43
IPMU 2016 1 The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) Fabrizio Arrigoni Battaia (ESO) S. Cantalupo (ETH) J. Hennawi (MPIA) J. Xavier Prochaska @ IMPS @ UCSC Camille Leibler (UCSC/IMPS)

The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    6

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 1

The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN)

Fabrizio Arrigoni Battaia (ESO)

S. C

anta

lupo

(E

TH

)

J. H

enn

awi (

MP

IA)

J. Xavier Prochaska @ IMPS @ UCSC

Camille Leibler(UCSC/IMPS)

Page 2: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 2

Rise of the Proto-Galaxy System in the Universe

Fabrizio Arrigoni Battaia (ESO)

S. C

anta

lupo

(E

TH

)

J. H

enn

awi (

MP

IA)

J. Xavier Prochaska @ IMPS @ UCSC

Camille Leibler(UCSC/IMPS)

Page 3: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 3

A brief aside...

Page 4: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 4

The Cosmic Web

Page 5: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 5

The Cosmic Web

Page 6: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 6

The Cosmic Web

Page 7: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 7

The Cosmic Web (aka IGM)

Page 8: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 8

Resolving the Universe's Web

Page 9: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 9

The Baryonic Halo (aka CGM)

log Tgas [ K ]

4.4 6.3

4.5 5.0 5.5 6.0

Nelson+15

Page 10: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 10

How does this gas fuel galaxies?

Agertz+12

Page 11: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 11

What 'Quenched' these Galaxies?

Bell+Faber+

Page 12: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 12

What 'Quenched' these Galaxies?

Feedback No Feedback

Page 13: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 13

What 'Quenched' these Galaxies?

Feedback No Feedback

Page 14: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 14

Quasars 'Tag' Massive Galaxies

White+12

Page 15: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 15

Quasar Halo Mass

White+12

Page 16: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 16

Quasars Probing Quasars (QPQ)

Hennami+05

Page 17: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 17

Quasars Probing Quasars (QPQ)

HennamiProchaska

30kpc - 1Mpc

f/gQSO

b/gQSO

Page 18: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 18

Quasars Probing Quasars (QPQ)

HennamiProchaska

Strong HI Lya absorption from gas at the f/g quasar.

Page 19: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 19

Quasars Probing Quasars (QPQ)

HennamiProchaska

Strong HI Lya absorption from gas at the f/g quasar.

Page 20: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 20

Quasars Probing Quasars (QPQ)

Hennami, Prochaska

Strong HI Lya absorption from gas at

the f/g quasar.

Page 21: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 21

Quasars Probing Quasars (QPQ)

HennamiProchaska

Strong HI Lya absorption from gas at the f/g quasar.

Page 22: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 22

Quasars Probing Quasars (QPQ)

HennamiProchaska

Strong HI Lya absorption from gas at the f/g quasar.

Page 23: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 23

Quasars Probing Quasars (QPQ)

HennamiProchaska

Page 24: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 24

Massive Galaxy: Gaseous Env.

Their CGM is likely fueling SF

Page 25: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 25

So what 'Quenched' these Galaxies?

Feldmann+15

Feedback No Feedback

Page 26: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 26

Slug NebulaC

anta

lupo

+14

Keck/LRIS

Page 27: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 27

Lya Blobs

Page 28: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 28

Enormous Lya Nebula (ELAN)C

anta

lupo

+14

Page 29: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 29

Enormous Lya Nebula (ELAN)

Page 30: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 30

Science with ELAN

Internal: How common are ELAN,i.e. what is their role in galaxy formation? What astrophysics dominates the emission?

Page 31: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 31

Science with ELAN

External (CGM/IGM): What are the CGM kinematics? What is the CGM metallicity? What governs CGM astrophysics? What is the morphology/extent of the CGM?

Page 32: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 32

Slug Nebula – Clumping

Page 33: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 33

Jackpot Nebula (ELAN)

Hennawi+15

Page 34: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 34

Jackpot Nebula (ELAN)H

enn

awi+

15

Do ELANe 'tag' proto-clusters?!

Page 35: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 35

MAMMOTH-1 ELAN

Cai+16b

Page 36: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 36

MAMMOTH-1 ELAN

Cai+16

Page 37: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016 37

MAMMOTH-1 ELAN

Cai+16

Page 38: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016

ELAN at z>3

Page 39: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016

ELAN at z>3

See also QPQ4

Page 40: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016

Future Paths: More Protoclusters

Z. Cai(preparing for a Hawaiian hurricane at Subaru)

Page 41: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016

Future Paths: KCWI

Martin+Shipping in October

Page 42: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016

Future Paths: Numerical

??+

Page 43: The Rise of Enormous Lya Nebulae (ELAN) · 2016. 9. 8. · IPMU 2016 Summary Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)

IPMU 2016

Summary● Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive

and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in absorption (QPQ)– 1011 Msun, ~1/3 solar– Fuel for future SF– Highly improbable that quasars quench galaxies

● Massive galaxies hosting quasars exhibit a massive and enriched reservoir of cool gas, in emission (ELAN)– Illuminating the CGM and nearby IGM (d>300 kpc)– Kinematic characteristic of dark matter halo potential

(FWHM ~ 500 km/s)– Lya Luminosity and absence of HeII imply clumpy, dense

(>102 cm-3) gas not currently captured by hydro simulations