112
The Pacific Institute for the Mathematical Sciences http://www.pims.math.ca [email protected]

The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

The

PacificInstitutefor the Mathematical Sciences

http://[email protected]

����������� ����������������� ��������� �"! # �%$'&)(+*-,/.1032546�7."8)9�4;:'< #=8>4@?A0B$DC E 8F.HG�*JI+8)K

L M�N O M�L O P

Q-RTSVUXWYR[Z\U]R_^a`cbed�f�ghAi[jlknmporqtsumHvxw-y"z{j[|�yYj_}�mt|�~� |1��z�|�j_j[s�z�|�����j_}�j_m1suy_i�����qt|�y"z�vx������mt|�m�~tmhAi[j���v���j�s3o�m�w�y"z{j[|[y�j�mH|[~���j_}�j_m1suypi)�Dqpori��Hs�z�oB�hAi[j ��s�z�oXz{}ri ����v�qt����z{m ��|1�V��sB��mpo�z{��|���w�y"z{j[|�yYjmH|[~lh�j_ypit|[��v����t��� �tj[|�yY�

¡ b[¢¤£¥R_^�g�Q�¦¨§�RYU]`�©xªJZ"¢¤«T`¬^­U�¢®£;f¯R�°�± ¢³²�£´Rp^;¢³µ

Page 2: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

����������� ������� ��������� � ������ � ���! #"�$%� &(' )

&*�+# ��,�-���."�$/�����10#$2�43 )!�5$76+����� �1��89�-���1:

;=<?>A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP�C7NZ>X@\[]B_^�`a>cb�@7BDCd>fe

gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwvx(y qHz,{7|~}�po{����F����q�n��\q�j�{�n.rJ�?n��2��n�q\q�po��n�����q�joq�{7po� y gLh�}�n��\���Oh���g�{�n�{�r�{

x(y q�����s_q�pm|~{����\��q�n��\q-{�n.rJ��q\jmq�{�pm� y ��}F| y h2pm��|ktx(y q��Lpo��|~��j y gLh2��}.�=s���{=�knF�Xh2po��{7|~��h2nO�.�F�\��q\n���qH{7n�r x q�� y n�h2��h2��t�����q\n���t

� {�n�}�{�p�t2�_�� 2 � 

Page 3: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

�������������� ��������������� ���������! "�����#"$%$'&)(*&)(,+.-/$%0.1�$'&)(�243658793;:=<?>=@A$/- � +CB�DE>?$'-/(,+CFG&H24-'0CIJ-'+CKL+.-'(M$/&=( � :N$'(O:=@ �QP (*R"(O(OSNTUBQ0J:)IWV)-'0CX)BY(OKZ@A0JB P[� :)I�R"0C-'S[@/&)0JV=@� : � $ � +.$/(,<\R � $/&\$'&)(]+ � K^0.1_FO-/(,+`$ � :)Ia+aK�>?$'>=+.BYBYbcXd(e:)(�fdF � +CBMB � :)ScXg(�$6R"(O(O:h-/(,@A(,+.-GFG&)(O-G@ � : � :=<?>=@A$/-'bc+.:=<i+CFO+J<?(OK � FK�+`$'&)(OK�+`$ � F � +C:=@ejlk(,@A(,+.-GFG&)(O-G@�R � $/& � :=<?>=@A$/- � +CBd+C:=<�F�0JKmKW(e-'F � +CB=F�0J:=F�(e-/:=@n+.-'( � : P[� $'(e<m$'0*V)-'(e@/(O:N$40C:)(%0.1o$/&)( � -"F�>)-'-'(O:N$$/(,FG&): � FO+CB�V)-/0JX)BY(OK�@p1q0C-!@A$/>d<?b � :�Rr0J-/S � :)Im@/(e@'@ � 0J:=@pR � $'&�BQ(,+C< � :)I�@AVg(eF � +CB � @A$'@"1q-'0CKs$'&)(*+CFe+C<?(eK � FMF�0JKWK�>): � $6bCjr#%@FO+C:Xg(*@A(e(O: � :9$'&)(e@/(MV)-/0?FO(O(e< � :)IN@Ot?V=-/0JX)BQ(eK�@pKW+ubvF�0CKW(w1q-'0CKx+mR � <?( P +.- � (O$6by0.1�@/>)X?z6(eF�$%+.-'(e+J@Ot[X)>?$%@/&)0J>)BY<9Xg(*+.KW(O:d+.X)BY($/0WK�+`$'&)(OK�+.$ � FO+.B{Km0?<?(eB � :)I�+.:d<9+C:=+.BYb?@ � @ej2436587|&)(eBY< � $'@mf=-G@6$�3;:=<)>=@6$'- � +.B2n-/0JX)BQ(eK}7[0CB P[� :=I8~�0C-'S?@A&)0JV � :�#%>)IC>d@6$��,�C�N��+`$y�%�!�Ej4�=0CBYBQ0`R � :)I8$/&)(H@/>=FOFO(e@'@0.1r$/& � @�R"0C-'S?@A&)0JV�t � $*Rp+C@M<?(,F � <?(e<8$'09K�+CSC(m362r7[~�+.:]+.:):[>=+CB424365�7�( P (O:N$M+C:=<�+9@/(eFO0C:=<80C:=(��[(e�N>=+CBQBYb�@A>dFOF�(,@/@A1q>)B��Rp+C@m0C-'IJ+C: �Q� (e< � :�5�+ub\�,�C�C�8+`$�$'&)(H�!: �YP (e-'@ � $6ba0.1��"+CBQIN+.-'bCj��p& � @WbJ(e+C-et"+.V)V)-'0u� � K�+.$/(OBYb|�C�81�+CFO>)BQ$6bCtnVg0J@A$'<)0[F�$/0J-'+CB1q(OBYBY0`R!@Ot"IC-G+C<?>d+`$/(H@A$/>=<)(O:N$'@y+C:=< � :d<?>=@A$/-'ba@/F � (e:N$ � @6$G@yFO+CKm(�$'0CIJ(�$/&=(O-y+`$�$'&)(��!: �QP (O-G@ � $6b�0.1M� � F�$'0C- � +81q0J-�$/&)(��p& � -G<2436587y3;:=<)>=@6$'- � +.B�24-'0CX)BY(OKL7[0JB P[� :)IW~80J-/S?@/&)0CV�1q-/0JKx5�+uby�=�w$/0y�J>):)(M�=t��,�C�C�=j7 � �*V)-'0CX)BY(OK�@lRr(e-/( � : P (e@A$ � IJ+`$'(e<*+.$�$/& � @lbC(e+C-e� @�Rr0J-/S?@/&)0CV�j��p&)(rV=-/0JX)BQ(eK�@�R"(O-'(rFO0C:N$/- � X)>?$/(,<�X[bW �¡'¢.£�¤Q¡�¥4¦.£¨§)¦.£/¢`©¨ª�¦`«¬ ¥{­[ª�®G¢O¯N¦G°u±l²w ?³v´d¡G®'­?«g¦`¤Y¦/¯Cª�¡�µ ¬,¶ ª�®�©;¦`£�ª�¢�°u±!¥�­=¢`£�¤Q¡�µw·_¦`¸n¢`£'¹v¢.«g¹WºwµGµO¦e®Oª�¢`©;¡�µ ¬u¶ ª�®�©;¦`£�ª�¢�°,±!¥{­=¡�»�¡/¼y½�¢C¾�µ ¬u¶ ¢`«o®G¦`¿?À`¡�£U°u±

Á ¡�£'¢e ¬ ¥4¢.¤ ¯J¢.£�ÃG°u±w+.:d<�Ä"«o¾�£�ª�¹e¯J¡ ¬ ¥4¢`¤ ¯N¢`£�ÃG°CÅi�)-'0CKÆ$'&)(��N>=+.B � $6ba0.1%$'&)(e@/(�V)-'0[FO(O(,< � :=IJ@ � $ � @�F�BY(e+C-m$/&=+.$�@ � IC: � fdFe+.:N$V)-'0CIJ-/(,@/@�+C:=< � :d@ � IC&N$�Rp+C@�KW+J<?(y0J:|(e+CFG&|0C1p$/&)(vV)-/0JX)BY(OK�@Oj�3;:=<)>=@6$'-/b�-'(OV)-'(e@/(O:N$'+.$ �YP (,@M&=+ P (y(O�?V)-/(,@/@/(e<]@'+`$ � @A1�+CF�$ � 0C:R � $/&9$/&)(�0J>?$'FO0CKW(M0.1l$/&)(�R"0C-'S?@A&=0CV�j�p&)(y@/>=FOFO(e@'@�0.1p$'&)(�2436587�3;:=<?>=@A$/- � +CBn24-'0CX=BQ(eKÇ7[0JB P[� :)I�24-'0CIJ-'+CKÈ&=+C@�Xd(e(O:�F�-'>=F � +CB�$/0H$'&)(�<?( P (eBQ0JV)KW(O:N$*0.1p$/&=(É (O$6Rr0J-/SW0C1��r(O:N$'(O-G@r0C1�Ê��)FO(OBYBQ(e:=F�(M5H36�l#%�p7oË)�p&)(�5�+`$'&)(OK�+.$ � FO@"0.1l3;:?1q0C-'K�+`$ � 0C:9�{(,FG&):)0JBQ0JICbW+.:=<H�r0CKWV)BY(��v7[b?@A$/(eKW@É (O$6Rr0J-/S�R& � FG& � @*F�>=-/-'(O:N$/BYbH$'&)(�BY+C-/IJ(e@A$�-/(,@A(,+.-GFG&�:)(O$6Rr0J-/S � :a�"+.:=+J<)+v$/&=+.$�F�0JKmV=- � @A(,@MKW0C-'(_$'&=+.:��,�JÌv-/(,@A(,+.-GFG&)(O-G@� :HÍC�m>): �YP (O-G@ � $ � (,@Oj��p&=+C:)S?@"$/0m$/&)(*2n365�7�0C>?$'-/(,+CFG&9V)-/0JIC-G+.K�t?ÍCÍ_V)- �QP +`$'(�F�0CKWV=+C: � (e@p&=+ P (w+CBQ-'(e+J<?b�F�0J:N$/- � X)>)$/(e<vKW0C-'($/&d+.:�ÎJ�`�J�)t �C�C� � :N$/0�$/&)(H��5�36��#%�p7�V)-/0Cz6(eF�$'@_BQ(,<�X[b]$/&)(�2436587�@'F � (O:N$ � @6$G@Oj|5H36�l#%�p7aR � BYBpXd(e:)(�f)$W1q-'0CKÆ+�1q(e<?(e-'+CB� : P (e@A$/KW(O:N$0.1�F�BY0J@/(w$/0�Î[�e�=jÏÌ*K � BQB � 0C:�0 P (e-n$'&)(�:)(��[$1q0J>)-bC(,+.-G@Oj2436587yBY0[0CS?@"1q0C-'R"+C-'<�$/0�FO0C:N$ � :[> � :=IW$/&)(�3;:=<)>=@6$'- � +.B�24-'0CX)BY(OKx7?0CB PN� :)IW~�0C-'S[@/&)0JV�7[(e- � (e@et?R � $/&�$/&=(�:)(��[$!0C:=(M$/0�Xg(&)(eBY<8+`$w$/&)(��!: �QP (O-G@ � $6b�0.1r#%BQXg(O-/$'+ � :��C>=:)(WÍC�C�J�)jM5H0C-'( � :?1q0J-/K�+`$ � 0J:�+.Xg0C>)$w>)VoF�0JK � :)I�+CF�$ �YP[� $ � (,@w+.$M2n365�7�K�+ubHXg(1q0C>=:=<90C:v$/&)(�R"(OX�V=+CIC(Cto¸�¸�¸nÅ §oªÐ»�µOÅY»�¢`©q­)ÅЮG¢CÅ~�0C-'S[@/&)0JV=@9B � SC(]$'& � @�+.-'(�0J:)BYbhVg0J@'@ � X)BY(]$/&)-'0C>)IJ&h$'&)(�<?(,< � Fe+`$ � 0J:Ñ+C:=<Ò&=+.-G<iRr0J-/S\0C1mK�+C:NbÒ24365�7i@'F � (O:N$ � @6$G@Oj24-'0.16j4�=-'+C:)Sak>d@ASJ(ObCtr$/&=(�24365�7�7 � $/(�Ó � -'(eF�$/0J-�+`$W$/&=(��!: �YP (e-'@ � $6b�0.1M� � F�$'0C- � +=trÔM(OBYBYb��r&)0[0=tr$/&=(�24365�7�#%<)K � : � @6T$/-G+`$ �QP (E#E@/@ � @A$'+C:N$p+.$r$'&)(��!: �YP (e-'@ � $6bW0C1�� � F�$'0C- � +_+.:=<vÓ%-,j?Õ*j)Õ%>=+.:)IdtN$/&)(w1q0C-'KW(O-p24365�7y3;:=<?>=@A$/- � +.B��=+JF � B � $'+.$/0C-r1q0C-�!�+.BYBoRr0J-/SJ(e<W$ � -'(OBY(e@'@/BQbW1q0J-r$'&)(�@A>dFOF�(,@/@r0.1�$/& � @pR"0C-'S[@/&)0JV�jl7[Vg(eF � +CBo$/&=+C:)S?@"IC0_$/0W24-'0.16j4�r&)- � @p�"0J@/(%1q-'0CK$'&)(��!: �YP (e-'@ � $6b0.1�� � F�$/0C- � +WR&)0W$/0[0CS9FG&=+.-'IC(M0C1�FO0CKWV � B � :)I�+C:=<9(e< � $ � :)I�$'&)(e@/(*V)-'0?F�(e(e< � :)IJ@ejn3pR"0C>)BÖ<�+.BÖ@A0�B � SC(M$/0y$/&=+C:)S�$'&)( É +`$/>=-'+CB7?F � (e:=F�(,@�+.:d<�Ê4:)I � :=(O(O- � :)I�k(e@/(e+C-'FG&a�r0J>):=F � B"0.1E�"+.:=+J<)+)tl$'&)(v#%BQXg(O-/$'+�7)F � (O:=FO(v+.:d<�k(e@/(e+C-'FG&|#%>?$/&)0J- � $6bCt�+C:=<]$/&=(�"- � $ � @/&��r0CBY>)K_X � +_3;:?1q0J-/K�+`$ � 0J:�t?7?F � (O:=FO(�+.:=<v�{(,FG&):)0CBY0CIJbm#%IC(e:=F�bW1q0J-p@/>)V)Vg0C-/$ � :)IW24365�7�+.:=< � $G@pK�+.:[bWV)-/0JIC-G+.KWKW(e@ej

ÓE-ej É +C@'@ � 1�×w&=0C>=@'@A0J>)X�t)Ó � -'(eF�$/0J-2�+CF � fgF%3;:=@A$ � $/>)$/(�1q0J-p$/&)(*5�+.$/&)(eK�+`$ � FO+CB{7?F � (O:dF�(e@

Ø

Page 4: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

�Y�

Ø

Page 5: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� �����������

�)0J-/(eRr0J-'<yXNb�$/&)(*2n365�7vÓ � -/(,F�$'0C-�j�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �Ên< � $'0C-,� @p24-'(�1�+JF�(�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �� ������������������������ !�#"$�&%'���)($*+��,-� ./102�)�3��45,6�+��45�3�879�:4;���#�<�)���=�+�?>A@��$���B�C�D45*9EF4G�#����HJIJ�#�#�K,6� ���Í?jY� 3;:N$/-'0?<?>=F�$ � 0J:�j j�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �J�Í?jÏÍ �lBQ0`R � :v~]+`$'(O-%Ó � @A$/- � X)>?$ � 0C: É (�$6R"0C-'S[@ejÑj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �uÍ

Í?jÏÍ?jY� É (�$6R"0C-'SyF�0CKWVg0C:)(e:N$'@ejxj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �uÍÍ?jÏÍ?jÏÍ Õ%b[<)-'+C>)B � FM@ � K�>=BY+.$ � 0C:=@ej�j�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �e�Í?jÏÍ?j � �r0J:J$G+.K � :=+.:N$p$/-G+.:=@/Vg0C-/$ej�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �e�

Í?j � �p&)(MLON:PRQJSGT8@A0JBQ>?$ � 0J:9+CBQIJ0C- � $'&)K�j j�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �uÌÍ?j �)jY� LON:PRQJSGTl� @B � K � $G+`$ � 0J:=@OË�-'( P (O-G@A(VU=0`R�jrj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj ��W

Í?j � #!:d+.BYb[@ � @p0.147 � KWV)BY( É (O$6Rr0J-/S?@ejhj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �`�Í?j �=jY� Ê4�?+JF�$!@/0CBY>?$ � 0C:v1q0C-!FO0C:N$'+CK � :=+C:J$!U=0`R jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �`�Í?j �=jÏÍ 3;BYB�TUVg0J@/(e<?:)(,@/@p0C1 � : P (O-G@/(wV=-/0JX)BQ(eK 1q0C-!@ � KmV=BQ(MBY0N0JV=@ej�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �,�Í?j �=j � 3;BYB�TUVg0J@/(e<?:)(,@/@p0C1{1q0J-/Rp+.-G<yV)-'0CX=BQ(eK9j_jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj ÍC�Í?j �=j � 7[0JB P[� :)Im$/&)(�3;: P (O-G@A(M24-'0CX)BY(OK�jjMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj ÍJÍ

Í?jÏÌ 7[>)KWK�+.-'bv+C:=<9�)>?$'>)-/(*Ó � -/(,F�$ � 0C:d@Oj]j�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj ÍJÍ. XY@$45*+�C�ZI�02�)�3�#���)*! [�;�\>A@�*��#�C]_^54G����45($*+�`%'�:�)(D*��K,6� /�a�)jY� 3;:N$/-'0?<?>=F�$ � 0J:�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj ÍJÌ�)jÏÍ �p&)(*5�+C-/SJ0 P �r&=+ � :H5H0?<?(OB�j�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj ÍbW

�)jÏÍ?jY� 3;:N$/-'0?<?>=F�$ � 0C: j�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj ÍbW�)jÏÍ?jÏÍ �p&)(*5�0[<)(OB�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj ÍbW�)jÏÍ?j � 2�0N@6$G@/FO- � V?$|j�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj ÍN�

�)j � �p+ubC(,@ � +.:9�r(eB � (�1 É (O$6Rr0J-/S?@�j�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj ÍC��)j � 5H>)BQ$ �YP +.- � +.$/(_�r0J:J$'-/0JB{�r&=+.-/$'@HjMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj ÍC�

�)j �=jY� 2n- � :=F � V=+CB��r0CKWVd0J:)(O:N$!#!:d+.BYb[@ � @^j�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj ÍC��)j �=jÏÍ �r0J:?fd<?(e:=F�(�k(eI � 0C:�+.:=<H7 � K�>)BQ$'+C:)(O0J>=@�"0C>):d<)@ jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �J��)j �=j � >A@$*C����c$��,6�K�$�#�+�)�$45*<HR"���dY"$4G�:�=02���3�e����*f02"$4G�:�#� j�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �=�

�)jÏÌ Ó � @'F�>=@'@ � 0J:ij�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �C�g17h@R�:(D@�*+���3�Y>A��iJ���$jk4G�Yl24G���:"nmo�3�#���� [45�b�K� .3p�=jY� 3;:N$/-'0?<?>=F�$ � 0J:�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �[��=jÏÍ ×w0 P (e-/: � :)Im(e�N>=+.$ � 0C:=@sj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �J��=j � 5 � � � :)I�0C1RU=> � <)@!R � $'&�+�@ � K � BÖ+.-<?(O:d@ � $6b^j�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �N�

�=j �)jY� # @ � K � BY+C- � $6b�@/0CBY>?$ � 0C:ÈjMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �d��=j � ÓE(O:=@ � $6b9<?- �QP (O:9K � � � :=I^j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �[Í

�=j �=jY� 7 � K � BÖ+.- � $6b�@A0JBQ>)$ � 0C: j�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �N��=j �=jÏÍ ~ � <[$/&H0C1 � :N$/(O-/1�+CFO( j�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �J�

�=jÏÌ �r0C:dF�BY>=@ � 0C:d@hjMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �J�

�Y�Q�

Page 6: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

�YP �������������

a� ��6�b���K�3�8% �)�:�# [�)*+���6HR��*+�K���#�+�)� g��Ì?jY� 3;:N$/-'0?<?>=F�$ � 0J:�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �N�Ì?jÏÍ �p&)(*2�0J-A$/1q0CB � 0�7[(OBY(eF�$ � 0C:�#!BYIC0J- � $/&)K #!V)V=-/0N+CFG&�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj ÌC�

Ì?jÏÍ?jY� �p&)(*Ów+`$G+�j�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj ÌC�Ì?jÏÍ?jÏÍ �p&)(_�r0J:=@A$/-G+ � :J$G@ jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj ÌC�Ì?jÏÍ?j � 2�0J-A$/1q0CB � 0�7[(OBY(eF�$ � 0C:�#!BYIC0J- � $/&)K���2"7?#�� jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj Ì)�Ì?jÏÍ?j � 2"7?# k(e@/>)BQ$'@ j�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj Ì)�Ì?jÏÍ?jÏÌ k(,@A>=B�$G@!#!:=+CBQb?@ � @�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj Ì)�Ì?jÏÍ?j W 7[(,F�0J:=<��"+C@/(CË�+9�,Ì�V)-/0Cz6(eF�$'@<)+.$'+.Xd+C@/( jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj ÌJÍÌ?jÏÍ?j � �r0J:=F�BY>=@ � 0J:=@]jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj ÌJÍ

Ì?j � �p&)(�7N$G+`$ � @A$ � FO+CB�3;:?1q(O-'(O:dF�(�#!V)V=-/0N+CFG&Èj�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj ÌC�Ì?j �)jY� 2�(e-'FO(O:N$ � BQ(MÊn@A$ � K�+`$ � 0J: j�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj Ì.�Ì?j �)jÏÍ Ê���F � (e:N$�=-/0J:N$ � (O-!Ên@A$ � K�+`$ � 0J: jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj ÌJÌ

Ì?j � �p&)(�3;:N$/(eIC(e-!24-'0CIC-G+.KWK � :)I_#%V)V)-'0J+CFG& jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj ÌC�Ì?j �=jY� �r0J:=@6$'-'+ � :N$G@ jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj ÌC�Ì?j �=jÏÍ �p&)(�3;:N$'(OIC(e-24-'0CIC-G+.KWK � :)I_2n-/0JX)BQ(eK�j�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj WJ�Ì?j �=j � � � :=< � :)IW$/&)(*Ê��yF � (O:N$!�)(O:dF�(OVg0J@A$'@ jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj WNÍÌ?j �=j � �r0J:=F�BY>=@ � 0J: jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj WNÍ

Ì?jÏÌ 7[>)KWK�+.-'b�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj WJ�� �\IJ��45,-���b�8�� ��<4G��j�� >A�+���+��j� ViJ�b4B^54G�#�)��� �3pW)jY� 3;:N$/-'0?<?>=F�$ � 0J:�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj W[�W)jÏÍ 5H0?<?(eBQB � :=Iy+.V)V)-'0J+JFG&�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj WJ�W)j � 5H0?<?(eB{Ê��)FO+ P +.$/0C-�j�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �?�W)j � 2436587vÓ � ICIC(e-�j�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �CÍW)jÏÌ �r0C:dF�BY>=@ � 0C:d@hjMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �.�

p102*�45�������D�b4G������� �� % "$4G��,645�b�)��� HJ�e��@��b�#@������ ��.�[jY� 3;:N$/-'0?<?>=F�$ � 0J:�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �J��[jÏÍ 7[b[KWKW(�$/- � (e@0C1{$/&=(M$/(�$'-'+C&)(e<)-/0J: jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �C��[jÏÍ?jY� 5H0J-/(w$'&=+.:���F�(e:J$'-/(,@ jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �NÌ

�[jÏÍ?jÏÍ ~c& � FG&H< � @6$G+.:=FO(e@pI �YP (w$'- � +.:)IJBQ(,@p+.:=<v$/(O$/-G+.&)(,<?-G+�� j�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �NÌ�[j � �r&)(eK � @A$/-'bij�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �BW�[j � � � :�7 �Y� (,@ j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �J��[jÏÌ 3;KWV)BY(OKW(O:N$'+.$ � 0C:ÑjMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �J��[j W �r0C:dF�BY>=@ � 0C: jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �=�

! �$�<�K�$c���i �3al �$�<�K�$c���i-l �3p

Ø

Page 7: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� � � ��� � ����� �

Í?jY� #Ò$6b[V � FO+.B{R"+.$/(O-< � @A$/- � X)>)$ � 0C:�:)(�$6R"0C-'Soj�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �uÍÍ?jÏÍ #Ò$6b[V � FO+.B{V � Vg(�B � :)S � :H+W:)(O$6Rr0J-/Soj j�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �,�Í?j � �p&)(MXg0C>):=<=+.-'bWFO0C:=< � $ � 0J:�0C:�$/&)(MF�0J:=F�(e:N$/-G+`$ � 0C: � :9+�B � :=Sgt� �� ��� ��t � @"0CX)$'+ � :)(,<�X[byF�0CK_X � : � :=I�$'&)(EK�+J@/@� :GU=0`RÒ0.1lFO0C:N$'+CK � :=+C:N$et�� � t=+.:=<�$/&=(�K � � � :=I�0.1 � :GU=0`R!@ � :N$/0W:)0?<?( �Gj9jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �uÌÍ?j � �r0CKWV)>)$/(e< FG&)BY0C- � :)(yFO0C:=FO(O:N$/-G+`$ � 0J:=@*+.$�$/&=(�>)V=@A$/-'(e+CK :=0[<)(y1q0C-_Vd(e- � 0?< � FO+.BYBYbJTU-'( P (e-'@/(e< U=0`R�Ë ��+=t X{t F ��Ë� $'-/>=(��_$/- � +C:)IC>=BY+C- P (OBY0[F � $6b�V=-/0Cf=BQ(Jt)F�0JKmV=>?$/(,<�R � $/&��������h��� �JÍCÌ �"! ��<�t (Ct 1 ��Ë4$6bNV � Fe+.BJLVN:P�QJSGT�Fe+.BÖF�>)BÖ+`T$ � 0C:{t)R � $'&������#�Ñ�$�{j�j�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj ��WÍ?jÏÌ #c@ � KWV)BY(-/(,<?>=FO(e<*:=(�$6R"0C-'S*F�0C:d@ � @6$ � :=Iw0C1=$6R"0E:=0[<)(e@�F�0J:):)(,F�$/(,< � :W+wBQ0[0CV{t.R � $'&WXd0C$/&2U=0`R!@ � :_$/&=(!@/+CKm(< � -/(,F�$ � 0J:�jE�p&)(m<?0.$/$/(,<HB � :)(,@ � :�V � Vd(v��-'(OV)-'(e@/(O:N$$'&)(*1�+JF�$%$'&=+`$w$/&=(O-'(�FO+C:):)0.$wXd(�$6Rr0�V � Vg(e@nz60 � : � :)Iv+@ � :)IJBQ(MV=+ � -p0C1=z6>):=F�$ � 0C:=@ � : LVN:PRQJS5T%!=-'+.$/&)(e-r$'&)(O-'(wK�>=@A$Xd(*@/0CKW(MF�0CBYBY(eF�$ � 0J:�0C1�0.$'&)(O-p:)0?<?(,@+.:=<�B � :)S?@� :9Xg(�$6R"(O(e:91q0C-R& � FG&�Rr(w$'+CSC( � ('&g(,F�$ �QP (�� P +C- � +.X=BQ(,@)(+*`t�,-*E+.:d<./*`j�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �,�Í?j W #!:v(��)+CF�$"@/0CBY>?$ � 0C:�0.1 �¨Í?jY�e����R � $'&v+�<)(eFO+ub � :)I�@ � :[>=@/0 � <)+CB � :)V)>?$F�0J:=F�(e:N$/-G+`$ � 0C:{tJ+.:d<0, * � �e�=t1( * �Ñ�,�)t,32$�iÌ?t�(42�� �,Ì)t657�h��� �C�NÍ � @A0m$/&d+`$$8 �:9%Í<;.�_+C:=<>=�?@9!��� W=�e�)�,�C� ��j�j�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �,�Í?j � #!:�(O�)+CF�$n@/0CBY>?$ � 0J:m0C1�� Í?jY�e� �{1q0C-n+C:m>=:=<)+.KWVg(e<�Vg(O- � 0[< � F � :)V)>?$,tJR � $/&0,A*/�Ñ�,�)tB(C*)� �e�)tB, 2 ?h�C��� �N�.�bW=t( 2 � �uÍ?t�57�c���Q� �D8E? �F� �JÍC�JÍ?��W)t<=��c��� ����j�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj ÍC�Í?j � #!: LVN:PRQJS5T�FO0CKWV)>?$G+`$ � 0J:HR � $'&�+y<?(eFe+ub � :)Idt)Vg(O- � 0?< � F.to@/�N>=+C-/(MRp+ P ( � :)V)>?$E$/&=+.$%V)-'0?<?>=F�(,@!+yFO0C:=@A$'+C:J$0C>)$/V)>?$w+`$:)0?<?(*�wjÆjMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj Í)�Í?j � # @/(eF�0J:=<v:)(�$6R"0C-'SyR � $/&H+ � 1q(O(,<?X=+JFGS1�_BY0N0JV�jmj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj Í)��)jY�HG 2 � :?TUFO0C:N$/-'0CB�<=+`$'+ jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �J��)jÏÍIG 2 0C>)$AT;F�0C:N$'-/0JBo<=+`$'+�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �=��)j � 7 � B P (O- jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �NÍ�)j � 5�+C:)IJ+C:)(e@/( jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �NÍ�=jY� 24-'0CX=BQ(eKLF�0J:?f=IC>=-'+.$ � 0C:y1q0J-/�KJ�� jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �J��=jÏÍ ��(OBY0?F � $6b�V)-'0.fdBQ(w1q-'0CKMLN�\�_$'0POÇjMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �J��=j � ��0CBY>)KW(M1q-G+CF�$ � 0J:=@et�QR*`t)R&)(O:.�S� �,��TGÍ.��T'�C��!<U0*'�_�WV.Í_+.:=<>U 2 �_�XV?�e�}jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �N��=j � ��0CBY>)KW(M1q-G+CF�$ � 0J:=@et�QR*`t��Y� �e�J��Te�C�e��TO�uÍ.��!<U7*��_�XVCÍ�+C:=<ZU 2 �_�XV[�,�WjMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �N��=jÏÌ 7[0JBQ>?$ � 0J:9$/0 �q�djQ�e� ��t[$6R"0�FO+J@A(,@OË�Ó_�X�_�XVCÍ�+C:=<9ÓwÍB�_�XV[�,��+C:=< PN� F�(OT P (O-G@/+�j�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �d��=j W\[�]S�_^S`a�cbedB*af �gT�[4hc�i^S`a�"bjd 2 f �gT�[CkK�_^S`a�g!lU7*/� �X;CÍ6TlU 2 � �X;[�,�Òjwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �[Í�=j � �r0C:dF�(O:N$'-'+.$ � 0C:�t�QY* �m["T�� ��t=R&)(e:�$ �s�e�=t ÍC�)t �C��!BU#nX�_��jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �N��=j � �r0C:dF�(O:N$'-'+.$ � 0C:�t�Q * t)R&=(O:9$ ��,�C�)tY�C�,�)tY�,ÍC��!FU n �_� jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �N��=j � 7[0JBQ>?$ � 0J:9$/0 �q�djQ�`� �UT �q�djQ�,���\jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �J��=jY�e�o[�]S�_^S`a�cbedB*af �gT�[4hc�i^S`a�"bjd 2 f �gT�[CkK�_^S`a�g!lU�n�� �X;CÍ j�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �J�Ì?jY� # V)BY0.$�0C1p+CBQB�1q(,+C@ � X)BY(y@/0CBY>?$ � 0C:=@ej�Ê��yF � (O:N$�1q(e:=F�(eVd0N@6$G@�+.-'(W@/&)0`R:]+C@E[�� @ej�ÓE0CK � :d+`$/(,<�Vd0J-A$/1q0CB � 0N@w+C-/(@/&)0`R:9+J@/p[� @ej4�p&)(M1q(e:=F�(eVd0N@6$%FO0C-'-/(,@AVg0C:=< � :)I�$/0W$'&)(�ICBY0CX=+CBQBYb�K � : � K�+.B{- � @AS � @pBÖ+.Xg(OBY(e<.q n j�j�jwj�jMj�jMj W=�Ì?jÏÍ #%@'@/0[F � +.$/(,<vR � $/&�(,+CFG&�( �yF � (O:N$1q(O:=FO(OVg0J@A$$q"n3�'�'�lq%r � @!+C:v(O�[Vg(eF�$/(,<v-'(�$'>)-':ZL�n3�'���sL�rJjMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj WNÍW)jY� #Ò$6b[V � FO+.B{(��)FO+ P +`$'0C-p+.-'K�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj WJ�W)jÏÍ #!V=V)-/0u� � K�+`$ � 0C:�0.1w$/&=(�V=+ub[BQ0N+C<a>=@ � :)I|-G+C< � +.BXd+C@ � @m1q>):dF�$ � 0C:d@OjÒÊ P +.BY>=+`$ � 0J: 0C1E$'&)(�1q>):=F�$ � 0C:\+.$�$/&)($/-G+ � : � :)IWVd0 � :N$G@Oj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj WJ�

P

Page 8: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

P[� ��� � � ����������� � �

W)j � #!V=V)-/0u� � K�+`$ � 0C:90.1l$/&=(�V=+ub[BQ0N+C<y>d@ � :)IW-'+J< � +.B�X=+J@ � @r1q>):=F�$ � 0J:=@ejnÊ P +.BY>=+.$ � 0C:�0C1�$'&)(M1q>):=F�$ � 0C:91q0C-K�+J@/@/(e@:)0C$!>=@A(,< � :9$/-G+ � : � :)I=jaj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �.�W)j � �r0[0C-G< � :=+`$'(M@/b?@6$'(OK 1q0J-p$/&)(�IJ(O:)(e-'+CB�KW0[<)(OB¨j j�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �?�W)jÏÌ �p&)(*2 � 5�79Ó � IJIC(e-eË�+�@ � KWV)BY(Ct)@ � :)IJBQ(*<)(OIC-'(O(w0.1l1q-'(O(e<)0CKL< � ICIJ(O-,j�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �.�W)j W �r0C:N$'0C>)[email protected]�$/&)(�(O�?+JF�$V=+ub[BY0J+C<y1q>):=F�$ � 0C:91q0C-$'&)(*2 � 5�7vÓ � ICIJ(O-9j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �CÌW)j � Ów+`$'+�@A(O$'@1q0J-$/-G+ � : � :)Iy+.:d<�$'(e@A$ � :)Iy0C1l$'&)(*KW0?<?(OBÖ@ej"�p&)(*$/-G+ � : � :=Iy<)+`$G+ � @%KW+C-/SJ(e<vX[b9FO-/0N@/@AT¨&d+ � -'@p+.:d<$/&=(M$/(e@A$ � :)Iy<)+.$'+mX[b�F � -GF�BY(e@ejlj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj ��WW)j � �r0C:N$'0C>)[email protected]$/&)(H:)0J:?TUV=+.-G+.KW(�$'- � F�+CV)V)-'0u� � K�+`$ � 0J:=@_$/0�$/&=(HV=+ub[BQ0N+C<|1q>=:=F�$ � 0J: 1q0J-W$/&)(�2 � 587aÓ � IJIC(e-ej��0CV�t=<=+`$'+W@/(�$%#�t)Xd0C$A$'0CK�t=<)+.$'+W@A(O$!� jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �J�W)j � 2�+.-G+.KW(O$/- � Fr+.V)V)-'0u� � K�+.$ � 0C:=@�$/0E$/&)(pV=+ub[BY0J+C<�1q>):=F�$ � 0J:�1q0J-l$/&)(2 � 5�7�Ó � ICIJ(O-,j���0CV�tC<=+`$'+w@/(�$�#*t`Xg0.$A$'0CK�t<)+.$'+�@/(�$!�wj jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �.��[jY� 5�+CS � :)I�+_$/(O$/-G+.&)(,<?-/0J:�j�Õ � :)IC( � @� uj4Ê4�N$'-/(eKW( P +CBQ>)(,@"1q0C-���@A&)0`R:{j�j�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �BW

Ø

Page 9: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� � � ��� � ��� �V�

�CjY� ÓE(O:=@ � $6b9+.:=<9� � @'F�0N@ � $6b�0.1�2�(�$'-/0JBQ(e>)Ks24-'0?<?>=F�$G@ j�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj W�[jY� 24&d+.-'KW+JF�0JV)&)0C-'(e@rR � $/&H�W+.:=<9��F�(e:J$'-/(,@Oj8j�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �C��[jÏÍ �4+.BY>)(,@0.1 G�� +.:=<ZG��pj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �NÌ�[j � �4+.BY>)(,@0.1R8F;�W1q0J- P +C- � 0C>d@rVd+ � -'@p0C1lF�(e:N$/-'(e@ejÆj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �J��[j � �4+.BY>)(,@!+C@'@A>=Km( UM�Ñ�uÌ�#�1q0C-!+.BYB�V=+ � -G@Ojxj�jMj�jwj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jMj�jwj�jMj�j�jMj�jMj�jMj�j�jwj�jMj�jMj �J�

P[�Q�

Page 10: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

P[�Q�Y� ��� � � ��� ������� � �

Ø

Page 11: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

��Ò���G�l�_�����Z� �������� ��)-'0CK 5�+ub��)�m$/&=-/0J>)IC&��C>):=(m�dtn�,�C�C�v+.V)V=-/0u� � KW+.$/(eBQbH�C�9K�+`$'&)(OK�+.$ � F � +.:=@�+C:=< � :=<?>d@6$'- � +.B�V=+C-A$ � F � Vd+.:N$'@wIJ+.$/&)(e-/(,<�+.$$/&=(��%: �YP (O-G@ � $6b|0C1E� � F�$'0C- � +�1q0C-m$'&)(��p& � -'< #!:):[>=+CB!24365�7a3;:=<?>=@A$/- � +.B24-'0CX)BY(OK}7?0CB PN� :)I�~80J-/S?@/&)0CV��|$/&)(�362r7?~�TU�=j�p&)(,@A(�24-'0?F�(e(e< � :)IJ@"<?0?F�>=Km(e:N$$/&)(MR"0C-'S�R& � FG&9Rp+C@p<?0C:=(M<)>)- � :)Im$/& � @ � :N$/(O:d@A(MR"(O(OSot)+J@rR"(OBYB�+C@r$'&)(*@ � IC: � fdFe+.:N$p( &o0C-/$V)>?$ � :8+`1Ð$'(O-w( P (O-'bC0C:=(�Rr(e:J$w&)0CKW(_XNb9$'&)(_-'(OVg0C-/$ER- � $/(O-G@%+C:=<�$'&)( � -�+C@'@ � @6$G+.:N$'@ejwDE:H$'&)(mBY+J@6$M<)+ub�0.1�$/&=(mFO0C:?1q(e-/(e:=F�(Jt(e+JFG&�R"0C-'S � :)IvIC-'0C>)V�IJ+ P (m+�V=-/(,@A(e:J$G+`$ � 0J:8@/>)KWKW+C- �Y�O� :)I�$/&)( � -Mf=:d< � :=IJ@ej_��09+�f=-G@6$/T $ � KW(W362r7[~ V=+.-/$ � F � V=+C:J$M@A>dFG&�+J@K�b?@/(OBQ16t � $mR"+J@�+CKW+ �O� :)IH$'0�@A(e(y$'&)(�Rp+ub � :�R& � FG&|$'&)(�IJ-/0J>)V=@*R"(O-'(�+CX)BQ(y$/0�KW(e(�$�$'&)(�FG&=+.BYBQ(e:)IC(�0C1%F�0JKmV � B � :=I�$/&=(@'F � (O:N$ � fdFw+.:=<�KW+.$/&)(eK�+`$ � FO+CB�+CF�$ �QP[� $ � (e@"0.1{$/&)( � -F�0JBQBY(e+CIC>)(,@41q-'0CK $'&)( P +C- � 0C>d@nR"0C-'S � :)I�IC-'0C>)V=@ � :9@/>=FG&v+_F�0J&)(e@ �QP (E+C:=<V)-'0?<?>=F�$ �QP (MR"+uby+C:=< � :�@A>=FG&�+W@A&=0C-/$r$ � KW(Cj4��0�@A0JKW(w(O�[$/(O:N$,t[$/&)(,@A(�@/>)KWKW+C-/b�V=-/(,@A(e:J$G+`$ � 0J:=@r1q0C-'Km(,<y$'&)(Mf=-G@6$!@A$/(eV � :$/&=(�V)-'0?<?>=F�$ � 0J:�0.1�$'&)(e@/(_2n-/0?F�(e(e< � :)IN@Oj!Õ%0`Rr( P (O-,t)$'&)(_@/S � BYB�+C:=<H('&g0J-A$w-/(,�J> � -'(e<v$/0�$'+CSC(�$'&)(_@/>)KWK�+.-'bvV)-'(e@/(O:N$G+`$ � 0C:d@+.:d<91q-/0JKx$'&)(OKZV)-'0?<?>=FO(�$/&)(_Vd0JB � @/&)(e<�$'(eFG&): � Fe+.B{-'(OVg0C-/$'@EF�0J:J$G+ � :)(e<�&=(O-'( � : � @E:)0.$%$/0�Xg(�>=:=<?(O-'(e@A$ � K�+`$'(e<�j!3pRp+.:N$!$'0(��?V)-'(e@'@wK�b�@ � :=F�(e-/(,@6$w$/&d+.:)S?@w$/0�$'&)(�R- � $'(O-G@ER&=0 P 0CBY>):N$/(e(O-'(e<H$'0H&=+.:d<?BQ(m$'& � @*V=+.-/$�0.1n$'&)(Mz60CX8��3%&d+ P (m0C:)BYb�$'&)(OK$/0�$/&=+C:)S�1q0C-_$/&)(v& � IC&a@A$'+C:=<)+.-G<)@�0.1!(��?Vg0J@ � $ � 0J:a+.:d< � KWV)-'(e@'@ �QP (�@/F � (e:N$ � fdFyBY( P (OBn0C1$/&)(9-'(OVg0C-/$'@ej�D%1!KW0C-'( � :N$'(O-'(e@A$$/0�$/&)(m(e< � $'0C-w$/&=+C:H$/&=(_-'(e+J<?(O-,tdX=>?$ � KWVg0C-/$'+.:N$w:)0C:)(O$/&)(eBQ(,@/@eto3!+.BÖ@A0vR"+C:N$%$/0�$/&=+C:)S�$/&=(_R- � $'(O-G@!1q0J-%$'&)(mV)-/0JKWV?$w+C:=<V)-'0.1q(,@/@ � 0J:=+.BoRp+ub � :�R& � FG&9$/&)(eb�F�0JKWV)BQ(O$/(,<�$'&)( � -!R"0C-'Soj�p&)(MV)- � :dF � V=+.B�+C>?$/&)0J-'@p0C1{$'&)(�-/(eVd0J-A$G@+.-'(�+C@r1q0CBYBQ0`R!@ej

�C0J&):�7[$/0?FGS � (Jt=7 � KW0J:��=-'+J@A(e-�!: �YP (e-'@ � $6b �U�r&=+.-'BY(e@Õ!0`Rp+.-G<�+C:=<�#%@'@A0?F � +.$/(e@� � K � $/(e< � �> � 2�+.BÖ+CF � 0N@r+C:=<�k � $'+W#!IJIJ+.-'Rp+.BÖ+)t[�!: �YP (e-'@ � $6b�0.1��"+CBQIN+.-'b �¨�r&)(eKW(����+.X=@ � � � KL5�bC(O-G@etd�r-'+C:?f=(OBÖ<9�!: �YP (e-'@ � $6bv+.:=<9� � Kx�"-G+.:):d+.:�t=�rBY(OK�@A0J:9�%: �YP (O-G@ � $6b � Ê4:[X)- � <)IC(w3;:=F�0J-/Vg0C-G+`$'(e< � 5 � :H�@'+.0dt[�%: �YP (O-G@ � $6by0C1�� � F�$/0C- � + � 5H(O-G+.Sv24-'0.z6(eF�$'@� � K � $'(e< � �J+CKm(,@"~�+.$/KW0C>)IJ&�t=�%: �QP (O-G@ � $6b�0.1�� � F�$'0C- � + � k%7[3p�{(,FG&):)0CBY0CI � (,@ � #!:=<?-'(6z�"0C:=+m+.:d<H�rBÖ+.>d<?( {+�Ug+.KWKW(Ct)�!: �QP (O-G@ � $6by0.14�"+.BYIJ+C-/b �¨7[(e+C-/BY(��r0C-'Vd0J-'+.$ � 0C: �Ên+JFG&|-/(eVd0J-A$mR"+J@�Fe+.-'(�1q>)BYBQb]V)-'0[0.1q-'(e+J<|+.:=<�� -'(�1q(e-/(e(e<���XNb�+8F�0JBQBY(e+CIC>)( � :a0J>)-W<?(OV=+C-A$'KW(O:N$et4+C:=<|3*R"0C>)BÖ<|B � SJ(y$'0$/&d+.:)SvK�by-'(�1q(e-/(e(e@r1q0C-p$'&)( � -%F�0J:=@'F � (O:N$ � 0C>=@�z60JX�j

3�Rp+C@�+.BÖ@/0E0J:)(r0C1=$'&)(pV)- � :=F � V=+CB?0C-'IJ+C: �Q� (O-G@�0C1d362r7?~�TU�=t.+.:=<*$/& � @4@/(O(OK�@�$/0MXg(+C@lIC0[0?<*V)BÖ+CFO("+J@�+.:[bM$/0M+CFGS[:)0`RBY(e<)IC($/&=(*F�0C:N$'- � X)>?$ � 0J:[email protected]�<?0 � (O:=@p0C1lVg(O0JV)BQ(MR&)0�R"0C-'SC(,<yXg(O& � :=<v$/&=(*@/FO(O:)(,@"$/0WK�+.SC(w$'&)(�( P (O:N$!F�0CKW(w$/0JIC(O$/&)(e-ej� � -G@A$et�$'&)(�24365�7 � :d<?>=@A$/- � +CB�1�+CF � B � $G+`$/0J-'@et�Õ!>d+`� � 0J:)I�Õ!>=+C:)I ���%�!�Et�:)0`R +y1�+JF�>)BQ$6b�KW(OK_Xd(e-*+`$��40C-'S��%: �QP (O-G@ � $6b �+.:d<�5�+C-/Sy2�+C>)BQ&[>=@ �¨�"+CBQIN+.-'b ��$'+CSC(E$/&)(MX)>=BQS�0C1{$/&=(MFO-/(,< � $r1q0J-r$'&)(�@/F � (e:N$ � fdFE@/>=FeF�(e@'@"0.1�$'&)(MRr0J-/S?@/&)0CV{jl�p&)(�@/(OBY(eF�$ � 0C:0.1l$/&=(�V)-/0JX)BY(OK�@p+.:=<90.1�$/&)(�� (��?Vg(O-/$'@e�=+.-'(MF�- � $ � Fe+.B�@A$/(OVd@Ot=+C:=<�$/&)(eb�&=+C:=<?BY(e<9Xd0C$/&�R � $/&H@AS � BQB¨t)< � V)BY0CK�+CFOb�+.:=<\Ud+ � -,j�p&)(M� (��?Vd(e-A$G@OtY�N�r&)- � @l�">=<=< � �p+`$/&{tC�%Ô ��t.� � K 5�bC(O-G@��¨�r-G+.:?fd(OBÖ<�tC�%Ô ��+C:=<�ÊnBQB � @n�r>)K�Xg(O-'X=+`$GFG& �U�rBY+ � -'KW0C:N$et.�w7?#��K�+C<?( � $MBY0N0JS�(e+C@/bCtgX)>?$M3!S[:)0`RÒ$/&d+`$w$/&)( � -rz60CX=@wR"(O-'(�+yBY0.$M0.14R"0C-'Sotd-'(e�N> � - � :)IvF�0C:d@ � <?(O-G+.X=BQ(�@/S � BYB�$/0�IJ(�$w$/&)(_IC-'0C>)Vd@R"0C-'S � :)IW+.:=<vSC(e(OVv$/&)(eKxKW0 P[� :)I � :�V)-'0[<)>=F�$ �QP (M< � -'(eF�$ � 0C:=@ej�p&)(*FO0CKWV=+.:[by-'(OV=-/(,@A(e:J$G+`$ �QP (e@"Rr(e-/(�+WIJ-/(,+`$!+C@'@A(O$ej4~c& � BY(�$/&=(Ob�K�+ubv&=+ P (MXg(O(O:�+WX � $!>):d@A>)-'(�0.1�R&=+.$!$/&)(eb�R"(O-'(IC(O$A$ � :)I � :J$'0]R&)(O:a$/&)(ebaFO+CKm(v$/0]I �QP (y$/&=( � -�V)-/(,@A(e:N$'+`$ � 0J:=@_0C: 5�0C:=<)+ub|KW0J-/: � :)Idtn@6$G+.:=< � :)I � :a1q-'0C:N$W0.1%:)(,+.-'BQb��J�(e+CIC(e-nK�+`$'&)(OK�+`$ � F � +C:=@etJ$'&)(Ob�&=(OBÖ<�$/&=( � -"0`R:9+C<?K � -'+CX)BYbCt[+.:=< � :9@A0JKm(wFO+J@A(,@nXg(eFe+.KW(w+JF�$ �QP (%KW(OK_Xd(e-'@"0.1�$'&)(MRr0J-/S � :)IIC-'0C>=V=@Oj��p&)( � :=<?>=@A$/- � +.B�-'(OV)-'(e@/(O:N$'+.$ �YP (,@n$'& � @bC(,+.-pRr(e-/( Ó%0J>)Iy7[K � $'& �U�r&=+.-'BY(e@Õ!0`Rp+.-G<�+C:=<9#%@'@A0?F � +`$'(e@� � K � $/(e< � �r-'(O:d<)+W�"+C>)IC&=B � :��U�r&)(OKW(O��{+CX=@ � Ó%0J:�7?FO0.$/$ ��Ê4:[X)- � <?IC(M3;:=FO0C-'Vd0J-'+.$/(e< � �J+J@A0J:v5�FO��(e+.: ��5�(O-G+.S�2n-/0Cz6(eF�$G@� � K � $/(,< � ÓE+ P[� <�{0CS[&)0C-G@A$ � k%7[3p�{(,FG&):)0CBY0CI � (,@ � �{0JKLÓ%0JK�+.: � 7[(,+.-'BQ( �

Ø

Page 12: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

Í�0?Fe+.BYBQbJt!Rr(�&=+J<h+ :N>=K�Xg(O-90.1�Vg(O0JV)BQ(�&)(eBQV � :)I�$/0 V)>?$�$/& � @HFO0C:?1q(e-/(e:=F�(�$/0CIJ(�$'&)(O-,j ÔM(OBYBQbi�r&)0[0 ���!� � F]2n365�7#%<)K � : � @6$'-'+.$ �YP (�#E@/@ � @A$'+C:N$ �m@A(O$y>)Vc0C>=-yF�0CKWV)>)$/(O-�:)(�$6R"0C-'S�+.:=<�&=+C:=<?BY(e< $/&=(HK�b[- � +C< 0.1�<?(O$'+ � BÖ@y+.Xg0C>?$yR& � FG&�$/&=(-'(e@A$M0C1">d@�&=+C<8:)0 � <?(e+=j��)-G+.:)S�k!>=@ASJ(Ob � 24365�7�@ � $'(y< � -/(,F�$/0J-M1q0C-*�%� � F �wSC(eV?$*>=@*+CBQB�KW0 P[� :)I91q0C-'R"+C-'<8+.:=<�+CF�$/(e<]+J@IC0CT¨Xg(�$6R"(O(e:�R � $/&8$/&)(��4+C:=F�0J> P (e-E0 �yF�( ��+J@MRr(eBQB4+J@w@ � IC: � :)I�+.BYB�$/&)(yFG&)(,�N>)(e@ ��jWk0?<8Êr<?Rp+.-G<)@E< � <]+�f=:)(Mz60CX�0C:8$/&=(+CFeF�0JKmKW0?<)+.$ � 0C:y1q-'0C:N$,t)+.:=<H7[(,+.:��r0J&[>):9@/Vg(O:N$%+mBQ0J:)Iy7?+`$'>)-'<=+ub�R � $'&�ÔM(eBQBYb�@/(�$/$ � :)IW>)V�Rr0J-/S?@A$'+`$ � 0J:=@ejl#Ñ:[>)K_Xd(e-0.10.$'&)(O-!�%� � Fw1�+CFO>)B�$6b9<?0C:d+`$/(,<vFO0CKWV)>?$'(O-G@Ot P 0CBY>):N$/(e(O-"$ � KW(Ct)0J-Xd0C$/&�j� � :d+.BYBQbJt � $ � @!+mV)BY(e+J@A>=-/(M$'0W$/&=+C:)Sy$'&)(*@A>=V)Vd0J-A$ � :=I � :=@A$ � $/>)$ � 0C:=@ejr�%� � F�IJ+ P (w>d@-/0[0JKW@et?(e�N> � V)KW(O:N$%+C:=<�F�0CKWV)>)$/(O-@/(O- PN� F�(,@Oj��p&)(��%� � Fv�r0CKWV)>?$'(O-�7?F � (e:=F�(yÓE(OVd+.-/$/KW(O:N$*FO+CKm(W$'&)-'0C>)IJ&�R � $/&|K�>dFG&80C1r$'&)(yF�0JKmV=>?$ � :)I�&=+.-G<?Rp+.-'(Ct�+C:=<KW0J@A$ � KWVg0C-/$'+C:J$40C1�+.BYB tC2n365�7W@A$'+.-/$/(,<*$'&)(!X=+CBQB=-/0JBQB � :=IM$/&)-'(O(bJ(e+.-G@�+.IJ0wR � $/&�362"7[~�TG�CtJ+C:=<m&=+C@4SC(OV)$�$/&)(!V=-/0Cz6(eF�$�IJ0 � :)I@ � :=FO(!$'&)(O:�t[<?( P 0.$ � :=I*KW0C:)(ebCtNVd(e0CV)BY(E+C:=<y@/(O(OK � :)ICBYbm>):)B � K � $/(e<y(O:N$/&[>=@ � +J@AK�1q0C-r$/&=( � :=<?>=@A$/- � +CB�T;+CFe+C<?(eK � FpV=+C-A$':)(O-G@/& � V{j

�r&)- � @A$/0JV)&)(e-!�=j)�"0J@/(Ct)Êr< � $/0C-ÓE(OV=+C-A$'Km(e:N$!0.1l5�+`$/&=(OK�+`$ � Fe@+.:=<H7N$G+`$ � @A$ � FO@�!: �QP (O-G@ � $6by0.1l� � F�$'0C- � +

Ø

Page 13: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� ��������� �

� � ��� � � � � � �� ��� � � ��� ��� ��� �

� � �V���

� ���m� � � �!� � �m�#" � � � �%$��_�l���!��� &'�H�� !�($ � )+* �w�l�!�Ò�y� �{�l�,� �.- � � ���/)����10Æ�E� ������ ���32 � �l�y !� �w�����54 �!� ���l�!�687:9/;,<>=@? AB=@CEDF7:G>HJIKGL9NM�p&)(mV)-'0CX)BY(OK � @%$'09<)(�$/(e-/K � :)(mR"+.$/(O-M�N>=+.B � $6b � :8+vRp+`$/(e-w< � @A$/- � X=>?$ � 0C:8:)(�$6R"0C-'S9+J@M+�1q>):=F�$ � 0C:�0.1�$ � KW(�+.:=<�BQ0?Fe+`$ � 0C:{j�p&)(WK�+`$'&)(OK�+`$ � Fe+.B�V)-'0CX)BY(OK Fe+.:�Xd( P[� @A>=+CB �Y� (,< � P +CIC>)(eBQb �E+C@M+�@Ab?@A$/(eKÈ0.1r(,�N>=+`$ � 0J:=@E$/&=+.$�<)(e@'F�- � Xg(�$'&)(�@AVd+`$ � +.B�+C:=<$/(eKWVd0J-'+CBo$/-G+.:=@/Vd0J-A$!+C:=<v< � BY>?$ � 0C:�0C1�+WF�0J:N$'+.K � :=+.:N$ � :`z6(eF�$/(e<�+.$+�@/Vg(eF � fdFwBY0[Fe+`$ � 0J:�j5H>): � F � V=+CB�Rp+`$'(O-%< � @A$/- � X=>?$ � 0C:�@/b?@6$'(OK�@w+.-'(�>):=@A$/(e+J<?b�U=0`R�tg:)0C:)B � :)(e+C-%:)(O$6Rr0J-/S?@ej3;:�IC(e:)(O-G+.B¨t)$'&)(�>):=SN:=0`R:=@%+C-/(JË$/&=(�V)-'(e@'@A>)-'(e@ � +`1Ð$'(O-y(eB � K � :=+.$ � :)I�(eBQ( P +.$ � 0C:c< � &g(e-/(e:=F�(,@ �y+`$y(e+JFG&�:)0?<?(Ct"$/&=(�F�0J:=@A>=KmV)$ � 0C:\+`$y(,+CFG&�:)0?<?(Jtp+C:=<�$/&=(1q- � F�$ � 0C:=+CB�FG&=+C-'+JF�$/(e- � @A$ � FO@0C14(e+CFG&HB � :)SojE�p&)( U=0`R � :�+�B � :)S � @%+�<)(O- �QP (e< P +.- � +CX)BY(�$/&=+.$w<?(eVd(e:=<)@E0C:H$'&)(_< � &o(O-'(O:=FO( � :V)-'(e@'@A>=-/(*+JF�-'0J@'@p$/&)(mB � :)SH+C:=<9$/&)(�1q- � F�$ � 0J:=+.B�FG&=+C-'+JF�$/(e- � @A$ � FM0.1�$/&)(mB � :)Soj!3;:8@AVg(eF � +CBlFe+C@/(e@%@/0CKW(*0C1�$/&)(_>):)S[:)0`R:=@E+.-'(S[:)0`R:91q-/0JKLfd(OBÖ<HKW(e+C@/>)-'(OKW(O:N$G@Ot)X=>?$ � :HIC(e:)(O-G+.B�$'&)(*:[>)K_Xd(e-%0.1�>):=SN:=0`R:=@!(O�?FO(O(,<)@p$/&=(�:[>)K�Xg(O-%0.14(e�N>=+.$ � 0C:=@$/&=+.$FO+C:yXg(ER- � $/$/(e: �q0J:)(%(,�J>d+`$ � 0C:�0.1 U=0`R\FO0C:N$ � :[> � $6bm1q0J-r(,+CFG&�:)0?<?( ��j�3;:yV)-G+CF�$ � F�(EKm(,+C@/>)-'(OKW(O:N$'@r+.-'(!(��?Vg(O:=@ �YP (E@/0�K�+C:Nb0.1l$/&=(�>):)S[:)0`R:=@p+.-'(�+C@'@A>=Km(,<y$'0�Xd(�S[:)0`R:{j�p&)(mK�+ � : � :J$'(O-'(e@A$w0C14$/&=(WFO0CKWV=+C:Nb � @E$/0�<?(�$'(O-'K � :)(_$/&)(�< � @A$/- � X)>)$ � 0C:�0C1n$'&)(mFO0C:N$'+CK � :=+C:N$ P 0CBY>)KW(Ct � (Jt � $G@MK�+C@'@+.:d<�F�0C:dF�(O:N$'-'+.$ � 0C:�tN+C@4+M1q>=:=F�$ � 0J:y0.1o$ � KW(!TlR&)0*IC(O$'@4$/0�<?- � :)S � $etJ1q0C-r&)0`R�BQ0J:)I=t[+.:=<WR&=(O:�j�3U$ � @n<?(,@ � -G+.X)BY($/0_<?( P (OBY0CVf=-G@6$,t�+�F�BY0J@/(e<�1q0C-'K K�+.$/&)(eKW+.$ � FO+CB4@A0JBQ>?$ � 0J:�1q0J-�+.:]+.V=V)-/0u� � K�+`$ � 0C:�$/0�$'&)(�-/(,+.B�V)-'0CX=BQ(eK9t�+.:=<]@/(eF�0J:=<�tl+v:[>)KW(e- � FO+CBKW(�$'&)0?<H$/&d+`$wFO0C>)BÖ<HXg(�>=@/(e<H$/0v<)(�$/(e-/K � :)(_$/&)(_-'+C:)IC(*0C1n+.V)V=B � FO+CX � B � $6bv0C1�$/&)(mK�+`$/&=(OK�+`$ � Fe+.BlKm(O$/&)0?<�jw�p&)(O:8>=@/(*$/&=(K�+`$'&)(OK�+`$ � Fe+.B"KW(�$/&=0[<|$/08@/0CB P (y$/&)( � : P (O-G@A(yV=-/0JX)BQ(eK TMI �YP (e:]$ � KW( P +.-'b � :=I�KW(e+C@/>)-'(OKW(O:N$G@ �q0C1EF�0J:=F�(e:N$/-G+`$ � 0C:|+C:=<@/0CKW(M0.1l$/&)(�V)-'(e@'@/>)-/(,@ �r<?(O$/(O-'K � :=(M$/&)(MB � SJ(OBYbv@/0C>)-GF�( ��@ �40C1�$'&)(*F�0J:J$G+.K � :=+.:N$ej

24-'(e@/(O:N$'(e<yX[boËÓE0C>)Iy7[K � $/&�r&=+C-/BY(e@pÕ!0`Rp+.-G<�+C:=<�#%@'@A0?F � +.$/(e@� � K � $/(,<�t)� � F�$'0C- � +=t)�wjÏ�Ej

Page 14: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� � � � � � ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� � � ��� ��� �

� & � )e�G�o� � ���m�l����) �C���È� &')G����� ���4� �*�')�� � ���m�')�� � ��- � ��� � �� 4 �*���_� �w�l���4�O���� M I 7K9����,D IKGL9NM#!:d+.BYbJ$ � Fe+.B4KW(O$/&)0?<)@�R&=(O-'(�KW+C:[b�(OBY(OKW(e:J$G@*+.-'(�<?(�$'(O-'K � :)(,<|@ � K�>=B�$G+.:)(e0C>=@/BQb�V)-/(,@A(e:N$�@/Vg(eF � +.Br< � �yFO>)B�$ � (,@ � :��N>=+.B � $6bF�0J:N$/-'0CB¨j��p&)(�>=@/(�0C1 � :d< �QP[� <?>=+CB"FO0C:N$/-'0CBnFG&d+.-/$'@�1q0J-_(,+CFG& P +.- � +.X)BY( �q(eBQ(eKm(e:N$ � � @_IC(e:)(O-G+.BYBQb8:)0.$m( &o(eF�$ �YP (v<)>)(y$'0�$/&=(F�0JK�X � :=+.$ �YP (!+C@/Vg(eF�$40C1o$/&)( P +C- � +`$ � 0J:�j�3U1o$'&)(O-'(!+.-'(���(OBY(OKW(O:N$'@n+.:=<m$'&)(!(O-'-'0C-�0C:W(,+CFG& � @ � :d<?(OVg(O:=<)(O:N$etJ$/&)(%V)-/0JX=+.X � B � $6b$/&d+`$�+.BYB�$/&=(y-/(,@A>=B�$G@MR � BYB�1�+.BYB4R � $/& � :�$/&)( � -�-/(,@AVg(eF�$ �YP (��JÌ��ZF�0J:?fd<?(e:=F�(WB � K � $'@ � @ ����� �NÌ ���dj�3U1�� ��C� �qK_>)BQ$ � T¨(eBQ(eKm(e:N$+.:d+.BYbJ$ � Fe+.BNV=+CFGS`+CIC(e@�$6bNV � Fe+.BYBQbM&=+ P ("ÍCÌp$/0w�J�(eBQ(eKm(e:N$'@ ��$'& � @lV)-'0CXd+.X � B � $6b � @�(e�N>=+CBC$'0� ��� �JÌ���� n 0C-l�)jÏÍ?�e�BW)j{3;:*0.$'&)(O-lRr0J-'<=@$/&=(O-'(*R � BYB{Xg(�0J:)(�0C-EKW0C-'(�(OBY(OKW(O:N$'@%0C>?$E0.1�Xd0J>):=<)@ � :]�`�)jÏÌ.��� 0.14+CBQB�X=+`$GFG&)(e@et=R& � FG&H0C:�+�@ � KWV)B � @A$ � F � :N$'(O-'V)-/(O$'+.$ � 0C:@/>)ICIJ(e@A$'@%$/&=+.$�+CXd0J>?$M$6Rr0CT $'& � -'<)@w0C1r+.BYB�X=+`$GFG&)(e@wR � BQB�Xg(W-/(Az6(eF�$/(e<8R&)(e:�:)0C$/& � :)I � @�+JF�$'>=+.BYBQbHR-'0C:=I�R � $/&8$/&)(�@'+.KWV)BY(<)+.$'+)j3;:�V)-G+CF�$ � F�(p$/&=(O-'(R � BYBd:=0C-'KW+CBQBYb*Xg(%Xg0.$'&yF�0C-'-'(OBÖ+`$/(,<�(e-/-'0C-,t � <?>)($'0 � :d@6$'-/>)KW(e:J$ P +C- � +`$ � 0J:=@l$/&d+`$"+ &g(,F�$r+CBQB=(OBY(OKW(O:N$'@0C-IJ-/0J>)V=@"0.1�(OBY(OKW(e:J$G@ �p+C:=< � :d<?(OVg(O:=<)(O:N$!(O-'-/0J-pR& � FG& � @!<?>)(M$'0 P +C- � +`$ � 0J:=@ � :v$'&)( � :=< �YPN� <?>=+CB�(OBY(OKW(e:J$!KW(,+C@/>)-/(eKW(O:N$FG&=+C:):)(OBÖ@ej7[0JKm(M0C1{$/&=(*@A0JBQ>?$ � 0J:=@"$/&d+`$%+.-'(MXd( � :=Im>d@A(,<v0J-p$/(,@6$'(e<�+.-'(EB � @6$'(e< � :9$'&)(�:)(��[$%@/(eF�$ � 0C:�j

� G��J=@M�� 9NM I 7K9N<! G ? G IKC�p&)(�IJ(O:)(e-'+CB�+.V)V)-'0J+JFG&�&=+J@Xg(O(O:9$'0�R � <?(e:9$/&)(�FO0C:N$/-'0CB�B � K � $'@1q0C-!K_>)B�$ � TU(OBY(OKW(e:J$%+C:=+.BYb?@A(,@"$/0y�J@Oj4�p& � @!&d+C@"$/&=(*( &o(eF�$0.1�-'(e<?>dF � :)IW$/&)(�V)-/0JX=+.X � B � $6bv0.1�1�+.BÖ@/(�X=+`$GFG&H-/(Az6(eF�$ � 0J:91q0C-%V=>)-/(eBQb � :d<?(OVg(O:=<)(O:N$E(e-/-'0C-p$'0H�)9 ����� �C�[�u� � � R& � FG& � @%�=j �[�.Ì�¨�?j Ì����j�p&)(W< � @/+J< P +.:N$'+CIC(e@w0C14$/& � @*+CV)V)-'0J+CFG&8+.-'(_+�@/+JF�- � fgF�( � :]<)+`$G+v�N>=+CB � $6b�1q0C-�(,+CFG& � :=< �QP[� <?>=+.B�(eBQ(eKW(O:N$*+.:=<�+C@wKW0C-'(+.:d<yKW0C-'(E(eBQ(eKW(O:N$'@+C-/( � :=FOBQ>d<?(e< � :v<)+.$'+mV=+CFGS`+CIC(e@�� ÌC�Bb �4$/&)(MV)-'0CX=+CX � B � $6b�0.1�1�+CBY@/(MX=+`$GFG&�-'(6z6(,F�$ � 0C: � @p-'(OBÖ+`$ �QP (OBYbW& � IJ&T4IC-'(e+.$/(e-r$'&=+.:]�,����1q0J-%Ì.�m(OBY(OKW(O:N$G@Oj

"#�,< IKG%$�& 7:G�&%I =(')�*& <>GLI,+-� 9 MNI 7K9 <24- � :=F � V)BY(�F�0JKmVg0C:=(O:N$E+.:d+.BYb[@ � @!&=+J@!Xg(O(O:�(��)+.K � :)(e<�jEk�j �djdÕ%0`R"+C-A$'&�td5�j Õ�jok%+.K�@A(eb9+C:=<H�wj �dj��r0CBY(e@V)-'(e@/(O:N$'(e< � �p&)(Vg0.$/(e:N$ � +.B�0C1�K_>)BQ$ �YP +C- � +`$'(*�N>=+.B � $6bvF�0C:N$'-/0JB{+C@+�< � +.IJ:)0J@A$ � Fw$/0[0JB � :�×w(e0J+C:=+.BYb?@ � @ �m+`$E×w(e0J+C:=+.BYb?@ � @�N� �q�4+ � B¨to�D_td�C>):=(�N� ��jnÓw+`$G+m1q-/0JKL+��JÌ_(eBQ(eKm(e:N$!K�>)BQ$ � T¨(eBQ(eKW(O:N$E+.:d+.BYbJ$ � Fe+.B�V=+JFGS`+.IC(wRp+C@p-'(e<?>=FO(e<v$/0W1q0J>)-V)- � :dF � V)BQ(*FO0CKWVg0C:)(e:J$G@Ojr�p&)(Ob$/&=(O:�@A>)IJIC(,@6$'(e<yFO0C:N$/-'0CBgXd(M<?0J:)(EX[b�>=@ � :)I�$'&)(wf P (MF�0J:N$/-'0CBoFG&=+.-/$'@nT�0C:)(E1q0C-"(e+JFG&�0.1{$/&)(w1q0C>=-"FO0CKWVd0J:)(O:N$G@"+C:=<�+�f)1Ð$'&1q0C-!Õ%0.$'(OBYB � :)I=� @�hT4-/(eV)-/(,@A(e:N$ � :)I�$'&)(�K�>=B�$ �QP +.- � +`$/(�< � @A$'+.:dF�(Cj�p& � @ � @�+9@/0CV=& � @A$ � FO+.$/(,<8+CV)V)-'0J+CFG&�$/&=+.$�-/(,�J> � -'(e@MBÖ+.-'IC(_$/-G+ � : � :)IH@A(O$'@�+.:d<�@ � IC: � fdFO+C:N$MFe+.BÖF�>)BÖ+`$ � 0J:=@w1q0C-�(,+CFG&8$/(e@A$ej36<?(,+.BYBQb�$'&)(/.��hF�0C:N$'-/0JBoFe+.:9Xd(_<?0C:)( � 0C:?TUB � :)(J�)<?>)- � :=IW$/&)(*+C:=+.BYbN$ � FO+.B�@/(e�N>)(e:=F�( �q$/&)( � :=@A$/-'>)KW(O:N$%@A0C1Ð$6R"+C-/(w-'(eF�0JIC: �Y� (,@+�FO0C:N$/-'0CBl@/+CKWV)BQ(_+.:=<�@/>)X)-'0C>)$ � :)(*$'(e@A$ � :)Iy1q0J- � : VW0J>?$E0C1nF�0J:J$'-/0JB � @E<)0`R:�Xd(O1q0C-'(*$'&)(�:)(O�[$M@'+.KWV)BY( � @E+C:=+.BYb � (,<9T � :BY(e@'@n$'&=+.:9+�K � :[>?$/(ET4@A0�$/&=+.$"$ � KW( � @":)0C$"Rp+C@A$/(,<�<?0 � :=I�0C>)$"0C1�@AVg(eF � fgFO+`$ � 0J:v+C:=+.BYb?@ � @ ��jl�p&=(MFe+.BÖF�>)BÖ+`$ � 0J:=@rKW+ubWXg(%$'0[0F�0JKWV)BQ(O�y1q0C-0J:?TUB � :)(�F�0J:J$'-/0JB j5H0J-/(WV)-'0CX)BY(OK�+.$ � F � @M$'&)( � FO0CKWVg0C:)(e:J$G@O��$/&=+.$�+.-'( � <?(e:J$ � fd(e<�jHDE:=F�(�+H@'+.KWV)BY( � @ � <?(O:N$ � f=(,<|+C@M>):d+CFOFO(OV?$G+.X)BY(W$/&=(� :=@6$'-/>=Km(e:N$v0CVg(O-G+`$'0C-v:)(O(,<)@y$'0�$G+.SC(8F�0C-'-'(eF�$ �QP (�+CF�$ � 0C:=@�$/0 -/(,@A0JB P (�$/&)(�V)-'0CX)BY(OK Xd(O1q0C-'(�V)-'0?F�(e(e< � :)I�R � $/&h1q>)-A$'&)(O-+.:d+.BYb[@/(e@ejp3U1�$/&)(mF�0JKmVg0C:=(O:N$'@E+.-'(*:)0.$wF�BY0J@/(OBYbv-'(OBÖ+`$'(e<9$/0�V)&[b[@ � FO+.B�V)-'0CVg(O-/$ � (e@ ��0C-E+C-/(_+.BYB�F�0JK�X � :=+.$ � 0C:=@%0.14+�:[>)K�Xg(O-0.1�V)-'0CVg(O-/$ � (e@ ��t � <?(O:N$ � fdFe+`$ � 0J:v0C1�$'&)(�� f=�o�[$'0W$/&)(�0J>?$0.1�F�0J:J$'-/0JBoV)-/0JX)BY(OKsK�+ubyXg(*< � ��FO>)BQ$ej#%@pR"(OBYB¨t)K�>)BQ$ � V)BY(*F�0J:J$'-/0JB�FG&=+.-/$'@et?0C:)(w1q0J-(e+CFG&�F�0JKWVd0J:)(O:N$et)+C-/(�@A$ � BQB{Xd( � :)IW>=@/(e<�j0 G>M 9N? G�& < 6 7K9/;1&%;�G>< G IKGL=@C�l+.X)BY(e@M0C1r$'&)(�X � :)0CK � +.B�V)-'0CX=+CX � B � $6b�0.1)� 0J>?$*0.1�2 Vd0 � :N$'@�1�+.BYB � :)IH+.Xg0 P (m$/&=(y�JÌu$'& � �C�.$/&�0C-*�C�.$/&|+C@MR"(OBYB �EFe+.:]Xg(F�0J:=@A$/-'>=F�$'(e<�j4�r0C:N$/-'0CB[B � K � $'@4Fe+.:_$/&)(e:�@A(O$l1q0J-4�JÌ�� ��Í.@ �l+.:=<�$/&)(:[>)K_Xd(e-�0.1o(OBY(OKW(O:N$G@l1�+ � B � :)I P (e-'@/>=@�$/&)(p$'0.$G+.B?:[>)K�Xg(O-<?(O$/(O-'K � :=(e<9Xd(�( P +.BY>=+`$'(e<�j�3U1l$/&)(�V=-/0JX=+.X � B � $6by0C1{$'& � @!( P (e:N$ � @BY(e@'@"$/&=+C:H+_V=-/(,<?(�$'(O-'K � :)(,<vBY( P (OB�� � j (Cj4�=j Ì��4$'&)(*@'+.KWV)BY(FO+C:vXg(*<?(O$/(O-'K � :=(e<v$/0WXg(*+m1�+ � BQ>)-'(Cj24-'(e@/(O:N$'(e<yX[boË�"-/(e:=<)+y�"+.>=IC&)B � :�r&)(eKm(O���+.Xg0C-G+`$/0J- � (e@etN�4+.:=FO0C> P (O-,t[�wj �Ej

Ø

Page 15: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� � � � � ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� � � ��� ��� � Ì� �y�H� )!)e�!����� �w�l r� � �W�l�!� ���� ��� - � �y���4�����_��� �� ���/$���� �w���!�0 & D����/7K9 � M�� � M 9/7:? &%IKGL9NM2�(�$'-/0JBQ(e>)KÑV)-'0[<)>=F�$G@�+C-/(rKm0N@6$�(eFO0C:)0JK � Fe+.BYBQb�@/& � V=Vd(,< � :_BY0C:)Iw< � @6$G+.:=FO(rV � Vg(OB � :)(,@Oj��p&)(e-/("FO+.:_Xd(p@ � IJ: � fgFO+.:N$�< � &o(O-'(O:dF�(e@Xg(�$6R"(O(O:�$/&)(�FG&d+.-G+CF�$'(O- � @A$ � FO@!0.1�$/&)( P +.- � 0J>=@!Vg(�$'-/0JBQ(e>)KxV=-/0?<?>=F�$'@!$/&=+.$w+.-'(�@/& � V)Vd(,<�t�@A0W$'&)(ObH+C-/(�@/& � V)Vg(e< � :�X=+.$'FG&)(,@0.1$U=> � <)@R � $/&�B � SJ(*FG&=+.-G+CF�$/(e- � @6$ � Fe@Oj�#"$$/&=(�B � K � $G@!0.1�< � &g(e- � :)IyFG&=+C-'+JF�$/(e- � @A$ � FO@p+.-'(W� FOBQ(,+.:��?-'(�f=:=(e<9V)-'0[<)>=F�$G@ �qIJ+J@A0JB � :)(Jt< � (e@/(OB�1q>=(OB¨td+.:d<H+ PN� +`$ � 0J:�1q>=(OBÖ@ �FO0CKWV=+C-/(,<y$'0�&)(e+ P b�FO-/>=<)(�0 � BY@p$'&=+`$wF�0C:N$G+ � :�@/>)BQ1q>)-%FO0CKWVd0J>):=<)@ejr�p&=(�0`R:)([email protected]�$/&=(V)-'0?<?>=F�$G@ � :=@ � @A$4$/&=+.$rF�-'0J@'@4FO0C:N$'+CK � :=+.$ � 0C:m0.1o$/&)(%X=+`$GFG&)(e@�Xg(!K � : � K �Y� (,<�jn7[(OVd+.-G+`$ � 0C:m0.1o$'&)(!X=+.$'FG&)(,@�X[bm+MKW(eFG&d+.: � FO+CB<?( PN� @/(M@/>=FG&�+C@+WV � Vg(OB � :)(�V � I � @:)0.$V)-G+CF�$ � FO+CBQBYbyVg0J@'@ � X)BY(Cj~c&)(e:v$'&)(*< � &g(e-/(e:N$!Vd(O$/-'0CBY(O>)KxV)-/0?<?>dF�$'@!R � $'&�< � &o(O-'(O:N$!V)-'0CVg(O-/$ � (e@@/>=FG&H+C@<?(e:=@ � $6b9+.:=<9KW0CBY(eFO>)BY+C- PN� @'F�0J@ � $6b�+.-'($/-G+.:d@AVg0C-/$/(,< � $ � @ � KmVg0C-/$'+C:N$*$/0HXg(�+.X=BQ(�$'0�< � @6$ � :)IJ> � @A&]$'&)(yXg0C>):=<=+.-'b�Xg(�$6R"(O(O:]$'&)(OK�@/0�$/&=+.$�>)Vg0C:�+.-'- �QP +.B4+.$*$/&=($/(e-/K � :=+.B�FO0C:=@/(eFO>?$ �YP (wV)-'0?<?>=F�$G@pK�+ub�Xd(�@/(OIC-'(OIN+`$'(e< � :N$/0m$/&)( � --'(e@/Vg(eF�$ �QP (w$'+.:=S[@"R � $/&H+_K � : � K�>)Kx0.1�F�0C:N$G+.K � :d+`$ � 0C:{j�p& � @�V)-'0?F�(e@'@�0C1M@/(OIJ-/(eIJ+`$ � 0J: ��0C-�� F�>?$/$ � :)I=�n$/&)(8@6$'-/(,+.K � � @�K�+C<?(�FO0C:=@ � <)(O-G+.X)BYb�KW0C-'(�< � ��FO>)BQ$�R&)(O:�$'&)( � :N$/(O-/1�+CFO(Xg(�$6R"(O(O:�< � &o(O-'(O:N$EV=-/0?<?>=F�$'@ � @!$/0C-/$/>=0C>=@R � $/&�f=:)IC(e- � :)I�0C1�0J:)(�FO0CKWVd0J:)(O:N$ � :N$/0�$'&)(�0C$/&)(e-ej��0y-'(e<?>=FO(�$/&=(�( &o(eF�$'@%0.1X=+.$'FG& � :N$/(O-/1�+CFO(e@%$/&)(mV)-'0?<?>=F�$MX=+.$'FG&)(,@E+C-/(*K�+J<?(m+J@%BÖ+.-'IC(_+C@EVd0N@/@ � X=BQ(m@A0�$/&)(mX=+`$GFG& � :N$/(O-/1�+CFO(�Xg(eFO0CKW(e@w+�@/K�+.BYBQ(e- �0.1l$/&=(*(O:N$ � -'(wXd+`$'FG&{j"7[0JKm(M0C1l$'&)( � :J$'(O-/1�+CFO(e@+.-'(�F�0J:=@ � <?(e-/(,<9+J@M� $'-'+C:=@/K � ���=+.:d<vK_>=@A$!Xd(�-'(�TU-/(Of=:)(,< � � j (Cj"F�-'>=<?(�0 � B � :IJ+J@A0JB � :)( ��j4D%$/&)(e- � :N$/(O-/1�+CFO(e@rFO+.:�Xd(E>=@A(,<�X[b�+.BYBQ0`R � :)I�$'&)(E& � IJ&)(O- P +CBQ>=(%V)-'0?<?>=F�$ � :�$/&)( � :N$'(O-/1�+CF�(%$/0_Xd(M<?(OIJ-'+J<?(e< � � j (Cj+mV)-'(OK � >=KLIJ+J@A0JB � :)(WVu-'(OIC>=BY+C-nIJ+J@A0JB � :)( � :N$'(O-/1�+CF�(MR � BQB�+.BYB�IC0m$/0m$/&=(�-/(eIC>)BÖ+.-pIJ+J@A0JB � :)(E$'+C:)S ��j�r0CKWVg0C>):d< � :=I�$/&)( � :J$'(O-/1�+CFO(*K � � � :)Iv+C-/(�$'&)(�KW(,FG&=+.: � FO+CB�FO0CKWVd0J:)(O:N$G@!0.1n+�V � Vd(eB � :)(Cjw# V � Vg(OB � :=(�&=+J@%Xg(O:=<=@E+C:=<f)$/$ � :)IJ@ ��@/(eF�$ � 0J:=+.B �Y�O� :)I P +CB P (e@ �E$/&=+.$_< � @6$'>)-'X8$'&)(YU=0`R+.:d<8-'(OV=>)KWV � :=I�@6$G+`$ � 0C:d@ ��FO(O:N$/- � 1q>=IJ+.BnV)>)KWV=@ ��+`$*R& � FG&]$/&=(V)-'(e@'@A>=-/( � @!Xd0[0J@A$/(,<v+.$%+.V)V=-/0u� � KW+.$/(eBQbyÌ.�mK � BQ( � :N$/(O- P +.BÖ@Oj3U1 � $�R"(O-'(WVd0N@/@ � X)BQ(W$'0�FO+CBYFO>)BY+.$/(�X=+.$'FG& � :J$'(O-/1�+CFO(e@et{0C-�( P (e:8$'0HXd(O$A$'(O-*>):d<?(O-G@6$G+.:=<�R& � FG&]V=+.-G+.KW(O$/(O-G@�<?(O$/(O-'K � :=($/&=( � -*IC-'0`Rp$/&�-'+.$/( � $�K�+ub�Xd(�Vg0J@'@ � X)BY(W$/0H0JV?$ � K �Q� (�X=+`$GFG&|@A& � V)KW(O:N$G@�X[b�-'(e<?>=F � :=Iv$'&)(yV)-'0?<?>=F�$�<?(OIJ-'+J<)+`$ � 0J:�j��p& � @R"0C>)BÖ<9&=+ P (�+�F�0J:=@ � <?(e-'+CX)BY(w(,F�0J:)0CK � F � KWV=+JF�$%0J:9Vg(�$'-/0JBQ(e>)KLV=- � F � :)I=j"#%@E+�@ � <?( � @/@/>)(*0C1�$'& � @%V)-'0CX)BY(OK � @p$'&)(�FO0J@A$!0.1@/& � V=V � :=IW$/&)-'0C>)IJ&v+WV � Vg(OB � :)(�R&=(O:9$/&)(*<)-'+CImFO0N( �yF � (O:N$ � @BÖ+.-'IC(e-"$/&=+C:v:)(e(e<9Xg(Cj

� I &%I =@?�=@M I 9� I� = 6 7K9/;�<L=@? C�p&)(MV)>)-'Vg0J@/(w0C1�$'&)(MRr0J-/S?@/&)0CV � @"$'0W(��?V)BY0C-'(E$'&)(MKW(eFG&=+C: � @/K�@pX[byR& � FG&�$'&)(�X � T+U=> � < P (e-A$ � Fe+.B � :J$'(O-/1�+CFO(M<)(�1q0C-'K�@pR � $'&$ � KW(�R&)(e:]$/&)(,@A(y$6Rr0`Ud> � <=@ U=0`R $/&=-/0J>)IC&�+�V � Vg(�0.1%FOb[B � :=<?- � Fe+.B4IJ(O0JKm(O$/-'b�>):d<?(O-�$/&)(9<?- �YP[� :=I�1q0C-GF�(y0C1+�F�0C:d@6$G+.:N$V)-'(e@'@A>=-/(mIC-G+C< � (O:N$,jm�p&)(,@A(�< � &o(O- � :)I Ud> � <=@MKW+ub�&=+ P (W< � &g(e-/(e:J$ P[� @/FO0J@ � $6bH0J-�< � &o(O-'(O:N$�<?(e:=@ � $ � (,@M0C-�Xg0.$/&{jyDEX P[� 0C>=@/BQb$/&=(*FO+C@/(�0.1�< � &g(e- � :)Iy<?(e:=@ � $ � (,@R � BYB�Xg(*F�0J:=@ � <?(e-'+CX)BQb�Km0J-/(�< � �yF�>)BQ$%Xg(eFe+.>=@/(M$/&)('Ud0`RiR � BQB{BQ0N@A(�F�b[B � :d<?- � FO+CB{@/bNKWKW(�$'-/b<?>)(M$'0m$/&)( � :GU=>)(e:=F�(�0C1lIJ-'+ P[� $6bWV)-/0?<?>dF � :)IW:)(OIN+`$ �YP (MX)>=0`bJ+.:dF�b�( &o(eF�$'@ej6� +JCEG>D C�p&)( U=0`RÑR � $'&�Xd0C$/&�V=-/0JVd(e-A$ � (,@!< � &g(e-/(e:J$wR � BYBlXd(e&=+ P (*B � SC(�+yFO0CK_X � :d+`$ � 0C:H0C1n+y2�0 � @/(O> � BQBY('U=0`RÑKW0?< � fd(e<HX[b9IC-G+ PN� $6bNTF�>=-/-'(O:N$ATUB � SJ(*Xd(e&=+ P[� 0J>)-,jE�p&=+.$ � @!$'&)(mFO>)-'-/(e:J$wR � BYBlBQ0N@A(m@Ab[KWKW(�$/-'bH+C@%$/&)(_&)(e+ P[� (O- U=> � <�KW0 P (,@%<?0`R:H$'&)(W@ � <?(�0C14$/&=(F�0J:N$'+ � :)(e-p+C:=<9>):=<?(e-p$/&)(�B � IC&N$/(e-!U=> � <�j� <��,G��,C 687K9NH+= 7 IKGL=@C�lBQ> � <)@W2n-/0JVd(e-A$ � (,@_�r0C:=@ � <?(O-�$/&=+.$W+C:Nb]F�0JK�X � :=+.$ � 0C:|0.1%$/&)(,@A( U=> � <)@_FO0C>)BÖ<|Xg(9@/& � V)Vg(e<|0J-_X=+.$'FG&)(,<|R � $/&a+C:Nb]0C$/&)(e-�q&=(e+C<v$'0_$G+ � B ��Ë

�'?�H,GL7 G>D & < � M� 9/7:? &%I G>9NM2 � Vg(OB � :)(HFO0CKWV=+.: � (,@_&d+ P (�<?( P (OBY0CVg(e< Km(,+.:=@m$'0|F�0CVg(9R � $'& $'&)(�V)-'0CX)BY(OK�j�� � -G@6$'BQba+CBQBp$'&)(�V � Vd(eB � :)( U=0`R!@W+.-'(91q>)BYBQb$/>=-/X)>=BQ(e:J$,t)+.:=<vV � Vd(eB � :)(*@A$'+C-A$/T¨>)VvV)-'(eF�(,<?>)-'(e@r&=+ P (wXg(O(O:�<?( P (OBY0CVg(e<�$/&d+`$!�N> � FGS[BYbW$'+CSC(E$/&)(OU=0`Rh$/&)-'0C>)IJ&y$'&)(MBY+CK � :=+C--'(OI � 0C:{jl�rb[V � Fe+.BYBQbW$'&)('U=0`Rh@/Vg(O(e< � @!Ì*KWV)&�+.:=<9k(ebN:=0CBÖ<)@":N>=K�Xg(O-G@+.-'(w+_K � : � K�>=KL0.1l�J�J�C�)jl�p+`$'FG& � :J$'(O-/1�+CFO(e@r$/(e:=<$/0�@A$'+CX � B �Y� ( � :�+�ÍC�F�_V � Vg(OB � :)(*+`$%+CXd0J>?$%ÍCÌ.�mK��)j�# ÍC�F�_0C-%Í`�B��V � Vg(OB � :=( � @+mIJ0N0?<9@ �Y� (M$'0�F�0C:d@ � <?(O-,j

Ø

Page 16: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

W � � � � � ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� � � ��� ��� �

5�#��Êrk36#� ÓwÊ É 7?36� � �qS[I1V.F�>)X � FwKW(�$/(e- � �%3A7=�DM7?36� � ��F�(e:N$ � @6$'0CSC(,@p+`$*�,Ì����É ×� Ì�WJ� �)jY�×M+C@/0CB � :)( �`�J� �)j �Ó � (,@A(eB{�)>)(eB �C�J� �)j �7[b[:N$/&)(O$ � F��r-/>d<?( Ì.�NÌ Ì?jÏÌ�r0C:d<?(O:=@'+`$'( WN�CÍ �)jÏÌ7[R"(O(O$� � IJ&N$'@ �C�J� W)j �7[0J>)-� � IC&N$'@ �JÌJÍ �uÌ?j �5H(,< � >=KZ�r-'>=<?( �C�BW ÌJÌ?j �Õ!(,+ P bv�r-/>=<)( �JÍC� �`�`�)j �

�l+.X=BQ(��JjQ�JË�ÓE(O:d@ � $6b�+.:d<v� � @'F�0N@ � $6by0C1l2�(�$'-/0JBQ(e>)KL2n-/0?<?>=F�$'@

24-'(e@/(O:N$'(e<yX[boËÓE0C:�7?F�0C$A$Ê4:[X)- � <?IC(w3;:=F�0J-/Vg0C-G+`$'(e<�t=�"+CBQIN+.-'bCt?#!BYXd(e-A$G+

Ø

Page 17: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� � � � � ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� � � ��� ��� � ���� !���,�m�Z�Ò���l� �.� )e��� ��� )O�! "���O� � -�� �!� ��� � �����{�! "� � 4 �!� ���l�!�3U14Vg0C-/$A1q0CB � 0J@!K�+J<?(�>)V�0.1n+�@/(OBY(eF�$ � 0C:H0C14Vd(O$/-'0CBY(O>)KZV)-'0.z6(,F�$'@E+.-'(*V)BY0.$/$/(e<�0C:�+�IJ-'+CV)&H0.14(O�?Vd(,F�$/(,< P +.BY>)( P (O-G@A>d@!- � @/Sot$/&=(O-'( � @+.:9>)V)Vg(O-%Xd0J>):=<)+C-/by+CXd0 P (ER& � FG&9:)0WVd0J-A$/1q0CB � 0N@"+C-/(w1q0J>):=<�j4�p& � @p>)V)Vg(O-%Xd0J>):=<)+C-/b � @pS[:)0`R:9+J@r$/&)(�( ��F � (e:N$1q-'0C:N$ � (O-,jÕ%+C-/-'ba5�+C-/SJ0`R � $ � -'( P 0CBY>?$ � 0C: �Q� (e<a$/&)(Hfd(OBÖ<�0.1MVd0J-A$/1q0CB � 0]$'&)(O0J-/b R � $'&�& � @�V � 0J:)(O(e- � :)I]R"0C-'S � :�$'&)(��,�JÌ.�J@Oj\Õ � @+.V=V)-/0N+CFG&a$/0|( �yF � (e:J$�1q-'0C:N$ � (e-y+.:=+CBQb?@ � @m>=@/(e@�K�+.$/- � � +CBQIJ(OX)-G+�$/0�<?(O$/(O-'K � :=(�+.:c+.:=+CBQbN$ � Fe+.B(��?V)-'(e@'@ � 0J:�1q0C-y$/&)(HB � :=(-'(OV)-'(e@/(O:N$ � :)I_$/&)(�( �yF � (O:N$1q-/0J:N$ � (O-,j3;:�+.V)V)BYb � :=I�( �yF � (O:N$�1q-/0J:N$ � (O-W$/&=(O0C-'b|$'08$'&)(H-'(e+.BYK�0C1E$'&)(HVd(O$/-'0CBY(O>)K � :d<?>=@A$/-'bCtp5H(O-G+.S�&d+C@m$'+CSC(e:�+]< � &g(e-/(e:N$+.V=V)-/0N+CFG&�j!5�(O-G+.So� @E+.V)V=-/0N+CFG&�>=@/(e@EV)-/( P[� 0J>=@ABYb9IC(O:=(O-G+`$/(,<H5H0C:N$'(m�"+.-'BQ0�-/(,@A>)BQ$'@w+.:d<H+y-G+.:=<?0JKxVg0C-/$A1q0JB � 0�IJ(O:)(e-'+.$ � 0C:@'FG&)(OKW(�$'0�V)BY0.$_$/&)0J>=@/+C:=<)@�0.1 P +.B � <|Vg0C-/$A1q0JB � 0J@�0C:�+C:�( �yF � (O:N$_1q-/0J:J$ � (e-�IJ-'+CV)&�jH3U$m�N> � FGS[BQb�Xg(eF�0JKW(e@�+CV)V=+C-/(e:J$�$/&=+.$$/&=(O-'( � @!+C:v>)V=Vd(e-!Xd0J>):=<)+C-/bJt)+.BQ$/&)0J>)IC&�+mB � :)( � @p:)0.$!(O�?V)B � F � $/BYbv<)-'+uR:�j�"0.$'&m0C1d$'&)(e@/(%+CV)V)-'0J+CFG&=(e@l&=+ P (@A$/-'(O:)IC$/&=@n+.:=<WR"(e+CSN:=(e@'@A(,@Oj{�=0C- � :=@A$'+C:=F�(JtJ5H(e-'+CSg� @�+.V=V)-/0N+CFG&mBY+JFGS?@l$/&)(%+C:=+.BYbN$ � FO+CBF�(e-A$G+ � :N$6bv-'(OIN+.-G< � :=IW$/&)(_( �yF � (O:=FOb�0.14V)-'0CK � @ � :)I�Vg0C-/$A1q0CB � 0J@%$/&=+.$%$/&=(_5�+C-/SJ0`R � $ � +.V)V)-'0J+JFG&�&=+C@ejEÊ P (O:�$'&)0C>=IC&�$/&=(O-'(K�+uba@/(O(OK}$/0|Xg(H:)0|Vg0C-/$A1q0CB � 0J@�+.Xg0 P (�+]V=+C-A$ � FO>)BY+C-�Vd0J-A$/1q0CB � 0]0J: $'&)(HIC-G+.V=&�t � $ � @y+.BYR"+ub?@mVg0J@'@ � X)BY(v$'&=+`$�$/&)(H:)(O�[$-G+.:=<?0JKWBQbyIJ(O:)(e-'+.$/(,<yVg0C-/$A1q0CB � 0mR � BYB�Xd(M$'&)(�Xg(e@A$!bC(�$,jDE: $/&)(H0C$/&)(e-m&d+.:=<�tr$/&=(�5�+.-'SC0`R � $ � +.V)V=-/0N+CFG&�&=+J@�@A0JKW(�@/( P (O-'(vB � K � $'+.$ � 0C:=@WR&=(O:c+.V)V=B � (e<a$/0�$/&=(HVd(O$/-'0CBY(O>)K� :=<?>=@A$/-'boË

�p&)(�@ � KWV)B � fdFe+`$ � 0C:�0.1p<?(e@'F�- � X � :=I9+v- � @/S�V)-'0.f=BY(_R � $/&]0J:)BQb�+9KW(e+C:�+C:=< P +C- � +.:dF�(�R � BYB4BQ(,+C<�$/0 � :d+CFOFO>)-G+CF � (e@ � :$/&)(�( ��F � (e:N$"1q-'0C:N$ � (e-ej 3U$!KW+ub�:)0.$!Xg(*Vg0J@'@ � X)BY(E$'0�V=+.-/$ � F � V=+.$/( � :�+WV=-/0Cz6(eF�$!+.$%+.:H+.-'X � $/-G+.- � BYbWf=:)(�BY( P (OB�0.1�IC-G+.:[>)BÖ+.- � $6bCj47[0CKW(�V)-'0.z6(,F�$G@KW+ub�Xg(*@/>=FG&9$/&=+.$$/&)(eby-/(,�N> � -'(W�e�J��� � : P (e@A$/KW(O:N$0C-p$'&)(Ob9FO+C:):)0.$Xg(*<?0C:=(M+.$%+.BYB j �p&)(mFO0C:=@A$/-G+ � :N$'@%$/&=+.$*<?(�$'(O-'K � :)(WR& � FG&�Vg0C-/$A1q0JB � 0J@M+.-'( P +CB � <8Fe+.:8Xd(�F�0JKWV)B � FO+.$/(,< � :�$'&)(WVd(O$/-'0CBY(O>)K � :=<?>=@A$/-'bCj�r0C:=@A$/-G+ � :N$'@pB � SJ(E�C3U14#Ò$/&)(e:�+.BÖ@A0��wto�Et=+C:=<�Ó��W0J-$�.3U1�Ê�$/&=(O:H:)0C$%�a0J-%×E�W0C-)�C#"$EBQ(,+C@A$!Ím0C14Õ*t)3�tg�=t=+C:=<�Ô �FO+.:=:)0.$Xg(�(e+C@ � BQb�(O�[V=-/(,@/@/(e<9+C@+mB � :)(,+.-(,�J>d+`$ � 0C:{t?R& � FG& � @-/(,�N> � -'(e<�1q0C-p$'&)(*5�+C-/SJ0`R � $ � +.V=V)-/0N+CFG&�j

�p&)(!IJ0J+CB?0.1g$/& � @4V)-'0.z6(,F�$ � @�$'0*+C<)<?-'(e@'@l$/&=(!Rr(,+.S[:)(,@/@/(e@�0C1g$'&)($6R"0*+.V)V=-/0N+CFG&)(,@Ot`Vg0.$'(O:N$ � +.BYBQb_X[b_F�0JK�X � : � :)I�0C-nV=+.-/$ � +.BYBQbF�0JK�X � : � :)IM$/&=(OK�j�#\( �yF � (e:J$n1q-/0J:J$ � (e-4+.:=+CBQb?@ � @4Km(O$/&)0?<m$'&=+`$rFO0CK_X � :=(e<m$/&=(!-/0JX)>=@A$/:)(,@/@40.1o$/&)(E5H0C:N$/(M�"+.-'BQ0�+.V=V)-/0N+CFG&R � $/&9$/&)(*FO0C:?fg<?(O:=FO(M0.1l$/&)(*5�+C-/SJ0`R � $ � +CV)V)-'0J+JFG&yRr0J>)BÖ<�Xg(*+WVd0`R"(O-/1q>)Bo$'0N0JBo1q0C-!+C:Nb � :=<)>=@6$'-/bJj24-'(e@/(O:N$'(e<yX[boË�N+C@/0C:v5�F���(e+C:5H(e-'+CS�24-'0.z6(,F�$'@� � K � $/(e<�tg�"+.BYIJ+C-/bJtN#%BQXg(O-/$'+

Ø

Page 18: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� � � � � � ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� � � ��� ��� �

� � � � � �O ��x� � 4 ��� ��� � �(�H�!��� � v ��*���w����� � -��Ç��� " �! n�'����)�� �_�����7[b[:=FO-/>=<)(90JVd(e-'+.$/(,@m+8BÖ+.-'IC(90 � B�T;@/+C:=<�K � :)( � :�:)0J-A$'&)(O-': #%BQXg(O-/$'+]+.:d<a0`R:=@W@/( P (O-G+.B"0.1%$'&)(HR"0C-'BY<�� @_BY+C-/IJ(e@A$mK � : � :=I(��)Fe+ P +.$/0J-'@ej��p&)(�Xd0[0JK +.:d<8X=>=FGSC(O$et{R& � FG&]BY0N0JS8@/0CKW(OR&d+`$�B � SC(W$'&)0J@/(�0.1+�@6$G+.:=<=+.-G<8FO0C:=@A$/-'>=F�$ � 0J:](��)FO+ P +`$'0C-,t�+.-'(<?- �QP (O:9X[byX[b�BÖ+.-'IC(w&Nb?<?-G+.>=B � FEFOb[B � :=<?(e-'@p0JVd(e-'+.$ � :)I�+`$>)V9$/0y�J�C5�2�+ �q�J�NÌ.�CV=@ � ��jDEVg(O-G+`$/0J-'@!0.14$'&)(e@/(�BÖ+.-'IC(*K�+JFG& � :=(e@ERr0J>)BY<�Xd(e:)(�f)$w1q-'0CKZ-/(,+.BQT $ � KW(_SN:=0`Rr(,<?IC(*0C1 �6� �$'&)(_Vd+ubNBY0J+J< � :�$/&)(_X)>=FGSJ(�$et+.:d<��¨Í �r$'&)(*< � ICI � :)Im1q0C-GF�(�+.$"$'&)(*X)>dFGSC(�$p$'(O(�$'&�j43;:�0C-G<?(e-p$/0WXd(_+ P[� +.X)BY(MV)-'0[<)>=F�$,t?$/& � @ � :?1q0C-'K�+`$ � 0J:9K_>=@A$pXg(*-'(OBÖ+`$'(e<$/0]$'&)(H0CVg(O-G+`$'0C-WR � $/&)0J>?$y$/&=(H:)(O(,<a$'0�@6$'0CV�$/&=(HKm0C$ � 0C:�0.1w$/&=(HKW+JFG& � :)(H0C-y<?0�+C:[bJ$'& � :)I�$/&=+.$yRr0J>)BY<�& � :=<?(e-�$/&=(V)-'0?<?>=F�$ � 0J:�j��{0�Xg(!>=@/(�1q>)B¨tJ$/&)( � :?1q0C-'K�+`$ � 0J:W@/&)0J>)BY<mXg(%+ P + � BY+CX)BY(r$'0M$/&)(%0CVg(O-G+`$/0J-�R � $'&y+`$4KW0J@A$!�e@4BY+.$/(O:dF�b_+C:=<W@A&=0C>)BÖ<Xg(y+CFOFO>)-G+`$/(m$'09R � $/& � :aÌ�� 0.1"$/&)(�Vd+ubNBY0J+J<�j��)>)-/$/&=(O-'Km0J-/(Jt{+�F�0JKmKW(e-'F � +CB�V)-/0?<?>dF�$�Rr0J>)BÖ<�Xg(y(e+J@ � BYb�+.V)V=B � (e<�$/0�+C:Nb(��)Fe+ P +.$/0J-"R � $/&=0C>?$$'&)(�:)(O(,<y1q0J-(��[$/(e:=@ �QP (wKW0?<?(eB � :)I=j24-'( P[� 0C>=@�+CV)V)-'0J+JFG&)(e@w$'0H$/& � @_V)-/0JX)BY(OKÇ&=+ P (W1q0JBQBY0`Rr(,<]+�$/-G+C< � $ � 0C:d+.Bn-'0CXg0.$ � Fe@ V.<?b[:=+.K � FO@�+CV)V)-'0J+CFG&{j�#L<?b[:=+.K � FKW0?<?(OB[0.1=$/&)("Xd0[0JK +.:=<*FOb[B � :=<?(e-'@�R"+J@�<)( P (eBQ0JVd(,<�j�k!(e+C< � :)IN@�1q-'0CK &[b?<?-G+.>)B � F4V)-'(e@'@A>=-/(n@/(O:d@A0J-'@�+.:=<!z60 � :J$�+.:=ICBY(r@/(O:=@/0C-G@R"(O-'(*1q(e<�$/&)-'0C>=IC&�$'&)(mKm0?<?(eBl$/0�<?(�$'(O-'K � :)(_$/&)(mV=+ub[BY0J+C<�jMÕ%0`Rr( P (e-etd$/&)(e-/(m+.-'(_@/(O- � 0J>=@EB � K � $G+`$ � 0C:d@E0C14$/& � @M+.V=V)-/0N+CFG&@ � :=FO( � $ � @ � KmV=-'+JF�$ � FO+CB4$'0�<?( P (OBY0CV|+�<?(O$'+ � BY(e<�<)bN:d+.K � FyKm0?<?(eBn0C1p( P (e-/b8KW+JFG& � :)(�$/08R& � FG&]$/&)(vV)-/0?<?>dF�$�R"0C>)BÖ<]Xg(+.V=V)B � (e<�j�p&)(!FO0CKWV=+.:[b � @ � :N$/(O-'(e@A$/(,<_$/0�S[:)0`Ra0C1o+C:)0.$'&)(O-4+CV)V)-'0J+JFG&�R& � FG&�FO+.:WV)-'0?<?>=FO(p$/&)(-'(e�N> � -/(,<mVd(e-A1q0J-/K�+.:dF�(pR � $'&)0C>)$$/&=(�:)(O(,<�$'0�<?( P (OBY0CV�+_KW0J-/(�<?(O$'+ � BY(e<�<?b[:=+.K � FwKm0?<?(eB j24-'(e@/(O:N$'(e<yX[boËÓw+ PN� <��0CS[&)0J-'@A$k%7[3p��(eFG&):)0JBQ0JI � (e@et[� � F�$/0J- � +)t)�wj �Ej

Ø

Page 19: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� � � � � ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� � � ��� ��� � �� ) � � ������ ��w������� � � � ��� � �O �� ) � ��� $�� &'��� � � ���/� �� ��$H������� ���l�/&� "� &������ -�������/)O� � �_�/$���� �w���O� ��p&)(e-/(%+C-/(!+�@A$'+CICIJ(O- � :)IJBQb�BY+C-/IJ(":[>)K_Xd(e-n0C1 � <?-'>)ICB � SJ(��MFG&)(eK � FO+CBdFO0CKWVd0J>):=<)@4R& � FG&yFe+.:�Xg(!K�+C<?(JtN+C:=<m$/&=(!:[>)K�Xg(O-r0.1>): � �N>)(!KW0CBY(eFO>)BÖ+.-n@A$/-'>=F�$'>)-'(e@4K�+ub P (O-'b�R"(OBYB=Xg( � :W$/&)(E0C-G<?(O-n0.1��e� * nln j��{0_<)+`$'(CtC0J:)BYb_0J:W$/&)(!0J-'<)(O-40C1��,� r FO0CKWVd0J>):=<)@&=+ P (EXg(O(e:9K�+J<?(*+.:=<9FG&=+C-'+JF�$/(e- �Y� (,<�j�p&)(yK�+ � :�&=0CVg( � : +�F�BÖ+C@'@ � fdFe+`$ � 0J: � @�$'&)(�(O� � @A$/(e:=F�(v0.1!+�@ � K � BY+C- � $6b8Vd+`$A$'(O-': � :]$/&)(9FG&)(OK � FO+.Bp@A$/-'>=F�$'>)-/(JtlFe+.BYBQ(,<� V=&=+.-'K�+CF�0JV)&)0J-/(a�)jl�r0JKmVg0C>=:=<)@pK�+`$GFG& � :=I�$'&)(�@/+CKm(MV)&d+.-'KW+JF�0JV)&)0C-'( � :N$/(O-G+CF�$"R � $/&�X � 0CBY0CI � Fe+.BgKW0CBY(eF�>=BQ(,@ ��(O: � b[Km(,@Ot-'(eF�(eV?$/0J-'@etu(�$GF � � :m+%@ � K � BY+C-{1�+J@A& � 0C:{t.+.:=<*+wF�BÖ+C@'@ � fdFe+`$ � 0J:�0.1)$'&)(e@/(rV=&=+.-'K�+CF�0JV)&)0J-/(,@�Rr0J>)BÖ<�Xd(pF�0J:=@ � <?(e-/(,<*+.:�(O:)0J-/KW0C>d@X)-'(e+CSJ$'&)-'0C>)IJ& � :�<)-/>)I�< � @'F�0 P (e-/bJtJV=-/0 P[� < � :=Im+JFOF�(,@/@"$'0�+ � SC(eb1��$/0�( P (e-/b � BQ0?FGS6�)j#!: � KWKW(e< � +.$/(p�J>=(e@A$ � 0C: � @�$/0w(e@A$ � KW+.$/(n$/&)(p:[>)K�Xg(O-l0.1=$/&)(,@A("V)&=+C-/K�+CFO0CV)&=0C-'(e@ej�5�+`$'&)(OK�+`$ � Fe+.BYBQbJt,$/& � @ � @�+%�N>)(,@6$ � 0J:+.Xg0C>)$�&)0`R+.:|0CX)z6(eF�$_R � $'&a+H@AK�+CBQB¨tlf)�?(e<]:[>)K�Xg(O-_0.1V)&=+C-/K�+JF�0CV=&)0C- � F�1q(e+.$/>)-'(e@*f=BYBY@_+�FO+ P[� $6bCt{X=>?$m+CBY@/0�+.:|(O�[V=BQ0CT-G+`$ � 0C:H0C1�$/&)(mK � : � K_>)K @A(O$E0C140CX?z6(,F�$'@%-/(,�N> � -'(e<9$'0v< � @/V)BY+ubH+CBQBlV)&=+C-/K�+CFO0CV)&=0C- � Fw(OBY(OKW(e:J$G@ � :8+CBQB�Vd0N@/@ � X)BQ(_IC(e0CKW(�$'- � F+.-'-G+.:)IJ(OKW(O:N$'@ej2�+.-/$ � F � V=+C:J$G@ � :N$'(O-'(e@A$/(e< � :�$/& � @EV)-'0CX)BY(OK @A&)0J>)BÖ<91�+.K � B � +.- �Q� (�$/&)(eK�@A(eB P (e@R � $/&H$'&)(��CV)&=+C-/K�+CFO0CV)&=0C-'(�� � <?(,+)j�p&=+.$F�0J:=F�(eV?$E+J@Rr(eBQB�+C@!0C$/&)(e-'@%+.-'(*< � @'F�>d@/@/(e< � :�$/&)(�1q0JBQBY0`R � :)I�V=+.Vg(O-G@ej"# :[>)K_Xd(e-%0C1�-'(�1q(e-/(e:=F�(,@ � :�$'&)(e@/(*V=+CVd(e-'@%K�+ub�Xg(0.1 � :J$'(O-'(e@A$!+C@pR"(OBYBo1q0C-p1q0CBYBY0`R>)V�Ë 2 � FGSC(�$/$et�7oj Ó_j !�5�+C@/0C:�t*�dj 7�j !y5�F {+ubJt�3�j 5|j �CÓ �QP (O-G@ � $6bi2n-/0Cf=B � :)Ic+C:=< Ó%(,@ � IC: �E@ � :)I\�JÓ}24&d+.-'KW+JF�0JV)&)0C-'(e@eË24&=+C-/K�+CFO0CV)&=0C-'(�T;Ó%(e- �YP (,< .E>=(O- � (,@ ��2nÓ . �s�W�djd�r&)(OK�j43;:)16jr�r0CKWV)>?$,jn7?F � j �6�,�C�bW ��t)�BW)to�,Í)�O�.TG�,ÍJÍ.�=j #%@/&J$'0C:�t�5|j �dj !n�N+ubC(Jt�5|j �Ej !n5�+C@/0C:{t��djÏ7oj%� É (OR 2�(e-'@/Vd(,F�$ �QP (e@ � : �(,+C<�×w(O:=(O-G+`$ � 0C:|3/3�ËlÊ P +.BY>=+`$ � :)I�5�0CBY(eF�>=BY+C-Ó �YP (e-'@ � $6b6�mÓ%-'>)I�Ó � @'F�0 P (O-'by�{0?<)+ub �A�e�C�BW���t P 0CB¨jp�Ct?:)0djnÍ?td�?��TA�`�)j ×w-/(e(O:)(JtC�=j ![Ô�+.&):�t[7oj ![7?+ P 0.z�tCÕ�j !?7[V)-G+.IJ>)(CtJ2�j ![�{( � IdtN7ojB�N�r&)(eK � Fe+.B)�)>=:=F�$ � 0J: .E>)(O- � (,@�1q0C-r�CÓ\Ów+`$G+.X=+J@A(%7[(,+.-GFG&���=jd�r&)(eK�j�3;:?16j"�r0CKWV)>)$ejn7?F � j �A�e�C�C� ��t[�C�=t��uÍ.�N�uT'�,�C�J�)j �rBY+C-/SotoÓ�j Ê!j !�~ � BQBY(�$/$et{2�j !{ÔM(O:=:NbJt�2�j ~ j �C2n&=+.-'K�+CFO0CV)&)0J- � F�2�+`$/$/(e-/:�5�+`$'FG& � :)I � :�� � BY([email protected]"�p&)-/(e(�T;Ó � KW(O:=@ � 0C:=+CB�r&)(OK � FO+.B{7[$/-'>=F�$'>)-/(,@OË�3;KWV)BY(OKW(O:N$G+`$ � 0C:�0C1��lBY(�� � X=BQ(*7[(,+.-GFG& � :=I<�m�=j)5H0JB jn×w-G+.V=& � Fe@ �6�,�C�C� ��t P 0JB jp�J�Ct��O��W`TG�,ÌbW)j ÔM>)&)B¨t[�"jÏ7oj !d�r- � V)Vg(O:�t)×mj 5|j !)�=- � (e@/(O:{t[Ó_j ÔWj1�J#Ñ�r0JK�X � :=+.$/0C- � +.Bd#%BQIJ0C- � $'&)K 1q0C-%�"+.BÖF�>=BY+.$ � :)I � IN+.:=<y� � :=< � :)I<�_�=j�r0CKWV)>?$,jr�r&)(OK�j �6�,�C�C� ��t P 0CB¨j�Ì)t?:)0=j�Jt=Í`�CTU�C�=j#!BÖ@/0=t[$/&=(O-'( � @!+mR"(OX9V=+.IJ(wR& � FG&�: � F�(eBQb�<)(e@'F�- � Xg(e@+WF�0JKWKm(e-'F � +CB � KWV)BY(OKW(e:J$G+`$ � 0J:v0C1lV)&d+.-'KW+JF�0JV)&)0C-'(E+C:=+.BYb?@ � @eË

&N$A$'V�Ë V<VuRRR�j 0u�?Km0JB j F�0dj >=S�V`V)-'0[<=@ V.FG&)(OKmT¨��V`V)&N$/(,FG&�j &N$'KmB24-'(e@/(O:N$'(e<yX[boË��0CKLÓE0CK�+.:7[(,+.-'BQ(��r0C-'Vg0C-G+`$ � 0C:{t?�r& � FO+CIC0dt?3;BQB � :=0 � @

Ø

Page 20: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

�e� � � � � � ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� � � ��� ��� �

Ø

Page 21: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� ��������� �

� ����� � � � � � ��� � � � � � � � � � � � � ��� � �

� ��� ��� �����

���������� �� *���� ������������ � 2 ����� � �"!#�%$�&'& � � �(&'� �"*)�,+-�.���&0/1.1 2 ��2 *3 � 4)657���"!8 �/09;:=< �'> *��?@4� �3 ��4)'?@A � � .4�B! $�9�C3;D ��09/*383 > 49 49 � "*)�A �'> *��)'� > �"! � )�4D � � � �� � ��FEG��)�&0��;A � EH���� ���)I� � � 2 ��� � �"!J3���)�,��3 /4�"9 2 ���=KML �� � ��"*��! D ��N �� �� L $ 2O �PQ/4� 3#P'� ��P�*����&FR�� � / � )I�=3 /09;:���� D

S,T�U V �XWHY[Z�\&^]%WH_Z � T` � �ba=$�* ��c3J�d/4ef�g$')'�"9C��P�4 -hi13���6!8$'P�P' �����! � @!jRQ��9/4�,�k4)l�"! ! $'�m/*ef?4����*3j���XPQ/4� 3�4)�9C�neo/4�6 �4� ?@� � $�� R�4)p9C��)=3 ����!�qL �"&0��! P'����4&r��)�&0$�!83 ����4 ��"! *3 ��/4) � P�/@ � �$03 ��/4) � 4)�&s&'�.4�� �/@P'�,�)=3,/*e-4� �B4!X9C �/@! �j3�/m3 �;4&0��3 ��/4)�4 ih%*3 ��,! /4$'�;9C�B! � �.4�F4 � 9C/@)=3 ����R'$'3 ��&63�/�3 � ��&0��?4�;4&'*3 ��/4)^/*e[/4$��t&0����)�:=��)'?�hi13��� � 4)�&^��4&0�u3 � �f3�/4P'�"9f�! $'R0vJ�B9w3-/*e � ��*3 �B&x&0�R�13 �@qty(z�9C�"* "!*)�&^P' �4)')'����!t13t4 � { ���.4�� �!#/4e|?4/1.@���)'�,�)=3 � �.4�f����9/4?@)'��! ��&F3 � �g)'����&63�/j��*)�4?4�uhi13���(&0�"!83 ����R'$'3 ��/4)x)'�3Jh�/@� :0!�! /j@!3 /���4��)=3�4��)^49�9C��P03�4R' ��7 ��.@� "!#/*e{h%*3 ���a=$�4 ���3J�4q����B94$�!8�-/*e{3 � �g9C/@�XP� ��}���3J��/4e{��.4�)F3 � �f!8���,P' ��B!J3t/*e�~�/1h�)'�3Jh�/@� :0! �)�$'�,�����9�* '9/4�,P'$03;13 ��/4)�! � �.4�%R��B9C/@�X��4)��B! ! �)=3���4 �3 /�/4 '��)�3 � �#hi13���|a=$�* ���3J�f��*)�4?4��,��)@3[P'��/09C�B! ! � *)�&,! ����$' "13 ��/4)�!/*eH)'�3Jh�/@� :0!�h#�c3 �I� $�)�&0����&'!i/4e�vJ$')�9C3 ��/4)�! � P'$��XP���)'?�!83�*3 ��/4)�! � 3�4)':0!#*)�&6����! ���.4/@���;!G4� �u9C/@�,�X/@)'P' "49�,� �1��q` � �-eo/4��hi*�;&�/4�#&0��)�4�X�"97!8���g$� �*3 ��/4)j/4e�hi13���i)'�C3Jh%/4��:0!Gh#��3 � :�)'/1h#)69 � *�;49C3 ����"!J3���9�!�4)�&F9/4)=3�4�,��)�4)=3%��)'P'$03;!i��!e�*���� ��Xh��� � ���$')�&0����!83 /�/0& � *)�&�! /*e�3Jhi*���#P�@9;:�4?4�B!|!8$�9 � 4!��t�������'�m� ��� � h � �"9 � ��!|eo� ��� ��=���.1*�� "*R' ��#/1.4���[3 � �-��)=3 ��� )'�3 � *���h#�"&0� ��x$�! ��&m��)n3 � ����)�&0$�!83 ���4q���/1h%�.@�� � F�,/@� ��&0��z�9C$' �3g4! P��B9w3u/*e%h%*3 ���u)'�C3Jh%/4��:0!(�"!73 � �m� ��)�.@��;!8�B��/4�I�8eo/4���)�! �"9�P'��/4R' ����h � ��� � � eo/@���C}'*�,P' �� � /@)'�|hi*)=3�!�3�/�:�)'/1h � /1hk��$�9 � /*e'�9/4)=3�4�,��)�4)=3 � 4!�R����)u��� ���4! ��&-?@��.@�)7�,��4! $'����,�)=3;!/*e�9C/@)@3;*�,��)�*)=3[ ���.4�� �!H13|9�� 3�*��)X �/09*3 ��/4)�!��1q ` � �"!H��!H3 � �iP'��/4R' ����3 � 13 ��� *�� ��B!{�(/1h%4��&g�p�(!�! /�9��*3 �B![��3�&�q%� � �(�(�{� �X �/09�* ��(�"9w3�/4����X��)'?4��)'���� ��)'?,9C/@)�!8$� c3���)'?, �� � � R'��/4$'? � 3%3�/X3 � �fEG� > ��P�� /@R' ����X��! /4 �.���)'?Xh%/4��:�! � /@P�qyt$'�u ���!83f3�@!8:neo� /@� � �t�(�¡hi4!u3 /x�}04�,��)'�,3 � �F&'�=)�*�,��9n��eo/4��hi*�;&��7* �?4/@� ��3 � �¢$�!8�B&b��)s�t�������'� � 4)�&b�)�! $'���3 � 13���3G�"!�9/4�,P'$03���)�?fP � �0!8�"94 � ��g����@!8/@)�*R' ��#!8/@ �$'3 ��/4)�!|eo/4�G)��C3Jh%/4��:�!{3 � 13%�C}0PQ�������)�9C���;*P���&m�J~�/1h£���.@��;! 4 �! � �t��)�h � �"9 �3 � �(~�/1h¡��)j�P'��P��7!8�B9w3���/@)j9 � *)�?4��!�&0��� �B9w3 ��/4)j/1.4��%g! � /4� 3|3����,�-��)=3 ��� .14 �!�q ` � ��!��"!%gP�*� 3 �"9C$� �4��9C/@)�9C��� ),eo/@�%�-�������0� �RQ��94$�! �f3 � �,9�* "9C$' "13���/@)I/*eGhi13���t~�/1h���)x3 � ��P'��PQ�X)��C3Jh%/4��:F�"!t3 /*3;* � ��I&0�B9C/@$'P' ���&Ieo��/4�¤3 � �X9/4)=3�4�,��)�4)=3(3 �;*)�!8PQ/4� 3!83 �P�q ` � �-&0�"!�9C���C3 �(3 ���,�t!83 �PF$�! ��&,eo/@�G3 � �(~�/1h¡��!G3J��P'��9�* � ��,��$�9 � "*��?4��|3 � 4)�eo/4��3 � �-9/4)=3�4�X��)�4)@3 � 4)�&�! /g�t�������0����� � �.4�-&0�cz�9$' c3����B! � *)�&0 ���)'?�~�/1h¡���.4����!�* "!�q � �(�t�n�"!i* "!8/X9C/@)�9C��� )'�B&�*RQ/4$'3%h � �3 � ���i/4�%)'/*3i3 � �t��)�.4��;! �(P'��/4R' ����"!|h%� � c��P�/=!8�B& � *)�&,��e��c3%��!�PQ/@!�!8��R' ��#3 /f$�!8�t�C}0��!83 ��)'?ueo/@� hi*�;&,!8/@ �.@��;!{3 /X9C/4)�!J3�� $�9C3�*)�4 �?@/4���c3 � �¥eo/@��! /4 �.���)'?f3 � �t��)�.4����! �P'��/4R' ���^q

¦8§�¨�© ªC«J¬®­¯© °�±(²;³�´�µ;¶¸·Cµ;¬�±¹;§�¨�© ªC«J¬®­¯© °�±(²;³0ºH©¸»�°®²w¬¯©¼µ½ §�¨�© ªC«J¬®­¯© °�±(²;³�¾�µ�°®¿Àw§�¨�© ªC«J¬®­¯© °�±(²;³�Á�«J·w©¸¨1µÂ §�¨�© ªC«J¬®­¯© °�±(²;³�¾�¬®© °¯©¸­®¿-´�²w¶¸ÃBÄ%Å�©¼µÆCÇ ©¸Ä#²w¨tÈ1¬®µ;­®«J¬�§�¨�© ªC«J¬¯­®© °�±É�Ê ¿B«i©¸Ä#Ë*²w¬¯°®µ;¨�»J«%²;³Q³�²w¬®«J¨�­¯©¸»�Ì�µ�°¯«J¬|Í�Ã1µ;¶¸© °�±uµ;¨1µ;¶ ±B­¯©¸­[¿1µ;­[¬®«J»J«J© ªC«JÎgÌ�©¸Î�«J­®ËB¬®«8µ;ÎXµ�°�°¯«8¨C°¯©¸²w¨�Ì�© °®¿u°¯¿�«i¬¯«8»J«J¨C°�¬¯«J¶¸« µ;­¯«%²;³�°¯¿�«#Ï�²w¶¸¶ ±�Ì�²�²ÎÄ#² ª�©¸«�Ð�´�© ª�©¸¶=Ñ{»�°¯©¸²w¨�Òi­�°�µ;¬¯¬®©¸¨�·%ÓC²w¿B¨ Ê ¬�µJªC²w¶ °�µBÔ

Õ4Õ

Page 22: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

Õ�� ������������� ��������� �1��������������������� ����������� ��� ���!�"���#��$�%��������� &'�(��� �)�L ��R���?4��)���),3 � ��eo/@ � �/1h#��)'?f!8�B9w3���/@)�![h#��3 � 4)�/1.4���.�����hr/4eQ3 � ��P � �0! ��9�![/*e�~�/1hd��)�h%*3 ���&0��!83 ����R'$03 ��/4)�)��C3Jh%/4��:�! � 4)�&3 � �g���XP� ����X��)=3�13���/@)x$�! ��&I��)x3 � ���-�������0�m~�/1h ! /4 �.4����q ` � �gR'$' �:^/*e|/@$'�t����! $' �3�!�eo� /@� 3 � �gh%/4��:0! � /4PI*���g9C/@)�9C��� )���&h#��3 � *)�4 ��0! ��)�?�! ���,P' ��7~�/1hl)'�3Jh�/@� :0!%*)�&F$�! ��)�?�3 � �u����! $' c3;!�3 /�&0�;�hp9C/@)�9C �$�! ��/@)�!i*RQ/4$03i3 � �uh��� � ��®PQ/@! ��&')'��!�!%/*e�RQ/*3 �3 � �7eo/4��h%4��&F*)�&F��)�.@��;!8�-P'��/4R' ����!�q

S,TwS *,+ Z�- _!.0/ 1-W"2�Y43 _65�W{Y|_87�9FWH_Z�.;:<2iW=- ZgY �>5 T�¤3J��P'�"9* (h%*3 ���&'��!83 ����R�$03 ��/4)d)'�3Jh�/@� : � P'��9C3 $'����&£��) K ��?4$�� � � q Õ � 9�*)£R��n9/4)�! �"&0�����&£4!�b9/4 � ��B9w3 ��/4)d/4e�?A@CBEDGFx4)�&BIH�JLK6Fwq ` � �f ���)':0!�9/4�,�u��)^3Jh�/�.1*�����C3 ����!NMPO'QI@ Q KRFX*)�&SQITEU�QVFwq ` � �fP���PQ��!t9C/4)�.@���hi13����P�@! ! ��.4� ���eo��/4� /4)'�u)'�3Jh�/@� :

junction

pump

tank

pipe

B

A

reservoir

K ��?@$'� � � q Õ OH��3J��P'�"94 �h%*3 ���i&'��!83 ����R�$03 ��/4)^)'�3Jh�/@� :�qvJ$')�9C3 ��/4)M3�/n*)�/*3 � ��g��)M3 � �F&0������9w3���/@)M/*e�&0�B9C����4! ��)'?IP'����!�!8$'��� � �C}'9�P03gh � �����eo/4�;9C�B&bR=�mP'$'�,P�!�h � �"9 � *P'P� ��M! /4�,��C}�3����)�* �eo/4�;9C��)'?�3 /F��4��! �u3 � � � �0&0�;*$' ��"9 � ��@&^/*e[3 � ��hi13���t��)I3 � �X)'�C3Jh%/4��:�q ` � ��)�/�&'��!(4� �g���3 � ���WRTEB=X6YZ@[H\B F � Y^]\BEDGF/4�`_aKRF!K!_RbGHP@C_cFwq � $�)�9w3���/@)�!(9/4)')'�B9w3�3Jh%/�P'��P��X!8�B9w3���/@)�!#3�/4?4�3 � ���(*)�&^�,��6* "!8/F!8��� .@�7@!�PQ/4��)=3�!�/4e[h%*3 ��t9C/4)�!8$'�,P03���/@)�o�@q ?�q � ,� �B!8�"&0��)@3���4 �/4�(��)�&'$�!J3�� �"* {9C$�!83 /@�,��w�%/4���}=3����)�* �h%*3 ��t!8/@$'��9��!u���4q ?�q � �hi13���#3�� �B13 �,��)@3�P� �4)@3w�wq ` *)':0!�4)�&����! ���.4/4���;!�4� �-�C}�3 ��� )�* �)'/0&0�B!%3 � *3(!8��� .@�7@!%h%*3 ���!83 /@��4?4�7*����@!qd�efd�ehg i�j IPkml'n��po=lrq�Hslrt j t Ivu e�%�Ceo/@� �X�,/1.=��)'?F/4)x3�/Ij��13 � ���*3 �"9* [&0�B! 9� ��P03���/@)n/*eG3 � �,P � �0!8�"94 HP'� /09��!�!8�B!(��)n�B49 � /4eG3 � ��)��C3Jh%/4��:x9C/4�,PQ/4)'��)=3�! �h%�u)'��B&j3�/�&0�C �)��u3 � �uR�4! ��9-.1*����4R' ���!%3 � 13�h#�� � �RQ�f$�! ��&j3 /�&'��!�9C����RQ�uh%*3 ���i3 �;*)�! P�/@�83#��)63 � �u)'�3Jh�/@� :�q O *3 � ���i3 � 4)3 � ��.�4� �"*R� ��B!t.@� �/09C��3J�n*)�&kP'����!�!8$�� �X3 � 13f*���X3J�=P���9�* � ��x$�!8�B&k��)k~�$'�"&b�X�B9 � *)���9�!(3�/x&0��!�9C����R��X~�/1h � h%�,h#�� � |��)�!83 ��@&eo/4���g$� �*3 �-3 � �uP�� /@R' ���� ��)F3������!i/*e

wyx{z J\_N]\TE?A@[X�|L_a]}JLK�?A@CB=K�/@� x Kc]LJx�[~n�Hh � ��9 � eo/@� Õ + � !83 �B4&0� � ��)�9C/@�XP�� �B! ! ��R� ��i~�/1hd�"![?4��.4��),R=�,�%���)'/4$� � ��f� ![�Ba@$�13 ��/4)�O~4����}���

���� �y� ~)�\�

h � ���� � �"!i3 � �uP�� �B! ! $'��� � � ��!#3 � �f@99C�� �����*3 ��/4)j&'$'�73 /�?@���.���3J� � � 3 � �7~�$���&6.4�� �/09�c3J� � *)�&�~ � �"!%3 � �u�� ���.�*3 ��/4)(�w bGHP?ATEU�K!YZ_R@[X'��H\��_a]PY�K��Z�f�G3 � ��/4$�? � X! ��9w3���/@)F/4e�P'��P�� � h � �"9 � �"!i� �� �*3 �B&�3 /�3 � �-.@� �/09C��3J� � R��S��� ���R� � h � ����� �"!i3 � �f9C��/@!�!J��! ��9w3���/@)�* �*�����/*e�3 � �uP���PQ�4q

L ��)'/1h P'� /09���&x3 /I&0�B! 9� ��R��XR'�����~��^3 � �XP � �0! ��9�!-?4/1.4��� )���)'?j��49 � /*e|3 � �,)'�C3Jh%/4��:x9C/@�,P�/@)'�)=3�!-���,P' ����,�)=3 �B&n��)�t�������0� � h#��3 � 9C/@�XP� ��3 �f&0�3�*�� "!i?4��.4�)6��)b� ����O� Ê ¿B«8¬¯«|µ;¬®«|µ;¶¸­¯²%­®«�ªC«J¬�µ;¶@°�±BË*«J­{²;³#�N�6� �c�h��� �N =Ì�¿�©¸»®¿tÌ�«HÌ�©¸¶¸¶4¨�²;°{»J²w¨�­¯©¸Î�«J¬�¿�«J¬®«H³�²w¬�°¯¿�«|­�µc¡w«[²;³'­¯©¸Ä#Ë�¶¸©¸»J© °�±CÔ

¢

Page 23: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

v� v����$��% ��� %�����������h�(�����������"�!����������%��������#� Õ���� ������t` � ��~�/1h¡��)���@9 � P'��P��-�"!�@! ! $'�,��&,3�/gRQ�t!83 �B4&0� � $�)'�ceo/@� � 4)�&�9 � 4��@9w3 ��� �"! ��&XR���eo$� � ��=��&0��.4�� �/@P��B&,3 $'��R'$' ��)�9C�4q�(!Hhi13 ���H~�/1h�!H* �/4)'?t3 � �#P'��PQ��! ��9w3���/@)(vJ/@��)���)'?u)�/�&'����3 /u)'/0&0��� � 3 � ����ih#�� � 'RQ�i- �/@!�!H��) � �B4& ��� ~�������~�����~ � �&0$'�%3 /teo� �"9w3���/@)�RQ�C3Jh%���)g3 � �ih%*3 ���H4)�&g3 � �ihi* � �!{/*e�3 � �iP'��PQ�4q ` � ����i*���%! �.@��;* �!8���X������,P'��� �"94 =�Ba=$�13���/@)�!{$�!8�B&��) � �0&0�;*$' ��"9!G3 � *3%��� "13��#3 � �"! � ��@&� �/@!�![3�/g3 � �(~�/1h¡��*3 � � /4)��(/*e�h � ��9 � ��!�3 � �"!�]$#�K6B&%('�@C?C?A@[]\U�F`K*)6T ]PYf@[HPBb� � �,+ �� �-���/.0��� � ~ ���1 � ~ �-� 1 2$3 <�D � � � q Õ �

h � ����u3 � ��9C/@)�!83�*)=34. ��� ��94 � ���&I3 � ��XNHPBIJPT X6Y^]\B=XNK��t&0�PQ�)�&'!(/@)^3 � �X&0���X��)�! ��/@)�!(/4e[3 � ��P'��P��X*)�&I��3�!(eo����9C3 ��/4)�4 � �B!8�"!J3;*)�9�4q 2 /43 �"9C�teo� /@� 3 � �-eo/4��� /*e%� � q Õ �|3 � 13�� ��� ��!i4 �hi��0!GPQ/@! �c3���.@�(h � ��)j3 � �-~�/1h¡��)FP'��PQ�0�5�6�X�"!i&0��� �B9w3 �B&eo� /@� )'/0&0�"�|3�/X)�/�&'�7�I�o���Ceo���#3 / K ��?@$'��� � q � �wq

ijQ

iB

iS

i j

K ��?4$�� � � q � O[��3J��P'�"94 �P'��PQ�u ���)':F��)IX)'�3Jh�/@� :�q

�8:9; :��� EG$'�,P�!X*���F&0��.=�"9C�B!g$�!8�B&M3 /k��4��! ��3 � � � �0&0�;*$� ��"9 � �B4&M/4e�3 � �Fhi13���X��)r3 � �6)'�C3Jh%/4��:�q ` � �j~�/1h �;13��j��)P'$'�,P0��&0� ��.4��)F ���)':0!i��!#��� "13���&j3 /X3 � � � ��@&j?=*��)FR���3 � �7eo/4 � �/1h#��)'?X��� "13 ��/4)�! � ��P(O

� �<� � =>>>? >>>@ A ~CB�D��� � � ~ ���E FHGJIJK �ceML�N � ~�����N�~CB�D�-� �L /*3 � ���h#��! �P�� � q � �

h � �����~CB�D��� �"!(3 � ��F x TEYPOhH�Q x Kc]LJ � *RQ/1.4��h � ��9 � 3 � �,P'$��XPk��!-$')�*R' ��g3�/F/@P�����*3 �@q 2 /*3���9�g3 � 13-3 � �XP�$'�,Pn/4)� ��/4PQ��;13 �B!|h � ��)�3 � � � ��4&F13i)'/0&0�0�{�"!%?4����*3 ��G3 � 4)�3 � 13#13i)'/0&0���,4)�& � �)�9�-4 �hi��0!|P'$'�,P�!%hi13����eo� /@� )�/�&'��f3�/g)'/0&0�4�c�=�®q �4q=P'$'�,P�!i* �h%��0![h%/4��:,*?@4��)�!J3|3 � �(P�� �B! ! $'����?4�;4&0���)=3Bq ` � �-9C/��Cz�9����)@3;! E 4)�&SRk4� �(P�*�;*�,�C3���;!!8PQ��9�c �9t3�/���49 � P'$'�,P63 � 13# '3#3 � �7~�/1hp�;13���!�3 /�4)F/@P�����*3 ��/4)�4 VQITEU�Q X!TE_RbGKqTU8WV:XZY�\[]VW��� E|��P��-vJ$')�9C3 ��/4)�!7����x4 �! /FRQ��9C/@)�!8$��X����!-/@�-! $'P'P' �����;!7/*e�hi13��� � h#�c3 � F?4��.4��)k! $'P'P' ��_^#�\`8�t/4�u&0���4)�&a ��`8��~�/1hp�;13 � � 4!iP'�"9w3�$'����&F��) K ��?@$'��� � q � qb�c V(dU��� ��!83 /@��4?4�#3;*)':��"!ig! P��B9C�"* �3J��P��7/*e�)�/�&'�(3 � 13 � 4!ifeo� ���thi13���i!8$'� e�49�(h � ��� �(3 � � � �B4&��"!%!8���,P' ���?@��.@�)�R��3 � � � ���? � 3i*RQ/1.4�(! ��g ���.4� ®q ` � ��3����,�-.1*����*3 ��/4)�/4e�3 � � � ��@&S~Se#*3%g!83 /@��4?4��)�/�&'�-9/4)')'�B9w3���&�R���g! ��)�?4 ��(P'��P��3 /,)'/0&0�gf7�"!�&0�B! 9� ��R��B&jR���3 � �u��a=$�*3 ��/4) h~ eh ` � ��� e

� e � � � q � �h � ���� � e ��!i3 � �f9C��/@!�!8��! ��9C3 ��/4)�4 �*����X/4e�3 � �f!J3�/4�;*?4�-.4�B! ! � ®qij�,���kl][&�\k��m�-` � ��! ��*����*)�/*3 � ��-3J��P��,/*ei!J3�/4�;*?@�f)'/0&0�,��)mh � �"9 � 3 � �,h%*3 ���7! $'� e�49�g�����*��)�!71373 � �,!�*�,�X ���.4�� {)�/�,*383���-h � 13t3 � ��~�/1h��;13 �g��! � *)�&k!8/�3 � � � ��@&I��!7F9C/4)�!J3;*)=3�q O ��! ���.4/@���t)'/0&0��!(3J��P'��9�* � ��^���P'����! �)=3(�}�3 ���)�4 !8/@$'��9��!%/*e{h%*3 ����!8$�9 � 4!i "*:@��!%/4�#����.4��;!�q

¢

Page 24: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

Õ � ������������� ��������� ��������������������������������������� ���!�"���#��$�%��������� &'�(����)�d�efd�efd ��� n��������ho u��aq������%I��hlrt�u e` � �-&0��)�*�,�"9#��a=$�*3 ��/4)�!�&0��!�9C����R���)'?�7~�/1hd)'�C3Jh%/4��:�9�*)�RQ�t&0��� ��.4�B&,R�4! ��&,/@)�9C/@)�!8��� .1*3 ��/4)�P'����)�9C��P' ��B!q[��$'P�P�/=!8�(3 � *3,)'�3Jh�/@� :j9/4)=3�4��)�!��"�ivJ$')�9C3 ��/4)�! � ���|3;*)':0!(4)�&����7����! ���.4/@���;!q L ��3 � ��)x�B49 � )'/0&0�7�k��! �� K ��?4$'��� � q � � � 3 � �u3 /43�* �/*e* � �~�/1h�!i��)=3 /X3 � �u)�/�&'�u�g$�!83���a=$�4 �3 � *3(&0������9C3 �B&j/@$03�/*e�3 � �u)'/0&0�@q > 13 � ���*3 �"9* � �� � 3 � ��!�9�*)6R��uh#����383 ��)I4!^ � � �� � � G

� ��� � a � � � � q ���h � ��� �!� ����� � �"��*���f3 � �,)�$'�gRQ��-/*eG)�/�&'��!-h#�c3 �n� �B4&'!t3 � 137.1*���b��� �B!8��� .@/4����!(*���g�C}'9 �$�&'��& � ����gRQ��94$�! �g3 � ��� �.@�fj9C/@)�!83�*)=3 � �B4&��Cqt����)�9C�g3 � �g~�/1h ��*3 �B!(!�13 �"!8eo�������s� ���0�<� � 3 � ��� �g��!t/4)'��4&'&0��3 ��/4)�* �9/4)�! ���.113���/@)^9/4)�!83 �;*��)=33 � 13��g$�!J3�RQ�f! *3 �"!J ���&FR=��3 � �f! $'P'P' ��$#1&0����*)�&F��)�P'$03(.1* �$'�B!!�0)�4�,� �� � 3 � 13���%� G

�P^ � � a � �'� L�& � � q �@��i4! ��&n/4)k3 � ��@! ! $'�,P03 ��/4)k3 � 13g9C/@)�! $'�,P03 ��/4)�! a � � ! $'P'P� �����! ^ � � *)�&mP'$��XPb/@P�����*3 ��/4)�!79 � 4)'?4�,!8 �/1h# ��x��)m3����,� �h%��3 ����*3f3 � �6! �0!J3��� 4!g/4)'�j3 � *3X94) RQ�j�,/0&0� ���&r/1.4��f3 ���X�64!Xn! ������B!f/4e(a@$�4! �('0!J3���4&'�k!83�13��F! ����$' "13 ��/4)�!qn�%�! $'R�!83 ��3 $03���)'?,��)=3 /^� � q �=�G3 � �7�C}0P'����!�!8��/4)�!|eo/4�������teo��/4� � � q Õ ��*)�&m� � q � � � *)�&j3 � �7&'��!�9C���C3��(eo/@� � �������¥�f~*),+.-� �)~ B�/10� � �� � �32 � `8�%/4e�3 � �u3�4)':j�Ba@$�13 ��/4)b� � q � � � h%�u/4R'3�*��)^�!8�0!83 �� /*e�� )�/4)' ���)���*�#�Ba=$�13���/@)�!%eo/4�#3 � �"� $')':�)'/1h#) � �B4&'!�~g�13�4)=�j?4��.4�)F3 ���,�4q

d�efd�e54 6 lrt I7� q8�ht�� tNI I{n$��t�u Hsl'n I e����*?@��)'�X3 � 13�^&0�"!�!8/@ �.@��&m!8$'R�!J3;*)�9�X�"!u��)=3 ��/�&'$�9C�B&m*3g^9C�� 3�4��)b)'/0&0�x���4q ?�q � 3 � ��� �B!8��� .@/4���7)'/0&0�:9 ��) K ��?4$'��� � q Õ � �h � �"9 � �"!|3 � �)�3���4)�! P�/@�83���&X3 � � /@$'? � 3 � �()'�3Jh�/@� :�q ` � �t! $'R�!83�4)�9C� � 4!G)'/g�<;Q�B9w3�/@)�3 � �(hi13 ���|~�/1hd�;13���!|h%��/@R03�4��)'�B&��)F3 � � � �0&0��4$' ���9t�,/�&'� �4)�&^!8/,��3�!#9C/@)�9C��)=3 �;13 ��/4)694)6RQ�f&0�3 ����,��)���&F��)�&'�PQ�)�&0��)=3 ��4q���3>=��-���@?��<`8�#���P'����! �)=3i3 � ��9C/@)�9C��)=3 �;13 ��/4)6/*e[3 � �g! $'R�!83�4)�9C�f��)I ���)': �:� ��q L¡� �� ���/4$'�t4!�!8$'�,P03���/@)^3 � *3�3 � �f~�/1h�;13 �u�"!�9/4)�!83�4)@3(4 �/@)'?�,?4��.4��)6P���PQ�f ���)':6�"!#� �B4! /4)�4R' �� � h%�f9*)�)'/*3(!����3 � �g! 4�,�7eo/4�#3 � �g9C/@)=3�*�,��)�*)=3 � h � �"9 � ��$�!83RQ�73�*:@�)^4!��eo$')�9w3 ��/4)^/4e�3����,� � ` � *)�&^&0�"!83�*)�9C�u* �/4)'?X3 � �uP'��P�� � ?�q ` � �u��a=$�*3 ��/4)6/*e{9/4)�! ���.113���/@)jeo/@��9C/4)=3;*�,��)�*)=3��4!�!ih#�c3 � ��)6�B49 � ���)':j3 � ��)6����@&'! h

=����h ` ������� ��� h =����h ? � ��A �-� = ��� & � � q B=�

� ���-�"!%3 � �-P���PQ�L� !#9C��/@!�!J��! ��9w3���/@)�* ���@&0��$�!%4)�&�Am���-�"!ig�;13��-9/4)�!83�4)@3%3 � 13�&0��!�9C����R��B!G3 � �u&0��9���,/*e{9/4)=3�4�,��)�4)=3%&0$'�-3�/����49C3 ��/4)Fh#�c3 � 3 � �uP'��PQ�uh%4 � "! � 4)�&FR'$' �:j����49C3 ��/4)�!%h#��3 � 3 � �uh%*3 ��DC1q` � �Xa@$�*)=3 ��3J� �f�����E2 � �-�1�����P'����! �)=3;!(�:�)'/1h#)n.4� �/09C��3J�^h#�c3 � h � �"9 � 3 � �X! $'R�!83�4)�9C�X�"!t9/4)�.4�B9w3 �B&I��)x3 � ��P'��PQ�X4)�&3 � ����Ceo/4��� � � � q B=�[�"!�! ���XP� ���f ���)'��4��4&'.4��9C3 ��/4)��Ba@$�13 ��/4)�q{��)j/4�;&0��G3 /�! /4 �.4��3 � �"!G�Ba=$�13���/@)�h��()'��B&�/4)� ��,&0�C3�����,��)'�t3 � �.1* �$'�>= �� ��`8�G/*e�3 � �-9/4)�9�)=3 �;13���/@)�13? �-� � L � h � ����(h%� � �.@��$�! ��&,3 � �79C/4)�.@�)=3 ��/4)X3 � 13%3 � �-9C/�/4�;&0��)�13���?64 �/@)'?f�B49 �P'��P�����!t9 � /@! �)I! /,3 � *3�3 � �g/4����?4��)6�"!(*3#3 � ��$'P�!83 ����4� �)�& �o�®q �@q � 13�)�/�&'�g�G��e� ����F L�*)�&^)'/0&0�4�j�cer� ���HG L@�Cq ` � ��!! �c3�$�13���/@)F�"!#P'�"9w3�$'� �B&6��) K ��?@$'� � � q � q` � �xRQ/4$�)�&'*���£.�4 �$���!�= �� ��`8�j94)¡R��keo/4$')�&deo/4�F��49 � )�/�&'� �,R=�d4!�! $'�,��)'? 3 � *3j3 � �x3 $�� R'$� ���)@3F~�/1h ��)=3�/ 3 � �)'/0&0�,�"!th%� � ��®�,��}��B&n4)�&x3 � �)b*P�P' �����)'?F3 � �Xeo/4 � �/1h#��)'?69C/@)�!8��� .1*3 ��/4)n4� ?@$'�,�)=3�q L �,� �Ba=$'�����f3 � 1373 � �X3 /*3;* H��4!�!-/*e9C/@)=3�*�,��)�*)=3i3 �;*)�!8PQ/4� 3 �B&���)@3�/7vJ$')�9C3 ��/4) �I � � �JEK LNM�O�P 2 = J ���5Q J �a�J`8� � J �

�oh � ���� I � ��!G3 � �t��4!�!G��)0~�/1hd�;13 �t/*e�9C/@)=3�*�,��)�*)=3i*)�&RQ J � �"!G3 � �- ���)'?*3 � /*e�3 � �(P���PQ�SA�'��J�H�g$�!J3%R��-R�* "*)�9C��&,R��X3 � �3 /43�4 ��,@! !i/@$03= �� ��TUJa � � �JVK LNM�OXW 2 ����� J �®�.YZ[&

\ Ê ¿B«G²8ªC«J¬�µ;¶¸¶0¬�µ�°¯«|»J²w¨�­¯°®µ;¨°{°�µc¡w«J­{°¯¿�«|³�²w¬¯Ä^]�_[]a`cbedf]<g�]VhEi�� j�kl]<gHbe]ahEm  0Ì�¿B«8¬¯«n]a`[©¸­�°®¿�«po1¬¯­¯°rq�²w¬®Î�«J¬�Å�Ã�¶ ¡(¬®«8µ;»�°®©¸²w¨u¬®µ�°®«|»J²w¨�­�°�µ;¨C°%s] h ©¸­�°®¿B«GÄ�µ;­¯­�°®¬®µ;¨�­¯³�«J¬�»8²«Xt#»J©¸«J¨°�Å*«J°�Ì�«8«J¨7Ì�µ;¶¸¶=µ;¨�Î-ËB©¸Ë4«fs,]<gF©¸­�°¯¿�«[¬®«8µ;»�°¯©¸²w¨7¬�µ�°¯«|µ�°�°®¿�«[Ì�µ;¶¸¶lsBµ;¨�Î"jI©¸­�°®¿B«[Ë�©¸Ë*«[¬�µ;Î�©¸Ã�­8Ô

¢

Page 25: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

v���E������� ���������� �(��$�� �"�!������$�������!����� � Õ �

ijQ

ij ijLC ( ,t)ijoiC =C (0,t)

Mi

i j

K ��?@$'��� � q � O ` � �XRQ/4$')�&�*���x9C/4)�&0�c3���/@)k/@)x3 � ��9C/@)�9C��)@3���*3 ��/4)x��)bj ���)�: � = �� ��`8� � �"!7/4R03;*��)'��&nR��n9C/@�gR'��)'��)'?j3 � �,��4!�!��)0~�/1hp/4eH9/4)=3�4�,��)�4)=3 � I � � *)�&F3 � �u�X��}0��)�?X/4e{��)0~�/1h�!i��)=3 /,)'/0&0���;q� a=$�*3 ��)'?X3 � �B!8�-3Jh%/,�C}0P'����!�!8��/4)�!i4)�&j$�!8��)'?x� � q ��� � h%�u9*)^! /4 �.4�-eo/4�i3 � �uR�/@$')�&'4� �j.�4 �$��

=s�� �\`8�'� I � � �JVK L M�O�P 2 = J ���rQ J �a�J`8�v� J �^ � � �JVK L M�O�P 2 � J � � � q� 4�� a=$�*3 ��/4)n� � q B@�%94)j)'/1hpR��u! /4 �.4��&j��)6��@9 � ���)�:�$�! ��)'?^� � q� 4�G@!i�RQ/4$�)�&'*����9C/@)�&0��3 ��/4) � 4)�&jh#��3 � 3 � �t~�/1hl��*3 �s�� �� �&^9C/@)�!83�*)=3#/1.4���%3 � �73����,�u��)@3����.1* ®q

S,T�� ��� 2������������ 5{Z + 9FWH_Z�.;1 + � ZgY|_wW �"! T` � �i!8/@ �$'3 ��/4)fP'��/09C�B&0$'���|h#�c3 � ��)g3 � �%�-�������0�,hi13���Ha=$�* ��c3J�u! ����$' "13 ��/4)gP�49;:1*?@�|P'��/09C��B&'!{4!�eo/4 � �/1h�!���)���49 �g� �0&0�;*$� ��"93 ���,�f!J3��P(O

Õ q � * "9C$' "13���3 � �-! $'P'P' ���*)�&�&0���4)�&j*3%�B49 � )'/0&0� � *)�&�3 � �7!J3;13�$�!G/4e�3 � �tP'$��XP6 ���)':0!�$�! ��)'?X$�! �� ��! PQ��9C�� ��B&,3 ���,��8P�*383 ��� )�!q �� q(��/4 �.4��3 � �6)'/4)0�� ���)'�B*�,!8�0!83 ��� /4e(��a=$�*3 ��/4)�!F� � q Õ � '�� � q �=�ueo/4��3 � � � ��@&M.1* �$'��!�~ � $�!8��)'?mxeo$' � 2 ��hi3 /4)£!8/@ �.@��Bq` � � � 49/4R'�"*)k��13 ����}x��!u9/4)�!83 ��$�9w3���&n�C}0P' ���9�c3� ��n4)�&n3 � �,����! $' c3���)�?F ���)���*�u! �0!J3��� �"!7!8/@ �.@��&x$�!8��)'?I ��� /4 ���! :=�e�49w3�/4����!�13���/@)jh � �"9 � 3�*:@��!#@&0.1*)=3�4?4�-/*e�3 � �f! P�*�;!8�u!83 ��$�9w3�$'���-/4e�3 � �u��13 ����}�q� q�EH�� eo/4��� 3 � �Ihi13 ����a=$�* ��c3J�s9* "9C$� �*3 ��/4)�!X$�! ��)�?k3 � �$#`@ F6X!_aK!Y�K�%VH\? TEU�K�& ? K!U�K!B Y�' K!Y x H�J���/4��+#� � > � � h � �"9 �P'� /09���&�!%@!%eo/4 � �/1h�!8O

��@�6���� ��B9w3#3 � �fh%*3 ����a@$�* ��c3J��3����,�g!83 ��P)( �l�,��)��� �5Q ���32 � ���B� � h � ���� � ��� � �����E2 � �-�f�"!%3 � �f~�/1hp.@� �/�9�c3J�j��)^P'��P��� �;��q � /@)�! ��a=$'�)=3� �� � (r��!���a=$�4 G3�/x3 � �6! � /4� 3 �B!J3g3 �;�.4� G3 ���,��3 � � /@$'? � 4 � %P'��P��B!g��) 3 � �F! �0!J3��� � h � �"9 ��)�!8$'����!(3 � 13thi13���-��!t)'/43(3 �;*)�!8PQ/4� 3 �B&IR����4/@)�&^3 � �X&0/1h#)�!J3�� �B*�¤)'/0&0�g��)k4)=�6 ���)':Ih#��3 � ��)mj! ��)'?@ ��g3 ���,�!83 �P�q�oR��F��)=3 ��� PQ/4 "13���3 � �j9/4)�9�)=3 �;13���/@)�!teo� /@� 3 � �F&0��!�9C���C3��,.4/4 �$'�,�,� ���,�)=3;!f13u3 � ��R���?4��)')'��)'?I/*e%3 � � � �0&0�;*$� ��"93 ���,��!J3��Pb/4)=3�/j3 � ����g9C$�� ���)=37 �/09*3 ��/4)�!��¯!8��)�9��3 � ��PQ/@! �c3���/@)k/4e�3 � �,� ���,�)=3�!g9 � *)'?@��!-��)k�B49 �m� �0&0�;*$� ��"93 ���,�f!J3��P��Cq�¯9�� � @9 � P���PQ� �:� ����!i3 � �)I���C��P�4�83��c3���/@)'��&F��)=3�/+* �-� &0�"!�9C���C3 �u�� ����,�)=3�!#/4e{�Ba=$�* �.@/4 �$'�,� � h#��3 � 3 � �u)�$'�gRQ��(/*e� ���,��)@3;!�9 � /=!8��)F! /�3 � 13

* ��� �-, Q ���( � ���/. &` � �"!#�)�!8$'����!%3 � 13i3 � �73 �;*)�! PQ/4� 3i��)I* � � ���)':0!#�"!i� �B!8/@ �.@��&F4&0�Ba@$�13 �� ��j/1.4��%3 � �73 ���,�f!J3��P�(�q

¢

Page 26: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

Õ B ������������� ��������� ��������������������������������������� ���!�"���#��$�%��������� &'�(����)���&��6E|��/4P�*?@*3 ��3 � ��9/4)�9�)=3 �;13���/@)�!{3 � � /@$'? � 3 � �#)��C3Jh%/4��:f$�! ��)'?u�Ba=$�13���/@)6� � q B@�H*)�&�RQ/4$�)�&'*���g9/4)�&0��3 ��/4)I� � q *�wq` � �-h%*3 ���%a=$�4 ���3J�X3 ���X�u!83 ��P (��"!�3J�=P���9�* � ��,�g$�9 � ! �,4 � ����3 � *)�3 � � � �0&0�;*$� ��"9#3����,�7!J3��P � 4)�&�! /g3 � ��!%h#�� � ����a=$'��� �u! �.4����4 ���)=3 ��?4�;13���/@)F!83 �P�!q

+t�C3�4�� "!{/*e03 � � 2 �hi3�/4)g! /4 �.4����eo/@��3 � �%)'�C3Jh%/4��:(~�/1h *���G?4��.4��)f��)F� + �'*)�&f3 � �i+#� � > 9/4)=3�4�X��)�4)@3�3 �;*)�! P�/@�83H* �?4/@� ��3 � ��"!#&0�C3;*�� ��B&F��)M� B*�®qd�e54�ehg ��������� �fu ���aq8� I��%I��hlrt�u�� n j��rj nVu j�� l k eyt)'�#/4eQ3 � ����1vJ/@�| ����,��3�13���/@)�![/4e��-�������0�F�"![3 � �#3 /43�* �&0��9/4$'P' ���)'?f/*eQ3 � � � ��&'��4$' ��"9#*)�&,h%*3 ��|a=$�4 ���3J�,9C/4�,P'$'3�13���/@)�! �! /g3 � 13i3 � �(3����,�u!J3��P�!i$�!8�B&���)F�B49 � 9/4�,PQ/4)'��)@3i)'����&�)�/*3�9C/@��)�9��&'�4q ` � �7&0�Ce�4$' c3 � �0&0�;*$' ���9(3 ���,�u!J3��Pj��)^�t�������'�I��!� `��`� Õ x H\TE_ � h � �����@!{3 � �#hi13���Ga=$�4 ���3J�g9/4�,P'$03;13 ��/4)�!|*���%3J�=P���9�* � ��g&'/4)'�#/@),7��$�9 �  �)'���H3 ���X�t! 9�* ��%/4e � `��� L�& Õx q���/@ �.���)'?F3 � ��)'�3Jh�/@� :6~�/1h P'��/4R' ��� 9�*)mR����}�PQ�)�!8��.4�XR��B94$�!8���-�������0�M$�!8�B!ujeo$� � 2 �hi3�/4)b!8/@ �.@�� � 4)�&m!8/63 � �9 � /@��9��/4eiF �4� ?@�� � `��6��!%vJ$�!J3��c ��B&m��)m3 ��� ��!7/4e��Cz�9����)�9C�@q,�(/1h���.4��� ��� /@ �&0��)'?63 � �,~�/1h¥�;13 �B!u9C/@)�!J3;*)=37/1.4��uF �4� ?@�� �0&0��4$' ���9�3 ���X�7!83 �PF9*)F ��B4&,3�/g��)�49�9C$'�;13��(/@����.4�)j)'/4)0��P � �0!8�"94 �����! $' �3�!�q K /4�%�C}'*�,P' �� � ��e�3 � �749C3 $�4 �~�/1h¡��)6fP'��P�� ���)':I���.@��;!8�B!���)x3 � ���,�"&'&0 ��,/*e� � �0&0�;*$� ��"9u3����,��!J3��P � 3 � �)n3 � �,9C/@)=3�*�,��)�*)=3-��)k3 � *3-P���PQ������IRQ�g3���4)�! P�/@�83���&I��)3 � �uh#� /@)'?X&'������9C3 ��/4)��` /��� � �$�!J3���*3 �u3 � �g)�/4)0��P � �0!8�"94 �� �B!8$' �3�!�3 � *3-9�*)I/099$'�(h � ��)n9 � /�/@! ��)'?� � ` � 3 � 13-��!�3 /�/j "*��?4� � 9C/@)�!8�"&0���(�P'��P��! ��9w3���/@)I/*e[ ��)'?43 � Õ $')��c3-h � ������)^3 � �g~�/1h�.4� �/09C��3J�F.14� ����!#PQ�����/�&'��9�* � ��64!(! � /1h#)^��) K ��?@$'� � � q ����=�wq���$'P�P�/=!8�u3 � 13-

��=� ` ��$'�-~�/1h�.4� �/09C��3J����)6P���PQ���(� ��q �oR�� ��� �/@� ��)'�u13#)'/0&0���;q �¯9�� ��� �/@� ��)'�u13#)'/0&0�7��q

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7−2.5

−2

−1.5

−1

−0.5

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

Time (h)

Vel

ocity

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

4

4.5

5

Time (h)

Con

cent

ratio

n (m

g/L)

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7−1

−0.8

−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1x 10

−8

Time (h)

Con

cent

ratio

n (m

g/L)

��&��i�-�������0�n.4� �/09C��3J�n� � ` � � �� �wq �o�B� ��� �/@� ��)'�u13�)'/0&0�"�;q ��e;� ��� �/4����)'�u*3i)�/�&'�7��q

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7−2.5

−2

−1.5

−1

−0.5

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

Time (h)

Vel

ocity

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

4

4.5

5

Time (h)

Con

cent

ratio

n (m

g/L)

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

Time (h)

Con

cent

ratio

n (m

g/L)

K ��?@$'��� � q � O � /@�XP�$03 �B&f9 � �/4����)'��9C/4)�9C�)=3���*3 ��/4)�!�*3�3 � �G$'P�!J3�� �B*��)'/0&0�|eo/@��PQ�����/0&0�"94 � ��=�®���.@��;!8�B&�~�/1hsO|�� � R � 9��6O��J3�� $'�B�3 ���"*)'?@$' �4�i.4� �/09C��3J��P'��/* � �� � 9/4�,P'$03���&Fh#�c3 � � `��`� L$& L � � � ���¯& � � � e��ROG3J�=P���9�* ��t�������0�n9�* "9C$' "13���/@) � h#��3 � � `��`� Õ� qP'$' "! �g/*e%9C/4)=3;*�,��)�*)=3(�"!(��� ���@!8�B&I13-3 ���X� `�� G< � ��)n3 � ��$'P�!83 ����*� )'/0&0�6���J�(/*e[3 � ��P'��PQ�X! ��9C3 ��/4) � � ��q ` � �gP'$' "! �h#�� � Q3 �;�.4�� �/@)' �� ? � CG D /*e�3 � �7&0�"!J3;*)�9�t&0/1h#)�3 � �-P'��PQ�,�oh � �"9 � �"!%! ���XP� ��X3 � �-4� �Bu$')�&0���G3 � �-.4� �/09C��3J��9C$'��.4��RQ�C3Jh%���)`�� G< *)�& Õ � � 13-h � ��9 � 3 ���,�g3 � ��P�$' �! �Xh#�� � H� ��.4��;! �g&0��� �B9w3 ��/4)�q ` � ����Ceo/4��� � 3 � ��P�$' �! �X� �3 $'��)�!t�.4��)=3 $�4 � ��63 /6)'/0&0�g�*)�&j)'��.4���#?4�C3;!%3 �;*)�! PQ/4� 3 ��&F��)@3�/X3 � �u����!83#/*e{3 � �u)'�3Jh�/@� :,3 � ��/4$'? � )'/0&0����q��e�3 � ��!i!�*�,�(P'��/4R� ���� h%����#3�/�RQ�-9/4�,P'$03���&�$�!8��)'?��-�������0�^h#��3 � � �0&0�;*$' ���9�3 ���,�-!83 ��P�/*e Õ� � 3 � ��)�3 � �t.@� �/�9�c3J�.1*����*3 ��/4)�h%/4$� �&jR��7���P'����! �)=3 �B&�4!iX!J3��PFeo$')�9C3 ��/4) � @!�P���9C3 $'����&j��) K ��?@$'� � � q ���¯&��wq[��P'$' "! �t/4e{9C/@)=3�*�,��)�*)=3%� �� ��B4! ��&

¢

Page 27: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

v���E� ������$�&'�E�h� � � �{���[�$���������% �������(� Õ 13(3 ���X�g`� G< h%/4$' "&6� �B49 � 3 � ��&0/1h#)�!83 ����*� )'/0&0�f13(3 ���X� `���< *)�&^R��u3���4)�! P�/@�83���&6��)=3�/�3 � �g� �B!J3�/4e{3 � �f)'�3Jh�/@� :RQ�Ceo/4���%3 � �#P���PQ�i~�/1hr�}0P���� ���)�9��![-���.4����!�* ®q � /@)�!8�Ba=$'�)=3 �� � 3�*:���)'?u � �0&0�;*$� ��"9|3����,��!83 ��P�3 � 13|�"!{3 /�/7 "*��?4��3 /u����! /4 �.4�.1*����*3 ��/4)�!%��)63 � �uhi13���i~�/1h�/4�#9C/@)@3;*�,��)�*)=3i3 �;*)�! PQ/4� 3#9�*)6 ��B4&j3 /,��)�9C/@� ����9C3ihi13���#a=$�* ���3J�j!8/@ �$'3 ��/4)�!�q` /b! ��^3 � 13�3 � �"!���!���)de�@9w3�h � *3 � *P'PQ�)�!���)¡�-�������0� �#K ��?@$'� �B! � q ���¯ � R � 9B�,&0�P���9C3jM!8���g$' "13���/@)s/4et3 � �l�83 ��$'�~�/1h��^9C/@)�&0��3 ��/4)�!fh#�c3 � 63 ����4)'?4$' "*�7.@� �/�9�c3J�kP'��/* � ���*)�&bI! ��* � � ��&'��4$' ��"9�3 ���,�j!J3��P�q ` � ��$'P�!83 ����4�¢)'/0&0�k���J�-��!?4��.4��)rPQ�����/0&0�"9FP'$' "!8�B!�/4e-9/4)=3�4�X��)�4)@3 � *)�&M3 � �6���C3�$'��)rP'$' "! �F�"!�9C ���4� ��M!8$'PQ������XPQ/@! ��&r/4)r3 � �^��)'P'$03�P'$' "! �4q ` � �&0/1h#)�!83 ����4� )'/0&0�I� ���-�����*��)�!u13f^9C/@)=3�*�,��)�*)=37 ���.4�� [/*e������/j3 � ��/4$'? � /4$0373 � ��!8���g$' "13���/@)�q K ��?@$'� �B! � q ����& � � � e��-/@)3 � �u/*3 � �� � 4)�& � ! � /1hl3 � �f����! $' �3�!%eo/4�� � �0&0�;*$' ��"9(3����,�f!83 ��P6/4e Õ � /@$'�(9/4��� �B!8PQ/4)�&'��)'?�3 /X3 � �g!83 �P6eo$')�9w3 ��/4)^.@� �/�9�c3J�P'��/* � ��4q � /@)=3�*�,��)�*)=3(�"!���� ���@!8�B&I13�3 � ��!�*�,�ueo����a=$'��)�9C� � 4)�&63 � �gP'$' "! ��!-*���f9C ���*�� ��6! ���)^3 /j�}0�c3�3 � �g �/�/4Px.��",3 � �&0/1h#)�!83 ����4� )'/0&0�uRQ�Ceo/4���-3 � �7~�/1hp���.4����! ��!�q` � ��� ����!t)'/j����@!8/@)I��)kP'����)�9��P� ��g3 � *3 � ` � 94)')'/*3-R��,9 � /=!8��)x�g$�9 � !8��* � ���7!8/j3 � *3t��3-�"!-��a=$�* �3 / � ` � ��)x/4�;&0���3 /��,��)'���X�"! �73 � �"!�P � 4! �-��� ��/4��&'$'�73 /,~�/1h�� ��.4����!�* ®q[��/1h%�.4��� � 3 � �f94 �9$' "13 ��/4)�!iR��B9C/4�,�u��$�9 � �X/@� �7�}�PQ�)�!8��.4�@q 2 /43/4)� ���3 � �"! � 3 � �-eo/4���,*3#/*e�3 � �7��)�P'$03# � ���!i����a=$'��� �B!|3 � 13#3 � �7$�! ��iP'��/1.=�"&0�7m�8P�*383 ��� )��ueo/4�i3 � �-3 ���,�u.�4� �"13���/@)�/*e{)'/0&'* ! $'P'P' ��g*)�&�&0����*)�&X*)�&�P'$'�,P,/4PQ��;13���/@)�! � h � ��9 � �g$�!J3[RQ�#?4��.4�)X13[��@9 �g� �0&0�;*$' ���9G3 ���,��!J3��P^�o�®q �@q � �t�������0�j&0/��B!�)�/��)@3����P�/@ �*3 ��/4)��Cq���)X����* ���3J� � &0���,4)�&�P�13 3 ���)�![4� �%:�)'/1h#)�/@)' ��f13 Õ 'f/4� � ' � /@$'�H��)=3 ��� .14 �! � *)�&X! /t��*)�$�4 0��)=3����P�/@ �*3 ��/4)�"!i� �Ba@$�������&F�ce[,!8��4 � ��� � �0&0�;*$' ���9t3����,�f!83 �P^�"!%3 /,RQ�73�*:@�)�q2 /@)'�C3 � � ���!�!H3 � ������"!G7P'�;49C3 �"9* � ����,�c3�3 / � /1hd! �,4 � �3 � ��3 ���X�-!J3��P�9�*)�RQ�#3�4:4�)�q L ��3 � ��)�3 � �t�-�������0�6* �?4/@� ��3 � ��"!G���gRQ��&'&0�B&� 2 �hi3 /@)j! /4 �.4��|3 � *3���)=.@�� 3�!�7eo$' � � 49/4R'�"*),��13�� ��},��)��B49 � ��3 ����*3 ��/4)�q ` � �"!G�"!G)�/*3G��$�9 � /*e�g9C/4)�9C���)h � ��)x3 � � � �0&0�;*$' ��"9u3 ���,�X!83 ��Pk�"!t/4)x3 � �,/4�;&0��t/*e � /4$'�;! � R�$0379/4$' "&xRQ�,P'��/ � ��R'��3 ��.4� ��^�C}0PQ�)�! ��.@�g��eG3 � �g3����,��!83 �Pk��!3�4:4��)m! ��* � [�)'/@$'? � 3 /I49�9C$'�;13�� ��I� �B!8/@ �.@�geo����a=$'��)@37~�/1h � ��.4��;!�* "!qX��)b/4R�.���/@$�!7* �3 ��� )�*3 ��.4�X��!-3 � ��9C "4!�!7/*e�)6T ]\Fc@ %� K!� Y^H\Bd�,�C3 � /�&�! � h � ��9 � )'�.@��X�C}0P' ���9�c3� �� 9/4)�!83 ��$�9w3�3 � � � 49C/@R'�"*)M��13�� ��} � *)�&r!8/@ �.@��3 � �6! �0!J3��� $�! ��)�?n��3 ��;13���.@�3 �B9 � )'�"a=$'��!(��*3 � ����3 � *)n&0������9w3t�X�3 � /0&'!�q > 4)��FP'$�R' ��"9D'0&0/4��4��)x9/�&'��!(4� ���.�4�� "*R� ��73 � 1379C/4$� �&IRQ�g��)�9/4��P�/@��*3 ��&6��)3 � �t�t�������0�^!8/4e�3Jh%4� � � /@)'��/*e�h � ��9 � �"!�+ 2 ��� � G 2 q L �-&0��&�)'/*3 � �.4�#3 � ��3����,�t&'$'� ��)'?u3 � � L /4��:0! � /4P,3 /g���,P' ���,�)=3i)'/@)0�® ���)'��4�i! /4 �.4������)^�t�������'� � R�$03�h��7&0/,RQ� �����.4�-3 � *3i3 � �7�,/0&0�c Q913���/@)�!%� �Ba=$'������&�3 /X3 � �79/0&0�-eo/4�#!8$�9 � 4)F4&�&0�c3���/@)*���u!J3���4��? � 38eo/4��hi*�;&�qS,T � .�1 + � 5H_65 Z����F_ !���+ 2�:<2iW=- Z�Y��>5 TL �6)�/1h P'� /09���& 3 /b*)�4 ��0! �j! /4�,�F.@����M!8���,P' ��^&0�"!J3�� ��R'$03���/@)r)'�3Jh�/@� :0! � ��)s/4�;&0���3 /m��*:@�69/4)�9 �$�! ��/4)�!X*RQ/4$03X3 � �! /4 �.�4R'�� ���3J�I/*e|3 � �,eo/4��hi*�;&I*)�&k��)�.@��;!8��P'� /@R' ����!teo/4�u9C/@)@3;*�,��)�*)=3-3 �;*)�! P�/@�83Bq L �,@! ! $'�,��eo/4�-3 � �,�����*��)�&0���-3 � *3h%� � �.4�uX?4��.4�)^! �C3#/*e{~�/1hp�;13���!�� ��� eo/@�i3 � �u ���)':0!#��)63 � �u)'�C3Jh%/4��:�qd�e���ehg ��� � o I u ln���JI���lrt��cl'n�o=lrt I7� q8�ht�� tNI � l�kL �m9/4)�! ��&'���3 � �k! ���XP� ��B!J3^P�/=! ! ��R' ��n)'�C3Jh%/4��:£9/4)�! �"!J3���)'?r/*ef3Jh%/IvJ$')�9C3 ��/4)�!69C/@)')'�B9w3 �B&¡R��¡r! ��)'?@ ��kP'��P��@q ���C383���)�?� �\`8�'� ����`8�%2 � &0�)�/*3 �73 � �7~�/1h�.4� �/09C��3J� � h%�f*���t����&0$�9C��&F3�/,! /4 �.���)�?�3 � �u��a=$�*3 ��/4)

= � � � ��`8��=��`� ��A =��=,�\L �J`8�'� = � �\`8� ��?4��.4��)��c�h � ��� �-3 � �uR�/@$')�&'4� �j9/4)�&'�c3���/@)F�"!#?4��.4��)6*3i3 � �u$'P�!J3�� �B*� )'/0&0�@q[��e{h%�u&0�C �)'�

� ��`8�r� � �2 � � (��"! (3 /�RQ�u3 � �g&0�"!J3;*)�9�73 �;�.4�� ��B&jR���~�$'��&^P�*� 3 �"9C ���!ieo��/4� 3 ���X� LX3 /S` � 3 � �)^3 � �g! /4 �$03 ��/4)63�/,3 � �"!�P'��/4R� ���� 94)^R��fh#����383 ��)�C}0P' ��"9C��3 ��F4!

=,�@?��<`8�r� =s�@� �$# G � � � ?Q� �"% # J'& � #�(*),+ & (-# �'.�. & � � q + �¦0/ 132 Ç5476 ©¸­�Ë1µ;¬¯°�²;³'°®¿B« Ç-8 Ñ Ê 6 ´6¶¸©¸Å�¬�µ;¬�±<sÌ�¿�©¸»�¿7©¸­�³�¬®«J«J¶ ±tµ8ªwµ;©¸¶¼µ;ÅB¶¸«G²w¨(°®¿B«:9�¨C°¯«8¬¯¨�«�°{°¯¿�¬®²wÃB·w¿;2�«�°¯¶¸©¸ÅHk=<*> >@?BA�C CED D DBFHG-I@>-JLKNMBF�OQP R'CEMSKNM'CR*TVUXW,FH<*>USJfm�Ô

¢

Page 28: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

Õ + ������������� ��������� ��������������������������������������� ���!�"���#��$�%��������� &'�(����)�� .4��� �����,P�/@�83;*)=3(! P��B9C�"* �9@!8�7�"!%3 � �f! ��3 $�*3 ��/4)^/*eH9C/4)�!J3;*)=3#.4� �/09C��3J� � � ��`8��� � � � eo/4�#h � �"9 �

=,�@?��<`8���= � ��` � ? 2 � �� ��� �0 + /��� % # J � I � �� ��� ������ + ) � ����� B ) & � � q �=�

K ��/4� 3 � �"!Xeo/4��� /*e(3 � �I!8/@ �$'3 ��/4) � �c3��"!X9 ��B*�X3 � 13,~�/1h ��)r3 � �^P'��P��^�"!Xb9/4�gR���)�*3 ��/4)s/*e�J}K6? ] z ��&'$'�63 /k3 � �^ �)��c3��P'��/4P�4?@*3 ��/4) .@� �/�9�c3J�r/*e-9/4)=3�4�,��)�4)=3X��)£3 � �x! �0!J3�����X*)�&�]\YZY�K!B T ]PYf@[HPB ��eo��/4� 3 � �x&0�B9��M/4e-9C/@)=3�*�,��)�*)=3�&0$'�63�/����49C3 ��/4)�!i*3#3 � �uP'��PQ�uh%4 � �4)�&j��)63 � �uR�$' �:j~�/1h(�wq��)I���,P�/@�83;*)=3t9/4)�! ��a=$'��)�9C�u/4e{3 � �feo/@� � /*e�� � q �=�i�"!#3 � 13t��.4��)F3 � /4$�? � 3 � �f3 �;*)�!8PQ/4� 3�/*e|9C/@)=3�*�,��)�*)=3��"!(� ���)'��4�P'��/09C��!�!i�o�®q �@q � =,�@? �J`8����= � � � ��3|��!�B=H\YH79C/4)�.@/4 �$03 ��/4)6�oRQ��94$�! �#/*e�3 � �#�C}0PQ/4)'��)=3 �"* '&0�B9��u3�������Cq ` � ����Ceo/4��� � h��i�C}0PQ��9C33 � 13#3 � ����-�����RQ�f! /4�,�u&0�cz�9$' c3����B!#h#��3 � 3 � �f! /4 �$03���/@)F/4e�3 � �u��)�.@��;!8�-P'��/4R' ���^q2 ��.4���83 � � ���!�! � ��C3j$�!F9/4)=3 ��)�$'�I/4)l4)�&d��)�.@��!83 ��?@13��^3 � �m!8/@ �$'3 ��/4)¡/*e73 � �n��)�.4��;! �IP'� /@R' ��� eo/@�F ! ���XP� ��l� �/�/@P��)'�3Jh�/@� : � P'�"9w3�$'����&,��) K ��?4$�� � � q �'q ` h%/u)'/0&0��! � � 4)�& a � *���#9C/@)')'��9C3 �B&,R=�X7P�*���|/4e�P���PQ��!Gh#�c3 � &0�1;�����)=3G ��)�?*3 � !��rQ G

V , L , C

AC (t)o

C (t)Bo

1 1 1

2 2 2

V , L , C

A B

K ��?@$'��� � q �vO|�¥! ���,P' ��u� �B&0$�9��&6)'�C3Jh%/4��:�9C/@)�! ��!83 ��)'?�/*e{3Jh%/X)�/�&'��!�9/4)')'�B9w3���&6��)I, �/�/4P � h#��3 � RQ/*3 � ~�/1h�!i��)63 � �g!�*�,�&0��� �B9w3���/@)�q ` � �X&'/*383���&k ���)'�B!t��)nP���PQ� Õ ���P'����! �)=3(3 � ��e�49w3-3 � 13-3 � ��� �,94)')'/*3-R��X3Jh%/jP'��PQ��!�vJ/4��)'��)'?6F!8��)'?@ ��XP�*���-/*evJ$')�9C3 ��/4)�!G��)��-�������0�"���;13 � ��H3 � ������g$�!83GRQ�(! /4�,��9C/@ � ���9C3 ��/4),/*e�/*3 � ��G)'/0&0��!�*)�&X ���)':0!G��)�RQ�C3Jh%���),eo/4�|h � �"9 � h���3�*:@��8�<;Q�B9w3���.@���X.1*����4R' ��B! � G � Q G 4)�& = G q*)�&[Q � �(4)�&^~�/1h .4�� �/09�c3����B!�� � G *)�& � � �wqu��$'P'PQ/@! ��)'?j3 � 1379C/@)@3;*�,��)�*)=3t��)=3 ��;!�)�/�&'� � h#�c3 � �.14� �"13���/@)I?4��.4�)IR��= ��� � = �� ��`8� � h%�uR���?4��)^R=�6&0�C3�����,��)'��)'? � /1hl3 � �f/4$03 ~�/1h�9/4)�9�)=3 �;13���/@)�= �� �,�B4! $'� �B&F*3�)'/0&0� a &0��P���)�&'!(/4)[= �� q�(!�! $'�,��)'?,3 � �f.@� �/�9�c3����B!�*���7P�/=!8��3 ��.4�f4)�&^9C/@)�!J3;*)=3 � ��a=$�13���/@)M� � q �@�%?@��.@��!#$�!�9C/@)�9C��)@3���*3 ��/4)�!i/4e�3 � �g9/4)=3�4�X��)�4)@3�*33 � �u�)�&6/*e�3 � �uP���PQ�g! ��9w3���/@)(O= G �5Q G �J`8�r��=s�� �\`W� Q G 2 � G �"% # J�� + I � + �= � �rQ � �J`8�'� =s�� ��`:� Q � 2 � � �"% # J���� I ��� &

yt)�9�t3 � �u��)0~�/1h�!%eo��/4� 3 � �73Jh�/,P'��PQ��!#�,��3���)^)'/0&0� a 4)�&6�X��} � 3 � �u/4$03 ~�/1h¡eo��/4� 3 � �u)'/0&0�7�"!#?4��.4��)FR��= �� � � G = G � � � = �� G � � �

� � G = �� �\`W� Q G 2 � G �"% # J�� + I � + � � � = �� �\` � Q � 2 � � � % # J�� � I � �� G � � �& � � q Õ L=�

d�e���efd � ���! Hslru j t j u{u�l:� �ht �rj n u j H�nvl�"�� j q �cl'n�u��aq�H�� j ��l�l/H�u eL �uh#�� � �)'/1h�$�!8�-3 � �u�C}'49C3�!8/@ �$03���/@)m� � q Õ L=�|3�/�*)�! h%��%3 � �7eo/@ � �/1h#��)'?Xa=$'�B!J3���/@)�!8O

# F�Y x K�@CBVbGK!_cF!KQI_aH%$6? K6Up�rK6?C?�O Q HGF!KcJ'&)( _+*�@CB)H\Y x K!_��rH\_aJ\F�*�@ F�Y x K!_aK�]�TEBV@\)6T K�@CB���HP��H,�XcHPB Y^]\U�@CBI]\BVY = �� ��`8�XNHP_R_aK6FfQ H\B=J\@CB{|SY^H>Kc]LX x U�Kc]GFRTE_aKcJ H\TEY ��HP� = �� ��`8�-&

��)Ie�@9w3 � h%�gh#�� � H! � /1h�3 � 137�9C/@)�!83�*)=3(/@$038~�/1h�= �� � L�9�*)xRQ�g?@�)'����*3 �B&^R=�6�,/4���u3 � *)x/@)'�f��)'P'$03-eo/4�-�?4��.4��)x!8�3/*eH)'�3Jh�/@� :�P�4��4�,�C3 ���#*)�&j~�/1hp�;13���!�q

¢

Page 29: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

v���E� ������$�&'�E�h� � � �{���[�$���������% �������(� Õ �� /4)�!8�"&0��f3 � �j! ��)'?4 ��C�� �/�/@Pm)��C3Jh%/4��:x��) K ��?4$�� � � q � � 4)�&M4!�!8$��X�,3 � 13 � � F � G F L'q ` /x!8���,P' ���eo�m3 � �F!8��3 $�*3 ��/4) �

h%�� �/�/4:neo/4����)'P�$03�9C/@)�9C��)=3 �;13 ��/4)�!7/*ei3 � ��eo/4��� = �� ��`8�`� = %�� ��� h � ������I�"!fx9C/@�,P' ��}k)�$'��R�����qI��$'R�!83 ��3 $'3 ��)'?x3 � ��!�C}0P'����!�! ��/@)j��)@3�/I� � q Õ L=�%*)�&^! �C383���)�?R= �� � L � h%�7/4R03;*��)%�� � � � � �� G % # � J �h � ��� ��� �¥� ���� � � � +� + �|�"!�3 � �7&0� ;Q��� ��)�9C�-��)F3 ���,�t��3i3�4:4��!Geo/4��3 � �79/4)�9�)=3 �;13���/@)�P'$' "!8�t3 /�3 �;�.4�� �3 � ��/4$'? � P'��P�� � .@��;!8$�!P'��P�� Õ q ` 4:���)'?�3 � �u �/@?@*����3 � � /4e�3 � ��!��C}0P'����!�!8��/4) � h%�f94)6! /4 �.4�teo/4���vO

��� ��A � � �/4? � �� G��

� ��� � Õ �� � � � Õ � � � q Õ4Õ �h � ��� � � ��!#4)=�j��)=3 ��?4����q ` � ��� �eo/4��� � 3 � �u��)0~�/1h�!ih%�u*���7��)=3 ��� �B!J3���&F��)63;*:4�-3 � �7eo/4���

= �� ��`8�� � ��`8� %�� # J���� ���5& � � I � + . I ��� � � � � q �� �h � ��� � � ��`8�%�"!`]PB z PQ�����/0&0�"9-eo$')�9C3 ��/4)^h#�c3 � P���� ��/0& � N2���q� /4)�!8�Ba@$��)=3 �� � 3 � ��� �u4� �-*))@CB��'BV@CY�K7)�$'��R����i/*e�PQ/@!�!8��R' ��t��)0~�/1h�!�eo/@�%h � ��9 � 3 � �7�,��@!8$'����&F9C/@)�9C��)@3���*3 ��/4)j*3%)�/�&'��dh#�� � �RQ� �����/F�o/@�%9/4)�!83�4)=3;�wq[��!8�B9C/@)�&�! $�9 � ��)0~�/1hl�"!GP���9C3 $'����&j��) K ��?4$�� � � q B � h � ����(��3i��!i9C ���4�G3 � 13#1e�3���i*)F��)'��3 �"* 3 �;*)�!8���)=3 � 3 � �7�X�B4! $'����&j9/4)�9�)=3 �;13���/@)��"!��"&0��)@3���9�* � ���9/4)�!83�4)=3 � �.@�)F3 � /@$'? � 3 � �u9C/@)=3�*�,��)�*)=3i9C/4)=3���)�$'�B!G3�/,.�4� ��*3)'/0&0�f�gq

�¯@� � /4)=3;*�,��)�*)=3#��)'P�$03���)^)'/0&0�f�gq ��R�� � /4)=3�4�,��)�4)=3i�,�B4! $'� �B&F*3#)'/0&0�f�-q

0 2 4 6 8 10

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

4

Time

Con

cent

ratio

n

0 2 4 6 8 10

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

Time

Con

cent

ratio

n

K ��?@$'��� � q BvO��()n�}0@9w3u!8/@ �$'3 ��/4)x/4e(� � q Õ L=�#h#��3 � j&0�B9�����)'?j! ��)�$�! /4�"&'* {��)'P'$03u9C/@)�9C��)@3���*3 ��/4) � *)�& Q G � Õ L � � G � Õ L �Q � �p� � � � � Õ � � A �/L�& LmL � ��! /X3 � *3�� � � � 2 � 4)�&��� ��L�& B Õ L Õ � + �Cq��)�����4 �hi13���i&0��!83 ����R'$03 ��/4)F)'�C3Jh%/4��:0! � 3 � �7! /4$'�;9C�B!�&0/�)'/*3#&0�B9��X��)j3 ���X�7��)F4)��C}0PQ/4)'��)@3���4 �e�@! � ��/@)�qH��)�!J3���@& � �c3i��!�g$�9 � �,/4���t3J�=P���9�* Qeo/4�#! /4$'�;9C�B!G3�/�.14� ��PQ�����/0&0�"94 � ���� @CY x H\TEYi&0�B9�� � 9/4��� �B!8PQ/4)�&'��)'? � eo/@�#�C}'*�,P' �� � 3�/ � �3' � /4$'�i9C�09 ��B!/*e%&0���*)�&n*)�&x!8$�P'P' ��4qu��)n/@��&'��teo/4�t3 � �,!8/@ �$'3 ��/4)x��)s� � q Õ�� ��3 /FR��X$')�&�*�,P��B& � 3 � �g3����� ��)n3 � �X�C}0PQ/4)'��)=3-��$�!J37RQ����� / � !8/�3 � 13

�s� ÕA �/@?� � �� G� �

h � �"9 � 9*)^* "! /�RQ�uh#� ��383��)I4!#X����!83 ����9C3 ��/4)6/4)6)'�C3Jh%/4��:�P�4��4�X�3 ����!Q � � � ��� Q G� G �

ÕA �/4? � �� G��! &

K ��?@$'��� � q XP'����! �)=3�!t*)x$�)�&'*�,PQ��&k!8/@ �$03���/@)^eo/4�-*)'/43 � ���()'�3Jh�/@� :6h � �"9 � *?=*��)^9 ��B*�� ��6�C} � ��R'��3�!-j9/4)�!83�4)@3-9C/4)�9C�)'�3 �;13���/@)6*3#)'/0&0�f�p*e�3 ��i3 � �u��)'�c3���4 �3 �;*)�!8���)=3�! � �.@�u&0���B&6/4$03Bq

¢

Page 30: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� L ������������� ��������� ��������������������������������������� ���!�"���#��$�%��������� &'�(����)���=� � /4)=3�4�X��)�4)@3#��)'P'$03(*3#)'/0&0�f�fq ��R�� � /4)=3�4�,��)�4)=3i�,�B4! $'� �B&F*3#)'/0&0�f�-q

0 5 10 15

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

Time

Con

cent

ratio

n

0 5 10 15

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

1.6

1.8

Time

Con

cent

ratio

n

K ��?@$'��� � q {O%��)x�}0@9w3t! /4 �$03���/@)I/*e�� � q Õ L@�%eo/@�t*)I$�)�&'*�,PQ��&IPQ�����/�&'��9u��)'P'$'3 � h#�c3 � Q G � Õ L � � G � Õ L � Q � � �m� & + + B �� � � ÕG� � A �/L$& Õ � � � Õ & + �Z� �0Õ B � ��� L�& L@�Cq

�� � �/4eH/@$'�#� ;�/4� 3�!���)^3 � ��!(!8�B9w3 ��/4) � �.@�u!8/,e�4��R����)^3 � �/@� �3 �"9* �4)�&^!8/���3(�"!#h%/4� 3 � h � �� ��-eo/4�($�!i3 /�.@����ceo�j3 � *3�3 � �!�*�,�f3J��PQ��/4e|R�� � �.���/@$'�(�"!-/4R�! ���.4�B&^��)m49w3�$�* H�t�������0�M9C/@�,P'$03�*3 ��/4)�!�q L �,9C/@)�!J3�� $�9w3 �B&xj! ���XP� �� � ��)'/0&0�f)'�3Jh�/@� :9C/@)�! ��!83 ��)'?�/*e|, �/�/4P � @!#P'�"9w3�$'� �B&^��) K ��?4$'��� � q + �¯@�7�o3 � ���C}�3 �;-vJ$')�9C3 ��/4)I�"!#)'��B&0��&6eo/@�#3 � �g �/1h����#P'��PQ�g! ��)�9C�f�t�������0�� @!(�����!83 ���"9w3 ��/4)^3 � 13-/4)' ��6/4)'��P'��PQ��9�*)n9/4)')���9w3-*)��j3Jh%/fvJ$�)�9w3���/@)�!��Cq L ��4P'P' ����B&x�PQ�����/0&0�"9 � !�a@$�*���C��h%�.@�t��)'P'$03/*e(9/4)=3�4�,��)�4)=3g3 /k)'/0&0�^� � 4!�! � /1h#)r��) K ��?4$�� � � q + �oRQ� � *)�&b3 � ��)r�,��@!8$�� �B&b3 � �^9C/@)�9C��)=3 �;13 ��/4) *3�)'/0&0�^�-q ` � ��,��@!8$'����&k9 � �/4����)'�, ��.@� "!-*3u)'/0&0������) K ��?4$'��� � q + ��9B�-*?@4��)m! � /1h¥3 � 1373 � ��9/4)=3�4�,��)�4)=3-����@9 � ��!7^9C/@)�!J3;*)=3u ���.4�� 1e�3���i3 � �u��)��c3���4 �3 �;*)�! ���)=3�! � �.@�-&'���B&F/@$03�qd�e���e54 � ���! Hslru j t j u{u�l:� �cl'nEk ��n H�nvl�">� j q eL �%h#�� � ')'/1hr! � /1hM3 � 13[�.@�)�3 � �%eo/@� hi*�;&f9C/@)=3�*�,��)�*)=3HP'��/4R' ��� 9�*)�R��#�� � ���P�/=!8�B&�q K /4�H3 � ��!HP'$�� PQ/@! � � h%�ih#�� � '9C/@)�!8�"&0���f! ���,�� �4�| �/=/@P�)'�C3Jh%/4��:u3�/u3 � *3�vJ$�!83%9/4)�! ��&'�����& � �C}'9C��P03|3 � 13|3 � �(.@� �/�9�c3J� � G G Lf! /73 � *3|3 � �������!� _aK!YfTE_RB ? H�HNQQq ` � �! �c3�$�13���/@)���!�P'�"9w3 $�� �B&���) K ��?4$'��� � q ��q ` � �t���,PQ/4� 3�4)@3%&0��!83 ��)�9C3 ��/4) � ��� �(��!G3 � *3�h%�(*���#)'/43%13 3 ���XP'3 ��)'?f3�/u �)�&e= ����� 3 � �9C/@)�9C��)=3 �;13 ��/4)j~�/1h#��)'?,��)=3 /,)'/0&0�f�gq'��)�!83 �B4& � = ��� ��!#X?4��.4��)jeo$�)�9w3���/@)�q

� ! ��)'?g3 � �u! 4�,�-�,��}0��)'?,*��?4$��X��)=3�!�eo� /@� 3 � �7P'���.���/4$�!i! ��9C3 ��/4) � 3 � �u9C/4)�9C�)=3���*3 ��/4)�/4e�3 � �-RQ/4$�)�&'*����.1* �$'�u13i3 � �� �B4&F/*eHP'��PQ� � � = �� � �"!�X ���)'�B*��9C/@�gR'��)�*3 ��/4)6/*e�= ��� *)�&j3 � �u��)0~�/1hleo��/4� P���PQ� Õ O= �� ��`8�����= ��� ��`8� � � = G �5Q G �<`8�R��oh � ������I4)�& � 4� �X9C/@)�!J3;*)=3�!-&0��P���)�&0��)'?F/@)x3 � �g~�/1h�.4� �/09C��3 ����!;�wqf�(/1h���.4�� � �ceGh%�,*P'P' ��^�,�c}0��)'?j3�/j3 � �X��)0~�/1h�!t*3)'/0&0�f� � 3 � �)[= G �5Q G �<`8�%��!#4)I1383��)�$�*3 ��&6*)�&�3����,�C��! � �ce�3���&^.@��;!8��/4)F/*e�= �� �\`8�RO

= G �rQ G �J`8�r��= �� ��`:� �*�"% # J �P�h#��3 � �m� � �� � � � +� + �o)'/43 �"9C�F3 � �^9 � *)�?4����)s! ��?@)Meo��/4� 3 � �F�}�P�� �B! ! ��/@)beo/4� �I��)s����9C3 ��/4) � q ��q � � �Cqk��eth��F3 � ��)s@! ! $'�,�= �� � = %�� � ��*)�&j3;*:@� = ��� �/L�eo/@��!8���,P' ��"9C��3J�'� � 3 � �)^h%�u9*)^! /4 �.4�-3 � �B!8�7�Ba@$�13 ��/4)�!#4!iRQ�Ceo/4���-3 /�/@R03�4��)

= �� ��`8�r� � ��`8�"% & # J���� ����� I � . � �h � ��� � � �\`8�i��!t*)��jPQ�����/�&'��9-eo$')�9w3 ��/4)Ih#��3 � P���� ��/0& ��� qiE � �0!8�"94 � �� � 3 � �"!�RQ� � �.���/4$'��9�*)^RQ�f��)=3����P'� �3 �B&^��)^3�����,!�/*e[?4��.4��)69/4)=3�4�,��)�4)=3%P'$� �! �u?4��)'��;13���)'?�KcX x H8K6Ff/4� _R@CB{|P@CB{|j��)^)'�C3Jh%/4��:0!i9C/4)=3;*��)'��)�?X,���C3�$'� )6 �/=/@P�q� /4)�!8�Ba@$��)=3 �� � eo/@�g |L@CbGK!Bs9/4)=3�4�X��)�4)@3u��)0~�/1h = ��� ��`8� � 3 � �����9*)mRQ���,/4����3 � *)b/@)'��/4$03 ~�/1h = �� ��)=3�/IP'��PQ� � q` � �"!G! $'?4?@��!83�!H3 � 13G3 � �#eo/@� hi*�;&XP'��/4R' ��� ��!�* "!8/u�� � ���P�/=!8�B&�q L¡� �C3 � ��G/@�G)'/43�! $�9 � f!8��3 $�13 ��/4)��"!G@9w3�$�* � ����)�9/4$')=3������&��)�P'��@9w3���9�#��![)�/*3G9C ���4��qH��/1h%�.@�� � 13|3 � �#.4��� �� ��B4!83|�c3%&0/���!|! $'?4?@��!83H3 � *3Gh��#P�� /09C����&Xh#��3 � 94$03 ��/4),h � ��)�13 3 ��,P03���)�?3 /�9/4�,P'$03��f!8/@ �$03���/@)�!%3 /X3 � �u)'�C3Jh%/4��:�~�/1h�P'��/4R' ���^q

¢

Page 31: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

v���E� ������$�&'�E�h� � � �{���[�$���������% �������(� �'Õ

��=�i��/�/4P6)'�3Jh�/@� :���)I�t�������'��q

A B

C

�oR�� ��� �/@� ��)'�7!8/@$'��9�u13#)'/0&0�f�fq ��9�� ��� �/@� ��)'�-�,��4! $'����&613�)'/0&0�u�-q

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

Time (h)

Con

cent

ratio

n (m

g/L)

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

Time (h)

Con

cent

ratio

n (m

g/L)

K ��?@$'��� � q + O���)s�t�������'�¡9C/4�,P'$'3�13���/@)Mh#�c3 � n&'��9�����)'? � PQ�����/0&0�"9 � !�a=$�*����h%�.@����)�P'$03X3 � *3�P'��/0&0$�9C�B!gk9C/4)�!J3;*)=3/4$'3 P'$03(*3�)'/0&0�u�-q

V , L , C

BC (t)

oAC (t)

1oC (L ,t)1

C (t)in

11 1

2 2 2

V , L , C

A B

K ��?@$'��� � q � O[��!8�B9C/4)�&j)'�3Jh�/@� :�h#��3 � m�Jeo����&0R�49;:0�g �/�/4P�q

¢

Page 32: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

�L� ������������� ��������� ��������������������������������������� ���!�"���#��$�%��������� &'�(����)�d�e���e�� � ln� � �at�� I�� j � t �rj n u j�� nvl "�� j q e` � ��� �X*���f��*)��^P�/=! ! ��R� ��X*P'P'��/@@9 � ��!#3 /^!8/@ �.���)'?�3 � ����)�.4��;! �fh%*3 ���ta=$�* ���3J�6P�� /@R' ���� � /@)'�g/4e|h � �"9 � ��!7&0�B! 9� ��RQ��&I��)� Õ ��q�+($'����)'?63 � ��h%/4��:0! � /@P � h%��h���� �X)'/*3g4R' ���3�/I���,P' ���,��)@3g4)��x��)�.@��;!8�,!8/@ �$'3 ��/4)b* �?4/4����3 � ��!-/4�73�/I��)�.4�B!J3���?=13�����)&0�3�*�� �3 � �f�,�����3�!�/4eH3 � �fPQ/@!�! ��R' ��g4P'P'��/@49 � ��!�qG��/1h%�.@�� � h#�c3 � *)I�z�9����)=3�eo/4��h%4��&6! /4 �.4��#��) � 4)�& � 3 � ��� �g4� �u��4)=�P'$'R� ��"9f&0/@�,4��)I! /*e�3Jhi*���tP�49;:1*?@��!#�.1*�� �4R' ��teo/@�#)'/4)'�® ���)���*�#/@P03 ���,��!�13���/@)63 � *3($�! �73 � �ueo/@� hi*�;&j! /4 �$03���/@)^@!�m�8R' "49;:RQ/�}0�n��)£!8/@ �.���)'?x3 � �6��)�.4����! �jP�� /@R' ����^q yt)��FP�@9;:1*?4�jh � ��9 � h�/@$' "& RQ�Fh%/4� 3 � 9/4)�! �"&0�����)�?n�"!�+��-��y-E ` � � � � /@����3�!! $�99��!�!8/@� � yuy-E ` � B� � h � ��9 � *���tR�4! ��&�/@)j3 � �7h��� � ���:=)�/1h#)j)'/@)' ���)'�B*�#&0� ;Q��� ��)@3���4 c��* �?4��R'�;*�"9�!8�0!83 ��� !8/@ �.@��i+��t���0�|qE|��/1.���&'��&M3 � 13jkeo/@� hi*�;&b3 ���,�x!J3��Pd/*e-3 � �6hi13����a=$�4 ���3J�r94 �9$' "13 ��/4)£9C/@$' �&£RQ�I��)�9C/4��PQ/4�;13 �B& ��)=3 /m3 � �"!�P�@9;:1*?4� �3 � �)F3 � �u9C/@)=3�*�,��)�*)=3i9C/4)�9C�)=3���*3 ��/4)�!�/4�%P�/=!8��3 ��/4)�!%9/4$' "&�RQ�-3 ����*3 ��&F4!�eo����-P�*�;*�,�C3���;!G4)�&j/@P03 ���,��! ��&j$�! ��)'?�3 � ��! �* �?4/@� ��3 � �,!�qS,T�� � 9 ! ! 1uY � 1�.^\ * 9FW�9^Y 2<3 _CY 2(]%WH_CZ�.�5 Tyt$'�u��*��)M9C/@)�9C �$�! ��/@)n�"!73 � *3u3 � ���-�������0�s9C/0&0���"!f94 �9$' "13 ��)'?F3 � �F9C/4������9w3u! /4 �$03 ��/4) � P'� /1.��"&0��&n3 � 13u3 � � � �0&0�;*$� ��"93 ���,�f!J3��P^�"!%3�*:@�)^!8��4 � ���)'/4$�? � 3 /,� �B!8/@ �.@�(~�/1hp���.4����!�* "!�q��(!(�����! $' �3 � h%�u��*:4�t3 � �7eo/4 � �/1h#��)'?�!8$�?4?4�B!J3���/@)�!8O

w K ���;!J3 � 3 � � � �0&0�;*$' ��"9g3����,��!83 ��Pb4)�&n3 � ��hi13���fa=$�* ���3J�I3 ���,��!J3��PM! � /4$' "&nRQ���C}0P' ��"9C��3 ��k9 � /=!8��)n��a=$�4 H3 /I�B49 �/*3 � �� � ��)�!83 �B4&F/*eH ��383���)'?��-�������0�k&0�Ce�4$' �3#3 /� � �0&0�;*$� ��"97!J3��P^/*e{/4)'� � /@$'�Bqw ����9/4)�& � P�*383 ��� )�!7eo/4�u3 � ��3����,�j.14� �"13���/@)k/4e#9/4)�! $'�,P03���/@) � ! $'P'P� ��b*)�&bP�$'�,P #�.1* �.4��/@P�����*3 ��/4)�!7��$�!83gR��j��)0�3 ���PQ/4 "13 �B&6/4)=3 /,3 � � � �0&0��4$' ���9-3����,��!83 ��P�!#eo��/4� :�)'/1h#)M�o�,��@!8$'����&��#&'13;'q ` h�/�/@P03 ��/4)�!#eo/4�t&0��4 ���)'?�h#��3 � 3 � ��!*���LO

P'���P'��/09C�B! ! ��)�?�3 � �%��)'P'$'3[&�13�( � ���!�3 /7��)=3 ���PQ/4 "13 ��3 � �%:�)'/1h#)gP�13 3 ���)�!{/4)=3�/--&0�)�!8���H! �������!{/*e'3����,�iPQ/4��)@3;!q` � �"!#����a=$'��� �B!�)�/X�,/0&0�� �9*3 ��/4)�!%3�/��t�������0�n4)�&^9*)6��@!8�� ���R��u��@&0�-3 �;*)�! P�*���)=3%3 /X3 � �u$�!8����q ��)�9C/@� PQ/4�;13���)'?k*)r��)=3 ��� PQ/4 "13���/@)r* �?4/@� ��3 � � ��)=3 /b�t�������'� � h � �"9 � �"!���$�9 � �,/@� �FP'� /@R' ����13���96!8��)�9�j/4)���g$�!J3(&0�B* �h#��3 � 3 � �u��)=3 ��� )�* �&'*3�,!J3�� $�9w3 $�� �B!i$�!8�B&F3 /�!J3�/4���-3 � �7~�/1h���)'eo/4���,*3 ��/4)�q

w ���B94$�!8�t3 � �t~�/1hp��a=$�*3 ��/4)�!#4� �-)'/1hlRQ���)'?�! /4 �.4�B&j13�X�g$�9 � "*��?4����)�$'��R�����/*e�3 ���X�f!83 ��P�! � e�4!83 ��#4 �?@/4���c3 � ��!*���t����a=$'��� �B&�eo/@��!8/@ �.���)'?X3 � �u)�/4)' ���)���*�#! �0!J3���^q�yt$'��! $'?4?@��!83 ��/4)j�"!i3�/X$�!8�f,a=$�4! ��� 2 �hi3 /@)64 �?@/4���c3 � � � !8$�9 � @!+ 2 �B� � qw L � � �.4�7eo/@$')�&n9/4)�9� �3 �u�}04�,P' ��B!(h � ����u3 � ����)�.@��;!8�uP'��/4R� ���� eo/@�t9/4)=3�4�X��)�4)@3(3 �;*)�! P�/@�83t��!(�� � c��PQ/@! ��&Ih � ��)3 � ��� �^*���r� �/�/4P�! �n��)s3 � �^)'�3Jh�/@� : � 4)�&r! /k��3�����mRQ�I&0��z�9$' �3,/@�,���,PQ/@!�!8��R' ��j3�/b! /4 �.4�F��)£P'�;49C3 �"9C�4q 2 �.@�� �3 � �� ��B! ! � h%� � �.4�X)'/^�.���&'�)�9��3 � 1373 � ��!7�"!73�� $'�,��)k?@�)'����4 [*)�&m!8/6��3f�,��k!J3��� � [R���h%/4� 3 � h � �� ��g3�/6P�$'��! $'�X3 � ����,P' ���,�)=3;13 ��/4)6/*e[*)6��)=.@��;!8�7! /4 �.4��Bq|yt$'��4&0.��"9C�}O� _aH�XNKcKcJ � @CY x Xc]PTEYf@[HPB �w yt)�9C�(4)��Cz�9C���)=3�eo/4��h%4��&,! /4 �$03 ��/4)�4 �?@/4���c3 � � �"!�h�/@� :���)'? � 3 � ����t4� �#��4)=�Xeo����(! /*e�3Jhi*���#P�@9;:�4?4�B!|�.1*�� �4R' ��#/@)3 � �u��)=3 ��� )��C3ieo/4��! /4 �.���)'?X3 � �u��)�.@��;!8�-P'��/4R' ��� � ��)6h � ��9 � 3 � �7eo/@� hi*�;&j! /4 �.4���i��!#$�!8�B&F@!#X! ���XP� ��I� R' �@9;:�R�/�}�q �

¢

Page 33: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� ��� ������� ��� ���

� Õ � `�� ��������� O q�� � �!� �#" �%$ $ � � > q >'&#( P!���@q*) � ( �,+-� � � �f~ & }b��� " � $ e.� ( 9/� ��0 ��9/� � 0 � � �   $ � ( 1� � � � O K � ( h% ( " �#"�2��0 � ( + � + � $ & � � � �#+ e.� ( 93� $ � ( �4" �7�� +5+ R� $ � 9C� + � & "6� � + qS'�]PY�K!_87�K6F!H\TE_aXcK6F97�KRF!Kc]\_aX x�: �m� � �@�6O � L B@�E' � L � : Õ �%� 0q� � �f�;� ( @9C� L q�5 � � ? :=< �'� + ��� ( y�q L � +�$ � ( : �#"?> *�,� + �Xq L �@� " R &!( � q ! z J\_a]PTE?A@[X6F;q > ��� � L � $ �A�^�CB6� �#+ :,D �hFE%� ( : :�G�5�6� "6� � � � � : Õ �*� + q� � �f� � �#" 6EH�/�Q�A� $4" : > qIH�� �mO � + � � : EJ� �2$ � P � qK� � $2$ : �� &!( � � �gy�q > G�I �#"MLN� �#� � ?^E[ ( :�q D & �,� ( � O $ �4P!� � �, $PO � � � ( � $�*e�P� ( *RQ� $ � O ESR �S+ & +-� � ?TR;)�B�y-E ` : � � _aH�XNKcKcJ\@CB{|\FsH ,�Y x K # 'VU '�HP_aDGF x HcQ HPBVW�]P_f|}K OYX=Xc]P? K ( QIYZ@CU�@ #8]PYf@[HPB : Õ � � B�q) 0 � $ *R $ �f1��Z6[�[]\�^�_�_a`@`�`�b-c�d�e=fgd!c@c]hQfgd@eibkjQl�mgn�boc@p]j!_#q]l�mac�_]p@r#mas�\�[SbY\,m0q� �*�f�|qKB�q O � "!" � : � �2�," � $ $ � q�y ( � + R���� : �#" R8� �M> q L ��� " q `�� �,�C�� 0 � ( 4? � � ?,h%a� � ( a & $2� �t�I +5+ � +�+ �,� � ��q�uEH\TE_RBI]P?�H,

Y x K�U�U K!_R@[XN]PB '�]\Y^K6_ '�H\_aD\F�U�FcF!H8X!@[]\YZ@[H\B : P�4?4� + B4�3'/ � : > & $ � Õ �%�@�0q� ���f����h � + )gq O � +�+ �� � q�& IU � &wvyx F!K6_cF�')]\B T ]P?8z %VK!_cFR@[H\B|{]}~{3�1q O;� +��kO � " & O � � � � �%� ? �2� �� ( � � ?6��*RQ� ( 1�5� ( � : � q�B�q�%��0�� ( � � �X� � �� $ E ( �a��� O � � � � )�?@� �#O � :�< � �#O/� �!� a� � : y�� � � : > � & ( � Õ � �*��q < � " �X �#"M" � O & �,� � �;1� � � � ( �g 0 � $ *R $ �e ( �@� Z6[�[]\�^�_�_a`@`�`�b-c�\!rJboe!sa�#_]p�s!l@m]_1�������6_'q� B1�f����h � + )fq O � +5+ �� � : E[ & $ K q=HS� & $ � + : �,"I` �@��) $ ���, � q8R � +5O ( �/��� 0 � $ & �,�C��� $ ��,� � ���,�/�5�!� " e.� ( � �/�Jhi� ( � hi1��� ( �a & $ � �t�j�T� " � $ + q;uEH\TE_RB=]\? H, '�]PY�K!_87�K6F!H\TE_aXcK6F� ? ]\B BV@CB |�]\B=J+')]\B=]!| K6U K!B Y : Õ4Õ ���¯�@�RO¸�ZL=�V'0� Õ : Õ �%� � q�� B� O " & B�� ( R� � q < yuy-E ` ' < � � � ( � $ �#" �@P6� � � � �B1� � � � �*e " � � *� � O�+ � + � ��� + O ��+ � ( � + ? & �4" �4q ` � O � �!�4O $%O �PQ� ( �

� < B6H�� > � �!� �*� Õ : �;�!� 0 � ( +�� �t�*�*e < $ � e.� ( �!� 61��B' � ��'Hi ( R� ( : Õ � �%�'qK) 0 �2$ *R $ ��1��Z�[�[@\�^�_@_a`�`�`�btc�d6e=fAd#c@c]hQf�d6eJbj=l@mGn�b-c@p�j,_#q@l�mac6_!l�s�s1\6[Sbk\Qm0q� + � � ( � B���4� � ( �#" < �� ( $ � + RgqiRgq��;�1hi ( " q L a� � ( "6� + � ( � R & � � � ��+ � + ���� + � $ � +�� + q�uEH\TE_RBI]P?�H ,�Y x K6! z JP_a]\TE?A@[X6F#�@Cb�@ FR@[H\B * _aH�XcKcKNJP@CB |PF`H ,sY x KNU�U�K!_R@[Xc]\B�X=H�X6@[K!Y z H,���@Cb8@C? & B |L@CBIKcK!_cF : �*�Q���9E Õ �6O �'Õ �E' �Z� � : > � & ( � Õ � B + q

�Z�

Page 34: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� � � ����$(�!� ������n��&

¢

Page 35: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� ��������� �

� ����� � � ����� C� � � �� ��� ����� ��y��� � ���� C��� ����� �

� ( � O ) ���4� � & � � : ) �," ( �����)��� ( � � � � : H ( � �#" < & ��� $ � �"! : >]� � < ��� � � � : �%$ $ $# & + �/� � � :&% � + � $ �2�?> & � � �4O(' : � �,�� � & � $D �4���*)Q�,+ : � ( O �wB��,- :". & $0/�� �1)Q� G :2 �13Q� ( ��3 ( �43� ( � " )��65 & � . $ O/� � + G7o� � ( � " & O � � � � : R � +5O & +�+�� � � �#")�J"6� � � � �8)�� 29� �� ) �9�@ (;: $ G�=<4> ?A@$BDCFEHGIKJLBDM1EN@

< �'���X�1O85�P)Q� ( 1�5� ( � � + �,�B + &!( � +PO � �#O � � � ( a� � � �#+ �9Q 0 ( � � & + � � � � ( $ +P� � $ �#"�+ *�83 $ � + 3 ( � 0�� " � " )��w����� � ( O/$ � � � � +4RTS ���3 ( �9) $ ��U3 ( � + � � ��� " )�� < �'���X�1O � + ����1�����'��� : � & $ "*$2� � �����V)��,P) $ �w�5� " �/� � O � : �'� � ���'� � ( �,�� + &#( ���X� � �-P3"3� ( 1� & +� ��� "!+ ( �(W O $2� ) ( 1� � � ��" & �N�5�, + � � Q~� �2� 3 ( � O � +5+ 3� ( 4�X�A� � ( + : + �� + �5�,� � �!� � � ��� ( � : � ( �XR< &!(5( � � � $ � : O $ � ) ( a� � � � �PQI�5�'�(�,�� + &#( � � �u�� O � � � � �4+ �T� �!� ��� ( � " )��X�,�� + &!( �2� �f� �2� � ( $,O � �#O � � � ( 1� � � �#+P� � O � � � ( � $+ *�83 $ � + 9),� & ��� 0 � ( � Y�Li� �2� & ��� + � ([Z L + 4�83 $ � +1R < �'��,�(O : � & $4"N� " �� $ $ � $ �2� �P���(�, � �G " � OA� +�� � � P)Q� & � ���'� O $ � ) ( a� � � �1��� 0 � ( � O � � � ( � $K+ *�83 $ �f +5+ � +�+ �,� � � : �5��1� �4+ : �2� ( �� $ � � �X� : : � ���x $ � : � (5( � (�( a� � R\S �'� ( �(Q.� ( �����'�w����� $I� �83 $ ���,� � � � "� & + �F)Q��] & � � � +�� �83 $ � : 3Q� : � ( Q & $ �#" ( �B "6� $ � � � � � ( 3 ( �/�;P) $ � RTS � �4+ �4+PO �@�83 $2�4O a� � " )��N���'�LQ� O ������a�{� & $ � � 3 $ � " �43�� �#" � � ��,�� + &!( ��,� � � + ( �f�� " �w� � �� O � O � � � ( � $ + 4�$3 $ � : �#" � �#$ �?� � � + �A�t�,�� + &#( ���X� � � +;�4+ �� " �*)Q�(Q.� ( �����'� " � OA� +�� � �'� +�� " � R )i�^3 ( � + � � � : �5�'� ( �(W O $2� ) ( 1� � � �?" � O/�4+�� � �*� + �� " � & +��2� � � ( "!� � � � � $ : & �!�20 ( � 1��� O � � � ( � $�O �� ( � + Q.� ( =Qo� : � �A�� �2� � ( $ �,�� + &!( ��,� � � +1RH ( � �(_,� : �5�'�I�,�� + &!( ��,� � �=3 ( � O � +�+�O � )�� " � +�O ( � )Q� " + Q.� $ $ � : +1` B��@�X� O �4�83,� & �#" : : �!� + � O �4�83,� +-� � � � � �4+ �PQ� � ��� ( � + � �4+ 3 ( �13� ( � " �#"M�4+ 3� +5+ � " ���IF�, O � � � � : �5�'� 7 <L.�: : � �4O � + 3 ( G� +;� �N��� ( � & �]�ka3 $ + �,H_�*�,�,�(O OA� � �2� �V�����1�5�4� +4R . �!�a�5� �#+ �9Q O �� ( O � � ( �4+ � �4O : 0 � $ � � �a��� + ( �-�� � �-��� " + �����f1���@� + ( �/� &!( � �5���5�'� � ( � ( � & �#" + ��a� � +4RFS �'� + �u ( �O � & � � � " �5� " �/��� ( � � � ������� O � �,O � � � ( a� � � �#+ �PQ �����f1���@� + 3 ( � + � � � � � ���'� O �4�83Q� & �#"ARS �'� ( �7 ( �t�� � � + � &#( O � + �PQ�� (�( � ( � � �5� � + 3 ( � O � +�+ ) & � : �5�'����� ( �� : � ���V���'� $ ( �4� + � O � � � ( � ) & � � � �#+ ( � ` ���'� + *�83 $ ��4+�+ & +�O �136� � ) $ � �5� O � � ��*� � � 1� � � � 1�w�5�'�H3 ( �13� ( 1� � � � + ��9�4� : ����� + 3 ( G� � � �L� $ � + �9Q~� � � �4�/�N3 $ & �9�4� " �#" �5�'�63 $ + ��_�4�X�7��G� � ���;�'��a�����=3 ( � OA� + � $ � ����� O � (5( � O �i� ���83�� ( a� &!( � R� O � + 4�$3 $ � O � � �� �2�,+ ��� ( �9���� � Z Lu� $ ���,� � � + : �!� + ��1�5�4� O � �,O � � � ( a� � � �#+ ( ���5�*)Q���,�� + &!( � "AR[7o� O � �#+ & $ ��a� � � �: � ���*�5�'� �2�#" & + � ( � $ �,� � �5� ( :Tb B �9QP���'� + �X� $ ��,� � � + : � ( � �4" � � � �dc � " �5�6)Q���9Q � � ��� ( � + ��Q.� ( �5� �4+ 3 ( �,) $ ��� ` )e� : ) $ : ) + :< :,< � :,< ( :=< & :&f � :"g � :hg � :#D � :".�:&. ) : B ( :&% �,"KiQ�jRkml[npo q(rtsvuwo xzy {}|h~A�}���(�}s�y� l[npo q(rtsvuwo xzy {}|��Do���xv{�swo��� l[npo q(rtsvuwo xzy {}|&�T���Prtswxv��(�4o���{�n���sv�}uvrtsjl[npo q(rtswuvo xzy� l[npo q(rtsvuwo xzy {}|"�^{�n1xwsvrm�}���l[npo q(rtsvuwo xzy {}|&��{�sv{�n(xv{� ~0��rm��r�� 8��}�P{�s���xw{�svo�rtu

Z9�

Page 36: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

Z B � ����������� ���� ���������� ����� ��� � ��� � � �� ��������! "�����#��$��%� ��� � $����n�'&< �'���X�1O��� +8O � �#+��4" � ( � " & �!� 0 ( � a� �*] & $2� �t� O � � � ( � $ � $ � + � + : ����1� �4+ : �����A���� 0 � O � �#+�� " � ( � " � (5( � ( +��2� �,�� + &#( �1W�,� � �;�PQH�� O � � �#"6� 0�� " & $�O �� ( O ��� ( � + � �4O � � �fa�(�� � �,� : ) & ���� 0 � � �a� O � �#+��4" � ( � " $ $ �PQ ����� O �� ( O � � ( �4+ � � O�+ �5�9�@�/����� ( :����� ( �1)�� 3,��� � � � � $2$ � $ � +-� � � �2� Q.� ( ��a� � � � 9),� & � " �13Q� �#" � �#O/� � + )Q�/� : �� � � �2� � ( $ �X�B + &!( ��,� � � + �#" �2� _�1� �2� �|�����O �� �#O � + �PQ Q� $4+ �6 $ ( � +4R7o� "!"6� � � � � : ���'� $ ( �@� � & �*)Q� ( �PQ��,�B + &!( ���,� � � +��2��0 � $20 � " ( � �#" � ( + ��� � + O & �*)Q� ( + �4�,�3 ( � O � " &!( � RaS �'� " � OA� +�� � � (�& $ � & + � " )�� < �'��,�(OM1� 3 ( � + � � � �4+ �5��1� ( � O $ � ) ( a� � � � � + 3�� ( Q.� ( �,� " � Q#��� ( ������ �)( �PQ����� b Bf� �2� � ( $=O � �,O � � � ( a� � � �#+ Q.� ( ���'� O � � � ( � $Q+ *�83 $ �t ( ��� & � +-�4" �8���'��� ( "6� � � � � $ & �!� 0 ( � 1����B���� : �� ( �+*t� : �PW +-� �4��O � � � ( � $=$2� � � � +1R ,R � ;�� ( � � �(� & $ � �20 ( � 1���gP3&3 ( �= O �'� + ( � 3 ( � + � � � � " �'� ( � Q.� ( �5�'� b B,� $ ��,� � � + �PQ � � � � ( � + � : O � �#+-�4" � ( � � ������� O �� ( O W� � ( �4+ � �4OA+ ���,�4�A���'� ( �#" �� �@� � �u "!0 � ��P�@�S�9Q O �4�83 & � �2� � O P3�9) � $2� �t�g 0 � $ 9) $ �i� � � 0 � � �5�'�#��� + �D)� +�� O�+ � + � ��� +P�2� � ( " � (

���� (�( �20 �(1�#�<;Q� O � � 0 � " � O/�4+-� � � (�& $ � + : � � O �^ O�O &!( 1��� $ �, �#" 3 ( � O/�4+ � $ �8_QP�w� (�& $ � � & �mWY�PQzW O � � � ( � $ �X�B + &!( ��,� � � + � � �����3 ( � O � +5+4R[S � ( �� 0 � ( � O � � � ( + � �2� �793&3 ( �@ O �'� + ���N�5�'�e3 ( �9) $ ��� : � ( ���; � � ��" &!( �2� �N�5�'� . 7 g B b � �%� 7o�," & + � ( � $ . ( �9) $ ��B�� $20�� � � / � ( �6+ �!�,3 R S �'�A�� ( � ` O � �#+��4" � ( �2� �w������3 ( � O � +�+ + g ( � � 0 < �� � ��- & + �8�PQ H%G�@� +�� � H%� $ � �1Q D �A� : � ( �6+.- �#"g & $ � � 0 ( � a� � O � � � ( � $iO �� ( � � �83 $ ���,� � ��a� � � �AR . ( � $2� � �2� ( � " a��x � $ � +-�4+ Q.� ( " a�� 3 ( � 0�� " � " )�� < ����,�(O : + $ + �3Q� ( Q.� ( �X� " � � � ( " � ( �5� �2�!� � � $ $ �j +5+ � +�+�+ �4�,���PQ ���'�u��� " � $ +;O � �#+��4" � ( � "0R� � �KCFE0/ J �21�3�=<!4 ���2165 / C � E�798;:2/ M4@<5 E6G=1�>?�@BA�CEDGFIHKJLH=@M�N�O�PQFSR2TVUXWXHKY�A�Z[�\S]�\�^ _K`�acbBd�e�f�ghai#d�`S �'� < �'���,�(OV5�P) + � & $ � � 0 ( � 1��� ] & $ � �t� O � � � ( � $ 3 ( �,) $ �� �4+ ��� " � O/�4" �N�5�'�+j )Q� + �.k (�& $ � + Q.� ( O � � � ( � $ $2� � �����'� � ( 3 ( � O � +5+�PQ " �/��� ( � �2�!� � �M1�5�4� �4O�O � �#O � � � ( 1� � � �#+4R #;� : � 0 � ( )��1Q.� ( �I�] & $2� �t� �5�@� $;O � )Q� � �83 $ ��,� � ��� " ���'�^��1�5�'���a� �4O $Q.� & �#" 1� � � �#+ �PQ����'�K3 ( � O � +�+ �PQ � � ��� ( � + �X� & + �H)�� & �#O � 0 � ( � " �,"|O �4�83� ( � " : � �5� �5�'�I��1�5�'���1� � O $ +�+ & �836� � � �,+ +5+ � OA� a� � " : � �������'���5�@� $wR\S ��� + & � ��9) �2$ � �t� �PQH 0 � O ��� ( g ( � � 0 < �� � � ��� " � $ Q.� ( ����� < �'��,�(OF�X�B + &!( ��,� � ��3 ( � O � +5+�4+9+ � & "6� � "V�2� ��� �4+9O � � � �(O�� RT7 � �4+ *�]��� " ��� " � $ Q.� ( +�� � & $ a��� ( : � �4O � � + �B + ���5� � �83 $ ��,� � �� �," � � : � �4O �a3Q�a��� � � � $O � � � ( � $ (�& $ � +9O � )Q�N� � + ��� " : � �5�!� & �9�t� � � � & 3������u�, O � � � � R[�\S]�\S] lnm�oqprd�e�o%sS �'�=3!��� +�� O�+ �PQi���'� � � � � ( O � � � �,+N�2� �����H3 $ + �,a_�4�,�� ( � � �a� : � $ $J" � +5O ( � )�� " �#" ���'� �����'� ( � : � + � &!( O � + �PQi� (5( � (t O � � ��4� �2� a� � � � 1�P�����L3 ( �43� ( 1� � � ��+ ��P�@�% �#"T+ 3 ( G� � �vu�u $ �L3 $ & �9� � � �cw + ��������^)Q��3 &!( � $ � + �5� O �� + � �4Oi�2�T� 1� &!( �%�1O O �13!�����1�9����� 3 $ & �9� � � � + �!� & $4" �yx�� O �(�� ( � �#"0R\S � �4+9$ � " & + ���� g ( � � 0 O �� � ��" � +5O ( � 36� � � �AR5��A� :

z `v{�|2}�~��)Q�N���'� "6�4+5O ( �/� �y�]� � �,�^3 ( � O � +5+

z `�� t z=������z��������.������z'��� w: � ��� + �;1��� + 3� O �

� `���� ��� |=� ��� |��.���B|=� �����S �'� " � O/�4+-� � � ����j �1O�� ( � O � � � ( � $ k : � ( ����� Rv�XM��.P��XC�P�A�CSH : � � �5�'� 7 <L. �4+ �T� " � $2$ � " + + �5�93&3 �2� ��� � �,� t : � ��� ( � + 3Q� O �S�5������ c#$ � ( a� � � � �4� � � ( 1��� " )@� z w :

� `K{�~�} �S � �4+N� + 6Q & �#O � � � � � � ���'� + *�83 $ �N3�a��� + �9QJ�5�'�83 ( � O � +5+�z �2� ��� "6�4+5O ( �/� ��� � �,� ` �� O � + *�83 $ �N3�a��� � + +�+ � O/� 1��� " �5� � � �,� � : ���'��� � �X�����'j �1O0� ( � O � � � ( � $ k R�7 �-��G�V)��, ( � & � " ����a� � �4+ + ���93"3 �2� � � � �,�X �#" �5��1� z �� + ����� g ( � � 03 ( �93Q� ( �t� R

Page 37: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

�" � ������������� � � ����� � � �� ��� Z�5 �A��� t z t � � b w �.���.����z t � ��� w�w )��N������� $ ����� � �;�PQ ����� c#$ � ( 1� � � � ��� � � ( a��� " )�� z & 3������ � ��� �FRB � �#O � � � � +�� �83,� +�+�� ) $ �������(O�� ( OA� + �- O � � � ( � $ (�& $ � : � �4O � " �43�� �#"!+ � � Q & � &!( � + ��a��� + �PQ��5���^3 ( � O � +5+ t � Q � � : � ( ������� ���� � + 3 ( �,) $ �� : � & $ "�� �����1O �4+ � w : � �-� & + � )�������� O + �N�5��1� b���� � ��!#"$&%�'�( � � t z*)����.������z ' w R #+� �#O �g + ���93"3 �2� � � � ����4+ 8����� " ��� " � $ Q.� ( ����� O � � � ( � $ (5& $ � RS ��� g ( � � 0 3 ( �,3�� ( �t� :

, t z t � ���.- b w $0/21 � t z t � � b w ���.������z t � �3� w�w �4, t z t � �3�*- b w $#/#1 � t z t � �3� w�w:65 �87�� /9$ � t � w;:=<?>@<BA�C��87;3�7��DC��8ErF> QHG�IBIJG : > ` CKG&E��DC��87 ��<JA��*C 5 �a3�7�G,)�P)�IJ�L>3C�MC��LG9Q6C 5 �a3�7KGOND�8>K>gMCPC�<���� �Q- b C 5 �<JA�QHGF7���RC�<JGFA6P)�GFS�CC 5 ��NTG4�83�IJ�TCK� 5 <J>3C�G�7�U.G9QVC 5 �^3�7�G�ND�8>K>W<?>A�G,��GF7K� t GF7IB�X>�> wYS�>��(QHS�I C 5 MA2C 5 �Z<JA�QHGF7���RCK<BG�AFP)�GFS�C<BCK>NTS�7�7K�DA�C[>3C�MC�� t MCYCK<���� � w RW\ G�<]C<?>%F7;��S��8E.C 5 MCYC 5 �+CK7�FA�>�<]CK<BG�AHQH7KG4�^GFA��Z>3C�RCK�+CKG�FA�GMC 5 �D7 t 3�G�>K>3< )�IJU�C 5 ��>�*����>3C�MC��Qw<JA_G�A���C�<�����>3C��43`E�GO�8>ZA�GFC�E��13��DA�E_GFAa>3C�RCK�8>ZGFC 5 �87ZC 5 FA&C 5 �.NTS�7K7K�DA�Cb>cC;RC�� R87 Cb<J>�NDGFA�ND�D<Jd�9)�IJ�PC 5 RC�C 5 ��C�7;MA�>�<BC�<JGFAE�GO�8>E��43��8A�E2GFA63�7��8d�<JGFS�>Y>3C�MC��8> - QHGF7�(O'4�$3�IB�e<dQfC 5 �eA�Gvu�uDIJ�e<J>L3�IJS&�9���8E*C 5 �87��-���U$)��ubCK<����u�QgCK�D7 :65 <?N 5 <BCL)��8NDG4���8>S�A&3�IBS&�,�F�XE RD7 QfC 5 <J>[CK<����Z<?>6> 5 G�73C[C 5 MA : �ZNFA2< �FA�G�7��+C 5 � 3�IBS&�,�F<JA&� R 7 A2C 5 ���DdF�8A�CYC 5 RCC 5 <J><?>3A%k C6C 5 ��NF>��F: 3�IJS&�,�F<JA&�: <JIBI�F7�7K�8>3CC 5 � 3�7�G�NT�X>�> R\7 AIMAOU*�8dF�8A�C6C 5 � g F7�h�GRd=3�7�G,3��873CcUL7����,F<BA�><BA�C��N;C R[\ S�N 5 F7;��S'���DA�CK>NFAK)�� 3�7�G�IBG�A&�F�XE&iFjkgl8mWl�kgnpo�q )�S�C�C 5 ��7K��FI 7K��F>�GFAaQHGF7�NDGFA�>�<?E��D7K<BA"�@C 5 � g F7�h�GRd*N 5 M<JA^��GOE��DI <?>�<BCK> : �DIJI �OE��8dF�DIJG93��8ELC 5 �DGF7KUF:�MA�E2C 5 � Q�FNTCC 5 RC g F7�h�GRd�N 5 M<JAF��G�E��DI?>�F7��eGPQgCK�DA0S�>��(QHS�I <JAIP3&3�7�GpO�<��,MC�<JA&�$3 5 UO>�<?NMI03�7�G�NT�X>�>��8> R7 �,���8E�<"RCK�DIJUF:RC : GuF>;3��XN;CK>=GPQ g M7KhFGRdbN 5 F<BA@C 5 �8GF7KUgM7K�[S�>3�1QHS�I ` C 5 �C�7;MA�>�<BC�<JGFA$3�7�G,)�P)�<BIJ<]CcUg�,MC�7K<dOXMA�E@C 5 ��N 5 M<JA�k >�4]�S�<JIJ< )�7K<JS'�rE�<J>3C�7K< )�S�C�<JGFA RDS 5 �6C�7;MA�>�<BC�<JGFA=3�7KG9)�9)�<JIB<BCcU���MC�7K<dO.E��8>KNT7K< )��X>sC 5 ��E�UOA�4��<?ND>WGPQ C 5 � 3�7KG�NT�8>K> R f GF7�FAOUN��<Bd��DANTS�7�7K�DA�Cf>3C�MC��=C 5 �%�,MC�7K<dO^�F<JdF�X>tC 5 �YNDGFA�E�<BC�<JGFA�MIOE�<J>3C�7K< )�S�C�<JGFAPGPQ�FE�d�FA�NT<JA&�6CKG j A��(OOC k�>3C�MC��X> RTS 5 <J>f<?>V<��83�G�73C;MA�Cj)��8NFS�>��<BC�<J>6<JA�QHG�7 ��RCK<BG�A2G�ALC 5 �^QHS�CKS�7���G9QfC 5 � 3�7KG�NT�8>K> R f GF76�1O04�83�IB��:�< QfC 5 �bNTG�A�E�<BC�<JGFA�FI E�<J>3C�7K< )�S�C�<JGFA0<?> j A���M7KIJULE��1���DA��87�MC��vkC 5 �DAu<BC�NMA )��,FNTC��XEvS&3�GFA : <BC 5 NTG�A c E��8A�NT� R^S 5 �@��]�S�<BIJ< )�7�<JS'�wE�<?>cCK7�< )�S�CK<BG�AQGPQWC 5 � g M7KhFGRd#N 5 M<JAu<?>+C 5 ��IBG�A&�PWpC��87 �3�7KG93�GF7�C�<JGFA�GPQ CK<����+�BFN 5 �DIJ����8A�CY<J>W<BA*�BFN 5 >3C�RCK� R=\ G�:F< Q�MA.�DIJ����8A�C 5 F>\Q�M7=�1O�ND�D�XE��8E�<BCK>W�(O�3��XN;CK�8E�CK<����+<JA�bND�D7�C�M<JA>3C�RCK�F:OC 5 ��G93��D7;RCKGF7i���UL>3S�>m3��8NTC6C 5 MC(�> 5 < QgC 5 F>G�N8NTS�7K7��XEL<JA#C 5 � 3�7�G�NT�X>�>L3�F7�4���TC��87K> R7 A`C 5 �j�@S�I]CK<Bd1F7�<"RCK�2N�>3��:�<dQtu>3S&)�>3�DC@GPQ��8IB�����DA�CK>XM7K�LNTG�7�7K�DI"RCK�8Et:xC 5 �8>��2> 5 GFS�IJE )��6��7�G�S&3��8E R�S 5 <J>�����FA�>D:[MC: GF7y>cCX:FC;MhO<BA"�bC 5 ��z%F73CK�8>�<�FAH3�7KGOE�S�N;CGPQtC 5 �D<J77��X>m3��8NTC�<JdF��>3C�MC��Z>m3�FNT�X> - < Q C 5 ��>3C�7KS�N;CKS�7K�+GPQVC 5 �-�PS�IBC�< �ONDGF7K7��8I�MC�<JGFA.NFA)��PE��TCK�D7���<BA��XE#C 5 �8An.> �,FIBIJ�D7�>cC;RC��@>m3��NT��<?>�QH�BF>�< )�IJ� R�{ dF�87�FIBI : � : GFS�I?E#IB<JhF�ZCKG 5 �d��f83�M7�C�<BC�<JGFAvG9QfC 5 � QHS�IJIf>��TC�GPQ�DIJ����8A�Cy><BA�CKG*>cC;RC�<?>3C�<?NMIJIJU*S�A�7K�DI"RCK�8Ea�F7KGFS&3�> :65 G�>3��E�UOA�4��<JN8>6NMAK)��bE��TCK�D7���<BA��XEL<JA�E��43��8A�E��8A�CKIBU RS 5 � g M7KhFGRd_z 5 F<BAr��G�E��8IW<?>�FIJ>�GxMA|�(O�NT�8IBIJ�DA�C@N�MA�E�<?E'MC��=QHG�7@>�<��@S�I�MC�<JGFA R&{ A��*GFA�IJU_A��D�XE�>bCKGuE��DC��D7���<BA��*C 5 �C�7;MA�>3<BC�<JGFA���RCK7�<?NT�X>=G9Q �BFN 5 G9Q�C 5 � ��7�G�S&3�>sG9Q 7��8I�MC��XE��DIJ����DA�CK> RDS 5 �8>���N�MA=)��+�8>3C�<���RCK�8E,��G�>3C[>�<��83�IJU t )�S�C[C 5 �D7K�(M7K�3�7KG9)�9)�IJUF��GF7K�b�8IB�4�@MA�C(FA�Ev7KG9)�S�>3C : �U�> w�)OU0NTG�S�A�C�<JA&�.C 5 �@>3C�RCK�bCK7�FA�>3<BC�<JGFA�> ReS G2>�<��@S�I"RC���:h)��1��<BAQC 5 �N3�7�G�ND�8>K>6<BAkhOA�G : AQ>3C�RCK� t C 5 �@�(O�3��XN;CK�8Eu>3C�MC��Qw - C 5 �PC�7;MA�>�<BC�<JGFAI��RCK7�< O �F<JdF�8>6C 5 �$3�7KG9)�9)�<BIJ<BCcU2E�<?>cCK7�< )�S�CK<BG�AQGPQ�j A��1O�C k�>3C�MC��X> ��<Bd��DAC 5 �ZNDS�7K7��8A�CGFA��F:�>3G�E�7; : QH7�G@�r<]C R=} G : C 5 �^3�7KGOND�8>K>[<J>[<JA6FA�GMC 5 �D7[hOA�G : A2>3C�MC��7MA�ELC 5 �eCK7�FA�>3<BC�<JGFAj�,MC�7K<dOH��<Bd��8>YC 5 �t A�� : w�E�<J>3C�7K< )�S�C�<JGFAQG9Q�j A��1OOC.k >cC;RC��X>D: >�GLE�7; : QH7KG4�~<]CX: �TCKN R�� F>��8E0GFA0C 5 � 5 <J>3C�G�7�U#GPQ�C 5 �@>�<��@S�I�MC��XE 3�7KGOND�8>K>D:�NTGFA�CK7�G�I7KS�IB�X>sNFAN)��C��X>cCK�8E,MA�EPC 5 ��QHS�C�S�7K��>3C�RCK�8>�G9Q�C 5 ��N 5 M<JA�NDG4�83�F7��XE : <BC 5 GMC 5 �D7DQHS�C�S�7K��>cC;RCK�8>D)��>3�XEPG�A�E�< x �D7K�DA�C=NTGFA�CK7�G�I7KS�IB�X> R[�\S]�\S[ �2dW�va��cg�bBic��a� g M7�C�<JA&�=MIJ�|��GOE��DI : F>{MI?>3GeNTGFA�>3<?E��D7K�8E )�S�C=E�<?>�N�M7yE��8Eb>�<JA�NT�YC 5 � g F73CK<BA"�@MIJ� 3�7�G,3��873CcUZ<��$3�IB<J�8>fC 5 RC�C 5 �[�(O�3��8NTC�RCK<BG�AGPQ�C 5 ��3�7KG�NT�X>�>HRC|FA�UZCK<����<?>xC 5 ��>�*���iF>x<]C : F>x<JA@C 5 ��)��4�F<JA�A�<JA&� RT7 ANQ�FN;CX:RC 5 <J>[93&3��BM7y>fC�G^)��# 3�F73C�GPQ�C 5 �A�GFC�<JGFA�GPQ 3�7�G�NT�X>�> )��D<JA&�Vj <JA2NTG�A�C�7KGFI�k Rs\ GP<BC�>3�8��.>Y<BA�<BC�<"MIJIJU�C 5 MCi@NTGFA�CK7�G�I�7KS�IJ�(��GFA�<BC�G�7�<JA&�PC 5 �-����MA2GPQ� g M7�C�<JA&�=MIJ�+> 5 GFS�I?EA��8dF�D7�E����,FA�E|C 5 MC�NDGFA�C�7KGFIL)��0�1OO�873CK�8E R � >�<���<JI�F7�>3C�MC������8A�C�NDGFS�I?E )��^�,�E��^P)�GFS�C�C 5 � t C�<����Qw�NT7KG�>K>���>3�XN;C�<JGFA�MId1M7K<�FA�NT��GPQ C 5 �^3�7KGOND�8>K> ` F>>�GOGFAj�>Y<BC�NT�BF>��8>WC�G$)���NTG�A�>3C�MA�C t 3�7KG9)�9)�<JIB<?>cCK<JN�MIJIBUw )�S�C�>3C�M7�CK>WC�G��(O�3�FA�E t 3��87 5 P3�>[IJ<Bh�� � 7KG : A�<�FAb��GFC�<JGFAXwbNTS�7K7��8A�C \ 5 � :65 M7�CP7KS�IB�X>bG,)��c�8NTC�MA�E`E����MA�E`C 5 MC@NTG�A�CK7�G�I\)��L�(O��873CK�8E RS 5 <?>@<JE��B )�7K<BA"��>ZCKG��<BA�ELC 5 ��A�GFC�<JGFA#GPQ[MA HvP�Uh��N�FIR��8��HK�XP�HcZ R

� A0�87;��GOE�<JN�C 5 �DGF7K���<J>��CKGOGFI :65 <?N 5 C��DIJI?>C 5 �*3�7��N;CK<]CK<BG�A��D7C 5 RC+>3C�MC�<?>cCK<JN�MI03�7KG93��D7�C�<J�8>G9QH83�7KG�NT�X>�>8:�S�A�E��87+>�G4���>3C�RCK<BG�A�M7K<BCcUQ�.NTGFA�E�<]CK<BG�A : S�>�S�FIBIJUuNFA )���P3"3�7�GpO�<���RC��XE)OUvC 5 �.>cC;RC�<?>3C�<?ND>�G9Q%0>3<JA&��IB�.>�*�83�IJ�$3�RC 5 R$7 CP>��D���.>eC 5 MCNTG�A�C�7KGFI�7KS�IB�X>[M7K�6E�<JNTC�MC��8E$)OUb�87;��GOE�<JNYC 5 �DGF7K��.>8:MGF7s<JA83�M7�C�<?NTS�I�F7F)�UbC 5 �8<B7WNDGFA�C�7;P3�G�>�<BC�<JdF�8> RjS 5 MC=<J>8:9��<Bd��DA,MA��D7��FG�E�<?NC 5 �DGF7K���GFA.>�G4����>cC;RCK<J>3C�<?N���G9Q�C 5 ��3�7KG�NT�8>K>8:4F>=>�GOGFA�F>=<]CWN�MA8)���E��TCK�D7���<JA��XE : <]C 5 >3G@���6ND�D7�C�M<JA�CcUbC 5 RCsC 5 ���8>3C�<���RCK�GPQ=�8)��>3�XELG�ALC 5 �b>�*�83�IJ� 3�RC 5 <?>�E��8d�<"RCK<BA"�@C 5 �DA0<BC�<J>[CK<����ZCKG.�(O��D7�C�NTGFA�CK7�G�I R� �a�psv{1�trtuvus� o�uT�m�}����rc�@�������;�������M���No |ho xvuf��npo xwr[�po���rtnpuwo�{�n��}���po�uwxwsvo��X��xvo�{�n�uF�}svr o�n1q}�}svo��}n(xs�pn���rmsTuv�po |dxvuT{}|hxwo���r+�9o xTo�uD�m�}����r3���W�D�M�O�]����K���y�]�����M�K� o |&o xwuA��r;�}n��}n�� �y�4xv{1�t{�svsvrt����xwo�{�n �}svrT�m{�n�uwxv�}n1xTo�n xwo���r;�

Page 38: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

Z�� � ����������� ���� ���������� ����� ��� � ��� � � �� ��������! "�����#��$��%����� � $����W�'&�=<�� � 3TM4@�� / �01�3DMy/ @� 1�>1M�1����r1�B�� E*C�� 3��9E*C�� I2/ >4M}B�� 8�E$@$BTCFE�>��FIH��@��HKM�US 5 � � �UF�X>3<"MA )��8IB<J�(Q6A��DC : G�7�h t �} wZ<?> 3�G : �87mQHS�I=C�GOGFIFQHG�7�hOA�G : IB�XE��F��7K�13�7K�8>��DA�C;RC�<JGFAbMA�E&7K���>3G�A�<JA&�2S�A�E��D7@NTGFA&WE�<BC�<JGFA�>ZG9Q[S�A�NT�873C;M<JA�CcU R��} > 5 �dF�$)��D�DAaS�>��8E_>�S�NDND�8>K>tQHS�IJIJUQ<BA�Q�FS�I]CPE�<�9�FA�G�>3<?>D: E��8NT<?>�<BG�A_>�S&3&3�GF7�CfMA�E_NTI"F>K>3< c N�RC�<JGFA R� A�IB<JhF�.7KS�IJ�(W�)�F>��8Euh�A�G : IB�XE��F�8)��>3�.>�UO>3C����.>D:VC 5 � �} <?> )�F>��8E&GFA&C 5 �L>3G�IB<?E QHGFS�A�E�RC�<JGFAaG9Q 3�7KG9)�9)�<JIB<BCcUvC 5 �DGF7KUnFA�E�F7;P3 5 C 5 �8GF7KU W�<BC�N�MA@�(O�3�7K�8>K> S�A�ND�D7�C�F<BA�C�<J�8>f<JA��A�RCKS�7�FI : �U R�� A�IJ<Bh��%+A��DS�7�FI�A��DC : G�7�h : :65 <?N 5 <?>VG9QgC��8AP<JA�CK�D7�3�7K�TC��XEg�>=*;)�I��Nyh*)�GpO , :�C 5 ��A�G�E��8>W<BAj �[} M7K�+E�G4��F<BA.d1M7K<"P)�IJ�8>|FA�E�C 5 �+IJ<BA�hO>�M7K�+NFS�>�MI�NDGFA�A��XN;CK<BG�A�>G4��G�A&�ZC 5 �+d1M7K<�9)�IJ�8> RS 5 �87��1QHGF7K�F: 5 S��,FAQ�(O�3��D7�CK>eNFAuNT7K��MC��g �[} )OU 5 MA�E R�7 AvC 5 ��NF>���C 5 RCeC 5 � �} <?>�E��DdF�8IBG,3��XEKQH7KG4�~C�7;M<JA�<JA&�2E'MC��:5 S'��MA �1O�3��873Cy>PNFA`���>3<JIBU_S�A�E��D7y>cC;MA�E`<BCXFA�Eb��Mh�����GOE�< c N�RCK<BG�A�> R � �} S�>�S�FIBIJU&7K�4]�S�<J7K�8>�IJ�8>K>bCK7�F<BA�<BA&�QC 5 FA A��8S�7�FI A��TC : GF7Kh�E�G��X> R� d�<?E��8A�NT�Z> 5 G : >=C 5 RC �} >[GPQgCK�DA2GFS�C�3��87mQHG�7 �rGFC 5 �87YCKGOGFI?>YIJ<JhF��E��8NT<?>�<BG�A*C�7K�D�X>D:OA��8S�7;MI A��TC : GF7Kh�>MA�Ev>cC;RC�<?>3C�<?NMI[3�7KG9�F7;*�.><JAuNTI"F>K>�< c N�RCK<BG�A2C;F>�h�> R f G�7+�BFN 5 A�G�E��b<JAn �} :�C 5 �D7K�b<J>-MAx�>�>�G�NT<"RCK�8EV3�7KG9)�9)�<BIJ<BCcU*C�9)�IJ�C 5 RC+>;3��XNT< c �8>[C 5 � 3�7KG9)�9)�<BIJ<BCcULE�<?>cCK7�< )�S�CK<BG�A#G9QVC 5 ��d1M7K<�9)�IB�^��<Bd��DAL<BCK>e3�M7K�DA�CK> R

f G�7bC 5 �vz 5 ����(O 3�7KG9)�IJ��0: : �2N�MA|ND7��BRC��F�F7KGFS"3`GPQ �} >8:sGFA��HQHGF7����N 5 3�M7�C�<?NTS�I�F7*3 5 U�>3<?NFI 3�7�G,)�IB��� G9Q�C 5 �<JA�>cCK7�S����8A�C R � QgCK�D7����TC3CK<BA"�@C 5 ��7K��FE�<BA&��>\QH7KG4� C 5 �Z<JA�>cCK7�S����8A�C(F>[<BA"3�S�C8:���FN 5 �} : <JIJIA�F<JdF��C 5 �^3�7KG9)�P)�<JIB<BCcU�C 5 RC6C 5 �3 5 U�>3<?NFIh3�7�G,)�IB���^GON8NTS�7y> R t S 5 <J>NDG4�83�S�C;RC�<JGFA : <BIJI�C�Mh��+IJ�8>K>=C 5 MA"! R ! b >��8NDGFA�E*GFAjFAF�dF�87�9�F� . z R w S 5 �DA : �eNMA2>3�DCt FA�E c A��ZCKS�A�� wi�7KS�IJ��C 5 RC : <JIJItC�7K< �,�F�87YC 5 �fMI"M7�� :65 �8A6$3�7KG9)�P)�<JIB<BCcUj93&3��BM7y>YC�G=)��ZC�GOG 5 < � 5 RS 5 �87��uM7K��C 5 7K�D� : �U�>WCKG8�F�TC6C 5 �8>�� �} > R

b R 5V��M7KAV)�GFC 5 C 5 �b>3C�7KS�NTC�S�7K�uMA�ELC 5 � 3�M7;*���TCK�D7y> t 3�7KG9)�9)�<BIJ<BCcU.C�9)�IB�X> wYG9QfC 5 � �} >LQH7KG4� E�RC� RZ R 5V�TC 5 S'��MA#�(O�3��D7�CK>6>;3��XNT< QHU*C 5 �b>cCK7�S�NTC�S�7K�ZGPQ �} >#MA�E#E��TC��87 ��<JA��ZC 5 � 3�M7;*���TCK�D7y>\QH7KG4�~E'RC; R(&R 5V�TC 5 S'��MA#�(O�3��D7�CK>6>;3��XNT< QHU6)�GMC 5 C 5 �b>cCK7�S�N;C�S�7��uMA�ELC 5 � 3�F7�4���DC��87K>[GPQfC 5 � �} > R� F>��8EPGFA�C 5 �6<JA�QHG�7 ��RCK<BG�A*QH7KG4� C 5 � : GF7Kh�> 5 G,3 : : �N�MA$3�7KG9)�9)�IBU@NTGFA�>cCK7�S�NTC�C 5 � �} >D)OU 5 MA�E :M< R � R :MC 5 ��E�<"P��A�G�>3C�<?Nt 3�7�G,)�IB��� w�A�G�E���<?>�C 5 �$3�M7K�DA�CZGPQ�FIBI��8IB�����8A�CK> R f G�7��1O04�83�IB��:t<BA&C 5 �N3�G : �87 Q�M<JIBS�7K� �} : C 5 �83�G : �87e>�S&3&3�IJUvA�G�E���<J>

C 5 ��3�F7��8A�CYGPQ�FIBI��DIJ����8A�Cy>iMA�E�C 5 �e�DIJ����DA�CK>%M7K�+<JA�E��43��8A�E��8A�C��F<JdF�8A.C 5 ��>3C�RCKS�>[GPQtC 5 ��3�G : �D7Y>�S&3&3�IBU R f GF7WC 5 � 3�G : �87>�S&3&3�IJUvA�G�E��F:�C 5 �N3�7�G,)�P)�<JIJ<]CcU^��< � 5 C )�� . t Q�F<BIJS�7K� w � ! R ! � : . t A�GF7��,FI w � ! R # � R f G�7-FAu�DIJ����8A�CZA�G�E���:�C 5 �$3�7�G,)�P)�<BIJ<]CcU��< � 5 Ce)�� `, t%$'&)(+* ,-(.& 10/�132547698;: w � !� Z, t<$ Z &)(+* ,-( Z & 1 �>= &@?.* ,A? $'& 1B/�1C2D47698;: w � !B� (, tE* ,F(G$ ( &.H 8 *�,A? ( & 1I/�1C254J6�8;: w � !� �

, t%$'&)(+* ,-()& 1 � H 8LK1M4 w � !� �, t%$ Z &N( * ,A( Z & 1 �>= &O?P*�,A?Q$'& 1 � H 8LK"1M4 w � !� b �, t7* ,R(G$ ( &.H 8 *�,A? ( & 1 � H 8LK1M4 w � !� ! �

t \ C�7K<JNTC�IJUu>m3���FhO<BA&��:tC 5 <J> : �UvGPQNTG�A�>cCK7�S�N;C�<JA&� �} >u�>�>�S'���8>eC 5 RC����N 5 3�7�G,)�IB���wG�NDNDS�7K>e<JA�E��43��8A�E��DA�CKIBUmMA�E&C 5 �3�7KG9)�IJ��.>xE�G+A�GMCfG�N8NTS�7HRCfC 5 �> 4���sC�<���� RT7 Q�C 5 �iF>K>�S'�83�C�<JGFAb<?>fS�A�FN8NT�43�C�9)�IB��: : �YA��D�XEg���G�7��WNDG4�83�IJ�(O �} >3C�7KS�NTC�S�7K�<JA�>cCK���ELG9QH$�F7KGFS"32G9Qx>�<��83�IJ� �} > R w7 Q�>�S�N 5 3�7KG9)�P)�<JIB<BCcUaE�<J>3C�7K< )�S�C�<JGFA�>�N�MA�A�GMCN)��V�F<JdF�DAV:=E'RC;uNTG�IBIJ�8NTC�<JGFArFA�E �1O�3��87�<����DA�CK> : <BIJI�)��#A��XNT�8>K>�M7KU R S 5 �E'MC�QN�MA )��2NTG�IBIJ�8NTC��XE_C 5 7KGFS&� 5 �Dd��D7KUOE��UQG93��D7;RCK<BG�A�)OU_7��XNTG�7KE�<JA&�0C 5 �L7K���E�<BA"��>�G9Q[C 5 �LA�GF7��,FIWNTG�A�E�<BC�<JGFA FA�EaC 5 �7K��FE�<BA&��> :65 �8AL>3G@���TC 5 <BA&�@<J> : 7KGFA&� R t S 5 ��E�<"P��A�G�>3C�<?N67K�8>�S�I]Cy>Y> 5 G�S�IJE�FIJ>�G )��+7K�8NDGF7yE��8E R w � I]CK�D7KA�RCK<Bd��DIJUF:�C 5 �eE'RC;bNFA)��bNTGFIJIJ�8N;CK�8Ea)OU2E�G�<BA&���1O 3��D7K<����8A�CK>LWWNT7K��MC��u$3 5 U�>3<?NFI03�7�G,)�IJ�� <JA�C��DA�CK<BG�A�MIJIBUFMA�E27��XNTG�7KE*C 5 ��7K���E�<BA"��> R�=<<S 5 I=>}BFM!7 / C\My/ B�1 8 EN@$BDCFE0> 8;:2/ CTB�3z 5 �����1OH3�7KGRd�<?E��XE*E'RC;@NDGFA�C�F<BA�<BA&� b ! # j <JA�W�NTG�A�CK7�G�ISkOE'MC�N3�G�<BA�CK> t C 5 MC[<?>D:�>�*�83�IJ�t���BF>�S�7������DA�CK> :65 <?N 5 P3"3��BM7K�8E�CKG)�� : <BC 5 <JAPNTG�A�C�7KGFIMIJ<���<BCK>{F>fE��TCK�D7���<JA��XE )OU�z 5 �����(O k >fNTS�7K7K�DA�CV7KS�IB�X> wT:��8>3C�<��,MC��X> GPQ&3�G93�S�I�MC�<JGFAu����FAbNTG�A�NT�8A�CK7�MC�<JGFA�> GPQC 5 ��d1M7K<BG�S�>s>3S")�>cC;MA�ND�8>sG9Q�<JA�C��87��X>cC :65 �DA�C 5 � 3�7�G�ND�8>K>s<J>=G93��D7;RC�<JA&� : <BC 5 <JA*A�MC�S�7;MI�d1M7K<"RC�<JGFAV:@MA�E ( Y � j GFS�C;WpG9QzW NDGFA�C�7KGFI�k>�*�83�IJ�8> t C 5 RC=<?>D:4���BF>�S�7K����DA�CK> :65 <?N 5 <BA�NDIBS�E��8E$)�GMC 5 <JA�W NDGFA�C�7KGFI0FA�EPG�S�CmW GPQzW�NTG�A�C�7KGFI 3�G�<BA�CK>[�>T3��87Yz 5 ����(O k >sNTS�7K7K�DA�C7KS�IB�X> w RD7 C> 5 GFS�IJE=)��eA�GMCK�8E�C 5 RC��FGOG�Et:�d�FIB<?ELE�RC�@NTG�IBIJ�8NTC�<JGFA :�MIBC 5 G�S&� 5 A�GMCYC 5 ��QHG�NTS�>YGPQ C 5 <?>W7K�13�GF7�C8:O<?>�FA�GMC 5 �D7Y<J>K>3S��

Page 39: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

�"��" �� ������Q "�����#����� ����� ��� � � � ������� & Z #:65 <?N 5 > 5 GFS�IJE )���FE�E�7��X>�>��8E)��1QHGF7K�P<��$3�IB�����8A�C�<JA&�IMAOUvNTGFA�CK7�G�IVCKG�G�I R S 5 ��E�RC�63�7KGRd�<?E��XE )OU&z 5 ����(O : �D7K��S�>3�XEQ<JAGF7yE��87PCKGb�>�>��8>K>PC : Gm�PS�IBC�<Jd1M7K<�MC��^MI �FG�7�<BC 5 �.>8: :65 <?N 5 F7��0E�<?>�NDS�>K>3�XE <JA|C 5 �VQHGFIJIBG : <JA&�&C : Ga>3S")�>3�XN;CK<BG�A�> R S 5 � c A�MI>�S&)�>��8N;CK<BG�AvGFA^�PS�I]CK<JE�<����DA�>�<JGFA�FI \ 5 � :65 M7�C�NDGFA�C�7KGFI N 5 F73Cy>6�(O�3�IJGF7K�8>6C 5 �f��MC 5 ���,MC�<?NFIj�F�8A��D7;MIJ< u�RCK<BG�A2G9QsS�A�<Jd�F7�<"RCK�NTG�A�C�7KGFIs7KS�IB�X>ZC�GQC 5 ���@S�I]CK<JE�<����DA�>3<JGFA�FIYN�F>�� RaS 5 �.S�>3�LGPQ[C : GvG�7f��GF7K��G9QC 5 �.CKGOGFI?> 3�7K�8>��DA�C��XE&<JA_C 5 <?>P>��8NTC�<JGFA`NFA3�GMC��8A�C�<"MIJIBU 3�7KGRdO<JE��jQd��D7KUa>3C�7KGFA"��:D3�7;FN;CK<JN�MIYC�GOGFILQHG�7N)�GMC 5 3�<JA&3�GF<JA�CK<BA"� :65 �8AsFA�E F>K>��8>K>3<JA&� :65 U_C 5 �K3�7KG�NT�X>�>PGPQ<JA�CK�D7K�8>3C�P3&3���F7K>[CKG$)���GFS�C�GPQxNDGFA�C�7KGFI R[�\���\�^ ��bBi�`�g ic����s���d� � dL`�o%`�a��`�� s� 6�ci��� P�@R H����S 5 �.h��DU_<JE��B0GPQ�3�7K<BA�NT< 3�IB�2NTG4�83�GFA��8A�CK>�<?>PE�<����DA�>�<JGFA`7K�8E�S�NTC�<JGFA RQ{ S�7 ��G@FI=<J>bC�Gv7K�8E�S�NT�.C 5 �LE�<����DA�>�<BG�A`GPQC 5 �3�7KG9)�IJ�� C�G=)��b>8��MIJIJ�D7[C 5 FA b�� : : <BC 5 �8A�GFS&� 5 �1O�3�I�FA�RCK<BG�ALG9Qxd1M7K<"P)�<JIB<BCcU RS 5 ��NTG�7�7K�DI"RCK<BG�Aj��RCK7�< OLG9QVC 5 ��<BA�W�NTG�A�C�7KGFItE'RC; : �>[S�>3�XE2C�G.NF7�7KU.GFS�C6C 5 � 3�7K<BA�NT< 3�MI NDG4�83�G�A��DA�Cy>#MA�FIBU�>�<J> RS 5 � c 7y>cC � �8< ���DAOdF�XN;C�G�7K> : �D7K�ZN 5 G�>��DA : :65 <?N 5 �(O�3�I"M<JA69)�G�S�C �,��� GPQfC 5 ��d1M7K<"RC�<JGFA Rb R � ��RCK7�< O � NTG�A�>�<J>3C�<JA&�bG9QtC 5 ���D< �F�DAOd��8N;CKGF7y> 6 )Q� 6�� �.�����%� 6 � : F>FQHG�7 ���XE R � IJ>�G�:���� � � ��� : �>=G9)�C�M<JA��XEt: :65 �D7K�5a<J>tMA � | � E�<"P��GFA�FI��,MC�7K<dOvNTG�A�>�<J>3C�<JA&�.GPQ�C 5 �b�D< �F�8AOd�FIBS��8> 4 )�� 4�� �.���.� � 4 � G9Q \0RhS 5 � 3�7�<JA�NT< 3�IJ�PNTG@�83�G�A��DA�CK>�GPQO2NFAa)��^QHGF7����8EV)OU.C 5 �^QHG�IBIJG : <JA&�PCK7�FA�>mQHGF7��,MC�<JGFA `

� � � � t� $"! w t ("R b wZ R�/ ��S�>��PC 5 �=#�GMCK�DIJIB<JA&� � � QHGF7�C 5 � t � E�<����DA�>�<BG�A�MI w 3�7�<JA�ND< 3�FIsNTG4�83�GFA��8A�CK>�C�G0E��TCK�D7���<BA�� :65 �DC 5 �87e�BFN 5 G9)�>��D7;W

d�MC�<JGFAv<?>+G�S�C+G9QWNTGFA�CK7�G�I R�7 QG=3�M7�C�<?NTS�I"M7�G,)�>��D7Kd�MC�<JGFA0<?>+G�S�C�G9QsNDGFA�C�7KGFIp: : �P> 5 GFS�IJE )���9)�IJ��C�G#N 5 �8Nyh :65 <?N 5 GPQC 5 � � . 7K<JA�NT< 3�MIYzYG@�83�G�A��DA�CK>�N�MS�>��8EuC 5 �=3�7�G,)�IJ�� <JA�QHS�7�C 5 �87fMA�FIBU�>�<J> R8/ ��F7���A�G : 7��BFE�UvCKGQNFIJNDS�I�MC���C 5 �#�GMCK�DIJIB<JA&� � � RP� �1QHGF7K�@E�G�<BA&�2C 5 <J>8: C 5 �83�7K<JA�NT< 3�IJ��NDG4�83�G�A��DA�Cy> : �D7K�@7K�4]�S�<J7K�8E0CKGa)��.>�N�MIJ�8E R S 5 �NQHGF7��PS�I�LS�>3�XEQHGF7�>KNMIJ<JA&�PC 5 � 3�7K<BA�NT< 3�IB�bNDG4�83�GFA��8A�Cy><J>

#%$ � 6 $& t 4 $ w t ("R Z w>3S�N 5 C 5 RC(�>�N�MIJ�8EF��RC�7K< O : / : F>LQHGF7����8E6MA�E

' � ' �(�%) ) t ("R ( wS 5 � #�GMCK�DIJIB<JA&� � � <?>6E�� c A��8E^F>

� � � � � ��) ) � t ("R YcwS 5 � b ! # d1FIBS��X>6GPQ � � : �D7K�ZG9)�C;M<JA��8EaQH7KG4� C 5 �b<JA�W�NTGFA�CK7�G�I E'RC; R S 5 � # �*� ]�S�MA�C�<JIB��G9QfC 5 �PE�<?>3C�7K< )�S�C�<JGFA0GPQ�C 5 �� � >cC;RC�<?>3C�<?NeN�MAV)����BF>�<BIJU=QHG�S�A�Et:�>�<JA�NT�,+

� �.-./ t � $ b wt � $ / w103254 � ) 2 t ("R � w7 A2C 5 <?>��(O'4�$3�IB��: / � � �6��� b ! # :�MA�E76 � � ! � � 0 � 4 )�8 + 4 8�9 8 + � Z � ! ( b Y�>�G �;: )<8 + ) )>=: )<8 + ) � = 0 � 4 )�8 + 4 8;9 8 + � b � ( F YB��?�@�@xGPQC 5 � b ! # G9)�>��D7KdF�XE � � d1MIJS��X> : �87��^��7��BRC��87[C 5 FA0C 5 <?>6d1MIJS��F:�<BA�E�<JN�RC�<JA&��83�7KG9)�IB��� �D<BC 5 �87�<JA2C 5 �PE'MC��GF76<JA0C 5 �P3&3�IJ<?NRCK<BG�A*GPQtC 5 �-���DC 5 G�E�G�IBG,�FU R � >YC 5 � 3�7KG9)�IJ�� : F> QHS�73C 5 �D7L3�GFA�E��87��XEt:�C 5 �ZE�<BA*NTS�IBCcU.GPQ <JA�C��D7�3�7K�TC;RC�<JGFA : �>E�<J>KNTS�>�>��8Et:t>�<BA�NT�@C 5 ��<BA�E�<BdO<?E�S�FIs�DA�C�7K<B�X>+G9Q=C 5 ����M<JA�3�7�<JA�ND< 3�FIxNDG4�83�GFA��8A�Cy> : �87���>3<���<BI"M7 R S 5 <?>7���DC 5 G�E : �>C 5 �87��1QHGF7K�+E�<?>�N�M7yE��8E��>YC 5 � )��X>cC#P3"3�7�G=FN 5 C 5 <J>L3�7KG9)�IB���#:0FA�EjFA�GMC 5 �D7iP3&3�7�G=FN 58: �>YNDGFA�>�<?E��D7K�8Et:0�> 3�7K�8>��DA�CK�8E<BA2C 5 �^QHG�IBIJG : <JA&�.>3S&)�>3�XN;C�<JGFA R

C �Tuvu �p�6��xwo�{�npuA{}|&�[�p� xwo q��}swo���xvrTnp{�sv�e�}��o xzy �}n���o�n��prc�Prtn��prtnp�tr �Pr�x�D0rtrtn^u��}�6����rmuA�Y�puwxA�PrF���prt�FE�rc� �}n�� q(rtsvo ��rc���

Page 40: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

( ! � ����������� ���� ���������� ����� ��� � ��� � � �� ��������! "�����#��$��%����� � $����W�'&[�\���\S] �ndL`�� e�o%`�g�o���o��Li#dL` � `�e���i>� f�s�a � `�o�d�f+���dLf�`�e+�LA��=?�@BCI@RvFI�� @M�N�O Z)Z)@BM A�HcC��=UhHcZ'JL�

\ <JA�NT�@C 5 ��E�<����DA�>3<JGFA_GPQ=C 5 �83�7KG9)�IJ��wNDGFS�I?EuA�GMC^)���7K�8E�S�ND�8Eu� A*NT<J�DA�C�IJUvC 5 7�G�S&� 5 3�7K<BA�ND< 3�MIsNTG@�$3�GFA��DA�C7FA�MIJU�>3<?>8:QHS�7�C 5 �87(MA�MIJUO>��8> : �D7K�eE�GFA�� : <BC 5 C 5 � b�� N 5 M7;FNTC��D7K<?>cCK<JN8>D:OS�>�<BA"�*zYG�A c E��8A�NT� 2 �4�F<JGFA�>#FA�E \ <��@S�IBC�MA��DGFS�> � GFS�A�E�> R )�87 A.GF7yE��87=C�G@NTG4�83�F7���C 5 �-F>K>3�X>�> ���DA�C=GPQ :65 <?N 5 3�GF<JA�Cy>�F7���NDI��>�>�< c �8E��>=<JA�W NDGFA�C�7KGFIh)OU.z 5 �����(O k >YNTS�7K7K�DA�CW7KS�IB�X>GFA�EC 5 �8#+GMCK�DIJIB<JA&�^�PS�IBC�<Jd1M7K<�MC��,P3&3�7�G=FN 5 NDGFA�>�<JE��D7K�8E 5 �87���:j#�GFC��8IBIJ<BA"�Bk > � � QHG�7�C 5 ��GF7K< ��<BA�MI t b�� W E�<����DA�>3<JGFA�FI w�E'MC� : �>NFIJNDS�I"RC��XENQHGF7=�BFN 5 GPQ C 5 � b ! # z 5 ����(O�<BA&W NDGFA�C�7KGFI�>�*�83�IJ�8>8:FS�>�<JA&�ZC 5 �t����MA�>|MA�E�NDGRd�F7�<"MA�NT�i��RC�7K< O*QH7KG4��C 5 <?>WE'MC� R

� � � t�� $�� w � � ) ) t�� $�� wS 5 �ZS&3&3��D7�NTGFA�CK7�G�I�IJ<���<BC+<?>

�� ) - � Z � � Z # � �

S 5 �ZIJG : �87NDGFA�C�7KGFI IJ<���<BC+<?> ! R

0 20 40 60 80 100

1020

3040

50 Upper Limit

f < ��S�7K� ("R b `�� � <BA�W�NTG�A�C�7KGFItE'RC;� >�>��D�8A&G�A f < �FS�7�� (&R b :��,FAOU3�G�<BA�Cy> Q�MIJI=GFS�Cy>3<?E���GPQ[C 5 �.IB<���<]Cy> RHS 5 <?>Z<?>bE�S���CKG2C 5 �8Q�FNTC�C 5 MC@z 5 ����(O_S�>��8Em

E�< x��87��8A�C����DC 5 G�EaQHGF7�E��TC��87 ��<JA�<JA&��<BA�W�NTG�A�C�7KGFIt> 4�83�IB�X> R#�GFC��8IBIJ<BA"�Bk > � � : F>,FIJ>�G_N�MI?NTS�I"RCK�8E QHGF7.�BFN 5 G9Q+C 5 �vGFS�C;WpG9QzW NDGFA�C�7KGFI>�*�83�IJ�8>8:WS�>�<BA"�&C 5 �^����MAdMA�E NDGRd�F7�<"MA�NT���RCK7�< Oj���DA�C�<JGFA��8E^P)�GRdF��QH7�G@�rC 5 ��<BA�W�NTG�A�C�7KGFItE'RC; R\S 5 �ZS&3"3��87(MA�E2IJG : �87[IJ<���<BCK>tM7K�+C 5 �b>�*���uF>�)��(QHGF7K� R� >6>��D�8A0GFA f < �FS�7�� (&R Z :0��FA�U2> 4�$3�IB�X>LQ�MIJItGFS�Cy>3<?E��ZC 5 ��IB<���<]C R� CxC 5 <?>D3�G�<BA�CX: : � : GFS�I?EbIJ<JhF�YC�G )��#P)�IB�[C�GZE��DC��D7���<BA��YC 5 �6NFS�>3� t 3�M7�C�<?NTS�I"M7x�DIJ����DA�C[�����>3S�7K����8A�Cy> wfNTG�A�C�7K< )�S�C�<JA&�

C�GPC 5 ��3�7KGOND�8>K>FQ�FIBIJ<BA"�bGFS�Cy>3<?E��eNTGFA�CK7�G�I�IJ<���<BCK>8:�< QtC 5 � 3�7KG�NT�8>K>\3�M7;*���TCK�D7y> 5 �dF�tFN;CKS�MIJIJU�> 5 < QgC��8E R S 5 <J> : GFS�I?E8)��eE�GFA��QHGF76�BFN 5 3�G�<BA�C�Q�FIBIJ<BA"��G�S�CK>�<?E��eC 5 �bNDGFA�C�7KGFItIJ<���<BCK> R7 A_GF7yE��D7ZCKG#<JIJIBS�>3C�7;RCK��C 5 �.7K�8>3C�GPQ[C 5 ��FA�MIJU�>3<?>8:V> 4�83�IB� b �a: F>�N 5 G�>��DAbF>uMA_�(O'4�$3�IB� RHS 5 � � � d1MIJS��8QHGF7ZC 5 <J>>�*�83�IJ�[<?>[P3"3�7�GpO�<���RC��8IBU � !�: :65 <?N 5 <?>D�F7K��MC��87VC 5 MA Z � R Z # � : :65 <?N 5 ���BMA�>xC 5 RC|�3�7KG9)�IJ��¥��< � 5 Cs�(O�<?>cCs<JAPC 5 <J>s>�*�83�IJ�F:>�Gu>3<��PS�I]C;MA��8GFS�> )�GFS�A�E�>*QHGF7P�BFN 5 N 5 F7��N;C��87�<?>3C�<?N : �87��*N�MI?NTS�I"RCK�8E RS 5 �X>3�FM7K�H)�F>��8E_G�A � GFA�QH�87�7KGFA�< \ <��@S�IBC�MA��DGFS�>zYGFA c E��DA�NT� 7 A�C��87�d1FIJ>8:�MA�E 5 �dF�uMAvGRd��D7;MIJI NTG�A c E��8A�NT��IJ�Dd��DIVG9Q|P)�GFS�C b ! ! t b W<6�w � 3�7KGRdO<JE��8E^F>K>3G�ND<�MC��8E^�>�>�S'�83�C�<JGFA�>M7K�7���TC R t #��87���: / <J>[C 5 �bE�<����8A�>�<BG�A#G9QfC 5 �^3�7KG9)�IJ��0:�<JA#C 5 <?>6N�>3��: b�� ��wk�� �Tuvu �p�6��xwo�{�npuA{}|&�[�p� xwo q��}swo���xvrTnp{�sv�e�}��o xzy �}n���o�n��prc�Prtn��prtnp�tr �Pr�x�D0rtrtn^u��}�6����rmuA�Y�puwxA�PrF���prt�FE�rc� �}n�� q(rtsvo ��rc���

Page 41: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

�"��" �� ������Q "�����#����� ����� ��� � � � ������� & ( b

0 100 200 300

020

040

060

080

0

Upper Limit

f < ��S�7�� ("R Z `�� � G�S�CmW�NTG�A�C�7KGFItE'RC;

� $���������� $ 2 � b � � � � � b,�

� C�9)�IB��<?>�3�7K�8>��DA�CK�8EL> 5 G : <JA&��C 5 � \ <BIJdF�87 t � �cwiMA�E g FA&�@FA��8>�� t g AXw6N 5 M7;FN;CK�D7K<J>3C�<?ND>YS�>�<BA"� 6 � !B� ! � Rz 5 M7;FNTC��87�<?>cCK<JN � 3&3��D7�IJ<���<BC 5VG : �87[IJ<���<BC { )�>3�87�d1MC�<JGFA� � � R ��� Z R # Z,Z � R �g A b : ! # �P� b : ! Z !f < ��S�7K� ("R ( MA�E f < �FS�7K� (&R YXF7��eC 5 � �F7;P3 5 > QHG�7 \ <JIBd��D7�MA�E g MA&�=MA��X>3� RS 5 ��d1FIBS�� QHGF7 \ <BIJdF�87FQ�MIJI?>WG�S�CK>�<JE���GPQtC 5 �+IJ<���<BCK>8:�>3G : ��N�MA*>��UbC 5 RC% 3�7�G,)�IJ�� ��< � 5 C[�(O�<J>3CW<JA.C 5 <J>[N 5 M7;FNTC��87�<?>cCK<JN RS 5 �.d1MIJS��=QHG�7 g MA"�@MA��8>���E�G��X>�A�GFC Q�MIJI=GFS�CK>�<JE��.G9QYC 5 �*IJ<���<BCK>8: :65 <JN 5 ����FA�>eC 5 �D7K�*<J>bA�GQ>3< �FA�MIDQHGF7@> �UO<JA&�#C 5 MCg3�7KG9)�IJ����(O�<J>3CK><JA#C 5 <?>�N 5 F7��N;CK�D7K<J>3C�<?N RS 5 �X>3�fFA�MIJU�>3�X>�NFAV)��@E�GFA�� : <BC 5 �BFN 5 >�*�83�IJ�gF>K>3G�ND<�MC��8E : <BC 5 =3�GF<JA�CeQ�MIJIJ<BA&�.G�S�CK>�<?E���C 5 �@NTG�A�C�7KGFItIJ<���<BCK>8:QFA�E

���N 5 N 5 M7;FN;CK�D7K<J>3C�<?NM: :65 <JIB�u��F<BA�C�F<BA�<BA&��C 5 ��GRdF�87�FIBItNTG�A c E��8A�NT�ZIJ�Dd��DIXQHGF76�BFN 5 3�G�<BA�C R[�\���\S[ p�f�s�ai�e�i>� o%`��ci#dL`1��s ��m�o m���b"a(��dL`�a"bdLs �nm���b"a��� H .HcCIFSM ��A�M�UhFIR � O�CSCI@��=A� ���.F���@BM�N�T�M�N�P�HKHc@nTVZ)@PQFSHcFS 5 <?>=A�GFC���<J>Y<BA�>m3�<J7K�8E=)OU@C 5 ��Q�FNTCWC 5 RC \ 5 � :65 F73CNTG�A�CK7�G�I�N 5 F73Cy> : GF7Kh : �DIJI�<JA.C 5 ��S�A�<Bd1M7K<"RC�� t GFA���N 5 F7��N;C��87�<?>3C�<?N.wN�>3� R S 5 ���yx �8NTC�<JdF�DA��8>K>�G9Q \ 5 � :65 M7�C.k >e<JE���2<BA&UF��F7K>�GPQ 3�7��N;CK<JND�XFA�EQ<BCK> : �DIJIsE�� c A��8EnFA�E_>3<��83�IB��NTG�A�>3C�7;M<JA�Cy> ��<Bd��MA�GMC 5 �D7[7��BF>�GFA8QHGF7[C 5 <J>[�1OO�87KND<J>�� R � I?>�G�:0g��GFC�<JdF��QHGF7YC 5 <?>[A�GMCK��<?>YC 5 MC[G�A��eN�MA2��F>�<JIBU�<��,9�F<JA��t�>�<]CKS�RCK<BG�A*C 5 RC<dQ�FA<JA�>cCK7�S����8A�C=C 5 MCG�����>3S�7K�8> � N 5 F7��N;CK�D7K<J>3C�<?ND>s>�<��@S�IBC�MA��DGFS�>3IJU Q�M<JI?>D:�C 5 �8A.<]CY7�F7��8IBUPE�G��X>W>�G^QHGF7=G�A�IJU@G�A���N 5 M7;FNTC��87�<?>cCK<JN R

{ dF�87*C 5 �&U���F7K>8:C 5 �m��GF7K�u7KS�IJ�8>6QHGF70GFS�C;WpG9QzW NDGFA�C�7KGFI�E��TCK�8N;CK<BG�A 5 �d�� )��D�8A <��$3�IB�����8A�C��8E <BA�MA�FIBUcu8<BA&� NTGFA�CK7�G�IN 5 F73Cy> R f G�76�(O'*�83�IJ�F:�<JAIFE�E�<]CK<BG�ALCKG�C 5 �bE��XNT<?>3<JGFA#7KS�IB�^)��>3�XELG�AIN3�GF<JA�C�Q�MIJIB<JA&��GFS�CK>�<JE��eC 5 � ( W�>3< �4���NTG�A�CK7�G�ItIB<���<]Cy>D:C 5 �*QHG�IBIJG : <BA"�L7KS�IB�X>7M7K�PS�>��8EQHGF7eS�A�<Jd�F7�<"RCK�@NDGFA�C�7KGFI�N 5 M7�CK>�<JAn��MAOUv<JA�E�S�>3C�7K<�FIx>��TC�C�<JA&��>�CKG6FIB�873C�C 5 ��G93��D7;RCKGF7+C 5 MCC 5 �b>3U�>3C��� P3&3���F7K>[CKG$)���G93��D7;RCK<BA"��<JAIMA#GFS�C;WpG9QzW NDGFA�C�7KGFI >3C�RCK� ` >3S�NDNT�X>�>�<JdF� 3�G�<BA�CK>S"3#G�7�E�G : AZ >3S�NDNT�X>�>�<JdF� 3�G�<BA�CK>G�S�CK>�<?E��ZC 5 � Z W >�< �4��@NDGFA�C�7KGFI IJ<���<BCK>Y.>3S�NDNT�X>�>�<JdF� 3�G�<BA�CK>G�S�CK>�<?E��ZC 5 � b W >�< �4��@NDGFA�C�7KGFI IJ<���<BCK>S 5 �7��RC 5 ���RCK<JN�MIXQHG�7 �@S�I�MC�<JGFAaQHGF76�1O�CK�DA�E�<BA&��C 5 �8>��Z7�S�IB�X>[C�G�C 5 �u�PS�IBC�<Jd1M7K<�MC���>3<BC�S�RC�<JGFAaQHGFIJIJG : > R

Page 42: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

( Z � ����������� ���� ���������� ����� ��� � ��� � � �� ��������! "�����#��$��%����� � $����W�'&

0 100 200 300

46

810

Lower Limit

Upper Limit

Mean

f < ��S�7�� ("R ("`s\ <BIJdF�87

0 100 200 300

850

900

950

1000

1050 Upper Limit

Mean

f < �FS�7K� (&R Y ` g MA"�@MA��8>��

Page 43: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

�"��" �� ������Q "�����#����� ����� ��� � � � ������� & (v(5 �DC K ��� $ � R 5 �DC8:�QHG�7 2W$�� b ��(�� : t 1 : $ =) � �.��� � 1 : $ =� w $�� � )��b>3S�N 5 C 5 RC

t��� $� b ����� w ! ( 1 : )>=� ( 1 : � =� ( 1 :� =� �f G�7C 5 � 3�GFIJU 5 �8E�7��E�� c A��8EV)OU

, $ ��� t� )Q� ����� � � w ` 1 � 1�� 1 : $ =��� � 2=$� b ��(��: � 5 �dF�eC 5 MC,�)�� , � � , �

\ S&3"3�G�>3�eC 5 RC(NQHS�A�NTC�<JGFA/ ` � b � K �h~ � �

<?>��F<JdF�DA^MA�E2IJ�TC�S�> : 7�<BC��/ t 4 w � t� :�� =) � ����� � :�� =� w �

� I?>�G�: QHGF7 4x$� b � K �� � ��� � $� b �����A` 1 :�� =� 1 ? 1 : � =� �MA�E� � ��� � $�� b �3���j` 1 :�� =� 1 ? 1 : )�=� � �

} GFC��ZC 5 RC� � � � � �5 �DC��6)��ZC 5 �u�,PO�<��@S'� GPQ[MIJI � $�� b � K � >�S�N 5 C 5 MC

t�� 2=$�� b � � � w / t 2 w $ , t C 5 <?>P<?>fMA�MIJG9�FG�S�>eC�GQC 5 �*S�A�<Bd1F7�<"RCK�*7�S�IB�.G9Q b 3�G�<BA�CPG�S�CK>�<JE��.C 5 � ( W�>3< �4��0NTG�A�CK7�G�I=IJ<���<BCK> wfMA�E : <BC 5 C 5 �=QHG�IBIJG : <JA&�C 5 7��8� 3�7�G,3��873CK<B�X> Rb R f GF7�FIBI 2Y$�� � � � :

t�� 4x$� 2 $ � � 2 $ b � w ��<JA2�� ) 4 �"!

t 1 : )>=2 $ :�� =2 w � ��<JA2�� ) 4 �"!

t 1 : )>=2 $ :���# )>=2 w �t C 5 <J>6<?>#MA�MIJG9�FG�S�>YC�G�C 5 ��S�A�<Jd�F7�<"RCK�Z7�S�IJ�ZGPQ >3S�N8NT�X>�>�<Bd���3�GF<JA�CK>6S"3#G�76E�G : AXwZ R f GF7�FIBI 2Y$�� Z � � � :

� / t 2 w � / t 2 $ b w � � , �$ , �&% � $(' � $ ) )��*) �t C 5 <J>6<?>#MA�MIJG9�FG�S�>YC�G�C 5 ��S�A�<Jd�F7�<"RCK�Z7�S�IJ�ZGPQ Z >3S�N8NT�X>�>�<Bd���3�GF<JA�CK>6G�S�CK>�<?E��eC 5 � Z W >�< �@��@NDGFA�C�7KGFI IJ<���<BCK> w

("R f GF7�FIBI 2Y$�� Y � � � :� / t 2 $ / w ` / $�� ! ��(�� � � , $ , ) % ' ��+ 8 � $ ) � �,) �

t C 5 <J>6<?>#MA�MIJG9�FG�S�>YC�G�C 5 ��S�A�<Jd�F7�<"RCK�Z7�S�IJ�ZGPQDY.>3S�N8NT�X>�>�<Bd���3�GF<JA�CK>6G�S�CK>�<?E��eC 5 � b W >�< �@��@NDGFA�C�7KGFI IJ<���<BCK> w7 Q-� � K : : �uM7K��E�GFA�� R{ C 5 �D7 : <J>��F:�E�G.C 5 ��FER�cS�>cC����DA�C8: < R � R :hQHGF7�� .A�� : QHS�A�N;C�<JGFAV: N�MIJIV<BC / 9�@M<JA :�>3G.C 5 RCX:"QHG�7 2.� � : / t 2 w<J>+C 5 �@>�*���F>�)��(QHG�7��uFA�E2C 5 MC / t � - b w $ , ) : <BC 5

��<BA2"� ) 4 �"!

t 1 : )>=2 $ :0/ =2 w � ��<BA2"� ) 4 �"!

t 1 : )>=2 $ :0/1# )>=2 w �zYGFA�CK<BAOS��eC�<JIJI2� � K R{ C 5 �D76S�A�<Jd1M7K<�MC���NTG�A�C�7KGFI 7�S�IB�X>i�,�U6)��b>�<���<JI�F7�IJU=�F�8A��D7;MIJ< uD�8E R

Page 44: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

( Y � ����������� ���� ���������� ����� ��� � ��� � � �� ��������! "�����#��$��%����� � $����W�'&�=<�� � My3TJeI23�3DM(E$@S 5 �L3�7KG9)�IJ�� 3�G�>��8E )OUPz 5 �����1ObI�9)�G�7�MC�G�7�<J�8>fNMA*)��iRC�C�FNyh��8E�<JA�+d1M7K<B�DCcUeG9Q : �UO> RA7 AXMIJI�C 5 �%��G�E��8IJ>xNTG�A�>�<JE��87��XEt:�C 5 �NTG@�,��G�A�P3&3�7�G=FN 5 <J>WC�G�E�� c A��tu��G�E��8I :0MA�E*E�<?>�NDS�>�>W<]Cy>Y>�S�<BC�9)�<BIJ<BCcU@CKG�C 5 ��z 5 �����(O83�7�G,)�IJ�� RFS 5 �+A��1OOC[>3C��13L<J>WC 5 �8AC�G.E��DC��87 ��<JA��-�>�S�<BC�P)�IB�7�����>3S�7K�+G�A :65 <JN 5 C�G8)�F>��7�E��8NT<?>�<BG�ALGFA :65 �TC 5 �D76G�7A�GMCC�G�7K�8NFIB< )�7;RCK� R � ���BF>�S�7�� :65 <?N 5<?>�GPQgCK�DA`S�>��8Ea<JAb�PS�IBC�< 3�IJ�(W�NTG4�83�GFA��8A�C@>3U�>3C�����>gMA�E :65 <?N 5a5 F>�A�GMC*)��D�8AaC�GFS�N 5 �8E_S&3�GFA 5 �87��.<?>+j E��(QH�XN;Cy> 3��D7bS�A�<]C k RS 5 <?> 5 �>xC 5 �6A�<?NT��3�7KG93��D7�CcUbG9Q�edF�87�U�A�RC�S�7�FI�E�<����8A�>3<JGFA�7K�8E�S�N;C�<JGFAV:P)�S�C|���UbA�GFC\)���ed��D7KU 3�G : �D7;QHS�IOCK�8N 5 A�< ]�S��6>3<JA�ND�<BCZ<?>7MAbRC�C�7K< )�S�C��8> t >m3��8ND< c N�MIJIBU�:�#NTGFS�A�C!wt���BF>�S�7K� R@{ A�ND�,F�����>3S�7K� 5 F> )��8�DAaN 5 G�>��DAV:t7��BMIsE'RC;j���U )���S�>3�XEvCKGE��DC��D7���<BA�� :65 �TC 5 �D7sG�7xA�GMCsC 5 �#��G�E��8I'FNTC�S�FIBIJU 3��D7;QHGF7���>s>�RCK<J>mQ�FNTC�G�7�<JIBU R g G�E��8I'MA�E�E�<?>3C�7K< )�S�C�<JGFA�FI'F>K>3S'�83�CK<BG�A�>8:FE'RC;E��43��8A�E��DA�NT�#MA�E*QHGF7��.>�GPQ E'RC;�E��43��8A�E��8A�NT��F7��[GPQgCK�DANQ�FN;CKGF7y> :65 <JN 5 M7K�[GRdF�D7KIJG�G�hF�XEuMA�E����U�7��8A�E��D7[�C�GOG�I�S�>3�8IB�X>�>xG�7A��8�8E�<JA&�@>�G4���(�E��cS�>3C ���DA�Cy> Rs} MC�S�7;MI�E'RC;bE��43��8A�E��DA�NT��>�S�N 5 �>=7KS�A�A�<JA&�P>�*�83�IJ�8>W<BA6)�RCyN 5 �8>8:=�>=<?>WE�G�A�� )OU*z 5 ����1O :NFA.GPQgCK�DAH)��+S�>��8E�CKGbC 5 �t�E�d1MA�C�9�F�6GPQ C 5 � 3�7;FNTC�<BC�<JGFA��87W<JAL>;3��XNT< QHU�<JA&�gf��G�7�� 3�7��XNT<?>3�(��G�E��8I R � N;C�S�MI E'RC;bNTG�IBIJ�8NTC�<JGFA���UPE�< x��87\QH7KG4� ��G�E��8I�7K�4]�S�<J7������8A�C[FA�E@C 5 �87��1QHGF7K�F:M< Q C 5 ��>cCKS�E�UP<?>|Z7K�TCK7�G�>m3��8NTC�<JdF�GFA���:M<BCW<J>=dF�D7KUb<��83�G�73C;MA�CsC�G�hOA�G :�(O'�N;C�IJU 5 G : C 5 �bE'MC�N)��8<BA&��FA�MIJUcuD�8E 5 �dF� )��D�DA0NTG�IBIJ�8NTC��XE R f GF76�1O'*�83�IJ�F:O<BA2C 5 �@z 5 ����(Oa3�7�G,)�IJ��0:�C 5 ��j <BA�W�NTG�A�C�7KGFI�kE'MC�X���U*GF7i���U*A�GFC 5 �dF� )��8�DA07��43�7K�8>��DA�C�MC�<JdF�+G9QfC 5 �Z�DA�C�<J7K� 3�7�G�NT�X>�>8:�>�<BA�ND�ZG93��D7;RC�G�7K>%MA�E*CK<����8> : �87��eA�GMC�hOA�G : A RS 5 ��k G�S�CmW GPQzW�NTG�A�C�7KGFI�kFE'RC;f���U 5 �dF��)��8�DA6P>��D7K<B�X>=GPQ[3�G�<BA�CK>YGRdF�87=CK<����eGF7i �@MC 5 �87�<JA&�@GPQA3�GF<JA�Cy> QH7�G@� :65 �D7K�DdF�87=C 5 �DU: �D7K�j�d1M<JI�9)�IB� R S 5 �X>3�#E'RC;I���U 5 �d��H)��D�DA >3S�N 5 C 5 MCXFER�cS�>cC����DA�CK> 5 �E )��8�DAr���E��6)OU_G93��D7;RC�G�7K>8:x<dQ�C 5 �DU : �D7K�NTG�IBIJ�8NTC��XE0<BAQ7K��FI CK<���� R 7 QsC 5 ��>cCKS�E�U07���]�S�<B7K�8>+E'RC;�C�Ga)���NTGFIJIJ�8N;CK�8Et:�C 5 �DU0> 5 G�S�I?E )���NTG�IBIJ�8NTC��8E0<JAn : �U2>�S�N 5 C 5 RC->�S�<]C;P)�IJ�#��G�E��DI�N�MA$)���)�S�<BIBCWG�7sS�>3�XE Rs\ <BA�NT�6A�G7��RC 5 ���RCK<JN�MI'��G�E��8I'��<B7K7�G�7K>x7K��FIB<BCcUF:F>�<��PS�I"RCK<BG�A@<?>|ZNTG@�X��G�A�IBUPS�>3�XEC��XN 5 A�< ]�S�� :65 <JN 5 FIBIJG : >��(O�3��87�<����DA�C��87K>�C�G0NTG@�$3�M7K��C 5 �8GF7K�TCK<JN�MI�NTGFA c E��DA�NT��IB�8dF�DI?> : <]C 5 FNTC�S�FIfG,)�C�F<BA��8EQNDGFA c E��DA�ND�IJ�DdF�8IJ> R

Page 45: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� ��� ������� ��� ���

��� � � IBC8:���� � � t � # ��� w����QS�I]CK<Bd1F7�<"RCK����S�MIJ<BCcU�zYG�A�CK7�G�I : � l"!�#$! @�%'&)(yj k i*%,+.- n i n k0/;npk1! i5@2- !Dk ( l3! ( / :�4��XE�<]CK�8E�5OU } �76.�98FG 5 A�>�GFA: \ �<;ZGMC�u�:=8FG 5 A?>4<BIJ�DU6MA�E \ G�A�>D: } � :A@ GF7Kh3�

� B � z%MS=C 5 IJ<BA : � � t z 5 �����DE6��5�GF7;RCKGF7K<B�X> wGFIH+<"MIJG$C�S��(FA�ELzYGF7K7��X>,J�GFA�E��DA�ND��E�S�7K<BA)C�MA�ELKHGFIJIBG : <JA=C*MONP� \ � #3# # N�A�E�S�>PFC�7K<�FIQM=7KG$5�IJ�� \ GFIJdO<BA=CL>_GF7Kh�> 5 G�JQ�

� (�� �vGFA�C'CFG4���87�U�:"HR�Vz�� t � #3# � wS�UT l�nWV %Xj o)!Dn k % l&n %X- n i npk0/;n k1! i5@ZY o i5@ kgn[#]\ % l�nWV %5@]: ( 7yEv�8E^�^8�G 5 A_>4<BIJ�DUxFA�E \ G�A�>D: } � :@ GF7Kh : } @ �

( �

Page 46: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

( � $��#$������������W��

Page 47: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� ��������� �

��� � ��� � ������� � � � � ������� ��� ��� � ���

� ����� � ��!�"� $# �%�&���

8�<�� � 7;MA�A�MA ) : IJIB<?>+zYS'�R5��87 5�MCKN 5 � : � 7�U=MA�CZ�QG�G�E�<J� :('<�� �vU��D7y>*)M:,+eGF7yE�GFA { k zYG�A�A��DIJI.-M:)H�GFS=C�I��>ZM=<?NyhF�D7K<JA=C0/7�1 � J�G�73C J�7�� J�M7K�8E 5�U2'<�� �vUF�87K> : 8F<�� � 7;MA�A�FA

Sa<43 57698;:=<?>@BAC8;DE<F6M=< J��DIJ<BA��X> J�7KGRd�<?E���MA_�8NDGFA�G@��<JN�MIJIBUv�;A.ND<B�8A�C7���DC 5 G�E_G�K[C�7;MA�> J�GF7�C�<JA=C2IJ<.G�S�<JE 5 UOE�7�G�NF7 5�GFA]J�7KGOE�S�N;Cy>ZGRdF�D7ZIJGFA=C0E�<?>PFC�FA�NT�X>�� � J�< J��DIJ<BA��j�,�U_5��E5�MCKN 5 �XEt:tC 5 RCb<?>D:f<]Cf���UuNDGFA�C�F<BAb#AOS'�*5��D7�G$KE�< x �D7K�DA�CZCcU2J��8>bG�KIB<.G�S�<JE�>D:f��FN 5 5�RCyN 55 �dO<JA=C.<]Cy>+G : ABH�S�<JEuN 5 M7;FNTC��D7K<?>cCK<JN8>G�KWE��8A�>3<BCcU^MA�EvdO<?>�NDG�>�<]CcU�� 6 <.G�S�<JE 5 U�E�7KG�NM7'5�GFA�>6NDGFS�I?E 5��IH�S�<?E�>�>3S�N 5 F>�ND7�S�E��GF<JI t 5 ���dOUF:����XE�<JS'�0:�IJ<�C 5 C�GF7�>�U�A�C 5 �TCK<JN wGF767K�KJ�A��8E?J�7KGOE�S�N;Cy> t C=F>�GFIJ<BA��bE�<B�X>3�8I^KHS��DIp:��dO<"RCK<BG�A KHS��8I w6GF7�d�GFI"RC�<JIJ�eIJ<.G�S�<JE�>>�S�N 5 F> } RCKS�7;MIL+7�>*6 <.G�S�<?E�> t } + 6�wS� N CP<J>@�8NDGFA�G@��<JN�MIJIBUuE��8>�<B7;�5�IJ�F:��X>,J��8ND<�FIBIJU : <BC 5 7K�KJ�A��8EUJ�7KG�E�S�NTCK>8:fC 5 RC�NT7KG�>K>NTG�A�C�*��<JA�RCK<BG�A 5��TC : �D�DA£FE��8�NT�8A�CL5�MCKN 5 �X>*5��^��<JA�<���< u8�8E^� N K�C 5 �0E��8A�>3<BC�<J�8>�G$K+C 5 �MH�S�<JE�>�<JAs�E��8FND�DA�CL5�RCyN 5 �8>XM7K�E�< x��87��8A�CjMA�E|C 5 �BH�G : <?>.I�4��<BA�F78: 5�S�GRU=MA�NDUUKHGF7yNT�8>�IJ���E CKG MA S�A�E��X>3<J7;�5�IJ� 5 GF7K< u8GFA�C�FIi��<�D�<BA)C J�7�G�ND�8>K>R5��TC : �D�8AC 5 �@C : GNH�S�<?E�> : <]C 5 C 5 � 5 ���dO<J�D7�H�S�<?E KHG�7KND<BA)C2<BCK>��DI�KYS�A�E��D7eC 5 ��IJ< C 5 C��87�H�S�<JEmF>�C 5 �DUnF7�� 5�GMC 5 NTG�AOdF�8NTC��XExMIJGFA=C2C 5 �J�< J��R5OU6.NDGFA�>3C�FA�C�J�7��X>�>�S�7K��CF7;FE�<J�DA�C9�C' 5 <?>6CcU J��PG$KH��<�D�<BA=CL<J> J�7�<���M7K<BIJU2E�7�<JdF�8A?5OU0E��DA�>3<BCcUXC�7��E�<J�DA�CK>�FA�E CF7;�dO<]CcU�:5�S�CZE�< x��87��8A�NT�X>+<JAQdO<J>KNTG�>3<BCcU : <JIJI{FIJ>�Gj�x �8NTC+C 5 �g��<�DO<JA=CXJ�7�G�ND�8>K>�� N�AvC 5 �PI"*��<JA�M7OH�G : 7�� CF<����F:�C 5 �,*��GFS�A�C+G$KWNT7KG�>K>NTG�A�C�*��<JA�RCK<BG�AU5��DC : �8�DAU5�RCyN 5 �8>b<J>P7�G�S=C 5 IJU_J�7�G�J�G�73CK<BG�A�MI�CKG0C 5 �LE�<J>3C�FA�NT�.C 5 RCPC 5 �PH�S�<JE�>gM7K��C�7;MA�>,J�GF7�C��XE^� \ <JA�ND�C 5 �f�dF�D7;�C��OH�S�<JE#d��DIJGOND<]CcUL<J>�NDGFA�>3C�FA�C6C 5 <?>#����FA�>C 5 RC6C 5 � : <JEOC 5 G�KxC 5 ��<JA�C��87,K��NT�F: ' :=CF7KG : >�J�7�G�J�G�73CK<BG�A�MI CKG�C�<����Q �LM=< J��8IB<JA��.NTG@� J�MA�<J�8>7��<JA�<���< uD�,��< D�<JA=C 5OUQG$J��D7;RCK<BA=C2C 5 � J�<�J��DIJ<BA��.<BA&C 5 � KHS�IJIJUQC�S�7 5�S�IB�8A�CRH�G : 7�� CF<JGFAQ� 1 �DUOA�G�IJE�>AOS'�*5��D7y>YG�K C�7��BRC��87=C 5 MA B ! !3!fM7K��NDGFA�>�<?E��D7K�8E�CKG*5���KHS�IBIJU�C�S�7 5�S�IB�8A�CZ5�S�C#��G�>3C[NDG4�LJ�FA�<B�X>WS�>3�7bIJG : �87YIJ<���<BCG�KTSC! ! !)�' 5 <?>�F>K>�S�7��X>[C 5 MC6C 5 �IH�G : : <JIBIG5�� KHS�IBIJULCKS�7'5�S�IJ�DA�C � � J�GFAv>cC;M7�C,F S=JIMA�E0> 5 S�CKE�G : A#G�K[LJ�< J��8IB<JA���C 5 ��H�G : E�GO�8> J�F>K>C 5 7�G�S=C 5 C 5 �[I�4��<BA�F7�7�� CF<JGFA 5�S�CxC 5 <?>�<J>fCcU J�<?NMIJIJUf�> 5 GF7�C�<BA�C��87�d1FI[� � �X>3<?E��X>D:M>3C�F73Cy>{FA�EP>3C�G�J�>xG�K)J�<�J��DIJ<BA��iF7���CF�8A��D7;MIJIJUA�GFC KH7��UG�S��DA�C � D J��D7K<����8A�C;MI������>3S�7������8A�CK>> 5 G : C 5 RC6C 5 <J>67K�8>�S�IBCK><JAIMA#<BA�C��87,K��NT� CF7KG : C 5 7�MC�� 'WV Q 8�9 -X/$�N�A#C 5 � KHGFIJIBG : <JA=C�MA�FIBU�>�<J>���G�E��8IJ>(M7K�ZE��DdF�8IBG�J��XEXKHGF76C 5 ��C�S�7 5�S�IB�8A�Ct��<�D�<BA)C�MA�E?CF7KG : C 5 MC(L5�RCyN 5 <JA�C��87,K��NT�$� N�AYXS<� B C 5 �X��RC 5 ���RCK<JN�MI{��GOE��DI�<J>eE��EJ�A��8E : C 5 <?>ZE���J��DA�E�>eND7�S�NT<"MIJIBU0GFAQC 5 ��N 5 GF<?NT�@G�KYE�< x S�>�<BG�A&NTGO�;A.ND<B�8A�C[Z � N�A\Y]S)� (���G�E��8Ix<?>7MA�FIBU�>��8E :65 �87��9Zw<?>�C 5 � 5 M7���GFA�<?Ng�d��D7;�C��eG$K=C 5 ����<�DO<JA=C0NTGO� A*ND<B�8A�Cy>+G$K=C 5 �PC : G J�S�7��^H�S�<?E�>��I' 5 <J>�<J>IJ<Bh��DIJU.C�GE5��f CFGOG�EF$J=J�7KG7DO<���RCK<BG�A :65 �DA#C 5 �bE��DA�>3<BCcU2E�< x �D7K�DA�ND��5��TC : �D�8A#C 5 �RH�S�<JE�>�<J>6> ��MIJI[�

> 5 �8A C 5 �vE��DA�>3<BCcU E�< x �D7K�DA�ND�#<?>�I"M7'CF�F:Y<BA C 5 �vI�4��<BA�F79H�G : 7K��C�<����NJ�A=CF�87�<JA=C : <JIBI�G�N8NTS�7�MA�E|C 5 �D7K� : <BIJI 5��I7K�DI"RC�<JdF�8IBU0> 5 M7'JQ<JA�CK�D7 K�FND�*5��TC : �D�DAuC 5 �FH�S�<?E�> ��_�G : �DdF�878:�<BAuC 5 �@C�S�7 5�S�IB�8A�C�N�>3��:Q�> C�7��dO<BCcU#E�7�<JdF�X>�C 5 ��E��DA�>��D7�H�S�<?E<JA�CKGLC 5 ��IB�X>�>ZE��8A�>3��GFA��PC 5 �@<JAOd1FE�<JA=CNH�S�<?Eu<?>e<��,���8E�<"RCK�DIJUI��< D��8E]5OU#C�S�7'5�S�IJ�DA�CbE�< x�S�>�<JGFAQ�^' 5 <J>-����FA�>�C 5 MCZ> 5 M7'J<JA�CK�D7 K�FND�8> : <JIJIYA�GFC@��DO<?>3C �_N�A�>cCK��FE`C 5 �87�� : <BIJI 5��FJ�A�<BC��F��<�D�<BA)Cu7K��CF<JGFA :65 �D7K�.C 5 �#dFG�IBS���� KH7��N;C�<JGFA`G$K����N 5 H�S�<?E`Xacbedgf�hjilk[mTkon pKdgqrhrn sutvlacbxwyneqjf�ilkEs7z{q|w ��� w]sjd}m~kon pKdgqjhrn sut� m~kon pKdgqrhjn sutOiy�(�{be��dgqjsrw� acqrwyk � dgb � mTkon pKdgqrhjn sut� m~kon pKdgqrhjn sutOiy���;ne��srilqjnxw�l��q|wyk � ilk[m~kon pKdgqjhrn sut

(

Page 48: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

( � � � ������� ������ �$� ��� �� � ��� ��� � ��� $���� � � ������ �� � � ��&N 5 FA=CF�X> KH7KG4� � C�G !=�EN�A&C 5 <J>bN�F>��EH : <JIBIWE���J��DA�E_S=J�GFA_C 5 �.7��8I�MC�<JdF�.NTG�A�NT�8A�CK7�MC�<JGFA&G�K[C 5 � H�S�<JE�> �?' 5 <?>f�J)J�7�G=FN 5IJ��FE�>[C�G�.E���C��DA��87�MC��ZE�< x�S�>�<JGFA J�7KG$5�IJ�� :65 <JN 5 <?>#MA�FIBU�>��8E*<JA YXS<� S<�Sa<�� � <���O: 6 DE6�����M@��[8;DE<F6��

Fluid 1 Fluid 2

X=-X

u(r)

X=X1 1

Mixing

region

r

x u(r)

�f< CFS�7��RS)� ��� MW7�G�5�IB����NTG�A�J)C�S�7�MC�<JGFA KHGF7 Q ? !

� CfMA&<BA�<BC�<"MI�CK<���� Q � ! : ��NTG�A�>�<JE��87[H�S�<?E � G�NDNDS=JOU�<JA=C2C 5 �.>��8NTC�<JGFAuG$K J�< J�� ( !6MA�E H�S�<?E B G�NDNDS=JOUO<BA=C2C 5 �>��8N;CK<BG�A`G�K J�< J�� Q? !�:[F>�E���J�<JNTC��8E <BA|>��D�X�f< CFS�7��NS)� � � 6 �DC! ) t� � Q wgMA�E" � t� � Q w@E��DA�GMC��#NTG�A�NT�8A�CK7�MC�<JGFA�> t AOS'�*5��D7J��D7ZS�A�<BCed�GFIJS'��� w�G�KWdO<J73CKS�MI J�M7�C�<?NTIJ�8>�G�KsCcU J��8> � FA�E B : 7��X>,J��8NTC�<JdF�DIJU$�R' 5 ��NTG�A�NT�8A�CK7�MC�<JGFA�>+G�K=C 5 �@C : GXJ�G�J�S�I"RC�<JGFA�>G�K�d�<J7�C�S�FI�J�M7�C�<?NTIJ�8>,M7K�6�>�>�S'���8E C�G 5�� J�7KG7D�<B�X>PG�7@<JA�E�<?NMC�G�7K>RKHGF7�C 5 �^��<�D�<BA)C&G$K�C 5 �#C : G H�S�<JE�>�� ' 5 �LC : G&CcU2J��8>G�KIJ�F73CK<JNDIB�X>(F7��f�>�>�S'���8E#CKG 5���E�<?>cCK<BA=C�S�<?> 5 $5�IJ��KH7�G@� G�A��gFA�GMC 5 �D7-MA�E07K�8> J�G�A�E#C�G*C 5 �*KHGF7yNT�8>+G�K�C 5 ��FER�8FNT�8A�C�H�S�<?E�DIJ����8A�Cy>��cS�>3CGF>�<�K�C 5 �DU : �87��YC 5 ���.>3�8IBd��8>sN 5 F7��N;C��87�<?>3C�<?NWd�GFIJS'���Y�8IB�����8A�CK>sG$K�C 5 � H�S�<?E@<JA�<]Cy>xC�S�7'5�S�IJ�DA�CW>3C�MC��$� � >K>�S'���C 5 RC6C 5 �RH�S�<?E�>�M7K�e<BA�NDG4�LJ�7K�8>K>3< 5�IJ��>3G�C 5 RC

) t � Q w - � t � Q w � ! � Q ? ! � t S<� � w' 5 �ZCKS�7 5�S�IB�8A�C+E�< x S�>�<BG�A2�UG�S�RCK<BG�A�>�KHGF7C 5 �ZC : G.>��TCy>G�K J�M7�C�<?NTIJ�8>#F7�� �# $# Q -"$��&% $ �'% � t Z $ % $ w � t S<� B w:65 �87��^Z $ <?>6C 5 �bCKS�7'5�S�IJ�DA�C�E�< x�S�>3<JGFAuNDGO� A*NT<J�DA�C+<JABH�S�<?E 2 MA�E $ � t 6 � # w<J>�C 5 �^H�S�<?EvdF�8IBG�ND<]CcU����x<JA�MIJIBU�: : �g�>�>�S'���<JA�<]CK<�FIVNTG�A�NT�8A�C�7;RC�<JGFA�>

) t� � !vw �)( ! � ( !! � ? ! t S<� ( w

MA�E � t � !vw � ( ! � ? !

! � ( ! � t S<� ScwN K 6 ) t� � Q w�FA�E76 � t� � Q w�7�� J�7��X>3�8A�C[C 5 �bd�GFIJS'��� KH7��N;C�<JGFA�>6G�K;H�S�<?E � MA�EMH�S�<JE B 7��X>,J��8NTC�<JdF�DIJUF:)5��XNMS�>3��G$KxC 5 �b<?E��DA�CK< J=FNMC�<JGFA0E�<?>�NDS�>�>��8E6�5�GRdF��: : ��>��TC

6 )�� ) ) - � � )! 6 � � � ) - � � �

! � t S<� � w\ <JA�NT� ! �<?>��NTGFA�>cC;MA�CC 5 �ZCKS�7 5�S�IB�8A�C+E�< x S�>�<BG�A0�4G�S�RCK<BG�A�>%���U 5���7K� : 7K<BC3C��8AIF>

# 6 $# Q -*$��+% 6 $ �'% � t Z $ % 6 $ w'� t S<� � w' 5 ��CKS�7 5�S�IB�8A�CPE�< x S�>�<BG�A_NDGO� A*NT<J�DA�Cb<JA t S)� � wt�PS�>cC 5��*E��TCK�D7���<BA��XE_�SD J��87�<����DA�C�FIBIJU KHG�7ZC 5 � H�S�<JE�>b<BA G�S��8>3C�<JGFAQ�?' 5 �C�S�7 5�S�IB�8A�C�d��DIJG�NT<BCcU $ ���U 5����X>cCK<���MC��8EXKH7KG4� �d1F<BI"�5�IJ�e�SD�<J>3C�<JA=C.7K�8>�S�IBCK> �;' 5 <J>6<?>6E�<?>�NDS�>K>3�XE 5��DIJG : �

Page 49: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

��� � � � � �� �� ��� � � � � ��� ��� � & (3#>4<BC 5 B !�� t !=� � ! � � w J�<�J��F:{MAb�dF�87�$CF�bd��DIJGOND<]CcUvG$K � � J 5 t B � B ( � ���R> wtFA�EvC 5 � H�S�<?E_E�UOA�*��<?N@dO<?>�NDG�>�<]CcU07;MA=C��

>�S=J=J�IJ<B�XE_5OU A25�7�<?E CF��� $�� !� � � � ! � N \ t � $���� ! )� � � � | � ! ) ) � � � �R> w6C 5 � 1 �DUOA�G�IJE�>eAOS'�R5��87�KHG�7eC 5 �9H�G : <?>e<BA&C 5 �7;MA=C��� � $ � � � � � | � ! � � � � | � ! � � �I' 5 �IH�G : <J>+C 5 �D7K�SKHGF7K�bCKS�7'5�S�IJ�DA�C�KHG�7uMIJIxN�F>��8>�G�KW<JA�C��D7K�8>3C � D J��D7K<����8A�C�MI : GF7Kh> 5 G : >YC 5 MC KHGF7C�S�7 5�S�IB�8A�C�H�G : :OC 5 ��d��DIJGOND<]CcU2NTG4�LJ�GFA��8A�C#FIBG�A=C�C 5 ��J�<�J���<J>6NDIBG�>3�8IBUF�J=J�7KG7D�<���MC��8E 5OU

6 � � '�������� $ 8�� )�� � � t S<� w:65 �87�� �=� � � � � !�KHGF7 1 �DUOA�G�IJE�>WAOS'�R5��87K>� ��� S | � ! � � � � | � ! - ��( � B | � ! / ��� � �=' 5 � : <JE���d1M7K<�MC�<JGFALN�MI?NTS�I"RCK�8ELKHG�7C 5 � 1 �8UOA�GFI?E�>eAOS'�*5��D7e<BA&C 5 �RJ�7K�8>��DA�CZNF>��P<JA�E�<?NMC��X>+C 5 RCeC 5 �X$J=J�7KG$J�7K<�MC��@d�FIBS�� KHGF7 � : <JIJI�E���J��DA�E&>cCK7�G�A=CFIJU0S=J�G�AC 5 �RH�S�<?E�>6<JABG�S��X>cCK<BG�AQ�

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1r/R

laminar

n=6

n=10

u/umax

�f< CFS�7��RS)� B���� �8IBG�NT<BCcU J�7�G J�IB��KH7KG4� 8 � !�CKG�' 5 �6d��DIJGOND<]CcURJ�7KG�J�IJ�8>sNDGF7K7��X>,J�GFA�E�<BA=CeCKG�d�FIBS��8>=G$K ��� � MA�E � !uF7��6> 5 G : A�<BA �x< CFS�7K��S)� B �{' 5 ��I"*��<JA�M7X:�J�F7�$5�G�IB<?NJ�7KG�J�IJ�+<?>%MI?>3GRJ�IBGFC3CK�8E^� > 5 �8A*C 5 �OH�G : <?>WC�S�7'5�S�IJ�DA�C8:�<JA.C 5 ��dO<?NT<JA�<BCcU.G�K 8 � �:�C 5 �87��e<J>% 5�GFS�A�E'M7KU�I��U��D7X:@ : �U KH7KG4�

C 5 <J>�7�� CF<JGFA#C 5 �PdF�8IBG�ND<]CcU2d�F7�<J�8>+GFA�IJU#dF�D7KU2>�IJG : IBU�� ��GF7+C 5 <?>�7K���>3G�A 6 <?> : �DIJI�$J=J�7KG7DO<���RCK�8E?5OU6*NDGFA�>3C�FA�C+d1MIJS��.� � :�SD�ND��J�C KHG�7+<JA0C 5 �@dO<JND<BA�<BCcU#G�K 8 � ��_�G : �DdF�878:�>�<JA�NT��C 5 <?> 5�GFS�A�E'M7KULI"�UF�87�G�NDNTS)J�<B�X>6GFA�IBU^*> �,FIBIGJ�7KG$J�GF7�C�<JGFA0G�K�C 5 �NT7KG�>K>,F >��8NTC�<JGFAb<BC : <BIJI�A�GFC 5 �dF�ie>�< CFA�< J�NFA�C���x��XN;C=G�AbC 5 � 5�S�IJh*J�7KG$J��D7�C�<J�8>HMA�E@>�G�NMAR5��6A���CFIJ�8NTC��XE^�{' 5 �[��D J��87�<J�DA�ND�G�KJ�< J��8IB<JA���NTG@�LJ�MA�<J�8>[<JA�E�<?NMC��8>YC 5 RCZKHGF7ZJ�< J��8>G�KxE�<�4���TC��87 CF7K��MC��D7WC 5 FA �7B �bC 5 � 5�GFS�A�E�M7KU.I��U��D7[<J>[A�GFC 5 U�E�7;MS�IJ<?NMIJIJU>�<�C�A�< J�NMA�C9�

\ <JA�NT�C 5 ��H�G : <?>�C�S�7 5�S�IB�8A�CX:@��<�D�<BA=C�FNT7KG�>K>fC 5 � J�<�J�� 5 �J=J��DA�>=GRdF�D7|bdF�D7KUP> 5 GF7�CsC�<����SF�>�N�MIJ�$�;' 5 <?>|����FA�>�C 5 RC�FA�U7;FE�<"MI�d1M7K<�MC�<JGFA�>7F7�� G�S�<JNyhOIJUQ>8��GOGMC 5 �8E&GFS�CuFA�E_>3G07;FE�<"MIsE��87�<Jd1RC�<JdF�X> : <BIJII5��.A���CFIJ< CF< 5�IB��NTG@�LJ�M7K�8EQC�GvE��D7K<Jd�MC�<JdF�X>MIJGFA)CQC 5 �XJ�< J��$� ��S�73C 5 �D7X:sC 5 � t C�<���� wX�dF�87�$CF�.d��DIJGOND<]CcUa<JA|C 5 �#7��E�<�FI[E�<B7K�8NTC�<JGFA : # :G�PS�>cCL5�� uD�87�G<�\' 5 �0E�< x S�>�<BG�A�4G�S�MC�<JGFA�>i���U.C 5 �D7K�SKHG�7��eA�G : 5�� : 7K<]C�C��8A#<JAI�NTGFA�>3<?E��D7;�5�IBU*>�<��LJ�IJ�D7ZKHG�7 �

# 6 $# Q - � � # 6 $# � ## �� Z $ # 6 $# � � t S<� � w:65 �87��Z7;FE�<"MItd1M7K<"RC�<JGFA�> 5 �dF��5��8�DA0A���C�IB�XN;CK�8E^�

' 5 � 5 �BM7�CG$KVC 5 �bNTS�7K7K�DA�C�J�7�G�5�IB��� IJ<B�X><BAvE��DC��D7���<BA�<BA=C�C 5 �ZC�S�7'5�S�IJ�DA�C�E�< x�S�>3<JGFAvNTGO�;A.ND<B�8A�CK>�Z $ �IN�A2C 5 � KHG�IBIJG : <JA=C>��8N;CK<BG�AM#>3C�FA�E'F7KE_E�< x�S�>�<JGFAb��GOE��DI : <JIBI 5��.���LJ�IBGRU��8E^�?' 5 �*E�< x S�>�<BG�A`NTGO� A*NT<J�DA�C : <JIBIO5��*N 5 G�>3�8Am�>ZC 5 � 5 M7���GFA�<?N�dF�87�$CF�eG�K�C 5 ��C : G*E�< x S�>�<BG�AQNTGO� A*NT<J�DA�Cy> KHGF7�C 5 � J�S�7��IH�S�<?E�>�� � C+�8<]C 5 �D7��DA�E0G$KfC 5 �P<JA�C��87,K��NT�ZC 5 � 5 M7���GFA�<?Nu�dF�87�$CF�7K�8E�S�ND�8>bC�GQC 5 �#d�FIBS��EKHGF7,Q>�<BA=C�IB�MH�S�<?E^� � > : <]C 5 >cC;MA�E�M7yE`E�< x S�>�<BG�A J�7KG$5�IJ��.>PC 5 <?> : <BIJIY<��LJ�IJUbFA <JA�J�A�<BC��0>,J��D�XEG�K J�7�G�J��C=RCK<BG�AnMA�EQC 5 � : <?EOC 5 G�KWC 5 �,��< D�<JA=C2uDG�A�� : <JIBII5���<BA(J�A�<BC��$�9' 5 <?>Z<J>�C 5 ���X>�>��DA�NT��G�K=C 5 ���J=J�7KG@�N 5 FE�G�J�C��XE<JA � B � ��N�AuC 5 <?>ZN�>3�PC 5 �X��< D�<JA=CVu8GFA����PS�>3C�5���E��KJ�A��8E 5OU0C 5 �@7K��C�<BG�A :65 �D7K�bC 5 �.NTG�A�NT�8A�CK7�MC�<JGFAvG$K=��FN 5 NTG4�LJ�GFA��8A�C<?>u�5�GRdF��>3G@���,��<JA�<��@S'� d1FIBS����P' 5 <J>7��G�E��8I : <BIJI.5�����G�>cCf$J=J�7KG$J�7K<�MC�� :65 �DA_C 5 �D7K��<?>ZdF�87�UvIJ<BC3C�IJ�.d1M7K<�MC�<JGFA&<BA_C 5 �

Page 50: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

S3! � � ������� ������ �$� ��� �� � ��� ��� � ��� $���� � � ������ �� � � ��&E��8A�>3<BC�<J�8>[G$K C 5 ��H�S�<?E�><JANG�S��X>cCK<BG�AQ� N�AYXS<� S�:�<BC : <BIJI35��7F>K>�S'���8E.C 5 RC[C 5 �-4��G�S�A�C[G$K���< D�<JA=C�E���J��DA�E�>YG�A*C 5 ��7K�DI"RCK<Bd��NTG�A�NT�8A�C�7;RC�<JGFALG�KVC 5 �bNTG@�LJ�G�A��DA�CK> � � CC 5 ��NT�8A�C�7K��G$KVC 5 �u��<�D�<BA)C0u8GFA���:OC 5 �7��< D�<JA=C : <BIJI^5���C�7��BRCK�8>3C8:�E�S��eC�G�C 5 � 5 <�C 5NTG�A�NT�8A�C�7;RC�<JGFA#G�K����N 5 NTG4�LJ�GFA��8A�C8:� : �ULKH7KG4� C 5 �PND�DA�C�7K�ZC 5 �g��<�D�<BA)C : <BIJIfE��XNT7K���>3�uMA�E27K���N 5 uD�D7KG�RC6C 5 �b�8E=CF�8>�G�KC 5 �u��<�D�<BA)C�u8GFA����Sa<�� � D��2D46� < ��� @ DK> �N� Dl8�� � �;D�� D� ��:&> �O6��{Dl8��N�A2C 5 <?>6>3�XN;CK<BG�A*C 5 �ZE�<� S�>�<BG�A#NDG��;A*NT<J�DA�C : <JIJI^5���N 5 G�>3�8AFF>YC 5 � 5 M7���GFA�<?Nt�d��D7;�C��6G�KVC 5 �eC : G�E�<��S�>3<JGFA0NTGO� A*ND<B�8A�Cy>[G�KC 5 ��J�S�7K��H�S�<JE�> �

Z� �)��� 6 ) - )� � 6 ��� � S<� #��} GFC��6C 5 RC Z�� Z )�� >6 � �F! � A�EPZ�� Z � � >6 ) �R!)�{' 5 �+7 � C�<JGFA � IB�ZKHG�7WS�>�<BA)C�C 5 � 5 � 7���GFA�<?N � dF�87 � CF�6NTG����8> KH7KG��� A � A � IJG$CFU : <BC 5 E�<� S�>3<JGFA0<JA 5 G���G$C��DA�<��D�XE ���8E�< � � ' 5 ���! �8NTC�<JdF�bE�<��S�>3<JGFA0NTGO� A*ND<B�8A�C�<JA#C 5 <?>�N � >���<?> : �DIJIth�A�G : ALCKG5��ZC 5 � 5 � 7"��G�A�<JN � d��D7 � CF�+G�KxC 5 �bE�<� S�>3<JGFAvNDG��;A*NT<J�DA�CK>GRd��D7 � J��87�<JG�ELIJ�DA=CFC 5 G�KxC 5 �#��<?NT7KG�>KNTG�J�<?N$���8E�< � �

−10 −8 −6 −4 −2 0 2 4 6 8 10−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

position in mixing zone, X

volu

me

frac

tion

t=10t=20t=30

�f< CFS�7��RS)� ( ��� G�IBS%��� KH7 � NTC�<JGFA�>8: 6 ) : :65 �8A Q � !%& B !%& ( !(' Z ) � � B � A�E2Z � � � � !

−10 −8 −6 −4 −2 0 2 4 6 8 100

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

position in mixing zone, X

volu

me

frac

tion

t=100t=110t=120

�x<�C�S�7��RS<� S � � G�IBS(��� KH7 � NTC�<JGFA�>8: 6 ) : Q � ! !(& �$� !%& �9B !(' Z ) � � B � A�E2Z � � � � !\ 5 <�KgC�<JA=C*NDG�F GF7yE�<BA � C��Z>�UO>3C��)�rC�G*��GRdF� : <BC 5 C 5 �RH�S�<?E,+- $ � � Q C 5 ��J�7KG$5�IJ����<J>A�G : E��KJ�A��8E?5OU# 6 )# Q ## + � Z # 6 )# + � � S)� � ! �

.

Page 51: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

��������� ��� ��� � � � � ��� ��� &�� � �� � & ��� � � � ��� ��& � �� S �

6� � + & ! � ( � & + ( !!(& + ? ! � S)� �$� �

6�� � + & Q � � � � > +-� $� & 6�� � + & Q � �R! � > + � � S)� �9B �:65�� 7 �Z� ��� � 6� - �� � � � $ 6� �

Z��lZ �Z � 6 � - Z � � � $ 6 � � � � S)� � (��

��������� ���>�����>�����! r�#"$��%� &��"$'N K :(� > � C16�� � & Q � / �*) � :65�� 7 � ) ,+- . :(� J�A�E2C 5 � C / �PS�>3C+> � C�<?>PKHU*C 5�� C : GLJ�G�<BA�C 5�GFS�A�E � 7KU*d � IJS � J�7�G�5�I � �

( Z � Z �Z � /0/ Z�� � � $ / � / ��1

� / �B ) / � �!%& IB<��243 )65 / �*) � � & IB<��243 5 / �*) � ! � � S)� � S �

' 5�� >�GFIJS�C�<JGFA#G�KfC 5 <?>�>�U�>cC � � : <JIJI^5 � � C�G�G�E � J=J�7�G7D�<�� � C�<JGFA.CKG�C 5 � C�G�K � S)� � ! � F � S<� �7B � KHGF76I � 7'C� C�<�� � >��

>4<BC 5 � NTGFA�>cC � A�C�E�<� S�>�<BG�AvNTG � A*NT< � A�C � >�<���<JI � 7�<BCcU*>3G�IBS�C�<JGFA � D�<J>3CK> KHGF7 � IJI C�<�� � � ( �/ �

B� 7,K N � )7 B Z � � � S)� �

� �> 5�� A C 5�� E�<��S�>3<JGFA4NTG � A.ND< � A�C*<J>.E � J�A � E 5�U � S)� � (�� C

5�� J�7KG$5�I � � �PS�>3C 5 � >3G�IBd � E A�S(� � 7�<?N � IBIJU$� >4<BC 5 d � IJS � >�G�KZ��$ ! � � : Z � Q! � � >3G�IBS�C�<JGFA�>ZKHG�7�CK<�� � > Q � !%& B !(& ( ! � 7 � > 5 G : A0<BA �x< CFS�7 � S)� ( : KHG�7 Q � !3!%& �$� !(& �7B !b>�GFIJS�C�<JGFA�> � 7 �> 5 G : A0<BA �x< CFS�7 � S)� S)�}' : G*>�GFIJS�C�<JGFA�> � 7 � NTG��LJ � 7 � EL<JA �x<�C�S�7 � S)� � CKGLE � ��G�A�>3C�7 � C � C 5�� E�<� � 7 � A�N � <BAQNDGFA�N � A�C�7 � CK<BG�A�>:65�� AuC 5�� E�<� S�>�<BG�A_NDG � A*NT< � A�CK> � 7 � > : � J)J � E^�^' 5 <?> 5 < C 5 IJ<�C 5 CK>�C 5�� K � N;CZC 5 � C KHGF7 � AOU0C : GMH�S�<JE�>eC 5�� NTG�A�N � A�CK7 � C�<JGFAJ�7KG�J�I � <BA#C 5�� ��< D�<JA=C*�DGFA � E � J � A�E�>�GFA#C 5�� G�7KE � 7G�KfC 5�� H�S�<JE�>8: k98 ( 8 :65 <JN 5 <?>�E�7K<BdO<JA=C � A�E :65 <?N 5 <?>Z5 � <JA=C*E�7K<Bd � AQ�

−4 −3 −2 −1 0 1 2 3 4

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

η

α 1

D1=1/2, D

2=1/10

D1=1/10, D

2=1/2

�x< CFS�7 � S)� � � \ GFIJS�CK<BG�ALCKG � S)� � S � :�C : G�N � > � > � H � � � B � A�EXH B � � � ! � A�E#dO<?N � F d � 7K> �N K :(� � 7 5�<]CK7 � 7�<JIBU*E � J�A � C 5�� J�G�>�<BC�<JGFA0G�KxC 5�� C�7 � <JIB<JA=C � E=C � : . � Q � : � A�E2C 5�� J�G�>�<BC�<JGFA0G�K�C 5:� I � � E�<JA=C � E C � : � � Q � :�G�KC 5:� ��<�D�<BA)C �8GFA � CKGL5 � IJG�N � CK<BG�A�> :65�� 7 � C 5:� NTG��LJ�G�>�<]CK<BG�A2<?> # ! � H�S�<?E � � A�E # ! � H�S�<?E B :�7 � > J � N;CK<Bd � IJUF:OC 5:� A

. � Q � ) � 7 Q / � � Q� A�E*C 5�� I � � E�<JA=C � E=C �

� � Q � ) � 7 Q / � � Q.

Page 52: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

S B � � ������� ������ �$� ��� �� � ��� ��� � ��� $���� � � ������ �� � � ��&

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10−2

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

time

posi

tion

xtrail

(t)U

avet

xlead

(t)

�x<�C�S�7 � S<� � � . "� � Q / ) � 7 Q & � (� � Q / ) � 7 Q & � � � Q 'XZ��� ����B &]Z � ��� � !

:65�� 7 � ) � � A�E ) � � 7 � E � C � 7���<JA � E?KH7�G�� / �9) � � ! � # � A�E / �9) � � ! � � ��+e7 � J 5 >6G$K . � Q � � A�E � � Q �$� 7 � <JIBIJS�>3C�7 � C � Ev<JA�x<�C�S�7 � S)� � KHGF76C 5�� N � > � Z�� ! � � � A�EBZ � ! � � � >�G.C 5 � C�C 5�� � A.ND< � A�NTU#G�KxC 5:� C�S�7'5�S�I � A�C$��<�D�<BA=CL<J> CF7 � � C � 76<JABH�S�<?E� C 5 � A&<BCb<?>Z<BA H�S�<?E B � � ' 5�� � � N;C�G�K[C 5 <?>Z<?>�> 5 G : A]5OUvC 5�� C�7 � � C � 7�C 5 <?NyhOA � >K>ZG�KYC 5�� ��<�DO<JA=C �DG�A � 5 � IBG : C 5�� IJ<BA � � � Q C 5 � A � 5�GRd � �

N�A#C 5�� N � > � C 5 � C6C 5�� I � � E�<JA=C H�S�<?E#<J> ��G�7 � � A*NT< � A�C � C ��<�DO<JA=C�C 5 � A0C 5�� C�7 � <JIB<JA=C H�S�<JE � Z � ! � � � A�EBZ � �! � � �C 5:� >�<]CKS � CK<BG�AL<?>[7 � d � 7y> � E : <BC 5 C 5�� C 5 <?NyhOA � >K>YG�K C 5�� ��<�D�<BA=C �DG�A � � 5�GRd � C 5�� IJ<JA � (� � Q CF7 � � C � 7WC 5 � A*C 5:� C 5 <?Nyh�A � >K>5 � IJG : C 5:� IB<JA � �Sa<<S � �O6��;Dy8��!> : D��!�O6 � D �2DE6�' 5�� ��G�E � IsG$KWC 5:� J�7 � d�<JGFS�>�> � NTC�<JGFA_<J>�5 � > � EuG�AQC�S�7 5�S�I � A�CbE�<� S�>3<JGFA �RN C 5 � >�<JA�J�A�<]C � >,J �4� EuG$KOJ�7KG$J � C � CK<BG�A � A�E&>�GN � A�A�GFCZE � >�ND7�< 5 � � J�A�<BC � <JA�C � 7 K � N � � � A � IBC � 7KA � C�<Jd � � J=J�7KG � N 5 :tE�<?>�NDS�>�> � Eu<BA Y � : <?> � E � A�>�<]CcUQE�7K<Jd � A ��< D�<JA=C ��G�E � I[�' 5 <?>+7 � G�S�<J7 � > � C�S�7'5�S�I � A�C ��<�D�<BA=C#NTG � A*ND< � A�C :65 <?N 5 <J> � � 7�G � C � <]C 5�� 7 � A�EuG�KsC 5�� <JA�C � 7 K � N � :�7 � H � NTC�<JA=C.C 5�� K � N;C�C 5 � CA�G ��< D�<JA=CvG�NDNDS�7K> 5 � U�GFA�EuC 5 <J>�J�GF<JA�C �2zYIJG�> � C�G � A_<JA�C � 7 K � N � : C 5�� ��< D�<JA=C : <BIJI.5 � > � � IBIWE�S � C�G#C 5:� > � � IJI � ��G�S�A�CG�K[GFA � G$KWC 5:� H�S�<?E�>��P' 5�� ��<�DO<JA=C0C 5�� A_<BA�NT7 � � > � >�CKG � � � D�<��PS%� � CZC 5�� N � A�C�7 � � A�E_E � NT7 � � > � > � C � <JA � >eC 5�� GFC 5�� 7<JA�C � 7 K � N � <J> � J=J�7�G � N 5�� E^�C' 5:� >3<��LJ�I � >3C$��GOE � I :65 <JN 5 N � J�CKS�7 � >C 5�� > � K � � C�S�7 � >6<J>�Z $ Z 8 6 � � � $ 6 � � '<5 � N � S�> � C 5:�H�S�<?E�> � 7 �8: � IJI F ��< D � EQC 5�� E�<��S�>3<JGFA`NTG � A.ND< � A�CZ<?>ZC 5�� > � � � <BA � � N 5 J 5 � > � �?' 5�� d � IBS � G$K Z 8 : <JIBI.5 � NTG�A�>3C � A�C�KHG�7� � N 5 J � <J7=G�K,H�S�<?E�>8:�<BCW<?> � D J � NTC � E�C 5 � CCZ 8 : <BIJI�d � 7KU : <BC 5 C 5�� dO<J>KNTG�>3<BCcU � A�E.E � A�>3<BCcU@E�<� � 7 � A�N � 5 � C :(� � A�C 5:� H�S�<?E�>8:�<JAJ � 73CK<JNDS�I � 7=<BC �PS�>3CW<JA�NT7 � � > � � >�C 5:� E � A�>3<BCcU�E�<� � 7 � A�N � <JA�NT7 � � > � >��GN CY> � � �.>=7 � � >3G�A � 5�I � C�G � >�>�S%� � Z 8 Z 8 � � � & � � � �� > 5 < C 5 IB< C 5 C � E 5OU�C 5�� 7 � >�S�IBCK>[G�KfC 5�� J�7 � dO<JGFS�>> � N;CK<BG�ANZ �PS�>3C 5 � N � IJNDS�I � C � EEKHGF7 � � N 5 J � <J7YG$KTH�S�<?E�> � A�E : <BC 5 � d � 7�UH�S�<?E0E�7K<BdO<JA=C � A�EX5 � <BA)C*E�7�<Jd � AQ�=' 5�� J�7KG$5�I � ��<J>6A�G : CFGRd � 7KA � E 5�U

# 6��# Q ## + � Z 8 6 � � � $ 6 � � # 6��# + � & � S)� � � �:65�� 7 � :�G�A�N � � C � <BA + A$ � � Q � � A�GFC 5�� 7�>�<��LJ�I � ��G�E � I KHG�7�C 5:� ��< D�<JA=C2NDG � A*NT< � A�C+<?>�Z Z 8 # 6 � � # �O_�G : � d � 7X:C 5 <J>I � � E�>YC�G � AL<JA�C � 7,K � N � :65 <JN 5 CF7KG : > : <BC 5 Q � � �: :65�� 7 � � > � D J � 7�<�� � A�CK>[<JA�E�<?N � C � C 5�� C�7�G : C 5 <J> � J=J�7KG7DO<�� � C � IJU Q 8�9 -]/>�G@C 5 <?>���GOE � I : <JIBItA�GMC 5 � E�<J>KNTS�>�> � E KHS�7�C 5�� 7 � G�S � C�<JGFA � S)� � � � � � U 5 � >�GFIJd � E AOS%� � 7K<?N � IJIJUF: � I]C � 7KA � CK<Bd � IJU � IJGMC.G�K+S�> � KHS�I6<BA=KHGF7�� � C�<JGFA � � U 5 � C � <BA � E KH7KG��

C 5:� >�<���<JI � 7K<]CcU`>�GFIJS�C�<JGFA�>�G$K�C 5�� KHG�IBIJG : <BA)C&> � N;CK<BG�AQ� } GMC � : � G�S � C�<JGFA � S)� � � � <?>�<BAOd � 7K< � A�C@S�A�E � 7�C 5:� CK7 � A�>,KHGF7�� � C�<JGFA6���� � $ 6��R:�>�G�C 5�� 7 � <?>6>3U �*� � CK7�U � 5�G�S�C6C 5:� G�7�< CF<JAQ�=' 5�� J�7KG$5�I � � C 5�� 7 � KHGF7 � G�A�IJU*7 � G�S�<B7 � >>�GFIJdO<BA=C�GFA#GFA � >�<?E � G�KC 5:� IB<JA � + !)�

.

Page 53: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

����������� ��& � �� � �Q �� � � ��� ��� � S (

−10 −8 −6 −4 −2 0 2 4 6 8 100

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

position in mixing zone, X

volu

me

frac

tion

t=10t=20t=30

�x<�C�S�7 � S<��� � zYGFA�N � A�C�7 � CK<BG�A : 6� � & Q � : :65�� A#C � !�: B !�: ( !%' Z 8 �

−10 −8 −6 −4 −2 0 2 4 6 8 100

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

position in mixing zone, X

volu

me

frac

tion

t=100t=110t=120

�x< CFS�7 � S)� � � zYGFA�N � A�CK7 � C�<JGFA : 6��R: :65�� A#C � !3!�: �$� !�: �9B !('0Z 8 �

����� ��� ���>�����>��:�! r�#"$��%� ���"$' �LJ�IJGRUO<BA)CPC 5�� >3<���<BI � 7K<BCcUL>3S)5�>cCK<]CKS�C�<JGFA ) + � 7 Z 8 Q : � G�S � CK<BG�A � S)� � � � 5 � NDG�� � >

$ �B ) 6 � � ## ) � 6 � � � $ 6 � � 6 � � � � � S)� � � �

� J)J�7�G�J�7K< � C � 5�G�S�A�E � 7�U*NDGFA�E�<]CK<BG�A�> � 7 �6�� � ! � �

B 6 ���� � ! � �! 6� �*) � � ! & � S)� �� �

:65�� 7 � ) � <?>[C 5�� S�A�hOA�G : AXJ�G�>�<BC�<JGFA0G�KfC 5�� � E C � G�KxC 5:� ��<�D�<BA)C �8GFA � �=' 5�� J�7y>cCC : G�NDGFA�E�<]CK<BG�A�> � 7K<J> � KH7�G�� >�U��*� � CK7�UNTG�A�>�<JE � 7 � C�<JGFA�> �

� A � D � NTCZ>�GFIJS�CK<BG�AvC�G2C 5 <?>�J�7KG$5�I � � <?>�6 � � � $ ) � �$B �I' 5 � C�C 5 <J>Z<?>�C 5�� � J)J�7�G�J�7K< � C � >�GFIJS�C�<JGFA&<J>ZNDGFA�J�7�� � E 5OUC 5:� AOS%� � 7K<?N � I >�GFIJS�C�<JGFA�>[G$K � S<� � � � F � S<� �

� � > 5 G : A*<JAX�x< CFS�7 � >LS)���O: S<� � � } GMC � :OC 5�� GF7yE�<JA � C � <JA*C 5�� > � J<CFS�7 � >Y<J> + : :65�� A) <?>YC � h � A � >YC 5�� G�7KE�<JA � C � � IJI C 5�� NTS�7�d � >[NTGFIJI � J�> � G�A�CKG � >�<BA=C�I � IJ<BA � : � >> 5 G : AL<JAX�x< CFS�7 � S)� # �I��7KG��^C 5 <J>CJ<CFS�7 � <BC6<J>NTI � � 7C 5 � CC 5�� : <?EOC 5 G$KVC 5�� ��< D�<JA=C �DG�A � <J> B ) �� B �

.

Page 54: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

S S � � ������� ������ �$� ��� �� � ��� ��� � ��� $���� � � ������ �� � � ��&

−4 −3 −2 −1 0 1 2 3 4

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

η

α 1

�x< CFS�7 � S<� # � \ GFIJS�CK<BG�ALCKG � S)� � � � F � S)� �� �

����� ��� � ���� �� "�� � '( ��� ��� ' 5��H: <?EOC 5 G�K[C 5�� <JA�C � 7,K � N � <?>b>3<��LJ�IJU]C�<Bd � A 5�U ' B + ��: :65�� 7 � + ��<?>ZC 5:� J�G�>3<BC�<JGFAaG$KYC 5�� I � � E�<BA=C � E C � : + �* ) � 7 Z 8 Q � ' 5�� � D � NTC�>3G�IBS�CK<BG�A2G$KfC 5�� J�7 � dO<JGFS�>> � N;CK<BG�Av> 5 G : > ) �$ � : � A�E2C 5�� <JA�C � 7,K � N �^: <JE�C 5 <J>6C 5�� 7 � KHGF7 �

' B & Z 8 Q � � S)� � #��' 5 <?>Z<BA�E�<JN � C � >eC 5 � C�C 5:� <JA�C � 7,K � N � CF7KG : > J�7�G�J�G�73CK<BG�A � IfC�G Q 8�9 - � A�EuC 5�� NDGFA�>3C � A�CZG�K�J�7KG$J�GF7�C�<JGFA � IB<BCcUv<J> B 7 Z 8 � ' 5:�AOS%� � 7K<JN � I�7 � >�S�I]Cy>eG�K��x< CFS�7 � >[S<����:7S)� � : :65�� 7 � Z 8 <J>�> � CZC�G � : 5 � d � � A_<BA�C � 7 K � N �$: <?EOC 5 B 7 Q � D J � 7K<�� � A�C � I�7 � >3S�I]Cy>CF<Jd � A2<JA � B � <BA�E�<JN � C � '�� Q 8;9 -]/ � � J�IJGMC�G$KVC 5�� CF7KG : C 5 G�KfC 5�� <JA�C � 7 K � N �^: <]C 5 CK<�� � <?>�> 5 G : A2<JA �x<�C�S�7 � S<� � !=�

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10−2

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

time

posi

tion

xtrail

(t)U

avet

xlead

(t)

�f< CFS�7 � S)� � ! � . (� � Q / ) � 7 Q & � � � Q / ) � 7 Q & � � � Q 'XZ 8 ����B

Sa<�� ��<F6BA E@��;DK<96��' : G ��G�E � I?> 5 � d � 5 �4� AvE�<?>KNTS�>K> � E*<JALC 5 <?>ZJ � J � 79� ' 5�� J�7K>3C���GOE � I : <JIBI^5 � ��G�>cC67 � I � d � A�C[C�G9H�G : > :65�� 7 � C 5�� E � A�>�<]CcUE�<� � 7 � A�N � 5 � C : �4� A|C 5�� H�S�<JE�>�<?>�> � � IJIW� N�A C 5 <J>.N � > � C 5:� E�<� S�>3<JGFA � ��< D�<JA=CaNTG � A*NT< � A�C�<J>�7 � I � C � EaCKGuC 5�� E�<� S�>�<BG�ANTG � A.ND< � A�CK>e<BAuC 5�� J�S�7 � H�S�<?E�>8:7Z $ �*��G�7eC 5�� � A � IBU�>�<J>�G�KOYXS)� ( C 5�� NTG � A*ND< � A�CZ<?>eN 5 G�> � A � >�C 5���5 � 7���GFA�<?N � d � 7 � C � G�KZ � � A�E Z � �O' 5�� > � NTG�A�E ��GOE � I : <BIJIG5 � 7 � I � d � A�C+C�GPH�G : > :65�� 7 � C 5�� E � A�>�<]CcUvE�<� � 7 � A�N � <J>e>3< CFA�< J�N � A�C � N�AQC 5 <?>�N � > �CF7 � dO<]CcU*E�7�<Jd � >WC 5�� ��< D�<JA=C � A�E*C 5�� E�<��S�>�<JGFAvNTG � A*ND< � A�C6<?>6A�GFCA � N � >�> � 7K<JIBU.7 � I � C � ELC�G?Z�� � A�EBZ � �

� GMC 5 ��G�E � I?>�>3C�S�E�< � E2I � � ELC�G � CF7KG : C 5 G�KfC 5�� <JA�C � 7 K � N � : <BC 5 Q 8�9 - : :65 <?N 5 <J><JA#NDIBG�> � � CF7 �4� � � A�C : <]C 5 C 5�� � D J � 7K<�F� � A�C � I�7 � >�S�IBCK>.C�<Bd � A�<JA � B � �=' 5�� > � <BA�E�<JN � C � � CF7KG : C 5 7 � C � J�7�G�J�G�73CK<BG�A � I�CKG Q 8�9 -X/ �;' 5:� J�7KG$5�I � � E � >KNT7K< J�C�<JGFAEJ�7KGRdO<JE � E.

Page 55: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

����� � � � � � ����& ��� � & S �

5OU A 5�7K<JE C � >cC � C � E�C 5 � CYC 5���: <JEOC 5 G$KtC 5�� ��<�D�<BA)C �DG�A � >3C � 5�<BIJ<�� � > � KgC � 7 � >�S A*NT< � A�C�IJU�IBG�A=C�C�<�� � �=' 5�� 7 � C � G$KVN 5 � A=C �<JA : <JE�C 5 G$KtC 5�� <BA�C � 7 K � N � <BA 5�GFC 5 G$KtC 5�� NTS�7K7 � A�C ��G�E � I?>W<?> J�7�G�J�G�73CK<BG�A � I�C�G ��� 7 Q � C 5 <J>[7 � C �e: G�S�I?E � I?>3G*5 � J�7 � E�<?N;C � E5OU � NDGFA�>3C � A�CbE�<� S�>3<JGFA NDG � A*NT< � A�C ��G�E � I � � � >�<JA�E�<?N � C � E]5OU �f< CFS�7 � > ( :~S�: �O: � A�E � C 5 <?>bE � NT7 � � > � <JAaC 5�� 7 � C � G�KN 5 � A=C � G$K ��<�D�<BA)C �DG�A �e: <?EOC 5 � � U 5 � NTG�A�>3<?E � 7 � E � >WNDGFA�>�<J>3C � A�C : <]C 5 C 5:� >3C � 5�<BIJ<�� � CK<BG�A�G�5�> � 7Kd � E 5OU A 5�7K<JE C ��: <]C 5 <JAC 5:� IB<���<]Cy>6G�K � D J � 7K<�� � A�C � I � 7K7KGF7

' 5�� <BA�C � 7 K � N �V: <?EOC 5 � I?>3G_E � J � A�E�>.NT7KS�NT< � IJIJU_S)J�G�A|C 5�� d � IBS � G$K+C 5:� E�<� S�>3<JGFA�NTG � A.ND< � A�C8: :65 <JN 5 �PS�>3C 5 � E � FC � 7"��<JA � E � D J � 7K<�� � A�C � IJIBU���N�AuC 5�� C�S�7'5�S�I � A�C ��< D�<JA=C2> � NTC�<JGFA � d � 7KUv>3<��LJ�I � KHGF7��PS�I � : � >�G$5�C � <JA � E KHGF7�C 5:� <JA�C � 7 K � N �: <?EOC 5 : ' B 7 Z 8 Q � \ G�:�C 5�� GFA�IBUEJ � 7 � � � C � 7[NDGFA�C�7KGFIJIJ<BA=C@C 5:� : <?EOC 5 <?>[C 5�� E�<� S�>3<JGFA0NTG � A.ND< � A�C � ' 5�� 5 � >3C6N 5 GF<?N � G�KH�S�<?E�>+C�G.CK7 � d � I CKG$C � C 5�� 7 : <JIBIVC 5�� 7 � KHGF7 � 5 � C 5�� J � <J7 : <BC 5 C 5�� ��<JA�<��PS%� d � IJS � G$K=Z 8 ��' 5�� 7 � >�S�I]Cy>�G$KCY]S)� ( 5 < C 5 IJ<�C 5 CC 5:� K � N;C+C 5 � C6C 5�� ��<�D�<BA=CE5 � C : �4� A � AOU.C : GFH�S�<JE�>+E � J � A�E�>6S=J�GFA :65 <JN 5 H�S�<?E#<J>+E�7�<JdO<BA)C � A�E :65 <?N 5 <J> 5 � <JA=C*E�7K<Jd � A �N�A`IJ<�C 5 C@G�KC 5 <?>*K � N;C@<]C�<J>P7 � NTG��*� � A�E � E&C 5 � C :65:� A E � C � 7���<BA�<BA=C Z 8 C � >3CK> � 7 � N � 7�7K< � E_GFS�CPG�A � � N 5 J � <J7PG�K H�S�<JE�>� A�E : <BC 5 � d � 7�U H�S�<JE`E�7�<JdO<BA=C � A�E 5 � <BA=C&E�7�<Jd � AQ� N CP<?>�IJ<Bh � IJUQC 5 � C�C 5�� d � IJS � G�K�Z 8 <?> � KHS�A�NTC�<JGFA`G�K[C 5:� 1 � UOA�G�IJE�>AOS%�*5 � 7y>sG$K�C 5�� C : GRH�S�<?E�>8: 5:� A�N � >�N � I � E�E�G : A�C � >cCy> � � U*5 � N � 7K7�< � E@GFS�COJ�7KGRd�<?E � EPC 5�� 1 � UOA�GFI?E�>sAOS%�R5 � 7K> � 7 � >�N � I � E� J)J�7�G�J�7K< � C � IJU$�

.

Page 56: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

S � � � ������� ������ �$� ��� �� � ��� ��� � ��� $���� � � ������ �� � � ��&

.

Page 57: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� ��� ������� ��� ���

��� �I1 � � � � <J7yEt: > � � \ C �1: � 7�C : � } �=6V<�C 5 C KHGOGMC ��� V����=/ &=% V���� ( � % �E( ��� � 8������?>���� ��� :�� ����� � # � !=�� B � + � N�� ' � � � ��!9��'"� �$# �%� J � !&�������'��K � ��()( � !*��� (�+ !'5 + � � � ( H�� : ( ��!&� + C�� � J���J � ���ZV % ! ( (-, . �0/ / %P+ �1 (32 % #�� @ -3% ! .1( �W# %,+

4 % � ,�% ��� B$B (�5 � J=J S S � FrS ��6 � � # � S<�� (�� 8)� HR��78! � ��9 ��:^V ( ( � � ,;�E% <=. �>/@? %�A � , � V�# < � @BA)( & V % ? @�(C� /��ED D KF��! # ��G � � � G � M + 5�� � G � ( ������� � �IH 6 S)�

S �

Page 58: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

S 6 $��#$������������$��

.

Page 59: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� ��������� �

� � � ������� � �� ��#E� ����� � � ����� � �����

� � � � � + � � � 5 ��� � + �� � H � � 7 � � � � ( ! � ( � � � � � !�� � � 7 � J�!&����C�� ���� � � ! � � # � _ � : 90��� � ) � � � + ��� � ;�� � !�� � ' � � � ! � ; ����� � 9 ) �� ��� G � � ( 6 � � � � ! � � 8 � �����?� G � � � � - � � � !��EM � : ��� � : ��9>� � � � ��� � 1 � �I# / � � � ( �������7' ��� � # � � � 8 + � � ��� ��� + / �1 � J���! ( J�! � J � ! �=# 5 � �'��� ' � � � / �

� � ( � � ����� � (�� � G � KF!&��� 1 � (�� 5 C$C � ! � � � � � � _ � �&� � � 5 + ! � C� � � � # � � ! G M ��+ ��� + � � ����43 57698;:=<?>@BAC8;DE<F6'"� � J�!&�$5�� � � #&� � G !�� 5 �=# � � ( ��� �$! � J���! ( #&� � �%� � � ( �\J�� # ���=C � � ��� G � � � ( ��!$�$J ( ��� � � J���! ( KF����� �_KF!&��� � � � � J����&�)� 5�� �J���! ( KF��� � ��� � � G � ��K � ��� G � G ��� �)�%� ( � �$K � � + 5 � � ( �$K � � � !'C � � � ( �$K J�!&��� � G ( ����'"� � J�!&�$5�� � � � � ��5�!&� + C�� (*( � ( � � MONP� �� ��!&90������J 5 � � � ! � 9UM !&��� � G ( 6 ( # �'�$K*7 � � C � ! � � � #&��� � ����J � ! ��K ����� � � # C � ���)�$K ( � � ! � KF��! ( � � J � ( !&��� � + � � � # + � ( ! � �N K.J���! ( KF��� � ��� � � #&� + J ��K � � � � � G ( � ��� �$K.J � ( !&��� � + � J�!&��� � G ( � � ! � J�� � (�( �I# ��� � C�! � J�� ��K � D J � G ( �=#�� � � + ��� � !-� + � !&� ��9 �( � � ! � �%� � � + J=J � !Z5 � + � # � ! � � 5 � � � � ��� G �;���RJ���! ( KF����� ��� � ! � KF� + � # � '"� � J���! ( KF����� ��� ��� ( ���%�Z5�� + � # � ! � � ! � � � � # ( �L5 ���� G � � � ( � '"� � G ����� � G ( � ���@��K ( � � � � ��� G � � � ( J ��! ( KF��� ���>�8�%� 90��� � � � � ( � � ��� G � � � ( KF!&��� ( � � !9�

����! � J���! ( KF����� � ( � 5 � ��� G � � � ( � � ( � + � ( 5 � ( � � G � � � ( � � ( ��� � ( � � !�J���! ( KF����� � � � � � ��! ��� � � + � � ����� � � � � ���=C ( � �� � � � ��! � � ��� !&�%�)9 � � � # ( � � ! � � � ��� � ( � � ! J ��! ( KF��� ��� ( � � ( � � � � � �&� !&�%�)9 � ����� � � � � � �=C ( � � � � � � ��! � ��! ��� � � + � � _ � !&! �� � !�9�� � � ( �3! ��� ��� + ( ��������� �I# ( � � J � � # ��K J ��! ( KF��� ��� ( � � ��! � � � ( � ��� ��J�� ��� �4� !&� �=C � ��!&9 � � ( � � �=H � � � � � � !&9�� � � ( � � �=H � B ��IH � H � ��_ � � � J=J�!&� � G � ( � ��� G � � � ( KF!&��� ( � � ! � � � � � ��� � + � � � � � ( !&��D � ��C � 5�! � ( � #&� ( � !�� ��� � � � � � � � � ( � G � � � D J�! � �&�)� ��� KF��!( � � G + ! � � ! � J�! � � � � ( � �=C ( � � ��� G � � � ( KF!���� ( � � ! �

� � ! � 9 #&��� � � �$J � � G �������$� G ����K ( � � ! � KF��! ( � � J � ( !���� � + � � � # + � ( ! � � N � � J=J�� � ���)C ��� G � � � ( KF!&��� ( � � ! ( � � ��! � ( � ( � �! � � ��� �$K ( � � J � ( !&��� � + � � � # + � ( ! � � � � ! � 9 � � � (�� 9 � � � # �� � ! � � ( � J=J�!&� � G � KF!&��� ( � � ( ! � # � ( ����� � � � � !�9�� � � ( � ( � G �����.G + � �! ��� �=C J�! ��� ��� + ��� � C � � � ! ��( �I# � ��� ( � 7 � !&���@! � � + � ( � ! � � # ��� � � � � � � G ( �I# J���! ( KF����� ��� � ! � C � � � ! � ( �I# � � # J�� � (�( �I# ��� � ���� G � � � ( KF!&��� ( � � ! C�! � J��Q� 5 � �$��! � J���! ( KF����� ��� � ! � J�� � ()( �I# � � ( G + � G 90� � 5 � G ��� � � � J)J � ! � � ( ( � ��( ( � � ! � �%� � � + J=J � !5�� + � # � ! � �;'"� ����� G � � � ( KF!&��� ( � � ! � � � ( � � ! � KF��! � � ���LJ���� �I# 5 � ( � � + J=J � !O5�� + � # � ! � � 5 + ( � G + ! � � � ����� ( � D J���� G � ( � � # ! � � � �� � ( �$�$K ( � � � � � J=J�!&� � G � � � � � � � � ( ! � �=C ( ��� � � # � � � 9>� � �&� � ��� ����! � ��� (�� � G � � � � ! � 9#" � � J)J�!�� � G �$� � G 9 � ( � � � � � � � ( � G � �G � ! (�� � � ( � ! � C � ! # ���)C ( � � ��� G � � � G � ��K.J�!&��� �%�)� �=CEJ���! ( KF��� � ��� ( � ��( ( � � � � !�9�� � � ( � � J=J�!&� � G � � � � �%$ � � � ( ��� + C�� ( � � ! �� � � � �4� � ( � 5 � ��� J���! ( KF��� � ��� � 5�� � � � J � ! ( � G + � � !EJ ��! ( KF��� ��� ��� ( � � C�! � J�� � � ( �%� � � � � � � J����&�)� 5�� � ( � � (;( � � � � D (! � � # ��� � � C � � � ! ��( �=# J���! ( KF��� � � � � � �Q5 � 5 � (�( � ! �

D � ( � � � ( � � !$� � � # � ( � � � � !&9�� � � ( � � J=J�!�� � G � � � � �)��� � � ��� � ! � � ���$� (���( � ����� � � � � � J=J���� �I# ( � ( � � J � ( !&��� � + �� � # + � ( ! � �`*m~kon pKdgqrhjn sutOiy� a7wyb'&Kwyq tv)({�*d*wyk�wyk+*�a�iKwyhjsrwyb-,,kKp4neqrilkof�dgkKs|wyb-.4dgkohrnek/&10ukU��2� m~kon pKdgqrhjn sutOiy�3RilkEsjqrd*wyb� m~kon pKdgqrhjn sutOiy�(�{be��dgqjsrw� 3Rd*qrw5476,qri98jdg��s;: s<*�2�lm~kon pKdgqrn sutOiy���{ne�gsjilqrnxw

S H

Page 60: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

��� � � ������� � �*� ��� � � ��� �!� � �� ����������� & � ��� � � ��� �� '"� � �)���LJ���� J G � ( � ��� ��K #&� � G !&� 5����)C � !��%��9 J�!&��J�� � � � ( � ����� � � � � � � � � # � � !�� � � G � � � � � � � � # ( �@��� � G�G + ! � G � � �*� �

( � � ��� G � � � ( KF!&��� ( � � ! �� N ( � � � ��� ( 5 � J����&�)� 5�� � ( �EJ � ! ( � G � J ��( � � � � J�!�� � � G ( ��($� � � !'5�� ( ! � !&��� � J�� � � ��� � � ��K C�! � � + � � !&� ( � � � ��� � J�!&��� � G ( �� � � 5 � � + G � ( � ��( ( � �I� ! � G + ��! � � ����� � � � � � ( � � � ( ��! ( � ��� G � ����� ( 5 �3# ��� � ��($� � �[�� '"� � G ����� ( ! � � � ( � ( � ��( #&� ( � !��$� � � � ��� G �_J���! ( KF����� ��� � ! ��� � ��� # G � �]5 � G ���LJ���� G ��( �=# � � ( � � J � ( !&��� � + � � � # + � ( ! � �

78����� ( ! � � � ( � � � 9 ��� N K 5 ( � � � � �%��� � � 7 � � � # H �;��! � N K $ ( � � � ��� ( � ��! � ��! � 5 ( � � � � ( B ��KC_ � N � 8 � � � # ; �G � ����� ( 5 � � � ��� � � � D J�! � ��� �I# � � � � ��� � � ! � G + � ( � ��� � � ��� G �@�%� ! � G + ��! �I# KF��! ( � � � � !�9�� � � ( � � J)J�!�� � G �Q�

� � ! � 9�5�!&� + C�� ( ( ��� � J�!&�$5�� � � ( � ( � � � ��!&9 �)����J ��� ( � � ���$J � ( � � ( � � G � + � # J�� # � � � � ( � � #�# ! � ��� ( � � � � � 90� � ��� � � ��K( � � ( � � � J=J�!�� � G � � � � J�� ( � � ( � � � � � 5 � G ���*5�� ��� �=C ��!OJ � ! ( � � ��� � G ���*5������ �=C ( � � �?� 5 � ��� G � � � ( KF!���� ( � � ! � � � � � �)�%� � � ( ��� #( � � ( G ���*5�� � � � ( � � !&�$5 + � ( � � �&� ��K ( � � � ��� ( � 7 � !&��� � J=J�!�� � G � � � ( � ( � � G ����J #�� � G � ��K ( � � � � !�9�� � � ( � � J=J�!&� � G � � � + � #� � #&�4�=# 5 � � J � � � ! K + � ( �0���ZKF��! � � � � � # + � ( ! � � _ � � ��� � ! � � ( ���0��� 5 � G � � � G � � � ! ( � + � ( � � ( ( � � ! � � ! � � ( � � ! � � � �( � � #�# ! � �&� ( � � J�!&�$5�� � � � ��� G � # �@��� ( ! � G + � ! � � � ��� ( � 7 � !�� � G ���LJ���� � � ( � � � �*5 � !-� ��K"� + ! C�!&� + J_KF��!"� �I# ( ��! � �� + 5=C�!&� + J�� � � # � � G � � + 5=C�!&� + J #&��� � ����J �=# � # �� � ! � � ( � J=J�!&� � G � KF��!*�)��� � � �=C ( � � J�!���5�� � � �C'"� � J�!-� ( �%� ( � � M ��! ( KF����� �� � � � G ( � ��� 5 � C���!&� ( �%� 5 J)J�!�� � G � � � � ! � � � ( ! � ( � #&��� � ����J � J�! � G ( � G � � � � � ! G ��� �=C � � C���!�� ( �%� � ��� G � � � ��� � � � # + � ( �( � � ��� G � � � ( J���! ( KF����� � � � ( ��� +�( � � � ���)C ( � � D � �$� � � � � G � � � # ��� � ! � J����&�)� 5�� � J ��! ( KF��� ���<�L'"� � � � G ��� # � J=J�!&� � G �;�%� ( � �� (�� ( �%� ( � G � �ZN � K � ! � � G � 5 J)J�!�� � G � � � � ! � � � # �%� G + �&� � (�� ( �%� ( � G � � � � ( ��� � ( ����� � � # � � K � ! � � G � ��K ( � � ��� G � � � ( J ��! ( KF��� ���<�'"���%� � J=J�!�� � G � J�!&� � � #�� � � ����� + ( ����� ( � ( � � � � � 90� � ���8��K ( � � � ��� ( � 7 � !&��� � � ( ��� # ��K � � ! � 93�='"� � ( ����! # � J=J�!&� � G � � �( � � N � ( � C � ! M !&�$C�! � �*�$� �=C 5 J=J�!&� � G � � � � ! � � � ( ! � ( � J�� # ( � � � D � G ( ��� G � � � ( J���! ( KF��� � � 5 � � � ()( � �=C + J ( � � J�!&�$5�� � �� � � � � � ( � C � ! J�!���C�! � �*� ���=CRJ�!&�$5�� � � � � # ( � � � �)��� � � �=C�� ( �

'"� � ! � � ( ��K ( ��� � ! � J ��! ( �%� ��! C � ����� �=# � �3KF��� ��� � � � � � G ( � ��� � � � B � � � (�� � # � � S G � � � ! ( � � ( ��! �4� � J)J�!�� � G � � � � ! � �,J � G ( � � � � � �� � G ( � ��� � � � G ��� (�� � ��� � �)����! ( � + �*� � ! � ������ � ����� <^:{8��< 4DK<� �$ �OAC8;DK<96 �-��^<F: Dy8�� � �����B:=<��A �� � �*5 � !-� �$K ( � � � + 5=C�!&� + J � ��� G � #&��� � � �$J �I# ( ���%� � J=J�!&� � G � � ! � _ � ��� � � 5 + ! � C � � � !&� � � 7 � J�!&����C�� ��� � � � + ��� � ;�� � !��� � # � ��� G � � ( 6 � � � � ! � � � � � ��K ( � � ! ��� � � !-�)� ( � ��KI� ��� ( ! � � �W�{'"��� � � J=J�!&� � G � � � �$� ( � � � ( �=# 5 � ( � � K � G ("( � ��( � D � ��+ � ( � � �G ���LJ + (���( � ��� ��K�J ��! ( KF��� ���>� G � ����� ( 5 � + � #&� ! (�� 9 � � � � � � ( � � � + �*5 � ! ��K�J�!&��� � G ( � � D G �4�I# � ( � � '"� + � � � � � � � ( �J�!&�$J���� � � � � � � G ( � � � � � ( ��� # � N � � � ! � 9#" � � ��� ( � 7 � !&� � � � ( ��� # � J���! ( KF����� ��� � ! � C � � � ! � ( �=# + �����)C � � ��� ( � 7 � !�� �( � G �����.G + � � � � � G � ( � � J���! ( KF����� ��� � ! � � � � � G ( �=# ! � � # ��� � � � ( � � 5 � � ( ��� � ��� � � ��� ( � J=J � � ! ��� ( � � C�! � J��Q� 7 � � � � J � #� � � � C���!�� ( �(� ( � ��( � � + � # ��� � � (�+(� ��� � � � � � G ( � ! � J�! � � � � (���( � � � � � ( �$KGJ���! ( KF����� ���"� + G � ( � � ( ����� � ��K ( � � 5 � � ( J ��! ( KF��� ���>�� ! � � �%��� �I#�� N � ( � � KF��� ��� � � �=C � � ��#&� � G !�� 5 � � J ��! ( KF��� ��� � � � � G ( ����� � � C���!�� ( �%� KF��! ( ���%��J + ! J���� � � > � � ��� � � D J�� � � � ( � �� � C���!�� ( �(� + �)� �=C � � � D � �LJ�� � # ��(�� � � ( �� ������� � � ����� ��'"� �;# � (�� G �������%� ( � ��K � � � ( ��K � � J�!&��� � G ( ���?����! � � G �UJ�!&��� � G ( � � � � � # ( � � � � ( �3�$K � + �R5 � !&� � ��K � � �=C ( � B ��� � � G � �G ��!�! � � J���� # � �=C ( ��� � ( M ! � � � � ( � � � + � � � M � � � � # 7 � J�� (�� � N � � � � ( � � � ( � 7 N � ��'"� �(� D J � G ( �=# � � � + � � � # !��%��9 ��K � J�!&��� � G (� ! � ! � � J � G ( � � � � � ( � � � � � � � � # � (�� � # � ! #@#���� � ��( � ��� ��K ( � � � M � " ����'"� � � D J � G ( �I# � � � + � � � # !��%�)9@��K � J���! ( KF����� � � ! �! � � J � G ( � � � � � ( � � � � � � � � # � (�� � # � ! #;#&��� � � ( ����� �$K ( � � � + � ��K � ( � G ���LJ ��� � � ( J�!&��� � G ( � �� ������� � � �� "('! &�"����'( " '"� � J�!-� ( G ����� ( ! � � � ( �%� ��� ( � (�� � G � J�� (�� �0� � � � � ( � � � ( �{'"� � � ��� � � � � ( � #&� � � � � ( � �)��� � J � ( !&��� � + � �,J � G � J G8G ����� ( ! � � � ( � �� � C)� � G ����� ( ! � � � ( � B F|S 5 � � � � � N � � � � � + ! ( � � ( � � � � + � �I# ( � � KF��� ��� � � �=C � � ( ��K ! + � � � �

� ��'"� � � � D ��� + � � � � � � ( � � � ( �%�!# B � ��� � � � ��� �B � M !&��� � G ( � � � � # S*� � � ��� ( 5 � � ���)C ( � ( � � � � � � J���! ( KF��� � �)�( � N K � J���! ( KF��� � � G ��� (�� ��� � J�!�� � � G ( H � � ( � + � ($� � ��� G ��� (�� � � ��� � � � # ����� � ��� � ��K J�!&��� � G ( � � � � # � � �S<� N K � J���! ( KF��� � � G ��� (�� ��� � J�!�� � � G ( S ( � � � � ( � + � ( G ��� (�� � �XJ�!&��� � G ( 6 �

.

Page 61: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� � � � ���� � �� ����������� &�� ��� � � ��� � � � � ��� ���� ��� � �� �� � � �

� ������� � " �� � "$� ��"�� � � &��"$'�� ��� " ���! ��� ���� ���

'"� � � #&� � � � ( � G � � ����� K � ( � � � � ( ��K � ���<J ��! ( KF��� ���>�I5 � ( � � � + �*5 � !8��K^J�!&��� � G ( � ( � �I� G ��� (�� ���Q� D � � ( � � �;� (�� ! ( �I5 � J�� G 90� �=C� ! � � # ��� J�!�� � � G ($� � ���=C ( � � � + 5�� � ( �$KI5 � � ( J���! ( KF����� ��� � 5 ( ( � � � � D ( � (�� C � � � � + G �����)� #&� ! � � � �LJ���� �=C �$KIJ ��! ( KF��� ���>�G ��� (�� � ��� �=C ( � �*J�!&��� � G ( � � � ( � ( � � G ����� ( ! � � � ( ( � � ( ��� � �$K ( � � � � + � ( 5 � ( � � ��� � � � � (�� ! ( �I# � � ( �Q� N � � � � � + 5�� � G + � � (� (�� C � � � � � 9 �4� J � #�# � �=C � � � �LJ�� ���=C���KQJ�!&��� � G ( ��� � ��! � � � � ! � � ( � � G �;� (�� C � � � � � ��� � ! � G + � ! � � + !�J���! ( KF��� � ��� ( �*5 �%� � ��� #� � # � � ����� � 9 �4� J ( ����� � G ������� #&� ! �I# 5 � � ( �� � ( � G � ( � � ( � � G � ����� ( � � � � � � G ��� J � ! � ( � � J���! ( KF��� � ��� �M_ � � G � � � � � � � � G ( ���=C ( � � 5 � � ( J ��! ( KF��� ���>� � � � ��� � ����� �

9 � � J ( ���>� � J���! ( KF��� � ��� ( � � ( � ��( �%�PK � ( � � KF��� � � � ���=C � N ( � � M � � �ZC�! � � ( � ! ( � � � ( � � � M � �$K � � �^J���! ( KF��� � ��� ( � ��( � � � � � � �&���! � G +(� � !&� ��93�

� ������� ������� #%��! "

300000 600000Risk

500000

1·106

1.5·106

2·106

2.5·106

Net Value

PSA

Non PSA

� ����� � � �%��! " �� ' ����� �� N ��� ( � � � ! � � + � ( � �)��� � ( � ��( � #�# ���)CE5 �0��� � � � ( � J � G ����� ( ! � � � ( � # � � � ��� ( � � G ( ( � � ��� G � � � ( KF!���� ( � � ! � � ! � � + G �Q� ! �����)C� + ! � J=J�!&� � G � � � � � � � � ��� ( � G �=# ( � � ( � � # � # � " ( � �%��� ( � � 5 � � ( J���! ( KF����� ��� � '"� � J���� ( 5 � ��� � K + ! ( � � ! � � � + � ( ! � ( � � ( ��� �J���� � ( �

100000 200000 300000 400000 500000 600000 700000Risk

500000

1·106

1.5·106

2·106

2.5·106

Net Value

N � ( � � J���� ( ( � �3# � ( � ! � J�! � � � � ( � ���QJ���! ( KF����� ���"��� ($� � � ��K � ��� G � � ��( �%�PK � ( � � 5��0��� � � � ( � J � G ��� � ( ! � ��� ( � � D � � ��K ( � �( � � � ��� � ��! � J�! � � � � ( � ( � � ��� G � � � ( KF!&��� ( � � !OKF��! � ���"J ��! ( KF��� ���>� � � # ( � � � ( � � !8! � J�! � � � � ( � ( � � ( KF��! ( ���>� � ( � � ( � � ( � �,K � ( � �5��>��� � � � ( � J � G ����� ( ! � � � ( � �{'"� � ( � � ��� � � � � ! ��� � ! � G � ��� � ( � � � G �;� ( � � ! �

N ( �)��� + � # 5 � ��� ( �=# ( � � ( ( � �3# � (�� C�� � � � ( � + �Z5 � � � ! � 9 � � �"��� ( � ( !����=C�� � G ��!�! � � � ( �I# �

.

Page 62: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� B � � ������� � �*� ��� � � ��� �!� � �� ����������� & � ��� � � ��� �� ������� � �6"$' � � � �� � � ������"�� � " �!�� �� � _ � ! � � � + � �I# ( � � ��!�� C�� � � � � � J�!&��� � G ( � � � # � � #�� + J � ��� ( � � ! � �$K ( � � ��!�� C�� � � � ��� � � + �����)C ��� � � � ! G ���*5���� ��( � ����� � � ���! #&� ! ( � �$5 (�� � �;����C�� � ! G ��!�! � � � ( �����E5 � ( � � � � ����� � ��K ( � � J�!�� � � G ( ���='"� � G ��!�! � � � ( ����� � � ( !&��D �$K ( � � � � ( ��K � � J�!&��� � G ( ��%� � � � 5 � � � � � ( !&��D � ( �0� � � ! C � ( � 5 � ����� � � � �?K + � � � � ! � � '"� � J !&� ( � � G ��� + �$� � � ! � �

������������

�� ������������ � � ������ � ��� ������ � / ���� � / �������� � ���������� ��� / � �� ��� - ���� � � ������ � � �� � � ���� � � ��� �� ������������ � � ��� ���� � / � ���� ��� �9� ���� � � ���� � � � �!���� � - � ���� � /*) ���� � � � �� � � �� � ��� ������ � � ��� �� ���������� � � � ������ � / � ���� � � ) �!���� � � � � ���� � ��" ���� � � ������ � " / � � � ���� � / � ���� � / � ���� � � � � �� ������������ � ������ ��� /]/ ���� ������� ���� � � ������ � � ������ � ��� � � �� � / ������ ��� �9� ���� � / � � ���� � ��� �� ������������ � ���������� � ) ���� � � �������� ��� � �#�� � ) ���� � � ���� � ����� ���� � � ���� � � ) ���� ��� /]/ ���� � ����� �� ���������� � ��� �$�� � � - ������ � )]/ � ���� � )]/ � � � ���� ��� / � �� � � � ������ � � � � ���� ������� ���� � ) ���� � ��� � �� �������$�� � � ���� � ) � ���� �������� � � �� ��� - �%���� � - � � ���� � ��" � ���� � � ������ � � ������ � � - ���� � � � �� ���������� � � - ���� ��� ) � � � �� � � ������ � /X) ���� � � ���� � � ������ ��� � �&���� � )]/ ���� � ) � �$�� � � - � �� ������������ � ����� � � �� � � ���� � � � ������ � " / � ���� � ������ � ) �������� � )]/ ���� �������$�� ��� ) � ���� � ����� �� �������� � � �� � ) �������� � - � � ���� � � � ���� � � ������ � ������ ����� ) �� � � � �$�� ��� ������ � � ���� ��� � / � � ���� � � � ���� ��� �������� � � ��� ���� � � / � ���� ��� � ) ���� � � � ���� � - ���!���� � )]/ ���� � / " ���� � � ���� � � ���� � � / � ���� � -X- ���� ��� ������ � � �������� � � ������ ��" ������ � �9 �!���� ��� -]/ ���� � ��� ���� � / � � � � �� � - �������� � � - � ���� � ) ������ � - ������ � / �������� � ���������� � / ���� � � ) ������ ��� 9 �� � ������ � � �� � ) ������ � ) � ���� � � ) ���� )]- ������ " � �������� � � / ������ � "�� ���� � � ) ���� ��� � �� � ) ���� � �

'�((((((((((()

5 C � � � � ��� � �$5 (�� � ��� ����� � � � ! ! � � + � ( � � � � � ( � � G � � � ��K ( � � � � ��!�� C�� � � �^J�!�� � � G ( ���C'"� � C�! � J��?5 � � � � ! � J�! � � � � ( � ( � �! � � + � ( �"��K � + ! � ��C���!&� ( �%� �

200000 400000 600000 800000Risk

500000

1·106

1.5·106

2·106

2.5·106

3·106Net Value

PSA

Non PSA

� �����+* � "$' � � %! ���"$' > � � � + � # � ��9 � � � � � G ��� G � + �)� ��� � ( � ! � � � � ����� � G + � � ( � ��� � � � # C�� � � � + ! � � � � �"! � C � ! # � �=C ( � � � ! � � � � � !-���

� � >�� � � � � � � � � � � � !'C � � + �R5 � !3��K J�!&��� � G ( � � � � � � �I# ( �'� (�� ! ( G ���0�������=C � ! � � # ��� � + �R5 � !3��K J���! ( KF����� ��� ��(� � G �@� ( � JQ�.H � � � � ( � � �QC � ( ( � � � GIG + ! � G � �$5 (�� � � �I# � � � + ! G � � � �B � N ( �%� ��� ( � � G � ��� � ! � ( � � (�� ! ( � � ( � � F J�!&��� � G ( J ��! ( KF��� ���>��� 7 � � � � KF��! � D � �LJ�� � � (�� ! ( � � ( �-,9F J�!�� � � G ( ��J ��! ( KF��� ���>�

� � � ! � ,/.10 � � � # 0 � � ( � � � + �R5 � ! ��K J�!�� � � G ( � ��� ( � � G ��� J � � � " � # ��(�� 5 � � � �( � N �"� ( J����&�)� 5�� � ( � � � !'C � ( ���%� � J=J�!&� � G � � � ( � � � ! � 9 " � G + !&! � � ( � ��� ( � F)7 � !&� � � J=J�!&� � G � �> � 5 � ��� ��� � ( � � � � � � � !-� ( � ( � � � � G + � � ( ��������� ��C�� ( 5 � �$K"C�! � � ( � � � J ��� � G ��� ��� � �=C 5 � ()( � ! � G�G + ! � G � KF��! ( � � J���! ( KF����� �� � � � � ���%� �)�$K ( � � ! � �.N � ( � � �)����! ( ( ��� � � � � � # KF��! ( ��� � � (&+ # � � � � G � + � # ��� ( � � 9 � � ��� ( � � � � G � ��� � ! � ( � � ( � �C'"� + � � � �� + � ( � � � ( � ��( ( � � � ��� � � ! ( � ( � � J !&� ( G + � � ( � ���@� � + ��90��� � � ( � + ���H � J � � # � �=C ��� � + !�C�� � � � ( � � � ��� � � ! ( �G + � � ( � ��� B G � �U5 � � � � � ��K � � � J=J�!�� � G � � + G � � � � + !&� �%� + � �I# ( � ! � J�� �

� � ! � 9#" � G + !&! � � ( � � #�� �W� > � G � � � � �)� � � ��� � C�� � � � ��� (&+(� ( ����� � � � ! � � � � �E��/ ( V � � + � # 5 � � 5�� � ( � � � � � G ( G � ! (�� � �J���! ( KF��� � ��� � � # � �)9EKF��! � ! � J�� � � � � ( �$K ( � � ! � � + � ( + �����)C$� + ! M � 5 � N � ( ���%� G � � � � � � � � + � # � + � ( � (�� ! ( KF!&��� ( � � C�� � � �, �78��� G � !&��� �=C � + ! � � � ( J ����� ( � � K ( � � � ��� � � ! ( � ( � � J�!-� ( � � � � C ��( � � � � � � 5 � � � ��� � � � G � + � # � ( � ��� + � � � + ! � J=J�!�� � G � � �� � ��J ( � ��� � �)J � ( � KF��! ( � � � � # F + � � ! � � � C)� � ( �3! � J�� � ! � � + � ( � � � � �.J�!&�$J���� �I# � 5 � � � �;'"� � + � � ! � � + � # � + J)J�� � ( � � J�!&��� � G ( �� � # � � � � + � # 5 + � � # ( � � J���! ( KF����� ��� + �����=C � + ! � J=J�!&� � G �Q�GN � ( ��� � G � � � � ( � � + � � ! ����� + � # 5 � � � � ! � ( � ��( ��� � ��! � ( � � �� G � ! (�� ��� � + �R5 � !8�$K3J�!�� � � G ( � G � � 5 � � � � � G ( �I# ' ( ���%��� + �R5 � ! #&� J � � # � �=C ��� ( � � G ���LJ + (���( � ��� � � G ��� ( ��K � + ! � J=J�!&� � G �Q�

.

Page 63: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� ����� �����& � ��� ��& � � � � � ������� �� � � � � � � � � � � � (� ��� � � � � � � � � � + � # � � 9 � ( ��� � � ( � ��� ( � ��( � � � � + ! �)��� + � ��( � ����� � � ! �@# ��� � + �)� �=CU� � ( � � � ��( � G � �)�$K ( � � ! � � $ � � �

( ��� + C��L� � ( � � � � ( � G � �%� � C��>� # ����K ( � � ! � KF��!��)��� + � ��( � ��� � � ( �%� G � ! (�� � ��� � ( ! + � ( � � ( � + G � K � � ( � ! G � #&� G � � 5 � J�!&� # + G �=#+ �����)C'7 KF��! � ��� (�� � G � �L� ��( � � � ��( � G � � � � � 5�� � ( � � � � # � � � � D0� ��+ � ( � � � � � � + J ( � � � J�!&��� � G ( � � � ( � � � � + ( � � � � ( ��� +�(� � � �$J ( ���$��� ��( � ���Q� N �XC � � � ! � � � ( ��� � � � � ��� ( � ��( ��� � G � �XC�� + J ( � B � J�!�� � � G ( � � � D � ��+ � ( � � � � � � � �;� � �&� ( � � � B �$� � + ( � � �� � ( ��� + ( G � + � ( � �=C � D J � ! ( J�!���C�! � �*� � !+" �8�$J ( ��� ��� ��( � ����� �

����� � ��� P8��[8;D �T8;DEA � 576 � ��: �O6BA � � ���B:=< ��A �� � �*5 � !-� ��K ( � � � + 5)C�!&� + J � ��� G � #&��� � � �$J �I# ( ���%� � J=J�!&� � G � � ! � 1 � (�� 5 C$C � ! � � � � ��K ( � � ! ��� � � !-�)� ( � ��K$7 � � C � ! � �� ! � � # � _ � � 90��� � � � # ' � � � ! � ; ����� � 9 ��K ( � � ! ��� � � !&��� ( � �$K 5 � 5 � ! (�� � � � # � � � � 1 �4�I# � � � � ' � � � � � # 8 + � � ��� ��� +��K ( � � ! ��� � � !&��� ( � �$K � � G ( ��!&� � � '"��� � � J=J�!&� � G � � D J�����! � � ( � � G + � � ( � ��� �$K � � ��( G ����� ( � (�+ ( � � � ,�(���A � � ( /�� � &��B. �>/ ��KJ���! ( KF��� � � � � � + � �8� � ( � � � � ��� � ( � � ("( � � G ��� � � ( " � ,$( / . V (-, ! % ��� ,�( �3! ( ���@�$5 (�� � ��� �=C � ����� + ( � ��� ! ��% / ( � % ( � � ( ! + � �$J ( ��� � �J���! ( KF��� � � � � � + � G � �_5 � �,J � G � J �I# � � # � � ( � �*J �I# � K � #&� G + � ( � � � �LJ���� �=C � � G � !�!&� �=# � +�( �$'"� � � #&� � � ��K G ����J #&� � G � � � #G � ��� � ( � ( � � ( ! + � �$J ( ��� � � � ��� � � �%���R5 �3# �%� G + ��� �I# � ��! � ( ����!�� + C���� � �$ � � ! � J ��! ( KF��� ��� �%� G ���LJ���� �I# ��K � � + �R5 � ! ��K J�!�� � � G ( � � � � G �@��K � ��� G � � � � 5 � � �&�)� G � � ( �I# � � ( � � � !&� � + � # �%� ( !�� 5 + F( � ��� � � � � # G ��� � ( ! � ��� ( � ��� + �LJ ( � ��� ��� ����! � D � �LJ�� � � � J � ! ( � G + � � ! J�!�� � � G ( � � � � � � ��� � �8# !&��� � ���=C � �3����� � � � �[�B'"� � ! � � + � ( �� � ��� G � � � � ()( � �LJ ( �%� + � +(� � � � � � #&� ( � G + � � ( ��K � � KF��! � D � �LJ�� � � ( � � � � ( ! � (&+ !�� � �$K8� + G � � # !&��� � � � ������ ( 5 � 90��� � �J�!&����! ( � ( � � # !�� ��� � �=C � ��� � ��� � ! � � � #�� � ��K ( � �7� � !&��� + �IJ����&�)� 5�� ��� ( � � ����! ! � � + � ( � + ( G ��� � � � � � � 5 � � #&� G +(� ( � � � � D J�! � �&� �I#5 � � J=J�� � � �=C � # � � ( !&��5 + ( � ��� � � � �&� + �LJ ( � ��� ( � ( � � � � J����&�)� 5�� ��� ( � � � � N � � #�# � ( � ��� � � � C � � � �&� + � ��� � � # � G (�� ( � G ����� ( ! � ��� ( ���� ( � ��# !�� ��� � �=C;�$K ( � � � � � �W� '"� � ( � (�� � J���! ( KF����� � � ( � � ��K � � � � � ��� 5 � � + 5 � � G ( ( � � �&� + � J ( � ����� � � # G ����� ( ! � � � ( � � � + G �� �Z5 + # C � (�� ! � � � # ! � �)� + ! G � G ������� #&� ! � ( ������� � � � # � ��!"! � � ( !�� G ( � � � ! � � � ( �������)����J���5 � ( � �4� �?J����&����5�� � J�!&��� � G ( � �

� � � G � � � G � J���! ( KF��� � � �%� + � + � � � � G ���LJ �>� �=# �$K J�!&��� � G ( � � � ( � + � G � ! (�� � � ! � (�+ !���� � ( � � ! � (&+ !&� ��� � � � J � ! ( � G + � � !J���! ( KF��� � � � ( � � ��K8�%� � �%�)� + � G � ! (�� ��� � � # ( � � ! � KF��! � � ����� G � � ( �I# � � ( � ����� � J�!���5 � 5�� � � ( �'# �%� ( !&��5 +�( � ���Q� M ! � � � � ( J�! � G ( � G �� �&����C���� � � G � J���! ( KF����� � � < � �BA)( � 5 � � �I# ��� ( � � (��S&=( !�� (-, ! � (&+ !&� ��K ( � � J ��! ( KF��� ��� � � � # � V . / � � G ���0�>�)� �=C ( � � J ��! ( KF��� ��� �5 � � �=# ��� ( � � # �� � ! � � G � �*5 � ( � �4� � ( � � &=% /'/ . ? ��( ! � (&+ !�� �*KF��! ( � � J ��! ( KF��� ��� � � # ( � � � D J � G ( �I# ! � (�+ !&�Q� '"� � � � ( � �G +(� � ( � ( � � � � ! � G � � G + � � ( �I# + �)� �=C ( � �"# � � ( !&� 5 + ( � ��� � � � ��� + �LJ ( ������� � � # G ����� ( ! � � � ( � # � � G + �&� �I# � 5 � � � � � ��� G � � ! � � + J=J�� � �=#5 � � G � � � � ( � �%�)��� �=C ( � #�� G � #&� + J ��� � � + � (�� 5�� � J���! ( KF����� �)� 5 � � C � � � ! � � ! + � � � J���! ( KF��� � ��� � � ( � ��� C�� � ! � � � + � � ( � � # ( �� � � � ��� C�� � ! G ��!�! � � J���� # � �=C$!��%��9"�

5 � G � � 5 � C ��( � � ! �=# KF!&��� ( ���%� J�! � � ��� � � � ! � # � � G + �&������� � ( � � ! � � ! � G + � ( � � K � � � ��� + �LJ ( ������� � � # � J=J�!&�7D0��� � ( �������� � � ��� � �=# ��� G ���LJ + ( � �=C � � � �����=C�� � J���! ( KF��� � � � � � + � � � # !��%��9"� '"� � ! � KF��! � � � � ( ��� + C�� � ( �%� � � ! � � � � � ( � 5 � G ��� � � 5�����!'5 �I#� � ( � � � � � ! G ��KF��! ( � � ( � � ��! � ( � G � � � � � 5��)��� +�( � �$J ( ��� � � J���! ( KF����� � � � ( ����� + � # 5 � 9 � J ( ��� � ��� # ( � � ( ��� � ��� K ( � � ( � � ��! � ( � G � ��$J ( ��� � � � � ! � ( � 5 � #&� J � �I# � � ��� ( � � KF��� � � � ���=C # �%� G + ����� ����� � � � # KF� + � #

� � ��� G �;� � � �>� ( G � � � ���%� � � ( � � !8��� ( J����&����5�� � ���� ( K � � ��� 5�� � ��! 5�� ( � ��( J�! � � � � (�� � � ( � � + � # 5 � 5 � � �I# ��� ����� � � J)J�!��7D ��� � ( �=# � � � 5 � � ( � D J � !�� � � G � F 5 � � �=# � �=J + ( � C�� � � �5 � ( � � G ��� � � ( � '"� � G ��� G � + �)� ��� ( � ��($( ���%�RJ���! ( KF����� � � � � � � ! � � ��� ( � � �F ( �$J ( ��� � �"��� � �%� � ��� ��� ( G � ! (�� � ��� � ��� G ��!&! � G ( �_ � � ��� � ! � C�� � � � ( � � � � KF��!"� � ( ����� � � � � � � 5�� � �%� ( � � 5 � � (*( � ��( � � � � � � � ( � � � 5���� � ( � ( �?J � # ( � � ( � � ��! � ( � G � ��� � �$J ( ��� � �J���! ( KF��� � � � � � # J � !�� � J�� � ( � � !-� � � ( � � ( ! � C�� ��� � � � + � # 5 � + � � K + ���� � � 90���)C � � ��� ( � ��� � C � � ( #&� G � ��� ���Q� � � � �I# ��� ( ��� �! � � ���������=C � 5 � ���)C ��� ( � � V ( / .1% � �$K ( � � ( � � ��! � ( � G � � ��J ( ��� + � � � ( � ��� C�� G ����J #&� � G � �%� � � � ! � ! � � ����� � 5�� � (�� ! C � ( KF��! �G � � � � ( �

6 � ( + � � + J=J���� � ( � � (@( � � ! � � ! ��� J����&����5�� � J���! ( KF����� ���,� �4� ( � �=C ( � � ! � G + ��! �I# G ����� ( ! � � � ( � � � � # ( � � ! � KF��! � �� �&��� G � ��( �=# J�!���5 � 5���� � ( � # �%� ( !�� 5 + ( ������� � C�� � � �=C � � � � + � � � # !��%�)9 J � ��!-��� � + � ( � ��K ( � � � � �%� + ��90��� � � � ��� � ��� � ! � � � ! �+ � +(� � � � � 5�� � ( � J + ( � ( � � � � ( �)��� � !&� + C�� G ����� ( ! � ��� ( ���� � � N � ( � � �����LJ�� � G � � � � � � ! � ( � � ! � � ! ��� J �>����� 5�� � J�!�� � � G ( � �� � # � � G � J�!�� � � G ( �%� � � ( � � ! �$J ( �I# ��� ( � ��!"��J ( �=# � + ( ��K � � � G � �@� � � ( � � ( ��� B�� � N �?J�! � G ( � G � � �)��� � J�!�� � � G ( � � � �� �%���?5 � ��J ( �=# � � ( � ��( � � ��� ( � � � K + � � G ���*� � ( � � � ( � KF��! � D � �LJ�� � ����� � J�!&��� � G ( � � � � � � ��� � G ���*� � ( � � � ( � ��� � �%� ��K��� � � ��� � ��! � � � � ��78����� ( ! � � � ( � � #�#&�I# ( � ( � � J���! ( KF��� � � � � � � #&� ( � !�� ��� � ��� � � � � � J���! ( KF����� ��� � ! � � � ���$� � ��( �I# KF!&���( � � G ����� � G ( � ��� ! � J�! � � � � ( �I# 5 � ( � � + J=J � !�5�� + � # ��� � � N � �)� (�+ � ( � ��� � � � � ! � ( � � 5 � + � # ��� � � � ��� ( ( �0� � � !'C � KF��!� D � ��+ � ( � � ��� � + � � ! ��( � ���$��K^J ��! ( KF��� ��� � � � + � � � � # !&�%�)9 � � � �

# ����� + � ��( �=# J�!���5 � 5���� � ( ��#&� ����� ( � � �IKF��! ! � (�+ !���� � � � D � ��+ � ( � � �� � + � � ! ��( � ���@� � ( � � � � ( ��� # (�� 9 � � � � � # � (���( �%� ( � G � � � � �LJ�� ���)C � � # ��� K � ! � � G � ( � G ����� G + � �"� �4�=# ��� ( 5 � � J=J�� � �=# �� � ( � G � ( � ��( ( � � G ��� � � G ( �����3��K � � � + � � � � D J � G ( �I# ! � (�+ !&��� � � ( � � ��K G � �*5 � � �4� � � � � � � � � + ! � � � � ( � ��� ( � � J��$J + � � ( �����

��K � � � � J����&����5�� � J ��! ( KF��� ���>��� � ��� G ��� � G �RJ���! ( KF����� � � � � + � � � ( � ��� D J � G ( �I#�� � � + � ��K �)��� �"# � � ( !&��5 + ( � ��� � ��� G ���%� � !�!&� � �I#� ( ( ��!&� + C�� # �� � ! � � ( � J����&����5�� � G ��� ( ��� + � + � � # �%� ( !&��5 +�( � ��� � � � �&� + � J ( � ����� � G ����� ( ! � � � ( � � � ( G � � ( � � ����C���� � + ����� 9 � � � ( � ��(� � � ( � � ��K ( � ��� J �>������5�� � � � � + � � � ��� �Z5 � ( � � � � � � � '"� � � (�� � # � ! # J�!�� G �I# + ! � � � � ( � � G � � � � � � ! � ( � � � + �*5 � !��K�J �>������5�� � J ��! ( KF��� ���>� �%� ( �0� � � !'C � ( � � � + � � ! � ( � � D � ��+ � ( � � � � � � � # ( �0� G ���LJ�� � G � ( �I# ( � ��()(�� G 9 � � � � � ( � G � � � � � � ( �

.

Page 64: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� S � � ������� � �*� ��� � � ��� �!� � �� ����������� & � ��� � � ��� �! � � # ��� � � � � � J�� � � J�! � F #�� ( � !"� � � �I# � + �R5 � !�� ��K + ���.G + � J���! ( KF����� ���.KF!���� ( � � J��$J + � � ( ����� ��K^J����&�)� 5�� � J���! ( KF��� � ��� � � #�$5 (�� � � ( � � � !�� G ��!&! � � J ��� # � �=C � � � + � � � ( � � ( � � � ( � �$5 (�� � � � ! � � # ��� � � � J�� � � � � ( ��� +�( ! � J�� � G � � � � (�� ��K������ � � KF!&���( � � J�!&�$5 � 5���� � ( � � � �&��K + � G ( � ��� KF��! J ��! ( KF��� ��� � � � + � ��� '"� � J���! ( KF��� � � #&� G � #&�=# + J ��� G � + � # ( � � � 5 � ( � � � � !'C � � ( ��K ( � �� � � � J�� �=# � N � � #�# � ( � ��� ( � ( � � G � ! # ��� � � � ( � � ��K ( � � J�!&�$5 � 5�� ��� ( � � � ��� K + � G ( �����_5 � � �=C + ��90��� � � � ( � � � + J)J ��! ( ��K( ��� � J�!���5 � 5���� � ( � � � ��� K + � G ( ����� � ( �

� ! � �=C � ��K � � ��� � � 5�� � J ��! ( KF��� ��� � � � + � � � �%� � � ��� + ��90��� � �Q� � ��� � � � ! ! � � ���������=C G � �5 � � J=J�� � �I# ( � � � ! # � ( � � G ��� � � G ( � ���@��K J���! ( KF��� � �$!&�%�)9 � �

D + ! � J=J�!&� � G � � � � ( � #&� J�� � � � �$J ( ��� � � J���! ( KF��� � � � � ( � � ( � ��� G � C � � � ( � � � � D ��� + � � � � + � ��! � D J � G ( �=# ! � (�+ !&�KF��! � � J � G � J �=# V . / ? . � � 5 !&� ��9 5�� � � � (�� 9 � � ( �L5 � � ! � �)C � ��K=G + � � ( � J �I# !&� ��9 � ��� G � ( � � G ��� � � ( �%� G ���RKF��! (�� 5�� � � � ( �� � # � � # �� � ! � � (*( �<� > � � � ��� � ��� + � � ( � � ( 0 �%� ( � � � + �*5 � ! ��K � ��� � � � 5�� � J���! ( KF��� � ��� ��� ( � � � J � G � J �I# !��%�)9 5�� � � � � #( � � ( � V&� � ,�% � � � �LJ�� � ��K�� � � � + � � G � �U5 � � (�(�� ��� �=# KF!���� ( ��� � !��%��9]5�� �Q� > � � ��� � � � ��� � �&� + � � ( � ��(3( ��� � ! � � # ���� � �LJ�� ���=C � J=J�!&� � G � � � ���G5 � � J=J�� � �I# � � G � � � � � � � ! � 0 � � J�!������ 5�� ( � � � � � � � !'C � ( � � � + � � ! � ( � � � � J���! ( KF��� � � � � � + � � � � #!&� ��9 � ��� ( � � �,J � G � J �=# !��%�)9_5���� � D � ��+ � ( � � � � � � � � # � � � � � � � ( � G �)��� + ( ����� KF��! ( � � � � D ��� + � � � � + � �%� ��� ( � ()(�� � � � 5�� � �'"� + � � � � (�� ( � � ( � G � � � J=J�!&� � G � ( � #�� G � # � �=C + J���� � � + � (�� 5�� ��� � � + � ��K��UC�� � � � � #&� �)� ! �I# G ����J #&� � G � � � # ! � �=C � �$K!��%�)9�%� ! � G + � ! �I# ��N ( ����� + � # 5 � ��� ( �I# ( � ��( + ��� � ��� � � � ! � � 5�� � ( � � � � ( � !&� � � � � � J (#� � + � (�� 5�� � J�!&�$5 � 5�� ��� ( �'# �%� ( !�� 5 + ( ����� ( �� � # � � � # +(� � G � � � � ( ��"�� � �LJ�� � �8��K�� J���! ( KF��� � � � � � + � � � � # + � � J � ! � � � ( !&� G ��� K � ! � � G � KF!&��� ( � � ( J ����� ( ��� � � ( � � ��� J���! (�� � (( � #&��� � ����J !&�$5 + � ( J�!&� G �I# + ! � ���

'"� � � + 5=C�!&� + J �$K � � � � � ( � C ��( ��!-� � D J�� ��! �I# ( � � KF����� � � ���)C$� J � G � J G G + � � ( � ��� ��KF!���� � � + �*5 � ! �$K � �=C�� � � �� >�� � ( � � ( � � G ����J #�� � G � � ����� G � � ( �=# � � ( �X5 � � �=C���� ( � � ( ��J � ��� � � ��K J����&�)� 5�� � J���! ( KF����� ��� � � � + � � � � K��_J ��! ( KF��� ���>�� ! � ! � � # ��� � � � � � J�� �=# �

� 7 � � � G ����J #&� � G � ��� ( � ! � � ��5 � �,J � G � J �=# KF��! ( � � � � ( ��� ��( � ��� ��K ( � � ( � � ��! � ( � G � ��� � �$J ( ��� � � � ����C�� � � ( J �>������5�� � �J ��! ( KF��� ��� � � � + � �

� ������� � � � '( &� � � �� � �� ���"$'1 ��5 + � ( ( � G ����� G + � � KF��!�J � ! G � � ( � � � � � ( ��� � ( ����� � � � � 5 �4� � � D J�����! �=# � ��� � � � 5��>��9 � ��� ��! #&� ! � (���( �%� ( � G � � � � � KF��! � D F� �LJ�� � � � H � � � # � �IH 6 � � � � # 5 !&����� # � � � � � 90!&� ����� � � � � # � � C � ! � � � � �=H�H2B � � '"� � � J=J���� G ��( � ���@��K ( � � � � ( � G �����.G + � � � � ���� J)J�� � ( � ( ���%� J�!&�$5�� � � � � � � � ��� � J�!�� � � #&�I# � � � ��� + � � ( � � ( ( � � ! � � # ��� � � �LJ�� � ��K �)��� � � ��K J���! ( KF��� � � � � � + � �ZKF!&��� �!&� ��9 5�� � �%��� + G �'�"� � � � � ! ( � � � ( � � !��%�)9X5�� � J ��J + � � ( � ��� 0 � � '"���%� �%� � � ��! #&� ! ( � � ( � � � � � � + � ( � K � ( � � � �&� + � J ( � �����K � J=J�!&�7D ��� � ( � � � � � �LJ�� � �=C�KF!&��� � � � ��J���� ( � J��$J + � ��( � ��� � �\'"��� � � �&� + �LJ ( � ��� �%� � G (&+(� � � � � G ��� � � ! � � ( � � � ��� � � ��� ( � ��(��K � ( # � � �"��� ( ����� # � ( � � ! � � + � ( �"��K ( ���%� � + 5�� � G ( ����� � ! � C � � � ! � ��� � � ( !����=C � ! ( � � �@� (���( �I# �

5 �)���LJ�� � � � # !���5 + � ( J�!���5 � 5�� � � � ( � G � ! C + � � � ( � � � 5 � + � �I# ( � #&� ( � !�� ��� � ( � � J�!&�$5 � 5�� ��� ( ��� ( � � ( ( � � , .� � � ! C � � (� � � + � � � ( � � � � �LJ�� � � � � � 5 � � � ( � � ( �$J � � � � � ��K J����&�)� 5�� � J ��! ( KF��� ��� � � � + � ��5 � � �=# ��� � � � �LJ�� � ��K ����� � � � � � � ! �� � ��C � � � ! � ��� � (�� 9 � � ( �X5 � � � � � ��� J�!&�$J���! ( � ���Q� D � G � ( � � � � �LJ�� � � � ��5 � � � (�� 9 � � � ( � � ( � !�� & V % ?&��? . � . �[# � + � ( 5 �! � J�� � G �I# 5 � ! % � � ,$( �"! ( ��(�<7( � � 78��� � � !&� � � � � KF��!^J=D �I# , � � � � � # #&� �)� ! �=# G ����J #&� � G � � ��� � � � � ( � � ! � G + � ! �I# � � �LJ�� ������ � � G � �U5 � #&� ( � !�� ��� �I# �B'"� ��� D J�! � ����������� C�� � � � ����� # KF��! G ��� ( � � + � + � # �%� ( !�� 5 + ( ������� ��K J���! ( KF����� � � � � + � � � � � � G �� � � ! � � G (&+(� � � � #&� � ��� �=C � � ( � � # �%� G ! � ( � # �%� ( !�� 5 + ( ����� ��K J ��! ( KF��� ��� � � � + � � � ( � � J�!&�$5 � 5���� � ( � � � � �$5 (�� � � �=# � � ! � � � � � 5 �� J)J�!��7D ��� � ( � ��� ���\'"� �I� � ��� �^5 ��� � ! � G � ��� � � J=J�!&�7D ��� ��( � ������� K � ( � � � 5 � � �&� + � �=# ( � � ( � ��( � � � � ("( � � ( �$J � ��� � � ��K �( � � # �%� ( !�� 5 + ( �����@�$KIJ ��! ( KF��� ��� � � � + � � G � �?5 � � J)J�!��7D ��� � ( �=# 5 � � G ��� ( ��� + � + � # �%� ( !�� 5 + ( �����Q� � � ( � G � ( � � ( ( ���%� ���LJ���� � �( � � ( ( � � ( � � ��! � ( � G � �(� � D # � � �8��� ( � � (�� � # � � ��� � � � '"���%� � � � �"5 � ���LJ���! (�� � ( ��� � + ! # �%� G + ����� ��� �$K � J=J�!&�7D ��� ��( � �=C ( � �� G (�+(� � � � D0��� + � J �>������5�� � J ��! ( KF��� ��� � � � + � � � ( � � � � D ( � � G ( � ���Q� ��!���� � D � � ��� � ( � ��� �$K ( � J�� G � �"J�� � ( � � � # # �%� G + �&�)� ��� �� � ( � ( � � � � # + � ( !&� � � � � � ( ��! � ( � � � � � ! � ��� ("+ ��! � � �)��� � 5�� � � �&� + �LJ ( ������� �\'"� � J�!���5 � 5���� � ( ��� � �ZC�� � � � � � KF��� ��� � � � > �� � ��� #�� ��� ( � ( � ��� .� ��! #�� ! � (�� ( � � ( � G � ��! #&� ! �=# � � � + � � ��� ( � � ! � � # ��� � � �LJ�� � ��K�)��� � � 5 ������� � �

� � � ��( � � � � ( , ��K ( � � � �$5 � � ! � �I# � � � + � � � ! � ���( � � ( �$J � ��� � � ��K J �>����� 5�� � J���! ( KF����� � � � � + � � �

�� ����� � � � � � � � ��� � � � � �

���� � �� ��� � � � � � � � � ��� � �

� � ��

.

Page 65: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� ����� �����& � ��� ��& � � � � � ������� �� � � � � � � � � � � ���

N ( �%� � � ����� � � �4� � ( � � ( KF��!�, � � � � � ! � � � � ! � ����� � ��� ( � ! � � ( �I# � � ( � � J�!&�$5 � 5���� � ( � ��K ( � � � � !'C � � ( �$5 � � ! � �I# � � � + �5 � � �=C ��� ( � � ( ��J � � � � � ��K J �>����� 5�� ��� � � + � � � ( � � � 5 � � � � D J�! � �&�������EKF��! � ! �=# + G � � ( � � � � ��� � �� � � � �,J � G � K � � �=C �� � # � � ( �%� � � ��� � � � � ( � #&� ( � !�� ��� � ( � � ! � G + ��! �I# � � �LJ�� � ����� � � ��� ( � � G � � � , � � ����! � � !'C � ! � � � + � � ��K , � �)��� � � �=C

KF��! � � � ��� � � � ��� � � J ��� � �����$� � � !&�>� ( J�� # ���)C � � ��� G � �%� � � � # � �I# � � ( � � � � � + �����)C � � � �����LJ�� � � ��( � � � ��( � G � � ����K ( � � ! �( �0���[� 1 � G � � � ( � � ( � � � � � � � ( � � ( � ��� G � � G + � ��( �=# J ��! ( KF��� ��� � � � + � � � ! � 5 � � �I# ��� � J=J�!&�7D ��� � ( ������� ( � � � � � � � � � � � ( � � � 5 ���K C�! � � ( � !�J�! � G ( � G � � � � ( � ! � � ( ( � G ��� �)� #&� ! � K � � K � � �)� 5�� � J���! ( KF����� ��� ��� ( � � ( ��J_J � ! G � � ( ��� � � ��K J �>������5�� ��� � � + � � ! ��( � � !( � � � � �����)C�� � ��� � � � � # J � !&� � J��O5 � � � ( � � J�� � ��� � � � G ( � ��� �$K3J���! ( KF����� ��� ��� � ( � � ! G �����)� #&� ! ��( � ����� � + G � � � G ��� � � ��� � � G � �

5 (�� 5�� �3# � � J�� � � � �=C � � � � G ( �I# � � � + � �"�$K���&�, & � � � #�� KF����� � � ���

� � ��� � � � � � � B � � B � � B ��� � � � ����� � � �, � � ( � � � � ( � �� � � � � ��� � �2� � � � � �2� � ��� � � � � � � � ���� � � ( S � H�H S � 6�6 B � 6 ��� � � � � � H �oS � H�H ( � 6 � � � � ���

'"� + � � KF��! � D � � J�� � � ��K B ��� J���� � ( � � ! � � � �LJ�� �I# KF!&��� ( � � #�� ����! �I# !��%�)9 5���� � � � � � ��� � � � � � J=J�!&�7D ��� � ( � � � H ��

G ����J #&� � G � ( � � ( ( � � ( ��J � ��5�� � ! � �I# J ��! ( KF��� ��� � � � + � � � ! � � � ( ����� ( � � ( ��J ��� ��K � � �IJ����&�)� 5�� � J���! ( KF����� � � � � + � � � � � #� ��� ��� ( � ����� G ����J #�� � ( ( � ��(3( � � ��� C�� � � ( ��5�� � ! � �I# J ��! ( KF��� ��� � � � + � �%� � � ( ��� � ( � � ( ��J ��� �$K � ���OJ �>������5�� � J���! ( KF����� �� � � + � � �� ������� �� � � '( �����"$'( �� � �� � �� ���"$''"� � J�! ��� ��� + �*� � G ( � ��� ���]J � ! G � � ( � � �0� � ( ��� � ( ����� # �%� G + �&� �=# !&�$5 + � ( � � ( ��� # ��KF��! #�� ( � !"� � ��� �=C ( � � J�!���5 � 5���� � ( � �$K��$5=F� � ! � � �=C'��� � ��! � ��! � J���! ( KF��� � � � � � + � � ��� ( � � ( �$J � � � � � ��K � ��� J �>������5�� � � � � + � �3�$K J ��! ( KF��� ���>� � KF��! � � J � G � J �I# !��%�)95�� �Q�\_ � � ��� � ! � ( � � ( ! + � � � D0��� + � J����&����5�� � J ��! ( KF��� ��� � � � + � � � �8� ��� � ! � �&� + � �=# ����! � � ( ��� � ( �I# � N � K � G ( � ( � + � � ( � �( � G �����.G + � � �$K ( � � J�! ��� ��� + � � � G ( ����� � ��� ( ! + � � � D0��� + � � �4�=# � ( � � D � � ( � N � ( � � J�! � � � � ( G ��� ( � D ( � ( � � ! � � � � ( � � ��! � ( � G � �( ! + � � � D0��� + � J���! ( KF��� � � � � � + ��� � ��� G � ( � � G ��� � � ( #&� �)� ! � � ( ��5 � � ( ��! G � ��� � ( �)�]N � ( ���%��� � G ( � ��� � � � ��� � � D J�����! � J���� � (� � # ��� ( � ! � � � � � ( ��� � ( � ��� �$K ( � � � � � + �� 5 � � �I# ��� � ! � � # ��� � � �LJ�� � �$K �)��� � � ��K ( � � 0 J����&�)� 5�� � J ��! ( KF��� ��� � � � + � � � �� !��%��9 5�� �Q�

> � � ��� � � C � ��� � �&� + � � ( � ��( � � � � + G � �"� � � � � ! ( � � � 0 � KF��! � K ( ��� � � � ! � ��� (3( � � G � � � � � ��� J �>����� 5�� � J ��! ( KF��� ���>�� � + � # 5 ��� � + � � ! ��( �=# � > � � ��� � � � ��� � �&� + � � ( � � ( ( � � # � � ( !&� 5 + ( � ��� �$K�J���! ( KF����� � � � � + � � G � � 5 � � J=J�!&�7D0��� � ( �I# 5 ������ � � J � !�� � J��GJ�� � G � � � � �"# � � � ��� � (�� G ��� ( � � + � + � # �%� ( !�� 5 + ( �����Q� 1 � G � � � ( � � ( ( ��� � ���LJ���� � � ( � � ( ( � � ( � � ��! � ( � G � ��� � D ��� + �# � � �8��� ( � � (�� � # � ����� � � � 5 C � � � � ( ��� � � � � � � ( �*5 � � ! � � ����� � 5�� � � �&� + �LJ ( � ��� � ��� � ��� � ! � KF��! ( ���%�"� � G ( ����� � ( � � G ��� G � J (��K ��� ( � (�� � # � �=C � � ��� � �%� G � � !&� J �I# � � # G +(� � ( � J �=# ���� ������� ��������� ��! #"#$&%N � ( ���%� � J)J�!�� � G � � ( � � G � � � � ( � � + � # � � � ( ( �@90��� � ( � � J�!&�$5 � 5�� ��� ( � ( � � ( ( � � � !#� � D ��� + � �$5 � � ! � �I# J���! ( KF����� � � � � + �� � � � �%� � � ( �����('$��K ( � � ( ! + � � � D ��� + � J �>����� 5�� � J ��! ( KF��� ��� � � � + � � � � � � � ! � '$� � � � + �*5 � ! � J � !�� � J�� � J � ! G � � (�� C � ��K( � � � � !'C � � ( �$5�� � ! � �=# � � � + � � � J � G � J �I# 5 � ( � � G � � � � ( � N ( ����� + � # 5 � ��� ( �I# ( � ��( � � � J=J�!&�$J�!&� ��( � � � �LJ�� � �)��� � � � � 5 �G ���>� � � 5 � � � ( ��� # �"��� ( � � � � G ( � ���@���XJ � ! G � � ( � � � � � ( ��� ��( � ���Q� '"� � J�!���5 � 5���� � ( � � ��� G � � � � � ��� � � ( ��� ��( � � � ! � � ��� �Q5 �� � �)� � � G ���LJ +�( �I# � K ( � ! ( � � � � �LJ�� � � � ��5 �4� � �$5 � � ! � �I# � � � � J �>� ( F ��� G � � � � � ���%� � � � # ( � � ! � KF��! � � ��� � 5 ��� � � � �I# � � �G ����J #&� � G � � ��� � �W�

> � � � + � # � ��9 � ( � � � ( ��� ��( � � � � � � �*),+ � � ' & �.- � � � � � G � � � � � � � � ! � � # ��� � � �LJ�� � �$K�$5�� � ! � � ( � ��� � � ( � � J�!&�$5 � F5�� ��� ( � ( � � ($� � � �$5�� � ! � �=# � � � + � � � � �"��� ( � � ��� ( � ! � � � + � � ' & �/- � � ( � � � � � � � � � � � � '"� � ! � KF��! � �

� � � ( � � � � ( ��� � ��5�� � ! � ��( � ���;�%� � � + � � ' & �.- � ��� � ��� � ���

� � ( � G � ( � � (( ��� � � D J�! � �&�)� ���$� �>��9 � � � ! � ����� � � � ! ( � ( � � 5�� �����$� � � � + � � D J�! � �&�)� ���RKF��! ,# � ��� ( � � J�! ��� ��� + �� � G ( �������� J � ! G � � ( ��� � � � ( ��� ��( � ���Q� _ � � ��� � ! � � � ( ���%� G � � � � � � � ��� ( �,J � G � J �I# 5 � ( � � G ��� � � ( � ! ��( � � ! � ( �%� �)��� � ( ��� �=C � ��� G �� + � ( 5 �0� � ( ��� � ( �=# KF!&��� ( � � # ��(�� � � ��! #&� ! ( � � !&!&� � � � ( � � � J)J�!��7D ��� � ( � J�!���5 � 5�� � � ( � � 5 �&� + � ���=C ( � � # �%� ( !�� 5 + ( �������K � � � + � �Z5 � � � � � �"����� � � � !�� � � � + � � � � � ' & � � � � - � � # + � � ' & �/- � � � � � ��� � ( ��� � ( � � 5 �

� + �*5 � ! �$K ��5�� � ! � ��( � ����� � � + ��� � � � ' & � � � ��-� �

.

Page 66: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� � � � ������� � �*� ��� � � ��� �!� � �� ����������� & � ��� � � ��� �'"���%� � J=J�!&�7D0��� � ( ����� � � + � # 5 � ! � � ����� � 5�� � ��K ( � � # �%� ( !&��5 +�( � ��� ��K^J���! ( KF����� � � � � + � � � � ! � � �&� + � �I# ( ��5 � � � � � + ����KF��!�� � �� � + ��� � � � ' & �/- � 78���>�>�)� �=C � � � �LJ�� � �)��� � � � !'C �0� ��� + C�� ( � ��(*( � � ! � � � � ! � � ����� � 5�� � J�!&�$5 � 5�� ��� ( � ��K"� � �LJ���� �=C � K � �� � � + � �3��� ( � � ��� C�� � ! J � ! G � � ( � � � ��5 � + �)� �=C ( � � ( � G ����� G + � � # �%� G + �&� �=# � � ( � � J�! ��� ��� + � � � G ( ����� ����� + � # � ��� G � ( � C��0� #� #&� � ��K ( � � �)� � J � �$K ( � �3# �%� ( !�� 5 + ( ����� � ��� � � ��� ( � � (�� � �%� � ��� � G � ( � � � � � J���� �=C � � ! � � # ��� �� ��� �$&����������� ���� ��! #"#$&%'"� � � #&� � �$K � ��9 � � �����0� # ��� ( � ! � � � � �%� � D J�� ��! �I# � KF��! � D � �LJ�� � � ��� ; � � 5�H � � � G � � � ��� + � � B � �=H 6 � � � � # 1 � � � ��� � �IH�H � � � N �( � � J�! � � � � ( �)� (�+(��( � ��� � ��� 9 � ��� ���0� # J ����� ( � � ( ��� � ( ����� � � � � ! � � � (&+ � ( � � � � � � # ( � � ! � KF��! � � ��9 � � �����0� # ��� ( � ! � � � � � ! � � � � (�+ ! � �� � � ( � � � ( ��� � ( � � � '"� � � � ( � !'J�! � (�� ( � ���@��K � ��9 � � �����0� # ��� ( � ! � � � � G � � 5 � G ��� J � ! �I# ( � ( � � ( ��K ( ! � # � ( ����� � � G ����J #�� � G �� � ( � ! � � �%�*KF��! � � ! C � � � �LJ�� � �)��� � � � KF��! � D � �LJ�� � � ( � � ��+ ( ����!-� � � � ( � ��� �=# � 5 � � �@# � � G + �&� ( � � � � � ! � G + � � � � � � G � ��K �� S<��� � � � 9 � � � ���0� # ��� ( � ! � � � � � ( � � H ��� G ����J #�� � G � � � ( � ! � � � � � � # �� � � � � � 9 � � � ���0� # ��� ( � ! � � � � � ( � � H�H � G ����J #�� � G �� � ( � ! � � �^KF��! ! � C + � � ! # �%� ( !&��5 +�( � �����ZKF!&��� � ��� G � � � ! C � � � �LJ�� � �"� � � � 5 �4� � # ! � � �Q� 5 � � C � � � ! � � ! + � � � J���� � ( � � ����� #�� �� � � ��� 9 � ��� ���0� # � � ( � ! � � � � ! � � � 5 � � �I# � � � J�� ��+ �)� 5�� � � � � + � � �*KF��! ( � � J � ! � � � ( � ! � � � � # J���� � ( � � +�( ��� #&� � � � ��� 9 � ��� ���0� #� � ( � ! � � � � � � � � ! � ���LJ�� ��+ ����5�� ��� � � + � � � � N ( � � ��� J���! (�� � ( ( � ! � � ����� � � � ! � ( � � ( � � � � !GJ � ! G � � (�� C � � ��9 � � �����>� # ��� ( � ! � � � � � ! �� ��! � #&� �)� ! � 5�� � � � � � ! � � � � � ( � ( ! � # � ( ����� � � G ����J #&� � G � ��� ( � ! � � � � � ����C�� � !ZJ � ! G � � (�� C � G ����J #&� � G � ��� ( � ! � � � � � ! �*#&� ����! �I# �'"���%� �%� �)���LJ�� �@# + � ( � ( � � G ����� ( ! + G ( ����� �$K ( � � ��� ( � ! � � � � �N � C � � � ! � � � ( � � � � D ��� + � 6 ��9 � � �����>� # $8� ( ��� � ( � �$K � J � ! � � � ( � !��%� ( � ��� � � + � ��K ( � � J � ! � � � ( � ! � ��� G �,� � D ��� ��� � �( � � � ��9 � � �����>� # K + � G ( ����� �$K ( � � ��5�� � ! � �I#�# ��(�� � '"� � ��� 9 � ��� ���0� # K + � G ( � ��� � � �����LJ�� � ( � � J�!&� # + G ( ��K���� # � � � # +(� �J�!&�$5 � 5�� ��� ( � K + � G ( � �����ZKF��! ( � � ��5�� � ! � �I# # � (�� � � � � ( � � # ��(��*� ! � � ! � � # ��� � � �LJ�� � � > � � � ��� � �4� 9 !���5 + � ( � � ( ��� ��( � �� � # � � ( � ! � � �%� � � � ( � � � ����� � � � �&� + � J ( � ����� � � #&� ��� J�!���5 � 5�� � � ( � K + � G ( � ����� � � J � G � J G � � � � � � � � � ��� � ��� + � � ( � � ( ( � �# �%� ( !�� 5 + ( ����� ��K J ��! ( KF��� ��� � � � + � � G � � 5 � � J=J�!&�7D ��� ��( �I# 5 � � ( ! + � G � ( �=#

� J����&�)� 5�� � ��� ( � ! � � � J�� � G � � � � � � G ��� ( � � + � + �# �%� ( !�� 5 + ( �����Q� ����� ��� � � �=C # �%� G + �&�)� ����� � � ( � ( � � � � # + � ( !&� � � � � � ( ��! � � # � D � � ��� ��( � ��� �$K����� � � � �LJ�� ��# � (�� � � ( � �4� � �( � � ( � ( � �OG + � ( � G ���*� ���?KF��! ( � �3#�� ����� ( � ��K J ��! ( KF��� ��� � � � + � � ( � � J=J � � ! ( �E5 � ( ! + � G ��( �=# ��( � � '"���%��� � � 5 � # + � ( ���� � ��!�� ��! � �$K ( � � G ����� ( ! � ��� ( � � ����� G � � ( �I# � � ( � � J�!&�$5�� � �?�

> � � �&� + � � ( � � ( ! + � G ��( �I# # �%� ( !&��5 +�( � ��� (�� 9 � � ( � � KF��� ��� � � �=C KF��!�� � ��� � ��� �� � � � &

� � � � �

� & � ( � � ! � � � � �� � � ! � ��� � ��� � � ��� � � � � # � ��� � �%� � � � � � # � # �� � ! � � ( � � 5�� � G + � + � � ( � � �*# �%� ( !&��5 +�( � ��� K + � G ( �����Q� '"� � ��� � � ! 5 � + � # ���( � � � + J)J ��! ( � � �I# ��� ( 5 � � �

'"� � � ��9 � � �����0� # K + � G ( ����� KF��! � ! � � # ��� � � �LJ�� � �$K � � � � + � ��KF!&��� ( ���%� # �%� ( !�� 5 + ( �����@�%� ( � � �� � � � �

���� � ��� � �+ � ��� � -� & ����� � � � � & � . � � � � �

� � � G � � ��� � � + � (�� � � � � � G ! � � �)� ����� + � G ( ����� � ( ��� � � � 9 � � � ���0� # � � ��� (�� 9 � � ( � � ��� ��� + � � � � + � � ( � � � � � � � � # ( � + �� � � � � � ( � � � ��� ��� + � � � 9 � � � ���0� # � � ( ��� � ( � � � � � � ! �"!# �$� � � � ! � � �$% ����& � ��� 9 � ��� ���0� # � � ( � ! � � �'�F��! �)( � ! � � � ( � ! � � �*��� � � � � �

+ � � � ��� �-, & � �.�0/ �21� � � ! � � / �%� ( � � � ��� ��� + � ��� 9 � ��� ���0� # � � ( ��� � ( � � � � ! 53% � ��& � � ��9 � � �����>� # � � ( � ! � � �4�F��! � � � ( ��� � ( !&� � � � � � � ( � � ! � �F��! �

5 � � � ��� � � � � � � ��� � �6& � � � � � ��� � � � �87 �# � ��� � G � � � ��� + � � �9((� ! � � � ( !�� G �F��!"�:�F��!;� ��� � � �F��! � �%� � ( � � � � � ��� ( � !�� � � � � J (�( � ��� �3( ! + � G ��( �=#;# �%� ( !�� ��+ ( ����� ( � ( � �� � � � ! � �I# ! � � # ��� � � � ( � � � � ��� � G � � ����� � � ( ��� � ��� � G +(� � � ( �"!=< ��! � �%� � ( � � �>� ( � �3# �%� ( !&� ��+�( � ��� � � ( ��! ( �F��� � � � � � + � � G � �� � � �&� + � �=# ( � � � + ���>�F��!�� � �@# �%� ( !�� ��+ ( �I# ��� �

� � � � � ( � � � ( � � � ��9 � � �����0� # ��� ( � ! � � �'�F��! � � �5 � � � � � � � � �?& � � � � � � � � 7 &

.

Page 67: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� ����� ������ ��������� ��� � ������������� � � ��� � ��� �� � � � �

� � � ! � � � �>� ( � �*# �%� ( !&� ��+�( � ��� �"� ( ��! ( �F��� ��� � � � + � � G � � � � � ��� + � �I# ( � G ��� � �F!&��� � ( ! + � G ��( �I# � � ( ��� � � ( � � � # �%� ( !�� ��+ ( ������ � ( � � � � � % ��� � ( � � � ��9 � � �����>� # ��� ( � ! � � � � �

5 � � � � � � � � � � ����� % � & � � � �� % � � � ( � ��� � � � � ����� ��� 7 �

� � ( � G � ( � � ( � � G �@� � ( � � � � � � � � ( � � � � �&� + � � � ��( � # � ((� ! � � � ( !�� G �F��!�� �F��! ( � � #&� ����� ( � ��� � ��� � � � ��� � � � � ! ( � �� � ( ��! � ! � �4� � �"��� � � �)� � � � ( ��! ( �F����� � � � � + � � � � � � � � ! # ( �%� ( �>����� � � � ( � � ( ( � � # ��(�� � � + � # � � ��� � � + G � � #&� ���)� ( � ( � � �J ( ( � ( ��! ( �F��� ��� � � � + � � � ��� � ��� � ! � � � � ��� � ��� � � � � � � � #&� � �"��� ( � � ��� 9 � � ����� � � ("( � � ( ( ��� � � �"��� ( ( � � G � � �"!< ��!-� ( � � � � ' � � � ��!+" �"� � !&� � � � � ((� � �)� ���@� � ��� � ��� � � � � + ( � � � � � � � � � ��� � � + � ( � � ��� ( � ! � � �

( � � ���� � � �� ��� � � � � ��� � � � � � � /������ � � %

� ��� & 1 �D � � � � � ( !&� G �4�=# ( � � � (�� � � ( � � J�!-� ( ��! #&� !"��� 9 � ��� ���0� # � � ( � ! � � �'�F��! �( � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � &

�� ��� � � � � 1� � � ! � � ������� ((� ! � � � ( !�� G � � ( ��� ��( � �"� ( � � #&� ����� ( � � � � � ( � � � � � � � � � � +4� � ( � (&+ ( �=# �F��! ��� � � � �-( !&� � � #&�=# � �%� � � ! � �� ��� + ��� ( ��� � (�� � � � ���0� # � � ( ��� � ( � �"� ( ���%� � � � + � � � ��� � � � !�� � � � � � G ��� # ��! #�� !�� � 9 � � � ���0� # ��� ( � ! � � �(� � � � � � � (�� � � �I# � ������ � � ��� ( � � G +(� # ! ��( � G � G +(��( � ��� � !&� �����4� �F!&��� ( � � ' � � ����!�" � � � !&� � � � � ((� � �)� ��� � � � � �"! '"���%� � ��� �0��� � ��� � � ������� ((� ! � � � ( !�� G� � ( ��� � ( � �"� � � � � � � # �� � � � ��( � � � � �5 ��� ( � � ! ( ���&�)� � � � �"(�( !&� � G � � � ( � � ! � + � ( � ��( �)� � G � ( � � ��� 9 � ��� ���0� # � + � G ( ����� �%� ������� � � !&� ����� � �F��! � �6� � � � � ( ���%�"� �( � � ! � �������'� � � ��� G � � ((� ! � � � ( !&� G �F��!�� �F��! � � � � � � � # � � � ! � � + � ( � � � �"� � ��� � � � � � �I#&�=# � � � � (�� ����� ��� ( � � #&� �)� ! �I#� � ( � ! � � � ! ! � �F��! (&+ � ��( � � � � � � � � � � ��� # ��(�� � � ( ���%� � � ( � ! � � ��� # � � � G ������� #&� ! + ������� � � � � � � � � ,*� � ( � � +4(�( � !�� � � � ! � �I#��! #&� ! �=# � � � + � �3��� ��! #&� ! ( � � � ( ��� � ( � ( � � �)� � ( � � �*� ��� � � � ( � � ( ! � ������� � � ( � � � � � � � + � G � � � ( ( � � �&� + � � ( � � ( ( � �A! � #"�$ � � . �E� � ( � � # �%� ( !�� ��+ ( ����� � �F!���� � � � � � � ( � � G � � � � � (4( !�� � ��� � ( �=# � � � G ��� ( � � + � + � # � � ( !&� ��+ ( � ��� ��� ��� � ��� ( � ! � � �� � ��� � � ( � � � # ( � � � � � ( � � ����� � �"�8� � � � ! � �I# � � � + � �*����� + � # � � G ���>� � �'� � ! � � � ��� + ��� ( � � (#� ( � � � � ( , � � � + � �*� � ( � � �� � � ( � �I# � � � � � � ��� ( ���%� +�(�( � ! (�� ��� � � ( �;���>��� ( !&� �(�"� � ��� ( � � ( �

� � ��! � !�� ��+ � (�( � G �����.G + � � � � ( � � ( ! ��� ��� + ��� � G ( � ���,� � �� � + � �=# ( � #�� ( � !"� � � � � � � ! � � � ��� + ���@� � � ( � � ����� � �F��! ( ��� � � � (�( � ! G ��� # � ( ����� ' # � � �F��! � � � � ( � � � � ( �%�-� � � ( ( � ��( � ( �%�"� � � �( � � �&� + � � ( � � ( � ( % ��� � � ( � ! G � � ( � � � � � + � � G � � � � � (4( !�� � ��� � ( �=# � � � G ��� ( � � + � + � # � � ( !&� ��+ ( � ��� � � � � � ( � � �)��� � � � �� � G ���>� � �'�)� ( � ��( ( � � G ��!&! � � ( ��� # ���4� ( !&� �(�"� ��� � ( � � # � � G + ��� �I# � � ( � � ( ! ��� � � + � � � G ( � ���'��� ( � ! G � � ( � � � � � ( ��� � ( �����'� ���� ��� �F��!3����� � ! � � ����� � � � ��� � � + � �"� , � ! '"� � � � ( � � � ��� + � �I# ((� ! � � � ( !&� G �F��!"� �F��! � � � � ��� ( ��� � (�� � � ! � ������� � � ��� G �� � G � + #&� � � �6� � � � � � � � � + � �=# ( � �)��� � � ( � � ��� 9 � ��� ���0� # ��� ( � ! � � �

5 � � � ��� � � � � � � ��� � �6& � � � � � ��� � � � � 7 �'"���%� � (4( !�� � G � � � � � � � ��� ( ! � � ����� �"� � � �>� � �F��! � � � � ( � � � ( � � � � � ( � � � � ( ��! ( �F��� � � � � � + � � # � � � ��� ( � � � � ( � � �G ��� ( � � + � + � ��� ��� � � � ( � ! � � � � ��+ ( ! ��( � � ! � � � ! � � ( � ! � � � � � ��� � � ( � ! '"� � � � # + � ( !&� � � � � � ( ��! # � # ��� # � G � ( � ( � � ( G + � ( �� � ( � � � # � (�� �%� � � � � ! � �I# ��� � G � + � ( � � !< ��� � � � � � � ( ����� + � # � � ��� ( �=# ( � � ( �>� ((� ! � � � ( !&� G �F��!�� � � ! � � ��� + � �I# �F��! ( � � ( !�� �(� � ��� � ( � #&� ����� ( � �"� ( ��! ( �F����� � � � � + � � �G � � �&��� G � � G ����J #&� � G � � � ( � ! � � �%�$� � � � �%�)� � � � � ( ����! �=# �F��! � ! 7 � ! � �)��� + � # � � (�� 9 � � ( � ��( ( � � � � G ����J #�� � G � � � ( � ! � � �%�� � 9 � � � ��� � � ��� ( � ��( ( � ��� # �;��� ( � � G � + #���� � � + � � � � � . � � � � � 5 � ��� � G � � � �4� �F!&��� ( � � � ��9 � � �����>� # � � ( � ! � � � � � � � � �( ��� � �%�"��� ($� G ��� G � !&��F��! ( � � � � 9 � � � ���0� # � � ( � ! � � �%� # � � G + ��� �I# � � ! � � ��� � G � � � � � �%� � � ��� G ! � � ��� ���9� + � G ( ����� !% � G � ��� � � � ( � ( � � �F��� ��� � � ��� � �%� � ( � � � � +�(�( ��� � � ( �%� ! � � �)��� � � � � ( � � �&� + � � ( � � ( � � � G � � � � �"(�( !&� � ��� � ( �I# � ���+ ���>�F��!�� # � � ( !&� ��+ ( � ��� ��� + � � � � � � & � - � � ( � ���>��� ( !&� � � � � ��� ( �"! '"� � � � � � � � � ��� � � � � � � � !8� � ( ��� � � � ( � ! � � � ! '"��� � G � + � #� � G + � ( � � ! � � �)��� � � � � � ��� + � ( ( � ���$�F��! � � ! � � � ��� + ��� � ! '"� + � � � ��� � '& � /)( � � # ( � � ��� 9 � ��� ���0� # ��� ( � ! � � � �%� ��� � � �� �

( � � � � � � � � � � � � � / (& � � � � � � � % � 1 �'"� � G +(� � ( � ( �+*� � � � � � � (�( !�� � ��� ��( �=# � �;# ! � � ���4� � � ��� � �"� � � � ( J ( ( ��!�� + ��� ( � � � � ! � � � ( , � � � + � �"� � ( � � � � ( � !�� G � �G + � + � � ( � � �3# � � ( !&� ��+ ( � ��� � + � G ( ����� �F��! � � � ! '"� + � � �)� � G � ��� � ��� � � � ��� � � � � #-,

��� � � ��� � � � ��� � � ( � � ��� � ( �.

Page 68: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� 6 � ��������� � �*� ����� � ��� �!� � ��� � �� +� ����� � ���� �� � ( � � � ��� � � � ��� � � � � � � ( ��� � ( � �F��! & � � ��� �$� � # ( � � � � ( � ! G � ( ( � ��� � � � � � � � ( ��� ��( � �F��! ( � � ��� � � � � # � � � � ( ��� � ( � � �( � & G � � � � � � (�� � � �I# + �����4� ( � � ! � ( � � � � ( � � J ()( �=# ��� ( � ! G � ( ("( � ( � � J (�( �=# ��� � ( �"!

5 �;��� ( � ! � � ( ���4�3� � � � ! � � ( ����� � !��%������� �F!���� ( ��� � � � � � ( � � G � � � � � � #&�"! # � � � # � � �&� + � � �3+ ���>�F��!�� � ��! ��� � �;����� �� ( � � ! � # � � ( !&� ��+ ( � ��� � � ( ��! ( �F��� ��� � � � + � �*� � ( � � +4(�( � ! (�� ��� � � ( � � #&� ���)� ( � � � � � � � G ������� #&� ! ( � � �F����� � � ���4� � � + � � � + �( !&� ( � ! ( � � ����! #&� ! � (���( �%� ( � G � � � ( � ��( ��� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ( � � ! � � � ��������� � � ! � � ! ��! #�� !� (�� ( � � ( � G � � � � � � � � � & ���)� & � � � �� � � � � � � � � ! � � # ����� � � ( � � � � �)��� � , �F!&��� ( � � � � � � # �%� ( !�� ��+ ( ����� � + ���>�F��!�� ��! ����� � � ( � � ! � � � � ( ( ! + � G � ( �I# � ( � � � � � � !5 � ��9 � � �����>� # � � ( � ! � � � � � � ( � � � � �$#&� ( � !��$� � �=# # ��! � G ( � � �F��! � �F!&��� J !&� ( ( !&��� G � ( � � � � ��+ ( ����� � + ��� ��� ( � � , � � � + � � � �( � � (�� ��� � � # �%� G + �&� �=# � � !&��� � ! ! � � ( � G � ( � � (�( ���%� � (4( !�� � G � # � � ���� ( ! � G + � ! � ( � ��� � ( ��! � # �%� ( !�� ��+ ( �����$�"� ( ��! ( �F��� ��� � � � + � �( � � � �"� �$( ! + � G ��( �=# �F��!�� ! # � ( � � G � � � � � ( � � + ���>�F��!�� � ��� + � ( ( ����� �F��! ( � � +�(�( � ! (�� ��� � ( � � � ��9 � � �����0� # ��� ( � ! � � � �F��!� � � G ��� � �

( � � � � � � � � � � � ��� � � � � � � � � � � � �% � � � � � � 1 �< ��! ( � � + ���>�F��!�� # � � ( !&� ��+ ( � ��� (�� ��� � �&� + � ( ( � ��� � � ( ! � # � ( � ��� � � G ���(J #&� � G � ��� ( � ! � � �4�F��! � � � � � ��� � � ����� � � � (�� � � �I# � �+ �����4� ( � � � � G ( ( � � ( ��! #&� ! � (�� ( � � ( � G � �F!&��� + ���>�F��!�� # �%� ( !�� ��+ ( ������� � � � � � � � � � � (�� ! � � # ��� � � !&� �"� � � � ! 53% � � � % � � � �+�(�( � ! G ���(J #&� � G � ��� ( � ! � � �'�F��! � � � ( ���%� G � � � �%� ��� � � � � �

����"� � � � � � � � � � � � � / � � � � � � � � � � �

� % � � � � � ��� � � � � # � � � (�� � � � � � � ( � � � ( � � � � G � � � � �%� ( � � (( � � �F��!�� � � ( � � +4(�( � ! � � + � # ��� � �%� � � ! � ����� ( � � ! 5 # �%� � # � � � (�� � ��%� ( � � ( ( � � � + � � � ! � � � � � + � � , �%� � � ! � ��� ( ��! (�� � ( � � ( � � ! � � + � ( ����� � � # ( � � � ( � � ��� ( � ! � � � � � � # � � � ! � � ! � � � ( � � ����� �� � ��� � � � � � G � ��� � ! � ( � � ��� + ! � � � � � ! � ��( � ���;�"� � ��� + ��� �"� ( � � � � (�� ��� � � � + � � � � ( � ���>��� ( !�� �(� � ��� � ( � ! � G � # � ��� +�( ��� ( � � � � � ( � � ( ��� # ( � � � ( � � �

� ��! �>� � ( � � ! � � ( ��� # � �)��� + � # � � �)� + ��� (�� �)��� + � # ��� � ��� � � � � ( � !���� � � ( �� � # ����� + � � ( � ��� � � � ( � ( � ( � G � � ( !&��� � G ( � � � # ( ��! ( �F��� ���>� !����� � �� ������� �� �� ����� ����� � ����� � ������������A � � � � � !-� � � ( � � � +�� ��!�� +�( � ��� G � #&��� � ��� ( �=# ( ���%� � (�( !�� � G � � ! � � � � � � + � � � 5 ��� � + ��� � ( � � D G � � � � � # 78� � � (�� �$ � � � !����%� � � (�� � � � �������4� # � G ! � � # � ! G�! ��+ ��� + � � � !&� ! � � � � � � �)90� � � # � � ( ������� ��� � # � � � ( � � ! ��� � � !&��� ( � � �7 � � � � ! � ! ��� � �"(�( !&� � G � ( !&� � � #&� � � !&� ����!&� + � � � ( ��� # �F��! ����� � ����� � � � ! � � G � � �&�8�"� ( ��! ( �F����� � � � � � G ( ����� ( !&� � � � � � ! % ���� � ��� � � � #&� (�� � � �=# #&� � G !�� ( ( ����� �"� ( ��� � � (�( !&� � G � � � � ��� ����� ��� � � ( � �)��� � �(� G 9 ��!&� + � # � � ( � !�� � � ! � � ( !&� � � � � �%� ( �#" � # � � ��� G � � � ( ( ��! ( �F��� ��� �"� ( !�� � � G ( � + � #�� !8����� � G ����� ( ! � � � ( � ! # � !��%��9 �%��� � � � + ! �I# � � � ��� ����� �((� ! � � � ( � ! � � � # ( � � G ��� ((� � � � � � �&� + � �=# ( � � � $ � � .%$ �E� � � ( ! � � � !$�$��! � � � � � ( � ( � � � �&� � � � � ( � � � # � � ��� !&�%�)9 ( � � ��! �!&� ��9 � ( � � � ����� G � � � ('& � � � � � � ( � #&� " � �"! # � � � ( ��� (#� ��� � � � � � � � � � ( ��! ( �F����� ��� ��� � � (�� � # � ! # � � ( � G ( �I# ! � (�+ !&� � � !-� + �!&� ��9 ��! �"( � � ( � � � ��( ��! ( �F��� � ��� � � "%(*)�. " � � �>� ( � � ! � � ! � ��� ( ��! ( �F����� ��� � � ( � �"� � � � � � # ( � ( � � � � � ( � � � ! � � �)< � � + ! �� ! % ! % � � � � � � �&� + � � ( � � ( ( � � ! � � ! � � ( !�� � � G ( � � ��� G � � ! � � � � ��� � � � � ( � � G ��� ( � � � � � ��� G � � � � � ��� � � � � � � ����� � � % ! � �G ��� ((� � � �%� ��� ( �F! �4� ( � � � ( � ! ( � � � � ( !�� � � G ( � ��($� � � � ��� � � �"� ��! � � + � � !�� ( � � � � #&� �I# � � � �)� � ��� � �&� + � � ( � � ( � G ��� ((� � ��%� � � ( � � ! ��� � � � ( �I# ��� �9( !&��� � G ( ��!���� ( � � � � � ( �=# ��� ��( !&��� � G ( � ��� � � G ( � ��� � ! + ! % � ��� � ( � � � � ��� � ( �$! � � � ��( ���%�8����� ��� ( � � � !, � � G � � �F��! ( !�� � � G ( � ) + � & �)��� & � � % 1 � � G � � � �&�)� G � ��( � ( � ��� � !&� � � � � � � � � + G � ( � � (

� � .- � �>� ( !�� � � G ( � �%�"��� ( ��� G � + #&�I#% �>� ( !�� � � G ( � �%�"� � G � + #&�=# !

� + � ( � ��� � G ( ��!�+ ��� � & ����� & � � � � � � �%� � � � G ( ��! �"� � � !&��� � � # ��� � � � ��� G � #&� "�� � � � ( ��! ( �F��� � � !< + ! ( � � ! � ����� G � � ( � � � ( � ( !&��� � G ( � �� � # ��� � � ! G ��� (0/ � � � � (21 � / ��& ���)� & / � � � � � � �� � � � � ( � G ( �I# � � ( ! � (&+ !&�43 � � � � (�5 � 3 ��& ���)� &�3 � � � � � � !# � � + ! �"(�( !&� � G � ( � � ( !&��� � G ( G ��� ( � � ! � (�� 9 � � ( � � � " � �I# ! � � � � � � ! � ����� ��( � ��� � � � + ! �"(�( !&� � G � � � � ! � G ��� ( � � ! �

� ( � G � � � ( � G �$� ��� ( � � �F� + � # ��� ( � � � � ( � ! � (&+ ! � ���76 � $8) �� 6 � .%) �$9$ / $ � ���$. �>/ ! � � � � ( � ! � � ( �I# ! � � #&� ! G � + � # � (�� ! ( � � ( �+ +/- !.

Page 69: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

������������)������ ��� ��� � ��� �-�� � � ��� ���� � H� � (�� ���

��� � � � ( � � G � � � !&� � � G � � ��( !&� � � ( � � ( � � ���� � � ( � � G � � � !&� � � G � � � ( !&��� � G ( � � � � #�� � � #

���� � � ( � �7� � !�� � � G �

� ��� ( ( � � � (�� � # � ! # #&��� � � ( ����� � �"� ( � � ! � (�+ !&� � � ( !&��� � G ( � ! % � � � ��� � � 9 � + � � � � ( � � � � G ( ( � � (�� � ������� � � � � ��( � � �#&� "���� ( �"!D + ! � � ( ��� # ! ��� + ��! � � ( � � � ��� + � ( ( ������� �% ! � � � � � � + ! � �F��! !��%��9 � � ( � � � (�� � # � ! # #���� � ��( � ��� �� ! 5 � � ( � � G ����� ( ! � � � ( � � ! � � � ( ! � �&�)� � � � � �"��� � � � ! ��! ((� ! �"� ����� G � � +(��( � ����� ! � � � � �0( � � G ( � ��� � � ��� ����� � ��� � ( � � � � G ��� # � ��� + � ( ( � ��� � �>��� ( ��� (*� � ( �0� ! � � ( !�� G ( � � �"!

� ��� ��� � ""!! &�"���#!( " # � ( � � � � � ( � � G ( ����� � � � � � ( � ��� �I# ( � ��( �F��! � + ! � (�( !�� � G � ( � � ��!�9 � � � ( � � G ����� ( ! � � � ( � � � + � # � � � � ( � � � � � ( ! � �&�)� � � �� �"� � � � � ! ��! ((� ! � � ��� � G ��� +(� ( ������� !� ��(�+ ! � � � � ( � � ! � � � ��� � � ���+ # � � (�� ! � G ����� ( ! � � � ( � ( � !&� �"( � ( � � G ��� ((� � � � + � ( � ( � � # � � ��� ( � � � � # ����� � !-� � � #

� ��! � ( � � � �%$ ��� ( ��� � ( ��! ( �F����� � ! , � � G �� $ � + � 1 � � � � � ! � � �%��� � � ��� ( � � � ( � � ! G ����� ( ! � ��� ( � � + G � � � ( � � G ����� G � �"� ��� � ( !�� � � G ( �F��! � � # � ( � � � (�( � ��� ( � G ���0��� � � ��� ( � � !( !&��� � G ( ! � � � � � ( � � � � ( � ( � � �"� G ����� ( ! � � � ( � G � � � � � !�� ()( � � � ��� � � !&� � ! < ��! � �%� � ( � � �

� � # � ( !�� � � G ( & ( � � � � � ��� ( !�� � � G ( � ( � / � � #'& & G � � � �3#&� � G !&� � �=# � �� �)( � � * / � � / � � �

� � # � ( !�� � � G (+* ( � � � ��� ( ( !&��� � G ( � '��! & G � � � �3#�� � G !&� � �I# � ��), / �.- � � � � �)/�0

� � 5 ( � � � � ("( � � � �21 � � � �43 � # � & G 3 � � �3#&� � G !�� � �I#53 �

� / � � / � � / � � � � 0� � # � ( !�� � � G (+6 ( � � � ��� ( � � ( � ( !�� � � G ( � � 3 � # � & G 3 � � �3#&� � G !�� � �I#53 �

� � / � � � � � � $ 0D � G � + !&� � � ( �%� ( �>����� � � � ( � G ����� ( ! + G ( G ����� ( ! 3 � � ( � � ��� G � G 3 ����� (*� � � !�� ()( � � 3 � 3 � ��� ��3 ! ��� + 3 ( � ��� � �F��! � � 387 ( � �� � $ � 3 G ( � � ��� � ��! � � 3 G ( � � ( ��! � � �"� ( !&��� � G ( � & � ( 3 � # / ! &

� + ( � ( � � ��� 7 ( � � � ��� + ��� ( � G ��� �)� #&� ! ( � � ( � � # �:9 � ! � � ( � � 3 �)� � � � ! � ��������� G ��!�! � � ( ��� # � ��� ( �

� � $ � 3 G ( � � ��� � �"� ( !&��� � G ( � & � ( 3 � # /�& � ��� G � G 3 � � �3#&� � G !�� � �=#;3 �

�)( / � * / � �=< %8>� � $ � 3 G ( � � ( ��! � � �"� ( !�� � � G ( � & � ( 3 � # / & � ��� G � G 3 � � �3#&� � G !�� � �=#;3 �

�)( / � * / � �=< � 0 � � � ����� � � ( � � ( !�� � � �?7 � � � ! � 3 G � �"� ( � � � � ! � ��� ����� 3 � # G � 7 ( 3 ! � ( � � ����� + ( ������� !# � ( � � � � ( !&� # + G ( ����� � � � ( 3 ( �I# ( � 3 (*( � � G � 7 ( 3 � � G 3 � � � ( � � ! � � � + ��� � � � � � � ( �=# ��� 3 ( !&��� � G ( ��! ��� ( � � � � � ( �I#@3 (3 � � ! # �;! ��3 � � ( � ( ���%� 7 �>��� ( ��� (-� � ( ! + �"! ! � !�� 3 ( � � �F��! 3 ( 3 ! ( � G + � 3 ! ( !�� � � G (�A �F��! � � 387 ( � � � ��� ( ����� � G 3 � ( � � G � 7 ( 3 � �� � � � ( � � ! G � 7 ( � � ( � � � ��� ( � � ( !�� � � G ( ��! G � 7 ( � � ( � � � � + ( � � ( � � ( !&��� � G ( � ��+�(8( � ���B7 �>��� (;� �C3 � � � ( � � � � � � ( ��� % � � � % � ���! � � � � � ( � � ( !&��� � G ( ! # � ( ��� � G 3 � � � � #&� "�� � �F� + ! � � � ( !&��� � G ( � �

.

Page 70: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� � ���������� � � � ��� �?����" � � �� � � �� +� ��� �C������ �

� ! !&��� � G ( & � � � � � � ( ��� % � � � � ( !�� � � G (+A !� ! !&��� � G ( ( � � � � � � ( � � % � � � � ( !&��� � G (+A !� ! !&��� � G ( / � ��� � � � ( � � % � � � � ( !&��� � G (+A !� ! !&��� � G ( & � � � � � � ( ��� % � � �"� ( !�� � � G (+A !

� � ( � ( � 3 ( ( !&��� � G ( � ( � / 3 � #;&�3 ! � � #&� � ( � G 3 � ! � � G ��� � ( ! 3 ��� ( � �

� * / � � / � � � � � � �)(�0, � � G � � �>� � � G ���0�>� � ( � � � � � � ( � � ( !�� � � G ( &�� % � � � � � � � ( 7 � � ( � � A�� ( � � � � �+3 ! � �F��! � � #�#&� � ( � � � � � � ( � � 3 � � �"� ( !&��� � G ( �( >'/ 3 � #;&4! D ( � � ! � �%� � � ��3 ! � �F! �4� ( � � � � � � ( � � 3 G ( � � ��� � �"� ( !&��� � G ( � ( >9/ 3 � # & � % � � ��� � � � ( 7 � � ( � � A�� � � � 3 G ( � � ( � �� � ( !&��� � G ( � ( >9/ 3 � #;& � � � � ��� � � � ( 7 � � ( ��� A�� ��! � � � � � ( � � 3 � � ( ��! �4� �"� ( !�� � � G ( � ( >9/ 3 � #;& � % � � � ��� � � � ( 7 � � ( � � A�� !! � !&� 3 ( � 3 � ��� ( � ! � � ( � ��� � � � � ! 3 � �� 3 ( � ��� � � + � # � � ( � � G ��!&! � � ( ��� # � ��� 7 � � �I# � ��� ( � � � ! ( !&� � � �?7 � � � ! � �)� 70� ( !&��� � G ( �G 3 � � � � � G � + #&�=#53 ( 3 G ��� ( ��� +�+ 7 � � � ��� � �%� ! � "�� �� ( � � � ( � � � � ( � � 3 � � ( � � G ����� ( ! 3 ��� ( � ! # � � � 3 ( �F��� ��� � � � ��3 ��� + 7 � ( � 3 ( G ��� �)�%� ( � �"�8����� � � � � � 3 ! 3 � #( 3 ! 3 � ����� G ��� + 3 ( ������� !

5 ( ��! ( �F����� � � � ��� � � � G 3 � � �=# � " � 6�. ? � "��>� � ( � 3 ( �%� " � � 3 ��� � � ( � � G ����� ( ! 3 ��� ( � ��� *! ! ��� ()( � ��� 3 ��� ( � � � � 3 ��� � � � ( ��! ( �F��� ���>���� 3 ��! 3 ( � � � � � ( � G ( �I# ! � (�+ !&� � � !&� + ��!��%�)9 � � � � + � # � � ( 3 ��! 3 ( � ��� 7 � � 3 ! ( � < � � + ! � � ! % ! � � ( � ( � 3 ( # + � ( � ( � � "���� ( ���! 3 � + � 3 !&� ( � G ����� ( ! 3 � � ( ( � � ! � � ��� �"����� � � �;3 "���� ( � � + 7 � � !��"� ( �>����� � � � ( ��! ( �F��� ���>� ! , � � G � � + ��� ��9 � ( � � ( ! 3�# � ( � ��� 3 � 3 !�9�� � � ( � ( ��! ( �F����� � ( !&� � � � 7 � + H - � � � ! ��3 G ��� ( � � + � + � ����� G � � � ( �F!���� ( � � ! & �%� � � ( � G ( �=# � ( � � ��� G � � � ( 3 � # � � 3 �)� � � �( ��! ( �F��� � ����F!�� 7 ( ���%� ( !�� � � �?7 � � ��� �F��! 7 3 � � ( � � ����� G � � � ( � � � G � ( ��� ( � & ! # � < �>� + ! � � ! %'( � � ��� G � � � ( ( ��! ( �F��� ���>��.� � � G � ( �>� ( � � 3 ! � �)��� � � 3 � � " � 3 � # ( � � # � 7 � � 3 ( �I# ( ��! ( �F��� ���>� 3 ! � �)��� � � 3 ���-" � ! D � � ( ��! ( �F��� � � � � 3 � � � �I# ��� � � � ( � ���� � � 3 � 7 ����� 7 + 7 �F��! !��%�)9 3 � # � � 3 � ��� G � � � ( � � � G � ( ��� ( !! � #&� ! ( � �B3 �&� + 7 ( ( � ��� ( � 3 ( ( � � � ( 3 � # 3 ! #'#&��� � 3 ( �����'�%� ( � ��7 ��3 � + ! � � � !&� ��9 � � G 3 � ��� G 3 ( � ( ����� ( � � �)� 7 ( � � � �7 ����� 7 ����� ��� ( � � � � � � G ( � � � � + � G ( ������� � � � + � #�� ! ( � � G ��� � ( ! 3 ��� ( � � ( ! � � � � �>( � � G ( ����� � ��� � #&� � G !&� � � ��� � ( � # �( ��� � ! � � G ( � ��� � ! +4! � � ��� � #&� � G !�� � � ��� � ( � � � G 3 ( � ( � � � ( � � ! � � � G � ( ��� ( � !� ��� ��� � � ���!$ � � � ��" � � � �����#!� � �:"����� � � � ( !&� � � �?7 � � ( � " � # ( � � � � ��� G � 7 � ��� 7 ��� � ��� � � � � +4� � � G ( ( � 3 � � ( � �*��� � ��3 ! 3 � # ( 3 ! 3 � ����� G � � + 3 ( ������� !< ����� � � � ��� ( � � � + ( � ��� � � � 3�7 � ( ��� # #&� � G !&� � �=# ��� + � - � � � � � � #�� � G !&� � � ��� � ( � ( ! 3 � � �F��! 7 ( ��� � � + 3�# ! 3 ( � G ( !&� � � �?7 ��� ( �3 � � � + � � 3 � � � ( ( !&� � � �?7 � ��� G � G 3 � � � ����� � �=# !� ���� ������� ������������ � $ ��? $ �B.%) ) $ � 6 � $ � . ��� $ � $ ��� � . 6 $ � "! .%) ) ��� ? " EA � . � � $ �1 " � $�$��

& ��� � � � �"� � �( � � � � �"� �#� � � ����� � ( � � � � �"� �#� � � � > "�$ " �%$ ��� � < & $ � � � /+����� / & $ � � � > & <

� > % > ����� > �� $ " � 6 " � $ � � / % �B. � " � $ �(' . � , "� #" � ,�" ��� $�� $ / " � "'$�A 6 �B. � " � $ � $ $���6�$ � ��< � $�. ��? � " 6 � � ,

( � � � > �< % > ����� > � 0% � 3 ( � �3# � � � ( ! 3 ��� �F��! 7 ( � � � � � � G ( � � � � + � G ( � ����� � � � � � ( � 3 � � � � � � � G ( � � � � + � G ( � ���*) 3 � # 3�#�# 3 ( 3 ! 3 � ����� G

G ����� ( ! 3 � � () � � � � � � �

( � ! � ��� 3 !�� 3 � � � ) � � G 3 � � �I#53 ��� 3 G 9 � 3 !&� 3 � � �"! ���%� 7 � 3 � � ( � 3 ( � � � 3/� � ( � � � ( ! � �&�+) � � � � � � � � � ( � � �F��! 7& ��� � � � ��� � �( � � � � ��� �#� � � ����� �( � � � � ��� �#� � � �

3 �"� � � "���� ( � ��� � ! +4! % ! � ( ���%� � � # � G ������� #&� !A < � ��� � �� / � � � � � � � � /������ / � � � � � � � � � � � �

,

Page 71: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

�������������)������ ��� ��� � �����-�� � � ��� ����� � %

x

x

x

xx

x

x

x

o

o

o

o

o

o

o

o

o

o

o

o

o

oo

o

o

o

o

oo

ooo

o

o

Risk

Return

P0

Expected

no feasible porfolios both above and

to the left.

A portfolio is efficient if there are

< �>� + !�� � ! % � 5=( ��� ( � � 3 � � ��� 3 ��� � �� ����� + ( � ��� � ! $ � G ���� ( ���I� G � ( �>� ( � 3 !�� �)��� � � 3 � � " � ! � 7 � � 3 ( � # ( ��! ( �F����� ��� 3 !� ����� � �3 �+�-" � ! ��� ����� G � ( ��� ( G ��!&!��I� ( ��� # � ��� ( � ( ��������� � 3 � � � 7 � ��� 7 3 � !&� ��9 �%�"� 3 � �I��� # � � !� ��� G � � � 3 � � ( ��� ( ��! 7 � � � ( � ( ��� � 3 !&� 3 � ��� � � � � ( ��� � � ( 3 ���)� ��� �"� � � � � � � � ( � ( � 3 ( ( ��� G � � 3 !�� 3 � G � 7B3 ( !&� � � � �� ��7B7 � ( !�� G � ! % � G 3 �@!� � !�� ( � A 3 �

A <%

� ��� � � � � � � & �#�� � G � 7 ( ��� ( � ��� ( ���3� � + 3 !� � � ����!��

� < �� ����� � � � � � � � � � >

�<

� ����� � � � � � � � � � � > 3 � #

&<

� ������� � � �

� � � � � � � � � � � 0� � ( � ( � 3 ( � � � � � A � � 3 � # & � 3/� � ��� � � ( �I! 7 � ! � + � � ��� � G � � �%� ������� ��� � 3 ( � � � # � "���� ( � � � � � � �%� 3 ����� � ���8� 3 ( � � �# ��"���� ( � � + 3�# ! 3 ( � G �F��! 7 �F�� ( � � � � ( � ! 3 ��9 � 3 � # ( ����!��2�F��!�� ( ��� !�=� + � ( ������� � ( !�=����������� � � � � A � �

����� �����& � �%� 3

������� ��� � 3 ( � � � # ��"���� ( � � + 3�# ! 3 ( � G �F��! 7 � � � ( � ! 3 ��9 � � % � ! % � G 3 � !�� ( � 3 ( ( ��� � ( !&� G �I�&� �"� G � 7 ( �� ( ���4� ( ���*� � + 3 !�=� �F��!� 3 G � � 3 !�� 3 � �� ! 78�� 3 !�� � � ( ��� !��I� + � ( ���4��� � ( !�=����� ��� ) � ���

� ������ � � � & ��� � � � � � � � 3 ( � ��"��I� ( ��� G ��� # � ( � �����"�"� ( ��� ( 3 ! 3 � ����� GG ����� ( ! 3 � � ( # ��"���� # � � ��"���� ( � ��� � ! +4! % ! 5 � ( ��! ( ���%� ( ! 3 ��� �F��! 7 3 ( ����� � � + ! ( !&� � ��� 7 G 3 � � �3� ( 3 ( � #;3 �-�F����� � � � �

7 � � )

,

Page 72: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� � ����������� � � � ��� �?����" � � �� � � �� +� ��� �C������ �

� +�� � � G ( ( � ( ��� ��!&�>����� 3 � G ��� � ( ! 3 ��� ( � � ( � � # �I� G !&� � � # � � � � G ( ����� � ! +4! % ( �"� � ( ���I! � � ( � ( ��� ( 3 ! 3 � ����� G*G ��� � ( ! 3 ��� (

) � �� ������� � � � &

��� � � � � � �

� ���I!��& ��� �%� 3 � 3 (�( !�� ( !�� 3 ( � G � � � G ���� ( # ��!&� � � # �F!&� 7 G � 7 ( �� ( � ��� ( ���3� � + 3 !� �F��! ( ��� � 3 !&� 3 � �� � � ! ��� 3 � ����!�� ( � 7 ( � �)��� � � ( ��� � ( ! 3 ��� �F��! 7 � # ( !&� � ��� 7 � � ! 3 ( ����! ������ ( � � 3 � # ��� 3 � � � �@� 7 � (�( � # ! ��� � � ( ��!��I� ( � #!�� 3�# ��! �%�*��� � � ( � # ( � � � ( � ��!�� + � - � ( 3 � � � ��� ! 5 � + 7 � ��!*� � G � 7B7 ��! G � 3 � �)�"� ( � 3 !� ( 3 G 9 3 � �I� � � � � ( � ��� G � �)��� + � # �)��� � �( ��� ( ! 3 ��� �F��! 7 � # ( !�� � �� 7 ! 5 � � � 3 7 ( �� 7 � ��� ( � � ( ��� � ! !&� ���=��������� 3 � � � ��� 3 ! ! !�� ��! 3 7B7 ����� � � � ( � 7 & 3/� 3 � � 3 � �� �F!&� 7� + � � � ( � � � ( � 3 !�� � G ������� �"� ��� + %"% - !�������� �� !�� #! ������� ������� !�� ��� ! ��� ��� ��" # � ( ��� � 3 � ( � � G ( ����� � � # �I� G !&� � � # ��� � ( � � � G 3 ( � ( ��� � � G ���� ( ���I� G � ( �>� ( � � ! % � 3 !�� ��� � ( � � ( � ( ��� ( 3 ��9��"�E� � G 3 ( � ��� ( ���� ( ����! ����� G � ( ��� ( � ! 5 ����� G � 3 ( � # � � ( ��� 3 G � ����� G � ( ��� ( ��� 0 0?0 � � ( ���I!� � � �%� ( � 3 � 3 �&�)� G � 3 ( � # � � ( � G ( � # !� (�+ !&� ,�� 0?0 0 , �3 ������ � � � � < � � + !�� � ! � ! D � G � � � � 3/� �"� � G 3 ( � # � � � � 90��� � ( ��� � 3 � + � �"��, � ! � + � � � � � � G 3 � 7 � ��� 7 ��� � ( ��� � � � � G ( � � �� + � G ( � ��� � � � � + � # ��! ( ��� G ����� ( ! 3 � � ( �� ( ( � + � 3 � + ! ( ���I! G ����� ( ! 3 � � ( � � 5 � , � ��� � � �%�"���=��� ( � 3 � 3 ( ����� �53 � # � �� � G � + # � # ( � � ��� + !� � + !*��� 3 ��� � ���3� ( 3 G � � � G � ���� # � � ( ����� ( ��� ����� + ( � ��� � � ��� � � � � ! � ��� G � ( ���3��� � G ����� ( ! 3 � � ( � � ��� ��� 3 ! �( ��� ( !&� G �I�&� # �I� G !&� � � # � � � � G ( ����� � ! +4! � G 3 � � � + �� # ! # ( �I! 3 ( � ��� ( ��� � ( !&� G �=��� � + � ( � �"� + ! 3 � ����!�� ( � 7 !�� (�+ !���� 3 � �������� + ( � ��� & !��I� + � ( � � ��� � � � G 3 ( � 3 � � ( ��� � � G ���I� ( ����� G � ( ��� ( � 3 � # ����� G �3�)��� � � ( ��� ( !&� � �� 7 ��� � ��� !

x

x

x

xx

x

x

x

o

o

o

o

o

o

o

o

o

o

o

o

o

oo

o

o

o

o

oo

ooo

o

o

Risk

P

P

P

PP

PP

P

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

r

r

r

rr

r

rr

0

1

2

34

5

6

7

Expected

Return

< �>� + !�� � ! � � 5 �&�)� G � 3 ( � # � � ( ��� 3 G � � � G ���I� ( ���I� G � ( �>� ( ��� 0 0?0 � � � � 3 � � � ( � G ( � # !� (�+ !&� ,�� 0 0?0 , � !��������� ���"!��� "!! �#�"!% � � 3/� � ( !��I���� ( � #'3 !&�>����!&� + � 7 � ( ��� # �F��! �)��� � � ��� ( ��� ( ��! ( �F����� � ( !�� � �� 7 + � # ��! ��� 7 � 3 �&� + 7 ( ( � ����� !$"%&%'% 2 (*),+-(*.0/(*1324/ 2 5#176

,

Page 73: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

��� ���)��� � ������ � � ��� 3 �&� + 7 (�( � ��� ( � 3 ( !&� ��9 �%� 7 � 3 � + !� # � � � ( 3 � # 3 ! # # � � � 3 ( � ��� G 3 ����� ( � � � 3 ����� � !���� 3 � � # ! 5 � ( ��� + ��� ( ��� � ( 3 � # 3 ! ## � � � 3 ( ����� �%� 3 G � 7B7 ��� 7 � 3 � + !�� �F��!!��%�)9 � �F��! ��� 7 � !� 3 ����� 3 � �� + ( ��� � ( � � + � G ( � ����� 3 � # ������� ����! 7 3 � ( 3 � �89 # � � ( !&� ��+ ( � �����

( ��� � ( 3 � # 3 ! #'# � � � 3 ( � ��� 7 � ��� ( ��� ( � � 3 ���0� # 7 � 3 � + !�)�F��! G � 7 ( 3 !&����� ( ��! ( �F��� ���>� ! ����!�� 3 !� 7B3 � �@3�# � 3 � ( 3 � �=� ( �+ �����4� 3 �����4���� ( 3 ! 3 7 � ( ��! !��%��9 7 � 3 � + !�� � ��+ ( � ��� ( ��� G 3 �� � ����!�� � ( 3 � # 3 ! # # � � � 3 ( ����� �%� ( ��� + ��� ( ( � � � � � 3�# � � + 3 ( �( ��!&� 3 ( � ( ��� G ��� G � ( ( � � 6�� $8) �� 6�� .%) , $ �$.� � ��) "3����� + � # � � + �� # ! � ( � G � 3 � ( � G # � 7 � � 3 � G � �%� 3 ( 3 ! ( � 3 � � ��! # ��!*!�I� 3 ( � ���+ �� # ( � G � 7 ( 3 !�� ( 3 � � 9 # � � ( !&� ��+ ( � ����� ! � � G ��� # � # �8��!�� �8� ( � G � 3 � ( � G # � 7 ��� 3 � G � �%� � � 3 G ( � � ( ��� G ��� G � ( ( ( � 3 ( 3 ��� � � �I� ( ��!�%�"! 3 ( � ��� 3 � ! % � !� ����! ( ��� !�� 3�# ��! ( � 3 � � ��! 3�# + 3 ( � ( � �0( ���4"�� 3 � G � � �F��! � � 387 ( ��� + � - � ��! ( � + � - �F��! �)� 7 � !��I� + � ( � � ��� G ���� 7 ( � � � � ( ��� G � 7 (�+ ( 3 ( �������"��� G �I�&� 3 ! � ( � G � 7 ( 3 !� # �%� ( !&� ��+�( � ����� !% � 3 ! � + � � � � � G ( � ��� � ! + ! % ( � 3 ("( ��� 3 ��� + 7 ( ( � ��� ( � 3 ( 3 � � G ����� ( ! 3 � � ( � 7 + � (*� � � � ( !�=����� � ��� 3 � � ����� 3 !"��! ( 3 ! 3 � ����� G� � + 3 ( � ����� 7 � ��� ( ��� ( � � ( �0� !��I� ( !&� G ( � � � ! ���2"�� 3 � ( ��� � ( � �*� 3/� � ��� ( � � ( 3�#�# !��I�&� � # �%� ( ��� � + �I� ( � ���;�"� G � 7 (�+ ( 3 ( � ��� 3 � � � G ���� G �"! ��� 7 � ( ��� #;# �=� G !�� � � #!�� � + � !�=� 7 + � ( � ( ��;�)��� +�( � ����� ( � ( � ( ��� ( � 3 ��� � � 3 ! � �$� � ( � � ��! ( !&�"��! 387B7 � ��� ( !&� � �� 7 � ! ���I�� ( !&� � �� 7 � G 3 � � � �)��� � � #� �I! � � � G ���� ( � � ��+ ( � ( � � ( ���&��� � �� � �I� ( � G � 3 � � � � ����� ( ����!�� 3 !�� 7 3 � � ( !&��� � G ( � 3 � # 7B3 � � G ����� ( ! 3 ��� ( � � ( � 3 (( ��� 7 � ( ��� #7 �>��� ( � � ( �>� G � 7 (�+ ( 3 ( � ��� 3 � � �;# � 7 3 � # ����� �F��! G � 7B7 ��! G � 3 � 3 (�( � � G 3 ( � ��� � !� � ( � ( � 3 (;( ��� ( !&� � �� 7 � 3 �;��� 7 � ��� G � ( !&� ( ��! ( ��I� � ( ��� � 3 !�� 3 � ���=� 3 !�� � � � 3 ! � 3 � # ( ��� G � � 3 !&� 3 � G � 7 3 ( !&� � � �

� ��7B7 � ( !�� G ! # ( 7 � ��� ( � � ( ���&��� � �� ( � � � ( ����� ("( ���I�� ( !�� ( �I! ( ���=� ( � 7 3 9 � ( ��� 7 � ( ��� # � � �I� 7 ��!�� � � G ���� ( !# � 3 � � G 3 �� � ( ���%� 7 � ( ��� # G 3 � � � + �� # ( �3����� � � 3 � 3 ! � � G � 3 �&� � � � � ( ��!��I� ( � ��� 3 � # ������� ( !&� � � 3 � ( ��! ( �F��� � � ( !�� � �� 7 � ! # �( ��� � �I����! 3 � G 3 �� # � �I� ��� ( � 3 ( �%� � � ( ��� 3 �&� + 7 ( ( � ����� !� � + ��!�� # � � ( ���%� 7 � ( ��� # ��! � � ( �0� G � 7 (�+ ( 3 ( ����� 3 � � �*# � 7 3 � # � ��� �F��!G � 7B7 �I! G � 3 � 3 (�( � � G 3 ( � ��� � � ( ���I� ( ��!&� 3 ( � ( ��� � 7 � ( ��� # G 3 � � � + �� # ( � ( �=� ( 3 � # � �I� G � 7 3 !&9 7 ��!� ��� + !&� � ( � G 3 (�( !&� 3 G ���I� !���)� � ��� � ���$ 3 G � � � ( ��� ( ��!��� 3 (�( !&� 3 G ���I� � 3 ��� ( � 3�# � 3 � ( 3 � �I� 3 � # # �%� 3�# � 3 � ( 3 � �=� ! ��� ! ��! ( �F��� ��� � �I��� G ( ����� 5 � ����!&� ( � 7 3 (4( !�� 3 G ��%� � 3 � � # ��� ( ��� 3 (�( � 3 ��� ��� � # � 3 � � ( ! � ����� ( � "�� # ( ��� � � G ���� ( ( ��! ( �F����� � � � ( � ( ��� 7 ����� 7 + 7 387 � + � ( �"���?9���! ( ! # ( � �� 3 � � ( ��� 7 ( �� 7 ��� ( 3 � # � ( � ��!&9 � � ��� � ��� � � 3 7 ( ��I� � � � 3/� � G ������� # ��!�� # ! # � ( !�� � ��� 7 ��! 3 �%� � # � � � � G ( ����� � ! � ! � G 3 � � �� + G�G �I�&� � + � � � !�=�)��� � � # � ( ��� � 3 (�( !&� 3 G � � � ��� ( !�� � � # � 3�� 3 � + 3 � �� ����� + ( ����� ( � ��! 3 9 " � ( !�� � ��� 7 ! ��� � ( 3 ( � � ( � G 3 � # � ���I!�I� G � 5 (�( !&� 3 G � �%� 3 � ��� � 3 � � ( � + � � ! # ( � 7 3 � � # �%� 3�# � 3 � ( 3 � � �%� ( � 3 ( � ( # � �I� ��� ( ��� � � ( ������ � 3 G ( � � � G ���� ( ( ��! ( �F��� ��� ! D � ( ���"� ( ���I!� 3 � # � � ( � 3 � ( ��� 3�# � 3 � ( 3 � � ( � 3 ( � ( G 3 � � � + � � # � � 3 � � �)� (�+ 3 ( � ��� � !�8� 3 ! # ��I�&�� � ( ��� � + 7 � �I! �"� ( !�� � � G ( � 3 � # ( ����� 3 (&+ !��3� � ( ��� G ����� ( ! 3 � � ( � ! # � ( ��� 3 � ���� G �3� � 3 + ��� � ��!-� 3 ��� �'3 (�( � � G 3 � �� 7 � ( ��� #� ��� G � � ��� � 3 � � 3 � � "�� # ( ��� � � G ���� ( ( ��! ( �F����� � � ( ��� � 3 (�( !&� 3 G � ( !&� � � # �=� 3 ( ! 3 G ( � G 3 � �)��� +�( � ��� ( � �I! 3 9#" � ( !&� � �� 7 ! ��� ( ! 3 G ( � G 3 � � ( � �"� ( ��� # � ( � � ��! ! !&�"��! 387 7 � ��� 5 (�( !&� 3 G � # � ( ��� # � ��� ( ��� � + 7 � ��! �"� ( !&��� � G ( � 3 � # ( ��� � 3 (�+ !��� � ( ��� G ����� ( ! 3 ��� ( � ! � � � ��! ( ���I���=��� � � ( � 3 � ( ��� 3�# � 3 � ( 3 � � ( � 3 ( � ( ��� � �I� ( ����� � G ���� ( ( ��! ( �F��� ����F��! ( !�� � �� 7 � � ����!�� � (�%� 3 (�( � � G 3 � �� ! � ��� G � 7 ��� ( G ������ ( � � � ��! 3 9 � � � � � ��9 ��� � � 3 � ( ( � 90��� � ( ��� � � G ���I� ( ( ��! ( �F��� � � � � � ( G 3 � � � �F� + � # � �F��!( !&� � �� 7 � � ���I!� ( ��� � 7 � ( ��� # �%� 3 (�( � � G 3 � ��� � � ( �%� ( ��� 7 �>� (*( !��2���I!�!�� #53 (4( !�� 3 G � !

,

Page 74: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� + ����������� � � � ��� �?����" � � �� � � �� +� ��� �C������ �

,

Page 75: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� ��� ������� ��� ���

+ % -�� !������ #�� � !�� !�� � 3 � 3! !�"$#&%'� 3 � � � ! 3 � # � 3 � 3 ! 3 � 3�� , ! � ! � %)(�( � � ! �+* . $ 6��-, $/.�$ 6�"@.�10 $&,�"�$32 � � � . 6�� .%) 6 �54 ��%��% "����)687:9;�!�'# � � � �=< ��! '!+ � ->�=3 �?"$# ( ! 3 ( � � !�� ! 3 + ��% + # � ! 3 � # 9@"�A B�'C ! � %D(!(�E � ! � ! #&"����GF � 3 �IH ( ( "��!�J# ( � 3 � 3 � ��FK"�# & �'L $9$8) " "&,�.� / 6�$ �8MBN "O ��,QP " � �50 � .%$ � 6R, $ � � "�$ " ��) "TSVU $�� 6��KWYX $Z. � / � �[��! ( % � �)# ( �I!�� ! ��" � �I!\#�" ( 6 !+ � - 3/� " #]� , !'� ! � %)(�E�% � ! 0 $�, " $^2 � � � . 6�� .%) 6 � 9 �DA_��� # $ # " ( "��!� ��4 �!%'� % "����)6`7a9;�!�'# � � � �b< ��! '!+ +/- � 7 ( # ( �I! � !J� ! , ! � %D(!E � � ! 2 � $8) N � 6�� .%) L $'$ / $ �/cRc .� / �J� A 3�# � 7 "�A ! !��)#\# !+ � - , + � !J� ! � %)( � ( � !'d ��� " / "�$ L $9$ / $ �/cRc .� /�� ��,Re " � $�$ * � $ �6 �J� #�# "$#��!��� % �D#&��f6 ! +�� ��"$#&%�"���� � � 7 ( 3 �;6 � # �'A !+ � - # ��� ��!g#&���?� �@44! $ ! � %D(!E � � !hMBN " $�$ '4$ � * .� � � )�. � �Bi " )�. 6�.%$ �kj �� .� / � FK� � 7 3 �l7 � " (�( �� "��)� # !+ � -�m 3 � �@n �f"$#�Ag% ��4 !�C ! � %D(!E � � !oL $9$!p � p�. �B.� ' � �E,l2 � � � . 6�� .%) � � d � � "�$ " � ) "rq $ �s. c " Out 2 � � � . 6 � .%) � � d � � "�$ " ��) " � 9 ( !�"���� ��! �v �I!�� 3 � � � � �w< ��! '!+ E - 3 ! � � " ( � � , ! � %)( �8� � ! ! ��! ( �x���?"��G9 �f��)A ( "?��� !bMyN "Rz $Z.�$�� � � $ � * .� � � ) " � v �!� ! v # # � �[� ! % � (4( ! � � � (4% !+ ( - 3 ! � � " ( � � , ! � %)( � ( � !{L $�$�� � $ �B.%$|2�" � " ) � .%$ � t U�(*)C. " ���}i3.�~ "�$ 6-. � ) � � .%$ � $ ��d �J~ " 6�� c " � �%6 � � � 3 A � �)�?� ! +�� ��"�#�%���!g# ��=387 � !\" # � � � 3 � # H � �x��! # ! mG� #�)A_��� # � # !�� %)(�( � !+ % �.- FK�/6 3 ��� � F ! � %)(�( � � ! 2 � � � . 6�� .%) � �yU�~=. ,�" � ) " �B� % 3 ( 7 3 � 3 � # , 3 ��� � � � �w< ��! !+ %"% - 9 + �'# � ( 9;� � ( � 3 !�� �)Ag%��'�!���"�!6�� %)(�E � � ! � ! !\� ���D#�#�"?��� 3 � � "���� 3 ! ! !\�"��! 3 7B7 "����>9;6@# ( � 7 & � % � % � � %��)��#� 3 FK� 3�#]� 9 + " ( �% � � ! 9 3 � 3 !\"?��� �J��� (�% % � E � ! 9 � !

� �

Page 76: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

��� � ��� � �� � ��� � �

,

Page 77: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� ��������� �

� � ��� ����� ��� � � :��� ��� ��� � � � � ��� � � ��!�

� %�!�"$##" + #�# � � , + 3%$ "?���'& , + 3 �'&)( � 3+* " # � � %���!g# (-, �'m �)" ( % ! !�� 7 "�#��?�/.#0 � F � $ % �D# (-1 !��;� 32Z� " !�" 3 � % � ()( ���4(F �65y��! ( 5�!�75 3 !�� # 1 6 4 387 �)# % 3 ( 7 � + &!%48

9 �7: ���������<; BA �������H=5 ��! 3 ( ��!\#V�?>]� 3 !@& � 7 "���"��'& � $ A 3+* 3 ( ��!\#VAf� + � # " 7 5�!\� * � ( %��f" ! �6A3A_"�f�'Af6Q"B> ( %��)6C. ��!��#5�!\� * " # � # .K" ( % 3 !� 3 �BD ( " 7 � ���/.K�BD� # & �[�?> 1 � ( % ( %�� 7 3 #\#5"�� ( %�� 1�+ A � ( 3 � # ( %��E>x��!gA �[��� ( %�� # "B&)&!"��'& ( ��� ( %-�%> ( %�� 7 3 Ag%�"����?F � � ( %�� + &�%3#&% 3 5 � # !\� + &�%��?6��" � 3 # ( 3 � # 3 ! # A_���'# ( ! + A ( "?��� � $ A 3+* 3 ( ��! � 7 "���"��'& � $ A 3+* 3 ( ��!\# 3 !� 7B3 �;6 ( " 7 �)#>� 3 !-& ��!GF %��)"�!H5 3 6;�?� 3�# A 3 � 1 �8� * �I!+)I ( �!�����D# � .K" ( % ( %��-%;6 # ! 3 + ��"�ARA_6;��"?� # ��!g#^�?5 ��! 3 ( "?�'& 3 ( + 5 ( �J I ! 3 F8H 1 * "?� + #��?6 � ( %��-"�� (�+ " ( "��!� 3 � # >�� �f� ( % 3 ( 3 ��?5 ��! 3 ( ��! 7 3 68% 3+* ��>x��! 3 # 7 3 �����! 7 3 Ag%'"?����"$#[����# ( �!� ( %��)#��&!���?" 3 ( %'# � 3 � # 3 �;68"��K>x��! 7 3 ( "��!� 3 1 � + ( ( %��L>x��!gA �D#}�!� ( %��1�+ A � ( "�#�" 7 5y��! ( 3 � ( ( � ( %��>�?5 ��! 3 ( ��!GF + !�"��'&`����! 7 3 � �)5 �I! 3 ( "��!� � �!��� ( ! + A "$# ��� 3�# � # ���|�!���>#�" # �>�%> ( %�� 7B3 Ag%�"����.K%�"���� 3 #�)A_��� # ( ! + A 57 � * �D#K"?� ( �M5y��#�" ( "?��� �!� ( %��Q� ( %��I!�#�" # �)F %�� 7B3 Ag%�"����Q��� 3�# # * �f%�"$A_��)#�A_�!� ( "?� + � + #&��6 � #N5 �f� # "?�4&3 545�!�� $ " 7 3 ( �)�?6`�!��� 7 "�� + ( �H.K" ( %�� 3 Ag% ( ! + A F , �f�'A � � ( � 1 �Q�?> + #� ( � ( %��>�?5 ��! 3 ( ��! � ( %��C5 3 6;�?� 3�#;3 � #'# "O&?&!"��'&P>x��!\A �7 + # (Q1 ��� 1 ( 3 "���� #@# + !\"��'&G����! 7 3 �]�?5 ��! 3 ( "?���8�?> ( %�� 7 3 Ag%�"�����.K" ( % 3 ( 7 ��# ( 3 ������# �DA_��� # # �f� 3 6?F � 1 � �)Af�!��� 7 "�A 3 ���?6 * " 3 1 �� � 3 # � * "�A � ( � 7 � 3 # + !�� ( %��P5 3 6;��� 3�# 3 � # # "O&?&�"?�'&R>x��!\A �R#�%�� + � # 1 � 3 5'5���"$A 3 1 ��� ( � 3 �u6� $ A 3+* 3 ( ��!S.K" ( %'� + ( � $ ( �f�'#�" * � 7 � # �f���?"��'& 3 � # " (�( "��'&|A_�u# ( # 3 � # #�%�� + � # 1 �3Af�!�'# ( ! + A ( � # �%>"!\� 1�+ # ( � �?�/.aA_��# ( #�f�'#���!g#��" 7 " ( � # ( � 7 � 3 # + !�� 7 �f� ( �?> 3 �'&����D# 1 � ( . � �)� ( %�� Af� 7 5J�����f� ( #8�?> ( %�� � $ A 3+* 3 ( ��! 3 � # 5�!�D#�# + !��)#8"?� ( %�� %u6 # ! 3 + �?"$AA_6;��"?� # ��!g#6F[H�����5�!�� * "�� + # 3 5'5�!\� 3 Ag% ( � ( %��T5�!\� 1 �� 7 . 3 # ( � # � * �)�?�)5 3 # � ( 3 "���� #;7 � # �)� �?> ( %�� # 6;� 387 "�A 1 �f% 3+* "�� + !K�%>( %�� 7 3 Ag%�"?���?U # 3 ! 7 3 � # 1�+ A � ( FCV �W5�! 3 A ( "$A � � %��/. � * �I! � " ( "$#^��� ( �DA_����� 7 "$A 3 � ( � " ( # + Ag% 3 # � ( 3 "?�� # 7 � # �f� ( ��� 3 Ag%7 3 Ag%�"����)FYX + ! ( %��I! � ( %���!�� 3 !�� 3 � 3 !-& ��� + 7 1 ��!K�?> + � �'�/.K� �?9 �DA ( ##>F!�� 7 + � 7 � # �f���� # # 6;� 3 7 "$Af# � # + Ag% 3 #Z>F!�"$A ( "?��� 3 � #%;6 # ! 3 + ��"�A �f� 3 # ( "$A_" ( 6 � 3 � # >F!�� 7 ��!&!���!\# # + � ( �3# �)�'#���!}�?" 7 " ( 3 ( "?���'# 3 � # 1 3 A &�!\� + � # ���!"$# �^"��[5�!�D#�# + !�� 3 � #;3 �'&���� # 3 ( 3 F %��[" # � 3 � # � * "�A �Q.�� + � # ��� ( !� � + "�!�� ( �DAg%���"$A 3 � " ()( "?�4&���! 7 � # �)�?��"��'&��%>�� 3 Ag% 7 3 Ag%�"���� � 1�+ ( .h� + � # 1 � 3 # ( ! 3 "B&�% ( >x��!@D. 3 ! #�7 �)Ag% 3 ��"$A 3 �;"��'# ( 3 ��� 3 ( "��!� � .K" ( % 3 #�"?�4&!�� # � * "�A ��# + " ( 3 1 ���Z>x��! 3 �;6 7 3 Ag%�"����?F %��}" # � 3 ( % 3 ( 3 p]\ � )-^Rp $6_ 1 �}"��'# ( 3 ����� #3 � # �a` � .�cb-, ( � � 3 Ag% 7 3 Ag%�"����-�� 3�# #^� 3 (&+ ! 3 �?��6 ( � ( %�� + # �-�?>Z5 3 ! 387 � ( !\"$A>��!����!�'Da5 3 ! 387 � ( !\"$A�!��6&�!�D#�#�"��!� ( �)Ag%���" � + �)#( � �)# ( " 7 3 ( � ( %��C> + �'A ( "��!� 3 �d>x��! 7 �?> ( %�� # �65 �f� # �f�'A �>�?> ( %��C5 3 6;�?� 3�# �!� ( %��RA_�!� "4& + ! 3 ( "?��� �%> ( %�� 7 3 Ag%'"?���)F � ���!�'D5 3 ! 387 � ( !\"�A 7 � # �f� 3 #\# + 7 �)#��!����6 ( % 3 ( ( %��H5 3 6u��� 3�# A 3 � 1 � � $ 5�!��)#\# � # 3 # 3 > + �'A ( "��!� �%> ( %��-"�� # �75 �)� # �f� ( * 3 !\" 3 1 ��)# �3 � # ( % 3 (3( %�"$#�> + �'A ( "?��� A 3 � 1 � 3 5'5�!\� $ " 7 3 ( � # 1 6 3 . �f"O&!% ( � # # + 7 �%> 3 #� ( �?> 1 3 #�"�#�> + �'A ( "?���'#7F � "?��� 3 ! !�7&�!��)#\#&"��!�"$# + # � # .K" ( % 3 # � ( �?> ( ! 3 "���"��'& # 3 ( 3 ( � �D# ( " 7 3 ( � ( %��e. �f"O&!% ( #7FTV � A_��� ( ! 3 # ( � 3 5 3 ! 3 7 � ( !�"$A 7 � # �f� 3 #�# + 7 �)# ( % 3 ( ( %��5 3 6;��� 3�# A 3 � 1 � � $ 5�!�D#�#� #B3 # 3^ ���/.K�H> + �'A ( "?���-�%> ( %�� "?� # �65 �f� # �)� ( * 3 !\" 3 1 ��)# 3 � # # � * ��! 3 �35 3 ! 387 � ( �I!\#7F %�� ( ! 3 "���"��'&# 3 ( 3 "�# ( %��)� + # � # ( � �)# ( " 7B3 ( � ( %���5 3 ! 3 7 � ( ��!g#6FfNg ++h i .kj*(lh /nm�1324oqp /arstg ++h i .kj*(lh /nm�1324oujah /lh (arSv�1xw ),6Zy+hzp{x|~}7�c� .�5ar-+-1xw 1x�xh .#(� } h 6�17+=�/jap3(*.kjdg ++h i .kj(ah /nm� g ++h i .kj*(lh /nm�132K�Yh 50/*1xjlhzp�xg ++h i .kj*(lh /nm�132�v�ptw��]ptj�m

� �

Page 78: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� E ������������������� �2�� ��?�� � ��� ���� �� ����� ������������+������

����������������������������������������������������

BUCKET

BOOM

STICK

�����! #"%$'&#(�)!*�+-,/.10#��243657$98�243;:<3<,>=?"�36"%@A(

BDC�,>EF��G�">$40H=?"I,�JK$L2M=?@N0F36"%$O,>E#$P FGI$L=6Q�0F36"R36@N$9,>"%��2S36CHT�C#=!C�UV0F3!"%3!@W$9,>"%��2O"%$9�?">$XG>G>�Y=?CZ@N=�T�$45�G�3!CFTA,>EF$9��"�G> #�[,R36\#��5��[,/.,>=P,>EF$�0#"%=!\F5Y$4@]=6Q^T�$9,>$4">@N��C#�YCF�_,>EF$O@`3?G>G��YCa,>E#$S\# H2Rb!$M,X(�c�EF$�0#"%=!\F5Y$4@]=6Q^T�$9,>$4">@N��C#�YCF�L,%E#$�Qd=?"%29$�=?Ce,>EF$�,%$9$M,%EZ=!Qf,>EF$\# F2Rb?$M,'293!Cg\h$P@N=�T�$95�5�$4Ti�YCj3ZG>�Y@N��5�3!"OQk3!G>E#�Y=?Cf(_l�=<JK$9:?$9"XmH�Y,'��GOC#=!,S295Y$X36"�,>EF36,S,>E#$4">$W��GS3AGI��C#�?5Y$PQd=!"R2M$W3!2n,%�YCF�Z=?C,>EF$,>$4$M,%E =6QK,>E#$`\# H2Rb!$M,LT# #">��C#�oT����!�?�YC#�o3!CFTjC#=6,L3�@N=!"%$`2M=?@W0F5Y$98j2M=?Cp,%3!2M,'\H$9,/J�$4$9Cj,>E#$a\# F2Rb!$9,_36CFTi,>EF$`�!"%=! #CFTf(a�#=?",>EF��G�"%$43?GI=?Cfm!,%E#�qG�">$40H=?"I,KQd=�2M FG>$4GK=!Ca,>E#$S0#"%=!\F5Y$4@]=6Q�T#$M,>$4">@N��C#��C#�L,%E#$S0F3;.15Y=p3!T`@`3?G>G4(�c�E#$S0#">=?\#5�$9@]=6Q^@W$X3!G> #"%�YC#�P,>EF$T����!�?�YC#�WQd=?"%29$�=?CZ,%E#$'\# F2Rb?$M,�,>$4$M,%EA�qG�C#=!,�T�$43!5[,�J��Y,>E���C�3!C1.aT�$M,R36��5r(c�E#$���Cp:?$4GI,>���?36,>��=!CL=!QF,%E#$�C#=!C�UV0F3!"%3!@W$9,>"%��2�"%$9�!"%$4G%G>�Y=?C_@N=1T#$95���CFT��q293<,%$4G�,%EF3<,�,%E#$�\#5�3?2Rb_\h=;8L360#0#"%=?3?2REL�qG��Y@N0#"R3!2M,>�q293!5T� #$a,>=o,%E#$A5�3!">�?$e36@N=! #Cp,L=!Q�,>"R36��C#��C#�gT#36,%3oC#$4$4T�$XTs,>=g$4GI,>��@N36,>$a,>E#$Z0F3;.15Y=p3!TiQd #CF2M,>��=!Cf(iBV,PJK=! #5qT GI$4$9@t,>EH3<,P\h=6,%E$M81,%">$4@W$XG9m1,%E#$LT�$9,%3!�Y5�$4TA@N=�T�$95f=?C�=!C#$SEF3!CFT7mF3!CFTZ,>E#$_\F5�3?2Rbe\H=;8Z=!CA,>E#$'=!,>E#$4"4mF">$Xu? F�Y"%$O,>=1=N@L F2REA,>��@N$L36CHTZ$9vh=?"I,�,%=@N$43?GI #"%$N0F36"R36@N$9,>$9"RG�,>=o\h$`=6Q�0#"R3!2n,%��24365� FG>$!(Zc�E#$`0F36"R36@N$9,>"%��2P@N=1T#$95�"%$4up #��">$XGOQk36"'5�$4G%G_T#36,%3ZQd=!"S,%"%3!�YC#��C#��,%EF36Cj,>EF$C#=?C�Uw0H36"R36@N$M,%">�q2�">$4�!"%$4G%GI��=!CN@N=�T�$95wm#36CHT`$9:?$9C`,%E#=! #�?Ea3LT#$M,%3!�Y5�$4Te@W=�T�$45x=6Qf$43?2RE`,/.10H$O=6Qf@`3?2RE#�YCF$�@L HG/,�\H$OT�$9:?$95�=!0h$4T7m36CA$M8#3?2n,�@W$X3!G> #"%$9@N$9Cp,�=6Qy,%E#$S@N=1T#$95f0F3!"%3!@N$M,>$4"%G��qG�C#=6,�"%$4up #��">$XT7(�l�$9CF29$!m�,%E#$S0F36"R36@N$9,>"%��2�@N=1T#$95f360F0H$X36"RG�,%=W\h$S,>EF$\h$4GI,�360#0#"%=?3?2REf(ze{R| } ~e�o���4�9�9�A���L�o�A��~L�'�K����Y�? #"%$�&F(Y)�G>E#=<J�G�3�,/.p0F��24365�$M8#243;:;36,>=?"�29=!CFG>�qG/,%�YC#�S=!Qh3O\H=1=?@AmpG/,%��2RbP36CFTP\# F2Rb?$M,�2M=?C#C#$X2n,>$XTL\1._0F�YCO�/=!��Cp,%G�3!CFTPEp.�T�"R36 F5Y�q22M.15��YCHT�$9"RG9(���G>��C#�_,%$42RE#C#�qup #$4G�Qd">=?@�T#.pCH36@N��24G�3!CFTN"%=!\h=6,>�q29G4m6,%E#$�@`3?G>G��YC`,%E#$�\F F2Rb!$9,�293!Ce\H$OGI0h$429�[�H$4Te3?G�3SQd #CH2n,>��=!Ca=6Q,>EF$�0#"%$4G%GI #"%$4Gx��CS,>EF$�E1.1T#"%3! #5Y�q2�2M.15��YCFT#$9"RG9m4,>E#$�36C#�?5Y$XG7\H$9,/J�$4$9CS$43?2RE'2M=!@N0h=!C#$4Cp,y36CFTO,%E#$9��"yT�$4">��:<3<,>��:!$XG��kG>$9$���$42n,%�Y=?C_&#( �?�M(l�$4CF2M$?m6�YQh365�51,>EF$K0H36"R36@N$M,%$9"RGf��CL,%E#��G�@N=�T�$45#2M=! F5�TP\H$�T�$9,>$4">@N��C#$4T7m6,>E#$4CWT�$9,>$4">@N��C#�YCF��,%E#$�@N3?G>G���CL,%E#$�\# F2Rb?$M,�J�=? #5�TP\h$3`G>�Y@N0#5�$'@`3<,I,%$9"�=!Q�$4:;3!5Y H3<,>��C#�N,%E#$SQd #CF2M,>��=!Co�!��:!$4CA3P,%�Y@N$_E#�qGI,>=!"%.e=!Q^,%E#$_36C#�?5Y$XG�36CFTA0#"%$4G%G> #">$XG9(���C�Qd=!">,> FCF3<,%$95�.!m�,%E#��G360F0#">=p3!2REP��G���@N0#"R3!2n,%��243651Qd=?"�GI$4:!$9"R3651"%$43?GI=?CFG9(���\1:p��=! HGI5�.!m<$4:!$9CNJ��Y,>E`3'T�$9,%36��5�$4TW@N=1T#$95�,%E#$9"%$�36"%$K FC#@N=1T#$95�5Y$XTWQd$43<,% #"%$4G4mG> F2REA3?GKQd">�q2n,%�Y=?CZ��CA,>E#$'0F�YCFG�3!CFT�2M.15��YCFT#$9"RG9m#3!CFTe,%E#$'E1.�T�"%3! #5���2�$95q3!GI,>�q2M�Y,/.a36CHTa��C#$9">,>�q3W=6Q�,>E#$_29.15Y��CFT�$4"%G4(�c�E#$9"%$S��G�3!5�G>=35q36"%�!$e3!@N=! #Cp,L=!Q�C#=!�qGI$Z�YC�,>E#$AT#3<,R3#m�0F3!"I,%��29 #5�3!">5�.g��C ,%E#$Z@N$X3!G> #">$4@N$9Cp,L=6Q�3!C#�! F5�3!"L3!242M$95�$9"R3<,%�Y=?CFG4(l�=<JK$9:!$4"4m^,>EF$

Page 79: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

��� ��� ������� �y� ���� � � ���'������ � (

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450−200

−100

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

Data point

payl

oad

mas

s (k

g)

X "B& + !�� � F ��� � 5'5�!\� $ "���� ( "?���G�%> ( %��=5�� 6;�?��� # + #&"��'& !�� # "��Z� 1 �!#�"�# > + �'A ( "?���'#7F�� * �!� + � ( "��!�G�?> ( %��#> + �JA ( "��!��� ( ( %�� ( !��Z"���"��'&5y�!"�� ( #6F�G��# ( #&"O&!�'"��JA��Z� ( # !��+. 1 �!A + #&"��'&�� # � ( �Z"���� # �G� # �f��"$# ( %���"��e5�!��!A ( "$A��!�?" ( 63�%>�� ����# + !\"��'&��Z��� ( %��L5���!�� � � ( ��!g# >x��! �!�!Ag%���!Ag%�"����)F�"I� 1 � �DA_�!�'�#�G"�A��Z���?6 * "�� 1 �� � � # � * "$A � ( �$� ����# + !�� ( %���5�� 6;����� # #&%�� + � # ��� ( !�!% + "�!�� # � ( �!"?�� # � ���!# + !���� �f� ( #>x��! �!�!Ag%&���!Ag%�"����?F� �'� ( %���!'�?5'5�!\����Ag% �=# "(�#��� ( !\"�A��Z���?6��?5'5y��#� # ( � ( %�� # � ( �!"?�� # �G� # �)��"$# ( � + #�5�����KD 5���!�� � � ( !�"$A !��6&�!��)#\#�"?��� ( � �)# ( "(��� ( �( %��L5�� 6;����� # > + �'A ( "?����F�FK� + ( "����D# "(�e5������ �f� ( "��'& ( %��)#� ( �)Ag%��'"(% + �D#)��!�T.K" # �)�?6*� * �Z"��(� 1 ��?F#V � >+��A ( � �`#&"(�e5����R# �!��!gAg% �%>( %��PV � ( ��!\��� ( !�� * ���!��� # � # � ( �%> 5 +'1 ��"$A # �#���Z"��-,.� ( �(� 1 !\� +�( "����)# � >x��! ( %����%5'5�!\� $ "���� ( "��!� �?> > + �'A ( "?���'# + #�"?�4&@!�� # "(�!�1 ��#&"$#H> + �'A ( "��!�'#0/ � - F " !\"�� n 6 � ( %�"�#1�%5'5�!\����Ag%2��#�# + � �)# ( %�� ( ( %�� > + �JA ( "��!� "��3% + �)# ( "��!� A��!� 1 �4�?5'5�!\� $ "(��� ( � # 1 62�. �f"O&!% ( � # # + � �?> !�� # "(�!� 1 �!#�"�# > + �'A ( "?���'#5�Z� # + #�)#[�?"�������! !�7&�!��)#\#&"��!� ( � # � ( ��!6�G"?��� ( %���. �f"O&!% ( #7F59;�#� ��#��?5�%'"�# ( "$A�� ( "��!�"$#7� #�# � # ( � # � ( ��!6�R"���� ( %��8�R�u# ( # + " ( � 1 ���K#� ( �%> 1 �!#�"$#d> + �'A ( "?���'#6F7"I� ( �)# (( %�"$#�� � ( %�� #]��# � ( ����� # �9� * �Z"���� 1 �� >F!\�#� F 93V" �)Ag%������?�)&!"�)#Y.8�!# + #� # ( �QA_���'# ( ! + A ( �Z���%545�!�� $ "(��� ( "��!� ( � ( %��Q5�� 6;����� # > + �JA ( "��!�dF�"}%�� # � ( ��.:��# � 1 ( �Z"���� # 1 6L5'�(��A_"��'& ���/.K�&�;��#�#�)#�"�� ( %�� 1�+ A � ( �?>��!� � $ A�� * � ( ��!9�Z� # � ���!# + !\"?�4& ( %���5�!��)#\# + !��)#8�!� # �Z�'&����D#:��# ( %���Af�!����& + !�� ( "?���8�%> ( %����!6� .:��# * ��!�"� # F7"I� !�� # + A � ( %��^A_���H5'��� $ " ( 6-�%> ( %���5�!\� 1 ���� � ( %�� ( �D# ( "?�4&C.8�!# # �!��� �!�'�?6-���<�Q# +'1 #� ( �%> ( %�"$# # � ( �T>x��!.K%�"$Ag% ( %���A_�����4& + !6� ( "��!�P.8�!#5# ( � ( "$A%FYV � ( %�"�#}A��!#� � ( %��S5�� 6;�?��� # > + �'A ( "��!� # �65 �f� # #h�!� ( %�� ( %�!�� ���Z�'&����D# # �D#�A�!�" 1 "��'& ( %��A_�����4& + !6� ( "��!� �?> ( %�����!=�>�Z� # ( %��C5�!��)#\# + !�>"?�k�!���GA_6;��"?� # ��! � 1�+ ( ��� ( �!� ( %��;�Z�4& + ����! * �)�?�@A_" ( "�)#��Z� # �!A)A �)���I!6� ( "��!�'#7FX "B& + !�� � F �-#�%��/.[# ( %��C5��?� ( �?> ( %��;�%545�!�� $ "(��� ( � # > + �'A ( "��!�>x��! ( %�� # � ( �<5y�!"�� ( # + # � # "?� ( %��$!��6&�!��)#\#�"?����F?"I� ( �D# (*( %��� 1 "?��" ( 6 �%> ( %����%5'5�!�� $ "(�;� ( "��!� ( �l"?� ( �I!@5y�!��� ( � � # � ( � >x��!@�&���!#\#��%>9� � A &M.8�!#*!�D# �I! * � # �Z� # ( %��;�G� # �f� .8�!# ( !6�!"?��� #�!� ( %�� !������!"?��"��'& # � ( �4F5"}%�� !��)# + � ( "��'&<5�� 6;����� # > + �'A ( "?���.:��# ( %��f��� * �!� + � ( � # >x��! ( %��;� �#A & # � ( �'F5"}%���!�D# + � ( #)��!��#�%��/.K� &�!��%5�%�"$A��!�?��6 "�� X "B& + !�� � F J'F*"}%���� � ( %�� # "�#>A_�����!���6 + �B� 1 �� ( � "?� ( �I!@5y�!��� ( � 1 � ( . ���f�C���!#\#�)#�"�� ( %�� ( !��Z"���"��'&# � ( �'F�9;"?�JA � ( %�� # � * "�A �Q"$# � $ 5 �)A ( � # ( � 1 � + # � # >x��!@�P.K" # �3!6�!�'& �Q�%> 5�� 6;�?��� # ���!#\# �D# � " ( "$#["(�H5�!6��A ( "$A��!� ( � ( !��Z"�� ( %��# � * "$A � ( � ( %��3�� * �f� �?> # � ( �!"?� !���% + " !�� # F�D �3A_���'A_� + # � � ( %���!��]>x��!�� � ( %�� ( ( %�� 1 �(��A 1 � $ �%5'5�!\����Ag% �?>������KD 5���!�� � � ( !�"$A!��6&�!��)#\#�"?���3"�#[��� ( �Z���DA_�!�'�#�G"�A��Z���?6e>��!�!#�" 1 ���^�?5 ( "��!��F$ r / /FE�G HIH %&%'%KJ p3+-5 J .�L J p35 J )NM!HIO 67P1�H-jly,2 J r /6#w

,

Page 80: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� I ������������������ �K��� ���� ��� � ���@�9� ��������� ����������������

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90−600

−400

−200

0

200

400

600

800

Data point

payl

oad

mas

s (k

g)

X "B& + !�� � F J�� � 5'5�!\� $ "���� ( "��!�G�%> ( %��E5�� 6;����� # + #�"��'&3!�� # "��Z� 1 �!#�"�# > + �'A ( "?���'#7F�� * �Z� + � ( "?���-�%> ( %��E> + �'A ( "��!�P>x��! ���!#\# �D# ��� (+ #� # "�� ( !6�!"?��"��'&�F

,

Page 81: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

������� ������� � �������1������� ���

2

θ3

����� � �� � �� � �� � �� � �� � �

θ1P1

P2

P3

θY

� �� � � � ��

��

��

� � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � �� � � � � �� � � � � �� � � � � �� � � � � �� � � � � �

X

X��O& +���� � F ��"!$#%# �'& �)(�� (*�,+.-�+)(�� �!>/# �"(�0�� & � ( �1� �32 �4# &5� 2aF" 05� 56#%# � � 1 �)27� (8- #%> (*05� (5#9('Da5�� � �#� �C(�� �;:1�%545 � #��9: 0<&��=� � * �>+ > � ##� (�05� 27#�:��32?(�� (&+5�*� #?> (�0�� �?5'5 � # $ �(��� ( �7#@(�F VA(# �'&��=� ( #B�7( (��=� 5C#92�� (*� ( � . �;� +�+��=+ (5# ( �7( (�05�;(�� �3�)(5�7(4& & � ( �5D + ##� �FE (5#/.G2 �=& & � #%> (�0�� &@27# 1 �32 >/# � �H#?> (*05� > + (�: ( �7#@(� +I��� % + � �*�=& FCVA( (*05� >/#92)27#/.G�)('& +.� : ( �7#@(W. �J&5� * � 27#)50� &���( �3�)2 �=& �J# &�� 2Y>/# � �3( � $ :�� * � ( # � � � �[FLKM#/. � * �=� D � � (�0��1�*(�0 �9(

� � � +)+5�*� 5�� � � � �C(*�1�'+?& � �*� : ( 2 - > � ##� (*05� �;�@: 0 �)( � DK. � 5 � #)56# +.� ( # +�+��I��� & �*�=+*+ �)#9(<�3(��92 -�+ � + #%> & � ( �C>/# �?E (5#/.G( . � �O& 0>('+( # �>+ ( ����� (�� (*05� 5�� � �#� ��(��=�*+ �)( (�05� �J# &�� 2lFYVA(e& � ( �1� �32ND (*05�1�*� � + �I(5#9('DN2)�7( � � �$&�� 5 � ( &5� (�: � #%> (�05� 5�� - 27#�� & �;� +�+ #9( (�0���)( &�� 5 � ( &�� ( ( * � � �(� 1 2 �>+ �9( & (*05��+ ( E (5#/.G(5�� � �#� ��(��=�*+ F�"�#<� * #9� &@(�05� :O#��e5527�;:�� ( �)#9( + #%> +�+ �)('&P(5#9(KDQ2)�7( � � �R��� & �*�=+*+ �)#9(�32O&9# � � (�0 � + D (*05� � &�� � + � �*� �)272 +�+)(�� � (��>& �7(TS � : ( �7#@( � F +�+ �7(4&1� + �(�e552 � #9( � D � � � �>&P& �B&)& �1� F X5# � (�0 � + �4# &�� 2 & �O&?& �1� D (�0��5�� - 2)#�� & � + �L2)�)( � � � > + (�: ( �7#@(U#%> ( .V#e5�� � � � ��(��1�'+ D �9272)#/.G�)('&L2)�)( � � �G��� & �*�=+*+ �)#9( ( # 16� +6+.�>& >/# �"(�05� � �W�>+ ( ����� ( �)#9(�F9 �'X Y Z<;\[M]_^a`PbGcWdIcfegZih" 05�L� $ :�� * � ( # �W+�0 #/.G(\�)(X��O& +���� � F � � + & � ( �1� �32)�7j �=& ( # (�05� (*05�*�1� 2)�)( E � � � +�0 #/.G(\�7(Xk�O& +5�*� � F �FWl &�- (��#�J�;: �4# &�� 2#%> (�0 � + & � ( �1� �;: � $ :�� * � ( # � � +?&�� * � 2)#?5 �=& +�+ �)('& (�05�,m �%& � �3(4&9���3(��%545 � #��9: 0 F�� �@: 0 :O#��e56#@( � ( ( #%> (*05�,& �O&?& �=� � +?�*� 552��9: �=&1%- � + �)('&92 � 27�)( E FK" 05� 2)�7( E�+ � �*� :O#9(�( � : (��=& 1%- 55�)( + . 0 �;: 0 �9272)#/. � �9: 0 2)�)( E � + �)('&@2 �I&�� & ���=� #?>d> �*�1�>& ##� �9( & :1#9( +)(�� �3�)(�32)2 (*05� 2)�7( E%+ ( #n2)� � �7( (*05�i+ � � � 552��3( � F9" 05� 2)�7( E�+ � ��� ( + � 16�=���>& > � #�� � (*05� # + & 0 J�D4.G� (�0\o9p�1C� �)('& (*05� �9('&92 � #%> (�0��� �'+ ( 27�)( E .G� (*0'(*05�i0 # � �)j1#@( ( �32d552(�9( � �9( &\orq DCsGt � D 1C� �)('& (*05�i�*� 2�� ( � * � �3(4&92 �T16��( . �=� (u2)�)( E�+ sgv � �3( & s-F)" 05� �9('&92 �oxw � +?�*�=+��1� * �>& >/# �"(�05�,� # ( � ( �)#9(y#%> (�05��1 � +�� � � # + ( &;(�05�{z � $ � + Fm �?& � �3('& � U +|� % + � ( �)#9( + #%>��J# ( �)#9(-/ � - + 5 � :1� > -;(�0 � ( (�05�,� ( �1� &9� �=+G+ � ( � + > - (*05� >/#92)27#/.G�)('& +.-�+)(�� �}#%> � % + � ( �)#9( + �~~@�4�M�C��y�o q1� v ���� o qM��� q8� s � I � 0 0?0 ����� � � F �x�. 05�=��� � q � + (*05�?� � (�� #%>�.V# �*E,& #9( � #@( (�0��?+�-�+ (*� � 1%- (*05� (5#9(KDA:O#@( +��1� * � ( � * � >/# � : �=+ .G� (�0 �7(�: ��� � +��=+ �7( (�0�� �9('&92 �"orq F�" 0��& �O&?& �1� � � ��� +I+)+41��8� : (*( #y:1#9( +��1� * � ( � * � >/# � : �>+ D & +5�$( # & � � * � (8- D �3( & (5#9(KDA:O#@( +��1� * � ( � * � >/# � : �=+ (�05� # + & 0'(*05�J0�-�&�� � + 27�;:: - 2)�7( &��1�'+ 16��( . �=� ( � �@: 0 2)�7( E �3( & (*05� ( # � % +5� �%545527� �=& ( # (*05�,� # ( � ( �)('& 1 � +�� Fla:1#�# �*& �7(�� (��W+�-�+ (*� ��� + � (�( �9: 0��=&$( # (�05� � $ �=&e1 � +.� #?> (�05� � �*+)( 2)�7( E F7" 05�R� � $ � + � + �32)�B&@( �=& .G� (�0 (�05�f& �B&)& �=� � � �UD(�0��Jz � $ � + * �1��( �;:��32 ( # (�0��H1 � +�� �3( & (�0��n� � $ � + 5 �1� 5 � ( & �;: + 2(� � ( # (*05� � � ���)( (�05�J0 # � �)j1#9( ( �32~552(�9( � F{l (�� �3( + 2�� (*�=&:O#%# �*& �)(�� (��R+�-�+ (*� � >/# � 2)�)( E s�� + � ()( �@: 05�=& ( # (�05� 55�)(U:O#9(�( � : ( �)('&i2)�7( E s�v � ( #L2)�)( E stFg� q � +�(*05� 56# + � ( �)#9( * � : ( # � #?> (�0��s (�0 27�)( E �7( (�05� � $ �>& :O#%# �'& �)(�� (*�f+�-�+ (*� �[F

Page 82: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� � ��������������������K�������� ��� � ���@�9���������� ����������������� �@: 0 27�)( E � + � � �O&9� & 1 # &�- + ( &��1� &9#@�7('& � # ( � ( �7#@( �3( & (�� �3( + 2(� ( �)#9(�F m �)( E s � # ( � (*�=+ .G� (�0 �3('& + 2�� � * � 2)#%:1� (8-� q �� I � �oxw9� � q

��� p �o � � �3( & � ( U +#1 � +��4�1(�0�� 56#@�7( ( � q �8(*� �9( + 2�� (*�=+ .G� (�0 * � 27#�:1� (8-��3q D'. 05�=���� p � I �� q � � q�� p�� � � q v � q�� p ���� q�� p 0

" 05�{E �)( �C( �):�3( & 5C# (*� ( ( ���32 � ( �=� & - #%> � �9: 0 2)�7( EU&�� 5 � ( &5+ #@( (�05� �;� +�+��yq DC: � ( (��*� #%>7��� +*+��>q �9( & �7( �1��( ���32 (*� ( + # ���Oq FX5# � :O#@( * � (�� � (�: � D (�05� : � ( (*��� #?> ��� +*+ �9( & �7( �=�)( �(�92 (*� ( + # �'+ � �*� ( � E@� ( �*� 2�� ( � * �"( #�56# + � ( �)#9(n� q >/# �|� �@: 0 2)�)( E F � 1 * �7# +�+ 2 - D+ �7(�: � (�0�� 27�)( E � +|� # ( � ( �7(4& � �O&9� & 2 - �)( (�0 � + :1#�# �*& �7(�� (��W+�-�+ (*� �UD � q �3( &!� q &�� 5 � ( & �)(�� E (�#/.G(C>+� +.0 �7#@(n#9( (�05� 27�)( E �3('&@2 �>+o p (�05� # + & 0yo q FK" 05�,E �7( �C( �;: �3( & 5C# (*� ( ( ���32 � ( �1� & - #?> � �9: 0 27�)( E � ��� &@� * � ( 1�- (�05�,� $ 5 ���>+�+ �7#@( +" q � �

� �Uq����3q$#%�3qQ� � �Uq&�3q$#@��kq �'�=qQ� � �� kq&�Oq&�(q � � � F � �

)6q � �yq�� � q � �=qQ��#9� I �+*�� I � � � � F J �. 05�=����* � +8(*05� �9:1: � 2 �1� � ( �7#@( & +5�*( #e& � � * � (8- F�" 0 � ( � + D " q �3( &,) q � ��� (�05�,E �)( �C( �):��3( & 5C# (*� ( ( ���32 � ( �1� &9� �=+ #%>k27�)( E sK�9( &� � � ,q � p " q v ) q � + (�0�� ( # ( �32 � ( �1� & - +6+.� �)( � % + � ( �7#@( � F � F

D # �*E � +M& #@( �L1%- (�05� (5#9('DQ:1#9( +��1� * � ( � * � >/# � : �=+ � + (*05� 2 � ('& (�0�+ #%> (*05�i0%-�&�� � + 2)�;:,: - 27�)( &��=�*+ : 0 �3(4& � F m �C(.-�q*�/orqQ�#1C�(�0�� 2 � (4& (�0 #%> (�05� : - 2)�7( &��1� :O#@(5( � : ( �)('&J27�)( E s .G� (�0 (�05� 5 �*� * �)# +�+ 2)�7( E D%# �8(*05��1 � +�� �7( (�05� :�� +.� #%> (�05� � �'+ ( 2)�7( E F"S%�)(�: �� �@: 0 : - 2)�7( &5�1� :1#9(5( � : ('+ ( � �B& 031 # +5� �)('&{2)�)( E�+ D (�05� .$# ��E :O# ���*�=+ 56#@( & �)('& ( #L: 0 �3('& �=+ �7( orqk&�� 5 � ( &�+ #@(52 - #9( (*05� > + (�: ( �7#@(-6q.�/orqQ� �3( & (*05� >/# � : �>+ #@( (�05� s (�/ : - 2)�7( &��1� � + >/#92)27#/. +

� q �10 q -32q �/o q � 0 � � F �" 05� >/# � : � 0 q � + 5 � #)56# �)( �7#@(��32 ( # (*05� 5 ���>+�+�+5�*�W& �54 �1�*� (6: � �@: � # +*+ (�0�� : - 2)�7( &��1� �4�7( +�+ �3( - > � �;: ( �7#@(��324>/# � : �=+ F~V ( � +"0 #)5 �>&(�0 � ("(�05�>+.� > � �): ( �)#9(��92c>/# � : �=+ � ���I+ ���9272 � (�# + & 0;( # 1C� ( � &@2 � : (*�=& F�KW#/. � * �1� D@�)( (�05�I� * � ( ("(�0 � ("(�05�=- � �*� (�# ( D (*05�1- �;� -1C� � +*+)+ � �>& ( # 1C� �)(R5 � #)56# �)( �7#@( ( # (*05� * � 27#�:1� (8- #?> (*05� : - 2)�7( &5�1��- 2 � o q � �o q F" 05�4� $ :�� * � ( # �S1�+ : E9��( � +,�*� 5 �*�=+�� ( (*�=& � +*(�05� (*0 � �*& 2)�7( E FFK � (�: � (�05� 5�� - 2)#�� & ��� +*+ � +6� , F S��7(�: � (�05� 5C# (*� ( ( ���32� ( �1� & - #?> (*05� ��(B�32 2)�)( E D6� q D &�� 5 � ( &5+ #@( � �9: 0 #%> (*05� �3(4&92 �=+ D (�05� 5�� - 27#�� & �;� +�+ �%5'5 � � �*+ �)( � % + � ( �)#9(U�)( (�05�i+�-�+ (*� �&9� * � ( 1%- � % + � ( �)#9( � F � F5" 0 � ( � + D �3( - #@( � #?> (*05�=+��i� % + � ( �7#@( + :��3( 1C� +�+��=& ( # &��=� � * � �P> + (�: ( �7#@(>/# � (�0�� 5�� - 2)#�� & �)((��=� � + #?> (*05� �9('&92 �=+ D9: - 2)�7( &��1� 5 �*�=+*+�+5���>+ �3( & 5�� � �#� �C(��=�*+ #?> (*05�M+�-%+)(�� �[F87M# (�� D 0 #/. � * �1� D (�0 � ("� �@: 0L� % + � ( �7#@( &5� 5 � ( &5+#9(�2 - #9(2� + �7('&@2 � 5 �*�=+*+)+5�*� F K � (�: � DY>/# ��(�05� (5#9('Da5�� � �#� �C(�� �;:��%5'5 � #��9: 0 D (�05� 5�� - 2)#�� & > + (�: ( �7#@( :��9( 1C� � +*+�+ � �=& ( #&�� 5 � ( & #9( (�05� (*05�*�1� �3('&@2 �>+ D (*05� � �"( �(� �,� � (��>+ #%>k: 0 �3('& � D��3( & �9( -P+ �)('&92 � 5 �*�=+*+)+5�*� FX5# � (�05� 5�� � � � �C(*� �;:;�%5'5 � #��9: 0 D�. � � �*� �7( (*�1�*�=+)(��=& �)( 0 #/. (�05� 5�� - 2)#�� & > + (6: ( �)#9( &5� 5 � ( &5+ #9( (�0�� + ( E (5#/.G( 5��%D� � � �C(*�1�'+ F4" 0��=+��;+ ( E (5#/.G( 5B� � � � �C(*�1�'+ � �*� (*05� ��� +*+��=+ D �Uq DK�3( & (*05� �4#�� � ( (*+��yq&�=q �3( &9�Oq #?> (�05� 2)�7( E�+ F S%�)(�: �(�0�� � ( �1� &9� �=+ �9( & & � ( �=� �927�)j �>& >/# � : �=+ � �*� 27�)( � � � �)( (*05�=+�� 5B� � � � �C(*�1�'+ D (�05� 5�� - 27#�� & ��� +*+ � + � � � ( �)#9(��92 > + (6: ( �)#9(_#%>(�0�� 5B� � � � �C(*�1�'+ D�2)�7( � � � �)( 1 # (�0 (�0�� ( + � �=� � ( # � �3( &'(*05�J&5� (5#��J�)(�� ( # � FiK � (�: � D (*05� 5�� � � � �C(*� �;:�?5'5 � #��@: 0\� ( ( �9�72 + �(5#@(KDN2)�)( � � �V�*� & ���>+�+ �)#9(1�9(��32 -�+ � + F9 �;: <>= Y ?A@CBEDFDL[Wh"�#P:O#��e5�� �*� (�05� 5�� � �#� ��(�� �): �9( & (5#@(KD 5�� � � � �C(*� �;: �%545 � #��9: 05�>+ D6:O#9( + � &��1� (�05�J+ �(�e552 �L& �O&?& �1�R+�0 #/.G( + : 05� ��� ( �;:��32)2 - �)(Xk�B& +5�*� � F A F�" 05��1 � +.� � + � $ �>& D��3( & (�05� :1#9(��4& +5� � ( �)#9(P: 0 �3('& �=+ #9(52 - .G� (�0 (�05� �3('&@2 �fo F|l +�(*05�1�*� � + #9(�2 - � + �)('&@2 � 27�)( E#%>|2 � (4& (�0HG . 0 �;: 0T& # �=+ (5# (R� # ( � (�� D (*05�J+�+'1�+ : � �O5 (*+ � �*�i&�� #?5'5 �=& F)" 05� : � ( (*��� #%> ��� +*+ #?> (�05� 2)�7( E � + � +�+�+ � �=& ( # 2)� �#9( (*05� 2)�7( E � ( � & � +)( �3(6: �.I > � ##� (�05��1 � +.� F"KW#/. � * �1� D��7(*� &5& � ( �)#9( ( # (*05� ��� +*+ #%> (�0�� 27�)( E D��;��� +*+�J ��� 5 �*�=+�� ( ( �)('&(�0�� 5�� - 2)#�� & � + � (�( �@: 05�=& ( # (*05�L� ( & #?> (�0�� 2)�7( E F " 00+�+ D � p � I D p � �o �3( &K� p � ��I :O# +5o5�;IM+ �)( o@� D �9( & � % + � ( �)#9( +� � F � � D � � F J � �3( &B� � F � 16� :O#�� �

" � �� �o ( � � �

� JLG ( �o ( � � F A@�) � �&JLG � �'IC��+ �7( o � � F � �� � - 2 � o@�NMPO � � F �9�

Page 83: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

������� ���+�gZ��� � �9��� � J

2d

1d

h(θ)

l

m

M

θ

x

�^���! F">$'&�������c�EF$������� ����!�!$4"����NG>�Y@N0#5�$��FG>��C#�!5�$���$9�?">$4$�=!Q^Qd"%$9$���=!@��#�Y�?�!$9"��

Page 84: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� ��������������������K�������� ��� � ���@�9���������� ����������������S +'16+ ( � (&+ ( �)('& (�0��,��� % + � �*�=&y&��1� � * � ( � * �>+ �)( ( #�� % + � ( �)#9( � F � D�2 � � &5+ ( # (�0��,��� 2(� ( �)#9(� � � JLG (����o � *I�&JLG � ��I�� :O# +�o � - 2 � o@�NMPO{�

. 0 �;: 0 :��3( 1C�{+ #@2 * �=& >/# �"(�05� 5B� - 2)#�� & ��� +*+ FK" 0 � + � +G� $ 5 ���>+�+��=& � +J�� M��.o@� � - 2 � o@�NMPO v * �'I :O# +%o v � �o

G ( �o � * G :1# +�o 0 � � F � �" 05� 2 � ('& (�0K- � + &9� * � ( 1%- (�0��,� $ 5 �*�=+*+ �)#9(

-��/o@� ��� ~ ( p �<~ (( vC� ~ p ~ ( :O# +�o5��3( &P+ #

-32N�/o@� � ~ p ~ ( + �7( � o@�� - � o@� 0" 05� 2 � ('& (�0�+ ~%p �3( & ~ ( D4. 0 �): 0\&��>+ : � � 16� (*05� :1#9(��4& +5� � ( �)#9(y#%> (�0�� 55� + ( #9( D � �*� � +�+�+ � �=& ( # 16�{E (5#/.G( ( #��3( -P&��>+ � �*�=&�9:=: +5� �9: - F�D 05�1�*� � + D�rD � � D��3( &�G :��3(P#9(52 -P16�I�>+ ( ����� (*�=& F7" 0 � + � +$�*� 5 ���>+.� ( ( � ( � * � #%> (�05�I�*� �32�:�� +.� . 05�=��� (�05� : � ( (��*�#%> ��� +*+ #%> (�05� 5B� - 2)#�� & :��3(5(5# ( 16�W&5�C(��=� �4�)( �=& �)(�� & * �3(6: �G+ �(�e552 -L1C� :�� +�+��"(�05�W& � +)(�� � 1�+�( �)#9(4#%> (�05� 2)#�� & �)( (�05�#1�+ : E9��(� + (5# (IE (5#/.G(�FCX +5��(�05�=� D (*05� : � ( (*��� #%> �;� +�+ �9( &'(*05� �7( �1��( ���32 (�� ( + # �*+ #?> � �@: 0 2)�7( E :��3(�(5# (�1C�4&5�C(��=� �4�)( �=& >/# �I� �9: 0���9: 0 �)( �,& +5� ( # � :O#@(5##�4�;:I:O#9( + (*� �9�7( (*+ FX5# ��(*05�,&�- (�� �4�;: � % + � ( �7#@( D (�05� ��� +*+ � + �i(�#9(KDQ27�)( � � � > + (�: ( �7#@( #?> (�0�� (*05���=� 5B� � � � �C(*�1�'+ F�" #;� * #@� &$(*05� :O#��H5�27�;:��%D( �)#9( + #%>�(�#9(KDQ27�)( � � �?��� & �*�=+*+ �)#9(P:O#9( + � &��1� (*05�{+ ( � ( �):I:�� +.� FYVA( (*0 � + :�� +�� D (*05� ��� +*+ :��3( 16�,�*� 5 ���>+.� ( (*�=& � + �C> + (�: ( �7#@(U#%>(�0�� 5 ���>+�+�+5�*� D��3(4&92 � �9( & (�05�*( .V# + ( E (5#/.G(R5�� � � � �C(*�1�'+ D� p �9( & ( � + �9( & � % + � ( �7#@( � F � 1C� :O#�� �=+

J�� M��.o@� � p M ( �3( o�� -��/o@� v ( 0 � � F � �. 05�=��� p � ~%pO~ ( O�� * G �9( & ( � �'I�� G F 7M# (*� D (*0 � (f+ �)(�: � �;�9( - #%> (�0��3+ ( E (5#/.G( 5�� � �#� �C(��=�*+ :��3(5(�# (Q1C�i&��C(*�1� �4�7( �>&( #;�3( -F&��>+ � �*�=& �@:1: +5� �@: - D@(5#@(KD & ��� � ( + �)#9(B�32)�7j!� ( �)#9( � + (5# ( 5 � �@: ( �;:��92lFYX5# �G+ �(�e5527�;:O� (8- D (*05� + (5� (*+VE �72)#?& � �#� + D�� �C(��=�*+ �9( &+�� :O#@( &5+ .G�)2)2 1C� +�+��=& D � + (*05�=+�� � �*�G�*� 2 � * �3( (( # (�05�M+ :��92 � #?> (�05� �4�)(5�)('& � $ :�� * � ( # �*+ FdXk�B& +5�*� � F � +.0 #/. +(�05� :1#9( ( # +5�'+ #%>:O#@( +)( �3( ( ��� +*+ >/# �"(*05�i+ ���e552 � �4# &5� 2 � + �L> + (�: ( �7#@(y#?> (*05�{+ �7('&@2 � �9('&92 �Io �3( & (�0�� 5 ���>+�+�+5�*� D M �)( (*05�{+ �7('&@2 � : - 2)�)( &��1�+�+ �7(4& (*05� 5�� � �#� ��(��=� * �92 +5�>+ p � � I �P( + (4D� ( � � E &6D ~%p � � �yD ~ ( � � �[FVA( (*0 � +G+ �(�e552 � �4# &�� 2u. �R0 � * � (�05� #?5 ( �)#9( #?> +�+ �7(4& � � & ���32 1 � + � + > + (�: ( �7#@( ( #;�%5'5 � # $ ����� (�� (*0 � + > + (�: ( �7#@( D5# � +�+ �7(4&2)�7( � � �G�*� & ���>+�+ �7#@(<.G� (�0 � `�� .���.�� / & � ( �C>/# ��J D o �9( &FM@( # �=+)( �(�;� (��*(�0�� 5�� � � � �C(*�1�'+ F"�#,�72)2 +6+ (*� � (��"(�0��W� 4 � : ( � * � ( �=+*+ #%> (�0�� 5�� � � � ��(�� �):8�3( & (�#9(KD 5�� � � � ��(�� �):8�%545 � #��9: 05�>+ ( # (�0�� 5 � # 1 2 � �UD ( .V# & � ( � +��C(*+. �1�*� & � ( �1� � (*�=& >/# � (��>+ ( �7(4&4F@" 05� � �*+)(f& � ( � +��C( .8� + & � ( �=� � (��>&[1�- : 0 #%# + �)('& � I?I?I � �3( & ##� 5C#9�)( ('+ �)( (*05��M D o 552(�9( � D:O#��e5 + ( �)('& (�0�� ��� +�+ D J�� M ��o@� > � #�� � % + � ( �)#9( � F � �9( & � &5& �)('&�� + ���32)2 � �4# + ( ( #%>k(5#9� +.� ( #��9272 (�0����=� * � � ��� 1 2 �=+ F�" 0 � +& � ( �f� +"+.0 #/.G(J�)(eXk�O& +5�*� � F � �4F'" 05� U 552 +6+ U + �O&9( +g�*� 5 �*�=+�� ( (|& � ( � +�+��=& >/# � (*� �9�7(5�)('& (�0�� �J# &�� 2��3( &3(*05� :O� � :12 �>+g��� 5 �*�=+�� ( (& � ( � +�+��=&�( # (*�=+)((�05�M���>+)+ 2 ( �)('&�5�� - 2)#�� & > + (�: ( �)#9(�F�l +�� :1#9( &J+��C( #?> & � ( ��D +.0 #/.G(J�)(PXk�B& +5��� � F �/1 D%.8� + & � ( �=� � (��=&�+�+ �7(4&#9(�2 -@(�0����=� * �32 +5�=+ #%> (*05� ��� +*+�J � � I E &6DcJ I E &<�3( & I E & � F?� % + � ( �)#9( � F �M.:� + +�+��=& ( # &���(��=� �4�)( �3(*05� 5 ���>+�+�+5�*� M

� + �L> + (�: ( �7#@( #?> (�05� ��� +*+ J �3( & �9('&92 �Mo FK" 0 � + > + (6: ( �)#9( .:� + (*05� ( +�+��=& ( # &5�C(��=� �4�)( � (�05� 5 �*�=+*+)+5�*�=+ :O# ���*�=+ 56#@( & �)('&( # (�05�;(�05�*�1� �;� +�+��=+ �3( & � � �9( & #�� + � �e552 � #%>?�9('&92 �=+ FH�R(�: � �%&��3�)( Dk(5#9� +.� .:� + � &�&��=& ( # (�0�� �*�=+�+ 2 ( �7(4& 5C#9�)( ('+ ( #�*� 5 �*�=+�� ( (I��� �32 �1�*� # �'+ �)(-� � � +�+5�*� � � ( ( F�" 05�F& � ( �R5C#9�)( (*+ :1# �*���>+ 5C#9( & �7('& ( # (*05� 2(� � & �=+)( �9( & + ���32)2 �=+)( �;� +�+��=+ . �1�*�+�+��=& >/# �"(*� �9�7(��7('&6D��3( &;(�0��{& � ( �L>/# �"(�05� �4� &5& 2 � ��� +*+ .:� +"+�+.�>& >/# � * �=� ���6:�� ( �)#9(�F

" 05� > + (6: ( �)#9( J�� M ��o@� # 1 ( �9�7( �>&$+�+ �)('&�?5'5 � # $ ����� ( �7#@( 1%- � � � & �(�92 1 � + � + > + (�: ( �)#9( + (�� �3�)( �=& #@( (�05�>+.� ( .V# & � ( � +��C(*+� +R+�0 #/.G(\�)(WXk�B& +5�*� � F �'F,!$##�e5�� � �)('& (�05��( .V# :O#@( ( # +5� 552)# (*+ ( # (�05�L� $ �9: ( :1#9( ( # +5� 552)# ( #%> Xk�O& +5�*� � F � :12 � � � 2 -U+.0 #/. +(�0�� ( �1�>&;( # (�� �3�)( (*05� �%5'5 � # $ �(�;� ( �)#9(P#9( �42(� � & � D + (5�B>/# � �42 - & � +)(�� � 1�+ (��>&y+ � �e552)�)('&4#%> & � ( �'FS%�)(�: � (�05� �J# &�� 2"� + 2)�7( � � � �7( (*05� ( .V# 5�� � �#� ��(��=�*+ D � ( � +i+)(�� �3�O& 0>( >/# � .8� �'& ( # 5 �1� >/# � � �\2)�)( � � �i�*� & �*�=+*+ �7#@( +�+ �7(4&� % + � ( �)#9( � F � ( # �>+ ( ����� (��Q1 # (*0 p �9( & ( >/# �$� �@: 04& � ( � +��C( F X��O& +���� � F � +�0 #/. + (�0�� :O#@( ( # +�� 5527# (*+ #%> (�05� �%5'5 � # $ ����� (��> + (�: ( �)#9( + +�+ �)('& (*05�"( .$# & � ( � +��C('+ FglW2 (�0 # + & 0$(*05�W�1�*� # �'+ � ��� � + : 0 2�� � & �=� >/# �(*05�W+.� :O#@( &4+.��( D (*05� 5�� � �#� ��(�� �)::� �C(*0 # &5 � # & + : �>+ >+� �#1C�C(�(��1�M���>+)+ 2 (*+ (*0 �3( (*05� (5#9('Da5�� � �#� �C(�� �;:5� �C(*0 # & F

Page 85: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

������� ���+�gZ��� � �9��� �#A

3 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 3.7 3.8 3.9 40.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

1.1

pressure

angl

e

15

15

20

20

25

25

30

3035

3540

45

�����! #"%$'&�� &�����=!Cp,%=! #"RGK=6Q�,>E#$'$98��?2n,�0 �;.15�= ���eQd #CF2M,>��=!CAQd=!"�,%E#$ ��� � ����!�?$9"

Page 86: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� � ��������������������K�������� ��� � ���@�9���������� ����������������

3 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 3.7 3.8 3.9 40.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

1.1

1.2

1.3

pressure

angl

e

� � ��� � ( � +.��( l

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 140.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

1.1

1.2

1.3

pressure

angl

e

� 16��� � ( � +.��( "Xk�B& +5�*� � F � � � � ( � +��C('+ >/# � (�� �3�)(5�7(4&$�9( & (*�=+)( �)('&L#?> (�0�� �4# &�� 2 + F7" 05�*(�� �3�)(5�7(4& & � ( �L� + ��� �*E9�>&P1%- : � # +*+ D 0 �3� �'+ �3( & (�0��(��>+ ( �7(4& & � ( � 1%- :1� � :O2 �=+ F

Page 87: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

������� ���+�gZ��� � �9��� � �

3 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 3.7 3.8 3.9 40.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

1.1

pressure

angl

e

15

15

20

20

25

25

30

3035

3540

40

� � ��� � ( � +.��( l

3 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 3.7 3.8 3.9 40.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

1.1

pressure

angl

e

0

0

5

510

10

10

15

15

20

20

25

25

30

35

� 16��� � ( � +.��( "Xk�B& +5�*� � F ���V!$#@( ( # +5�'+ #%> (*05� (5#@(KDa5B� � � � �C(*� �;:)�?5'5 � # $ ����� ( �7#@( + ( # (*05� 5�� - 2)#�� & > + (6: ( �)#9([>/# � (�0���� ��,TS � �O&?& �1� F "�#?5 D& � ( � +.��( l{D 1 # (�( #��yD & � ( � +��C( "

Page 88: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� � ��������������������K�������� ��� � ���@�9���������� ����������������

3 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 3.7 3.8 3.9 40.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

1.1

pressure

angl

e

15

15

20

20

25

25

30

30

35

3540

40

� � ��� � ( � +.��( l

3 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 3.7 3.8 3.9 40.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

1.1

pressure

angl

e

10

10

15

15

20

2025

25

25

30

30

35

� 16��� � ( � +.��( "Xk�B& +5�*� � F ��� � � � �#� ��(�� �):��%545 � # $ �(��� ( �)#9( + ( # (�0�� 5�� - 27#�� & > + (�: ( �)#9([>/# � (�05��� �(,BS � �O&?& �1� F " #)5 D & � ( � +��C( l{D 1 # (�( #��yD& � ( � +.��( "SF

Page 89: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

������� ��8� ��� 1�9�8�O � �9 ��� ��Z��UbW]���BOZ ���� +5� (*�=+)( �)('&<#%> 1 # (�0 5�� � �#� �C(�� �;:&�9( & (5#9('Da5�� � �#� �C(�� �;:1� �C(*0 # &5+ #?> �*� :1#9( +)(��&+ : ( �)('& (�05� ��� +*+ > + (6: ( �)#9( > � ##� & � ( ��)( & �;:�� (*� (*0 � (�(�05� (5#9(KD 5�� � �#� ��(�� �):��6\ ���t^����6_<�%545 � #��9: 0 ( # (�05� 5 � # 1 2 � � � + (5# ( 27� E9� 2 - ( # 16�P� :O#@(5##�4�;:��9272 - > � � + � 1 2 � FlW2 (�0 # + & 0 �)( (*05� # ��- (*05� �%5'5 � #��9: 0 � +,+ �(�e552 ��( #U���e552 � � � ( ( �3( & :��3( 16� �%545527� �=& ( #*� * � � � ��(8- #%> ���@: 0 �7( �=+ .G� (*0 (�#� &�& � ( �7#@(��32 �J# &�� 272)�)('&�D6�7( 5 � �9: ( �;: � D (�0�� ( + � 1C�1� #%> & � ( �P56#@�7( ('+ ( � : �=+*+ � ��- >/# � (*05� (*� �9�7(5�)('&n#?> � �9: 0[1 # $ � + ( #%#n2�� � & � F�R( (�05� # (�0��1�G0 �9( & D�� ( � + :O2 � � �"(�0 � ( (�0�� 5�� � � � �C(*� �;:@�%5'5 � #��9: 0 :��3( 1C�3+�+��=& ( # �>+ ( ����� (*� (�0�� �;� +�+ > + (�: ( �7#@( .G� (*0 # +�(E (5#/.G2 �=& & � #?> (*05�n� $ �@: ( & � ##� �C(*��- #%> (�05� ���9: 0 �7( � D + # (�0 � ( � + �)('&@2 � Dd5�� � �#� ��(�� �):9D�� & �*�1- U 1 # $ :��9( 1C� �%545527� �=& ( #.�.G� &�� * � � � ��(8- #%>��;�@: 0 �)( �=+ .G� (�0@(�0��{+ �#� ��1 � + �;:S& � ##� �C(*��- FVA( (�0 � +G�*� 5C# ��( . � :O#@( + � &��=���>& #@(52 - � + �(�H5�2 � 2)�7( � � � �4# &�� 2 ( #n�)272 +�+)(�� � (��*(*05� � & * �9( ( �%& �=+ #%>~5�� � � � �C(*� �;: ��� & �*�=+*+ �)#9(# * �=� (5#@(KD 5�� � � � �C(*� �;: �*� & ���>+�+ �7#@([>/# � (�0 � + 5�� ��( �;: + 2(� � �?5'552)�):�� ( �)#9(dF�X�# � (�05� > + 2)2����9: 0 �)( � D � ( � + 2)� E@� 2 - (*0 � ( (5#@(KDN2)�)( � � ��*� & �*�=+*+ �7#@( (�� : 0 (5��% +��=+ � +�+ (T1C� �%545527� �=& FPV ({��� �;�9�7( +*( # 16�F+�0 #/.G( (�0 � ( (�05�>+.� � ��(�0 # &5+ .G�)2)2":O#@( * �1� & � >/# � (�0�� & � ( �� * �3�)2(� 1 2 � >/# �8(�� �3�)(5�)('&4F|S%�)(�: � (�0�� (5# � ���92�#?5 �1� � ( �7#@(F#%> (*05�f� $ :�� * � ( # � � + (5# ( ( # 1C� �)( (��1� > �1�*�=& .G� (*0 D (�05� �9: (�+ �92 &�� * �): �.V# + 2 & ( � : �=+*+ � � �)2 -;+�+.� (*05� > + 2)2 &�- (��#�4�):@�4# &�� 2 � � (�05�=�"(�0 �9( (�05�{+ �(�H5�2 �=�M+ ( � ( �):@�4# &�� 2 � $ 552)# �*�=&P05�1�*� F VA( (��1�*�=+)( �)('&@2 - D(�0��1�*� � + 2 �=+*+ + (6: �1��( �9�7( (8- �)( (�0�� &�- (�� �4�;:;�4# ( �)#9( #?> (*05� & �O&?& �1� � � � (*0 �3( �)( (�05� +)( � ( �;: + � (�+ � ( �)#9(dFMVA( (�05� E �)( ��( �;::�� +.� D (�05� > � �;: ( �7#@(��32 >/# � : � �7( �u: - 2)�7( &5�1� � + � > + (6: ( �)#9( #%> (*05� 5�� +)( #@( * � 27#�:O� (8- FWVA(_:O#@( (�� � +)( D (�05� ���%&9(�� (&+�&�� #%> (�0��+)( � ( �):C> � �): ( �)#9(��92~>/# � : � .G�72)2 &�� 5 � ( & #@( (*05�40 � +)( # ��- #?> �4# ( �7#@(�F;" 0 � ( � + D � * � ( �)( (*05� # ��- Dq. 05� (W> � �;: ( �7#@(��32~>/# � : �=+ � �*��)(�:O2 +�&��>& D (*05� �;� +�+ �)( (�05�P1�+ : E9�C( :��9(B(�# (�16�F&5�C(��=� �4�)( �=& > � ##� 5 �*�=+*+�+5��� �3( & �9('&92 �J& � ( � �927#@( � F4l�:O#9( ( �7( +�+ � #%>:O#@(��4& +5� � ( �)#9( + � ��� 56# +�+ � 1 2 � >/# �"(�05�{+ � � � ��� +*+ F

Page 90: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� I ��������������������K�������� ��� � ���@�9���������� ����������������

Page 91: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� ��� ������� ��� ���

/ � -�� �1�*��- KLF��f�)( +N1C�1� &4F�� ,�� � � �tb&,�� � / .��cbtb6`�.�� /���� � �� $. �"!"#6K?� � 5 �1�%$'& #/.,D 7 � .)(|# ��E D � � � �/ � - ,.� ��E � � F+* � � ` �=,�, � � . � � � �.-���,�. �/\%/ ��!-.0!213,�� � � . � �54Cb �76 �/`@^�!8#8" � : 0 (5�;:��92 �*� 5C# ��( D#VA( +)( � (�+ (*� #?>,l & �%5 ( � * � �9( &

7 ��+5� �32�!$#��H5 + ( � ( �)#9( D � � * � + �)#9(U#?> VA(K>/# � ��� ( �): + D�� & �)( 1�+5� & 029 (5� * �1�'+ � (8- D � � � �

� �

Page 92: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

��� � � � � �9�@������� � �

Page 93: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� ��������� �

� ��� � �'�� � � � ��� � ��� � � � � ��� � � � � � � �� � �

� � � � � ��� � �� � � � � � �� ���

m - (5(R"8� ()(*� ( p D6!=F5S � �9( "V# 00+ (4(9D�� � 2)2 ! 05� ('& , D�"�##� � ##���3('0@D � # 0 ( �R�*� .Q83D & # & � & .8� �'&5+ (xD�S +�+ �3(�� + ( � -K, D �R� * #9(,u:x! ��� �?(rD�D � ( &�- , -�� * #@2 & (rD4X � �3( E & +�+�E9�=- (3D � # � S��+.8� & �)(xD � � + 27�)( � * �3( &�� ( �R� � �=+*+ : 0�� (rD � �3(B���K�9( &��=� �I27# �C(t, D� � (*05��- ( m F "SF�DB#%# & ()F

&G� 5C# ��( 5 �*� 5�� ���>&<1%- lM( &��*�8� "$#@(�� , �9( & !$2(� +�&��,m ���B� �;� �7, F� �7: = �Jegh�Z<; UbVe�B1Z��" 05�=��� � + � + ( �%&?& �1� �7(4&92 - 2�� � & � ( + � 16�=� #%>$: 05� �4�):��32g:O##�e5C# + ( &5+ (�0 � ( :��3( 1C� �;� &���� � * � (. 05� (T#9( � :1#9( + � &5�1�'+ #9(�2 -(�0 # +��W0%- 5C# (*05�C( �):��32B�J#@2 � : + 2 �=+(�0 � ( � �*����&5��+ &?DN2)� E9��� D (�05�=��� � �*�W+ ( �72)245 � # 1 � 1 2 - #@( (�05� # �'&��1� #?> � I p8w�w + (5��% +�� �4#92 � : + 2(� �+)(��&+ : (&+5���>+ F'" # & � (�� Dx#9(52 - #@( (�05� # �*&5�1� #?> � I�� :1##�e56# + ( &5+ 0 � * � 1C�1� ( ��� &�� �9( & : 0 � � �@: (��=� �)j �>& F " 05�=��� � + :1#9( +�� % +5� ( ( 2 -(5# 0 #)5 � #?> 5 � # & + :O�)('& (�0�� ( # ( �32)� (8- #%> E (�#/.G(y: 05� �4�):��32 :O#��e56# + ( &5+ � ( �3( - ( �(� � �7( (*05� > + (�+���� FKW#/. � * �1� D#���3( - #%> (�05� :O#��H5C# + ( &5+�(�0 � (V0 � * �E1C�1� ( +�- ( (*05�=+ �7j �=& D�� + . � 2)2 � + (*0 # +�� (�0 � ( :1# + 2 &P1C� �(���%&9�)( �>& �)( (�0��+ �7j �M� I pAw*w +��C( D � �*�"+)(��&+ : (&+5� �9272 - :O2)# +�� ( # � �@: 0 # (�0��1� �3( & .V# + 2 &�1C�V� $ 5 � : (*�=& ( #R�)( (��1� �9: ( .G� (�0L1 �7#@27#)&9�;:��32��4#92 � : + 2 �>+ +�+ : 0� +k� (5j - � �=+G� �9:1:1# �'& �)('& ( #SXk� + : 0��1� U + � 2)#�: E�$aE@�1-!� :1#9(�: � 5 ( � �7(;� + �(�4�72�� � >+� +�0 �)#9(�F��R( � 5 � ##�4� + �)('&R(�# ( �)#9(J#%> + (*��+ : (�+�� �92+ ���4�)2(� � � (8- � + (�05� :1#9(�: � 5 ( #?>@� � 5 0 � � ���9:1#?5 0 # ���"� D . 05�=��� :1##�e56# + ( &5+ �;� ( : 0 �)('& (�0��u+ �#� � 5 0 � � �;�@:O#)5 0 # �*� #%> (�� (�)( (*�1� �9: ( .G� (�0 1 �7#@27#)&9�;:��32'�4#92 � : + 2 �>+L� � (5j - � �>+ D �*� : � 5 ( # �*+ D �C( : � �)(4� + �(�4�72�� � .:� - FSX�# �f� $ � �e552 � D (*05� 5 0 � � �;�@:O#)5 0 # �*���('& �1� 5 � �7( ( :��3(e5 � # * � &5� * �32 + � 1 2 � �)(K>/# � ��� ( �7#@(L�)( (*05�W+�� � � : 0 >/# � (5# * � 2��9: ( � * � :O##�e5C# + ( &5+ D9�7( (�0�� � � � +�+5�*� #?> & � * �=�*+ � (8-#%>7� + : ���=� (5�)('&J27� 15� � �*- D��9( & #?> +)(��&+ : (�+5�*� D �9: ( � * � (8-n�*� 2�� ( �)#9( +.0 �O5 +Z1C�C( . �1� ( (*05�=+�� :O##�e5C# + ( &5+ F

D � � �*� �92 + #�5�� ��( �;: + 2�� � 2 - �7( (��=���>+ (*�=& �7(n:12(� +�+ � > - �)('&I27#/.2�4#92 � : + 2(� � . � �B& 0�( : 05� �4�):��325:O#��e56# + ( &5+ >/# �|&���+ & & � + :O# * �1�*-5 � # �8� : (*+ (*0 � ( :��3(J�7( 0 � 1 � ( (*05� �9: ( �)#9(4#%> �3( � (�j - � �Z1%- 27# & &@�7('& (*05� � +�� 2 * �=+ .G� (�0 �7(n� (*+ �@: ( � * �?+ � (�� F�S%�)(�: �"(*05� & � ##� �C(*��-#%> (�0��=+�� :O##�e5C# + ( &5+ � +�+)( ��� ( : 0�(*05� :O#@(��4& +5� � ( �)#9(J#%> (�05�G�*� : � � * �7('&�5 � # (*� �)( D (*05� 5 0 � � ���9:1#?5 0 # �*� �)(K>/# � ��� ( �7#@(J:1# + 2 &1C� +�+.�>& ( #4���e5 � # * � (�0��{+)+ :=: �>+�+?� � (*� Fl 5 0 � � ���@:O#?5 0 # �*� � + � + (*��+ : (�+�� �92 � 1�+)(�� �9: ( �)#9( #?> (*05� �)( (*�1� �9: ( �)#9( + 1C�C( . �1� ( * � � �)# +�+ > + (6: ( �)#9(B�32�& � # + 5 (8- 5 �=+ �)(*�:O#��e56# + ( & F7" 05�=- � ���f&��=+ : � � 16�>&P1%- � + 5B� ( ���32 ��� 5 �*�=+�� ( ( � ( �)#9(n#%> (*05�=+�� & � # + 5 + � + : � ( (*���>+M� # � * �1��( �;: �>+*� #?>d& � ##� �C(*� �;:��925C#92 -�0��=&�� �5D ( #)& ��(�05�=� .G� (�0 5��3� � .G� +��R& � + ( �3(�: �=+Z1C�C( . �1� (y: � ( (*���>+ F7" 05� :O# ���*�=+ 5C#9( & �)('&T& � # + 5 +8+ ( &��=� :O#9( + � &��1� � ( �7#@(�� �*�(8- 55�;:��32)2 -$# � ,/` � / b � ��� ��, �����tb&% � �%` � KMlM!G! � D # � ,%` � / b�� ��� �E,',�� � �/` � K � � 7 � D �ub / � � . �/b � 7)� � � �9( & % � !�. � . �+b � � �IS �: 0 � � & �=+ D��3( &'# � ,%` �(% # ����. � � K ( �f� & � # + 5 + F � (*05�1� & � # + 5 + :��9( � � + �)2 -H1C� �7(�:1# � 56# � � (��>& �7( ( # (�05� �3(B�32 -%+ � + F�" 05� : � ( (*��� D( #?DQ: � ( (��*�{& � + ( �3(�: �=+M0 � * ��1C�1� ( �=+)( �(��� (��>& � (E1C�C( . �1� (4�)l ( # �NA )l{D � 1�+�( �%&��3�)( D�# (�05�=�R& � + ( �3(�: �{� �3('& �=+ :��9( 16�L� � + �)2 -f g+*+h i-,kj/.lh 0nm214365�p4*+h 0/1xy+ps g+*+h i-,kj/.lh 0nm2143K�Yh8790/1xjlhzp{ g+*+h i-,kj/.lh 0nm2143�v�ptw��]ptj�m� } ,Nptjaw8, v:1xjFE�1xj p(0lh81;*�xv<1xw�w8,k�;,=143!> h�w�w�hzp4? p4*!L@5�ptjlm� g+*+h i-,kj/.lh 0nm2143�v�ptw��]ptj�mA�BDCEGF BIH"J fLK;?

�?J

Page 94: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

�3 ������ ��������� � ��#�� �^��������9�8� ��� � �������������?� ��� � � � �5�K� & �%5 (*�=& F9" - 5��):��32)2 - D (�05�L�=& & � 2 � ('& (*0�+ � ���{& � * � &��=& �)( ( # & � +)( �3(6: � �)( (��1� * �32 + D4. 05�1�*�{� * �1�*- 5 0 � � ���@:O#?5 0 # �*� .G� (*0u�=& & �2 � ('& (�0�+ �)( (�05�{+ � � �,+ 5 � :1��� �=& �7( (*�1� * �92 +?- � � 2 &5+G+ ���4�)2(� � : 05� �4�;:��32q5 � #)5 �=�)( � �>+ F

D � 5 � # * � &5� �3( �3(��92 -�+ � + (�0 � ( >+�9:1�72)� ( � (*�=+ :O# + ( ( �)('&RJ&�3( & U: � ( (*��� 5 0 � � ���9:1#?5 0 # ���>+ DC�)(�:O2 +�& �)('&*����� (*05� ��� ( �;:��32�4# &�� 2Z>/# �4& � + ( �3(�: � �)( (��1� * �32 � � ( �)# + D (�� �(�9('&92 � �9( & # (*05�1� �)( � % + �927� (8- ��� % + � �*� � � ( ('+ >/# � > � � + � 1 2 � (*� ���3(4&92 �=+ �9( & (*�C(*� �%D05�>&�� ��D7�3( &<+�- �;� ��(�� � �>+ F0D � �32 + #u�7(6:O2 +�&��P+ ##� �y+ 5 � :1�(�92V:�� +��=+ � + �9(<�7( & �):�� ( �7#@(<#%> (*05�P+�05�1�=� ( + � 16�=� #?> ��� 2 � * �3( (5 0 � � ���@:O#?5 0 # �*�=+$� * � ( + ( &��=� * �=��-F+ 5 � :O���6:I2)���4� ( �)('&F:O� � : + � + ( �3(�: �=+ F" �=+ � &5�I+ 5�� ( ���32 +�- �;� �C(*� � �=+ �3( &U& � + ( �3(�: �,+ �(�4�72�� � � ( � �>+ >/# �W� �9: 0y�=& & � #%> (�05� 5C#92 -%05�=&5� ��D (�05�=���{& # �>+ (5# ( �?5'5 � � �"( #1C� �3( - # (�05�=�G��� 2 � * �9( (G+)(��&+ : (�+5� �32 + ���4�)2(� � � (8- > � � (�+�����1C�C( . �1� ( ( .V#e5 0 � � ���9:1#?5 0 # �*�=+�(�0 � ( :��9( 1C� +�+��=& ( # �*�=& + : � (�0��:O2�� +*+ ���6:�� ( �7#@( #%>7� (8- 55�):��32 :1##�e56# + ( & F

� ��� ?������ [?egh�BO[ � Z e��U[ ek[?egh�c �U[Q;\h�Z��"�#L& ��( * �=��-J� # + & 0 D 1�+ ( % + � (�� & � ( �1� �32 �>+ ( ����� (��=+ #9( (�05� ( + � 1C�1� #%>�5C# +*+ � 1 2 � J/DA: � ( (��*� �3( & ?DQ: � ( (��*� 5 0 � � �;�@:O#)5 0 # �*�=+ D�R. � 272 E (5#/.G( ��� (*05� ��� ( �):��32|:1# + ( ( �)('&[5 � �7(6:O�O552 � :��32)2 �>& " +5� ( + � &�� U + 2 � �;���U:��9( 1C� +�+��=& F�" 0 � + >/# � � + 2��U:O# + ( (*+*(�0��� $ �@: ( ( + � 1C�1� #%>M(�#9(KDQ� + ##�4# � 5 0 �): (�� �(�9('&92 �=+ �3( & (���(�� � 05�>&�� � .G� (*0�� 56# +�+ � 1 2 �y�=& & � (8- 5 �=+ �9( & M56# +�+ � 1 2 � (8- 5 �>+ #%>* �=�)( �): �=+,� : � ( (*���>+*� D ( � E �7('&n�)( ( #��@:1:O# + ( (W� % + � * �32 � (�: � :O2�� +*+.�>+ #%> +.- �;� �C(*� � �=+ &@� * � ( 1%- � + 5 � :O��� �=& & � # + 5�� �@: ( �7('&n#@(� (�� �(�9('&92 � # �"(*�C(�� � 0��=&�� #9( D�� + &9� * � ( 1%- �

"i��� � � � �� � ���-����

� �N*5� �. 05�=��� � ��*�� � + (�0�� ( + � 1C�1� #?>k:O#@(��4& +5� � ( �)#9( + � $ �>& 1%- * FVA( (�0�� :�� +.� #?> (*05� J%DQ: � ( (��*� 5 0 � � ���9:1#?5 0 # ���,� ��� 5 ���>+.� ( (��=&H1%- � (�� �(�9('&92 ���U� D +.- �;� �C(�� � �=+ :1# �*��� : ( 2 - �)(�:O2 +�&�� �4� �*� # ��(�;�?& �>+ FZX5# � (�05� ?DQ: � ( (��*� :�� +.�F� ��� 5 ���>+.� ( (��=&R1%- � (*�C(*� � 05�=&�� #9(�� � D��4� �*� # � �(�;�?& �>+{� � �*� � � : ( �7#@( (*05� # + & 0 �9( - #9( � #%>

(�0�� >+�9: �>+*� � ���,& � + ( �7(6: ( �)( (*05� : 05� �J�;:��92 +.� ( +�� D��3( & � +�+)( 1C�,� $ :12 +�&5�=& > � #�� (�0�� :O##�e5 +�( � ( �7#@(�F" 05�I�*�=+�+ 2 ( �7(4& �>+ ( ����� (�� #9( (�0�� ( + � 1C�1� #%> J;�3( & n: � ( (��*� 5 0 � � ���9:O#)5 0 # ���>+ � + &9� * � ( 1%- (*05� >/#92)27#/.G�)('& ( � 1 2 � �+.- �;� �C(��*- (8- 5 � � &��=+ : � �B5 ( �)#9( ( + � ���U� � �N*5� ( + � � � � � �N*5�� & � &�� ( ( � (8- � �', , � � 2 x0� � 1C�O� : &�� �3( ( �O56# & �92 �=& & �=+ J � 0 ](� � 1 : � (�� �(�9('& + 2�� � >+�@: � � � p p � � ( ](� � 1C� ���B5 J � (�](

" # ( �32 � � � � � �"�� 1 2 �F� F � � �|0 � � �;�@:O#)5 0 # �*�=+ .G� (�0 J;�3( & n: � ( (*���>+ F

7W# (�� (*0 � ( >/# � (*05� (���(�� � 05�>&�� #9( � �9: 0 #?> (*05�{�*�=+�+ 2 ( �)('&P5 �=� � + ( � ( �)#9( + � +M� * � ( �1(�0�� 5 � # & + : ( #?>K�3( � * � (\( + � 1C�1� #%>(�� �3( + 5C# + � ( �7#@( +'� �3( & (�0��1�*� � ���L� �i#%> (*05� �[FK" 00+�+8(�05� & � # + 5F� +8(*05� �32 (��1� (�� ( �)('&L& � # + 5 D O 0 FK" 0 � + >+�@: ( � + +�+��=& 2(� (��1� �)((�0�� 5 � #)& � � � � + � ( :O#��e5 + (��>+ :��9(5#9(��):��32 ��� 5 �*�=+�� ( ( � ( � * �=+ #?> � �@: 0;(*�C(*� � 05�=&�� #9(dFX5# �"(�05�*(*� ���3('&@2 � D (�05� " +5� ( + � &5� :1##�e5 + ( � ( �7#@(R&@� * �=+ +�+

"L����� �! � �� ��� , , � J � ( ( � � � � 0

X5# �"(�05� (*�C(*� � 05�=&�� #9( . � & �C(

"L����� �#" � �� � ��� 2 0 � J � 0 ( � � � ( ( � 0K �=��� � ��� 2)� +)(��>&y& �54 �1�*� ( ( * �32 +5�=+ #?> "$ �9( & "%" >/# � * � � �)# +�+ * �32 +5�>+ #%> � �9( & ��

Page 95: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

��� ��� � � �.���������Ki��� ���?� �����������?�����'�8� � AE : "$ ,����� � "%"G��� � �� � A� A J A � A� � �9 �r A� � � �J � � A A � � � � I � � �J � A � J�� ��� I � �#� � �?J � I � AJ � � � � � �)�?� � � � � A � � I J �)J � A"�� 1 2 �F� F ��� �K�32 +5�=+ #?> " �9( &'" " F

" 05� �9: (�+ �92 :O#@(��4& +�� � ( �)#9( + >/# � "L�8�9� � � � �*�,+.0 #/.G( 1C� 2)#/.�F

��������� � ���������������������������

"�#T: �*� � (�� �9( � � � DA: � ( (*��� 5 0 � � ���9:O#)5 0 # ��� > � ##� �3( � DA: � ( (*��� 5 0 � � ���9:1#?5 0 # ���4�*� % + � ���>+ ( � E �7('&WJ.� &5& � ( �7#@(��32 �=& & �& � + ( �3(�: �=+ �3( & �L5�� ��( �;: + 2(� � >+�9: � #%> (*05� 5 ��� * �)# +6+ 2 - :1#9( +)(��&+ : (��=& 56#@2 -%05�>&�� #@( ��(�0 � + � +V+)+ AF:1� � ( (8( # &��C(*�1� �J�)( �R� �9: 0 ( � .: � ( (��*� U + 27#�:�� ( �)#9(y�7( + 5��9: � F7" 05�,& #��J�)(�� ( �)('& (��=� � # 1 ( �9�7( �=& > � #�� " +5� ( + � &�� U + 2 � �;���J� +"(*05�1�*� >/# ��� � ( �4# + (�� � � � ,! #" � (%$ " �. 05�=��� �?&��9�7( � � + (�0�� ( + � 1C�1� #%> (�0�� : � ( (��*�=+ D � � +3(*05� & � # + 5 #%>5� +�( ##�4# � 5 0 � + � + . 05� ( (�05�>+.� : � ( (��*�=+ � �*� 552��9: �>&�)( (�05� � �4# +)(J+�- �;� ��(�� �):<.:� -!� #9(2� + 5 05�1�*� F & l + �3( � $ � �e552 � D (�05�y& ##�4�)(�� ( �7(4& (��=� �H�)( (�0�� ( + � 1C�1� #%> �%DQ: � ( (��*�5 0 � � ���@:O#?5 0 # �*�=+f�/� � ��DK&9� * �7('& � � � � �r � DK.G� (*0 J I 56# +�+ � 1 2 �I�>& & �*(8- 5 �>+{��� � J I � D��3( &&A : � ( (��*� (8- 5 �=+{� � A@� D�� + �

��r J I p & A &(' � 0 J � � I , w 0

��������� )*�(+��,��-(+��.�����(���/�10�+32��4���5+6���(0�76�/�8���9-����:���������/-(����;l �4# �*�I��� �32)� +)( �;:I:O# + ( ( � +�+ ( :1#9( + � &��1�"(*05�{& � + ( �3(�: �=+ 1C�C( . �1� (\: � ( (��*�=+ D 16� :�� +�+.� �9(&� �@1 � (*� � ��-F+��C( #%> & � + ( �3(�: �=+ � + (5# (( � : �=+ � � �)2 - �9: 0 � � * � 1 2 �<1%- (�� �(�9('&92 �=+ # � (*�C(�� � 0��=&�� �'F VA( (*05� (*� ���3('&@2 � :�� +�� D��\( � : �>+�+ � �*- �9( & +)+ An:1� � ( ( :O#@( & � ( �)#9( >/# �( + � 1C�1�'+�<>=@?A= ( #CB �{�*� �32)�)j �=& � +G+ � &�� 2 � (�D (*0�+ � +"(�0 � ( =E< � ?J�1(*� ���3(�D@2 � �)( � % + �927� (8-5� FZX5# �"(*05� (*�C(�� � 0��=&�� �5D (*0 � +:O#@( & � ( �)#9( 0 #@2 & �7(�Dn#@( � �@: 0 (*� ���3(5D + 2�� � >+�@: � � + :12 � � � 2 - ( � : �>+�+ � �*- D5B + ( � ( � + (5# (R+)+ An:1� � ( ( F9" 05�1�*� � ���{+ ##� � ( � : �=+*+ � �*-�3( &<+)+ An:1� � ( ( :O#@( & � ( �)#9( + >/# �J& � + ( �3(�: �=+ ( #FB � �@: 0 � �HG �IB52 � B - � (*�C(�� � 0��=&�� #9( DJB +�( (�0�� >/#@272)#LKG�7(5D4�IM�M � #��9: 0 � + �4# �*�+�+ � ( �IB52 � >/# � # +5� M +5� M6# +.�>+ F4l +*+)+ � �$(*0 � ( ( KV# (*� ���3(5D + 2�� � >+�9: �=+I0 � G@� B �1� ( &5�C(��=� �4�)( �=&ON (�0�� (�� �(�9(�D92 �=+ KG� (�0 + � &��=+< D ? D ��3( &P? D ~ D *{+�0 #LKG(y�7( Xk�#D +5�*�F� F � F � # +*+ �#B52 �9G �92 +5�>+ (�0 � (9Q :��3( 0 � G9� � +6+ ( B �{&��C(*�1� �J�)( �>& F

" 05� �,D +5�*� +�0 #LK + (�0�� ( KV# �!R0(��*� � � :�� +��=+ >/# �3(*05� 2 � (5D (�0 #?> Q � �7(SB6# (�0 :�� +��=+ (*05� (*�C(*� � 05�=&�� #9( 2)� �>+ �B� ( �)( (�0��M52��3( � F" 0 �)( E �7(5Dy#?> ? � + � 0 �)(�D � D �9272 (�0�� MC# +*+ �TB52 ��(��C(*� � 05�=&5� �>KG� (*0 �9272 & � + ( �3(�: �=+f�!R : � M (UQ � R��>& KG�)272JB � #VB ( �3�)( �=& F7W# ( �)(�D (�0 � ( (�05� �9(�D92 �=+ � ���

W � :1# + � p � <YX � ?ZX v X� <Y? �

[t� 1xj 7ar , ?#h87@ptw j/,Np4./1;* .:\<,=7Np4*�p4. .^] ? ,+0ar/p(0~ptw�w 7 , *-0aj ,I.dw�h8, 1;*20ar , 7 1;*]i-,6_=rH]+w�w 143�0lr 1;./,=7 , * 0lj/, .�`Bi-,kj 0lh87 , .3a J

Page 96: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� � ������ ��������� � ��#�� �^��������9�8� ��� � �������������?� ��� � � � �5�K

� �

� �

Xk�TD +5���F� F � ��,4� E �7(5D$� (*�C(�� � 0��=&�� #9(�FgKW�)(�D � � +�? FK� R0(��*� � � G �92 +��=+ >/# �(QT+.0 #LKG(�F�3( &

� � :O# + � p � ~ X � ?!X v * X� ~ ? � �

(�0�� M6# +�+ �TB�2 � G �32 +5�=+ #?> Q � �*� B6# + ( &��>& � + >/#92)27#LK +< X �_~ X v-� < ~ # :1# +1� W v � � =@Q X =E< X �_~ X v-� < ~ # :1# +1� W � � � 0 � � F �x�l &�& �7(5D (*05� (*� ���3(5D92 � �7( � % + �32)� (8- :O#9( + (*� �9�7( (*+ �3( &T� � F �>� D �*� � ( 2 -L�*�=&�+ : �>+ (*05� ( + � B �=� #%> MC# +*+ �#B52 � M 0 � � �;�@:O#.M 0 # �*�=+ F

" 05�?�!R �@: ( �;�VD9(5� (�+6&�� #%> (*05�?���>& + : ( �)#9(UKG�)2)2 &�� M � ( & #@( (�0�� ( + � B �=� �3( & 2 � (�D (�0�+ #%> (�05� �)( (��1�%G �32 + #9( (�05�?�=& D � 2 � (�D (*0�+ F� �'X � �U[ � B� egh��"�#<> +5��(�05�=�I���>& + : � # +5�f�=+)( �(��� (*� #?> (�05� ( + �UB �1� #%>�M 0 � � ���9:1#VM 0 # ���>+ D + #�� � MC# +*+ �#B52 � : 05� �J�;:��92 ���>+ (*� �;: ( �7#@( + � ��� :O#9('D+ � &��=���>& �7( (�0 � +P+.� : ( �)#9(dF�l�M 0 � � ���9:1#VM 0 # �*� � + � �*� M �*�=+�� ( ( � ( �)#9( #%> (�05� D � ( �=� �927�)j �>& �4#@2 � : + 2�� � > � � (�+����>+ (�0 � ( � �*�:O#@( + � &��=���>&@( # B �J�*�=+ M6#@( + �#B52 � >/# � � &5�=+ � �*�=& B��7#@27#.D9�;:��32��9: ( � G � (8- F "�# �(� M � # G9� (*05� 2)�#B � � ��- #%>�M6# (�� ( ( �(�92'�4#92 � : + 2 �=+ #%>M 0 � � ���@:O#92)#VD@�):��32 �@: ( � G � (8- D S � � � 2 � � + �7( (*�1�*�=+)(��=& �7( &��HG@� 2)#VM5�)(�D1�<� �C(*0 # & (�0 � ( K$# + 2 & ��� M � # G9�3(�05��(��>+ ( �7(�D � AF:1� � (�: -#%> &��&+ D%DQ2)� E@� �4#92 � : + 2 �=+ Fl +f+)( � (*�=& �7( (�05� �)( (*� # & + : ( �)#9( D (*05� >/#92)27#LKG�)(�D�� G9� D � ( �1� �32�:�� (*� D9# � � �=+ #%> �4#@2 � : + 2�� � > � � (�+5�*�=+ � G �3�)2(�VB52 � >/# � �7( (*�1� D�9: ( �)#9( KG� (*0 �9( � (�j - � � � ��� :O#@( + � &��=���>& � 0%-�&�� #.M 0 #.B5�):&/ K ( �� D 0�-�&�� #VD � (OBC#9( &B& #@(�� ( �7(5D / K � � 7 D 0%-%&5� #.D � (FB6#@( &�9:=: � M ( �)(�D2/ KMlM!G! �9( & �)#9(5�;: + � (��>+ K 0 �): 0 :O#9( + � + ( #%>(MC# + � ( � G9� 2 - / � �IS �3( & ( � D�� ( � G@� 2 - / 7?� � : 0 � � D �>& > + (�: ( �7#@(��32D � # + M + Fn!$##�;� �1� :O���32)2 - D + � R ( # +��HG@� (FD � # + M +f0 � G@� B �1� ( +�+��=& ( # &��>+ : � �#B ��(*05� �9: ( � G9�4+ � (��>+ ��0 #LK � G9�=� D�K �J0 � G9� :O#9('D+)(�� �3�)( �=&$(*05� ( + � B �=� #%> M 0 � � ���9:O#.M 0 # � �;: D � # + M +( #�� G9� B - D � # + M��7(�D (*05� � � #���� ( �;:9�3( &40�-�&�� #VM 0 #VB5�;:W:�� (�� D9# � � �=+ �9( &B - (5# ( :O#9( + � &��1� �)(�D$�@:O� & �;:��9( & B�� + �;:E> + (�: ( �7#@(��32 D � # + M + � +G+�� MB� � � (�� > � ##� (*05� # (*05�1� > � � (�+����>+ Fm #LK �1� B6# + ( &5+ >/# ��(*05�,& � +)( �9(�: �>+ B �C( K �1� ( (*05� G � � �)# +6+ MC# +*+ �#B52 � :1##�UB��7(�� ( �)#9( + #%> (�05�>+.� � G9� (8- M �>+ #?> + � (*�=+ ( �1�>& ( #B �M&�� �6( �=& �)( (��=� � + #?> & � +)( �9(�: �>+ B �C( K �1� ( (*05� D � # + M + #@(�� M�� ��( �;: + 2�� � �J#@2 � : + 2 � B�� +.�>& #9( B6#@( & 2 � (�D (�0�+ D.BC#9( & �3(�D@2 �>+�3( & �VM�M � # R �(��� (*�J&�� D �*�1�>+ #?> � # ( � ( �)#9(dF$D 0�� ( (�05� �@: ( � G9�n+ � (*�=+ �)( (��1� �9: ( (�05� # + D 0 + M��@: �4� � (�05�=�*(�0 �9( (*05� �4#92 � : + 2(� �+)(��&+ : (&+5��� #?> (�0�� :O##� MC# + ( & D (�05�{+�+ � #%> (*05� G �3( &��1� D-�#�92 +V� � & �)�:KV# + 2 & B � (�0�� 27�(�4� ( �7(�Dn:�� +�� �)( (�05� :��32;: + 2�� ( �7#@(M>/# �(�0��i& � + ( �3(�: � #%>|:O2)# +��=+)( �IM�M � #��9: 0 F"K �1�*� � �*� 27� +)(��=&\+ ##� � G �3( &5�1� D-�#�92 +G� � & �7�q>/# �M+ ##� � ��� MC# ��( �9( ( � ( #�� + � � � � F )l �7�� � F A )l � K�� � F �)lLF�|0 � � �;�@:O#.M 0 # �*�$+ M��@: � � +"&�� ��( �=& B -3(�0��G��� 2(� ( � G9�G& � + ( �3(�: � B ��( K �=� ( (�05� : � ( (��*�=+ #?> � �9: 04+ � (�� BB� +��=& #9( (�05� B5�7( & �7(5D#VM5M6# �)(&+ (5� ( � �=+ #%> (�05�J� (�j - � � �9: ( � G9�i+ � (*�=+ F)" 05��+ M�M �1� B6# + ( & K8� +R&�� �6( �=& B - � �*� � + #@(��IB52 �{& � + ( �3(�: �P�.�!A )l � >/# � (�0��2)#LK �4#92 � : + 2(� � K � �TD 0�(G� (5j - � � �7( 0 �TB�� ( # �'+ F7" 05� B�� + � + >/# �"(*05�{& � + ( �3(�: �=+ � ���V� +�+)( ��� �=& � + >/#92)27#LK + ��t� 1xj ? 1xj ,Yh8*"3 1xj/?Qp(0lh81;*5E+w8,Np4./,=7 1;* .^]Gw 0+0lr ,J\<,ky� .lh 0/, p(0������������������������� "!$#&%(')!+*�,�#-�/.(021� ��21���#30�43*5�(05#-��#&* �� �'76���!8���5#-

Page 97: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

������� ��?� �o�I ����� � �� K � � 7 # � KMlM!G! + � (�� KG� (�0 �9(5# (*05�1� K � � 7 # � KMlM!G! + � (�� ��f� G@� ( (�05� MC# +*+ �TB5�)2)� (8- #�� (*0 � + �4#92 � : + 2(� �|+ (*��+ : (�+5�*� D ( K$#+ � (��>+ #�� (�0�� K � � 7 # � KRlM!G! (8- M � :O# + 2 & B � 2)#�:�� (��=&#9( (�05�W0%-�&�� #�:�� � BC#9( ( �3�)2 + DVK 0 �): 0n& +5� ( # (�0�� � �!R �#B5�72)� (8-#�� (�05� ( �3�)2 + D%:O# + 2 & �IM5M � #��9: 04& � + ( �3(�: �=+ � +|+ ���9272�� + �)l��� G9� (C�u: 0 �3(5D � �)( & � + ( �3(�: � #���� �!A )l :O# + 2 & & ���4�)(5� +.0# �|�*� �4# G9� (*05� B � ( � �6:O���326�7( (��=� �@: ( �7#@(CKG� (*0 (�05�W� (5j - � ���� : � M ( # � B � :�� +�+�� #�� (*05� +�� ( + � ( � G � (8- #�� (�05�>+.� �7( (��=� �@:��( �)#9( + �

� lW(\K � � 7 �"KMlM!G! + � (�� KG� (�0 �4K ( � + � (*� �" 05� 27�(�4� ( �7(5D & � +)( �9(�: � B �C( K �1� (*� 0%-�&�� #VM 0 #VB5�;:I: � ( (*����3( & � � (�0��1� �9( K � � 7�# � �3( KRlM!G! K8� +,&���(��=� �4�)( �=&B -n�HR � �4�7(B� ( �)#9(P#���� E@�C( #9( ��� �32 &��=0�-�&��f+ � (�� BC#9( &5�=& ( #� 0%-%&5� #�:�� � BC#9(CM � #.M - 2C: 0 �3�)(��7" 05� : � ( (��*� #�� (�05� K ( �M � #.M - 2�D � # + M8K8� + BB� +��=& #9( (*05� �VM�M � # R �(��� (*� : � ( (*���#��B��� +�+ �3( & (*05�G+.0 # ��(��=+)(|& � + ( �3(�: � B �C( K �1� ( (*05�=+��W+ � (*�=+K:� +V&5�C(��=� �4�)( �=& B - (*05� B6#@( & 2 � (�D (*0�+ �9( & �9(�D92 �=+ �

� lW(\K � � 7 �"KMlM!G! + � (�� KG� (�0 � � �IS + � (*� �" 05� :O2)# +��=+)( �VM�M � #��9: 0 B �C( K �1� ( (�05�>+.��( K$# (8- M �=+ #�� + � (*�=+K:� + �/# + ( & ( #CB � �� A )l B�� +��=& #9( (�0�� B6#@( & �3(�D@2 �>+ �3( &B6#@( & 2 � (�D (�0�+ #�� (�0��"� �7(�DM�72)2 +6+ (*� � (��=& ��" 05� �5D +5�*�$+�0 #LK +(�0 � ( #9( � (5� (�� #VD � ( � ( #�� :1# + 2 & B �10 � G9� � + � MC# + � ( � G@� 2 -: 0 � � D �>&y+ � (�� K 0 �72 � (*05� # (�0��1� :1# + 2 & �@: ( � + �9(TK � � 7D � # + M��

� lW(\K � � 7 �"KMlM!G! + � (�� KG� (�0 � 7?� � + � (�� �" 05� :127# +.�>+ ( �IM�M � #��9: 0 B �C( K �1� ( (�0��=+�� ( KV# (8- M �=+ #�� + � (��>+ :��3(>B �,&���(��1� �4�7( �=& B - (*05�I+)+ �}#�� (*05� G �9( &��=� D ���32 +� � & �7����" 05�R�HR � � M52 � +�+��=& ( # &��C(*�1� �J�)( �>& (�0��f& � +)( �3(6: � #���:O2)# +��=+)( �VM�M � #��@: 0u��� )l � K8� + � (*05� ( � D�� ( � G9� 2 - : 0 � � D �=&# R%- D � ( + #��K� M 0 # + M 0 � (*� D � # + M �3( & �n:O##�;�4#9(\K � � 7�QKRlM!G! + � (��=+ D +�+ : 0 � +?0%-�&�� # R � &�� # �WE9��( #9( � � + (�: ( �7#@(��32D � # + M + �

� lW(\K ( � + � &�� KG� (�0 �3(�# (�0��1� K ( � + � (*� ��

Page 98: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� � ������ ��� ����� ���������� ����������8���� � ��� ��� ��� �?��� ��� � � � �5���

�f� G@� (-� + �#� M�2 � �4#92 � : + 2 � :1#9( ( �9�7(��7(�D ( KV# 0�-�&�� #VM 0 #��B5�):�D � # + M + Dx#@( � �9B � (5j � ( �V� �)(�D)�9( & (*05� # (*05�1� ��M � #VM - 2�J#@� ��(8- D (�0�� �IM�M � # R �(�;� (�� � � & � +�+ �9: � # +�+ (*05�<� �7(�D � +� )l �3( &'(*05� �IM�M � # R ����� (��4& � +)( �9(�: � � � ##� (*05�4� �)(�D ( #(�05� : � ( (��*� #�� M � #VM - 2�D � # + M � +F� � A )l � " 0�� : 0 #9�;: � #��8�� �)(�D-�3( & � (�05�*�1� :�� � B6#@( 0%-�&�� #%:�� � B6#@( : 0 �9�7( � +$(*05��J# &�� 2 �/# � � K ( � �AK ( � �)( (*�1� �9: ( �)#9(\� +"� +6+ ( ��� �>&B+ �)(�: �� � ##��� ( �): � �)(�D + � ��� :O#��$�4#@( ( # &5��+ D �4#92 � : + 2 �>+ �3( &(�05�?0%-�&�� #�:�� � B6#@(i: 0 �3�)( + KG� (�0 K ( � � + (�: ( �)#9(��927� (8- ��� -:O#9( ( �3�)($� + � � K � + � :�� � BC#9( + �'" 0�� 2(� � D � ��� � D9�)( �/# ���1� �� # � #���� � � �2)l � + �@:1: � M ( �IB52 � + �7(�: � (�0�� 0%-�&�� #.M 0 #.B5�):�7( (��=� �@: ( �7#@(\� +I& � 4 +6+.� �3( &'(�05�=��� �/# �*� (5# ( � +R& � �*� : ( �7#@( ��32)2 - + M � :O���6:��

� lW(\K ( � + � (�� KG� (�0 � � �IS + � (*� �" 05�"+�0 # ��(��>+ ( & � +)( �3(6: � B �C( K �1� (�GK ( � �9( & � � �IS + � (��K:� +|&��C(*�1� �4�7( �>& + ( &5�1� :1#9( + � &��1� � ( �7#@(J#�� � � �IS;�#�J�)( �D � # + M � v�7RK��X v � B6#@( &��=&�( #2�1M � #.M - 2fK ( � D � # + M��" 05�n& � +)( �9(�: � K8� + :��32;: + 2�� (*�=& B�� +��=& #9( (�0�� : � ( (*��� #��(�05� M � #.M - 2 D � # + M � � + � � ( ( �)#9( �>& M ��� G �7# +�+ 2 -5� �3( &@(*05�M6# + � ( �)#9( (�05� (�� (*� #.D � ( � ( ##� �

� lW(\K ( � + � (�� KG� (�0 � 7?� � + � (�� �" 05� �4#92 � : + 2 � �)272 +�+)(�� � (��>& 05�=��� &�� �4#@( + (*� � (��>+ �a( �C(( � D�� ( � G9� : 0 � � D � � ( (*05� ! �.� � D � # + M.�9( & (*05� : � ( (*���#�� (�05� K ( � D � # + M ( � � � (*05�{� + (6: ( �)#9( :�� � BC#9( #�� (*05�M � #.M - 2 D � # + M�� " 00+�+ D BC#9( & 2 � (�D (*0�+n� ! �.! � K �=���$+�+��=&( #��IM5M � # R �(��� (��*(*05�L+�0 # ��(��>+ ( MC# +*+ �TB52 �{& � + ( �3(�: �3+ ( &5�1�(�05�>+.� :O#@( & � ( �)#9( + �

� l � �IS + � (�� KG� (�0 � 7?� � + � (*� �" 05�M+�0 # ��(��>+ ($& � +)( �9(�: � B �C( K �1� ( (�0��=+�� ( KV#i: � ( (*���>+ K8� +:��32;: + 2(� (��=& BB� +��=& #9( (�05� B6#@( & 2 � (�D (�0�+ #��C! � 7 �9( & ! �.!�3( &;(�05� �9(�D92 � #�� � � ����B �C( K �1� ( (�05�>+.� BC#9( &�+ �

� l � �IS + � (�� KG� (�0 � � �IS + � (�� ��

Page 99: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

������� � ��� ��� � � � � �� ( (*05�_+ � R � � �UB �1�u� �7(5D �)2)2 +�+)(�� � (*�=& D BC# (*0 (�� (*� #.D � (� ( #�� + :1# + 2 & �9:1: � M ( � 0%-�&�� #VD � (4� ( ##�UD 2 � � G �)(�D (�05� �M6# + � ( � G9� 2 - : 0 � � D �>& �1" 0 � +{+ M��3(8K8� + �VD��3�)( :��32;: + 2(� (��=&+�+ �)(�D<! � 7 BC#9( & 2 � (�D (*0�+ �3( & (�0�� �9(�D92 � #�� � ��� � B � �( K �=� ( (�05�>+.� BC#9( &5+ �

� l 7)� � + � (�� KG� (�0 � 7?� � + � (�� �" 0 � + :1##�;�4#9( �!R � � M52 � #�� � � + (�: ( �)#9(��92�D � # + Mi:O#@( ( �3�)( ��7(�D0� + 2 ( �#M52 � ( � D�� ( � G9� : 0 � � D �>+{0 � + �T2(� � D �1� �4�)(5�(�;�92& � +)( �9(�: �4��� )l � B ��( K �=� ( (�05�AG � � �7# +�+ M6#@�7( ('+ #���: 0 � � D � �(�05� # R%- D � (�� ( ##� + � (�0 �3( (*05� MC# + � ( � G9� � MC# + � ( � G@� : 0 � � D �& � +)( �9(�: �4� �� A )l � � " 0��I+�+ � #�� (�0��AG �9( &��=� D-�#�92 +V� � & �)�K:� +8+�( �)27�)j �>& + ( &��1� (�05�>+.� :O� � : + � +)( �3(6: �=+ �

� ( (�05� �/#92)2)#LKG�7(�D ( �IB52 � � + D@� G@� (0� +�+ �;��� �*- #��:�VB6# G@�L�*�=+�+ 2 (*+ �JK �1�*� � +,&�� (5# (*�=& (�05� �4�)(5�(�;�92 & � + ( �3(�: � B �C( K �1� (( KV#;�@: ( � G@� : � ( (��*�=+ B - ~ �3( & �4�7(5�(���32 ( #92 �1� �3(�: � B -�� �K � � 7 � KRlM!G! K%( � � �IS 7?� �K � � 7 � KRlM!G! �� �!A � � � � �� � A ��� � � �� � A � � � A �� � A ��� � �K%( � � � � � � A �� � A � � � � �� � A � � � A

� �IS �� � A � � � A �� � A � � � A7?� � �� � A ��� � �

"��IB52 ��� � � � �K�32 +5�>+ #�� � � ~ �/# ��G � � �)# +�+ M��9� �'+ #���: � ( (��*�=+ �� �;: � B � ?�B��G[ �" KV#.�4#92 � : + 2 �>+L&�� ��( �;(�05�U+ �#� � M 0 � � ���@:O#VM 0 # �*� � � (*05�1- 0 � G@� (�0��y+ � � � :1#9(��5D +5� � ( �)#9( #��M: � ( (*���>+ �9( & (�0��y+��C( #��& � + ( �3(�: �=+ B ��( K �=� ( �9: ( � G@� MB� ��(*+ #�� (*05� �4#@2 � : + 2 �=+ � �*�i�*� 2�� ( � G@� 2 - :O2)# +�� � " 05�=+��4& �54 �1�*� (6: �=+ ��� - B � :O#�� � 2(� � D �1� KG� (*0�)(�: �*� � + �)(�D & � + ( �3(�: � B �C( K �1� ( (�05� : � ( (*���>+ �7( (�05�f+.� ( +.� (�0 � ( : � ( (��*�=+ (*0 � ( � �*� �+� � �IM�� �)("+�0 # + 2 & �9272)#LK �J# ��� � ���=�=& #�� �)((�0�� �@: (�+ �32YM6# + � ( �)#9(L#�� (*05� : � ( (*���>+ �)( G #92 G9�>& � �8&�� �32)2 - DLK � KV# + 2 & 2)� E@��( #R�)( &��HR (�05�?& � 4 �=��� ( ( :O2�� +*+��=+ #��5M 0 � � �;�@:O#.M 0 # �*�=+ �" 0 � +W+�+ DVD �=+)(*+8(�0 � ( (�05�{& � +)( �9(�: �>+G+.0 # + 2 &P+ :��92 � � + ~�

� � ? ~ IK 05�=��� ?G&�� M � ( &5+ #9( (�05� (�� (�+5�*� #�� (�0�� : � ( (��*�=+ �7( G #92 G9�=& D � � +8(�05�*( # ( �92 & � +)( �9(�: � B ��( K �=� (<�9( - ( K$#J: � ( (*���>+ D ~� � +8(�0����� R �(� + � & � 4 �1�*� (�: � �)( & � +)( �9(�: � (�0 � (G&5� ��( �>+8(�05�,+ � � � M 0 � � �;�@:O#.M 0 # �*� �9( & ~ I � +8(�0��f& � 4 �1�*� (�: � B �C( K �1� (&� &x� �9: � ( ((8- M �>+ �"S�#92 G �)(�D �/# � � K � D ��(

� ��IC� � <=*� � � � � � ��

Page 100: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

��� ������ ��� ����� ���������� ����������8���� � ��� ��� ��� �?��� ��� � � � �5���

�/# �L+ #�� �CG �92 +5� #�� < � " 0 � + � + � ( KV# MB� � � � �C(*�1� �4# &�� 2 �3( & < �3( &1? :��9(8B � &5�C(��=� �4�)( �=& B - � +*+ �#D9(5�)(�D ( # (*05� � �'+)(M 0 � � ���@:O#VM 0 # �*� D I � � D (*05� �4�)(5�����92 & � +)( �3(6: � B �C( K �1� ( (�05� : � ( (*�1�'+ D ~ �gl + �3(5# (�05�=� :O#@( +)(�� �3�)( ( D (*05�$+ ���32)2 �>+ ( �32)27#LK8�IB52 �: 0 �9(�D � �)( � � ( (*0 � + �4�7(������32 & � +)( �9(�: �F&5� (5# (��=& � + � � � � � � v � �.�>� :��3(8B �P+ M � :1��� �>& �<" 0�� G �32 +5�=+ #�� ~ �3( & � � �*�� � M5� � �):��32 % + �3( ( � ( � �>+ K 0 �): 0U&�� M � ( &@+ M6#@( (�05� : 05� �4�):��32 �)( (*�1� �9: ( �)#9( �)( G #@2 G@�=& ��" 05�=+��,� � M5� � �):��32 % + �3( ( � ( � �=+ � ��� 2)� +)(��>&�)( "��IB�2 �F� � � ��f� G9� (0����� R �(� + � & � + ( �3(�: � B �C( K �1� (4�3( -@( KV#P: � ( (��*�=+ D � D (*05� :1# �*���>+ MC#9( & �7(5D + M�M �1� BC# + ( & #9( (*05� ( + �UB �1� #��

B5�)( + D�� D5:��9( B � :O#�� M + (��>& B -y+ #@2 G �)(�D � � � � � � �K" 0 � + D9� G9�=+� � � 2)( ��� � ~ �2)( �8� � � � ~ ��� � � � � � ���

K 05�=�����J&�� (5# (��>+"(�05� ��#%# � #�� (*05� G �32 +5� �:" 05� 2(� + ( ( KV#F:O#@2 + �4( + #��7"'�VB52 �!� � n27� +)( (�0 � +�G �92 +5� #���� �/# �W� �9: 0 M��3� � �)("��IB52 �F� � � �S%�)(�: � (*05� & � +)( �3(6: � � + (�: ( �)#9( � � � � � � +,�!R MC#9( � ( ( �(�92 D�� + �#D9(����6:��3( (,���>& + : ( �)#9( �7( (*05� G �32 +5� #�� � :��9(8B �F�HR M � : (��>&KG� (�0 #9(52 - � + 2)�TD 0>( : 0 �3(�D � �)( (*05� G �92 +�� #�� � �4KW#LK �HG@�1� D � +6+ ( K 0 � ( � + :O#@( + � &��=���>& ( # B � � + 2)�TD 0�( : 0 �9(�D � � + #.M � ( ( #�)( (*�1� M �*�C( � ( �)#9(&�3( &y+.0 # + 2 & &�� M � ( &U+ (*� #@(�D92 - #9( (�05� (�� (�+5�*� #�� (�05� : � ( (��*�=+ ��"��IB�2 � � � 4� + �)(�:O2 +�&��>& �/# �G&�� �4#9( + (*� � ( �)#9(#�� +�� ( + � ( � G � (8- #���� KG� (*0y�*�=+ M � : ("( # � � ~ �

� � ~ � � � ~ ��� � � �� � � �� �!A � � � � � ��� � ��� � � ��� �� � A ��� � � � ��� � � �� A �3 �� � A � � � A ����� � � �� � ��� �� � A � � � � � �� � � � � A � � � � � � A �

"��IB52 �F� � �� �K�32 +5�>+ � +*+)+ � ��� � �NA )l �/# � �32)2:M��9� �'+ �� ��� =%���\]O[ � [��Jekcfe BOZ �D �\0 � G9�U&��HG@� 2)#VM �=& � M � #.D � � � ( # �>+ ( ����� (��@(�05� ( + � B �=� #�� (�05�*�1� �9( & �/# +5� : � ( (��*� M 0 � � ���9:1#VM 0 # ���>+3+ ( &��1� +6+.�=�+ M � :O��� �=& :1#9( & � ( �7#@( + ��" 05�>+.� �)(�:12 +�&5� (5# ( #9(�2 -J���>+ (*� �;: ( �7#@( + #@( (�05� ( + �UB �1� #��:M6# +�+ �#B52 � D � # + Mn2��IB � 2 + D B + ( �32 + # �*� 2�� ( � G@�& � + ( �3(�: � �)( (��1�%G �32 + �9( & � �3(�D �=+ �/# �i� �9: 0 #�� (�05� M��3� �'+ #��M: � ( (��*�=+ �0" 0�� M � #VD � �#� � 2)�(�J�)(�� (��=+ �32)2 & + M52)�):�� (*� M 0 � � �����:O#.M 0 # ���>+J&�+5�@( # MC# +*+ �#B52 �U+�- �;� ��(�� � �>+ �7( ( KV# # �$(�05�*�1�\& �(� � ( + �7#@( + � � ( �92 + # G9�1� ��� �=+$(*05�U��� % + � �*�=& :O#@( & � ( �)#9( + �/# �� � � + �#B52 � :O#9( + (*��+ : ( �)#9( + #�� (*� ���3(�D@2 �>+ �3( &;(���(�� � 05�>&�� ��D ( � E �)(�D4�7( ( #;�@:1:1# + ( ( �;� � D@�7( + #�� �=��� # �'+ �7( & �):�� (��>& �)( � �@: 0 #�� (�0��& � + ( �3(�: � B5�7( + �K �=��� � ��� 27� +)(��=&U+ ##� � #��g# +5�G�*�=+�+ 2 (*+ �" 05� ��(B�32 ( + �UB �1� #�� M 0 � � ���9:O#.M 0 # ���>+ KG� (�0 �

� � : � ( (��*�=+ D A 2(�VB � 2 +n� �7(�:12 +6& �7(5D �HR �9: ( 2 -'( K$#UK ( � (8- M � : � ( (��*�=+'� KG� (�0 � ( �VB52 � #�� & � + ( �3(�: �=+ � + �)(-"'�VB52 � � � � � +� D � �3

� � : � ( (*���>+ D A 2(�VB � 2 +F� �7(6:O2 +�& �)(�D �!R �@: ( 2 -'( KV#\K ( � (8- M � : � ( (*���>+*� KG� (�0 � ( �IB52 � #�� & � + ( �3(�: �=+ :1# �*���>+ MC#9( & �7(5D ( #� �*+)( :O#@2 + �4(y#��7"'�VB52 � � � 4� +?A D � �#A

� � : � ( (��*�=+ D�� + M �*�HG �)# +�+ D�B + ( �9( -<A : � ( (*���>+ � + � � A D A���A� y: � ( (��*�=+ D A 2(�VB � 2 +n� �7(�:12 +6& �7(5D �HR �9: ( 2 -'( K$#UK ( � (8- M � : � ( (��*�=+'� KG� (�0 � ( �VB52 � #�� & � + ( �3(�: �=+ � + �)(-"'�VB52 � � � � � +

� � D � A�� D � � �� W: � ( (*���>+ KG� (*0 �32)2IM � #VM �1��( � �=+ � + �IBC# G9� D B + ( �)( +)(�� � & #����8�4�7( � �)(�: �*� � � ( ( �/# � & � + ( �3(�: � B5�7( + B ��( K �=� ({K � � 7 � KMlM!G!�"K � � 7 � KRlM!G! � � � 0 �NA K � M + ( � � � 0 � ��DYK � D �C( � �5D �3 � D � ��A

� u: � ( (*���>+ D A 2(�VB � 2 +F� �7(6:O2 +�& �)(�D �!R �@: ( 2 -'( KV#\K ( � (8- M � : � ( (*���>+*� KG� (�0 � ( �IB52 � #�� & � + ( �3(�: �=+ :1# �*���>+ MC#9( & �7(5D ( #� �*+)( :O#@2 + �4(y#��7"'�VB52 � � � 4� + � ��D � � ��D � � � �

Page 101: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

������� �8� �� � � ��8� � �� ��� ��Z��UbW]���BOZ �� ( (�0 � +,�*� MC# ��( � + D9� G9� ( �9( �>+ ( ����� (*� #9( (�05�n+ �7j � #�� (*05� � M 0 � � �;�@:O#.M 0 # � �;: + MB�9: �"� KG� (�0 + ##� �J���>+ (*� �;: ( �7#@( + #9( (8- M �=+#��AM6# +�+ �#B52 � M 0 � � ���@:O#VM 0 # �*�=+ �C" 05�=+��U���>+ (*� �;: ( �7#@( + K �1�*�U&��1� � G@�=& BC# (*0 � � #�� D � #�� �C(�� �;:��328� � D + � � ( (*+ �3( & : 05� �4�;:��92M � #VM �1��( � �=+ #�� +�+�+ �32 &��&+ D��Q27� E9� :1##� MC# + ( &�+ �?" 0��=+��i�=+)( �(��� (*�=+ D@� G@� � +�� ( +�� #�� (�05� � � � + �#B5�72)� (8- �)(OB + �72 & �)(�D<� + : �*�1� (5�)(�D2)�TB � � �*- :O# G9�=� �)(�D��9272 � �9( & L: � ( (��*� M 0 � � ���9:O#.M 0 # ���>+W�1( # & � (�� (�05�=��� � �*� #9(52 - #9( (*05� # �'&��1� #�� � � � :1##� M6# + ( &5+ K 0 �;: 0� �*� ��� &�� �9( & : 0 � � �9: (*�1� �7j �=&�� D,K 0 �): 0 :O# + 2 & M52(� - �9(T�(� M6# �)( �3( (f� #92 � �)( &5��+ D +�� � � : 05�>+W�=+ M � :O���32)2 - � �"#@( � :��3(B� + #92�� (*��!R0(*� � �*�=+)(�� �): ( �)#9( + �)( + M � :O���6:,:1#9( (��HR>('+ �l :O# + ( ( �)(�D.� � D + � � ( ( �/# � � G@� : � ( (*��� # � 2(� � D �1� M 0 � � ���@:O#VM 0 # �*�=+ KV# + 2 & B �CG@�1�*-B+ ���4�)2(� � D�B + ( KV# + 2 & �7( G #92 G9� ��4# �*�$&�� 27�;:�� (��?+.- �;� �C(*��- �3(B�32 -%+ � + #�� (�05� M 0 � � ���9:1#VM 0 # �*� � & # + D 0i�=+)( �(�;� (��>+�+�+ DVD �=+)(��>& B - (�05� :��92): + 2(� ( �)#9( + #��CS � : ( �7#@(� � � �)( & �;:�� (*�3(*0 � ( �F27�#B � � �*- �)(�:O# � MC# � � ( �7(�D��9272 A : � ( (*��� M 0 � � ���9:O#.M 0 # ���>+ D �/# �M�!R �#� M�2 � D�� + (5# ( M6# +�+ �#B52 � KG� (*0 : +5�*�*� ( ((�� : 0 (5#@27#.D9� �=+ � � ( (�0��=+�� :�� +��=+ D%( � K�M � �9: ( �;:��32�� &�� � + ( # �*�=& + : �*(�05� M 0 � � ���9:O#.M 0 # ���f+ M��@: � � �*� �IB + #92 + (*� 2 - ( � : �=+*+ � ��- �

Page 102: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

��� ������ ��� ����� ���������� ����������8���� � ��� ��� ��� �?��� ��� � � � �5���

Page 103: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� ��� ������� ��� ���

/ �� � � � �*�1� ( � D S � � � 0 ( D�K � S�� G # � D � � SYM � �ID +5� D S � " � �#D � ! 05� �4�):��32�� + (�: ( �7#@(�� +5�=� � �=+ �/# � � � � � ( �VB�� +�� S � � � : 0 D�� #����8 �#3* ��"#�� � % , � #� �C. #)D � � �9 �D�����D � � � � � � � � � �

/ � � �$!$2�� �*E D � � � #@( �=+ D � ��D �72)2 �C()( D � �=� � (5( - D & � �f2 � (�� �"0 � � ���9:1#VM 0 # � �;: � � (�(��=� ( ,4� ( : 0 �7(�D �)(��k�72 �=+ #��)" 05�*�1� �� �(� � ( + �)#9(��92 ! 0�� �4�):��32 S (��&+ : (�+5�*�=+ ��!$#�� M�� � � + #9(n#��g!$#9(�/# � �;� ( �)#9(��92 �8S � � � : 0 �7(5DIlM2TD@# � � (*0 � + �/# � �k2 �!R �#B52 � S � � � : 0 ��7(5D�D�� #�����8 �#3* ��"#�� � % , � #� �C. #)D � � �9 �D�����D � � � ����� ��

/ �- S � � �): E@�C(�( D ��,.� + #9( D � �',T: m � - � � � G@�=+ � (8- �|� # ��2)�7(5D �9( & �M�>+ �#D9( 9R+ �)(�D � � �|0 � � �;�@:O#.M 0 # �*�=+ � �|0 � � ���9:1#VM 0 # �*� ��M�=� � G9�>& � +��1� � �>+,� � � �I� D�� #�����8 #3* ��"#�� �� 2% , � #� ��. #)D � � ����D����xD � � � �� � �#� � �

/ , ��l +�0�( #9( D , � � � -@� D � �B,4� + #9(��P7 � K M �1�'+ M � : ( � G9�>+ �)(u2 �>& D � ( �1� � ( �7#@( � � � � G �32 + � ( �7(5D��J#@2 � : + 2�� �f& � G9�1�'+ � (8- D ��� , /� .0!������� ��� � �=, � � D � � ����D"!rD37M# �B�5D �%� � � � �

/ A3 , �8,u: � �*� D@# � DGS �:, +6+.E �32�� �|0 � � ���9:1#VM 0 # �*� �k�)(�D �=� M � �)( ( �7(5D � � �$l(M�M52)�):�� ( �)#9( ( ##�IS5l & �3( & �5#�: +6+.�>&am �#B � � �*-�M�>+ �#D9( D�� #$���%�" #3* ��"#�� �� 2% , � #� ��. #)D � � � � �

� �

Page 104: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

�3 � � � � ��@� � ��� � �

Page 105: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� � ��������� �

� � �� � � � � � � �� � ��� ��� � ��� ������ � ��� �� � ������ � ��� � � ����� �! � "� ��# ��� �$ %�&�

& � ( �4l�D.D�� � K8�32�� 9 (5� G9�1�'+ � (8- #���!:�92TD�� �*- � . � �('+ � � � # , � �*) / � ��� # � �� � �;:Rl(D -9�=E0+ � 9 (5� G9�1�'+ � (8- #��+�R�): ( # � ��� � / � �,+�, -'+ � � � # , �I. � # � �� �3( � jIlM2 �>+ S����4#9( � � � +.�=�+9 (5� G9�1�'+ � (8- . � ���0/1' ! , # � �S �=� ���4lW2)� 9 (5� G ��#��32 � � ( � +�0 !$#92 + �UB5��� !�� �" �('+,���.54 / # , ��� # � �lW( &����=� �4l5��� � � � � 9 (5� G9�1�'+ � (8- #��klM2TB �1��( � � �E, � � � �� �� �(' � ��� � � # ���� 2 � (Ul5� � # + ( �,!:� 7RS � � � . ��,6' ���7) # ���� K?� +�+ �3(yl +5� �ID 9 (5� G9�1�'+ � (8- #���,\#@( (��*� �32 ��, � � / ' , �!8# , � � � � � �7) # � �m - (5(828� (�(�� ( 9 (5� G9�1�'+ � (8- #���,.�9(5� ( #VBB� � � � � ���9' ��� # , � ��. � ��� � # � �� �1�*� � - 2 � 272 9 (5� G9�1�'+ � (8- #��+�R�): ( # � ��� . � �:);)<' � � � # , �=. � # ���� �=+*+.� � 2V�)(�D 0 �#� 9 (5� G9�1�'+ � (8- #��+�R�): ( # � ��� . ��.�� / � �� -' / ,() "# � !� # , �I. � # � �! �6S � �3(82V# 00+ ( 9 (5� G9�1�'+ � (8- #��+�R�): ( # � ��� ����� ,��9'+ � � � # , �I. � # � �lW( &����.� 2V#@(�� 9 (5� G9�1�'+ � (8- #���!:�92TD�� �*- ��� ���('+ � � � # , � �*) / � ��� # � �! 05� � + 2V# +.� 9 (5� G9�1�'+ � (8- #��+�R�): ( # � ��� � � ��!��7'+ � � � # , �=. � # � �� � � �=+ 2 � �9(5(��9( !$2 � � + #9( 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- . � � � �9'+ � � � # �:) �" !� � # �-, ,! 05� � + 2 +�&�& 9 (5� G9�1�'+ � (8- #��=28� (*0 D 9 � � . �7'+ � � � !8# � � � � #���� # ,>+� �3(T!:�32)� +)(�� � (*� 9 (5� G9�1�'+ � (8- #���!:�92TD�� �*- � �*)B.0! � � �('+ � � � # , � �*) / � ��� # ���, -%� �(�#��!:�IM � �)#VD92)�)# 9 (5� G9�1�'+ � (8- #���,\#@( (��*� �32 � �(% � . � / )?' � � # , � � � � � �*) # ���2 ��� ( & �n!:� + D 0 2)�7( ! 0�� � �!RUm �IBC# � � ( # � � �>+ ��� ��, / �@)B.��A' � ��8 �B4 # ���� � � � ! 05� (�D 9 (5� G9�1�'+ � (8- #��klM2TB �1��( � . � ���� / ' �"!8# ,��*) � � � � � # � �� � 2)2�! 05� (�D 9 (5� G9�1�'+ � (8- #���!:�92TD�� �*- +��� � ���� / ' � � � # , � �7) / � ��� # � �� � 2)2 - ! 0 #%# 9 (5� G9�1�'+ � (8- #��+�R�): ( # � ��� � � � �C+D' � � � # , �=. � # ���7W�;:O#@2(�F!$# + ( �3(5j=�7(5# S����4#9( � � � +.�=�+9 (5� G9�1�'+ � (8- � ����! � � �(/1' � � � # ! , # � ��|2)2)� + ! + � B �=� BB� ( : 0 !$2�� �*� �4#@( ( � � � & + � (�� 9 (�� G � �E);)B.0!8# �", � � � � � � � �' � / , # �-,�,"�� ��� � � � � E �;: S����4#9( � � � +.�=�+9 (5� G9�1�'+ � (8- , �F+ . �1' � !8# ! , # � �l &5� ���3(�� � � G � & # G � 9 (5� G9�1�'+ � (8- #��+�R�): ( # � ��� ��, � . � ���('+ � � � # , �I. � # � �S%�(�4#9( � � 9 (5� G9�1�'+ � (8- #��+�R�): ( # � ��� !�, .G'+, �=. � # � �"�##� � ##���3( S � � � 2 � �IHKJ # 4 # �LHKJNM 4L'+ � � !�� � � � # � � � # 0 ( �M�*� K !$#@272 � D � #��AO �)2)27�QP7R $ 9 �R�): . ��, � � 6 ' � � � # , �=. � # ���& # &8S"& KTP �'&5+ 9 (5� G9�1�'+ � (8- #��+�R�): ( # � �QP �-, 6 � � , !*'+ � � � # , �I. � # � �7UP ( P927� � �5#%# �'&�� 9 (5� G9�1�'+ � (8- #��+�R�): ( # � �QP � � � � V'+ � � � # , �I. � # � �2 ��� ( & PJKUP K E �)( + 9 (5� G9�1�'+ � (8- #��klM2TB �1��( P � � 6 + .�� !*' !�. "# � � � # ,��7) � � � � � # � �K + P R �7#@(�D4K + P9(�D � �XW S � 9 2W! � � ,�� � / ' � � � + # � �S 2)2QPJK +�+ j ( � 9 (5� G9�1�'+ � (8- #��klM2TB �1��( P � , !B/ � .G' � � � # ,��7) � � � � � # � �� �=+�� 2)�)( � + (�D@�): S��YR4#9( � � P +.�=�+9 (5� G9�1�'+ � (8- � . ,�� / . �7' ! , # � �W # + (5�QP � � � � � 9 (5� G9�1�'+ � (8- #�� W #@( (��*� P32 + . . � .G' , �!8# , � � � � � �7) # � �Z P7R[P � P��I#@j1�QP E 9 (5� G9�1�'+ � (8- #��klM2TB �1��( P + �C/�. �C+D'+ � � � # ,��*) � � � � � # ���

�>\

Page 106: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

��� ��� ����������� �� ��� ����������� �

7UP (�0 P9( � � � + 2)#�: E 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #�� &G� D@�7( P + � .0!,) � �,+('+ � � � # , � � / .�� � # ���S +�+ P3( � + ( P - 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #��|!KP32#D>P �*- ! �+ , � � � '+, � �*) / � ��� # � �!$2 P +�&��{m P � P1R R � 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #��|!KP32#D>P �*- ) � V' � � � # , � �7) / � ��� # � ��M�)(�: � ( (Mm � R[P9� �*� 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #�� W #9( (��*� P92 ) �8 ��. � �1' , �!8# , � � � � � �7) # � �W P � D>P ����(?m � P9(�D 9 (5� G ��#�� 2 � � ( � +.0 !$#92 + R B5� P )B. � � / '+%� � !�. � !8# , ��� # � �� P G � &Um # E%0 # �*+)( & S �TZ � : 0 (5#@27#.D9� �=+ ) �F+�� � � ! � ' ���� 2% , !�� � � � # ���� ( G@�=+Gm + : �C( ! S ! W D�S��YR4#9( � � P +.�=�+9 (5� G ��) , � � � ' � ���" # ! , # ���S�:O# ()(UW P@: m P9: 0 2QP3( 9 (5� G ��#�� 2 � � ( � +.0 !$#92 + R B5� P !��� � � ���1'".�� � � � � � � � / � # , ��� # � ��M� G #@( W :x! ��� P 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #�� �M�;: ( # � �QP , ��� � �9'+ � � � # , �=. � # � �� P + #@( W :-� � P9( W\�1� P E ��� !� �� N'+ � � �C+ # � � � P +�+ ( # W �72)�)( P3j=j1# 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #�� �M�;: ( # � �QP $.;)B.�� �F/7'+ � � � # , �=. � # � �W P � (5� W � +�0 ( P S%� RJ#@( � � P +��1� 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- � �.0! �����('+ � � � # ! , # � �2 ��- P3( (TW #�# & � � 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #��glW2#B �=�)( P � ��� � � � # � �=, . �1'+,��*) � � � � � # ���Z �YR W\-9�=�*+ ! � P9(� � 2 &29 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- D 9 � � # / # � � � !*' � � � � ���E)�, #�� � # ,>+O � ( &�--W\-%� G #92 & 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #�� �M�;: ( # � �QP 6 ����, � -' � ! � # �"!� # , �=. � # � �S R R[P3( +5� 2 7�D � RUBC# 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #�� W #9( (��*� P92 � / �8 ���(' , �!8# , � � � � � �*) # ����f# �'& #9( ��� !$#9(5( � 272 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #�� �M�;: ( # � �QP / � ��� � ���1' / ,() "# �"!� # , �=. � # ���� P92 � �R2 �=+�E%- 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #�� �M�;: ( # � �QP ,��7) �"! + � ' � ! � # , �=. � # � �Z # &5& �R2)� - ( -%E 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #��glW2#B �=�)( P � �*)B. � � � +('+ � � � # ,��*) � � � � � # � �m + j � P92 P@:O�)# + 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #��|!KP32#D>P �*- %��*) � �C. ��!V'+ ! !"# � � � # , � �7) / � ��� # � �W P � : � P + 2 00+�+ 9 (5� G ��#��"!KP32#D>P ��- � � �XW S %���,() � , ! -'+ � � � # , � �*) / � ��� # � �� # + D92QP + � �): E@�1� �7(5D 2 � P9( & #9( 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- � . �,+ � � .�� / '�� � � ��, � ��� # � �S 05� 272 - � �7( &5�1� 9 (5� G ��#�� 2 � � ( � +.0 !$#92 + R B5� P %�.��E, � � '+ � � � # , � � # � �W � � # � #LKV# � #LK +�E � 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #��|!KP32#D>P �*- % � 6 � . �D'+ � � � # , ���7) / � ��� # � �� � � (�0 �|� #1R4� + 2)#LK S%� RJ#@( � � P +��1� 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- +4% � � �.0! )?' ! , # � �2V�72)2 &G�=�=& 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #�� �M�;: ( # � �QP � � �-,('+ � � � # , �=. � # � �� � P3( E & +�+�E9�1- 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #�� �M�;: ( # � �QP � , !B+ � � ' � ! � # �"!� # , �=. � # � �W P (*�8� PFS(P � ( P S%� RJ#@( � � P +��1� 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- ! � . � �D' �"!8# ! , # ���� # � S(P KTP & P 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #�� �M�;: ( # � �QP . !�� 6 ��, �(' �"! � # � !� # , �I. � # � �� #@( P32 & S�:O# ()( S (YB � � & D � � � � # ��� � � ' ��� % ) # � � � � . , / � # ���� KW#.M � S �=� P (�� 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #��|!KP32#D>P �*- � �4%�1'+ � � � # , � �*) / � ��� # � �7W� E%0 �72kS 0 P 0 7W# �)(*05�1� ( �k�)( P3(6:O�QP32 Z�� : 0 (�� % � !����(' � �*) # ���� �g� �)27�)(\S 0 � 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #�� �M�;: ( # � �QP ! �0.G'+ � � � # , �=. � # � �� # + D S@R4� (�0 ! 0 P � 2 �=+ KW#LKTP �'& P9( & l +*+ #�:�� ,�� , / # ! $. � �6' � ���*) # ��� # ���� � P@: � S%# 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #�� Z # � #@( ( # / � ��� �"!V'+, � ! � � � # � � � � � � � # �-,�,� # 0 (\S ( #�: E � � S%� RJ#@( � � P +��1� 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- . !V' ! , # � �! � � +)( �)( PnS ( #@�):CP 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #�� �M�;: ( # � �QP �"! � � . � �D' � � � # , �=. � # ���KW#@2TD �1��Z�� � + R[P3(�( 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #�� �M�;: ( # � �QP � �C.0! � ���A'+ � � � # , �I. � # � �S(P ( # +�0 � Z #1R4# & P 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #��|!KP32#D>P �*- � �� �I, �('+ � � � # , � �*) / � ��� # � �W �)( ZG+ P3# 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #�� �M�;: ( # � �QP � ! � �('+ � � � # , �=. � # � �S ( P9( Z + 2)2 �1� 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #�� �M�;: ( # � �QP ! � ,();) � � ' ��� � � # / ��� / # , �=. � # � �� P + 2)�)( � � P3( &�� ( �R� � �=+*+ : 0�� 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #�� �M�;: ( # � �QP %�� ,�,D'+ � � � # , �I. � # � �� P9( P � P3( &5�1� �I2)# ��( 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #��|!KP32#D>P �*- + . � � ��, � � '+, � �*) / � ��� # � �� P1R �=+ O P ( R4# + D 0 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #�� �M�;: ( # � �QP 6 � � ��, / �'+ � � � # , �I. � # � �&G�!R O �>+ ( B � #�# E 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #��|!KP32#D>P �*- 6 �"! � � � � �D'+, ���7) / � ��� # � �2 � �QP3(-O ��()( #9( 9 (5� G ��#�� 2 � � ( � +.0 !$#92 + R B5� P 6 � � � � �A' � � � # , ��� # � �� P + 26O � � B � 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #��glW2#B �=�)( P %���,();) � '�� � 6 ����� # ���� � � O �72)2)� P1R + S%� RJ#@( � � P +��1� 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- . 6 .;);)B. �D' � � � # ! , # � ���P (*05��- (-OB#%# & 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #�� �M�;: ( # � �QP + � � � ��� �9'+ � � � # , �=. � # � �� �)27� O + 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #�� �M�;: ( # � �QP 6 /E)?'+ � � � # , �I. � # � �(IP3(�D ��0 P3# 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #�� �M�;: ( # � �QP � / � � �('+ � � � # , �I. � # � �� + 27� ���C0 # + 9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- #�� �M�;: ( # � �QP . / � � ,6' � � � # , �=. � # ���

Page 107: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� � ��������� �

� � � � ��� ��� � � ���% �! � � � ��� ��� �

��� ����� � � ��� �� � ���� �'� ���

= �Jegh�Z�� UbVe�B1Z��� +��.�� ���Z?05� � S (�+�&5- � � # + M +(� KG� (*0 � ( & +�+)(��*-B+)( P �)(*�=& �)( � R �/# �*& �7( ��� �5D KG� (�0 (�0�� P3� R #��?: ��� P ( �)(�D P8R +�(�+ P9272 - B � ( � 6:O�QP322)�7( E B �C( K �1� ( �*�=+�� P � : 05�=�*+ �7(P�7( &�+�+ (*��- P9( & P@:EP &�� R4�;:UPIM5M527� �=& R P (�05� R[P ( �;:O�QP3( + � Z?05� �/# � R + 2QP{#�� +��C()( �7(5D P + � &�� P K �1�1E�/# � �)( (�� ( + � G9�J+ (&+�&�- #��KP � � K ��� P32 K$# � 2 & M � #VB�2 � R + M � # G9�>&\+ # +�+ :1: �=+*+ � + 2 (�0 P ( (�05� S (&+�&�- � � # + MFB � :EP7R � P3( P3(5( + P92 R0(�+���� �)( R[P3( - :1# + ( (�� � �=+ P � # + ( &'(�05� KV# � 2 & � Z?05�4+)+ :1: �>+�+ #�� +�+ : 0 KV# �*E�+.0 #.M + :EP3( B � P ()(*� �#B + (*�=& ( #8PP( + R B �=� #���*� P + #9( + D �/# �G�HR P7R M52 ���

� (�05�=-F05� 2#M �/# +)(��=� :O#9( ( P9: ('+ B ��( K �=� (8P9:CP &�� RJ�QP P3( & �)( & +�+)(��*- D + #1R ��( � R �>+ 2 � P & �)(�D ( # �*�=+�� P � : 0 :O#9( (*� P@: (*+ D� (�05�=- � ���� >+5� ( ( 2 - 2 � P & ( #n: 0 P32)2 � (�D9�)(�D4( � K �*�=+�� P � : 0 P ��� P + DYK 0 �): 0y0 P G@� P & � �*� : ( B � P � �)(�D4#9( M 0%-�+ �;:EP92:M � #.B52 � R + D� (�05�=- P �*� P3( �!R : � 272 � ( (M+ # +5� : � #�� ���>+.� P � : 0 ( #.M5�;: + �/# � D � P & + P (��I+ (&+�&�� ( ('+{� P + K � 272 P + P9:CP &�� RJ�;: +'� � � +5�)(*05�1� D (*05�1-P32)27#LK�:1#1R M P9(5� �>+ ( # B � :O#>R � P9: >+ P9�7( (*�=& KG� (�0u+)(�+6&�� ( (*+ P9( &y�HG P32 + P (��*(�05� R �/# � � + (�+5�*�,� R M52)# - R � ( ( �

Z?05� ( (*05�1�*� P ��� (�05� #.B G �)# +�+R�*� P + #9( +�� (*05� :O#1R M P9( - KKP9( ( �7(5DNP M � #.B52 � R + #92 G9�=& P3( &'(�05� M52 � P +)+5�*� #���KV# �*E �7(�D KG� (*0� ( (*0>+6+ �QP +)( �;:I:O#92)2 � PID +5�=+ �� � ������� ��>������� �/�:��+���0��

Z?05� +�+�+ P92 �/# � R P ( #�� (�05� R �1��( �)(�D + � +��� W #9( & P - RJ# � (��7(�D � M � #.B52 � R M �*�=+�� ( ( P ( �)#9( + B - �7( &�+�+ (*� �QP32 �*� M ���>+.� ( ( P ( � G@�=+ D� W #9( & P - P�� (��=� (�#�#@( ( # Z?0>+��*+*& P -�� �7( (�� ( + � G@� KV# �*E�+.0 #VM +��=+*+ �)#9( + D� � � � & P -���+�+ R RJ�)(�D + M B - P9:CP &�� R4�): + �S%#>R � R �1��( �)(�D + P32 + # 0 P G9� P �*� D + 2 P �?+�+ R R4�7(5D + My#�� (*05�{& P - � + M � #.D �*�=+*+ �� ( � + :1#9( + � &5�1�*�=&OG@�1�*- +�+.� � + 2 ( # 0 P G@� P ( 2 � P + ( #9( � :1#1R M P3( -\�*� M �*�=+�� ( ( P ( � G9� M �*�=+�� ( (I&�+5� �)(�D (�05� K 0 #@2 � K �1�1E D ( #P3( + K �1� P9( -� >+5�=+)( �)#9( +(�0 P ( R[P - P � � +�� �klW2 (�0 # + D 0 D@� � (�0 � + � + (5# ( M6# +�+ �TB�2 � (*05�1-4+�0 # + 2 & P ( 2 � P +)( B � M �*�=+�� ( ( #9( W #9( & P -P3( & � � � & P - P9( & B �,� P + �72 - :O#@( ( P9: ( PIB�2 �*(�0�� # + D 0 # + ("(�05� K �1�=E �

� �

Page 108: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� � ��� ����� ����� � � ��� ����� ����� �

� Z�� � Z � Z �Jekc,bVe = � � �� ekh���g�1�'+ #9( P92%:1#9( ( P@: ('+ P �*� :O2 � P � 2 -3(�0�� B �>+ ( KKP - ( # D ��( �7( ( # + : 0 KG� (�0 P{:1#1R M P9( - � Z?05�>+.� R[P - :O#1R � PVB6# + ( � � #1R M ��� G �)# +6+KV# �*E%+�0 #.M +4� R[P3( - :1#1R M P9(5� �>+ B � :O#>R �n�*� D + 2QP �'+*� D # � �)( (�05� :CP +�� #�� � �XW S�D�� � #>R (�0�� �7( &�+�+ (*� �QP32�K$# ��E �)(�D +�� R4�)( P �'+ �W P9( - P9:EP &�� R4�;: +f0 P G@��(*05� � � #LKG( :O#9( ( P9: ('+ D/M P ��( �;: + 2QP � 2 - � � #>R D � P & + P (��4+)(�+�&�� ( (*+ (*0 P ({0 P G@� R4# G@�=& �7( ( #U�)( & +�+)(��*- �l + P D � # + M � +V�!R M �=� � � (6: � KG� (*0 �7( &�+�+ (*� �QP329RJ# &�� 27�)(�D4�)(�: �*� P +.�>+V+ # & # �=+ � (*+G�*� M + ( P ( �)#9(8P3( & ( + RUB �1� #��g:1#9( ( P@: ('+ �Z # �/# +)(��1� ( � K :1#9( ( P@: (*+ P,2 �C()(*�1� D��<P R # � M 0 #@( � :CP32)2 ( # P{:O#>R M P3( - � +��*�=+�� P � : 04&�� M P ��( R � ( ( R[P - K$# ��E � Z?0 � +$+.0 # + 2 &# +�( 2)�7( ���

� 0 #LK (*05� R �1�C( �7(5DJ� +W+��C( + M D� (�05� B � ( � (*+ �/# �"(�0�� :O#1R M P9( - P3( &y0 #LK�R + : 0 � # � 27� ()( 2 �x� � ( KG�)2)2 :O# + ("(�0�� RUD� (�05� M �*�HG �)# +�+ � (�� R"R[P - R[P E9� (�05� R +�+�+ M5�):1�7# +�+ P9( &� >+5�>+ ( �7#@( (�05� KV# ��(�0 #�� (�0�� R �=�C( �7(�D6D + # �!R M52QP3�)( (*05� B � ( � (*+

( #[P9:CP &�� RJ�;: + P +V0 �TD 0 2)�TD 0�(*�=& �)( (*05�,0 � + ( # �*-F+.� : ( �7#@( D� �7( P �<P R # � 2 �C(�(��=�W- # +U+�0 # + 2 & �)(�:O2 +�&�� P427� + ( #��JM � #.B52 � R +"( P@: E 2 �>& P ( M �*�HG �7# +�+ R �1��( �)(�D + D ( # �7( & �):CP (�� K 0 P ( :EP9(B �{& #@( �n� � �=� 2 � �*�1�*( #CB�� P + (�0 � + 2)� +)( ( # (�0�� :O#1R M P9(5� �=+ �)( (*�1�*�=+)(*+'� �l +�� 2 � : ( �7#@(P#�� M � #.B52 � R + �)( G9�>+ ( �TD P (��>& P (G��� : � ( ( � �XW S>KV# �*E�+.0 #VM + � + D9� G9� (P�7( (*05� l�M�M � ( & � R �

? bGh�[W[��KB �,D�� �U[ < h�Z��\]O[ � �

�R(�: � M � #.B52 � R +�+ ( P ��(( #@��#%# & D@# � (�� �;: E 2 � D@�7( D (�0��1-J���� �+ � �*� �2 (*�1� �7(5D � � ( & +�+)(�� � P92 �*�=+�� P � : 05�=�*+ R[P - (5# ( B � �<P1RJ�)2)� P � KG� (*0�*� : � ( ( P@:EP &5� R4�):UK$# ��E P9( &u+ # (*05� M � #.B52 � R + (*05�1-u+�+ BDR4� ( R P - B � P32 ��� P &�-U+ #@2 G@�=& D (*� � G � P92 D �*� P + #@( PIB52 � # � �)( + #92 + B52 ��/0 #LK � G9�1� D �HG@� (i�)( + #92 + B52 � M � #.B52 � R + R[P - B � #����)( (*�1�*�=+)( D . # � # P & �54 �1�*� ( ( PIM5M � # P9: 0 R[P - B �?+�+ D.D �=+)(��>&�� � �|�*�=+�+ R4�7(5D (�0��:O#%# �*& �)( P ( # � � + (5# ( P9( �!R M �1��( #@( � G9�1�*-n+)+ B �8� : ( D (�05�=-F+.0 # + 2 & (*��- ( # � (527� +)(V�HR M �1��(?05� 2#M ( # &���(��=� R4�)( � K 0 �): 0 :EP (*� D@# �*-P M � #.B52 � R �<P9272 + �7( ( # � � P1R4�72)� P � � (8- KG� (*0 D�# �ME (5#LKG2 �=& D � #��8D �HR M �=�)('+ �)( & � 4 �=��� ( ( � 2 &5+ � +R�=+*+�� ( ( �QP32 �/# � PF:O#%# �'& �)( P ( # � �S�: ���=� (5�)(�D R[P - P32 + # B � :EP �*� � �>& # +�( B -P+.� P � : 0 �7(5D (*05� 27� (��=� P (�+5�*� D +6+ �)(�D[P + :1� � (�: � :1� ( P ( �)#9(y�)( &��!R �S G@� (u� �KP M � #VB�2 � R PIM�M � P �*+ (�� P9: ( PIB�2 ��( # (�0�� :1#%# �'& �7( P ( # � DC� ( R +�+)( B �n+)+ � ( PIB52 � �/# �*(�05� M P �)( �):1�TM P3( (*+ �iKW#LK �HG@�1� D�!R M �1��(*+ :CP3( +�+)+ P32)2 - B �,� (527� +)(��=& � 2 +5�*�=&�� � � (�05�=-FE (5#LK�P M � #VB�2 � R #�� + M � :1� C:I�7( (��=���>+ ( KG�)272/B � M �*�=+�� ( (*�=& �Z?05� ( + R B �=� #��:M � #.B52 � R + : 0 # +.� ( +.0 # + 2 & B � B P +��=& #@( (�05� (�05� ( + RUB �1� #�� M P �)( �):1�TM P9( (*+ � Z$- M5�):CP32)2 -�(�� ( M � #VM�2 � M �1�M � #VB52 � R � + P ��� P32)� +)( �;:I( + RUB �1� � 2 � P � �7( R4�)( &@(�0 P ( #@(52 - P + R[P9272 M � #.M6# �)( �7#@(P#��JM P ��( �;:O�#M P3( (*+ KG�)2)2/B �{E (5#LKG2 �>& D � PIB52 ��)(8P9( - D9� G9� ( � 2 & � W P3( - M � #.M52 � P ()(�� ( & ( #n2 � P � (P( � K ( #.M5�): + # �"(*05� # + D 0 : +�� �)# + � (8- �� [ � Zihke� < h�ZFbG[W[�� B �,D �2 --Z?00+5�'+*& P - � (f+�0 # + 2 &U0 P G@� B �1� ( &�� :O� &��=& K 0 # � + ( # M �*�=+�� ( ( (*05�i�*�=+�+ 2 (*+"(*05� �/#@272)#LKG�7(5D & P - � Z?0 � + M �1�'+ #@(PKG�72)2AP92 + #B � �)(T: 0 P � D � #�� (�05� K � � ( �)(�D + M D,K 05��(�05�=� (*05�1-\& #F� ( P9272 (�05� R +.� 2 G@�=+ # � :1#�# �*& �7( P (��,� 4C# �)('+ B - D � # + M8R � RUB �1�'+ � + + M( # (�05� RyDJM � # G � &5�=& (�05� ��� M6# �)( D �C('+ :O#>R M�2 ��(��=& � Z KV# R4#9( (�06+ � + (�0�� + ( P3( & P �'& ( �YR � �/# � (*0 � +3( P +.E:� (�0�� R4# �*� ( � R �&�� PID + #9( D (�05� 2 �=+*+ :1#1R R4� (�(��=& M � #.M52 � P �*�"( # &�� P32)�7(�D KG� (�0 � ( � Z?05� :1#1R M P9(5� �>+|+�0 # + 2 & B � P32)27#LK �=& ( # + : �*�1� ( (*05�W�*� MC# ��(B � �/# �*� � ( � + �( P32)�7j �=& �l�R � R B �=� #�� (�05� # � D P3(5�)jCP ( �)#9(U:O#>R R4� ()(*�1� KG�)2)2/B � �)(T: 0 P � D � #�� +��1� �7(5D (�0 P ( (�0��L&�� P & 2)�7( �=+ P ��� #.B �=-9�>& P3( & P92 + #( # M +�( (�05� 6( P32 �*� MC# ��("( #VD �C(*05�1� � h DLc �KB��Gcfe�B1Z��W # + (k���� �+ � �*� R � ( ('+ �/# � # � D>P9(5�7j=�7(5D�P �|� #VB�2 � R �8S%#@2 G �)(�DTOB# ��E�+�0 #VM P ���"+ � RJ�)2QP � ( # (*0 # +�� #�� PW(5# � R[P32 P9:CP &�� RJ�;: R �1��( �)(�D �Z?05� �/#@272)#LKG�7(5D 0 �#D 0 27�#D 0>(*+ PJ( + R B �=� #�� & �54 �1�*� (6: �=+ (�0 P (G+�0 # + 2 & B �,E9� M ( �7(8R4�7( & �

Page 109: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� �� ���� ��+6��S + : 0 P KV# �*E%+�0 #.M R +6+ ( B �,05� 2 & �7( (*05� G �):1�7(5� (8- #��3P + (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- DDP + BC# (*0 27�#B � P �*- P3( & :O#>R M + (��=� P9:=: �>+�+ P �*�I�=+*+.� ( ( �QP32���5# �"(�05� M � #VB�2 � R M �*�=+�� ( ( P ( �)#9( #@( (*05� �'+ (W& P - P9( & (*05�{+�+ R RJ�)(�D�� + My#9( (�0�� 2QP +)(W& P - D(P B5�#D � #%#1R � +?�*�� >+ � ���>& D�KG� (*0# G9�=��0�� P & M � # �8� : ( # � �<P@:O�)27� ( � �=+ P3( & P BC#>P �'& � �5# ��(*05� KV# �*E�+.0 #.M � +|& � + : +�+�+ �)#9( + D +��HG@�1� P32 + R[P32)2 � #%#1R + P ��� M ��� � �1�*���>& KG� (*0BC#>P �'&5+ ��lW2)2 � #%#1R +?+�0 # + 2 & B � :O2)# +��*( #.D �C(*05�1� D(P +?+ #1R � M P ��( �;:O�#M P3( ('+ KG�)2)2:KKP9( ( ( # ��� ( B �C( K �1� ( (�0��I& �54 �1�*� ( ( M � #VB52 � R+��=+*+ �)#9( + �� �:�� � ���-�� ��+6��lM:CP &�� R4�): + +�0 # + 2 & B �$0 # +6+.�>& :127# +.� ( #VD �C(�0��1� DFP9272)#LKG�7(5D (*05�$& � + : +�+*+ �7#@( +E( # E@�1� M D9#9�)(�D?�)( ( # (�0��|�HG@� (5�)(�D � P9( & � �*�� >+5� ( ( 2 -�)( (*05� B P � � � 7W# (�� D��7( &�+�+ (*� �QP32�M � #.M52 � KG�)272:M � #VB PIB52 - M ��� � �1�?0 # (�� 2 P@:1:1#1R R4# & P ( �)#9( ( # + (5� G9�1�'+ � (8-F& # � R +��>(�05�>+.�I+.0 # + 2 &B � :O2)# +�� ( # (�05� + (�� G@�1�'+ � (8- + # (*05�,�*� M �*�=+�� ( ( P ( � G9�>+ P ��� (5# ( � 2 � � ( # + ( � �

� � ���

W # + ( R �=�C( �7(�D + �*�� >+ � �*� :O#>R M P3(5� �=+ ( #9M P - P � �1� D ( # 05� 2#M � &�� � � P - �>:1# +)(*+ �/# � (�05� P9:CP &�� RJ�;: +$�1(*05� � �=� � � #1R�PVM�M � # R � R[P (*� 2 -�\:O#>R M P3(5� �=+ � + + (52)� E9� 2 -'( #u:O# G@�1�*(�� P G9� 2 P3( & P9:=:O#1R R4# & P ( �7#@( :1# +)(*+ �/# �{�HG@�1�*- BC# &�-5� � Z$- M5�):CP32|: 0 P � D �=+f� P3(�D � � � #1R� ��� � ( # � ��� ��2�f# G@�1� (DR � ( ( P3( & # (�0��1�3(8- M �=+ #�� ���>+.� P � : 0 D � P9( (*+ :CP3( P32 + #PB � +6+.� � + 2 �"� R M 0 P + �)j1�)(�D (*05� B � ( � (*+( #>B � D P3�)( �=& � � #1R��)( (*�1� P9: ( �)#9( B ��( K �=� ( + (�� G@�1�'+ � ( � �=+ P9( & �)( & +�+)(��*- D +)+ : 0 P + �)(�: �*� P +.�>& :O#1R M �C( � ( � G@� ( �>+�+ D6:CP3( 05� 2#Mu�)(#VB ( P3�)(5�)(�D � + ( &5+ �|lM:CP &�� R4�): + D P9( &;(�05� � � + (5� G@�1�'+ � ( � �=+ D(R[P - P32 + # B � KG�72)2)�7(�D ( #CM P - (�0�� � � #LKG(y:1# +)(*+ �� ���:+�7 +3��+6���

Z?05� 2)�TB � P ��-T+�0 # + 2 & B � P9:=: �>+�+ �TB�2 � �/# � P32)2 M P ��( �;:O�#M P9( ('+*( #u:1#9( +�+ 2 (G� # +5� ( P32 + P9( & R P E9� R��1� # R :O#.M5� �=+ � � ��PIM�M52)�;:EPIB�2 � DP �*� P3(�D � �/# � :1#VM - :EP �*&�+ # � P9:1: �=+*+ :O# &��=+ P9( & P +�E 27�#B � P �*- R � RUB �1�'+ P (�(�� ( & �7(5D (*05� R �1��( �)(�D ( # 05� 2#M KG� (*0$(�05� BC# �*� #LKG�)(�D#��JBC#�# E�+ �!$#1R M +�(��1� P@:1: �>+�+ � + P�R +6+ ( �/# �g� � R[P3�)2 � + ( E � �>+ DVB + ( P32 + # ( #AM � # G � &�� �<P9:1�72)� ( � �>+�+)+ : 0 P + (*� 2)( �C( D7R[PIM52 � D*R[P (*05� R[P ( �;:EP5DR[P ( 2 PVB D �/# ��(�� P3( �C( :��)D�M52)# ()( �7(5D $ M � �7( ( �N# + (*+ �� �-����(- -��,+����lM:=:O#>R R4# & P ( �)#9( P9( & R � P92 +k+.0 # + 2 & B � M � # G � &5�=&*( # P32)2.M P ��( �;:O�#M P3( (*+ �g!$# 4 �=� P9( & (�� P�B �*� P E�+ P �*� �)( G P92 + PIB52 � �/# ���*� D + 2 P �+�+ R RJ�)(�D + M P3( & ( # D �C(,0 #9( �=+)( #.M5�)(5�7#@( + P3( & � �*�=+�0 � &�� P + � � #>R M � #VM52 � K 0 #8P �*� KV# �*E �7(�DP#9( # (*05�1� M � #VB�2 � R + � � ( � +(5�;: � ( # M6#@�7( ( # +�(?+ #1R �f���>+ ( P +5� P3( (*+ DVM + B + P3( & B P �*+ �7( (�0��9G �;:O�)(5� (8- #�� (*05� K$# ��E�+�0 #VM � #%#1R + D + # (*0 P ( (�05�,& � + : +�+*+ �)#9( +:EP9(y:1#9( ( �)( +5� �7( (*05�,�HG@� (5�)(�D �� [ 3[Mh�[��UbG[ �� � � � �(7��8 �57 - �� +�-�� ���������� ���1�� ���(� �V� �9- � 0��� ��� ��� �:��+ ��0���!KP3( P & P � �R� ��7UP +*+ � � � 0 # +�+*+ # + B � . � � � � � � D � P@:O� 6: � ( + ( � (&+ (�� �/# � (�05��W P (�05� R[P ( �;:EP92�S�:1� � (�: �>+ �9 � � �M� � # 0 ( �f: E9� ( & #@( H �3* M J - � !�� � � � � � . � ��� � � � 9 (5� G@�1�'+ � (8- #�� � R �/# �'& �9 � � �M��Z � R W\-@�1�'+ * �E,�, ! � � . �7) � ��! � �),�� �M! � P3(� � 2 & 9 (5� G@�1�'+ � (8- �l +6+ (*� P927�QP � �R� � �1�*��-Fm P3( & R P9( J *� � � . � � � � � � W\� 2#B6# +5� ( ��9 (5� G9�=�*+ � (8- �9 S � �M��S 2)27� + ! + RUB �1� B P ( : 0 � � � �"! !� � !$2 P ��� R4#9( ( � � P & + P (*� S5: 0 #%#92��9 S � �M� l G ( �1� � � � �=& R P9( � . � ��� � � � �XW l W �7(5( �=+ # ( P�D W �)(5( � PVM6#@27� + �9 S � � #@( P32 & S�: 0 K � ( &�� R P9( M ! !� �C. � � � � � � �"! !� � &W� ( +*+.� 2 P �1� � #92 ->(�� : 0 (5�;: � ( +)( � (�+�(�� � & � �.� �) �����Y+6�Y��������� M � � � K�K�K � M�� R�� � R P ��� � �EP����� M � � � R[P������ G ��� � R[P ��� � � R���� 9j�� P!� � R��"� D ������ M � � � K�K�K � R[P ��� � � B P �#� � P���� ��$ �*S&% � � � �

Page 110: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� � ��� ����� ����� � � ��� ����� ����� �

����� M � � � K�K�K � R[P ��� � � R � P ��� ��$ � � �QP7R � ����� � � K����"� ��� �� � � M P�� � �"����� P�� ������ M � � � K�K�K � R[P ��� � �%M���� ��� ������ M � � � K�K�K � � � �(R[P ��� � � � � ��� � ��� � P ��� P ������ M � � � K�K�K � R[P � � � � ��� ��$ �7SKW ������ M � � � K�K�K � ���QP7R � ��%D

Page 111: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

� � ?����������B��� <�� ����� � � = ����� ����B%D�������� @ ���B�,D � ����������� �� ������ ��������! #" $%'& � ) ��� ( � ��0 �9�V�#)C��*+* �-, � �9+32�� �,� +6� � ��/.8�,+3��+��Y�10 �7 ��� �9+��

� � � G ��� ���" � � ���2 � �"�� � �� .M��"� �/� � � ��� �43�5 P��0P1R�� � ���6 5 � � �� �� P � P �DP87� � � � D ���%M���� � � � ��� � � � ��EP � �" � 6L� � � � � � � % � �"� � ���� � � ��� 7� W � � �"� � D 2&�# � � � � P � S M�� ��� � � �QP �:9����� � �;6<2 P � ������99PVB �<7�>= M � � R[P � � 3 � ��� � � D�9� VD �?6 W P�� W � � �QP � 2� � ��� �@7� W � � �"� � D % � �#��#� � � � � � ��� �43 � � P Z � ��BR� ��# � � 6 W P � W � � � P � 2�" � � � �A7� W �CP �����#� � D �#� � % � ��� ��� � � � � � ��� �43 ��3P >R M� ��� � �@� ��#��� �B6 5 LK&��� � � � � 99PVB �C7� S G P �"� P � � � D >R M � � P � �" � P � W � �#� ��� � � � ��� � � � � % 3 � � �ER �D6<2TP � �QP!� � 5 LK&��� � 3 � � �CR��C7� & PIM�� � Z � ���0R[P � 5 �# � � ����� � D� �� % �CR � � � � � � � �#�;6L� �� � ��$ � � � � � � �#� � ��9 � � � 7�>= M � � R[P � Z �0P � � � D % � �,P � � D��"�� � �� S � � � � ��� � � �43 Z �0P � � � DE6 5 LK ���� R 9 � ��� 7

%'& � ) �I�F(�G �9���+)C��*+*BHI, � �9+32�� �,� +6� � ��J0 ��760 �J���� 2 �K= M � � R[P � % � �0P � � D 3 � � W P!� � � P!� � � � D S�R � � ��� PVM P���� �43 6 2 �� � D � M � 7� � � G � � � � 3 = M � �YR�� � P � �" � � ��� � D[P & � � �HKTP � W � � � � �� % P �"��;6<2& ��� � D ��%M��L7� 2 5 �� .B��"�ER � � 5 � � �# �"��� R & ������ G � � % � R ���QP � � � 6 1R M�� � ��� W ��� � � � � D � �� ��M�9 � ��� 7�>= � % ��� � R�� � � R[PID�� � D � � �� � � ��� ���NM � �� � �# � �NM P � � �����0R[P � � � 5 ��� � ���TM��"��6 Z � � � �� >R � � � P � �"�� 5 �# PO � � � M 9 � � G ��#��� �43 �� P �TD P!� 3 7

� Z �#�TM-O �"���;Q � � � � � � � � ���99P � � W � � ��D6 �XZ &�S % & ����CP��#� � 9 � � � 7� Z �#��� � � � W ��� � � � � �0P � � PVB��"��;6 5 LK&��� � � � � 9APIB � � � ��� 7� 2�� � 1R[P � �"�?Q � � � � � � � �� S DVD % � � � � �,P�� $ �?6 � �"���" � % R[P�� � � � ��� 7

R

Page 112: The Pacific Institute - Pacific Institute for the ... · $/10#$243)!5$76+ 1 89 - 1:;=A@7BDCFEHGJILKMBONQPORTSVU?>XWYP C7NZ>X@\[]B_^ `a>cb @7BDCd>fe gLh7ikjml_h2n.joh2pmq\rJsutwv

����� � ������ ���������������� �������� "!$#&%('�)�#* ,+.-/)�#* ,+10( �!325460879!432:25)6'<;�;>=?=?="0@)�#& "+A0( �!325460B71!

C�D8EGF1H5I:J1E:KML?NPORQ>J�S9T:TUJ�S�VWYX�Z�[B\B] ^9[B_*Wa`Ubdc9_(egf�[BXihajBX�Z.b:k3j `aZfAklc>mlWA] npo�q�r1s�t�uAu5vxw�yAu�uz Za{3] npo�q�r1s�t�uAu5vxq�tAt�w

| HAD F9}3I:D�~�H�����F1HAS9IUD �AF"����H5F9E�K | N���S9I�Q3F1E��xJ1Ed� |����g��| D I�F�C�D8EGF1H5I:J1E�K��$N���J9EG��F1DB}W�X�Z�[B\B]Ph�Z1m5^Y�YegfY[BX�hajBX�Z.b:k9j `�Z WYX�Z�[B\B]�h zx� egf�[BXih.j8X�Z.b:k3j `�Z��S3T�DB}9FAT:T�CRF��AF1��J��¡ ¢F9}9I?����H5F9E�K?£3DB}3�¡TU¤5¥�¦�S3§�Q9FAT � ��¨ ��| D I�F�C�DBEGFAH5I:J9E�K?C?N©��J¡� �GT:F9}W�X�Z�[B\B]g\�fAk �.ª k.Wah�egf�[BXihajBX�Z.b:k3j `aZ WYX�Z�[B\B] �1« `aegf�[BXih.j8X�Z.b:k3j `�Z� D<}3¤>}3H�D8¤9���¬��HYF1E�K®­�N | J�Q ��¯ D�H ��| D�I�F�C�D8EGF1H5I:J1E:K � N�C�D8¤1H1SW�X�Z�[B\B]g°:Z.b:_±[Bm5ZYegfY[BXih.j8X�Z.b:k9j `�Z WYX�Z�[B\B] �.² [ `aegf�[BXihajBX�Z.b:k3j `aZ³(}3��S3T:IUEdD�¤3� � ¤9H�DB�8D I:¤1I�J9E´DB}�¨�¤3� §¡¤AEG¥¡K?µ¶N���¤>S>�BQ�S9T � ¨ ��| D�I�F·C�D8ExFAH5I:J9E�K?µ¸N�£9¤> ¢J�S>EGF3S9�W�X�Z�[B\B]gflZ � \�k � hUX¬egX�Z.b:k9j `�Z1\ ª ZY_&�aj `�Z WYX�Z�[B\B] � `aegf � m.h.j8X�Z.b:k3j `�Z����S>HY¤1I:D8J�}�¨�J�J9Ex��D<}3¤1I:J1E�K¬­�N�¦iJ�FAH1Q9Ta ¹¤3}�} ��º���| D I�F·C�D8EGF1H5I:J1E�K®�iN�µ»J�J���D FW�X�Z�[B\B]gk.c9WY°legfY[BXih.j8X�Z.b:k9j `�Z WYX�Z�[B\B] � ZYegf�[BXihajBX�Z.b:k3j `aZ