Sr. II No. 18 · the Constitution of Rajiv Gandhi Kala Mandir, Ponda--Goa, the Government is pleased to appoint Shri Uday B. Dangui, Ponda-Goa as Vice-Chairman of Rajiv Gandhi Kala

777

GOVERNMENT OF GOADepartment of Education, Art & Culture

Directorate of Art & Culture__

Order

No. DAC/7/AUTOBODIES/COMITTIES/2012/2126

In exercise of powers conferred by Clause 5 ofthe Constitution of Rajiv Gandhi Kala Mandir, Ponda--Goa, the Government is pleased to appointShri Vishwas Satarkar, Priol, Ponda-Goa as Chairmanof Rajiv Gandhi Kala Mandir, Ponda-Goa withimmediate effect.

By order and in the name of the Governorof Goa.

Prasad Lolayekar, Director & ex officio Addl.Secretary (Art & Culture).

Panaji, 25th July, 2012.________

Order


In exercise of powers conferred by Clause 6 ofthe Constitution of Rajiv Gandhi Kala Mandir, Ponda--Goa, the Government is pleased to appointShri Uday B. Dangui, Ponda-Goa as Vice-Chairmanof Rajiv Gandhi Kala Mandir, Ponda-Goa withimmediate effect.



Panaji, 25th July, 2012.

Panaji, 2nd August, 2012 (Sravana 11, 1934) SERIES II No. 18

Reg. No. GR/RNP/GOA/32 RNI No. GOAENG/2002/6410

PUBLISHED BY AUTHORITY

Suggestions are welcome on e-mail: [email protected]

Order


In exercise of powers conferred by Clause 9(iv)of the Constitution of Rajiv Gandhi Kala Mandir,Ponda-Goa, the Government is pleased to nominateShri Rasik Parkar, Ponda-Goa as a member of RajivGandhi Kala Mandir, Ponda-Goa with immediateeffect.



Panaji, 25th July, 2012.________

Order


In exercise of powers conferred by Clause 4 (I) ofthe Constitution of Institute Menezes Braganza,Panaji-Goa, the Government is pleased to appointShri Sanjay Harmalkar, Kamurlim, Bardez-Goa asChairman of Institute Menezes Braganza, Panaji--Goa with immediate effect.



Panaji, 25th July, 2012.________

Order


In exercise of powers conferred by Clause 3(ix) ofthe Constitution of Institute Menezes Braganza,Panaji-Goa, the Government is pleased to nominatefollowing members for Institute Menezes Braganza,Panaji, Goa with immediate effect.

1. Shri Juino D’Souza, Porvorim, Goa.2. Shri Uday Naik, H. No. 157, Opp. Pharmacy

College, 18th June Road, Panaji, Goa.

Note:- There is one Extraordinary issue to the OfficialGazette, Series II No. 17 dated 26-07-2012 namely,Extraordinary dated 31-07-2012 from pages 775to 776 regarding Notification and Notices inForm-2 from Department of Elections (Goa StateElection Commission).

OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOASERIES II No. 18 2ND AUGUST, 2012

778

3. Shri Pundalik Raut Desai, Panaji, Goa.4. Shri Nikhil Varerkar, Goa.



Panaji, 25th July, 2012.________

Order


In exercise of powers conferred by Clause 6 (a)of the Constitution of Tiatr Academy, Panaji-Goa,the Government is pleased to appoint Shri PrinceJacob, Fatorda, Margao-Goa as Chairman of TiatrAcademy, Panaji-Goa with immediate effect.



Panaji, 25th July, 2012.________

Order


In exercise of powers conferred by Clause 10 (h)of the Constitution of Tiatr Academy, Panaji-Goa,the Government is pleased to nominate followingmembers on General Council of Tiatr Academy,Panaji-Goa with immediate effect.

1. Shri Joaquim M. Cruz, Shenvivaddo, Shiroda--Goa.

2. Shri Rosario Antonio Fernandes, (Rose Fern),Benaulim.

3. Shri William Fernandes, Bepquel, Curchorem.4. Shri Milagres De Chandor, Chandor, Salcete-

-Goa.5. Shri Jose Maria Mathias Ignatius Thomas

D’Souza, Goa.6. Shri Joe Rose, Olaulim, Pomburpa, Bardez-Goa.

9822272426.7. Shri Anthony Silvestor, Goa.8. Shri Francis Misquita, Talevaddo, Revora,

Bardez-Goa.9. Shri Agustin Timot, Dongurlim, Navelim,

Salcete-Goa.10. Shri Ramesh Komarpant, Chavdi, Canacona,

Goa.




Order


In exercise of powers conferred by clause 5 ofthe Constitution of Ravindra Bhavan, Margao--Goa, the Government is pleased to appointShri Damu Naik, Fatorda, Margao-Goa as Chairmanof Ravindra Bhavan, Margao-Goa with immediateeffect.



Panaji, 25th July, 2012.________

Order


In exercise of powers conferred by Clause 6 ofthe Constitution of Ravindra Bhavan, Margao--Goa, the Government is pleased to appointShri Chandan Naik, Comba, Margao-Goa asVice-Chairman of Ravindra Bhavan, Margao-Goawith immediate effect.



Panaji, 25th July, 2012.________

Order


In exercise of powers conferred by Clause 9(viii)of the Constitution of Ravindra Bhavan, Margao--Goa, the Government is pleased to nominatefollowing members on General Council of RavindraBhavan, Margao-Goa with immediate effect.

1. Shri Navnath Khandeparkar, Margao-Goa.2. Shri Dominic Gaonkar, Curtorim-Goa.3. Smt. Shaila Parsekar, Babai Kamat Centre,

Pajifond, Margao-Goa.4. Smt. Sangeeta Bhatikar, Aquem, Margao-Goa.5. Shri Anil Raikar.6. Shri Suhas Vernekar.7. Smt. Priya Kamat.8. Shri Jayesh Kolvekar, Curtorim-Goa.





779

Order


In exercise of powers conferred by Clause 6 (a)of the Constitution of Tiatr Academy, Panaji-Goa,the Government is pleased to appoint Shri MinguelJacob Carmo Luis Fernandes, Fatorda, Margao-Goaas President of Tiatr Academy, Panaji-Goa withimmediate effect.

This supersedes earlier Order No. DAC/7//AUTOBODIES/COMITTIES/2012/2132 dated25-07-2012.



Panaji, 27th July, 2012.________

Order


In exercise of powers conferred by Clause 10 (h)of the Constitution of Tiatr Academy, Panaji-Goa,the Government is pleased to nominate followingmembers on General Council of Tiatr Academy,Panaji-Goa with immediate effect.

1. Shri Joaquim M. Cruz, Shenvivaddo, Shiroda--Goa.

2. Shri Rosario Antonio Fernandes, (Rose Fern),Benaulim.

3. Shri William Fernandes, Bepquel, Curchorem.4. Shri Milagres De Chandor, Chandor, Salcete-

-Goa.5. Shri Jose Maria Mathias Ignatius Thomas

D’Souza alias Joe Rose, Olaulim, Pomburpa,Bardez-Goa.

6. Shri Anthony Silvestor, Goa.7. Shri Francis Misquita, Talevaddo, Revora,

Bardez-Goa.8. Shri Agostinho Temudo, Dongurlim, Navelim,

Salcete-Goa.9. Shri Ramesh Komarpant, Chavdi, Canacona,

Goa.

This supersedes earlier Order No. DAC/7//AUTOBODIES/COMITTIES/2012/2132 dated25-07-2012.




Department of Forest__

Order

No. 4-2-2011/FOR

Government is pleased to transfer Shri N. D.Naik, presently working as the Principal, ForestTraining School, Valpoi and post him as AssistantConservator of Forest in Research & UtilizationDivision, Margao-Goa.

Shri N. D. Naik, Assistant Conservator of Forests,Research & Utilization Division, Margao-Goashall hold the charge of Principal, Forest TrainingSchool, Valpoi, in addition to his own duties inResearch & Utilization Division, Margao-Goa, untilfurther orders.


Pushpa Naik, Under Secretary (Forests).


——— ———

Department of HomeHome—General Division

__

Order

No. 24/4/2012-HD(G)

Read: Order No. 24/4/2012-HD(G) dated30-04-2012.

Governor of Goa is pleased to grant extensionin service of Smt. Shobha Dhumaskar, Director ofProsecution, for a further period of three monthswith effect from 01-08-2012 upto 31-10-2012 oruntil the post is filled on regular basis through GoaPublic Service Commission whichever is earlier.

The extension is subject to termination withoutassigning any reason at any time during the periodof extension.


Neetal P. Amonkar, Under Secretary (Home).

Porvorim, 30th July, 2012.________

Notification

No. HD(G)45-59/575/66-Vol III

The Rajya Sainik Board, Goa is herebyre-constituted as under w.e.f. 01-08-2012.


780

1. Hon’ble Chief Minister — President.

2. GOC-in-C, Southern — Vice-Command, Pune -President.

3. GOC-in-C, Western Naval — Vice-Command, Mumbai -President.

4. AOC-in-C, South Western Air — Vice-Command, Ahmedabad -President.

5. Minister for Home — Member.

6. Shri Aleixo Reginaldo — Member.Lourenco, MLA, Curtorim

7. Chief Secretary — Member.

8. Flag Officer Commanding, — Member.Goa Area

9. Station Commander, — Member.Panaji, Goa

10. Director Resettlement, — Member.Zone (South)

11. Director General of Police — Member.

12. Development Commissioner — Member.

13. Secretary (Finance) — Member.

14. Secretary (Education) — Member.

15. Secretary (Information & — Member.Publicity)

16. Collector, North Goa, Panaji — Member.

17. Collector, South Goa, Margao — Member.

18. Special Secretary, (Personnel) — Member.

19. Special Secretary (Home) — Member.

20. Director of Sports & Youth — Member.Affairs

21. Director, Social Welfare — Member.

22. Brig. A R. M. Rebello — Non-Offical(Retd) Member.

23. Cmde. N. Venugopal (Retd) — Non-OfficialMember.

24. Gp. Capt. K. A. Braganza — Non-Official(Retd) Member.

25. Ex-Sub Maj (Hony Capt) — Non-OfficialDattaram G. Sawant Member.

26. President, Indian Ex-service — Non-OfficialLeague Goa Member.

27. President, Air Force Associa- — Non-Officialtion, Goa Member.

28. President, Goa Foundation — Non-OfficialMember.

29. Dir. General Resettlement, — SpecialMinistry of Defence, Invitee.New Delhi

30. Secretary, Kendriya Sainik — SpecialBoard, New Delhi Invitee.

31. Rep. of Department of — SpecialEx-Servicemen Welfare, Invitee.Ministry of Defence,New Delhi

32. Secretary, Rajya Sainik Board — MemberSecretary.

The function of the Board are specified below:-

(i) Co-ordinating and administering the workof Department of Sainik Welfare.

(ii) Promoting measures relating to the Welfareof Ex-Servicemen and the families ofserving and deceased personnel.

(iii) Disseminating information to the GeneralPublic regarding the Arm Forces in theCountry and taking measures to encouragethe general public to take active interestin the Arm Forces.

The re-constituted Board shall hold office for aperiod of 2 years, from the date of issue of thisNotification. It shall meet every year.

This supersedes this Department’s earlierNotification No. HD(G) 59/575/66-Vol III dated03-09-2010.


Neetal P. Amonkar, Under Secretary (Home).

Porvorim, 30th July, 2012.

——— ———

Department of Labour__

Notification

No. 28/1/2012-LAB/395

The following award passed by the Labour Court--cum-Labour Court, at Panaji-Goa on 15-06-2012 inreference No. IT/11/11 is hereby published asrequired by Section 17 of the Industrial DisputesAct, 1947 (Central Act 14 of 1947).


D. S. Morajkar, Under Secretary (Labour).

Porvorim, 12th July, 2012.________

IN THE INDUSTRIAL TRIBUNAL ANDLABOUR COURT

GOVERNMENT OF GOA AT PANAJI

(Before Smt. Bimba K. Thaly, Presiding Officer)

No. IT/11/11


781

WorkmenRep. by the President,Kamgarancho Ekvott,Gurudutt Building, 3rd Floor,Dr. Dada Vaidhya Road,Panaji, Goa. … Workmen/Party I

V/s

M/s. Hindustan Unilever Ltd.,Kundaim Industrial Estate,Kundaim, Goa. … Employer/Party II

Workmen/Party I represented by Adv. Shri B.D’Costa.

Employer/Party II represented by Adv. Shri G. K.Sardessai.

INTERIM AWARD

(Passed on 15th day of June, 2012)

This order shall deal with the applicationsfor interim relief filed by Party I and Party IIrespectively. The application for interim relief filedby Party I is at Exb. 6, whereas the application forinterim relief filed by Party II is at Exb. 22.

2. In exercise of the powers conferred by clause(d) of sub-section (1) of Section 10 of the IndustrialDisputes Act, 1947 (for short the Act), the Govern-ment of Goa by order dated 16-6-2011 bearingNo. 28/29/2010-LAB referred the following disputefor adjudication by this Tribunal.

“(1) Whether the action of the management ofM/s. Hindustan Unilever Limited, Kundaim,in not conceding to the following charterof demands raised by the KamgaranchoEkvott vide letter dated 07-09-2009, on themanagement of M/s. Hindustan UnileverLimited, Kundaim, Goa, is legal andjustified?

(2) If not, to what relief the Workmen areentitled?”

CHARTER OF DEMANDS

Demand No. (1): Revision of Basic Pay Scales

It is demanded that with effect from 01-06-2008,

the new Basic Pay Scales should be as follows:

Grade Rate (Monthly)

Grade “A” 6,000-325 – till retirement.Grade “B” 5,000-300 – till retirement.

It is further demanded that all Workmen whohave joined the company before the year 2005 shouldbe placed in Grade “A” and should be fittedin Grade “A” as per their seniority in service/pointto point fitment.

Demand No. (2): Flat Rise in Basic Pay

It is demanded that each employee shall begiven Flat Rise of ` 2,000/- per month in his basicpay. Besides, the existing FDA shall be mergedin the new basic pay and after adding the FlatRise of ` 2,000/- per month, the employee shall befitted in the next higher pay scale.

Demand No. (3): Revision in Fixed DearnessAllowance

It is demanded that each employee be paid anadditional Fixed Dearness Allowance of ` 1,000/-per month.

Demand No. (4): Revision in Variable DearnessAllowance

It is demanded that the dearness allowance shallbe as follows:

The A.I.C.P. 1960=100 as per the last settlementand shall be the basis for calculation of DearnessAllowance.

The existing Variable Dearness Allowancescheme will continue upto the AICPI 3357.

For point rise in index above AICPI 3357, theVariable Dearness Allowance should be paid at thefollowing rates:

Basic Salary DA in rupees applicable perpoint increase above CPI 3357

(1960–100)

Below 7,000 ` 2.10/- per point

7,001-8,000 ` 2.40/- per point

8,001-9,000 ` 2.70/- per point

9,001-10,000 ` 3.00/- per point

10,001-11,000 ` 3.30/- per point

11,001 and above ` 3.60/- per point

Demand No. (5): House Rent Allowance

It is demanded that the employees shall be paidHouse Rent Allowance at the rate of 50% of the newbasic pay every month besides the existingHouse Rent Allowance.

Demand No. (6): Conveyance Allowance

It is demanded that the employees shall be paidConveyance Allowance at the rate of 40% of thenew basic pay every month besides the existingConveyance Allowance.

Demand No. (7): Education Allowance

It is demanded that the employees shall be paidadditional Education Allowance of ̀ 500/- per monthover the existing Educational Allowance.


782

Demand No. (8): Medical Allowance

It is demanded that the Medical Allowance shallbe paid to employees at the rate of ` 800/- permonth to all the employees who are not coveredunder the Employees State Insurance Scheme andat the rate of ` 300/- per month to those employeeswho are covered under the Employees StateInsurance Scheme.

Demand No. (9): Leave Travel Allowance

It is demanded that employees shall be paidLeave Travel Allowance at the rate of ` 6,100/- perannum to Grade “A” employees and at the rateof ` 5,500/- per annum to Grade “B” employees.

Demand No. (10): Washing Allowance

It is demanded that employees shall be paidWashing Allowance of ` 300/- per month.

Demand No. (11): Bonus-cum-Ex-Gratia

It is demanded that the employees shall be paidBonus-cum-ex Gratia at the rate of 20% of the grosswages every year.

Demand No. (12): Attendance Allowance

It is demanded that employees shall bepaid Attendance Allowance at the rate of ` 20/-per day.

Demand No. (13): Automatic Promotion

It is demanded that all employees shall begranted Automatic Promotion after 3 years ofcompleted service.

Demand No. (14): Shift Allowance

It is demanded that the company should payShift Allowance at the following rates:

“A” Shift ` 20/- per day 8 a.m. to 4 p.m.

“B” Shift ` 30/- per day 4 p.m. to 12 a.m.“C” Shift ` 40/- per day 12 a.m. to 8 a.m.

General ` 20/- per day General

Demand No. (15): Death Relief Scheme

It is demanded that in case of unfortunate deathof an employee while in the service of the company,the company should pay ` 4 lakhs to the legalheirs of the deceased Workman. The companyshould also provide employment on compassionategrounds to the kith and kin of the deceased.

Demand No. (16): Accident Benefit

It is demanded that whenever any employeemeets with an accident while on duty and while anemployee comes to work from his home andreturns home after work, he shall be treated as on

duty and all his medical expenses shall be paid bythe company. In case an employee gets ESICbenefits, whatever shortfall is there in the amountpaid by E.S.I. the said shortfall shall be paid by thecompany.

Demand No. (17): Designations

It is demanded that all employees shall begiven suitable Designations according to theduties performed by them.

Demand No. (18): Boiler Operators

It is demanded that Boiler Operators be givenpromotions as first class boiler attendants witha rise in salary of ` 3,000/- per month. Theyshall be paid thermic fluid heater and operationallowance of ` 4,000/- per month. In HP Boiler Houseone first class attendant with an assistantsecond class boiler attendant shall be provided.In MP Boiler house, one first class attendantwith an assistant second class boiler attendantshould be provided. Weekly off reliever and leavereliever shall be provided. They also shall be givensuitable designation.

Demand No. (19): Essential Service Allowance

It is demanded that Essential Service Allowanceof ` 400/- per day shall be paid to all thosewho are required to work in essential serviceDepartments.

Demand No. (20): Shift Change Allowance

It is demanded that whenever there is changein shift, the Workman shall be paid Shift ChangeAllowance of ` 300/- per day in case of shiftchange from third to second shift and an amountof ` 250/- in case of change of shift from secondto first shift. In case of changes in shift afterovertime then also the shift change allowanceshall be paid.

Demand No. (21): Canteen Subsidy

It is demanded that the amount of CanteenSubsidy shall be increased to ` 28/- per day toall Workman.

Demand No. (22): Discount in Purchase ofCompany Products

It is demanded that employees be given aDiscount of 50% on the Purchase of CompanyProducts with a limit of purchase of upto ` 1,000/-per month.

Demand No. (23): Overtime

It is demanded that in case an employee isasked to come for work on weekly off days or onholidays, he should be paid double Overtime


783

besides giving a compensatory off. Weekly off dayshould be on Sunday.

Demand No. (24): Uniforms

It is demanded that employees be providedfour sets of tericott full Uniforms, sweaters, safetyshoes, cotton socks, helmet and one raincoat everyyear in the month of January.

Demand No. (25): Incentive Quality SafetySchemes

It is demanded that for percentage achievementof the factory CUI, the company should payadditional 1% (new Basic+D.A.) as incentives.

Demand No. (26): Seniority Increment

It is demanded that employees be givenSeniority Increments at the rate of five incrementsafter completion of every five years since thestarting of this factory.

Demand No. (27): Family Get Together

It is demanded that every year there should bea Family Get Together in the factory.

Demand No. (28): Festival Advance

It is demanded that Festival Advance of` 4,000/- per annum shall be given to eachWorkperson.

Demand No. (29): Gratuity

It is demanded that all employees be paidGratuity on retirement/resignation at the rate ofone month’s gross salary, without any ceiling.

Demand No. (30): Medical Insurance

It is demanded that all employees and theirfamily members shall be insured under MedicalInsurance scheme for an amount of Rupees twolakhs.

Demand No. (31): House Loan

It is demanded that employees shall be givenHousing Loan of Rupees three lakhs without anyinterest for purchase of a house/plot or for repair ofhouse.

Demand No. (32): Leave

(a) Annual Leave:

The company should grant Annual Leave to allthe employees at the rate of one day leave for every12 days worked (including leave) for the employeewho has put in 240 days service in a year. Fordays worked beyond 240 days, leave at the rateof one day for every 8 days worked be granted,accumulation of annual leave should be allowed

upto 120 days. The Workman should be allowedto encash this leave.

(b) Casual Leave:

The company should grant 12 days Casual Leaveevery year to all the employees.

(c) Sick Leave:

The company should grant Sick Leave every yearto all employees at the rate of 12 days sick leave forthose who are not covered under the EmployeesState Insurance Scheme and 6 days sick leavefor those who avail benefits of Employees StateInsurance Scheme. Accumulation of Sick Leaveshould be allowed upto 26 days.

(d) It is further demanded that all Workmenshould be granted the above said leave i.e. annualleave, casual leave and sick leave irrespective ofthe number of days worked in a particular year.

(e) Paid Holidays:

The company should grant 12 Paid Holidays(excluding weekly off) every year to all theemployees. These paid holidays should be decidedin consultation with the Union. The employeeshould also be granted restricted holidays fortwo days in a year.

Demand No. (33): Period of Settlement

It is demanded that the Period of Settlementshould be for three years with effect from01-04-2009.

Demand No. (34): Retrospective effect andInterest

(1) All demands except demand No. (1), shouldbe effective from 01-04-2009 onwards.

(2) Interest shall be paid at the rate of 15% perannum on all arrears and other payment paidafter 01-04-2009.

Demand No. (35): General

The Union reserves its right to amend and/oralter and/or modify the above demands, if foundnecessary. All existing terms and conditions ofservice and existing practices shall continue tobe in operation unless specifically altered bysubsequent settlements.

(II) If the answer to issue No. (1) above is in thenegative, then what relief the Workmen areentitled to?

3. In the statement of claim it is in short thecontention of Party I that Party II Companymanufactures and sells soaps and detergents,personal products, beverages, foods etc., and the


784

same is located in Goa at plot Nos. 128-139 and324-326 at Kundaim Industrial Estate, Kundaim,Goa. It is stated that Party I i.e., KamgaranchoEkvott is a registered Trade Union and is themajority Union in the factory of Party II Companyat Goa. It is stated that the last settlement dated29-4-05 came to an end on 31-3-09; the settlementwas terminated and fresh charter of demands onwage issues were raised on 4-8-08 and amendedon 7-9-09. Since no settlement was arrived at theconciliation machinery was invoked however thesame ended in failure which report wassubmitted u/s 12(3) of the Act but as despite it theappropriate Government did not refer the disputefor adjudication. Party I filed a Writ Petition andfinally the Government referred the dispute videletter dated 16-6-2011.

4. It is stated that the Workman covered by the

present demands comprise of Workmen in the Grade‘A’ and Grade ‘B’. It is stated that M/s. Hindustan

Unilever Co. has its head office and research centrein Mumbai and that the service conditions of the

head office Workmen, the research centre workershave been uniform and that the company also has

factories in other parts of India. It is stated that theproducts manufactured by the company are fast

moving consumer products and has a virtualmonopoly in all the segments that it operates in.

That HUL has very little debts and interest burdenis very low, it is financially sound and will continue

to make huge profits as no other company enjoyscredit worthiness like HUL. That it is a number 1

company in India. It is stated that the profitsof HUL have increased from year of the last

settlement and there has been tremendous growthin profits and prosperity of the company since last

ten years. Thus, HUL is a unique and highlyprofitable multinational.

5. It is also the case of Party I that there is anincrease in the cost of living index, the Workmenare justified in demanding an increase in theirbasic wages as well as dearness allowance andeven the other allowances. It is stated thatalongwith the rise in profits there is a steep risein the salaries of the Managerial Staff as comparedto the employees in Goa factory. It is stated thatthere is disparity in the wages drawn by the dailyrated Workmen, Grade ‘B’ as compared to thesalaries drawn by the Chairman, Directors etc., andthat the workers wages are nowhere near theliving wage. It is further the case of Party I that theworkers demands are based on comparison withthe Nestle, Hindustan Petroleum, Cadila Health

Centre, Colgate, P&G and Workmen covered bySixth Pay Commissioner etc., for comparability ofwages. It is stated that the company’s like Nestle,Colgate and P&G are FMCG Companies andhence are comparable; Hindustan Petroleum aPetroleum Company, Cadila Health Care a Pharma-ceutical Company and the Workmen covered bythe Sixth Pay Commission are from the same regionand are comparable with HUL. These companiesare much smaller in size in terms of profit etc., andare not comparable as such but they pay muchhigher wages than the employer Company to thecorresponding category of the Workmen coveredunder the present reference. Therefore, there isadequate scope to raise the wages of the workersand lend a helping hand to move towards a livingwage. It is stated that there has been rise in thewage structure of comparable companies in theregion and that after the implementation of SixthPay Commission the wages of the Workmencovered by the commission have also beenincreased. According to Party I the wage structureof the Workmen comprises of Basic Wage, DearnessAllowance, Other Allowances, Incentive/Produc-tivity Payments and Retrial Benefits. Thus, the Unionhas raised the various demands as mentionedsupra numbering 35 which include revision inBasic Pay Scale, flat rise in Basic Pay, revisionin FDA, revision in VDA, House Rent Allowance,Conveyance Allowance, Education Allowance,Medical Allowance, Leave Travel Allowance,Washing Allowance, Bonus-cum-Ex-gratia,Attendance Allowance, Automatic Promotion, ShiftAllowance, Death Relief Scheme, Accident Benefit,Designations, Boiler Operators, Essential ServiceAllowance, Discount in purchase of CompanyProducts, Overtime, Uniforms, Incentive, Quality,Safety Schemes, Seniority Increment, Family GetTogether, Festival Advance, Gratuity, MedicalInsurance, Housing Loan, Annual Leave, CasualLeave, Sick Leave, Paid Holidays, Period ofSettlement to be of three years from 1-4-09, Demandwherever not specified to be effective from 1-4-09onwards and payment of interest @15% p.a. onall the arrears and other payments paid later than1-4-09 and the general demands.

6. In Exb. 6 Party I has sought an interim reliefof ` 6,500/- per month to each of the employeescovered by this reference. It is stated that sincethere has been increase in the paying capacity ofthe employer, there is an increase in CPI, that thewages of workers have not reached the livingwage, and there has been a rise in the wagestructure in the comparable industry in theregion and that the Party I/Union is entitled for the


785

interim relief as prayed for. It is also stated thatthe company HUL is a financially sound, marketleader and a dominant undertaking in most ofthe market segments; that the products manufac-tured by the company are fast moving consumerproducts and the company is growing fromstrength to strength every year with various typesof mergers, amalgamations and acquisitions. It isstated that HUL is a market leader in toilet soaps,detergents, washing soaps, branded tea, ice-creams,tomato ketchup, tooth paste, shampoo, talcumpowder, skin cream etc., that it is a topmostadvertisers in India and has more than 30 powerbrands sold through millions of outlets and thatthe financial position of the company isextremely sound and has been increasing. It isstated that when the settlement was arrived at29-4-05, the All India CPI was 2608 (1960=100) inMay, 2011 CPI is 4268 (1960=100) which isan increase of 63.65% in barely a period of 6 yearsresulting in an astounding rise of 63.65% in cost ofliving and therefore there is need for grant ofinterim relief. It is stated that today the employeesare not left with the purchasing power they hadobtained through collective bargaining even wayback on 29-4-05. It is stated that the cost of livingitself protects those items that are in the basketwhich itself does not include all the items whichthe workers use and what were the luxuriesthen have become necessities today but thebasket has remained the same and hence theremust be an increase in the wages to protect theworkmen and nullify the adverse effects of inflationon items outside the basket. It is stated that CPIcannot be used to measure changes in costs orstandards of living since both are affected by manyfactors other than changes in prices measuredby the index and that the wage revision is witha view to increase the standard of living as wellas protecting the real wage. According to Party ICPI cannot be used to measure changes in costsor standards of living since both are affectedby many factors other than changes in pricesmeasured by the index. It is stated that comparisoncan be done between the wages of the Workmenof the same employer working in different regionsand even for that matter it could be on thebasis of companies region-cum-industry. It is statedthat the companies like Nestle, Colgate and P & G

are competitors of HUL and are in the same region

and therefore comparison deserves to be done with

the wages of the employees in those companies.

It is stated that even if the interim relief as sought

for is granted, the Workmen covered by this

reference will be drawing far less than comparable

companies and that the financial impact of sucha small interim relief will be negligible on thefinancial state of Party II.

7. In their written statement at Exb. 12 Party IIhas stated that the reference is bad in law andnot maintainable. It is also their case that Party IICompany has manufacturing units spread acrossthe country and the Goa factory is a very smallcontributor to the turnover of the company havinga paltry contribution of less than 1.5% of thetotal turnover. That it is incorrect to make anycomparison with the entire Company as everyfactory in HUL Ltd. is a separate entity. That theabsenteeism in the factory is very high andincreasing causing a lot of loss to the Company inmeeting its production plans. It is the contentionof Party II that the demands of the workmen hasto be realistic in nature and based on the settledprinciples of industry-cum-region and it cannotbe based on some contingency. That the natureof work carried out at Research Centre Mumbaiand the work at the Head Office is differentfrom the nature of work carried out at Goa factoryand therefore Research Centre and Head Officecannot be compared with Goa office. It is statedthat the financial position and the paying capacityof the Company cannot be only consideration todecide the issue of wage revision. Since Party IIhas to undergo several economic stress such asadvertising, marketing, sales, raw material purchasekeeping in mind the stiff competition in themarket. Party II has also denied the figures givenby Party I to indicate the financial position ofParty II Company. It is stated that with constantchange in consumer life style and preferences anddemands, the continuity of products/business isalways at risk. It is stated that market share is anindicator of the competitiveness of HUL viz-a-vizthe other players in the market and thereforethe market share of the products manufactured inGoa factory only should be looked at, instead ofchecking the market share of HUL as whole andthat the contribution of Goa factory to achieve thismarket share need to be factored before evaluatingthe paying capacity of the employer. It is statedthat the profit and loss statement and thereflective numbers are for the investors and cannotalone be the basis for ascertaining the payingcapacity of the Party II. It is stated that rise in costof living index is taken care of by the VDAcomponent in the long term settlement signed inFebruary, 2001 and April, 2005 and that VDA ispaid specifically to neutralize inflation and prices.It is stated that the present wage structure takescare of the rise in CPI index and production in Goa


786

unit is going down therefore there is no need forrevision in the existing wage structure and thatParty I union is deliberately ignoring the factualposition that VDA component is increased by 122%as against increase of 64% in CPI. It is stated thatthe salary of CEO cannot be compared with theworkers in one factory as the CEO is responsiblefor more than 30 such factories all over Indiaincluding all other departments, branch offices,research and development centres, depots, with itshead office only in India and in addition he is alsothe CEO for the operations in Nepal, Bangladesh,Pakistan and Sri Lanka so also that the skill set,functions discharged by the CEO and otherManagers are totally different from the workers ofGoa unit and therefore irrelevant for the purposeof wage revision claimed filed by the Union. It isstated that the underlying concept of fifthpay commission with respect to the pre-taxmaximum/minimum disparity ratio is not applicableto private sector and is irrelevant for the purposesof wage adjudication of workers of Goa unit. It isstated that the workers earn well above theminimum wages fixed by boards. Party II has statedthat the Workmen in Goa and Khamgaon do nothave same set of experience as alleged. It is statedthat based on region, nature of product, profitmargin and countervailing obligations cast on theworkers of Nestle, Hindustan Petroleum, Cadila,Colgate), the said companies are not comparablewith the establishment at Goa and that Party IIcompany is a soap manufacturing company and isengaged in a completely different business thanthe other companies and that the demand for theirproducts, the volume growth of their business, theprofitability of their business, their technology andautomation in the manufacturing processes andresultant man power requirement, the capabilityand skill requirement of Workmen, educationalqualification of Workmen of those companies areradically different from Party II company andtherefore these companies cannot be comparedwith Party II company. It is stated that thepromotions cannot be linked to years of service butit depends upon skills of employee, attendancerecord, attitude towards work, involvement inactivities etc. That the promotions are indepen-dent settlements and cannot be linked tosettlements but to superior quality of work. ThatParty II company being a soap manufacturingunit in Goa is engaged in a completely differentlybusiness in Goa than the other companies withwhom the applicant union has sought comparisonin terms of the gross wages. It is stated thatapproximately 80% of the Workmen have theirown houses in Goa and therefore the HRA of

` 825/- per month being paid at present is stilljustified. It is stated that the existing localallowance is adequate and does not call forrevision. It is stated that the employees from theGoa undertaking has been provided transportationtill interiors which is not provided by any othercompanies by the union. It is stated that theexisting education allowance is adequate anddoes not call for any revision. As regards medicalallowance it is stated that all the employees ofParty I Union fall within the limits of ESI andtherefore the existing medical allowance receivedalongwith medical facilities is adequate to meetthe medical expenses of an employee. That apart,with respect to the employees falling out of ESI,Goa factory has got a medical insurance plan of` 40,000/- covering each employee and theirfamily and in addition a sum of ` 200/- is given tomeet the medical expenses to such employee. Asregards LTA to Grade ‘A’ it is paid at ` 4,101 p.a. andto Grade ‘8’ at ` 3,540 p.a. which is adequate tomeet the expenses. As regards washing allowancecompany provides five sets of uniform to theemployees over a period of two years and it beingof good quality lasts for more than two years. Itis stated that the existing bonus and attendanceallowance are adequate and do not call for anyrevision. As regards automatic promotions, it isstated that the same are granted on the basis ofparameters like knowledge in current job, number

of skills, attendance, participation in activities,attitude towards work etc., and it is an established

practice to promote high performance and thesame is followed here. The shift allowance was

revised in the year 2005 and it does not requireto be revised regularly. The debt relief scheme

was revised from ` 1,00000/- to ` 2,00000/- andis justified in the current scenario. As regards

the revision of accident benefit the companyhas already taken adequate and multiple measures

for the well being of its employees and no furthermeasures are required nor it is justified. Asregards demand for designations all the employeesat HUL Goa factory have the same designation tomaintain parity and encourage flexibility inwork operations. With respect to the demand forboiler operators, the company has no right to givea person promotion as first class boiler operators asthe Inspectorate of Factories & Boilers conductexaminations and certifies persons as secondclass boiler operator and first class boiler operator.As regards the demands for essential serviceallowance, shift change allowance, canteensubsidy, discount in purchase of company product,overtime, uniform, incentive quality, safety scheme,


787

seniority increment, family get-together, festivaladvance, gratuity/medical insurance and housingloan etc., these existing allowances are adequateand does not call for any revision. It is stated thatGoa factory organizes a family get-together eachyear on Dasara Pooja and as regards house loanParty II has contributed a hefty amount towardsthe formation of the Co-operative Credit Society ofthe employees as the initial corpus to start thesociety as regards revision in annual leave, casualleave, sick leave, long leave and paid holiday, theexisting leaves are sufficient and do not call forrevision. It is stated that demand for a three yearsettlement is impractical as the Union itself hassigned two settlements for a period of four yearseach and that each time, after a settlement is signed,it takes six months for the production to improve.It is stated that as the DA has increased by 122%since April, 2005 while the CPI has increased by64% since April, 2005 the rise in cost of living ismore than adequately compensated for andtherefore the question of payment of all demandswith retrospective effect from 1-4-2009 withinterest @15% does not arise. It is stated that theapplicant union are being paid wages which arebest in the region and best in the soap industryacross India, besides the Workmen are providedwith the best environment.

8. Thus, amongst above and other groundsParty II has stated that the claim statement isdevoid of any merits and deserved to be rejectedwith costs.

9. In the reply to the application for interim reliefvide Exb. 11, Party II has stated that the referencedeserves to be rejected as it is vague, bad inlaw and not capable of adjudication. It is also thecase of Party II that the demands are unreasonableand unjustified; that the statement of claimconsists of rhetoric, irrational comparisons andstatements and that while adjudicating thedemands, the total wage packet or cost toCompany (CTC) is required to be taken intoconsideration. It is stated that though the turnoverof the Company was around ` 19,401 cr. approxi-mately for the year 2010, Goa factory has made apaltry contribution of around 1.5 approximately ofthe turnover which is very low as compared to totalturnover of the Company and therefore comparisoncould not be made with the entire Company. It isstated that the every factory in HUL is a separateentity and has to be efficient, cost effective andeconomically viable. It is stated that to remainviable this factory has to remain lean, trim andcompetitive and that the Company is in the FMCG

sector and faces constant competitive pressure fromnumber of small and medium players both fromorganized and unorganized sectors. It is stated thatthe world economy has, of late, shown majorrecessionary trends thereby putting pressure onprices of consumer goods including soaps and sucheconomic scenario, the buyers are more particularabout the cost of the product and the deliveredquality. That the Goa factory management team isunder a mandate to reduce its overheads consider-ably and all cost effective measures are being putin place to ensure that the Goa factory has notrendered a costly source of soap manufacturingloosing its competitiveness to attract productionplans from the sourcing division of HUL. It is statedthat though there has been increase in the cost ofliving index but the financial position and thepaying capacity of the Company cannot be aconsideration to decide the issue of wage revisionand that the financial position and payingcapacity of Goa unit has to be considered for wageadjudication. It is stated that the percentage rise inCPI points since April, 2005 to September, 2011 is63.7% while the VDA amount paid to compensatethe same in percentage for the same period isstaggering 122% i.e. almost double of the inflationrate, which more than adequately neutralizes theincrease in cost of living. It is stated that therate from April, 2005 to September, 2011 is 191.5%and thus the increase in VDA is more than enoughto compensate the rise in CPI. It is stated that the

last settlement expired on 31-3-09 and since thenCPI points increase from April, 2009 to September,2011 is 26% while during the same period theincrease in the VDA amount paid by the Companyto the workers has increased by 45% i.e. almostdouble the rate of inflation, with the neutralizationrate being 173% thus more than adequatelycompensating the inflation rate. It is stated that

the aspects such as turnover/marker share/merger

and acquisition activities/real estate development//financial leverage/media spends/creditworthiness//ROCE/RONW/EVA/market capitalization have tobe considered to determine the financial health ofthe entity as a whole. It is stated that the turnoverof the factory has been declining over the pastfew years. It is stated that the comparison mustbe done on the region-cum-industry principle andthe various other companies used for comparisonby Party I are not from the same industry. It isstated that the profit margins in the business ofchocolates which are manufactured by M/s. NestleLtd., Goa is around 25% where as a profit margin ofsoaps which are manufactured at Goa factory isaround 10%. It is stated that the profit margins in


788

petroleum business is also incomparable withsoap manufacturing and that as regards Cadilathe net profit is much higher as compared to HULfor the financial year 2010-11. Even the net profitof Colgate for the above year is very high ascompared to HUL and therefore the abovecompanies are clearly not comparable with theestablishment of Party II at Goa. It is stated thatthere is no similar industry in the region of Goa. Itis thus stated that the applicant Union has notmade out a case justifying grant in the revision ofwages as prayed for.

10. Party I then filed rejoinder to the replyfiled by Party II on interim relief vide Exb. 13. Inthe further course of proceeding Party II filedadditional written statement at Exb. 21 andsubsequent thereto Party I filed additionalrejoinder to Exb. 21 vide Exb. 23.

11. In the application for interim relief filed byParty II at Exb. 22 it is in short the contention ofParty II that company faces heightened competi-tion and uncertain and low business plans posingthreat to the profitability and consequently theviability of the company and therefore it expectsbest efforts for productivity improvement, qualityimprovement, cost reduction and much greaterflexibility. It is stated that due to high absenteeismin the factory, the factory’s competitiveness andreliability is affected and inspite of earning incomefrom other sources and causing huge financial lossesto the factory, chronic absentees who do not cometo the factory for even 240 days in a year, receiveannual increments and wage increases throughsettlements, which is an unfair practice and shouldbe stopped. It is stated that increasing the wageof the Workmen per se without considering thenecessity of wages being based on productivityand granting of any relief to the workmen inthe present charter of the union without thisTribunal devising a productivity linked waged oran assessor being appointed to determine theproductivity linked wage will otherwise render theCharter of Demands of the management a futileexercise and any interim relief by enhancementof wages on the Charter of Demands of the Unionwill be discriminatory and arbitrary. Thus, Party IIhas prayed that the Tribunal should determinethe productivity linked wage scheme or in thealternative issue direction for appointment of anassessor to determine the productivity linked wagescheme; to direct that the transportation costs beshared by the employees and the management andto freeze the pay scale at the level existing as on

31-3-09 and minimum attendance of 270 days toearn increment as per the scale.

12. In reply to Exb. 22 vide Exb. 24 Party I has in

short stated that in view of Section 10(4) of the

Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, the jurisdiction of

this Tribunal is confined to the points of reference

and the matters incidental thereto and therefore

the company’s Charter of Demands cannot be

agitated in the present reference and consequently

there cannot be any final relief much less any

interim relief. It is stated that the party replying

is also not entitled to any relief in a proceeding

brought in by the party who institutes it and

even for this reason no relief could be granted

to Party II. It is stated that the prayers in theinterim relief application are in the nature of finalrelief and on this ground also the applicationdeserves to be rejected. Thus amongst above andother grounds, Party I has prayed to dismiss theapplication at Exb. 22.

13. Heard at length Lnd. Adv. Shri B. D’Costa

for Party I and Lnd. Adv. Shri G. K. Sardessai for

Party II. Lnd. Both the learned advocates also filed

written arguments at Exb. 27 and Exb. 30.

14. I have gone through the records of the case

and have duly considered the arguments advanced.

The points arising for my determination are

mentioned below along with their findings and

reasons thereof:

Points Findings

1 2

1. Whether the application Positive.

for interim relief filed by

Party I is maintainable?

2. Whether the application Negative.

for interim relief filed by

the Party II is maintainable?

3. Whether the Party I has Party I has made

made out a prima facie out a case for

case for grant of interim grant of interim

relief to the extent of relief of ` 3,000/-

` 6,500/- per month to per month to

every employee in Party II every employee

company? in Party II

company?

4. In whose favour the In favour ofbalance convenience tilts? Party I


789

REASONS

15. Points 1 & 2: Both these points are answeredtogether for the sake of convenience as they are onthe same subject matter and therefore discussingthem together could avoid repetition of facts.

16. It is the contention of learned advocate forParty II that the Tribunal has no powers to grantinterim relief more so when there is no referenceon the subject of grant of interim relief to Party I.In support of his above submissions he relied onthe judgments in the cases of Hotel Imperial,New Delhi and others v/s Hotel Workers Union(Civil appeals No. 31-33/1958, SC), in MRF, Ltd.,Goa v/s Goa MRF Employees Union, Goa andanother 2003 (4) LLN 1182, in Goa MRFEmployees Union v/s M/s. MRF Ltd., Civilappeals No. 1007/2004 (SC), in Special referenceNo. 1/1991 in the matter of Cauvery WaterDisputes Tribunal AIR 1995 522, in RajeevHitendra Pathak and others v/s AchyutKashinath Karekar Civil Appeal No. 4307/07 (SC)and in Super Cassettes Industry Ltd., v/s MusicBroadcasts Pvt. Ltd., civil appeal Nos. 4196-4197//2012 (SC).

17. On the other hand learned advocate forParty II by inviting my attention to the findings ofthis Tribunal at Exb. 17 rendered while rejectingthe application made by Party II for stay of theproceedings, contended that in para 7 of this order,this Tribunal has observed that the IndustrialTribunal has powers to grant interim relief inappropriate cases since the expression “mattersincidental thereto” in Section 10(4) of the Act,covers the aspect of grant of interim relief inappropriate cases. He further stated that this orderwas challenged by Party II before Hon’ble HighCourt but later the challenge was withdrawn andtherefore it is clear that there is no review of theabove findings of this Tribunal. According to himthe judgment in the case of Hotel Imperial (supra)holds the field and in context of this judgmenthe distinguished the other judgments on whichreliance has been placed by learned advocate forParty I.

18. It may be mentioned here that though learnedadvocate for Party I by relying on the judgment ofHotel Imperial (supra) tried to canvas that interms of this judgment the Tribunal has to make anaward about the matters which are referred to itand as the matter regarding interim reliefto Party I herein is not referred to this Tribunal, thesame cannot be granted by this Tribunal, learnedadvocate for Party II by referring to the very same

judgment made it clear that the observations in itindicate that where an order referring an industrialdispute has been made specifying the points ofdispute for adjudication, the Tribunal has toconfine its adjudication to those points and thematters incidental thereto in terms of Section 10(4)of the Act and that such matter need not bespecifically referred in terms to the Tribunal. Healso stated that the interim relief thereforewhere it is admissible can be granted as a matterincidental to the question referred to the Tribunalwithout being itself referred in express terms.

19. I have gone through the above judgmentwhich clearly specifies that there is no need torefer the matter incidental to the matter referredto the Tribunal and that the Tribunal has powersto decide such incidental matter. Since the matterof interim relief which is a monetary relief claimedby Party I herein is incidental to the main reliefof the demands of Party I, the same in my viewbeing incidental to the main reference, couldbe decided by this Tribunal, without specificreference by the Government.

20. As regards the judgment in the case of MRFLtd., (Supra) relied upon by the learned advocatefor Party II, reading of the same makes it clear thatthe relief sought herein by the union was in thenature of preventive injunction which was todirect the company to cease and resist from serviceconditions of the Workmen in the complaint underSection 33A of the Act. It is observed in thisjudgment that what is incidental is somethingassociated with the main reference or which issecondary or minor and adjunct to it and it cannotbe something not associated with the mainreference. No doubt, this judgment also indicatesthat the interim relief sought must arise from thesubject matter of the reference and not outsideit but it cannot be lost sight of the fact that whatis discussed in this judgment is the aspect ofthe jurisdiction of the Tribunal to injunct anemployer from breaching a standing order orsettlement or other conditions of service andalso that if it was done, how the same could beenforced but at the same time this judgment alsostates that the Tribunal is a creature of statute andcan exercise those powers which are conferredupon it expressly or by necessary implication. Thus,in light of above observations the Hon’ble HighCourt restored the order of the Industrial Tribunalrejecting the application for interim relief on theground that it had no power to grant such relief asit was in the nature of injunction. This judgmentwas carried in appeal before Hon’ble Apex court in


790

civil appeal No. 1007/2004 (cited supra) however,by referring to the judgment in Hotel Imperial(supra) which was a decision of the three judgebench, the matter was referred to a larger bench.Learned advocate for Party II in the above contextrelied on the judgment in the case of Oil andNatural Gas Corporation Ltd., v/s Transport &Dock Workers Union 2007 (001) CLR-0897-97 inwhich by referring to the case of MRF Ltd., (supra)so also in the case of M/s. Lokmat NewspapersPvt. Ltd., V. Shankarprasad, reported in AIR1999SC 2423 and in the case of Hotel Imperial(supra) held that the law on the point of jurisdic-tion of the Industrial Tribunal to grant interimrelief, as its stands today, is the one which hasbeen laid down in the case of Hotel Imperial(supra). It is therefore clear from above, that thisTribunal has powers to decide the applicationfor interim relief, in the instant case as the reliefsought vide the application under consideration, isincidental to the main relief.

21. In the case of Cauvery Water (Supra)specific reference was made to grant interim reliefand in this context it is observed that the Tribunal(Water disputes Tribunal) constituted under theAct is not prevented from passing an interim orderor direction, or granting an interim relief pursuantto the reference merely because at the interim stageit has not carried out a complete investigation. It istherefore the contention of learned advocate forParty I that no interim relief could be granted incase where there is no specific reference madetowards its grant. Nevertheless, as rightly pointedout by learned advocate for Party I reading of thisjudgment in entirety makes it clear that there isnothing in it stating that no interim relief couldbe granted under the Act if there is no specificreference made towards its grant. On the contrary,what is observed in para 32 of this judgment isthat whether the Tribunal has power to grant aninterim relief when no reference is made by theCentral Government for such relief is a questionwhich does not arise in the facts and circumstancesunder which the reference is made and thereforethe same need not be answered. Even for thatmatter learned advocate for Party I by referringto the judgment in Sarva Shramik Sanghatana (K.V.) Mumbai, Petitioner v/s State of Maharashtraand others, 2008-(002)- LLJ-0501-SC contended thata case is only an authority for what it actuallydecides and that every judgment must be read asapplicable to the particular facts proved, or assumedto be proved since the generality of the expres-sions which may be found there are not intendedto be expositions of the whole law, but are

governed and qualified by the particular facts ofthe case in which such expressions are to be found.Viz a-viz above, he referred to the judgment in thecase of Cauvery Water (supra) to state that whenthis judgment does not state that the Tribunal hasno power to grant interim relief when no referenceis made to it for such relief, it would not be justifiedand legal to import such a ratio. I find force in theabove submissions of learned advocate for Party Isince the observations in the judgment of Cauvery(supra) are not in consonance with what hasbeen urged before me by the learned advocate ofParty II and therefore the ratio in the case ofCauvery (supra) is not applicable to the situationunder consideration.

22. As regards in the judgment in the case ofRajeev Hitendra (supra) the same discusses aboutthe implied powers of the Tribunal by observingthat the powers which are not conferred upon bystatute cannot be exercised. It may be mentionedhere that the judgment in the case of HotelImperial (supra) is an answer to the aboveproposition wherein the powers are conferred onthe Tribunal to decide interim relief applicationin terms of Section 10(4) of the Act.

23. As regards the judgment in the case of SuperCassettes (supra) the facts in it make it clear thatthe relief of grant of interim compulsory licensewas sought pending the final relief and it wasin this situation such relief was rejected sincegrant of such relief amounted to grant of final reliefat interim stage. Thus, to my mind the ratio inthe above case cannot be made applicable tothe instant case wherein the grant of interimrelief would not amount to grant of final relief.

24. Thus, in the light of above discussion, itfollows that this Tribunal is empowered to dealwith the application for interim relief in thisreference.

25. Now coming to the application for interimrelief filed by Party II vide Exb. 22, it is worthwhilenoting that having contended that this Tribunalhas no powers to decide the applications ofthe nature seeking interim relief, it is infact notopen to Party II to file such an application (andmoreso in a dispute which is not referred by theGovernment) and therefore on this count itselfExb. 22 deserves to be rejected.

26. Nevertheless, learned advocate for Party Irelied on the judgment in the case of The JaipurUdyog Ltd. and The Cement Work KarmachariSangh, Sahu Nagar I LLJ (SC)437 and in PotteryMazdoor Panchayat, v/s The Perfect Pottery Co.


791

Ltd. and another 1979 LAB I.C. 827 the observa-tions in which indicate that the Tribunal cannotadjudicate upon the dispute which has not beenreferred so also that the Tribunal tan not go beyondthe terms of the reference. Learned advocate forParty I also invited my attention to the observa-tions of the Hon’ble High Court of Judicatureat Bombay in C.A. No. 147/2009 in L.P.A. of397/2008 the ratio in which is that in an appealfiled by the appellant, the respondent cannotapply for interim relief in his favour. Thus, from theabove judicial pronouncements, it becomes clearthat Party II herein cannot file an application forinterim relief in a reference by the Government onbehalf of Party I.

27. Be that as it may, reading of the applicationat Exb. 22 also makes it clear that the prayers madein it are, to determine the productivity linkedwage scheme or in the alternative to issue adirection for appointment of an assessor todetermine the productivity wage scheme, todirect that the transportation costs may be sharedby the employees and the management and tofreeze the pay scales at the level existing as on31-3-09 and minimum attendance of 270 days toearn increment as per the scale.

28. The above prayers, as rightly pointed outby the learned advocate for Party I, give a clearindication that they are in the nature of finalreliefs and being so I am of the considered opinionthat the same even otherwise could not havebeen granted and this is moreso in the light ofthe observations in the judgment in the case ofSuper Cassettes Industries (supra).

29. Thus, in view of discussion supra pointNo. 1 is answered in the positive and point No. 2is answered in the negative.

30. Point No. 3: There is no dispute that theParty I Workmen has terminated their earliersettlement and filed a new Charter of Demands on4-8-2008 with amendment to it on 7-9-09. Party Ihas filed various documents in support of theircontentions to which reference would be made inthe latter part of the award.

31. Interim relief has been sought by Party Ibasically on the grounds such as capacity of thecompany to pay, increase in the cost of livingand rise in the wage structure in the comparableindustry in the region.

32. Lnd. Adv. for Party II by relying on thejudgment in the case of Shankar Chakravorthyv/s. Brittania Biscuit Co. Ltd. 1979 (3) SCC 371

tried to impress upon the court that a quasi judicialTribunal proceeding to adjudicate upon a lisbetween the parties before it must decide thematter on the evidence produced by the partiesbefore it I have gone through this judgment andhave noticed that the observations above havebeen made in a totally different context which iswhile deciding as to whether the Tribunal is dutybound to suo motu call upon the employer toadduce the evidence if he is not seeking theopportunity to adduce evidence in support ofcharges. Even otherwise, reading of this judgmentfurther reveals that the observations in it arethat if the dispute between the parties is aquestion of fact, evidence has to be adduced toascertain the said fact. It is pertinent to note thatthe instant application is the one for interim reliefand hence has to be decided on the basis of primafacie evidence produced by the parties. It may bementioned here that orders if any passed in suchapplication would be subject to final outcome ofthe reference and therefore question of leadingevidence while deciding such application, doesnot arise and consequently the observations in thisjudgment do not apply to the instant application.

33. In order to justify the claim for interimrelief, Party I has relied upon the judgment inthe case of Balmer Lawrie & Co. v/s BalmersLawrie & Co. Ltd. 1964 (1) LLJ 380, the observa-tions in which indicate that if the paying capacityof the employer increases or the cost of living showsan upward trend or if there has been a rise inthe wage structure in the comparable industry inthe region, the industrial employees would bejustified in making a claim for the re-examinationof the wage structure and if such a claim isreferred for an industrial adjudication, the adjudi-cator would not normally be justified in rejectingit solely on the ground that enough time has notpassed after the making of the Award, or that thematerial change in relevant circumstances had notbeen proved. In this context it is the submission oflearned advocate for Party II that in order to findout the comparison in the nature suggested above,the evidence deserves to be recorded and thatsuch assessment cannot be done merely on thebasis of documentary evidence. Nonetheless,observations in this, judgment also indicate thatin dealing with the comparable character ofindustrial undertakings, industrial adjudicationdoes not usually rely on oral evidence alone. Ittherefore follows from above that even if thereis oral evidence, reliance has also to be placedon the documentary evidence. Reading of thisjudgment further indicates that the documentary


792

evidence deserves to be looked into to find out asto what is the total capital invested by the con-cern, what is the extent of its business, what is theorder of profits made by the concern, what are thedividends paid, how many employees are employedby the concern and what is the standing in theindustry to which it belong in order to find outwhether one concern is comparable with anotherin the matter of fixing wages. This being theposition of law, I find no force in the contention oflearned advocate for Party I that oral evidenceneeds to be recorded to compare one concern withthe other, more so while deciding the applicationfor interim relief, which is to be decided on thebasis of prima facie evidence produced beforethe Tribunal.

34. Be that as it may, the union in support oftheir contention has relied upon various documentssuch as copy of settlement dated 4-6-04 ofKhamgaon factory, copy of award dated 15-4-11 ofKhamgaon factory, copy of award dated 12-8-08 ofMumbai region, copy of settlement dated 25-4-05and settlement dated 22-2-01 of Goa factory, copyof settlement dated 29-12-10 of Nestle, copy ofsettlement dated 11-11-10 of Colgate, copy ofsettlement dated 2-2-10 of Cadila Health CareLtd. and copy of settlement dated 28-6-01 ofHindustan Petroleum.

35. It may be mentioned here that it is otherwisenot disputed by the learned advocate for Party IIthat, there has been increase in the cost ofliving and also that the company has financialcapacity to make the payment but according tohim the financial position and the payingcapacity of the company cannot be a considerationto decide the issue of wage revision.

36. In the statement of claim Party I has giventhe data and the size of the company, themarket share to indicate that in the soap industrythe company commanded 54.3% of the marketwhile the nearest competitor is only 9.7%. Even inthe application under consideration Party I hascompared the growth of sales and profit of thecompany in the year 2000 with the year 2009-10wherein there has been an increase in the salesfrom ` 11,392/- crores to ` 18,220/- crores andan increase in gross profit from ` 1,665/- crores to`/- crores. Party II has also shown the latestposition of the growth of the company in theadditional rejoinder which indicates increasein net profit from ` 2,306/- crores in 2010-11 to` 2,800/- crores in 2011-12 and the increase insales from ` 19,647/- to ` 22,987/- crores. It is alsoapparent from the records produced by Party I

that the turnover of the Party II company is` 18,220.27/- cr. and profit is ` 2,707/- cr., theturnover of Nestle Ltd., is ` 5,167.2/- cr. and profitis ` 96 cr., turnover of P & G is ` 914/- cr. and profitis ` 234/- cr. and turnover of Colgate Ltd., is` 2,060.92/- cr. and profit is ` 484.80/- cr.

37. The above material brought on record byParty I is otherwise not disputed by Party II.

38. It may be mentioned here that it is alsoprima facie apparent from the “chart of burdenon company” prepared by Party I that the totalburden on the company in case of grant of interimrelief, in relation to the gross profits would beonly 0.072% and this position is also not disputedby the Party II.

39. Learned advocate for Party II relied on thejudgment in the case of Unichem LaboratoriesLtd., v/s The Workmen 1971 (I) LLJ 576, theobservations in which indicate that the financialcapacity of the company has to be considered tofind out if it can bear the additional burden. Itis also observed in this judgment that the twoprinciple factors which must weigh while fixingor revising wage scales and grades is firstly; thecomparison of the wages prevailing in theestablishment in question with those given to theWorkmen of similar grade and scale by similarestablishments in the same industry or in theirabsence in similar establishments in otherindustries in the region and secondly; to find outas to what wage scales the establishment inquestion can pay without any undue strain on itsfinancial resources.

40. It is therefore clear from the above observa-tions that the financial capacity of the companyhas to be looked into while fixing the wagerevision. I have already pointed out supra byreferring to the financial capacity of Party IICompany that there is growth in its sales, that it isa profit making company and that its turnover isalso high as compared to Nestle, P & G and Colgate.

41. It may be mentioned here that in thejudgment in French Motor Car Company, Ltd.,v/s Their Workmen 1962 II LLJ 744, relied uponby learned advocate for Party I it is observed thatit is not necessary for the purposes of comparisonthat the two concerns must be exactly equal in allrespects. It may be mentioned here that Party I hassought to compare itself with Nestle, P & G andColgate, though in his arguments Ld. Advocatefor Party I restricted the comparison with onlyNestle and Colgate. There is otherwise no dispute


793

that the products manufactured by the Party II com-pany as well as by Nestle, P & G and Colgate arefast moving consumer goods and therefore at thisinterim stage it would not be out of place to primafacie come to the conclusion that all the aforesaidcompanies come within the category of sameindustry and hence are comparable.

42. Lnd. Adv. for Party II relied on the) 1 LLJjudgment in the case of Novex Dry Cleaners v/sits Workmen (1962 271 the observations in whichindicate that before comparing the establishmentin question with other establishments engagedin the same trade in the region it is necessary tocompare the establishments in respect of theirstanding, the extent of the labour force employedby them, the extent of their respective customersand also a comparative study has to be made of theprofits and losses incurred by them for some yearsbefore the date of the award.

43. However Learned Advocate for Party I byrelying on the judgment in the case of ChandanMetal Products (Pvt.) Ltd., v/s EngineeringKamdar Union, Baroda and another 1997 (II) LLJ27 contended that in every case there should notbe minutest classification nor it is required thatthe classification should be according to theproduct. It is held that broadly speaking twocriteria on which classification is based areGeographical and Size. It is therefore clear fromabove observations that, it is not mandatory thatcomparable establishments should produce similarproducts. In the instant case as pointed out supra,the consumer goods produced by Party II company,Colgate Ltd., and Nestle Ltd., being all fast movinggoods and all these establishments being in Goathe same in my view, at this prima facie stagecould be compared, irrespective of the fact thatColgate Ltd., and Nestle. Ltd., are smallerestablishments as compared to HUL.

44. Even for that matter, in the judgment in thecase of Hindustan Lever Ltd., (supra) the Hon’bleApex Court by observing that the appellantcompany is a big industrial establishment and thereis no other similar establishment of that size inthat region and though the volume of business ofappellant company is many times more than thecompanies like Godrej, Tomco, Phillips, Colgate etc.has treated the aforesaid companies ascomparable units in the absence of a reallycomparable unit in that area. Also in the case ofHindustan Lever Ltd. v/s Hindustan LeverEmployees Union 2007 (1) CLR 737 the manage-ment had accepted that Colgate was a comparableestablishment.

45. Learned advocate for Party I by relying onthe judgment in the case of Workmen of NewEagerton Woolen Mills v/s New Eagerton WoolenMills 1969 (II) LLJ 782 in which a textile company,Eagerton Mills was compared with Orient Carpetmanufacturing company since other mills in thesame industry in Amritsar region were much smallerin size, in the case of Workmen of Orient PaperMills Ltd., v/s Orient Paper Mills Ltd., 1969 (II)LLJ 398 in which Orient Paper Mills was comparedwith other industries i.e. Collieries, Rourkela SteelPlant and a Cement factory since other papermills were much smaller and in Workmen of IndianHume Pipe Company Ltd., v/s Indian Hume PipeCompany Ltd., Bombay 1986 (I) LLJ 520 in whichan engineering company was compared withpharmaceutical companies which were financiallyin a similar position like it, contended that incase the contention of Party II that there are nocomparable companies in the industry in Goaregion is accepted, than in such event, in terms ofthe observations in the above judgments, compari-son can be done with any other industry in theregion which is quite similar. To my mind, thoughColgate Ltd., and Nestle Ltd., are not comparablein terms of the products they manufacture, thanin the absence of any comparable industry ascontended by the Ld. Advocate for Party II, theregion principle will hold good and therefore it isjustifiable at this stage to compare both the abovecompanies with Party II company, to decide theapplication for interim relief, on the basis of primafacie material before this Tribunal.

46. It may be mentioned here that, in terms ofratio in the judgment in the case of Food Corpora-tion of India Workers Union v/s Food Corporationof India AIR 1990 SC 2178 (relied upon by thelearned advocate for Party I) incase there is nocomparable company in the region then compari-son could be made with the industry of the sameemployer on the basis of Zone-cum-same employerrule. Nonetheless, since I am of the view that atthis prima facie stage there is sufficient materialto compare HUL with Colgate Ltd., and NestleLtd., the question of applying Zone-cum-sameemployer rule, does not arise.

47. Perusal of the updated charts produced byParty I alongwith the rejoinder reveals that HULWorkmen in the lowest comparable grade get` 9,428/- to ` 12,553/- per month less than ColgateLtd., and ` 8,903/- to ` 11,753/- per month in thehigher comparable grade, and HUL Workmen inthe lower comparable grade get ` 8,569/- to` 11.190/- per month less than Nestle Ltd., and` 17,812/- to ` 23,962/- in the highest comparable


794

grade. It is therefore clear that the wages paid tothe Party/Workmen are comparatively less thenthe wages paid in the comparable concerns andthis prima facie evidence is sufficient to supportthe case of Workmen that they should be grantedinterim relief pending adjudication of their Charterof Demands, irrespective of the contentions of theLnd. Adv. for Party II that grant of instant applica-tion would lead to total industrial unrest in theunit and other units of the Company, which infactis not a criteria while deciding the application forinterim relief like the one in hand, where Party Ihas made out a strong prima facie case in supportof their contention.

48. Though it is the contention of learnedadvocate of Party II that the entire turnover of thecompany cannot be considered for deciding thefinancial position of the company and as everyfactory in HUL being a separate entity only theturnover of the Goa factory of the Party II which isaround 1.5% approximately of the total turnoverhas to be considered but as rightly pointed outby learned advocate for Party II by relying onthe judgment in the case of Unichem LaboratoriesLtd., (supra) the paying capacity of the employerhas to be assessed on the basis of audited balancesheet and profit and loss accounts of the company.Learned advocate for Party I also relied on thejudgment in Hindustan Steel Ltd., v/s Workmenof its Refractories department and another1965 I LLJ 253 the observation in which indicatethat the financial position of the employer as awhole has to be considered since the financialcapacity of the employer will be raised upon thefinancial position of the company as a whole. Itmay be mentioned here that though it is pleadedby Party II that the net proceeds of sales of Goafactory was mere 284 crores approximately, nodocumentary evidence has been produced by thecompany to substantiate its above pleading and onthe contrary as it is apparent from the aforemen-tioned judicial pronouncements that the financialcapacity of the company as a whole has to be lookedinto, the contention of learned advocate for Party Ithat the net proceeds of sales of Goa factory wasmerely 284 crore approx. and therefore it cannotbe compared with the above referred establish-ments, do not merit consideration.

49. To substantiate his contention that wagescould be revised also upon considering the netprofits of the company, learned advocate forParty I relied on the judgment in the case of KamaniMetals and Alloys Ltd. v/s their Workmen 1967(II) LLJ 55 in which the Hon’ble Apex Court by

considering the net profits of the companyincreased the burden of 10% of the net profits.

50. As mentioned supra, rise in the cost ofliving is one of the factors which requires to beconsidered while deciding the wage revision andin this context learned advocate for Party I reliedon the judgment in the case of Hindustan LeverLtd., v/s B. N. Dongre and others 1994 II CLR673 in which it is observed that the relationbetween wages and prices of food, clothing andother necessities of life which even the lowest wageearner purchases has to be considered because ifthe prices of these commodities rise and the basicwage remains constant, real wage actually fallscreating a problem for survival for the lowestwage earner. It is also observed that this frequentlyhappens during periods of inflation and toprevent the real wages from falling with the rise inCPI, some allowance has to be paid to the workerswhich give rise to the introduction of the DearnessAllowance scheme. It is pertinent to note that itis the contention of learned advocate for Party IIthat since there has been rise in the DearnessAllowance Scheme the Party I has not made out acase in the revision of wages however, it is clearfrom the observations in the judgment in thecase of Unichem Laboratories (supra) that theclaim made by the workmen, if otherwise justified,cannot be rejected on the sole ground that aprovision is already made in the existing scheme ofDearness Allowance for adjustment dependingupon an increase in the cost of living index. It istherefore clear that the total wage packet has tobe considered in comparison with the increasein CPI, more so because admittedly in the instantcase, there has been rise in the cost of living.

51. Considering the totality of the facts and thediscussion made supra, in my considered opinion,Party I has made out a prima-facie case for grantof interim relief and in my view it would be justand fair to grant an amount of ` 3000/- per monthtowards interim relief to each of the Workmenwhich would at this stage, meet the ends ofjustice and also would help the Workmen toprotect their pay atleast till the adjudication ofCharter of Demands. Hence, my findings.

52. Point No. 4: I have already come to theconclusion that Party I Workmen have made out aprima facie case for grant of interim relief. It cannotbe disputed that the order of interim relief has tobe passed on the basis of prima facie materialbefore the court and there is no need for theTribunal to make a roving enquiry in the matterwhile passing the order on interim relief applica-


795

tion. As rightly pointed out by Lnd. advocatefor Party I the Workmen have to face the brunt ofinflation and has to feed their children, giveeducation and take care of their health and theseaspects cannot wait till the final adjudication ofthe matter. On the other hand Party II Companybeing a multinational Company has sufficientcapacity to pay and therefore no prejudice couldbe caused to Party II Company if the applicationunder consideration is granted in terms specifiedabove moreso because the amount grantedtowards interim relief would be subject to the finalaward. Thus, balance of convenience tilts in favourof Party I Workmen.

53. Party I Workmen have prayed for grant ofinterim relief with effect from 1-4-09 and to pay tothe employees in Grade A and Grade B alongwith arrears thereof. Though it is the contentionof Lnd. advocate for Party I that Tribunal has thejurisdiction to grant interim relief order fromthe date prior to the date of order and that inthe instant case since the expiry of last settlementand making of fresh charter the cost of living hasincreased steeply so also that the profits of theCompany has also increased, it cannot lost the sightof the fact that the date from which the benefitsare to be given is the discretion of the Tribunal andin the facts and circumstances in this case, in myopinion it would be justified to grant the interimrelief to Party I workmen from the date of the filingof the application at Exb. 6.

In the result, I pass the following:

ORDER

1. The application for interim relief at Exb. 6 ispartly allowed.

2. Application for interim relief at Exb. 22 isdismissed.

3. The Party II Company is hereby directed topay ` 3,000/- per month to Party I Workmenfrom the date of the application at Exb. 6,pending the final adjudication of the Charterof Demands.

4. The amount shall be paid to each Workmenwithin thirty days from the date of the orderand it shall be subject to final order/awardwhich will be passed in this reference.

5. No order as to costs.

Inform the Government accordingly.

Sd/-(D. K. Thaly),

Presiding Officer,Industrial Tribunal--cum-Labour Court.

Notification

No. 28/1/2012-LAB/378

The following award passed by the IndustrialTribunal and Labour Court, at Panaji-Goa on07-05-2012 in reference No. IT/62/95 is herebypublished as required by Section 17 of the IndustrialDisputes Act, 1947 (Central Act 14 of 1947).


D. S. Morajkar, Under Secretary (Labour).

Porvorim, 5th July, 2012._________

IN THE INDUSTRIAL TRIBUNAL ANDLABOUR COURT

GOVERNMENT OF GOA AT PANAJI

(Before Smt. Bimba K. Thaly, Presiding Officer)

Ref. No. IT/62/95Shri Vithal V. Pai,Near Ganesh Chawk,H. No. 22, Khorlim,Mapusa, Goa. … Workman/Party I

V/s

M/s. Goa Telecommunications& System Ltd.,Mapusa Industrial Estate,Mapusa, Goa. … Employer/Party II

Adv. Shri V. Menezes of Party I.

Adv. Shri P. J. Kamat for Party II.

AWARD

(Passed on 7th May, 2012)

In exercise of the powers conferred by clause (d)of sub-section (1) of Section 10 of the IndustrialDisputes Act, 1947 (for short the Act), the Governmentof Goa by order dated 27-10-95 bearing number28/51/95-LAB referred the following dispute foradjudication by this Tribunal.

“Whether the action of the management ofM/s. Goa Telecommunication and SystemsLtd., Mapusa Industrial Estate, Mapusa,Bardez, Goa, in terminating the services ofShri Vital V. Pai, Senior Accounts Assistant,with effect from 31-3-95, is legal justified?”

If not, to what relief the Workman isentitled?”

2. Upon receipt of the reference, a case wasregistered under No. IT/62/95 and registeredA. D notice was issued to the parties. In pursuance


796

to the said notice the parties put in theirappearance. The Workman/Party I (for shortWorkman) filed the statement of claim at Exb. 3whereas the Employer/Party II filed the writtenstatement at Exb. 5. Workman then filed therejoinder at Exb. 6.

3. It is in short the case of the Workman that hewas employed with Party II as Accounts Clerkw.e.f. 7-4-84. He was kept on probation for sixmonths and on satisfactory completion ofprobation period he was placed on higher gradew.e.f. 7-4-85 and later was promoted to the post ofAccounts Assistant grade “B” w.e.f. 7-4-88. Thatwithout obtaining his consent the Party II askedhim to function as a cashier which involved thework of handling of cash and other associatedduties and he accepted the abrupt change in hisduties under protest. That Party II did not reducein writing the specific duties entrusted to him asalso the procedure for accounting which he wasto follow for proper accountability inspite of hisoral request which resulted into argumentsbetween them. That he was served with five showcause notices within the short period from31-1-91 to 13-2-91 and was then charge sheetedon 27-2-191. That the charges levelled against himwere vague, biased and motivated and Party IIappointed one of their advocates as the enquiryofficer. That he requested in writing to changethe enquiry officer but Party II did not accept hisrequest. The enquiry lasted for about three yearsand throughout this period he was kept undersuspension. The enquiry was not conductedaccording to the rules and was closed abruptlywhen he did not agree with the approach of theenquiry officer as well as the manner in whichthe enquiry was being conducted. Not a singlecharge was proved against him and this isapparent from the enquiry report. That thereaftera show cause notice dated 20-2-95 was issued tohim and he replied the same by reply dated24-3-95. It is the contention of the Workman thatthe termination of his services by Party II is illegaland disproportionate to the minor lapses/offencesalleged against him. He has therefore prayed tohold that the action of Party II in terminating hisservices as illegal and unjustified, to directParty II to reinstate him in service immediatelywith all the back wages and service and if deemednecessary to order a fresh enquiry by any impartialand disinterested officer.

4. In the written statement it is the case ofParty II that the reference is not maintainablesince the services of Workman were terminated

by the company which was existing upto 31-3-95A.N.; that Party II has purchased majority sharesof the company and took over the managementwith the express understanding that it will employall such staff, workers etc. who are in employmentas on 31-3-95 and who are willing to work withParty II; that the Workman was not on the roles ofthe company as on 31-3-95 and that Party II wasnot under obligation to employ the Workman whowere dismissed by the company or who have leftthe services of the company as on 31-3-95. It isfurther stated by Party II that the duties of theWorkman were to prepare the payment vouchersof cash and bank, write cheques, handle cash,accept loan installments and account for the same,prepare credit vouchers for the same, prepare ‘C’forms, S: T. XI, Bank statements, tally the cash andsuch other work connected with the accounts andentrusted to him from time to time and theWorkman was aware of all such duties. Thatthough the Workman and other similarly situatedemployees from accounts department werepromoted to higher scale, grade or designationfrom time to time, the duties entrusted to themremained the same and they performed the sameduties. That one of the duties of the Workman wasto handle cash on rotation with other twoemployees and no separate cash handlingallowance was paid to them and it was introducedfor the first time in the settlement dated 20-2-90.That from 3-7-89 the Workman refused to handlethe cash repeatedly and therefore a charge-sheetwas issued to him and after holding the enquiryhe was awarded punishment of suspensionwithout wages for four days from 23-4-90 to26-4-90 and subsequently the Workman tookpossession of cash and handled the same. Thatfrom 28-1-91 the Workman started committingwillful acts of misconducts day to day till he wassuspended during the enquiry and he was issuedvarious show cause notices incorporatingmisconducts committed by him. That since theWorkman continued his acts of willfuldisobedience. He was charge-sheeted and anenquiry was conducted against him andsubsequently he was suspended from 18-2-91.That an independent officer was appointed toconduct the enquiry in which the Workman fullyparticipated and hew as given all and reasonableopportunities to defend himself. That the enquirywas conducted in fair and proper manner and theenquiry officer submitted his finding holding theWorkman guilty of the charges. That thereafter ashow cause notice was issued to the Workman towhich he submitted his explanation on 24-3-95but it was not found satisfactory. That taking into


797

consideration the gravity of the misconduct provedagainst the Workman and his past record, theWorkman was dismissed from service withimmediate effect. Vide amendment to the writtenstatement Party II has also taken the plea that itsfactory has been permanently closed w.e.f.31-12-08 and all the Workman and staff have beenretrenched on account of the closure. Thus, it isthe case of the Party II that termination of theservices of the Workman is legal and justified andthat the Workman is not entitled to any relief asclaimed.

5. In the rejoinder at Exb. 6 Party I has deniedthe averments made by Party II in the writtenstatement and in the additional rejoinder at Exb. 63Party I has stated that the factory is not closedand all the Workman are not retrenched but in thefactory premises, the Party II is conductingbusiness and the Workman are still employed withthe Party II.

6. On the above pleadings of both the partiesinitially the issues were framed on 8-3-96 atExb. 7 which read as under:

1. Whether the Party I proves that thedomestic enquiry held against him is notfair and proper?

2. Whether the charges of misconduct levelledagainst the Party I are proved to thesatisfaction of the tribunal by acceptableevidence?

3. Whether the Party II proves that thereference is not maintainable?

7. Upon recording evidence, by order dated7-7-98 it was held that the reference wasmaintainable and that the domestic enquiryconducted against the Workman was not fair andproper and therefore it was set aside. The partieshowever were given opportunities to leadevidence on the merits of the case and accordinglythe following additional issues were framed on27-7-98 vide Exb. 17.

Issue No. 2A: Whether the Party II proves thatParty I is guilty of the chargesof misconduct?

Issue No. 3A: Whether the Party I provesthat the action of Party II interminating his servicesw.e.f. 31-3-95 is illegal andunjustified?

8. Further additional issue was framed on5-1-10 at Exb. 65 and the same reads as under:

Issue No. 5: Whether the Party II provesthat the factory has beenpermanently closed w.e.f.31-12-08?

9. In the course of enquiry on merits, Party IIexamined the witnesses namely Shri TulshidasKerkar, Sr. Manager (Finance and Accounts)Mr. Sajro Naik (Asstt. Accounts Officer) Shri UdayKamat (Asstt. General Manager HR) andShri Prakash Tamse (Accounts Clerk). On the otherhand Party I examined himself and closed thecase.

10. It is apparent from the charge-sheet dated27-2-91 (Exb. 52) that the following acts ofmisconduct are levelled against Party I.

(a) Theft, fraud or dishonesty in connectionwith the company business or property ormisappropriation, embezzlement of money,property or goods of the company.

(b) Willful falsification, defacement,destruction or tempering with any recordof the company.

(c) Willful insubordination, disobedience ofany lawful/or reasonable order of thesuperiors.

(d) Willful slowing down in performance ofwork.

(e) Habitual neglect of work or gross orhabitual negligence.

(f) Breach of any rules or instructions givenby superiors, for the proper functioning ofthe establishment.

(g) Commission of any act subversive ofdiscipline or good behaviour on thepremises of the establishment.

11. The incidents of misconducts chargedagainst the Workman vide show cause noticesdated 31-1-91 (Exb. 34), 4-2-91 (Exb. 36), 5-2-91(Exb. 39), 7-2-91 (Exb. 42) and 13-2-91 (Exb. 47)have been enlisted in the charge-sheet at(Exb. 52).

12. It may be mentioned here that Shri T. Kerkarhas deposed in details about the charges levelledagainst the Workman vide the various show causenotices mentioned above. Witness Sazro Naik hasdeposed about the procedure for payment of bills.Shri Uday Kamat has been examined tosubstantiate the case of Party II that Party I hasbeen gainfully employed after the termination ofhis services and Shri Prakash Tamse has beenexamined to establish that the factory of Party II


798

was closed w.e.f. 31-12-08. Shri Vithal Naik hasstated that he was served with five show causenotices in concerted move to victimize and harasshim, between a period of fourteen days from31-1-91 to 13-2-91 and that he has replied each ofthese show cause notices. He has stated that heused to insist upon specific written instructionswhenever the established procedure of makingpayments was not being followed. He hasproduced various documents on record to whichreference would be made in the discussion tofollow.

13. Learned Adv. for Party II filed writtensubmissions at Exb. 69 and also advanced oralarguments. Even Learned Adv. for Party I filedshort written synopsis at Exb. 71 and advancedoral arguments.

14. Lnd. Adv. for Party II by relying on thejudgments in Food Corporation of India WorkersUnion v/s Food Corporation of India and Anr. 1996(74) FLR 1893 (SC) and in S. K. Awasthy v/s. M.R.Bhope, Presiding Officer, 1st Labour Court and Ors.1994 I CLR 254 contended that the Tribunal is nota Court; that there should be only ‘material’ andnot evidence as required by The Evidence Act;that on weighing the probabilities the Tribunalhas to only come to conclusion if the materialplaced before it is acceptable or probable and thatthe standard of proof required while assessing theevidence is of preponderance of probabilities andnot the proof beyond the reasonable doubt. Thereis no dispute about the above position of lawhowever since in the instant case the enquiry isheld as not fair and proper, the question of lookinginto the evidence recorded by the enquiry Officer,does not arise. In this context reliance is placedon the judgment in the case of Neeta Kaplish v/sPresiding Officer 1999 LAB I.C. 445 wherein it isobserved that in terms of Section 11-A of the Act,the record pertaining to the domestic enquirywould not constitute “fresh evidence” when theseproceedings have been found by the Court asdefective and therefore such record cannotconstitute “material on record”, as the enquiryproceedings on being found to be bad have to beignored. Thus, only the evidence adduced beforethis Court has to be considered while decidingthe above additional issues, by advetting to theprinciples culled out in the judgments in FoodCorporation and S.K. Awasthy (both cited supra)

15. I have gone through the records of the caseand have duly considered the arguments of boththe learned advocates. My findings on theadditional issues are as under:

Issue No. 2A ............ In the Negative.Issue No. 3A ............ In the Positive.Issue No. 5 ............ In the Positive.

REASONS

16. Issues No. 2A & 3A: Both these issues areanswered together for the sake of convenience asthey are interconnected, to avoid repetition of facts.

17. Charge 1 levelled against Party I videExb. 34 dated 31-1-1991 is that vide receiptNo. 097/89-90 dated 23-3-90, Party I had receivedan amount of ` 200/- from Mr. Xavier Mesquita,towards recovery of loan installment and Party Iwas required to account for the said amount inthe cash book by making necessary voucherhowever upon scrutiny of the cash book of therelevant period it is found that Party I has notaccounted for the said amount of `. 200/- and hasmisappropriated the said amount of` 200/-.

18. In reply to the above charge vide reply dated11-2-91 at Exb. 46. Party I has admitted the receiptof the amount of ` 200/- from Mr. Xavier Mesquitaon 23-3-90 and of he preparing the receipt atExb. E-4. It is also his contention that on the sameday he prepared the credit voucher and passed iton to the dealing clerk for entering the same inthe cash book and the amount was deposited inthe cash box maintained by him and not in hispocket

19. It is stated by Tulshidas Kerkar that Party Iwas given the work of preparing cash vouchers,bank vouchers, issue of receipts for cash andbank, preparing credit vouchers, receiving loaninstallments, tallying of cash, issue of C forms,ST form 11, bank reconciliation and such otherwork as per exigencies. The above statement ofTulshidas Kerkar is not seriously denied byParty I. This is because Shri Vithal Pai has producedhis appointment letter dated 31-3-84 at Exb. 27and another letter dated 7-10-84 addressed byManaging Director to him at Exb. 28 and in hiscross examination made it clear that vide Exb. 28his service as Accounts Clerk was confirmed. Hehas also stated that as Accounts Clerk he wasrequired to do the work as entrusted to him bythe Superiors in the Accounts Department. ShriPai has produced letter dated 2-6-88 addressed tohim by the Managing Director wherein he waspromoted to the post of “Accounts-AssistantGrade “B” at Exb. 29 and has made it clear in hiscross examination that Exb. 29 does not mentionany separate service conditions which were


799

applicable to him and it also does not say that hisservice conditions had changed with hispromotion. Mr. Vithal Kamat has further producedletter dated 20-3-90 at Exb. 30 wherein he wasredesignated as Sr. Accounts Assistant by makingit clear that nature of his duties still remained thesame. He has admitted that as per Exb. 30 he wasrequired to do such other work pertaining to theaccounts as assigned to him. No doubt, he hasalso stated that cash handling is not the job of anaccountant and that it has to be done by a cashierbut he has further stated that the cashier workersin the Accounts Department. Nevertheless, thefact that remains is that at the relevant timeMr. Pai was allotted the duties of handling thecash.

20. Shri Kerkar has produced a receipt dated23-3-1990 towards receipt of amount of ` 200/-from Mr. Xavier Mesquita towards repayment ofloan, at Exb. E- 4. He has identified the signatureof Party I on this receipt and has stated that asper the procedure after the receipt is issued, theParty I prepares a credit voucher which isauthorized for payment by him and then it is sentto the dealing clerk for serial numbering andentering in the petty cash book and thereafter itis sent for computerizing. It may be mentionedhere that the above procedure explained by thiswitness and which is also stated by Shri SazroNaik is otherwise not disputed. It is thus clearfrom the above statement of Mr. Kerkar that creditvoucher is sent for computerizing only after it isserially numbered and entered in the petty cashbook by dealing hand. This in turn makes it clearthat there is a separate dealing hand for seriallynumbering and entering the credit vouchers inthe petty cash book. Shri Kerkar has categoricallystated that for receipt dated 23-3-90 at Exb. E-4no credit voucher was prepared by Party I norcash book entry was made in respect of the saidvoucher. He was shown credit vouchers dated5-3-90, 6-3-90, 9-3-90, 12-3-90, 21-3-90, 22-3-90,26-3-90, 29-3-90, 30-3-90 and 31-3-90 bearingNos. A-126 to A-141 and he has identified theabove vouchers except the one bearing A-135,A-140 and A-141 as the ones prepared by Party I.These vouchers are marked as Exb-E-5 colly.

21. No doubt, Shri Kerkar has not stated in clearterms that voucher dated 23-3-90 is not amongstthe above mentioned voucher which are seriallynumbered from A-126 to A-141 but a judicial notecan be definitely taken of the said fact since thesaid vouchers are the records of the Party II andthus a presumption can definitely be drawn that

voucher dated 23-3-90 is missing from amongstthe vouchers at serial Nos. A-126 to A-141 onlybecause it was not prepared. Thus, the contentionof Party I that he had prepared a voucher relatingto the receipt at Exb. E-4 and handed it over tothe dealing clerk, cannot be prima facie accepted.

22. It is pertinent to note that in his crossexamination Mr. Kerkar has also made it clear thatsince the credit voucher is not prepared thediscrepancy regarding less amount of ` 200/- inthe petty cash would not reflect.

23. As regards making entry in the petty cashbook, it is clear from the own showing of Party IIthat it is the work of the dealing hand andtherefore the question of imposing the charge ofnot making entry in the petty cash book onParty I, does not arise. I have already mentionedabove that the entries in the vouchers are sent forcomputerizing only after they are recorded in thecash book and in this context cross examination ofMr. Kerkar reveals that either Mr. Tamse, Mr. SazroNaik or Mr. Jagannath Parsekar were doing thework of computer feeding in respect of the recordsof the Accounts department. He has also statedthat party I used to send the work of computerfeeding to anyone of the above said persons.Nevertheless, the fact that remains that thequestion of computer feeding would arise only ifin the first place the credit voucher is prepared.

24. In his cross-examination Shri Kerkar has alsostated that the instances of theft, fraud ordishonesty have been mentioned in the noticedated 31-1-91 (Exb. 34) and according to him theParty I has committed the theft since he did notprepare a credit voucher nor made available thesaid voucher of ` 200/-. I have already stated inthe preceding paras about the allegation levelledagainst Party I vide first charge and apparently itdoes not include the charge of theft. I have alsodiscussed supra that voucher dated 23-3-90 wasnot prepared by Party I and it therefore followsthat the subsequent procedure of Shri T. Kerkarauthorizing the same for payment or the dealinghand entering it in the cash book or sending it forcomputerization was not followed. It is thereforeclear that Party II has succeeded in establishingthat Party I has not made the necessary vouchertowards an amount of ` 200/- and hence no entryto that effect is found in cash book. Shri Kerkarhas stated in his cross-examination that thecash-book was tallied every day. Even Shri SazroNaik has made it clear in his cross examinationthat at the end of the day the amount mentionedin the cash book has to be verified with the amount


800

existing in the cash box. In the context of aboveevidence it is submitted by learned advocate forParty I that with regards to this charge there is noevidence to indicate that the amount mentionedin the cash book was tallied with the amount inthe cash box as according to him Party I had keptthe said amount in the cash box. Evidence onrecord also indicates that the cash box in theaccounts department and the keys of the sameremain with the cashier and in this case with Party Isince he was handling the cash. Shri Kerkar wasshown the computerized cash book for the monthof March, ’90 from the file of original enquiryproceeding at Exb.E-l colly which shows theentries towards receipts and expenditure for themonth of March, ’90 and this computerized cashbook is marked as Exb. E-6. He has also stated thatthe amount of ` 200/- mentioned in Exb. E-4 isnot reflected in Exb. E-6 and that as per Exb. E-6Party I had in his hand an amount of Rs. 8561.01at the end of March, 1990. Shri Kerkar was alsoshown petty cash book for the period from 2-4-90to 5-4-90 from Exb. E-I colly. alongwith thesupporting vouchers which are marked asExb. E-7 colly. and he has stated that as perExb. E-7 colly. the opening balance was Rs. 8561.01and that Party I was holding the said amount.Thus, it can be safely inferred from the aboveevidence that in case the Party I had kept the saidamount of ` 200/- in the cash box on 23-3-90,the opening balance on 2-4-90 would not showthe same amount of ` 561.01 which was theamount in a cash book at the end of March, ’90 asin such a case the opening balance as on 20-4-90would be ` 8561.01 + Rs. 200/- i.e. ` 8761.01.Thus, it is clear that the arguments for learnedadvocate for Party I that Party I had kept theamount of ` 200/- in the cash box do not meritconsideration. It is further clear from the nature ofabove evidence that the reply at Exb. 46 filed byParty I to this charge No. 1 is not in line with thematerial brought on record in the deposition ofShri Kerkar Party II having established that Party Ihas failed to account for the said amount ofRs. 200/- and Party I having failed, to prove thathe had kept the said amount of ` 200/- in thecash box, the only inference that could be drawnon the basis of evidence adduced before this Court isthat Party I has misappropriated the said amountof ` 200/- and therefore it is clear that theParty II has succeeded in proving charge No. I asagainst Party I.

25. As regard the second charge levelled videExb. 34 dated 31-1-91, it states that on 28-11-89an amount of ` 91.60 was passed for payment

and sent to Party I for payment; that Party Iprepared necessary voucher on that day by makingthe entry “paid 28-11-89” on the statement ofaccounts submitted by Mr. Zalmi and necessaryentry was made in the cash book for having paidthe said amount on 28-11-89 but it was noticedthat Party I did not make payment but retainedthe aforesaid amount for his personal use upto23-12-89 and also tempered with the originalpayment voucher for his advantage.

26. In reply to this charge vide reply dated11-2-91 (Exb. 46) Party I has admitted that theamount of ` 91.60 was passed for payment on28-11-91 and on the same day he prepared thenecessary voucher for payment but Mr. Zalmi didnot turn upto receive the payment and the paymentwas made on 23-11-89 when Mr. Zalmi reportedfor the payment. It is also stated that during theintervening period the amount was held in thecash box as usual.

27. Shri Kerkar has produced a xerox copy ofsaid voucher along with statements dated20-11-89 at Exb. E-9 colly. He has stated that thereis stamp “paid” on Exb. E-9 colly and there isoverwriting of the date as the earlier datementioned 28-11-89 has been changed to23-12-89. Thus, according to him an amount of` 91.60 accounted for as on 28-11-89 was heldby Party I till 23-12-89. It is pertinent to note thatin his cross examination Shri Kerkar has admittedthat he had not checked the cash book of28-11-89; that he does not know whether on28-11-89 the amount of ` 91.60 was less as perthe cash tallying on that date; that he did notinspect the cash box on 28-11-89 and non of theofficials had made inspection of the cash box on28-11-89. He has denied the suggestion thatamount of ` 91.60 was always there in the cashbox till the time Mr. Pratap Jalmi came to collectthe cash on 23-12-89. He has also denied asuggestion that Party I had prepared a voucher on28-11-89 presuming that Mr. Pratap Jalmi wouldcome on that date to collect the amount. He hashowever admitted that said Pratap Jalmi cameonly on 23-12-89. To the suggestion that on23-12-89 Party I took the signature of Pratap Jalmion the stamp receipt and corrected the date onE-9 colly and thereafter paid the amount of` 91.60 from the cash box to Pratap Jalmi,Shri Kerkar has expressed ignorance. Thus fromthe nature of above evidence brought on record inthe cross-examination of Mr. Kerkar it becomesclear that Shri Kerkar has not ruled out thepossibility of Party I paying an amount of


801

` 91.60 from the cash box to Shri Pratap Jalmi on23-12-89 after correcting the date on Exb. E-9 colly,though he had prepared the voucher on28-11-1989 even for that matter it is noted thatParty II has not examined Shri Jalmi to find out ifthe contention of Party I that he had not paid theamount reflected in the voucher dated 28-11-89as the concerned person had not turned up, iscorrect. That apart, no evidence has been adducedby Party II to establish that during the interveningperiod i.e. from 28-11-89 to 23-12-89, Party I utilizedthe said amount for his personal use. This beingthe situation, it become clear that Party II hasfailed to prove with cogent and convincingevidence that Party I retained the said amountfor his personal use upto 23-12-89 or that hetempered with the original payment voucher forhis advantage and this is more because, there isno evidence on record suggesting any tamperingwith the original voucher by Party I.

28. The third charge levelled against Party I videExb. 34 dated 31-1-91 is that on 19-5-90 Party Ireceived a cash of ` 190/- from the Workmen ofParty II towards payment of telephone calls butParty I did not account for the same on the verysame day by making necessary voucher andaccounted for the same on 25-5-90 therebyunauthorizedly used the Company’s cash for hispersonal use.

29. In reply to the above charge vide Exb. 46dated 11-2-91 Party I has admitted of havingreceived an amount of ` 190/- and also of havingreceived receipt towards it. It is also stated byParty I that on the same day the credit voucherwas prepared and passed on to the dealing handfor necessary entry in the cash book and theamount was deposited in the cash box.

30. Shri Kerkar has produced the receipt dated19-5-90 issued by Party I towards receipt ofamount of ` 190/- at Exb. E-10. He has alsoproduced a xerox copy of the credit voucher dated25-5-90 at Exb. E-11 and the xerox copy of pettycash book showing the entries from 15-5-90 to29-5-90 at Exb. E-12 colly, He has stated that asper the entry in the petty cash book, the saidamount of ` 190/- was accounted for on 25-5-90.He has also produced the xerox copy of thecomputerized cash book for the period from18-5-90 to 26-5-90 at Exb. E-13 colly and has statedthat as per the Exb. E-13 colly the said amountof ` 190/- was accounted on 25-5-90. He hasidentified the signature of Party I at Exb. E-12colly. According to him during the period from19-5-90 to 25-5-90 the said amount was lying with

Party I. There is otherwise no dispute on the partof Party I that he prepared the credit voucher atExb. E-11 on 25-5-90 and this is because it is hisdefence while cross examining Shri Kerkar, thatMr. Tamse made entry of ` l90/- in the petty cashbook at Exb. E-12 colly on 25-5-90 only becausethe credit voucher at Exb. E-1 mentions the dateas 25-5-90 though it is further the defence ofParty I that Exb. E-11 was prepared by him on19-5-90 and it was left incomplete because he wasnot aware as to under what head of account theamount was to be credited. It may be mentionedhere that in his cross examination Shri Vithal Paiwas shown a receipt for payment dated 19-5-90at Exb. E-10 colly and Shri Pai has admitted thathe had prepared the same. He was also shownxerox copy of petty cash book at Exb. E-12 collyand upon this he has stated that some of theseentries in this cash book relate to petty cash andsome are not. He has confirmed the entries madeon 24-5-90, 25-5-90 and 26-5-90 and stated that hehad initiated the same. He has however statedthat the entries in the petty cash book were madeby billing clerk and not by him and that the saidamount of ` 190/- was entered by the billing clerkin the petty cash book on 25-5-90. It may bementioned here that if Party I had sent the voucherto the dealing clerk on 19-5-90 for making entry inthe petty cash book at Exb. E-12 colly then at thetime of verifying the cash on 24-5-90 he shouldhave realized that the entry of ` 190/- was notmade in the cash book this fact by itself goes toestablish that Party I had not accounted for thesaid money before 24-5-90. It is therefore clear thatParty I has failed to establish his defence projectedthrough his reply at Exb. 46 and therefore the onlyinference which could be drawn on the basis ofevidence before the Court is that Party I hasunauthorizedly used the companies cash duringthe period between 19-5-90 to 24-5-90. Thus, it isclear that Party II has succeeded in provingcharge No. 3 as against Party I.

31. Coming to the fourth charge levelled againstParty I vide Exb. 36 dated 4-2-1991, it relates torefusal by Party I to make payment to Mr. A.Oliveira, against a cash memo No. 9129 dated28-1-91 of M/s. Natekar Drugists and Chemists on28-1-91. The charge also states that the said billwas certified for payment and was sent to Party Ifor making the payment upon which Party Iprepared the voucher, got it certified but whenMr. A. Oliveira approached for collection of cash,Party I refused to make the payment without anyreason and returned the voucher alongwith cashmemo to Dy. Manager (Accounts) and even


802

thereafter when instructed with Dy. Manager(Accounts) to make the payment, Party I refusedto obey his orders.

32. In reply to the above charge vide Exb. 50dated 18-2-91, Party I has admitted that Mr. A.Oliveira came to him with the aforesaid cashmemo for receiving payment but according to himhe asked Mr. A. Oliveira to sign on the voucher forhaving received the payment which he receivedand to ensure that the payment was made againstthe correct bill he asked Mr. A. Oliveira refuse tosign as recipient which was essential since cashmemo was not inwarded as per practice.

33. In the above context, Shri Kerkar hasproduced the said bill dated 28-1-91 alongwiththe voucher dated 28-1-1991 at Exb. E-16 collyand has stated that Party I sent the said voucherfor authorization which he did and sent to Mr. A.Oliveira to be handed over to Party I for receivingthe payment from him. He has stated that Party Idid not make the payment to Mr. Oliveira butreturned Exb. E-16 colly with an endorsement onthe reverse page of the bill stating that the nameof the person to whom the amount to be paid isnot written and also that the bill was not inwardedand the receivers sign was not on the bill. He hasstated that thereafter he called Party I in his cabinand told him to make the payment to Mr. Oliveirabut Party I did not make the payment and thispayment was subsequently made by Mr. Tamsewhen Party I had gone on leave.

34. In his cross examination on the above chargeShri T. Kerkar has stated that looking at Exb. E-16colly it cannot be made out to whom it was issuedand that on the said bill there is no mention as towhom the amount was to be paid. So also, on thepayment voucher there is no mention as to whomthe amount had to be handed over.

35. It may be mentioned here that though asper charge four it is the contention of Party II thatParty I refused to make payment to Mr. A. Oliveirawithout any reason, in his examination in ChiefShri T. Kerkar has stated the reason for whichParty I refused to make payment to Mr. Oliveirawhich is by making endorsement on the reverseof the bill that the name of the person to whomthe amount was to be paid was not written, thatthe bill was not inwarded and that the receiver’ssign was not on the bill. Thus, it is clear that therefusal to make the payment by Party I was dueto specific reasons mentioned by Shri T. Kerkar. Itis pertinent to note that Party I has not examinedMr. Tamse and therefore the statement made by

Shri T. Kerkar that the said amount wassubsequently paid to Mr. Oliveira by Mr. Tamse,when Party I had gone on leave is not supportedby any evidence. In the cross examination ofShri Vithal Pai he was shown vouchers No. B 1787,B 1789, B 2082, B 2350, B 2397 and B 2577 whichformed part of Exb. E-3 colly and Shri Pai hasadmitted that these vouchers were prepared byhim and the payment was also made by him soalso that the signature of recipient of cash wasnot obtained on these vouchers as the paymentwas made against the cash bills produced by therecipients. As rightly pointed out by learnedadvocate for Party I the above vouchers have beenshown to Shri Pai mainly to establish that in thepast Mr. Pai was making the payments withoutobtaining the signature of the recipient, howeverit deserves to be noted that charge four levelledagainst Party I does not speak about any practicewhich was being followed or prevailed whilemaking payment against the vouchers andtherefore confronting Mr. Pai with the aforesaidvouchers, is of no consequence. Apparently, thecash memo dated 28-1-91 was in the name ofM/s. Natekar Druggists and Chemists and theamounts was to be reimbursed to Mr. A. Oliveiraand therefore in the absence of details which wererequired by Party I, one would not know as towhom the said amount was to be paid. Thus, Ifind no reason to hold that Party I refused to makepayment to Mr. A. Oliveira without any reasonresulting in disobedience of the orders of thesuperiors.

36. The fifth charge levied against Party I videExb. 36 dated 4-2-91 is that the Party I on 21-1-91refused to hand over cash amount towardsbill No 2081 of Shri Manguirish Enterprisespresented by one Mr. Mayuresh Khaunte fortaking cash and upon refusal of Party I to makethe payment to Mr. Khaunte the Dy. Manager(Accounts) instructed him to make the paymentsbut he refuse to obey the said orders.

37. In reply to the above charge vide Exb. 50dated 18-2-91, Party I has stated that since thebill was only checked for purchase order, headvised Mr. Khaute to get it certified also forpayment by the officer and in the alternative heasked Mr. Khaute to sign for having received thepayment against the relevant payment voucherwhich he refused.

38. In the context of above charge Shri T. Kerkarhas produced the Xerox copy of the said voucherand the bill at Exb. E-17 colly. He has stated thatafter he certified the said bill and sent it to Party I


803

for preparing the voucher which Party I did andsent back to him for authorization and after heauthorized the said voucher for making paymentand sent it back to Party I through Mr. Khaute formaking payment, Party I did not make thepayment. That thereafter he personally went toParty I and told him to make the payment butParty I did not make the payment to Mr. Khauteand subsequently the payment was made byMr. Tamse when Patty I was on leave.

39. In the cross examination of Shri T. Kerkar onthe above subject upon being shown cash billdated 23-1-91 at Exb. E-17 colly he has admittedthat there is no certification for payment inExb. E-17 colly. Further upon being shown thepayment voucher dated 29-1-91 at Exb. E-17 collyShri Kerkar has stated that it is not mentioned inthe said voucher that the amount could be paid toanyone other than Shri Manguirish Enterprises. Hehas also stated that Mr. Mayuresh Khaute is notan employee of Mr. Manguirish Enterprises. Hehas further stated that there is no signature ofMr. Mayurish Khaute on this voucher inacknowledgement of the receipt of the amount.He has admitted that there is no record withParty II that Mr. Mayurish Khaute had actually hadreceived the amount.

40. From the nature of above evidence itbecomes clear that there was no certification forpayment in the cash bill at Exb. E-17 colly andsecondly there was nothing in the said voucherindicating that the amount could be paid toanyone much less to Mr. Khaute who was not anemployee of Manguirish Enterprises. As regardsthe statement of Shri Kerkar the said amount waspaid to Mr. Khaute by Mr. Tambse when Party Iwas on leave, from his cross examination itbecomes clear that they do not have any suchrecords. That apart, Mr. Mayuresh Khaute has notbeen examined by Party II to support their caseregarding this charge. Thus, I am of the opinionthat in the circumstances pointed out above itwould not proper to say that Party I refused tohand over the cash to Mr. Khaute without anyreason and consequently this cannot called asdisobedience of the orders of the superiors.

41. The sixth charge levied against Party I isvide Exb. 39 dated 5-2-91. In terms of this chargeon 4-2-91 a bill was sent to Party I for makingpayment to Mr. Krishna Satardekar (as per billdated 2-2-91 of Mrs. Shobha K. Satardekar)towards cost of water proof bags supplied by her.The bill was duly certified for payment byDy. Manager (Pers & Admn. and Managing

Director) however of instead of making cashpayment, as per normal practice Party I returnedthe bill to Dy. Manager (Accounts) with remarksto tell whether the cheque was to be drawn orcash was to be paid to Krishna. The charge alsostates that Party I was called by Dy. Manager(Accounts) and instructed to make the paymentin cash but despite this he refused to makepayment and insisted for orders in writing to makepayment in cash.

42. In reply to the above charge vide Exb. 51dated 19-2-91 Party I has stated that to avoidduplication of work and unnecessary argumentwith his officer he asked the officer to indicatethe mode of payment because on several occasionshis officer had asked him to cancel cheques whenprepared and ordered him to pay in cash.

43. In his evidence on the above charge Shri T.Ketkar has produced the xerox copy of the billdated 2-2-91 at Exb. E-20. He has stated that thisbill was produced by Mr. Krishna Satardekartowards stitching charges of water proof bags fromMrs. Shobha Satardekar. He has stated that thisbill was certified for payment by the ManagingDirector on 2-2-91 and it was sent to Party I on4-2-91 for preparing voucher and making thepayment. He has stated that Party I did not preparethe voucher but put a remark on the bill askingwhether the cheque was to be drawn or theamount was to be paid in cash. He has stated thathe then called Party I in his cabin and told himthat no written instructions are required for routinematters and that he should make the payment.He has stated that he made the remarks in writingon the reverse of the said bill but inspite of hisinstructions Party I did not make the payment. Hehas stated that prior to 4-2-91 Party I had madethe payments without any written instructions.He has produced the Xerox copies of the vouchersdated 13-11-90, 23-5-90 and 27-7-90 at Exb. E-21colly and has stated that vouchers dated 23-5-90and 27-7-90 were prepared by Party I and he hadmade the payments and that these vouchers donot carry remarks from Party I seeking writteninstructions as to how the payment was to bemade i.e. whether in cash or cheque or to whomit is to be made. In his cross-examinationShri Kerkar has made it clear that a bill atExb. E-20 is in the name of Mrs. ShobhaSatardekar; that he has put a remark on the billthat the payment was to be made to Mr. KrishnaSatardekar and he has admitted that there are noinstructions on Exb. E-20 from Mrs. ShobhaSatardekar that the amount in the bill was to be


804

paid to Shri Krishna Satardekar. He has alsoadmitted that sometimes the bill amount is paidto a party in cash and sometimes by way ofcheque. He has further stated that whether theamount was to be paid in cash or by cheque isnot decided by Party I but by the controlling officer.He has also admitted that in the vouchers atExb. E-21 colly there are instructions as to whomand how the payment of the bill is to be made.

44. In the light of above evidence of Mr. Kerkarit becomes clear that though he has stated thatfor day to day routine matters no writteninstructions are given but by producing the billsat Exb. E-21 colly, in the same breathe, he hasadmitted that in Exb. E-21 colly there areinstructions as to whom and how the paymentsare to be made. That apart, it is also clear fromhis evidence that whether the amount is to bepaid by cheque or in cash is decided by thecontrolling officer. Thus, in such situation it wouldnot be proper and justified to say that it was wrongon the part of Party I to put remark on Exb. E-20asking as to whether the cheque was to be drawnor the amount was to be paid in cash. Even forthat matter, perusal of Exb. E-20 makes it clearthat Shri Kerkar has made endorsement on thesame which reads as under:

“Shri Pai was called by me and asked to paycash to Shri Krishna Satardekar on 4-2-91around 12.00 p.m. Mr. Pai replied that hewanted instructions in writing only.”

Sd/-4-2-91

45. As rightly pointed out by Learned Advocatefor Party I reading of above endorsement byShri Kerkar makes it clear that it is a notingmentioning as to what had happened afterParty I refused to make payment to Shri KrishnaSatardekar and there is nothing in the aboveendorsement indicating that Shri Kerkar gave anyinstructions to Party I that he should make cashpayment to Mr. Krishna. Even otherwise, there isnothing on record to indicate that there wereinstructions from Mrs. Shobha Satardekar that shehad authorized Mr. Krishna Satardekar to acceptthe payment on her behalf. This being thesituation, it would not be out of place to say thatthere was no disobedience of the orders of thesuperiors by Party I, with respect to the abovecharge.

46. Now coming to seventh charge leviedagainst Party I vide Exb. 39 dated 5-2-91, it statesthat Party I refused another bill received from

Goa, Daman and Diu Industrial DevelopmentCorporation towards payment of water chargesby putting the remarks to let him know whethercheque was to be drawn or cash was to be paidto G.D.D.I.D.C. It further states that Party I wasagain called by the Dy. Manager (Accounts) andinstructed that as per the prevailing practice hewas to issue cheque in the name of the Party andsend it to the party but Party I again refused todraw the cheque and insisted that the order shouldbe given in writing.

47. In reply to the above charge vide Exb. 51dated 19-2-91 Party I has stated that he asked theofficer to indicate the mode of payment to avoidduplication of work since on several occasions hisofficer had asked her to cancel the cheques whenprepared and ordered her to pay in cash.

48. Shri Kerkar has stated that on 4-2-91 G.D.D.I.D.C. submitted a bill dated 30-1-91 for an amountof ` 150/-, towards the payment of water charges.He has produced the xerox copy of this bill atExb. E-22 and has identified the signature ofParty I below the remark on the reverse page ofthis bill. He has stated that this bill was certifiedby Managing Director and sent to Party I forpreparing voucher and making the payment butParty I returned the bill to him asking as towhether the payment was to be made in cash orby cheque. In his cross examination, Shri Kerkarwas shown an earlier bill of G.D.D.I.D.C. markedas Exb. E-23 and upon perusal of the same hestated that with respect to this bill Party I hadasked him as to whether the payment should bemade in cheque or by cash and for instruction tobe given in writing.

49. He was also shown the vouchers at Exb. 23colly and upon perusal of the same Shri Kerkarhas stated in the said vouchers it is mentioned asto in which manner the payment was to be made.He has also admitted that two days prior to theabove bill similar instructions were sought fromhim by Party I. It is therefore clear from the aboveevidence that instructions are sought each timeby Party I to know the manner in which thepayment has to be made. It may be mentionedhere that Shri Kerkar has also made it clear thatthe payment has to be made in cash or by chequeis not decided by Party I but by the controllingofficer. This statement of Shri Kerkar by itselfindicates that every bill has to show mode of itspayment and considering this position it wouldnot be proper to say that Party I disobeyed theorders of his superiors wherein he was told thathe has to issue the cheque in favour of G.D.D.I.D.C.


805

as per the prevailing practice since it is apparentfrom above discussion that no any practice as suchprevailed while making the payments towards thebills presented.

50. As regards the eighth charge levelled againstParty I vide Exb. 42 dated 7-2-1991, it states thaton 4-2-91 at 11.30 a.m. Party I was instructed todraw a self cheque of ` 1,39,919.05 towards thewages of the staff and Workmen for the month ofJanuary, 1991 but Party I refused to draw thesaid cheque upon which it was drawn by theDy. Manager (Accounts) himself and this act onthe part of Party I amounted to disobedience oflawful and reasonable orders of his superior.

51. In reply to the above charge vide Exb. 51dated 19-2-91 Party I has stated that the selfcheque could not be drawn by him as his officerdid not give him any specific instructions eitherverbally or in writing.

52. In the above context Shri T. Kerkar has statedthat the procedure followed for the payment ofsalary to the employees of Party II was thatParty I had to write a self cheque for withdrawingthe amount from the bank and prepare a voucherin respect of the amount mentioned in the chequeand thereafter the said cheque and the voucherare to be sent to him (Shri Kerkar) for his signature.He has stated that the amount to be withdrawnfor the payment of the salary of the employeeswas being informed to Party I orally or by writingon a piece of paper. He has stated that prior toFebruary, 1991, Party I was following the aboveprocedure. This witness was shown vouchersdated 4-1-90, 4-10-90, 5-11-90, 4-12-90 and 4-1-91from Exb. E-1 colly and he has stated that thesevouchers were prepared by Party I. The same aremarked as Exb. E-27 colly. He has stated that on4-2-91 he called Party I and asked him to draw aself cheque for ` 1,39,919.05 by giving instructionsin writing on a piece of paper and he has producedthe said piece of paper which is in his handwritingat Exb. E-28. He has stated that Party I told himthat he would not draw the said self cheque unlessit is mentioned on the said piece of paper as“certified for payment” and Party I returned thesaid piece of paper back to him. He has statedthat thereafter he prepared the voucher anddrew the said self cheque for the amount of` 1,39,919.05 and he has produced the said voucherdated 4-2-91 (from Exb. E-1 colly) at Exb. E-29.

53. In his cross examination upon being shownthe piece of paper at Exb. E-28 he has stated thatonly the amount is mentioned on this document.He has also admitted that if a third person looks

at Exb. E-28 he would not know as to what is tobe done with the said amount in the paper. He hasfurther admitted that if an auditor looks at thepaper at Exb. E-28 he would not know as to whatis to be done about the amount mentioned in thepaper. He has denied the suggestion that thepayment vouchers at Exb. E-27 colly wereprepared by Party I based on the statementsfurnished to him and that in the case of theincident on 4-2-91 no such statement wasfurnished to Party I but piece of paper at Exb.E-28 was furnished to him. He has also stated thatin the payment voucher at Exb. E-29 there is noreference to any statement.

54. As rightly pointed out by Learned Adv. forParty I charge 8 mentioned supra does not speakof any procedure that was followed for paymentof salary to the employees of Party II and thereforethe production of vouchers at Exb. E-27 colly toestablish the so called procedure that was followedis of no significance. That apart, no evidence hasbeen produced by Shri Kerkar to indicate thatpayment at vouchers at Exb. E-27 colly wereprepared by Party I without there being anystatements, furnished to him and therefore in theabsence of any such evidence it is rather hard forme to come to the conclusion that any suchpractice as stated by Shri Kerkar prevailed.Nevertheless, the tact that deserves considerationis that there is admission on the part of Shri Kerkarthat if a third party or an auditor looks atExb. E-28 they would not know as to what wasto be done about to the amount mentioned inExb. E-28. It therefore follows from above thatExb. E-28 by itself did not indicate anything or forthat matter it was not an authoritative piece ofpaper. At any rate, since it is clear from abovediscussion that Party II has failed to establish thatfor the payment of salary to the employees ofParty II, a certain procedure towards drawing ofthe cheque was followed and therefore in my viewthe question of Party I disobeying the orders ofsuperior does not arise and hence Party II hasfailed to prove this charge.

55. Coming to charge number nine leviedagainst Party I vide Exb. 42 dated 7-2-91, it statesthat on 5th Feb., 1991 at 9.30 am a copy of letterNo.GTEL/ACCTS/GEN/4453 dated 2-1-1991,addressed to the Manager, Syndicate Bank,Mapusa was sent to Party I was making creditvoucher since the party to whom the cheque wasissued had not presented the cheque No. 360061dated 14-12-1989, for more than one year and thepayment was stopped. That Party I refused to obey


806

the instructions of the Dy. Manager (Accounts)and returned the said letter to the Dy. Manager(Accounts) and this act on the part of Party Iamounted to misconduct of disobedience of lawfulorders of the superior.

56. In reply to the above charge vide Exb. 51dated 19-2-91 Party I has stated that since theletter dated 23-1-91 addressed to the SyndicateBank, Mapusa was given to him for preparing acredit voucher on 5-2-91, he requested the officerto indicate the date thereon so that he could notbe later on blamed for delaying action.

57. In the above context, it is stated by Shri T.Kerkar that a cheque was issued in favour of HCLLtd., and it was not presented for payment for along time. That Shri Kerkar wrote letter dated23-1-91 to the Manager of the Syndicate Bankasking for stopping of the said cheque and he hasproduced the said letter at Exb. E-30. He hasstated that he told Party I to prepare a creditvoucher for the amount of ` 700/- and handedover to him copy of Exb. E-30 on 5-2-91 howeverParty I told him that unless he puts a remark onExb. E-30 that it was handed over to him on5-2-91, he would not prepare the voucher. He hasstated that he did not put the remark and thatParty I did not prepare the voucher. He has statedthat there was no procedure of putting a remarkon any letter that was handed over to Party I on aparticular date and that earlier the Party I hadprepared the vouchers in similar situations. Hehas stated that Party II had issued a cheque infavour of Pack n Print for ` 5,679/- drawn onSyndicate Bank, Mapusa but the said cheque waslost by the company and it was informed toParty II by the company by letter dated 4-5-90which letter he has produced at Exb. E-31. He hasstated that at the request of company a freshcheque was to be issued and therefore Party I wasasked to prepare a voucher for the above saidamount. He has stated that the letter at Exb. E-31was sent to Party I for preparing the voucher on9-5-90 without any remark on it stating that it wassent on 9-5-90 and despite it Party I had preparedthe voucher dated 9-5-90. He has produced thesaid voucher at Exb. E-32 and has identified thesignature of Party I on the same. He has statedthat he had sent one letter dated 4-12-90 to theManager, Syndicate Bank, Panaji requesting thestopping of payment of cheque dated 30-8-90 for` 122/- issued in favour of Virgo ComputerConsultants and he has produced the said letterat Exb. E-33. He has stated that this letter wassent to Party I on 17-12-90 for preparing voucher

in respect of the amount of ` 122/-, withoutendorsement on it stating that the said letterwas sent to Party I on 17-12-90 and despite itParty I had prepared the voucher dated 17-12-90for the amount of ` 122/- and he had producedthe said voucher at Exb. E-34. He has identifiedthe signature on Exb. E-34. He has stated thatParty II had issued a cheque in favour of ArkayElectroplating Company for the sum of ` 2,213.85which was subsequently cancelled and Party Iwas verbally told to prepare a voucher forthe above amount which Party I prepared on21-12-90. He has produced the said voucher atExb. E-35.

58. In his cross examination upon being shownthe letter dated 23-1-91 at Exb. E-30 Shri T. Kerkarhas admitted that there are no instructions toParty I, on this letter. He has also stated thatExb. E-30 does not indicate that it was handedover to Party I by him on 5-2-91. He has also statedthat in reply to the show cause notice, Party I hadstated that he should put the date on which hewas instructed to prepare the voucher so that heshould not be blamed later on, for the delay inpreparing the voucher since the letter was dated23-1-91. He has denied the suggestion that justprior to 5-2-91 there were differences between himand Party I regarding the performance of duty byParty I. He has also denied the suggestion thatthe inference by Exb. E-32, that Party I had notsought instructions previously is not relevant inthe matter of 5-1-91 since it referred to a letter of23-1-91 and that the Party I wanted the date toabsolve himself from the allegation of delay.

59. As rightly pointed out by Learned Adv. forParty I reading of charge nine above makes it clearthat there is nothing in it indicating that as a matterof practice and the procedure followed in casesfor preparing credit vouchers no date was put onwhich instructions were given to prepare thevouchers. Being so, the question of looking intoExb. E-32, to say that Party I had not soughtinstructions previously while preparing thevouchers does not arise. Even for that matter,admittedly Exb. E-30 does not indicate that it washanded over to Party I by Shri T. Kerkar on 5-2-91and therefore the basis for levelling this chargepertaining to the incident dated 5-2-91, is notknown. It is also apparent from the tenor of crossexamination of Shri T. Kerkar on this charge, thatprior to 5-2-91 there were differences betweenParty I and Shri Kerkar and if one believes this, itwould be reasonable to hold that Party I requestedShri T. Kerkar to put the date on which he was


807

instructed to prepare the voucher, to get himselfabsolved from the allegation of delay. Thus, thisact by itself, on the part of Party I cannot beconstrued to mean that there is disobedience ofthe order of superior. I am therefore of the opinionthat Party II has failed to prove charge No. 9.

60. As regards to charge ten levied againstParty I vide Exb. 42 dated 7-2-91, it states that on5-2-91 at 3.15 p.m. 5 bills (cash memos) and onestatement of travelling was sent to Party I throughMr. Sadanand Shet who had paid the said amountfrom the miscellaneous amount kept with him forreimbursement. That it is the practice prevailingin the company that Mr. Sadanand Shet is allowedto spend the amount from the miscellaneousadvance of ` 1000/- kept with him and onsubmission of the cash memos the reimbursementof cash spent, was made to said Sadanand byParty I on certifying the payment by the concernedauthorities. However, when the said cash billswere sent to Party I for reimbursement, Party Irefused to make the payment and remarked thathe should be given specific instructions to whomto reimburse the amount. That upon the refusal ofParty I to make payment to Mr. Sadanand, he wasagain instructed by the Dy. Manager (Accounts)to make the payment to Mr. Sadanand but Party Iinsisted that the instructions should be given inwriting though he was aware that there wasalready a procedure prevailing about the paymentand therefore no question arose of giving writteninstructions. Thus, Party I was charged for the actamounting to misconduct of disobedience oflawful and reasonable orders of his superior.

61. In reply to this charge vide reply Exb. 51dated 19-2-91 Party I has stated that since thename of the individual to whom the amount wasto be reimbursed was not mentioned and alsobecause one statement given to him along withthe bills was incomplete, he asked his officer forspecific instructions.

62. In the above context, it is stated by Shri T.Kerkar that an amount of ` 1000/- was beingkept with the Accounts Clerk, Mr. Sadanand Shetfor purchasing miscellaneous items and Mr. Shetafter making such purchases used to produce thebills to Shri Kerkar or the authorized officer forcertifying the same. He has stated that after thebills were certified the same were being sent toParty I for preparing the vouchers and makingpayment to Mr. Shet. He has stated that Mr. Shethad produced a bill of TCI Ltd., for ` 226/- forcertifying the payment which he certified and hehas produced the said bill at Exb. E-36 by

identifying his signature on it. He has stated thatthe bill was then sent to Party I for preparing thevouchers which Party I did not prepare but put aremark on the reverse of the bill asking for specificinstructions as to whom the amount of ` 226/-was to be reimbursed. He has stated that he signedbelow the said endorsement and he has identifiedthe said signature. He has stated that Mr. Shethad produced the bills dated 4-2-91, 5-2-91 and1-2-9 which bills were duly certified for paymentand then sent for preparing the vouchers toParty I but Party I refused by putting the remarkas mentioned above. He has produced the saidbills at Exb. E-37 colly and has identified thesignature of Party I below the remark put byParty I. He has produced the statement made byMr. Shet which was certified by him for paymentat Exb. E-38. He has also stated that he then calledParty I in his chamber and told him to prepare thevouchers but Party I refused and asked forinstructions in writing. According to him, at nopoint of time written instructions as demandedby Party I were given as the transactions wereroutine transactions. He has also stated that Party Ihad prepared the vouchers in respect of the billswhich were certified for payment, where nowritten instructions were given to him and hehas produced the said vouchers dated 4-10-90(two), 8-12-90, 15-12-90, 27-12-90, 5-1-91, 11-1-91,18-1-91 and 29-1-91 at Exb. E-39 colly,

63. In his cross examination on the abovesubject he has stated that in respect of the bills atExb. E-37 colly Mr. Sadanand Shet had notprepared the payment vouchers while making thepayment to the party. He has also stated that thevouchers were to be prepared by Party I in thename of the concerned party but the payment wasto be made to Mr. Sadanand Shet. He has admittedthat there are no instructions on Exb. E-38 and thatExb. E-38 was prepared subsequent to incurringof expenditure by Mr. Sadanand Shet. He hasstated that there are no written instructions toMr. Sadanand Shet authorizing him to makeexpenditure and subsequently to make the refund.According to him, though there are no instructionson Exb. E-38 as above, oral instructions weregiven to make the expenditure and get itreimbursed from Party II.

64. It may be mentioned here that there isnothing in charge ten indicating that oralinstructions were given to Mr. Sadanand Shet tomake the expenditure and get it reimbursed fromParty II. Even otherwise, it is apparent from theabove cross examination of Shri Kerkar that the


808

vouchers were to be prepared in the name of theconcerned party but the payment was to be madeto Mr. Sadanand Shet and therefore in suchsituation it was required of Party II to haveestablished that as a matter of procedure therewere oral instructions to Mr. Sadanand Shet tomake the expenditure and get the samereimbursed from Party II. It may be mentionedhere that Party II has also not examinedMr. Sadanand Shet to confirm the fact that he wasorally instructed to make the expenditure and getit reimbursed from Party II. In the absence of suchmaterial before the court, it would not be properand justified to hold that Party I ought not to haveput remark on the statement asking for specificinstructions to whom the amount was to bereimbursed. This being the case, I am of the viewthat Party II has failed to establish any suchprevailing practice as mentioned in charge tenand therefore has failed to prove charge ten.

65. As regards to charge eleven levied againstParty I vide Exb. 42 dated 7-2-91, it states that on6-2-91, Mr. Uday Gavande offered an amount of` 300/- towards repayment of loan installment ofMr. Clifford Nunes under the GTEL Employees LoanScheme but Party I refused to acceptthe said amount and despite instructions byDy. Manager (Accounts) to accept the same andpass necessary receipt, Party I refused to acceptthe same and pass the receipt and therefore theDy. Manager (Accounts) had to himself give areceipt on the letter head of the company and thisact on the part of Party I amounted to themisconduct of disobedience of lawful andreasonable orders of his superior.

66. In reply to this charge vide Exb. 51 dated19-2-91 Party I has stated that for the purpose ofaccounting he asked Mr. Uday Gavande to furnishmore details as to the month to which therepayment related to.

67. In the context of above charge it is statedby Shri T. Kerkar that Party II had given certainloan to his Employee Mr. Clifford Nunes; that saidNunes handed over loan installment of ` 300/- toMr. Uday Gavande, Sr. Personal Assistant who gavethe amount to Party I on 6-2-91 for preparing thecredit voucher and also asked him to issue thereceipt to Mr. Clifford Nunes. He has stated thatParty I refused to accept the amount and also toprepare the voucher and the receipt which factwas told to him by Mr. Gavande by stating thatParty I wanted written instructions from him i.e.Mr. Kerkar. He has stated that he then sent theamount of ` 300/- to Party I through one

Mr. Anthony Oliveira asking the Party I to preparethe voucher and prepare the receipt but Party Idid not accept the amount upon which he calledParty I in his chamber and asked him to acceptthe amount and issued a voucher and a receiptbut Party I refused and asked for writteninstructions from him. He has stated that he thenissued the receipt dated 6-2-91 to Mr. Nunes whichhe had produced to Exb. E-40. He has stated thatin the past whenever any employee made thepayment towards the loan installment, Party Iused to accept the amount, prepare the voucherand issue receipt to the concerned Employee.He has produced receipts dated 7-5-90, 6-6-90,7-7-90, 6-9-90, 17-12-90, 19-1-91 issued by Party Ito Mr. Augusto Negredo and Miss Shenaz Khan, atExb. E-41 colly by making it clear that the samewere issued by Party I in acknowledgment of thereceipt of the amount towards repayment of theloan amount from the coneerned employees of theParty II, without any written instructions from himor any other authorized officer.

68. In his cross examination on the abovesubject, Shri T. Kerkar has admitted that receiptsat Exb. E-41 colly are from the official receipt bookof Party II and that Party II had its official receiptbooks which were used for issuing receipts to theparties who make payments to Party II. As regardsreceipt, dated 6-2-91 at Exb. E-40 Shri T. Kerkarhas stated that the said receipt issued by me wasnot on the official receipt book of Party II. He hasalso stated that the amount mentioned in thereceipt at Exb. E-40 was received by him and afterthat he prepared the credit voucher and sent theamount to Party I. He has admitted that there isno charge against Party I that on receipt of thecredit voucher prepared by Shri Kerkar in respectof the amount of ` 300/- mentioned in Exb. E-40,the Party I did not prepare receipt on the officialreceipt book. He has denied the suggestion thatMr. Uday Gavande never gave an amount of` 300/- to Party I on 6-2-91 for preparing creditvoucher nor asked him to issue the receipt toMr. Clifford Nunes. He has stated that Party I wasin custody of receipt book and therefore only hewas entitled to receive the money of Party II andissue the receipt from the book. He has stated thatMr. Clifford Nunes had not directly given theamount to Party I. He has denied the suggestionthat he never prepared the credit voucher afterreceiving the amount of ` 300/- and has admittedthat he has not produced the said credit voucherprepared by him. As regards the receipts atExb. E-41 colly, he has stated that the amountmentioned in the said receipts was directly paidby the concerned parties, to Party I.


809

69. Thus from the nature of above evidence it isclear that though Party I had in the past issuedreceipts at Exb. E-41 colly acknowledging thereceipt of amount towards repayment of the loanamount from the concerned employees fromParty II, it is also clear that the receipts atExb. E-41 colly are from the receipt book ofParty II and that these receipts are issued byParty I upon directly receiving the amountmentioned in these receipts, by the concernedparties. Undoubtedly, receipt dated 6-2-91 atExb. E-40 is not from the official receipt book ofParty II and therefore on the face of this receipt itcannot be said that it was an official receipt. Evenfor that matter the statement of Shri T. Kerkar thathe prepared the credit voucher and sent theamount to Party I, also cannot be believed sincethe said credit voucher is not produced before theCourt. That apart, Party II has not examinedMr. Uday Gavande to establish the fact that on6-2-91 he had given an amount of ` 300/- toParty I for preparing the credit voucher and toissue the notice in the name of Mr. Clifford Nunes.Thus, there is no concrete evidence before theCourt to hold that on 6-2-91 Party I refused toaccept the amount of ` 300/- offered by Mr. UdayGavande towards repayment of loan installment ofMr. Clifford Nunes. Hence I am of the view thatParty II has failed to prove charge eleven.

70. As regards charge twelve levied againstParty I vide Exb. 42 dated 7-2-91, it states that on5-2-91 a cheque for ` 400/- issued in favour ofPostmaster, Panaji towards payment of telephonebills of telephone No. 4031 of Panaji and No. 230 ofPorvorim was cancelled and sent to Party I formaking credit voucher and he was instructed toissue separate cheque in favour of Postmaster,Panaji for ` 248/- towards bill of telephoneNo. 4013 which Party I drew and sent for payment.That since the expiry date of other bill of telephoneNo. 230 of Porvorim was dated 6-2-91 for theamount of ` 152/- towards this bill was paid incash by Mr. Sadanand Shet from misc. advance.That Mr. Sadanand Shet presented the cash receiptwith the duplicate bill for ` 152/- to Party I dulycertified by the Dy. Manager (Accounts) forreimbursement but Party I refused to make thepayment and pass the remark saying that sincethe bill of Porvorim telephone No. 230 is alreadypaid by receipt No. 2332 he should be givenspecific instructions to whom to reimburse theamount of ` 152/- on the said bill. Upon this,Party I was called by the Dy. Manager (Accounts)and instructed to make the payments toMr. Sadanand Shet but Party I refused and this act

on his part amounted to misconduct ofdisobedience of lawful and reasonable orders ofhis superior.

71 . In reply to the above charge vide Exb. 51dated 19-2-91, Party I has stated that since theamount of ` 152/- against telephone No. 230 wasalready paid and receipt thereof was brought tohim for making payment by Mr. Sadanand Shet,he asked his officer to indicate the name of theindividual to whom the amount was required tobe reimbursed.

72. In the above context Shri T. Kerkar has statedthat Telephone Department had issued two billsone for the amount of ` 152/- and the other for` 248/- and therefore one cheque of ` 400/- wasissued in favour of Postmaster with respect to theabove bills. He has stated that the cheque wasrefused stating that separate cheques should beissued in respect of each bill and therefore thecheque was cancelled and it was sent to Party Ifor preparing credit voucher. He has produced thesaid telephone bills at Exb. E-32 colly. He hasstated that Party I prepared a voucher in respectof the cancelled cheque and also prepared aseparate cheque for ` 248/- in respect of Panajitelephone bill. As regards the Panaji telephone bill,Shri Kerkar has produced the receipt issued bythe post office acknowledging the receipt of theamount of ` 142/- at Exb. E-43. He has stated thatMr. Sadanand Shet paid this amount of ` 152/-and produced before him the telephone billfor ` 152/- alongwith the receipt issued by thepost office, for certifying the payment which hecertified and he has identified his signature onExb. E-43. He has stated that he then sent this billalong with receipt to Party I for preparing thevoucher and for making payment to Mr. SadanandShet but Party I put a remark asking forinstructions as to whom the amount of ` 152/-was to be reimbursed since the telephone bill wasalready paid. He has identified the signature ofParty I below the above remark on the bill atExb. E-42 colly. He has stated that he then calledParty I in his chamber and instructed him toprepare the voucher and make payment toMr. Sadanand Shet.

73. In his cross examination on the abovesubject he has stated that there is no endorsementon the telephone bill at Exb. E-42 colly forreimbursing the amount to the person who hadpaid the said bill. He has also admitted that hehas not produced any application made by theperson who had paid the said bill amount, claimingreimbursement of the said amount as no such


810

application was made. He has further admittedthat he has not produced voucher to show thatthe amount of ` 152/- was paid to Sadanand Shettowards the reimbursement of the telephonebill and has denied the suggestion that no voucherwas prepared in respect of the payment of` 152/- to Sadanand Shet so also that the saidamount was taken by Mr. Sadanand Shet inadvance against IOU and thereafter produced thereceipt and the bill to prove that the amount of` 152/- on behalf of Party II and that the IOU isdischarged.

74. It may be mentioned here that though chargeNo. 12 makes mention of payment of telephonebill of telephone No. 4031 of Panaji, no charge islevelled against Party I with respect to the bill ofthe above telephone number. As regards thecharge with respect to the bill amount of ` 152/-of telephone No. 230 of Porvorim telephone whichwas certified by Shri Kerkar for payment and thepreparation of the voucher was refused by Party I,it is seen that in his examination in Chief Shri T.Kerkar has nowhere stated that after Party I wascalled by the Dy. Manager (Accounts) andinstructed to make the payment to Mr. SadanandShet for reimbursement, he refused to make thesaid payment. What appears from his examinationin chief that when the bill came back he calledParty I in his chamber and instructed him toprepare the voucher and make the payment toMr. Sadanand Shet. There is nothing in hisexamination in chief indicating that upon hisabove instructions, Party I failed to prepare thevoucher and make the payment to Mr. SadanandShet. Thus, in the absence of such crucial evidencebefore the Court it would not be proper to saythat Party II has proved charge No. 12.

75. As regards to charge No. 13 levied againstParty I vide Exb. 42 dated 7-2-91, it states that on6-2-91 a counter foil of the Syndicate Bank ofMapusa Branch for ` 406.15 was sent to Party I formaking a receipt and credit voucher and thisamount was in respect of the unpaid wages ofMrs. Urmila Kunnan and was deposited in the bankthrough Mr. Uday Gavande and Party I refused tomake a receipt and the credit voucher withremarks requesting to give him instructions ofwhich month target allowance amounting to` 142.65 is deposited in the A/c 349 Mapusa on6-2-91 and to give the name of the person to whomthe receipt was to be prepared. The Party I wascalled by Dy. Manager (Accounts) and instructedthat the receipt should be drawn in the name ofMr. Uday Gavande since the cash was deposited

by him and the narration in the credit voucherwas given as “Salary for January, 1991 and targetallowance” but inspire of these instructionsParty I refused to make the receipt and the creditvoucher and returned the said counter foil to theDy. Manager (Accounts) and this act on the partof Party I amounts to misconduct of disobedienceof lawful orders and negligence in his duties.

76. In reply to the above charge vide Exb. 51dated 19-2-91 Party I has stated that when thecounter foil from the Syndicate Bank for ` 406.15was brought to him by Mr. Sadanand Shet forpreparing necessary vouchers he asked Mr. Shetto indicate thereon the month for which the targetallowance relates and also the name of theindividual in whose name the receipt was requiredto be prepared and this is because the amountof ` 406.15 consisted of both the salary forJanuary, 1991 and target allowance of the previousmonths.

77. In the context of above charge it is statedby Shri T. Kerkar that on 6-2-91 an amoant of` 406.15 was deposited in Syndicate Bank, Mapusabranch under pay in slip and the counter foil ofthe pay in slip was sent by him to Party I formaking a receipt and a credit voucher. He hasstated that this amount which was deposited inthe bank was in respect of unpaid wages and targetallowance of Mrs. Urmila Kunnan but inspite of hisinstructions Party I did not prepare the receiptand the credit voucher and put remark on theduplicate on the pay-in slip asking for informationas to for which month the target allowancepertained to. He has stated that he sent thecounter foil of pay-in slip to Mr. Sadanand Shet forfurnishing the necessary details which Mr.Sadanand Shet did and then the said counter foilof pay-in slip was sent back to Party I for preparingthe receipt and the credit voucher but Party I didnot prepare it and put further remark asking forthe name of the person in whose favour the receiptwas to be prepared. He has stated that he toldParty I that as per the existing practice the receiptshould be drawn in the name of Uday Gavandesince he had produced the counter foil butParty I demanded written instructions from him.He has stated that since these were routinematters, no written instructions were required. Hehas produced the counter foil dated 6-2-91 atExb. E-44 and has stated that since Party I refusedto prepare the receipt and the voucher he himselfprepared it on the letter head of Party II and hehas produced the receipt and credit voucher bothdated 6-2-91 at Exb. E-45 colly. He has stated that


811

in the past Party I had prepared similar receiptsand credit vouchers without written instructionsand has produced the said receipts, creditvouchers and the counter foils of pay-in slipsprepared by Party I in the past at Exb. E-46 colly.He has stated that for having refused to preparethe receipts and the credit vouchers the Party Iwas issued a show cause notice dated 7-2-91which he has produced at Exb. E-47 and the replydated 19-2-91 sent by Party I to this show causenotice at Exb. E-26 colly.

78. In the cross examination on the abovesubject he has stated that the receipt dated7-6-90 from Exb. E-46 colly is in respect ofunclaimed salary deposited in the bank in thename of Mr. Sadanand Shet. According to him, thiscounter foil was produced by Mr. Sadanand Shetand therefore it is deposited in the bank in hisname though he has stated in his examination inchief that the existing practice was to draw thereceipt in the name of Uday Gavande. He hasfurther stated that the normal practice is that thereceipt is issued in the name of the person whoproduced the counter foil to Party I. He has deniedthe suggestion that Mr. Uday Gavande neverapproached Party I with the counter of pay-in slipat Exb. E-44.

79. From the nature of above evidence it appearsthat Shri T. Kerkar himself is not sure as to whatis the existing practice with respect to drawing ofthe receipts because though in his chiefexamination he has stated that as per the existingpractice the receipts should be drawn in thename of Uday Gavande, in the cross examinationhe has admitted that the receipt dated 7-6-90from amongst Exb. E-40 colly is in the name ofShri Sadanand Shet. Though Shri T. Kerkar hasfurther tried to justify that the normal practice isthat the receipt is issued in the name of the personwho produced the counter foil to Party I, itdeserves to be noted that the above justificationhas been given apparently because he was shownthe above receipt dated 7-6-90 in the name ofSadanand Shet. Nevertheless the fact thatbecomes clear is that Shri T. Kerkar has failed toestablish in clear and cogent terms as to what isthe real existing practice in respect of the namesin whose the receipts are to be issued. Even forthat matter, Party II has not examined Mr. UdayGavande to establish this charge and thereforesuggestion put to Shri T. Kerkar that Mr. UdayGavande never approached Party I with thecounter foil of the pay in slip at Exb. E-44 deservesto be given sufficient weightage, It is therefore

clear from the above discussion that Party II hasfailed to produce convincing evidence towards thecharge No. 13 and therefore I am of the view thatcharge No. 13 is not established against Party I.

80. As regards charge No. 14 levelled againstParty I vide Exb. 47 dated 13-2-91, it states thaton 8-2-91 a taxi No. GDS 567 was hired byMr. Sadanand Shet to transport 5 cases ofM/s. Ratan Mica Trading from Indian Airlinesoffice, Panaji to the factory at Mapusa and onarriving the taxi to the factory and unloading thegoods, Mr. Sadanand Shet brought the taxi driverto Party I to prepare payment voucher for` 90/- as per the practice but the Party I refusedto prepare the voucher and also to make thepayment and on such refusal said Sadanand Shetapproached the Dy. Manager (Accounts) andreported about the refusal by Party I upon whichsaid Dy. Manager (Accounts) instructed Party I tomake the payments but Party I refused and thenthe payment voucher was prepared by Mr. Shetand effected the payment from mise. advanceand therefore this act of Party I amounts todisobedience of lawful and reasonable order of hissuperior and also negligence in his duties.

81. In the above context it is stated by Shri T.Kerkar that on 8-2-91 Shri Sadanand Shet hired ataxi for taking certain material from IndianAirlines office, Panaji to the factory of Party II atMapusa and then took the driver of the taxi toParty I for effecting payment of taxi hiring chargesbut Party I refused to make the payment anddemanded instructions in writing. He has statedthat Mr. Shet then reported the matter to him uponwhich he told Party I to prepare the paymentvoucher and make the payment to taxi driver butParty I refused and thereafter upon his instructionsMr. Shet prepared the payment voucher and madepayment to the taxi driver. He has produced thispayment voucher dated 8-2-91 at Exb. E-48. Hehas stated that this payment voucher wasaccounted on 11-2-91. He has stated that Party Ihad made similar payments in the past as per thepractice without written instructions and hasproduced payment vouchers dated 25-1-91,18-1-91, 5-1-91 prepared by Party I for makingsimilar payments without written instructions atExb. E-49 colly.

82. In his cross examination in the above chargeShri T. Kerkar has stated that Exb. E-48 dated11-2-91 was prepared upon oral instructions andat the time when Exb. E-48 was required to beprepared by Party I, he had with him only oralinstructions. He has also stated that about a week


812

prior to 8-2-91 conflicts were going on betweenhim and Party I regarding the work which wasnot carried out by Party I and there were alsoallegations that Party I had misappropriatedcertain amount. He has admitted that there wereno documents before Party I to indicate that driverMr. Dilip Naik had done transportation work forParty II for which he was entitled to receive theamount of ` 90/- from Party II. He has also statedthat Mr. Dilip Naik had not presented any bill orany authorization letter in respect of the paymentof ` 90/- to him, to Party I. He has stated thatthe amount of ` 90/- was paid to Mr. Dilip Naikby Mr. Sadanand Shet from the impressed cashwhich was in his hands and this impressed cashwas meant for meeting the expenses incurred byMr. Sadanand Shet whenever he used to go outsidethe company premises. He has denied thesuggestion that the payment voucher at Exb. E-48was prepared on 11-2-91 and not on 8-2-91. Hehas also denied the suggestion that as perExb. E-48 the amount of ` 90/- consisted of colliecharges besides transport. He has admitted thatParty I was required to prepare Exb. E-48 in thesame manner as prepared by Mr. Sadanand Shet.He has stated that in respect of Exb. E-48 the billwas prepared on 8-2-91 but it was accounted on11-2-91 as Mr. Sadanand Shet was reimbursed theamount on 11-2-91. He has stated that thereimbursement of the amount spent for company’swork is to be obtained from Party I. He has furtherstated that the amount of ` 90/- was reimbursedto Mr. Sadanand Shet not by Party I but bysomebody else and that on 11-2-91 Party I wason leave.

83. From the nature of above evidence, it becomeclear that there is nothing on Exb. E-48 indicatingthat it was prepared on 8-2-91 because apparentlyit is dated 11-2-91. Even for that matter, Party IIhas not examined Shri Sadanand Shet to establishthat on 8-2-91 he had hired taxi No. GDS 567driven by Mr. Dilip Naik and that Party I refusedto prepare the payment voucher and also to makethe payment of ` 90/- to said Mr. Dilip Naik. Thisis more because Party II has not examined thesaid driver Mr. Dilip Naik to substantiate the abovecharge. That apart, it is also clear from the crossexamination of Shri T. Kerkar that about a weekprior to 8-2-91 conflicts were going on betweenhim and Party I regarding the work which wasnot being carried out by Party I and also therewere allegations of misappropriation againstParty I. It may also be mentioned here that it ismade clear by Shri T. Kerkar that the amountwhich was in the hands of Mr. Shet was the

impressed cash which was meant for expenses tobe incurred by Mr. Shet whenever he went outsidethe company premises. This by itself makes it clearthat the amount which was paid by Mr. Shet toShri Dilip Naik was the cash belonging to Party IIand therefore the question of reimbursing Mr. Shettowards the amount spent by him, would not arise.Thus, considering that the relations betweenMr. T. Kerkar and Party I were strained for about aweek prior to 8-2-91, the above charge levelledagainst the Party I cannot be said to have beenestablished in the absence of convincing evidence.

84. Coming to charge No. 15 levelled againstParty I vide Exb. 47 dated 13-2-91, it states thaton 9-2-91, a tempo was hired for collecting parcelsfrom TCI, Prakash Roadlines and NityanandTransport to the factory and unloading the parcelsMr. Sadanand Shet brought the driver to Party I formaking payment voucher and cash payment butParty I refused whereupon he was instructed byDy. Manager (Acct) to make the payments butParty I again refused and this act amounted todisobedience of lawful and reasonable orders ofhis superiors.

85. It is seen that in respect of the above chargeShri T. Kerkar has not stated anything in hisdeposition and therefore the above charge No. 15stands as not established by Party II.

86. As regards to charge No. 16 levelled againstParty I vide Exb. 47 dated 13-2-91, it states thaton 9-2-91, Mr. Pandari Kalangutkar approachedParty I for reimbursement of ferry tickets of Panajito Betim and back, against ticket Nos. 76555,76293, 76970, 73321, 72849, 72493, 73638, 72194,74035, 74276, 74554, 75025, 74755, 75668 and 75857but Party I refused to make the payment voucherand payments to him. That upon refusal ShriKalangutkar approached the Dy. Manager(Accounts) whereupon Party I was instructed tomake the vouchers and payments but Party Irefused to obey the orders of his superior and thenthe payment was made by Mr. Tamse on 11-2-91and this act of Party I amounted to misconduct ofdisobedience of lawful and reasonable order of hissuperior.

87. In the context of above charge it is statedby Shri T. Kerkar that on 9-2-91 one Mr. PandariKalangutkar approached Party I with some ferrytickets which were issued to the vehicles ofParty II for crossing the Mandovi river, for makingthe payment to him. He has stated that Party Iprepared the voucher and sent to him forauthorization which he did and sent back the


813

voucher to Party I but Party I did not make thepayment. He has stated that Party I toldMr. Kalangutkar that unless he signs the voucher,he would not make the payment. He has producedthe payment voucher dated 9-2-91 at Exb. E-50and has stated that the xerox copies of ferry ticketsare on the reverse of this payment vouchers. Hehas stated that in the past no signatures of thepersons receiving the payments were obtained onthe vouchers and he has produced the paymentsvouchers dated 21-11-90, 10-12-90, 22-12-90,8-1-91 and 23-1-91 alongwith ferry tickets whichwere prepared by Party I and the payment weremade to concerned person without obtaining hissignature on the voucher at Exb. E-51 colly. Hehas stated that in respect of the incident dated9-2-91 a show cause was issued to Party I and hehas produced the same at Exb. E-52. He has statedthat Party I replied the show cause notice byreply dated 15-2-91, which he has produced atExb. E-53.

88. In his cross examination Mr. T. Kerkar hasstated that the payment voucher dated 11-2-91 atExb. E-50 was prepared by Party I in favour ofMr. Pandari Kalangutkar but subsequently hecorrected the name from Mr. Pandari Kalangutkarto River Navigation Department. He has also statedthat as per the above correction made by him theamount was to be paid to Mr. Pandari Kalangutkarbecause he had already incurred the expenses.He has denied the suggestion that Party I couldnot have made the payment to the person otherthan whose name was mentioned in the voucherand without acknowledging the receipt of theamount. He has also denied the suggestion thatsince the name of Mr. Pandari Kalangutkar wasstruck off from the payment voucher Exb. E-50,the Party I was not authorized to make thepayment to Mr. Pandari Kalangutkar. As regardsthe payment vouchers at Exb. E-51 colly he hasadmitted that one cannot know to which personthe amount mentioned in the vouchers was paid.He has stated that as regards the voucher dated11-2-91 at Exb. E-50 the amount was paid on11-2-91 and that the River Navigation receiptswhich are on the reverse of Exb. E-50 bear thestamp as “paid”.

89. Thus, on the nature of above evidence ofMr. T. Kerkar it becomes clear that the paymentvoucher at Exb. E-50 was though initially preparedby Party I in the name of Mr. Pandari Kalangutkar,Shri Kerkar then changed the said name to RiverNavigation Department. Thus, from the face of thisvoucher it becomes clear that the amount

mentioned in the same was required to be paid toRiver Navigation Department and not to PandariKalangutkar.

90. It may be mentioned here that there isnothing in charge No. 16 indicating that there hasbeen a practice of making payment to the personwho presents the voucher irrespective of whatevername has been mentioned on the payment voucherand therefore in such situation it would not bejustified to say that Party I was wrong in tellingMr. Pandari Kalangutkar to sign on the voucher forcollecting the payment. It may be mentioned herethat Mr. T. Kerkar in his examination chief hasnowhere mentioned that after Party I toldMr. Kalangutkar that he would not sign thevoucher unless he signs on it, said Mr. Kalangutkarcame to him and thereafter he instructed Party Ito make the payment but Party I refused to obeythe orders and thereafter the said voucher wassigned by Mr. Tamse on 11-2-91, which is so statedin charge No. 16 and therefore it would not beproper to say that Party I disobeyed the order ofthe superior amounting to misconduct ofdisobedience of lawful and reasonable order of hissuperior. Therefore, I am of the considered opinionthat Party II has failed to proved charge No. 16.

91. Thus, from above discussion, it is clear thatout of the sixteen charges levelled against Party Iexcept for charge Nos. 1, 2 and 3 the remainingcharges are on the subject of disobedience of theorders of superiors by Party I charge No. 1 relatesto misappropriation, charge 2 relates to makingpersonal use of amount of Party II and temperingwith the documents of Party II and charge No. 3is regarding unauthorizedly using the cashbelonging to Party II. Discussion supra also makesit clear that Party II has proved only the charges1 and 3 as against Party I and has failed to provethe remaining charges. Nevertheless, looking atthe nature of the charges proved against Party Iviz-a-viz the charges which are not proved, itbecomes clear that the charges proved againstParty I are grave and serious as they relate tomisappropriation and unauthorizedly using thecash belonging to Party II and therefore such actsare sufficient for the employer loose faith andconfidence in the employee. As compared to thesecharges, the charges that are not proved are minorcharges (except charge No. 2) and therefore failureon the part of Party II to prove these charges is ofno much significance.

92. Lnd. Adv. for Party II has relied on thejudgment in the case of Divisional Controller,M.S.R.T.C., Division Office, Buldana v/s Pramod


814

Onkarrao Deshmukh reported in 2007 1 CLR 271 (9)in which it is observed as under:

“considering the law on the point in issue, itis absolutely clear that when the person isentrusted with the job of collecting moneyfor the service rendered by the employer tothe strangers, the employee has to performhis obligation of collecting the fees or theamount in accordance with his obligation asin terms of the contract between theemployer and the .employee, and once it isestablished that the employee has failed toperform his duties in accordance with theterms of the employment and thereby hasmisappropriated the amount, whether smallor large, he looses the confidence of theemployer and in those circumstancesimposition of penalty of dismissal fromservice cannot be found fault with nor it canbe said to be shockingly disproportionate tothe proved misconduct............”

93. It may be mentioned that the recentdecisions of the Apex Court makes it amply clearthat the quantum of the amount misappropriatedor stolen is of little relevance. The judgment of theHon’ble Supreme Court in the case of JanathaBazar (South Canara Central Co-op. WholesaleStores Ltd.) etc. v/s Secretary, Sahakari NoukararaSangha etc. reported in 2000(7) S.C.C. 517 can beusefully referred in this case. In the said case, theHon’ble Supreme Court has held that

“the law is well settled that once the act ofmisappropriation is proved, may be for asmall or large amount, there is no questionof showing uncalled for sympathy andreinstating the employees in service ... In caseof proved misappropriation, in our view,there is no question of considering past servicerecord. It is the discretion of the employer toconsider the same in appropriate cases, butthe Labour Court cannot substitute thepenalty imposed by the employer in suchcases ...”

94. In U. P. State Road Transport Corporationv/s Vinod Kumar, reported in (2007 B.C.I.151) theApex Court has held that:

“This Court in a number of judgments hasheld that the punishment of removal//dismissal is the appropriate punishment foran employee found guilty of misappropriationof funds; and the Courts should be reluctantto reduce the punishment on misplacedsympathy for a Workman. That, there is

nothing wrong in the employer losingconfidence or faith in such an employee andawarding punishment of dismissal. That, insuch cases, there is no place for generosity ormisplaced sympathy on the part of thejudicial forums and interfering with thequantum of punishment. Without burdeningthe judgment with all the judgments of thisCourt on this point, we may only refer to arecent judgment in Divisional Controller,N.E.K.R. T. C. vs. H. Anzaresh, 2006(6) 5CC187, wherein this Court, after taking intoaccount the earlier decisions, held in para 18as under:-

“In the instant case, the misappropriation ofthe funds by the delinquent employee wasonly ` 360.95. This Court has considered thepunishment that may be awarded to thedelinquent employees who misappropriatedthe funds of the Corporation and the factorsto be considered. This Court in a catena ofjudgments held that the loss of confidence isthe primary factor and not the amount ofmoney misappropriated and that thesympathy or generosity cannot be a factorwhich is impermissible in law. When anemployee is found guilty of pilferage or ofmisappropriating the Corporation’s funds,there is nothing wrong in the Corporationlosing confidence or faith in such an employeeand awarding punishment of dismissal.In such cases, there is no place for generosityor misplaced sympathy on the part of thejudicial forums and interfering therefore withthe quantum of punishment.”

95. Thus in the light of above settledpropositions of law viz-a-viz the fact that thecharges which are proved against Party I are graveand serious, I am of the considered opinion thatthe punishment of dismissal from services,imposed upon Party I is appropriate. Hence issueNo. 2A is answered in the positive whereas issueNo. 3A is answered in the negative.

96. Issue No. 5: Vide this issue Party II isrequired to prove that the factory has beenpermanently closed w.e.f. 31-12-08. It is thepleading of Party II in the written statement thatits factory has been permanently closed w.e.f.31-12-08 and all the Workmen and staff have beenretrenched on account of closure. In the additionalrejoinder Party I has denied the above case ofParty II and has stated that in the factory premisesthe Party II is conducting business and theWorkmen are still employed with the Party II. It is


815

therefore clear from the above rival pleadings thataccording to Party I factory of Party II is not closedbut the business is being conducted in the saidfactory premises.

97. It is stated by Shri Uday Kamat that thefactory, of Party II is closed w.e.f. 31-12-08 and allthe Workmen were retrenched arising out of theclosure of the factory and that he and theAccounts Manager Mr. Tamse are retained till theaccounts are finalized. In his cross examinationShri Uday Kamat has stated that Party II hassurrendered the license and also issued closurenotice and the Labour Commissioner is informedabout the closure. He has stated that themachinery no longer exists in the said factory andit is shifted to the parent Company Bharati Telecomat Punjab. He has stated that the auditing//accounting of the Company is still going on. Hehas stated that the factory premises is put up forsale. He has stated that the plot wherein thefactory premises is situated belongs to IOC. Hehas also stated that he is retained till the end ofJune and after he will be transferred to Delhi. Hehas denied the suggestion that the factory ofParty II is not closed w.e.f. 31-12-2008 and thatthe Workmen have not been retrenched on accountof closure.

98. Shri Prakash Tamse has stated that thefactory of Party II was closed w.e.f. 31-12-2008and its license has been surrendered. He hasstated that the Party II had given closure noticeto the Chief Inspector of Factories and Boilers,Government of Goa, Panaji on 4-2-09 under rule143 (2) of The Goa, Daman & Diu Factories Rules,1985 and that the said Chief Inspector hascommunicated to Party II vide its letter dated9-2-09 that the name of the factory of Party II hasbeen deleted from their register and the factorylicense No. GOA/418 issued to Party II has beencancelled. He has produced the said letter dated9-2-09 from Chief Inspector of factories at Exb. 67.He has also produced the closure notice dated4-2-09 at Exb. 68. In his cross examination he hasdenied the suggestion that he is not authorized todepose on behalf of Party II. He has stated thatthe Board of the company is not functioning andthe secretary of the company has given him theauthority to depose in the matter. He has statedthat he does not know whether the Board ofDirectors of the company has been dissolved asper the Company’s Act. He has stated that he doesnot know if the final accounting of the companystands completed or whether any winding upproceedings of the company have been initiated

in the High Court. He has also stated that hispresent employer is Goa Telecommunication. Hehas stated that he does not have any document toshow that the plot on which Goa Communicationfactory was existing has been now sold to RoyalAqua Guard. He has stated that he does not haveany letter from the Secretary or from the Companyauthorizing him to depose.

99. Lnd. Adv. for Party I by referring to theevidence of aforesaid witnesses contended thatShri Uday Kamat has been still working as Asstt.General Manager (HR) with Party II andShri Tamse has stated that he is employed byParty II. Thus according to him the contention ofParty II that their factory has been closed cannotbe believed. It may be mentioned here thatShri Uday Kamat has stated that the factory ofParty II is closed w.e.f. 31-12-2008 but he and theaccounts manager Mr. Tamse are retained till theaccounts are finalized and the above statement ofShri Kamat is not denied in his cross examination.It is pertinent to note that Shri Tamse has notproduced documentary evidence to indicate thathe has been authorized by Party II to depose onits behalf but from the documents at Exb. 67 andExb. 68 produced by Shri Tamse the fact thatbecome clear is that factory of Party II has beenclosed w.e.f. 31-12-2008 and that its name has beendeleted from the office register and the factorylicense No. GOA/418 has been cancelled. Thus onthe basis of above documentary evidence whichis not challenged it becomes clear that the factoryof Party II has been closed.

100. Be that as it may, it is the contention ofLnd. Adv. for Party I that the Industry of GoaTelecommunication is still functioning andtherefore Party I deserves to be reinstated in thesaid industry. In this context it deserves to benoted that Party I has not adduced evidence toestablish that the vacancies pertaining to the postwhich he holds or held are existing in the industryof Goa Telecommunication or that he could bereinstated in the aforesaid industry and thereforein the absence of such evidence I find no meritsin the above arguments of Lnd. Adv. for Party I.Even for that matter it is not the case of Party I inhis additional rejoinder that the industry of GoaTelecommunication is still functioning but whatis stated by Party I in his additional rejoinder isthat factory of Party II is not closed and thatParty II is conducting business so also Workmenare still employed in the factory premises. It wastherefore required of Party I to prove that thefactory of Party II has been conducting the


816

business which the Party I has failed to prove.Thus, the arguments as above of Lnd. Adv. forParty I, cannot at all be considered and in suchsituation it becomes clear that Party I has failedto make out a case of his reinstatement in service.

101. It is also the contention of Party II thatParty I has been gainfully employed since the timeof termination of his services by Party II and inthis context it is stated by Shri T. Kerkar that fromthe date of termination of the service of Party I, hehas started his stationary shop under the name of“Speedy Distributors”. In his cross-examinationShri T. Kerkar has stated that the shop “SpeedyDistributors” was started by Party I at Corlim,Mapusa. He has denied the suggestion that hisabove statement is without any substance.

102. Party I has stated in his evidence thatduring the pendency of this reference as wellas the entire dispute he was not gainfullyemployed in any job despite making efforts tosecure one, nor was he having any income or wasself employed during that period till date. He hastherefore stated that he is entitled for full backwages and all benefits that have accrued to himif he were in service from the date of his illegaltermination. In his cross examination he hasadmitted that his father has a shop in Mapusamarket; that his father is no longer living; that heis the only son with three sisters; that his familyconsists of seventy years old mother, wife and twosons; that his father was conducting business inthe name of Vassudev Vithal Pai; that his motheris running the said shop, and that he is not runningthe said shop. He has also stated that his motherown vehicle bearing No. GA01/R7613 but she doesnot have a driving license. He has stated that theyhave bungalow at Mapusa which is owned by allhis family members including his sisters and theirhusbands and that all these family members haveavailed loan to construct the said bungalow. Hehas stated that he does not recollect the name ofthe bank from which he availed the loan. Hehas denied the suggestion that he is runningthe said shop and that from the date of histermination, he is gainfully employed and isearning ` 2.00,000/- p.a. He has also denied thesuggestion that the bungalow at Mapusa is onlyowned by him and his wife and that the abovenumbered car is owned by him.

103. Shri Uday Kamat has stated that Party I isconducting business in the shop bearing No. 101which is in the Mapusa market under the nameand style Vassudev Vithal Pai for last abouteighteen years and supplies stationary to various

concerns/advocates on retail and wholesale basis.He has stated that the father of Party I expiredleaving behind his wife and Party I as successorfor the business run in shop No. 101 and that thebusiness is run by Party I himself after the deathof his father. He has stated that the three sistersof Party I are married and they stay with theirhusbands beyond Mapusa Municipal limits. Hehas stated that the mother of Party I is more thanseventy years of age and is not in a position to runthe shop on account of her old age. He has statedthat Party I has purchased the vehicle bearingNo. GA01/R7613 in the name of his mother bytaking loan from ICICI Bank, Panaji branch andthat Party I himself drives the said vehicle. Hehas stated that Party I has constructed bunglowat Mapusa by taking loan from the bank and theinstallments of the loan are paid by Party I fromthe income from the shop as well as his otherbusiness namely Speedy Distributors. He hasstated since Party I is engaged in his own businessand the business of his family, he has not tried tosecure job elsewhere during all this period.

104. In his cross examination Shri Uday Kamathas expressed ignorance to the suggestion thatMirabai Vasudev Pai, the mother of Party I is theproprietor of the said shop and is paying incometax for the said shop. He has also stated that hehas not seen any documents indicating thatParty I is paying the installments as regards thevehicle purchased on loan from ICICI Bank. Hehas expressed ignorance to the suggestion thatmother of Party I pays monthly installments of theloan for the said vehicle and that she accounts forthe same. He has stated that he does not knowfrom which bank Party I has taken loan for thebungalow and that he was told by one Shri UdayGaunekar that Party I had constructed thebungalow by taking loan from the bank. He hasstated that he does not know in whose name thebusiness M/s. Speedy Distributors is Registeredunder Shops and Establishments Act and that thesaid business may have been closed. He hasstated that it may have been true that this businesswas registered in the name of Mirabai Pai but hasasserted that Party I is conducting the saidbusiness. He has stated that friends of Party I havetold him that the sisters of Party I reside beyondMapusa Municipal limits.

105. It is submitted by learned Adv. for Party Ithat once Party I makes a statement that he is notgainfully employed, the burden lies on Party II toestablish otherwise. However, learned Adv. forParty II by relying on the judgment in Navin J.


817

Surti v/s Moti Rubber Ltd., 2004 II CLR 46contended that apart from the obligation on thepart of the employer to establish gainfullyemployment of the employee during such period,it would also be necessary for the employee todisclose the efforts made by him to get some otherjob or employment during such period as well asabout the source of income during the said periodand if so, to what extent and mere silence on thepart of the employee in that regard cannot, in anymanner, enure to the benefit of the employee tojustify the claim for back wages in entirety. Inthis judgment by relying on the judgment in thecase of Sadanand Patankar v/s New PrabhatSilk Mills (No. 2) Bombay 1974 Mhlj 761 it isobserved that merely because the employer hasfailed to establish the gainful employment of theemployee after the termination of his service bysuch employer that by itself would not be ajustification to grant back the back wages inentirety and eventually there would be a burdencaste upon the employee to disclose the effortsmade by him to secure another job during the timehe was out of employment on account oftermination of the service, in order to justify theclaim of the back wages in its entirety.

106. As rightly pointed out by learned Adv. forParty I, it becomes apparent from the nature ofabove evidence that the business M/s. SpeedyDistributors stands in the name of the mother ofParty I and even the car is in her name and thatthe bungalow at Mapusa is a family bungalowand this is because the evidence of Shri UdayKamat is hearsay evidence. Nevertheless, it is notstated by Party I in his evidence that the businessM/s. Speedy Distributors is closed and thereforethere is every reason for me to hold that the saidbusiness is a running business. Even for thatmatter, it would not stand to reason to believe thestatement of Party I that his mother who isadmittedly 70 years old is looking after the saidbusiness ‘Speedy Distributor’ and this is becauseone cannot expect a 70 year old mother to lookafter the business when she has a son likeParty I who claims to have been unemployed. Thatapart, it is rather surprising to note that Party Idoes not recollect the name of the bank fromwhich he availed the loan to construct thebungalow at Mapusa wherein he resides, as inthe normal circumstances no prudent man wouldforget the name of the bank wherein he pays theloan installments. It may be mentioned here thataccording to Party I this bungalow at Mapusa isowned by all family members including his sistersand their husbands but it appears that Party I does

not even know whether his sisters are residing intheir marital houses. It may be true that in theabsence of any cogent and convincing evidence,it would not be proper and justified to say thatthis business belongs exclusively to Party I butthe inference which could definitely be drawn fromthe above evidence is that Party I has a share inthe business since it belongs to his deceasedfather and similar is the case with the bungalowat Mapusa. It is therefore clear that Party I hassuppressed the above material facts from the courtand more particularly of the income which hederives from the business and this by itself leadsme to draw adverse inference against Party I. Thisis because, nothing had prevented Party I fromdisclosing before this court that he has beenderiving some income from the business. It istherefore clear from the evidence adduced by theparties on the subject of gainful employment thatParty II has succeeded in establishing thatParty I has been gainfully employed since the timeof dismissal from service. That apart, as observedin the judgment in Navin Surti (Supra) Party I hasnot produced anything on record to show that hemade efforts to secure the job during thependency of this reference as well the entiredispute though Party I has made this specificstatement in his affidavit in evidence.

107. It deserves to be noted that the order forpayment of back wages is granted to compensatethe employee for the loss suffered during the timehe was out of employment and not as a reward forhaving succeeded in establishing that the actionof termination of service by the employer is illegal.Since Party I herein has failed to honestly discloseall the full particulars of the facts which are purelywithin his knowledge and has attempted tomislead the Tribunal, I am of the consideredopinion that Party I is not entitled to claim theback wages irrespective of the failure of theParty I to prove that his termination of services byParty II was illegal and unjustified.

108. Since in the instant case it is establishedthat the action of Party II in terminating theservices of Party I is legal and justified so alsothat Party I has been gainfully employed pursuantto termination of his services and that the factoryof Party II has been closed, in my view Party I isnot entitled to any relief. Hence my findings.

109. In the result and in view of discussionsupra I pass the following:

ORDER

1. The action of the management of M/s. GoaTelecommunications & Systems Ltd., MapusaIndustrial Estate, Mapusa, Bardez, Goa in


818

terminating the services of Shri Vithal V. Pai,Senior Accounts Assistant, with effect from31-3-1995, is held as legal and justified.

2. The Party I is not entitled for any relief.

3. No order as to costs.

Inform the Government accordingly.

Sd/-(B. K. Thaly),

Presiding Officer,Industrial Tribunal--cum-Labour Court.

——— ———

Department of Personnel__

Order

File No. 15/1/99-PER(Part)

The Governor of Goa is pleased to order transferand posting of the following Officers in the cadreof Mamlatdar/Joint Mamlatdar/Assistant Directorof Civil Supplies, with immediate effect, in public

interest:

Sr. Name of Present To be posted

No. the Officer posting on transfer as

1 2 3 4

1. Shri Rajesh Joint Mamlatdar-in-Ajgaonkar Mamlatdar-I, -Collectorate,

Canacona North.

2. Shri Manoj Mamlatdar-in- Mamlatdar,Korgaonkar -Collectorate, Quepem.

North

3. Shri Pravin H. Mamlatdar, JointParab Quepem Mamlatdar-II,

Bicholim.

4. Shri Ravishe- Joint Jointkhar Nipanikar Mamlatdar-II, Mamlatdar-I,

Bicholim Canacona.


Yetindra M. Maralkar, Addl. Secretary (Personnel).

Porvorim, 25th July, 2012._________

Order

File No. 15/16/2012-PER

The Governor of Goa is pleased to promote onad hoc basis, the following Awal Karkuns to the

posts in the cadre of Mamlatdar/Joint Mamlatdar/

/Assistant Director of Civil Supplies (Group ‘B’

Gazetted) in the Pay Scale of ` 9,300-34,800+Grade

Pay ` 4,600/- with immediate effect and post them

on the posts shown against their names:

Sr. Name of Posted onNo. the Officer promotion as

1 2 3

1. Shri Pratap Joint Mamlatdar-IV, Bardez.Gaunkar, AK,Collectorate,North

2. Shri Shripad Asstt. Director of Civil

Majik, AK, Supplies thereby relieving

Collectorate, Shri Manoj Korgaonkar,

North Mamlatdar-in-Collectorate,

North of the additional

charge.

3. Shri Nathan Joint Mamlatdar-II,Leonard, Mormugao.Afonso, AK,Collectorate,South

4. Kum. Deona Joint Mamlatdar-III,Pereira, AK, Salcete.Collectorate,North

5. Shri Rajesh G. Mamlatdar Disaster Manage-

Sakhalkar, AK, ment & E-Governance

Collectorate, thereby relieving Shri

North Jeetendra Bugde, Mamlat-

dar-in-Collectorate, South

of the additional charge.

The above ad hoc promotion will not bestow onthem any claim for regular appointment and theservices rendered on ad hoc basis in the gradewill not count for the purpose of seniority in thatgrade and for eligibility for promotion to the nexthigher post.

The above ad hoc promotion shall be for a period

of one year in the first instance, or till the posts are

filled on regular basis, whichever is earlier.

The pay of the above officers, on promotion, shall

be fixed as per rules.

Consequently, Shri Pundalik Khorjuenkar, Joint

Mamlatdar-IV, Bardez is posted as Mamlatdar,

Bardez, Shri Laxmikant Dessai, Joint Mamlatdar-II,

Mormugao is posted as Mamlatdar, Mormugao and


819

Kum. Triveni Velip, Joint Mamlatdar-III, Salcete is

posted as Mamlatdar, Salcete.


Yetindra M. Maralkar, Addl. Secretary(Personnel).


——— ———

Department of Public Health__

Corrigendum

No. 13/25/2002-I/PHD

Read: Order No. 13/25/2002-I/PHD dated12-07-2012.

In the first para of the Government order readin preamble, the pay scale indicated in thefourth line shall be substituted to read as “PB—2,` 9,300-34,800+GP ` 4,200/-” instead of “PB—2,` 9,300-34,800+GP ` 4,600/-”.

Rest of the content remains unchanged.


Maria Seomara Desouza, Under Secretary(Health-II).


——— ———

Department of Revenue__

Notification

No. 23/5/2011-RD

Whereas by Government Notification No. 23/5//2011-RD dated 29-03-2011 published on OfficialGazette, Series II No. 1 dated 07-04-2011 and intwo newspapers (1) “The Navhind Times” dated31-03-2011 and (2) “Pudhari” dated 31-03-2011, itwas notified under Section 4 of the LandAcquisition Act, 1894 (Central Act 1 of 1894)(hereinafter referred to as “the said Act”), that theland specified in the Schedule appended to thesaid Notification (hereinafter referred to as the saidland) was needed for public purpose, viz. LandAcquisition for construction of Minor-1 of B/6distributory of Right Bank Main Canal of TillariIrrigation Project in Torxem Village of PernemTaluka.

And Whereas, the Government of Goa (herein-after referred to as the “Government”) afterconsidering the report made under sub-section (2)of Section 5-A the said Act is satisfied that theland specified in the Schedule hereto is needed forthe public purpose specified above (hereinafterreferred to as “the said land”).

Now, therefore, the Government herebydeclares under the provisions of Section 6 of thesaid Act that the said land is required for thepublic purpose specified above.

The Government also hereby appoints underclause (c) of Section 3 of the said Act, SpecialLand Acquisition Officer (N), G.T.I.D.C. Karaswada,Colvale Road, Bardez-Goa to perform the functionsof the Collector for all proceedings hereinafter tobe taken in respect of the said land and directshim under Section 7 of the said Act to take orderfor the acquisition of the said land.

3. A plan of the said land can be inspectedat the office of the Special Land Acquisition Officer,(N), G.T.I.D.C., Karaswada, Colvale Road, Bardez-Goa till the award is made under Section 11.

SCHEDULE

(Description of the said land)

Taluka: Pernem Village: Torxem

Survey No./ Names of the persons Approx./Sub-Div. No. believed to be area in

interested sq. mts.

1 2 3

123 P O: Purushotham Ramanath Keni. 302124 P O: Purushotham Ramanath Keni. 12033125 P O: Shree Dev Mauli Panchayath 1447

Var Devastan CommitteeTorcem.Inspector General of A Police,Panaji.Executive Engineer, W.D. XVII,(PHE), P.W.D., Porvorim.

71/2 P O: Raghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. 322T: Narayan Babu Bandodkar.

Laxman Shambaji Tari.Raghunath Babu Tari.Gopal Shambaji Tari.Krishna Mahadev Badodkar.Rama Tilu Bhagat.Soma Vithu Tari.Vishwanath Gunaji Tari.Gurunath Pandurang Tari.Ganesh Bhiva Tari.Ankush Laxman Bandodkar.Shankar Bhiva Tari.


820

Ladu Bablo Zante.Pandurang Saba Ghatawal.Sitaram Krishna Bhagat.Ladu Pundalik Tari.Vasudev Balkrishna Shirodkar.Vasu Tilu Bhagat.Achut Arjun Tari.Dattaram Mahadev Kamat.Dnyanba Savlaram Tari.Narayan Krishna Tari.

71/11 P O: Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. 1147T: Achut Arjun Tari.

Dnyanba Savlaram Tari.Shankar Bhiva Tari.Narayan Krishna Tari.

71/12 P O: Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. 72T: Ladu Pundalik Tari.

71/13 P O: Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. 133

T: Raghunath Babu Tari.70/3 P O: Raghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. 315

T: Pandurang Saba Ghatawal.70/31 P O: Raghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. 48

T: Ankush Laxman Bandodkar.Ganesh Bhiva Tari.

70/32 P O: Raghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. 77T: Viswanath Gunaji Tari.

Gurunath Pandurang Tari.70/33 P O: Raghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. 81

T: Vasu Tilu Bhagat.Soma Vithal Tari.

70/34 P O: Raghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. 88T: Gopal Shambaji Tari.

Krishna Mahadev Badodkar.70/35 P O: Raghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. 85

T: Laxman Shambaji Tari.Narayan Babu Bandodkar.

70/36 P O: Raghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. 119T: Raghunath Babu Tari.

Ladu Pundalik Tari.70/37 P O: Raghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. 90

T: Vasudev Balkrishna Shirodkar.Dattaram Mahadev Kamat.

70/38 P O: Raghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. 113T: Rama Tilu Bhagat.

Shantaram Dattaram Tari.70/39 P O: Raghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. 132

T: Ladu Bablo Zante.70/40 P O: Raghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. 117

T: Sitaram Krishna Bhagat.70/41 P O: Raghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. 95

T: Shankar Bhiva Tari.Dnyanba Savlaram Tari.

70/42 P O: Raghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. 226T: Achut Arjun Tari.

Narayan Krishna Tari.

69/1 P O: Raghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. 341T: Viswanath Gunaji Tari.

Ganesh Bhiva Tari.Gurunath Pandurang Tari.Ankush Laxman Bandodkar.

69/2 P O: Raghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. 221T: Narayan Babu Bandodkar.

69/3 P O: Raghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. 277T: Ladu Pundalik Tari.

69/29 P O: Raghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. 5135138 P O: Shree Dev Mauli Panchayath 2245

Var Devastan CommitteeTorcem.

156/1 P O: Raghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. 204T: Krishna Yeshwant Naik.

Narayan Yeshwant Naik.156/2 P O: Raghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. 4

T: Shiva Raghobha Naik.165 P O: Daji Pandu Naik. 802

Bhikaji Vishnu Naik.

Hari Gopal Naik.

Boundaries :

North : S. No. 124, Nallah, S. No. 165,S. No. 138, S. No. 125.

South : S. No. 72, S. No. 138, S. No. 165.

East : S. No. 124, S. No. 71/2, 12, 11,S. No. 70/3, S. No. 70/31 to 42,S. No. 169/1, 2, 3, 29, S. No. 125,S. No. 138, S. No. 156/1, 165.

West : S. No. 123, S. No. 124, 71/2, 13,14, 11, S. No. 70/4, 31 to 42,S. No. 69/1, 2, 3, 29, S. No. 125,Road, S. No. 156/1, S. No. 165.

Total: 26271


Ashutosh Apte, Under Secretary (Revenue-I).

Porvorim, 23rd July, 2012.________

Notification

F. No. 22/21/2008-RD

Whereas the Government of Goa (hereinafterreferred to as “the Government”) vide NotificationNo. 22/21/2008-RD dated 25th July, 2008 hadnotified certain land in Pernem Taluka for thepurpose of acquisition for public purpose, viz. LandAcquisition for construction of New InternationalAirport at Mopa in Pernem Taluka (hereinafter

1 2 3 1 2 3


821

referred to as “Principal Notification”). The saidNotification was published in the Official Gazette(Extraordinary No. 4), Series II No. 19, dated 08thAugust, 2008.

And whereas, during the pendency of the said

land acquisition process, four numbers of Writ

Petitions were filed before the Hon’ble High Court

of Bombay at Goa viz. Writ Petition No. 568 of 2009,

Writ Petition No. 135 of 2010 alongwith Writ

Petition No. 641 of 2009, thereby challenging

the land acquisition for construction of New

International Airport at Mopa.

And whereas, the Hon’ble High Court of Bombay

at Goa disposing these Writ Petition by its

Judgment & Order dated 07-05-2012 (hereinafter

referred to as ”Judgment and Order”) mentioned

that the Notification under Section 4 and

declaration under Section 6 (1) of the L. A. Act

stands quashed and set aside only qua the lands

belonging to the petitioners in these petitions.

And whereas, the Hon’ble High Court of Bombay

at Goa in its said Judgment & Order clarified

that “ ... nothing else would be considered in the

inquiry/hearing under Section 5-A which the State

shall hold and conclude, as provided therein and

within a period of thirty days from the date of

receipt of a copy of this judgment. At such an

inquiry/hearing, the petitioner can raise objections

in terms of Rule 4 of the Goa Daman & Diu Land

Acquisition Rules, 1972. However, the petitioners

shall not be permitted to raise an objections on the

competence of the State Government to initiate

the subject acquisition proceedings nor can they

urge that the notified purpose is not genuinely or

properly a public purpose. These issues have

been decided and .... the notified purpose is a

public purpose”.

And whereas, now in order to comply with

the Order of Hon’ble High Court of Bombay at Goa

to hear the petitioners under Section 5-A, the

notification under Section 4, limited to the

petitioners in the aforementioned Writ Petitions,

is required to be published in terms of Rule 4 of

the Goa Daman & Diu Land Acquisition Rules,

1972 and Section 5A of the L. A. Act.

Now, therefore, the Government hereby notifies,

under sub-section (1) of Section 4 of the Land

Acquisition Act, 1894 (Central Act 1 of 1894)

(hereinafter referred to as the “said Act”) that the

land mentioned in the Principal Notification is

needed for the purpose specified in the Principal

Notification.

2. All persons interested in the said land are

hereby warned not to obstruct or interfere with

any surveyor or other persons employed upon the

said land for the purpose of the said acquisition.

Any contract for the disposal of the said land

by sale, lease, mortgage, assignment, exchange

or otherwise, or any outlay commenced or

improvements made thereon without the sanction

of the Collector appointed under paragraph 4

below, after the date of the publication of Principal

Notification, will under clause (seventh) of Section

24 of the said Act be disregarded by him while

assessing compensation for such parts of the said

land as may be finally acquired.

3. If the Government is satisfied that the said

land is needed for the aforesaid purpose, a

declaration to that effect under Section 6 of the

said Act will be published in the Official Gazette

and in two daily newspapers and public notice

thereof shall be given in due course. If the

acquisition is abandoned wholly or in part, the fact

will also be notified in the same manner.

4. The Government further appoints under clause

(c) of Section 3 of the said Act, the Special Land

Acquisition Officer, Mopa Airport Cell, Panaji-Goa,

to perform the functions of Collector, North Goa

District, Panaji-Goa, under the said Act in respect

of the said land.

5. The Government also authorizes undersub-section (2) of Section 4 of the said Act, thefollowing Officers to do the Acts, specified thereinin respect of the said land.

1) The Collector, North Goa District, Panaji-Goa.

2) The Special Land Acquisition Officer, MopaAirport Cell, Panaji-Goa.

3) The Director, Directorate of Transport, Panaji--Goa.

4) The Director of Settlement and Land Records,Panaji-Goa.

6. A rough plan of the said land is available for

inspection in the Office of the Special Land

Acquisition Officer Mopa Airport Cell, Panaji-Goa

for a period of 30 days from the date of publication

of this Notification in the Official Gazette.


822

Schedule

(Description of the said land)

Taluka: Pernem Village: Chandel

Survey No./ Names of the persons Area in/Sub-Div. No. believed to be sq. mts

interested

1 2 3

21/2 Sita Rama Satelkar.Malkumi Payo Gauns. O 8900

21/4 Bhikaji Laxman Gawas.Laxman Bhikaji Gauns. O 2900

21/5 Anant Ramchandra Gawas.Tukaram Rama Gauns. O 3200Apa Nana Gauns. O

21/6 Anant Ramchandra Gawas.Tukaram Rama Gauns. O 600Apa Nana Gauns. O

22/2 Anand Bhiva Bhaip.Bhiva Vishnu Baip. O 19100

22/3(P) Sakharam Laxman Gauns. O 356022/4 Keshav Devu Gawas.

Devu Keshav Gauns. O 10100Ladu Joge Gans. OBablo Keshav Gauns. OBala Mhataro Gawas. OPrakash Narayan Gawas. O

22/5 Keshav Devu Gawas.Devu Keshav Gauns. O 2800

22/6 Raghunath Yeshwant Gawas.Yeshwant Nelu Gauns. O 2450

22/8 Herabai Gopal Gawas.Laxmibai Gopal Gauns. O 1350

22/10 Anant Ramchandra Gawas.Prakash Narayan Gawas. O 2450

22/12 Bala Vitha Gawas.Mahadev Rajaram Gawas.Shashikant Rama Gawas.Bala Matro Gauns. O 1475Vithal Sadhu Gauns. ORama Sadhu Gauns. ORajaram Sadhu Gauns. O


22/14 Raghunath Yeshwant Gawas.Yeshwant Neelu Gauns. O 3150

22/15 Vijayawanti Dattaram Gawas.Bala Vithal Gawas.Keshav Dattaram Gawas.Dattaram Tane Gauns. O 8475Vithal Sadu Gauns. OLadoo Joma Gauns. OPrakash Narayan Gawas. O

22/18 Srimati Sukdo Gawas.Sukdo Krishna Gauns. O 1650

22/21 Raghunath Yeshwant Gawas.Keshav Devu Gawas.Devu Keshav Gauns. O 550Yeshwant Neelu Gauns. O


24/2 (P) Anand Bhiva Bhaip.Bhiva Vishnu Bahip. O 415

27/1 (P) Vijayawanti Dattaram Gawas.Keshav Dattaram Gawas.Herabai Gopal Gawas.Dattaram Tanu Gauns. O 28720Ladoo Joma Gauns. OBablo Ladoo Gauns. OBabji Budhe Gauns. OBala Mhatro Gauns. OLaxmi Gopal Gauns. O

27/2 (P) Anand Bhiva Bhaip.Bhiva Vishnu Bhaip. O 1160

28/2 Anand Bhiva Bhaip.Bhiva Vishnu Bhaip. O 2900

28/3 Raghunath Yeshwant Gawas.Yeshwant Neelu Gauns. O 3350

28/4 Chandrakant Dataram Gawas.Dattaram Bhudha Gauns. O 375Shashikant Babji Gauns. OAnkush Budha Gauns. O

28/6 Rama Jhilu Gauns. O 90028/7 Rama Jhilu Gauns. O 67528/8 Chandrakant Dataram Gawas.

Shashikant Babji Gauns. O 575Dattaram Budha Gauns. OAnkush Budha Gauns. O

29/0 Anand Bhiva Bhaip.Bhiva Vishnu Bhaip. O 37000

30/2 Krishna Babli Gawas.Babli Krishna Gauns. O 525

30/4 Srimati Sukdo GawasSukdo Krishna Gauns. O 1000


30/10 Shashikant Rama Gawas.Rama Sadu Gauns. O 925



30/19 Ratan Yeshwant Gawas.Yeshwant Sakharam Gauns. O 2675Dattaram Tane Gauns. OBabla Keshav Gauns. O

30/20 Keshav Devu Gawas.Deu Keshav Gauns. O 2300

1 2 3


823

30/21 Srimati Sukdo Gawas.Sukdo Krishna Gauns. O 2250

30/22 Rama Jhilu Gauns. O 140030/26 Vijay Krishna Gawas.

Krishna Dulji Gauns. O 75030/30 Srimati Sukdo Gawas.

Sukdo Krishna Gauns. O 137530/31 Sita Rama Satelkar.

Malkumi Payu Gauns. O 210030/33 Keshav Devu Gawas.

Devu Keshav Gauns. O 155030/34 Shashikant Rama Gawas.

Rama Sadu Gauns. O 375030/37 Mohini Mohan Gawas.

Sita Rama Satelkar.Malkumi Payu Gauns. O 8925Janki Deu Gauns. O

30/38 Bhikaji Laxman Gawas.Laxman Bhikaji Gauns. O 1850

30/39 Raghu Bhise Gauns. O 230030/40 Vijay Krishna Gawas.

Krishna Dulaji Gauns. O 237530/43 Shashikant Rama Gawas.

Rama Sadu Gauns. O 235030/44 Krishna Babli Gawas.

Babli Krishna Gauns. O 1675Sakharam Laxman Gauns. O

30/48 Ratan Yeshwant Gawas.Bala Anant Gawas.Yeshwant Sakharam Gauns. O 5175Anant Bal Gauns. ODattaram Keshav Gauns. OBabal Keshav Gauns. O

30/49 Srimati Sukdo Gawas. O 1400Sukdo Krishna Gauns. O

31/0 Vijayawanti Dattaram Gawas.Keshav Dattaram Gawas.Bala Anant Gawas.Bala Mhataro Gauns. O 11100Anant Bala Gauns. ODattaram Tane Gauns. OBabal Keshav Gauns. O

32/1 Bappu Rajaram LaxmanNarulkar.Nakul Sagun Narulkar.Shivaji Govind P. P. Dessai. O 2925Sagun Laxman Narulkar. TRajaram Laxman Narulkar. T

32/2 Shripad Mahadev Nadkarni. O 16000Krishnaji Mahadev Nadkarni. ODattaram Mahadev Nadkarni. ODamodar Ramchandra ONadkarni.Narayan Balkrishna Nadkarni.O

Ravalnath Ramchandra ONadkarni.Raghunath Yeshwant ONadkarni.Vassudev Sadashiv Nadkarni. OVaman Dattaram Nadkarni. OSadashiv Balkrishna ONadkarni.Ankush Jhilu Narulkar. TSoma Kanu Narulkar. TJivaji Bhikaji Narulkar. TUttam Rama Narulkar. TVishnu Narayan Ghogale. T

32/3 Tukaram Krishna Gawas.Shivaji Govind V. V. Dessai. O 16650Rama Arjun Narulkar. TBhiva Phati Narulkar. T

32/4 Sunil Amrut Narulkar.Amrut Nagu Narulkar. O 6825Sitabai Sitaram Narulkar. O

32/5 Vishnu Narayan Ghogale.Tukaram Krishna Gawas.Rama Arjun Narulkar. O 2600Bhiva Fati Narulkar. O

32/6 Bappu Rajaram LaxmanNarulkar.Nakul Sagun Narulkar.Keshav Laxman Narulkar. O 3325Sagun Laxman Narulkar. OVishram Laxman Narulkar. ORajaram Laxman Narulkar. O

32/8 (P) Krishna Babli Gawas.Sakharam Laxman Gauns. O 975Babli Krishna Gauns. O

32/10 (P) Vishnu Narayan Ghogale.Tukaram Krishna Gawas.Shivaji Govind P. P. Dessai. O 2600Bhiva Pati Narulkar. TRama Arjun Narulkar. T

32/11(P) Subhadra Hari Narulkar. O 3175Gopal Pandurang Narulkar. OVithal Krishna Narulkar. OVassudev Narayan Narulkar. OVishvanath Narayan Narulkar.O

32/14(P) Uttam Rama Narulkar. O 60032/15 Shivaji Govind P. P. Dessasi. O 1200

Ankush Jhilu Narulkar. T32/18 Anand Bhiva Bhaip.

Bhiva Vishnu Bhaip. O 500032/21 (P) Bhikaji Laxman Gawas.

Shashikant Rama Gawas.Rama Sadu Gauns. O 2500Laxman Bikaji Gauns. ONarayan Joge Gauns. O

1 2 3 1 2 3


824

32/26 Anand Bhiva Bhaip. OBhiva Vishnu Bhaip. O 13400

32/27 (P) Shashikant Rama Gawas.Rama Sadu Gauns. O 885

32/28 Bala Ankush Gawas.Vijayawanti Dattaram Gawas.Keshav Dattaram Gawas.Ratan Yeshwant Gawas.Ankush Bala Gauns. O 1525Dattaram Tane Gauns. OYeshwant Sakharam Gauns. OBabla Keshav Gauns. O



32/34 Bhikaji Laxman Gawas.Herabai Gopal Gawas.Laxman Bhikaji Gauns. O 2625

32/35 Herabai Gopal Gawas.Laxmi Gopal Gauns. O 1150

32/37 Ratan Yeshwant Gawas.Yeshwant Sakharam Gauns. O 2225

32/40 Bala Anant Gawas.Anant Bala Gauns. O 550

32/44 Rama Jhilu Gauns. O 82533/1 Mohini Mohan Gawas.

Janki Deu Gawas. O 2825Vassant Shantaram Sawant. T

33/2 Sita Rama Satelkar.Narayan Joge Gawas. O 42850Laxman Bhikaji Gawas. OMalkumi Payu Gawas. O

33/4 Srimati Sukdo Gawas.Sukdo Krishna Gawas. O 3825

34/2 Shakaram Laxman Gawas.Shripad Mahadev Nadkarni. O 2600Dattaram Mahadev Nadkarni. OKrishnaji Mahadev Nadkarni. ODamodar Ramchandra ONadkarni.Narayan Balkrishna Nadkarni. ORavalnath Ramchandra ONadkarni.Raghunath Yeshwant ONadkarni.Vassudev Sadashiv Nadkarni. OVaman Dattaram Telang. OSadashiv Balkrishna Nadkarni. OAnkush Jhilu Narulkar. T

34/4 Shakaram Laxman Gawas.Nakul Sagun Narulkar. OShripad Mahadev Nadkarni. O 2025Krishnaji Mahadev Nadkarni. O

Dattaram Nahadev Nadkarni. ODamodar Ramchandra ONadkarni.Narayan Balkrishna Nadkarni.ORavalnath Ramchandra ONadkarni. RaghunathYeshwant Nadkarni. OVassudev Sadashiv Nadkarni. OVaman Dattaram Telang. OSadashiv Balkrishna Nadkarni.OAnkush Jhilu Narulkar. T

34/5 Vishnu Narayan Ghogale.Bappu Rajaram LaxmanNarulkar.Tukaram Krishna Gawas.Shivaji Govind P. P. Dessai. O 2125Sagun Laxman Narulkar. TRajaram Laxman Narulkar. TRama Arjun Narulkar. TBhiva Phati Narulakar. T

34/6 Shripad Mahadev Nadkarni. O 1400Krishnaji Mahadev Nadkarni. ODattaram Mahadev Nadkarni. ODamodar Ramchandra ONadkarni.Narayan Balkrishna Nadkarni. ORavalnath Ramchandra ONadkarni.Raghunath Yeshwant ONadkarni.Vassudev Sadashiv Nadkarni. OVaman Dattaram Telang. OSadashiv Balkarishna Nadkarni. OAnkush Jhilu Narulkar. T

34/11 Vishwanath NayrayanNarulkar.Vishnu Narayan Ghogale.Tukaram Krishna Gawas.Sitabai Sitaram Narulkar. O 2375Rama Arjun Narulkar. OBhiva Phati Narulkar. ORaghoba Nagu Narulkar. O

34/12 Bappu Rajaram LaxmanNarulkar.Nakul Laxman Narulkar.Sagun Laxman Narulkar. O 2125Rajarm Laxman Narulkar. OKeshav Laxman Narulkar. OVishram Laxman Narulkar. O

34/14 Jiva Bhikaji Narulkar. O 7225Uttam Rama Narulakar. O

34/15 Jiva Bhikaji Narulkar. O 1150Uttam Rama Narulkar. O

1 2 3 1 2 3


825

34/17 Tukaram Krishna Gawas.Rama Arjun Narulkar. O 450Jiva Bhikaji Narulkar. O

34/18 Bappu Rajaram LaxmanNarulkar.Nakul Sagun Narulkar.Sagun Laxman Narulkar. O 500Rajaram Laxman Narulkar. OKeshav Laxman Narulkar. OVishram Laxman Narulkar. O

34/20 Bappu Rajaram LaxmanNarulkar.Nakul Sagun Narulkar.Sagun Laxman Narulkar. O 1675Rajaram Laxman Narulkar. OKeshav Laxman Narulkar. OVishram Laxman Narulkar. O

34/21 Vassudev Narayan Narulkar.Govind Pundalik Narulkar. O 17225Vasu Narayan Narulkar. OVithal Krishna Narulkar. OSubhadra Hari Narulkar. OGopal Pandurang Narulkar. O

34/25 Vishnu Narayan Ghogale.Bappu Rajaram LaxmanNarulkar.Tukaram Krishna Gawas.Shivaji Govind P. P. Dessai. O 11550Sagun Laxman Narulkar. TRajaram Laxman Narulkar. TRama Arjun Narulkar. TBhiva Phati Narulkar. T

34/26 Jiva Bhikaji Narulkar. O 3325Jiva Bhivaji Narulkar. OUttam Rama Narulkar. T

34/29 Shripad Mahadev Nadkarni. O 1650Krishnaji Mahadev Nadkarni. ODattaram Mahadev Nadkarni. ODamodar Ramchandra ONadkarni.Narayan Balkrishna Nadkarni. ORavalnath Ramchandra ONadkarni.Raghunath Yeshwant ONadkarni.Vassudev Sadashiv Nadkarni. OVaman Dattaram Telang. OSadashiv Balkrishna ONadkarni.Ankush Jhilu Narulkar. TSoma Kanu Narulkar. TJiva Bhikaji Narulakar. TUttam Rama Narulkar. T

34/30 (P) Bappu Rajaram LaxmanNarulkar.Nakul Sagun Narulkar.Sagun Laxman Narulkar. O 3450Rajaram Laxman Narulkar. OKeshav Laxman Narulkar. OVishwanath Laxman Narulkar.O

34/31 Shripad Mahadev Nadkarni. O 4950Krishnaji Mahadev Nadkarni. ODattaram Mahadev Nadkarni. ODamodar Ramchandra ONadkarni.Narayan Balkrishna Nadkarni. ORavalnath Ramchandra ONadkarni.Raghunath Yeshwant ONadkarni.Vassudev Sadashiv Nadkarni. OVaman Dattaram Telang. OSadashiv Balkarishna Nadkarni.OAnkush Jhilu Narulkar. T

34/32(P) Sitabai Sitaram Narulkar. O 1600Raghoba Nagu Narulkar. ORama Arjun Narulkar. OBhiva Phati Narulkar. O

34/33 (P) Vishnu Narayan Ghogale.Anand Bhiva Bhaip.Bhiva Vishnu Bhaip. O 1100

34/34 Shashikant Rama Gawas.Sahdev Vishnu Bhaip. O 5300Rama Sadu Gauns. O

34/35(P) Govind Pundalik Narulkar. O 4710Vithal Krishna Narulkar. O

35/1 Vishnu Narayan Ghogale.Bappu Rajaram LaxmanNarulkar.Tukaram Krishna Gawas.Nakul Sagun Narulkar.Shivaji Govind P. P. Dessai. O 55900Sagun Laxman Narulkar. TRajaram Laxman Narulkar. TSitabai Sitaram Narulkar. TRaghoba Nagu Narulkar. TRama Arjun Narulkar. TBhiva Phati Narulkar. T

35/2 Tukaram Krishna Gawas.Shivaji Govind P. P. Dessai. O 850Rama Arjun Narulkar. TSoma Anu Narulkar. T

35/3 Bappu Rajaram LaxmanNarulkar.Nakul Sagun Narulkar.Shivaji Govind P. P. Dessai. O 1750Rajaram Laxman Narulkar. OSagun Laxman Narulkar. O

1 2 3 1 2 3


826

35/4 Tukaram Krishna Gawas.Shivaji Govind P. P. Dessai. O 3150Rama Arjun Narulkar. T



35/16 Bappu Rajaram LaxmanNarulkar.Nakul Sagun Narulkar.Shivaji Govind P. P. Dessai. O 1250Rajaram Laxman Narulkar. TSagun Laxman Narulkar. T

35/17 Tukaram Krishna Gawas.Shivaji Govind P. P. Dessai. O 1200Rama Arjun Narulkar. T



35/21 Vishnu Narayan Ghogale.Shivaji Govind P. P. Dessai. O 925Bhiva Phatai Narulkar. T

35/22 Vishnu Narayan Ghogale.Shivaji Govind P. P. Dessai. O 4925Bhiva Phati Narulkar. T

Total: 514050

Taluka: Pernem Village: Casarvornem

220/1 Chandrakant SitaramSalgaonkar.Vasant Narayan Naik. O 2250Sitaram Laxman Salgaonkar. T

220/2 Chandrakant SitaramSalgaonkar.Sonu Sarado Gaad. O 5925Sitaram Laxman Salgaonkar. T

221/1 Mohan Rama Salgaonkar. 49725Shri Devi Sateri Devasthan OVahit.Vishram Krishna Naik. ORama Babani Salgaonkar. T

221/2 Arjun Jayram Salgaonkar.Shri Devi Sateri Devasthan O 8400Vahit.Vishram Krishna Naik. OJairam Laxman Salgonkar. T

222/1 Prashant Namdev Tulaskar.Shri Devi Sateri Devasthan O 11450Vahit.Vishram Krishna Naik. OJairam Laxman Salgonkar. T

222/3 (P) Chandrakant SitaramSalgaonkar.Shri Devi Sateri Devasthan O 5201Vahit.Vishram Krishna Naik. OSitaram Laxman Salgaonkar. T

222/6 (P) Chandrakant SitaramSalgaonkar.Shri Devi Sateri Devasthan O 1540Vahit.Vishram Krishna Naik. OManohar ShankarSalgaonkar. TSitaram Laxman Salgaonkar. T

223/0 (P) Chandrakant SitaramSalgaonkar.Mohan Rama Salgaonkar.Shri Dev Vas Tulaskar O 56257Vadi Vahit.Vithal Govind Tulaskar. ORama Babli Salgaonkar. TSavalo Sajo Salgaonkar. TSitaram Laxman Salgaonkar. T

224/1 Tulsidas Ladu Mayekar.Shri Devi Sateri Devasthan O 4425Vahit.Vithal Govind Tulaskar. OShri Dev Vas Tulaskar OVadi Vahit.Vithal Govind Tulaskar. OLadu Mahadeo Mayekar. T

224/2 Shamsundar NarayanMayekar.Shri Dev Vas Tulaskar O 27300Vadi Vahit.Vithal Govind Tulaskar. ONarayan Babu Mayekar. T

225/1 (P) Bhima Jairam Tulaskar.Babaji Krishna Tulaskar.

1 2 3 1 2 3


827

Shri Dev Vas Tulaskar O 640Vadi Vahit.Vithal Govind Tulaskar. OJairam Krishna Tulaskar. TBabaji Krishna Tulaskar. TVishnu Krishna Tulaskar. T

225/2 (P) Rupesh Nilkhant Tulaskar.Shri Dev Vas Tulaskar O 30005Vadi Vahit.Vithal Govind Tulaskar. OKeshav Sukha Tulaskar. T

225/3 Shamsundar NarayanMayekar.Shri Dev Vas Tulaskar O 1500Vadi Vahit.Vithal Govind Tulaskar. ONarayan Babu Mayekar. T

238/6 (P) Dinkar Dharma Tulaskar.Shri Devi Sateri Devasthan O 1212Vahit.Vishram Krishna Naik. ODharma Surba Tulaskar. T

238/7 Dinkar Dharma Tulaskar. O 8475Shri Devi Sateri Devasthan TVahit.Vishram Krishna Naik.Dharma Surba Tulaskar.

238/8 (P) Rupesh Nilkhant Tulaskar.Shri Devi Sateri Devasthan O 4630Vahit.Vishram Krishna Naik. OKeshav Surba Tulaskar. T

238/11 Janardhan Ganesh Tulaskar.Shri Devi Sateri Devasthan O 1100Vahit.Vishram Krishna Naik. OGanesh Surba Tulaskar. T

238/13 Dinkar Dharma Tulaskar.Shri Dev Vas Tulaskarvadi. O 1600Vahi.Vithal G. Tulaskar. TDharma Surba Tulaskar.

238/14 Dinkar Dharma Tulaskar.Prashant Namdev Tulaskar.Shri Dev Vas Tulaskarvadi O 1700Vahi.Vithal G. Tulaskar. ODharma Surba Tulaskar. TJairam Laxma Salgaonkar.

238/16 Prashant Namdev Tulaskar.Shri Dev Sateri Devasthan O 2225Vahit.Vishram Krishna Naik. OJairam Laxman Salgoankar. T

239/0 Shri Dev Vas Tulaskar Vadi O 17100Vahit.Vithal Govind Tulaskar. ONavso Savalo Salgaonkar. T

240/2 Prashant Namdev Tulaskar.Shri Dev Vas Tulaskar Vadi O 7500Vahit.Vithal Govind Tulaskar. OJairam Laxman Salgaonkar. T

240/3 Tulsidas Ladu Mayekar.Shri Dev Vas Tulaskar Vadi O 8100Vahit.Vithal Govind Tulaskar. OLadu Mahadev Mayekar. T

240/4 Shamsundar NarayanMayekar.Shri Dev Vas Tulaskar Vadi O 2050Vahit.Vithal Govind Tulaskar. ONarayan Babu Mayekar. T

240/6 Navo Savlo Salgaonkar.Shri Dev Vas Tulaskar Vadi O 5300Vahit.Vithal Govind Tulaskar. OSavlo Sajo Salgaonkar. T

240/7 Tulsidas Ladu Mayekar.Shri Dev Vas Tulaskar Vadi O 3400Vahit.Vithal Govind Tulaskar. OLadu Mahadev Mayekar. T

240/9 Navso Savlo Salgaonkar.Shri Dev Vas Tulaskar Vadi O 2400Vahit.Vithal Govind Tulaskar. OSavlo Sajo Salgaonkar. T

240/10 Chandrakant SitaramSalgaonkar.Shri Dev Vas Tulaskar Vadi O 15800Vahit.Vithal Govind Tulaskar. OSitaram Laxman Sadekar. T

241/1 Rupesh Nilkhant Tulaskar.Shri Devi Sateri Devasthan O 22600Vahit.Vishram Krishna Naik. OKeshav Surba Tulaskar. T

241/2 Prashant Namdev Tulaskar.Shri Devi Sateri Devasthan O 20500Vahit.Vishram Krishna Naik. OJairam Laxman Salgaonkar.

242/1 Nauso Savlo Salgaonkar.Shri Devi Sateri Devasthan O 1950Vahit.Vishram Krishna Naik. ONavso Sajo Tulaskar. O

1 2 3 1 2 3


828

242/2 Janardhan Ganesh Tulaskar.Shri Devi Sateri Devasthan O 4175Vahit.Vishram Krishna Naik. OBhiva Badu Tulaskar. T

242/3 Nauso Savlo Salgaonkar.Shri Devi Sateri Devasthan O 1075Vahit.Vishram Krishna Naik. ONavso Sajo Tulaskar. T

242/5 Nauso Savlo Salgaonkar. OShri Devi Sateri Devasthan O 1025Vahit.Vishram Krishna Naik. ONavso Saju Tulaskar. T

242/7 Shri Devi Sateri Devasthan O 2600Vahit.Vishram Krishna Naik. ONavso Sajo Tulaskar. T


242/14 Shamsundar NarayanMayekar.Shri Devi Sateri Devasthan O 2250Vahit.Vishram Krishna Naik. ONarayan Babu Mayekar. T

242/17 Vishnu Krishna Tulaskar.Shri Dev Vas Sateri O 7800Devasthan Vahit.Vishram Krishna Naik. OVishnu Krishna Tulaskar. T


244/1 Vithal Sagun Harijan.Laxman Gonde Parab. O 1475Sagun Naguesh Harijan. T

244/3 Dinkar Dharma Tulaskar.Vishram Krishna Naik. O 3050

244/4 Vishram Baji Tulaskar. O 1475Vishram Krishna Naik. OVishram Baji Tulaskar. T

244/5 Prashant Namdev Tulaskar.Vishram Krishna Naik. O 1450Namdeo Mahadev Tulaskar. T

244/7 Prashant Namdev Tulaskar.Laxman Govind Parab. O 625Namdeo Mahadev Tulaskar. T

244/9 Prashant Namdev Tulaskar.Vishram Krishna Naik O 1025Namdeo Mahadev Tulaskar. T

244/10 Dinkar Dharma Tulaskar.Vishram Krishna Naik. O 1075Dharma Sukha Tulaskar. T

244/11 Dinkar Dharma Tulaskar.Vishram Krishna Naik. O 725Dharma Sukha Tulaskar. T

244/12 Vishram Krishna Naik. O 1050Navso Sajo Tulaskar. T

245/3 Shantaram Krishna Tulaskar. O 675Vishram Krishna Naik. OShantaram Krishna Tulaskar. T

245/4 Bhima Jairam Tulaskar.Vishram Krishna Naik. O 575Jairam Krishna Tulaskar. T

245/10 Mohan Rama Salgaonkar. 600Gangaram Bhiva Keni. ORama Babani Salgaonkar. T

245/13 Rupesh Nilkhant Tulaskar.Vishram Krishna Naik. O 700Keshav Sukha Tulaskar. T

245/14 Navso Savlo Salgaonkar.Vishram Krishna Naik. O 750Navso Sajo Salgaonkar. T

245/17 Janardhan Ganesh Tulaskar.Laxman Gonde Parab. O 975Ganesh Sukha Tulaskar. T

245/18 Gurudas Dattaram Harijan. O 1025Laxman Gonde Parab. TDattaram Yesso Harijan.

245/19 Gurudas Dattaram Harijan. O 1950Laxman Gonde Parab. TDattaram Yesso Harijan.

245/26 Gurudas Dattaram Harijan. O 900Sonu Sardo Gaad. TDattaram Yesso Harijan.

245/27 Gurudas Dattaram Harijan.Sonu Sardo Gaad. O 1600Dattaram Yesso Harijan. T

245/28 Sonu Sardo Gaad. O 1675Dattaram Yesso Harijan. T

245/29 Gurudas Dattaram Harijan.Sonu Sardo Gaad. O 2025Dattaram Yesso Harijan. T


247/7 Chandrakant SitaramSalgaonkar.Shri Devi Sateri Devasthan O 1600Vahit.

1 2 3 1 2 3


829

Vishram Krishna Naik. OVishram Baji Tulasker. TGunaji Nanulo Tulaskar. T

247/9 Chandrakant SitaramSalgaonkar.Shri Devi Sateri Devasthan O 6050Vahit.Vishram Krishna Naik. OSitaram Laxman Salgaonkar.T

247/12 Janardhan Ganesh Tulaskar.Shri Devi Sateri Devasthan O 2800Vahit.Vishram Krishna Naik. OGanesh Sukha Tulaskar. T


252/0 Dhaku Sudu Varak.Budhaji Sadu Gad. O 82600Seedu Chima Varak. T

254/1 Dhaku Sudu Varak.Bablo Bhikaji Gad. O 2900Seedu Chima Varak. T

254/2 Dhaku Sudu Varak.Bhiva Sarshetty. O 1675Seedu Chima Varak. T

254/3 Dhaku Sudu Varak.Vasu Rama Kubal. O 1600Seedu Chima Varak. T

254/11 Dhaku Babau Varak.Vasant Narayan Naik. O 1575Krishna Sadashiv Shetkar. OBabu Dhulo Varak. T

254/12 Dhaku Babau Varak.Jairam Sarmalkar. O 3375Gangaram Bhikaji Palyekar. OBudho Dhulo Varak. T

254/13 Dhaku Babau Varak.Rama Ganu Shetkar. O 2850Shivaji Govind P. P. Dessai. OVasant Narayan Naik. OBudho Dhulo Varak. T

254/14 Dhaku Babau Varak.Vishram Krishna Naik. O 2500Babu Dhulo Varak. T

254/15 Padu Nagu Varak.Vishram Krishna Naik. O 2150Nagu Bhairu Varak. T

254/16 Padu Nagu Varak.Vishram Maso Naik. O 4150Nagu Bhairu Varak. T

254/17 Padu Nagu Varak.Vasant Narayan Naik. O 2025Nagu Bhairu Varak. T

254/18 Padu Nagu Varak.Shivaji Govind P. P. Dessai. O 3 1 0 0Nagu Bhairu Varak. T

254/19 Padu Nagu Varak.Laxman Yeshwant Parab. O 1175Nagu Bhairu Varak. T


254/22 Dhaku Sudu Varak.Sadu Gad. O 2500Laxman Shankar Gad. OSeedu Chima Varak. T

256/4 Dhaku Babau Varak.Vasant Narayan Naik. O 325Krishna Sadashiv Shetkat. OBabu Dhulo Varak. T

256/5 Dhaku Babau Varak.Jairam Sarmalkar. O 750Gangaram Bhikaji Palyekar. OBabu Dhulo Varak. T

256/6 Dhaku Babau Varak.Rama Ganu Shetkar. O 600Shivaji Govind P. P. Dessai. OBabu Dhulo Varak. T

256/7 Dhaku Babau Varak.Vishram Krishna Naik. O 1125Babu Dhulo Varak. T





256/12 Padu Nagu Varak.Shivaji Govind P. P. Dessai. O 1850Nagu Bhairu Varak. T

256/13 Padu Nagu Varak.Laxman Gonde Parab. O 1125Nagu Bhairu Varak. T

256/14 Padu Nagu Varak.Soma Narayan Naik. O 1325Nagu Bhairu Varak. T

256/15 Padu Nagu Varak.Apa Sagun Naik. O 2250Nagu Bhairu Varak. T

257/3 Shantaram Krishna Tulaskar. O 500Vishram Shivaram Naik. OShantaram Krishna Tulaskar. T

1 2 3 1 2 3


830

257/4 Bhima Jairam Tulaskar.Vishram Shivaram Naik. O 600Jairam Krishna Tulaskar. T

257/7 Chandrakant SitaramSalgaonkar.Vishram Shivaram Naik. O 1200Sitaram Laxman Salgaonkar.T

257/11 Navso Savlo Salgaonkar.Vishram Krishna Naik. O 1450Savalo Sajo Salgaonkar. T

257/13 Rupesh Nilkhant Tulaskar.Vasant Narayan Naik. O 1425Keshav Suka Tulaskar. T

257/14 Navso Savlo Salgaonkar.Vasant Narayan Naik. O 1300Navso Sajo Tulaskar. T

257/17 Janardhan Ganesh Tulaskar.Vasant Narayan Naik. O 550Ganesh Sukha Tulaskar. T

257/18 Gurudas Dattaram Harijan.Vasu Rama Kubal. O 100Dattaram Yesso Harijan. T

257/19 Gurudas Dattaram Harijan.Soma Narayan Naik. O 175Dattaram Yesso Harijan. T

258/1 Bhima Jairam Tulaskar.Vishnu Krishna Tulaskar.Jairam Krishna Tulaskar. O 4600Vishram Krishna Tulaskar. T



258/4 Bhima Jairam Tulaskar.Jairam Krishna Tulaskar. O 1525Bala Laxman Sadekar. T


258/6 Bhima Jairam Tulaskar.Dinkar Dharma Tulaskar.Jairam Krishna Tulaskar. O 675Dharma Sukha Tulaskar. T



Total: 548310

Taluka: Pernem Village: Varconda

100/0 Anant Atmaram Satardekar.Government Land. 21223Govind Atmaram Saterdekar. T

101/1 Narhari Laxman Aroskar.Government Land. 15630Laxman Bala Aroskar. T

102/1 Madan Malji Kambli.Vithal Ladu Kambli.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Narayan Jairam Kambli. O 68000Malji Jairam Kambli. ONakul Jairam Kambli. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. OLadu Vishram Kambli. OArjun Vishram Kambli. OUtttam Mahadev Kambli. ONavso Laxman Kambli. OShivram Yeshwant Kambli. OMukund Arjun Kambli. ORadhe Dharma Kambli. OAtmaram Vishram Kambli. T

103/1 Madan Malji Kambli.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Arjun Ladu Parab. O 13600Narayan Jairam Kambli. TVasant Dattaram Parab. OMalji Jairam Kambli. TRama Mahadev Parab. ONakul Jairam Kambli. TVishnu Chandre Parab. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. TBala Gopal Parab. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. OJairam Ganesh Parab. ORajendra Vasudev ODeshprabhu.Raghuraj Vasudev ODeshprabhu.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. OVishnu Narayan Parab. OYeshwant Bablo Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OGovind Laxman Parab. OBaghirathi Biva Parab. ONarayan Yesso Parab. ODattaram Narayan Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. ONavso Jairam Parab. OShiva Keshav Parab. O

1 2 3 1 2 3


831

Atmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. ONarayan Madgo Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. OSattu Vitu Parab. OBala Vittu Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. OLaxman Vitu Parab. ORama Laxman Dessai. OBablo Sakho Parab. ORamchandra Atmaram Josalkar. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OBala Sajo Josalkar. OParvati Shankar Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OBuddha Bhise Parab. OGunaji Bhise Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. ONakul Bhanji Parab. OAnant Sabaji Parab. OSavlo Rama Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OSakharam Ganesh Parab. OJijabai Tukaram Parab. OMalji Jairam Kambli. O Kuso Keshav Parab. ONavso Ladu Parab. OJagnath Sakharam Parab. OAnant Keshav Parab. OShantabai Bhikaji Parab. OVinayak Pandurang Dessai. O

103/2 Madan Malji Kambli.Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu.O 15000Malji Jairam Kambli. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. OYeshwant Laxman Parab. OGopal Dharma Parab. OVishnu Narayan Parab. OYeshwant Bablo Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OGovind Laxman Parab. OBaghirathi Biva Parab. ONarayan Yesso Parab. ODattaram Narayan Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. ONavso Jairam Parab. O

Shiva Keshav Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. ONarayan Madgo Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. OSattu Vitu Parab. OBala Vitu Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. OLaxman Vitu Parab. ORama Laxman Dessai. OBablo Sakho Parab. ORamchandra Atmaram Josalkar. OSoma Pandurang Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OBala Sajo Josalkar. OParvati Shankar Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OBuddha Bhise Parab. OGunaji Bhise Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. OAnant Sabaji Parab. OSavlo Rama Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OSakharam Ganesh Parab. OJijabai Tukaram Parab. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OKuso Keshav Parab. ONavso Ladu Parab. OJagnath Sakharam Parab. OAnant Keshav Parab. OShantabai Bhikaji Parab. OArjun Ladu Parab. OVasant Dattaram Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. ONarayan Ganesh Parab. OJairam Ganesh Parab. OVinayak Pandurang Dessai. O

103/3 Madan Malji Kambli.Parvati Shankar Parab. O 4000Bhimsen Narayan Kambli. TRama Hire Parab. OBuddha Bhise Parab. OGunaji Bhise Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. O

1 2 3 1 2 3


832

Nakul Bhanji Parab. OAnant Sabaji Parab. OSawlo Rama Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OSakharam Ganesh Parab. OJijabai Tukaram Parab. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OKuso Keshav Parab. ONavso Ladu Parab. OJagnath Sakharam Parab. OAnant Keshav Parab. OShantabai Bhikaji Parab. OArjun Ladu Parab. OVasant Dattaram Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. OJairam Ganesh Parab. ORajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. ORaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. OYeshwant Laxman Parab. OGopal Dharma Parab. OVishnu Narayan Parab. OYeshwant Bablo Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OGovind Laxman Parab. OBhagirathi Bhiva Parab. ONarayan Yesso Parab. ODattaram Narayan Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. ONavso Jairam Parab. OShiva Keshav Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. OSattu Vitu Parab. OBala Vitu Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. OLaxman Vitu Parab. ORama Laxman Dessai. OBablo Sakho Parab. ORamchandra Atmaram Josalkar. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OBala Sajo Josalkar. O

103/4 Madan Malji Kambli.Ankush Narayan Kambli.

Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 5400Malji Jairam Kambli. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu.ONarayan Jairam Kambli. TYeshwant Laxman Parab. ONakul Jairam Kambli. TGopal Dharma Parab. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. TVishnu Narayan Parab. OYeshwant Bablo Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OGovind Laxman Parab. OBhagirathi Bhiva Parab. ONarayan Yesso Parab. ONarayan Madgo Parab. ODattaram Narayan Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. ONavso Jairam Parab. OShiva Keshav Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. OSatu Vitu Parab. OBala Vitu Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. OLaxman Vitu Parab. ORama Laxman Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Dessai. OBablo Sakho Parab. ORamchandra Atmaram Josalkar. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OBala Sakho Josalkar. OParvati Shankar Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OBuddha Bhise Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OGunaji Bhise Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OGanagaram Sade Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. ONakul Bhanji Parab. OAnant Sabaji Parab. OSawlo Rama Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OSakharam Ganesh Parab. OJijabai Tukaram Parab. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OKuso Keshav Parab. O

1 2 3 1 2 3


833

Navso Ladu Parab. OJagnath Sakharam Parab. OAnant Keshav Parab. OShantabai Bhikaji Parab. OArjun Ladu Parab. OVasant Dattaram Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. OJairama Ganesh Parab. O

103/5 Madan Malji Kambli.Narhari Laxman Aroskar.Gunaji Bhise Parab. O 3925Laxman Bablo Arorkar. TYesso Mukund Parab. OGanagaram Sade Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. ONakul Bhanji Parab. OAnant Sabaji Parab. OSawlo Rama Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OSakharam Ganesh Parab. OJijabai Tukaram Parab. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OKuso Keshav Parab. ONavso Ladu Parab. OJaganath Sakharam Parab. OAnant Keshav Parab. OShantabai Bhikaji Parab. OArjun Ladu Parab. OVasant Dattaram Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. OJairama Ganesh Parab. OGopal Dharma Parab. OVishnu Narayan Parab. OYeshwant Bablo Parab. ONarayan Madgo Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. ORajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. ORaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. OYeshwant Laxman Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OGovind Laxman Parab. OBhagirathi Bhiva Parab. ONarayan Yesso Parab. ODattaram Narayan Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. ONavso Jairam Parab. O

Shiva Keshav Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. OSatu Vitu Parab. OBala Vitu Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. OLaxman Vitu Parab. ORama Laxman Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Dessai. OBablo Sakho Parab. ORamchandra Atmaram Josalkar. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OBala Sajo Josalkar. OParvati Shankar Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OBuddha Bhise Parab. O

103/6 Madan Malji Kambli.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 650Vasant Mukund Kambli. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. OYeshwant Laxman Parab. OGopal Dharma Parab. OVishnu Narayan Parab. OYeshwant Bablo Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OGovind Laxman Parab. OBhagirathi Bhiva Parab. ONarayan Yesso Parab. ONarayan Madgo Parab. ODattaram Narayan Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. ONavso Jairam Parab. OShiva Keshav Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. OSatu Vitu Parab. OBala Vitu Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. OLaxman Vitu Parab. ORama Laxman Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Dessai. OBabalo Sakho Parab. ORamchandra Atmaram Josalkar. OSoma Pandurang Parab. O

1 2 3 1 2 3


834

Vithal Pandurang Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OBala Sajo Josalkar. OParvati Shankar Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OBuddha Bhise Parab. OGunaji Bhise Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OGanagaram Sade Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. ONakul Bhanji Parab. OAnant Sabaji Parab. OSawlo Rama Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OSakharam Ganesh Parab. OJijabai Tukaram Parab. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OKuso Keshav Parab. ONavso Ladu Parab. OJaganath Sakharam Parab. OAnant Keshav Parab. OShantabai Bhikaji Parab. OArjun Ladu Parab. OVasant Dattaram Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. OJairama Ganesh Parab. O

103/7 Madan Malji Kambli.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Ramchandra Atmaram Josalkar. O 4025Malji Jairam Kambli. TSoma Pandurang Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OBala Saju Josalkar. OParvati Shankar Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OBuddha Bhise Parab. OGunaji Bhise Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OGanagaram Sade Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. ONakul Bhanji Parab. OAnant Sabaji Parab. OSawlo Rama Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OSakharam Ganesh Parab. OJijabai Tukaram Parab. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OKuso Keshav Parab. ONavso Ladu Parab. O

Jaganath Sakharam Parab. OAnant Keshav Parab. OShantabai Bhikaji Parab. OArjun Ladu Parab. OVasant Dattaram Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. OJairama Ganesh Parab. ORajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu.ORaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. OYeshwant Laxman Parab. OGopal Dharma Parab. OVishnu Narayan Parab. OYeshwant Bablo Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OGovind Laxman Parab. OBhagirathi Bhiva Parab. ONarayan Yesso Parab. ONarayan Madgo Parab. ODattaram Narayan Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. ONavso Jairam Parab. OShiva Keshav Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. OSatu Vitu Parab. OBala Vitu Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. OLaxman Vitu Parab. ORama Laxman Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Dessai. OBablo Sakho Parab. O

104/2 Gurudas Panduran Kudav.Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 1375Pandurang Narayan Kudav. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. O

104/3 Prakesh Tukaram Satardekar.Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 2220Tukaram Govind Satardekar. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. O

104/4 Ankush Narayan Kambli.Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 6350Narayan Jairam Kambli. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. O

104/8 Prakash Tukaram Satardekar.Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 110Tukaram Govind Satardekar. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. O

1 2 3 1 2 3


835



106/9 Gurudas Pandurang Kudav.Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 275Pandurang Narayan Kudav. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. O

106/10 Anand Navso Naik.Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 825Navso Krishna Naik. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. O

106/12 Madan Malji Kambli.Ganagaram Sade Parab. O 500Purshottam Jairam Kambli. TSakharam Sade Parab. ONakul Bhanji Parab. OAnant Sadu Parab. OSawlo Rama Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OSakharam Ganesh Parab. OJijabai Tukaram Parab. OKuso Keshav Parab. OBala Sajo Josalkar. ONavso Ladu Parab. OJaganath Sakharam Parab. OAnant Keshav Parab. OShantabai Bhikaji Parab. OArjun Ladu Parab. OVasant Dattaram Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. ONarayan Maygo Parab. OYeshwant Laxman Parab. OGopal Dharma Parab. OVishram Narayan Parab. OYeshwant Bablo Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OGovind Laxman Parab. OBhagirathi Bhiva Parab. ONarayan Yesso Parab. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. ONakul Jairam Kambli. ODattaram Narayan Parab. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. ONavso Jairam Parab. O

Shiva Keshav Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OSatu Vitu Parab. OBapu Vite Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. OLaxman Vitu Parab. ORama Laxman Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Naik Dessai. OBablo Sakho Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. OJairama Ganesh Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OParvati Shankar Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OBuddha Bhise Parab. OGunaji Bhise Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. O

106/13 Madan Malji Kambli.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 845Nakul Jairam Kambli. TGopal Dharma Parab. OVishram Narayan Parab. OYeshwant Bablo Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OGovind Laxman Parab. OBhagirathi Bhiva Parab. ONarayan Yesso Parab. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. ONakul Jairam Kambli. ODattaram Narayan Parab. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. ONavso Jairam Parab. OShiva Keshav Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Phati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OSatu Vitu Parab. OBapu Vite Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. OLaxman Vitu Parab. O

1 2 3 1 2 3


836

Rama Laxman Dessai. OPandurang Naik Dessai. OBablo Sakho Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. OJairama Ganesh Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OParvati Shankar Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OBuddha Bhise Parab. OGunaji Bhise Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. ONakul Bhanji Parab. OAnant Sadu Parab. OSavalo Rama Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OSakharam Ganesh Parab. OJijabai Tukaram Parab. OKusso Keshav Parab. OBala Sajo Josalkar. ONavso Ladu Parab. OJaganath Sakharam Parab. OAnant Keshav Parab. OShantabai Bhikaji Parab. OArjun Ladu Parab. OVasant Dattaram Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. ONarayan Maigo Parab. O

106/16 Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 845Madan Malji Kambli. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. O

106/17 Narhari Laxman Aroskar.Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 480Laxman Bablo Arorkar. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. O

40/9 Ambika Vasudev Aroskar.Soma Pandurang Parab. O 8650Rama Vasu Aroskar. TFondu Hire Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OParshuram Sade Parab. OBuddha Bhise Parab. O

70/1 Madan Malji Kambli.Hari Gangaram Andurlekar.Laxman Kashiram Mavlankar.Dasharath Vithal Aroskar.Keshav Krishna Lad. O 13045Kashiram Maso Mavlankar. TShrikant Aba Lad. OVithal Purshottam Lad. O

Vithal Vasu Aroskar. TRajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu.ORaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OShivaji Govind Dessi. OBabli Krishna Lad. O

70/2 Madan Malji Kambli.Keshav Krishna Lad. O 735Jairam Vasu Aroskar. TShrikant Aba Lad. OVithal Purshottam Lad. ORajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. ORaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OShivaji Govind Dessi. OBabli Krishna Lad. O

70/3 Madan Malji Kambli.Ashwini Ashok Aroskar.Keshav Krishna Lad. O 325Krishna Vasu Aroskar. TShrikant Aba Lad. OVithal Purshottam Lad. ORajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. ORaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OShivaji Govind Dessi. OBabli Krishna Lad. O

70/4 Madan Malji Kambli.Dasharath Vithal Aroskar.Keshav Krishna Lad. O 160Vithal Vasu Aroskar. TShrikant Aba Lad. OVithal Purshottam Lad. ORajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. ORaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OShivaji Govind Dessi. OBabli Krishna Lad. O

70/5 Madan Malji Kambli.Ambika Vasudev Aroskar.Keshav Krishna Lad. O 70Rama Vasu Aroskar. TShrikant Aba Lad. OVithal Prushottam Lad. ORajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. ORaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OShivaji Govind Dessi. OBabli Krishna Lad. O

70/6 Laxman Sakharam Aroskar.Madan Malji Kambli.Sakharam Shiva Aroskar.Dasharath Vithal Aroskar. 4060Keshav Krishna Lad. O

1 2 3 1 2 3


837

Mohan Mahadev Aroskar. TShrikant Aba Lad. OShiva Pundalik Aroskar. TVithal Purshottam Lad. OSatybham Savlo Aroskar. TRajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. OVithal Vaman Aroskar. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. OLaxman Sakharam Aroskar. TMalji Jairam Kambli. OShivaji Govind Dessi. OVasant Soma Aroskar. TBabli Krishna Lad. O

70/7 Madan Malji Kambli.Hari Gangaram Andurlekar.Keshav Krishna Lad. O 10675Ganagaram Raghunath TMalvankar.Shrikant Aba Lad. OVithal Purshottam Lad. ORajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. ORaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OShivaji Govind Dessi. OBabli Krishna Lad. O

70/8 Reshma Ramesh Anulekar.Madan Malji Kambli.Keshav Krishna Lad. O 500Arjun Bala Adorlekar. OShrikant Aba Lad. OVithal Purshottam Lad. ORajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. ORaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OShivaji Govind Dessi. OBabli Krishna Lad. O

70/9 Madan Malji Kambli.Laxman Kashiram Mavlankar.Keshav Krishna Lad. O 900Kashiram Maso Mavlankar. OShrikant Aba Lad. OVithal Purshottam Lad. ORajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. ORaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OBabli Krishna Lad. OShivaji Govind Dessi. O

70/10 Reshma Ramesh Anulekar.Madan Malji Kambli.Sitaram Navso Andurlekar.Keshav Krishna Lad. O 105Navso Laxman Adorlekar. OShrikant Aba Lad. OArjun Bala Adorlekar. O

Vithal Purshottam Lad. ORajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. ORaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu.OMalji Jairam Kambli. OShivaji Govind Dessi. OBabli Krishna Lad. O

70/13 Shantaram Bablo Maulankar.Madan Malji Kambli.Keshav Krishna Lad. O 530Babal Raghunath Mavlankar. TShrikant Aba Lad. OVithal Purshottam Lad. ORajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. ORaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OShivaji Govind Dessi. OBabli Krishna Lad. O

70/14 Reshma Ramesh Anulekar.Madan Malji Kambli.Keshav Krishna Lad. O 1525Arjun Bala Adorlekar. TShrikant Aba Lad. OVithal Purshottam Lad. ORajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. ORaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OShivaji Govind Dessi. OBabli Krishna Lad. O

70/15 Madan Malji Kambli.Keshav Krishna Lad. O 315Mathura Shantaram Mavalankar.TShrikant Aba Lad. OVithal Purshottam Lad. ORajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. ORaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OShivaji Govind Dessi. OBabli Krishna Lad. O

70/16 Madan Malji Kambli.Laxman Kashiram Mavlankar.Keshav Krishna Lad. O 5045Kashiram Maso Mavlankar. TShrikant Aba Lad. OVithal Prushottam Lad. ORajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu.ORaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OShivaji Govind Dessi. OBabli Krishna Lad. O

70/17 Madan Malji Kambli.Keshav Krishna Lad. O 880Ganagaram Raghunath TMavlankar.Shrikant Aba Lad. O

1 2 3 1 2 3


838

Vithal Purshottam Lad. ORajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OShivaji Govind Dessi. OBabli Krishna Lad. ORaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. O

71/4 Rajaram Sakharam Parab. O 6375Laxman Sakharam Aroskar. TAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ODattaram Narayan Parab. ONarayan Jairam Parab. O

71/5 Laxman Kashiram Mavlankar.Dattaram Narayan Parab. O 7575Kashiram Maso Mavlankar. TNarayan Jairam Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OYeshwant Laxman Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. O

71/7 Laxman Kashiram Mavlankar.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Dattaram Narayan Parab. O 825Kashiram Maso Mavlankar. TNaryan Jairam Kambli. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. O

71/9 Madan Malji Kambli.Ashwini Ashok Aroskar.Ganagaram Sade Parab. O 2100Krishna Vasu Aroskar. TFondu Hire Parab. OKuso Keshav Parab. ONavso Ladu Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OMalji Jairam Kambli. ONakul Bhanji Parab. O

71/10 Dasharath Vithal Aroskar.Parvatibai Neilu Parab. O 13325Vithal Vasu Aroskar. TGangaram Sade Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. OKuso Keshav Parab. ODondu Anant Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. O

71/11 Madan Malji Kambli.Gangaram Sade Parab. O 525Vithal Vasu Aroskar. TVithal Pandurang Parab. OKuso Keshav Parab. ODondu Anant Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OMalji Jairam Kambli. ONakul Bhanji Parab. OParvatibai Neilu Parab. O

71/12 Hari Gangaram Andurlekar.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 1050

Gangaram Dattaram Aroskar. TVishnu Narayan Parab. OYeshwant Bablo Parab. OGopal Dharma Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. ONakul Jairam Kambli. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. O

71/13 Hari Gangaram Andurlekar.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Satu Vitu Parab. O 1575Gangaram Dattaram Andolekar. TNaryan Jairam Kambli. O

71/14 Madan Malji Kambli.Ambika Vasudev Aroskar.Jagnath Sakharam Parab. O 2575Rama Vasu Aroskar. TYesso Mukund Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. OBuddha Bhise Parab. OKuso Keshav Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OSavlo Rama Parab. OParvatibai Neilu Parab. O

71/15 Laxman Kashiram Mavlankar.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Dattaram Narayan Parab. O 1600Kashiram Maso Mavlankar. TNaryan Jairam Kambli. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. O

71/18 Satu Vitu Parab. O 5850Bhagwan Sakharam Sonulikar. T

71/20 Madan Malji Kambli.Ashwini Ashok Aroskar.Fondu Hire Parab. O 6700Krishna Vasu Aroskar. TSakharam Ganesh Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. ONavso Ladu Parab. OKuso Keshav Parab. OSavlo Rama Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OMalji Jairam Kambli. O

71/21 Bhagwan Sakharam Sonulikar.Satu Vitu Parab. O 775

71/22 Ankush Narayan Kambli.Dattaram Narayan Parab. O 3525Keshav Bala Andolekar. TNarayan Jairam Kambli. O

71/23 Laxman Kashiram Mavlankar.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Dattaram Narayan Parab. O 8500Kashiram Maso Mavlankar. T

1 2 3 1 2 3


839

Narayan Jairam Kambli. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. O

71/24 Hari Gangaram Andurlekar.Satu Vitu Parab. O 15650Gangaram Dattaram Andolekar. T

71/25 Laxman Kashiram Mavlankar.Dattaram Narayan Parab. O 13450Kashiram Maso Mavlankar. TNarayan Jairam Parab. OYeshwant Laxman Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. O

71/26 Laxman Kashiram Mavlankar.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Dattaram Narayan Parab. O 9400Kashiram Maso Mavlankar. TNarayan Jairam Kambli. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. O

71/28 Ankush Narayan Kambli.Dattaram Narayan Parab. O 1100Keshav Bala Andolekar. TNaryan Jairam Kambli. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. O

71/29 Ankush Narayan Kambli.Dattaram Narayan Parab. O 3675Keshav Bala Andolekar. TNarayan Jairam Kambli. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. O


71/32 Laxman Kashiram Mavlankar.Dattaram Narayan Parab. O 575Kashiram Maso Mavlankar. TNarayan Jairam Kambli. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. O

71/33 Madan Malji Kambli.Buddhaji Kise Parab. O 14125Jairam Vasu Aroskar. TVasant Dattaram Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. OKuso Keshav Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OParvatibai Neilu Parab. O


72/2 Madan Malji Kambli.Ambika Vasudev Aroskar.Soma Pandurang Parab. O 4575Rama Vasu Aroskar. TGangaram Sade Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OKuso Keshav Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OAnant Sabhaji Parab. O

72/4 Madan Malji Kambli.Fondu Hire Parab. O 2025Vithal Vasu Aroskar. TGangaram Sade Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. OKuso Keshav Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OVasant Dattaram Parab. OMalji Jairam Kambli. ONakul Kanji Parab. OParvatibai Neilu Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. O

72/5 Laxman Kashiram Mavlankar.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Dattaram Narayan Parab. O 2375Kashiram Maso Mavlankar. TRamkrishna Mukund Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. O

72/6 Bhagwan Sakharam Sonulikar.T 2400Satu Vitu Parab. ORamchandra Atmaram Josalkar. OFati Saju Keni. OLaxman Rama Dessai. ONaryan Sakhe Parab. OHari Vite Parab. O

72/8 Dasharath Vithal Aroskar.Gangaram Sade Parab. O 3900Vithal Vasu Aroskar. T

72/10 Laxman Sakharam Aroskar. TLaxman Kashiram Mavlankar.Ankush Narayan Kambli. O 3400Dattaram Narayan Parab. TKashiram Maso Mavlankar.Ramkrishna Mukund Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. O

72/11 Bhagwan Sakharam Sonulikar. T 2175Fati Saju Keni. OSatu Vitu Parab. OLaxman Rama Dessai. OHari Vite Parab. OAnant Arjun Parab. ORamchandra Atmaram Josalkar. O

72/12 Hari Gangaram Andurlekar.Jairam Bale Parab. O 2900

1 2 3 1 2 3


840

Gangaram Dataram Andole. TSatu Vitu Parab. OHari Vite Parab. OLaxman Vitu Parab. OAnant Arjun Parab. OBiva Vite Parab. ORajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. ORaghunath Vasudev ODeshprabhu.

74/1 Ankush Narayan Kambli.Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 136500Narayan Jairam Kambli. TRaghunath Vasudev ODeshprabhu.



75/4 Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 4225Navso Laxman Adorlekar. TRaghunath Vasudev Deshprabhu. O

75/5 Krishna Pundalik Bhagat.Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 2225Dondu Anant Parab. T

75/6 Purushottam Sonu Aroskar.Ramchandra Fati Parab. O 1575Sonu Narayan Aroskar. T

75/7 Jayanti Jagannath Aroskar.Shiva Ladu Chari. O 950Shankar Anant Nasulkar. TNakul Narayan Aroskar. O

75/8 Ankush Narayan Kambli.Bhagwan Sakharam Sonulikar.T 1025Satu Vitu Parab. OLaxman Rama Dessai. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. O

75/9 Hari Gangaram Andurlekar.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Satu Vitu Parab. O 725Gangaram Dataram Andolekar. TRamchandra Fati Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. O

75/10 Laxman Kashiram Mavlankar.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Dattaram Narayan Parab. O 900Kashiram Moso Malvankar. TNarayan Jairam Kambli. O

Ramkrishna Mukund Parab. OYeshwant Laxman Parab. O

75/11 Ankush Narayan Kambli.Keshav Bala Andolekar. T 1000Vishnu Narayan Parab. O

TNarayan Jairam Kambli. ODattaram Narayan Parab. O

75/12 Ankush Narayan Kambli.Laxman Sakharam Aroskar. T 425Vishnu Dattaram Parab. ODattaram Narayan Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. ORajaram Sakharam Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. O

75/13 Ankush Narayan Kambli.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 1275Gangaram Raghunath Malvankar. TYeshwant Bablo Parab. OGopal Dharma Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. O


75/15 Laxman Kashiram Mavlankar.Satu Vitu Parab. O 1425Kashiram Maso Mavlankar. TDattaram Narayan Parab. O

75/17 Madan Malji Kambli.Aswini Ashok Aroskar.Gangaram Sade Parab. O 2100Vithu Vasu Aroskar. TFondu Hire Parab. ORama Vasu Aroskar. TBala Gopal Parab. OKrishna Vasu Aroskar. TBuddha Bhise Parab. ORama Vasu Aroskar. TArjun Govind Parab. ODondu Anant Parab. ONakul Bhanji Parab. OBablo Devo Parab. OParvatibai Neilu Parab. OMalji Jairam Kambli. O

76/1 Bhagwan Sakharam Sonulikar. T 1800Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. ORaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. O

76/2 Laxman Sakharam Aroskar. T 1725Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. ORaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. O

76/3 Krishna Pundalik Bhagat.Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 1375

1 2 3 1 2 3


841

Dondu Anant Parab. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. O

76/4 Purushottam Sonu Aroskar.Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 1525Sonu Narayan Aroskar. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. O

76/5 Jayanti Jagannath Aroskar.Shiva Ladu Chari. O 1500Nakul Narayan Aroskar. T

76/7 Ankush Narayan Kambli.Bhagwan Sakharam Sonulikar. T 1350Satu Vitu Parab. OLaxman Rama Dessai. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. O

76/8 Hari Gangaram Andurlekar.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Ramkrishna Mukund Parab. O 825Gangaram Dattaram Sonulikar. TLaxman Rama Dessai. OSatu Vitu Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. O

76/9 Laxman Kashiram Mavlankar.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Satu Vitu Parab. O 1225Kashiram Maso Mavlankar. TDattaram Narayan Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. O

76/10 Ankush Narayan Kambli.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 1025Keshav Bala Andolekar. TSatu Vitu Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. O

76/11 Ankush Narayan Kambli.Ramchandra Fati Parab. O 450Laxman Sakharam Aroskar. TSatu Vitu Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. O

76/12 Ankush Narayan Kambli.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 1600Gangaram Raghunath Malvankar. TVishnu Narayan Parab. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. O

76/13 Laxman Kashiram Mavlankar.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Narayan Jairam Kambli. O 950Kashiram Maso Mavlankar. TDattaram Narayan Parab. O

76/15 Ambika Vasudev Aroskar.Ashwini Ashok Aroskar.Vithal Vasu Aroskar. O 9450Jairam Vasu Aroskar. T

Krishna Vasu Aroskar. ORama Vasu Aroskar. O

76/17 Laxman Kashiram Mavlankar.Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 1125Kashiram Yesso Mavlankar. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. O

77/1 Laxman Kashiram Mavlankar.Dattaram Narayan Parab. O 650Kashiram Maso Mavlankar. TRamchandra Soiraji Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. OKrishna Nanaji Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. O


77/3 Hari Gangaram Andurlekar.Satu Vitu Parab. O 50Gangaram Dattaram Andolekar. THari Vite Parab. OBablo Sakho Parab. TJairam Bale Parab. OJaganath Sathu Mahale. TArjun Laxman Parab. OSahadev Laxman Parab. OAnant Arjun Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. O

77/5 Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 125Keshav Bala Aroskar. TSatu Vitu Parab. ORajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. ORaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. O

77/6 Madan Malji Kambli.Hari Gangaram Andurlekar.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Satu Vitu Parab. O 3575Gangaram Dattaram Andolekar. THari Vite Parab. OJairam Bale Parab. OArjun Laxman Parab. OSahadev Laxman Parab. OAnant Arjun Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. ORamchandra Atmaram Josalkar. OLaxman Rama Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Dessai. ONarayan Sakhe Parab. OBablo Sakho Parab. OAtmaram Bapu Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. OMalji Jairam Kambli. O

1 2 3 1 2 3


842

77/7 Jayanti Jagannath Aroskar.Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 2125Nakul Narayan Aroskar. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. OShankar Anant Aroskar. T

77/8 Hari Gangaram Andurlekar.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Satu Vitu Parab. O 750Gangaram Dattaram Andolekar. THari Vitu Parab. OJairam Bale Parab. OArjun Laxman Parab. OSahadev Laxman Parab. OBabalo Sakho Parab. OAtmaram Bapu Parab. OAnant Arjun Parab. OVishnu Bhiva Parab. ORamchandra Atmaram Josalkar. OLaxman Rama Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Dessai. ONarayan Sakhe Parab. OBablo Sakho Parab. OFati Saju Keni. OAtmaram Bapu Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. O

77/10 Laxman Kashiram Mavlankar.Dattaram Narayan Parab. O 400Kashiram Maso Mavlankar. TRamchandra Soiraji Parab. OLaxman Raghunath Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. O

77/11 Laxman Kashiram Mavlankar.Dattaram Narayan Parab. O 550Kashiram Maso Mavlankar. TRamchandra Soiraji Parab. OLaxman Raghunath Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. O

78/1 Madan Malji Kambli.Keshav Bala Andolekar. T 14000Dattaram Narayan Parab.Malji Jairam Kambli. O

78/2 Dasharath Vithal Aroskar.Shriram Appa Parab. O 7575Vithal Vasu Aroskar. T

Vaman Dattaram Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. OBuddha Bhise Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. OJairam Ganesh Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OParvati Shankar Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OKuso Keshav Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OManohar Shankar Parab. ODhondu Anant Parab. OJagnath Sakharam Parab. ONavso Ladu Parab. O

78/4 Ashwini Ashok Aroskar.Shriram Appa Parab. O 6400Krishna Vasu Aroskar. TVaman Dattaram Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. OBuddha Bhise Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. OJairama Ganesh Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OParvati Shankar Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OKuso Keshav Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OManohar Shankar Parab. ODhondu Anant Parab. OJaganath Sakharam Parab. ONavso Ladu Parab. O

78/5 Hari Gangaram Andurlekar.Shripad Appa Parab. O 5050Laxman Sakharam Aroskar. TVaman Dattaram Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. OBuddha Bhise Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. OJairam Ganesh Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. O

1 2 3 1 2 3


843

Parvati Shankar Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OManohar Shankar Parab. ODhondu Anant Parab. OJaganath Sakharam Parab. ONavso Ladu Parab. OKuso Keshav Parab. O

78/6 Hari Gangaram Andurlekar.Laxman Sakharam Aroskar. T 13675Satu Vitu Parab. OGangaram Dattaram Andolekar. THari Vitu Parab. OArjun Laxman Parab. OSahadev Laxman Parab. OAnant Arjun Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. OJairam Bale Parab. O

78/7 Hari Gangaram Andurlekar.Satu Vitu Parab. O 12525Gangaram Dattaram Andolekar. THari Vitu Parab. OArjun Laxman Parab. OSahadev Laxman Parab. OAnant Arjun Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. OJairam Bale Parab. O

78/8 Raghuvir Atmaram Aroskar.Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 6800Atmaram Narayan Aroskar. T

78/9 Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 2450Laxman Sakharam Aroskar. T

78/10 Purushottam Sonu Aroskar.Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 10750Sonu Narayan Aroskar. O

78/11 Dasharath Vithal Aroskar.Shriram Appa Parab. O 1000Vithal Vasu Aroskar. TVaman Dattaram Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. OBuddha Bhise Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. OJairam Ganesh Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OParvati Shankar Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. O

Rama Mahadev Parab. OKuso Keshav Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OManohar Shankar Parab. ODhondu Anant Parab. OJagnath Sakharam Parab. ONavso Ladu Parab. O

79/1 Purushottam Sonu Aroskar.Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 9800Sonu Narayan Adorlekar. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. O

79/2 Sitaram Navso Andurlekar.Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 2400Navso Laxman Adolekar. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. O

79/3 Jayanti Jagannath Aroskar.Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 5000Nakul Narayan Aroskar. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. O

79/4 Laxman Sakharam Aroskar.Ambika Vasudev Aroskar.Sitaram Navso Andurlekar.Hari Gangaram Andurlekar.Laxman Kashiram Mavlankar.Bhagwan Sakharam Sonulikar.Dasharath Vithal Aroskar.Shriram Appa Parab. O 6500Gangaram Dattaram Andolekar. TVaman Dattaram Parab. OLaxman Govind Aroskar. TSakharam Sade Parab. OKashiram Maso Malvankar. TGanagaram Sade Parab. OBuddha Bhise Parab. OKeshav Bala Andolekar. ORama Hire Parab. OGangaram Raghu Malvankar. TVithal Pandurang Parab. ORama Vasu Aroskar. OJairam Ganesh Parab. OVithal Vasu Aroskar. TYesso Mukund Parab. OKrishna Vasu Aroskar. OParvati Shankar Parab. OJairam Vasu Aroskar. TNarayan Raghu Parab. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OKuso Keshav Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OManohar Shankar Parab. O

1 2 3 1 2 3


844

Dhondu Anant Parab. OJaganath Sakharam Parab. ONavso Ladu Parab. O

79/5 Laxman Sakharam Aroskar.Ashwini Ashok Aroskar.Hari Gangaram Andurlekar.Laxman Kashiram Mavlankar.Bhagwan Sakharam Sonulikar.Dasharath Vithal Aroskar.Keshav Bala Andolekar. T 35900Shriram Appa Parab. OGangaram Dattaram Andolekar. TVaman Dattaram Parab. OLaxman Govind Aroskar. TSakharam Sade Parab. OKashiram Maso Malvankar. TGangaram Sade Parab. OBuddha Bhise Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OGangaram Raghu Malvankar. TVithal Pandurang Parab. ORama Vasu Aroskar. TJairam Ganesh Parab. OVithal Vasu Aroskar. TYesso Mukund Parab. OKrishna Vasu Aroskar. TParvati Shankar Parab. OJairam Vasu Aroskar. TNarayan Raghu Parab. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OKuso Keshav Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OManohar Shankar Parab. ODhondu Anant Parab. OJaganath Sakharam Parab. ONavso Ladu Parab. O

79/6 Laxman Kashiram Mavlankar.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 125Kashiram Maso Malvankar. TVishnu Narayan Parab. OGopal Dharma Parab. OYeshwant Bablo Parab. OSakharam Bablo Parab. ONakul Jairam Kambli. O

79/7 Laxman Sakharam Aroskar. T 125Bala Gopal Parab. ONavso Ladu Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. O

79/8 Madan Malji Kambli.Hari Gangaram Andurlekar.Ankush Narayan Kambli.

Jairam Bale Parab. O 275Gangaram Dattaram Andolekar. THari Bale parab. OAnant Arjun Parab. ORamchandra Atmaram Josalkar. OLaxman Rama Naik Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Naik Dessai. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OBiva Vitu Parab. OSathu Vitu Parab. O

80/1 Laxman Kashiram Mavlankar.Laxman Sakharam Aroskar. T 2250Dattaram Narayan Parab. OKashiram Maso Malvankar. TYeshwant Laxman Parab. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. OSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OBhagirathi Biva Parab. O

80/2 Hari Gangaram Andurlekar.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Sathu Vitu Parab. O 1275Gangaram Dattaram Andolekar. TRamchandra Laxman Naik. OVinayak Pandurang Dessai. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. O

80/3 Laxman Kashiram Mavlankar.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 1075Keshav Bala Andurlekar. TYeshwant Bablo Parab. OGangaram Raghu Malvankar. TDattaram Narayan Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. OKashiram Maso Malvankar. O

80/6 Sakharam Shiva Aroskar.Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 600Shiva Pundalik Aroskar. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. O

80/7 Sakharam Shiva Aroskar.Jayanti Jagannath Aroskar.Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 925Shiva Pundalik Aroskar. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. ONakul Narayan Aroskar. T

81/1 Hari Gangaram Andurlekar.Laxman Kashiram Mavlankar.Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 5600Laxman Sakharam Aroskar. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. O

1 2 3 1 2 3


845

Vithal Vasu Aroskar. TKashiram Maso Malvankar. TKeshav Bala Andolekar. T

81/3 Jayanti Jagannath Aroskar.Hari Gangaram Andurlekar.Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 2950Laxman Sakharam Aroskar. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. OVithal Vasu Aroskar. ONakul Narayan Aroskar. T

82/0 Purushottam Sonu Aroskar.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 7820Narayan Jairam Kambli. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. OSonu Narayan Aroskar. T

83/1 Madan Malji Kambli.Hari Gangaram Andurlekar.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Satu Vitu Parab. O 6825Gangaram Dattaram Andolekar. THari Vitu Parab. OBala Vitu Parab. OArjun Laxman Parab. OSahadev Laxman Parab. OAnant Arjun Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. ORamchandra Atmaram Josalkar. OLaxman Rama Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Dessai. ONarayan Laxman Dessai. ONarayan Sakhe Parab. OBablo Sakho Parab. OAtmaram Bapu Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. OMalji Jairam Kambli.

83/2 Madan Malji Kambli.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Laxman Sakharam Aroskar. T 3950Satu Vitu Parab. OHari Vitu Parab. OBala Vitu Parab. OArjun Laxman Parab. OSahadev Laxman Parab. OAnant Arjun Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. ORamchandra Atmaram Josalkar. OLaxman Rama Dessai. OVinayak Rama Dessai. ONarayan Laxman Dessai. OBablo Sakho Parab. ONarayan Sakhe Parab. OAtmaram Bapu Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. OMalji Jairam Kambli. O

83/3 Madan Malji Kambli.Hari Gangaram Andurlekar.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Satu Vitu Parab. O 7150Gangaram Dattaram Andolekar. THari Vitu Parab. OBala Vitu Parab. OArjun Laxman Parab. OSahadev Laxman Parab. OAnant Arjun Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. ORamchandra Atmaram Josalkar. OLaxman Rama Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Dessai. ONarayan Sakhe Parab. OBablo Sakho Parab. ONarayan Sakhe Parab. OAtmaram Bapu Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. OMalji Jairam Kambli. O

83/4 Laxman Sakharam Aroskar. T 5200Jijabai Tukaram Parab. ONakul Banji Parab. O

83/5 Madan Malji Kambli.Hari Gangaram Andurlekar.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Satu Vitu Parab. O 2725Gangaram Dataram Andolekar. THari Vitu Parab. OBala Vitu Parab. OArjun Laxman Parab. OSahadev Laxman Parab. OAnant Arjun Parab. OBiva Vitu Parab. ORamchandra Atmaram Josalkar. OLaxman Rama Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Dessai. ONarayan Laxman Dessai. OBablo Sakho Parab. ONarayan Sakhe Parab. OAtmaram Bapu Parab. OMalji Jairam Kambli. O

83/6 Madan Malji Kambli.Dattaram Narayan Parab. O 2650Kashiram Maso Malvankar. TRamchandra Soiraji Parab. OLaxman Raghunath Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ONakul Jairam Kambli. ORamchandra Fati Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. OPandurang Amtmaram Parab. O

1 2 3 1 2 3


846

Shriram Appa Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OBhagirathi Biva Parab. OMalji Jairam Kambli. ONarayan Ladu Parab. O

83/7 Madan Malji Kambli.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Satu Vitu Parab. O 2500Bhagwan Sakharam Sonulekar. TRamchandra Atmaram Josalkar. OLaxman Rama Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Dessai. ONarayan Sakhe Parab. OBablo Sakho Parab. OAtmaram Babu Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. O

83/8 Laxman Kashiram Mavlankar.Dattaram Narayan Parab. O 2225Kashiram Maso Malvankar. TRamchandra Soiraji Parab. OLaxman Raghunath Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OBhagirathi Biva Parab. ONarayan Laxman Parab. O

83/9 Madan Malji Kambli.Narayan Laxman Parab. O 1875Keshav Bala Andolekar. TDattaram Narayan Parab. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. OLaxman Raghunath Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. OPandurang Amtmaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. OSaju Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OBhagirathi Biva Parab. OMalji Jairam Kambli. O

83/10 Laxman Kashiram Malvankar.Shriram Appa Parab. O 2175Kashiram Yesso Mavlankar. TAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. O

Ramkrishna Mukund Parab. OBhagirathi Biva Parab. ONarayan Laxman Parab. ODattaram Narayan Parab. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. OLaxman Raghunath Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. O

83/13 Ashwini Ashok Aroskar.Sakharam Sade Parab. O 3150Krishna Vasu Aroskar. TGangaram Sade Parab. OBuddha Bhise Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OGunaji Bhise Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. OJairam Ganesh Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OParvati Shankar Parab. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OVaman Dattaram Parab. ONavso Ladu Parab. OJaganath Sakharam Parab. ODhondu Anant Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OSakharam Ganesh Parab. OJizabai Tukaram Parab. ONakul Banji Parab. OAnant Sabhaji Parab. OSavlo Rama Parab. OParvatibai Neilu Parab. OBablo Devu Parab. O

83/15 Ambika Vasudev Aroskar.Rama Mahadev Parab. O 3350Rama Vasu Aroskar. TVaman Dattaram Parab. ONavso Ladu Parab. OJaganath Sakharam Parab. ODhondu Anant Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OSakharam Ganesh Parab. OJizabai Tukaram Parab. ONakul Banji Parab. OAnant Sabhaji Parab. OSavlo Rama Parab. OParvatibai Neilu Parab. OBablo Devu Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. OBuddha Bhise Parab. O

1 2 3 1 2 3


847

Rama Hire Parab. OYeso Mukund Parab. OGunaji Bhise Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. OJairam Ganesh Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OParvati Shankar Parab. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. O

83/16 Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 10450Keshav Bala Andolekar. TSajo Laxman Parab. OYeshwant Bablo Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OBhagirathi Biva Parab. OGovind Laxman Parab. OVishnu Narayan Parab. O

84/1 Ambika Vasudev Aroskar.Ashwini Ashok Aroskar.Hari Gangaram Andurlekar.Laxman Kashiram Mavlankar.Dasharath Vithal Aroskar.Sakharam Sade Parab. O 52075Gangaram Dataram Andolekar. TGangaram Sade Parab. OLaxman Sakharam Aroskar. TBuddha Bhise Parab. OKashiram Maso Malvankar. TRama Hire Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OVithal Vasu Aroskar. TGunaji Bhise Parab. ORama Vasu Aroskar. TVithal Pandurang Parab. OKrishna Vasu Aroskar. TJairam Ganesh Parab. OJairam Vasu Aroskar. TNarayan Raghu Parab. OParvati Shankar Parab. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OVaman Dattaram Parab. ONavso Ladu Parab. OJaganath Sakharam Parab. ODhondu Anant Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OSakharam Ganesh Parab. OJizabai Tukaram Parab. ONakul Banji Parab. O

Anant Sabhaji Parab. OSavlo Rama Parab. OParvatibai Neilu Parab. OBablo Devu Parab. O

98/1 Anand Navso Naik.Government Land. O 1643Navso Krishna Naik. T

99/1 Gurudas Pandurang Kudav.Government Land. O 18580Pandurang Narayan Kudav. T

105/2 Vithal Ladu Kambli.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 2275Vasant Mukund Kambli. TDattaram Narayan Parab. OLadu Vishram Kambli. TSoma Pandurang Parab. OSatu Vitu Parab. O

105/6 Gurudas Pandurang Kudav.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 2500Pandurang Narayan Kudav. TDattaram Naryan Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OSatu Vitu Parab. O

105/8 Ankush Narayan Kambli.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 1075Narayan Jairam Kambli.Dattaram Naryan Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OSatu Vitu Parab. O

105/13 Narhari Laxman Aroskar.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 1600Laxman Balgo Aroskar. TDattaram Naryan Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OSatu Vitu Parab. O

105/14 Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 6600Madan Malji Kambli. TDattaram Naryan Parab. OUttam Mahadev Kambli. TSoma Pandurang Parab. OArjun Mahadev Kambli. TSatu Vitu Parab. O

105/15 Vithal Ladu Kambli.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 650Ladu Vishram Kambli. TDattaram Naryan Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OSatu Vitu Parab. O

105/16 Ankush Narayan Kambli.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 925Narayan Jairam Kambli. TDattaram Naryan Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OSatu Vitu Parab. O

1 2 3 1 2 3


848

105/17 Vithal Ladu Kambli.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 1000Ladu Vishram Kambli. TDattaram Naryan Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OSatu Vitu Parab. O

105/18 Anand Navso Naik.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 650Navso Krishna Naik. TDattaram Naryan Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OSatu Vitu Parab. O

105/20 Anant Atmaram Satardekar.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 500Atmaram Govind Satardekar. TDattaram Naryan Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OSatu Vitu Parab. O

105/21 Vithal Ladu Kambli.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 2775Ladu Vishram Kambli. TDattaram Naryan Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OSatu Vitu Parab. O

105/24 Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 1225Narayan Jairam Kambli. TDattaram Naryan Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OSatu Vitu Parab. O

105/25 Anant Atmaram Satardekar.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 5600Madan Malji Kambli. TDattaram Naryan Parab. OAtmaram Govind Satardekar. TSoma Pandurang Parab. OSatu Vitu Parab. O

105/28 Anand Navso Naik.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 1425Navso Krishna Naik. TDattaram Naryan Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OSatu Vitu Parab. O

105/29 Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 1375Raghuvir Krishna Talkatkar. TDattaram Naryan Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OSatu Vitu Parab. O

105/30 Prakesh Tukaram Satardekar.Yeshwant Laxman Kambli. O 1150Navso Laxman Parab. TDattaram Naryan Parab. OVasudeo Govind Satardekar. TSoma Pandurang Parab. OSatu Vitu Parab. O

105/31 Narayan Shamba Salgaonkar.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 850Shaba Narayan Salgonkar. TDattaram Naryan Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OSatu Vitu Parab. O

105/34 Anand Navso Naik.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 1875Shivsen Narayan Kambli. TDattaram Naryan Parab. ONavso Krishna Naik. TSoma Pandurang Parab. OSatu Vitu Parab. O

105/35 Narayan Shamba Salgaonkar.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 1050Shamba Narayan Salgaonkar. TDattaram Naryan Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OSatu Vitu Parab. O

105/36 Prakesh Tukaram Satardekar.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 800Tukaram Govind Satardekar. TDattaram Naryan Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OSatu Vitu Parab. O

105/37 Anant Atmaram Satardekar.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 2800Atmaram Govind Satardekar. TDattaram Naryan Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OSatu Vitu Parab. O

105/38 Anant Atmaram Satardekar.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 6350Madan Malji Kambli. TDattaram Naryan Parab. OAtmaram Govind Satardekar. TSoma Pandurang Parab. OSatu Vitu Parab. O

105/42 Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 750Madan Malji Kambli. TDattaram Naryan Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OSatu Vitu Parab. O

105/43 Narayan Shamba Salgaonkar.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 1200Shamba Narayan Salgaonkar. TDattaram Naryan Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OSatu Vitu Parab. O

107/1 Madan Malji Kambli.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 196350Purshottam Jairam Kambli. TGopal Dharma Parab. O

1 2 3 1 2 3


849

Vishram Narayan Parab. OYeshwant Bablo Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OGovind Laxman Parab. OBhagirathi Biva Parab. ONarayan Yesso Parab. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. ONakul Jairam Kambli. ODattaram Naryan Parab. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. ONavso Jairam Parab. OShiva Keshav Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OSatu Vitu Parab. OBapu Vithe Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. OLaxman Vite Parab. ORama Laxman Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Naik Dessai. OBablo Sakho Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. OJairam Ganesh Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OParvati Shankar Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OBuda Bise Parab. OGunaji Bhise Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. ONakul Banji Parab. OAnant Sadu Parab. OSavlo Rama Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OSakharam Ganesh Parab. OJijabai Tukaram Parab. OKusso Keshav Parab. OBala Sajo Joshalkar. ONavso Ladu Parab. OJagannath Sakharam Parab OAnant Keshav Parab. OShantabai Bhikaji Parab. OArjun Ladu Parab. OVasant Dattaram Parab. O

Rama Mahadev Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. ONarayan Maigo Parab. O

107/2 Madan Malji Kambli.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 875Nakul Jairam Kambli. TGopal Dharma Parab. OVishram Narayan Parab. OYeshwant Bablo Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OGovind Laxman Parab. OBhagirathi Biva Parab. ONarayan Yesso Parab. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. ONakul Jairam Kambli. ODattaram Naryan Parab. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. ONavso Jairam Parab. OShiva Keshav Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OSatu Vitu Parab. OBapu Vithe Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. OLaxman Vite Parab. ORama Laxman Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Naik Dessai. OBablo Sakho Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. OJairam Ganesh Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OParvati Shankar Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OBuda Bhise Parab. OGunaji Bise Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. ONakul Banji Parab. OAnant Sadu Parab. OSavlo Rama Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OSakharam Ganesh Parab. O

1 2 3 1 2 3


850

Jijabai Tukaram Parab. OKusso Keshav Parab. OBala Sajo Joshalkar. ONavso Ladu Parab. OJagannath Sakharam Parab. OAnant Keshav Parab. OShantabai Bhikaji Parab. OArjun Ladu Parab. OVasant Dattaram Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. ONarayan Maigo Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. O

107/3 Madan Malji Kambli.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 2475Gopal Dharma Parab. OVishnu Narayan Parab. OYeshwant Bablo Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OGovind Laxman Parab. OBhagirathi Biva Parab. ONarayan Yesso Parab. ONarayan Maigo Parab. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. ONakul Jairam Kambli. ODattaram Naryan Parab. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. OMahadeo Sitaram Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. ONavso Jairam Parab. OShiva Keshav Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OLaxman Fati Parab. OSatu Vitu Parab. OBala Vithe Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. OLaxman Vithe Parab. ORama Laxman Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Naik Dessai. OBablo Sakho Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. OJairam Ganesh Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OParvati Shankar Parab. O

Laxman Shankar Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OBuda Bise Parab. OGunaji Bhise Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. OBala Sajo Joshalkar. ONakul Banji Parab. OAnant Sabhaji Parab. OSavalo Rama Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OSakharam Govind Parab. OJijabai Tukaram Parab. OKusso Keshav Parab. ONavso Buda Parab. OJagannath Sakharam Parab. OAnant Keshav Parab. OShantabai Bhikaji Parab. OArjun Ladu Parab. OVasant Dattaram Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. O

107/4 Madan Malji Kambli.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 1200Uttam Mahadev Kambli. TGopal Dharma Parab. OVishnu Narayan Parab. OYeshwant Bablo Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OGovind Laxman Parab. OBhagirathi Biva Parab. ONarayan Yesso Parab. ONarayan Mhadgo Parab. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. ONakul Jairam Kambli. ODattaram Naryan Parab. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. ONakul Jairam Kambli. ODattaram Narayan Parab. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. OMahadeo Sitaram Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. ONavso Jairam Parab. OShiva Keshav Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. O

1 2 3 1 2 3


851

Malji Jairam Kambli. OLaxman Fati Parab. OSatu Vitu Parab. OBala Vithe Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. OLaxman Vithe Parab. ORama Laxman Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Naik Dessai. OBablo Sakho Parab. OJairam Ganesh Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OParvati Shankar Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OBuda Bise Parab. OGunaji Bhise Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. OBala Sajo Joshalkar. ONakul Banji Parab. OAnant Sabaji Parab. OSavalo Rama Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OSakharam Govind Parab. OJijabai Tukaram Parab. OKusso Keshav Parab. ONavso Buda Parab. OJagannath Sakharam Parab. OAnant Keshav Parab. OShantabai Bhikaji Parab. OArjun Ladu Parab. OVasant Dattaram Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. O

107/5 Madan Malji Kambli.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 2300Uttam Mahadev Kambli. TGopal Dharma Parab. OVishnu Narayan Parab. OYeshwant Bablo Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OGovind Laxman Parab. OBhagirathi Biva Parab. ONarayan Yesso Parab. ONarayan Mhadgo Parab. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. ONakul Jairam Kambli. ODattaram Narayan Parab. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. ONakul Jairam Kambli. O

Dattaram Naryan Parab. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. OMahadeo Sitaram Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. ONavso Jairam Parab. OShiva Keshav Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OLaxman Fati Parab. OSatu Vitu Parab. OBala Vithe Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. OLaxman Vithe Parab. ORama Laxman Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Naik Dessai. OBablo Sakho Parab. OJairam Ganesh Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OParvati Shankar Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OBuda Bise Parab. OGunaji Bhise Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. OBala Sajo Joshalkar. ONakul Banji Parab. OAnant Sabaji Parab. OSavalo Rama Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OSakharam Govind Parab. OJijabai Tukaram Parab. OKusso Keshav Parab. ONavso Buda Parab. OJagannath Sakharam Parab. OAnant Keshav Parab. OShantabai Bhikaji Parab. OArjun Ladu Parab. OVasant Dattaram Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. ONarayan Yesso Parab. O

107/6 Madan Malji Kambli.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 8200Nakul Jairam Kambli. TGopal Dharma Parab. OVishnu Narayan Parab. O

1 2 3 1 2 3


852

Yeshwant Bablo Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OGovind Laxman Parab. OBhagirathi Biva Parab. ONarayan Yesso Parab. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. ONakul Jairam Kambli. ODattaram Narayan Parab. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. ONavso Jairam Parab. OShiva Keshav Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OSatu Vitu Parab. OBala Vithe Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. ORama Laxman Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Naik Dessai. OBablo Sakho Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. OJairam Ganesh Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OParvati Shankar Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OBuda Bise Parab. OGunaji Bhise Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. ONakul Banji Parab. OAnant Sadu Parab. OSakharam Ganesh Parab. OJijabai Tukaram Parab. OKusso Keshav Parab. OBala Sajo Joshalkar. ONavso Ladu Parab. OJagannath Sakharam Parab. OAnant Keshav Parab. OShatabai Bhikaji Parab. OArjun Ladu Parab. OVasant Dattaram Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OSavalo Rama Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. O

107/7 Madan Malji Kambli.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 3350Malji Jairam Kambli. TGopal Dharma Parab. OVishram Narayan Parab. OYeshwant Bablo Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OGovind Laxman Parab. OBhagirathi Biva Parab. ONarayan Yesso Parab. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. ONakul Jairam Kambli. ODattaram Naryan Parab. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. ONavso Jairam Parab. OShiva Keshav Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OSatu Vithe Parab. OBala Vithe Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. ORama Laxman Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Naik Dessai. OBablo Sakho Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. OJairam Ganesh Parab. OJairam Ganesh Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OParvati Shankar Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OBuda Bise Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. OJijabai Tukaram Parab. OKusso Keshav Parab. OBala Sajo Joshalkar. ONavso Ladu Parab. OJagannath Sakharam Parab. OAnant Keshav Parab. ONakul Banji Parab. OAnant Sadu Parab. OSavalo Rama Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. O

1 2 3 1 2 3


853

Sakharam Ganesh Parab. OShantaram Bhikaji Parab. OArjun Ladu Parab. OVasant Dattaram Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. OGunaji Bhise Parab. O

107/8 Madan Malji Kambli.Prakesh Tukaram Satardekar.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 2075Tukaram Govind Satardekar. TGopal Dharma Parab. OVishram Narayan Parab. OYeshwant Bablo Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OGovind Laxman Parab. OBhagirathi Biva Parab. ONarayan Yesso Parab. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. ONakul Jairam Kambli. ODattaram Narayan Kambli. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. ONavso Jairam Parab. OShiva Keshav Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OSatu Vithe Parab. OBala Vithe Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. OLaxman Vithe Parab. ORama Laxman Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Naik Dessai. OBablo Sakho Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. OJairam Ganesh Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OParvati Shankar Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OBuda Bise Parab. OGunaji Bhise Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. O

Nakul Banji Parab. OAnant Sadu Parab. OSavalo Rama Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OSakharam Ganesh Parab. OJijabai Tukaram Parab. OKusso Keshav Parab. OBala Saju Josalkar. ONavso Ladu Parab. OJagannath Sakharam Parab. OAnant Keshav Parab. OShantabai Bhikaji Parab. OArjun Ladu Parab. OVasant Dattaram Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. O


107/10 Madan Malji Kambli.Vithal Ladu Kambli.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 7200Ladu Vishram Kambli. TGopal Dharma Parab. OVishram Narayan Parab. OYeshwant Bablo Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OGovind Laxman Parab. OBhagirathi Biva Parab. ONarayan Yesso Parab. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. ONakul Jairam Kambli. ODattaram Naryan Parab. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. ONavso Jairam Parab. OShiva Keshav Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OSatu Vithe Parab. OBala Vithe Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. ORama Laxman Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Naik Dessai. O

1 2 3 1 2 3


854

Bablo Sakho Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. OJairam Ganesh Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OParvati Shankar Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OBuda Bise Parab. OGunaji Bhise Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. ONakul Banji Parab. OAnant Sadu Parab. OSavalo Rama Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OSakharam Ganesh Parab. OJijabai Tukaram Parab. OKusso Keshav Parab. OBala Saju Josalkar. ONavso Ladu Parab. OJagannath Sakharam Parab. OAnant Keshav Parab. OShantabai Bhikaji Parab. OArjun Ladu Parab. OVasant Dattaram Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. O

107/11 Madan Malji Kambli.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 2725Gopal Dharma Parab. OVishram Narayan Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OGovind Laxman Parab. OBhagirathi Biva Parab. ONarayan Yesso Parab. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. ONakul Jairam Kambli. ODattaram Narayan Parab. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. ONavso Jairam Parab. OShiva Keshav Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. OMalji Jairam Kambli. O

Satu Vithe Parab. OBala Vithe Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. ORama Laxman Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Naik Dessai. OBablo Sakho Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. OJairam Ganesh Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OParvati Shankar Parab. OBuda Bise Parab. OGunaji Bhise Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. ONakul Banji Parab. OAnant Saud Parab. OSavalo Rama Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OSakharam Ganesh Parab. OJijabai Tukaram Parab. OKusso Keshav Parab. OBala Saju Josalkar. ONavso Ladu Parab. OJagannath Sakharam Parab. OShantabai Bhikaji Parab. OArjun Ladu Parab. OVasant Dattaram Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. O

107/12 Madan Malji Kambli.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 14900Malji Jairam Kambli. TGopal Dharma Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. TVishram Narayan Parab. ONakul Jairam Kambli. TYeshwant Bablo Parab. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. TSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OGovind Laxman Parab. OBhagirathi Biva Parab. ONarayan Yesso Parab. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. ODattaram Narayan Parab. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. ONavso Jairam Parab. OShiva Keshav Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. O

1 2 3 1 2 3


855

Ramchandra Fati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OSatu Vithe Parab. OBala Vithe Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. OLaxman Vithe Parab. ORama Laxman Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Naik Dessai. OBablo Sakho Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. OJairam Ganesh Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OParvati Shankar Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OBuda Bise Parab. OGunaji Bhise Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. ONakul Banji Parab. OAnant Sadu Parab. OSavalo Rama Parab. ONakul Jairam Kambli. OArjun Govind Parab. OSakharam Ganesh Parab. OJijabai Tukaram Parab. OKusso Keshav Parab. OBala Sajo Joshalkar. ONavso Ladu Parab. OJagannath Sakharam Parab. OAnant Keshav Parab. OShantabai Bhikaji Parab. OArjun Ladu Parab. OVasant Dattaram Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. O

107/13 Madan Malji Kambli.Vithal Ladu Kambli.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 2675Ladu Vishram Kambli. TGopal Dharma Parab. OVishram Narayan Parab. OYeshwant Bablo Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OGovind Laxman Parab. OBhagirathi Biva Parab. O

Narayan Yesso Parab. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. ONakul Jairam Kambli. ODattaram Narayan Parab. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. ONavso Jairam Parab. OShiva Keshav Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OSatu Vithe Parab. OBala Vithe Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. ORama Laxman Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Naik Dessai. OBablo Sakho Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. OJairam Ganesh Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OParvati Shankar Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OBuda Bise Parab. OGunaji Bhise Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. ONakul Bhanji Parab. OAnant Sadu Parab. OSavalo Rama Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OSakharam Ganesh Parab. OJijabai Tukaram Parab. OKusso Keshav Parab. OBala Sajo Joshalkar. ONavso Ladu Parab. OJagannath Sakharam Parab. OAnant Keshav Parab. OShantabai Bhikaji Parab. OArjun Ladu Parab. OVasant Dattaram Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. O

107/14 Madan Malji Kambli.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 2650Vasant Mukund Kambli. T

1 2 3 1 2 3


856

Gopal Dharma Parab. OVishram Narayan Parab. OYeshwant Bablo Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OGovind Laxman Parab. OBhagirathi Biva Parab. ONarayan Yesso Parab. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. ONakul Jairam Kambli. ODattaram Narayan Parab. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. ONavso Jairam Parab. OShiva Keshav Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OSatu Vithe Parab. OBala Vithe Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. ORama Laxman Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Naik Dessai. OBablo Sakho Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. OJairam Ganesh Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OParvati Shankar Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OBuda Bise Parab. OGunaji Bhise Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. ONakul Bhanji Parab. OAnant Sadu Parab. OSavalo Rama Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OSakharam Ganesh Parab. OJijabai Tukaram Parab. OKusso Keshav Parab. OBala Saju Josalkar. ONavso Ladu Parab. OJagannath Sakharam Parab. OShantabai Bhikaji Parab. OVasant Dattaram Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. O

107/15 Madan Malji Kambli.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 2800Anant Soma Tulaskar. TGopal Dharma Parab. OVishram Narayan Parab. OYeshwant Bablo Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OGovind Laxman Parab. OBhagirathi Biva Parab. ONarayan Yesso Parab. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. ONakul Jairam Kambli. ODattaram Narayan Parab. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. ONavso Jairam Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OSatu Vithe Parab. OBala Vithe Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. ORama Laxman Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Naik Dessai. OBablo Sakho Parab. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. OJairam Ganesh Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OParvati Shankar Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OBuda Bise Parab. OGunaji Bhise Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. ONakul Bhanji Parab. OAnant Sadu Parab. OSavalo Rama Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OSakharam Ganesh Parab. OJijabai Tukaram Parab. OKusso Keshav Parab. OBala Sajo Joshalkar. ONavso Ladu Parab. OJagannath Sakharam Parab. OAnant Keshav Parab. O

1 2 3 1 2 3


857

Shantabai Bhikaji Parab. OArjun Ladu Parab. OVasant Dattaram Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. O

114/1 Narayan Shamba Salgaonkar.Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 4900Shamba Narayan Salgaonkar. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. O

114/2 Anant Atmaram Satardekar.Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 2425Dhondu Govind Satardekar. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. O

115/1 Madan Malji Kambli.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 4350Ladu Vishram Kambli. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. OYeshwant Laxman Parab. OGopal Dharma Parab. OVishnu Narayan Parab. OYeshwant Bablo Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OGovind Laxman Parab. OBhagirathi Biva Parab. ONarayan Yesso Parab. ONarayan Maigo Parab. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. ONakul Jairam Kambli. ODattaram Narayan Parab. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. OMahadeo Sitaram Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. ONavso Jairam Parab. OShiva Keshav Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OSatu Vithe Parab. OBala Vithe Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. OLaxman Vithe Parab. ORama Laxman Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Naik Dessai. OBablo Sakho Parab. ORamchandra Atmaram Josalkar. OSoma Pandurang Parab. O

Vithal Pandurang Parab. OJairam Ganesh Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OParvati Shankar Parab. OLaxman Shankar Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OBuda Bise Parab. OGunaji Bhise Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. OBala Saju Josalkar. ONakul Bhanji Parab. OAnant Sabaji Parab. OSavalo Rama Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OSakharam Ganesh Parab. OJijabai Tukaram Parab. OKusso Keshav Parab. ONavso Buda Parab. OJagannath Sakharam Parab. OAnant Keshav Parab. OShantabai Bhikaji Parab. OArjun Ladu Parab. OVasant Dattaram Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. O

115/2 Narayan Shamba Salgaonkar.Madan Malji Kambli.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 4000Shamba Narayan Salgaonkar. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. OYeshwant Laxman Parab. OGopal Dharma Parab. OVishnu Narayan Parab. OYeshwant Bablo Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OGovind Laxman Parab. OBhagirathi Biva Parab. ONarayan Yesso Parab. ONarayan Maigo Parab. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. ONakul Jairam Kambli. ODattaram Narayan Parab. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. OMahadeo Sitaram Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. ONavso Jairam Parab. OShiva Keshav Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. O

1 2 3 1 2 3


858

Ramchandra Fati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OSatu Vithe Parab. OBala Vithe Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. OLaxman Vithe Parab. ORama Laxman Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Naik Dessai. OBablo Sakho Parab. ORamchandra Atmaram Josalkar. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. OJairam Ganesh Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OParvati Shankar Parab. OLaxman Shankar Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OBuda Bise Parab. OGunaji Bhise Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. OBala Saju Josalkar. ONakul Bhanji Parab. OAnant Sabaji Parab. OSavalo Rama Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OSakharam Ganesh Parab. OJijabai Tukaram Parab. OKusso Keshav Parab. ONavso Buda Parab. OJagannath Sakharam Parab. OAnant Keshav Parab. OShantabai Bhikaji Parab. OArjun Ladu Parab. OVasant Dattaram Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. O

115/3 Madan Malji Kambli.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 1730Malji Jairam Kambli. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. TYeshwant Laxman Parab. ONakul Jairam Kambli. TGopal Dharma Parab. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. TVishnu Narayan Parab. O

Yeshwant Bablo Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OGovind Laxman Parab. OBhagirathi Biva Parab. ONarayan Yesso Parab. ONarayan Maigo Parab. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. ONakul Jairam Kambli. ODattaram Narayan Parab. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. OMahadeo Sitaram Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. ONavso Jairam Parab. OShiva Keshav Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OSatu Vithe Parab. OBala Vithe Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. OLaxman Vithe Parab. ORama Laxman Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Naik Dessai. OBablo Sakho Parab. ORamchandra Atmaram Josalkar. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. OJairam Ganesh Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OParvati Shankar Parab. OLaxman Shankar Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OBuda Bise Parab. OGunaji Bhise Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. OBala Saju Josalkar. ONakul Bhanji Parab. OAnant Sabaji Parab. OSavalo Rama Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OSakharam Ganesh Parab. OJijabai Tukaram Parab. O

115/4 Madan Malji Kambli.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 1900Raghuvir Krishna Talkatkar. T

1 2 3 1 2 3


859

Raghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. OYeshwant Laxman Parab. OGopal Dharma Parab. OVishnu Narayan Parab. OYeshwant Bablo Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OGovind Laxman Parab. OBhagirathi Biva Parab. ONarayan Yesso Parab. ONarayan Maigo Parab. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. ONakul Jairam Kambli. ODattaram Narayan Parab. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. OMahadeo Sitaram Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. ONavso Jairam Parab. OShiva Keshav Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OSatu Vithe Parab. OBala Vithe Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. OLaxman Vithe Parab. ORama Laxman Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Naik Dessai. OBablo Sakho Parab. ORamchandra Atmaram Josalkar. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. OJairam Ganesh Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OParvati Shankar Parab. OLaxman Shankar Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OBuda Bise Parab. OGunaji Bhise Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. OBala Saju Josalkar. ONakul Bhanji Parab. OAnant Sabaji Parab. OSavalo Rama Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OSakharam Ganesh Parab. OJijabai Tukaram Parab. O

Kusso Keshav Parab. ONavso Buda Parab. OJagannath Sakharam Parab. OAnant Keshav Parab. OShantabai Bhikaji Parab. OArjun Ladu Parab. OVasant Dattaram Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. O

115/5 Madan Malji Kambli.Ankush Narayan Kambli.Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 390Anant Soma Tulaskar. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. OYeshwant Laxman Parab. OGopal Dharma Parab. OVishnu Narayan Parab. OYeshwant Bablo Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OGovind Laxman Parab. OBhagirathi Biva Parab. ONarayan Yesso Parab. ONarayan Maigo Parab. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. ONakul Jairam Kambli. ODattaram Narayan Parab. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. OMahadeo Sitaram Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. ONavso Jairam Parab. OShiva Keshav Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OSatu Vithe Parab. OBala Vithe Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. OLaxman Vithe Parab. ORama Laxman Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Naik Dessai. OBablo Sakho Parab. ORamchandra Atmaram Josalkar. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. OJairam Ganesh Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OParvati Shankar Parab. O

1 2 3 1 2 3


860

Laxman Shankar Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OBuda Bise Parab. OGunaji Bhise Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. OBala Saju Josalkar. ONakul Bhanji Parab. OAnant Sabaji Parab. OSavalo Rama Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OSakharam Ganesh Parab. OJijabai Tukaram Parab. OKusso Keshav Parab. ONavso Buda Parab. OJagannath Sakharam Parab. OAnant Keshav Parab. OShantabai Bhikaji Parab. OArjun Ladu Parab. OVasant Dattaram Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. O

115/6 (P) Ankush Narayan Kambli.Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 1210Anant Soma Tulaskar. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. OYeshwant Laxman Parab. OGopal Dharma Parab. OVishnu Narayan Parab. OYeshwant Bablo Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OGovind Laxman Parab. OBhagirathi Biva Parab. ONarayan Yesso Parab. ONarayan Maigo Parab. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. ONakul Jairam Kambli. ODattaram Narayan Parab. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. OMahadeo Sitaram Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. ONavso Jairam Parab. OShiva Keshav Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. OMalji Jairam Kambli. O

Satu Vithe Parab. OBala Vithe Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. OLaxman Vithe Parab. ORama Laxman Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Naik Dessai. OBablo Sakho Parab. ORamchandra Atmaram Josalkar. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. OJairam Ganesh Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OParvati Shankar Parab. OLaxman Shankar Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OBuda Bise Parab. OGunaji Bhise Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. OBala Saju Josalkar. ONakul Bhanji Parab. OAnant Sabaji Parab. OSavalo Rama Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OSakharam Ganesh Parab. OJijabai Tukaram Parab. OKusso Keshav Parab. ONavso Buda Parab. OJagannath Sakharam Parab. OAnant Keshav Parab. OShantabai Bhikaji Parab. OArjun Ladu Parab. OVasant Dattaram Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. O

116/1 Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 1700Raghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. ORaghuvir Krishna Talkatkar. T

116/2 Rajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 15650Raghuvir Krishna Talkatkar. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. O

116/3 Madan Malji Kambli.Ankush Narayan KambliRajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 1350Raghuvir Krishna Talkatkar. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. OYeshwant Laxman Parab. OGopal Dharma Parab. OVishnu Narayan Parab. OYeshwant Bablo Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. O

1 2 3 1 2 3


861

Govind Laxman Parab. OBhagirathi Biva Parab. ONarayan Yesso Parab. ONarayan Maigo Parab. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. ONakul Jairam Kambli. ODattaram Narayan Parab. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. OMahadev Sitaram Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. ONavso Jairam Parab. OShiva Keshav Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OSatu Vithe Parab. OBala Vithe Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. OLaxman Vithe Parab. ORama Laxman Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Naik Dessai.OBablo Sakho Parab. ORamchandra Atmaram Josalkar. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. OJairam Ganesh Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OParvati Shankar Parab. OLaxman Shankar Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OBuda Bise Parab. OGunaji Bhise Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. OBala Saju Josalkar. ONakul Bhanji Parab. OAnant Sabaji Parab. OSavalo Rama Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OSakharam Ganesh Parab. OJijabai Tukaram Parab. OKusso Keshav Parab. ONavso Buda Parab. OJagannath Sakharam Parab. OAnant Keshav Parab. OShantabai Bhikaji Parab. OArjun Ladu Parab. OVasant Dattaram Parab. O

Rama Mahadev Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. O

116/4 Madan Malji Kambli.Ankush Narayan KambliRajendra Vasudev Deshprabhu. O 1450Ladu Vishram Kambli. TRaghuraj Vasudev Deshprabhu. OYeshwant Laxman Parab. OGopal Dharma Parab. OVishnu Narayan Parab. OYeshwant Bablo Parab. OSajo Ganesh Parab. ORamkrishna Mukund Parab. OGovind Laxman Parab. OBhagirathi Biva Parab. ONarayan Yesso Parab. ONarayan Maigo Parab. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. ONakul Jairam Kambli. ODattaram Narayan Parab. ORamchandra Soiraji Parab. OKrishna Babaji Parab. OMahadeo Sitaram Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. ONavso Jairam Parab. OShiva Keshav Parab. OAtmaram Mahadev Thakur. ORamchandra Fati Parab. OLaxman Fati Parab. OVishnu Dattaram Parab. OShriram Appa Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. OMalji Jairam Kambli. OSatu Vithe Parab. OBala Vithe Parab. OBhiva Vitu Parab. OLaxman Vithe Parab. ORama Laxman Dessai. OVinayak Pandurang Naik Dessai. OBablo Sakho Parab. ORamchandra Atmaram Josalkar. OSoma Pandurang Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. OJairam Ganesh Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OParvati Shankar Parab. OLaxman Shankar Parab. ORama Hire Parab. OBuda Bise Parab. OGunaji Bhise Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. OGangaram Sade Parab. OSakharam Sade Parab. O

1 2 3 1 2 3


862

Bala Saju Josalkar. ONakul Bhanji Parab. OAnant Sabaji Parab. OSavalo Rama Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OSakharam Ganesh Parab. OJijabai Tukaram Parab. OKusso Keshav Parab. ONavso Buda Parab. OJagannath Sakharam Parab. OAnant Keshav Parab. OShantabai Bhikaji Parab. OArjun Ladu Parab. OVasant Dattaram Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OVishnu Chandre Parab. OBala Gopal Parab. ORaghuvir Sadashiv Parab. O


118/3 Madan Malji Kambli.Ankush Narayan KambliSatu Vithe Parab. O 750Malji Jairam Kambli. TBhiva Vitu Parab. ONakul Jairam Kambli. TLaxman Vithe Parab. ONarayan Jairam Kambli. TLaxman Rama Dessai. OMalji Jairam Kambli. ONakul Jairam Kambli. O

118/4 (P) Ankush Narayan KambliNarayan Jairam Kambli. O 5280Narayan Jairam Kambli. TDattaram Narayan Parab. OPurshottam Jairam Kambli. T

118/5 (P) Gurudas Pandurang Kudav.Yeshwant Laxman Parab. O 790Pandurang Narayan Kudav. T

118/7 (P) Anand Navso Naik.Ramchandra Fati Parab. O 10225Navso Krishna Naik. TLaxman Fati Parab. OParvati Shankar Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. O

118/8 (P) Vithal Ladu Kambli.Vithal Pandurang Parab. O 3915Ladu Vishram Kambli. T

118/9 (P) Anand Navso Naik.Ramchandra Fati Parab. O 1415Navso Krishna Naik. TLaxman Fati Parab. OParvati Shankar Parab. ONarayan Raghu Parab. OVithal Pandurang Parab. OYesso Mukund Parab. O

71/2 Madan Malji Kambli.Dasharath Vithal Aroskar.Gangaram Sade Parab. O 650Vithal Vasu Aroskar. TFondu Hire Parab. OKuso Keshav Parab. ORama Mahadev Parab. OArjun Govind Parab. OMalji Jairam Kambli. ONakul Banji Parab. OParvatibai Neilu Parab. O

Babli Deu Parab. O

Total: 1225896

Grand Total: 2288256


Ashutosh Apte, Under Secretary (Revenue-I).


1 2 3 1 2 3

www.goaprintingpress.gov.in

Published and Printed by the Director, Printing & Stationery,Government Printing Press,

Mahatma Gandhi Road, Panaji-Goa 403 001.

PRICE–Rs. 86.00

PRINTED AT THE GOVERNMENT PRINTING PRESS, PANAJI-GOA–155/420–8/2012.

Documents

Sr. II No. 18 · the Constitution of Rajiv Gandhi Kala Mandir, Ponda--Goa, the Government is pleased to appoint Shri Uday B. Dangui, Ponda-Goa as Vice-Chairman of Rajiv Gandhi Kala