Upload
grace-carpenter
View
220
Download
0
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Spreading the Word:
The challenge of the corpus as an agent of change
Hilary NesiCoventry University, UK
A talk about connecting theory and practice
The original research questions of the BAWE corpus
1. What are the characteristics of proficient student writing produced for degree programmes in British universities?
2. How can this writing be categorised in terms of genres and sub-genres?
3. What are the characteristics of genres produced at different stages of university study?
4. What are the characteristics of genres produced in different disciplines, and for different degree programmes?
Its aim:to develop descriptors for all the genres of British university student assignment – identifying assignment types according to their social purposes.
• 6,506,995 words • 2,896 texts• 2,761 assignments• 1,953 written by L1 speakers of English• 1,251 “distinction” and 1,402 “merit”• 1000+ modules & 300 degree courses
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Arts & Humanities 200 200 200 200
Life Science 200 200 200 200
Physical Science 200 200 200 200
Social Science 200 200 200 200
30+ disciplines representedArts & Humanities
Archaeology, Applied Linguistics, Classics, Comparative American Studies, English, History, Philosophy
Life Sciences Agriculture, Biological Sciences, Food Sciences, Health, Psychology, Medical Science
Physical Sciences
Architecture, Chemistry, Computer Science, Cybernetics & Electronics, Engineering, Mathematics, Meteorology, Physics, Planning
Social Sciences Anthropology, Business, Economics, HLTM (Hospitality, Leisure and Tourism Management), Law, Politics, Publishing, Sociology
Contextual and Textual Information
Files marked for• writer (age,L1,gender,schooling, course) • module (title, department, disc. group)• assignment (title, level, date, grade
>60) • number of words, s-units, p-units, tables,
figures, block quotes, formulae, lists, abstract, w/s, s/p, …
• and genre family
The Genre Families1. Case Study2. Critique3. Design Specification4. Empathy Writing5. Essay6. Exercise7. Explanation8. Literature Survey9. Methodology Recount10.Narrative Recount11.Problem Question12.Proposal13.Research Report
Also tagged for 67 linguistic features
Tense and aspect markers Prepositional phrases, adjectives and adverbs
Place and time adverbials Lexical specificity (type token ratio, mean word length)
Pronouns and pro-verbs Downtoners, hedges, amplifiers, emphatics etc.
Modals Questions
Specialized verb classes such as 'public', 'private' and 'suasive' verbs
Nominal forms
Reduced forms and dispreferred structures such as split infinitives
Passives
Coordination Stative forms
Negation Subordination features
Plenty of data here!
For comparisons across:• Disciplines• Disciplinary groupings• Levels• Genre families
And possibly between:• Writers with different L1s
Some findings: across levels Level Average
1 2 3 4
Words per assignment 1782 2323 2637 2903
Sentences per assignment 75 95 108 122
Words per sentence 24.8 25.6 25.5 24.6
Involved Narrative Elaborated
Persuasive
Abstract / Impersonal
1 -12.8 -2.7 5.1 -1.4 5.9
2 -13.9 -2.8 5.6 -1.5 6.2
3 -14.8 -3.0 5.7 -1.4 6.4
4 -17.3 -3.2 6.4 -2.0 5.4
Across levels, L1-English students show
• Increase in nouns; slight decrease in verbs
• Increase in the use of phrasal post-modifiers of nouns
• Strong increase in the use of phrasal pre-modifiers of nouns
• Decrease in the use of complement clauses, finite relative clauses
Some findings: across genres
Some findings: across genres
Distribution of Genre Families
194
322
93
35
1238
114
214
35
362
75
40
76
61 case study
critique
design specification
empathy writing
essay
exercise
explanation
literature survey
methodology recount
narrative recount
problem question
proposal
research report
Arts and Humanities
0 481
4
602
14 9718 10029case study
critique
design specif ication
empathy w riting
essay
exercise
explanation
literature survey
methodology recount
narrative recount
problem question
proposal
research report
Social Sciences
66
114
3
3
444
18
23
10
16
19
3229 14
case study
critique
design specif ication
empathy w riting
essay
exercise
explanation
literature survey
methodology recount
narrative recount
problem question
proposal
research report
Life Sciences
91
84
2
19
127
33117
14
158
25
2
26
22case study
critique
design specif ication
empathy w riting
essay
exercise
explanation
literature survey
methodology recount
narrative recount
problem question
proposal
research report
Physical Sciences
37
76
87
9
65
4965
4
170
21
6
19
16case study
critique
design specif ication
empathy w riting
essay
exercise
explanation
literature survey
methodology recount
narrative recount
problem question
proposal
research report
BUT....where’s the connection?
Recent publications on the BAWE website
An ESRC-funded follow-on project
March 2012 - April 2013
Intended to apply findings from ‘An Investigation of Genres of Assessed
Writing in British Higher Education’ 2004-2007
For the British Council Learn English website http://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/en/
Beneficiaries
• student writers who are not yet fully familiar with departmental writing conventions.
• tutors - the materials will be suitable for use in class, in one-to-one writing tutorials, or on a self-access basis, according to local requirements.
• subject lecturers, by providing insights into the specific language features that characterise writing in their disciplines.
Project objectives
• To raise teachers' and learners' awareness of the types of writing produced by students in specific disciplines
• To create motivating and attractive academic writing materials
• To improve the quality of student writing, especially the writing produced by users of English as a second or a foreign language.
The exercises on the Learn English site
The five purposes of student writing
Demonstrating knowledge & understanding
Building Research Skills
Developing powers of independent reasoning
Writing for oneself and others
Preparing for professional practice
Genre families Disciplines
Archaeology, Applied Linguistics, Classics, American Studies, English, History,
Philosophy
Agriculture, Biological Sciences, Food
Sciences, Health, Psychology, Medicine
Architecture, Chemistry, Computer Science, Electronics,
Engineering, Mathematics,
Meteorology, Physics, Planning
Anthropology, Business, Economics, HLTM , Law, Politics, Publishing, Sociology
Exercise
Critique
Essay
ResearchReport
Literature Survey
Methodology Recount
Explanation
Problem Question
Proposal
Design Specification
Case Study
EmpathyWriting
NarrativeRecount
The British Council site
http://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/en/
The Wordtree
Word Tree http://wordtree.coventry.ac.uk/?BAWE
From Case Study clusters to the Sketch Engine
Some examplesMethodology Recount (the) aim of this experiment/report is/was
Case Study it is important / recommended / suggested / vital that
The Writing for a Purpose team• Hilary Nesi and Sheena Gardner - from the original ESRC project• Andy Gillett – materials developer• Tim Kelly – video and multimedia• Alex Woolner – consultant from Coventry Serious Games Institute• Elly Hutchins – art work• Martin Peacock and Melissa Cudmore – British Council• Adam Kightley – British Council website• Stakeholders – representing EAP practitioners in universities and
language schools• A wider group of EAP practitioners – to pilot materials
The end - thanks for listening!