Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
San Francisco Department of Police Accountability
PAUL DAVID HENDERSONExecutive Director
July 18, 2018
President Thomas Mazzucco and Members of the San Francisco Police Commission
Re: Department of Police Accountability Statistical Reports: Summary of Cases Received,Mediation of Complaints, Adjudication of Sustained Complaints for June 2018 and CompanionReports
Dear President Thomas Mazzucco and San Francisco Police Commissioners:
Summary of Complaints Received in June 2018 and Companion Reports
In compliance with San Francisco City Charter section 4.136 and Police Commission Resolutionnumber 97-04, which require the Department of Police Accountability (DPA) to provide the PoliceCommission with a monthly summary of complaints received, including the number and type ofcomplaints filed, attached please find a summary of cases received in June 2018, a ComprehensiveStatistical Report, a pending case list, and a “How Complaints Were Received” report for the periodJanuary 1, 2018 through June 30, 2018. For comparison purposes, reports for the period January 1,2017 through June 30, 2017 are also included.
Mediation of Complaints in June 2018
The DPA mediated two (2) cases in June 2018. The DPA mediated seven (7) cases from January 1,2018 through June 30, 2018, compared with 14 cases mediated in the same period last year.
Chief’s Proposed Discipline on DPA Sustained Complaints in June 2018
In June 2018, Chief William Scott imposed discipline in two (2) cases involving five (5) investigatedofficers and determined by the DPA to have sustainable allegations. The DPA’s findings andrecommended discipline and the Chief’s proposed discipline are as follows:
1. Neglect of Duty — Two officers failed to properly investigate and failed to properlyprocess property.
Neglect of Duty — The officers’ supervisor failed to properly supervise.
The DPA Director recommended an admonishment for each officer.
The Chief of Police concurred with the DPA Director’s sustained findingsfor the two officers. The Chief of Police imposed written reprimands andretraining for the two officers. The Chief of Police found insufficientevidence to sustain the officers’ supervisor and did not impose discipline.
25 VAN NESS AVENUE, SUITE 100, SAN FRANCISCO, CAliFORNIA 94102 • WWWSF0OV.ORG/DPATE1EPHONE (415) 241-7711 • FAX (415) 241-7133 • TEY (415) 241-1770
President Thomas Mazzucco and Members of the San Francisco Police CommissionDPA’s June 2018 Monthly Statistical ReportJuly 18, 2018Page 2 of 2
2. Conduct Reflecting Discredit — An officer behaved inappropriately.
Conduct Reflecting Discredit and Unwarranted Action — Another officerbehaved inappropriately and placed the complainant in handcuffs withoutjustification.
The DPA Director recommended a written reprimand for both officers.
The Chief of Police imposed a written reprimand and retraining for thefirst officer and an admonishment and retraining for the second officer.
SincerelYp,
Paul HendersonExecutive Director
Attachments (7)
THE POLICE COMMISSION
CASES RECEIVED DEPARTMENT OF POLICE ACCOUNTABILITY
June 2018 CITY AND COUNTY Of SAN FRANCISCO
Case # Received Synopsis of Case
0250-18 06/01/2018 ARREST WITHOUT CAUSE
0275-18 06/01/2018 FAILURE TO TAKE REQUIRED ACTON
0252-18 06/04/2018 FAILURE TO PROPERLY INVESTIGATE
0254-18 06/04/2018 INAPPROPRIATE BEHAVIOR
0253-18 06/05/2018 FAILURE TO PROMPTLY RESPOND TO SCENE
0255-18 06/05/2018 INAPPROPRIATE BEHAVIOR-COMMENTS/FAILED TO TAKE REQUIRED ACTION
0259-18 06/05/2018 INAPPROPRIATE COMMENTS
0260-18 06/05/2018 CITA11ON WITHOUT CAUSE!INAPPROPRIATE COMMENTS
0261-18 06/05/2018 INAPPROPRIATE ACTIONSCOMMENTS /UNNECESSARY FORCE
0262-18 06/05/2018 INAPPROPRIATE ACTIONS/FAILURE TO INVESTIGATE
0256-18 06/06/2018 FAILURE TO TAKE REQUIRED ACTION
0257-18 06/07/2018 SEIZURE/TOW/SEARCH VEH, DAMAGED VEHICLE, INAPPCOMMENTS/BEHAVIOR
0258-18 06/07/2018 INFORMATION ONLY
0263-18 06/07/2018 INFORMATION ONLY
0264-18 06/07/2018 HARASSMENT/THREATS
0265-18 06/08/2018 iNAPPROPRIATE BEHAVIOR
0266-18 06/11/2018 THREATENING AND OR INTIMIDATING BEHAVIOR
0267-18 06/11/2018 INAPPROPRIATE BEHAVIOR/COMMENTS
0268-18 06/11/2018 FAILURE TO TAKE REQUIRED ACTION
269-18 06/11/2018 USE OF EXCESSIVE FORCE
0270-18 06/11/2018 OFFICER-INVOLVED SHOOTING
0271-18 06/11/2018 FILING A FALSE POLICE REPORT
Case # Received Synopsis of Case
0272-18 06/11/2018 INTIMIDATING BEHAVIOR
0273-18 06/12/2018 FAILURE TO TAKE REQUIRED ACTION
0276-18 06/12/2018 0-2
0277-18 06/13/2018 10-2
0278-18 06/13/2018 0-1
0298-18 06/14/2018 CANTONESE TRANSLATION SERVICES NEEDED FOR TRAFFIC STOP
0279-18 06/14/2018 FAILED TO WRITE AN INCIDENT REPORT
0280-18 06/14/2018 MISREPRESENTING THE TRUTH
0281-18 06/14/2018 USE OF FORCE
0282-18 06/14/2018 UA
0283-18 06/15/2018 INAPPROPRIATE BEHAVIOR AND COMMENTS
0284-18 06/15/2018 INAPPROPRIATE BEHAVIOR AND COMMENTS
0285-18 06/15/2018 BIASED POLICING ARREST WITHOUT CAUSE EXCESSIVE FORCE
0286-18 06/15/2018 HARASSMENT INAPPROPRIATE BEHAVIOR AND COMMENTS USE OF PROFANITY
0287-18 06/18/2018 ISSUED CITATION WIHTOUT CAUSE
0289-18 06/19/2018 THREATENING AND OR INTIMIDATING BEHAVIOR
0290-18 06/19/2018 UNNECESSARY AND EXCESSIVE FORCE
0291-18 06/19/2018 10-2
0288-18 06/19/2018 UA
0292-18 06/20/2018 FAILURE TO INVESTIGATE
0293-18 06/20/2018 FAILURE TO INVESTIGATE
0294-18 06/20/2018 FAILURE TO INVESTIGATE
0299-18 06/20/2018 THREATENED CONTRACTOR
0295-18 06/21/2018 CITATION WITHOUT CAUSE/FAIL TO PROVIDE NAME & STAR
0296-18 06/21/2018 FAIL TO PROMPTLY RESPOND
Case # Received Synopsis of Case
0297-18 06121/2018 INAPPROPRIATE COMMENTS
0300-18 06/21/2018 ALLOWING INSURANCE SALES PITCHES DURING LINEUP
0301-18 06/22/2018 brother “KIDNAPPED” BY SFPD, detained 647(f), BEATEN, HANDCUFFED
0302-18 06/24/2018 OFFICER THREAT TO RUN OVER CROWD AT PROTEST
0303-18 06/25/2018 COMMENTS/BEHAVIOR
0304-18 06/25/2018 FAILURE TO INVESTIGATE
0305-18 06/25/2018 FAILURE TO TAKE REQUIRED ACTION
0306-18 06/26/2018 FAILURE TO PROPERLY PROCESS PROPERTY
0309-18 06/2612018 UA for search/CRD for harassment
0310-18 06/26/2018 OFFICER STOLE CASH FROM COMPLAINANT
0307-18 06/27/2018 FAILURE TO PROVIDE NAME AND STAR NUMBER
0308-18 06/27/2018 DETENTION W/O JUSTIFICATION
031 1-18 06/28/2018 INAPPROPRIATE BEHAVIOR/COMMENTS
0312-18 06/28/2018 INTENTIONALLY DAMAGE PROPERTY/INAPPROPRIATE BEHAVIOR AND/OR COMM
0313-18 06/28/2018 CITATION W/O CAUSE, INAPPROPRIATE BEHAVIOR&COMMENTS
0314-18 06/28/2018 UF DURING TRAFFIC STOP, CRD COMMENTS AND BEHAVIOR
031 5-18 06/28/2018 UA FOR DETENTION/UF DURING DETENTION
0326-18 06/28/2018 10-2
0316-18 06/29/2018 FAILED TO MAKE AN ARREST
0317-18 06/29/2018 HARRASSING THE COMPLAINANT
0318-18 06/29/2018 ATTACKED AND STOLE VALUABLE PAINTING
0320-18 06/29/2018 UNNECESSARY FORCE
0325-18 06/29/2018 INAPPROPRIATE COMMENT
0324-18 06/30/2018 FAILURE TO TAKE REQUIRED ACTION
CO
MP
RE
HE
NS
IVE
STA
TIS
TIC
AL
RE
PO
RT
Januar
y201$-
June
2018
TH
EP
OL
ICE
CO
MM
ISS
ION
OF
FIC
EO
FC
ITIZ
EN
CO
MP
LA
INT
SC
ITY
AN
DC
OU
NT
YO
FSA
NF
RA
NC
ISC
O
CA
SE
YE
AR
JAN
FEB
MA
R1S
TA
PR
MA
YJU
N2N
DJU
LA
UG
SE
P3R
DO
CT
NO
VD
EC
CA
SE
SO
PE
NE
D
2018
4244
4913
549
6771
187
00
00
00
00
322
CA
SE
SM
ER
GE
D/V
OID
ED
/WIT
FID
RA
WN
33
28
11
02
00
00
CA
SE
SC
LO
SE
D,
BY
YE
AR
CA
SE
WA
SF
ILE
D
2015
00
00
00
11
00
00
00
00
2016
00
00
10
01
00
00
00
00
2017
3626
3294
2520
1620
1$1
612
1921
2035
TO
TA
L37
3244
113
4740
5213
9
2017
2018
TO
TA
L
CA
SE
SO
UT
SiD
EJU
RIS
DIC
TIO
N
00
00
7
00
00
19
oo
00
26
CA
SE
SS
US
TA
INE
D
2017
12
58
22
15
00
00
00
00
13
2018
4111
YT
D
00
00
10
610
00
00
00
015
576
00
00
00
00
95
00
00
00
00
252
50
27
00
00
00
00
01
45
56
314
00
00
51
612
56
314
00
00
2018
00
00
00
22
00
00
00
00
2
[HE
PO
LIC
EC
OM
MIS
SIO
N
HO
WC
OM
PL
AIN
TS
WE
RE
RE
CE
IVE
DO
FF
ICE
Of
CIT
IZE
NC
OM
PL
AIN
TS
Janu
ary2018-
June
2018
CII
YA
ND
CO
UN
TY
OF
SAN
FRA
NC
ISC
O,
RE
CE
IVE
DJA
NF
EB
MA
R1S
TA
PR
MA
YJU
N2N
DJU
LA
UG
SE
P3R
DO
CT
NO
VD
EC
4Th
YT
D
00
00
00
55
00
00
00
00
5
[NP
ER
SO
N19
116
3615
1111
370
00
00
00
073
LE
TT
ER
02
02
00
00
0t)
00
00
00
2M
AIL
16
512
25
714
00
00
00
00
26O
NL
INE
17
1321
139
931
00
00
00
00
52O
1FIE
RI
00
1I
I2
40
00
00
00
05
PH
ON
E13
1720
5016
3330
790
00
00
00
012
9S
fPD
71
513
2$
717
00
00
00
00
30
TO
TA
L42
4449
135
4967
7118
70
00
00
00
032
2
nfl
00000
0000 0
> 0000.0
00000
000 0
0000 0
000000
00000
nn
>w0000 0
_0000 0
00000
0000 0
U 000000
In > 0000 0
00
zIn
-, 0 0 0 0n n n n
TIl
EP0
1IC
EC
OM
MIS
SIO
Nj,
,
CO
MP
RE
HE
NS
IVE
ST
AT
IST
ICA
LR
EP
OR
TO
FF
ICE
OF
CIT
IZE
NC
OM
PL
AIN
TS
Januar
y2
01
7-
June
2017
CIF
YA
ND
CO
UN
TY
OF
SAN
FR
AN
CIS
CO
CA
SE
YE
AR
JAN
FE
BM
AR
1ST
AP
RM
AY
,JU
N2N
DJU
L.
AU
GS
EP
3RD
OC
TN
OV
DE
C4T
hY
TD
CA
SE
SO
PE
NE
D
2016
t)1
01
00
00
00
00
00
00
120
1746
5065
161
4249
3512
60
00
00
00
026
7
CA
SE
SM
ER
GE
D/V
OID
ED
/WIT
IID
RA
WN
2017
21
36
41
27
00
00
00
00
13
CA
SE
SC
LO
SE
D,
BY
YE
AR
CA
SE
WA
SF
ILE
D
2013
00
00
10
01
00
00
00
00
2014
1)0
11
0I
12
00
00
00
00
320
154
49
173
28
130
00
00
00
030
2016
4126
5011
727
2845
100
00
00
00
00
217
2017
43
1926
2116
2764
00
00
00
00
90
TO
TA
L49
3379
161
5247
8118
00
00
00
00
034
1
CA
SE
SO
UT
SID
EJU
RIS
DIC
TC
ON
2016
83
213
02
02
00
00
00
00
15
2017
3I
1216
93
820
00
00
00
00
36
TO
TA
L11
414
299
58
220
0t)
00
00
051
CA
SE
SS
US
TA
INE
D
2016
106
824
25
714
00
00
00
00
38
TH
EP
OL
ICE
CO
MM
ISS
IONfir
HO
WC
OM
PL
AIN
TS
WE
RE
RE
CE
IVE
DO
FF
ICE
OF
CIT
IZE
NC
OM
PL
AIN
TS
Jan
uar
y20
17Ju
ne20
17C
ITY
AN
DC
OU
NT
YO
FS
AN
FR
AN
CIS
CO.
RE
CE
IVE
DJA
NF
EB
MA
R1S
TA
PR
MA
YJU
N2N
DJU
LA
1G
SE
P3R
DO
CT
NO
VD
EC
4TH
YT
D
NP
ER
SO
N12
1324
4916
109
350
00
00
00
084
LE
TIE
R1
00
12
3I
60
00
00
00
07
MA
IL4
45
133
39
150
00
00
00
028
ON
LIN
E8
1111
304
75
160
00
00
00
046
OF
HE
R1
02
31
10
20
00
00
00
05
PH
ON
E14
1$17
4911
2111
430
00
00
00
092
SF
PD
65
617
54
09
00
00
00
00
26
TO
TA
L46
5165
162
4249
3512
60
00
00
00
028
8
-‘NO’
00000 0
0000000
000000.0
0000000
0000000
I.)
md 000000.0
Q000000 0
‘C
oooooo;o
a,
——en
a, ——en
>d 0000000
000000 0
IC
I-aw Ioooooo 0
_I 0000000
00 0 00 0 0
000000 0
00
Wa=
ctj —ntOp. f-aS
