Upload
others
View
3
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
The Bureau of Economic Geology
Established in 1909, the Bureau of Economic Geology is the oldest and second-largest organized research unit at The University of Texas at Austin. The Bureau functions as the State Geological Survey of Texas, and Director Scott W. Tinker as the state geologist. Bureau researchers spearhead basic and applied research projects globally in energy resources and economics, coastal and environmental studies, land resources and use, geologic and mineral mapping, hydrogeology, geochemistry and subsurface nano- technology. The Bureau provides advisory, educational, technical, and informational services related to the resources and geology of Texas, the nation, and the world.
The Bureau is an international leader in a number of research thrusts, working at the intersection of energy, the environment and the economy, with strengths that include: Unconventional oil and gas exploration
and production Salt tectonics
Natural fractures and structural diagenesis Subsurface micro- and nano-sensing Reservoir characterization in carbonates,
mudrocks, and sandstones Carbon storage in geological reservoirs The water-energy nexus Energy economics
Talented people are the Bureau’s formula for success. The research staff includes more than 120 scientists, engineers and economists, representing 27 countries, working in integrated, multi-disciplinary research teams. Together with 60 skilled graduate students, 15 post docs, and 50 professional support staff, they find solutions to the world’s greatest challenges in energy and environmental research.
Superb facilities and equipment give researchers the tools they need to find objective, rock-based research answers.
More than 15 individual laboratories hosting research teams investigating everything from nano-particles to shale porosity and permeability
Three massive well core research and storage facilities, in Houston, Austin and Midland – collectively, the largest archive of rock material in the world
One of the largest collections of well logs in the U.S.
An extensive inventory of modern imaging devices and integrated technologies for outcrop and land-surface mapping
Over 100 years of producing research results have earned the Bureau an unparalleled reputation. Successful outcomes can be measured by many yardsticks, and Bureau researchers more than measure up.
Over 100 peer-reviewed articles and books published annually
Hundreds of abstracts and peer-reviewed articles published each year in conference proceedings volumes
More than 50 keynote addresses made annually
Bureau researchers are frequently presidents of international professional societies and editors of major professional journals, and are recognized by their peers with top medals and awards in their fields
www.beg.utexas.eduQAe2806
Where energy, the environment and the economy converge.
Government, agency, foundation and non-governmental organization (NGO) partners include: The State of Texas U.S. Department of Energy USGS NASA Cynthia & George Mitchell Foundation O’Donnell Foundation Alfred P. Sloan Foundation Environmental Defense Fund
The laser line
Horizontal wordmark
Stacked wordmark
For much more information about The Bureau of Economic Geology, please visit our website: www.beg.utexas.edu. Call the Bureau at 512-471-1534.
With its reputation for success, external financial support flows into the Bureau. Research and operations expenditures have increased from roughly $10 million to more than $30 million over the last decade. Bureau research is funded mostly via grants and contracts with various federal, state, and local governments, private agencies and foundations, and industry-based sponsors.
Service to society is a crucial element of the Bureau’s mission, and every effort is made to inform people about geoscience issues and to provide educational outreach. The Bureau sponsors Earth Science Week Career Day for middle school students, lends personnel and expertise to the GeoFORCE college prep program for underserved students, conducts an annual Industry Day open house for company representatives, and hosts a professional Information Geologist to serve educators and the general public.
Partnerships drive strategy, innovation and investigation, and the Bureau engages partners, new and old, on a multitude of levels. Investments in Bureau research provide incredible returns. Corporate partners participate in and gain vital new insights from the Bureau’s many research consortia. Advanced Energy Consortium State of Texas Advanced Resource Recovery Reservoir Characterization Research Laboratory Applied Geodynamics Laboratory Center for Energy Economics Mudrock Systems Research Laboratory Fracture Research and Application Consortium Deep Shelf Western Gulf of Mexico Gulf Coast Carbon Center UT GeoFluids Quantitative Clastics Laboratory Exploration Geophysics Laboratory Texas Consortium for Computational Seismology
Who We AreBased within UT’s largest research organization, the Bureau of Economic Geology, CEE performs research and provides training and outreach on energy economics, markets, and frameworks for commercial and strategic investment. CEE is externally funded through research grants and contracts, corporate and government partnerships, and our training programs and partnerships.
MissionCEE conducts applied research on energy-value-chain economics and educates stakeholders to improve public policy and investment for economic development. “We develop viable solutions to problems across energy value chains and frameworks, identifying trade-offs and addressing externalities.”
CEE TrainingUsing our knowledge base, CEE prepares and delivers training on economic fundamentals of energy value chains, the roles of industry and government, and technology and investment frameworks for commercialization. We also facilitate Commercial Frameworks©; stakeholder interactions (business-government-public); engineering, production, and procurement management; and energy finance.
Center for Energy EconomicsSupply Transport DistributeConvert Use
Energy value chains
Externalities (via stakeholder perceptions about value)Investment frameworks Oil, gas, supply,
deliverability
Economicbenefits andcommodity
markets
Gas/powerchallenges
Upstream,midstreameconomics
Gas utilizationin power gen
Job creation,Federal/State
revenues,supply-demand and price
interactions
Liquidscommercialization
Impact of oil andgas tax changes
Water developmentand use
Adding intermittentresources
Integrated Scenarios
An Energy Web
Sample of Factors Impacting Gas Use for Power
Our Geography and Reach
Oil & gasupstream, midstream
economics, riskanalysis
Oil & gas market dynamics:supply-demand, pricing
Economic impacts
Energy webs: Trade-offs and policy/regulatory drivers
Power value chain:generation cost,
risk analysis,power dispatch
5
4
3
2
1
0
GHG (climate)
Envt (land, water)
Envt (air)
Market friendly
Reliability
Safety
Energy security
Impact (scale)
CoalNatural gasLNGNuclearHydroelectricSolar, wind (grid-based)Solar, distributed
Demand-side responseLarge-scale electricity storage
Decreasing price of oilCC for gas-fired plants
Energy-security concernsGas price < $6Gas price > $7
GHG regulationHigher-demand growthLower-demand growthMercury (EPA MATS)
Methane regulationMore renewables
Nuclear retirementSmart-grid deployment
SOX & NOX (EPA CSAPR)Water scarcity
New Era in Oil, Gas & Power Value Creationdelegate countries (2001–2010)
Major CEE Research and Technical Assistance ProjectsUT McCombs/CEE ExxonMobil Upstream Comm. Overview 1 Program
Custom programs
Houston HQ
Frame of Reference
Clear a Clogged Sink Drain Clear a Clogged Sink Drain
Supply Transport DistributeConvert Use
Energy value chains
Externalities (via stakeholder perceptions about value)Investment frameworks Oil, gas, supply,
deliverability
Economicbenefits andcommodity
markets
Gas/powerchallenges
Upstream,midstreameconomics
Gas utilizationin power gen
Job creation,Federal/State
revenues,supply-demand and price
interactions
Liquidscommercialization
Impact of oil andgas tax changes
Water developmentand use
Adding intermittentresources
Integrated Scenarios
An Energy Web
Sample of Factors Impacting Gas Use for Power
Our Geography and Reach
Oil & gasupstream, midstream
economics, riskanalysis
Oil & gas market dynamics:supply-demand, pricing
Economic impacts
Energy webs: Trade-offs and policy/regulatory drivers
Power value chain:generation cost,
risk analysis,power dispatch
5
4
3
2
1
0
GHG (climate)
Envt (land, water)
Envt (air)
Market friendly
Reliability
Safety
Energy security
Impact (scale)
CoalNatural gasLNGNuclearHydroelectricSolar, wind (grid-based)Solar, distributed
Demand-side responseLarge-scale electricity storage
Decreasing price of oilCC for gas-fired plants
Energy-security concernsGas price < $6Gas price > $7
GHG regulationHigher-demand growthLower-demand growthMercury (EPA MATS)
Methane regulationMore renewables
Nuclear retirementSmart-grid deployment
SOX & NOX (EPA CSAPR)Water scarcity
New Era in Oil, Gas & Power Value Creationdelegate countries (2001–2010)
Major CEE Research and Technical Assistance ProjectsUT McCombs/CEE ExxonMobil Upstream Comm. Overview 1 Program
Custom programs
Houston HQ
Frame of Reference
Clear a Clogged Sink Drain Clear a Clogged Sink Drain
APPLIED RESEARCH IN ENERGY
ECONOMICS With international
collaborations
OUTREACH Research papers and publications,
forums, web resources
TRAINING AND EDUCATION
McCombs Executive Education and
custom programs
Current Activitiest Natural gas markets: commodity market
trends and demand-side analysis including modeling EPA regulations; gas use in power generation; database for petrochemicals and other industrial demand; exports via pipelines or LNG; use of gas in vehicles; residential and commercial requirements
t Electricity markets: economics of generation technologies, demand response, storage, ancillary services and other design issues
t Critical energy infrastructure: value chain costs and other considerations such as stakeholder risk including oil and gas pipelines; processing; refining to connect oil, gas, liquids production to markets; grids
t Energy webs: evaluating energy options across multiple dimensions
t U.S. producer and national oil company benchmarking: cost structures, performance, financial state of companies, funding sources and capital market risk
B E G R E S E A R C H
ContactMichelle Michot Foss, Chief Energy Economist and Program Manager
Gürcan Gülen, [email protected], (U.S.) 713-654-5404 Laura Martinez, [email protected], (U.S.) 713-654-5400 www.beg.utexas.edu/energyecon [email protected]
Center for Energy Economics
CENTER FOR ENERGY
ECONOMICS
Bureau of Economic GeologyJackson School of Geosciences, The University of Texas at Austin
Supply Transport DistributeConvert Use
Energy value chains
Externalities (via stakeholder perceptions about value)Investment frameworks Oil, gas, supply,
deliverability
Economicbenefits andcommodity
markets
Gas/powerchallenges
Upstream,midstreameconomics
Gas utilizationin power gen
Job creation,Federal/State
revenues,supply-demand and price
interactions
Liquidscommercialization
Impact of oil andgas tax changes
Water developmentand use
Adding intermittentresources
Integrated Scenarios
An Energy Web
Sample of Factors Impacting Gas Use for Power
Our Geography and Reach
Oil & gasupstream, midstream
economics, riskanalysis
Oil & gas market dynamics:supply-demand, pricing
Economic impacts
Energy webs: Trade-offs and policy/regulatory drivers
Power value chain:generation cost,
risk analysis,power dispatch
5
4
3
2
1
0
GHG (climate)
Envt (land, water)
Envt (air)
Market friendly
Reliability
Safety
Energy security
Impact (scale)
CoalNatural gasLNGNuclearHydroelectricSolar, wind (grid-based)Solar, distributed
Demand-side responseLarge-scale electricity storage
Decreasing price of oilCC for gas-fired plants
Energy-security concernsGas price < $6Gas price > $7
GHG regulationHigher-demand growthLower-demand growthMercury (EPA MATS)
Methane regulationMore renewables
Nuclear retirementSmart-grid deployment
SOX & NOX (EPA CSAPR)Water scarcity
New Era in Oil, Gas & Power Value Creationdelegate countries (2001–2010)
Major CEE Research and Technical Assistance ProjectsUT McCombs/CEE ExxonMobil Upstream Comm. Overview 1 Program
Custom programs
Houston HQ
Frame of Reference
Clear a Clogged Sink Drain Clear a Clogged Sink Drain
CEE Analytics and Modeling
Supply Transport DistributeConvert Use
Energy value chains
Externalities (via stakeholder perceptions about value)Investment frameworks Oil, gas, supply,
deliverability
Economicbenefits andcommodity
markets
Gas/powerchallenges
Upstream,midstreameconomics
Gas utilizationin power gen
Job creation,Federal/State
revenues,supply-demand and price
interactions
Liquidscommercialization
Impact of oil andgas tax changes
Water developmentand use
Adding intermittentresources
Integrated Scenarios
An Energy Web
Sample of Factors Impacting Gas Use for Power
Our Geography and Reach
Oil & gasupstream, midstream
economics, riskanalysis
Oil & gas market dynamics:supply-demand, pricing
Economic impacts
Energy webs: Trade-offs and policy/regulatory drivers
Power value chain:generation cost,
risk analysis,power dispatch
5
4
3
2
1
0
GHG (climate)
Envt (land, water)
Envt (air)
Market friendly
Reliability
Safety
Energy security
Impact (scale)
CoalNatural gasLNGNuclearHydroelectricSolar, wind (grid-based)Solar, distributed
Demand-side responseLarge-scale electricity storage
Decreasing price of oilCC for gas-fired plants
Energy-security concernsGas price < $6Gas price > $7
GHG regulationHigher-demand growthLower-demand growthMercury (EPA MATS)
Methane regulationMore renewables
Nuclear retirementSmart-grid deployment
SOX & NOX (EPA CSAPR)Water scarcity
New Era in Oil, Gas & Power Value Creationdelegate countries (2001–2010)
Major CEE Research and Technical Assistance ProjectsUT McCombs/CEE ExxonMobil Upstream Comm. Overview 1 Program
Custom programs
Houston HQ
Frame of Reference
Clear a Clogged Sink Drain Clear a Clogged Sink Drain
Sample Factors Impacting Gas Use for Power
Supply Transport DistributeConvert Use
Energy value chains
Externalities (via stakeholder perceptions about value)Investment frameworks Oil, gas, supply,
deliverability
Economicbenefits andcommodity
markets
Gas/powerchallenges
Upstream,midstreameconomics
Gas utilizationin power gen
Job creation,Federal/State
revenues,supply-demand and price
interactions
Liquidscommercialization
Impact of oil andgas tax changes
Water developmentand use
Adding intermittentresources
Integrated Scenarios
An Energy Web
Sample of Factors Impacting Gas Use for Power
Our Geography and Reach
Oil & gasupstream, midstream
economics, riskanalysis
Oil & gas market dynamics:supply-demand, pricing
Economic impacts
Energy webs: Trade-offs and policy/regulatory drivers
Power value chain:generation cost,
risk analysis,power dispatch
5
4
3
2
1
0
GHG (climate)
Envt (land, water)
Envt (air)
Market friendly
Reliability
Safety
Energy security
Impact (scale)
CoalNatural gasLNGNuclearHydroelectricSolar, wind (grid-based)Solar, distributed
Demand-side responseLarge-scale electricity storage
Decreasing price of oilCC for gas-fired plants
Energy-security concernsGas price < $6Gas price > $7
GHG regulationHigher-demand growthLower-demand growthMercury (EPA MATS)
Methane regulationMore renewables
Nuclear retirementSmart-grid deployment
SOX & NOX (EPA CSAPR)Water scarcity
New Era in Oil, Gas & Power Value Creationdelegate countries (2001–2010)
Major CEE Research and Technical Assistance ProjectsUT McCombs/CEE ExxonMobil Upstream Comm. Overview 1 Program
Custom programs
Houston HQ
Frame of Reference
Clear a Clogged Sink Drain Clear a Clogged Sink Drain
Our Geography and Reach
Supply Transport DistributeConvert Use
Energy value chains
Externalities (via stakeholder perceptions about value)Investment frameworks Oil, gas, supply,
deliverability
Economicbenefits andcommodity
markets
Gas/powerchallenges
Upstream,midstreameconomics
Gas utilizationin power gen
Job creation,Federal/State
revenues,supply-demand and price
interactions
Liquidscommercialization
Impact of oil andgas tax changes
Water developmentand use
Adding intermittentresources
Integrated Scenarios
An Energy Web
Sample of Factors Impacting Gas Use for Power
Our Geography and Reach
Oil & gasupstream, midstream
economics, riskanalysis
Oil & gas market dynamics:supply-demand, pricing
Economic impacts
Energy webs: Trade-offs and policy/regulatory drivers
Power value chain:generation cost,
risk analysis,power dispatch
5
4
3
2
1
0
GHG (climate)
Envt (land, water)
Envt (air)
Market friendly
Reliability
Safety
Energy security
Impact (scale)
CoalNatural gasLNGNuclearHydroelectricSolar, wind (grid-based)Solar, distributed
Demand-side responseLarge-scale electricity storage
Decreasing price of oilCC for gas-fired plants
Energy-security concernsGas price < $6Gas price > $7
GHG regulationHigher-demand growthLower-demand growthMercury (EPA MATS)
Methane regulationMore renewables
Nuclear retirementSmart-grid deployment
SOX & NOX (EPA CSAPR)Water scarcity
New Era in Oil, Gas & Power Value Creationdelegate countries (2001–2010)
Major CEE Research and Technical Assistance ProjectsUT McCombs/CEE ExxonMobil Upstream Comm. Overview 1 Program
Custom programs
Houston HQ
Frame of Reference
Clear a Clogged Sink Drain Clear a Clogged Sink Drain
The Energy Web
B E G R E S E A R C H
CE
For travelhttp://ww As a remiHouse rulhonor Ho
Session
8:00AM
8:30
9:00
9:30
10:30
10:45
11:00
11:45
E 2014 Annua
Hous
lers using theww.cpdownt
inder, by tradles apply. Ceuse rules.
Arrival, regist
Welcome – aMichelle Mic Overview of CMichelle Mic “What KeepsFor the 2014 cards for coll
Paradigms LoScene‐setting
Risks to t
Key ener
EmergingAndrew Slaug
Big Moving PActive discusthrough five supply/deliv Asia‐Pacific
Hisanori
Jim Jense
Break
Welcome – B
Europe
Serge Kr
Middle East
al Meeting AgCEEC
CEEston Branch –
htt
e Crowne Plazown.com/
dition our mertain news m
tration, refresh
agenda for annhot Foss, Chief
CEE briefing bohot Foss and G
s Me Up at Nigmeeting, all pection by noon
ost?? g discussion to
the global econ
rgy risks
g global gas deghter, Senior E
Parts sion on key poregional lenseery implication
Nei, National
en, Jensen Ass
BEG Director Sc
ebs, French Co
genda ‐ WatchE mid‐year meeCEE annual mee
PARAD 2014 Annua– Federal Resp://www.da
za Hotel, dow
etings are comedia represe
OPE
Thoug
Wednes
hments – Brazo
ual meeting anf Energy Econo
ook for meetinGürcan Gülen,
ght” articipants aren. CEE staff wi
frame key issu
nomy that are
emand consideEnergy Advisor
oints from thoues – Asia‐Pacificns.
Graduate Insti
ociates
cott Tinker
onsulate Gener
h for Think Dayeting week of Meting Decembe
IGMS LOl Meeting, Deserve Bank ofllasfed.org/h
wntown Hous
onducted on aentatives are
EN MEETINGAgenda It
ght Leaders/Co
sday, Decembe
os Ballroom
nd workshopomist and Prog
ng and introducSenior Energy
e invited to subll summarize a
ues developed
not embedded
erations
ught leaders. Mc, Europe, Mid
tute for Policy
ral
y announcemeMay 18, 2015er 1‐3, 2015
ST?? ecember 3‐4f Dallas Confehouston.cfm
ston, link for
a non‐attribuinvited for th
emommentators
er 3
gram Manager
ctions of BEG/Economist/Re
bmit your “Up and add to ana
through rema
d in outlooks
Major issues afddle East, Russi
y Studies, Japan
ents and other
erence Cente
information
ution basis. Sheir expertise
CEE personnelesearch Associa
at Night” contalysis from prev
ainder of annua
ffecting gas/enia, North Amer
n
2015 events:
er
and maps:
Strict Chathame and expecte
l ate
ributions on novious years.
al meeting.
nergy demand rica – and
m ed to
ote
CE
Session
12:30PM
1:00
1:45
2:45
3:00
4:00
5:00
5:30
8:00
8:00AM
8:15
8:45
10:45
11:00
12:00PM
E 2014 Annua
Herman
Lunch/netwo
Russia
Jonathan
North Americ
Robert S
Javier Es
Break
Supply/Deliv
Robert S
Wrap up, keyAndrew Slaug
Closing thougVince Kamins
Reception – B
Adjourn
Arrival, regist
Breakfast Opening comJerry Langdo
Interactive WWrap up from
Break ou
Discussio In this interacgroups, each of the Decempolicy/regulastate of the ispolicy inconsfurther reseaopportunity tadvisors will CEE research
Break
Conclusions fFindings from
Adjourn
al Meeting AgCEEC
Franssen, Ene
orking – collect
n Stern and Jim
ca
Skinner, Univer
trada, Analytic
very Implicatio
Stibolt, Galway
y questions, prghter, Michelle
ghts on gas maski, Rice Univer
Buffalo Bayou
tration – Trinit
mments on gasn, Former Mem
Workshop to Bum December 3
uts organized a
on
ctive workshopto explore mo
mber 3 deliberaatory conditionssue, framing pistencies or otarch by UT/BEGto present thefacilitate the wers will assist i
from Workshom break out gro
genda ‐ WatchE mid‐year meeCEE annual mee
Thoug
rgy Intelligenc
t “Up at Night”
m Henderson, O
rsity of Calgary
ca Energetica
ons
Group
reparation fore Michot Foss,
arket transitiorsity
Room
Thursd
y Room
s market evolumber, Federal
uild Themes anidentifies big q
around major t
p segment of tore deeply oneations, includinns. Each grouppossible futureher impedimeG‐CEE or othersir conclusions workshop. Thein facilitating d
ops oups
h for Think Dayeting week of Meting Decembe
Agenda Itght Leaders/Co
e Group/CEE G
” submissions
Oxford Institut
y/CEE Global Ad
December 4Gürcan Gülen
ons and energy
day, December
ution Energy Regula
nd Conclusionsquestions for D
themes
he program, p of the key issung competing f will work on ie pathways to onts to gas mars would be helin the final sese CEE briefing bdiscussions as n
y announcemeMay 18, 2015er 1‐3, 2015
emommentators
Global Advisor
e for Energy St
dvisor (joining
y risk managem
r 4
tory Commissi
sDecember 4.
participants wilues or questionfuels and techndentifying the overcome bottrket developmelpful. Each bression of the mebook will be avneeded.
ents and other
tudies
via telecon)
ment
ion
ll break into smns about gas mnologies, commkey drivers betlenecks, strucent and highligeak out group weeting. UT/BEGvailable from th
2015 events:
mall discussionmarkets comingmercial and ehind the currectural constrainghting areas wwill have an G‐CEE staff andhe previous da
g out
ent nts, here
d ay and
CE
BEG/CEE Scott TinkEric PotteMichelle MGürcan GSvetlana ILaura MaXinya ZhaMiranda FDeniese PDaniel QuDerya EryAndrew SMark Blou CEE AdvisGlobal AdVicky BaileHal ChappeJuan EibenHerman FrLuis Giusti,Ernesto MEd Morse, Bob Skinne
Chevron C& Young
MeProgram
E 2014 Annua
personnel foker, BEG Direcer, BEG AssociMichot Foss, ülen, Senior Ekonnikova, Ertinez, Prograng, Post‐doctFerrell WainbPalmer Hugginuijano, Researyılmaz, Doctorlaughter, Senunt, External
sory Boards: dvisors ey, Consultant elle, Alta Mesanschutz, CNSNSranssen, EIG , CSIS arcos, Marcos Citibank er, CSEE
Corporation (G▪ Frost Bank ▪ exico ▪ Shell Mm/Office of the
Education (U
al Meeting AgCEEC
r meeting: ctor iate Director Chief Energy Energy Econonergy Economam Coordinattoral Researcberg, Senior Ens, Senior Enercher ral Researchenior Energy AdAffairs
a S‐Mexico
y Asociados
Global Gas, AfrSouthern Com
Mexico ▪ SUEZ Ee Comptroller UT‐ExxonMob
genda ‐ WatchE mid‐year meeCEE annual mee
– Energy Economist/P
omist, Researcmist, Researctor her nergy Advisoergy Advisor
er dvisor
We tharica/Latin Amempany ▪ HaddinEnergy North A▪ UT Jackson Sil Upstream Co
h for Think Dayeting week of Meting Decembe
Program Manach Associateh Associate
r
AnalyLes DBill GEd KeDaveDon Rae MBruceTeren
ank our donoerica, Energía dngton VentureAmerica ▪ StateSchool of Geosommercial Ove
y announcemeMay 18, 2015er 1‐3, 2015
ager
lytics/ModelinDeman, ConsulGilmer, Universelly, IHSE e Knapp, EIG Knop, ConsultaMcQuade, NAEe Stram, Elemence Thorn, Con
ors: de México) ▪ Ees ▪ McKinsey &e of Texas Advciences Endowerview1, UT‐P
ents and other
ng Advisors tant sity of Houston
ant ESB ent Markets nsultant
ExxonMobil (PG& Company ▪ Bvanced Resourwment ▪ UT McPetrobras, UT‐C
2015 events:
n
GA, Mexico) ▪BP Mexico ▪ Rerce Recovery cCombs ExecuCNOOC)
Ernst epsol
tive
CE
Man, I h
I'm backYou donBack in
Been awaGee, it's Leave it tHoney, d
I'm backYou donBack in Back in
Well the out They leaAnd Mosshout That GeoOh, come
I'm backYou donBack in
Well the out
E 2014 Annua
ad a dreadf
k in the USS't know how the USSR
ay so long Igood to be btill tomorrowdisconnect t
k in the USS't know how the US, bac the USSR
Ukraine gi
ve the West scow girls m
orgia's alwae on
k in the USS't know how the USSR
Ukraine gi
al Meeting AgCEEC
BA
Flew in fMiami BBOAC Didn't glast nigOn the wpaper bamy kne
ful flight
SR w lucky you
hardly kneack home w to unpackthe phone
SR w lucky you ck in the US
rls really kn
behind make me sin
ys on m-m-
SR w lucky you
rls really kn
genda ‐ WatchE mid‐year meeCEE annual mee
ACK IN TH
from Beach,
get to bed ht
way the g was on e
are, boy
ew the place
k my case
are, boy S
nock me
ng and
-my mind
are, boys
nock me
h for Think Dayeting week of Meting Decembe
HE U.S.S.
TheyAndshouThat
Oh, mouTakLet Com
I'm HeyboysBacOh,
SongLENMCC
PublLyri
y announcemeMay 18, 2015er 1‐3, 2015
.R. (1968)
y leave the Wd Moscow giut t Georgia's
show me rouuntains wayke me to youme hear you
me and keep
back in the y, you don't s k in the US let me tell y
gwriters NNON, JOHCARTNEY,
lished by ics © Sony/A
ents and other
West behindirls make m
always on m
und the snoy down soutu daddy's fau balalaikas your comra
USSR know how l
SSR you honey
HN WINSTO, PAUL JAM
ATV Music
2015 events:
d me sing and
m-m-my m
ow-peaked th arm s ringing ouade warm
lucky you a
ON / MES
Publishing L
mind
ut
are,
LLC
CE
The TNosta'Weedw
By SpencUpdated S
The tiny, sin the U.S
NEW YOguy magmidtown
Based onyear-old walked oTrabants
Most peoremarkabVolkswagGerman plunged in 1991.
Traban
E 2014 Annua
Trabant algia wackers in
cer Jakab Sept. 24, 201
smoke-belchiS.
ORK CITY—"net," said AnManhattan t
n the onlookengineer live
over while hes in the forme
ople just snably loud 26-hgen, Trabancity that wasafter the fall
nts line up at t
al Meeting AgCEEC
Takes M
n a Plastic
4 10:37 p.m.
ing Trabant, E
"I can't decidndy Burzynstraffic.
kers who waves, it is deci
e was stoppeer East Germ
ap photographorsepower ts—more ths once home of the Berlin
the Parade of
genda ‐ WatchE mid‐year meeCEE annual mee
Manhat
c Box' Are
ET
East Germany
de if this carski as he ma
ved and grindedly the lated in traffic omany.
phs or shoutcar. Introducan 3 million e to Audi. Den Wall almos
f Trabants, hoInternatio
h for Think Dayeting week of Meting Decembe
tan on a
e Collecto
y's answer to
r is more of aaneuvered hi
nned on the jtter. The onlon 52nd Stre
"what is it?"ced in 1957 of them—w
espite a mulst 25 years a
osted by the Ional Spy Mus
y announcemeMay 18, 2015er 1‐3, 2015
a Tour o
or's Item
the Volkswag
a chick magis lime green
journey fromy exception
eet to say sh
" when they as the Sovi
were manufactiyear waitinago and the
International Sseum
ents and other
of East
gen, has bec
net or an oldn 1985 Trab
m Queens, wwas a beam
he had grow
see—and hiet Bloc's anctured in Zw
ng list at the last "Trabi"
Spy Museum
2015 events:
Bloc
ome a collect
d East Europant through
where the 48ming blonde wn up with
hear—the nswer to the
wickau, an Eatime, sales rolled off the
m in Washingto
tible
pean
8-who
e ast
e line
on.
CE
As Mr. Bshort of scase. Thshores.
The Modrelatively
Most of tthrough 1from Wh
A Trabant
This yeaanniversawhimsicaas many vehicles.
Andy Burz a street in
"It's not amuseum
E 2014 Annua
urzynski andsafety and eat means th
del 1.1, deridy modern one
he 200 or so1989. Roughite Hall, Md.
t 601
r's event, scary of the Beal as the carspeople as p The record
zynski's lime n Manhattan.
all sweet me.
al Meeting AgCEEC
d other enthmissions regat the last T
ded by somee in a futile b
o Trabants ohly a third ofHe says he
cheduled for erlin Wall's cs themselve
possible cramis 16 in a "k
green 1985 TRobert Alcar
mories, for s
genda ‐ WatchE mid‐year meeCEE annual mee
usiasts knowgulations to
Trabant mode
e purists, repbid to stay in
on U.S. roadf those were e owns "abou
40"Wruen
TmexanInw
Nov. 8, maycollapse the es. Activities m themselvekombi" mode
hsc
TCwamac
Trabant on raz for The W
sure," says A
h for Think Dayeting week of Meting Decembe
w, 25 years abe importedels, 23 or 24
placed the orn business a
s are the Moimported by
ut 30"—he h0 of the smoWeedwackeuns an all-elenvironmenta
he Trabant imade, but do
xpected to cnnual Parad
nternational Swith Cold Wa
y be the largfollowing dahave includ
es like circusel—a sort of has some hismuggled ou
compartment
The museumCharlie and awearing repliappreciated bmember of a attend said scostume.
Wall Stre
Amanda Oh
y announcemeMay 18, 2015er 1‐3, 2015
also is the ad as antiques4 years old, s
riginal lawnmafter German
odel 601, viry Mike Annehas lost counoke-belchingrs in a plastiectric lawn-cally concerne
is on many ln't tell that to
converge on de of TrabanSpy Museum
ar memorabil
gest yet, giveay. Past occaed a Traban
s clowns intoEast Bloc s
storical signiut of East Gets of Traban
m constructs a few of the ca Stasi uniby most partDachshund
she couldn't p
lke, Director
ents and other
age that allows—a must inshould soon
mower-style n reunificatio
rtually unchaen, a 55-yeant—and he hg cars he calic box." Paracare service ed homeown
ists of the wo the dozensWashington
nts hosted bym, a private lia.
en the quarteasions havent-stuffing coo one of the tation wagoificance as permany in thents.
a replica of owners get forms. That ticipants, bu
d owners cluparticipate b
r of Adult Ed
2015 events:
ws cars that n the Trabann arrive on U
motor with aon.
anged from 1r-old collectohas sold abolls adoxically, hfor
ners.
worst cars evs of owners n for the eighy the institution fil
er century e been as ontest in whitiny, two-don. The exercpeople were e hidden
Checkpoint into the act prop is t not all. Onb invited to
because of th
ducation at th
fall nt's U.S.
a
1963 or out
he
ver
hth
lled
ch or cise
by
e
he
he
CE
Trabant orecounts ended. Fa TrabanDuroplasto test its
"People janyway,'
On the oThat cam
"One of tlifting out
Driving Tgasoline.
"I can geBurzynsk
On the dother car
Some resitems. Scwas: "Ho
Working U.S. toda
E 2014 Annua
owners haveone occasio
Fortunately, nnt. The cars ast, a waterpros strength in
joke, 'I don't " he says.
ther hand, Tme in handy
the things tht the motors
Trabants can. And getting
et up to trafficki.
rive into Mars on the roa
sidents of thcores of themow do you do
models solday. That is st
al Meeting AgCEEC
e to get usedon when theneither Mr. Bare made nooof resin stua collision.
know why y
Trabants areunder comm
at's so hilarior whatever
n present chag onto a high
c speed…m
nhattan, he ad, it adeptly
he former Eam were simpouble the va
d for $100 ortill a bargain
genda ‐ WatchE mid‐year meeCEE annual mee
d to people ce driver of a BBurzynski noot of steel, inuffed with rec
you're putting
so simple thmunism whe
ious is that tr," says Ms.
allenges, suhway is som
aybe 60 mile
also showedy snaked thro
astern Bloc aply abandonelue of a Trab
r so in the ean for a collec
h for Think Dayeting week of Meting Decembe
Justindeviceabout piece Forumdestinmany "ThereMacG
A rare Intern
constantly snBMW stoppeor Mr. Shephn short suppcycled cotto
g on your se
hat little techn mechanics
hey're constOhlke.
ch as the neetimes unne
es per hour
d off some oough gridloc
are shocked ed by the robant? By filli
arly 1990s actible car.
y announcemeMay 18, 2015er 1‐3, 2015
n Shepherd,e salesman fthe joys andof history. A
ms, the largenation for ent
tales of impe's a bunch
Gyveresque t
pre-1963 Tranational Spy M
napping picted in traffic therd has beeply in postwan fiber. Mr. S
eat belt, you'
hnical abilitys kept custo
tantly workin
eed to carry erving.
downhill wit
of the Trabi'scked Midtow
to hear thatoadside in Wing it with ga
and fetch abo
ents and other
a 32-year-ofrom San And challenges
As coordinatoest English-lathusiasts, he
promptu roadof stuff you to get it goin
abant in WashMuseum
tures. Mr. Buto take a phoen involved
ar East GermShepherd w
're dead if yo
y is required omers waiting
ng on them d
engine oil to
h a tailwind,
s advantagesn streets.
t cars are noWest Berlin. Aas."
out 30 times
2015 events:
ld medical-ntonio, knows of driving tor of Trabananguage onle has heard dside repairscould do tha
ng again."
hington, D.C.
urzynski oto and got in an accide
many, but would prefer n
ou get hit
to repair theg for months
during the ev
o mix with
," says Mr.
s. Dwarfed b
ow collector'sA joke at the
s as much in
ws all this nt line
s. at's
rear-ent in
not
em. s.
vent,
by
s time
the
CE
That mayto get onwhere yowere con
Today, W($77) for or leoparthe reachand powe
Attendan
Write to S
Copyright 20
This copy is fby copyright
www.djreprin
E 2014 Annua
y keep rising an eight-ye
oung couplesnceived in th
Western tour"Trabi Safa
rd spots. Somh of millions,erful, too.
nts dressed as
Spencer Jak
14 Dow Jones &
for your personal,law. For non-pers
nts.com.http://st
al Meeting AgCEEC
g. A quarter ear waiting liss had to shae back seat
rists see the ris"—tours inme collector, much as th
s members of
kab at spenc
Company, Inc. All
non-commercial sonal use or to ordtv.wsj.net/im htt
genda ‐ WatchE mid‐year meeCEE annual mee
century aftest for Trabanare tiny apart
of a Traban
Trabant as n one of the rs consider the Model T F
f East GermaSp
cer.jakab@w
l Rights Reserved
use only. Distribuder multiple copietp://stv.wsj.net/im
h for Think Dayeting week of Meting Decembe
r the end of nts feel a sotments with
nt.
a symbol of cars paintedhem engine
Ford did in A
any's Stasi at py Museum
wsj.com
d
ution and use of ths, please contact
y announcemeMay 18, 2015er 1‐3, 2015
communismrt of nostalgtheir extend
a bygone ed in bright d
eering icons—America. The
last year's Pa
his material are goDow Jones Repr
ents and other
m, many whoia for them.
ded families,
ra. Visitors tesigns such
—a car that e cars are ab
arade of Trab
overned by our Suints at 1-800-843-
2015 events:
o were too yIn a region many claim
to Berlin payh as zebra stput driving wbout as mod
ants. Internat
ubscriber Agreem-0008 or visit
oung
m they
y €60 tripes within ern
tional
ent and
©BEG/CEE-UT, 1
2014 Presentation Slides
Summary of Key Research Highlights Featured for External Groups ©BEG/CEE-UT, 2
It’s Complicated
• Big picture– Midstream build out – timing, logistics, perils, pitfalls– Demand – who, what, when, where– Trade and exports
• Short term– Oil demand jitters vs oil supply geopolitics– Gas storage dominant themes
• Longer term– Is gas still a byproduct???– Gas supply and deliverability in the face of demand pull
©BEG/CEE-UT, 3
Scenario Tracking: Crude Oil
Based on Foss, 2011, OIES NG 58; see Foss, Gulen, Wainberg, Oil & Gas Investor, September 2013
Offsetting factors:• Lower global demand (mainly China)• OECD supply• OPEC supply and geopolitical risk• “Political stabilization” premium
©BEG/CEE-UT, 4
Scenario Tracking: Natural Gas
Based on Foss, 2011, OIES NG 58; see Foss, Gulen, Wainberg, Oil & Gas Investor, September 2013
Offsetting factors:• Supply constraints – depleting inventory
of core acreage drilling locations, regulatory risk
• Demand build – industrial response, price and regulatory push on power gen
©BEG/CEE-UT, 5
Scenario Tracking: Oil, Gas Spread
Based on Foss, 2011, OIES NG 58; see Foss, Gulen, Wainberg, Oil & Gas Investor, September 2013
High risk projects such as GTL generally need 20:1 and preferably 25:1 for economics
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45Historical Oil:NG
CEE (Foss) Projection, Fall 2011 ($Nominal)
EIA AEO 2014 Oil:NG
Timing?
©BEG/CEE-UT, 6
Good News: U.S. Oil Replenishment
2,900
205,217
30,529
0
50,000
100,000
150,000
200,000
250,000
1900 ProvedReserves
1901‐2012Production
2012 ProvedReserves
Million Barrels
1900‐2012 change in:Production 3,637%Reserves 953%
TOP 10 *OIL PRODUCERS,2012:(Thousand Barrels per Day)Saudi Arabia 11,725.7United States 11,109.0Russia 10,397.0China 4,372.4Canada 3,856.4Iran 3,517.8UAE 3,213.2Iraq 2,986.6Mexico 2,936.0Kuwait 2,796.8*Crude oil only
CEE analysis based on EIA; BP places U.S. 3rd
after Russia in 2013 including NGLs
©BEG/CEE-UT, 7
Good News: U.S. Gas Replenishment
46
1,122
308
0
200
400
600
800
1,000
1,200
1930 Proved Reserves 1931‐2012 Production 2012 Proved Reserves
Trillion Cubic Feet (TCF)
TOP 10 *GAS PRODUCERS,2012:(Billion Cubic Feet per Day)United States 65.9Russia 59.4Iran 15.5Qatar 15.1Canada 13.9Norway 11.4China 10.4Saudi Arabia 9.8Algeria 8.4Netherlands 7.8*Dry gas production
1930‐2012 change in:Production 1,164%Reserves 570%
CEE analysis based on EIA ©BEG/CEE-UT, 8
U.S. Oil & Gas Production
• We need oil production growth rates of 15‐18% year on year to sustain dry gas growth rates of 4‐6%.
• 2014 gas storage “woulda coulda”
-30%
-20%
-10%
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
0
50,000
100,000
150,000
200,000
250,000
300,000
Y-Y Change
Prod
uctio
n, '0
00 B
BL
U.S. Oil Production (Thousand Barrels)
U.S. Oil Production 12-MO MA (Thousand Barrels)
Y-Y Chg Oil Production (%)
-15%
-10%
-5%
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
0
500,000
1,000,000
1,500,000
2,000,000
2,500,000
Y-Y Change
Prod
uctio
n, M
MC
F
U.S. Dry Gas Production (MMCF)
U.S. Dry Gas Production 12-MO MA (MMCF)
Y-Y Chg Dry Gas Production (%)
©BEG/CEE-UT, 9
Long Term Perspectives
©BEG/CEE-UT, 10
Feeling the Need for Shale
CEE based on EIA and other sources
Offshore (Federal, State)
Onshore (Conventional)
CBMShale
‐
5,000,000
10,000,000
15,000,000
20,000,000
25,000,000
30,000,000
35,000,000
Million Cubic Feet
Note: 2013 estimates for shales, CBM based on industry and state government data
©BEG/CEE-UT, 11
Comparative Tiers
Can deliver at $4 base case
Less uplift at $6 than other basins
Marcellus
BEG Shale Reserves, Production Research
Marcellus Preliminary
EMBARGOED
©BEG/CEE-UT, 12
It’s Expensive, and Location Dependent
‐$2
$0
$2
$4
$6
$8
$10
$12
$14
$16
$18
Tier 1 Tier 2 Tier 3 Tier 4 Tier 5 Tier 6 Tier 7 Tier 8 Tier 9 Tier 10
Barnett Low Btu
Barnett High Btu
Fayetteville Shallow
Fayetteville Medium
Fayetteville Deep
Haynesville
PA Dry
PA Wet
PA Rich
$4 Henry Hub
Breakeven Economics @ 10% IRR
Marcellus Preliminary
BEG Sloan shale resource assessment
EMBARGOED
©BEG/CEE-UT, 13
U.S. Cost and Performance
• Liquids driven business since 2007• CEE benchmarked companies: CAPEX, OPEX still rising –difficult to sustain economies of scale for unit cost management
• Price provides the main, or only, uplift – but not all barrels are the same– Only black oil can get full WTI price (with transport)– Condensate ~$20 below WTI– NGLs basket 60‐70% of WTI (depending upon C1 cut)– C1‐C2 mix 20‐30% of WTI
• Rapidly depleting the best, core acreage; continuous drilling• Public company business model (“Street”)
©BEG/CEE-UT, 14
GDP, Oil Price Linkages
‐100%
‐50%
0%
50%
100%
150%
200%
250%
‐3%
‐2%
‐1%
0%
1%
2%
3%
4%
5%
6%
7%
8%Chan
ge in
Oil P
rice, Y
‐Y
World GDP Growth, Y
‐Y
World GDP growth (annual %)Oil Price (annual %)
World Bank databank
©BEG/CEE-UT, 15
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
200
Energy
Metals & Minerals
Non‐Fuel
Oil: Catching up
World Bank commodity indexes from Quandl ©BEG/CEE-UT, 16
Fiscal Cost Curve 2012
Bar width: country’s production; bar heights: price estimate rangesAissaoui, A., Fiscal Break-Even Prices Revisited: What More Could They Tell Us About OPEC Policy Intent?, APICORP Research, Economic Commentary, Volume 7 No.8-9, August-September 2012 and Middle East Economic Survey, August 13, 2012. Used with permission.
CEE 2011 NOC benchmark range:
$73-86/BOE
©BEG/CEE-UT, 17
Fiscal Cost Curve YE 2013
Downward pressure on oil prices
Used with permission
CEE 2013 NOC benchmark
range: $74-96/BOE
©BEG/CEE-UT, 18
‐100%
‐50%
0%
50%
100%
150%
200%
250%
300%Y‐Y Change Cushing, OKMonthly Avg WTI SpotPrice, %
Y‐Y Change Henry HubMonthly Average SpotPrice, %
Markets ‘R Us• Small changes in
supply-demand balance exert large changes in price volatility.
• Natural gas has tended to demonstrate greater price volatility than oil. “Volatility is Dead”
CEE analysis based on EIA
©BEG/CEE-UT, 19
0
5
10
15
20
25
2012 2015 2018 2021 2024 2027 2030
TCF
Industrial CEE
Other (Res, Comm,Trans) EIA ER Dec2013
A Strong “Demand Stack” Brewing
CEE analysis; EIA 2014 Early Release (ER), Dec 2013 (reference case)
Other 2030 = 10.8 (residential+ commercial 10.5)
Industrial 2030 = 8.8 (EIA ER = 8.5)
©BEG/CEE-UT, 20
$3.91 $3.52
$2.41
$3.40
$2.71 $2.99
$3.66
$3.73
$0.66 $0.65
$0.61
$0.71 $7.28 $7.16
$6.67
$7.84
$‐
$1
$2
$3
$4
$5
$6
$7
$8
$9
Average AllProducers(2009)
Average AllProducers(2010)
Average AllProducers(2011)
Average AllProducers(2012)
$/MCFE
10% Return
U.S. Cash Operating Costs $/MCFE
U.S. All Source FD Costs $/MCFE
Henry Hub Spot Price $4/MCF
Note: All Source FD Costs are 3‐year rolling averages
As of: December 4, 2013
Producer Economics
Monitoring U.S./Global Oil and Gas: Upstream Attainment, Producer Challenges http://www.beg.utexas.edu/energyecon/thinkcorner/Think%20Corner%20‐%20Producers.pdf
NGL Uplift: how much, when & where?
©BEG/CEE-UT, 21
NGL Uplift is Volatile
CEE based on CME/NYMEX ©BEG/CEE-UT, 22
Industrial Gas Demand – A Growth Scenario Based on Projects in Progress
Xinya to Insert updated chart
• 23.6 BCFD or 8.6 TCF in 2019. 1.4 TCF increase since 2012
• CEE’s inventory is project based and does not include all sectors represented in EIA base demand.
Analysis based on CEE industrial project inventory
©BEG/CEE-UT, 23
Industrial Investment ($) by Region: LA, TX, Rest of US
• Projects that are completed or in permits, FEED or EPC phases:
• New investment 2013 – 2019 of $90.4 billion
• Regional shares:• LA: 39%• TX: 30%• Rest of US: 31%
• 123 projects total: ethylene, polyethylene, propylene, methanol, nitrogen fertilizers, chlor-alkali, hydrogen, other chemicals, plastics, metal, manufacturing and GTL
• All announced projects including those still in primary phases (under consideration, planning):
• 161 projects• Total investment of $124.5
billion• LA share drops to 35%
Analysis based on CEE industrial project inventory ©BEG/CEE-UT, 24
Major PetchemProject Count by Type by Region: LA, TX, Rest of US
• Ethylene plants (propylene, polyethylene included since many appear to be integrated): LA ‐ 8, TX ‐ 17, Rest of U.S. ‐ 4
• Methanol: all Gulf Coast. 3 in LA, 4 in TX.
• Nitrogen fertilizer (Ammonia, urea, UAN): Distributed in IA, IN, IL, TN, OK, ID, etc, close to demand market.
• GTL: SASOL in LA. Remainder are small‐scale plants.
Project Type LA TX Rest of US Grand Total
Nitrogen fertilizers 3 2 17 22
Other Chemicals 5 11 5 21
Ethylene 5 12 1 18
Metals 3 8 11
Polyethylene 3 6 1 10
Manufacturing 9 9
Methanol 3 4 7
Propylene 5 2 7
Chlor‐Alkali 1 1 3 5
GTL 2 3 5
Hydrogen 1 1 2 4
Plastics 1 2 3
MTG 1 1
Grand Total 28 42 53 123
Analysis based on CEE industrial project inventory
©BEG/CEE-UT, 25
Major New (2013‐19) Petchem Project Gas Use by Type by Region: LA, TX, Rest of US
Analysis based on CEE industrial project inventory ©BEG/CEE-UT, 26CEE based on EIA, NYMEX
NGL Frac Spread (NGL/Methane Prices)
$0
$2
$4
$6
$8
$10
$12
$14
January‐09 January‐10 January‐11 January‐12 January‐13 January‐14
$/M
MBtu
©BEG/CEE-UT, 27
Naptha/Ethane Cost Ratio
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
Jan‐10 Jul‐10 Jan‐11 Jul‐11 Jan‐12 Jul‐12 Jan‐13 Jul‐13
Ethane cracker more profitable
Naphtha cracker more profitable
©BEG/CEE-UT, 28
Cash Margins
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
‐$200
$0
$200
$400
$600
$800
$1,000
Nap
htha/ethan
e price ratio
$ per metric ton
Cash margin for ethane crackerCash margin for naphtha crackerNaphtha/ethane price ratio
©BEG/CEE-UT, 29
Cracker Cash Margins (Ethane/Naphtha)
1.50 1.55 1.60 1.65 1.70 1.75 1.80 1.85 1.90 1.95 2.00
0.20 1.02 1.09 1.18 1.28 1.40 1.54 1.72 1.94 2.23 2.61 3.17
0.25 0.97 1.04 1.12 1.21 1.33 1.46 1.63 1.84 2.12 2.48 3.01
0.30 0.91 0.98 1.06 1.15 1.26 1.38 1.54 1.74 2.00 2.35 2.86
0.35 0.86 0.93 1.00 1.08 1.19 1.31 1.46 1.65 1.89 2.22 2.70
0.40 0.81 0.87 0.94 1.02 1.12 1.23 1.38 1.55 1.79 2.09 2.54
0.45 0.76 0.82 0.88 0.96 1.05 1.16 1.29 1.46 1.67 1.96 2.38
0.50 0.71 0.77 0.83 0.90 0.98 1.08 1.20 1.36 1.56 1.83 2.23
0.55 0.66 0.71 0.77 0.83 0.91 1.00 1.12 1.26 1.45 1.70 2.07
0.60 0.61 0.66 0.71 0.77 0.84 0.93 1.03 1.17 1.34 1.57 1.91
0.65 0.56 0.60 0.65 0.71 0.77 0.85 0.95 1.07 1.23 1.45 1.76
0.70 0.51 0.55 0.59 0.64 0.70 0.78 0.86 0.98 1.12 1.32 1.60
0.75 0.46 0.50 0.53 0.58 0.63 0.70 0.78 0.88 1.01 1.19 1.44
0.80 0.41 0.44 0.48 0.52 0.56 0.62 0.69 0.78 0.90 1.06 1.28
0.85 0.36 0.39 0.42 0.45 0.49 0.55 0.61 0.69 0.79 0.93 1.13
Ethane Price ($/gallon)
Naphtha Price ($/gallon)
?
©BEG/CEE-UT, 30
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
2012 2015 2018 2021 2024 2027 2030
TCF
Power generationCEE
Industrial CEE
Other (Res, Comm,Trans) EIA ER Dec2013
A Strong “Demand Stack” Brewing
CEE analysis; EIA 2014 Early Release (ER), Dec 2013 (reference case)
Other 2030 = 10.8 (residential+ commercial 10.5)
Industrial 2030 = 8.8 (EIA ER = 8.5)
Power 2030 = 15.9 (EIA ER = 10.1)CEE assumes all possible EPA actions
©BEG/CEE-UT, 31
Different Views of the World
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040
Consumption of Natural Gas in Power Generation (Index, 2010 = 1)
AEO Real GDP IHS Real GDP AEO Electricity IHS Electricity
Based on data from EIA AEO 2013 & IHS Global Insight
Avg y‐y growth of 2.5%
©BEG/CEE-UT, 32
Coal Retirements• About 50 GW of coal capacity may retire by 2020
– Almost 21 GW already retired in 2010‐13 (mostly older units)
– Announced about 29 GW (2014‐2020)
©BEG/CEE-UT, 33
Nuclear Relicensing?• 4 recent announcements; more possible but our modeling does not retire nuclear units
• 5,500 MW in 3 plants under construction
©BEG/CEE-UT, 34
A Scenario on Gas Use in Power
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
2030
TCF
Nuclear shutdowns
Change in Gas Price Forecast
Coal risks
U.S. Gas‐Power Linkages: Building Future Views for details: http://www.beg.utexas.edu/energyecon/thinkcorner/Think%20Corner%20Gas‐Power%20Linkages.pdf
©BEG/CEE-UT, 35
A strong “demand stack” scenario
CEE analysis; EIA ER refers to EIA 2014 Early Release, Dec 2013 (reference case)
Other 2030 = 10.8 (residential+ commercial 10.5)
Industrial 2030 = 8.8 (EIA ER = 8.5)
Power 2030 = 15.9 (EIA ER = 10.1)
Pipe Exports 2030 = 3.9 (EIA ER = 3.4)
LNG Exports 2030 = 1.0 (EIA ER = 3.5)
©BEG/CEE-UT, 36
Is exporting crude oil a problem??
“yes”
Upstream economics, impacts on wellhead value
Regulatory efficiency (political risk of
alternative approaches)
Revoke EAA or remove all hydrocarbon components
(chance of success?)
Streamline existing process for long term “optionality” (exports,
imports)
Quick fix to add condensate to CCL (or remove, whichever is
correct)
Value chain integrity –supporting infrastructure
(“both regulatory process and infrastructure are so 70s”)
Transport modes, risks,
policy/regulatory considerations
“no”
Enough companies can get exemptions,
approvals
“Perception of risk” view: less drilling = less production = fewer
nuisances and hazards
The Crude Export Debate
©BEG/CEE-UT, 37
O Canada: Getting Their Dander Up
TransCanada Energy East
Enbridge Eastern Access
©BEG/CEE-UT, 38Map presents a possible gas flow scenario, Foss, Ch. 3 in Pricing Internationally Traded Gas, Oxford, 2012; gas trade data from EIA
The Future?2013: U.S. is
29% of Canadian consumption
2013: U.S. is29% of
Mexican consumption
~2x current NA exports by 2020?~9+ BCFD
©BEG/CEE-UT, 39
3
6 6 6 6
1 1 1 1
3
3 3 3 5
1.3
1.3 23.5
6
0.4
0.40.8
0.8
0.9
0123456789
1011121314151617181920
The Attraction "Reality" High Cost Delivery toAtlantic Basin
High Cost Delivery toPacific Basin
Super High CostDelivery to Pacific Basin
$/MMBtuRegasification Shipping Liquefaction Field to Terminal Henry Hub
Is U.S. LNG Competitive?
$9‐11 NBP
$14‐19 Asia spot
$10 Japan pre‐Fukushima
Sep14$6‐7Oct14 $9+
http://www.beg.utexas.edu/energyecon/thinkcorner/Is%20US%20LNG%20Competitive.pdf
Sep14 $10‐11Oct14$14‐15
V
o
l
a
t
i
l
i
t
y
Team mem
DecembeManagem
Novembeanniversa
Novembeprogram f
Novembemarket dySPE Gulf C
October 3Company
October 2Demand f
October 2advisory b
October 1Society‐G
October 1Monterre
October 1ConsultanHouston,
October 6in Palm Spthe non‐e
October 3OklahomaOK.
October 2future cru
Septembeluncheon
Septembeat the Ern
mbers: Dr. M
r 9, 2014 – Dment Worksho
er 18‐19, 2014ary energy con
er 17, 2014 ‐ Mfor new accou
er 13, 2014 – ynamics, and Coast Section
30, 2014 – Dr.fuel price ou
22, 2014 – Msfor Natural Ga
20‐21, 2014 –board meetin
16, 2014 – Dr.eophysical So
16, 2014 – Dr.ey, Mexico.
13, 2014 – Msnts Inc) confeTX.
6‐8, 2014 – Drprings. Ms. Paenergy profes
3, 2014 – Ms. a State Unive
2, 2014 – Dr. Mude oil supply
er 19, 2014 – of the Gulf C
er 9, 2014 – Dnst & Young M
CE
ichelle Micho
r. Michot Fosop, Midland, T
4 – Dr. Michonference, Em
Ms. Palmer Hunting manag
Dr. Gülen discpotential dev.
. Michot Fossutlook in Birm
s. Palmer Hugas as part of L
– Dr. Michot Fng, Kiawah Isla
. Gülen spokeociety of Hou
. Michot Foss
s. Palmer Hugrence on Solu
r. Michot Fosalmer‐Hugginsional. Dr. M
Palmer Huggrsity's Energy
Michot Foss py organized by
Dr. Gülen preCoast Power A
Dr. Michot FosMining and M
E EXTERNA
ot Foss; Dr. Gü
ss discussed oTX.
t Foss spoke irates Center
uggins presengers at Ernst &
cussed Unitedvelopments in
s served as a smingham, AL.
ggins presenteLSU’s “Outloo
Foss spoke onand, SC.
e on the U.S. eston Geoscie
s chaired the
ggins moderautions for Hir
s and Ms. Palns presented oMichot Foss pr
gins presentedy Marketing a
participated ay The Fusfeld
esented on thAssociation.
ss delivered tetals Confere
1
AL PRESEN
ürcan Gülen,
oil prices and
on U.S. oil anr for Strategic
nted on the H& Young at th
d States shalen major dema
speaker on oi
ed on the recok for Energy
n oil and gas t
economy andnce Day.
natural gas se
ted a panel ding and Retai
lmer‐Hugginson the Historresented a clo
d on Risk Maand Midstream
as an expert i Group on be
he U.S. natura
the keynote sence in Miam
NTATIONS
Ms. Deniese P
geopolitics fo
nd gas develoc Studies and
History of Oil he Museum o
e gas resourcand sectors a
il and gas tren
cent researchin Louisiana”
rends for the
d energy mar
ession at the
discussion at tining Talent in
s spoke at thery of Oil from osing keynote
nagement in m Program at
n a webinar oehalf of Phillip
al gas market
speech on enei.
Palmer‐Hugg
or the 12th an
pments for thResearch, Ab
for the internof Natural His
ce assessmentat the Genera
nds for the an
h by CEE on th” in Baton Ro
e annual Hadd
kets at the Ho
21st Border E
the EUCI (Elecn the Oil & Ga
e 90th Annuathe 1850’s toe on oil and g
the Midstreat the OSU cam
on strategic cps 66.
t dynamics at
ergy commod
gins
nual EOR Car
he 20th bu Dhabi.
nal training tory in Houst
ts, natural gal Meeting of
nnual Southe
he Industrial uge, LA.
dington Ventu
ouston Geolo
Energy Forum
ctric Utility as Industry in
l IECA Confero the presentgas trends.
am as part of mpus, Stillwat
consideration
the Austin
dities and ma
rbon
ton.
s the
rn
ures
ogical
m in
n
rence t for
ter,
s for
arkets
August 27resources
August 26
July 15, 20
July 8, 201Austin, in
June 19‐2Energy SeEconomicAssociatio
June 19, 2of Gulf Co
June 10, 2Capital Co
May 21, 2Amsterda
May 19, 2and Opera
April 30, 2short termForum in
April 28‐3DistributoGülen preshale gas
April 16, 2Oil & Gas
April 11, 2
April 8, 20Institute,
April 4, 20
April 2‐3,
April 1, 20
March 24Geoscienc
7, 2014 ‐ Dr. Gs at URTeC in
6, 2014 ‐ Dr. M
014 ‐ Dr. Güle
14 ‐ Dr. Gülencluding the G
21, 2014 ‐ Dr. ector", held bycs/Mexican chon of Natural
2014 ‐ Dr. Güloast Power As
2014 ‐ Dr. Miconference, Ho
2014 ‐ Dr. Micam, Netherlan
2014 ‐ Dr. Gülations Confer
2014 ‐ Ms. Pam or long termHouston, Tex
30, 2014 ‐ Dr. ors Associatioesented at thedevelopment
2014 ‐ Ms. Paon Houston R
2014 ‐ Dr. Gü
014 ‐Dr. MichNew York Cit
014 ‐ Dr. Mich
2014 ‐Dr. Mi
014 ‐ Dr. Mich
, 2014 – Dr. Gces' IX Latin A
Gülen presentDenver.
Michot Foss d
en was invited
n presented oGulf Coast Car
Michot Foss y the Mexicanhapter of the Gas, and the
len presentedssociation.
chot Foss servouston.
chot Foss servnds.
en was inviterence by RME
lmer Hugginsm solution?” xas
Gülen was anon of Chile (AGe Ministry of ts and prospe
lmer HugginsReal Estate” i
len presented
hot Foss spokety.
hot Foss addr
chot Foss spo
hot Foss pres
Gülen presentAmerican Foru
ted on Marce
delivered a br
d to participa
on CCUS econrbon Center o
spoke at the n Energy AssoInternationa Mexican cha
d on the U.S.
ved as a pres
ved as a keyn
ed as a keynoEL
s participatedat the 2nd Ann
n invited speaGN) in SantiagEnergy and vects for LNG e
s participatedn Houston, T
d CEE work at
e on prospect
ressed the Me
oke at the Gas
ented to the
ted on US natum on Energy
2
ellus shale eco
eakfast keyno
ate in an EIA w
nomics at the of the Bureau
annual joint fociation, the l Association apter of World
natural gas m
enter for the
ote presente
te speaker at
d in a panel dinual North Am
aker at a confgo, Chile on Avarious compaexports.
d on a panel fTexas
t the UT/BEG
ts for energy
exican chapte
s and Power C
Ernst & Youn
tural gas expoy & the Enviro
onomics as p
ote at URTeC
workshop on
IEAGHG Sum.
forum, "The TMexican Assofor Energy Ecd Energy Cou
market dynam
Hart Energy/
er at the annu
t the 2014 Sp
iscussion on “merican Mids
ference organApril 29. In adanies from th
or energy out
Industry Day
reform in Me
er of the Wor
Conference in
ng energy par
ort potential onment in Po
art of the BEG
C in Denver.
modeling.
mmer School h
Transformatioociation for Economics, theuncil, in Acapu
mics at the Ho
/Oil & Gas Inv
ual Flame gas
ring Managem
“Rail vs Pipe: stream Infras
nized by the Nddition, durinhe natural gas
tlook as part
y in Austin.
exico at the M
rld Energy Co
n Mexico City
rtners annual
at Jackson Scort of Spain, T
G team on sh
hosted by UT
on of the MeEnergy e Mexican ulco.
ouston lunche
vestor Energy
conference i
ment, Engine
Is crude‐by‐rstructure Fina
Natural Gas g his visit, Drs industry on
of the “Impa
Manhattan
uncil.
y, MX.
meeting.
chool of Trinidad & To
ale
‐
xican
eon
y
n
eering
rail a ance
. U.S.
ct of
bago.
February Internatio
February
February Ian Dunca
February Pacific reg
January 3TransactioResourcesNegotiato
January 7Exporters
January 3Internatio
April 24, 2
June 13, 2
August 8, Capture, Uresearch. analysis; Son CCUS e
Decembe
UT‐ExotherPappa
Janua
March
April 6
May 6
May 2
June 3
July 9
26, 2014 – Dronal Energy A
25, 2014 ‐ Dr
18, 2014 ‐ Dran, BEG.
11, 2014 ‐ Drgion for the Ja
0, 2014 – Dr. ons conferens Law Sectionors (AIPN).
, 2014 – Dr. G Association i
, 2014 – Dr. Gonal Associati
2014 ‐ Think D
2014 ‐ 2nd M
2014 – CEE hUtilization an PresentationSue Hovorka economics.
r 3‐4 – Annua
xxonMobil Glowise (Dr. Micas, Cockrell Sc
ary 25‐27 – Fr
h 3‐5 – Freun
6‐10 – Freund
6‐8 (Leatherh
20‐22 – Freun
3‐5 – Freund,
‐11 – Freund
r. Michot FosAgency’s 2nd U
r. Michot Foss
r. Michot Foss
r. Michot Fossapan America
Michot Foss ce organized n of the State
Gülen was thein Turkey.
Gülen presenton for Energy
Day Event on
id‐Year Revie
hosted a workd Storage (CCns featured reon geoscienc
al Meeting, “P
CEE EXEC
obal Upstreamchot Foss; Dr.chool of Engi
eund, Michot
d, Gülen
d, Gülen
ead) – Freun
nd, Gülen
Michot Foss
, Michot Foss
s chaired theUnconvention
s was the key
s presented a
s spoke on pran Society of
delivered theby The UniveBar of Texas
e keynote spe
ted on shale gy Economics.
CEE INTER
Global Gas D
ew and Think
kshop on “TecCUS) and Expaesults from Be for storage
Paradigms Lo
CUTIVE ED
m Commercia Gülen; Dr. Brneering):
t Foss
d, Michot Fos
s
3
session on wal Gas Forum
ynote present
at the Clean F
ospects for NDallas/Fort W
e keynote addersity of Texas(OGERL) and
eaker at the S
gas economic
RNAL MEE
Demand and G
Day.
chnical and Banding CO2‐EEG's Gulf Coa; William Am
st??”, and Th
DUCATION
al Overview 1ritt Freund, M
ss
water usage am in Calgary.
ter at the 4th
racking Confe
North AmericaWorth.
dress at the Is School of La The Associat
Shale Gas Con
cs to the Turk
ETINGS
Gas Trade flow
Business RisksEOR in Texas ast Carbon Cebrose on We
hink Day.
AND TRAI
1 2014 sessionMcCombs Sch
nd hazards fo
Norwegian F
erence in Hou
an energy tra
nternational aw, the Oil, Gtion of Intern
nference orga
kish Chapter o
ws.
s Associated wand Beyond”enter: Ian Dunst Branch Fie
NING
ns, Houston uhool of Busine
or the
Finance Day e
uston, TX with
ade with the A
Upstream EnGas and Energational Petro
anized by the
of the
with Carbon focused on Bncan on risk ld; Gürcan Gü
unless noted ess; Dr. Mike
event.
h Dr.
Asia‐
nergy gy oleum
Steel
BEG
ülen
July 2
Septe
Septe
Octob
April 3
Octob
Unive
Augus
Augus
Augus
ExtenEIG, F
AGA p
RBAC
Dr. MArgusKRCUgas pr
3‐25 – Freun
ember 16‐18 –
ember 23‐25 –
ber 7‐9 – Freu
30‐May 2, 20
ber 13‐15, 20
ersity of Ibada
st 7 & 9, 2014
st 28, Septem
st 5, Septemb
C
sive news covFuelFix and po
published an
incorporated
ichot Foss ans, Boston Glob Public Radiorices, and ene
d, Michot Fos
– Freund, Mic
– Pappas, Mic
und, Gülen
014 ‐ UT‐Petro
14 – UT‐CNO
an, Center for
4 – natural ga
mber 27, 2014
ber 9, 16, Nov
CEE CREDIT
verage of CEEossibly others
article on the
d regional gas
nd Dr. Gülen wbe, Energy M, Reuters, Fueergy geopolit
ss
chot Foss
chot Foss
obras Executiv
OC Senior Pla
r Petroleum E
as, Dr. Michot
4 – natural ga
vember 7, 201
TS AND AT
E’s industrial s, leading to i
e industrial ga
s demand imp
were quoted etro Desk, PlaelFix, and Turics among oth
4
ve Program (
anning Manag
Economics an
t Foss
s, Dr. Gülen
14 – electric p
TTRIBUTIO
sector gas denquiries from
as demand an
plications of t
in Bloombergatts, Fortune,rkish and Chilher topics.
Dr. Michot Fo
gers (Dr. Mich
nd Energy Law
power, Dr. Gü
ONS (HIGHL
emand analysm more than 2
nalysis in Ame
the analysis in
g, WSJ.com, A, NPR State Imean media on
oss)
hot Foss)
w sessions:
ülen
LIGHTS)
sis in Oil & Ga20 new entitie
erican Gas.
nto their gas
Austin Statesmmpact, Rigzonn shale devel
as Journal, SNes.
modeling.
man, Energy ne, EnergyWiopments, oil
L,
Risk, re, and