documents.worldbank.orgdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/360991468776748500/pdf/multi0page.pdf · RP24 Volume 9 REPUBUC OF THE PHIUPPINES DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS AND HIGHWAYS

RP24Volume 9

REPUBUC OF THE PHIUPPINESDEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS AND HIGHWAYS

PROJECT MANAGEMENT OFFICE FOR IBRD E

NATIONAL ROAD IMPROVEMENT AND MANAGEMEITPROJECT - PHASE I (NRIMP-I)

DETAILED ENGINEERING DESIGN AND PREPARATION OF BIDDING DOCUiWENTSFOR REHABILITATION OF

MALALAG-MALITA.JOSE ABAD SANTOS ROAD (CW-RU-1.5)

SULOP JCT. MALALAG-MATI SECTION

RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP)(Volume 4/6)

JUNE 2002

I KATAHIRA & ENGINEERS INTERNATIONAL

in association with

ilakcrow HALCROW GROUP LIMITED TECHNIKS GROUP CORPORATION

DCCD ENGINEERING CORPORATION MULTI-INFR KONSULT, INC.

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Sulop Junction-Malalag-Malita Road Section Resettlement Action Plan

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Table of Contents

List of Tables

List of Figures

List of Annexes

Acronyms and Abbreviations

Executive Summary

1. INTRODUCTION

1.1 Description of the Project ---------------------------------------------------- 2

1.2 Types of Impacts --------------------------------------------------- - 2

1.3 Steps Taken to Minimize Impacts ------------------------------------------ 3

1.4 Main Objectives of the Resettlement Action Plan --------------------- 5

2. DESCRIPTION OF IMPACTS AND SOCIO-ECONOMIC

CHARACTERISTICS -------------------------------------------------------------------- 6

2.1 Administrative Unit -- - - - --- 6

2.2 Social and Economic Characteristics of Project Affected Persons --------- 6

2.2.1 Household size --------------------------- -------------- - 6

2.2.2 Distribution of PAPs by Origin ------------------------------ - 6

2.2.3 Length of Stay in the Community ------------------------ - 7

2.2.4 Household Income -------------------------------------------------- 7

2.2.5 Land and Main Structure Use ---------------------------------------- 8

2.2.6 Tenure of Main Structure Occupants ----------------------- 8

2.2.7 Category of Main Structures ------------------------------ 8

23 Impacts of the Project ------------------------------------------- - 9

2.3.1 Impacts on Land - -------------------------------------- 9

2.3.2 Impacts on Structures ------------------------------------------------ 10

2.3.3 Loss of Crops and Trees ---------------------------------------- 12

2.3.4 Loss of Service Facilities ----------------------------------------- 12

2.3.5 Temporary Impacts ----------------------------------------- 12

2.3.6 Relocation Requirements -------------------------------------- 12

2.3.7 Summary of Impacts -------------------------------------------------- 12

3. COMPENSATION RATES AND ENTITLEMENTS


3.1 Introduction ----------------------------------------------------------------------- 19

3.2 Detailed Compensation Entitlements ------------------------------- 19

3.2.1 Loss of Arable Land --------------------------------------------------- 19

3.2.2 Loss of Residential or Commercial Land ------------------------------ 20

3.2.3 Loss of Residential and Residential cum Shop Structures --------- 20

3.2.4 Loss of Independent Shops/Stores---------------------------------------- 21

3.2.5 Loss of Public Structure -------------------------------------------------- 22

3.2.6 Loss of Other Fixed Assets ---------------------------------------- 22

3.2.7 Loss of Standing Crops and Trees-------------------- 23

3.3 Resettlement Costs and Budget -------------------------------------------------- 34

3.3.1 Procedures for Flow of Funds ------------------------------ 34

3.3.2 Cost Estimates and Inflation Adjustment ------------------ -------- 34

3.3.3 Implementation, Administration and Contingency Costs --------- 34

3.3.4 Unit Prices for Cost Estimation --------------------------------------- 34

4. IMPLEMENTATION SCHEDULE

4.1 Approval of the RAP ----------------------------------- ------ -- 37

4.2 Resettlement Implementation Activities -------------------------------------- 37

4.2.1 MOU with LGU and Establishment of the MRIC ------------------ 37

4.2.2 Training of the MRIC ------------------------------------ 37

4.2.3 Establishment of Detailed Compensation Rates ------------------ 37

4.2.4 Conducting Public Information Campaign --------------------------- 37

4.2.5 Stake-out --------------------------------------------------- 38

4.2.6 Finalization of Compensation and Other Entitlement to PAPs 38

4.2.7 Public Meeting ------------------------------------------------------- 38

4.2.8 Payment of Compensation and Other Entitlements ------------- 38

4.2.9 Reorganization and Relocation --------- ------- 38

4.2.10 Handing Over the Site for Civil Works ------- ------- 38

4.3 Monitoring and Supervision of RAP Implementation --------------- 39

5. ORGANIZATION SET-UP

5.1 Institutions for Resettlement ------------------------------------------------ 40

5.1.1 DPWH - - -- ------ 40

5.1.2 Environmental Impact Assessment Project Office (EL4PO) --------- 40

5.1.3 Municipal RAP Implementation Committee (MIRC) -------- 40

5.2 External Monitoring Agency -------------------------------------------------- 41


6. INDIGENOUS PEOPLE ACTION PLAN

6.1 Background ---------------------------------------------------------------------- 42

6.2 Provincial and Municipal Profile --------------------------------------------------- 42

6.2.1 Province of Davao del Sur ---------------------------------------- 42

6.2.2 Municipality of Malita -------------------------------------------------- 43

6.3 General Socio-Economic Characteristics of Manabo and

Tagacaulo Tribe --------------------------------------------------------------------- 43

6.3.1 Sub-group ------------------------------------------------------------- 43

6.3.2 Demography ------------------------------------------------------------- 44

6.3.3 Livelihood Activities and Sources of Income -------------------- 45

6.3.4 Income and Expenditures--------------------------------------------------- 46

6.3.5 Education ------------------------------------------------------------ 46

6.3.6 Health Nutrition and Sanitation ---------------------------------------- 46

6.4 Formal and Traditional Socio-Economic Structures -------------------- 47

6.5 Impacts of the Project on the Indigenous People Along

the Road Corridor ------------------------------------------------------------- 47

6.6 Resettlement Package -------------------------------------------------- 48


LIST OF TABLES

1.1 Location of Existing PCCP Sections

1.2 Private Lots Requiring Compensation

2.1 Distribution of PAPs by Household Size

2.2 Distribution of PAP Households by Origin

2.3 Distribution of Household Heads by Main Occupation

2.4 Distribution of PAPs by Use of Land/Main Structure

2.5 Category of Main Structures by Type of Construction

2.6 Distribution of Affected Land by Use

2.7 Distribution of Residential Structures

2.8 Distribution of Residential/Commercial Structures

2.9 Distribution of Commercial Structures

2.10 Distribution of Public Structures

2.11 Distribution of Affected Perennials

2.12 Summary of Affected Assets

3.1 Entitlement Matrix

3.2 Estimated Resettlement cost

4.1 Schedule of Activities


LIST OF FIGURES

Figure 1.1 Location Map of the Project Area


LIST OF ANNEXES

Annex A: List of Public Meetings Held

Annex B: List of PAPs

Annex C: Operational Framework on Public Participation and Consultation

Annex F: Draft Memorandum of Understanding

Annex G: Computation of Compensation Package for Structures per PAPs


ACRONYMS AND ABBREVIATIONS

AO Administrative OrderDEO District Engineering OfficeDO Department OrderDPWH Department of Public Works and HighwaysEIAPO Environmental Impact Assessment Project OfficeEO Executive OrderESS Environmental and Social ServiceGOP Government of the PhilippinesGRC Grievance Redressal CommitteeHa HectareIBRD Intemational Bank for Rural DevelopmentIPs Indigenous PeoplesKm KilometerLGU Local Government UnitLm Linear meterM MeterMOU Memorandum of UnderstandingNRIMP National Roads Improvement and Management ProgramOD Operational DirectivePAP Project-affected PersonPAF Project-affected FamilyPMO Project Management OfficeRA Republic ActRAP Resettlement Action PlanRIC Resettlement Implementation CommitteeROW Right-of-WaySIA Social Impact AssessmentTA Technical AssistanceTOR Terms of Reference


EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

The Sulop Junction-Malalag-Malita Road Section is a component of the Davao del Sur-Saranggani Coastal Road network. The project road sections starts at STA. 1583 + 766.54 atthe Sulop Junction and follows a south-easterly direction crossing through the Municipalitiesof Malalag, Sta. Maria, before ending at the first approach of the Culaman Bridge in theMunicipality of Sulop at STA. 1636 + 327.24. The 11 barangays that are traversed by theproject road section are Baclayon, Malalag Poblacion, Kaputian, Sta. Maria Poblacion,Kumasie, Basiawan, Buhangin, Tubalan, Kidalapong, Sungay, and Malita Poblacion. Theproject has an approximate length of 52.60 km.

Except for an aggregate length of about 16.0 km of mountainous terrain, the topography of thearea where the road cuts through is flat to rolling slops. There will be no major realignment andthe project will not re-touch an aggregate length of 5.4 km Portland Cement ConcretePavement (PCCP) found intermittently in various areas. Also, there are 5 existing concretebridges that are all in good condition. One reinforced box culvert will be replaced by a newconcrete bridge, though.

The restoration of the Sulop Junction-Malalag-Malita Road Section will involve the pavingwith PCCP that 13.0 km existing asphalt sections that are in bad condition and the remaining34.2 km gravel sections. The road will have a standard width 6.10 m and a thickness of 200mm. It will have a shoulder of 1.5 m on each side in flat and rolling areas ad 1.0 m inmountainous areas. Moreover, the existing drainage system will be improved and flood-proneareas will be elevated.

The project will adversely impact a total of 70 PAP households. Specifically, 49 privatelyowned main structures (i.e., houses and shops) will be affected, 23 of which are used purely forresidence, 22 for residence and commerce, and 4 purely for commerce. 45 of these mainstructures are made of temporary (i.e., wooden) materials, while 4 are made semi-permanentlymaterials. Moreover, 30 of these main structures are severely affected, all of which may yet bereorganized in adjoining areas. A total of 22 other structures, all of wooden/bamboo perimeterfences, will be affected. While no crops will be affected, 1,079 trees and perennials of variousspecies will have to be cut.

The project will likewise have to compensate for portions of agricultural land in Malalag thathave yet to be paid by the government although they have long been made part of the presentroad. These parcels of land, with an estimated aggregate area of 17,497.38 m2 belong to afamily that now resides in Davao City.

This RAP should be read in conjunction with the DPWH Land Acquisition, Resettlement andRehabilitation Policy. Said Policy applies to all road projects that will be implemented underthe National Roads Improvement and Management Program (NRlMP). Prior to theimplementation of this RAP, the list of PAPs and affected assets will be validated This willfacilitate the finalization of the resettlement package for the PAPs.

Sulop Junction-Maialag-Malita Road Section Resettlement Action Plan

CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION

1.1 Description of the Project

The Sulop Junction-Malalag-Malita Road Section is a component of the Davao del Sur-Saranggani Coastal Road network. The project road sections starts at STA. 1583 + 766.54 atthe Sulop Junction and follows a south-easterly direction crossing through the Municipalitiesof Malalag, Sta. Maria, before ending at the first approach of the Culaman Bridge in theMunicipality of Sulop at STA. 1636 + 327.24. The 11 barangays that are traversed by theproject road section are Baclayon, Malalag Poblacion, Kaputian, Sta. Maria Poblacion,Kumasie, Basiawan, Buhangin, Tubalan, Kidalapong, Sungay, and Malita Poblacion. Theproject has an approximate length of 52.60 km. (See Figure 1.1 for the Location Map).

Except for an aggregate length of about 16.0 km of mountainous terrain, the topography of thearea where the road cuts through is flat to rolling slopes. There will be no major realignmentand the project will not re-touch an aggregate length of 5.4 km Portland Cement ConcretePavement (PCCP) found intermittently in various areas. (See Table 1.1 for the Location ofExisting PCCP Section). Also, there are 5 existing concrete bridges that are all in goodcondition. One reinforced box culvert will be replaced by a new concrete bridge, though.

The restoration of the Sulop Junction-Malalag-Malita Road Section will involve the pavingwith PCCP that 13.0 km existing asphalt sections that are in bad condition and the remaining34.2 km gravel sections. The road will have a standard with 6.10 m and a thickness of 200 mm.It will have a shoulder of 1.5 m on each side in flat and rolling areas ad 1.0 m in mountainousareas. Moreover, the existing drainage system will be improved and flood-prone areas will beelevated.

1.2 Types of Impacts

The region served by the project road is rural and its economy relies heavily on agriculture andaquaculature. The project road will certainly help boost the socio-economic developmnent of theregion.

About 3 years back, the Sub-engineering District of the DPWH in Malita has starteddemarcating with monument a road right-of-way (ROW) of 30 m from the centerline. Previousto this, local DPWH personnel claimed that the road was a provincial road with a ROW of 20m from the road centerline. Since the construction limit of the present road section project isconfined to 10 m in flat lands and 15 in sloping areas, it is believed that acquisition of land forROW is limited to payment for private properties that have already been made part of the roadbut which have yet to compensated for. These properties, all found in the Municipality ofMalalag, belong to the family of Ma. Luisa P. Lanzar and Donato P. Lanzar with a total area ofapproximately 17,497.38 m2 . (See Table 1.2 for the list of Private Lots RequiringCompensation).

2

Sulop Junction-MMalalag-Malita Road-Section Resettlement Action -Plan

Figure 1.1 Location Map of the Project Area

. pbya p-13 of tht PhI44ppines

LEGENDt

Road Network-. lu S~

-Prov. adry.

A * City/capital

*Munici7pality

Sunot J g < deuX (* Barangay/citioE

Riverp/Creeks

P r o v i in c e

o f

D A V A 0ff \ \ K f ~~~~~ /r° _;<e -~AowD E L S U R

Name ofProject Typas of Map Sc&JeWART ub TnO C OR)R AD " GHWAYS [Ewvironmental1 IWact Assessmaent ProjectOe Silop Juncton - Malalag - Malta | Location Map 1 200,000


Table 1.1: Location of Existing PCCP Sections

`3 arI ,. 4 W, - |STA. 1583 + 846.50 - STA 1584 + 846.20 0.9997STA. 1591 + 155.30 - STA 1592 + 560.00 1.4047STA. 1593 + 766.01 - STA 1593 + 996.93 0.23083STA. 1602 + 899.12 - STA 1603 + 813.29 0.91419STA. 1605 + 282.58 - STA 1605 + 729.41 0.44683STA. 1610 + 059.13 - STA 1610 + 440.17 0.38104STA. 1616 + 816.95 - STA 1671 + 802.52 0.98557

In addition, the project will adversely impact a total of 70 PAP households. Specifically, 49privately owned main structures (i.e., houses and shops) will be affected, 23 of which are usedpurely for residence, 22 for residence and commerce, and 4 purely for commerce. 45 of thesemain structures are made of temporary (i.e., wooden) materials, while four are semi-permanently materials. Moreover, 30 of these main structures are severely affected, all ofwhich may yet be reorganized in adjoining areas. A total of 22 other structures, all ofwooden/bamboo perimeter fences, will be affected. While no crops will be affected, 1,079trees and perennials of various species will have to be cut. The project will likewise affectpermanent waiting sheds and temporary outposts.

Table 1.2: Private Lots Requiring Compensation

Lot 7613-L-2 890.03 Lot 70-D-2 960.55Lot 7613-K-2 1,627.66 Lot 70-E-2 804.39Lot 7613 I-2 939.26 Lot 70-F-2 650.46Lot 7613-D-2 1,377.33 Lot 70-G-2 872.16Lot 7613-J-2 575.92 Lot 70-H-2 511.21Lot 7613-B-2 2,788.43 Lot 7568-D-2 2.38Lot 7613-A-2 1,252.56 Lot 7568-C-2 78.36Lot 70-A-2 979.01 Lot 7568-B-2 142_02Lot 70-A-3 195.72 Lot 7568-A-2 629.97Lot 70-B-2 765.96 Lot 70-J-2 489.17Lot 70_C-2 964.83

Sub-total 12,356.71 Sub-total 5,140.67Total P 17,497.38

1.3 Step Taken to Minimize the Impacts

Although the established ROW is 60 m, the present restoration works will only require aconstruction limit' of 10 m in flat lands and 15 m in sloping areas from the road center line.


1.4 Main Objectives of the Resettlement Action Plan

Development projects that result to the involuntarily resettlement of people may cause severelong-term hardship, impoverishment, and environmental damages unless appropriate measuresare carefully planned and carried out. Cognizant of this, the principal objectives of this RAPare to:

a. provide an assessment of the impacts that the road projects will have on the localpopulations;

b. quantify in monetary terms the private and public assets that will have to beacquired for or impacted by the project;

c. present a strategy that will ensure the timely acquisition of assets, payment ofcompensation and delivery of other benefits to PAPs;

d. provide a plan on how the PAPs will be involved in the various stages of the project,including the implementation of this RAP, in the line with DPWH's landAcquisition, Resettlement and Rehabilitation (LARR) Policy (See Annex A for acopy of the LARR aka Resettlement Policy); and

e. give an over-all estimate of the required resources needed to implement this RAP.

This area is within the ROW and must be free from any other structures but the road system itself. While thecivil works will be confined within this area, the 60 m ROW remains the same. Govemment is not giving up itsclaim of ownership over the ROW.


CHAPTER 2. DESCRIPTION OF IMPACTS AND SOCIO-ECONOMIC CHARACTERISTICS

2.1 Administrative Unit

The Sulop Junction-Malalag-Malita Road section is located in the province of Davao del Sur.It is under the administrative jurisdiction of DPWH Region XI Office, located in Davao City,and the DPWH Sub-district Engineering Office located in the Municipality of Malita.

2.2 Social and Economic Characteristics of Project Affected Persons

Census and inventory of affected assets were conducted in January and February 2001,including the conduct of baseline socio-economic survey for severely affected households. Thecensus/inventory and socio-economic survey were conducted with the assistance andparticipation of municipal and barangay (village) officials. Consultation meeting were firstheld in the affected municipalities with the presence of barangay officials, before the said datagathering activities were undertaken. ( See Annex B for the List of Public Meeting Held).

When the Environmental Impact Assessment Project Office (EIAPO) of DPWH Central Officetogether with Staff from Regional Office and District Office returned to the area in December2001 to conduct a validation of the list of PAPs and affected fixed assets, consequently, morehouseholds have been identified than those identified in the 1999 census because of the newroad design/aligmnent.

The road project will adversely affect 70 PAP households and 15 public structures. 49 of thesePAPs will be adversely affected by the loss of their main structures (i.e., independent house,cum store, or independent shops). 30 severely and 19 marginally, most of which will lose otherstructures, perimeter fences of light materials (e., bamboo and wood). Two PAPs, who is saidto be residing already in Davao City, has yet to be paid for portions of their properties thathave been made part of the present road. These PAPs was not included in the socio-economicsurvey but parcellary surveys of their properties have been done to facilitate payment duringRAP implementation. The 15 affected barangay governments will lose a total of 11 concretewaiting sheds and 5 barangay outposts. On the other hand, 104 PAP households who arelosing an estimated 1,079 trees and perennials of various species have identified. All of thePAPs are to be compensated and provided other entitlements, as needed, based on theinventory of assets and as provided for by the DPWH's Resettlement Policy.

2.2.1 Household Size

29 (40.85%) of the PAP households have a family size of 4 - 6 persons, while 28 PAPhousehold (39.44%) have between 1 - 3 members. ( See Table 2.1 next page).


Table 2.1: Distribution of PAPs Households Size

Municipalities 1-3 penons 4-6 persons 7-10 persons >10 Total

MaJalag 7 6 3 1 17 24.29

Sta Maria 6 5 2 - 13 18.57

Malita 14 18 7 1 40 57.14

Total 27 ((38.57% 29 (41.43%) 12 (17.14%) 2 (2.85%) 70 100.0

2.2.2 Distribution of PAPs by Origin

53 PAP households (75.71%) trace their origin to the Visayas in Central Philippines. Tenbelongs to a minority group called Manobo and five TagacauloTribes who will be affectedmarginally.

Table 2.2: Distribution of PAP Households by Origin

-, -, :. - ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~Total'Municipality. .. . -;

- - - . . Bisaya- . longo - locano Manobo Tagacaulo I

Malalag 16 1 17

Sta. Maria 12 1 - 13

Malita 25 10 5 40

Total 53(75.71%) 1(1.42%) 1(1.42%) 10 (14.29%) 5(7.14%) 70(100.0%)

2.2.3 Length of stay in the Community

All of the PAPs have been living in their respective communities for more than 3 year.

2.2.4 Households Income

2.2.4.a Main source of Income

37 (52.86 %) of the PAP households surveyed reported that they derived their main incomefrom farning, while the 17 (24.26%) from business. (See Table 2.3 next page)


Table 2.3: Distribution of Household Heads by Main Occupation

i______ Occupation Malalag Sta. Maria Malita Total| Farmer 10 7 20 37(52.86%)Business Operator 1 4 12 17 (24.26%)Skilled Labor 2 - I 3 (4.29%)Professional Practice 2 1 1 4 (5.71%)Overseas Contract Worker - - 1 I (1.43%)Housekeeping I - 5 6 (8.57%/)None I I - 2 (2.86%)Total 17 13 40 70 100.0%

2.2.5 Land and Main Structure Use

Of the 49 PAP households losing main structures, 23 of them use the land where their affectedassets are located for residential purposes, 22 for residence and commerce and 4 exclusivelyfor business. (See Table 2.4 next page).

Table 2.4: Distribution of PAPs by Use of Land/Main Structure

r._____ _ - - - ; -Land Use .

Municipality, '.- Residential. Residentiali. r Commercial, Total'n- Commercial.

Malalag 3 7 2 12Sta. Maria 6 6 1 13Malita 14 9 1 24Total 23 22 4 49

2.2.6 Tenure of Main Structure Occupants

The 49 PAP households whose main structures will be adversely affected by the project claimownership over the said assets.

2.2.7 Category of Main Structures

Of the 49 main structures that will be adversely affected by the project, 45 (91.84%) are madeof temporary materials, 4 semi-permanent, and no permanent structure.

8


Table 2.5; Category of Main Structures by Type of Construction

Municipality Main Structure Categor TotalPermanent Semi-Permanent Temporary

Count 2 10 12Malalag - - 24.49 %

Count 1 12 13Sta. Maria % - 26.53%

Count 1 23 24Malita % 48.98%

Total Count - 4 45 49. % _ ~ ~~~~ 8.16%/ 91.84% 100.0

2.3 Impacts of the Project

The census of affected population and inventory of affected assets that were carried out inJanuary and February 2001 provide the basis in determining the type, degree and scale ofproject impacts and in establishing the categories of PAPs (household and institutions) thisinformation, in turn, is used as basis for establishing entitlements for compensation andallowances. A baseline socio-economic survey was also conducted to collect more informationon PAPs who are losing lands and main structures. Said census and socio-economic surveyswere conducted by a composite team of EIAPO personnel, Regional and Sub-Engineer Districtoffice staff of DPWH, with assistance from officials of affected municipalities and barangays.

As mentioned earlier, the project will adversely affect a total of 70 PAP households, who willbe losing partly or entirely their land and/or structures. In addition, 104 PAPs will be losing atotal of 1,079 trees and perennial of various species.

Major impacts of projects are summarized below.

2.3.1 Impacts on Land

A total of 17,497.38 m2 agricultural and land belonging to Ma. Luisa P. Lanzar and Donato P.Lanzar which have long been made part of the road have yet to be compensated for. Below isa breakdown of the affected land.

2.3.1 .a Arcultural Land

21 parcels of agricultural land totaling 17,497.38 m2 are affected. These properties are alllocated in Malalag.

2.3. .b Residential Land

There are 23 affected lots that are used purely for residence and these are all inside the roadROW. The dwelling units have an approximate group-level floor area of 376.73 m2.


2.3.1.c Residential/Commercial Land

There are 22 affected lots that are used for residence and commerce, all inside the ROW. Thesestructures have an approximate total area of 283.37m2.

2.3.1.d Commercial Land

There are 4 affected lots that are used purely for commerce, all inside the ROW. Thesestructures have an approximate total area of 24.12 M2 . (See Table 2.6 next page)

Table 2.6: Distribution of Affected Land By Use

Municipality Residential Residential' CommercialCommercial'Malalag Count 3 7 2

Area 27.2 89.49 11.0Sta. Maria Count 6 6 1

Area 130.10 85.91 9.12Malita Count 14 9 1

Area 219.43 107.97 4.0Count 23 22 4

Total Area 376.73 283.37 24.12

2.3.2 Impacts on Structures

A total of 49 main structures will be affected by the road project. The aggregate floor area ofthese main structures is 684.22 m . 45 of this structure are made of temporary materials and 4semi-permanent. 11 waiting sheds and 4 outposts belonging to barangay governments will beseverely affected. In addition, other structures, (i.e., perimeter fence made of bamboo andwooden materials) will be adversely affected.

2.3.2a Residential Structures

There are 23 affected main structures that are used purely for residence. 16 of these areseverely affected, all of which may yet re-orgnized on adjacent lots. 7 dwelling units aremarginally affected. The dwelling units have an aggregate floor area of 376.73m2 .

Table 2.7 Distributions of Residential Structures

F Municipality' :: ;;: Mar inal Severe (Re-organize) . Server (Relocate)l'_.':___:-_-'_-_:Count. Area r: -- CoArear trea Count: AreaMalalag 1 7.2 2 20.0

|Sta. Maria 18.0 5122.10Malita 5 37.14 9 182.29Total 7 52.34 16 324.39

i n


2.3.2.b Residential/Commercial Structures

There are 22 main structures that are used both for residence and commerce. 12 of these aremarginally affected, while 10 others are severely affected but may let be re-organized inadjoining areas. The aggregate floor area of these structures is 283.37 m

Table 2.8: Distribution of Residential/Commercial Structures

|Mtunicipality Marginal Severe (Re-organize) Server (Relocate)Count Area Count Area Count Area

Malalag 2 15.75 5 73.74Sta. Maria 3 33.75 3 52.16Malita 7 57.77 2 51.20

Iotal 12 106.27 10 177.10

2.3.2.c Commercial Structures

Four independent shops will be severely affected by the road project yet re-organized onadjacent lots. The total floor area of the affected independent shops is 24.12m

Table 2.9: Distribution of Commercial Structures

I Municipality 0 : Marginal , Severe (Re-organize), Server (Relocate)., ; ' ~~Count . ,^*,ra.'-Count-: Area : ,Count,. Area

Malalag 2 11.0Sta. Maria 1 9.12Malita 1 4.0Total - 4 24.12

2.3.2.d Public Structures

11 waiting sheds and 5 outposts of these will be severely affected but may be re-organized.The affected public structures have an estimated total floor area of 173.34m . (See Table 2.10next page).

Table 2.10: Distribution of Public Structures

. un i c ipaiity''' : , f OUIvost; .- ,,,, ............ , - ,',, ,, Waitig g,Shed,,- , W.itng.Shed. 7'.'.:'.- : Co'unt ' -'' .,Area:.. Count..> . i'ea

Malalag 1 - 3 22.50Sta. Maria 3 58.08 1 7.50Malita 1 7.44 7 77.82

Total 5* 65.52 11 107.82

Made of Temporary (i.e. wooden) materials.


2.3.2.e Other Strictures

13 bamboo fence and another five perimeter fence will be affected and totaling 245 linearmeters, will have to be shifted back from the construction limit.

2.3.3 Loss of Crops and Trees

The project will not affect any household due to loss of crops. However, 104 PAPs will loseabout 1,079 trees of commercial value (i.e., trees with a minimum diameter of 4 inches atbreast height) due to the road project. (See Table 2.11)

2.3.4 Loss of Service Facilities

One garage will have to be shifted back outside of the construction limit.

2.3.5 Temporary Impacts

The temporary impacts of the project during the implementation stage will be negligible sinceall of the proposed improvements in the project will be carried out within the existing ROW/

2.3.6 Relocation Requirements

No relocation site is being envisaged for the project.

2.3.7 Summary of Impacts

The summary of impacts of the road project is shown on Table 2.12 (See Annex C for the Listof PAPs).

TABLE 2.11: DISTRIBUTION OF AFFECTED FAMILIES FOR PERENNIALS

OWNER / CLAIMANT KIND OF NO. AFFECTED UNIT i MARKET

IMPROVEMENT DAMAGE VALUE VALUE

1. Municipal of Gov't. Starapple 1 bearing 210.00 210.00

of Malalag Talisay 1 bearing 80.00 80.00

Acasia 4 bearing 80.00 320.00

610.00

2. Antonio Antoque Banana 2 bearing 20.00 40.00

3. Jessie Apacible Mango Cebu 2 bearing 1,920.00 3,840.00

Banana 4 bearing 20.00 80.00

Guava 1 bearing 210.00 210.00

4,130.00

4. Vicente Porio Gemelina 2 bearing 80.00 160.00


3 yrs Mango Cebu 1 non-bearing 1,152.00 1,152.00

1,832 .00

5. Dalmacio Omboy Gemelina 2 bearing 80.00 160.00

3 yrs. Mango Cebu 1 non-bearing 1,152.00 1,152.00



1,512.00

6. Moises Jomao-as Banana 12 bearing 20.00 240.00

Coco 1 bearing 171.00 171.00

411.00

7. Noel Davide Gemelina 7 bearing 80.00 560.00


640.00

8. Maximo Estimada Bolbolan 1 bearing 80.00 80.00


260.00

9. Auria Pefialosa Gemelina 11 bearing 80.00 880.00


980.00

10. Leonard Dizon Guava 4 bearing 210.00 840.00

11. Dulce Nyabes Banana 6 bearing 20.00 120.00

12. Municipal Gov't. Ipil-Ipil 1 bearing 80.00 80.00

of Malalag

13. Leonardo Dapar 3 yrs. Mahogany 9 non-bearing 16.00 144.00

Gemelina 3 bearing 80.00 240.00


1,124.00

14. John Sunga Romblon 40 bearing 20.00 800.00

15. Winnie Java Jackfruit 2 bearing 210.00 420.00

16. Antonio Cabrera Banana 95 bearing 20.00 1,900.00

17. Inocenco Toremocha Jackfruit 1 bearing 210.00 210.00

18. Teody Agosto Banana 26 bearing 20.00 520.00

in,

OWNER / CLAIMAIT KIND OF NO. AFFECTED UNIT T MARKET

IMPROVEMENT DAMAGE VALUE VALUE

19. Lolita Agosto Banana 4 bearing 20.00 80.00

Romblon 10 bearing 20.00 200.00

280.00

20. Francisca Dodero Banana 1 bearing 20.00 20.00

21. Wilfredo Rosario Guava 2 bearing 210.00 420.00

Mango Paho 1 bearing 210.00 210.00


790.00

22. Mario Solis Coco 2 bearing 171.20 342.40

Mahogany 1 bearing 80.00 80.00

422.40

23. Gil Quibod Banana 2 bearing 20.00 40.00

24. Anecita Pantillo Ellorimo Coco 2 bearing 171.20 342.40


Lomboy 1 bearing 210.00 210.001,704.40

25. Quirino Tenajeros Gemelina 1 bearing 80.00 80.00

Coco 1 bearing 171.20 171.20

251.20

26. Geraldo Gencianos Nem-Tree 1 bearing 80.00 80.00

27. Municipal Gov't. Gemelina 2 bearing 80.00 160.00

of Malalag Mahogany 3 bearing 80.00 240.00

400.00

28. Eddie Dullin Bogo 1 bearing 80.00 80.00

29. Federico Toregosa Coco 1 bearing 171.20 171.20


1,031.20

30. Juanito Mejias Banana 9 bearing 20.00 180.00

31. Armando Mejias Banana 4 bearing 20.00 80.00

32. Francisca Auza Mango Carabao 1 bearing 800.00 800.00

33. Jun Lascuna Banana 4 bearing 20.00 80.00

34. Melchor Deypalubos Banana 15 bearing 20.00 300.00

35. Gregorio Bajado Bamboo 1 bearing 672.00 672.00

Gemelina 21 bearing 80.00 1,680.00


2,412.00

36. Alfonso Agosto Coco 2 bearing 171.20 342.40


382.40

37. Rogelio Magoncia Banana 15 bearing 20.00 300.00

38. Guadalope Bolabos Banana 6 bearing 20.00 120.00

14

OWNER / CLAIMANT KIND OF | NO. AFFECTED UNIT | MARKET

IMPROVEMENT DAMAGE | VALUE VALUE

2 yrs. Jackfruit 1 bnon-bearing 84.00 84.00

Tamarind 1 bearing 210.00 210.00

414.00

39. Rodolfo Develos Banana 4 bearing 20.00 80.00

Tamarind 1 bearing 210.00 210.00

290.00

40. Claudio Gomez Coco 7 bearing 171.20 1,198.40

41. Paciencia Labad Gemelina 1 bearing 80.00 80.00

5 yrs. Mahogany 42 non-bearing 26.65 1,119.30

1,199.30

42. Davao del Sur School Acasia 8 bearing 80.00 640.00

of Fisheries

43. Anecito Esposo Gemelina 9 bearing 80.00 720.00


1,040.00

44. Municipal Gov't. Mahogany 3 bearing 80.00 240.00

of Malalag

45. Ananias Santiago Nem Tree 1 bearing 80.00 80.00

46. Rodolfo Magdayao Nem Tree 2 bearing 80.00 160.00

Jackfruit 1 bearing 210.00 210.00

370.00

47. Bonifacio Mondelo Talisay 1 bearing 80.00 80.00

Pine Tree 1 bearing 80.00 80.00

160.00

48. Antonina Arellano Gemelina 1 bearing 80.00 80.00

49. Generoso Compafiero Nem Tree 8 bearing 80.00 640.00

50. Patrocenia Companiero Gemelina 3 bearing 80.00 240.00

Coco 1 bearing 171.20 171.20

Jackfruit 2 bearing 210.00 420.00

831.20

51. Maria Supatan Guava 1 bearing 210.00 210.00

BNem Tree 1 bearing 80.00 80.00




6,018.00

52. Carmelo Fernandez Mango Cebu 1 bearing 1,920.00 1,920.00

Mahogay 1 bearing 120.00 120.00

2,040.00

53. DENR Mahogany 24 bearing 80.00 1,920.00

54. Perpetua Villanueva Camanchiles 2 bearing 80.00 160.00

55. Portesia Luague Camanchiles 2 bearing 80.00 160.00

56. Restituto Cancamo Starapple 1 bearing 210.00 210.00

OWNER / CLAIMANT KIND OF | NO. AFFECTED | UNIT MARKET

_1 IMPROVEMENT | DAMAGE | VALUEJ VALUE

57. Ireneo Alcoseba Tamarind 1 bearing 210.00 210.00

58. Albina Carbaquel Nem Tree 3 bearing 80.00 240.00

59. Marcelo Sastre 7 yrs. Mahogany 8 non-bearing 37.30 298.40

60. Letecia Oscares Tamarind 1 bearing 210.00 210.00

Tambis 1 bearing 210.00 210.00

420.00

61. Generoso Compafiero Nem Tree 8 bearing 80.00 640.00

62. Soledad Daligdig Santol 1 bearing 210.00 210.00

Labana 1 bearing 210.00 210.00

420.00

63. Carmelo Fernandez Lomboy 1 bearing 210.00 210.00

Mango Carabao 1 bearing 800.00 800.00

1,010.00

64. Silvino Sasuman 4 yrs. Mango Cebu 2 non-bearing 1,536.00 3,072.00

2 yrs. Mango Kastila 1 non-bearing 42.00 42.00

3,114.00

65. Municipal Gov't. Nem Tree 1 bearing 80.00 80.00

of Malalag

66. Henry Ares Gemelina 5 bearing 120.00 600.00

67. Felipe Dianito Jackfruit 1 bearing 210.00 210.00


Talisay 1 bearing 80.00 80.00

500.00

68. John Sunga Jackfruit 1 bearing 210.00 210.00

69. Higuela Montejo Banana 1 bearing 20.00 20.00

Mango Cebu 1 bearing 1,920.00 1,920.00

1,940.00

70. Apolonia Ardiente Coco 4 bearing 171.20 684.80


Nem Tree 2 bearing 80.00 160.00

1,004.80

71. Municipal Gov't. Gemelina 30 bearing 80.00 2,400.00

of Malalag

72. Eleuteria Rosario Gemelina 30 bearing 80.00 2,400.00

73. Municipal Gov't. Gemelina 57 bearing 80.00 4,560.00

of Malalag

74. Bulacan Coco Farmers Gemelina 6 bearing 80.00 480.00

Multi Purpose Coop. Tamarind 1 bearing 210.00 210.00

690.00

75. Teresita Bero Coco 1 bearing 171.20 171.20

Pomelo 1 bearing 210.00 210.00

Lomboy 1 bearing 210.00 210.00

OWNER / CLAIMANT KIND OF | NO. AFFECTED UNIT MARKET

IMPROVEMENT DAMAGE V VALUE

591.20

76. Leo Emphasis Banana 4 bearing 20.00 80.00

77. Isabel Aleria Banana 12 bearing 20.00 240.00

78. Procopio Grumo Banana 3 bearing 20.00 60.00


Mango Cebu 1 bearing 1,920.00 1,920.00

2,820.00

79. Wilbert Tan Banana 8 bearing 20.00 160.00

80. Jesus Solidium Guava 1 bearing 210.00 210.00

81. Mario Pendon Atis 1 bearing 210.00 210.00

82. Dionesiana Tobias Jackfruit 1 bearing 210.00 210.00

83. Victor Peradillo Banana 18 bearing 20.00 360.00

84. Mamerta Pendon Banana 12 bearing 20.00 240.00

85. Jose Tanciongco Banana 12 bearing 20.00 240.00

86. Pablo Ausa Banana 29 bearing 20.00 580.00

87. Mun. Gov't. of Malalag Gemelina 11 bearing 80.00 880.00

88. Mamerta Pendon Ipil-Ipil 2 bearing 80.00 160.00

89. Mun. Gov't. of Malalag Gemelina 11 bearing 80.00 880.00

90. Julia Tatad Jackfruit 1 bearing 210.00 210.00

91. Mun. Gov't. of Malalag Gemelina 28 bearing 80.00 2,240.00

92. Amparo Ilo Banana 10 bearing 80.00 800.00

93. Federico Alfanta Gemelina 1 bearing 80.00 80.00


100.00

94. Mabel Raganas Ipil-Ipil 10 bearing 80.00 800.00

95. Porteza Ares Gemelina 6 bearing 80.00 480.00

Coco 3 bearing 171.00 513.60

Mango Cebu I bearing 1,920.00 1,920.00

2,913.60

96. Mun. Gov't. of Malalag Gemelina 16 bearing 80.00 1,280.00

97. Natalia Carrasco Banana 6 bearing 20.00 120.00

98. Anita Ilo Banana 2 bearing 20.00 40.00

99. Honorata Gulay 1 yr. Durian 1 non-bearing 220.00 220.00

100. Santiago Adtoon Tamarind 2 bearing 210.00 420.00

101. Pablito Lutap/Isaias Golez Banana 6 bearing 20.00 120.00

102. Jacinto Villaber Banana 12 bearing 20.00 240.00

103. Ricardo Sapong Banana 6 bearing 20.00 120.00

Coco 2 bearing 171.20 342.40

462.40

104. Nelly Nangcas Coco 2 bearing 171.20 342.40


902.40

GRANID TOTAL FOR MALALAG-MALITA 83,180.30

4-7


Table 2.12: Summary of Affected Assets

UniVItems Quantity PAPs Total Remarks

Use of Land

- Agricultural M2 2 17,497

- Residential M2

- Residential/Commercial M2

- Commercial M2

- Industrial M2

Main Structures

- Permanent M2

- Semi-Permanent M2 4 81.06

- Temporary m2 45 603.14

- Structures partially affected m2 19 158.61

- Structures severely affected M2 30 525.61

(may yet reorganize)

- Structures severely affected M2

(relocation required)

Public Structures

- Outposts (Temporary) M2 5 72.96

- Waiting Sheds (Permanent) M2 11 107.82

Other Structures

- Front yard fence (Bamboo) 13 1741m

- Perimeter fence (barbed wire) 5 71 Im

- Electric Posts

Garage 1 29.75

rees and crops

- Trees Tree 104 Person 1,079

- Crops


CHAPTER 3. COMPENSATION RATES AND ENTITLEMENTS

3.1 Introduction

This section presents the category of PAPs' (i.e., families and institutions) and theirentitlements, based on the results of the census and inventory of affected assets.

3.2 Detailed Compensation Entitlements

The impacts of the projects will result in the acquisition of titled lands, structures and trees,including income loss. PAPs will be compensated according to the DPWH Resettlement Policy.This section outlines compensation entitlement for each category of PAPs. The compensationentitlements are summarized in Table 3.1.

3.2.1 Loss of Arable Land:

PAPs will be eligible to compensation according to their status, thus:

a) Legal owners of marginally affected arable land. This category includes PAPs who havefull title to the land, those who hold tax declaration, those who are covered by customarylaws (e.g., possessory rights, usufruct), or those who hold some other kind of acceptableproof of ownership. PAPs in this category may or may not be within the existing ROW.

2 PAPs falls under this category. The PAP is entitled to the following:

- For the affected portion of her properties, this PAP will receive cash compensationequivalent to the fair market value of the lands as estimated by an independent landappraiser to be hired for the purpose and which uses internationally acceptedstandards.

- Cash compensation for perennials of commercial value as determined by the DENRor by the Municipal RAP Implementation Committee (MRIC) using market value.

b) Legal Owners of severely affected arable land. No PAP falls in this category.

c) Users of marginally of severely affected arable land without tax declaration, title, or anyacceptable proof of ownership. This category includes PAPs who have occupied the landwithin the 20-30 m (i.e., flat land-sloping areas) construction limit.

No PAP falls in this category.

Unless specifically stated as project-affected family (PAI), the term project-affected person (PAP) is used broadly to meanhouseholds, organizations and institutions.


d) There are no tenant or lessee occupants of agricultural land in the road project.

e) No PAP will be affected by the temporary use of his/her arable land for the roadproject.

3.2.2 Loss of Residential or Commercial Land

This category covers PAPs who have full title to the affected residential or commercial land,those who hold tax declaration, those who are covered by customary laws (e.g., possessoryrights, usufruct), or those who hold some other kind of acceptable proof of ownership. PAP inthis category may or may not be within the existing ROW.

a) No marginally affected PAP falls in this category.

b) No severely affected PAP falls in this category.

c) No PAP will be affected by the temporary use of his/her resident or commercial land forthe road project.

3.2.3 Loss of Residential/Residential cum Shop Structures

This policy applies to residential structures (e.g., houses) located within the 20-30 m (i.e., flatland-sloping areas) construction limit, with or without a building permit.

a) Partially affected residential structures, i.e., structures are not completely lost but are stillviable for continued use:

* No PAP, whose land is covered with full title, tax declaration, customary law, or someother acceptable proof of ownership, will have his/her residential structure partiallyaffected.

* 7 PAPs, who does not have any acceptable proof of ownership over the land he/sheuses for his/her residential structure, will be partially affected. Another 12 PAPs, whodo not have any acceptable proof of ownership where their house-cum-stores arelocated, will be partially affected. These 12 PAPs, whose business might be affected,will receive subsistence allowance for lost income during the reconstruction period ofthe residential structures, but not to exceed 1 month. This will be verified and computedby the municipal resettlement implementation committee (MRIC). All of the PAPs willlikewise be entitled to:

- Cash compensation at replacement cost (i.e., the cost of construction materials andlabor at current prices) for the affected portion, including the cost to repair theremaining structure and to restore damaged service facilities, as determined by theconcemed appraisal committee and without deduction for salvaged materials.

* No tenant PAP occupies any of the marginally affected main structures.

b) The entire main residential structures (house or house cum shop) are affected, or when theremaining residential structure is no longer viable for continued use. This category covers

Sulop Junction-Mailag-Malita Road Section Resettlement Action Plan

PAPs who will either reorganize their structures on adjacent or nearby lots or those whowill have to shift elsewhere.

* No PAP, whose land is covered with full title, tax declaration, customary law, or someother acceptable proof of ownership, will have his/her main residential structureseverely affected.

* 16 PAP households, who do not have any acceptable proof of ownership for the landwhere their houses are built, will be severely affected by the road project. They may,however, re-organize their houses on adjacent areas. Another 10 PAP households, whodo not have any acceptable proof of ownership where their house-cum-stores arelocated, will be severely affected but may re-organize their dwelling units. These PAPhouseholds, whose business will be affected, will receive subsistence allowance for lostincome during the reconstruction period of the residential structures, but not to exceedl month. This will be verified and computed by the municipal resettlementimplementation committee (MRIC). Moreover, all of the severely affected PAPhouseholds will be entitled to:

- Cash compensation for the entire structure at replacement cost as determined by theMRIC without deduction for salvaged materials.

- If the PAP does not own any land to relocate to, he/she will be allowed to moveback behind the construction limit but still within the ROW until such time that thesame is able to acquire a legitimate land or when the government will need the restof the ROW. (NOTE: a pledge of undertaking for this purpose will be executed bythe PAP).

- Free transportation will be provided for hauling belongings. (NOTE: Rehabilitationassistance (e.g., skills training and other development activities) equivalent to PhP15,000 will NOT be provided to the PAPs since the household heads may stillcontinue with their present means of livelihood).

* There are no severely affected residential structures that are occupied by tenant PAPs.

3.2.4 Loss of Independent Shops/Stores:

This policy applies to stores and other commercial shops that are not attached to, or are part of,the main residential structures (e.g., houses) and are located within the 20-30 m (i.e., flat land-sloping areas), with or without a building permit.

a) Partially affected commercial main structures, i.e., they are no completely lost but are stillviable for continued use:

* No PAP, who has full title, tax declaration, or other acceptable proof of ownership overthe land where his/her affected main commercial structure is located, falls in thiscategory.

* Four PAP household, who does not have any acceptable proof of ownership over theland where his/her affected main commercial structure is located, will be partiallyaffected by the road project. This PAP will be entitled to:

Sulop Junction-Malalag-Malita Road Section Resettlemnent Action Plan

- Compensation at replacement cost for the affected portion of the structure,including repair cost and reconnection of damaged service facilities, and withoutdeduction for salvaged materials.

- Subsistence allowance for lost income during the reconstruction period of the shop,but not to exceed I month. This will be verified and computed by the municipalresettlement implementation committee (MRIC).

* There is no tenant PAP of independent shops.

b) The entire commercial main structures are affected, or when the remaining structures areno longer viable for continued use. This category covers PAPs who will either reorganizetheir commercial structures on adjacent or nearby lots or those who will have to relocate orshift elsewhere.

* No PAP, who holds any acceptable proof or ownership over the land where his/heraffected main commercial structure is located, falls in this category.

* Tow PAP households without acceptable proof of ownership for the land where theiraffected independent shops are built, will be severely affected. These PAPs will eachbe entitled to:

- Replacement cost for the entire structure without deduction for salvaged materials.- Subsistence allowance of PhP 15,000.- Transportation assistance if relocating.- If the PAP does not own any land to relocate to, he/she will be allowed to move

back behind the construction limit but still within the ROW until such time that thesame is able to acquire a legitimate land or when the government will need the restof the ROW. (NOTE: a pledge of undertaking for this purpose will be executed bythe PAP).

- (NOTE: Rehabilitation assistance (e.g., skills training and other developmentactivities) equivalent to PhP 15,000 will NOT be provided to the PAPs since thehousehold heads may still continue with their present means of livelihood).

* There are no leased independent shops affected.

3.2.5 Loss of Public Infrastructure

The project will affect 15 government-owned structures, 4 wooden barangay outposts and 11concrete waiting sheds. Project authority will replace the affected structures.

3.2.6 Loss of Other Fixed Structures

This policy applies to other fixed structures stores, such as fence, gate, concrete pavement, thatare located within the 20-30 m (i.e., flat land-sloping areas) construction limit, with or withouta building permit.

Sulop Junction-Maialag-Malits Road Section Resettlement Action Plan

Owners of partially or severely affected other fixed (miscellaneous) structures are entitled tocash compensation for the affected portion of the structure, including the cost of restoration.

Thirteen (13) PAP households will lose the bamboo fence of their front yard. Another 71linear meters of barbed wire used as perimeter fence for farmlands will be severely affected.The owners if these farmlands have yet to be determined, though.

3.2.7 Loss of Standing Crops and Trees

A total 1,079 trees and other perennials will be lost. The project will pay for these trees andother perennials at replacement cost based on their assessed value as prepared by the Office ofthe Provincial Assessor of Davao del Sur. The owners of all affected trees will keep the woodor lumber and fuel.


Table 3.1 : Entitlement Matrix

Type of Loss Application Entitled Person Compensation Com ensation Amount (Php)I. Arabe Land Actual area needed by the Owners with full title, tax For the portion of the land needed: Ma. Luiza Lanzar

road project and the declaration or who are + Cash compensation at fair market2 HH remaining land is still covered by customary law value as determined by an independent 6,558.68 m2x 80/ 2=524,694.40Ma. Luisa economically viable (e.g., possessory rights, land appraiser (ILA) hired for the 7,334.94 m2xl5O/m 2=1,100,241Lanzar and usufruct) or other acceptable purpose and which uses internally 2,261.86m2xl60/m2=36l.897 60Donato Lanzar 17,497.38 sq.m. proof of ownership accepted standards. 1,986,833.00

+ Cash compensation for perennials of Donato Lanzar2 HH commercial value as determined by the

DENR or the MIRC. 1,341.9m 2xl60/m2 = 214.704.00+ PAP will be given sufficient time to 2,201,537.00harvest crops on the subject land.

Based on Appraisal Report:

Say ---- Php2,203,000.

PAPs without title, tax For the portion of the land needed:declaration, or are not covered + PAP will be given sufficient time toby customary law (e.g., harvest cropspossessory rights, usufruct) or + Cash compensation for perennials ofother acceptable proof of commercial value as determined by theownership DENR or the MRIC.

+ measures introduced by the PAP toNil make the land productive, such as

leveling, riprap, embankment, will bevaluated based on actual cost analysisand the PAP will be paid for them aspart of the improvements introduced tothe land.

Remaining land becomes Owner with full title, tax + Cash compensation at fair marketeconomically not viable declaration or who are value as determined by an independent(i.e., PAP losing > 20% of covered by customary law land appraiser (ILA) hired for theland holding or even when (e.g., possessory rights, purpose and which uses internallylosing < 20% but remnaining usufruct) or other acceptable accepted standards. If feasible, 'landland is not economically proof of ownership for land' will be provided in terms of a


Type of Loss Application Entitled Person Compensation Compensation Amount (Php)viable anymore) new parcel of land of equivalent

productivity, at a location acceptable toNil PAP, and with long-term security oftenure.+A disturabance fee of PhP 15,000will be added to the amount to be paidfor the land.+ PAP will be given sufficient time toharvest crops+ Cash compensation for perennials ofcommercial value as determined by theDENR or the MRUC.+ If relocating, PAP to be provided freetransportation+ Rehabilitation assistance (skillstraining and other developmentactivities) aquivalent to PhP 15,000 willbe provided in coordination with othergovernment agencies if the presentmeans of livelihood is no longer viableand the PAP will have to engage in a.____________ new income activity.

PAPs without title, tax + Financial assistance equivalent to thedeclaration, or are not covered average annual gross harvest for theby customary law (e.g., past 3 years but not less than PhPpossessory rights, usufruct) or 15,000 per ha.other acceptable proof of + PAP will be given sufficient time toownership harvest cropsq2

+ Cash compensation for perennials ofcommercial value as determined by theDENR or the concerned appraisalcommittee. Also, measures introducedby the PAP to make the landproductive, such as leveling, riprap,embankment, will be valuated based onactual cost analysis and the PAP will bepaid for them as part of the


Type of Loss Application Entitled Person Compensation Compensation Amount (Php)improvements introduced to the land.+ If relocating, PAP to be provided freetransportation+ Rehabilitation assistance (skillstraining and other developmentactivities) equivalent to PhP 15,000 willbe provided in coordination with othergovernment agencies if the presentmeans of livelihood is no longer viableand the PAP will have to engage in anew income activity.

Agricultural lessees + Disturbance compensation equivalentto five times the average of the grossharvest on the land holding during thefive preceding years but not less thanPhP 15,000 per ha.+ Rehabilitation assistance (skillstraining and other developmentactivities) equivalent to PhP 15,000 willbe provided in coordination with othergovernment agencies if the presentmeans of livelihood is no longer viableand the PAP will have to engage in anew income activity.

Temporary use of land All PAPs + Compensation to be provided for lossof income during the period, standingNil crops, cost of soil restoration anddamaged structures.2. Residential land Actual area needed by the Owners with full title, tax For the portion of the land needed:andlor road project and the declaration or who are + Cash compensation at fair marketCommercial remaining land is still viable covered by customary law value as determined by an independentland for continued use (e.g., possessory rights, land appraiser (ILA) hired for the

usufruct) or other acceptable purpose and which uses internallyNil proof of ownership accepted standards.+ Cash compensation for perennials ofcommercial value as determined by theDENR or the MRIC


Type of Loss Application Entitled Person Compensation Compensation Amount (Php)

Remaining residential or Owners with full title, tax + Cash compensation at fair marketcommercial land becomes declaration or who are value as determined by an independentnot viable for continued covered by customary law land appraiser (ILA) hired for theuse. (e.g., possessory rights, purpose and which uses internally

usufruct) or other acceptable accepted standards. If feasible, 'landproof of ownership for land' will be provided in terms of a

new parcel of land or similarcharacteristics or value, at a locationacceptable to PAP, and with long-termsecurity of tenure. The replacementland should be of acceptable in sizeunder zoning laws. When the affectedholding is larger in value than thereplacement plot, cash compensationwill cover the difference in value.+ Cash compensation for perennials ofcommercial value as determined by theDENR or the MRIC.+ If relocating, PAP to be provided freetransportation

Temporary use of land All PAPs + Compensation to be provided for lossof income during the period, standingcrops, cost of soil restoration and_.damaged structures.

3. Main Structures Structure, with or without a Owners of structure with full + Compensation in cash for the affected(e.g., house, building permit, partially title or tax declaration to the portion of the structure, including thehouse cum affected and the remaining land or those who are covered cost of restoring the remainingshop) structure is still viable for by customary law (e.g., structure, as determined by the MRICcontinued use. possessory rights, usufiuct) or with no deduction for salvaged building49 HH other acceptable proof of materials.23 HH ownership + PAPs who have business affected due

to the partial impact on the structure areNil entitled to a subsistence allowance for

income loss during the reconstructionperiod. (Such will be verified and


Type of Loss Application Entitled Person Compensation Compensation Amount (Php)computed by the MRIC).

Owners of structures, + Compensation in cash for the affected Residential 23 PAPsincluding shanty dwellers in portion of the structure, including theurban areas, have no title or cost of restoring the remaining structure Affected Structure: Php268,872.70tax declaration to the land or and reconnection of damaged utilities, Income loss: n/aother acceptable proof of as determined by the MRIC with no Relocation: n/aownership deduction for salvaged building Rehabilitation: n/a

materials. Others: n/a23PAPs + Shanty dwellers in urban areas who

opt to go back to their place of origin inthe province or be shifted togovernment relocation sites will beprovided free transportation.+ PAPs who have business affected dueto the partial impact on the structure are'entitled to a subsistence allowance forincome loss during the reconstructionperiod. (Such will be verified andcomputed by the MRIC).+ Professional squatters will not receivecompensation but they can collect theirsalvageable materials.

Renters (tenants) of leased + Given 3 month notice on the scheduleaffected structures, including of demolitionrenters of shanty dwellings in + If shifting is required, PAP is givenurban areas transitional allowance equivalent to one

month rent of a similar structure withinNil the same area.

+ For house tenants renting structuresoutside of, or within the ROW, but whohave to transfer elsewhere, will beprovided free transportation.+ Renting shanty dwellers in urbanareas who opt to go back to their placeof origin in the province or be shifted togovernment relocation sites will beprovided free transportation.


Type of Loss Application Entitled Person Compensation Compensation Amount (Php)Entire structure affected or Owners of structures with full + Compensation in cash for the entirewhen the remaining title or tax declaration to the structure at replacement cost asstructure becomes not land or those who are covered determined by the MRIC withoutviable for continued use, by customary law (e.g., deduction for salvaged buildingwith or without a building possessory rights, usufruct) or materials.permit other acceptable proof of + Disturbance fee of PhP 10,000 will

ownership be added to the amount to be paid forthe structure.

Nil + PAPs who have business affected dueto the severe impact on the structure areentitled to a subsistence allowance forthe loss of income during thereconstruction period. (Such will beverified and computed by the MRIC).+ If relocation is necessary, freetransportation will be provided.+ Rehabilitation assistance in the formof skills training and other developmentactivities and equivalent to PhP I 5,000wiJ be provided in coordination withother government agencies if thepresent means of livelihood is no longerviable and the PAP will have to engagein a new income activity.

Owners of structures, + Compensation in cash for the entireincluding shanty dwellers in structure at replacement cost asurban areas, have no title or determined by the MRIC withouttax declaration to the land or deduction for salvaged buildingother acceptable proof of materials.ownership + Substitute lot of equal or bigger area

and, preferably, near the PAPhousehold's original place+ Shanty dwellers in urban areas whoopt to go back to their place of origin inthe province or be shifted togovernment relocation sites will beprovided fee transportation.


Type of Loss Application Entitled Person Compensation Compensation Amount (Php)+ PAPs who have business affected dueto the severe impact on the structure areentitled to a subsistence allowance forthe loss of income during thereconstruction period.

(Such will be verified and computed bythe MRIC).+ If relocation is necessary, freetransportation will be provided.+ Rehabilitation assistance in the formof skills training and other developmentactivities and equivalent to PhP 15,000will be provided in coordination withother government agencies if thepresent means of livelihood is no longerviable and the PAP will have to engagein a new income activity.+ Professional squatters will not receivecompensation but they can collect theirsalvageable materials.

Renters (tenants) of leased + Given 3 month notice on the scheduleaffected structures, Including of demolitionrenters of shanty dwellings in + PAP is given transitional allowanceurban areas equivalent to on month rent of a similar

structure within the same area+ For house tenants renting structuresoutside of, or within the ROW, but whohave to transfer elsewhere will beprovided free transportation.+ Rehabilitation assistance in the formof skills training and other developmentactivities and equivalent to PhP 15,000will be provided in coordination withother government agencies if thepresent means of livelihood is no longer

__________ ___ _____ _________ ______ ___ _________ ________. viable and the PAP will have to engage


Type of Loss Application Entitled Person Compensation Compensation Amount (Php)in a new income activity.+ Renting shanty dwellers in urbanareas who opt to go back to their placeof origin in the province or be shifted togovernment relocation sites will beprovided free transportation.

4. Independent Shops, with or without Owners of structure with or + Compensation in cash for affected Commercial - 4 PAPsshops building permit, partially without full title or tax portion of the structure, including the(structures) affected and the remaining declaration to the land or cost of restoring the remaining structure Affected Structure: Php3 1,056.55structures are still viable for those who are covered by and reconnection of any damaged Income loss 5,950.004 H continued use. customary law (e.g., utilities, as determined by the MRIC Relocation: n/apossessory rights, usufruct) or with no deduction for salvaged building Rehabilitation: n/aother acceptable proof of materials. Others: n/aownership + As determined by the MRIC, PAPs

will be entitled to a transitionalHH allowance to cover for their computed

income loss during the demolition andreconstruction of their ships, but not toexceed a 1 month period..

Renters (tenants) of affected + As determined by the MRIC, shopshops renters will be entitled to a transitional

allowance to cover for their computedNil income loss during the period that their

business is interrupted.

Entire shop affected OR Owner of structure with or + Compensation in cash for the entirewhen the remaining without full title or tax structure at replacement cost asstructure becomes not declaration to the land or determined by the MRIC withoutviable for continued use, those who are covered by deduction for salvaged buildingwith or without a building customary law (e.g., materials.permit possessory rights, usufruct) or + Subsistence allowance of PhP 15,000

other accepatabl proof of to each PAPownership + Rehabilitation assistance in the form

of skills training and other developmentactivities and equivalent to PhP 15,000will be provided in coordination withother government agencies if the


Type of Loss Application Entitled Person Compensation Compensation Amount (Php)present means of livelihood is no longerviable and the PAP will have to engagein a new income activity+ Professional squatters will not receivecompensation but they can collect theirsalvageable materials.+ If household is relocating, PAP willbe entitled to:

- Free transportation- Substitute lot of equal or bigger area

and, preferably, near the PAPhousehold's original place

Renters (tenants) of affected + Given 3 month notice on the scheduleshops of demolition

+ Subsistence allowance of PhP 15,000Nil + If shifting, either permanently or

temporarily is required, shop renters areentitled to free transportation+ Rehabilitation assistance in the formof skills training and other developmentactivities and equivalent to PhP 15,000will be provided in coordination withother government agencies if thepresent means of livelihood is no longerviable and the PAP will have to engagein a new income activity

5. Other fixed Loss ot or damage to, 22 HH ResidentialUcomm'l + Compensation in cash for affected Residential/Commercialassets or affected assets, partially or portion of the structure, including thestructures entirely cost of restoring the remaining Affected Structure: Php262,750.50structure, as determined by the Income Loss: 28,720.50concerned appraisal committee, with no Relocation: n/adepreciation nor deduction for salvaged Rehabilitation: n/abuilding materials. Others: n/a


Type of Loss Application Entitled Person Compensation Com ensation Amount h6. Other structures Loss of, or damage to, Bamboo fence - 1741m + Compensation to cover cost of Affected Fences: Php61,891.25(Fence) affected assets, partially or Barbed wire - 71 Im restoring the facilities

entirely7. Public Loss of or damage to, Waiting sheds- 11 Compensation in cash at replacement 306,433.15structures public infrastructure (e.g., Outpost - 5 cost to respective barangay

Barangay waiting shed, Garage - I governments.m ilitary outpost). _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _8. Trees/Perennials . 1,079 trees/pcs owned by Php 83,180.30

104 PAPs


3.3 Resettlement Costs and Budget

Funds for RAP implementation will be part of the Project budget. The annual investmentplans for the Project will include resettlement costs. Costs are estimated based on theprevailing rates as of February 2002. Unless proven through the grievance redressalmechanism that certain households may have been inadvertently missed out during thecensus, only households, individuals and organizations covered in the inventory of affectedassets and socio-economic survey in January and February 2001 (cut-off date) are eligible forcompensation. The implementation of the RAP is expected to begin in March and will becompleted by May 2002. Therefore, the market rates used for assessment of compensationwill remain valid during the implementation period of the RAP. Validation of affected assetsand their replacement values will be done during RAP implementation. Said appraisal ofaffected assets will be done in accordance with the DPWH Resettlement Policy.

3.3.1 Procedures for Flow of Funds

On the basis of the approved RAP, funding for the implementation of the resettlement planwill be forwarded to the DPWH Sub-Engineering Office in Malita, which in turn is tasked toprepared and process the vouchers for payment of compensation to PAPs, relocationexpenses,

operational costs, etc. Requests for payment for the aforementioned will be made by the saidSub-Engineering District Office, which is principally tasked to spearhead the implementationof the RAP.

3.3.2 Cost Estimates and Inflation Adjustment

DPWH, in consultation with relevant agencies, will determine the annual inflation rate andwill ensure that annual adjustments are made to compensation rates and to other cashentitlements.

3.3.3 Implementation, Administration and Contingency Costs

Implementation costs include costs of stake-out/demarcation and validation of impacts,payment of allowances and per diem to the concerned EIAPO staff and DPWH regional anddistrict personnel, participating municipal staff, barangay officials and MRIC members.Administration costs represent 6.0% of the total project costs. The cost estimates for RAPimplementation also include a provision for contingencies equivalent to 15.0% of the totalproject cost. DPWH will ensure that adequate fumds are made available as and whennecessary for the efficient and timely implementation of the resetflement activities.

3.3.4 Unit Prices for Cost Estimation

Cost estimates for compensation are based on the provisions of the Resettlement Policy ofDPWH. Table 3.2 presents the cost estimates for the RAP.


Table 3.2: Estimated Resettlement Cost

AMOUNT AMOUNT

DESCRIPTION No. of UNIT RATE QUANTr Peso USDDESCRIPTION ~~Hils U P/UNIT QUANTITYrpCrt (LoaFund) Fund)

Compensation for Land andStructures and other fixedassetsLand (as per ILA estimates) 2 M2 100/M2 17,497.38 2,203,000

Agricultural M2

Residential/CommercialStructures (Residential and Actual Total=Shops) M2 Based on estimates 631,055.95- Permanent 4 M2 prevailing- Semi-Permanent 45 M rates- Temporary

Other Fixed Assets: Total =- Front yard bamboo fence 13 HH 1741m 61,891.25- Farmland barbed wire 5 HH 71 ImfenceWaiting Sheds 11Garage 1 306,433.15Outpost 4Crops/Trees- Arable crops - M2

- Trees/Perennials 104 Number variable 1,079 trees 83,180.30Sub-Total 3,285,560.50Transitional allowance tocbver income loss for 26partially and severely- Based on Income per 48,270.50affected house cum shops and HH Income day x 7 dayspartially-affected independent per dayshopsSubsistence Allowance(severely-affected titled land,severely-affected shop HH 15,000 2 30,000.00owners with/without title tothe land)Inconvenience Allowance(severely-affected house HH 10,000owners with land title)

Financial Assistance(severely-affected settlers, de HH 15,000facto owners of agriculturalland, etc.)Rehabilitation Assistince(severely-affected PAPs who HH 15,000have to engage in a newincome activity)Land Preparation Assistarnce(marginally-affected de facto - M2 Variable -

owners of agricultural land)Disturbance Compensation - HH 15,000 -

(lessees)Rent Allowance (severely- - HH 1,000 -

affected house tenants) _

Material Transport Allowance HH 1,000 (for 50,000.00to Relocating PAPs fuel of


AMOUNT AMOUNT I

DESCRIPTION No. of UNIT RAsT QUANTITY Peso USDHHs WUNIT ~~~~~(Counterpart (LoanFund) Fund)

DPWVHtruck)

Sub-Total 128,270.50

Relocation Area (site Lumpdevelopment & access road) Sum

Extemal Monitoring and LumpPost- implementation SumpEvaluationFee of Independent Land Lump 100,000Appraiser Sum

Extemal Monitoring 2,000.00

TOTAL 3,513,831.00-

Management cost 6% 210,829.86Price contingencies 15% 527,074.65

GRAND TOTAL 4,251,735.50 2,000.00


CHAPTER 4. IMPLEMENTATION SCLIEDULE

4.1 Approval of the RAP

The RAP will be presented to DPWH and the World bank for approval in March 2002. Also,the salient points of the RAP will be discussed with officials of the affected municipalitiesand barangays in April. Copies of the RAP will be given them for posting in the municipaland barangay halls. Once approved by the Bank and the DPWH, the RAP will becomelegally enforceable. Finalization of the RAP and the compensation and other entitlements tobe given to PAPs will begin as soon as approval of the same by the DPWH and the WorldBank is obtained. The Municipal RAP Implementation Comnmittee (MPIC) in each affectedtown will assist the Sub-Engineering District in Malita implement the RAP. Technicalassistance, when needed by the MRIC, will be extended by the Regional DPWH Office andthe ELAPO.

4.2 Resettlement Implementation Activities

Following are the activities to be undertaken in connection with the implementation of theRAP. Said activities are in consonance with the DPWH Operational Franework on PublicParticipation and Consultation. (See Annex D for a copy of the Operational Framework onPubic Participation and Consultation).

4.2.1 MOU with LGU and Establishment of the MRIC

Prior to the commencement of stake-out and validation of impacts, a Memorandum ofUnderstanding (MOU) will be executed between the DPWH and all the municipalgovernments of areas traversed by the road project Among others, the MOU will facilitatethe formation of the MRIC in the Municipalities of Malalag, Sta. Maria and Malita. TheELAPO will help set up and orient the MRIC. The MOU is deemed important to get thecooperation of the LGUs in maintaining the cleared construction limit even after completionof the road project. (See Annex E for a copy of the MOU).

4.2.2 Training of the MRIC

Immediately following the formation of the MRIC, its members will be oriented on the workof the committee. Specifically, the MRIC members will be trained in RAP policies andimplementation procedures.

4.2.3 Establishment of Detailed Compensation Rates

Upon completion of their orientation seminar, the MRIC members will validate census ofPAPs and inventory of impacts, review and update, where necessary, the rates forcompensation payable for lost assets and incomes.

4.2.4 Conducting Public Information Campaign

With assistance from concemed LGUs of Malalag, Sta. Maria, the MRIC will call for publicmeetings. It will also assist the Sub-Engineering District develop a public information


The PAPs will be informed of the schedule of the validation work of the MRIC and will berequested to keep their documents that indicate ownership of assets ready when projectrepresentatives visit them.

4.2.5 Stake-out

A stake-out of the project corridor will be done in the course of the validation work of theMRIC to clearly mark the area required by the rod project.

4.2.6 Finalization of Compensation and Other Entitlement of PAPs

After the unit price have been updated, and following a visit to each PAP to validate theinventory of affected assets, the MRIC shall finalize entitlements and the total amount ofcompensation payable to each PAP. An Inventory of Affected Fixed Assets Form for eachPAP will be accomplished and signed by them to indicate their concurrence with theestimates of the affected assets, entitlements and compensation amounts. A copy of thesigned copy of the form will be given to the PAPs for their own reference. Any disagreementon the inventory details of compensation rates will be recorded and the PAP will be advisedon what legal options he/she/it may take based on the grievance redressal proceduresenunciated in the DPWH Resettlement Policy and the Policy Framework on PublicParticipation and Consultation.

4.2.7 Public Meeting

Upon completion of the compensation and entitlements estimates for all the PAPs, publicmeetings will be arranged in each barangay to inform the PAPs of the results of the validationof impacts and computation of compensation and other entitlements, other resettlementactivities, and the schedule of payment to PAPs.

4.2.8 Payment of Compensation and Other Entitlements

All payment of compensation will be done in a public place. The place, date and time of thecompensation payment will be announced in advance and barangay officials will be requestedto ensure that all PAPs within their administrative jurisdiction are informed.

4.2.9 Reorganization and Relocation

No reorganization or relocation will take place until the PAPs are paid their compensationand other entitlements as disclosed in the public meetings to be held for the purpose.

4.2.10 Handing Over the Site for Civil Works

Civil works may only begin at least after 1 month following the satisfactory completion ofRAP implementation and after a "No Objection Letter" is secured from the World Bank.

-'0


4.3 Monitoring and Supervision of RAP Implementation

The implementation of the RAP will be supervised by the EIAPO, with assistance from theProject TA. The EIAPO will also carryout internal monitoring of the implementation of theRAP and will provide periodic progress reports to the IBRD-PMO. The supervision andmonitoring of the implementation of the RAP will be done through the EIAPO counterpartstaff at the Regional level.

An independent agency will be contracted to carry out external monitoring and post-evaluation study.

Table 4.1: Schedule of Activities

Activities May 2002 June 2002 July 2002_ 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4

Submission of RAP for WB andDPWH approval x

MOU and formation of MRIC x

Validation of impacts and _ xfinalization of compensation

Vouchering and payment x x x

Public information x x x x x x

Monitoring by EIAPO x x x x x

Monitoring by external agent x x x x

Submission of compliancemonitoring reports to WB x

Sulop Junction.Malalag-Malita Road Section Resettlement Action Pan

CHAPTER 5. ORGANIZATIONAL SET-UP

The IBRD-PMO will exercise overall management and supervision of the implementation ofcivil works and of the RAP. The provisions and policies of this RAP will serve as the legalbasis for implementing the project

5.1 Institutions for Resettlement

5.1.1 DPWH

DPWH, through the IBRD-PMO, is overall responsible for implementing the project,including resettlement activities and land acquisition. The OBRD-PMO will ensure that fundare available for the successful implementation and completion of the RAP. In thisconnection, the office will facilitate and ensure payment for the hiring of the independentland appraiser and the external monitoring agency. The IBRD-PMO will be assisted by theEnvironmental Impact Assessment Project Office (EIAPO) of the Planning Service inproviding technical guidance and support in the implementation of the RAP.

5.1.2 Environmental Impact Assessment Project Office (EIAPO)

The ELAPO will provide technical guidance and support in the implementation of the RAPand will be responsible for the following resettlement activities.

1. Train the Municipal RAP Implementation Committee (MRIC) for it to be able toeffectively assist the Sub-Engineering District Office in implementing the RAP inaccordance with the Department's Resettlement Policy,

2. Recommend amendment of the RAP in coordination with concerned govermmentagencies and with the prior approval of the World bank in case problems are identifiedduring the internal and/or external monitoring of RAP implementation;

3. Spearhead the overall planning of the RAP;4. Assist, when needed, the MRIC in carrying out the verification of inventory, finalization

of entitlements, and assessment of final compensation;5. Submit compensation/assistance costs to the IBRD-PMO for approval by concerned

PDWH offices for the allocation of needed resources;6. Monitor the compensation payment process and the implementation of the RAP in all the

affected barangays; and7. Prepare periodic supervision and monitoring reports on RAP implementation for

submission to IBRD-PMO and the World Bank.

Successful implementation of the RAP will require close coordination between DPWH, othergovernment agencies, and local government units.

5.1.3 Municipal RAP Implementation Committee (NMIC)

As provided in the Operational Framework on Public Participation and Consultation, anMRIC for each affected municipality will be set up and will be composed of the following:

a The Municipal Mayorb. The DPWH District Engineer


c. The Barangay Captain in each affected communityd. Representative of the PAPs per barangay

The MRIC will have the following functions:

a. Assist the Sub-Engineering District in Malita in (i) establishing compensation prices forstructures, crops and other fixed assets; (ii) validating tenure status of land and structure;(iii) procedures of land recovery and allocation; and (iv) coordinating resettlementactivities with other agencies.

b. Assist the Sub-Engineering District Office in Malita in the conduct of public informationcampaign, public participation and consultation.

c. Inform PAPs of their entitlements in coordination with local government authorities.d. Assist the Sub-Engineering District Office in Malita in finalizing compensation and

entitlement forms for each PAP;e. Assist the Sub-Engineering District Office in Malita in the payment of compensation and

entitlements;f. Receive and act on complaints and other grievance of the PAPs as per DPWH

Resettlement Policy;g. Maintain record of all public meetings, grievances, and actions taken in the enforcement

of laws/ordinances regarding encroachment into the project road corridor.h. In coordination with concemed govemment authorities, assist in the enforcement of

laws/ordinances regarding encroachment into the project road corridor.

5.2 External Monitoring Agency

An independent agency specializing in the social sciences will be identified and contracted tocarry out the extemal monitoring of RAP implementation. This external monitoring agencywill also be contracted to conduct post-implementation evaluation of the RAP to assesswhether the objectives of the resettlement policy have been achieved. A TOR for extemalmonitoring and evaluation will be provided by the EIAPO. The extemal monitoring agentwill be required to submit to the IBRD-PMO and the World Bank a compliance monitoringreport upon completion of payment of compensation and entitlement to PAPs and a finalreport at the end of NR1MP Phase 1.


CHAPTER 6 ACTION PLAN FOR INDIGENOUS PEOPLES

6.1 Background

As mentioned in Chapter 2, 10 PAPs belonging to the Manobo Tribe were found in BarangayKidalapong, Malita. Five (5) PAPs households of Tagacaulo tribe were found, two (2) inPoblacion, one (1) in Kidalapong, Buhangin, and Tubalan, respectively. Since these ManoboPAPs and Tagacaulo have already been included among the other PAPs who would bereceiving compensation for their dwellings, as discussed in Chapters 2 and 3, the majorobjective of this Indigenous People Action Plan (lPAP) is to provide the basic frameworkwithin which resettlement activities for said PAPs would be undertaken.

Among the specific objectives of this IPAP are:

a. To briefly describe the socio-economic characteristics of the Manobo Tribe and Tagacaulo;b. To provide framework of compensation to the tribal PAPs for damages to their properties

in a manner equitable (i.e., similar to the other PAPs) and consonant to their culturalpractices;

c. To recommend additional assistance to the IP community and/or IP association that willhelp the Manobo and Tagacaulo tribe to improve their standard of living withoutundermining their cultural practices; and,

d. To provide an implementation schedule and monitoring plan to ensure their standard ofliving.

6.2 Provincial and Municipal Profile

6.2.1 Province of Davao del Sur

The early inhabitants of Davao del Sur were the Bagobo-Guinggas, the Bilaans, the Manobos,and other primeval tribes. The Manobos were the early inhabitants of Malita and Jose AbadSantos. These early settlers developed a rich culture which remained uninfluenced until theend of the 14zh century when the Muslim Malays from Java and Sumatra introduced the Arabicstrain into the life of the early Davaoefios. The Muslim tribes like the Maranaos andMaguindanao occupied certain places of Davao del Sur then. However, the originalinhabitants remained uncovered by the new faith. Christianity was introduced into theprovince after the colonization of the northern islands. Other tribes from the Visayas arrivedand settled in Davao del Sur at the turn of the 20'h century. As of 2000, Davao del Sur has atotal population of 724,370. Based on the data in 1990, Cebuano, Tagacaulo, B'laan, Mabonoare the major groups with population of 439,523, 51,086, 42,606, and 40478, respectively.The present teacher-pupil ratio under the elementary level is within the national standard ofone teacher per 40 pupils for SY 1994-1996. There are exceptional cases in the hinterbarangays of Malita, where transportation is the number of one problem.The performance of the province to hold elementary school children in school for the wholeyear was sustained with only 0.26 percent Drop Rate. In the secondary level, the projectedschool age population was 69,222, however, only 38,280 enrolled in 1994, or 55.30 percentparticipation rate. Among the factors that affect the pupils to stop from going to school areinaccessibility of schools from homes, the unstable peace and order, and the need for children


to work to help the family in generating additional income. Especially there are cases thatusually happen in the hinter barangays in Malita.The leading causes of mortality were heart disease, pneumonia, PTB, cancer, diarrhea,coronary artery disease, senility, and etc in 1996. Other causes leading mortality aside fromdisease were accident and arrest. Leading causes of infant mortality were pneumonias,septicemia, diarrhea, asphyxia, etc. The number of private hospitals and clinics are 3 in Malitain 1996.

6.2.2 Municipality of Malita

Malita became a municipality on January 1, 1921 by virtue of Executive Order No. 8.However, records show that Malita has already been in existence even prior to the arrival ofthe Americans in Davao. It is comprised of 30 barangays with a total land area of 51,259hectares which makes up about 13% of the province's total land area.

As of 2000, Malita had a population of 84,127 and a population density of 164 persons persquare kilometer. In 1995, the number of households and average household size were 16,512and 5.0, respectively. There are 34,000 Manobo estimated, and some 32,000 Tagacaulo inMalita.

Malita has 47 public elementary schools with 353 teachers and one (1) private elementaryschool with nine (9) teachers. The projected school age population in 1996 was 17,031,however, there were only 14,820 enrollees which were about 87% of the projection. Likewisein 1996, the municipality has five (5) public secondary schools and one (1) private high schoolwith a combined enrollment of 2,893.

Malita has many tourist attractions. Among which are the Malita Prawn Culture, the DemolocCaves (with about 50), Little Buguip which has caves and waterfalls while it takes 3 hourshorse riding; Indalugong Falls with water cascading from a high mountain, Kepay Caves ofhabitat of bats, and Banahaw Forest Reserve and Springs which is very ideal for camping.

6.3 General Socio-economic Characteristics of the Manobo and Tagacaulo Tribe

6.3.1 Sub-group

The United Manobo Tribe Farmers Multipurpose Cooperative (UMTFMC) has about 3,000member-Manobos which covers 13 of the 30 barangays of Malita, Davao Del Sur. It wasestablished in 1999 and is duly registered with the Cooperative Developtment Authority(CDA) and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). The objectives for theestablishment of the cooperative are to unite for peace and order, to keep their ethnic identity,and to improve their living standard through livelihood projects. There are a set of committeesunder the UMTFMC. In addition, they say that they have informal groups for women, theyouth, etc.

Malita United Tagacaulo Farmers Multi-purpose Cooperative (MUTFMC) with a set ofcommittees was also established in 1999 and registered under the Cooperative DevelopmentAuthority (CDA) and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). It has already 1001members. Tagacaulo has tribal council on ancestral domain.

4,)


6.3.2 Demography

Manobo

All the PAPs belonging to the Manobo Tribe are from Barangay Kidalapong, Malita. Theyused to inhabit the highlands of Malita and its adjacent municipalities. In the last decades,however, they were forced to settle in the lowlands along the roadsides to be more accessibleto water, education, and other basic services.

In 1995, Barangay Kidalapong had a population of 1,629 people and 318 households. Table6.1 shows the composition of PAPs households. The average number of members perhousehold is five (5) and six (6) of the households have 5 to 8 members. Minimum number ofmembers per household is 3 and maximum is 13.

Table 6-1 Manobo PAPs Household Composition

. . . : - . . . . :: ~~~No. of Members by Sex - ..-Name of PAPs Respondent No:. N. f e y S6usehold Size,

. .,Male, Female

Anecita ECOS 6006 5 3 8Elmira ECOS 6009 1 4 5Elinda MAGUYA 6010 6 6 12Reden CABIGAS 6011 1 2 3Melicio 6012 1 2 3GUMALLAWE

Virgilio MACAMPAO 6013 2 2 4Faustino MAGUYA 6014 3 2 5Lito MACAMPAO 6015 3 2 5Ambrosio MAGUYA 6020 1 2Norma PADO 6021 3 2 5Total 26 27 53

Table 6-2 shows population distribution of PAPs by age. 40 out of 53 PAPs are within the 0to 30 age range. There is only on person over age 50, a 90-year old lady. It can therefore beconcluded that the PAPs are generally young.

Table 6-2 Population of PAPs by Age and Sex

S . :; Age-.______ 0-10 11-20 .21-30 3-40 41-50 51-6 61-70 71-80 80< Total

Male 9 10 1 4 3 0 0 0 0 27Female 6 9 5 5 0 0 0 0 1 26Total [ 15 19 6 9 3 0 l 0 0 1 53l


Tagacaulo

The total number of PAPs of Tagacaulo tribe is 23, and the average no. of members perhousehold is 4.4. Minimum no. of members per household is 3, while maximum is 7. (Seetable 6-3.) Table 6-4 shows population distribution of Tagacaulo PAPs by age. The oldest is 55years old, and the youngest is 8 years old. The largest no. of population is within 11-20 range.

Table 6-3 Tagacaulo PAPs Household Composition

Name of PAPs of Respondent. No. of member by Sex No. of HH

Tagacaulo No. SizeMale Female

Adelaida Manggaga 6002 3 2 5Lucia Lumayas 6003 2 2 4Villozo Josue 6007 1 2 3Carmencita Cawa 6016 3 3 6Discoro Odeno 6029 3 1 4Total 12 10 22

Table 6-4 Tagacaulo Population of PAPs by Age and Sex

PAPs -_Age _,__

. . .0-10 - 11- :21- 31- 41- 51- 61- 71- 80 < Total20 30. 40 50 60 70 80.

Male 1 3 4 1 3 2 0 0 0 14

Female 2 3 0 1 2 0 0 0 0 8Total 3 6 4 | 2 5 1 2 0 0 0 22

6.3.3 Livelihood Activities and Sources of Income

Manobo

The economic base of the areas is agriculture. Traditional farming is the dominant system used,such as mix cropping and stock raising. Major food crops are corn, banana, root crops, legumes,vegetables, native mango, Cebu Mango, coconuts, which serve for source of cash income andhome consumption. They raise goats, hogs, and cattle for cash income, while chicken areraised for home consumption. Copra and charcoal made from coconuts shell are importantagricultural industry. They sell their products in the local market in the town proper of Malita.There is no irrigated land and rice cultivated.Some of them work in urban area as housekeepers. They own their land or occupy with permitalthough there were no PAPs who have proof of ownership or legal justification for occupation.No tenancy as a primary occupation is reported among PAPs household.


Tagacaulo

Generally, traditional farming is the primary occupation, however, as to Tagacaulo PAPs,primary occupation of 3 PAPs households is business occupation (Sari-sari store) in theirresidential area. The primary occupation of the other PAPs households is farming.

6.3.4 Income and Expenditures

ManoboThe annual income of the PAPs were between PhP9500 to PhP35000 based on publicconsultation meeting on May 3, 2002, and the annual expenditure is in the same range. Most ofthem earn PhP10,000 per year. From this result, rate of self-subsistence is high, that is to say,they supply their needs by themselves from the community as well as through exchange at thelocal market and through local govermnent.

TagacauloThe annual income is between PhP 15,000 to PhP 228,000, and annual expenditure is betweenPhP 14,600 to PhP 24,000 based on the survey conducted on January 2001.

6.3.5 Education

ManoboThere are 14 children of school age in the elementary level. There are only one (1) high schoolstudents, although six (6) young peoples are of school age for high school level based on ourRAP survey.

TagacauloThere are three (3) children of school age in the elementary level. There is only one child ofhigh school student.Regarding to the last educational attainment, most of the parents of both tribal PAPs leftelementary school before graduation or graduated from elementary school. Few people enteredhigh school.

6.3.6 Health Nutrition and Sanitation

There are no empirical data specific to indigenous peoples, however it is said that they sufferfrom tuberculosis, malnourish, waterborne, and airbome disease or other disease of highmorbidity in the province.

Regarding water source, Manobo PAPs acquire water from artesian or pump wells, while someof Tagacaulo PAPs from river, spring, and dug well.Regarding toilet facilities, the both PAPs use open pit or antipolo type, which are no sealed bywater.

There is a barangay health center in each barangay, where some medicine and some kinds ofcheck-up are available.


6.4 Formal and Traditional Socio-economic Structures

The barangay government represents the formal socio-political structure. It is headed byBarangay Captain as the chief executive and the Barangay Council as the legislative. There areset of officers, and have regular meeting (e.g. monthly) meetings. The barangay governmentalso has its judiciary, made up of selected members of the community, which handles minorcivil and criminal cases.

They have more than one traditional leader in one barangay, mostly they are elders, who arecalled upon to over the resolution of conflict and the performance of rituals. Thus, it may beinferred that the informal/traditional leaders do not lord over the specific sub-area within thebarangay. They have also informal group of women and youth, according to them. Thetraditional leaders and formal leaders play their roles in a cooperative manner. It is said that thetribal peoples have fine and friendly relationship with other tribes in Malita. The Manobo tribeis originated in Malita have no socio-economic relationship Manobos in other provinces.

Regarding traditional practices, Horse Fighting is practiced by the both Tagacaulo and Manobo,respectively, which is rare and unusual practice in the world, however, most of thetraditions/customs seem to have been integrated into the Christian customs, since theyconverted to Christianity after World War II.

6.5 Impacts of the Project on the Indigenous People Along the Road Corridor

ManoboBased on the information gathered in January, 2001, all PAPS of Manobo counted wereresidents of Brgy. Kidalapong. The results of the RAP survey show that ten (10) Monobo willbe affected by the project. Fence of nine (9) out of ten (10) PAPs households will be affected,therefore the nine (9) have no need to relocate, since their houses are not affected. One out often (10) PAPs household is severely affected, that is to say, their houses are affected andresidual area is not viable.Regarding relocation, however, the PAP household has space in backyard, therefore they cansettle their relocation just to move backward, without finding any land to relocate. Table 6-5shows the affected area and severity of the impact on the property of Manobo tribe.


Table 6-5 Affected Area and Severity of the Impact (Manobo)

Name of PAPs of f Respondent I Affected Area Degree ofManobo Tribe No. SeverityAnecita ECOS 6006 Floorl2.21 ? Severe*Elmira ECOS 6009 15m Fence MarginalErlinda MAGUYA 6010 7m Fence MarginalReden CABIGAS 6011 15m Fence MarginalMelicio 6012 20m Fence MarginalGUMALLAWEVirgilio 6013 10m Fence MarginalMACAMPAOFaustino MAGUYA 6014 8m Fence MarginalLito MACAMPAO 6015 15m Fence MarginalAmbrosio MAGUYA 6020 12m Fence MarginalNorma PADO 6021 10m Fence MarginalTotal Floor 12.21 rn

Fence 112m'They can reorganize or relocate by moving backward space of the land they currently occupy.

Tagacaulo

Based on the information gathered in January, 2001, the results of the Tagacaulo RAPs showthat five (5) Monobo will be affected by the project. Among four (4) out of five (5) PAPshousehold, will be severely affected, however all PAPs have no need to relocate to other place,since they can re-organize or relocate to the backward, or adjacent spaces. Three (3) residentialstructures cum shops out are affected among the five (5). Table 6-5 shows the affected areaand severity of the impact on the property of Tagacaulo PAPs households.

Table 6-6 Affected Area and Severity of the Impact (Tagacaulo)

Name of PAPs. . Respondent Affected Area D'gree.of-.No. ; ; _- _- _;;-- S_; _ _ _X S r t

Adelaida Manggaga 6002 Floorl6 mr SevereLucia Lumayas 6003 Floorl8 mr SevereVillozo Josue 6007 Floor43 m SevereCarmencita Cawa 6016 Floorl2 n? SevereDiscoro Odeno 6029 Floor5 mTotal Floor 94 n

6.6 Resettlement Package

The resettlement package proposed for the 10 Manobo PAPs households and five (5)Tagacaulo PAPs households is based on the principle of the replacement cost. Nocompensation will be paid to indigenous cultural communities or representative organizations,

an


since the relocation to the other place is not needed, or right to stay in the same lot is securedbased on the survey on January 2001.

The right of IPs in ancestral domain is protected in Republic Act 8371 in the Philippines.Tagacaulo holds CADC in hinterland Malita, and Manobo is now going to apply for that.Actually, the both Manobo and Tagacaulo PAPs identified in the survey live outsides theCertified Ancestral Domain Claim (CADC).

Taking the situation into consideration, however, we propose that additional resource orfinancial assistance to indigenous cultural communities is needless, because of no damage tocommunity lands and/or resource, utilized by them, although indigenous peoples' rights shouldbe respected, and secured.

In the consideration of the abovementioned, the followings are proposed to make up theresettlement package for the Manobo and Tagacaulo tribes.

1. Compensation

a. Compensation to PAPs.

The compensation for the PAPs of Manobo and Tagacaulo tribes is basically on theprinciple of replacement cost for damaged assets to the household units, since the lands andstructures are owned by individual households and the base of life like production andconsumption is the household. Moreover, relocation to other place will not be involved,since identified PAPs can move to backyard or adjacent place, it means other communallands/resource will not be affected.

b. Compensation to the Representative Organization

No compensation to the Indigenous People Organization is involved, because of no damageto common property: burial ground, source of water, pasture, forest, worship area, place forhorse fighting and so on.

2. Implementation Schedule

a. Personnel of the civil works contractor, the Supervising Engineer, the DPWH Regional andDistrict Offices, the IBRD-PMO, and the ELWPO must be provided adequate orientation onthe IPs. These personnel must, at all times, observe the rules and regulations and must besensitive to the customs and views of the tribal people.

b. A ritual that is meant to dramatize the acceptance by project personnel of the ways andbeliefs of the Manobo and Tagacaulo residents, including appeasing the spirits of the deadand ancestors of the indigenous population, will be performed soonest and in accordancewith the local customs.

c. Implementation procedure and schedule is the same with them written in Chapter 4,however, institution for resettlement such as DPWH, and MRIC should have a closecoordination with National Commission on Indigenous Peoples (NCIP).

fin


3. Monitoring Plan

As mentioned in Chapter 4, the EIAPO will carry out internal monitoring of theimplementation, and an independent agency will be contracted to carry out post-evaluationstudy as an external monitoring.

In addition, MRIC has function/responsibility of on-going monitoring. MRIC is composedof the Municipal Mayor, the DPWH District Engineer, the Barangay Captain in eachaffected community, and representatives of the PAPs per barangay. Through theparticipation of stakeholders, it aims to secure accountability, acceptability of the project,and effective feedback.

For the indigenous peoples, free and prior informed consent is to be secured in this on-going process, particularly for finalizing entitlements and the total amount of compensationpayable to each indigenous people.To enhance it, MRIC is required to have a close coordination with National Commissionon Indigenous Peoples (NCIP).

ANNEX A

LIST OF PUBLIC MEETING HELD

Annex A

List of Public Meetings

1. Prior to the conduct of the inventory of affected assets and the census/socio-economic

survey of PAPs, an orientation and coordination meeting was held at the Municipal Hall of

Malalag in the morning of 8 January 2001. It'was attended by 20 municipal and barangay

officials, including DPWH personnel and consultants from the Katahira and Engineers

International. The meeting was presided over by the Municipal Mayor.

2. Another orientation and coordination meeting was held at the Municipal Hall of Sta. Maria

in the afternoon of 8 January 2001. It was attended by 12 municipal and barangay officials,

including DPWH personnel and consultants from the Katahira & Engineers International.

The Municipal Assessor presided over the meeting.

3. Another orientation and coordination meeting was held at the Municipal Hall of Malita in

the morning of 9 January 2001. It was attended by 12 municipal and barangay officials,including DPWH personnel and consultants from the Katahira & Engineers International.

The President of the Association of Barangay Captains of Malita presided over the

meeting.

4. A meeting with representative of affected Manobo Tribe households in Malita was held at

the Sub-Engineering District Office in Malita on 20 February 2001 on the initiative of the

consultants from the Katahira & Engineers International. Said meeting was attended by

13 people, which included DPWH personnel. The objectives of meeting were to inform

the affected Manobos about the project and the likely impact the road project would have

on them, to find out more about the life and practices of the tribe, and to determine their

places of origin. The meeting was presided over by the Chief of the Planning Section of

the local DPWH office.

5. Another consultation meeting with the affected Manobo and Tagacaulo tribes was held at

the Sub-Engineering District Office in Malita on May 3, 2002 on the initiative of the

consultants from the Katahira & Engineers International. Said meeting was attended by

around 30 people, which included DPWH personnel.

1

D 4s. OolT vt for/cat'4 to34 - 302 _k

.\fll'RFYES OP FF , TH T\2 ¢ 7 rG or .. r -r-m snw u-s vni Hi' G:u rr:pi. i*tt (I.P'u) wni-i iuw i. Alh 421-(AKR ..O.$LYT, I;f,.;-ai .sE.t.<'r

41~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~:

OF Nt.V_ALAL-A(JP.U. E \ PRA *AL"-AST M\, . It;- , Q WHl AT- CLA AINOFF , BtTrHX 'L' Y, 3\. t . O r- nA"VAO) DhS& .:.

i flC1lV A4 .se¢bi * l;4Mr4kv.,tt vio. i.t ¢ -, t.''. -'-t r' *'- -,' i- ,- l, 18 :t p P

Eugr. I-arete aru,c,td hims d; ad th'i L) 'Wi 1:Jf ki hii' w.ctr zLith.,I.' Kv;J&NVl .fla.t*1l . X-+ c... t-'~ Cir ' .5Sm.l (Wrts.x >AZ., Cuktn ' ; '='i' Y ]r f+ -' I ,- -fGx >,rlCAoffi,C, su. Dolly X.'eor:a. Mm. Jan into .' :. z,vnaihanti fr1om KAiAi.ITR,.

iVii. i t- a V&yxA-trrw d.. ^ -4 4X *-<- ..A 4-l *-. b. ;r' V -.X! ;>2.sti; Sliw,e thevtt are -.5:dzttlt;z:xt( w}nir,.cinlnAhl 13i .9:L [i!'lR4# _] t i. '-isc'oslllg.tation a-and gformAaO2C- s; i.ioro.J .cvi!.^ >!s m: r;: '.:. i 't :tnwe Tore not able to) t4 dutinL t,he 5i'survev&4uo'vzt- 1 Aid:o -: l-c;' i.t itthere &e some darifiti-^ns or reemtions caO tt; Ut -Lt f'-r nf 1i 1;ftpc?;fA

projoatuawas not dimcu-s.

*4e have nou pIz. or s.ja x whe toi ;- L ...-.i' - -x• .xfromn the ip's.

that hiv aea ig wid4ni thf rzad--ighn .Aay& di-1 : ' 8:-

it was isnUoknd thw. haVp '--e d.amasd kh ,t , a .. -t .. . -*-t'ill he-,-rrunt erir.n ia1-i , :;:t.4i;asiss,. lf 4s b4% fD i l-c I- UX o *7 * -{ I. ;-- -s

atenalu pa eoinp'satateion 'I'?,' tt- DPWŽ1tnA.;-nlt-.vrs:i>;7. i .e *-. @- -, ;..J1W 1Ž-'e j4V a bt' 1 .-z.rn .s. -t- a a- st. . -. .p ,. -r .

Mm. 34waskcd if w- wi ll b- np*'4%ni.i'7,3asaal oiF 'jbi a'. - -w .

a h';-i&hf io,-to he aisTo;red

Anwe: ,'t i�g of' big hel,

Ms.. Sr t,i xpjainid .fiwil-ter diaS the cornpaniOio is s6vi!i..*&t;o vo oXn «th~tTh aof ttheo*tj*ind At ;s, ithc' rpese of the goC annSS ^lCt to he4p *ht &.vc:, . pcsonsa dii t 1k portioot&- tPe laA d which wes idXu:tc, sntd oX c.u va'u s;inc

ehody are awarev that -it is hithin the roadl.igt of "-i apnd it ; iheefere.

owned by the governmet of the Philippines.2~~~~~~~~~~~~c h

VIIs. Jarat aU4 s Rgiffatt 9[ '1 .; ''. .J\ *k:t(, I t1

their presgnftl Iouavyr --. .Ytl h'Ftt ;! tiiv: re&< : ;r , ! :N4 r nrij.4,;4d

palca.

4'Xn'tsv:er NLrt,'. '3fl,grl;j 8 ct'3i &,, 2 ;d tb;.xt ;.i@ c,ijn.i n ; ;lt ,:urnf'iAl 'in'.L;utt;itnct'us

NISlari,

schbcasy, water M,id at tou: -&il{, sl [Ku a -Žce of o s ot

Qiwsvtel: ,,m -:me hi vhqix m> i ..: r 0z asus 4-C. !t t..}tr .t1�jsJ;sile,t

4rtcoo;gX!ma .t Vh;d:.:<wi, tvit o M~el' Zn A<;3 cet' t.i'-. f t-. .;:.k ar. n lt

Am¢Xwver: S'i f,zjrj, ,-s;- d,>e t .I' .£ '1¢.i> ^ J I " '4 C''

Qusrion: DD yoti? np pit liv,5torR rait' i sf.Q;:o, :'r .' -, iy of

AQtwtir: No, but X h ee sma±l-Aiaule ne.f fa! ,y

Ansver: Scvsirtie KF U1t" 2, tUs ito vtkvri i,ir r,.>.-:.~ >trl. .- ;:;.e.:^ a r i~ Ot

div ciood, whs ad th1c v;licy d Dg ;thr;pc.xJ r uVr. tl ua-:

Anciwrr:XVX 'lOWSJ t>; coe (C"' Wijfl, '¼.: ,.'A~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Mg\. Jnra asked wIhei lie theolught tesir tdttrtni u

Qcaction: Not adcTC duc so' 4O'Ji mcomc.

Ans. wer: aTk if othro: voe ib orbsizant iion of? i

Answer: oes, thty thear ark sr1afl-witl ntuyld 2x-_i-',TFC-. ; F;j nly

3

M{r. Cutzr%c th. njeeid.sr 2 4ut ?vf iok.; ' - . !i 4ith

Dttaan. A telw IN' .c Al.:-. veiv .r*,k .tw';c.-n t&

ditknercnt £ribea w. , & ;zttatz! 2i7$il &nb Ihey : iat'e ,'-," ; '.:.,d&. ass%imri.

Ms. Jirmi aked if if .ETh .M tIbC 'All , -JYUt lt .l1d i.bu .d

(Quetiou: \W2at is thot pC•i{i:' wlet QT .he £f'Ri1AP'}N;X.J .:

Nls. U>.ti4so1vvedtx s'i.;R'4't,:', A*'&f:j.'!, l: . :^ -:t.t:t J

develeOponmiit3 cff if lP s.

vL-. Ota 4s4ld # fill: I b.5L ,tb; fw,puiation c>< Žt i' .

?vfr. Cuutnc answz.e-d zEat trrc an cowetuc i2-; 'I ..- e

Ma. Velora aAiA if Ps t. ;. L 2 ;S, ' - C

profile of t¾ of4aate L,:&

Mr. Cwucnmn wid, ycti, erPS1 .4zxe.a vaiiable.

Nf'r. C)asake not thy ;X'.& ef d.iest; O-sbc;b:0 ' .1,e

,vAr. L_uetnze &2:+ 3a1\ U)a4 .j~ ~t9,,,(l Vi>itlONti; l.4 1 e -w,,.......................>r, .- I i.. Z .

Secretary Anpira wc'PŽd PMCC9QO.OO. 71Thy tw.scVi ', . 4 Yb ttJ s, rips

such as mangos. They zr't- atreeady plsctK ' i 'j;i'fl!¼r 'cteIP's really am vtiy po x, thwiy ate flon tUV -m *,.. C.;.4;% .Malt. Alathogh stey Lw tew-ir oiwed k imtu N '- s

depreed isiti.m, sAuh r'u: v MjwsCbiIli:, r,; 't\ *'r W9 . fYo'* , andfuvr fsrtntlia soin"A .ur,ntsyr ietnorr> ian,A ,t. : .A '1 &vr IC. [*4,6.

a betr way o(Jlifi and ;hni &C@Ae M o hto a bt .iA

Mir. Ota askcd, aside frc-nm hig[h valued crcup. .°' " ::. C, {jl;1 2nbclikc fiosga and other.

Mr. Cuente said yes;

Msmt SW sid yeCs, it iasi province Wide, h. aUe< inl-2 ,;C';) dn4 j4 fl, Wid hV I DS avaoM9w,§t like Don Mneli0no, Jose Abed Sattr anm d 'mheA,id

IvIs. iii. asls.u ift wlunt taalvbldvsital Unjks i-tic udivx Ur•daAa.ttn j4) Ijc Uxuittd

Mmaoco -tribe of aita.

mrW thi N1anot<o tibN in NMdiT. Waaa tL] 'wdy c ell sargniztxsrogrup Maa the pitwl. Andn; V'r tfhc other rrOr&i>,5!jt3 fb7rahvili orgazationlis still under prtocss.

Ms. J=ar ,t..> ¢A;5.ske it'r,s WVJz 3tafl tutv;u .s.&uric4...... :s' :2CAVpCTflIiV oras>Srl. .....n i

associion?

Mr. ornt ws ogiai 't caoper 'i and thaasso'iation.

Mr. Ota askod if vŽrt&a2tt< . M,,a* nco trit'e.'

Mr. Cueinc ha±wweU t9t in the rnnku, 'r 4 s"hi.- - NL \ika, Eon

Mircelino, Jost AbL SwS $ s io i- Davao dt,. S-wt

Mre. Ota asked, if {'t:tae art {!,,y ^.Aicr fedcReiUf>; 4V!,2:-;t.' ?r %:x ;2&a±zS jt$ta,n

MN. fara explaine-d that the grcup i3 Cryiis - .k4:-.:¢X:t., I-Al dh,,, r;rr.4cen1,, il, is

still on plan.

Mr. Qua asked, if the $roup iwv I I other a ffb-aJ. ti':?

M. Cun sai thz5 krW Žrzarxtsinn was MttTh; tClt &- Nstic'-rA Corulln&%ilion

of Indigenaous ? (NCI9Y

Mrt. k tlAL3 ±L * . I - ititc

Mr. Cume said yce.

Ms. J=ar a;ked, aside !Žclm &i (to LM¶ -. .1 is Tcem a&.' z';b.ijxnfzodelder?

W Cucmo s-ad yts, AI I "Lj - .-m T. .

MsU. Jam 3ased, da&oit d executioa of pc'v tt he,: 8 qv&& t•n 2r, dec tactol

presidont siac.- twrv were tibal chioftin ox t.i::, &a..i'; : •tI tdivc.r -ZUp4akllvwith regads to problcm or any other iiors

Mr. Cuewe azwwtred tRat the Wr o wene bosd '.~i . w'i- : tt;&A tes of lthe

onjaization c baNsat up:r thw decision if tL ¾n}cd & diteci.'i;. I ise; axe

problems encauntercd it bemtwrn, like for & t !va40b3h; wt'ibn, tht fbist tosettle is the triba. chieftain, if te1ic eufia n ear§ >t P'. prtAA Le, chif ,eftnwill endforsd it to the basxigay officias3 axdif th:; .' :ouncil canrot sohaM

or make any arnicale settlemcnt th baruagay cI will ertdorsod the unolvedproblem to ile chaimnw of the asociation anti with the d wbc'd of diiectors. Theywill now have diw final dcciskad/recoxrmendain of dte promblms wethor, it is tobe sulbmitted for the legal pocess of the govnrwuownt.

5

MY. Cu*ur,c vzviA- t ; 2aRe. 1^ a tr&e iEen , v, X.c uvw :t J cosz i r thernanoho tiei, , jwuk tnCollnuterz>i, , ')QPIAS mi . tC< txiI4fl of theasgoatculUn±

'Mr. CI sedIij.:i.~-Mr . aAcZ,: v4bv4 ii",&iv cz ¢. l > o-, {7At03)it Q r,, 4 : i' 24 /3l Ii ii? '9

Mr. 1c4n Qa'd >i

Stan~~~~~

Mr. V1 a sked', tflbz'.4 it tO ,3LiI'Jdl$ (A tEI¶ >2 '1. 5 i. 1< ' f :;'tt- £4; '

,start t)IU1UUfl4 JzJtsi ]: otkng siz-, xI *

oi6anizoSd.

Mr. CuleIf wW I t C)st f tafD v X&C1 VS$xar , xvi.2:h ? . *A. t! t(&VS 11wcorgarnzatiol wVasu cn fMm in it&is offiui ce¢ in Aig4 ta.

Ms. Jars asiS;. ,>f9 ;,oi; ,fth IpJ ',xtl,rAi;*ta to ht2l?, .. ............. ^ - ......o, .<STnbe.

MIT. L,UlTliuI fl13a;I;isVd : ,;c t.G........... &~-rv:?i. &vl.s.X* z , 2 - fli....... ...... .i it.e, ,t uX; lte

association, tWiny aThiid- d ;7z Mr si ro an, tti 4 i;7 C iOf* hw,zd

Mr. Ota askd if Ile wisa m s. v4cty,fmt- y Vs ;0. :

Mr. Cuern said na, buat soenr l ., vt $Jturi , , E4i'l4m; Aww; kit L theromoat/mountairiot g artla in Mfalita.

The groap deci-de to go aitd 5 iit the Ltn,' -.ip.. ,4n,K ' : ; lrg!iL3 to

got seme dzua and tkorte £ilXuItirX lI abtnit thulr Ax r: m

Msi. Velorta asked if thare wert other pcbikat.- ;'ta U:, . l >c tjA.. 2&41 ofrods Is the g.rnpw iLltYing toA marfov out in iPi .tc- . C )stf.i . :-

Cnberod: Yes, but there in one (1) {ljt& ' w n & .ttjt i an theJayto survy.

'EiifiD tig ig,vswoert.4 'tilt wAas not i'.t>lu.din c list of in<znborv aice

iiHictt survey no onc can give data, it wa& 2lxc-aJy dir a,alttd, bt liowcvcr we

Ms. Veloriaordermd to get the data and mncMc it .n liar; aspxnduls-hcct.

The gromup to the consltant decided to stribcua OLml qw4 '!tionnacm;s gl tpua4- tbr,to be awwed by the* TP's pesent.

6

complcted?

Engr. Lumogdi;,.d .t.' tiut fle as kcv 'a4; . t';, 'k'".' 2 ?.d 4ry bulding

Enr,. Dal t:jCte4i tj i5 LtCI pledge of

Uindta'inp mI 5v - ;. b tb- ow l neh r oifts

Enwr.l ,e uI&:, ; d&?4 rvP .tlii seLrt3 i ci dt; isp, s; 4, 43tio plr 1."t, theaffected tall.y WObid ol: r1tP.,!t.,i b rnovu M .t, *`t &-1m

ca shclotiA FACJ t thett4 2. > ')TWHt'afke qUCfi.1.1? 1. Ii: C

Pv1st VekcI 4 .s u~dL &., 1- - f wkit •~ L~r.z&

Mr. Cwmu adldfx': ill-lb-1 zt,-4*.J~ ; i!2 g

cash wif Lmctbe ras uv& ftu bo' W thatLs ,e ~ iii tUtfl.

CROWly dCt'. Wi,;y '. S 1tli5 TYXA;.0¶.".,;.'' ::i w !&dr, ic .Puzilyic

bulldozed?§

M$s. Jdar esptt|& td thu§ w'ithinscv ,' tt,0 4y2 tn.', tos,-- 4 t"7 '&X pyi'f5rwn.- tife

Mt, Ctwenv, add&ih&iv mh>, v:,;A>f :trt.e-e yeuii:$ ....&............ i -'. P f'".'.L; . At.' >['

ngr. Larc>t:in1Kttm.:'v lCe blo4y tha.t the Wc4trec1, kA a. Žtc - .w :£ >. 0 >)v<'&>t a..t ŽX:'•kn,

BROW, thaft> why¢ uthiA i;w':ting Wa r'mt.ds p'';'8$f ,Ae ''t.zK i:cr.s ':clarifivations. A.ffeo;tf&i.iUe wfll win L iw "t C'' v. af kreceiving tlhe pyzecd scV fvx they can 13w &''x4 ifl' ' ari.i:y. $isiethey were, already wel! .nIbrmeidring ti- t,, ; : 1%.'yt fit'r¶2W 'WVnow prepaed to 1o Av4flj S Iranfrsrcd t> i2: if '.';

Is there oehta qctiri -.h Il4i-ifk4;tius?

Thcre is none.

Engr. Larete adjoumii Ihe ll r meet-n and e .x..iAl ti.k :Y>A t.,i i.c:P pctfnt.

( -. .v

ALLEN E. DAU.GD1Q' AYtZl EVV, )t: /Rtecorder -D

C . _ A~~~t-<jbcizii, S&Aion

NOTIE AN i>:: tot

7

ANNEX B

FINAL VALIDATED LIST OF PAPs

Annex B

Final Validated Lists of PAPs

Severity of Type ofImpact Impact

Municipality of Sta Maria

1. Ellivira, Jose Marginal Residential2. Adto-on, Ricardo Marginal Res/Com3. Guillen, Nieves Marginal Residential4. Vismanus, Francisca Severe Res/Com5. Canete, Carlito Marginal Residential6. Lamoste, Babeth Severe Res/Com7. Estender, Mauro Severe Residential8. Bautista, Ponciana Severe Reidential9. Cabato, Esmeralda Marginal Res/Com10. Saplagio, Apolonio Severe Commercial11. Cabanda, Denvilita Marginal Residential12. Saragena, Moreta Severe Res/Com13. Patema, Gading Severe Res/Com

Municipality of Malita

1. Karim, Jure Marginal Extension2. Manggaga, Adelaida Severe Residential3. Lumayas, Lucia Severe Residential4. Villozo,Josue Severe Res/Comm5. Guallawe, Melicio Marginal Fence6. Macampao, Virgilio Marginal Fence7. Ortiza, Delia Mesias Severe Res/Comm8. Ortiza, Delia Marginal Commercial9. Solitana, Alfredo Marginal Fence10. Cabigas, Reden Marginal Fence11. Maguya, Erlinda Marginal Fence12. Ecos, Elmira Marginal Fence13. Ecos, Aniceta Severe Residential14. Macampao, Lito Marginal Fence15. Macampao, Madino Severe Waiting Shed16. Maguya, Faustino Marginal Fence17. Gonzaga, Agustino Severe Residential18. Doromal, Jose Severe Waiting Shed19. Pedo, Norma Marginal Fence20. Maguya, Ambrosio Marginal Fence21. Sapong, Milagros Marginal Res/Comm22. Mamolo, Isabelo Marginal Res/Comm23. Cinco, Rogelio Marginal Garage24. Lumayas, Nicasio Marginal Residential25. Talingting, Leoncio Severe Waiting Shed

26. Logronio, Flordeliza Severe Fence27. Florentino, Roy Marginal Res/Comm28. Asamudin, Gina Marginal Res/Comm29. Garedo, Meddy Marginal Fence30. Cawa, Carmencita Severe Residential31. Balawag, Olimpio Marginal Residential32. Pantajo, Hermedes Severe Residential33. Colano, Myrna Severe Residential34. Sanam, Imelda Severe Res/Comm35. Tabanao, Jovito Marginal Residential36. Mansigin, Saturnine Marginal Residential37. Mamulawan, Mercy Severe Residential38. Okay, Boy Severe Residential39. Odeno, Dioscoro Marginal Res/Comm40. Cinco, Rogelio Marginal Residential

Municipality of Malalag

1. Camia, Cresencia Severe Res/Comm2. Gomez, Claudio Marginal Fence3. Heiral, Romeo Severe Residential4. Baron, Alfredo Marginal Fence5. Campanero, Patrocinia Severe Residential6. Silva, Susan Marginal Res/Com7. Arellano, Antonina Marginal Commercial8. Pono, Eliakim Marginal Fence9. Cenon, Oscares Marginal Fence10. Aranaz, Pacencia Marginal Res/Comm11. Caraquel, Albina Marginal Fence12. Camcamo, Angelina Marginal Res/Comm13. Arizo, Melvin Severe Res/Comm14. Ellorimo, Aniceta Marginal Res/Comm15. Alcoseba, Ireneo Marginal Residential16. Camasura, Jenoviva Severe Commercial17. Cabonita, Armando Severe Res/Comm


ANNEX C

MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING(Sample)


Annex C

MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING(Sample)

DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS AND HIGHWAYS(DPWH)

and

MUNICIPAL GOVERNMENTS OF MALALAG, STA. MARIA

and

MALITA

I


MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING

KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS:

This MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING, made and executed this dayof November 2001 in Davao del Sur, Philippines, by and between:

The Department of Public Works and Highways, a government agency existingunder the laws of the Republic of the Philippines, with main office at Bonifacio Drive, PortArea, Metro Manila, and represented by its Director for Region XI, _ herein referred toas the "DPWH";

and

The Municipal Governments of Malalag, Sta. Maria and Malita, all in theProvince of Davao del Sur Region XI, and represented by their respective Mayors, hereinreferred to as the "LGU's".

WITNESSETH THAT

WHEREAS, the DPWH is one uf the major agencies responsible for the planned andsound development of the infrastucture system in the country;

WHEREAS, the LGUs are committed to protect and safeguard the interest of theirconstituents;

WHEREAS, as a way of ensuring the success of the various development programsof the government, all concerned public and private organizations and institutions must striveto work closely together in policy and program formulation and implementation;

WHEREAS, the National Government, through the DPWH and with financialsupport from the World Bank, will undertake the National Roads Improvement andManagement Program (NRRIP) in three phases over a nine year period;

WHEREAS, the overall objective of the NRIMP is to achieve effective managementand financing of the national road network, the upgrading of this road network to all-weatherstandards, and the preservation of the same to sustainable opemting conditions;

WHEREAS, the Land Acquisition, Resettlement and Rehabilitation PolicyFramework (to be referred hereinafter as the Resettlement Policy) of DPWH requires that, inthe design and implementation of NRIMP projects, all efforts must be exercised to ensurethat:

a) adverse social and physical impacts are avoided, minimized and/or mitigated;b) everybody, including project-affected (PAPs), will benefit from the projects;


c) PAPs are provided with sufficient compensation and assistance for lost assetswhich will assist them to improve or at least maintain their pre-project standardof living; and

d) Project stakeholders (which include PAPs) are consulted regarding the project'design, implementation and operation;

WHEREAS, the Operational Framework for Public Participation and Consultation ofDPWH defines Participation as an active and continuous process of interaction among aproject's stakeholders, including the communities adversely and/or positively affected,national and local government instrumentalities, civil society and international aid agencies;

WHEREAS, the term Participation as used by DPWH encompasses informationexchange (i.e., dissemination and consultation) and varying forms of decision-making (i.e.,collaboration);

NOW THEREFORE, for and in consideration of the foregoing premises, thePARTIES do hereby mutually agree and commit themselves to the following:

I To assist one another in ensuring that the Resettlement Action Plan (RAP) for the SulopJunction-Malalag-Malita Road Section Project is implemented as planned.

2. To be guided by the DPWH Resettlement Policy, especially with regard to ensuring theactive involvement of PAPs and other stakeholders.

3. In connection with the aforementioned, to set up the Municipal RAP ImplementationCommittee (IIIC) in each municipality affected by the road project With the DPWHSub-District Engineer or his/her representative as Chairperson and Convenor, the MRICwill be composed of the following:

a) City/Municipal Mayor or his/her representativeb) DPWH District Engineer or his/her representativec) Chairperson of the Barangay or his/her representatived) A representative of the PAPs in the barangaye) A representative of municipal-wide Non-government Organizatin (NGO), if

there is any, endorsed by the other members of the MRIC.

The Barangay Chairperson or his/her representative and the representative of PAPwill take active part in the activities of the MRIC on matters concerning theirrespective communities. The MRIC will have the following functions:

a) Validate the list of PAPs.b) Validate the assets that will be affected by the project and compute the

compensation and other entitlements due to the PAPs as per DPWHResettlement Policy and pertinent Departnent Guidelines and submit the sameto the DPWH District Engineering Office for appropriate action.

c) Assist the EIAPO in the conduct of public information campaign, publicparticipation and consultation.

d) Assist the District Engineering Office in the payment of compensation to PAPse) Receive complaints/grievance from PAPs and other stakeholders and act on the

same within 15 days upon receipt thereof, except for complaints and grievancesthat specifically pertain to the valuation of affected assets, since such will bedecided upon by the proper courts. (The PAP may refer his/her grievance to the


DPWH Regional Director, or even to a court of law, if he/she is not satisfiedwith the action of the MRIC or the Regional Director).

f) Maintain a record of all public meetings, complaints, and actions taken toaddress complaints and grievances.

4. Once the Mandatory Clearance Line of 10m (flat land) and 15, (sloping areas) from theroad centerline has been cleared of structures, the LGUs will help DPWH ensure andenforce the law that no new structures are constructed herein.

5. Transparency and collegiality will govern the relationship of the parties to thisMemorandum of Understanding.

This MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING shall take effect immediatelyupon its signing by the parties herein.

IN WITNESS THEREOF, the parties, through their duly authorized representatives,have hereunto entered into this Understanding and affixed their signatures below on the dateand place herein aforementioned.

Regional Director, DPWH Mayor, Malalag

Mayor, Sta. Maria Mayor, Malita

WITNESSES:

ANNEX D

COMPUTATION OF COMPENSATION PACKAGE FOR

STRUCTURES

4. SMUCH

Lan4mf5 1b5}5, Kb~~~~~~~

LA LNNLsZlej,

- 1- IOt 61

4.1. Wbat s txe of mrpact? V4.1 } [ leyue 2 Ma!

S. BTLT 0 MATERLALS

2. L I C CL6Y) .0R S C:) oS-a4 5-

L~~ ,L ...2ee .37C

.___J T0P L. -

_ __ . _ _ ___

4. SKIrTCH x~~/ *rR&'.'(. 0

4. 1. Wht is theextent o ir%,act V4.1)I I Svr -M*

PO/O41^7Av^f P --

f'ep{ fiargw;-z - -t

______~ ~ ~ ~ ________________ -Ie// _ ' ________________ -

S. BILLT- OFr MATERIALS

__ er "Y.~e $pS c.c . T'7 _ _

/go_ bP.f7 /2)4"XII'f/2 XOzua) CeXr-O LaAM J2Ict'.

. _r ,'o7Rpt --fh~t .

co O(' . g'j Az, ( /O ?A;#96oc "%6 (1W) b oojft r7- &9

pox~ W4M IA 1-7A5fun M. J, /&0. ____ ==~ffi -- •k~ ='. WI _A '4V = ,, -

4.1. ____ is_____a__f________[_V4.___}_____1rO= 3L . __2e____

W ~ .V1 16 ,s'o

_ ~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~ VA_7a

S.~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~7 T o 4S

4L.

- .. i..

! -- . - _ _

,_~~~~~ .,IL. __ .._.. _..'__ ............ ^ $--~

-&~ - - ! hF ~ W , - -- w--- -~- --------- --

t_~F~~~ U . -. I- ._-T .

______________~~e -P51J5 1

._. __ .__ __ _____V. .__,_..___..._...___ ___.-_.-aq

'~ ~~ Prl ULt ;. ---- ibLL -- ~-L-Q---L 4 ~ 1--

/ , ~ 1<t-oB81-a t : v ; MLo1-+ i~~~~~~~~~\(IL.

.. z_ /_._z,_ ....... ,4_ , _..........__

yU !- __,___

;6038. 6n1.i 4.

;~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~2c |f 6T ,;t;r. G45 1

~4" Thw

}~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~a <0w Tln I, Q 1I., !| e X Dcalt - - - (__2__

In k,tFXa'sUR NM L-

___ =&WS f 2 16 '74__csKT _ •WfT . .. .22--n- T "... , -4

4 7 24 we4' 128 - b

WS & i i -> --G _

ts JGS ! /sts ___j -- wa-g10 I .ST,_ _I_ ._q. o

CL N hl Lc =6[ .. I7-3

_ss_ __ CF gcJ _ _ _ ___.... TL7@_4I±'LRoLX _<sp _ _____ __ iSA~ -h | ZL

a4...1L~ 'i _____.Fj t 2S _ #hs_.-| __- - -. l , a bt<.e

__ --_ . ,_,_ ........................... I ___.____ - --- - - - - - --- __ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ t ___ __ __ __ _ _ __ _

1~~ ~ ~ -______ ..______ ....._____ _______.____.______ ______________.____

I .i .___ . ... ____. I__._._._.

. § t~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.-- L L..

603?7- La(qlq7

4. mIr

~-.4. I .

4. Wh rtat ax the exter of invat'? I V. 1) J Severe 2 Marginal

S. 3fl4 OF MA7DRIALS

CA?_ - -- D,re - at "f - . _ /s#r - -/QL S

64 00I Ic''c- 1V q4A A#4&e h

4.e.C"O~ I ,Az;w _ _----=___

/,.~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~A; ..-~~~~~~~~~~~~~..~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ __ .tsW _ .19/ ._._._._

2 K-/iS. L#9Rt 4 AXr fjw-

sr,4v -;o > se/0

.L. Vf801 h Z ie 4i -: Z

_____________.___._,_ . .

_ _ I _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ I _ _ _ _~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~....

5____ _____ _______________________________ ______ ______

JL 4 _ _ _ , _ 7-

6o0o- H-1-1k9

4. SETCH V1if A YCiT

Nn M~~~I ,Gn3 1<

_._. I qt~~~~~~~~ I ,

1~~~~~~~~~~~~r 1' -' tc , ! - l -__ _ _q

~~~~~~~~~5ALE l- I6b - -N

4.1. What is the extent of impact? (V4. 1 } .f I 1 = Severe 2= Maginal

5. BILL OF MATERIALS

J5L. G T /-S PMThtA712 CIEFI -T

z ). m L ACnqq CQAnL -

3ez 'D P 4 C-n TM . n-

SO I icn A lo m gam DEo. ,cpv. qo _______

'A I k-ag _ Jr. ____t __ IG S 1- d

, -ST( t.b X . -A 9 Q\ WJ0 - tY _

_ _ zTI C,& 6 8 25R-* cr •wr Ir76- ,P-- 4>Y x lo' LAiA-n A i.iFT. 28-iT _ 1,1

) pC Z)e ( Xe lo' -nc - 5 0 P ' F-r. 2-9- tn _

1 PC, ZuC X, e, - M-i - 8 l :T. _2-8-4 22zq n

p ,2 2 Zx - < 12. 0 -- - PIC 7O.FT 2-_- &!2z -^, pC"S l 3 l O' -n - In 13 0.fT. z_- ,w _A

pCS1 .2 X 2L X l L -m -z24 Pxp- U - d- 7 2 - '%

k-e- a 1/z " lf PJ C , rJ M NAL-( ?4s_ -b t4s-,

2SxsJ'Io' -T-Tp=i L _ p~-t, /) - at

ri~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

c'- L~ 2xz,(s [2'() 24n.=r

____. TQi - (t Z1755-L

I ~6c41 -haa

4.sCH .- _TC_

--- r -h

SnuleI- loo r

4.1. Whtt is the ed e( f .act? WV4. t I >sev1e 2i1bgsina

S. Eml OF MATRIALS

.$ CQ 4 x W xC.' bh1L H\JE AC.f~-r

. -SI ...... ._ ..... _. kX12- CobAD .f ,4 e-.. -MiMITED C.& MA~I L C

- - --T6%A L- - &6 -0-n

t -.. <EL- . 49 L-

_ .. __ _______ __ _ _

. _ _ __ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ I- _ _ _ _ _ _ _ .. __ __ _ _ .._

t - i~~. ... _ __ _ ._ _ _ _ _ ..... .A

60o2- _a/q/9_4. -- , , ,,

1i 1-1 ! Iri

| rl _ t __ !_

4. 1. Vlhd the f eflCeg g4.2 I |- m, |_o - jS. BELL OF MATcRI=L:

I q _ 12. -o - LJ1AE - )- 4d ht

lf-2 ;c- 2 _X g If0DJ FT I

1 -~. PcT'QTlo'1D CmT JC4F

zu . (9RA ,c ..

Iqs ~ ~~ 16 I n x n d x C. -> - v_ - )?CD2 / 1rsL-163 v<, rs I ac Ct __= CS: 2D -0. e-.. J ,

_z1/ PCZ§ Th%>1 CM Q F s

/5 _jjz J 2-Cxg' PL4T _ ____ CT __4-

_____ A(C -n7FV_4 2C do'rC r g__ ( __ _-_

____ -Tot - q .76 -e

_______________________ i . . . . . . . . . . . . _____________________________.__. ________________________.__________ _______

__ __ , |- ___ __ __ ____ ___8D

4. S 1WH 6o43 _- 1 9_ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

4.

f~~~~~~~~I H --

Li~~~~~~~~i

I 'D - - - O .t J . . f0<~~~~~~__ -I /' 'I ij -nA77_

4' .1. ,~ i. ,., 2 ;* . I

5. BULL OF TRLL

____ '~.'V/ l 35 ________CI ~_ _ _ _ ____ __m

I~~~~~~~~~ ,- A' F osF

! -- X--w$-ng~~~~~~~~--------

_ _ I __ _ _ _ _ _ __.. ..........

I _____ ~_ __ ____ _. __ _ _ _

j_._ O 1~ _ _ _-__ _ _-__ _-_ _ 1_ -

Ii ~~~~__4__ _ _ _ ____ _-__ _-_

I _ "'ii--

4~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~ - 1 ,,,________

_ ______ ...___ .. . _ __ .fi L _ !------------~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~I

664L Ha 14jq

4. SICTCH -I~~i~r

i-

+

Io4. PC =3 S3- L-kOim tE f I

; J~j.. AS.~6Z~T~10 -6 - I I +__T__-_

14 ____6 •tj$--OTRt ____-- I _

reLTaL. - -nq acs hss6ra1t GX N f: I Ls as- 7X3 L- C 15t _

6o4S- HA/4/q9

4. SEETCH / - a d

| Y-j

*1 7. ---. I~ L C s r

I-~~~~-

1~f5 ~Ph n tl ilv-

4. 1. Whnt in the extent of impact? [ V4. If L1-severe 2- M *arnl

S. BilL OF MATEXRIALS

li ~ ~ ~ * 8,T ___ l_.__ _

PCs Zx 3 ,<A'CO LW'7N~- a -PO.FT 69-dpr- :z .'3 x t Ail e 'FT.

4.1. 4L o.X 14' }- - 19 1ga, 2T ,

....Z....2l~ Ixxi YI,IO g~e- 24-C.'7 GOrF. J-: n Is~~C 1,gTraTs OFc ZLATEAI -... s+f *tS~Z~ Ci-gi N Prl LsX ?k6 / l7-

___ kP 2'/2" 10,f'J -Z-JL. *- ___2-4___ 4.

Is kGS - TCTA L- S

B- Tb7P,L /2 el

6*46- 8141ilq

41 S&T. C.

4.SC6} SC41t -

4. .Wa;s th exe t of imat 4I sve 2 aia

S. SU OF F TF---

I~ ~ .,+T- 2 e Cle,a 6 lIk

5cxa><R - DO - ° S clo - ( 1 -71> 90

| 4.t.whix9theeo X.-J4 12 1 PQ - .2X0FT -M264-e

S . O~~~~~i I

- . ,______________ .a ,>() _______FT . . _i

I o S S S~~~?X 24 )< z' 1 0 * C , F 8D SF-r Q576-1i vc-5 ) Zx x Xa' - -- =--- zQ g .FT ,sa,=-

Q~~16n pCa,L tcIe 2x3XI -r &J.T&_

k~~t~ 0a i SZ?W1t -V4. } L... FI _.e 2.'d L Qr°a-

pc) t 4~ Io 1' -M-p -aPT -A -5= _z 1;4q SI2. tcs C NAJ -/C6 1 - -- lb

to - 7e§.ob

_ . _iLL .F _ATKRTAL

_~~ S~ L M ... -.

~ 2 I.,. . Z

.4.

'2X . ~ .10 _I2~.T . -.

2. ~ ' ._ ...Z __k e ~ _____

_ A .J~ _~T2 CW _I •

l v o.4- Hilft

4. SKKICE

4.~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~r1u~~'jW i 'i*

4.1. lhaixthe exteiof oin:t? V4.1 f L J I Seveme 2.'M2

S. H. iT OF MA_I R=ALS

24ss )C S" t- _ 2,32

.i .4.SL IxR f ' Jo' r ',H3 plr z2q,5-'- -- lr- D1 In

4.S 146S NIV&S V/h _______ ____1--_

PC's_ -_Th77o'rn n lin ER ls 0. _________5. __ '757L- ______

PC SHT 2c X-3 8 9' -b6- ' -2 4 0 - PT.n /6 -,-b<3 Iz PC- /; X2- xlf NKA ;C, - 0 1 7 g P- -]d PU z % ..x 3 x 10- ' rr Vx)47 = kZ> je- 1=7.D - nsp,

oc C xR -x lo 9-/. =. B,P 2 sm ZZ R,S 2^y2 _ _ z X 2 x \ An -rfrn _3 4 s7{ ¢:2 >21 .G ?oz55 pc5 oL jV?IrA 2 % ' -- e- / cC-7J tOS'b

Yrb~~~~- 9 pcS T<J9l577)C.4X 2. g- d ,o

6UG3mDm -1 'PT g, Ue46

6 =,xY8,~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

6o48- Ha t1c-9

4. SKETCH

r/ -- /•4 L)3lc4nq

1t ~-n ,x I

tII Loifari g=hm±kk r rJ -

'~~ ' , 'vy ~ C'' <

lI .. <t-/ . , - Thb. ,

4.1. 'What is the caten± of ia t? [ V4. I I I Severe 2- Mw2nr

sBxor C. c a n

. V2 .2. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

i4 _>jtj lo i341 X1t ET. ' CR_____- atliO S*xv -D$ -x ' -t aO. .I. .)t 8t _' _.2,o

t e _ _Qi910 L , Y1)&n3T __71( _____^ .>-

| ,}.,> PCS 1.2x 3 X 19 7 - , -b 1 Ft ,gQ. 'F7. _2r 8- 1, IS-6, -

|, ' 'PCs i 2,x? x Is -X-, = 32 FT ,, 2-g, et 9 1 11 ,,

|2.7 p|,~ 5 | } >( i Do - 5 7 itD D Fr. n _ ,a , s,>1.9p x &C x 12GS2.-' _G-tz' ^9D~C=t0 3E 4n J,_

-A_ ME-S A x,-m acr 4SMQ~ Q,. ,p^, ,

,~~~~a , C* .LtL ,I~cfT Xmm >( 4 s.4 A pp-e L 't- &JL -TTF ,L35''-

I ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~. 3 . ..2 ,.

, _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __/_ _____ _ _ _ 1,_ t

1 - . - - ,_ _ _ _ _ _______ =_ _ _ -_

7 - 1, , _ __ ,_.- . . ._ _ _ _

! I - -_____ 1 ______ i

-I -I - ,

| i|I

15. A Ahe-rkm V I 1O o - HALQ|g

4. SZiTCH

I =_

4.1. WVt is the extent of irnact? (V4.1 } I1 1 =Severe Marginal

S. DEL OF MARATELS

90 '0&. lA110,1J ZoOf/WC ILI7I L )80 ParX- ll % /4) CC 6 - f 1Z I__

/o {' 2{' '-'D _________

/pa4 .jqr C7. . tAI b/eGYiTF~ PMN .. Co. /pc . meT

4 --II i 20VA 17A6i 1v /PC/ 4W.

t5 _ 7w( sZD. O. w #S/6 /t7 .V/ _ -/ Ih p / G7 9' I ______ /7G 00-. . _ . ,

c. /s I . _~~~~~~~~~~~~~1e

Cr-e 5ivciOr

_ Ir ¢_ C(

^ I -: ! - 1 II I -

L~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~y '- -e v

41a

>j 2!- - i- !-t 4

4.1. ¶itat in the e:t.;2t ,! : :z . F 1 - ZMve Zia mAi;1r ;uS

S. BVIL. OF MAT.ALS .

4 pC 4 4X Z2J - ,S-o s W i1e pcsc 14 2> 12- _pt _ aQ t, F rT,D ' Kr 5 o

__ PZ Ic' I ?,'3 x A lo'- - BO - FT. _ 2! __- 4i pC5 2.a3 A 12 - 148 QQ .FT. _ _ I 6___-AJr J x 2.' tA - 1 -n a FT. 8 U4o eo

1D~~~~~~ _ aor _______ 2 e P T !bC9 jD. p I a' - be- 5 n RD. t-7. Am 3___ , _o_

a.' -e D- 'L o-3Z3 2_ f_ _,_b JIG 0?'I's pc5~ Z XZ% -Po - i 1,3s &.r: T 8s7 io I I so19 pc-S IA,-, } = )C.-, ' 5FT -- 8lt- I.S is92-O19-3 =S X A -0- j4 O FT. __._4- n_

AT3 SttS W mx 4 ciZO. pLyLAo .TJ

_t __ -x~ c. . I 1-c7.J7-tCLA-t-3 acT ~siT Ir7l e4

Qt -, JoZ i i V7 Pn!/LL-b 'x noKC . I qs z2.2S A4tr,b pC5& e- 2. ' ' _ ____.__-_ _,12

-)Ž KS. - t s& __ t, c .JL .~¶ ____ ___._____

. .~ ,, __ N . 2__19 K-~~.i _N_ I . -. b2

-c- , ŽlS LCS __ , U

- ... ___A_ _ ......

1 4

C

- I-� .Ii *1

ill-� ..1 liii .1

.' 'I__ � N I I

__ -� .--.- ir.A.. --I

z I.- � '1 I

HI ci IN � 1\,.4zzzLA� ...t I'

½ �L

i�. I-vJ I -� -)

.. -

'1-�

______________________ >. �L �

C

- I-� .Ii *1

ill-� ..1 liii .1

.' 'I__ � N I I

__ -� .--.- ir.A.. --I

z I.- � '1 I

HI ci IN � 1\,.4zzzLA� ...t I'

½ �L

i�. I-vJ I -� -)

.. -

'1-�

______________________ >. �L �

1BatYbCi ia Conp4heyo Hola9..,, .- L\ ,.,'~ !:^

4- S- TCH- r?JNwrT .-.

CVOF/A/6. ~ ~ T 2. SD Ipr- $, ; jo'

_O '09 ',1 RoÂ 'l? r -/-I; /P\ sx I t

--i -- 1

,1~~ ~~~~~~~~~ 9U, DN

.70 'Pa r . 7 ..

' ' I52e l lD a s

4.1. Whatithe exen f mpc? V )1 L..1 I Seee2 aW

5. Z .H OF MAEIL

Qt. CAv SC x /0 Re CJ-. R6cDViV ee W°T#. t/ f770 oC. ~s'/Air/ OF/A/&, 2-5 50pG j 5D

/t0 PI - - M ____ _____ Ce I& Av/.

S_A 5 - fZ , /b, C70.0 0

._ __ O _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ 4, .,

S IJ &r SUiL,c4v - Hat4deg

4. SiKrrcH

! -

4. 1. What is the extait of in*ipd? Wf I4 C)L 2 evert Z- Margm4W

S. BIL 1 OMAIERILS

I ,.~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~s

2 . -D.CO

-,e _- -=-=. E(13 iV z-U7VA%!_ r

*1~~~~0

- . -_ _ .__ = IN

5.13~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ PF .ATLS

,3.

4_1_ Wha is th ex- of knpt -. 1 i i-tgm

S. IM- Ol MW MA

/6 $; C89Cf- vv cac I l\ iSC

09SM.~ .vV _ o_. I.

!Sx~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~dll 1)7 IFTeQA.

A 4 #05 09 -~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

bOt SIza . Hci&

4. SKETCH

I - ' I~Cr (Pl ,j "l)

I I I -N |b! ,b!ii

-rt AJ, I( `

I - -- ;j -- I: - I _ Ip

.- d .. .

4. 1.What is the etent ofirnpact?[V4. Ii 1 Severe 2 Mw&ia1

S. rH.. OF MATERIALS

Itb PC-S '/2 :le 16' go-UNO -m-Rns, Ma [2sa et20 PC-S .1 aC y) p 0 ea 8

5? PGS " ( X 1C' - M _-o

O _ PC-( NIPA_ _ ____ 2______- 47 2- p6s lrNt^)Tx;: 13 - Z9 - n . 2, 8- lb,3 9,SNLEK, 8 CC ajmg --ci- /b 1g,6 ^4

PCsL (D<7 x' 2 t3fl b ____4__-_/

j, J 4,RT 5 28' a,PLAIN GI 196 -c IJ - A_~ . 2) (xzI8' CO LVm)iEf - 3S3. 33 kD,FT. tl5-I 23.3e1

i B-l PC7T AIED-n O fn T iu cu. i A ,lrM12 CSi'flG -3-b1 cIJ, tAT C)a o J1L. Snea, jJrL bI T CtnJ 19l -, n

._ _ _ ISU,Bi - _ _ 2Z -,

I)n

6032- Sj2. NaIo 4

4. SxrrCH

_is e t of i_pact .. . -e - Mw '1

. -l , -- - = .- ,-

5. _ L O _ ___LF b AS

x a7i' /0, ~ )tua IA7,"r- z-ejmOj!x .i9 7A- q .Ck40

' I I f /1

h1 ! C 1' I. O _ _ _ _

,gag- _A .0 _, & . .uo - 7,

-.- rC k1 AI CL/A/ -, I 7 -- 0. -_ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ _____ ,

5. ___ zSLL7 -' ---- --

A3_bS7C 11d 0,119 I'wX /O CO~C.)~hQAS;/v rg/s /9

krr. 4r-wv XC"XA4 A119V4L Gw "a Sfh / iOcz

t32 Air W4&AZ6.1 Xb9l /' fat# MIXR f S

_ _ , P , . . f -~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~A ,A _ff

4. SWXrCH iillgrr tfs

, I ( 1 T ] i- g f) )5e'r I i

-- t- - ~~~~~ t T m~~ i ! i I

XP1Wr PFln

•~~2Ie kIab ~~~~~~1 ~~<a4 bl~-lb 1

4.1. Wba s the e=c of icipact [ V4. 1 } ) -e'Rrd z _ r:l |

5. OF MATERIAL

dg1IPCs z x 4 IL1i LA-v -J Zs 80 FTr 2s - ti RLi.o 2- x _- =-_ 430. FT. 2.8-_eb_ ___ 2

W ' PCA I_ 2* x 4 x s' - - - - 1 3.I jS 1)-'-i,tIrn 1 x 8 - - ~ cW t3X?,tO . _ 2t_ . 1..FT,

LL '~L p 2z o 4 o' c Am 41y){3CR_-&k33KT Mg _S 'k

Ro PCS t S , 4 x Iz. ,b e E 5 - _ X i s -

J.-~ I .L_ _ _ _ _ _

JLJAI co- _ CS. G lTt > _2 14T8- 55 KG5 _45:B_ c su _ t - 4 J9r~~~~~~~20- et

2. .R PL. . , .. , . __

Jv.L6 L2Ž_I _I~I_ _. __! 1!; .C____ _________--- ~-- -=--- 4 tZ ea~ S 1------ -

. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ..... ... _ _ ... ............... _ _...... _. _

_ __ _____ _--. ___ ____ __J_/t7 hw J. _____ _.___.__._,___.___.___ __.__ __ ____- __ ____-_ I

- ._ . _ _rr -l..- -

__~~I.._ .__..- - ,., .. S..--.j .,..

6 o34 - 5--k - a, - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

4. S'm.rI

* - .. - I~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~f o L'

2'46

5.~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~T InL

-f 6J~~~-_ ~~~~~~~~~~9

t0

I~~~~~~~A

6D36- -&Htit4. SKETCH c

GA4. 4 y V' 0.1 r;rscr

_~~~~ _ ,D,,__,, -.. ~.... __... I_.

4. 1. What is the extr of iffpact? v4. l I S evTere 2= Mw&

S. TT.A OF MATERIALS

2:4 SW. ae2a-eg CY ROOP.6 OF//Ya P7. 1WAr 13 Sa.o IPCs CSr1lWA5,weAD/P AOOa. SWO MZIIH47 IAOb .

,eD P" C-0 lakSV^°BO CA/PC DO4,j~ ,-(MD t .X

4.. t ADi Ft 44t f t? (4. 1 T I _ 3 2 a'30 Pei 2Z )PW' PMAEX 3/P5 /,4D )bD,ff tz-)VSx1o't4+) Cow 4.1Ah5 9J/. b0.,?b &DF Y Coc s+# A.V/2M 8 &/w C.

5'. IA _ L /7, T/Ooo. -L

.2 ____ K$t#/. w47

c. Ja TA49Or w ftJO s 7hfl)/ a-d

__._ [__ iYV ~.A~.R.dA/7'~~~~~REL4A ~ ~ NItIL

60149- S#-t a - L

4. SKETCH Ct 2i WIr:

2y'~ C - ~RLk/J.4C6/Cc

-1 ~~' - |Ic-- 1 .. lL w/_ X.,,2

- -~ A 1 D I I2-- I -

CeAJc. FL0OeINrM

2.I

4.1. Wht is the extent of irnpact? W.v4 1 } I I = Severe 2= Marginal

5. TIIT OF MATITRIAL8

/0 sAl. 4.z2C X 6' a RP. JC Oo,rhVC A 2 47 /J2z0 oo/1.0 tM/It it MZ/ DOO /O.,. /ywteoo) IA UNd7 AY 200.0d

/44 SD,PT .2 PA C^X ye , CoOO LSVW4' 0_______O

(F2 Ap- F". I? If)vv Coco IaA _ P.7 j-7. co00s"go _OS 41 _H j. 0q / P 0e o

3__ SO - pT_A-^/v C? 11 9 19, cO,7S COU-0I WAPNLfJ- j',q1 600 /C4#.,W. /. .4v- eo17 aM.7- m9wf?27 ah ,eViEL. -o- /.Mm .2 4aD. o6

/0x AM / _A7, VEF. 7°°AV 706________T /ec6r. - 7/4 -W /9'S. CO

2 -w -,tAf. L.LA _ 351 L0. ODS .'#. e')D. pU-40(y # ~ /v 2str , o

.t/O ZP M L __X __7 .C

B- - _ _d I _ _ .

___._ - -____ _1____..___

1T�

____ '1 �-*1

-�_____ -i- -- I.pr� I

I I K-� I K K

.-**...--.--.........-.--..- I I I. I H

-� I K 1 H HICl *- I I H I I K'£1� �J _______ H

____ I! 'I-I'. ---�***-* - �Ii I II I____ Ii I�' I

,,�*. ____ a I, II-. I Ii I

- - '-*1 �ij J 1';____ �Ij I I

____ J � ii_____ Ii-� II

_ ____ I H____ .1 Hi H____ 'I

-4 1LLI ___ 0

vi

.7 T ~~~~~------------- - -.-- - - - -- ----

IL~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~c

70-~~~~~~~~~~

-~~~ -. ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 - _ _ ------ Q

4. SKETCH

5. -IL OFMADIAL

tdlk,34

Jj = 2 <(.) 12. ' t ;,,, ,___ _______,

-~~-- .-J,L lx L.sl L . .' '74 l; i

F1If 0-y- pl(in a5-n_ -L l

5Ialj . 1-22/2." Yt1d ale.( _____I _'

4.1.VWha is the exent of inpact? V4.1 t I [ E s= evel 2= Mwrgin

____~~~~~~~ , . . - . _~ _

S. PMTZ OF MATERL9S1ALS

I PC -9 > 4 x i 2. 1 m - )?-A M .) T. I 'm A. s ' "b, sIC PCS x A x lZR -Ml - 7 BPA - FT. 48.(M ObM

p c .P o z < x l a . p t ) -_ is - - z F T. A t -n 4 2 .8 - e

4 C- PC.S 2. Ad 2- > 1' - I A 6 BP- FT,es @3 zpr3* . g7o 9 c x FT 6o =D,hl, £t tC-

f>CR 141N I5* P"' to, - b

29 w51+T<c~~ . ~ T .LAI- n ,t -GI OTa

KM) AGS Cg CLt NhiL ,In .z-14 13A(2c Pe -d) C sTnr:- 4-c-R- e-

-IU3 M W1 6D -E D - crb

, SVag-mt>XP(L & . N Ig22.5lit7C, -

SU8 T:MrlL -'l 504Gq . 2.

-MTPrL_ .

MAM A F-STEIN'DM - s- 4. SKErCH

LIT- fl. T .?-L

: Z P n | , - - nrrn+ \e\--

4. 1. What is the exten of irnp t? ( V4. [ I Severe 2_ _,rginl

MY EUl OF MATERIALS

2~~ ~~ j,'2.~~ X12- CAC- WhcE~ so. ET. 3 &46. 2 F x 2 - X ? |' 3 , - |f ||_ __ e

J;,L _-l 2 :,2 A lo D 7 S T. 15Zltl, -L-

4cs .. ZxZ 1Zc is' 9 OD. T'T ___,__ 2 92- -a

p .f . 2- lo' F1ND TIma1 -+ .L2 4L. .2 . .

(0 pcls Its X16 c o L& On -T 8b (ara 34n3S& PG-S zxAON Z X 8' -ma =3 8d(DT848cn

11 ITr 2. PC 2 7' Ccz - 1at rGw Grs qO F 8u- 7

2_ ___ 2N r , c i' -ti8 - I-- ^ -4

2- AI PLA 4A7h ( i V '_z- IZ_____ PG53- T 1 S~ T . - 1,TOTM I) 2 r3 7*

_____ ~~~~~~~~~~~~-lb 7PL __ _ __ _S_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ 1 , ZXn

7-PPo ci ca E kaus54 ki hqr;a GTinf.

4.~~~~~~~~~~ ,.-c - P1.4 Ck. (

- IaL

Ib S-H n I |* I j

-2.~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~ .. .1 St .CTI

n4s -h-ccxib, LAUK7) ,- JW F

4.1. What is thelu~ of unp~act? [ V4. 1) } 1 1= S evere 2= Marginal

5. DILOF MTAS

F 6WPe * 4l X CceRs GI tT -6 , _.

ID WHJs 2-a LG z} -PDO- IkA 2S=,,^ 2. a

.. s&r 1c*I e v R PLAiN G~I WhtT _)7_______>

_ffi4 P6:5 2i= x f _ ' -,(g 16' , ; I s, FT50 FT '-b # 24b nLG . .PLL- . X I-- = I Q A , .F=T, a *6 D : _n

)D~ EfL. 2.X (ax 12.' _ ~ L§,PT ___

_8 -S 2-( 2pcx3 XQ 8' . - b - I2 3t &D FT 8 __ 2_ 12 S

4oPC-& < fC L A x f Ift13 - Ob> f7,n -Fr 8 o1. 3pcmLS KRLA=Iam I-5--nb. 27 - A

i 8ur D ASS6* 97y CLj u tf .A r- In 2-2o~ - ow,Xs .s ASosZ7 GlLJ jsnr1 L• _ Ito , z2S. -

_.___ _____ ('sU, -- MT h L -________

I~ ~~~~ I

_ _ _ _ _ __ 1Z i h,

AVOLOcID 5s SAPLAGIO- S4-i,-oRR. cf. JH72 P1ii" -

4. rm=Z7 --

OApAi)Q20 0 -L.A -- I

- ~~~~~~I l

S p / - t , } | \ 1 a co X , d-2D

j , j 'ittf

1.2D

4%l. Wftd is td.e extFA of iwact? I V4. I" f.J I 3orae 2- Uw*

5 "L Or W4TIMPALS

)b. 00C0-fA*0

i PC8 SoS/ 1ee4F/MG _ ;2/ t- os Co o@A O/COrI,;0

4 dR T Jot> C < S{ l Y ______rC - e D -.t., _____ __T

ac ~ __________________ £D -r - .^D-2 ? 790, __ ____A_

_ _ __ ____ _ __ __ __ _.___ _._

c. '.)n. GA). co#,2e. 9J)%-r A I_ 1___,,/2fJ____ id£, £@fJ. ,2'/4 la, __OC_O ___AO

v5 ,vcKS' <0XF"Wi)A /SMl0 - 1 Jr/

i; - ft,"JLy C' ./ FA2',9 .OiS) JYAEop - - / WV

- -- i4 8- fliN ____________

OR ~ ~ g/7 AC>/7 J./2/( #", IR;C-4 tJ lo- Pdoos

. .~_ __-.,______ __________ T~~ /,

cal*?-~~~~~~~~~~~ LPR;u n/- g,.i

.zr-WE _ __ _ ._."a,zA 60R _WS ' - .. _ __ a, qa.7o

._~~~~~~~O 9^_ A _ _._ _ __

-. /vV .0w[- ss5 : ( 7 oM45 ,/ siD } , _,~~~~~T67 i _ ,

-errk. 5a - S- a4 ,&4. .. r _

-~~~~~~~ -~~~~~~~~GS/ ,CsY ' P/GJ:H w(r.?vi - -

~~~~~~~~~~~~rw7 §Rgn SLA -PLCOA'IA/b........ .4cLOORIAIr-a2s o>Vx6rf tV- '

4. 1. Wbht is the eztet of irrwt? V4.1 I LJ 1 nevee Z- Mam-zaI

5. SILL oFr MA3TM_-

'.9 91r 124. XC X C' logek. G-f. qJwzr 4 -c

2 ______ hN I A II/jO 7 ________

1O5 X~S TJN497*5'1)vhz7r- # ______ PC_

/2 A" (: I c0 Aous.V fl17,6& 0I/

2 XSW pi-A'# et. qVMT _________ PC Ax

___ dt I- __ J. I co

_______ .It- ______ _

s O P~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~s

/2 ~ ~~~~~~ -.- ---- -. , -~ -. I ~ - - ,

____ _____________________ fO,V_ LA9.____ _________F-- - ------- - ______-..- fM -- Z ____________

Ix 3

4.1 4,a ir tb |, t of _i4 mort ? & (17bA Jj

S. -BU-L OF 0MALS her. x t 1>er t(.~,o 4Y,rr,. ..- ~ T -. ~tr5A l-iie

&IQ - =-I

5Th 'L 3 fI!-rjl<}i4L ,

Jl Pn -<reJ | <x-

_ . ~. . 7 __ ________W\e-

*q 14 ir PPI b - m i

Stzk-.~~ RD ,^ r

__ J~__ _ _ _ _ _ ..... _ _ __ __ ....___ .____ ._..._...._ _,._,,,_~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~- - ---- - -------

Ma ; E M ts; O S44 @ D

J~~~ ~ T A4~L~lCh-! NMILC

__p___z t_ ____2 '3Sk&FPf . Wx1_ -?z- -4Bn_ t 7 32~~~~k p(C i__,._8 111>L)_- -- .W ZL.s- .... .t.. I.f

II X PCL- t..a.XW L. _.----pQ-. -.Q ---- L!- -3d).- l4

,Q L LCvXrrr, ,. _ .

_in,_~~~~~___ 4S i o UC__ -_tX?_la

__ _L;C C 1 6 M__ __ . - 1@ ____1 -- -�- -- 4. 1

~~~~~~~~~_ .__ _._ __ .._-_.. .. @ ___p;41

__.____ _________ ____________-_____.____________.__._. . . . ___,___. .

.~~~~~~~_ _ _ _ .1 - - _ ___ ___ __

~~~_- .L._ __ ___ _.__ ____ I

_ - - e --- t .. _~T

1---- -- --- --~~~~~~~~~')

4ui flapc -,C -out,,f-, {-

4. SKeirti

' -- i' i cr !I

-1 u-- £ i r-3 I __5. .T -,F. j m :

'4 12s .I = - 6-P =24 . L 1 .1

I g'- -

I I; I!P....

2-4 x 9 I RL4k7tj M- V+-rs 1nr6ft Zr1 e- e

Slr P1at, g~~~I9-TTPrL -. |-4O

Dt1 i S pior •e4I V lo

4.1. What us the eitet of impect? ( V4.t 1) fL 1 1 S evere 2= Mrina1

z --- 7 -

5. DILL O13 IATFRIALB

4 pcs '4<WR cCoe Lt i1- C4 >,OFT. ______ S

C.3 pcS 2x<3 ZX 1c ' - o - -p B0P |¢z;-O

j0 , 2C z. V. . 1s.f C NP. 2 LIa-

_ _ _ DI- T h Tm C > _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

____ _ ,__ p c__ __ _ -I -- - Co ____ ___ ___ __

a V.,~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~C.L b e e ffi %- : J -~ ~--, - r <, c> o o Hb -i-

w ,a -v

'I~~~\f

__ -,1 - 1 -< -- (1

\D, S '3 ' l \'

W b)tC tS i \t:~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~'

60/ I - Mizffa,

4. SECH

I-FO~-

-1------- ~ , JK t >.r/1

4. 1. What is the e=ent of irripact? ( V4. 1) Lf - 8evere = ;mw.gi.

S. BUIL OF MA37RIALN

~~- ~2 2x2."IZ' C."N -nti~aER Zsza r).FA

~~~-9 t -S -t< IO- -T- - --- , t ,gi J ' <. l 19m

StF T 9 (2 x Jt__ P_.v N a x Iv f -_ ____._. _ . ..-L. . . . . f f f _ i t -! ! + - . . .. .

L ~~~ A•~~i2-rE~~~ c~~i~M NLAm.S -Y7 -1-(8TtPl

__ __ G mS i-'1 i... 2fS F

3 PC5 - ^ , 1Ao_ n . SU8 -

4. S=rEI

' -- Sstmtt�,~~~~~~~

- - -- ~ ~ ~ ~~~~I = t--, ;- L:. .5u' .1',.

4, I - -- -the .of i a V4- --

S..IMA OF MAT S ' r

2.2- I I c 2- X 12- LUMZ;=- FT . a 1- 4 -1

5. PC- 2F MAAL z 1 2. -6F .-2-0 r-cs zxa t F

szO 6 >cS -4)0£ - 0 130 >- Fr8 TQ, o

A ' PC.S - x 4 x 16 -Pfd - -o ig f) -T. _8 "SD 12( a

IS 2. PC 4 x 12; ' - D6 - ?S-, Q, Cm -2 F. 9 o 6t

Pe '+ u, 4 xK I -0- _ = 3 u SD * 'FT, 8.t 14. n

tJzI f r_s TiwfVT^-o( P,< KM&) 2, M,gz- n

4&t' pctS 6fSII$GT if2 4- 4rI

3 IMNnLS tF Mna -c__s I-om f28 n1S , _ t zc x ' pL.yn r1F- s-

io K.CS *gja;9, r--W NI { LS t9-> G3-zi KC Z PC- FI" O50 C O;b I LS_

K.~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.1 -~~~~~~~k.U4 T I

L Asu -v, Q ezt

. .

5.~ .ILO AEIL

=__ c 2.x.x 'O .0FT

4. STLITH

.6 I

~Jorf '! . /

E ! Drl ! '174 10F, 4, drib

t~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~LC SD E f . ., -,. ,-4 1 A ;o ' '

. -s lo 6-; .- !6 M :1 7A R. '! I'

!- PLv, Gx cc, T

Kr" PK1> TE_'V c i, t!P LS- rbn

i 2---A-- - T O

S. EUI± C OF ATf J4IS

t J i 1pC { L . 4 >12 - ~ i 3O ,F- T. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

, I P'S I 2,O4's'I -, 5 J!a I,PT.t 8& JoS

<3s________________ ____ 2. L.fi4 1 i

<Sl1 Pv _fi- f_-r, X z 1iZOi C OtO

I CH v CI wM __ _ 0h L __ ___, _ -4

_~~~' 2.z ,TJLOLB ___,£ -- _L ___j o °

_I I' _ _ ! 'i___ St-T?'. ______

.__ 1" -----..- .- .4 _ __.__ _

. ~1 _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . __

, - , -

,! 4

460o0_ /ia/rio

4. SKETCHIL~t

---

P _ L

LL-S -c-J3 T~

x 2- XI Z'~~~ Ce- L 1_ ,W FT

4 "A x 2 ' a D [rT --...... |- - i i j -II- -- 1__ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - -6- -- 15 _ _ _ _ __o_ _A

841.A2s croiV"1 t 1 >

I_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ .__A n

-: -S .____ __ _ __ _ __ _ __ _ __ __ _ __ _ __ _ _____. W ________*__ ,= 4

- 3 . __ __ _ __ _ __ __ _ __ _ __ _ __ __ _ __ _ __ _ _ _ _ ___ ___ _ ___ __ ___ __ __

4. SKETCH

7~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

~~~-5NA----~H| >F--

4. 1. Wh_t is the extent of impact? v4. I: I S'4evere 2= Mw

S. B_._, OF MA.T R.S

ic y C' Mi- ! - 0.

' 7 ,e3'XA1/9C0 L1V. V 41i?S 4".O '- "f .2'-6' -co

%7X6)/6 q',qZ -do- I .-

____ Aa7V. cyl. /./,g i//_ -5 I.9 .-

/6 7/ he 4J/,e'=: 3 _____

_"k 4A 0 6F. I9/C-J -- - -- / 0 ,a -:

|0-p. 'C#zAV 5.F. &O 0F O

1 8 fi - &.2vo 0&4?Ie. Z -k S2li{. IM /, v60 'Cs

+ ^ C" .G 0-C ^ Gv _ &O ghl /075. 00

t4 P 7i-V. . S 1o / :vp7p- ________q o

/84 hd Xft Ûw'x 6M/67qzS) - - - 2t'7* +,0a2-¢-S - I3

/3-L 0gs ______ ______ ______ ______ ____

d D 79S - /0. X/a ou/ ln h/ Ct8V6oZ 1av.X7 / </00 ~~~~~~~1 v.~z . of5

a5 A0Sre ^ r vs'/OS 5,°w. 0O~~A

6& bO- Mq4d&4.uSKLIcH y~ W#'

40C]I~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~' ;y3i- 2=

,o ~~~ -v o I / _4:JX -ro

4.1. What io the extent of impact? V4. I) i j I Severe 2- Mazina

S&ILT 0MATERILS

8 s 1 p c PtV A t m i r _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __~ - - ;- l < < 4 - ~ ,

pC'S G4 CD

-8 t -/pr d"& D Xtr /T/Sc _ AVQ M Xr' 3&S e :''* CW , 'L.C R

/_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ I _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ________ _ _ _ _ __YP G_ _ _q o O _ _ _ _ _ _ _

I.________________________________________.___ _., _.~ ~ ~ ~ ~~2 .... L .. ...

_6e60- Modifa- - .

. ,2u~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~tn i: 4 -'na d w ( ,~~__- __ - | ~~7 >§tdOb'f.fXj('J

~6f~ Plan j~qVC Im' >

£ I ~~~~~ ~~ 4 - ~~~~~- ~~~-r- I& -i; 1i' 171QM ; , Xle: 1- 1e :~~~~~~~~ 1 3 c - 24 t- T J. A ' ---. -.4

s- to.e ~iLJ4O,^.*ES -a la,

.... .. .. $-__ __ .... ___ ........... ... J F,_

F § ; Pc5 - ;;1 2 <> . .PT-

z) ., . PC-S .. W....I~' i JPc . > ..4. fl. .4. .P 2 .

~~P~ . L"~<' J-S ._ IAA - Rl ...........T... _.. _. _ . 6.8-ot_ ......... ._.-

- - ---- ---J3_ pS. .. .... . .. .. -I. . .

- , p- X1L. .. =P=_ ..- 4 ,sS 8__ .,

~~~-4... a.;. ........................................... 8-G ,.,.,. .... 9a

: 9t \ 1 _5$%1s rrJ _JL5 ;_-~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~. 5 ....... _L. ..

Al~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~f

6OO0 - Aa//k

4. SlCIH

o --- P-V 4 77o-ML' ~, I 0 -1

.- o~~~~~~~~~~6 KP 6b -C

;5 .A#S - 1 115~SV W. /. :.,

6O6; & 7t. I //6f Î,e oc7 'M

5, XT^T 0F MATEEUALS ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~- -t

Is L-, , 6 _ C 7 A/b 7 ',, no. m

20 O 4,~,A2nd/e~7 7.M4'Y9 a .9#o 40.5 L

GS__ zd . c. if J{{z s } /8pt$) AlO . . -2 __ 0

= nrx1 I j 'c // 1SOE2.~ hi

L L . .R- ._ _ _ _~

60o9 - Madi, ,4p

4, SLTItHL

4'4f ROAouAX 77MNL1 --

v ,~e,O -7060 r -

_S. oZ0 rn c-+

4.1. WV& ui the : Of lMPaT,. 1) I J I -cvge 2- Mm2eir

5.IMLL OF MATEALS

C7 eSt 0 v/

-Kof -01- 77-76: __zW

-I _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _~~~~~~~~~~~'VbID A4I . PM-

'60o 1- HahiA4. StE1 .

COco _.~- ^

7. D e#

20 I

4.1. What is the extert of impact? [ v4.1) } 1 Severe 2- Maga

S. BILL 0F MATE_PALS

s. 1t$Z GIC& CDC* S'IZ- AtdD 1 _C __D -

OOS ~ ~ IV G" pt:t T/. /E OD

II60*- R/4i o

4, SEEI~

4..' 'Md O 7 A n -

coco 43 -- -

4.1. What is the cztat of impsac? v 4C1)~ II .e'ee Z )MB16ml

^z,~~~~~~~~~~~~~~0g >r

727?-[ 1,7 - I

5. .IL IFMIrI

~~~~~~~ 4~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~L! Coca LPL.#E~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~I 4'-s I

1- - _ 1_ __-ZQ A#a

I - t | , I t~~~~~~~~~~~~~-

6o 1 H_2 - /_____4, SKETrCH

CX! -'L d^ '

12sO rneLMI

41. Whis the eoX[t' .lo L. 1 2mw

S. AU 0O MATUJAL

l l OD. i=T .2 )tx 7 JOGS2 M'd4 ome 3 0 o- o- _ _

'S PCs -e~ Xco 0 -_lo2

ill A99r' C. W. N1-1- /IY I1 CO.@

OB- _ _: I _ _ _ _ 0 n

-I ,_ _ _

, , . , ._~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~I

. -1+ 1g1 1 0I-. 3O -

10 0 MMM1~-.

1- I a .I lI

A4~~~~~~~~~~C

4. SKET(c

.2 d RC6QVD r)") ecA" o o>#0 rc ** 0 -1 L- T'I

srnAifrOoo ML4 I,s

1 _ _9,00 rD hAfekrs .L

4.1. wnat is the extent of impact? [v4. 1 ) [ I Severe 2= Marirl

5. BILL OF MATERIALS

Ip /C-S C'9m a 06

IEt ." m .4 b /a W' ' / o

_ c. Lw N9N

_ _.. ... o7/*L ___ is

4. Sl&TCH

5 } p~tnPJ -n7rJzi &< ;c_

4. .WIS L~h~e x±.ezzofunpw;t?j V4.i 1I seo*rt it- J

S. BILL Or AEIL

- ~ ~~~~~~~i ..__ sJ -- lsA) ___________

12 g

14 !JW -., .1 .. ,

____ ~~~~~~~~~~TO-ML __ __ _

_ _ I _ _______ _ _ _ _ _ _F _ ___ .__ ______._____ R,_,__ _ =j.._=._---_ I6a

_ _ _ _ I _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _1

____________ _____________ ____________________ ________________________ 3~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

4. SKKrrC

WU __FV --: .-

O -O~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~j L3 J! 11 = B01,,'~H S 1-'

I l- n D =

I_ _ _ _ _ __~~~~11J I -1_._,1 __

: s '7. -- . -

4.1. Wid is the extir of ipact? V4.1) fI -Sevee 2- Mr al

S. DMI 0OF MATERIALS($Oc~~~~~~~ ..~~~~~L S/A'/~~~~~~~~~~e/7 ,eDofV ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ..

ISV PUS J}E0 7/,f/W/% A & M2 *

4" . ' J2,e__ pA ? C, 4~~~~l xzwv /7 W , n - OyR - COur

9C ~O.fJ. 4".s4-s/2' GfO CDe~ t'' sq,. 6 G~~~~~~~~~dO4 of- t OCt A,X< /t D. .X 4 -X 4& jOOJ Cec;L5 I'Awa!c'

._ ,l~ 2.

6o2o-~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Gq4-6020>- malik}

4. SKETCH

LL _

III F lo i I ' I

~~~~~ e- , * .b

4.1. WhVa is the extet of irnpact? [V4. 1f L _ = Severe 2 Mar&nn1

5. BILL OF MATERUS

L. I CZ 3LL l?~A7Z$_X3 X 8___L_) = 3C 1D FT. Vz J C n

L9 k < S c ASa S7 a, U n - _,4 s nL ) u x S:J. = )33.330. .¶ . lCD42.

.__ .... SU^_Th7 _Z _ _I___ ,Z, ^

___ __ T_ _ _ _ _ _ _ __- --- A__ ___ _ I , .3 T ,.

.. _ _E L - __

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ -

_ _ _ ______ _____

.~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-_T__ . .....

-II~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

', s3flZ~~ ~ ~~A,400 7 ;

S.Etl- OFMATEF&ALS ,l> tll

6 a -1- - t| 1

|4.1- '!a& i th Le ez~ n of impact? v4. 1 j L ! .. Ie n rLZa

I _ . --. -- .- - -. -- _ _ _ _ _ _ _ .

5, BiL OF MAT1lUIALS

p i-T7CL 0. Ri X4#/L 5tc/rz _./2T ___ 7c F S d 1-PCX i A 7 v n -t~-.

,~ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ -. __ / 6 ..

___________ I __ -

-_ - ___ _ _ _

1 _ .-.- _. - - - -..---- --- --- -- _.... _ ............... ._._ __ _ _ _ _ _ .

.,I. __ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ___ _ _ __. _ _ __ _ _ _ ___._ __ _ _ _ __ _ __._ ___ . . .. ,__. _,_

* __ .~ . ,,I_ 7

_ _ ._ _ ___ . _ _ _ .*.A __ _. _ . _ ._

I _ _ ___ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ ,,,___ __ __ __,,__ _-- - . - - - . . _-.- _ _ .'- .-v--... _ .... _ _. ._ _______.-_____.._..._._ _-

-I I____________________. ______ _ ______

1- _ -. _ ___

23

4. SKKTCE

I _ __ ____ __. j I

t__ -

4.1. V L i the eet of impacrf V4 11 * = ' erfe 2j

S5* DIL OYr MIIRI2ALS

T ~ ~ c7~69 -. 9 d /0' C1o9R. 62 lrllzz1SW OA 220z

i. , 9 S zm. ______

= ; CS X//0 ARg. 6~~C11 w --- I/ f431 } no

IS Ad 8"X6' Y/6' 9P> -) - i<_.@Y gt.. /" A3' -s g _ ___________

'4 ,.o0fIA/~ -M9/L -- ___ __/-( D ',_O_ .in

&q. I A}C72' C- W- M,V}L I-___- i.O20 4 # /C T/l /t)0 -'__ _ -_ __ -A

/~~~~ *B9~ / k,k. __ = -________

tS~~~~~L pw .0 'DF h&h / 8 A x

bd /OZA 7 .p5_ /cl /4 hem ogs 0.o7-0 -_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

fA~~~~•i . .

6024 A - a/,

4. SKIETCH

L5q 5 L ,A

§ . +~--

,4.~~~~~~~~~~~'

4.1. What is the eatent of inpact? V4. 1 } I Severe 2= Margial

S. BILL OF MATERALS

9 1MPZFLKYIO Ocm.E-OT g L e-bL. L i~1 ?4:tACEV -) _____A__

J , <,S * AtF1< GRML G¢,4 ~3 JOLLS AA&S fl 4J I CZEK ' 1,O

W, pbE C.6 BOL f3- e2t,

23X iVffi' , CV _ 1 Do 4APC-( pc &'4zT 2rT S4 - e-

I Pgfr 2. 3 x R _Li n _Wt _ 1J7Q . etI . cST i06s2 pzmnl, a wpu L qs-G " .L atj*** K<:~ 2. /V " E ~3~cl' C L .t CZL. kU AC(c3El) WM NP,l• Gra 2z

_ _ _ _ _ _ __I_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ I --

=_ _ _ _ _ _ _ m TrfiR_ _ _ _ _ _ _ - a, .Tq

6o21 B- kf4/l

4. SSCH

I~ ~ , F

4.I1. W!he is the eraL ±~, mact±?V4.i} L.' 1 Bevem l Z4arpzAl

S. BILOF MATERIALS

,5 . otd - d. -. K /2 dC J 2O/ ,,~ i :

60- PA = *VOSOtrC

I -. ." I .. P-OVt'A/0 7' 71A4 r _00

:_ _ ___ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _: l/&- _ _ 3,_<,7a._ccs

______________________________________________________I______ -_-

6o2 S- HA1, Wk

4. S1ITICH n-rr ~. m . _

4 - -Eq2c--t-4-h

jjtr1 ThhK1e

C6" . > o n n n I wll)1Sc 3_b Nl mckc

4.1. What is the exteit of inpact? [ 4.I } f 1 1- -Severe 2MuginI

5. BILLT Or MATIRIALS

.. 2 )HWTS 102t6p'____sSFV + X x lo' C * Q'I c&HT _______15kt

4 c9AtTS 7 x cI ( LA_ikA1 972. 'O. FT,

pCS 2 xGxJC ' -De - ~ /4Q Bn sOPT 28o tyL,6G-6P I X p D - 3L1 JBD F7. 2.e-

. s pc*S s c R~ x Jo -EX)- A 3 t:). F-r 28 -on ,5;-

1D Ic4;5 ^ /- " R,I\stlA-ltS eo M tI kG mn7tp CFIO hiLi -- 5 LUt/ 3- o

Lr-3 rn }mrn a s 6 rn D m9S nt5-o;3 ):nd 1 nl m qAX 07 nI__ y-O Z 1£

72- )"tasj+F__n 7bT -)

______ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~6ThTA

6b2 6 - f -|,-

4. TCH

e-~~~ -'i I 1r~-

I, I O IwO- %s

f~~ ~ ~ ~ il, *. . -t

~~E ..~ -: '.:_)-tWs-is

4.1. What is the exte of impact? [ V4.1 } L -Severe 2Z Marinal

S. B0IL OF MATKRIALS

2L..... ¢ Ga X /o' cOg .GxJ.j . .Sy/ - - t IS -/ 4_ X.X G A 9P x ci coe. s lvivT> .

4S bt,n .2'tx}X/(6;(Igs) Lh^q*,~ tknwVK ,Z /5 F ,&O/( .0/4y Do ri TT /II (q Pa -W,9)N 4^ A"Aw 29-15f _4,,432 L

3v_ Op- f /"X g' A/0, ITes) 4A&I 4;qO5 Z9 / 10;tt W 2. CD____ &}Tp. S/i C r-e C . ba t

130 o4S Ca__) P _ / IL ( _ _ _ __ V D _ d / __ 9 , 0- I LO k a#, /C Tic 94 I k1 t7x O

lb d Io /VPl? PM Ams AS -af5D bb C~ cO 700 1> i& b#As.

C4IM cam Qa.e- 410E Cc - -- 3 0.w /4o

v~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~Si tS -Pq MI Uq2s.Jt o

A~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

- t oL os, 0S W~PO

on~~~~~~~~nn

6o 27- Hot/Ii

=~SK~ICH . - T

I rN~~~~~~~~~~ Ii~~~Tn i1 ~~

.,-11. I I _ _ II

.3-16 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ -r ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1

4.1. Wbt igs 2e ed of iti pact? V4. L...1 Severe 2 pnir'

s. .L .,F _tinivs

,2 C I - ' , .-4 _ .A2, _

.J 2. L.S 2-X.3 x Ic' .~ -M- ~ i2 P XR -D< _ 8 1 C } X x 3 X o ,-D - 5 0 tZ D EQ, |t.ij ! JC<§ ,< L1 / - m- -A Fr go _ -

% b~~~~~X }x 10 I2 16, ' @F-1: 2oG -uAr S- i ?dac. 9a_I ic.c 1x / 8' A-M- - r24dD D.FQ T .

7___ I X *___ (SJL -a TTOK R 2,< z R-L.,C ~~~~~~~~~~~1LM SQ#_, 964 sfL j-6?

_SJ 1 9 _ _-_-,

LSUtB, _ _ _ _lL -__ _ _ _ _ _ _ _, _ _ _ _ _

,i __ ___71L ~f~-'sFQ

I- -i - . - -. __ __. _ _.

I ~ ~ ~ J. __ _ __ ___ __,______ _ __. _ .. .. __

0; I _ ~~~__ _ __ _ _ __ _ __ ___ - . . _ _ _ _-_ _ _ .. 4' , -_ _ 1 _

_I _ _ _ _-_ _ _ _

- - - - - -0"Ii 0 -.

r IA I -'& I

x - ;� QN -�---i *K�6') (��I2F 3.. ..

L 2(N

rnC)

t�)

- - - - t� �

63

�

6029 -la/i/.

4. SC3E[~

S.6WIOF 29ATERIAS -

5.BiD_ lL OF MkILeLA

c- CO/7 E 1Qaia a~60 ,. O -- VA - _i |2.

_~~~~~~~~~ -- f ;l ,9 Ao

6030) - Mal;i

4. SKErCH

jjt

SN~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~~~nl

T-- Ez i -----

4. 1. What is the ext of impwct? v 4. I f I - se" 2 M dsr

S. ILOF MTALS

I6 (SW _T'i2_

120 Pa x1 161 , _CC LuWE2 6 C 70 T

x-i E- !WX x 10 , - -- t3 3 AD t ET 53 3G41. What i eZn Xr3 A' -f DA- = ED..- FT. . 8.a nC. Bfl:L OF A Z TE RI in _ = *LS A zc d

2. Z) < 2Z)( 10' - _ W 6 9O SD -a. F4 cW...... SILL 4 C 2. 8 P' PLMl c(r <VT lt7-

I 14t; )2/2." k hI'JC kea Ls 4-c- rb

___ TLJ-TbrLX5K j A s§Z1 co NJ'IlSg ;3ro 4_ -...- -.__ _ _ _ __ _ _ I _.___ _ -

._______________ -,,.- . I

- ~~~~~~ ~ ~ ~ -------------- ----- ____________

4603/- h' / ;7*-

KO?I

4,. sTCH

I/i A If /

& AV - f - x- -e-F- I -6

I t _.,_. .__ = .,

LJI 01 . 0. e

,,_ __ _4 _ _

- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ -5, 13tT~ 7J oi9 i 1 4 'wo

F____ ___ - _ _ ._ _ _ efLWto f /aor

__ ___ _.__ , I_-It e ;'* - - - _ 77

__ - 7 .

MHC1d%ho HZQ(AflP- kab'k'4. SECTCH

- I_

Sxle~~~~~~~~ - 1- v-

4.1. What is the extent of irnpat [V4.1} L 1 Bevere 2-Msrginal, Scae I -'1

S. BULL OF MA1EIALS

PL c~S L4ua >i RcY~t'O KT;'- JQ- ________

)5 k.L.. 2 '/2. tl 2 V- -"! - 57)

Dwrif)1 Jim~ ad 11 QK C Ig

2! PC-C 2 - t 12.- C.cdc Lu r21siR e zc 1='T. .... L/.

L..4. JGlS &4J4 1-O cmiC NAIL-S ___ ___lo-__

___ -76T_L ___ ' T2A-Pb9 2

4. CH r-

. ( ( t!6-6Crj)

, _; ,F-- _

5< pjnr an51,-- PSkr

4.2 . Whi is teexetent oninact? ['4.1) } r J 2-evere 2 Mrginsl

S. BMLL OF MATKRIALS

j. 4*j 3") f .3a I' ptmij *-PW agFiJZQC iocS C ITI372S 2.e-a ,r

~L. KS A ,. •.g 6)1 TEn C4Lj NA) L C-b l4o - bBl! f*mpeo WsmCKc( _______=-

13- LA-cc O38- ____ lJ~~~~~~~7~~23~TOThL.

.1~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

______ ______F___.__________________________________________________________________

4ISARELD P. MAAoLO - F1aId0

4. SXITC

/''" -+-

-1,' '''''-,- S W W m 1

4.1. What is the exterit of irpact? (V4.1 I Severe 21 M} 1 S

S. BUT OF MAFIALS

/Vo, PCX SIA,11 fr ADor/lAl 12 --I l 8 0 IPM C,6 p , 0 .17'AD' P /97 C9 P OF

'8.+'l - i + 2 '9 ecr-z) Ce 0 D*t -- 0NA3V /

W__P COC 4 d X Ap /w t/ '/t. A/AC 6W. J1E. /Sh Sa .

yo * 9 -- rS~. C. W. ,V'9L 3S -IP ____

.T .2 _e r O,?O(3.ot5

-D Al If W CS h3CN _____ . 2,100 S '-'

NILA4i O B6 8AP.AI# - Mla/*

4. S7iTCH

--tOre

4.1. What is the etett of irnmpact? V4.1} r f I Severe 2 =Mar&inal

5. BIL OF MATKRILS

.. A a/ P/V,9OI Z(X iFA^VA)~ t-9~ ____t____5 04 -7 210102 lvelAv? 2 R /'P I 0 80 X C4 lpcr C"@. ecSS .7MA- 4; vg Ml.a

~{ p C , o Q v . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _t

/C t-1. 4 'a 5 f1t"1-7 (a 7aZ) OcaO Aoc oo.cc

/D~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~1 e-q *AZV â2 , #L, di

A16'x71 9pLJ cc oo'90

,8 . AM "3o. N,a. alb~~~ ~ ~ I~ ____ 2__

de4nc, - Ta fky - Nob

4. SKETCH

I ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 1= K .;3} +

*~ IS7.2 ~ ~ ~ 1.

4. 1. What is the extent of impact? V4. I) r J 1 Severe 2= lMarinal

5. DTI.TL OF MALTERIALS

~~~~~~~~~~~~. _____ =_~Z JY#~' A 7 A6

/ fi o /'1' Co -c'

:___ S F-D7P iI-i

- t0 1r ______ dig,. RV

.._ .. ,o _ 7 .~~ . . . _

FLOkOEL/ZA Al Lo SRoR/O t\\

4. SKETCH

`0 po5 r

4.1. Wbhi in the etent of inpact? f v4.1} L J I Severe 2 Ma*iW

5. DILT OF MATZRALS

.4- P -. ..-oo

__ _ A

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ _t _ /. a ~ '

-~~~~ in~~~ __ _L_ _ .

POGE LIO CINCc - MaI,ica

4. s1rcH -- -- * - a

,~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~4 |es2 ,1'

- I .. __M__T__

'~~~~~~~. j6 --:7,t } : it g einr"P I~~~~~~~~~~~~~~S.:TI

-/-~~ -t - ->~~~~--~ IP -sc!a= 4.1. Waisthe ex±erof impact? [V4.11 L} ... 1 1 =Severe 2=anI

5. BILOF M1AS

Z I x 4x 12. i/Y1c3 Lt1EQ - , FT. ____ t _

4; r qxt4.,.4T L x R -D - g -aFT 2 LI- a

kra fc( 2r x ROMT >(j a tjt,L- -- . =2r&dG-

4 CS NAILx-3X 1I -D _ l-

2 pC Ix . x 12' -X_ -iC ffD>t I. Qi9;4

2. jC j. zV2" C JP US _T_ T L- -

____ ~ ~ ~ ~ UtS L -tsT6T 1L -______Y15* __

-MT- L 4 7111-6

d~~~~~~ X CCIOSa? E :c1 _~ ~ ~ __ '->_3XSD-diz n ,

Wi . , r. Xt

I~o~- A-ltIi- D- '1.......4. MP121TCH ---

flA/Ab7~~~ Cm

I 'L ~ . _.__e . co

X 'I .VS _ 99 llfyt~_ 77M eeV- -------- --

f j-;r- -- Jo- - 77/J°OL zqd' u< ~~ j t

[ ~ II p . . 7 1W tMJZ i .........

(3 _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ |_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ I

J.

j____ 5. 4 ____ P_ A _66

------ --- T____ ___-

- 1 z Ot - a'~@f __ _ _ ___ __ ___ __ _ _ _ _

-A5 1 >D _ ,_____8^D ,7 ~ 6t_ _ _ _ _ _..- _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ ! - ~ 1K _ ____ ___ it_

t 1_ _ _ _ ___ _ I _ _ __.__ ,

1s --X4 '__ , ,

__ ....................... ~~~~~~~~~ ___ ..__^ . ._._______ ...... _ _ _ ._ .. _ ,_ _ ..__ _ .__.__*._...... .

._ _ _ . _.* . .. 1,I 1 _ _ _ __ _ _'__ _ _-I__ _ _ _,

f- , j --___ _ _ __ _ _ __ _ __ _ _ __ _ _ __ _ __ _ _ __ _-__ _ __ _--t--__ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ __ _ _--__ __ _ __ _ _ _ I_

0

I k5CV~~~~~

1.4 U~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~4

SATriRNINO C. HA45161/GI- /-l/j4

4. SI EIC-In -/ e Ijl

AZO' -,44~N /q- - /p/P ~ T., F ,_ _ __ _

4.r 1, Viht i th centof *t? 4.evee , ,-Ai

S. B1W ,:,,. I 'I ! _TMALSR@}774X L.

/O -IVX 4 -e ,,7- -,t, X l-- m-0 00 XX J a) -N lf1 /CRALE ',n/AI/lT .c

4 _P - 60! S A ----- _ @ 4 '¢ s

4.1, WbaZisthee=tentofirnct?t V4.1} ! 1-2 1 1-5 erc /-Marin

S. Bill. OF MAIXHiAJS

/4 p¢ OUAiD pn9bo c. __-________/n9

/o 40 j ROw n w w7f~~~~~c i___ ___

Is.. EM a/N/8/ ,OrAIN _____, _

_ _' -S- .

B. L czboL A/I/

__~~. _ _p _: I ,24

- I_ _

r/o'z -2±LLA

~~W6? Q~2~2 ri , x P 4at.'? 42P

I~~ ~ ~~~~~ ..l . ~)sdn; 19 '~l~

JJSJI1 - /------- .

7 -- 2 00- - -

-4 ilf3: 9/_ -_?es _ . _ ;~AY4 X

. ___ . . - _. _ . -~~~~- ~-~

_____S_ _____ __ _

Xf'/t2h1 -OyN.g* v1, ,,,O7I

._~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~Y V, .4 I. I. A .. C

IMELIDA SANAMA - HaI,7r4. SKKTCH

y'iI12r ze1e -

pA41=12c f L:IY £W I

, ID

-~ ~~ 1< T 1a 12

___~~~~~~~~ .- }Ii =_

4.1. Wh in the ta of irp4a? v4.i 11 I ievere 2- Mmnl

5; BTL OFr MLATKRALS

@0 DOW 45J^Wf! zzo;o) _ a/ _ 540 77-=;7*n &,M9P2& .//P 9&

h7 7'x A)0 /fl7C .

_ gsro cta Ly /ML 5

/,g#-/~~~~~~~~< A- a , 80

MYRNA c. CoLAO- Mai

4. SKETrCH c- PfJu r(?-)c

- - A/AD7bOD .A 4FO e/7 - -s

4. 1.Whgisatilee oin-; ect7k' S4.,8 L . -Severe _-. .mwgz

S. EIL OF MATIRIAL84,0 f .'- f,q-c '_-

I Ts L.

95 iO ' .2')' 617 /PC- I7 __. 1_4.1.w h is~ Sl extc' of im ________1__!__ w evre 2

IOD ___ ___ _Coco__ ___ ___ ___ ____ ___ ___ ___ 0, R 3._bb

fog ___- _ -- - -- - -- - __ _ __ _ __ ______ ___ __ __ _

96 .2 6'x /~~~~~~~~~- I lba JF)'~~~~~. .

C-.e XS.,00gG,a

t5.~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~__ tlL OF__ I ________

ewo v,r 1.7, o , YRV oc ,v7 1 7o .0o _

24st ~ ~ 4AA- fDo.f Sis ' Thkl# 3xx. ac M,2 evr g2

_._ - .

-O N r sZ. o -i _________________________ _____ ____ _ s k I ___________+ ___ __ ___

iz ..- - Q

4. SKKTrCH~ .f2e 4' 2~O(P c,) __ _ - C-fJV'/A- .,"S,4'<(cco) - - -

______ -i -.JALotl 'A/JI//VW (.g'O:D -~

.F4A0eoo V-'Azh-

. .LA'S.-r

A 7'~~~~~~~~~

-,=,IJA 2&I ,=. E'1.FVA7K10A1

XSCA.Lg e / /oov, _ SCA LF - .1 , 00 * 7

4.1. What is the extnt of irMact? [ v4. 1 LJ 1 Severe Z-Ma*w

5. IJLL OF MATRITALS

-2.0 CI/r IALO)OSIE (') P' 7L o . 00(24 )80,fr /'X ."A /Ij c/OCO 4tQ . __-_ MP __ _4_ co

st e f&Df ,M X4", /2'(4a CO-c LVv't jhJDf , e 3 2ni X2v4 eT fr' Xo"f/' p4 k) COCO . ______________

24 4.N.ff a .2Ic ,,0 I 'I'm,) Co 60 c. VeQPlb v#T riNo 7(Gr' (l&'A/a) 2 oAJT.20 pas 4.,N ' oo .77W? co

/o~~~~~~/V9 P96S + w .G /,,PC. _31 .WS .L .

x s .- 7m4 /A /,

,8. 4 ~ I_ __ _ ___e__ _

____ ,__ .. __7.ASIV r L ag dES.

HERMEDES C PANAJO - Malif44. S E-C

.~~ - .e_,Mq.8ptiIA4 yX

,4 :

VA~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~I

. . .~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.

-F I< L I s/f4;OR w2/ .- _-o!wr=X/

4.. VThais the exa of inpact? V4i} I I=Severe 2

15. 9ILL OF MA2TRALS

2o pC-S | T/V9-MO 0,91WWO /PC cCO

____ ____ /O 7 ePA9&x:1II 2 so .co

Q30 KZ j9irfP, CO. NlI . '/a )'IC le5 gV'AI0 r/fl I2/ i I. ROO00O OtI/t 77A9b" /? /SD 1 rO.co

.B I. I - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . , _ _ _ _ _ _

.~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~pn .. .' .21 0

-_. __ .ZZ

&~/ 2224,V AMrAlr40,a 00'.~~~~~~- _. 7I ~/4,eO-4

.~~~~~f . . 7 ._ .. _

H1H5 Ga. edo\4. SrCH

+~~~l {X R ~~CO 66

SC!S~ ~~ -a 19 100 [LK1

4.1. Whau is the extent of tn3pact7 . V4. 1 I .J - Severe 2- Magnal

5. BTLL OF MATERIALS

X Wa i+ A gld= -5:1cK5"- aed

CLt~ L; m . _K7 24__ _ .A ~~M-

~~~~~~1 ________ ____________________________________________________________ ___________~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

-t _ _ _ _____________________________ ._____ ._____

Documents

documents.worldbank.orgdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/360991468776748500/pdf/multi0page.pdf · RP24 Volume 9 REPUBUC OF THE PHIUPPINES DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS AND HIGHWAYS