17
Spectroscopic Separation of Solar Wind Charge Exchange, Local Bubble, and Nearby Supernova Remnant X-rays: Diffuse X-ray Spectrometer (DXS) Recent Results Morgenthaler et al. AAS 2011 Boston Meeting Oral presentation #219.06 DXS

Spectroscopic Separation of Solar Wind Charge Exchange

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Spectroscopic Separation of Solar Wind Charge Exchange

Spectroscopic Separation of Solar Wind Charge Exchange, Local Bubble, and Nearby Supernova Remnant X-rays:

Diffuse X-ray Spectrometer (DXS) Recent Results

Morgenthaler et al. AAS 2011 Boston Meeting Oral presentation #219.06

DXS

Presenter
Presentation Notes
DXS shown during its 1993 Shuttle flight
Page 2: Spectroscopic Separation of Solar Wind Charge Exchange

Authors/Acknowledgements • Jeffrey P. Morgenthaler (PSI) • Richard J. Edgar (Harvard-Smithsonian CfA) • Wilton T. Sanders (NASA HQ) • Randall K. Smith (Harvard-Smithsonian CfA) • Dimitra Koutroumpa (NASA/GSFC) • David B. Henley (University of Georgia) • Robin L. Shelton (University of Georgia) • Ina P. Robertson (University of Kansas) • Michael R. Collier (NASA/GSFC) • Thomas E. Cravens (University of Kansas)

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Original Wisconsin crew shown in red Particular thanks to Robin through whom I was introduced to the rest of the list
Page 3: Spectroscopic Separation of Solar Wind Charge Exchange

¼ keV Diffuse X-ray Background

• Old Paradigm: – “Local Bubble” – Solely Galactic

• New Paradigm: – Solar wind charge exchange mechanism (SWCX) – Local Bubble?

SWCX location Variation timescale Neutral target(s)

Heliosphere Months/years H, He

Geocorona/exosphere Hours/days H

Presenter
Presentation Notes
2 components of SWCX are particularly important Heliospheric SWCX relatively slow variation Geocoronal SWCX varies on time scales comparable to Shuttle flights Scratch chin, “we’ll get back to that.”
Page 4: Spectroscopic Separation of Solar Wind Charge Exchange

Diffuse X-ray Spectrometer (DXS) Dispersive spectrometer, 1993 Shuttle flight

Presenter
Presentation Notes
DXS was a dispersive spectrometer Short wavelength photons coming from this direction were collected at this end of the detector Long wavelength photons coming from that direction were collected at the other end of the detector In order to cover the entire free spectral range, DXS was rotated over a large angle
Page 5: Spectroscopic Separation of Solar Wind Charge Exchange

DXS Scan Path – RASS ¼ keV band map

Presenter
Presentation Notes
DXS scan path superimposed on the RASS ROSAT map centered on longitude 180° Blue regions = generic DXRB
Page 6: Spectroscopic Separation of Solar Wind Charge Exchange

DXS Diffuse X-ray Background

Local Bubble + Geocoronal SWCX + Heliospheric SWCX

150 eV 284 eV

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Here is a spectrum of the generic DXRB Astrophysical spectra did not fit well (Sanders et al. 2001) SWCX not considered in original DXS work
Page 7: Spectroscopic Separation of Solar Wind Charge Exchange

Isolating Geocoronal SWCX DX

S

Geocoronal SWCX Clean

Presenter
Presentation Notes
DXS count rate as a function of time over the 5-day Shuttle flight In my thesis I worried a lot about this: I demonstrated that these were photons coming from outside the insturment Now it is an opportunity “Clean” count rate is consistent with the RASS. Includes heliospheric SWCX and Galaxy, but not geocoronal SWCX Obviously the extra is geocoronal SWCX
Page 8: Spectroscopic Separation of Solar Wind Charge Exchange

Geocoronal SWCX +Heliospheric SWCX + Local Bubble

DXS Spectra, Geocoronal SWCX

Isolated Geocoronal SWCX!

150 eV 284 eV

Model = Robertson et al. (2006, 2010)

Total DXRB spectrum

SWCX with a hydrogen target

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Upper spectrum, generic DXRB from earlier slide Lower, spectrum geocoronal SWCX on – off Spectrum didn’t mean anything when I finished my thesis in 1998 Very excited when Ina Robertson handed me her geocoronal SWCX model and found that it threaded through most of the points! SWCX with a hydrogen target
Page 9: Spectroscopic Separation of Solar Wind Charge Exchange

Heliospheric SWCX Model Koutroumpa et al. 2009

SWCX with hydrogen and helium targets

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Solar wind onto hydrogen and helium targets
Page 10: Spectroscopic Separation of Solar Wind Charge Exchange

Heliospheric SWCX Model (Koutroumpa et al. 2009)

150 eV 284 eV

Total DXRB spectrum

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Convolved with DXS response matrix Room for Local Bubble emission at low energies
Page 11: Spectroscopic Separation of Solar Wind Charge Exchange

Heliospheric SWCX Model (Robertson et al. 2010)

284 eV 150 eV

Total DXRB spectrum

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Robertson et al. model similar
Page 12: Spectroscopic Separation of Solar Wind Charge Exchange

Conclusions/Future Research

• DXS measured geocoronal SWCX • Benchmark heliospheric SWCX models • Remove SWCX from any diffuse X-ray data • Isolate LISM X-ray spectrum • LISM ISM

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Out of time, lots more slides Questions?
Page 13: Spectroscopic Separation of Solar Wind Charge Exchange

O VII resonance/forbidden > 1

Equilibrium plasma is important

Page 14: Spectroscopic Separation of Solar Wind Charge Exchange

Heliospheric SWCX (Koutroumpa et al. 2009)

150 eV 284 eV

Page 15: Spectroscopic Separation of Solar Wind Charge Exchange

Isolated Monogem (old SNR) Breitschwerdt & Schmutzler (1994)

150 eV 284 eV

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Old = 90,000 yr
Page 16: Spectroscopic Separation of Solar Wind Charge Exchange

Isolated Vela (hot, young SNR) Mewe et al. (1995)

150 eV 284 eV

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Young = 11,000 yr
Page 17: Spectroscopic Separation of Solar Wind Charge Exchange

ROSAT/DXS comparison

DXS not dominated by geocoronal SWCX

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Collapse previous figure into 1 D DXS counting rate as a function of Galactic longitude Cleaned ROSAT all-sky survey count rate compares nicely NO DOMINATED BY “LTE” (geocoronal SWCX)