mulsimstherefore we are not under any obligation to abide by the
agreement. So we will wage war to avenge against the British
Government. To avenge the killing of our innocent Muslimbrothers and this would be regarded as Jehad (Holly war) He
sighted the example of Jange Mauta when Prophet Muhammad
(pbuh) had to wage war due to assassination of his emisary.
According to the statement of Maulana Ashiq Elahi that after
this short deliberation Ulama were unanimous on the decisionthat jehad (holy war) should be waged against the Britishgovernment. to establish an independent Islamic regime in the
village. If any body put hurdle in our objective of establishing
Islamic rule we would fight with them and this war would beregarded as full fledged Jehad".
After the decision was reached for undertaking Jehad againstthe British British, now the question arose that who will lead in
Jehad for the establishment of an Islamic Govternmen. Maulana
Manazir Ahsan Ghilani sheds some light in his voluminous
book: Sawaneh Qasmi; He wrote "Maulana Tayyeb, grand sonof Maulana Qasim Nanatwi recalls that Maulana Shaikh
Muhammad s.b Thanawi was disciple of Hazrat Muhammad
Shah Ishaq Muhaddis who had expressed excuse that if I acceptyour logic for initiating Jehad then importance of Imam would
acquire central importance. Therefore you tell me who is Imam?
Who will lead us in Jehad? Theses questions were askedaccording to Islamic tenets but reply came promptly from
Sayyedina Imamul Kabir Qasim Nanatwi who had said "there
was no problem in appointing an Imam.And it seem that afterhis candid reply this issue needed no much attention according
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
31/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan31
to Imamul Kabir. Perhaps his colleagues were thinking that thisissue would become complex about that but they were stunned
to know its easy solution. But inevitable had had happened and
Imamul Kabir suggested that all of us should do Bait at the handof Hazrat Murshide Barhq Haji Imdadullah s.b and immediately
after the Baait (Ritual for accepting a desciple oath of
allegience) Haji Imdadullah s.b was appointed as AmirulMu'minin (The Commander of the faithful)
After the formation of Majlise Shura they declaredindependence from the British government and had establishedan Islamic government. Haji Imdadullah Mahajir makki being
an Amir took central position of all administrative affaires in his
hand. Maulana Rashid Ahmed Gangohi and Maulana QasimNanatwi were appointed his assistant. At the end of village there
was some military barrack in which some British employ were
residing. They were promptly thrown out and barrack wasvacated from them. According to Maulanan Ashiq Elahi this
interim Islamic governmentt. had decided some cases according
to Islamic Sharia.
All these activities were going on in village Thanabhawon and
it is understood that the British government. knew about it. But
they had not paid any attention to it and had concentrated theirall attention at Shamli, Budhana and Muzaffarnagar. May be
they had regarded the affair of Thanabhaown as an insignificant
one, to be dealt with subsequently.
To know about the sequence of event regarding Jehade Shamli
and Thanabhawn we have many reliable source materials like
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
32/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan32
mutiny records, correspondence Tazkiratul Rashid and LailMuhammad.
According to series of events the incident of Bagh Sher Ali kaSarak come first. This incident had soon taken place after the
formation of Majlise Shura and after the establishment of an
Islamic state in Thanabhawan.
According to mutiny record Henry Malcolm, assistant
magistrate had presented report to Lieutenant W.T Hargai firstcommander of Panjab cavalry on 20
thof September 1857. He
wrote in the report that "as per instruction received from
Spenski we along with a bend of people left from Ram Kundi to
Muzaffarnagar, Shamli on 1857 Ath Mahe Rawan Me. In ourband following people were accompanying. One native official
thirty Dafadars and fourty five cavalries. I had separated one
Dafadars and five cavalry and assigned the duty to carryout theluggage and arm and ammunitions. I had also instructed the
people of this band to follow the same route, which I had
followed. But I felt sad to explain that the Tahsildar at Deoband,
partly due to wrong instruction and partly due to unawareness tothis region led this band from Thanabhawan route to Shamli.
Though this route was straight and shortcut but difficulty was
that at this place (Thana route) people had raised banner ofrevolt and were fiercely fighting against the British governt And
whenever any band of the British forces was passing from
Thana they were attacked from rebel who had alreadyassembled at this place. In this attack the leader of band (Risala
Sardar Partap Singh was killed and all our arms and
ammunition came under their control). Our men fought withgallant but were defeated because our enemy had nuemerical
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
33/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan33
strength and compratively powerful than us. ( Jehad Shamli andThanabhawan. P. 37-38.)
After this crushing defeat at the Thanabhawan, Henry Malcolmhad tentatively on 9th or10th of September 1958 led his
remaining troops via Muzaffarnagar to Shamli. Those British
forces that had survived at Thanabhawan had also joined them.These remaining forces might have been communicating this
news to British officials who were stationed at Shamli. The
prominent British officials who were stationed at Shamli wereHenry Malcolm, Collector of Muzaffar Nagar R.M. Adward andjoint magistrate C. Grant.
Now the question arises in our mind that why were allprominent British officials were stationed at shamli? And at this
critical juncture collector and joint magistrate both had left
district headquarters and was present at Shamli? To understandthis complex situation we should know the prevailing condition
of Shamli by that time.
Those days when momentous event of our history was takingplace, Shamli was the headquarter of Muzaffarnagar Tahsil and
also a thriving business centre. The Hindu constitutes the large
chunk of populations and Mehar Singh was an influentiallandlord of this village. Mehar Singh was not on good term with
another feudal lords of adjacent village, Ibrahim Khan. Mehar
Singh was under constant threat of rebellion from IbrahimKhan. And it was quite possible that due to enmity with Mehar
Singh Ibrahim Khan could have sent fabricated report about
Mehar Singh to the collector of Muzaffrnagar. This false reportcould might had served as threat and British officials were
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
34/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan34
compelled to take precautionary measure for their safety. Atseveral time the collector of District Muzaffarnagar had send
joint magistrate at C. Grant to Shamli for some administrative
arrangement. After the revolt of 1857 had come to an end theBritish Government. had recognized the service rendered by the
Ibrahim Khan. Mr. C. Grnat had issued a certificate to the son
of Ibrahim Khan in which they had hailed the service of IbrahimKhan. The citation of certificate reads as follows. "Particulay
during the initial phase of revolt we went from Meerut to
Shamli we stayed there for two days in the month of June, 12days in the month July and for 14 days in the month ofSeptember. During the stay of C. Grant in the month of
September at Shamli Mr. Edward had sent him arms and
ammunition and tanks. And after four days he had himselfarrived at Shamli. During his presence at Shamli Henry
Malcolm had sent him massive military forces from Saharanpur.
This way Shamli was virtualy converted in to a militarycantonment. And majorities of British officials were deployed
there.
It was a trouble time for the British Government becausesimultaneously they had to fight on several fronts. In the nearby
village (Hur Hur) people had raised banner of revolt. Several
British police have been in adjacent fort of Budhana and leaderof rebel Khairat Khan had established Tahsil in his own name.
Shamli also had become uncontrollable for the British
Government. (J.Sh.W.Th.Th. P.41)
The British officials were surprised by this sudden upheaval and
were busy in dealing with this complex situation. Meanwhilethose fighters who had escaped from Thanabhawan reached to
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
35/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan35
Shamli and conveyed full detail of the affair to the Sheir Ali.Sheir Ali was very angry at this incident and had withdrawn
from war sport. And was too busy to take any disciplinary
action or punish the people of Thanabhawan. Therefore he hadpostponded his disiplinary action and kept on working about his
previous programmes.
This was the prevailing condition in Shamli but Mujahidin
were not careless about the presence of British officials in
Thana. They were quite certain that British officials could turnto Thana Bhawan at any time to revenge theire previous loss.Therefore they clandestinely kept vigil on the movement of
British forces. When (Mujahidin) were about to make futuree
advancement towards the British officials, they were waiting sothat British army could advance towards Budhana and before
they could attack Thana Bhawan the Mujahidin would attack on
Shamli with all ferocity to destroy and weaken the centre ofthere power.
Henry Malcolm had narrated this story in the following words.
He said "Our forces had joined Mr. Edward at Shamli on 10th
ofSeptember and then we proceeded towards village Hur Hur,
where people had raised banner of revolt. When we had reached
to Hur Hur no one resisted and our forces easily surroundedentire village and arrested many of them. Governmental
property and arm and ammunition, which they had previously
looted, were recovered from them. After this adventure, whenthey were returning back to Shamli, a band of rebellion had
attempted to snatch away our arms and ammunitions. But
Dafadar Latif Khan along with four hundred cavalries hadfought bravely with them. The rebel had run away from the
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
36/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan36
battle of ground. And only one rebel was killed and another onewas arrested, who was letter on hanged".
All these minor incident of fighting was on with the Britishforces. But full fledge war with brutal force had started on 14th
of September 1857, at Shamli and all prominent Mujahidin like
Zamin Ali Shahid, Rashid Ahmed Gangohi, Maulana QasimNanatwi, Haji Imdadullah Muhajir Makki, Qazi Enayat Ali and
Maulana Munir Nanatwi had participated. Hafiz Zamin Ali
Shah, who was maternal uncle (khalu) of Qazi Inayat Ali waskilled by the British Army and breathed his last in the lap ofRasheedAhmedGangohi.Another great warrior Maulana Qasim
Nanutwi had fought with the British forces with all ferocity. He
along with Rasheed Ahmed Gangohi had acted as thecommander of the Mujahidin in this great battle.
Maulana Muneer Nanutwi following the instructions of HajiImdadullah Makki was personal guard of Qasim Nanutwi
during fight with British forces.
Haji Imdadullah who was Imam of this Jihad had migrated toMacca after the collapse of this uprising. His role in this battle
could be written in golden letters.
A part from prominent Ulama thousands of common masses
belonging to Shamli had also fought along with these Ulama in
this jihad, simply because Fatwa to fight against the Britishgovernment was issued by the outstanding Ulama of that
period. And also because despite many weaknesses, Muslims of
that period were filled with religious fervor and it was quite
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
37/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan37
certainly that majority of them would have taken part in thisgrand battle.
According to Henry Keen "Jihad of Shamli had continued forfull day. Mujahideen (Muslim freedom fighters) and their co-
fighters had numerical strength' therefore they had temporarily
tilted balance of war in their favour." (P.54 Jihad-e Shamli)
In this full day war One hundred and thirteen British armies had
been killed and Mujahideen had also suffered heavy loss of life.Though great Zamin Ali Shah was assassinated but Mujahideenhad attained their goal and had gain upperhand over the British
forces. All the army officials and staff had to flee from the area
and no one except one wounded British police had survived.The edifice of British war centre was destroyed and Mujahideen
had emerged victorious. (Jihad-e Shamli and Thana Bhawan
p.3-7-8-9-15-16 -17-18-21-22-23-30-31-32-33-34-35-37-39-40-41-42-47).
Darul Uloom Deobandand its role in the freedom
movement.
Deoband is a small town in the district of Saharanpur U.P at adistance of about ninety ninety miles from Delhi. Here in 1867
a small Arbic Maktab was raised to the status of Darul uloom
which soon began to attract the attention of students and loversof Islamic learning from far and near. Established within ten
years after the unsuccessful uprising of 1857 when bitter
frustration prevailed everywhere and futuree seemed dark andappallingly discouraging. It was undoubtedly a bold venture.
The guiding sprit of this venture was Maulana Qasim Nanutwi
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
38/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan38
who had already fought in the battlefield of Shamlin 1857.Thepart played byDarul Uloomin the religious, social and political
life of the Indian Muslims can be legitimately interpreted in
terms of the aims and objectives that lay behind the action of itsfounders during the days of rebellion. Shamli and Deoband are
as matter of fact, the two sides of one and the same picture. The
difference lies only in weapons. Now the pen and tonguereplaced the sword and spear. There at Shamli in order to secure
political independence and freedom of religion and culture,
resort was made to violence. Here at Deoband a start was madeto achieve the same goal through peaceful means.
Thus for the cause of religious politi cal freedom individuals
were produced. The roads though divergent from each other, ledtowards the same destination ie freedom of the country.
Deoband and freedom struggle
The founder of the Darul Uloom Deoband(Collage of rthodox
Islamic learning) represented the rebellion sprit of the
disgruntled Muslim, who since the days of Fraidiyah movementhad been manifesting their uneasiness and dissatisfaction in one
way or another, with state of affair created by establishment andperpetuation of a foreign rule in India. They were not going to
surrender before the resultant suffering after their suffering in
1857 and recoil into a fatal activity. They were fully conscious
of the fact that the British rule, now more powerful than beforewas not going to spared them in their efforts to leave up to the
standards of their religious and cultural heritage. Nor did they
believe in policy of compromise and appeasement. Yet theywere to march and they marched forward independently,
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
39/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan39
rejecting all official interference and depending entirely onDivine assistance and the sincere religiosity of their brethren.
So with these two pronged objectives in their mind i.e toeducate their brethern and complete the unfinished agenda of
rebellion1857 they fully cooperate with the newly emergent
Indian National Congress in 1885. Maulana Rashid Ahmed
Ganguhi who succeeded Maulana Qasim Nanatwi as the Ameer
Mohtamim (Rector) of Darul Uloom Deoband showed
progressive tendency in the field of politics while giving aFatwa declaring that in worldly matters cooperation with theHindus was permisible provided it did not violate any basic
principles of Islam. The occasion for thisFatwa arose with the
establishment of the Indian National Congress in 1885 and SirSayyed vigorous stand against it. This was a crucial point and it
created the political conflict between the traditionalist and the
modern Aligarh. It has been pointed out that in principle that thefounders of Darul Uloom were not opposed to the acquisition of
modern education ation by the Muslim Muslim but were
opposed to pernicious effect of english education on the Indian
for which they had fought vigourouslyduring the initial phase ofthe British Raj
The formation of Indian National Congress in 1885
and Ulama support to it
Seventy-two political workers founded the Indian National
Coingress in December1885. It was the first organized
expression of Indian nationalism on an all India scale. A. O.Hume, a retired English ICS Officer, played an important role
in its formations.
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
40/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan40
The foundation of the Indian National Congress was not asudden event, or a historical event. It was the culmination of a
process of political awakening that had its beginning in the
1860 and 1870 and early 1880s. The year 1885 marked aturning point in this process, for that was the year the political
Indian, the modern intellectuals interested in politics who no
longer saw them selves a spokesmen of a narrow group interestin politics but as a representative of national interest Visa-a-Vis
foreign rule as a national party saw their effort bear fruit. The
All India Nationalist body that they brought in to being was tobe the plate form, the organizer, the headquarter, the symbol ofnew national sprit and politics.
Before the formation of the Congress Indian politicians wereindividually complaining in the house of common (England)
about their grievances and complain but their appeal fell on deaf
ear. Their uneasiness grew day by day and now they approachedwith their problem to viceroy Dufferin. Here too their
grievances were not given a patient hearing. Instead Lord
Dufferin replied. Until now all of you are complaining about
your grievances in individual capacity. Why did not you forman organised group and collectively present your case before the
British Government. Therefore Indian National Congress was
set up in 1885, and its first session was held atBombay.Members of all casts, race, religion and sex were given
membership of the congress from its inception. In the first
session of Indian Congress at Bombay 78 members hadparticipated in which two Muslims, three Bengalis and
numerous Hindu and Zoroastrian of Mumbai had participated.
On behalf of Mumlim community the famous Muslim merchant
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
41/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan41
Seth Rahmatullah Sayani had participated. This first sessionwas presided over by Surendas Nath Banerjee.
The formation of the Indian National Congress was also awatershed event in our history because before its establishment
in 1885, The Indian had suffered unprecedented loss. British
forces had perpetrated all kinds of atrocities on Indian masses.Many freedom fighters were blown by tank, many were
trampled under the feet of elephant and innumerable people
were hanged. Common Indian masses in general and Muslim inparticularly were under shock and fear psychosis therefore theywanted to come out from this disaster. The Indian National
Congress had provided a forum from where they could ventilate
their genuine greivances. So after the first session of Congresspeople become conscious that there could be another way to
achieving independence. Therefore within short span of time the
Indian National Congress had registered phenomenal rise in itsmembership.
Therefore when second session of Indian National Congress
was held in 1886 at Calcutta under the presidentship of DadaBhai Noroji its membership had increased tremendously from
78 to 436 (within one month) in which 33 were Muslim
members. And when third session of the Indian NationalCongress was held in 1887 at Madras under the presidentship of
Badruddin Tayyebji its membership had gone up to 604 in
which Muslim members were eighty-three. It was quite naturalthat British officials were alarmed at this growing strength and
popularity of the Indian National Congress. Particularly Mr.
Beck (principal at Aligarh College) and other British officialsand staffs had become extremly worried for this national
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
42/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan42
concious. Therefore they tried theire best wanted to break theunity of the Indian National Congress. For this purpose Mr.
Beck had established (The Indian patriotic association)
(Anjuman Muhibbane Watan) Mr. Beck started tirade againstthe Indian national Congress by writting a series of articles
against the Indian National Congress. He had undertaken tours
at several places in India and had delivered public speechesagainst the Indian National Congress. He also pressurized Sir.
Sayyed Ahmed Khan to act against the Indian National C
ongress as a result Sir. Sayyed Ahmed khan had became anti-Congress. Now Sir. Sayyed came under the spell of Mr. Beckand started preaching Muslim community not to join Indian
National Congress. Sir SayyedAhmedKhan echoed his thought
and fervently appealed to the Muslim community to join Indianpatriotic association and show their allegiance to the British
government. He vehemently appealed to the common Indian
Muslim that participation of Muslims in the politics washarmful. He had persuaded few like minded Ulama to issue
Fatwa that participation of Muslims in the Indian National
Congress was Haraam (illegal) and it was a supreme duty of
Indian Muslim to join Indian Patriotic association. All theseanti- Congress activities of Sir. Sayyed Ahmed Khan continued
till 1888. Now Ulama of Deoband became active to counter Sir.
Sayyed Ahmed Khan anti Congress posture. Maulana RashidAhmed Ganguhi, Maulana Mahmudul Hassan and other
theologion of Deoband and Muslim from different parts of the
country opposed Sir. Sayyed Ahmed Khan and issued Fatwaagainst him. They had collectively issued Fatwa supporting
Muslims participation in the Indian National Congress and
barring them from joining the Indian Patriotic Association.Those Maulana who were in forefront to apposing sir sayed
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
43/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan43
Fatwa were Ulamai-Ludhiana Maulana Mohammed saheb andhis two brothers Maulana Aziz Saheb and Maulana Abdulllah
saheb.
They Had collected Fatwas against Sir sayyed from different
part of the country and compiled it in a comprehensive book
form v.i.z Nusratul Abrar.Maulana Mohammed Saheb in hisFatwa justified by his vehement argument that the participation
of Muslims in the Indian National Congress was permisible and
that they should keeping away from Indian patriotic association,which was founded by an English officer. For a reference theFatwa given by Maulana Rashid AhmedGangohi can be cited
in Nusratul Abrar page No. 19-20,26 and the Fatwa given by
Maulana Mohammed Hasan saheb and the fatwa of Ulama ofDeoband in page No. 23-24,Maulana Mohammed and the
Fatwa given by his two brothers can be cited on page No. 13-
19. In fact Nusratul Abrar containFatwa given by one hundredIndian Ulama in support of Muslim joining the Indian National
Congress and against Indian patriotic association. (Note Ref-
Indian struggle for Independence p.70 Naqshe Hayat, p 69, 70,
71.Nusratul Abrar)
It is also interesting to not that the Indian National Congress
during its initial phase of its formation was only confined toholding rallies and presenting memorandum to the British
government. On the other hand the Ulama of (Deoband) were
engaged in preparing plan and strategy and in envisagingstrategy to launch a comprehensive offence against the British
Government.
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
44/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan44
Shaikhul Hind Maulana Mahmudul Hasan and his
role in the Freedom Struggle
Maulana Mahmudul Hasan was educated at the feet of
reknowned and great Ulama of Deoband like Maulana QasimNanwatavi, Rashid Ahmed Gangohi and Haji Imdadullah
Makki. He was a favourite desciple of all these Ulama.
Maualana Mahmudul Hasan had spent several years under the
tutelage of those Ulama who were war hero of rebellion of1857. It was only due to bravery and supreme sacrifice of this
Ulama that the hold of British Government was weakened and
to a great extent completely wiped out from Shamli andThanaBhawan. Therefore Throughout their life anti-British fire
was burning in their chest and it was quit natural that Maulana
Mahmudul Hasan had to follow the path set by his ancestorsand kept anti-british activities throught his life to end the British
rule in India. Maulana Mahmudul Hasan had struggled against
the British government under very unfavourable and difficult
circumstances. He was sorrounded by such persons who weresecretly working for British interests had surrounded him and
no body could had even thought and dared to work against the
British government. The political scenario was so disccouragingthat even to talk about home rule and autonomy was considered
to be a great crime in the eyes of British government. He was
constantly under fear psychosis and great shocks because CIDwas after him and his own people had been conspiring for his
arrest Therefore firstly he had started preparing like-minded
people around him but soon he was disillusioned with Ulama
and Mashaikh. (Saintly guide) That was prime reason why hehad started brainwashing firstly to his students and Mureeds.
(Follower) Maulana Obaidullah Sindhi was his favoured
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
45/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan45
disciple who had responded to his call under very tryingcircumstances. Maulana Mahmudul Hasan had determinations
to complete the unfinished task of 1857. For this purpose he had
inspired thousands of his disciples at Deoband to fight againstthe British government. For this purpose he had formed
Samratut tarbiyah in 1878. This organisation was a training
centre for young students who were filled with patriotic fervor.In this organisation plans and strategies were devised how to
throw out foreign ruler from this country.
The first batch of students who had received military training inthe Samratut Tarbiyah (Fruit of upbringing) was students from
Punjab and Afghanistan. After receiving military training they
had started anti-British movement in the frontier region and hadplayed pioneering role for arousing nationalistic feelings among
tribesmen. (Aseeran-e- Malta, P. 8, 9)
Maulana Mahmudul Hasan wanted to achieve independence of
the country by the active support from all sections of Indian
society. Therefore he was assisted in his mision from
Mujahidin, Ulama and non-Muslim revolutionaries. MaulanaHussain Ahmed Madni wrote about Malana Mahmudul Hasan
that he had hired a permanent home near his residence that was
popularly known as kothi (Bunglow). The frequent visitors tothis house were those who were non-Muslim friends and
revolutionaries working with shaikhul Hind. These
revolutionaries were stayin here secretly and the Shaikhul Hindarranged all their arrangement like food etc. Many of these
revolutionaries had secret meeting with him and it was assumed
that these people were mainly Sikh Bengali or Hindurevoloutionries. At this meetings secrecy was top priiority
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
46/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan46
therefore their name is not known. However, it is assumed thatthey were mainlly mainly non-Muslim revoloutionaries.
Besides this there were thousands of anonymous freedom
fighters working with him which require detail discussion .Apart from Deoband branch there were five branches which
were known as under (1) Dinpur Shareef (2) Amrot Shareef (3)
Karachi Khadah (4) Delhi and (5) Chakwal.At all thesebranches people were working sincerely and were known as the
president of their branches. (Chiragh-e Muhammad p. 121)
(Naqshe Hayat vol.2 p.208-9)
Besides these numerous branches at home there were various
branches working abroad as well i.e Tokyo, China, Paris and at
Washington etc. From these revoulationary centres variousnewspapers and magazines were published. But important point
was that Shaikhul Hind Maulana Mahmudul Hasan was
supervising all these activities.
The late professor Karam Haidery had summed up the
independence struggle of Maulana Mahmudul Hasan in the
following words. He wrote "after the revolt of 1857 and duringthe beginning of 20th century an independent organisation v.i.z
(Ghadar party) was formed which was operating under the
guidance ofUlama of Deoband Maulana Mahmudul Hasan. Thevery name Ghadar party was pointer to the fact that the Ghadar
of 1857 was a bold step by the Indians and they were proud of
it. In the ghadar party there were nuemerous prominent MuslimUlama like Maulana Muhammad Ali, Maulana Shaukat Ali,
Maulana Obaidullah Sindhi, Maulana Abul Kalam Azad and
Maulana Maqboolur Rahman. This organisation consisted ofmany great Hindu freedom fighters like Mohandas Karam
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
47/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan47
Chand Gandhi, Moti Lal Nehru, Lala Lajpat Roy, BabuRajindra Parshad and Mr.Hardyal who are regarded as hero of
our freeedom struggle and now theythey have truely become
historical personalities. .But the fact remained that Ghadar partywas spearheaded by Musim Ulama.Its programmes and policies
were formulated by them and all great Hindu freedom fighters
were mere activists(political activists of this party )
The Islamic Character of ghadar party was also evident by the
fact that for its publicity in foreign countries it had publishedmany newspaper and magazine which were modeled on Islamicpattern. For instance a bilingual i.e English and Japanese
magazines were published from Japan.Its name was Islamic
fraternity Society and it was published by the same organisationthat was founded by professor Barkatullah. A magazine was
also published under the auspiece of Ghadar party. An
association was found in Paris which was publshing a newspaper v.i.z Inqalab. Likewise the Ghadar Party was publishing
two newspaper from Washington v.i.z Ghadar and Inqalab.
The Ghadar party had fixed february 19th
1915 to start broadbased rebellion againsst the british government But due to
ongoing second world war the British government was
maintaining strict surveillence against its enemy, thereforeplanned revolt had little chance of success. Therefore all
prominent rebels who were operating outside India were
arrested by the active support of allied power of the Britishgovernment And all stalwart were interned in the island of
malta. After serving rigorous imprisonment they were released.
(Pag 122 Charagh-E -Mohammed. Mohammed Ali JinnahSeerat aur kirdar by prifessor Karam Haidry Merhoom)
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
48/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan48
Maulana Mahmudul Hasan and Hindu-Muslim
joint effort for Indias independence.
Before departing from India to Hijaz Maulana Mahmudul
Hasan was well aware with the international political scenarioas wel as prevailing political tussle among various nations. But
fortunately when he was interned at Malta he had acquired
political maturity by entering into dialouge and discussion with
the revoloutionaries from the different part of the world. Theworld war had left many Islamic countries weaker and weaker
and they were desperately trying to wriggle out from this
devastating situation. Turkey that was once famous for braverywas termed as sick man of Europe. During the internment at
Malta Maulana Mahmudlul Hasan was entering into political
dialogue or interacting with the fellow presioners who hailedfrom different countries. Therefore when he had returned to
India he had set two necessary condition to be followed during
the future course of the freedom movement. Firstly, the struggle
for freedom movement should be confind within the countryand for this purpose all sections of Indian society should be
brought together for this noble cause. This was also imperative
because after the Jalianawalan massacre at Amritsar the Hinduswere willing to co-operat with Muslims. And this cooperation
was seen during the khilafat agitation when all prominent Hindu
leaders comprising M.K. Ghandhi had rallied around theMuslim Community to restore Ottoman Empire in Turkey.
Though at this auspicious occasion Maulana Mahmudul Hasan
was fully aware of the political situation in the country.
Therefore Hindu Muslim joint effort was close to his heart butat the same time he wanted non-interference in the religious
affairs of each other. Therefore despite serious aillment he had
8/2/2019 The Role of Muslims in India
49/218
Ulama Freedom Struggle And Concept Of Pakistan49
presided over the second session of Jamiat Ulama -e-Hindwhich was held at Delhi on Nov.19-2-1919.He had sent
Maulana Shabbir Ahmed Ushmani to deliver his presidential
adddress. The