330
Visit our website for other free publication downloads http://www.StrategicStudiesInstitute.army.mil/ To rate this publication click here.

Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Visit our website for other free publication downloads

http://www.StrategicStudiesInstitute.army.mil/

To rate this publication click here.

Page 2: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

STRATEGICSTUDIESINSTITUTE

The Strategic Studies Institute (SSI) is part of the U.S. Army War College and is the strategic-­level study agent for issues related to national security and military strategy with emphasis on geostrate-­gic analysis.

The mission of SSI is to use independent analysis to conduct strategic studies that develop policy recommendations on:

employment of military forces;;

special or immediate interest. These include edited proceedings of -­

Army to address strategic and other issues in support of Army par-­ticipation in national security policy formulation.

Page 3: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Strategic Studies Institute Monograph

RUSSIA'S HOMEGROWN INSURGENCY: JIHAD IN THE NORTH CAUCASUS

Stephen J. BlankEditor

October 2012

The views expressed in this report are those of the authors and -­

-­tions enjoy full academic freedom, provided they do not disclose

-­-­

ers them to offer new and sometimes controversial perspectives

*****

-­-­

Page 4: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

ii

*****

*****

-­-­

www.Strategic StudiesInstitute.army.mil

*****

newsletter to update the national security community on the re-­

www.StrategicStudiesInstitute.army.mil/newsletter/.

Page 5: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

iii

CONTENTS

Gordon M. Hahn

Sergey Markedonov

Svante E. Cornell

Page 6: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus
Page 7: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

v

FOREWORD

While the evident and primary cause of this cur-­

-­-­

Page 8: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

-­-­

vi

Page 9: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

CHAPTER 1

THE CAUCASUS EMIRATE JIHADISTS:THE SECURITY AND STRATEGIC

IMPLICATIONS

Gordon M. Hahn

-­-­

2 With the dissolu-­-­

We can point to a series of factors that for more -­-­-­

Page 10: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

2

-­-­

-­ism to a consistent portion of youth across the entire

-­-­

Page 11: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

THE CAUCASUS EMIRATE: THEO-­IDEOLOGY, GOALS, STRATEGY, AND OPERATIONAL CAPACITY

exponentially to include not only the international-­-­-­

-­-­

-­-­

Page 12: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

tawhid and -­

Islamdin.com, which

Islamdin.com and -­

In-­spire

Islam-­din.com

Page 13: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Minbar al-­Jihad wa’l-­Tawhid -­

close student-­mentor relationship of correspondence

Millat Ibrahim The Religion of Abraham

-­ Tawid, or strict monotheism,

-­-­-­

Page 14: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­munism, socialism, nationalism, and class or ethnic

Page 15: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

have passed death sentences, some of which have

-­-­

ity as major deviations from monotheism and thus

Given the extremist nature of their monotheism, taw-­

Page 16: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

Page 17: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

The remainder of this chapter -­-­

The CE’s Goals and Strategic Vision.

-­-­

-­-­

-­ The unilateral nature of

Page 18: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

surprised and want to understand how those plans

-­-­

22

Page 19: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Page 20: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­-­

-­lamic tithe or zakyat

Page 21: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

or jihadism experts, its operational capacity puts the

Page 22: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­-­

This

that it had already carried out two operations, includ-­

Page 23: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

Page 24: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

THE CAUCASUS EMIRATE AND THE GLOBAL JIHADI REVOLUTIONARY MOVEMENT

Swift Knight Report-­

Page 25: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

Page 26: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

Swift Knight Report, as well as numerous trial transcripts, document

Page 27: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

Qoqaz.net

Qoqaz.net, Qoqaz.co.uk, Webstorage.com/~azzam, and Waaqiah.com

-­-­

means, expert advice and assistance, communica-­

Page 28: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

and indeed were used to solicit donations for the jihad Ahmad also assisted

in order to raise money and purchase footwarmers for

-­-­

Page 29: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

-­-­

Soyuz musul’man Rossii

Page 30: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

22

travel route, which was used to route volunteers and

-­-­

-­-­

Thus, there

Page 31: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­an Glynn Williams claims that after extensive travel

Page 32: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

have seen that Americans, Germans, other Western-­

Page 33: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

-­-­-­

-­-­

The

perestroika and post-­perestroika periods, yielded the -­

gazavats

Page 34: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­-­

-­-­

Page 35: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

This set him and

-­-­-­

Page 36: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

As his jihadi nom de guerre-­

-­datsan

-­-­

Page 37: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Page 38: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

the respective wives of his predecessor and successor

-­ships with jihadi leaders and philosophers such as

Page 39: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Ansar al-­Mujahideen www.ansar1.info/

Ansar al-­Mujahideen

-­ Ansar al

Mujahideen’s -­

Ansar al Mujahideen’s -­

Ansar al-­Muja-­hideen -­

Ansar al-­Mujahideen’s

Ansar al-­Mujahideen announced

Ansar al-­Mujahedeen

Page 40: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Islamdin.comal-­ansar.info

Ansar al-­Mujahideen, an

-­-­

Al-­An-­sar.info

Ansar al-­MujahideenAl-­Ansar.info Islamdin.com -­ment of the joint project with the Ansar al-­Mujahideen

-­ Islamdin.com posted

DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL SECURITY IMPLICATIONS

Page 41: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Page 42: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­-­

-­-­

Page 43: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

creativity and modest resources on the part of the mu-­

has not demonstrated much of an existence no less ca-­

-­-­

Page 44: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­sian development efforts and international culture in

The Eurasian Horizon.

Page 45: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

security implications for the entire Transcaucasus and

-­-­

Geor-­

Page 46: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Hunafa.com, found-­

Page 47: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­Ka-­

vkaz tsentr

Page 48: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

All the suspects held dual -­-­

-­ All

-­ A

Page 49: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Islamdin.com

-­Ansar al-­Mujahidin

Islamdin.com co-­sponsored with Ansar al-­Mujahidin the Al-­Ansar.info

Page 50: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

-­-­-­

Jyllands-­Posten -­

Page 51: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Potential Threats to U.S. Interests.

Page 52: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

RUSSIAN COUNTER-­JIHADISM POLICY

-­sian military, police, and special security forces have

tactics to include more elements of soft power in its

-­-­

-­-­

Page 53: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

Page 54: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

-­creased for sectors crucial to socioeconomic develop-­

-­-­

Page 55: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

policies and his turn to more use of soft power in the

up in order to attract private investment, to pay more -­

the

Page 56: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Page 57: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

The planned tourism cluster -­

the nucleus of the healthcare and tourism industries of

Page 58: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

Caisse des Depots et Consignations

-­-­

Page 59: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­pected mujahedin are often harassed, detained, and

-­jahedin, and he has tried to enlist clerics in efforts to

Page 60: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­teip Ac-­

-­ishment to those who surrendered, and many were

reiterated the cornerstone of his anti-­jihadism policy -­

themselves in, they would receive soft sentences and

Page 61: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

Page 62: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

-­-­

-­-­-­

Page 63: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

called for the introduction of direct federal rule and

-­-­

Page 64: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­-­

Page 65: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

of civil society, reacted without fail, personally, and

-­ment of transport infrastructure and utilities should

Another invest-­-­

course has yielded few results unless one can show

Page 66: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Siloviki.

Page 67: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

operations, military helicopters, and more rarely ar-­

federal authorities decided that the dire situation in

Page 68: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

-­ There is no evidence that

THEORETICAL AND POLICY IMPLICATIONS

-­cepts, have concrete security policy implications for

-­potheses, and theories extant in the scholarly, ana-­

Page 69: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

not located near and do not cooperate as closely with

Page 70: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

exclusively a jihadist phenomenon, this mono-­causal explanation is simplistic, especially when it comes

testaments state explicitly that their motivation is to

Page 71: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

These theoretical conclusions have policy implica-­

would still have international security implications,

Page 72: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

Page 73: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

-­-­

-­-­

Page 74: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

ENDNOTES -­ CHAPTER 1

-­Nezavisimaya gazeta

Chechnya: From Nationalism to Jihad -­

Russia’s Islamic Threat

-­Kavkaz tsentr

from www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2010/03/08/71101.shtml

Kavkaz-­Tsentrwww.kavkazcenter.net/russ/content/2006/01/09/40869.shtml -­

Kavkaz-­Tsentrwww.kavkazcenter.com/russ/

content/2005/03/12/31285.shtml -­Russkii Zhurnal www.

russ.ru/publish/96073701Kavkaz-­Tsentr The Wolves of Is-­lam: Russia and the Faces of Chechen Terrorism

Russia’s Islamic Threat

www.islamdin.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=category&id=4&Itemid=28www.islamdin.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=category &id=33&Itemid=31 www.islamdin. com/index.php?option=com_content&view=category&id=7&Itemid=8

Kavkaz tsentr -­www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2011/04/12/80669.

shtml -­Kavkaz tsentr -­

www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2011/01/21/78402.shtml -­

Umma Newsummanews.com/minbar/359-­-­-­-­-­l-­-­-­-­r.html -­

Islamdin.comwww.islamdin.com/index.php?option=com_

Page 75: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

content&view=article&id=278:2009-­02-­19-­12-­11-­52&catid=4:2009-­02-­04-­14-­07-­09&Itemid=28

Islamdin.com www.islamdin.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=609:2010-­01-­04-­23-­52-­10&catid=8:2009-­02-­04-­22-­51-­14&Itemid=26

Jamaat Shariat, www.jamaatshariat.com/ru/

content/view/414/29/ Hunafa.com

Hunafa.com

Islamdin.com www.islamdin.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=992:2010-­12-­03-­10-­29-­08&catid=43:2010-­11-­25-­17-­50-­11&Itemid=33

Islamdin.com -­www.islamdin.com/index.

php?option=com_content&view=article&id=999:2010-­12-­08-­11-­56-­36&catid=27:2009-­02-­09-­17-­38-­17&Itemid=16 -­

Inspire, -­nie, Kavkaz tsentr www. kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2010/10/12/75767.shtml

Islam, Islamism, and Politics in Eurasia Report -­

www.miis.edu/media/view/23115/original/kavkazjihad_montrep_iiper_40_may_2011.pdf

Page 76: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Militant Ideology Atlas

Islamdin.comwww.islamdin.com/index.php?option=com_

content&view=article&id=656:-­q-­q-­&catid=7:2009-­02-­04-­15-­45-­20&Itemid=8Islamdin.com www.islamdin.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=651:-­q-­q-­1-­&catid=7:2009-­02-­04-­15-­45-­20&Itemid=8

Kavkaz tsentr -­www.kavkazcenter.com/eng/

content/2009/09/18/11018.shtmlAlmaqdese.net

almaqdese.net/r?i=07090901 -­Islamdin.com,

www.islamdin.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=1077:2011-­03-­14-­00-­00-­13&catid=4:2009-­02-­04-­14-­07-­09&Itemid=28

Kavkaz tsentr www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content

/2011/02/05/78885.shtml -­Hunafa.com

hunafa.com/?p=2530

Kavkaz tsentrwww.kavkazcenter.com/eng/content/2009/09/18/11018.

shtml Almaqdese.net, almaqdese.net/r?i=07090901

Kavkaz tsentrfrom www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2010/09/10/75149.shtml

-­Kavkaz tsentr

www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2007/ 11/20/54479.shtml

Page 77: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­Kavkaz tsentr -­

www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2007/11/20/54479.shtml -­

JamaatShariat.comwww.jamaatshariat.com/-­mainmenu-­29/14-­

facty/1345-­2010-­11-­12-­02-­18-­12.html

Guraba.infofrom www.guraba.info/2011-­02-­27-­17-­59-­21/30-­video/1107-­-­i-­.html

Kavkaz tsentr www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2009/08/25/67586.shtml and www.islamdin.com/in-­dex.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=467:2009-­08-­24-­21-­30-­20&catid=10:2009-­02-­06-­21-­56-­11&Itemid=26 -­

hijabAfter each of the accused was executed, the verdicts were posted on JamaatShariat.com -­

-­-­

JamaatShariat.comwww.jamaatshariat.com/new/15-­new/1095-­2010-­08-­10-­10-­58-­30.html

Jamaat Shariat.com www.jamaatshariat.com/new/15-­new/1298-­2010-­09-­25-­12-­47-­36.html

Page 78: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Islamdin.comwww.islamdin.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article &id=594:2009-­12-­12-­14-­58-­15&catid=27:2009-­02-­09-­17-­38-­17&Itemid=16

Hunafa.info hunafa.com??p=1534

Hunafa.infohunafa.info/?p=1715

Kavkaz tsentrwww.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2010/07/29/74167.shtml

-­KavkazInform.com,

www.kavkazinform.com/2011-­05-­27-­02-­00-­06/3-­2011-­05-­27-­05-­14-­31.html

to spread combat to the entire territory of the Caucasus”

Jamaat Shariat.com jamaatshariat.com/ru/-­mainmenu-­29/14-­facty/1105-­-­2-­.html

Page 79: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­Kavkaz-­Tsentr

from www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2004/08/01/24101.shtml

Kavkaz-­Tsentr www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2004/08/01/24101.shtml

Kavkaz tsentr www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2005/05/16/33965.shtml

Kavkaz-­Tsentr, www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/

content/2006/07/09/45779.shtml -­

Kavkaz tsentr www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2007/11/21/54480.shtml

Page 80: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Chechenpress.org www.chechen-­press.org/events/2007/10/29/04.shtml

www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/ 2011/05/17/81607.shtmlwww.kavkazcenter.com/eng/content/2011/05/17/14313.shtml

tlhrc.house.gov/docs/transcripts/2011_04_15_North_Caucasus/Lanskoy_Testimony.pdf -­

Caucasus Timeswww.caucasustimes.com/article.asp?id=20748

New York Times

Eurasia Daily Monitorwww.jamestown.org/single/?no_cache=1&tx_ttnews%5Btt_news% 5D=37230&tx_ttnews%5BbackPid%5D=7&cHash=85a84a8365

Ja-­maatShariat.com www.jamaatshariat.com

-­Kavkaz tsentr

www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content /2010/10/18/75902.shtml

Hunafa.com hunafa.com/?p=3451

Guraba.infoguraba.info/2011-­02-­27-­17-­59-­21/30-­video/1117-­-­

i-­q-­q-­1-­.html

Page 81: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

vdagestan.info/2011/07/08/%d0%ba%d0%b0%d0%b4%d0%b8%d0%b9-­%d0%b8%d0%ba-­%d0%b0%d0%b1%d1%83-­%d0%bc%d1%83%d1%85i%d0%b0%d0%bc%d0%bc%d0%b0%d0%b4-­%d0%be%d1%82%d0%b2%d0%b5%d1%82%d1%8b-­%d0%bd%d0%b0-­%d0%b2%d0%be%d0%bf%d1%80%d0%be/

-­Jamaat Shariat,

www.jamaatshariat.com/ru/-­mainmenu-­29/14-­-­/834-­2010-­06-­02-­03-­05-­02.html

Kavkaz tsentr www.kavkazcenter. com/russ/content/2010/03/08/71087.shtml

-­Islam, Islamism, and Politics in Eur-­

asia Report IIPER-­

IIPER-­

IIPER-­

IIPERwww.miis.edu/academics/faculty

/ghahn/report

-­Icasulaties.org,

icasualties.org/oef/ByMonth.aspx -­Icasualties.org

from icasualties.org/OEF/USCasualtiesByState.aspx

You Tube, www.youtube.com/watch?v=DQQKPNfmo1U

Page 82: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Kavkaz tsentr www. kavkaz.tv/eng/content/2009/05/17/10700.shtml

Hunafa.comhunafa.com/?p=2514 -­

Hunafa.com -­hunafa.com/?p=1984

-­Hunafa.info hunafa.

com??p=1534Hunafa.info

hunafa.info/?p=1715

Hunafa.com hunafa.com??p=1855

Kavkaz tsentr, www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/

content/2011/02/04/78877.shtml

Kavkaz tsentr www.kavka-­zcenter.com/russ/content/2011/02/07/78967.shtml

-­-­

GlobalSecurity.comand www.globalsecurity.org/military/library/news/1999/11/991104-­chechen-­usia1.htm

Page 83: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

www.charlierose.com/view/interview/3968 -­-­

Freeman.orgwww.freeman.org/m_online/bodansky/chechnya.htm

Swift Knight Report Judicial Watchfrom www.judicialwatch.org/cases/102/dia.pdf

Ibid

Ibid

Ibid

Ibid

www.ca9.uscourts.gov/media/view_subpage.php?pk_id=0000007126;; and the

-­www.

investigativeproject.org/documents/case_docs/1422.pdf#page=65

-­-­

-­Investigative Project

www.investigativeproject.org/documents/case_docs/94.pdf

Page 84: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

www.investigativeproject.org/documents/case_docs/1176.pdf

Investigative Proj-­ect www.investigative project.org/documents/case_docs/96.pdf

Inside Al Qaeda: Global Network of Ter-­ror

Vtorzhenie v Rossiyu,

Kavkaz tsentr The Globe and Mail -­www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/ArticleNews/TPStory/

LAC/20041102/CHECHEN02/TPInternational/?query=basayev

Transnational Security Issues Report -­

JamaatShariat.com www.jamaatshariat.com/-­mainmenu-­29/14-­facty/1345-­2010-­11-­12-­02-­18-­12.html

Ibid

Page 85: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Inside Al Qaeda

AFP Regions.rufrom www.regions.ru

Jamaat Shariat jamaatshariat.com/ru/-­mainmenu-­29/14-­facty/1105-­-­2-­.html

BNO News wireup-­date.com/wires/17128/czech-­police-­arrest-­suspected-­russias-­north-­cau-­casus-­terrorists/

-­tawba.info or jamaatbulgar.narod.ru -­

-­jamaatbulgar.narod.ru/statiy/v1_28-­02-­09.htm

Flashpoint Intel

Chechen Weekly -­

Ethno-­Nationalism, Islam and the State in the Caucasus: Post-­Soviet Disorder

Page 86: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Beirut LBC SAT Television -­

Inside Al Qaeda

Kavkaz uzel -­www.kavkaz.memo.ru/newstext/news/id/1198805.html

-­Retwa.org www.retwa.org/

home.cfm?articleId=4834 Kavkaz uzel www. kavkaz-­uzel.ru

-­Kavkaz-­uzel.ru

www.kavkaz-­uzel.ru/articles/182411/

-­Dzhikhad na Severnom Kavkaze:

storonniki i protivniki, Kavkaz tsentr -­www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/islam/jihad_in_ncaucasus/

PDF_version.pdf

gazavatists, de-­adat

Kavkazskie Voiny i Imamat Shamilya

Dzhikhad na Severnom Kavkaze: storonniki i protivniki.

Page 87: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­Novaya gazeta

www.novayagazeta.ru/data/2010/027/18.html-­

Gazeta yuga www.gazetayuga.ru/archive/2005/16.htm

Kabardino-­Balkariya: Na puti k katastofe, Kavkaz uzel -­

www.kavkaz-­uzel.ru/analyticstext/analytics/id/1231255.html Russia’s Islamic Threat

IIPERwww.miis.edu/media/view/21434/original/

kavkazjihad_montrep_iiper_23_sept_2010.pdf -­Kavkaz-­Tsentr

www. kavkazcenter.net/russ/content/2006/05/29/44895

Polit.ruwww.polit.ru/analytics/2006/05/18/

kanokov.html

Kavkaz tsentrwww.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2011/08/30/84755.shtml

-­Kavkaz uzel -­

www.kavkaz-­uzel.ru/articles/158565 -­

www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2009/07/30/67080.shtml

Hunafa.info hunafa.com??p=1534

Page 88: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Ibid -­

Rossiiskaya gazeta, www.rg.ru/2010/03/05/said-­bur-­site.

html

Kavkaz tsentr -­

Kavkaz tsentr www. kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2008/11/21/62314.shtml

Hunafa.info -­hunafa.info/?p=1715

i24 sishan tschetschenien jihad islam nasheed qoqaz kaukasus You Tube,

www.youtube.com/watch?v=XgE19xcasEg-­

Imam TV http://imamtv.com/news-­18-­05-­1009.htm citing Hunafa.com -­

Page 89: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

IIPERwww.miis.edu/media/view/21196/

original/KAVKAZJIHAD_MonTREP_IIPER_20_Aug2010.pdf -­

IIPERwww.miis.edu/media/view/23146/original/kavkazjihad_montrep_ iiper_41_june_2011.pdf

IIPER www.miis.edu/media/view/22492/original/kavkazjihad_montrep_iiper_35_feb_2011.pdf

Jamaat Shariatjamaatshariat.com/ru/fakty/29-­

facty/1089-­2010-­08-­08-­21-­40-­39.html

Jamaat Shariatjamaatshariat.com/ru/-­mainmenu-­29/14-­

facty/1105-­-­2-­.html

CTC Sentinelfrom www.ctc.usma.edu/posts/a-­beacon-­for-­extremists-­the-­ansar-­al-­mujahideen-­web-­forum.

-­Jawa Report mypetjawa.

mu.nu/archives/203766.php

www.justice.gov/usao/vae/Pressreleases/07-­JulyPDFArchive/10/20100721chessernr.html

Page 90: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Alqimmah.netfrom www.alqimmah.net/showthread.php?t=21139&goto=nextoldest

Islamdin -­www.islamdin.com/index.php?option=com_content&view

=article&id=849:2010-­07-­20-­16-­49-­47&catid=32:2009-­03-­05-­23-­19-­06&Itemid=29

Jawa Report mypetjawa.mu.nu/archives/203757.php

-­-­

Islamdin.com www.islamdin.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=849:2010-­07-­20-­16-­49-­47&catid=32:2009-­03-­05-­23-­19-­06&Itemid=29

Page 91: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Islamdin.com www. islamdin.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=854:-­q-­q-­1&catid=4:2009-­02-­04-­14-­07-­09&Itemid=28 -­

Islamdin.comwww.islamdin.com/index.php?option=com_

content&view=article&id=1084:2011-­03-­25-­22-­51-­31&catid=4:2009-­02-­04-­14-­07-­09&Itemid=28

-­Kavkaz-­Tsentr

www.kavkazcenter.net/russ/content/2006/01/09/40869.shtml

Kavkaz-­Tsentrfrom www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2006/07/09/45779.shtml

-­-­

Novaya gazetafrom www.novayagazeta.ru/data/09/10.html

-­Komsomolskaya Pravda

www.kp.ru/daily/24463.5/624739/

-­Islam.ru www.islam.ru/rus/2009-­

04-­29/-­

TsentrAzii www.centrasia.ru/newsA.php?st=1269840600

Page 92: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­Regnum.ru

www.regnum.ru/news/1267599.html -­

Regnum.ru www.regnum.ru/news/fd-­volga/bash/1269348.html

Lifenews.ru lifenews.ru/news/30293 www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2010/07/05/73590.shtml

Kavkaz tsentr-­

MediaKorSet www.mkset.ru/news/person/13353/

Rossiiskaya gazeta www.rg.ru/2010/12/17/reg-­bashkortostan/fsb-­anons.html

-­rest report stated that one of the arrestees was the amir of the

RFERL www.rferl.org/content/bashkortostan_islamists/2301430.html

Hizb ut-­Tahrir Islami was uncovered and de-­-­

Regnum.ruwww.regnum.ru/news/fd-­volga/tatarstan/1350137.

html -­

Page 93: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

IIPERwww.miis.edu/media/view/23146/

original/kavkazjihad_montrep_iiper_41_june_2011.pdfIIPER

www.miis.edu/media/view/22714/original/kavkazjihad_montrep_iiper_36_mar_2011.pdf

Kavkaz tsentr, www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/

content/2011/01/26/78553.shtml -­

Kavkaz tsentrwww.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2011/02/01/78726.shtml

JamaatShariat.comwww.jamaatshariat.com/ru Kavkaz tsentr -­

www.kavkazcenter.com

Jamaat Shariat, jamaatshariat.com/-­main-­

menu-­29/14-­facty/1152-­2010-­08-­22-­17-­00-­31.html

which ended in their defeat and eventual deportation and exile of

Page 94: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

-­IIPER

www.miis.edu/media/view/22714/original/ kavkazjihad_montrep_iiper_36_mar_2011.pdf

Kavkaz tsentr www. kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2011/02/12/79121.shtml

-­Kavkaz tsentr

from www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2010/12/06/77052.shtml

-­-­-­

Page 95: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Georgian Journalgeorgianjournal.ge/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=664:burjanadze-­talks-­about-­danger-­of-­one-­more-­war-­from-­russia-­&catid=9:news&Itemid=8 -­

Interfax www.interfax.com/newsinf.asp?pg=2&id=197175

-­-­-­

America-­Russia Netwww.america-­russia.net/eng/face/236661338?user_session=4827e878c0267ddbdd6ee738f8212f1d

New York Times

Kavkaz Jihad Blogspot -­kavkaz-­jihad.blogspot.com/2011/03/message-­of-­mujahideen-­

from-­khorasan-­to.htmlJihad-­e-­In-­

formacion jihad-­e-­informacion.blogspot.com/2011/03/video-­badr-­at-­tawheed-­mensaje-­de-­los.html

Ibid

-­Kavkaz tsentr -­

www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2010/09/03/75000.

Page 96: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

shtml

Kavkaz tsentrfrom www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2010/09/08/75108.shtml

Ferghana.rufrom www.ferghana.ru/news.php?id=15461&mode=snews -­

-­materik.ru/rubric/detail.

php?ID=10653Ferghana.ru,

www.ferghana.ru/news.php?id=15470&mode=snews

Ferghana.ru www.ferghana.ru/news.php?id=15475&mode=snews

Hunafa.com hu-­nafa.com/?p=3839

Hunafa.com hunafa.com/?p=4831#more-­4831

Kavkaz tsentrwww.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/

2011/03/19/80081.shtml

Nezavisma-­ya gazeta—Religii religion.ng.ru/ problems/2011-­07-­20/4_vahhabity.html -­

Eurasianet.orgwww.eurasianet.org/node/63549

from news.smh.com.au/breaking-­news-­world/two-­die-­in-­kazakhstan-­ car-­blast-­20110524-­1f1zk.html

RETWA www.retwa.com/home.cfm?articleId=11372

Radio Free Europe/Radio

Page 97: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Liberty www.rferl.org/content/kazakh-­stan_suicide_bomber/24177028.html -­

Telegraphwww.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/asia/kazakhstan/8518895/Sui-­cide-­bomber-­attacks-­Kazakh-­secret-­police-­HQ.html

Radio Free Eu-­rope/Radio Liberty www.rferl.org/content/blast_outside_security_service_building_kazakh_ capital/24184422.html

-­Kavkaz tsentr,

www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/ content/2011/03/22/80140.shtml

Russia’s Islamic Threat-­

Demokratizatsiya

MEMRIwww.memritv.org/clip/en/2695.htm

New York Timesfrom www.nytimes.com/2010/11/24/world/europe/24belgium.html

“Agence France Presse news. yahoo.com/s/afp/20101123/wl_afp/belgiumnetherlandsgermany securityattacks/print

NineMSNnews.ninemsn.com.au/world/8168623/10-­held-­over-­

terror-­plot-­in-­belgium

-­EU Observer

euobserver.com/9/31341Nezavsismaya gazeta

www.ng.ru/world/2010-­11-­25/1_belgium.html

Page 98: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

AP, www.themoscowtimes.

com/news/article/austria-­arrests-­chechen-­in-­belgian-­nato-­plot/425658.html.

Jihad Watch

www.jihadwatch.org/2010/12/austrian-­police-­arrest-­ chechen-­over-­poss ib l e -­ j ihad-­at tack-­on-­be lg ian-­nato-­base . html

Expatica www.expatica.com/be/news/belgian-­news/austrian-­police-­hold-­chechen-­in-­belgium-­attack-­probe_115126.html

Agence France Press

Die Presse diepresse.com/home/panorama/oesterreich/616045/Mutmasslicher-­Terrorist_Ein-­Phantom-­in-­Neunkirchen?direct=611111&_vl_backlink=/home/politik/innen-­politik/index.do&selChannel=100

Reuters www.reuters.com/article/2010/12/16/us-­iraq-­qaeda-­idUSTRE6BF3CR20101216.

Islamdin.com, www.islamdin.com/index.

php?option=com_content&view=article&id=814:2010-­06-­22-­19-­09-­08&catid=25:2009-­02-­09-­17-­15-­12&Itemid=17

“ -­

Page 99: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

BNO News wireupdate. com/wires/17128/czech-­police-­arrest-­suspected-­russias-­north-­caucasus-­terrorists/

Lydovki, www.lidovky.

cz/tiskni.asp?r=ln_domov&c=A110503_111957_ln_domov_ape-­

Radio Prahafrom terrorist-­network-­operating-­in-­the-­czech-­republic-­eight-­charged-­with-­aiding-­dagestani-­shariat-­jamaat

Kavkaz uzel www.kavkaz-­uzel.ru/articles/187809/

Lemans Maville www.lemans.maville.com/actu/actudet_-­Double-­operation-­antiterroriste-­au-­Mans-­_dep-­1440912_actu.Htm

Avisen.dk avisen.dk/doukaev-­faar-­12-­aar-­for-­terror_

147226.aspx?utm_source=avisen&utm_medium=frontpage&utm_campaign=latestNewsBox

newspaper Jyllands-­Posten -­

Kavkaz uzel www.kavkaz-­uzel.ru/articles/178729/

Page 100: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Islamdin.com

Encyclopedia of Bioterrorism Defense

Itar-­Tass www.itar-­tass.com Reuters,

www.reuters.com/article/2010/06/02/ us-­russia-­security-­nuclear-­idUSTRE6512RQ20100602

Jihadi -­-­

Post-­Soviet Affairs

-­-­

-­-­-­

-­Kremlin.ru www.

kremlin.ru/transcripts/5979

Page 101: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Reuters

-­The North Caucasus: Russia’s Volatile Fron-­

tier

-­Caucasus_WEB.pdfMoskovskie novosti mn.ru/ politics/20110404/300841916.html

Politkom.ruwww.politcom.ru

Ibid

The North Cau-­casus: Russia’s Volatile Frontier

-­www.edinros.ru/text.

shtml?14/4565,110040Vremya novostei www.vremya.ru/2010/117/4/257340.html

Ibid.

Islamdin.com

Page 102: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Kurorty Severnogo Kavkaza

-­Kommersant -­

www.kommersant.ru/doc.aspx?DocsID=1589344

RIA Novostien.rian.ru/russia/20110629/164915641.html

kavkazcenter. com/russ/content/2010/01/04/69927.shtml

Vremya novostei www.vremya.ru/246760.html Russia Eurasia Terrorism Watch www.retwa.com/home.cfm?articleDate=7Nov2010

Kavkaz uzelwww.kavkaz-­uzel.ru/articles/165231/

Ibid.

-­Kavkaz uzel

www.kavkaz-­uzel.ru/articles/166249/

Vremya novosteiwww.vremya.ru/2010/118/4/257507.html

Page 103: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­-­

www.kavkaz.memo.ru/newstext/news/id/118554.html

-­-­-­

-­-­

Infox.ruinfox.ru/accident/incident/2011/02/03/

Kabardino_Balkariya_.phtml

Kavkaz uzelkabardino-­balkariya.kavkaz-­uzel.ru/articles/168443/

Kavkaz uzelwww.kavkaz-­uzel.ru/articles/183646/?print=true,

sections 7.1 and 7.2

RIA No-­vosti www.riadagestan.com/news/2011/05/13/6472/

Page 104: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­Vedomosti

from www.vedomosti.ru/companies/news/1319006/kerimov_vlozhit_ v_gostinicy_i_stadiony_dagestana_14_mlrd

-­-­-­

Kavkaz uzel www.kavkaz-­uzel.ru/articles/189517/#6

-­Kavkaz uzel -­

www.kavkaz-­uzel.ru/articles/174793/Kavkaz news -­

www.kavkaz-­news.info/ portal/cnid_122389/alias__Caucasus-­Info/lang__en/tabid__2434/de-­fault.aspx

Leaderless Jihad: Terrorism Networks in the Twenty-­First Century -­

Page 105: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Dying to Win: The Strategic Logic of Sui-­cide Terrorism,

Cutting the Fuse: The Explosion of Global Suicide Terrorism and How to Stop It,

Georgian Journal georgianjournal.ge/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=664:burjanadze-­talks-­about-­danger-­of-­one-­more-­war-­from-­russia-­&catid=9:news&Itemid=8

Interfax -­www.interfax.com/newsinf.

asp?pg=2&id=197175-­

America-­Russia Netfrom www.america-­russia.net/eng/face/236661338?user_session=4827e878c0267ddbdd6ee738f8212f1d

Page 106: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus
Page 107: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

CHAPTER 2

THE NORTH CAUCASUS IN RUSSIAAND RUSSIA IN THE NORTH CAUCASUS:

STATE APPROACHES AND POLITICAL DYNAMICS IN THE TURBULENT REGION

-­-­

-­-­

-­-­

Page 108: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

Almost every

2

Page 109: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Page 110: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Why has the activity of the new plenipotentiary not

is to examine major social and political trends in the

“SOFT POWER”: MADE BY ALEXANDER KHLOPONIN

-­-­

the one hand, the West was seen as a natural ally at

Page 111: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

Page 112: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­al and local authorities, while the federal authorities

-­-­

-­-­

Page 113: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Federation administrative entities which are part

Page 114: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

actions, and an ethnocratic leadership automati-­

spheres of tourism and health tourism, electricity,

Page 115: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

importance offers no explanation for why events de-­

Page 116: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

importers are, or the extent to which the importers

This document seems to isolate the economy and the

Page 117: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

NORTH CAUCASUS: RADICAL ISLAMISM ON THE RISE

-­-­

also said that he denies the laws of the secular authori-­-­

-­-­

them, they have to determine the effectiveness of its

trained preachers who fully meet the standards of -­-­

Page 118: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

Page 119: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

ETHNIC NATIONALISM: NEW PERSPECTIVES?

Page 120: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

vival has occurred after a series of personnel decisions

-­-­

-­-­

Page 121: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

people prepared an appeal to the presidential envoy

-­-­

corruption, human resource policies, and issues of lo-­

leadership clearly rejects the claims for the return of -­

Page 122: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

Page 123: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

NORTH CAUCASUS: PUBLIC POLICY OF LIMITED DURATION

-­reaucratic competition for dominance in the frame-­

Page 124: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

THE NORTH CAUCASUS FROM THE PERSPECTIVE OF THE KREMLIN

Page 125: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Page 126: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

while there is simultaneously a more active desire of

ENDNOTES -­ CHAPTER 2

Anthropology and Archeology of Eurasia

Russian Separatism ( Russkii Separa-­tizm ), www.politcom.ru/11193.html

-­-­-­

-­www.

kremlin.ru/transcripts/5979

premier.gov.ru/events/news/13920/

Page 127: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Ibid

www.echo.msk.ru/news/717094-­echo.html

Ibid.

Ibid.

www.kavkaz-­uzel.ru/articles/164449/

Page 128: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus
Page 129: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

CHAPTER 3

THE “AFGHANIZATION” OF THE NORTH CAUCASUS: CAUSES AND IMPLICATIONS

OF A CHANGING CONFLICT

Svante E. Cornell

Page 130: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

THE NORTH CAUCASUS TODAY

constraints of their own system, they end up exacer-­

2 A

Page 131: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

their leaders are responsive mainly to the demands of

Page 132: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

resistance has morphed into a low-­to-­medium level

-­-­

a jihadi movement with whom central authorities

Page 133: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

HOW DID WE GET HERE?

The Salience of the Deportations.

Page 134: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

-­-­

Page 135: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Teip

-­portance of the deportations in the collective memory

that there was no way for them to live securely under

-­-­-­

Page 136: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

-­-­-­

Page 137: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

The First War.

-­-­

Page 138: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

destruction of the city, and hundreds of thousands of

-­-­

in several well-­documented massacres of civilians,

Page 139: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

there is ample evidence that there was little love lost

and were hardly in a position to turn away these new-­found allies, all the more since they were exception-­

Page 140: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

The Inter-­War Period.

this second attempt at independence in a decade end-­

Page 141: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

-­-­

-­-­

Page 142: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Mladi Muslimani

the Reis-­ul-­Ulema

Page 143: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

counterpart, and could not rely on an international -­

awash in international assistance already a year fol-­

confront the jihadis that had ensconced themselves

Page 144: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

The Second War.

-­-­

-­-­

Page 145: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

22

-­-­

Page 146: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

The second war proved as heavy on the civilian

Page 147: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

RUSSIAN POLICIES

Page 148: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­,

-­-­-­

Page 149: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

opulent residence was only a few miles away from a

Page 150: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

nationalist leadership was respected in Western cir-­

jihadi elements, needless to say, did not and do not

with a jihadi movement and

While a counterintuitive turn, the secu-­

Page 151: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

A PACIFIED CHECHNYA?

The last several years have seen widespread violence

-­-­

-­-­

Page 152: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­ This removed the sole

-­-­

Page 153: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Already in

loyalty to a new leader, or would they return to the

Page 154: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

leave power and his successor would discontinue the

CONCLUSION

-­-­

-­-­

-­-­

Page 155: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Page 156: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

scorecard for democratic development across the re-­-­

-­-­

Page 157: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

the situation continues to deteriorate, Western pow-­

ENDNOTES -­ CHAPTER 3

Time www.time. com/time/world/article/0,8599,1904234,00.html

-­Central Asia-­Caucasus Analyst

from www.cacianalyst.org/?q=node/5415

Central Asia-­Caucasus Analyst, www.cacianalyst.org/?q=node/5614

Caucasian Knot rf.eng.kavkaz-­uzel.ru/articles/18748

North Caucasus: On the Brink of Far-­Reaching Destabilisation

Page 158: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Caucasus Times www.cauca-­sustimes.com/article.asp?id=12365 et al

Eur-­asian Geography and Economics,

www.colorado.edu/ibs/waroutcomes/docs/EGE_2007_ WarChechnya_s4.pdf

-­Window on Eurasia

windowoneurasia.blogspot.com/2008/01/window-­on-­ eurasia-­kabardino-­balkaria.html

The North Caucasus Barrier, Russia Confronts Chech-­

Muslim Resistance to the Tsar: Shamil and the Conquest of Chechnia and Daghestan

The Punished Peoples: The Deportation and Fate of Soviet Minorities at the End of the Second World War

Chechnya: A Small Victorious War

The Nation Killers: The Soviet Deportation of Nationalities

Chechnya: A Small Victorious War

Small Nations and Great Powers: A Study of Ethnopolitical

-­Middle East Review of International Affairs

Page 159: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Europe-­Asia Studies

Central Asian Survey,

Russia under Yeltsin and Putin: Neo-­Lib-­eral Autocracy -­sian press reports in Novaya Gazeta, Rossiyskaya Gazeta, and Versiya

Chris-­tian Science Monitor

Journal of International Affairs www.georgefox.edu/academics/undergrad/departments/soc-­swk/ree/Powers_Religion_Oct%201996.pdf

Al Qaeda’s Jihad in Europe: The Afghan-­Bosnian Network

Denial of Sanctuary: Understanding Terrorist Safe Havens,

-­Jamestown Terrorism Monitor

www.jamestown.org/programs/gta/single/?tx_ttnews%5Btt_news%5D=4532&tx_ttnews%5BbackPid%5D=182&no_cache=1

Getting the Caucasus Emirate Right,

Page 160: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

The Washington Times

www.hrw.

Annals of the Association of American Geographers,

Central Asia-­Caucasus Analyst, -­www.cacianalyst.org/?q=node/3151

Eurasia Daily Monitor www.jamestown.org/programs/edm/single/?tx_ttnews%5Btt_news% 5 D = 3 7 3 5 0 & t x _ t t n e w s % 5 B b a c k P i d % 5 D = 2 7 & c H a s h = 660e50c38e

NorthCaucasus_2009optimize.pdf

-­ISN Insights

www.isn.ethz.ch/isn/Current-­Affairs/ISN-­Insights/Detail?lng=en &ots627=fce62fe0-­528d-­4884-­9cdf-­283c282cf0b2&id=125837&tabid=125818&contextid734=125837&contextid735=125818

Page 161: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

North_Caucasus_Spring_2010.pdf.

Eurasia Daily Monitor www.jamestown.org/programs/edm/single/?tx_ttnews%5Btt_news%5D=38732&cHash=530491ac52389684440e5dcc84e128a7

Central Asia-­Caucasus Analystfrom www.cacianalyst.org/?q=node/5573

European Security

Prague Watchdog Kommer-­sant www.kommersant.com/page.asp?idr=527&id=689111

Russia under Yeltsin and Putin,

Moscow NewsThe Oath: A

Surgeon Under Fire

-­Central Asia-­Caucasus Analyst

from www.cacianalyst.org/?q=node/5048

Agenstvo Politicheskikh Novostey www.apn.ru/publications/article1519.htm

New York Timesfrom www.nytimes.com/2009/04/07/world/europe/07chechnya.html

Page 162: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

The Independent www.

king-­of-­chechnya-­430738.html

RIA Novosti, April en.rian.ru/russia/20090407/120959179.html

-­versia.ru,

versia.ru/articles/2010/jan/11/ kadyrov_interview

Chechnya Weekly

Central Asia-­Cau-­casus Analystwww.cacianalyst.org/issues/20060517Analyst.pdf

-­Central Asia-­Caucasus Analyst,

www.cacianalyst.

You Dress According to Their Rules”: Enforcement of an Islamic Dress Code for Women in Chechnya,

www.hrw.

news.bbc.co.uk/hi/russian/russia/newsid_7800000/7800125.stm

RFE/RL www.rferl.org/content/article/1100642.html

Page 163: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

ABOUT THE CONTRIBUTORS

-­Imperial Decline: Russia’s

Changing Position in Asia, coeditor of Soviet Military and the Future, and author of The Sor cerer as Appren-­tice: Stalin’s Commissariat of Nationali ties, 1917-­1924has also written many articles and conference papers

-­rent research deals with prolifera tion and the revo-­

Russo-­Chinese Energy Relations: Politics in Command

Nat ural Allies? Re-­gional Security in Asia and Prospects for Indo-­American Strategic Cooperation -­

-­-­

Page 164: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

www.russiaotherpointsofview.comRussia’s Islamic

Threat Russia’s Revolution From Above, 1985-­2000and numerous articles in academic journals and other

-­De facto States of the

Page 165: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Post-­Soviet Space: Particularities of the Nation-­Building The Turbulent Eurasia -­

New Challenges and Prospects -­

Page 166: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

U.S. ARMY WAR COLLEGE

Major General Anthony A. Cucolo IIICommandant

*****

STRATEGIC STUDIES INSTITUTE

DirectorProfessor Douglas C. Lovelace, Jr.

Director of ResearchDr. Antulio J. Echevarria II

EditorDr. Stephen J. Blank

Director of PublicationsDr. James G. Pierce

Publications AssistantMs. Rita A. Rummel

*****

CompositionMrs. Jennifer E. Nevil

Page 167: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus
Page 168: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

STRATEGICSTUDIESINSTITUTE

The Strategic Studies Institute (SSI) is part of the U.S. Army War College and is the strategic-­level study agent for issues related to national security and military strategy with emphasis on geostrate-­gic analysis.

The mission of SSI is to use independent analysis to conduct strategic studies that develop policy recommendations on:

employment of military forces;;

special or immediate interest. These include edited proceedings of -­

Army to address strategic and other issues in support of Army par-­ticipation in national security policy formulation.

Page 169: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Strategic Studies Institute Monograph

RUSSIA'S HOMEGROWN INSURGENCY: JIHAD IN THE NORTH CAUCASUS

Stephen J. BlankEditor

October 2012

The views expressed in this report are those of the authors and -­

-­tions enjoy full academic freedom, provided they do not disclose

-­-­

ers them to offer new and sometimes controversial perspectives

*****

-­-­

Page 170: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

ii

*****

*****

-­-­

www.StrategicStudiesInstitute.army.mil

*****

newsletter to update the national security community on the re-­

www.StrategicStudiesInstitute.army.mil/newsletter/.

Page 171: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

iii

CONTENTS

Gordon M. Hahn

Sergey Markedonov

Svante E. Cornell

Page 172: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

v

FOREWORD

While the evident and primary cause of this cur-­

-­-­

Page 173: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

-­-­

vi

Page 174: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

CHAPTER 1

THE CAUCASUS EMIRATE JIHADISTS:THE SECURITY AND STRATEGIC

IMPLICATIONS

Gordon M. Hahn

-­-­

2 With the dissolu-­-­

We can point to a series of factors that for more -­-­-­

Page 175: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

2

-­-­

-­ism to a consistent portion of youth across the entire

-­-­

Page 176: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

THE CAUCASUS EMIRATE: THEO-­IDEOLOGY, GOALS, STRATEGY, AND OPERATIONAL CAPACITY

exponentially to include not only the international-­-­-­

-­-­

-­-­

Page 177: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

tawhid and -­

Islamdin.com, which

Islamdin.com and -­

In-­spire

Islam-­din.com

Page 178: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Minbar al-­Jihad wa’l-­Tawhid -­

close student-­mentor relationship of correspondence

Millat Ibrahim The Religion of Abraham

-­ Tawid, or strict monotheism,

-­-­-­

Page 179: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­munism, socialism, nationalism, and class or ethnic

Page 180: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

have passed death sentences, some of which have

-­-­

ity as major deviations from monotheism and thus

Given the extremist nature of their monotheism, taw-­

Page 181: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

Page 182: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

The remainder of this chapter -­-­

The CE’s Goals and Strategic Vision.

-­-­

-­-­

-­ The unilateral nature of

Page 183: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

surprised and want to understand how those plans

-­-­

22

Page 184: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Page 185: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­-­

-­lamic tithe or zakyat

Page 186: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

or jihadism experts, its operational capacity puts the

Page 187: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­-­

This

that it had already carried out two operations, includ-­

Page 188: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

Page 189: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

THE CAUCASUS EMIRATE AND THE GLOBAL JIHADI REVOLUTIONARY MOVEMENT

Swift Knight Report-­

Page 190: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

Page 191: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

Swift Knight Report, as well as numerous trial transcripts, document

Page 192: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

Qoqaz.net

Qoqaz.net, Qoqaz.co.uk, Webstorage.com/~azzam, and Waaqiah.com

-­-­

means, expert advice and assistance, communica-­

Page 193: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

and indeed were used to solicit donations for the jihad Ahmad also assisted

in order to raise money and purchase footwarmers for

-­-­

Page 194: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

-­-­

Soyuz musul’man Rossii

Page 195: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

22

travel route, which was used to route volunteers and

-­-­

-­-­

Thus, there

Page 196: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­an Glynn Williams claims that after extensive travel

Page 197: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

have seen that Americans, Germans, other Western-­

Page 198: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

-­-­-­

-­-­

The

perestroika and post-­perestroika periods, yielded the -­

gazavats

Page 199: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­-­

-­-­

Page 200: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

This set him and

-­-­-­

Page 201: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

As his jihadi nom de guerre-­

-­datsan

-­-­

Page 202: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Page 203: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

the respective wives of his predecessor and successor

-­ships with jihadi leaders and philosophers such as

Page 204: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Ansar al-­Mujahideen www.ansar1.info/

Ansar al-­Mujahideen

-­ Ansar al

Mujahideen’s -­

Ansar al Mujahideen’s -­

Ansar al-­Muja-­hideen -­

Ansar al-­Mujahideen’s

Ansar al-­Mujahideen announced

Ansar al-­Mujahedeen

Page 205: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Islamdin.comal-­ansar.info

Ansar al-­Mujahideen, an

-­-­

Al-­An-­sar.info

Ansar al-­MujahideenAl-­Ansar.info Islamdin.com -­ment of the joint project with the Ansar al-­Mujahideen

-­ Islamdin.com posted

DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL SECURITY IMPLICATIONS

Page 206: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Page 207: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­-­

-­-­

Page 208: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

creativity and modest resources on the part of the mu-­

has not demonstrated much of an existence no less ca-­

-­-­

Page 209: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­sian development efforts and international culture in

The Eurasian Horizon.

Page 210: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

security implications for the entire Transcaucasus and

-­-­

Geor-­

Page 211: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Hunafa.com, found-­

Page 212: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­Ka-­

vkaz tsentr

Page 213: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

All the suspects held dual -­-­

-­ All

-­ A

Page 214: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Islamdin.com

-­Ansar al-­Mujahidin

Islamdin.com co-­sponsored with Ansar al-­Mujahidin the Al-­Ansar.info

Page 215: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

-­-­-­

Jyllands-­Posten -­

Page 216: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Potential Threats to U.S. Interests.

Page 217: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

RUSSIAN COUNTER-­JIHADISM POLICY

-­sian military, police, and special security forces have

tactics to include more elements of soft power in its

-­-­

-­-­

Page 218: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

Page 219: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

-­creased for sectors crucial to socioeconomic develop-­

-­-­

Page 220: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

policies and his turn to more use of soft power in the

up in order to attract private investment, to pay more -­

the

Page 221: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Page 222: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

The planned tourism cluster -­

the nucleus of the healthcare and tourism industries of

Page 223: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

Caisse des Depots et Consignations

-­-­

Page 224: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­pected mujahedin are often harassed, detained, and

-­jahedin, and he has tried to enlist clerics in efforts to

Page 225: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­teip Ac-­

-­ishment to those who surrendered, and many were

reiterated the cornerstone of his anti-­jihadism policy -­

themselves in, they would receive soft sentences and

Page 226: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

Page 227: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

-­-­

-­-­-­

Page 228: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

called for the introduction of direct federal rule and

-­-­

Page 229: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­-­

Page 230: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

of civil society, reacted without fail, personally, and

-­ment of transport infrastructure and utilities should

Another invest-­-­

course has yielded few results unless one can show

Page 231: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Siloviki.

Page 232: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

operations, military helicopters, and more rarely ar-­

federal authorities decided that the dire situation in

Page 233: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

-­ There is no evidence that

THEORETICAL AND POLICY IMPLICATIONS

-­cepts, have concrete security policy implications for

-­potheses, and theories extant in the scholarly, ana-­

Page 234: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

not located near and do not cooperate as closely with

Page 235: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

exclusively a jihadist phenomenon, this mono-­causal explanation is simplistic, especially when it comes

testaments state explicitly that their motivation is to

Page 236: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

These theoretical conclusions have policy implica-­

would still have international security implications,

Page 237: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

Page 238: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

-­-­

-­-­

Page 239: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

ENDNOTES -­ CHAPTER 1

-­Nezavisimaya gazeta

Chechnya: From Nationalism to Jihad -­

Russia’s Islamic Threat

-­Kavkaz tsentr

from www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2010/03/08/71101.shtml

Kavkaz-­Tsentrwww.kavkazcenter.net/russ/content/2006/01/09/40869.shtml -­

Kavkaz-­Tsentrwww.kavkazcenter.com/russ/

content/2005/03/12/31285.shtml -­Russkii Zhurnal www.

russ.ru/publish/96073701Kavkaz-­Tsentr The Wolves of Is-­lam: Russia and the Faces of Chechen Terrorism

Russia’s Islamic Threat

www.islamdin.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=category&id=4&Itemid=28www.islamdin.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=category&id=33&Itemid=31 www.islamdin.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=category&id=7&Itemid=8

Kavkaz tsentr -­www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2011/04/12/80669.

shtml -­Kavkaz tsentr -­

www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2011/01/21/78402.shtml -­

Umma Newsummanews.com/minbar/359-­-­-­-­-­l-­-­-­-­r.html -­

Islamdin.comwww.islamdin.com/index.php?option=com_

Page 240: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

content&view=article&id=278:2009-­02-­19-­12-­11-­52&catid=4:2009-­02-­04-­14-­07-­09&Itemid=28

Islamdin.com www.islamdin.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=609:2010-­01-­04-­23-­52-­10&catid=8:2009-­02-­04-­22-­51-­14&Itemid=26

Jamaat Shariat, www.jamaatshariat.com/ru/

content/view/414/29/ Hunafa.com

Hunafa.com

Islamdin.com www.islamdin.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=992:2010-­12-­03-­10-­29-­08&catid=43:2010-­11-­25-­17-­50-­11&Itemid=33

Islamdin.com -­www.islamdin.com/index.

php?option=com_content&view=article&id=999:2010-­12-­08-­11-­56-­36&catid=27:2009-­02-­09-­17-­38-­17&Itemid=16 -­

Inspire, -­nie, Kavkaz tsentr www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2010/10/12/75767.shtml

Islam, Islamism, and Politics in Eurasia Report -­

www.miis.edu/media/view/23115/original/kavkazjihad_montrep_iiper_40_may_2011.pdf

Page 241: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Militant Ideology Atlas

Islamdin.comwww.islamdin.com/index.php?option=com_

content&view=article&id=656:-­q-­q-­&catid=7:2009-­02-­04-­15-­45-­20&Itemid=8Islamdin.com www.islamdin.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=651:-­q-­q-­1-­&catid=7:2009-­02-­04-­15-­45-­20&Itemid=8

Kavkaz tsentr -­www.kavkazcenter.com/eng/

content/2009/09/18/11018.shtmlAlmaqdese.net

almaqdese.net/r?i=07090901 -­Islamdin.com,

www.islamdin.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=1077:2011-­03-­14-­00-­00-­13&catid=4:2009-­02-­04-­14-­07-­09&Itemid=28

Kavkaz tsentrwww.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content

/2011/02/05/78885.shtml -­Hunafa.com

hunafa.com/?p=2530

Kavkaz tsentrwww.kavkazcenter.com/eng/content/2009/09/18/11018.

shtml Almaqdese.net, almaqdese.net/r?i=07090901

Kavkaz tsentrfrom www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2010/09/10/75149.shtml

-­Kavkaz tsentr

www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2007/11/20/54479.shtml

Page 242: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­Kavkaz tsentr -­

www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2007/11/20/54479.shtml -­

JamaatShariat.comwww.jamaatshariat.com/-­mainmenu-­29/14-­

facty/1345-­2010-­11-­12-­02-­18-­12.html

Guraba.infofrom www.guraba.info/2011-­02-­27-­17-­59-­21/30-­video/1107-­-­i-­.html

Kavkaz tsentr www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2009/08/25/67586.shtml and www.islamdin.com/in-­dex.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=467:2009-­08-­24-­21-­30-­20&catid=10:2009-­02-­06-­21-­56-­11&Itemid=26 -­

hijabAfter each of the accused was executed, the verdicts were posted on JamaatShariat.com -­

-­-­

JamaatShariat.comwww.jamaatshariat.com/new/15-­new/1095-­2010-­08-­10-­10-­58-­30.html

Jamaat Shariat.com www.jamaatshariat.com/new/15-­new/1298-­2010-­09-­25-­12-­47-­36.html

Page 243: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Islamdin.comwww.islamdin.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=594:2009-­12-­12-­14-­58-­15&catid=27:2009-­02-­09-­17-­38-­17&Itemid=16

Hunafa.infohunafa.com??p=1534

Hunafa.infohunafa.info/?p=1715

Kavkaz tsentrwww.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2010/07/29/74167.shtml

-­KavkazInform.com,

www.kavkazinform.com/2011-­05-­27-­02-­00-­06/3-­2011-­05-­27-­05-­14-­31.html

to spread combat to the entire territory of the Caucasus”

Jamaat Shariat.com jamaatshariat.com/ru/-­mainmenu-­29/14-­facty/1105-­-­2-­.html

Page 244: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­Kavkaz-­Tsentr

from www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2004/08/01/24101.shtml

Kavkaz-­Tsentr www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2004/08/01/24101.shtml

Kavkaz tsentr www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2005/05/16/33965.shtml

Kavkaz-­Tsentr, www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/

content/2006/07/09/45779.shtml -­

Kavkaz tsentr www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2007/11/21/54480.shtml

Page 245: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Chechenpress.org www.chechen-­press.org/events/2007/10/29/04.shtml

www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2011/05/17/81607.shtmlwww.kavkazcenter.com/eng/content/2011/05/17/14313.shtml

tlhrc.house.gov/docs/transcripts/2011_04_15_North_Caucasus/Lanskoy_Testimony.pdf -­

Caucasus Timeswww.caucasustimes.com/article.asp?id=20748

New York Times

Eurasia Daily Monitorwww.jamestown.org/single/?no_cache=1&tx_ttnews%5Btt_news%5D=37230&tx_ttnews%5BbackPid%5D=7&cHash=85a84a8365

Ja-­maatShariat.com www.jamaatshariat.com

-­Kavkaz tsentr

www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2010/10/18/75902.shtml

Hunafa.com hunafa.com/?p=3451

Guraba.infoguraba.info/2011-­02-­27-­17-­59-­21/30-­video/1117-­-­

i-­q-­q-­1-­.html

Page 246: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

vdagestan.info/2011/07/08/%d0%ba%d0%b0%d0%b4%d0%b8%d0%b9-­%d0%b8%d0%ba-­%d0%b0%d0%b1%d1%83-­%d0%bc%d1%83%d1%85i%d0%b0%d0%bc%d0%bc%d0%b0%d0%b4-­%d0%be%d1%82%d0%b2%d0%b5%d1%82%d1%8b-­%d0%bd%d0%b0-­%d0%b2%d0%be%d0%bf%d1%80%d0%be/

-­Jamaat Shariat,

www.jamaatshariat.com/ru/-­mainmenu-­29/14-­-­/834-­2010-­06-­02-­03-­05-­02.html

Kavkaz tsentr www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2010/03/08/71087.shtml

-­Islam, Islamism, and Politics in Eur-­

asia Report IIPER-­

IIPER-­

IIPER-­

IIPERwww.miis.edu/academics/faculty

/ghahn/report

-­Icasulaties.org,

icasualties.org/oef/ByMonth.aspx -­Icasualties.org

from icasualties.org/OEF/USCasualtiesByState.aspx

You Tube, www.youtube.com/watch?v=DQQKPNfmo1U

Page 247: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Kavkaz tsentr www.kavkaz.tv/eng/content/2009/05/17/10700.shtml

Hunafa.comhunafa.com/?p=2514 -­

Hunafa.com -­hunafa.com/?p=1984

-­Hunafa.info hunafa.

com??p=1534Hunafa.info

hunafa.info/?p=1715

Hunafa.com hunafa.com??p=1855

Kavkaz tsentr, www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/

content/2011/02/04/78877.shtml

Kavkaz tsentr www.kavka-­zcenter.com/russ/content/2011/02/07/78967.shtml

-­-­

GlobalSecurity.comand www.globalsecurity.org/military/library/news/1999/11/991104-­chechen-­usia1.htm

Page 248: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

www.charlierose.com/view/interview/3968 -­-­

Freeman.orgwww.freeman.org/m_online/bodansky/chechnya.htm

Swift Knight Report Judicial Watchfrom www.judicialwatch.org/cases/102/dia.pdf

Ibid

Ibid

Ibid

Ibid

www.ca9.uscourts.gov/media/view_subpage.php?pk_id=0000007126;; and the

-­www.

investigativeproject.org/documents/case_docs/1422.pdf#page=65

-­-­

-­Investigative Project

www.investigativeproject.org/documents/case_docs/94.pdf

Page 249: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

www.investigativeproject.org/documents/case_docs/1176.pdf

Investigative Proj-­ect www.investigativeproject.org/documents/case_docs/96.pdf

Inside Al Qaeda: Global Network of Ter-­ror

Vtorzhenie v Rossiyu,

Kavkaz tsentr The Globe and Mail -­www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/ArticleNews/TPStory/

LAC/20041102/CHECHEN02/TPInternational/?query=basayev

Transnational Security Issues Report -­

JamaatShariat.com www.jamaatshariat.com/-­mainmenu-­29/14-­facty/1345-­2010-­11-­12-­02-­18-­12.html

Ibid

Page 250: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Inside Al Qaeda

AFP Regions.rufrom www.regions.ru

Jamaat Shariat jamaatshariat.com/ru/-­mainmenu-­29/14-­facty/1105-­-­2-­.html

BNO News wireup-­date.com/wires/17128/czech-­police-­arrest-­suspected-­russias-­north-­cau-­casus-­terrorists/

-­tawba.info or jamaatbulgar.narod.ru -­

-­jamaatbulgar.narod.ru/statiy/v1_28-­02-­09.htm

Flashpoint Intel

Chechen Weekly -­

Ethno-­Nationalism, Islam and the State in the Caucasus: Post-­Soviet Disorder

Page 251: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Beirut LBC SAT Television -­

Inside Al Qaeda

Kavkaz uzel -­www.kavkaz.memo.ru/newstext/news/id/1198805.html

-­Retwa.org www.retwa.org/

home.cfm?articleId=4834 Kavkaz uzel www.kavkaz-­uzel.ru

-­Kavkaz-­uzel.ru

www.kavkaz-­uzel.ru/articles/182411/

-­Dzhikhad na Severnom Kavkaze:

storonniki i protivniki, Kavkaz tsentr -­www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/islam/jihad_in_ncaucasus/

PDF_version.pdf

gazavatists, de-­adat

Kavkazskie Voiny i Imamat Shamilya

Dzhikhad na Severnom Kavkaze: storonniki i protivniki.

Page 252: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­Novaya gazeta

www.novayagazeta.ru/data/2010/027/18.html-­

Gazeta yuga www.gazetayuga.ru/archive/2005/16.htm

Kabardino-­Balkariya: Na puti k katastofe, Kavkaz uzel -­

www.kavkaz-­uzel.ru/analyticstext/analytics/id/1231255.html Russia’s Islamic Threat

IIPERwww.miis.edu/media/view/21434/original/

kavkazjihad_montrep_iiper_23_sept_2010.pdf -­Kavkaz-­Tsentr

www.kavkazcenter.net/russ/content/2006/05/29/44895

Polit.ruwww.polit.ru/analytics/2006/05/18/

kanokov.html

Kavkaz tsentrwww.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2011/08/30/84755.shtml

-­Kavkaz uzel -­

www.kavkaz-­uzel.ru/articles/158565 -­

www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2009/07/30/67080.shtml

Hunafa.info hunafa.com??p=1534

Page 253: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Ibid -­

Rossiiskaya gazeta, www.rg.ru/2010/03/05/said-­bur-­site.

html

Kavkaz tsentr-­

Kavkaz tsentr www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2008/11/21/62314.shtml

Hunafa.info -­hunafa.info/?p=1715

i24 sishan tschetschenien jihad islam nasheed qoqaz kaukasus You Tube,

www.youtube.com/watch?v=XgE19xcasEg-­

Imam TV http://imamtv.com/news-­18-­05-­1009.htm citing Hunafa.com -­

Page 254: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

IIPERwww.miis.edu/media/view/21196/

original/KAVKAZJIHAD_MonTREP_IIPER_20_Aug2010.pdf -­

IIPERwww.miis.edu/media/view/23146/original/kavkazjihad_montrep_iiper_41_june_2011.pdf

IIPER www.miis.edu/media/view/22492/original/kavkazjihad_montrep_iiper_35_feb_2011.pdf

Jamaat Shariatjamaatshariat.com/ru/fakty/29-­

facty/1089-­2010-­08-­08-­21-­40-­39.html

Jamaat Shariatjamaatshariat.com/ru/-­mainmenu-­29/14-­

facty/1105-­-­2-­.html

CTC Sentinelfrom www.ctc.usma.edu/posts/a-­beacon-­for-­extremists-­the-­ansar-­al-­mujahideen-­web-­forum.

-­Jawa Report mypetjawa.

mu.nu/archives/203766.php

www.justice.gov/usao/vae/Pressreleases/07-­JulyPDFArchive/10/20100721chessernr.html

Page 255: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Alqimmah.netfrom www.alqimmah.net/showthread.php?t=21139&goto=nextoldest

Islamdin -­www.islamdin.com/index.php?option=com_content&view

=article&id=849:2010-­07-­20-­16-­49-­47&catid=32:2009-­03-­05-­23-­19-­06&Itemid=29

Jawa Report mypetjawa.mu.nu/archives/203757.php

-­-­

Islamdin.com www.islamdin.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=849:2010-­07-­20-­16-­49-­47&catid=32:2009-­03-­05-­23-­19-­06&Itemid=29

Page 256: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Islamdin.com www.islamdin.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=854:-­q-­q-­1&catid=4:2009-­02-­04-­14-­07-­09&Itemid=28 -­

Islamdin.comwww.islamdin.com/index.php?option=com_

content&view=article&id=1084:2011-­03-­25-­22-­51-­31&catid=4:2009-­02-­04-­14-­07-­09&Itemid=28

-­Kavkaz-­Tsentr

www.kavkazcenter.net/russ/content/2006/01/09/40869.shtml

Kavkaz-­Tsentrfrom www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2006/07/09/45779.shtml

-­-­

Novaya gazetafrom www.novayagazeta.ru/data/09/10.html

-­Komsomolskaya Pravda

www.kp.ru/daily/24463.5/624739/

-­Islam.ru www.islam.ru/rus/2009-­

04-­29/-­

TsentrAzii www.centrasia.ru/newsA.php?st=1269840600

Page 257: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­Regnum.ru

www.regnum.ru/news/1267599.html -­

Regnum.ru www.regnum.ru/news/fd-­volga/bash/1269348.html

Lifenews.ru lifenews.ru/news/30293 www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2010/07/05/73590.shtml

Kavkaz tsentr-­

MediaKorSet www.mkset.ru/news/person/13353/

Rossiiskaya gazeta www.rg.ru/2010/12/17/reg-­bashkortostan/fsb-­anons.html

-­rest report stated that one of the arrestees was the amir of the

RFERL www.rferl.org/content/bashkortostan_islamists/2301430.html

Hizb ut-­Tahrir Islami was uncovered and de-­-­

Regnum.ruwww.regnum.ru/news/fd-­volga/tatarstan/1350137.

html -­

Page 258: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

IIPERwww.miis.edu/media/view/23146/

original/kavkazjihad_montrep_iiper_41_june_2011.pdfIIPER

www.miis.edu/media/view/22714/original/kavkazjihad_montrep_iiper_36_mar_2011.pdf

Kavkaz tsentr, www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/

content/2011/01/26/78553.shtml -­

Kavkaz tsentrwww.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2011/02/01/78726.shtml

JamaatShariat.comwww.jamaatshariat.com/ru Kavkaz tsentr -­

www.kavkazcenter.com

Jamaat Shariat, jamaatshariat.com/-­main-­

menu-­29/14-­facty/1152-­2010-­08-­22-­17-­00-­31.html

which ended in their defeat and eventual deportation and exile of

Page 259: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

-­IIPER

www.miis.edu/media/view/22714/original/kavkazjihad_montrep_iiper_36_mar_2011.pdf

Kavkaz tsentr www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2011/02/12/79121.shtml

-­Kavkaz tsentr

from www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2010/12/06/77052.shtml

-­-­-­

Page 260: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Georgian Journalgeorgianjournal.ge/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=664:burjanadze-­talks-­about-­danger-­of-­one-­more-­war-­from-­russia-­&catid=9:news&Itemid=8 -­

Interfax www.interfax.com/newsinf.asp?pg=2&id=197175

-­-­-­

America-­Russia Netwww.america-­russia.net/eng/face/236661338?user_session=4827e878c0267ddbdd6ee738f8212f1d

New York Times

Kavkaz Jihad Blogspot -­kavkaz-­jihad.blogspot.com/2011/03/message-­of-­mujahideen-­

from-­khorasan-­to.htmlJihad-­e-­In-­

formacion jihad-­e-­informacion.blogspot.com/2011/03/video-­badr-­at-­tawheed-­mensaje-­de-­los.html

Ibid

-­Kavkaz tsentr -­

www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2010/09/03/75000.

Page 261: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

shtml

Kavkaz tsentrfrom www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2010/09/08/75108.shtml

Ferghana.rufrom www.ferghana.ru/news.php?id=15461&mode=snews -­

-­materik.ru/rubric/detail.

php?ID=10653Ferghana.ru,

www.ferghana.ru/news.php?id=15470&mode=snews

Ferghana.ru www.ferghana.ru/news.php?id=15475&mode=snews

Hunafa.com hu-­nafa.com/?p=3839

Hunafa.comhunafa.com/?p=4831#more-­4831

Kavkaz tsentrwww.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/

2011/03/19/80081.shtml

Nezavisma-­ya gazeta—Religii religion.ng.ru/problems/2011-­07-­20/4_vahhabity.html -­

Eurasianet.orgwww.eurasianet.org/node/63549

from news.smh.com.au/breaking-­news-­world/two-­die-­in-­kazakhstan-­car-­blast-­20110524-­1f1zk.html

RETWA www.retwa.com/home.cfm?articleId=11372

Radio Free Europe/Radio

Page 262: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Liberty www.rferl.org/content/kazakh-­stan_suicide_bomber/24177028.html -­

Telegraphwww.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/asia/kazakhstan/8518895/Sui-­cide-­bomber-­attacks-­Kazakh-­secret-­police-­HQ.html

Radio Free Eu-­rope/Radio Liberty www.rferl.org/content/blast_outside_security_service_building_kazakh_capital/24184422.html

-­Kavkaz tsentr,

www.kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2011/03/22/80140.shtml

Russia’s Islamic Threat-­

Demokratizatsiya

MEMRIwww.memritv.org/clip/en/2695.htm

New York Timesfrom www.nytimes.com/2010/11/24/world/europe/24belgium.html

“Agence France Presse news.yahoo.com/s/afp/20101123/wl_afp/belgiumnetherlandsgermanysecurityattacks/print

NineMSNnews.ninemsn.com.au/world/8168623/10-­held-­over-­

terror-­plot-­in-­belgium

-­EU Observer

euobserver.com/9/31341Nezavsismaya gazeta

www.ng.ru/world/2010-­11-­25/1_belgium.html

Page 263: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

AP, www.themoscowtimes.

com/news/article/austria-­arrests-­chechen-­in-­belgian-­nato-­plot/425658.html.

Jihad Watchwww.jihadwatch.org/2010/12/austrian-­police-­arrest-­

chechen-­over-­poss ib l e -­ j ihad-­at tack-­on-­be lg ian-­nato-­base .html

Expatica www.expatica.com/be/news/belgian-­news/austrian-­police-­hold-­chechen-­in-­belgium-­attack-­probe_115126.html

Agence France Press

Die Presse diepresse.com/home/panorama/oesterreich/616045/Mutmasslicher-­Terrorist_Ein-­Phantom-­in-­Neunkirchen?direct=611111&_vl_backlink=/home/politik/innen-­politik/index.do&selChannel=100

Reuters www.reuters.com/article/2010/12/16/us-­iraq-­qaeda-­idUSTRE6BF3CR20101216.

Islamdin.com, www.islamdin.com/index.

php?option=com_content&view=article&id=814:2010-­06-­22-­19-­09-­08&catid=25:2009-­02-­09-­17-­15-­12&Itemid=17

“ -­

Page 264: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

BNO News wireupdate.com/wires/17128/czech-­police-­arrest-­suspected-­russias-­north-­caucasus-­terrorists/

Lydovki, www.lidovky.

cz/tiskni.asp?r=ln_domov&c=A110503_111957_ln_domov_ape-­

Radio Prahafrom terrorist-­network-­operating-­in-­the-­czech-­republic-­eight-­charged-­with-­aiding-­dagestani-­shariat-­jamaat

Kavkaz uzel www.kavkaz-­uzel.ru/articles/187809/

Lemans Maville www.lemans.maville.com/actu/actudet_-­Double-­operation-­antiterroriste-­au-­Mans-­_dep-­1440912_actu.Htm

Avisen.dkavisen.dk/doukaev-­faar-­12-­aar-­for-­terror_

147226.aspx?utm_source=avisen&utm_medium=frontpage&utm_campaign=latestNewsBox

newspaper Jyllands-­Posten -­

Kavkaz uzel www.kavkaz-­uzel.ru/articles/178729/

Page 265: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Islamdin.com

Encyclopedia of Bioterrorism Defense

Itar-­Tass www.itar-­tass.com Reuters,

www.reuters.com/article/2010/06/02/us-­russia-­security-­nuclear-­idUSTRE6512RQ20100602

Jihadi -­-­

Post-­Soviet Affairs

-­-­

-­-­-­

-­Kremlin.ru www.

kremlin.ru/transcripts/5979

Page 266: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Reuters

-­The North Caucasus: Russia’s Volatile Fron-­

tier

-­Caucasus_WEB.pdfMoskovskie novosti mn.ru/politics/20110404/300841916.html

Politkom.ruwww.politcom.ru

Ibid

The North Cau-­casus: Russia’s Volatile Frontier

-­www.edinros.ru/text.

shtml?14/4565,110040Vremya novostei www.vremya.ru/2010/117/4/257340.html

Ibid.

Islamdin.com

Page 267: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Kurorty Severnogo Kavkaza

-­Kommersant -­

www.kommersant.ru/doc.aspx?DocsID=1589344

RIA Novostien.rian.ru/russia/20110629/164915641.html

kavkazcenter.com/russ/content/2010/01/04/69927.shtml

Vremya novostei www.vremya.ru/246760.html Russia Eurasia Terrorism Watch www.retwa.com/home.cfm?articleDate=7Nov2010

Kavkaz uzelwww.kavkaz-­uzel.ru/articles/165231/

Ibid.

-­Kavkaz uzel

www.kavkaz-­uzel.ru/articles/166249/

Vremya novosteiwww.vremya.ru/2010/118/4/257507.html

Page 268: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­-­

www.kavkaz.memo.ru/newstext/news/id/118554.html

-­-­-­

-­-­

Infox.ruinfox.ru/accident/incident/2011/02/03/

Kabardino_Balkariya_.phtml

Kavkaz uzelkabardino-­balkariya.kavkaz-­uzel.ru/articles/168443/

Kavkaz uzelwww.kavkaz-­uzel.ru/articles/183646/?print=true,

sections 7.1 and 7.2

RIA No-­vosti www.riadagestan.com/news/2011/05/13/6472/

Page 269: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­Vedomosti

from www.vedomosti.ru/companies/news/1319006/kerimov_vlozhit_v_gostinicy_i_stadiony_dagestana_14_mlrd

-­-­-­

Kavkaz uzel www.kavkaz-­uzel.ru/articles/189517/#6

-­Kavkaz uzel -­

www.kavkaz-­uzel.ru/articles/174793/Kavkaz news -­

www.kavkaz-­news.info/portal/cnid_122389/alias__Caucasus-­Info/lang__en/tabid__2434/de-­fault.aspx

Leaderless Jihad: Terrorism Networks in the Twenty-­First Century -­

Page 270: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Dying to Win: The Strategic Logic of Sui-­cide Terrorism,

Cutting the Fuse: The Explosion of Global Suicide Terrorism and How to Stop It,

Georgian Journal georgianjournal.ge/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=664:burjanadze-­talks-­about-­danger-­of-­one-­more-­war-­from-­russia-­&catid=9:news&Itemid=8

Interfax -­www.interfax.com/newsinf.

asp?pg=2&id=197175-­

America-­Russia Netfrom www.america-­russia.net/eng/face/236661338?user_session=4827e878c0267ddbdd6ee738f8212f1d

Page 271: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

CHAPTER 2

THE NORTH CAUCASUS IN RUSSIAAND RUSSIA IN THE NORTH CAUCASUS:

STATE APPROACHES AND POLITICAL DYNAMICS IN THE TURBULENT REGION

-­-­

-­-­

-­-­

Page 272: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

Almost every

2

Page 273: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Page 274: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Why has the activity of the new plenipotentiary not

is to examine major social and political trends in the

“SOFT POWER”: MADE BY ALEXANDER KHLOPONIN

-­-­

the one hand, the West was seen as a natural ally at

Page 275: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

Page 276: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­al and local authorities, while the federal authorities

-­-­

-­-­

Page 277: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Federation administrative entities which are part

Page 278: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

actions, and an ethnocratic leadership automati-­

spheres of tourism and health tourism, electricity,

Page 279: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

importance offers no explanation for why events de-­

Page 280: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

importers are, or the extent to which the importers

This document seems to isolate the economy and the

Page 281: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

NORTH CAUCASUS: RADICAL ISLAMISM ON THE RISE

-­-­

also said that he denies the laws of the secular authori-­-­

-­-­

them, they have to determine the effectiveness of its

trained preachers who fully meet the standards of -­-­

Page 282: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

Page 283: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

ETHNIC NATIONALISM: NEW PERSPECTIVES?

Page 284: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

vival has occurred after a series of personnel decisions

-­-­

-­-­

Page 285: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

people prepared an appeal to the presidential envoy

-­-­

corruption, human resource policies, and issues of lo-­

leadership clearly rejects the claims for the return of -­

Page 286: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

Page 287: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

NORTH CAUCASUS: PUBLIC POLICY OF LIMITED DURATION

-­reaucratic competition for dominance in the frame-­

Page 288: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

THE NORTH CAUCASUS FROM THE PERSPECTIVE OF THE KREMLIN

Page 289: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Page 290: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

while there is simultaneously a more active desire of

ENDNOTES -­ CHAPTER 2

Anthropology and Archeology of Eurasia

Russian Separatism ( Russkii Separa-­tizm ), www.politcom.ru/11193.html

-­-­-­

-­www.

kremlin.ru/transcripts/5979

premier.gov.ru/events/news/13920/

Page 291: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Ibid

www.echo.msk.ru/news/717094-­echo.html

Ibid.

Ibid.

www.kavkaz-­uzel.ru/articles/164449/

Page 292: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

CHAPTER 3

THE “AFGHANIZATION” OF THE NORTH CAUCASUS: CAUSES AND IMPLICATIONS

OF A CHANGING CONFLICT

Svante E. Cornell

Page 293: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

THE NORTH CAUCASUS TODAY

constraints of their own system, they end up exacer-­

2 A

Page 294: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

their leaders are responsive mainly to the demands of

Page 295: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

resistance has morphed into a low-­to-­medium level

-­-­

a jihadi movement with whom central authorities

Page 296: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

HOW DID WE GET HERE?

The Salience of the Deportations.

Page 297: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

-­-­

Page 298: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Teip

-­portance of the deportations in the collective memory

that there was no way for them to live securely under

-­-­-­

Page 299: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

-­-­-­

Page 300: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

The First War.

-­-­

Page 301: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

destruction of the city, and hundreds of thousands of

-­-­

in several well-­documented massacres of civilians,

Page 302: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

there is ample evidence that there was little love lost

and were hardly in a position to turn away these new-­found allies, all the more since they were exception-­

Page 303: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

The Inter-­War Period.

this second attempt at independence in a decade end-­

Page 304: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

-­-­

-­-­

Page 305: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Mladi Muslimani

the Reis-­ul-­Ulema

Page 306: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­-­

counterpart, and could not rely on an international -­

awash in international assistance already a year fol-­

confront the jihadis that had ensconced themselves

Page 307: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

The Second War.

-­-­

-­-­

Page 308: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

22

-­-­

Page 309: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

The second war proved as heavy on the civilian

Page 310: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

RUSSIAN POLICIES

Page 311: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­,

-­-­-­

Page 312: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

opulent residence was only a few miles away from a

Page 313: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

nationalist leadership was respected in Western cir-­

jihadi elements, needless to say, did not and do not

with a jihadi movement and

While a counterintuitive turn, the secu-­

Page 314: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

A PACIFIED CHECHNYA?

The last several years have seen widespread violence

-­-­

-­-­

Page 315: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­ This removed the sole

-­-­

Page 316: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Already in

loyalty to a new leader, or would they return to the

Page 317: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

leave power and his successor would discontinue the

CONCLUSION

-­-­

-­-­

-­-­

Page 318: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Page 319: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

scorecard for democratic development across the re-­-­

-­-­

Page 320: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

the situation continues to deteriorate, Western pow-­

ENDNOTES -­ CHAPTER 3

Time www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,1904234,00.html

-­Central Asia-­Caucasus Analyst

from www.cacianalyst.org/?q=node/5415

Central Asia-­Caucasus Analyst, www.cacianalyst.org/?q=node/5614

Caucasian Knot rf.eng.kavkaz-­uzel.ru/articles/18748

North Caucasus: On the Brink of Far-­Reaching Destabilisation

Page 321: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

-­Caucasus Times www.cauca-­

sustimes.com/article.asp?id=12365 et alEur-­

asian Geography and Economics, www.colorado.edu/ibs/waroutcomes/docs/EGE_2007_

WarChechnya_s4.pdf

-­Window on Eurasia

windowoneurasia.blogspot.com/2008/01/window-­on-­ eurasia-­kabardino-­balkaria.html

The North Caucasus Barrier, Russia Confronts Chech-­

Muslim Resistance to the Tsar: Shamil and the Conquest of Chechnia and Daghestan

The Punished Peoples: The Deportation and Fate of Soviet Minorities at the End of the Second World War

Chechnya: A Small Victorious War

The Nation Killers: The Soviet Deportation of Nationalities

Chechnya: A Small Victorious War

Small Nations and Great Powers: A Study of Ethnopolitical

-­Middle East Review of International Affairs

Page 322: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Europe-­Asia Studies

Central Asian Survey,

Russia under Yeltsin and Putin: Neo-­Lib-­eral Autocracy -­sian press reports in Novaya Gazeta, Rossiyskaya Gazeta, and Versiya

Chris-­tian Science Monitor

Journal of International Affairs www.georgefox.edu/academics/undergrad/departments/soc-­swk/ree/Powers_Religion_Oct%201996.pdf

Al Qaeda’s Jihad in Europe: The Afghan-­Bosnian Network

Denial of Sanctuary: Understanding Terrorist Safe Havens,

-­Jamestown Terrorism Monitor

www.jamestown.org/programs/gta/single/?tx_ttnews%5Btt_news%5D=4532&tx_ttnews%5BbackPid%5D=182&no_cache=1

Getting the Caucasus Emirate Right,

Page 323: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

The Washington Times

www.hrw.

Annals of the Association of American Geographers,

Central Asia-­Caucasus Analyst, -­www.cacianalyst.org/?q=node/3151

Eurasia Daily Monitor www.jamestown.org/programs/edm/single/?tx_ttnews%5Btt_news%5 D = 3 7 3 5 0 & t x _ t t n e w s % 5 B b a c k P i d % 5 D = 2 7 & c H a s h =660e50c38e

NorthCaucasus_2009optimize.pdf

-­ISN Insights

www.isn.ethz.ch/isn/Current-­Affairs/ISN-­Insights/Detail?lng=en&ots627=fce62fe0-­528d-­4884-­9cdf-­283c282cf0b2&id=125837&tabid=125818&contextid734=125837&contextid735=125818

Page 324: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

North_Caucasus_Spring_2010.pdf.

Eurasia Daily Monitor www.jamestown.org/programs/edm/single/?tx_ttnews%5Btt_news%5D=38732&cHash=530491ac52389684440e5dcc84e128a7

Central Asia-­Caucasus Analystfrom www.cacianalyst.org/?q=node/5573

European Security

Prague Watchdog Kommer-­sant www.kommersant.com/page.asp?idr=527&id=689111

Russia under Yeltsin and Putin,

Moscow NewsThe Oath: A

Surgeon Under Fire

-­Central Asia-­Caucasus Analyst

from www.cacianalyst.org/?q=node/5048

Agenstvo Politicheskikh Novostey www.apn.ru/publications/article1519.htm

New York Timesfrom www.nytimes.com/2009/04/07/world/europe/07chechnya.html

Page 325: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

The Independent www.

king-­of-­chechnya-­430738.html

RIA Novosti, April en.rian.ru/russia/20090407/120959179.html

-­versia.ru,

versia.ru/articles/2010/jan/11/kadyrov_interview

Chechnya Weekly

Central Asia-­Cau-­casus Analystwww.cacianalyst.org/issues/20060517Analyst.pdf

-­Central Asia-­Caucasus Analyst,

www.cacianalyst.

You Dress According to Their Rules”: Enforcement of an Islamic Dress Code for Women in Chechnya,

www.hrw.

news.bbc.co.uk/hi/russian/russia/newsid_7800000/7800125.stm

RFE/RL www.rferl.org/content/article/1100642.html

Page 326: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

ABOUT THE CONTRIBUTORS

-­Imperial Decline: Russia’s

Changing Position in Asia, coeditor of Soviet Military and the Future, and author of The Sor cerer as Appren-­tice: Stalin’s Commissariat of Nationali ties, 1917-­1924has also written many articles and conference papers

-­rent research deals with prolifera tion and the revo-­

Russo-­Chinese Energy Relations: Politics in Command

Nat ural Allies? Re-­gional Security in Asia and Prospects for Indo-­American Strategic Cooperation -­

-­-­

Page 327: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

www.russiaotherpointsofview.comRussia’s Islamic

Threat Russia’s Revolution From Above, 1985-­2000and numerous articles in academic journals and other

-­De facto States of the

Page 328: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

Post-­Soviet Space: Particularities of the Nation-­BuildingThe Turbulent Eurasia -­

New Challenges and Prospects -­

Page 329: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus

U.S. ARMY WAR COLLEGE

Major General Anthony A. Cucolo IIICommandant

*****

STRATEGIC STUDIES INSTITUTE

DirectorProfessor Douglas C. Lovelace, Jr.

Director of ResearchDr. Antulio J. Echevarria II

EditorDr. Stephen J. Blank

Director of PublicationsDr. James G. Pierce

Publications AssistantMs. Rita A. Rummel

*****

CompositionMrs. Jennifer E. Nevil

Page 330: Russias Homegrown Insurgency Jihad in the North Caucasus