27
Butler University Digital Commons @ Butler University Undergraduate Honors esis Collection Undergraduate Scholarship 5-10-2014 Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to Synthesize Z-Alkenes from Cyclic Boronic Half-Acids Daniel Lee French Butler University Follow this and additional works at: hp://digitalcommons.butler.edu/ugtheses Part of the Chemistry Commons is esis is brought to you for free and open access by the Undergraduate Scholarship at Digital Commons @ Butler University. It has been accepted for inclusion in Undergraduate Honors esis Collection by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons @ Butler University. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Recommended Citation French, Daniel Lee, "Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to Synthesize Z-Alkenes from Cyclic Boronic Half-Acids" (2014). Undergraduate Honors esis Collection. Paper 205.

Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to Synthesize Z-Alkenes ... · reverse istrue for Z-alkenes. Image courtesy of science.uvu.edu. Two conformations of alkenes, E(trans) and Z(cis),

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to Synthesize Z-Alkenes ... · reverse istrue for Z-alkenes. Image courtesy of science.uvu.edu. Two conformations of alkenes, E(trans) and Z(cis),

Butler UniversityDigital Commons @ Butler University

Undergraduate Honors Thesis Collection Undergraduate Scholarship

5-10-2014

Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to SynthesizeZ-Alkenes from Cyclic Boronic Half-AcidsDaniel Lee FrenchButler University

Follow this and additional works at: http://digitalcommons.butler.edu/ugtheses

Part of the Chemistry Commons

This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Undergraduate Scholarship at Digital Commons @ Butler University. It has been acceptedfor inclusion in Undergraduate Honors Thesis Collection by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons @ Butler University. For moreinformation, please contact [email protected].

Recommended CitationFrench, Daniel Lee, "Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to Synthesize Z-Alkenes from Cyclic Boronic Half-Acids" (2014).Undergraduate Honors Thesis Collection. Paper 205.

Page 2: Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to Synthesize Z-Alkenes ... · reverse istrue for Z-alkenes. Image courtesy of science.uvu.edu. Two conformations of alkenes, E(trans) and Z(cis),

BUTLER UNIVERSITY HONORS PROGRAM

Honors Thesis Certification

Please type all information in this section:

Applicant Daniel Lee French(Name as it is to appear on diploma)

Thesis title Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to Synthesize Z:

Alkenes from Cyclic Boronic Half-Acids

Intended date of commencement May 10, 2014--~--~-----------------------

Read, approved, and signed by:

Thesis adViSer(S)('~ -y\;Lb\JU=3LuAnne McNultv :tI;~~CV) 0/(:Reader(s) \

Stacy O'ReillyDate

Certified by ~l'rL~~Director, Honors Program Date

For Honors Program use:

Level of Honors conferred: University

Departmental

Page 3: Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to Synthesize Z-Alkenes ... · reverse istrue for Z-alkenes. Image courtesy of science.uvu.edu. Two conformations of alkenes, E(trans) and Z(cis),

Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to Synthesize Z-Alkenes from Cyclic Boronic Half-Acids

A Thesis

Presented to the Department of Chemistry

College of Liberal Arts and Sciences

And

The Honors Program

Of

Butler University

In Partial Fulfillment

of Requirements for Graduation Honors.

Daniel Lee French

27 April 2014

Page 4: Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to Synthesize Z-Alkenes ... · reverse istrue for Z-alkenes. Image courtesy of science.uvu.edu. Two conformations of alkenes, E(trans) and Z(cis),

CBHA

THF

Batho.

KOtBu

Ni(CODb

2-IPr

S-BuOH

[HP(tBubMejBF4

Pd(OAcb

I-Bu-2MePr

NMR

6-Br-l-hexanol

List of Abbreviations

Cyclic Boronic Half-Acid

Tetrahydrofuran

Bathophenanthroline

Potassium Tert-butoxide

Bis(l,S-cyclooctadiene) nickel(O)

2-lodopropane

s-butanol

Di-tert-butyl(methyl)phosphoniumtetrafluoroborate

Palladium (II) Acetate

I-butyl-2-methylpropane

Nuclear Magnetic Resonance

6-bromo-l-hexanol

Dicloro l,l'-bis( diphenylphosphino )ferrocene pa Iladium( II)

Dicloro(l,S-cyciooctadiene) palladium (II)

Horner-Wadsworth-Emmons Reaction

racemic-2,2' -Bis(diphenylphosphino )-l,l'-binaphthyl

PdCI2(DPPF)

Pd(COD)

HWE

BINAP

2

Page 5: Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to Synthesize Z-Alkenes ... · reverse istrue for Z-alkenes. Image courtesy of science.uvu.edu. Two conformations of alkenes, E(trans) and Z(cis),

-3

Abstract

Cis-Alkenes provide the basic structure and reactivity for a variety of compounds, from the

common chemicals found in any organic laboratory to advanced drugs used to treat cancer or

suppress the immune system (Littke & Fu, 2002). Synthetically, alkenes are also of use in that

they serve as a site for further chemistry. Historically, Z-alkenes have been more difficult to

synthesize than their E-counterparts (McNulty et al., 2010; Siau, Zhang, & Zhao, 2012).

Furthermore, in many reactions, a mixture of E- and Z- conformations of the alkene is produced.

Such differences may seem trivial upon first inspection, but because there can be no rotation

around the alkene bond, a change in conformation can drastically change the functionality of

the molecule. There have been many efforts to force the synthesis of the Z-alkene, revealing

that various coupling reactions are adept at forcing a desired conformation (Siau et al., 2012).

The Suzuki-Miyaura coupling is one such reaction. The Suzuki-Miyaura coupling is also desirable

for the non-toxicity of the reaction conditions and ease of synthesizing the starting materials

(Siau et al., 2012). To date, the efficacy of Suzuki-Miyaura couplings with alkyl halides has been

demonstrated with reported good yields (Littke, Dai, & Fu, 2000; Siau et aI., 2012). The

feasibility of forcing the z-conformation by using a cyclic alkene as the substrate for the reaction

was investigated. To test this possibility, a cyclic boronic half-acid (CBHA) was reacted with

various alkyl halides under differing conditions. HNMR was used for analysis. The reaction,

though offering only the Z-conformation of the desired product, produced a mixture of other

products. Finally, the mechanism of the reaction was explored.

Page 6: Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to Synthesize Z-Alkenes ... · reverse istrue for Z-alkenes. Image courtesy of science.uvu.edu. Two conformations of alkenes, E(trans) and Z(cis),

4

Introduction

Many aspects of chemistry, material science, and pharmacology depend on the synthesis of new

chemical compounds, or developing synthetic pathways to some natural product. One

functional group that dictates much of a compound's reactivity is the alkene, or carbon-carbon

double bond. Alkenes, or olefins, contribute to a static nature in molecules, meaning that they

hold the molecule in a particular arrangement around the double bond. Alkenes are crucial in

certain biological molecules (Siau et al., 2012), such as fatty acids and proteins, and other

natural products, including rubber. Furthermore, alkenes are useful in organic synthesis in that

they are much more reactive than the alkane counterpart in many regards (Siau et al., 2012).

L

Figure 1. E- vs. Z: alkenes. Note that Ealkenes have major substituents on opposite sides of the double bond. The

reverse is true for Z-alkenes. Image courtesy of science.uvu.edu.

Two conformations of alkenes, E (trans) and Z (cis), exist: Figure 1. The conformation of the

alkene dictates the chemistry that the molecule will perform. Historically, synthesis of E-alkenes

has been more developed than of the Z form of the alkene (McNulty et al., 2010; Siau et al.,

2012). Despite this difficulty, Z-alkenes have many uses biologically and synthetically, including

in the synthesis of certain drugs (Littke & Fu, 2002). As an example, Z-alkenes are one functional

component of a potent tumor inhibitor, (+)-discodermolide (Siau et al., 2012). Synthetically, Z-

alkenes also hold the molecule in a conformation that is conducive to ring formation, as seen

below.

Page 7: Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to Synthesize Z-Alkenes ... · reverse istrue for Z-alkenes. Image courtesy of science.uvu.edu. Two conformations of alkenes, E(trans) and Z(cis),

5

R'oFigure 2. Cis- vs. Trans-alkene in pseudo-cyclical structure. Demonstrates the <1bility of the Z-alkene to form cyclic

structures.

1.1 Methods for Alkene synthesis

The focus of this work was to develop new methods that efficiently force the Z-conformation of

an alkene. There are a variety of modern reactions known that are commonly used to

synthesize alkenes, each with their own advantages and disadvantages. Provided below is a

brief introduction into some of these methods, along with an explanation as to why the Suzuki-

Miyaura reaction was ultimately chosen to explore the selective synthesis of Z-alkenes.

1.1.1 Lindlar Reduction

Catalyst

Lindlar'sR--="....::'---R·

The Lindlar reduction reduces an alkyne (carbon-carbon triple bond) to an alkene using a

heterogeneous catalyst composed of metals and salts (Siau et al., 2012). Typically, an alkyne is

added for new carbon-carbon bond formation. Once in place, the new bond is reduced to

produce the desired alkene. Though this method produces Z-alkenes exclusively in good yield,

the heterogeneouS nature of the catalyst is such that it is difficult to control the reaction (Siau et

aL,2012). If too little catalyst is added, the reaction does not run to completion. Conversely, if

too much is added, there is over-reduction of the triple bond and an alkane is produced rather

than an alkene. Furthermore, this reaction requires a toxic catalyst containing lead, which is less

desirable for use in the manufacture of drugs (Siau et al., 2012).

Page 8: Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to Synthesize Z-Alkenes ... · reverse istrue for Z-alkenes. Image courtesy of science.uvu.edu. Two conformations of alkenes, E(trans) and Z(cis),

-6

1.1.2 Wittig Reaction

The Wittig reaction involves the reaction between a carbonyl with a phosphorous ylide to

produce an alkene. Though the Z-alkene can be produced, there have been a limited number of

substrates that are able to produce the Z-conformation exclusively. The E-alkene has been

found to be the predominant product in those cases. Furthermore, the reaction produces

extensive waste (Siau et aI., 2012). Because we desire to study the effectiveness of the CBHA in

alkene synthesis, and because the Wittig has historically been sub-optimal for the synthesis of Z-

alkenes other methods are required.,

1.1.3 Horner-Wadsworth-Emmons Reaction (HWE)

o 0II II

EtO-P~Etc) OEt

The Horner_Wadsworth-Emmons Reaction was developed as a modification of the Wittig

reaction that is easier to conduct and allows for a greater variety of substrates. However, as it is

a modification of the Wittig, the E-conformation of the produced alkene is still favored under

normal conditions (Siau et aI., 2012). Alternative conditions have been developed, however,

that allow for the stereoselectivity desired of our reaction (Ando, 1998). Furthermore, even

when the z_conformation is favored, it is not forced, and the reaction therefore produces a

mixture of the E- and Z-conformations.

1.1.4 Still-Gennari Reaction

Page 9: Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to Synthesize Z-Alkenes ... · reverse istrue for Z-alkenes. Image courtesy of science.uvu.edu. Two conformations of alkenes, E(trans) and Z(cis),

7

(Zl-Selective

Stilt W.C. and Gennarl, C. Tetrahedron Letters, 1983. 24. 4405

THF, low' temp.RCHO

R 0

UOrM

KHMDS, 18-crown-6

Further modification of the HWE was undertaken by Still and Gennari (Siau et aI., 2012). The

modifications allowed for the synthesis of Z-alkenes using organo-tin reagents (Littke & Fu,

2002). The reaction proceeds under even more mild conditions than the HWE, as the process is

found to be conserved throughout the reaction, which will lead to the Z-conformation of the

stable to air and moisture. This process was used to produce rapamycin, an

immunosuppressant, and dynemicin, a tumor suppressant (Littke & Fu, 2002). Though upon

first inspection the reaction appears favorable, organo-tin reagents are toxic (Littke & Fu, 2002).

1.1.5 Negishi Coupling

Because a majority of the previous reactions produce both isomers, coupling reactions were

explored to produce Z-alkenes exclusively. Coupling reactions have been typically identified by

the attachment of two hydrocarbon compounds using a metal catalyst (JACS). Coupling

reactions preserve existing stereochemistry, which can be established before the metal

mediated coupling (McNulty et aI., 2010; Siau et al., 2012). One example of a coupling reaction

is the Negishi coupling, which uses organo-zinc compounds and a palladium catalyst to assist the

formation of the z-alkenes (Littke & Fu, 2002). In alkenyl Negishi coupling, a trans-alkenylhalide

is required. As such, there can still be significant difficulty of synthesizing the required alkene.

1.1.6 Suzuki-Miyarua Coupling

The Suzuki-Miyaura coupling was developed in the mid-1970's and has been used extensively

throughout the past 40 years. The reaction proceeds by reacting "highly electrophilic boronic

compounds with alkyl halides" (Miyaura & Suzuki, 1995). Double bond geometry has been

Page 10: Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to Synthesize Z-Alkenes ... · reverse istrue for Z-alkenes. Image courtesy of science.uvu.edu. Two conformations of alkenes, E(trans) and Z(cis),

8

alkene, provided the desired conformation was in place prior to the coupling. The process is

catalyzed by a homogeneous palladium catalyst in the following steps: oxidative addition,

transmetalation, reductive elimination (see figure 3). Oxidative addition, the addition of the

alkyl halide to the PdQspecies, is commonly the rate-limiting step of the process with iodides

being more reactive than triflates, which in turn are more reactive than bromides, which are

much more reactive than chlorides (Littke et aI., 2000; Miyaura & Suzuki, 1995). Modifications

of the process have been expanded upon in recent years to extend this reaction to aryl

chlorides, which previously have been unreactive (Fu, 2008; Littke & Fu, 2002). Fu further

developed this work and described in depth the relationship between substrate, ligand, and

catalyst to provide the most reactive conditions, some of which were further explored in this

work (Littke & Fu, 2002).

R,-R) ~R/-X9 2Pd" _Reductiv~ / 1 OxidativeElimination ( Addition

,~::~-O""-"'=Z "7- N.O',"

; Transrnetalation \,--r~'-O""l, Na0 Y NaXh, NaO'Bu E> I~ --- ... R,-B-O'Bu

y' 'y ~5 6

Figl,.lre3. Catalytic cycle for the Suwki-!V1iyaura reaction. Adopted from Wikipedia.

As mentioned before, the Suzuki-Miyaura catalytic cycle can be separated into three steps:

oxidative addition, transmetallation, and reductive elimination. In the oxidative addition, the

alkyl halide, R2X, is added to the metal, forming a halide and alkyl ligand on the catalyst and

oxidizing the metal center from a PdQspecies to a Pd2+ species. The complex then undergoes

Page 11: Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to Synthesize Z-Alkenes ... · reverse istrue for Z-alkenes. Image courtesy of science.uvu.edu. Two conformations of alkenes, E(trans) and Z(cis),

9

transmetallation, in which ligands on different metal centers are exchanged. In this case, the R-

group on the boron complex is exchanged with the halide ligand on the palladium catalyst. In

the final step, reductive elimination, a bond is created between the R-groups to form the final

product and the PdQcatalyst is reformed (Cross Coupling Reactions).

The Suzuki-Miyaura coupling is convenient for a number of reasons. All of the reagents are easy

to synthesize or purchase, compared to some of the reactions discussed previously.

Organoboronic compounds are also stable in the presence oxygen and water, are temperature

stable, yet still react under mild conditions, and yield non-toxic byproducts (Littke et aI., 2000;

Littke & Fu, 2002; Miyaura & Suzuki, 1995). Extensive research had been done on the reaction,

illustrating that under a variety of conditions, the reaction produces good yields with a variety of

substrates.

1.2 Project FocUS

Though extensive research has been done on the Suzuki-Miyaura reaction in general, no reports

were found investigating the ability of the reaction to force isolated Z-alkenes using cyclic

boronic half-acids. Boronic half-acids are relatively easy to synthesize and the final product

contains a hydroxyl group on the homoallylic carbon, which is not only common to natural

products, but alloWS for further chemistry to be done at that site (McNulty et aI., 2010).

Optimization of conditions for the starting material catalyst with CBHA would allow for the use

of a new, powerful tool in synthetic chemistry.

Susuki-Miyauro reactions of cyclic boronic half-acids can be utilized to force the production of Z.

alkenes, producing a new compound with an alcohol on the homoa/lylic carbon. The

optimization of reaction conditions will provide a powerful tool for organic chemists for the

synthesis of Z-alkenes.

Page 12: Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to Synthesize Z-Alkenes ... · reverse istrue for Z-alkenes. Image courtesy of science.uvu.edu. Two conformations of alkenes, E(trans) and Z(cis),

..10

Results and Discussion

A series of experiments was performed demonstrating the ability to form the desired Z-alkenes

with the Suzuki-Miyaura reaction.

2.1 Suzuki Coupling

A variety of conditions were used to evaluate the efficacy of the Suzuki-Miyaura reaction. Work

was divided into three sub-categories based on the over-all goal of each section. To begin,

literature-published reaction conditions were tried to see if the reaction would work with our

modified starting material (Reports in the literature call for a true boronic acid, whereas we

utilized a cyclic boronic half-acid, Figure 4). Secondly, the reaction was performed in a

microwave, both for convenience and to show that the reaction could be accelerated, which

may be of benefit in various industrial applications. Finally, an extended reaction was

performed to provide information on the mechanism by which this reaction may occur.

OH

IB

HO/ ~R

Figure 4. Boronic t1<llfacid (left) vs. True Boronic Acid (Right).

2.2.1 Original Reaction Conditions

OH

+ RX

R

Page 13: Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to Synthesize Z-Alkenes ... · reverse istrue for Z-alkenes. Image courtesy of science.uvu.edu. Two conformations of alkenes, E(trans) and Z(cis),

--11

Literature conditions were first tried with the new electraphile (CBHA) in order to determine

whether or not this substrate would participate in the Suzuki-Miyaura reaction. Six trials were

run, Table 1.

Table 1. Re.action cond'itions as adopted from Fu, et al. Ratios of desired alkene to proteo-product also given.Some reactions were found to have starting materia' remaining (") and some produced a substituted dihydrofuran

nAlkyl Reaction

Reaction LigandBase Catalyst CBHA Halide Solvent Pre-Stir Temperature Time Product.Protec

1 Barbo.KOtBu Ni(COD)2 1 eq z-tcr S-BuOH 60C overnight '1:2

2 Bathe. KOtBu Ni(COD)2 1 eq z-tcr S-BuOH 25 min. 75C overnight 1:2

r-ec-z-(HP(tBu)2Me]BF4 KOtBu Pd(Oac)2 1.5 eq MePr S-BuOH Room overnight +1:2

3

[HP(tBu)2Me]BF4 KOtBu Pd(Oac)2 1.5 eq 2-lpr S-BuOH Room 24 Hr ·'1:1.54

(HP(tBu)2Me]BF4KOtBu Pd(Oac)2 1.5 eq z-rcr S-BuOH Room 24 Hr ·'1:1.5

5 i-sc-z over

[HP(tBu)2Me]BF4 KOtBu Pd(Oac)2 1.5 eq MePr S-BuOH Room weekend 1:0.'/5

6

In all cases, a mixture of products was observed. The mixture included the desired coupling

product and a product here refered to as prateo-product. The proteo-product is the same

chemical as that which was used as the alcohol starting material used to synthesize the CBHA.

In many cases, however, a third product, a substituted dihydrofuran, was observed in the

reaction mixture. The CBHA starting material was also present in some reactions.

Page 14: Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to Synthesize Z-Alkenes ... · reverse istrue for Z-alkenes. Image courtesy of science.uvu.edu. Two conformations of alkenes, E(trans) and Z(cis),

12

OHOH

R

nR

F. 4 P . ant n10iendes observed in reaction mixture: Desired Product (Top Left), Proteo-Product (TopIgure . ror11ln< -Right), Starting CBHA (Bottom Left), and the byproduct (Bottom Right).

Reactions 1 through 3 generated a mixture of desired Z-alkene and proteo species in a 1:2 ratio,

favoring the proteo-product. Starting material was also present in these three reactions.

Reaction 4 generated the same mixture, but the ratio was slightly improved to favor the Z-

alkene 1:1.5. Reactions 5 and 6 yielded more of the desired product, as they produced ratios of

1:1 and 1:0.75, respectively. However, the dihydrofuran product was also observed in reaction

5.

As can be seen from Figure 5 the desired product and proteo were similar in structure, and

therefore in chemical properties. As such, it was nearly impossible to separate the two from

each other. Separation was attempted using various conditions using chromatography. Two

solid phases were tested, silica and alumina. It was found that alumina was particularly well

suited to removing excess starting material and the dihydrofuran product. However, alumina

did not affect the separation between the product of interest and the proteo-product. Various

elution conditions were tested with both solid phases, and a solution of 1% methanol in

dichloromethane was found to be optimal. With the correct drip rate, it was sometimes

Page 15: Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to Synthesize Z-Alkenes ... · reverse istrue for Z-alkenes. Image courtesy of science.uvu.edu. Two conformations of alkenes, E(trans) and Z(cis),

-13

"pure" product. However, this required the formation of extremely smallpossible to get a

roducible, and did not yield enough product to successfully quantify. Inpartitions, was not rep

. . ld NMR integrations were used to approximate the yield ratios. This method oflieu of true Yle s,

t be entirely accurate, however, as some of the principle regions forquantization may no

detection overlap.

2.2.2 Microwave Series

.' c of those reactions run in the microwave. In some reactions startina material remained. ti conditiOn, o .

Table 2. Reac IOn (*) and in some, dihydrofuran product was formed n·

Catalyst CaHA Alkyl Halide Solvent Pre-Stir Temperature Reaction Time Product: ProteoBase

Reaction H Ligand

KOtBu Pd(O.c)2 1.5 eq I-Bu-2-MePr S-BuOH 35C 30 min. NA

7 [HP(tBU)2Me]BF4

KOtBu Pd(Oac)2 1.5 eq I-Bu-2-MePr S-BuOH overnight 35C 30 min. "1:1.2

8 [HP(tBU)2Me]BF4

KOtBu Pd(O.c)2 1.5 eq I-Bu-2-MePr S-BuOH 45C 45 min. ·'1:0.75

9 [HP(tBU)2Me]BF4

KOtBu Pd(Oac)2 1.5 eq I-Bu-2-MePr S·BuOH 35C 30min. ·'1:1

10 [HP(tBU)2Me]BF4

KOtBu Pd(O.c)2 1.5 eq I-Bu-2-MePr S-BuOH 35C 90 min. NA

11 [HP(tBu)2Me]BF4

KOtBu Pd(O.c)2 1.5 eq I-Bu-2-MePr S·BuOH 3SC 15 min. ·1:3

12 [HP(tBU)2Me]BF4

KOtBu Pd(O.c)2 1.5 eq 6-Br-l-hexanol $-8uOH 3SC 30 min. ·'1:!

13 [HP(tBU)2Me]BF4

KOtBu Pd(Oac)2 1.5 eq 1-Bu-2-MePr $-BuOH 135 min 35C 30 min. ·1:1.16

14 [HP(tBu)2Me]BF4

KOtBu Pd(Oac)2 1.S eq 1~Bu~2-MePr THF 35C 30 min. NA

15 [HP(tBU)2Me]BF4

KOtBu PdCI2(DPPF) 1.5 ec 1-Bu-2-MePr THF 30 min 35C 30 min. NA

16

KOtBu PdCI2(DPPF) 1.5 eq I-Bu-2~MePr THF 30 min 30C 45 min NA

17

KOtBu 1.5 eq I-Bu-2-MePr THF 30 min 3SC 30 min. NA

18 BINAP

KOtBu Pd(Oac)2 1.5 eq 1·lbu THF 35C 30 min. NA

19 [HP(tBu)2Me]8f4

KOtBu PdCI2(DPPF) 1.5 eq l-Ibu THf 30 min 35C 30 min. ·1:1

20

KOtBu Pd(COD) 1.5 eq 1-lbu THF 35C 30 min. NA

21

(s2e03 PdCI2(DPPF) 1.5 eo l-Bu-2-MePr THF 35C 30 min. •• 1:1.5

22

Cs2C03 PdCI2(DPPF) 1.5 eq 1-Bu-2-MePr Toluene 35C 30min. NA23

Cs2(03 PdCI2(DPPF) 1.5 eq 2-lpr Toluene 35C 30 min. NA24

KOtBu PdCI2(DPPF) 1.5 eq 1-lbu THF lODC 30min. NA25,29-32

(52C03 Pd(PPh3)4 1.5 eq l_lbu THF 8SC 35 min. NA26

27CsF Pd(PPh3)4 1.5 eq j-tbu THF S5e 35 min. NA

28 [HP(tBu)2Me]BF4(52(03 Pd(O.c)2 1.S eq I-Bu-2-MePr THF 35C 30min. NA

Page 16: Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to Synthesize Z-Alkenes ... · reverse istrue for Z-alkenes. Image courtesy of science.uvu.edu. Two conformations of alkenes, E(trans) and Z(cis),

14

In general, it was determined that the reaction was sufficiently able to produce desired product

that it was worthwhile to examine a broader set of reaction conditions. To do so, the reaction

was moved to the microwave reactor in both an effort to save time and to demonstrate the

ability to accelerate the reaction using this method, which may be of benefit in certain industrial

situations. Reaction conditions for this class of reaction can be seen in Table 2.

As before, a mixture of products was generally observed. No ratio data was available for

reactions 7, 11, 15-19, 21, or 23-32 due to in vast quantity of starting material observed in the

final product. Because of the structure commonalities between the starting material and the

products, some of the regions overlapped in the NMR spectra, making yield based on

integration unreliable. Furthermore, reactions 8, 9, 12, 13, and 22 generated ratios at or above

1:2 Z-alkene to proteo-product, marking them as no better than as observed in the non-

microwaved reactions. Reactions 10, 14, and 20, however, yielded ratios of around 1:1.

Upon inspection of the reactions that yielded ratios of 1:1, there appeared to be little

correlation. A variety of alkyl halides and catalyst systems were used - leaving the relationship

between these reactions and the improved yield of the Z-alkenes in mystery.

In many of the reactions, there remained starting material, indicating that the reaction had not

gone to completion. However, upon further examination, it seems that the excess CBHA may be

an artifact of the method by which the samples were prepared for analysis. Typically, an aliquot

would be removed from a reaction mixture, solvent would be removed via rotary evaporation

and the remaining material would be dissolved in deuterated chloroform for NMR. In one

instance, it was noted that when the NMR were performed in deuterated benzene, there

appeared to be no CBHA remaining. Another sample from the same source was processed as

previously described and NMR analysis revealed the presence of CBHA. As of now, it is not

Page 17: Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to Synthesize Z-Alkenes ... · reverse istrue for Z-alkenes. Image courtesy of science.uvu.edu. Two conformations of alkenes, E(trans) and Z(cis),

15

known whether the drying vessel was contaminated with CBHA hor wether the act of heating

the reaction mixture re-formed the CBHA. If tht . hIS IS t e case, however, yields may be higher than

initially observed.

In addition to the desired Z-alkene and the proteo-product a third by d t f ., pro uc 0 the reaction

was observed. Through analysis via HNMR and CNMR it was determined that thO b, IS yproduct

was a substituted cyclical alkenylether, previously described as the dihydrofura likn- I e product. If

oxidative addition is the rate limiting step, it is possible for the CBHA to undergo the

transmetallation process before the oxidative addition of the alkyl halide. The alkenylether

product may be generated from this alternative catalytic process.

2.2.3 Extended Reaction

To elucidate the mechanism by which this reaction proceeds, and therefore identify a method

by which it may be improved, a reaction was run without heating over the course of one or two

days. The reaction was prepared as with the original conditions described by Fu. Reaction

samples were collected every one to two hours. oeuterated benzene was added to the crude

reaction sample and NMR's were obtained.

The mechanistic experiment yielded little to no Z-alkene while forming the proteo-product and

the dihydrofuran product. No starting material remained. The lack of desired product formed

under these conditions was interesting in that it may reveal that under the current conditions,

we may fail to generate the active Pd' catalyst. As described above, this may be the result of

the sluggishness of the oxidative addition step. If the transmetallation step is possible before

the addition of the alkyl halide to the Pd' through oxidative addition, then it may be possible for

the side reaction to occur and the oxidative addition of the alkyl halide does not occur. This

effect, however, is not thought to contribute to the generation of the proteo-product, as the

Page 18: Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to Synthesize Z-Alkenes ... · reverse istrue for Z-alkenes. Image courtesy of science.uvu.edu. Two conformations of alkenes, E(trans) and Z(cis),

16 lsynthesis of proteo-product occurs without the generation of the dihydrofuran product in some

cases.

Experimental

3.1 Production of CyclicBoronic Half-Acid tCBHA)

Procedures adopted from McNulty, 2010.

To a round-bottom flask charged with 100 mL tetrahydrofuran tTHF)was added 5 g t47.11

mmol) benzaldehyde under nitrogen. Allyl-magnesium bromide t51.81 mmol, 51.81 mL 1 M

solution) was slowly added to the flask. The reaction was stirred at O°cfor one hour, then

allowed to warm to room temperature. The reaction was stirred for one week, following which

diethyl ether was added to dilute the product. Hydrochloric acid tl0%, 70.0 mL) was added to

quench the reaction. Product was extracted with 4 portions of 50 mL diethyl Ether. The alcohol

product was separated, dried, concentrated, and subjected to NMR to verify the product before

continuing to the next step.

To a round bottom flask charged with dichloromethane was added 2g t13.5 mmol) of the

alcohol and 1.16g t13.5 mmol) cis-l-propen-l-yl boronic acid. The flask was degassed and the

vessel was stirred for one hour, after which was added Grubbs catalyst tlst generation). The

contents were degassed a second time. The reaction was heated to reflux and stirred for one

day. After refluxing, the solution was cooled to room temperature, concentrated via rotary

evaporation and purified using flash column chromatography, yielding the cyclic boronic half-

acid.

Page 19: Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to Synthesize Z-Alkenes ... · reverse istrue for Z-alkenes. Image courtesy of science.uvu.edu. Two conformations of alkenes, E(trans) and Z(cis),

-17

3.2 Suzuki Coupling

3.2.1 Original Reaction Conditions

Original procedures adopted from Fu (Kirchhoff, Netherton, Hills, & Fu, 2002).

To a schlenk vial was added a stir bar and ligand (100 m.eq), Base (4/3 eq.), and Catalyst (50

m.eq), were added to the vessel, capping and evacuating the flask between each addition.

Following the final addition of the catalyst, the flask was evacuated and filled with argon twice.

In a separate, flame-dried rbf was added anhydrous solvent and the cyclic-boronic half acid (1.5

eq). This solution was added to the schlenk vial. After pre-stirring (when applicable), the alkyl

halide (1 eq) was added. The contents were vigorously stirred.

3.2.2 Microwave Series

To a dry microwave vial was added a stir-bar and CBHA in ether solution. The vial was capped

and evacuated to remove ether. Base, catalyst, and ligand (if separate from the catalyst) were

added to the vessel according to table 2. The vial was then subjected to three repetitions of

evacuation and flushing with argon. Solvent was added via syringe. After a period of pre-

stirring (when applicable), the alkyl halide was added. The vial was subjected to heating using a

CEM Discover Labmate.

2.2.3 Extended Reaction

A schlenk vial was prepared in the same manner as the microwave vials of the previous sub-

category. The reaction was stirred vigorously for an extended period of time. Aliquots (0.5 mL)

were removed throughout the course of the reaction. Samples were filtered through cotton and

added to 0.2 mL benzene d-f in an NMR tube. Samples were centrifuged for 4S seconds and

frozen at _80°C until subjected to NMR analysis, before which each sample was thawed.

Page 20: Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to Synthesize Z-Alkenes ... · reverse istrue for Z-alkenes. Image courtesy of science.uvu.edu. Two conformations of alkenes, E(trans) and Z(cis),

18

Conclusion

The application of the Suzuki-Miyaura reaction was shown to be capable of producing the Z-

conformation of an alkene. In spite of this accomplishment, however, the product was not pure.

A proteo-alkene and a dihydrofuran product were frequently observed in the reaction mixture.

It is thought that these products are the result of an inability of the system to generate the

active catalyst PdQ,either through bypassing the oxidative addition phase of the reaction or by

some other means.

There is still much to be done towards the optimization of this reaction to give high yields. First

needs to be developed a system capable of purifying the desired product from the proteo-

product in order to record accurate yields. The optimization of the reaction with respect to our

desired starting material will be minimal. Provided that a purification method can be produced,

reaction conditions must be optimized to be able to maximally produce the desired product. A

mechanistic understanding of the reaction may aid in this endeavor.

Page 21: Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to Synthesize Z-Alkenes ... · reverse istrue for Z-alkenes. Image courtesy of science.uvu.edu. Two conformations of alkenes, E(trans) and Z(cis),

19

Reference

Ando, K. (1998). Z-Selective Horner-Wadsworth-Emmons Reaction of alpha-SubstitutedEthyl(Diarylphosphono)acetates with Aldehydes. J. Org. Chem., 63,8411-8416.

Fu, G. C. (2008). The development of versatile methods for palladium-catalyzed couplingreactions of aryl electrophiles through the use of P(t-Bu)3 and PCy3as ligands.[Research Support, N.I.H., Extramural

Research Support, Non-U.S. Gov't]. Acc Chem Res, 41(11), 1555-1564. doi: 10.1021/ar800148fKirchhoff, J. H., Netherton, M. R., Hills, I. D., &.FU, G..c. (2002). Boronic Acids: New Coupling

Partners in Room-Temperature Suzuki Reactions of Alkyl Bromides. CrystallographicCharacterization of an Oxidative-Addition Adduct Generated under Remarkably MildConditions. Journal of the American Chemical Society, 124(46), 13662-13663. doi:10.1021/ja0283899

Littke, A. F., Dai, c., & Fu,G. C. (2000). Versatile Catalysts for the Suzuki Cross-Coupling ofArylboronic Acids with Aryl and Vinyl Halides and Triflates under Mild Conditions.Journal of the American Chemical Society, 122(17), 4020-4028. doi: 1O.l021/ja0002058

Littke, A. F., & Fu, G. C. (2002). Palladium-Catalyzed Coupling Reactions of Aryl Chlorides.Angewandte Chemie International Edition, 41(22),4176-4211. doi: 10.1002/1521-3773(20021115 )41:22<4176::aid-anie4176>3.0.co;2-u

McNulty, L., Kohlbacher, K., Borin, K., Dodd, B., Bishop, 1., Fuller, L., & Wright, Z. (2010). CyclicAlkenyl Boronic Half Acid Synthesis and Applications. J Org Chern, 75(17),6001-6004.doi: 10.1021/jol003423

Miyaura, N., & Suzuki, A. (1995). Palladium-Catalyzed Cross-C?upling Reactions of OrganoboronCompounds. Chemical Reviews, 95(7), 2457-2483. dol: 10.1021/cr00039a007

Siau, W.-Y., Zhang, Y., & Zhao, Y. (2012). Stereoselective Synthesis of Z-Alkenes. In 1.Wang (Ed.),Stereoselective Alkene Synthesis (Vol. 327, pp. 33-58): Springer Berlin Heidelberg.

Page 22: Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to Synthesize Z-Alkenes ... · reverse istrue for Z-alkenes. Image courtesy of science.uvu.edu. Two conformations of alkenes, E(trans) and Z(cis),

o

o

o

-20

2 5

-,.:--

Page 23: Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to Synthesize Z-Alkenes ... · reverse istrue for Z-alkenes. Image courtesy of science.uvu.edu. Two conformations of alkenes, E(trans) and Z(cis),

o

Figure 6. Z-<'tlkenE'

<I [ "106]

..21

Page 24: Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to Synthesize Z-Alkenes ... · reverse istrue for Z-alkenes. Image courtesy of science.uvu.edu. Two conformations of alkenes, E(trans) and Z(cis),

o 2 43

-"N

I 31.~511 ,,----.I

I4.7\11""·~

Q') _I (

f13~.ioJ ._. ---~- --------------.-.- ..

I4.9183'" '

0.433206~87

I

1'1.22y5'-C~(

23.31141 ._

12~72

OGf6iI

o7.4J 20·---~ ..· .........-... ---.-.-- ....-- ..- ...- .....----

II

Figure 'I. Substituted Dihvdrofuran

5 6 [ '1e6j

r';

;::/

'6

-,7.3735 fJ7.3565 c.

I 7.3339 0

I 7.3167 "\. 7.3011 ~j7.2826 ":1

7.262B ,I,I6.4296 /

6.3933

5.54215.50445.3037 "

4.75541:1

"4.7453

2.71382.68302.64972.61751.97371.96261.9512-1.5755

0.0000

22

Page 25: Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to Synthesize Z-Alkenes ... · reverse istrue for Z-alkenes. Image courtesy of science.uvu.edu. Two conformations of alkenes, E(trans) and Z(cis),

"""0-"

CXl-

N

o

Figure 8. Proteo-Product.

r 7.3711

it:5~g~..~42Q--- 02963 ~2783 11

7.2597 ~...../"

'"af--'f

5.83.25·5.80375.763'1'j 5.21015.20515.1738

--5.1351! 4.7719\'- 4.7494\4.7428- 4.7204

{

f ~:~1~~2.52672.52202.51742.5"1452.5015

"\l2.4840\. 2.0537

- 0.0000

-23

I~

,o

of-'Po

Page 26: Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to Synthesize Z-Alkenes ... · reverse istrue for Z-alkenes. Image courtesy of science.uvu.edu. Two conformations of alkenes, E(trans) and Z(cis),

....o

co

_- (\

C~,(

?~"!;;.

---:.

... "l;_;;.

2 4 6

--24

[ '1e6]-)

~.r

:,'-,'.,

.~.

~;

n-.:,~,I,:"','

;::-." n

:~"C'

_.:...f>.,._-' ( _.._..

/

(

(

",-

!/I

('

('r(

i!,I

l

Figure 9. Extended He;)ction

Page 27: Suzuki-Miyaura Reactions Are Used to Synthesize Z-Alkenes ... · reverse istrue for Z-alkenes. Image courtesy of science.uvu.edu. Two conformations of alkenes, E(trans) and Z(cis),

o 2 3 4

...o

i"-----

{..,

-25

5 6 ['1e61

c"

!-r

., -----.-.=--:.:-- ...~~.- ...-.-.~ ....---

._~.o..:.~.':.'"~~;~--""-::~;::'::::_::_'::'':':':':':''

.~..."".- __ ' .,>71 , ".,. _ 1'1~,.,_,_.~~--

~~:::_'),~')~1-"~_'_' . ~':-":'-~~~------------"*"''''''''"'''''''':;.-~..;. ..- ..-....'z:'''.''''''."...- ...~ ,f

N

o /"({,

I

Figure 10. Extended Re;)ction Samples 5··8