34

The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    3

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with
Page 2: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with

Theproblem:whatsetsthesizeoftheACC?Stommel1957,1962:EarlymodelsadaptSverdrupdynamicstotheACC,relaEngwindstresscurltotransport.MunkandPalmen,1951:Suchmodelsrequire‘uncomfortablylarge’valuesofeddyfricEoncoefficientstolimittheACCtransporttoreasonablevalues.Gill1968:LinearmodeloftheACCrequiresaboRomfricEoncoefficentof103cm2/salateralfricEoncoefficientof108cm2/s.

Page 3: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with

Theproblem:whatsetsthesizeoftheACC?Stommel1957,1962:EarlymodelsadaptSverdrupdynamicstotheACC,relaEngwindstresscurltotransport.MunkandPalmen,1951:Suchmodelsrequire‘uncomfortablylarge’valuesofeddyfricEoncoefficientstolimittheACCtransporttoreasonablevalues.Gill1968:LinearmodeloftheACCrequiresaboRomfricEoncoefficentof103cm2/salateralfricEoncoefficientof108cm2/s.Evenworse:howbig*is*theACC?ReidandNowlin,1971:Eastwardtransportof237SvthroughtheDrakePassageFoster,1972:Westwardtransportof15SvthroughtheDrakePassage(backwards!)InternaEonalSouthernOceanStudies(ISOS)programmeasuresDrakePassagetransport,structure,dynamics.NowlinandKlinck,1986:134Sv+-10%(eastward),withEmevariabilityof20%.

Page 4: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with

NowlinandKlinck,1986:134Sv+-10%(eastward),withEmevariabilityof20%.

ACCcharacterisEcs:-  NOTanarrowjetorboundary

currentwithwithRo

-  ThreenarrowfrontalregionsofwidthtwoorthreeEmestheRossbyradius

-  ThecurrentpenetratesdowntotheboRomofthewatercolumn,withsubstanEalmeridionaldensitygradientsatdepth.

Page 5: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with

McWilliamsetal.,1978:A2-layer,eddy-resolvingQGmodeloftheACCwithvariousconfiguraEonsoftopographyandwindforcing.Inallmodelruns,eddiesplayedakeyroleintransporEngzonalmomentumdownward.Inmodelrunswithouttopography,fricEonwasonlystrongenoughtoholdmodeltransportvaluesaround400-600Sv.Inmodelrunswithtopography,topographicformdragwasstrongenoughtolimitthemodeltransportto100Sv.BoRomandsidewallfricEonisnotenough!Thus:

Page 6: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with

Steadystatezonalmomentumbalance:

NoEngthat:

Wecanwriteeqn(1)as

and

(eqn1)

Page 7: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with

TakingtheverEcalintegral:

Page 8: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with

TakingtheverEcalintegral:

Page 9: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with

InthecircumpolarregionoftheSouthernOcean,integratedzonalmomentumbalancebecomes:

Momentumsource:FricEonalwindstressatthesurfaceofthefluid

SOSE mean τx [N/m2]!

Page 10: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with

InthecircumpolarregionoftheSouthernOcean,integratedzonalmomentumbalancebecomes:

Momentumsource:FricEonalwindstressatthesurfaceofthefluidPotenEalmomentumsinks:1)  FricEonalstressattheboRom;

SOSE mean τx [N/m2]!

Page 11: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with

InthecircumpolarregionoftheSouthernOcean,integratedzonalmomentumbalancebecomes:

Momentumsource:FricEonalwindstressatthesurfaceofthefluidPotenEalmomentumsinks:1)  FricEonalstressattheboRom;2)  FricEonalstressatthesidewalls,viameridionalmomentumfluxdivergence;

SOSE mean τx [N/m2]!

Page 12: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with

InthecircumpolarregionoftheSouthernOcean,integratedzonalmomentumbalancebecomes:

Momentumsource:FricEonalwindstressatthesurfaceofthefluidPotenEalmomentumsinks:1)  FricEonalstressattheboRom;2)  FricEonalstressatthesidewalls,viameridionalmomentumfluxdivergence;or3)  Topographicformstress.

SOSE mean τx [N/m2]!

Page 13: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with

Topographicformstress

Page 14: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with

Howdoesmomentumtravelfromsurfacesourcetoseafloorsink?Interfacialformstress.

Page 15: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with

Howdoesmomentumtravelfromsurfacesourcetoseafloorsink?Interfacialformstress.

geostrophycontinuous stratification

and

0 = �T

0

✓z

1

⇢0

@p

0

@x

= fv

0

0 = �T

0

✓z

1

⇢0

@p

0

@x

= fv

0

Page 16: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with

Interfacialformstress:

VerEcalfluxofeastwardmomentumisproporEonaltoeddyheatflux.

Polewardheatfluxcorrespondstothedownwardfluxofeastward

momentum.

Page 17: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with

Givenafewnumbers…….thismodelcanbetestedobservaEonally.

Page 18: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with
Page 19: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with

1977DrakeClusterArrayFDRAKE75Mooring8

FDRAKE75Mooring10

Page 20: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with
Page 21: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with

ObservaEonsusedtotest

Page 22: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with

SOLIDLINE

Page 23: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with

Secondtest:Candown-gradienteddyheatfluxbeparameterizedintermsofEme-averagedbaroclinicfieldsalaGreen(1970)andStone(1972)?

Page 24: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with

ObservaEonsusedtotest

Page 25: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with

SOLIDLINE

DOTTEDLINE

Page 26: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with

EsEmaEngtransport

SOLIDLINE

DOTTEDLINE

Page 27: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with

EsEmaEngtransport:

=

SeqngeddyheatfluxesEmatesequaltoeachother:

AllowsustocalculateEmeaveragedACCverEcalshear:

FromwhichwecanesEmateanACCtransport:

.

Page 28: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with
Page 29: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with
Page 30: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with

Fordiscussion:theauthorsassumethattheRHSisjustasevenlydistributedastheLHS.IsthisareasonableassumpEon?

EKEfromsurfacealEmetry,2003-2013.Sheenetal.,2014.

Windstress(N/m2)fromNCEPreanalysis,1980-2000.MarshallandSpeer,2012.

Page 31: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with
Page 32: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with

ZoomintoDrakePassage:cDrakeExperiment,2007-2011.

1977DrakeClusterArrayFDRAKE75Mooring8

FDRAKE75Mooring10

Page 33: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with
Page 34: The problem: what sets the size of the ACC?pordlabs.ucsd.edu/wryoung/theorySeminar/pdf16/Pres3_Masich.pdfMcWilliams et al., 1978: A 2-layer, eddy-resolving QG model of the ACC with

Pressure (dbar)!

cDrakespaEalandtemporalvariability.

VerEcal,EmemeanIFS. TimemeanIFSprofiles.