The Holy Trinity of Democracy, Economic Development, and Security. EU Democratization Efforts Beyond its Borders - The Case of Tunisia

7/27/2019 The Holy Trinity of Democracy, Economic Development, and Security. EU Democratization Efforts Beyond its Bord

1/23

The Holy Trinity of Democracy, EconomicDevelopment, and SecurityEU D E B B -T C T

A D

N. 42 | J 2012

WORKING PAPER


2/23

2 | KFG Working Paper No. 42 | July 2012

KFG Working Paper Series

Edited by the Kolleg-Forschergruppe T T Pw E

T KFG W P S K-F b

b b b. I x w b

x b x E E U.

A KFG W P b KFG wb www.. b

-@-b..

C : A D

E : A Bb, C B, D M

D, A 2012: T H T D, E D, S. EU D E

B B T C T, KFG W P S 42, K-F (KFG) T TPw E, B: F U B.

ISSN 1868-6834 (P)

ISSN 1868-7601 (I)

T b b b G R F (DFG).

F U B

K-F

T T Pw E:

T E U D I

I. 26

14195 B

G

P: +49 (0)30- 838 57033

Fx: +49 (0)30- 838 57096

-@-b.

www..


3/23

EU Democratization Efforts Beyond its Borders | 3

The Holy Trinity of Democracy, Economic Development,

and Security

EU Democratization Efforts Beyond its Borders - The Case of Tunisia

A D

Abstract

T EU b , , b M -

w w . T

Ab w EU W b ww

. T T w

b . W EU b T ?

A w EU T b w

w ? Aw q q

j EU M U M

( ) b qb. P D

R, b w EU

. Nw, , , b, EU

S b . T , ,

b b , , w

T.

T A

A D w K-F T

T Pw E F U B. H PD

P S U V, C (2012). A PD

w E. H

E , , C

E E, E Nb P, .

C: @.


4/23


C

1. I 5

2. EU D P B B: C L

S 6

3. A Fw: D MENA P Ab S 8

4. C S - T 9

5. D T, C, EU R 10

5.1TheDignityRevoluonAPostponedCertainty 10 5.2Post-RevoluonMeasuresandtheRoleoftheEU 11

6. C 17

L 20


5/23


1. I1

Tw-w b w S

M N A .2

A w w (..,E, T, Lb) w E Nb P (ENP) w . T -

. S C W, E U (EU) -

b w (N 1990)

C E E C (CEEC) (L 1994; B 1999; R

2000; F 2003). A EU w CEEC,

(B/ H 2011: 8). T EU CEEC

, ,

(R 1996, 2004; C . 2001; S/S 2004).

T CEEC ENP , EU

b , , b M

w w . T

EU w M b ,

b w

. T 2011 w ENP EU , -

w EU b

w (E C 2011: 1). T EU W

w b w T b b B A

.

T q w : W EU b T

? A w EU T 2011 Thawratal-Karama (D

R) b w w

?

Aw q, D R,

b w , EU

. Nw, , , b, EU S b , w EU b

T . Ib EU S b w b

EU b . T w

:

1 T w b b w K-F (KFG)

T T Pw E. T w Tj B T R -

b . T w V H

. T

KFG w C E Ab R P J 2011: C w

M C J 8-9, 2012 w b w . L b , w KFG .

2 T w 1970 w C R, P, 1980

1990 w L A E E.


6/23


S b S EU1.

b.

E w T,2.

, -, q, w w T.

A w I

b w T. T I

S.

T : F, w EU T w -

; , w EU x w w ENP; ,

w CEEC x T b; 3 , ,

w EU W w w I b b

H x.

T , , w q-

. I b b B (2010), B R (2012), B H (2011),

D (1971), Lx S (2011), L S (1996; 1996b), L (1959; 1960),

Pw (2009; 2009b), H (2012). T x EU -

b b . S w

. S b . S

T w b . F,

.

2. EU D P B B: C L

Shortcomings

W EU b

b ,4 E M b . D b b E j EU, CEEC

EU

b (S/S 2004: 661). T CEEC

acquiscommunautaire j EU 2004, w b B R 2007.

3 D b CEEC ( ) Ab M ( )

, I - T w b P CEEC.

T w CEEC, w b , b

w b EU-CEEC x.

4 W EU CEEC , w (S . 2006). B CEEC b 1993, CEEC

(B/ H 2011: 8; S 2005;

V 2005).


7/23


T w EU b M b -

w b q

(B 2010: 18). T b E b x EU

b b w . F, b x w (B 2010: 5). T

w M b , , , ,

w w x ( Y 2009). T b

EU M b.5

A , EU E b , w, w

(S 2007), b , , , , -

(Lx/S 2011). L b- w EU -

w b . L -b -

, .., , x w

. W b , (Lx/

S 2011). T w w w -

w b w b , b

. W ENP, w w

(Lx/S 2011: 895) w . T w

b (Lx/S 2011: 895).

M V (2005) Lx S (2011) EU -

CEEC w b b

b b . I EU ,

w EU b, w b , EU w b

( S 1990). I ENP w

b, b b b ,

EU b .6

5 T EU-M w B P 1995, w b

. W CEEC, w EU w

ENP 2004. T w EU b

b j (.., , )

(E C 2009), b EU I

M (E C 2004). T ENP x , w

b , , b AP [A P] ( H

2009: 7) w EU-M

( H 2009: 8). T (, , )

w P S M J 2008 b M

M E-M Nb 2008. T q w w

, , , w, j

. ENP. M, ENP w M b

w EU .

6 I b M E N A

(MENA) EU .


8/23


T, EU b -

b w I (Y 2009: 911). I -

M

T. Hw, b x w b w w EU -

. T b b , -, b

w x w -

(L/S 1996b: 15).

3. A Fwk: D MENA P Ab Sg

A ww T, E, Lb -

. T ENP7

, w w CEEC 1989. T EU

b w

I w EU . Nw,

w E

b b.

F , B P, b w

. W q ,

b /b, , w.

R (, ) b w

b W, EU. F, b bw

w W . T W,

w b b B A , w , w

T w . T T

b w . T w -

w U S w b T j

x w (T W T2012). S q W b

b T , b

w .

B S L (1996; 1996b), D (1971), L (1959; 1960), Lx S

(2011), Pw L (1997), R . (1992), I b T

W w

7 T ENP b b , - ENP A P. T

w - . I ENPA P ( 2005 w I, J, M, M, P A, T U,

2006 w A, Abj G, 2007 w E Lb) w (E

C 2009).


9/23


w : , naonalreconciliaon (L/M 2012) w

w b . E

w b b b-

, , , . I , b x CEEC. S, economicdevelopment, b R

. (1992) Pw L (1997), bw

. T b ,

. S T w

, j, q,

w

. T, w instuonal,

administrave,andpolicalreforms. T b T b b

, , . P

. F, ruleoflawandthesecuritysectors (L/M

2012) w q j .

F, b independentcivilsociety (L/M 2012), w b

, .., (NGO) , , b

b b- . T

q w T b EU

(, , ) w

W w US, I M F (IMF), E B

R D (EBRD), W B.

4. C S - T

T j w N A

M A. T T b EU

. T b -

w F . I b, T

, . S b T b EU w

, w b Ab W.8

A T Ab N A

Arabexceponalism . I

M , , j A w, w

w . S, T

: b b -

I, En-NahdaParty.

8 D q - T , b

T x ( ) w b w.


10/23


5. D T, C, EU R

F , T w w EU

, , EU b. T US F b BA (RassemblementconstuonaldmocraqueConstuonalDemocracRally

(RCD)) , , b. B A

, , ,

. A w . M

w x.

D , , , ,

, j, , A

A bw EU T 17 J 19959 - ENP,

w . I T

MENA , E-M b b E -

b , , b, -, . A

q, q, ,

j.

5.1TheDignityRevoluonAPostponedCertainty

R w , w , w

Ab x. S 1980, b

- , w W -

IMF W B, ,

x, jb, b w . T

T w . Hw,

b w (

), w , . T b

b 2008 E b .

T E T b .

Fw B D C B T Nb 16, 2011, b

w w T (T- 2011): Ex

w ( EU ), w w w w, b

w , b ( j

EU ) w , -

b b . I , b

9 T w MENA A A w EU 1995 w w

E-M P (EMP). F, T w A

P w EU, w 4 J 2005.


11/23


q, w b. T -

b, , , b.

T b B A - b b, w b , b

x. T w b - M B-A 17

Db 2010 b b b

S B. T b w

B-A . T b -

w b b w. I

b w T w B A.10

T B A w 23 Ob 2011, w b En-Nahda

Partyw w - CongressfortheRepublic Et-Takatol.

D , w b

. T, EU W b T -

. Hw, w , ,

, w b (T W B 2012 2012b).

5.2Post-RevoluonMeasuresandtheRoleoftheEU

W EU W b w: I -

Ab .11 T w EU I

b EU b

b . I En-Nahda T S

M B. T J D P M b En-Nahda.

B W I x I W ,

, b . D

b S b. Ow,

w b w EU w (-M , , .).

T I w

. T b

W EU , b x w I

. T b EU -

E P J B (M E M 2011). A

w .

10 B A S Ab 28 (14 J 2011), 23 .

11 A I T , -

, , ,

.


12/23


D T w EU b ( F) w

b B A b

, w EU . T EU

w x MENA CEEC w bj w x T. I

T , EU .

T EU b b: , ,

. A , w b . A

W B A w -

, b

. T, b q

T EU w w b

. M, w w

w ,

b, q .

A EU b ( EU T

M ), EU ,

b . T

b, b,

S M. I b w,

b EU b , b b .

B, EU IMF, W B,

U N . w w w

M .

M, , T EU . 12 T EU

T , 2008 64.5% T 72.1% T

x (E C 2010). I 2008, T w M

, w EU. F, T

EU - (E C 2010). A , EU T. E W

T b w w

T b

.

12 T E C T

. T E C - w T

b bw (E C 2012).

W w B P, T w j b M

(MEDA) P (b MEDA I MEDA II; 1995-2006) w -

80 . W ENP, w N

I P (NIP) 2007-2010 300 :

, , w EU; b;

b . T NIP 2011-2013 b 240

(), ( ), ( j ).


13/23


T T, EU, -

j:

NaonalReconciliaon

T b b w T EU w -

. A A G,13 T b

w A (D . 2011: 4), bw

A P C, CEEC, O

R U w. CEEC

b x w 1989. T

b , b b -

.

A w w b w

, , , b . A

b b T . CEEC x-

w w . I , w

, b w b ( x,

C P w 1993 ). D j, ,

, ,

w w . W b

CEEC. T T b

w w w

. T EU , bb

, , . T EU

, w b b EU, T, .

EconomicDevelopment

F w , -

q . I w b b b w . A b w w, -

, bw

, , q,

w .

T EU - b

( EU ). T -

P M H Jb T EU -M

P (E V 2012).

13 A G T NGO -Kwb D T C.


14/23


A , EU, W B, EBRD

w j -

, jb, w. B w

T , w T

T (T W B 2012b). C -

b w b

T w. T EBRD w b j w

wb . T EBRD w w, b

w x .

T EU w-w . T

w jb w. I ,

j. Hw, b

. T EU w T

. T b /b

( ), b , w

w w . T T

1990 MiseNiveaudelaFormaonetdelEmploi (M).

M bj b b bw ,

xb , q,

w-w b

(OECD 2008: 647). Hw,

b . T EU , b

x b T x

q EU .

T T w w EU b T

jb w w w . B

, b ,

, EU w T

- b . Ow, w w b

. U w EU

S b . E w

, , .

Instuonal,Administrave,andPolicalReforms

I w w

. F , , b, -

, j w T b EU -

. T EU w W B


15/23


b b j

b q b , ,

b.

T EU W x T b-

. T ,

j b b EU w T. T

EU EU b , US x

w T b b

, x b

w . S w b w w

x W T .

T US$1.5 b

, (T W

B, 2012). D , T w

x

b q q jb b T

(T W B, 2012).

T I B R D (IBRD) I F

C (IFC) (ISN) 2013-2014

[T] - jb ,

w , b (T W B 2012b). T

b T

w b. T b

q . V W B G: IBRD, IFC

M I G A (MIGA) (T W B

2012b).

S , , ,

b w . T - T w b EU. A

, b b

. T T b

, , b w

. T EU w NGO

w . T b

.

T w

w . A w -

x q w b . T


16/23


I E T

.

RuleofLawandSecuritySectors

O w -

w b x, , j, w

b b . T w . T

T b . T

; b . Cq, -

b w W , -

b ,

b w b

b.

T b b b

w. T w, q w

, b , x, ,

b b . Eq T b w , -

, b . b w . T w b , b

b b .

A j . T j,

w b T 1950 b -

, w . T EU

22 j . T w

j w j

b w w .

T M I b b w

b b . T EU b

j . O EU T x . M, T b b

W x EU, US

. R w T

b B A . C B A b

.

IndependentCivilSociety

S B , EU w -

. U, T b , EU w -

w w I , w w


17/23


. T I b

. T EU I

w T . B A w

w I x, w w b. T EU T b x w NGO (L/

M 2012: 5).

EU T . A

w . T EU b -

b w w

B A . I , , -

, q. A EU b ,

- b

(L/M 2012: 5).

T EU

w , , b , bb w

(L/M 2012: 5). T q w b

b b- .

6. C

T Ab S EU b . T w ENP w

, b w b . T

ENP ww EU -

. T , , -M P b x-

W S. P, ,

b . T

( b )

. W b jb

T, w b -. T w b EU S b.

T EU b w N A b b

S M. I ,

EU IMF, W B, EBRD . T

. T w EU b

b. T EU T

w x EU. Aw T b EU

w b , , w EU

T , , w

, w, x . A b w T, EU


18/23


b . A (

) b w I w

. T b

EU , b , , b-

(T 2011: 4). I w

w, EU w .14

T I b b . T

bw I T, T, M -

I w bw I w

T ( ) I .

NEn-Nahda b w w . T EU w

w En-Nahda . H w

T b . T -

, , ,

EU, , ,

. T , , , w w

D R T.

B, x w (C E x) b -

b . T

. N w I

En-Nahda b

T.

A w , N A, T ,

q w : T b b bw EU T

( , , -

, w , ). T w T

w EU. T

b E , w EU b w w (w US, C R). T j w

I b N A

. F, bw MENA w

.15 I EU MENA , EU

14 S A P (EU C 1996), w, w w

S M (B 2005). T b

w , , . T, b

.

15 T EU w M b -

S b, w, w , EU w

b (B . 2008; B/ H 2011). T EU w


19/23


, T, . O

, EU b

. T b

w . B, w .

T T x L A CEEC

w w b

w. T

b T , x

x bw E I . T T

w EU W, x

Ab W b.

w M , b -b-

. Nw, bw

w , b

j .


20/23


L

Baracani,Elena2005: F EMP ENP: A Nw P D? : J C-

R 1/2, 54-67.

Brzel,TanjaA.1999: Tw C E? I A E G- S, : J C M S 37/4, 573-596.

Brzel,TanjaA.2010: T T Pw E R. T L Ex E-

, : KFG W P S 11, K-F T T Pw

E, B: F U B.

Brzel,TanjaA./Pamuk,Yasemin/Stahn,Andreas 2008: O S F A? Hw E U P-

G G N Ab, : Sb (SFB) 700 W P-

S 18, B: F U B.

Brzel,TanjaA./Risse,Thomas2012: W E M D. Ex Nw T, :

W E P 35/1, 192-207.

Brzel,TanjaA./vanHllen,Vera 2011: G G B Nb? T L T- Pw E, : KFG W P S 35, K-F T T-

Pw E, B: F U B.

Chrisansen,Thomas/Jorgensen,KnudErik/Wiener,Antje () 2001: T S C E,

L: S Pb.

Dahl,Robert1971: P: P O, Nw H: Y U P.

Dennison,Susi/Dworkin,Anthony/Popescu,Nicu/Witney,Nick2011: A R: E

T T, : E C F R, P B N. 28, L: E-

C F R.

EUCouncil1996: C R (EC) N. 1488/96 13 J 1996

(MEDA) w

E-M , OJ L 189/1.

EuropeanCommission 2004: E Nb P: S P, B.

EuropeanCommission2009: T P: W E Nb P? : ://..

/w//_.; 14 Ob 2009.

EuropeanCommission 2010: T: B R T, : ://..//-

/b-///x_.; 28 M 2012.

EuropeanCommission 2011: A Nw R C Nb: A w E N-

b P, J C b H R T U F F A-

A S P E C, B, COM(2011) 303, 25 M.

EuropeanCommission2012: D C-E: T, : ://..//w/b/-//_.; 29 M 2012.

EuropeanVoice 2012: T S EU S, 2 Fb, : ://www../

/2012/b/----/73472.x; 24 M 2012.

Featherstone,Kevin2003: I: I N E, : F, K/R, C

M. (): T P E, Ox: Ox U P, 3-26.

Ladrech,Robert1994: E D P I: T C F, : J-

C M S 32/1, 69-88.

Lavenex, Sandra/Schimmelfennig, Frank2011: EU D P Nb: F

L G, : D 18/4, 885-909.

Linz,JuanJ./Stepan,Alfred1996: Pb D T C, B: JH U P.

Linz,JuanJ./Stepan,Alfred1996b: Tw C D, : J D 7/2, 14-

33.


21/23


Lipset,SimonM. 1959: S S Rq D: E D P L-

, : T A P S Rw 53/1, 69-105.

Lipset,SimonM. 1960: P M, T S B P, Nw Y: Db.

Loannides,Isabelle/Missiroli,Antonio (.) 2012: Ab S T S M-

: T EU C S O Y O,: B P N. 1, J 2012, E- C: B.

MiddleEastMonitor2011: E P I b T-

, 2 Nb, : ://www../w/-/3019--

-------b--; 2 M 2012.

Nye,JosephS.Jr. 1990: B L: T C N A Pw, Nw Y: B B.

OECD 2008: P q Aq: T, P: OECD.

Powel,BriegTomos 2009: A C N: N Pw EU D P T,

: D 16/1, 193-214.

Powel,BriegTomos 2009b: T Sb S: US EU D P T, : T

J N A S 14/1, 57-73.

Przeworski,Andrew/Limongi,Neto 1997: M: T F, : W P 49/2, 155-

183.

Radaelli,ClaudioM. 2000: W E? C S Sb C, : E-

I O P (EIP) 4/7, E C S A A:

V.

Risse,Thomas 1996: Ex N B: I R T C

P A M E U, : J C M S 34/1, 53-80.

Risse,Thomas2004: S C, : W, Aj/D, T (): E I

T, Ox: Ox U P, 159-176.

Rueschemeyer,Dietrich/HuberStephens,Evelyne/Stephens,JohnD.1992: C D D-, C: U C P.

Schimmelfennig, Frank2005: S C I S: Mb I-

, P C S C C E E, : I-

O 59/4, 827-860.

Schimmelfennig,Frank2007: E b E, : L Rw E G

2/1, : ://www.w./-2007-1; 1 J 2012.

Schimmelfennig,Frank/Sedelmeier,Ulrich 2004: G b C: EU R T

C C C E E, : J E Pb P 11/4,

661-679.

Schimmelfennig,Frank/Engert,Stefan/Knobel,Heiko2006: I S E: EO, P C, E D D C, H-

: P M.

TheWashingtonTimes 2012: Eb Rw: T A, 8 M, : ://www.w.

/w/2012//8/b-w--/; 1 J 2012.

TheWorldBank2012: T Ow, : ://www.wb.////w; 9

A 2012.

TheWorldBank2012b: I B R D I F

C I S N Rb T P FY13-14, R .

67692-TN, M 17.

Thpaut,Charles2011: C EU P D? R ENP C Ab S,

: EU D P 6, C E: B.

Tunisia-live 2011: A S I b T C B, 17 Nb, : ://www.

-./2011/11/17/--b----b/; 3 J 2012.


22/23


Vachudova,MiladaAnna 2005: E U D, L I C-

, Ox: Ox U P.

VanHllen,Vera 2009: EU D P M: C A O?

: KFG W P N. 9, Nb 2009, K-F T Pw

E, F U B.

VanHllen,Vera 2012: E C? EU D P M

T, : W E P 35/1, 117-134.

Youngs,Richard2009: D P Ex G? : J E Pb P-

16/6, 895-915.


23/23

T Kg-Fg - Egg A Exg

I R

T K-F (KFG) w -

b G R F 2008. I -

KFG

w b w b

b w j .

T K-F T T Pw E

b E B-B-

b w -

. I x EU -

,

x :

I Pb S

C, C B

C R E Ex R

Documents

The Holy Trinity of Democracy, Economic Development, and Security. EU Democratization Efforts Beyond its Borders - The Case of Tunisia