104
March 2, 2015 Dorothy Lowman, Chair Pacific Fishery Management Council 7700 N.E. Ambassador Place, Suite 101 Portland, OR 97220-1384 RE: Agenda Item E.4 – Unmanaged Forage Fish Protection Final Action Dear Chair Lowman and Members of the Council: The Pew Charitable Trusts has collected 2,952 comments in support of the Council’s final action this March to protect unmanaged forage fish through the adoption of a Final Preferred Alternative that prohibits new directed fishing on seven groups of currently unfished forage species absent robust prior review. Please include the attached petition as an electronic submission on the web site for the Council’s supplemental briefing book. The petition itself is included here, along with the names and cities of individual signers that were gathered as of February 27, 2015. The Council may continue to receive additional comments in the days ahead. Thank you very much. Sincerely, Gilly Lyons The Pew Charitable Trusts 111 SW Columbia Street, Suite 200 Portland, Oregon 97201 pewtrusts.org

rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

  • Upload
    vuminh

  • View
    237

  • Download
    6

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

March 2, 2015 Dorothy Lowman, Chair Pacific Fishery Management Council 7700 N.E. Ambassador Place, Suite 101 Portland, OR 97220-1384 RE: Agenda Item E.4 – Unmanaged Forage Fish Protection Final Action Dear Chair Lowman and Members of the Council: The Pew Charitable Trusts has collected 2,952 comments in support of the Council’s final action this March to protect unmanaged forage fish through the adoption of a Final Preferred Alternative that prohibits new directed fishing on seven groups of currently unfished forage species absent robust prior review. Please include the attached petition as an electronic submission on the web site for the Council’s supplemental briefing book. The petition itself is included here, along with the names and cities of individual signers that were gathered as of February 27, 2015. The Council may continue to receive additional comments in the days ahead. Thank you very much. Sincerely,

Gilly Lyons The Pew Charitable Trusts

111 SW Columbia Street, Suite 200 Portland, Oregon 97201

pewtrusts.org

Chico
Text Box
Agenda Item E.4.c Supplemental Public Comment 2 (Electronic Only) March 2015
Page 2: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

Dear Chair Lowman and council members, I greatly appreciate the steady progress the council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows—and the public recognizes—that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs. As you know, the ocean off the West Coast supports valuable commercial and recreational fisheries, as well as ecotourism and other industries that are economic drivers for our coastal communities. Healthy populations of forage fish make all of this possible. I join thousands of fellow citizens in supporting the council‘s final action, due in March, to protect currently unmanaged forage fish. This action will designate them as ecosystem component species and ensure that adequate science and management are in place before new commercial fisheries can target them. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Forage fish protection has also received strong support from a variety of stakeholders involved in fisheries management, including commercial and recreational fishermen, processors, environmentalists, and the agencies themselves. Rarely has there been such widespread agreement on a management action, and the council should be applauded for its inclusive, deliberate, and scientific process. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Certainly, protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Sincerely,

Page 3: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

FIRST LAST CITY ST COMMENT

LEANNE ABBOTT Yucca Valley CA

SUZANNE A'BECKET

Cupertino CA

MARY ABLE McArthur CA

RICARDO ABREU Long Beach CA Do the right thing.

LAURA ADAMS Sebastopol CA Thank you very much!

GENEVA ADAMS san bernardino

CA we all depend on this planet and a healthy ecosystem for our very survival.

DAVID ADAMS Penn Valley CA

EVA ADAMYAN Los Angeles CA

ELIZABETH ADAN

Carmichael CA

WILLY AENLLE Altadena CA

VICTOR AFANASIEV

La Grange CA

JANE AFFONSO Redondo Beach

CA

MARCO AGUILERA

Carlsbad CA

EDWIN AIKEN Sunnyvale CA

CHERYL ALBERT Freedom CA

RORY ALDEN Berkeley CA

CHARLES ALEXANDER

Rialto CA

SAMUEL ALFSEN Santa Clarita CA

DONNA ALLEYNE-CHIN

Montara CA

GAIL ALLISON Sacramento CA

CHARLES ALMACK

Calexico CA

CAROL ALTAVILLA

Woodland CA

JUDY ALTER Los Angeles CA

CHERIE ALTEVERS

Lincoln CA

SONIA ALVAREZ Laguna Niguel

CA I appreciate your support to protect our oceans and its inhabitants.

NANCY AMODEO

Los Angeles CA

FIRST LAST CITY ST COMMENT

GREG AMOUR Whittier CA When they are gone they are gone and so is the industry that depleted them! Learn from history and science.

JON ANDERHOLM

Cazadero CA

CHRISTINE ANDERSON

Lafayette CA Please protect forage fish.

DAVE ANDERSON

Berkeley CA

PATRICIA ANDERSON

Roseville CA

FRANK B. ANDERSON

San Pedro CA

JANIE ANDERSON

San Jose CA

KRISTY ANDRES oakland CA

CHRISTINE ANGELES

Burlingame CA

J ANGELL Rescue CA

TINA ANN Bolinas CA

LISA ANNECONE Santa Rosa CA

MARTIN ANSELL West Hollywood

CA

CRAIG KEITH ANTRIM

San Pedro CA

LAUREN APPLING

Penn Valley CA

KAREN AQUILA CA

ANDREE ARMAND

Venice CA

BEHNOOSH ARMANI

Brea CA

TAMI ARMITAGE Studio City CA

MARSHA ARMSTRONG

los gatos CA

TINA ARNOLD Oakland CA I believe this is an important measure to protect the vitality of our

Page 4: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

marine life.

DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA

VANCE ARQUILLA

Los Angeles CA

STEFANIE ARS Simi Valley CA We are not the only animals on the planet. Other animals eat too, why be so greedy, share the abundance.

KATE ASHLEY Redwood City

CA

JAY ATKINSON El Sobrante CA

BARBARA ATTELL

Mission Viejo

CA

EMMA AUSMAN Toluca Lake CA

JANICE AUSTIN Temecula CA

DIANA AYLWARD

Woodland Hills

CA Save our fish. Save our world. Where do you want our world to end up, sirs?

DENNIS B city CA

M B San Clemente

CA

R B Escondido CA

N. B. Oakland CA

CHRISTINA BABST

W Hollywood

CA

MARTIN BACLIJA Indio CA

LOIS BACON Freedom CA

ROSA BAEZA Reseda CA

ANGIE BAHRIS Santa Monica

CA

KATHY BALCOM Los Angeles CA

B E BALDWIN Long Beach CA

TANYA BALDWIN

Los Gatos CA

CAROL BANEVER Los Angeles CA

MATT BANGO Palo Alto CA

STAN BANOS SF CA

JOYCE BANZHAF Grass Valley CA

AMIE BARBER Universal City

CA

NANCY BARCELLONA

Los Angeles CA

SCOTT BARLOW Sunnyvale CA

CANDICE BARNETT

Santa Monica

CA

BRUNA BARRESI San Francisco

CA

DEBRA BARRINGER

Ventura CA I volunteer to monitor endangered least tern nesting and track dead seabirds for the USFWS. I have seen the terns struggle and more offshore birds washing in dead, both due to declining forage fish.

TIM BARRINGTON

San Jose CA

ALFREDO BARROSO RUIZ

San Diego CA

ABIGAIL BATES Los Angeles CA

CANDACE BATTEN

Los Angeles CA

WENDY BAUER san francisco

CA

ROSWITHA BAUGHMAN

San Clemente

CA

ALAN AND JANET BAUMANN.

Mission Viejo

CA

PAUL BECHTEL Redlands CA

CONNIE BECK El Cajon CA

CAROL BECKER Sherman Oaks

CA

MARK BECKWITH

Berkeley CA

ANN BEIN Los Angeles CA

ANNIE BELT San Jose CA

Page 5: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

JILL BENDALL San Diego CA

ELAINE BENJAMIN

Alpine CA

BETH BENNION McKinleyville

CA

RICHARD BENSON

Lawndale CA

OMAR BEQAJ Venice CA

KAREN BERGER Montrose CA

DARCY BERGH San Diego CA

DEBI BERGSMA Fontana CA

BRYAN BERGSTRAND

Fortuna CA

JAMES BERKHEIMER

Fremont CA

SUSAN BERLIN San Rafael CA

ADOLFO BERMEO

Topanga CA

SHAUNA BERNIE Agua Dulce CA

PAULA BERRY Los Angeles CA

MARK BETTI Sherman Oaks

CA

DIRK BEVING Los Angeles CA

BLAZE BHENCE Cypress CA

NICOLE BICKEL Pittsburg CA

GINA BILWIN Solvang CA

CHERYL BIVENS buena Park CA

INGE BJARKMAN Mariannelund, Sweden

CA

NANCY BLACK Santa Barbara

CA

PAT BLACKWELL-MARCHANT

Castro Valley

CA

JILL BLAISDELL La Canada Flintridge

CA

RUSSELL BLALACK

Cupertino CA

CAROL BLANEY Redlands CA

CLARE BLOCK San Diego CA

LARRY BLOOD Santa Cruz CA

GAIL BLUMBERG Santa cruz CA

HARRY BLUMENTHAL

Eureka CA

RONALD BOGIN El Cerrito CA

CONSTANTINE BOGIOS

Walnut Creek

CA

STEPHEN BOHAC

Twain Harte CA

DIANE BOLMAN Novato CA

FRANCESCA BOLOGNINI

Cambria CA

MARIA BON BON

simi valley CA

JOSEPH BOONE San Luis Obispo

CA Save the Earth.

CAROLYN BOOR Rancho Cucamonga

CA

JOAN BORAME El Cerrito CA

MARTY BOSTIC Los Angeles CA

VIC BOSTOCK Altadena CA

RENEE BOTEILHO

Los Angeles CA

SIMONE BOUDRIOT

Tujunga CA

CYRIL BOUTEILLE Mountain View

CA

DENISE BOWLAND

Lake Elsinore

CA Protect them, please! THANK YOU!!!!

CARMI BOWLES San Francisco

CA

CANDY BOWMAN

Sacramento CA

JASON BOWMAN

Placerville CA

NANCY BOYCE San Rafael CA

KYLE BRACKEN Los Angeles CA

LAURIE BRAMLAGE

Sunnyvale CA

ELAINE BRANDT Venice CA

KELLY BRANNIGAN

Fresno CA

KEVIN BRANSTETTER

Applegate CA

OLYMPIA BRAVO

rialto CA

TIM BRELLOW Guerneville CA

NANCY BRENNER

Murrieta CA

Page 6: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

ROSALIND BRESNAHAN

San Bernardino

CA We must protect marine ecosystems.

JULIE BRICKELL Fullerton CA

KATHY BRIGGER Nuevo CA

MYRNA BRITTON

Santa Cruz CA

BARBARA BRITTON

Pleasant Hill,

CA

NANCY BRODERSEN

Glendale CA

CT BROSS Walnut Creek

CA

VERA BROWN Redwood City

CA

JAMES BROWN Los Angeles CA

MYRNA BROWN Rosemead CA

ANNE BRUNELLI San Francisco

CA

NEIL BRYDON San Diego CA

JOE BUHOWSKY San Ramon CA

SUSAN BULLEN san rafael CA

EUGENE BUNCH Alameda CA

KAREN BURMAN Felton CA

RICHARD BURNETT

Sunnyvale CA No more lax oversight and toothless enforcement, please.

ROBERT BURTON

Fowler CA

K BUSHNELL palo alto CA

RAY BUSTOS Fullerton CA

KX BX lanc CA

TAMARA CAIN Sacramento CA

PATRICIA CALLAHAN

San Francisco

CA

RONALD CALVISI Toluca Lake CA

ADOLFO CAMACHO HUMPHREY

Santa Cruz CA

VALERIE CAMERON

Woodland Hills

CA

DUDLEY AND CANDACE CAMPBELL

Valley Glen CA

JOYCE CAMPBELL

Torrance CA

MARIATERESA CANOSA

Vallejo CA

RAFAEL CANTON Ventura CA

MARINA CAPELLA

Carlsbad CA

MARK CAPPETTA

Rancho Mirage

CA

JUNKO CARD Exeter CA

GERALDINE CARD-DERR

Exeter CA

E. CARDEN San Francisco

CA

SUZANNE CARDER

San Mateo CA

CAMILLE CARDINALE

Los Angeles CA

MICHAEL CARDOZA

Los Angeles CA

JERED CARGMAN

Banning CA

ERIC CARLSON Ventura CA Thanks for giving careful attention to these issues.

VICTOR CARMICHAEL

Pacifica CA

GARY CARPENTER

Belmont CA

SETH CARR signal hill CA

CORALIE CARRAWAY

Auburn CA

MARTHA CARRINGTON

Santa Cruz CA

GEORGIA CARVER

tancho cordova

CA

JENNIFER CASE Campbell CA

ROBERT CASSINELLI

Sacramento CA

KATHRYNE CASSIS

Emeryville CA

JAMIE CASTANEDA

Sierra Madre

CA

CATHY CASTRO long beach CA

GAIL CASWELL San Francisco

CA

Page 7: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

CLOVER CATSKILL

Pinole CA

LORI CAUDILL Los Osos, CA

KIM CHAMBERLAIN

Fortuna CA

CLAIRE CHAMBERS

Murrieta CA

VICKIE CHANDLER

San Jose CA

CHRISTINA CHANG

Huntington Beach

CA

SUSAN CHAPMAN

Los Angeles CA These all important little fish support the larger fish that we love to eat. Without these smaller fish no bigger fish!

STACIE CHARLEBOIS

SEBASTOPOL

CA

JANELLE CHASE San Francisco

CA

FELICIA CHASE Encino CA

ELLIOT CHASIN Sacramento CA

ESTHER CHAVEZ NORTHRIDGE

CA

PHYLLIS CHAVEZ Santa Monica

CA

TED CHEESEMAN

Saratoga CA

J CHEN Los Angeles CA

ALLAN CHEN Alameda CA

MICH CHEN Fremont CA

ANIMAE CHI Ojai CA

ANTONIA & ANDREW CHIANIS

Blue Jay CA

R CHING Redondo Beach

CA

ROBERT CHIRPIN Northridge CA

NATALIE CHRONISTER

Camarillo CA

IRIS CHYNOWETH

Midpines CA

LEIGH CLARK Granada Hills

CA Forage fish are a critical part of the total ecosystem. Please protect them!

MELISSA CLINE santa cruz CA

MIKE CLIPKA LATHROP CA

SCOTT COAHRAN

Los Banos CA

MICHELE COAKLEY

Rancho Cordova

CA

MITCH COHEN Berkeley CA

ELEANOR COHEN

Oakland CA

BARBARA COHN Carlsbad CA

RAE COHN Los Angeles CA

REBECCA COLE Concord CA

PATRICIA COLE San Francisco

CA

JUDITH COLLAS Pacific Palisades

CA

BARBARA COMESS

Rancho Mirage

CA

DAVID COMFORT

Santa Rosa CA

DENISE COMISKEY

McKinleyville

CA

SANDY COMMONS

Sacramento CA

ARTHUR CONNOR

Idyllwild CA

HARALD CONRADI

Los Angeles CA Let's hear it for the food pyramid - forage fish are crucial.

THOMAS CONROY

Manhattan Beach

CA

MATTHEW CONTI

Sacramento CA

CRISTIAN CONTRERAS

Bell CA

CHARLOTTE COOK

sacramento CA

TIFFANY COOPER

Gardena CA

Page 8: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

MARGARET COPI

Oakland CA

DAVE CORBIN San Jose CA

NORMA COREY Redwood City

CA

PETER CORKEY San Francisco

CA

CHEREALE CORMACK

Bristol CA

BILL CORNELIUS Albion CA Please protect Pacific forage fish. Oceans have always been considered an unlimited resource, but that's false, there are limits and we need to consider them.

PATTY CORNELL los angeles CA Please help our ocean ecosystems remain sustainable!

SEAN CORRIGAN Modesto CA

RONIT CORRY Santa Barbara

CA

LISA COSSETTINI Playa del Rey

CA

LESLEE COTLOW San Francisco

CA

ROBERT COTNER grover beach

CA

PAUL COUILLARD

San Diego CA

CATHY COUSINS North Hollywood

CA

BUZZ COY Red Bluff CA

JEANNE CRABB Fremont CA

PATRICK CRAIG Guerneville CA Life is inter-dependent and must be protected for our survival.

DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

MARK CRANE Los Angeles CA

STANFORD CRANE

San Jose CA

MARK CRANE Elk Grove CA

RICHARD CRAWFORD

Ojai CA duh!

MALLORY CREMIN

Idyllwild CA Thank you for your efforts to protect the health of our ocean creatures.

PHILLIP CRIPPS Cathedral City

CA

CYNTHIA CRITTENTON

Newbury Park

CA

TOM CRONIN Davis CA

NANETTE CRONK

truckee CA

CAROLYN CROW Burlingame CA

KURT CRUGER Long Beach CA

CATHY CRUM Agoura CA

JENNIFER CRUM La Mesa CA

KERMIT CUFF Mountain View

CA

WILLIAM CUSICK Oakhurst CA

JOE CUVIELLO Solana Beach

CA

JEAN DAKOTA San Rafael CA l also under-stand that it is not just the birds that are in trouble. The seals on the California coast are dying because of lack of fish.

IDAJANE DAL PINO

Corte Madera

CA

NAMITA DALAL los altos CA

MARCIA DALE-LEWINTER

San Francisco

CA

RHEA DAMON Calabasas CA Little fish are so important

Page 9: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

for a healthy ocean. Forage fish need protection now.

ERIK DANIELS Long Beach CA

DENISE DARDARIAN

Los Angeles CA

SANDIP DASGUPTA

Pasadena CA

LYNNE DAVIES San Francisco

CA

SUE DAVIES Philo CA

MATTHEW DAVILA

Modesto CA

CLARK DAVIS Los Osos CA

YVONNE DAVIS San Diego CA

TAMMY DAVIS Los Angeles CA

ROBERT DAVIS San Diego CA

MICHELLE DAVIS Vacaville CA

CHRIS DAWSON Playa Del Rey

CA

DISNA DAY Montetey CA Please fish responsibly. Take care of the ocean environment. Thank you for supporting the environment.

MISTY DAY Fullerton CA

REBECCA DAY Palm Dezert CA

JORGE DE CECCO

Ukiah CA

VICTORIA DE GOFF

Berkeley CA

ROBERT DE GOFF

Berkeley CA

MAIA DE RAAT San Francisco

CA

VICTOR DE VLAMING

Sacramento CA

VIC DEANGELO San Francisco

CA

BRIAN DEBASITIS

San Jose CA

YVES DECARGOUET

Sebastopol CA

MICHAEL DECKER

Los Angeles CA

SUZANNE DEERLYJOHNSON

Long Beach CA

JOHN DELANEY Ventura CA

DEBORAH DEMADDALENA

Tustin CA

MARGARET DEMOTT

Sacramento CA

WENDY DERBORT

Redlands CA

RICHARD DESANTIS

Palm Desert CA

JOEL DESPAS Castro Valley

CA

PAM DEWITT Clovis CA

HELEN DICKEY El Cerrito CA

CATHE DIETRICH Berkeley CA

RICHARD DIMATTEO

San Diego CA

JONATHAN DIRRENBERGER

San Francisco

CA

LAURA DIVENERE

Los Angeles CA

RACHEL DOCHERTY

Boyes Hot Springs

CA

CODY DOLNICK Joshua Tree CA

KENYON DONOHEW

Oceanside CA

JULIE DONOHO La Verne CA

JENNIFER DOOB Alameda CA

KRISTINE DOVE Indian Wells CA

LENORE DOWLING

Los Angeles CA

MYNKA DRAPER Los Angeles CA

COURTNEY DUBOIS

San Francisco

CA

CHRIS DUCEY Woodacre CA With the Pacific gyre now contam-inated beyond belief we need to

Page 10: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

move rapidly to save and protect what's left! NOW!

ERIC DUGGAN West Sacramento

CA

LINDA DUNSMORE

Santa Cruz CA

SHERI DUREN Anaheim CA

RAM DURISETI Menlo Park CA

SAMUEL DURKIN

Fairfield CA

DAMON DUVAL Santa Monica

CA

CAROL DWORNIK

Idyllwild CA It is too bad everything has to be a battle to protect everything LIVING from selfish people.

RUTH DYKE Foresthill CA

ERIC DYNAMIC Oakland CA

BONNIE EARLS-SOLARI

Port Hueneme

CA

LINDA EBERLE Venice CA

GERHARD ECKARDT

Stockton CA

JOHN ECKL;UND Newbury Park

CA

JOANNA ECONOMAKOS

Costa Mesa CA

JOHN EDMAN Sunnyvale CA

TERESA EDMONDS

Carmel Valley

CA

BITA EDWARDS Woodacre CA

LINDA JEAN EDWARDS

Penngrove CA

CAROLE EHRHARDT

Pebble Beach

CA We need the forage fish if seabirds, ma-rine mammals and bigger fish are to have food to eat.

FRANK EICHENBERG

Santa Barbara

CA

DONIS EICHHORN, RN, PHD

Carmichael CA thank you for helping us become aware of the signif-icance of these special fish

STEVE EKLUND Salinas CA

NANCY ELLESTAD

el cajon CA

NORM ELLIS Laguna Hills CA

MARIE ELLIS Watsonville CA

ERNEST ELY San Francisco

CA

CHELSEA ENG San Francisco

CA

JULIE ENGLISH Sacramento CA

LINDA ESPINO San Diego CA Remember that seven generations from now people will be impacted by your decisions - please make the right ones for our oceans, support forage fish protections now.

JOHN ESSMAN Healdsburg CA

DOUGLAS ESTES San Francisco

CA

MICHAEL W EVANS

Los Angeles CA

SHARON EWTON

Vista CA

RITA FAHRNER San Francisco

CA

DON FAIA Aptos CA

TOM FALVEY San Diego CA

DOMINICK FALZONE

Los Angeles CA

LORNA FARNUM Rossmoor CA

Page 11: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

CHRISTINE FAZIO

San Mateo CA

MARK FELDMAN Santa Rosa CA

GRACE FELDMANN

Santa Barbara, CA

CA

ALICE J. FELIX Walnut Creek

CA

ROBIN FELLNER McKinleyville

CA

JAMES FERGUSON

Fallbrook CA

ANA-PAULA FERNANDES

Redwood City

CA

DAVID FIELD Northridge CA

JOSE FIGUEROA JR

Fremont CA

NOELLE FILICE-SMITH

Loomis CA

DEBORAH FILIPELLI, PH.D.

The Sea Ranch

CA

CHRISTINE V FINK

Stockton CA

MARK J. FIORE San Francisco

CA

MARGARET FISH Boonville CA

ZELMA FISHMAN

Los Osos CA

TED FISHMAN San Jose CA

TODD FISK San Diego CA

DONNA FLADE Beverly Hills CA

REGINA FLORES Lake Elsinore

CA

BRIAN FLORIAN Beverly Hills CA

DEBRA FLOYD Coronado CA

SARA FOGAN Santa Clarita CA

SARAH FORESTER

Bakersfield CA

KIM FORREST Los Banos CA

HAL FORSEN San Clemente

CA

ELIZABETH FOWLER

Richmond CA

KIMBERLY FOWLER

San Ramon CA

LOUIS FOX san geronimo

CA

WENDY FRADO Los Angeles CA

JENNIFER FRAISSL

Morgan Hill CA

DARREN FRALE Los Angeles CA

REX FRANKLYN Tiburon CA

CARY FRAZEE Eureka CA Forage fish are crucial to ecosystem health. Please act to protect and conserve them.

BARBARA FRAZER

Sacramento CA

ROBERT FRCEK Los Angeles CA

JODI FREDIANI Santa Cruz CA

NANCY FREEDLAND

Big Bear City CA

ISABEL FREEMAN

Topanga CA

MARK FREEMAN San Diego CA

REBECCA FREY Ukiah CA

CHRISTINE FREYTAG

Nipomo CA

DEAN FRICK San Francisco

CA

EARL FROUNFELTER

Santa Maria CA

LUIS FUENTES San Diego CA

KRISTINA FUKUDA-SCHMID

Culver City CA

GILDA FUSILIER Sacramento CA

SHERRILL FUTRELL

Davis CA

JANET G HEINLE Santa Monica

CA

MAL GAFFNEY Lompoc CA

QUERIDO GALDO

Oakland CA

TOM GALLAGHER

Burlingame CA

JOE GALLAGHER Los Angeles CA

KATHRYN GALLAGHER

San Anselmo

CA

JOSEPH GALLEGOS

El Portal CA

Page 12: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

SUZAN GALLERITO

Newport Beach

CA

SHARMA GAPONOFF

Grass Valley CA

JEFFERY GARCIA Mendocino CA All animals deserve a right to life.

STEPHANIE GARCIA

hanford CA

BARBARA GARCIA

Yosemite National Park

CA

LUIS GARCIA Anaheim CA

EVETTE GARCIA Hawaiian Gardens

CA

MICHAEL GARDEN

Sacramento CA

MARK GARMAN Cambria CA Please make changes before it is too late.

KAREN GARNETT sacramento CA

JAMILA GARRECHT

Petaluma CA

JAN GATES Napa CA

GINA GATTO Castro Valley

CA

LISA GEE La Crescenta

CA

GEMMA GELUZ Fairfield CA

MIJA GENTES Saratoga CA

CONNIE GEORGE

San Francisco

CA Please protect the forage fish that inhabit our Pacific waters. They are important in our overall marine ecosystem.

DAWN GEORGE Elk Grove CA

BALFOUR GERBER

San Francisco

CA

JOANN GERFEN Santa Maria CA

CAMILE GETTER Sacramento CA

THOMAS GILES Laguna Beach

CA

AYESHA GILL Oakland CA

NAOMI GILMORE

Sacramento CA

PHILIP GLASER Laguna Niguel

CA

CRAIG D. GLASSER

Magalia CA

JANICE GLOE Oakland CA

SANDRA GLOVER

Malibu CA

NANCY GOLDBERG

Los Angeles CA

GENE GOLDEN Rancho Santa Margarita

CA

LAUREN GOLDMAN

San Francisco

CA

ANGELICA GOMEZ

LOS ANGELES

CA

ROBERT GONDELL

Woodacre CA

ALAN GONZALEZ Long Beach CA

GREG GOODMACHER

Carlsbad CA

JAMES GOODWIN

Hollywood CA

M GOSLINE Oakland CA

ELA GOTKOWSKA

LODZ CA

MARK GOTVALD Pleasant Hill CA

KATHY GOVREAU

Morongo Valley

CA

MORTY GR West Covina CA

KATHLYN GRABENSTEIN

Costa Mesa CA I work as a monitor for a breeding colony of Least Terns. It makes a critical difference to have the correct size of forage fish available as the chicks fledge. A wide range of forage fish is vital to

Page 13: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

their breeding success.

EDWARD GRACE Camarillo CA

STEVE GRAFF Los Angeles CA

JESS GRAFFELL Yucaipa CA

CARYN GRAVES Berkeley CA

JAMIE GREEN Ventura CA

LEE GREENAWALT

Merced CA

BERT GREENBEG San Jose CA

STEPHEN GREENBERG

Nevada City CA

BECCI GREENE Petaluma CA

KEN GREENWALD

Santa Monica

CA

ERICA GRIFFIN San Francisco

CA

NICOLA GROBE Crescent City

CA

MALCOLM GROOME

Topanga CA

JOHN GROTE Oakland CA

GLORIA GROTJAN

Aptos CA

J. BARRY GURDIN

San Francisco

CA

EDDIE GUTIERREZ

Los Banos CA

VICKY GUYON Santa Clara CA

CARL GWINN Goleta CA

ALAN HAGGARD San Diego CA

LAILA HAGHSHENO-SABET

Davis CA

VIRGINIA HAHN Fremont CA

HOLLY HALL Temecula CA

PAMELA HAMILTON

sacramento CA

VICTORIA HAMMAN

San Francisco

CA

LISAÂ HAMMERMEISTER

Granada Hills

CA

DAVID HAMMOND

Willits CA

MARCELLA HAMMOND

Spring Valley

CA

JAMES HAMPSON

San Francisco

CA

GREG AND ROBIN HANDGIS

Highland CA Protect the ecosystem. Please!

SUSAN HANGER Topanga CA We must protect oceans and all of the creatures that live there-before it's too late.

STEVE HANLON Los Angeles CA

HELEN HANNA Sacramento CA

JODY HANSELL Richmond CA

MARK HANSEN Oakland CA

MOLLY HANSEN Mt Shasta CA

SAMARA HANSON

Petaluma CA

JOSEPH HARDIN Santa Monica

CA as the fish go, we go...

POLLYANA HARMON

Torrance CA Nature, wild life, marine mammals are essential to human beings.

BARBARA HARPE

Lomita CA

REBECCA HARPER

Los Angeles CA

VINCE HARPER Orange CA

JOHN HARRIS Bay Point CA

LYNDA HARRISON

Sacramento CA

ANNE HARVEY San Diego CA Here in San Diego we live with the ocean -and we want to know that it is healthy.

RICHARD HARVEY

Paso Robles CA

JOE HARVEY Arnold CA

JORDAN HASHEMI-BRISKIN

Palo Alto CA

SUSAN HATHAWAY

Pico Rivera CA

Page 14: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

JOANNE HATTUM

Diablo CA

CURTIS HAUGEBORG

Sacramento CA

LISA HAUPT Garden grove

CA

PAULA HAWKINS

San Diego CA

CHRISTINE HAYES

Upland CA

TIM HAYES San Diego CA

SARA HAYES Long Beach CA

YURIKO HAZLETT

Oxnard CA

KRIS HEAD Garden Grove

CA

SARAH HEARON Santa Barbara

CA

NANCY HECK Santa Maria CA

LIN HEIDT San Diego CA

BRIDGETT HEINLY

San Diego CA

ROSALIND HELFAND

Los Angeles CA

STEVEN HENDERSON

Cathedral City

CA

MICHAEL HENDERSON

Huntington Beach

CA

RACHELLE HENDERSON

Simi Valley CA

DONALD HENDERSON

Morro Bay CA

GRACE HENGST Los Angeles CA

MICHAEL HENSON

West Hills CA

ELIZABETH HERBERT

Santa Cruz CA

A.L. HERN Los Angeles CA

CYNTHIA HERNANDEZ

Ukiah CA

KATHERINE HERNANDEZ

Del Rey CA

ANA HEROLD Pacifica CA

RANDY HERZ San Jose CA

ELLIS HEYER San Rafael CA

WALKER HIBBEN Newport Beach

CA

LACEY HICKS Union City CA

ROBERT HICKS Long Beach CA

FRANK HILL North Hollywood

CA

VALERIE HILL Long Beach CA

SHERI HILL Santa Maria CA

LANIER HINES Redding CA

BRUCE HIRAYAMA

Los Angeles CA thanks for considering an ecosystem approach to management

KEN HOAG El Cerrito CA

BERNARD HOCHENDONER

patterson CA

ANDREA HODGES

Carmel CA

SABRINA HOGAN

Monrovia CA

SHARON HOGAN

San Leandro CA

MICHAEL HOGAN

Del Mar CA

LISA HOIVIK monterey CA

CATHY HOLDEN Sacramento CA

BRETT HOLLAND Los Angeles CA

AMANDA HOLLAND

Davis CA

PAULA HOLLIE Laguna Woods

CA

DAVID HOLLIER Crestline CA

MR. SIDNEY J.P. HOLLISTER

San Francisco

CA

CELESTE HONG Los Angeles CA

VAL HONGO-WHITING

Laguna Niguel

CA

CLARE HOOSON Belmont CA

MICIHAEL HOOVER

Los Angeles CA

ERIC HORWITZ Lake Forest CA

JAMES HUBBARD

Los Angeles CA

ANNE HUBER Los Gatos CA

M HUDSON Redondo Beach

CA

KATHRYN HUGHES

CA

Page 15: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

SIAVASH HUMAN

Santa Monica

CA

GEORGE HUMMEL

Rosemead CA

GILIA HUMRICH Forestville CA

MARTHA HUNKINS

Arcata CA

JOAN HUNNICUTT

Citrus Heights

CA Save our oceans and the animals who live in them.

PAUL HUNRICHS Santee CA

MYPHON HUNT Yuba City CA

JACKI HUNTER Hollywood CA

GRACIELA HUTH Los Angeles CA Thank you for defending the balance in nature.

STEVE HYLTON Lake Isabella

CA

KEITH IGNATOWICZ

cupertino CA

MIRIAM L IOSUPOVICI

IMPERIAL BEACH

CA

DAVID ISAAC Livermore CA

ZIA ISLAM Winnetka CA

ELIZABETH JACHE

Lemon grove

CA

LAEL JACKSON Oceanside CA

ELIZABETH JACKSON

Elk Grove CA

RON JACOB San Jose CA

DAMIAN JAMES Oakland CA

MARSHA JARVIS Pinole CA

MARILYN JASPER

Loomis CA

LYNNE JEFFRIES Laguna Niguel

CA

CHERIEL JENSEN Saratoga CA

JENN JENSEN Canyon Country

CA

LAURA JENSEN Modesto CA

DARYNNE JESSLER

Valley Village

CA

IAN JEWETT Eureka CA These fish are the base of the food chain. Without

them we are in danger of major ecosystem collapse.

ROB JOHNSON El Cajon CA

CHAD JOHNSON Long Beach CA

SUSANNE JOHNSON

Rancho Cucamonga

CA

GREGG JOHNSON

San Jose CA

CATHERINE JOHNSTON

El Cerrito CA

FREDERIQUE JOLY

Venice CA

LINDA JONES Ontario CA

GARY JONES San Marino CA

V AND B JONES Torrance CA

GARY JONES san marino CA

ALLISON JONES San Francisco

CA

SUZANNE JONES Moraga CA

LAUREL JONES Santa Monica

CA

LAURA JONES-BEDEL

San Diego CA

LANCE JORDAN san diego CA

STEPHEN JOSEPHSON

berkeley CA

LIL JUDD Sylmar CA

ANNA K Los angeles CA

MAX KAEHN Sunnyvale CA

JUDITH KAHLE Fairfield CA Aside from protecting the food web from an ecological point of view, it is also good economics. Without a viable population of forage fish, we don't have a fishing industry, and

Page 16: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

fish on our tables.

LAURA KAISER Los Angeles CA

JAN KAMPA Soquel CA

SARAH KAPLAN Oakland CA

SANDY KASPER Hemet CA

VICKI & ROD KASTLIE

San Diego CA

JOANNA KATZ Berkeley CA

MICHELE KATZ Atascedero CA

DR. GEORGE B. KAUFFMAN

Fresno CA

ANDREA KAUFMAN

Guerneville CA

JOHN M KEEFE South Pasadena

CA

LORI KEGLER San Pedro CA

LARRY KELLER Santa Cruz CA

MEGAEN KELLY Newcastle CA Isn't it about time we got it right for animals?

NANCY KELLY Oakland CA

BEV KELLY long beach CA

NANCY KELLY San anselmo CA

LISA ANN KELLY & FAMILY

Santa Barbara

CA

GLENDA KENDRICK

Fresno CA

GRETCHEN KENNEY

Redwood City

CA

JO KENNEY La Canada CA

JANET KENNINGTON

Los Angeles CA

TJ KENNY sanjose CA

ALICIA KERN Palos Verdes Peninsula

CA

J. KERR Thousand Oaks

CA

SHARON KETCHERSIDE

Lincoln CA

DR. MHA ATMA S. KHALSA

Los Angeles CA

AMRIT KHALSA Redondo beach

CA

KATHERINE KICENIUK

Santa Paula CA

HAROLD KINCHEN

Atwater CA Less forage fish means less fish for human consumption. It is just that simple.

CHERYL KINLEY PINOLE CA And then there were none? THIS CANNOT HAPPEN. Please continue to protect forge fish so that the entire eco system is able to thrive. Thank you!

GAMZE KIRCALIOGLU

south pasadena

CA

JAMES KIRKS Chico CA

SARAN KIRSCHBAUM

Los Angeles CA Protecting fish, protects us too.

PAT KITTLE Santa Cruz CA I realize human overpopulation is the most basic problem -- you might remind environmentalists of that.

CRAIG KLEBER Los Angeles CA

TRACEY KLEBER Los Angeles CA

JOSEPH KLEIN Benicia CA

DIANA KLICHE long beach CA

GEORGE F. KLIPFEL II, CLS

Cathedral City

CA

LINDA KNIGHT Kenwood CA

ELENA KNOX Pioneer CA

ANNE KOBAYASHI

San Diego CA

CINDY KOCH Long Beach CA

LAURA KOHN Hillsborough CA

JOYCE KOLASA springville CA

Page 17: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

CAROL KOMMERSTAD-REICHE

Santa Barbara

CA

KASEY KONKEL Laguna Beach

CA

STEVEN KONOPACKI

Berkeley CA

REBECCA KOO San Jose CA

VICKI KOPINSKI menifee CA

MURIEL KOTIN Malibu CA

NATALIE KOVACS

Irvine CA

ANN KOWALESKI

Los Angeles CA

JULIE KRAMER San Francisco

CA

JOSHUA KRASNOFF

Oak View CA These species contribute to a healthy ocean eco-system. They deserve protection.

L. KRAUSZ Tiburon CA

K KRUPINSKI Los Angeles CA

KATHRYN KRUSEN

San Francisco

CA

VIRGINIA KRUTILEK

Alameda CA

KATHLEEN KUCZYNSKI

Lake Forest CA

CAROL KUELPER Oakland CA

SALLY KURZ Laguna Niguel

CA

CELIA KUTCHER Capistrano Beach

CA

ISABELLA LA ROCCA

Berkeley CA

SHARON LAABS La Jolla CA

JASON LABERGE Malibu CA

LESLIE LABRIN San Fernando

CA PLEASE!

IVAN LACORE Cayucos CA

SHARON LACY Sebastopol CA

ROBERTA LAFRANCE

San Leandro CA

JANA LALANNE Mountain View

CA

STEVEN LAMERS San Bernardino

CA

KELLEY LAMKE santa rosa CA

RON LANDSKRONER

oakland CA

CATHERINE LANZL

Encinitas CA

LARRY LAPUYADE

San Anselmo

CA

JILLANA LAUFER Studio City CA We cannot continue to take all the fish out of the ocean, leaving none for the other species! It's not all about us!

CHAR LAUGHON Montara CA

THOMAS LAVIGNE

Fremont CA

KATHLEEN LAWRENCE

Cathedral City

CA

CAROL LAWRENCE

Mckinleyville

CA

WILLIAM LAWSON

calimesa CA

SCOTT LAXIER Pacific Grove

CA Greed and deceit should not dictate public policy.

JAN LEATH glendale CA

CANDY LEBLANC Placerville CA

DENNIS LEDDEN Fiddletown CA

MISHWA LEE San Francisco

CA If it wasn't for the little fish there would be no big fish

MQ LEE Stockton CA

KYRA LEGAROFF Richmond CA

VICKI LEIDNER San Francisco

CA

BILL LEIKAM Palo Alto CA

MIRIAM LEISEROFF

San Jose CA

DOUG LENIER Valley Glen CA

SHAINA LERNER oakland CA

LESLIE LESLIE Mill Valley CA

Page 18: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

DEBRA LESSARD CA We must support our ecosystem from the most minute to the largest. There is a story about what happened to Yellowstone when the wolf was re-introduced to control the deer population. A lot more happened then deer control Read it you'll be amazed.

BOGDANA LETO Los Angeles CA

SANDY LEVINE Pasadena CA

PATRICK LEWIS Emeryville CA

O LEWIS Los Angeles CA

VICTORIA LEWIS San Francisco

CA

MAXINE LEWIS oakland CA

GEORGE LEWIS Los Osos CA

SYLVIA LEWIS-GUNNING

Thousand Oaks

CA

CAROL LILLIS albion CA

CAROLYN LILLY San Diego CA For a better country for our people and our future.

OLIVIA LIM Davis CA

STEPHANIE LINAM

Benicia CA I totally agree with Cpt. Paul Watson: If the Oceans die, we all die.

KJ LINAREZ Carmichael CA

PAT LIND Shasta Lake CA Little fish are important for forage and

feed so many. Please protect forage fish without them we will lose indicator species. Our oceans are already overtaxed by acidification, over fishing, extreme pollution and global warming. Please help in any way you can and start by protecting forage fishes.

BRITT LIND Thousand Oaks

CA

ERIN LINDQUIST Carlsbad CA

COLIN LINDSLY Walnut Creek

CA

MICHAEL LIPINSKI

San Mateo CA

CHRISTOPHER LISH

Olema CA

JUDITH LITTLE Arcata CA

ELAINE LIVESEY-FASSEL

Los Angeles CA This long term degradation of our Oceans and its inhabitants MUST STOP!! Protect forage fish!!!

GILLY LLOYD San Francisco

CA

COLLEEN LOBEL San Diego CA

PEGGY LOE Magalia CA

ALAN LONG Beverly hills CA

DONA LONGACRE

Rancho Santa Margarita

CA

Page 19: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

WALLY LONGSHORE

Riverside CA

JON LONGSWORTH

aptos CA

ED LOOSLI Walnut Creek

CA

NICOLE LOPEZ-HAGAN

Pacifica CA

CATHERINE LOUDIS

San Anselmo

CA

JACKLYN LOUGHBOM

manhattan beach

CA

DARLENE LOVELL

Bakersfield CA

PATSY LOWE Simi Valley CA

JAMES LOWMAN

San Bernardino

CA

DEBRA LUCCHESI

Barstow CA

SABRINA LUIS Watsonville CA

JOSE LUIS chula vista CA

RICK LUTTMANN Rohnert Park

CA

LINDA LYERLY Cardiff by the Sea

CA This is a critical time. We really do need to stop fishing!!

ERIN LYNCH Los Angeles CA

MICHAL LYNCH Santa Barbara

CA

LOLA LYNCH Port Hueneme

CA

GEORGIA LYNN Bakersfield CA

RHONDA LYNN Sacramento CA

ELIZABETH M DAROVIC

montrey CA

DONALD MACKAY

South Pasadena

CA

MICHELLE MACKENZIE

San Carlos CA Please protect the little fish for the bigger fish, birds and mammals.

SUSANNE MADDEN

Playa del Rey

CA

LOREN MADSEN Laytonville CA

SUSAN MAGANA

tracy CA

JANET MAKER Los Angeles CA

ANDREW MALK La Jolla CA

KAREN MALLEY Anaheim CA

MARSHA MALONE

Chino CA

ROBERT MAMMON

Richmond CA

RYANN MANALO Sacramento CA

JEFF MANKER Corralitos CA As pressures on ocean resources continue to increase, I am writing to ask you to pre-emptively protect Pacific forage fish and invertebrates from future fishing pressure that could push dependent populations of seabirds into threatened or even endangered status. The Council can prevent great harm in the future by extending this protection now.

LAURA MANNING

Goleta CA

MARA MARA heraklion city creta

CA

VIRGINIA MARIPOSA

Santa Barbara

CA Don't let them starve to death.

Page 20: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

AMBER MARISCAL

Hacienda Heights

CA

PAT MARRIOTT Los Altos CA Please protect the entire food chain!

RAYMOND MARSHALL

Foresthill CA

FRANCES MARTIN

carmel CA

JOEL MASSER San Jose CA

EILEEN MASSEY Oakland CA

THOMAS MASTERSON

Chico CA

GINA MATTEUCCI

Sacramento CA

EDWARD MAUPIN

San Diego, CA

CA

TIM MAURER Anaheim CA

CASEE MAXFIELD

Los Angeles CA

GERALDINE MAY Creston CA

MARITA MAYER San Anselmo

CA

PERSEPHONE MAYWALD

Orinda CA

JACK MCCLAIN Sacramento CA

DOUGLAS MCCORMICK

Trabuco Canyon

CA

DAN MCCOY Carlsbad CA Please appreciate the importance of forage fish to the health of our oceans. They need protection!

CATHERINE MCCOY

Murrieta CA

TAMI MCCREADY

Simi Valley CA

WARD MCCREERY

Yucaipa CA Without these protections you could be out of work!!!

BETTY JO MCDONALD

Camarillo CA

MAUREEN MCGEE

Pacific Palisades

CA

DAVID MCGLOCKLIN

Davis CA How can we have a future if we don't create a sustainable fishing environment?

RICHARD MCGOWAN

San Jose CA

BRUCE MCGRAW

San Diego CA

RENE MCINTYRE San Francisco

CA

MONIQUE MCKENNON

Ontario CA

SUSAN MCLAUGHLIN

Foothill Ranch

CA

LAURIE MCLAUGHLIN

San Diego CA

ROHANA MCLAUGHLIN

San Anselmo

CA

DIANE MCLAUGHLIN

Culver City CA

TAWNY MCLELLAN

Ojai CA

MICHAEL MCMAHAN

Huntington Beach

CA

GAIL MCMULLEN

Los Angeles CA

SUSAN MCMULLEN

Lemon Grove

CA

NICK MCNAUGHTON

Los Angeles CA

PAUL MCNEELY Pasadena CA

SUSAN MCREYNOLDS

San Leandro CA

KELLY MCVEY Anaheim CA

SHERRY MEDDICK

Silverado CA Please do all you can immediately to help save these important pelagic birds. We are fishing the ocean to death.

Page 21: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

J. MEDNIS Del Mar CA

O MEDZIHRADSKY

La Jolla CA

MICHELLE MEHLHORN

Richmond CA This is so important for the future of our oceans.

LILY MEJIA Ontario CA

ROSE MA R IE MENARD

Orange CA

MOLLY MENDEZ Oakley CA

PALMA MENNO - RICE

Oxnard CA

KARYNN MERKEL

Eureka CA

JANE MERKEL Eureka CA

VINCENT MESSINEO

Sacramento CA

KATHY METERAUD-ORTIZ

Poway CA

PAULP MEYER El Sobrante CA

JAY MICKLE Sacramento CA

CHARLES MILKEWICZ

Richmond CA Let the ocean grow its own and allow small business fisherman to thrive, this happens in part when forage fish are conserved and fish farming is eliminated.

HOWARD MILLER

VENTURA CA We must take a long term view at protecting our environ-ment and all parts of it

BOB MILLER Santa Rosa CA

A MILLER Santa Monica

CA

LEE MILLER Stockton CA

STEVEN MILLER Lakeside CA

MELISSA MILLER Pleasant Hill CA

ANNIKA MILLER Mill Valley CA

MADGE MILLER Tustin CA

DEBORAH MILLER

Monterey CA

VICTORIA MILLER

Encino CA

KIRSTEN MILLER Playa Vista CA

DIANNE MILLER San Diego CA

NANCY MILLER Santa Maria CA

ROSALIND MILLIKEN

Indio CA

ELIZABETH MILLIKEN

Saint Helena CA

MELVA MILLS Sacramento CA

CHRIS MILLS Needles CA

JACK MILTON Davis CA

KENT MINAULT Sherman Oaks

CA

DAN MINER Long Beach CA

MICHAEL MISQUEZ

Pico Rivera CA

MICHELLE MITCHELL

Claremont CA Thanks so much for your help in pushing this forward!

INA MITCHELL Van Nuys CA

WILLIAM MITCHELL

Oakland CA

KAZUKO MITOSE San Diego CA

MICHAEL MITSUDA

Fremont CA

WILLIAM MITTIG Mariposa CA

CAROL MOCK Fremont CA

BIANCA MOLGORA

San Francisco

CA

CAROLYN MONE Woodside CA

JANET MONFREDINI

san francisco

CA Our attention to these issues are at the heart of quality of life going forward. Thank you for taking the

Page 22: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

time to consider my comments.

ANTHONY MONTAPERT

Ventura CA

JOHN MONTGOMERY

San Rafael CA

RICHARD MONTGOMERY

San Francisco

CA

FJAERE MOONEY

North Hollywood

CA I will sign every petition I can to let the government know that its job is to protect our resources and animals!

MALC MOORE Portola CA Insanity to wipe out the oceans for rotten capitalist ends.

ROSY MORALES Rancho Palos Verdes

CA

TOOCHIS MORIN Los Angeles CA

RAY MORRIS Bakersfield CA

SUSANNE MORTENSEN

Newport Beach

CA

LANCE MOSELEY Santa Monica

CA Help the animals stop the stupid greedy people!

MARJORIE MOSS

Del Mar CA

PHYLLIS MOTTOLA

Bishop CA

ANN MOYER Westlake Village

CA

LINDSAY MUGGLESTONE

Berkeley CA

MARK MULDER San Jose CA

LAUREN MURDOCK

Santa Barbara

CA

VERONA MURRAY

Oroville CA

ROB MYERS Anaheim CA

JOE MYERS Azusa CA

NATHAN MYERS Davis CA

KATHERINE MYSKOWSKI

Martinez CA

JEFF NADLER Oceanside CA

TOM NASH Rohnert Park

CA

SANDRA NEALON

Laguna Beach

CA

SCOTT NELSON Bethel Island

CA

BRAD NELSON Oxnard CA

ALICE NEUHAUSER

Manhattan Beach

CA

ANN NEVANS San Francisco

CA The big fish need the little fish more than we do !

ROBERTA E. NEWMAN

Mill Valley CA

ROGER NEWTON

Los Angeles CA

GINNY NICHOLS Los Gatos CA

RICK NICHOLSON

Paso Robles CA

SHARON NICODEMUS

Sacramento CA

S NICOLA los angeles CA

RANDI NIELSEN Richmond CA

BOB NIEMEROW Los Angeles CA

AMIR NIKNAM Northridge CA

CHRISTINA NILLO

W Hollywood

CA

GAYLE NOBLE boulder creek

CA

SUNNIE NOELLERT

McKInleyville

CA

CAROLYN NOLAN

Madera CA

JAMES NOORDYK

San Diego CA

LAILA NOORI San Jose CA

GREGG NORMAN

santa monica

CA

KATHEY NORTON

Sacramento CA

Page 23: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

PAUL NORUP Crescent City

CA

JOSEPH NOWAK Temecula CA

MARIA NOWICKI San Francisco

CA

BRITNEY NUCCI Manhattan Bch

CA

CARLOS NUNEZ Reseda CA

TIM OBEN Dublin CA

CATHLEEN O'CONNELL

Boulder Creek

CA

CARITA O'CONNOR

Los Alamitos CA I urge you to take action to protect critical forage fish now so that there will be fish in the future. If you have children or grandchildren, I assume you plan on them having a planet to live on. Take action to ensure that they do.

SEAN O'DAY Corte Madera

CA

ROLLIN ODELL Orinda CA

NORMA ODELL Chico CA

KELLY O'DONNELL

Los Angeles CA

EDITH OGELLA Santa Barbara

CA

AUDREY OKUBO San Jose CA

FELIPE OLARTE MEDELLIN--COLOMBIA

CA

DENISE S OLIVER Nevada City CA No forage fish = no big fish = no fishing industry. I'm glad you're there to manage the numbers, so that the

West Coast Fishery AND the fish population will keep on being there.

JERRY OLIVER Sylmar CA

ANDREW OLSEN Los Angeles CA

M. OLSON Sunnyvale CA

CHRIS OMEARA DIETRICH

San Jose CA

FRANCES ONESTI

Lawndale CA

JOHN ONSTINE Eureka CA

GERALD ORCHOLSKI

Pasadena CA Forage fish need to remain in the ocean for mammals and birds, not for the pet trade to feed domestic animals.

STEPHEN ORSARY

Corte Madera

CA

LIONEL ORTIZ Bayside CA

ROBERT ORTIZ Novato CA

SALLY OSIER LODI CA

KATHERINE OTIS Palmdale CA

TINA OVERLAND Encinitas CA

E P talmage CA

TERESA PACHILIS

Modesto CA

GRACE PADELFORD

Los Angeles CA

MICHELLE PALLADINE

Palm Springs

CA

BEATRIZ PALLANES

Santa Ana CA

ROBERT PANN Los Angeles CA

RICH PANTER Bodega Bay CA

JEFF PANTUKHOFF

San Clemente

CA

SHERRYANN PARDEE

Riverside CA

MICHELE PASCOE

Rocklin CA

JEANNIE PASCUZZI

Orange CA

Page 24: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

JOHN PASQUA Escondido CA HELP PROTECT THE FORAGE FISH.

LYNNE PATEMAN

Los Angeles CA

ART PATEY Vallejo CA

CAROL PATTON Kensington CA We need new protections on the little fish. They are part of the web and what happens to them affects the rest of the ecosystem either directly or indirectly. Please make the smart choice and assess the cost of the rest of the ecosystem before allowing them to be fished. Thank you.

JAMES PATTON Los Altos CA

SHANNON PATTY

Riverside CA

STACY PATYK Aptos CA

JEAN PAULINE Oakland CA

MARLEEN PAULUS

Hoegaarden CA

SUZANNE PEñA Fullerton CA

JULIET PEARSON Grass Valley CA

JERRY PEAVY Chico CA

DONNA PEDROZA

Alameda CA

SUSAN PELICAN woodland CA

KATHLEEN PELLEY

Eureka CA

PAUL PENARDI Big Bear Lake

CA

DAN PERDIOS Palm Springs

CA

ALDORA PEREZ Seattle CA

S PERIL El Dorado Hills

CA

JANA PERINCHIEF

Sacramento CA

MARIA PETEINARAKI

heraklion city creta

CA

MARYANN PETERS

Los Angeles CA

NANCY PETERSEN

Claremont CA

KIM PETERSON Cloverdale CA thank you

STANLEY PETERSON

Los Banos CA

NANCY PETERSON

Scotts Valley CA

JIM PETKIEWICZ San Jose CA

LINDA PETRULIAS

Cazadero CA I was able to visit a resort near the island of Misool in Indonesia for scuba diving. the resort guarded a large no take zone in cooperation with several villages. the result was large schools of forage fish like anchovies and sardines which in turn supported large schools of rays, barracuda, sharks, dolphins. everything benefited from

Page 25: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

protecting the schools of forage fish; forage fish support the entire food web and feed every living thing.

CAROLYN PETTIS Santa Clarita CA

MINDY PFEIFFER Pasadena CA Each creature has its place in helping to keep the ecosystem healthy. Please support forage fish protections.

PAT PFEIFFER Los Gatos CA

LONG PHAM Westminster

CA

TAMI PHELPS Redding CA

CHIP PHILLIPS Los Angeles CA

REGINA PHILLIPS Winnetka CA

JIM PHILLIPS Sonoma CA

BOB PHILLIPS Simi Valley CA

JIM PHILLIPS Sonoma CA

ANDY PHILPOT Solvang CA

LAUREEN PICCIANI

fort bragg CA

THOMAS PICK L.A. CA

ANNALEE PINEDA

San Francisco

CA

RENE PINEDA Hollywood CA

LINDA PINK westlake village

CA

MARY F PLATTER-RIEGER

San Diego CA

WILLIAM POGUE La Mesa CA Going, going, gone, are up to 80% of the large fish of the ocean, which we eat.

BARBARA POLAND

La Crescenta

CA

ALICE POLESKY San Francisco

CA

JOSEPHINE POLIFRONI

Danville CA Please continue to protect forage fish. Entire ecosystems depend on it.

JEANNIE POLLAK Oxnard CA

JERI POLLOCK Altadena CA

JACKIE POMIES San Francisco

CA

BEVERLY PONCIA

Lower Lake CA

SAMUEL POPAILO

West Hollywood

CA

SUSAN PORTER Pasadena CA

JOELLE PORTER Susanville CA

TED PORTER North Hollywood

CA

ANGEL PORTILLO

Pasadena CA

MARIA POSTNIKOVA

San Luis Obispo

CA

DAVID C. POWELL

Pacific Grove

CA

KAMAL PRASAD Santa Rosa CA

RON PRICE Ontario CA I am very grateful for your work and dedication, preserving our environment.

LYNN PRICE South Lake Tahoe

CA

ALLAN PRIVAL Santa Monica

CA

PENELOPE PROCHAZKA

Simi Valley CA

JAMES PROVENZANO

Los Angeles CA

PAULA PRUNER North Hollywood

CA

LAUREL PRZYBYLSKI

Oakland CA

RICHARD PUAOI Novato CA

Page 26: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

FELENA PUENTES

Bakersfield CA

STEVE PURVIS Santa Monica

CA Please protect the Pacific forage fish.

D.MICHAEL QUINN

Rancho Cucamonga

CA

L R Los Angeles CA

K R San leandro CA

URSELA RABE Penn Valley CA besides ethical considerations, it is obvious that if we upset the balance of Nature and diminish the food chain, we will pay for it later.

CAROLIN RADCLIFF

Sacramento CA Forage fish are important for the entire ocean eco system. You take them out of the equation, and everything suffers down the line. We already have massive die offs of seabirds, because they can't feed themselves!

RUTA RADZINS San Francisco

CA

BRAD RAE Lake Forest CA

CHRISTINE RAFFETTO

healdsburg CA

ANNETTE RAIBLE

Petaluma CA

GAIL RAINS Sacramento CA

PAUL RAMOS Santa Ynez CA

RUDY RAMP Arcata CA

WALTER RAMSEY

Oakley CA

PHILLIP RANDALL

Woodland Hills

CA

LOUISE RANGEL SANTA PAULA

CA

BARBARA RASMUSSEN

San Diego CA

CYNTHIA RATLIFF

Santa Cruz CA This is a very important matter that needs an immediate response. I have long been c.oncerned about the protections for forage fish. Please act swiftly

KAREN RATZLAFF

Santa Rosa CA

MARIA RAUSIS Mountain View

CA

WENDY RAYMOND

Monrovia CA This is imperative for the health of our oceans

JOSEPH RAZO Camarillo CA

ANN READ Inverness CA

MARK REBACK Los Angeles CA

STEPHEN REBELLO

Los Angeles CA

ROBERT REED Lake Elsinore

CA

ANDREW REICH Los Angeles CA

JENA REID temecula CA

JENA REID Temecula CA

MISTI REIF San Francisco

CA

ROBIN REINHART

San Diego CA do not miss this opport-unity. This is essential!

Page 27: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

GARY REINOEHL Pioneer CA

LISA REMBOLD Canoga Park CA

ANN RENNACKER

Fort Bragg CA You cannot remove anything from the web of life without disastrous results to the food chain.

RANDY REPASS Watsonville CA

R. REYES san luis obispo

CA we can save what they & may be save ourselves.

DALE REYNOLDS Glendale CA

EVE REYNOLDS Los Angeles CA

SANDRA REYNOLDS

Windsor CA

JOSEPH RHOADES

Vacaville CA

JAY RICE Novato CA

MARIA RICH Lomma CA Protect our oceans and animals

MICHAEL C. FORD AND RICHARD B. MARKS

Watsonville CA

JUDITH RICHEY Discovery Bay

CA

LYNETTE RIDDER Concord CA

LINDA RIEBEL Lafayette CA It's a no-brainer to save the base of the food web.

NANCY RIGGLEMAN

tollhouse CA

MARTIN RILEY Corona CA

CALLIE RILEY Citrus Heights

CA

LAURA RILEY Citrus Heights

CA

JOSEPH RISSETTO

Chula Vista CA

ALISA RISSO Rsm CA I only purchase sustainably managed and caught fish. Now please do your part to insure my efforts are not in vain.

BARBARA ROBBIN

Studio City CA

ROB ROBERTO Santee CA

GAIL ROBERTS Tecate CA Our oceans are dying, we must all do whatever we can to protect them and all the sea creatures.

CRISTINA ROBERTS

El Centro CA

LES ROBERTS fresno CA

GAIL ROBERTS Tecate CA

SANDRA ROBERTS

Hayward CA

STEVE ROBEY Berkeley CA

JESSICA ROBIE San Diego CA

ETTA ROBIN Bakersfield CA

FLORENCE ROBIN

DAVIS CA

RICHARD ROBINSON

Manhattan Beach

CA

RICHARD ROBINSON

Fresno CA

SIDNEY ROBLES Napa CA

PRISCILLA ROCCO

Costa Mesa CA

CANDACE ROCHA

Los Angeles CA

MARYKAY RODARTE

Phelan CA We do need to protect the forage fish, the entire chain of fish depend on the forage fish to

Page 28: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

support the ocean food webs.

MARY RODRIGUEZ

Redwood City

CA

KATHLEEN ROGERS

Paramount CA

PATRICIA ROGERS

Concord CA

CONNIE ROGERS Gilroy CA

LENORE ROIZ San Francisco

CA Protect life in the oceans before there is no life at all!!!

MARY ROJESKI Santa Monica

CA We eat seafood WHAT does seafood eat???

NORA ROMAN San Francisco

CA

CYNTHIS ROMER San Francisco

CA

ROBERTO ROMO

San Francisco

CA

DIANE ROONEY El Cerrito CA Forage fish are critical food for larger creatures - their populations need to be protected and increased.

BARBARA ROOT Merced CA

JESSIE ROOT Oceanside CA

MARY ROSE Berkeley CA

CARLA ROSELLI hollywood CA

BOB ROSENBERG

Kentfield CA

RICHARD AND CAROLYN ROSENSTEIN

Los Angeles CA

MICHAEL E ROSS El Portal CA

M ROSS San Rafael CA

MICHAEL ROTCHER

Mission Viejo

CA

STEVE ROTH Santa Rosa CA

RALPH ROUG lake forest CA

PATI ROUZER Palo Alto CA Please support protections for our coastal birds and other sea life. Thank you!

ALLEN ROYER San Jose CA

LIANE RUDBERG Burbank CA We are All Nature. We are ALL ONE... Time to wake up and stop just following in customs that are outdated

LEE RUDIN Daly City CA

MARK RUDNINGEN

Citrus Heights

CA

DAVID RUGER Los Angeles CA

RIKJE MARIA RUITER

Utrecht CA

CHYRL A. RUSSELL

Blue Jay CA

CAROL RUTH Stanford CA

TIM RYAN Capistrano Beach

CA

KATHLEEN RYAN Lakewood CA

KATHERINE RYKOWSKI

Desert Hot Springs

CA Wake up - What will we eat and how will you make a living if there are no fish?

C S sdiego CA Please protect the foundation of our oceans - protect forage fish now! Thank you.

GAIL SABBADINI Lakeside CA

NINA SAGHEB San Diego CA

Page 29: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

DON SAITO SAN JOSE CA We need to protect what little natural resources we have left.

ALICIA SALAZAR Los Angeles CA

ROSALIE SALVATO

Burbank CA

JOAN SANDER Arcadia CA Please protect critical forage fish!!!

MICHAEL SANDLER

Los Angeles CA

GUSTAVOÂ SANDOVALÂ

San Mateo CA

MICHAEL SARABIA

Stockton CA

JANET SARNOFF Los Angeles CA

MARIJEANNE SARRAILLE

Pittsburg CA

JULIE SASAOKA Concord CA

PATRICIA SAVAGE

Mammoth Lakes

CA

LINDA SAVAGELINDASAVAGE

San leandro CA

CAROL SAWYERS Santa Cruz CA

DONATELLA SCABINI

El Cerrito CA

SUE SCHAAR laguna niguel

CA

KIRA SCHABRAM Valley Springs

CA

MICHELLE SCHAMACH

Petaluma CA

ALAN SCHENCK Sunnyvale CA

LAUREN SCHIFFMAN

El Cerrito CA

BENJAMIN SCHLAU

Los Angeles CA

HENRY SCHLINGER

Burbank CA

WILLIAM SCHOENE

Santa Monica

CA Thank you for your ecologically insightful approach to protecting the food

chains of commercial fish and other marine life.

ERNEST SCHOLZ SAN FRANCISCO

CA

KAREN SCHORTEMEYER

Point Arena CA Thank you for all you do to aid & protect forage fish.

BRANDY SCHUMACHER

Citrus Heights

CA

RICHARD SCHWAGER

Santa Barbara

CA We will starve ourselves AND the other fish eaters if we f up the food chain.

DON SCHWARTZ Larkspur CA

ALAN SCHWARTZ

Oxnard CA

DENA SCHWIMMER

Los Angeles CA

HEIDI SCOTT Kloof CA Protect Pacific Forage Fish before its too late!!!!

LAUREL SCOTT San Diego CA

DEANNA SEAGRAVES

Corralitos CA This past year we had a vivid demonstration of the importance of forage fish when millions (if not billions) of anchovies appeared in Monterey Bay, followed by everything from whales to sooty shearwaters to tuna, in

Page 30: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

great numbers. People flocked to the bay to see these amazing creatures, including us locals! But this is such a rare occurrence, no one could remember seeing such a thing before.

CHRIS SEATON Santa Barbara

CA

JO SEBERN Fallbrook CA

CARL SEBERN Fallbrook CA

FRANK SEEWESTER

Fairfield CA

LISA SELBY Santa Rosa CA

JENNIFER SELLERS

Concord CA

ROB SELTZER Malibu CA

LINDA SHADLE Anaheim CA

BETH SHAFER Huntington Beach

CA

KOOROSH SHAHIDZADEH

San Jose CA

GERALD SHAIA Sun Valley CA

EVAN SHAMOON

Los Angeles CA

SUSAN SHAPIRA San Rafael CA

VIRIGNIA SHARKEY

Santa Rosa CA

PATRICIA SHARP Grass Valley CA First and foremost...do no harm.

DR LINDSAY SHARP

Topanga CA Please help ensure success of this provision. Thank you.

ANORE SHAW San Ramon CA

MAUREEN SHEA San Francisco

CA

STEPHEN SHEARER

SAN FRANCISCO

CA

GABRIEL SHEETS Merced CA

MARILYN SHEPHERD

Trinidad CA

WAYNE SHERIDAN

San Francisco

CA

RICHARD SHERMAN

Berkeley CA

SUNDAE SHIELDS

oxnard CA

MARTHA SHOGREN

Sebastopol CA

ELIZABETH SHORE

San Anselmo

CA

DIANA SHREVES Vista CA

JOSEPH SHULMAN

San Diego CA

MARGUERITE SHUSTER

Sierra Madre

CA

MERCY SIDBURY sebastopol CA

SHEILA SILAN Somerset CA

ULY SILKEY Oakland CA We need a balance otherwise we will tip off the edge as well. Please be considerate. Thank you.

JON SILVER Portola Valley

CA

DAN SILVER Los Angeles CA

MARC SILVERMAN

Los Angeles CA

TWIKIE SIMMS Anaheim CA

ANITA SIMONS La Jolla CA

VIRGINIA SKELTON

Bonsall CA

STACEY SKLUTE Los Angeles CA

RICHARD SKWAREK

Santa Rosa CA

RAVEN SKY Berkeley CA We have a moral, ethical and humane obligation to ensure that

Page 31: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

there is more than enough for all the wildlife that rely on the salmon and other forage fish.

NANCY SLANGER

Piedmont CA

JULIE SLATER-GIGLIOLI

West Hollywood

CA

PAM SLATER-PRICE

Del Mar CA

ROSEMARIE SMALLCOMBE

Mariposa CA

JUDY SMARIO-JOHNSON

Hayward CA

JULIE SMITH Los Osos CA

BRET SMITH Santa Cruz CA

NANCY SMITH San Diego CA

LESLIE SMITH oakland CA

PAT SMITH Boulder Creek

CA

BELINDA SMITH Anaheim CA

ROGER SMITH Belmont CA

NANCY SMITH Santa Monica

CA

MARGUERITE SMUKLER

Berkeley CA

ALICIA SNOW San Francisco

CA

DAVID SOARES Pollock Pines

CA

RACHEL SONNENBLICK

Santa Cruz CA

JOYCE SORTLAND

Grass Valley CA

EDY G SOTO Sylmar CA

MIKE SOUZA San Diego CA

CHRIS SPANOS Los Angeles CA

GREGG SPARKMAN

Palo Alto CA

DONITA SPARKS Los Angeles CA Save our forage fish! Save our oceans!

RICK SPARKS Toluca Lake CA

KATHRYN SPENCE

Moraga CA

JEREMY SPENCER

Pacifica CA

LESLIE SPOON Los Osos CA

JERE SPRINGER Glendora CA

SHARON SPROUSE

San Diego CA

IRENE SRIBOONWONG

walnut CA

JOHN STALLONE San Jose CA

DAWN STANDLEY

Santa Maria CA

JUDY STANTON dana point CA

RELF STAR Claremont CA

JAMES STARK Berkeley CA

CARRIE STATON Santa Cruz CA

CHERYLE STEELE La Habra CA

CHARLEEN STEEVES

Topanga, CA

MIRELLA STEFAN

Redwood City

CA

WAYNE STEFFES Redding CA

BONNIE STEIGER San Francisco

CA

JOSEPH STEINBERGER

San Francisco

CA

NEAL STEINER Los Angeles CA

JOHN STEPONAITIS

San Francisco

CA

ROBERTA STERN Oakland CA

CHRISTINE STEWART

Escondido CA

MICHAEL STEWART

Elk Grove CA

REBECCA STEWART

Sacramento CA

VIRGINIA STEWART CARTON

Orinda CA This is so serious an issue that it is surprising that officials even need a petition or any other solicitation to prompt and encourage doing the

Page 32: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

CORRECT things to protect forage fish!

MIKA STICKFORD

Nevada City CA

RON STOCK Paso Robles CA

LINDA STOCK Cypress CA

JANINE STOKES Riverside CA

CONNIE STOMPER

Santa Barbara

CA

RUSSELL STONE San Jose CA

JEANETTE STONE

Menifee CA

MIKA STONEHAWK

Tustin CA

MICHELLE STORACE

Danville CA

FAITH STRAILEY Quincy CA

MARISA STRANGE

Long Beach CA

GERALD STRATMAN

Glen Ellen CA

ANTHONY STRATTON

Elk Grove CA

MARJORIE STREETER

Alameda CA

CAITLIN STROM-MARTIN

Sebastopol CA

SANDY STUHAAN

Ridgecrest CA

STEVE SUGARMAN

Malibu CA

SANDRA SULLIVAN

Orinda CA

JAMES SULLIVAN

Santa Cruz CA

KIAYU SUN Laguna Beach

CA

MELISSA SUNDERLAND

Sherman Oaks

CA

SUZANNE SUTTON

Roussillon CA We are all part of the network of our beautiful planet that GIVES us everything free of charge.

Please protect all species.

CONSTANCE SUTTON

Berkeley CA

SUSAN SWAN Carlsbad CA I am counting on your leadership to do the right thing.

GEOFFREY & LINDA SYMCOX

Pacific Palisades

CA

RUSSELL SYMONDS

Costa Mesa CA

JOSEPH SZABO Los Angeles CA

MARGARET T.M. PETKIEWICZ

San Jose CA

KENNETH TABACHNICK

West Hills CA

LINDA TABB North Hills CA Protect the Pacific Forage Fish!!

BARBARA TACKER

Camarillo CA

CAROL TAGGART

Menlo Park CA

CAROL TAO Salinas CA

EMILY TAYLOR Los Angeles CA

J. HOLLEY TAYLOR

Penn Valley CA

TIMOTHY TAYLOR

Los Angeles CA

TANNY TAYLOR santa barbara

CA

MARCIA TAYLOR yorba linda CA

ROBERT TEISTER sonoma CA Thank you for u'r efforts to protect the ocean ecosystem. seems like a near impossible task. under the capitalisitic system, everything seems targeted for abuse. i am

Page 33: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

encouraged by your focus on science rather than politics. i do wonder if the politicians have the power and the resolve to act in the best interest of the sea creatures, as opposed to the lobbiest demands.

CINDY TEJEDA Los Angeles CA

ELIZABETH THATCHER

McKinleyville

CA

CONNIE THOMAS

Eureka CA Massive scientific evidence makes clear the catastropic cascade effect when any part of an eco-system is eliminated.

CARRIE THOMAS Huntington Beach

CA

ELEANOR THOMAS

Livermore CA

MARY THOMAS Richmond CA

JASON THOMAS Shasta Lake CA

BONNIE THOMPSON

Los Osos CA If we don't protect the small fish, we'll surely lose the large fish. Thank you for considering the importance of the entire food web.

STACY THOMPSON

Alta Loma CA

LAWRENCE THOMPSON

Livermore CA

BRAD THORN LA CA

GARY THORNBRUGH

Kernville CA Forage fish are the foundation of the marine ecosystem. Thank you for protecting that ecosystem.

CATHY THORNBURN

los angeles CA

NADYA TICHMAN

Oakland CA

AMBER TIDWELL Los Angeles CA

GABRIELA TILL Escondido CA

LORI TISHGART Oakland CA

MIRANDA TODD redondo beach

CA

JUSTIN TOLEDO San Diego CA

MICHAEL TOMCZYSZYN

San Francisco

CA

MICHAEL TOMLINSON

Sacramento CA

ANDY TOMSKY san marcos CA

SHEILA TONER Auburn CA

MICHAEL TOOBERT

Grass Valley CA

NATALIE TORRE bh CA

TATIANA TORRES

Los Angeles CA

JENNIFER TOTH Santa Clarita CA

KAREN TOYOHARA

La Mesa CA

GENE R. TRAPP Davis CA

CAROL TREDO Eureka CA

MATT TRITT Atascadero CA

SUSAN TRIVISONNO

San Jose CA

VETZA TRUSSELL Cherry valley

CA

MARY TULLOCK Rohnert Park

CA

GABRIELLA TUREK

Pasadena CA

Page 34: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

JEAN TURLEY-SINCLAIR

Grass Valley CA Everything must be done to protect our environment; this Earth is our home and the home of all of God's creatures.

JOY TURLO Redondo Beach

CA

PAMELA TURNER

Oakland CA

CANAN TZELIL Beverly Hills CA

SYLVIA VALDEZ Bishop CA

ALI VAN ZEE Oakland CA

MAUREEN VANDERBOSCH

Laguna Niguel

CA

ELIZABETH VANDERVEN

Pasadena CA

MARJANNE VANGENECHTEN

Stad CA

ROBIN VANTASSELL

San Rafael CA

SHERRY VATTER Los Angeles CA

REUBEN VEEK Mountain View

CA

JORGE VELEZ San Jose CA

AMY VELOZ Van Nuys CA

SHERRI VENEZIA Davis CA The eco-systems of the ocean need to be whole so all species can utilize the interdependency and survive.

ANNE VERALDI San Francisco

CA

ENRICO VERGA Seal Beach CA

PAUL VESPER Berkeley CA

SHARON VICKERY

Adelanto CA

JANICE VIETH Covina CA

SHERROL VOIGT Huntington Beach

CA Please take action on this dire issue.

JAMES VOLLARO Lake Elsinore

CA

JOE AND MARY VOLPE

Ventura CA

BRUCE VON ALTEN

Yreka CA

KAY VON TRESS Menlo Park CA

DONNA J WAGNER

Pacifica CA

MANA-JEAN WAGNON

Alameda CA

DEBORAH WALDEN

Diamond Bar

CA

JOAN WALKER Bishop CA

JAMES WALKER McKinleyville

CA

ROBERT WALLACE

Whittier CA

VICTORIA WALLACE

Dulzura CA

ANNE WALLACE Grass Valley CA

SHIRLEY WALLACK

Santa Rosa CA

ROBERT WALLER San Diego CA

ERNIE WALTERS Union City CA

STEVE WALWORTH

la crescenta CA protect ecologically important areas of ocean habitat

NATHAN WALWORTH

los angeles CA

DEE WARENYCIA Roseville CA

CHARLES WARNER

Fontana CA

TRISTAN WARREN

Fairfax CA A healthy marine ecosystem will benefit all in the long run. Please put in place rules to protect the food web, so we do not later have to rebuild it.

Page 35: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

RONALD WARREN

Glendale CA

CAROLYN WATKINSON

atwater CA

MICHAEL WATSON

Sonoma CA

LEONARD WAY Rowland Heights

CA

ANNE WAYMAN National City

CA they need protection so the whole food chain doesn't collapse.

WILLIAM WEAVER

Folsom CA

HENRY WEINBERG

Santa Barbara

CA

JOAN WEINER San Anselmo

CA forage fish should never ever be harvested for pet food or fertilizer. Let the Japanese eat whatever they can catch off of their islands - VERY shortsighted and stupid to destroy our eco-system over here for few bucks.

VINCE WEIS sacramento CA

JOE WEIS Reedley CA

LYNNE WEISKE Los Angeles CA

RICHARD WEISS Thousand Oaks

CA Keep up the great work. This is the stuff of history and greatness, the survival of our planet.

ARLEEN WEISS San Lorenzo CA

RUSSELL WEISZ Santa Cruz CA

STEPHEN WEITZ Oakland CA

GUY WESTGAARD

Laguna Beach

CA Without the pyramid of food all life ceases to exist. Please protect our seas from greed and over fishing.

LUANN WHERRY San Diego CA

LINDA WHETSTINE

Poway CA

MICHAEL WHICKER

Sacramento CA

MARY PAT WHITE

berkeley CA

ALTA WHITLOCK El Cajon CA

ERIKA WHITTON Irvine CA

JOHN WIESNER Castro Valley

CA

RICHARD WIGHTMAN

Arcadia CA

WANDIS WILCOX

aptos CA

CAROL WILEY Victorville CA

CANDACE WILHELM

Redwood City

CA

ROB WILKERSON San Diego CA

JENNIFER WILL Morgan Hill CA

SUSAN WILLHOIT

Cardiff by the Sea,

CA When we lose a healthy Ocean....we lose a healthy earth.

YVETTA WILLIAMS

Rancho Palos Verdes

CA All the life forms that live near or in the ocean depend on these fish. Need to have a healthy population

JAYNA WILLIAMS

Pomona CA

LESLIE WILLIAMS

El Cajon CA

JOSH WILLIS San Diego CA

ELAINE WILSON Torrance CA

DAVE WILSON Palmdale CA

Page 36: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

ARLENE WILTBERGER

San Carlos CA

KEN WINDRUM Los Angeles CA

BETTY WINHOLTZ

morro bay CA

JOIE WINNICK Sherman Oaks

CA

K. WINNICK Los Angeles CA

LESLIE WINSTON Redondo Beach

CA

ANITA WISCH Valencia CA

TOM WISHING San Francisco

CA

AMANDA WITHROW

Los Angeles CA

WENDY WITTL Santa Barbara Ca

CA

JESSICA WODINSKY

Los Angeles CA

MARC WOERSCHING

Valley Village

CA

JOSH WOLF Half Moon Bay

CA

IVAN WOMBOLDT

Palm Springs

CA We are all one organism finely engraved in the mind of G_D. Please support sustainability

MICHELLE WONG

South Pasadena

CA

THERESA WONG Oakland CA

THOMAS WOOLARD

Fresno CA

SUSAN WORDEN Rio Vista CA

MADELINE WRIGHT

Los Angeles CA

DENISE WRIGHT Los Angeles CA

SHEILA WYSE Sherman Oaks

CA

STEVE YAFFEE Long Beach CA

REV GREGORY YAROSLOW

Redlands CA

ALEXANDER YEUNG

Clovis CA

HOLLY YOKOYAMA

Rancho Cucamonga

CA

CAROL YOTHERS Whittier CA

ANITA YOUABIAN

Beverly Hills CA

VINCENT YOUNG

Upland CA

DENNIS YOUNG Shell Beach, CA

A YOUNG Carmel CA

JOY ZADACA Long Beach CA

GUY ZAHLLER Aptos CA

DALIA ZATKIN Oakland CA

SANDRA ZELASKO

Valley Center

CA

JOHANNE ZELL Camarillo CA

SILVANA ZELMANOVICH

bsas CA

ARLENE ZIMMER Rancho Palos Verdes

CA

KATIE ZUKOSKI Chico CA

PATRICIA ZYLIUS Santa Cruz CA

HARRIET ADAMS Eugene OR

ANTHONY ALBERT

Corvallis OR

SKYLAAR AMANN

Portland OR

HECTOR R. AMARO

Salem OR

CAROL AMPEL Medford OR

HELEN ANDERSON

Gladstone OR

HAL ANTHONY Grants Pass OR This world is a fragile and complex as our own bodies. If children matter, make every decision sustainable.

BARBARA ARLEN Corvallis OR

ROBERT ASKEY Newberg OR Looking to prevent a problem and create a viable future is really a great plan. We need the forage bait fish that

Page 37: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

many species of animals and fish need to flourish.

SUSANNA ASKINS

Portland OR

SARA W. BAKER Portland OR

JOHN BARGER Portland OR

ROSE BARKER Salem OR Thank you for caring about this urgent matter!!! It's bigger than you and I today - it's about our future.

BRUCE BAUER Medford OR A couple of years ago I was on the island of Maui Hawaii. I went on a sub and several minutes went by before I saw any fish!

BECKY BELL-GREENSTREET

North Bend OR

ANN BERGMANN

Corvallis OR

TERRI BETZ Sutherlin OR It's the little things that matter! Especially to the big things! Thanks!

DANA BLECKINGER

Yachats OR

SHEILA BOB Portland OR

WILLIAM BODDEN

Redmond OR

PATTY BONNEY Portland OR

PAUL BORCHERDING

La Grande OR

CAROL BOSWORTH

Portland OR

KARA BRAY Portland OR

TARA BROCK Portland OR

CASSANDRA BROWNING

Salem OR

STEVE CAMPBELL

Eugene OR

LYNDA CAPEL Albany OR

TOM CAPEL Albany OR

PATRICIA CARCASSES

portland OR

DENNIS CARNEY Gaston OR

TASHA CARPENTER

Deer Island OR

SANDY CARTER corvallis OR

MV CASSELL eugene OR

RITA CASTILLO Springfield OR

EILEEN CHIECO Ashland OR

MARTY CLANCY Tigard OR

BLYTHE CLARK-MCKITRICK

Portland OR

TACEY CONOVER

Eugene OR

CAROL COONS redmond OR Please protect these valuable fish!!

JACKIE CRITSER Aloha OR Every effort we can make to ensure balanced and healthy ecosystems is important to protecting our children's future. For that, you need intelligent management of resources. In nature, even tiny things can make huge impacts on whether a give ecosystem remains vital.

Page 38: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

SCOTT CROCKETT

Florence OR

JAKE CULVER portland OR

R S D Dexter OR

AMY DANIELSON

Portland OR

JAY DEE Portland OR

TONY DEFALCO Portland OR

SUSAN DELLES rogue river OR

D. DELOFF ALoha OR

BENITO DELTORO

Barcelona OR

KAREN DEORA Portland OR

HARRIS DUBIN eugene OR

GWEN DUDLEY Dallas OR

DAVE DUNKAK Portland OR

BEN EARLE Portland OR

NIC ELDRIDGE Portland OR

DIANNE ENSIGN Portland OR I care about protecting the oceans and the diversity of life they support.

PAULA EPPLER Milwaukie OR

RANDALL ESPERAS

Bend OR

MELANIE FEDER Philomath OR

SHERRYLEE FELGER

Port Orford OR Thank you for your proactive actions that look to the future.

JAMIE FILLMORE Beaverton OR

CHERYL FISHER Milwaukie OR

LAURIE FISHER Tigard OR

LAURA FLEMING Eagle Point OR

TERESA FLOYD Boring OR

LORRAINE FOSTER

Portland OR

MATT FREEDMAN

Eugene OR

ARLENE FROMER

Portland OR

FRAN FULWILER Portland OR

JIM AND SUSAN GEEAR

Medford OR

JON GIBBS lebanon OR

MIKE GIBSON North Bend OR

GARY GILARDI Hood River OR

LYF GILDERSLEEVE

Portland OR Thanks for all your hard work protecting forage fish.

MONICA GILMAN

estacada OR

JAMES GILMORE Portland OR

RICHARD GLASS Eugene OR Please keep the ocean's food chain intact. Thank you.

RICHARD GORRINGE

Portland OR

MICHAEL GOTMER

Eugene OR

PATRICK GRADY Grants Pass OR

PAULINE GRAVIER

McMinnville OR

BARB GREEN Clatskanie OR We have to do this!

PAUL GRYCKO Lake Oswego

OR

VALERIE GUINAN

Bend OR

DODY H jacksonville OR

SARAH HAFER Portland OR

GEORGE HAGUE Astoria OR

CLAUDIA HALL Beaverton OR The greatness of a nation & its moral progress can be judged by the way its animals are treated. Mahatma Gandhi America was beautiful, animals thrived, the air was clear, the water clean....then, man dis-covered the continent. Since that

Page 39: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

time, we have placed our environ-ment in jeopardy. We have fouled the air & dirtied the waters. We have caused the extinction of species, in the air, on the land, & in the sea! I beg you, please, do not allow the greed of a few, to destroy the lives of many!!! Listen to your conscience...consider & adopt comprehensive conservation & recovery measures, save the little fish, which translates to save lives! Please, encourage the fishery management council to protect the little fish who feed the bigger fish, seabirds, & marine mammals! This is the oceans circle of life! This is the circle which will nourish and enrich all life. When you initiate measures to protect forage species, you protect &

recognize the importance of all sea life; ultimately, you protect human life! If you have men who will exclude any of god creatures from the shelter of compassion & pity, you will have men who will deal likewise with their fellow men. St. Francis of Assisi envision the restoration of clear air, clean water, the importance of all, no matter the size, then, life which will flourish! Now turn that vision to reality! Thank you, for reading my plea.

CAMILLE HALL Corvallis OR

CHAD HALSEY Salem OR

JOAN HAMILTON

Eugene OR Forage fish are the bases of all other life.

BOB HANNIGAN Corvallis OR

JAMES HANSEN portland OR

KIM HARRIS Springfield OR Please save our ecosystem with accountability and thought for our world and how we're affecting it. We can't keep taking

Page 40: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

and taking and not think there will not be consequences. Thank you.

RANDY HARRISON

Eugene OR

HELEN HAYS Oregon City OR

SUSAN HAYWOOD

Portland OR We must protect the ocean as a system; forage fish are a critical food supply for larger animals.

LINDA HENDRIX Bend OR

KATHLEEN HENLEY

Portland OR

DAVID HERMANNS

Portland OR

ROBERT HINELY Sheridan OR

MARCUS HINZ Tillamook OR

NANCY HISER Portland OR

EUGENE HOGAN Newport OR

NANCY HOMMEL

Eugene OR

KAREN HORTON Independence

OR

OSALYN HOUSER

Albany OR

LORI HOWK Portland OR In addition to the inherent value of forage fish species, they provide sustenance to marine mammals and numerous aquatic species. Please act now to protect them before we feel the negative

impacts of their loss.

JAY HUMPHREY Estacada OR

FRED INGRAM Portland OR We take care of the ocean and it will take care of us.

EVAN JACKSON Philomath OR

OMAR JAFF portland OR

GWEN JAMESON

Philomath OR

PATRICIA JANESH

Portland OR Sustainability is one of the most important concepts for a healthy product future for fish life as well as human life. Protecting forage fish is sustainability

LARS JEFFERSON Albany OR

T JEFFRIES Bend OR I hope you will do the best for the critical ocean creatures. That means affording them the highest level of protection possible.

D. WIESE JONES Portland OR We must protect the forage fish to maintain a healthy ocean ecosystem. They may be small, bu they're vital for a productive, healthy sea.

SANDRA JOOS Portland OR

Page 41: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

JOHN JORDAN Bend OR

FRANKLIN KAPUSTKA

Beaverton OR

MARGARET KEENE

White City OR

DIANA KEKU Lincoln City OR

WAYNE KELLY Ashland OR

BETTY KENNEDY Coos Bay OR

CATHERINE KEYS Medford OR

SUZANNE KINDLAND

Cannon Beach

OR

DAVE KING Portland OR

FRAN KLABUNDE

Beaverton OR

CHRISTINE KLEIMAN

Ashland OR

BASEY KLOPP Bend OR

ROGER KOFLER Portland OR It only makes sense that if you are going to protect a species of anything to also protect that species food supply.

WILLIAM LEE KOHLER

Eugene OR

ALEX KOPAC Salem OR

JENNIE LEAVER Ottawa OR Over fishing is a major concern that is causing huge problems in our eco-system. Don't humans have enough already?

PAT LEBARON Medford OR

SHARON LEE BEND OR

RUBA LEECH Portland OR

CAREN LIEBMAN Eugene OR

STU LIP eugene OR

KARLA LONG Albany OR

AARON LONGTON

Port Orford OR Don't steal my fishes food bro!

DAVID MACEIRA Salem OR

RICH MACKIN Portland OR

KENDRA MADDEN

elmira OR

LAUREN MAGNEE

Portland OR

MARIANNE MALEN

Beaverton OR No fish. Less food. Thanks for your work in this regard.

JOY MAMOYAC Corvallis OR

HEATHER MARSH

Lake Oswego

OR

NIKKI MARTIN Mount Angel

OR

SETSUKO MARUKI-FOX

Grants Pass OR

LISA MATTHEWS Medford OR

BRUCE MCCULLOUGH

Estacada OR

BARBARA MCDONALD

Beaverton OR

WENDY MCGOWAN

Eugene OR

MICHELE MCKAY Bend OR

WENDY MCKEE Corvallis OR It's becoming clear that the web of life includes all species, not just iconic ones. Please continue fighting for maintaining the populations of all ocean species.

JERRY MELTON Corvallis OR

H MILLARD Salem OR

ROBERT MILLER Portland OR

IRENE MILLS Portland OR We don't own this planet; we just borrow it from our children.

Page 42: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

GREGORY MONAHAN

Portland OR We need to be thinking about the ocean food chain as a system in order to protect our future food supply which will also protect the environment.

KIM MUESKE PORTLAND OR

BOBBEE MURR Portland OR I was a NOAA observer and an at-sea rep in Alaska for a fish broker, and saw the tremendous waste of fish due to dragging operations. Thank you for your proactive work on behalf of forage species!

MIKE NAKAMURA

Portland OR

SUE NELSON salem OR

KATHY NELSON milwaukie OR

JAN NELSON rural eugene

OR

KAREN NIENKAMP

Neskowin OR

WILLIAM OBRIEN

Beaverton OR

KIMBERLY OCUPE

Salem OR I have worked game fish and wild life boats and see a need for this, thank you for your work and support

STEPHEN ODER Corvallis OR

MAUREEN O'NEAL

Portland OR

VIRGINIA PABST Sisters OR

ANITA PARISH Sweet Home

OR

MICHELLE PARRIS

Bend, OR OR

CHRISTINA PASILLAS

Klamath Falls

OR

LEA PATTEN Florence OR I have spent my entire life at or near salt water. Fisheries should have to 1. prove their need BEFORE fishing, 2. prove their need(s) should take precedence over survival of forage fish, and 3. prove that their customers are more important than the survival of a food chain!

EVELYN PIETROWSKI-CIULLO

Salem OR

SUSAN C PILLING

Seal Rock OR Thank you for taking seriously the accessibility of internet communications for your constituency to reach you with our voices.

DAVE PLAEHN Corvallis OR

DEBRA POSCHARSCKY

Portland OR

Page 43: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

DEE POTTER Bend OR We NEED the whole system!

STEVE PRINCE Eugene OR

DEAN PRYER Eugene OR

MARGARET QUENTIN

Portland OR

P QUILLIAN Talent OR

KRISTIN RAMSEY Portland OR

DIANE RANDGAARD

Terrebonne OR

PHILIP RATCLIFF Salem OR Forage fish are an important element of the marine food chain, right above krill.

ELIZABETH REDMAN

Portland OR

CHERIE REEVES-RUTLEDGE

CENTRAL POINT

OR

PHIL REID klamath OR

BERKLEE ROBINS Lake Oswego

OR

JANET ROGERS Bandon OR PROTECT our ocean resources for the future liveability of this planet !!!

DEBRA ROMNEY Baker City OR Thank you for protecting Pacific forage fish!

SUSAN ROSE Corvallis OR

ERIC ROSS Sweet Home

OR

FRANK ROUSE Colton OR

JULIA RUSSELL Portland OR

ROSALIE SABLE Medford OR

GEORGEANNE SAMUELSON

Oakridge OR

ROBERT AND DOLORES SCHEELEN

Medford OR

JAYLEN SCHMITT Portland OR

SANDRA SCHOMBERG

corvallis OR

LISA SCHROEDER

Portland OR

LINDA SCHWARTZ

Cannon Beach

OR

STUART R. SHAW

Salem OR

SHEILA SHEARER Hood River OR

STEVE SHEEHY Klamath Falls

OR

IAN SHELLEY Portland OR

AUDREY SHEPARD

Springfield OR

GABRIEL SHERIDAN

Portland OR The actions you have taken benefit all mankind.

DEAN SIGLER Aloha OR Proceed cautiously, since overfishing will be disastrous for the planet.

DRESDEN SKEES-GREGORY

Hillsboro OR

JAN AND LARRY SLOBIN

Portland OR

RACHEL SMITH Eugene OR

DIANA SNOW Oregon City OR

LINDA SNYDER SALEM OR

SHEILA SPENCER Gresham OR

CHARLOTTE STAHL

Gresham OR We must act now to help protect and preserve all aquatic life to keep our oceans and all the flora and fauna healthy.

D STIRPE Portland OR

WADE STODDARD

Portland OR

LINDA K SWIFT Keno OR

DOE TABOR Eugene OR

MARCI TAYLOR St Helens OR

NANNETTE TAYLOR

Damascus OR

DAVID TAYLOR Corvallis OR

Page 44: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

BOB THOMAS Myrtle Creek

OR

PAMELA THOMAS

Clackamas OR

LAUREN THOMPSON

Oregon City OR

ANN TIEDEMAN Beaverton OR

JOSHUA TINDALL

Fairview OR

A. TODD Eugene OR

LAURIE TODD Portland OR

JODY TURNER Portland OR Please take the meaningful action to protect our oceans and keep balance for the life within.

JAMES TYREE II Portland OR

NATALIE VAN LEEKWIJCK

Beaverton OR

SATYA VAYU Portland OR

MARY VILLAUME

Portland OR

MICHAEL VOGT portland OR

M. W. Brookings OR Keep doing the right thing for the environment...

JESSICA WADDELL

Yachats OR

MARIE WAKEFIELD

Newport OR

ROBERT WALKER

Brightwood OR

SANDRA WARD portland OR Protect and Save Now!

SUSAN WECHSLER

Corvallis OR

MARK WHEELER Portland OR

KEN WHEELER Beaverton OR

MARIA WHITE Beaverton OR

JEFFREY WHITE Forest Grove

OR

LOIS WHITE Grants Pass OR

TERRY WHITLATCH

Lake Oswego

OR

THOMAS WICKS Portland OR

SARAH WIEBENSON

Portland OR

MICHAEL T WILLIAMS

eugene OR Please act in accordance with INTELLIGENCE

BEVERLY WILLIAMS

Medford OR

CARLA WILLIAMS

Cottage Grove

OR

DAVID WILSON Myrtle Point OR

JANE WILSON Oregon City OR

SERENA WITTKOPP

Portland OR

MARGUERY LEE ZUCKER

Eugene OR

MIKE ACKER Vancouver WA

DEBI ALDRICH Covington WA

PATRICK ALLEN Poulsbo WA Forage fish are CRITICAL to the food web and particularly to Salmon and Steelhead restoration!

TERESA ALLEN Deming WA

HARRIET ALLEN olympia WA

TIM ALLEN Seattle WA

CAROL ANDERBERG

Langley WA

BECKY ANDERSON

Bellingham WA

ANGELA ANDERSON

Snohomish WA

MARJORIE ANDO

Seattle WA forage fish must be protected. They are so important to the health of the oceans' food webs and the balance of the ecosystem.

Page 45: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

RUSSELL AND DEBORAH ANTHES

Malo WA Don't flounder. Protect what's left.

DEANNA ARMSTRONG

Seattle WA

ANNIE ASHES p.t. WA

GREGG ASKEY Vancouver WA

SIGRID ASMUS Seattle WA Forage species such as saury, sand lance, and various types of squid are essential to the survival of most seabirds and marine mammals, who would starve without them. Because the status of these fish is not managed or monitored, commercial vessels can begin fishing for these fish at any time with no accounting for the potential effect on the rest of the food web -- and a concern limited only for unaccountable private profit. I am writing to make it clear that I

fully support your action to protect our currently unmanaged forage fish -- there is no substitute for the key part they play in the food web.

LISA AYALA Tumwater WA

KAREN HEDWIG BACKMAN

Federal Way WA Maintain critical balance in the Pacific.

NORMAN BAKER Sequim WA It is obvious common ecological sense to protect forage fish. Please do so.

BRIAN BALTIN Seattle WA

ROBERT BAMFORD

Seattle WA

WESLEY BANKS Vancouver WA

NICK BARCOTT Lynnwood WA

MARGERY BARLOW

Packwood WA

RICK BARRETT Seattle WA

KALANIT BARSON

Langley WA

FAYE BARTLETT Bellingham WA History should have taught us the importance of keeping the food chain the way nature intended.

KATHERINE BASHER

Tacoma WA

MARK BASTIAN Helston WA

ALLEN BAUER Shoreline WA

ALBERT BECHTEL Seattle WA If we don't protect forage fish who will ?

Page 46: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

SUSAN BECHTHOLT

Port Orchard

WA It makes no sense to destroy the most important part of the food chain .

JOANNE BEESON Blaine WA

BRYAN BELL Port Angeles WA

PAT BERECZKI Vancouver WA Forage Fish protect our ecosystem and we must protect them.

WERNER BERGMAN

Stanwood WA

SUSAN BERTA Freeland WA

JUSTIN BEZOLD Yakima WA

DALE BIRDSELL Tacoma WA

SCOTT BISHOP Olympia WA

LAURIE BLACK Seattle WA

ANNA BLAEK Seattle WA

ADAM BLUMENTHAL

Seattle WA

BARBARA BONFIELD

Tacoma WA

CHRISTIAN BOOKTER

Goldendale WA

JEANNINE BOONE

Kenmore WA

JC BOWER Sumner WA

BOBBI BOYD Seattle WA

ROBIN BOYNTON

Carnation WA

TOBI BRAVERMAN

Olynpia WA

JOHN BREMER Bellingham WA Protect the significant Cherry Point herring.

TINA BROWN Anacortes WA

ROBERT BROWN Fircrest WA

JULIETTE BRUSH-HOOVER

Seattle WA

MELANIE BUERKLE

port townsend

WA

TIM BURNS Federal Way WA

DEBORAH BURNS

Seattle WA

BETH CALL Walla Walla WA

MATTHEW CAMARDO

Seattle WA I am a commercial fisherman, so I know the industry side of the forage fish issue. And I am a human... I'm 30 years old and my partner and I are considering starting a family. I am concerned that if the forage fish are targeted, the food web will collapse and there will not be enough food for my future family. Please keep my unborn children in mind when setting quotas and deciding on how to manage the fishery.

JAMIE CAYA Vancouver WA

BETTY CHAN Seattle WA

EVE CHEN seattle WA

JERRY CHILSON Enumclaw WA

SANDRA CISKE Seattle WA

RHONDA CLEMENTS

Lynnwood WA it is time to protect our oceans and the life in them, it is a matter of our own survival as well!

JUDITH COHEN Seattle WA

SANDRA COLE Vancouver WA

Page 47: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

KEITH COMESS Bellingham WA The logic behind preserving forage fish is the logic behind preserving the entire ecosystem. Without the one, everything else collapses. The scientific and empirical evidence behind that solution is foundational to all biological sciences and ecology. So, please do the right thing and protect these fish.

PATRICK CONN Kent WA I am glad to see this industry finally acknowledging that a knowledge and understanding that the whole food chain must be preserved to retain a viable and healthy industry, and their willingness to now incorp-orate this knowledge in new, and future, regulations

and guidelines. It is the only responsible solution to protect both the ocean's environmental health and preserve the industry's future resources and stock.

KLOUISE COOK seattle WA

TRINA COOPER Federal Way WA

CONOR CORKRUM

Seattle WA

LAURA CRAIG Lakewood WA

KIMBERLY CRANE

Snohomish WA

LIA CRAVEN Tacoma WA It is crucial work protecting these forage fish, thank you for your efforts! Keep up the good work!

P.E. CRAWFORD Stevenson WA

Don Dune Redmont WA

MR.SHELLEY DAHLGREN, PHD

Issaquah WA

DAVID DANIELS-LEE

Ocean Shores

WA

KEVIN DARCY Bellingham WA

RUTH DARDEN Seattle WA

SHATOIYA DE LA TOUT

Chimacum WA

BRANDIE DEAL Bothell WA

BEV DEERIMG seattle WA

BARBARA DELGIUDICE

Burien WA

BEN DEMAR seattle WA

PENNY DERLETH Deer Park WA

TIMOTHY DEWITT

Spokane WA

KIM DICKEY Leavenworth

WA

DEL E. DOMKE Bellevue WA

Page 48: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

ROSEMARY DONAGHUE

Seattle WA This part of the food chain is very important!

ELLEN DORFMAN

Olympia WA We can't keep overfishing and expect anything to live. Stop the insanity!

PAULETTE DOULATSHAHI

Mercer Island

WA

ELEANOR DOWSWON

Mill Creek WA

VICKIE DOYLE Kent WA

YAEL DRAGWYLA

Seattle WA

JOAN DURHAM Montesano WA

TIM DURNELL Rice WA

CAROLYN EDEN Bainbridge Island

WA

STEPHEN EICHELBERGER

Tacoma WA

GLENN EKLUND Oak Harbor WA

JAN ELLIS Gig Harbor WA We need to save the food chain for all creatures to save the planet!

CHAD EVANS Seattle WA

BRONWYN EVANS

vancouver WA

G F orting WA

GILL FAHRENWALD

Olympia WA

GLENN FAIN Seattle WA

COREY FELDON Lacey WA

REBECCA FERRELL

Kirkland WA

LAURA FINCH Kingston WA Please help protect these beautiful creatures for future generations!

ASHLEY FOWLER Seattle WA

KATHLEEN FRANCIS

Sedro Woolley

WA

LUTHER E. FRANKLIN

issaquah WA So crucial for survival of the food chain.

LARRY FRANKS Issaquah WA

NANCY FRIDAY Kenmore WA

BONNIE G Coupeville WA we must protect all parts of the food chain, for all species dependent on a healthy ocean, including humans!

ROBERT GABRIEL

Olympia WA

MARADEL GALE Bainbridge Island

WA

SERGEY GALUSHKO

Edmonds WA

CRAIG GARCIA Friday Harbor

WA For sports and commercial fisheries to florish forage fish must be protected to florish. It's only common sense and real science.

SUZ GARCIA Bellevue WA

LORY GARRETT Port Angeles WA

DELIA GERHARD seattle WA

HAL GLIDDEN Bellingham WA

WILLIAM GOFORTH

University Place

WA In the past we seem to care more about the just the big game fish and not on everything that goes with fishing in general. Healthy water, and good food source will

Page 49: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

always help big time for fish in the PNW.

LAURIE GOGIC Kirkland WA

JOHN GORDON Port Townsend

WA Let's do this management in the best possible way.

JENNY GORLE lynnwood WA

SHARON GRACE Friday Harbor

WA

JOYCE GRAJCZYK Kent WA

VICTORIA GRAYLAND

Kenmore WA

LEE ANN GREAVES

Spokane WA

LOULA GREGG Renton WA Using up the earth is not a viable option. Protect these forage fish before they, too, become endangered!

AVIVA GRELE Bainbridge Island

WA

BARBARA GRIFFITH

A WA There are too many marine animals and birds that depend on forage fish for their survival seals specially young just weaned seals depend on forage fish or they will starve just as other marine mammals such as whales that need an abundance of these fish.

KATHY GRIM Rochester WA

MARY GUARD Friday Harbor

WA

EVAN GUEST Spokane WA

CAROLYN HALL Renton WA

DONNA HANSON

Pullman WA

NATHANIEL HARRISON

Seattle WA

JO HARVEY Pacific WA

MARGARET HASHMI

BELLINGHAM

WA

RICK HATTEN Bainbridge Island

WA

LORENA HAVENS

Acme WA

JILL HEIN Coupeville WA

ASTRID HEINISCH

redmond WA

MAYELLEN HENRY

Bellevue WA It is the total health of the ocean that depends on your decisions, not just one species.

ROBERT HILGENBERG

Everett WA It is fundamental and wise; SAVE THE SMALL FISH TO SAVE ALL THE FISH.

NANCY HINES Seattle WA

WALTER HOESEL Duvall WA

MARIANNE HOFFMAN

Bremerton WA

SUE HOGAN Kennewick WA

JULIE HOLTZMAN

Snohomish WA

JOCELYNE HOUGHTON

Seattle WA

WILLIAM HOWALD

Marysville WA

LAURA HUDDLESTONE

Seattle WA

CAROLE HUELSBERG

Port Townsend

WA

CHASITY HUNGERFORD

Kirkland WA

JAMIE HUSON Bellingham WA Protecting the ocean ecosystem

Page 50: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

throughout the Pacific is important to preserve the natural resources of the Pacific Northwest and ensure sus-tainable fish populations for future economic security. Fish at all levels of the food chain need supported.

LURA IRISH Lakebay WA

DANYA JABLON Lynnwood WA Protect now and have long term rewards.

VANESSA JAMISON

Arlington WA

GAYLE JANZEN Seattle WA If the forage fish population crashes, then the entire ocean food chain will crash as well. These small fish are vital in keeping our oceans healthy so I applaud your decision to protect these small, but important fish.

JEAN JENSEN Graham WA

ROBERT JENSEN LACEY WA

AJ AND JOHN JITTIPSOPA-ZINNER

Mossyrock WA I suppose this is unlikely given the propensity of

humanity toward destruction of the planet and all of its inhabitants.

MELINDA JOHNSON

Bothell WA

CLAYTON JONES Shoreline WA

BROOKIE JUDGE Seattle WA

ALEXIS KANE Seattle WA

BLAIR KANGLEY Seattle WA

LUKE KELLY Seattle WA

KATHY KESTELL Spokane WA

RANDY KILMER Seattle WA

NADIA KIM Seattle WA

RANDAL KLEFBECK

Royal City WA

MERYLE A. KORN

Bellingham WA

SUMMER KOZISEK

Bonney Lake WA

SUNDAY KRAUSHAAR

camas WA Help them

MARK KRUKAR Seattle WA

ANN KUGLER Freeland WA You can make such a differ-ence. Please be the hero!

WM LAESTADIUS

Mercer island

WA

JUDITH LAIK Auburn WA

JUDITH LANDAU Port Townsend

WA

MARIANNE LARKINS-STRAWN

Vancouver WA

PAMELA LARSEN Camano Is. WA

BRIAN LARSON Seattle WA

CHARLENE LAUZON

Lynnwood WA

NADINE LAVONNE

Seattle WA

JULIE LAWELL Seattle WA

JULIE LEAVENWORTH

Indianola WA

HUGH LENTZ Olympia WA

PATRICIA A LENZEN.

Vancouver WA

ADAM LEVINE Seattle WA

Page 51: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

NANCY ENZ LILL Spokane WA

ROBIN LINDSEY Seattle WA

DELPHI LOCEY Seattle WA

KANDACE LOEWEN

Seattle WA

GREGRY LOOMIS Seattle WA

MARK LOPEZ Battle Ground

WA

SAMMY LOW Stanwood WA

JOANNE LUONGO

Kettle Falls WA PROTECT THESE FORAGE FISH!

K LYLE Gig harbor WA

MICHAEL LYMAN

COLVILLE WA

PATRICIA LYNK Port Orchard

WA

JUNE MACARTHUR

Port Orchard

WA

RON MACARTHUR

Port Orchard

WA

DIANN MACRAE Bothell WA Small fish should be protected in their own right and in order to feed seabirds, whales, and other large fish.

KATHLEEN MALLEY

Tacoma WA

SCOTT MARCKX Port Townsend

WA

GERRY MARTIN University Place

WA

RUTH MARTIN Everett WA

TOM MARTIN Bellevue WA

JUDY MASON Bellevue WA

LINDA MASSEY Seattle WA

MARY MASTERS Orcas WA

AI MCCARTHY Redmond WA

REBECCA MCDONOUGH

Eastsound WA

BARBARA MCKEE

VANCOUVER

WA

DONALD MCKELVY

Mount Vernon

WA

TODD MCKENNEY

Grapeview WA

JANICE MCLAUGHLIN

Bellingham WA

JANE METCALFE Seattle WA

ROBERT METZGER

Snoqualmie WA

BRENDA MICHAELS

Issaquah WA

RENEE MILKIE mercer island

WA

KRISTINA MILLER

Seattle WA Thank you for the time you spend protecting the web of life in our oceans.

JERRY MILLER Vancouver WA

LANCE MILLER Renton WA

DEBRA MOORE Langley WA Respectfully, the recent loss of a full term orca and mother has driven home the need to begin to regulate the public taking of fish. I do not advocate taking any from the Native Americans. Rather, we can all do without derbies and salmon for a year or two or with LESS to ensure that the fish stocks remain healthy for the wildlife. Our Southern Residents

Page 52: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

NEED this. Please, consider stricter regulations on public fishing.

KERRY MOORE Toledo WA

TOM & PATRICIA MORELAND

Port Townsend

WA

CAROLYN MORRISON

Olympia WA

AMY MOWER Maple Falls WA

JAMES MULCARE

Clarkston WA

MARY N vancouver WA

KATHERINE NELSON

Kent WA

MATTHEW NELSON

Kent WA

JOE NEUMANN Seattle WA

JON NOGGLE BELLINGHAM

WA

JERRY NOKES Newman Lake

WA

PAM OBST Seattle WA

BARBARA OCSKAI

Snohomish WA Please, we must strive to regain and maintain a balance for all living creatures on this planet - we are connected. Thank you.

DARLENE O'GRADY

Monroe WA

NORM OSTERMAN

Walla Walla WA You have to protect the entire food chain.

ADINA PARSLEY Stanwood WA

HIROKO PATTERSON

Silverdale WA

FAY PAYTON College Place

WA

JOHN B PEARCE SR

Seattle WA

P. PERRON Seattle WA

JOAN PETER Gig Harbor WA

JOE PIECUCH Suquamish WA

JOANN POLLEY Poulsbo WA

DEBBI PRATT Seattle WA

J R orting WA

PATRICIA RAAMOT

Pullman WA

KELLY RAGSDALE

Longview WA

PEGGY RANSON Bellingham WA

PEARL RANSTROM

Vashon WA

JAMES RANSTROM

Vashon WA

STEPHANIE RAYMOND

Seattle WA

MARK REDMOND

Seattle WA

MELISSA REES spokane valley

WA

BRIAN REID Winthrop WA

EMILY REITMAN Vashon WA

JEFF RENNER Sammamish WA

KAROL RICE Spokane WA

RUTH RIORDAN walla walla WA

JAMES ROBERTS Palouse WA We humans depend on forage fish to preserve the balance of nature. Degradation of the food chain has a negative impact on humans long-term existence.

ERIK ROBINSON Vancouver WA

PATT ROCHE port townsend

WA

PATRICIA RODGERS

Kirkland WA

KAREN ROGERS Vashon WA

RICK ROMITO Belllingham WA

SHARON RONSSE

Monroe WA

BARBARA ROSENKOTTER

Deer Harbor WA

Page 53: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

MICHELLE ROSSEE

Olympia WA

DR. JAMES L. ROWLAND, ED.D.

Pullman WA

AMANDA RUDISILL

Olympia WA

ELENA RUMIANTSEVA

Seattle WA

ZANDRA SAEZ Spokane WA And humans are supposed to have the larger brain?

JOHN SAILER Port Townsend

WA

TODD SANDELL Seattle WA

DARLENE SCHANFALD

Sequim WA

DAN SCHNEIDER Seattle WA

JERIANN SCHRINER

olympia WA

MEGAN SCHWEPPENHEISER

north bend WA

SUSANNE SCOTT Sequim WA Pls protect these fish - they are just the tip of the iceberg!

DENEE SCRIBNER

Ellensburg WA

JOHN SEEBURGER

lakewood WA conservation is priority

STEVE SERBOUSEK

Bremerton WA

PAULA SHAFRANSKY

Sedro Woolley

WA Thank you for your consideration in this matter.

DAVE SHREFFLER

Sequim WA

GARY SIMONSEN

Medical Lake

WA

VANESSA SKANTZE

Seattle WA

GLORIA SKOUGE Shoreline WA

CHARMAINE SLAVEN

Seattle WA

DAVID SMITH Olympia WA

BAKER SMITH Burien WA

MOLLIE SMITH Chehalis WA

SANDRA SMITH Seattle WA

BRUCE SMITH Shoreline WA

DEVIN SMITH Seattle WA

SETH SNAPP Bellingham WA

DARCEY SNOW Spokane WA

SCOTT SPECIES Seattle WA

LYNN SQUANCE Port Moody, BC

WA

P. ST. JOHN Port Townsend

WA

DARLENE ST. MARTIN

Mount Vernon

WA

JACK STANSFIELD

Stanwood WA

LOZZ STARSEED Seattle WA

JEFF STEENBERGEN

Seattle WA

LYNN STEVENSON

Gig Harbor WA

BETTINA STOKES Bellevue WA

ASHLEY SULLIVAN

Lacey WA

BRIAN SULLIVAN Lakewood WA

LINDA SWAN Snohomish WA

THOMAS SWOFFER

Ravensdale WA

PAUL TALBERT Seattle WA

KAREN TALBERT Mount Vernon

WA

SUSANNA TAM Renton WA

POLLY TARPLEY Poulsbo WA

ELIZABETH TAYLOR

Seattle WA

BARBARA TEMPLE-THURSTON

Tacoma WA

LISA THOMAS Issaquah WA

DEBBIE THORN Kirkland WA

LACE THORNBERG

Seattle WA

EUGENE THORNE

Tacoma WA

JEAN THORNSBURY

Federal Way WA

ALICE TOBIAS Seattle WA

JOTASHA TRAYLOR

Kent WA

Page 54: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

GREG TREECE Sequim WA Continued improvements in sustainable fishing is a requirement to allow my children and their children the opport-unity to include fish in their diet.

BOB TRIGGS Port Townsend

WA I am a fishing guide in the State of Washington. Our forage species are struggling against many factors here. Our whales are sometimes dying of starvation or malnutrition. Our salmon are often below normal weight and fat content. We do not have the density or widespread abundance of forage fish and other species that is needed here to promote healthier fish, bird and mammals, and sustains the myriad marine organisms that live

interdependently in our waters. We need to do more to rebuild our weakened marine food chain.

VICTORIA TRIMBLE-LOWE

Bellevue WA

JESSICA TUCKER Mill Creek WA

ALEXANDRA TUFNELL

Bothell WA

TAMARA A. TURNER

Seattle WA Think of the future, not current profits.

JOHN TUXILL Bellingham WA As a resident of a port city where fishing is a major activity, I greatly appreciate the work you do to maintain healthy fish stocks and marine ecosystems.

VICTORIA URIAS Seattle WA

ROBERT VAUGHN

Everett WA

RENEE VINCENT Sequim WA Protect Pacific Forage Fish!!

JOHN VINSON Olympia WA

DAKOTA VOGEL Elbe, WA

JOAN WATTLES Seattle WA

JAMES WAYRYNEN

Entiat WA

DEAN WEBB Seattle WA

MARIE WEIS Fox Island WA

JAN WEISEL Woodinville WA

DONNA WEISSBECK

Sultan WA

DAVE WERNTZ Bellingham WA

PRESTON WHEATON

olympia WA

Page 55: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

NANCY WHITE Spokane Valley

WA

ELIZABETH WHITE

SEATTLE WA

EMILY WHITE Tacoma WA

CAROL WHITEHURST

Tacoma WA

SCOTT WIDDAS Silverdale WA

GARRY WILLIAMS

Washougal WA Please protect all fisheries.

EMILY WILLOUGHBY

Tukwila WA These forage fish may not be directly important to you and me, but they are critical to many fish and the ocean's ecosystem.

EMILY WILLOUGHBY

Tukwila WA We need these fish, even though they may seem 'unimportant'.

MARGUERITE WINKEL

Spokane WA

MARK WIRTH Seattle WA

HOUSTON WONG

Kirkland WA

CHARLES WOOD olympia WA

LINDA WOODALL

Kennewick WA

ANITA WOODRUFF

SEATTLE WA

KEN WOOLARD University Place

WA

REUBEN YANCEY Olympia WA

K. YOUMANS Roslyn WA

NANCY YOUNG Seattle WA

OTTO YOUNGERS

Tacoma WA

HENDRICK ZITTER

Sammamish WA

GREG ZUPANSIC Bellevue WA

KATE ANDERSON, PHD

Hayden ID

ROBERT BELL, III Boise ID

DIAN BERGER Boise ID

RUSS BERGER Boise ID

GLORIA CARLTON

Hailey ID

JOY CASSIDY Coeur d' Alene

ID Balanced ecosystems are key to protecting the environments of the world!!!! Please protect these small but important fish!!!

CARMEN CHACON

Pocatello ID

BARBARA CHAFFIN

Mackay ID

BARB CRUMPACKER

Coeur D Alene

ID

GLORIA D. Cataldo ID

LESLEE DONER Boise ID

LYNNE DORIA hayden ID

LORNA EMDY Hailey ID

KENNETH FISHER

Kellogg ID

STEPHEN HACKNEY

Grangeville ID

DANIEL HAWLEY Ketchum ID

GRACE HIMMELBERGER

Boise ID

JILL HIRSCHI Pocatello ID

ANDRE E KOHLER

Pocatello ID

SUE LESMOND sydney Australia

ID

JANETH MALLORY

Lewiston ID

MIKE MATHIS Boise ID

JIM MAY Boise ID

SCOTT PLOGER Idaho Falls ID

TIM RHODES Boise ID

MARCI ROBINSON

POCATELLO ID

HEATHER RODMAN

Boise ID

Page 56: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

THOMAS ROGERS

Eagle ID

DANIELA ROSSI Pomezia (Roma)

ID

GUSTAF SARKKINEN

moscow ID

DENISE SIMONE bellevue ID

KJERSTIN STANAVIGE

Monmouth ID

VALERIE STONE Norfolk ID

BONNIE L. TANNER

Eagle ID

EARTH THUNDER

Boise ID

DALE TURNIPSEED

Twin Falls ID

BILL VENTRE Boise ID

KITTY VINCENT Blackfoot ID So important.

ALLYSA AARON henderson NV

JOAN ABBOTT Marietta GA

OLGA ABELLA Robinson IL

JACKIE ADAM Fargo ND

FRANK ADAMICK

Astoria NY It's encourage-ing to see emphasis being placed on such a vital compo-nent of the food chain. Looking at it from bottom up or top down we must do all possible to fortify the integrity of ocean food webs.

MR. & MRS E.R. ADAMS

Dexter MI Thank You for protecting Pacific Forage Fish... much needed action!

EVELYN ADAMS McKinney TX

ROGER ADAMS Spencer WV

BERNARDO ALAYZA MUJICA

surquillo IA

RAFAEL ALBARRAN

Chicago IL

JUDY ALBURY Miami FL

CHARLES ALEXANDER

Lutherville MD Forage fish are essential!

KELLY ALLISON Berlin MD

BETTY ALMAND Avondale Est.

GA Protect Pacific forage fish.

LUCY ALMEIDA Bloomfield NJ

CARA AMMON Chicago IL

SHEL ANDERSON Durham NC In this critical time of climate change, we must put as many protections in place as possible.

WILLIAM ANDERSON

Philadelphia PA

CHRISTEEN ANDERSON

Crestview FL

DOROTHY ANDERSON

North Weymouth

MA

KATHLEEN ANGOTTI

Boonsboro MD

MIRIAM ANGRESS

Durham NC

RAMIL ANIÑON San Fernando

DC

ERICA ANTHONY-BENAVIDES

Austin TX

BARBARA APPELBAUM

New York NY Die-outs in the ocean are signs of oncoming disaster - for us as well as wildlife.

SANDRA ARAPOUDIS

rhodos AL

PHYLLIS ARIST Evanston IL

ELIZABETH ASHBY

New York NY

Page 57: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

JACQUES AUTAIN

Miami FL

SHARI B Darrington TN My father was a small time commercial fisherman back when there was not any fancy equipment on board to track the fish. He said they knew where the salmon where by watching for the herring balls in the Puget Sound. He also said the salmon used to double their weight in Puget Sound before going upriver to spawn. Then along came International Fisheries for herring and other forage fish in the 1970's. That and the big ocean trawlers with the 30 mile long nets and the fish decline quickly. It is not about the habitat. You can build them a 5 star hotel but if you mug the fish before they get to

the rivers to spawn all the habitat is for not.

CHRISTINE B. Brooklyn NY

GERRI BAER Malvern PA

KRISTINA BAIN Greeley CO

WANDA BALLENTINE

Saint Paul MN

SHARON BALZANO

Wheat Ridge

CO

JANICE BANKS Center Barnstead

NH We're all links. All the beasts and fish of every kind need to be cherished, therefor protected. We shouldn't have to ask another human being to do so, but that's what we're doing! Please!!

NEAL BARON Fredericksburg

TX

SABRINA BARUSTA

toronto NY

JUDY BASH Little Rock AR

DAVE BASH Little Rock AR

TERESITA BASTIDES-HERON

LAWRENCE TOWNSHIP

NJ

MAE BASYE Fuquay Varina

NC without a healthy population of forage fish, there will be no more marine mammals, seabirds, marine reptiles or larger fish. It's as simple as that.

MELISSA BAUER Woodstock GA

SARAH BAUMAN Lincoln NE

Page 58: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

BARBARA BECKER

Melville NY

BARBARA BEIERL Nashua NH

MONA STEPHANIE BENEDETTO

Harrisburg PA

BIANCA BENINCASA

Silver Spring MD

KERI BENNETT Valley Stream

NY

SHIRLEY BENSETLER

Cresskill NJ

BLAKE BENTLEY Roanoke VA

DAVID BERKSHIRE

Houston TX

CHAZ BERLUSCONI

Pretoria IL

SIEGRID BERMAN

washington NJ PLEASE DON'T LET THE OCEANS DIE

SUSAN BERNAT New York NY

ROSE BERTRAND Madison WI I am a facts and figures person, a scientist. What I do know is that we absolutely must take action immediately to protect our oceans. I practice what I preach and am a vegan though I do not insist everyone becomes one.

LINDA BESCRIPT Tucson AZ

J BEVERLY Urbana IL

SOMDEV AND LEE BHATTACHARJI

Arkville NY

LYNN BIDDLE Swampscott MA

CAROL BISCHOFF

Kerkrade KS

LINDA BISHOP Overland Park

KS

ALAN BIXLER Sandia Park NM

NINA BLACK REID

Washington DC

FRANK BLAKE Houston TX

HANNAH BLAKEMAN

Myrtle Beach

SC

PATRICIA BLITON

Winthrop MA

TYE BLOCK wilmington NC

CHRISTINE BLUNT

Scottsdale AZ

CHRISTINE BOGDANOWICZ

Brooktondale

NY

WILLIAM J BOLEN

Brick NJ

VIRGINIE BONNIER

Miami FL

DEBORAH BOOMHOWER

Albany NY

HOWARD BOOTH

Boulder City NV Wow! What a step forward in the protection of whole ecosystems!

EDITH BORIE New Paltz NY

RICHARD BORINSKY

Westminster

CO

GAVIN BORNHOLTZ

Grand Blanc MI

CHRISTINE BOWER

Williamsport

PA

BETTINA BOWERS

Nashville TN

RHONDA BRADLEY

Crossville TN

JENNIFER BRANDON

Lexington NC

VICKY BRANDT New York NY

TINA BRENZA Loves Park IL

ANNA BREWER Fountain MI

RENEE BRINKER O'Fallon MO We humans need to imitate our more aware teachers, animals, all

Page 59: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

nature who and which have much to teach us.

IRENE BRIZARD Miami FL

PAMELA BROCIOUS

New York NY

DAVID BRODNAX

Oak Park IL

KAIREN BROOKE-ANDERSON

Cape Town AZ

GERALD BROOKMAN

Kenai AK

DUNCAN BROWN

Tucson AZ

VALERIE BROWN crownsville MD

BONNIE JEAN BROWN

Morgantown

WV

CHARLES BRUMLEVE

Manhattan KS It is so hard that the little fish are so important but they really are important. Please protect them.

JAMES BRUNTON

Tampa FL

BABETTE BRUTON

Treasure Island

FL

MAURA BUCKLEY

Indianapolis IN

MICHELLE BUERGER

Madison WI

ED BUKOVINSKY Lowellville OH

JASON BURCH Salt Lake City

UT

ROBERT BURNETT

Crested Butte

CO

NADIA BURNS Williamsburg

VA

GRACE BURSON Plymouth NH

KATEY BUSTER Aspen CO

JOAN BUTCER saint louis MO

EDWARD BUTLER

New York NY

GLORIA CAMERON

New Castle PA

THERESA M. CAMPBELL

Madison Heights

MI

ANTHONY CAPOBIANCO

Bethel Park PA

JEANETTE CAPOTORTO

Commack NY

CARLA CARBALLO

Oxon Hill MD

VANESSA CARBIA

Gainesville FL

CHRIS CARBONE camden NJ

PATRICIA CARLTON

SANTA FE NM

JANET CARMICHAEL

Shawnee KS

CHRISTY CAROSELLA

Ozone Park NY

CINDY CARPER Spencer WV

KRISTINE CASSAR

Newark DE

MARTHESE CASSAR

GUDJA MALTA

MA

LINDA CATLIN Armonk NY

DAVID CENCULA Sparks NV

DANA CHALBERG

Whitinsville MA

STANLEY CHARLES

Fort Mill SC

BARBARA CHARLES

New York NY

MICHAEL CHASE jacksonville FL

ELENA CHERNYSHEVA

Brooklyn NY

PATRICIA CHIORELLO

Delanco NJ

ANDREA CHISARI

Titusville FL

HOLLY CHISHOLM

Oxford MI

K. CHUNG Honolulu HI

CASSANDRA CHURCH

e. montpelier

VT I like the Pacific Fishery Management approach to protecting forage fish, now let's make the proposal law.

SUSAN CICERO Alta WY

Page 60: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

VIRGILIO CIULLO Venice FL We have to control the birth rate. They have to sterilize people who have more then 5 children. They have to have heavy financial penalties for more then three children.

BOS CLAUDINE Poligny WY

NINA CLAUSEN new york NY stop ALL hunt of whales

ILEANA CLAVIJO Wilmington NC Strong protection of forage fish is clearly a critical step for successful ecosystem management

RONALD CLAYTON

Asheboro NC

KARA CLAYTON Farmington MI

ESDRAS CLERGEAU

NYC CT Esdras Clergeau request you about the nausea infection , such small I have 4 years about that please I need your help I am very seeck please according me chance about the solution thanks.

JILL CLEVELAND Delavan WI

MARILYN K. COATS

Asheville NC It is an important factor in our future.

ERICA COCO Palm Bay FL

JOYCE COE Hastings MI

BRUCE COHEN Nanuet NY Please, just do it!

DORI COLE Wheaton IL

SOPHIA COLEMAN

Brandon FL

CAROL COLLINS Dover DE

JACKIE COLLINS Edwardsburg

MI

TERESA COLLINS Louisville CO

SILVANA COMACCHIO

Carema to NY

STEVEN COMBES

Gainesville FL STOP THE GLUTTONY!!

LIZA CONNELLY Brookline MA

LAURIE CONROY Wellesley Hills

MA

CATHERINE CONTARINO

lynbrook NY

JARED CORNELIA

Wilmington DE

MARIANNE CORONA

Middlefield CT This is so very important not only for us for also for the future!

M. CECILIA CORREIA

Elizabeth NJ

SEAN CORRIGAN Trinity Beach

Queensland

PAMELA COURTS

florissant CO

MARCELLA CRANE

Phoenix AZ time to do the right thing to put in these protections. Forage fish are part of the delicate ecosystem that supports larger fish and mammals.

Page 61: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

JEFF CREECH Burlington NJ I'm not an educated man, however through the Care2 website I am becoming more aware of many crucial issues like this, so I'd like to convey my gratitude for taking action on behalf of these Pacific Forage Fish. Thank You.

MARJORIE CROCKETT

Arlington MA Thanks for all you do to protect the oceans for all of us!

HEATHER CROSS Brooklyn NY

BENITA CROW Chesapeake VA

JAMES CROWLEY

GREENWICH CT

STEPHANIE CUELLAR

Sunnyside NY

JASMINA CUK Solna Bremen

MATTHEW CULL Vail CO

JENNIFER CUNNINGHAM

Aurora IL

CONNIE CURNOW

Bountiful UT

MARIE CURTIS Oakhurst NJ

SHERI CUTRIGHT St Augustine FL

G ALLEN DAILY Wauwatosa WI

ELLIOT DANIELS Arlington VA

CARRIE DARLING Phoenix AZ

JANE DAVIDSON Englewood NJ

JAN DAVIES laxey VA

SARAH DAVIS Raleigh NC

CANDACE DAVIS Carbondale IL

KATHY DAY Richmond VA

BARRY DE JASU Montague MA

SYLVIE DE PARNY

Miami FL

BETTY DEAN Sterling AK

KRISTOPHER DEAPEN

Laveen AZ

BARBARA DECOURSEY

Milwaukee WI All life is interconnected on this planet. We must respect every link and your actions are very deeply appreciated. Please extend protection to currently unmanaged forage fish.

PRISCILLA DELANEY

Wynnewood

PA

MICHAEL DELOYE

Boynton Beach

FL

PATRICIA DELUCA

Nokomis FL

MARILYN DEMPSEY

Jupiter FL

GUDRUN DENNIS

Gainesville FL

SAGAR DESHPANDE

Peoria IL

CLOTILDA G. DEVLIN

Bernardsville

NJ I do not want the auklet to starve on the coasts of Washington and Oregon because krill is used for bait and livestock.

CAROL DEWEES Pottstown PA

DONALD DI RUSSO

Hyde Park MA

JILL DIEHL Hope Valley RI

CHRISTI DILLON Mooresville NC

SHEILA DILLON Willmar MN

MERELYN DOLINS

Maplewood NJ

FRANCINE DOLINS

Ann Arbor MI

Page 62: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

GARRY M. DOLL Williamsport

PA

PEGGY DOMER Pittsburgh PA

PATRICIA DONNELLY

Harbor Beach

MI

ADAM D'ONOFRIO

North Dinwiddie

VA

LISHA DOUCET Wellington CO

DIANNE DOUGLAS

Phoenix AZ

CHRISTOPHER DOWLING

Austin TX

DEIRDRE DOWNEY

Fairbanks AK

HELEN DRWINGA

Franklin TN

LESLENE DUNN Cape Town OK

JANET DURAN New York NY

STEPHEN DUTSCHKE

Louisville KY

GJORGJI DZOLEV Sk NY

NANCY EARLE Bucksport ME Forage fish are critical for the oceans ecosystems. Please act to conserve these fish now. Thank you.

TAMMY EBERS Greenwood Lake

NY

ANGELA ECKERT west falls NY I am surprised that there are any fish left to catch! Whatever is not caught by gill nets will not be alive for too long!

JACQUELINE EDMUNDSON

New Orleans

LA Humans have many food options. We can eat beans and rice, lake fish, etc. The world is our

larder. Marine mammals, seabirds and larger fish have but one option - forage fish. They can't pick up the phone and order take out if the forage fish are low or depleted. If we fish out their forage fish., i.e. their food, they die from starvation. As humans we have to share the resources of the planet with other creatures. We can't simply take take take.

ERIC EDWARDS West Chicago

IL

ELAINE AL MEQDAD ELAINE AL MEQDAD

Willowbrook

IL

LYNN ELLIOTT Durham NC

PAUL EMERSON Washington DC

MARTHA ENNIS Albuquerque

NM We can't eat big fish if they've starved to death. Please protect the little fish.

PAMELA EVANS Kemp TX

MONICA EVANS Kalamazoo MI

TORY EWING Omaha NE

ANDREA F. Beach Park IL

DENNIS FAHEY Rapid City SD

JUDY FAIRLESS Warren NJ

Page 63: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

FRED FALL Cherry Hill NJ

PAT FARRELL West Warwick

RI

TATIANA FEDOTOVA

Cherepovets PA

GEORGIA FEILD Pittsburgh PA

VICKIE FIDLER Buckhannon WV

ED FIEDLER Austin TX

SCOTT FINAMORE

Citrus springs

FL

KRISTIN FISCHER South Windsor

CT

ANNA LOUISE FONTAINE

Lantier Quebec

JANET FORMAN new york NY

FAY FORMAN new york NY

MARYANNA FOSKETT

Arlington MA

IRENA FRANCHI Sunny Isle Beach

FL

CHRISTINE FRANK

Minneapolis MN Protect the foundation of the marine food web.

LEROY FRANKEL Longmont CO The earth is the only thing we leave our children.

SANDRA FRANZ Chicago IL

EVELYN FRASER Washington DC

SHELLEY FRAZIER

Durham NC

JUDITH FRIEND Fort Collins CO

DINA FRIGO chicago IN

JOYCE FROHN Oshkosh WI

ISABEL M. FUICA New York NY

BRANDON FULLER

Washington DC

JOHN FURLONG trevose PA The entire ecosystem needs our help to thrive

ROB FURSICH hartsdale NY

BURT FURUTA Honolulu HI

DAVID G Kailua Kona HI

CANDACE GABRIEL

Chicago IL

BRIAN GAGNON Franklin MA

SUSAN GARCIA Phoenix AZ

JAN GAREN Swansea NY

JG GAREY New York NY

ESTHER GARVETT

Miami FL

BONNY GATCHEL

Grandview TX

M.JEAN GAVIN Phila. PA

RITA GENTRY Santa Fe NM Thank you for all your work to preserve our Pacific fisheries for generations of fish, birds, marine mammals, and humans to come!

ELAINE GERHARDSTEIN

Miller Place NY

SARAH GERHARDSTEIN

Murfreesboro

TN

KEN GIBB Zephyr Cove NV

BRIAN GIBBONS Greenbelt MD

SCOTT GIBSON Saint Albans WV

THEO GIESY Norfolk VA

ELIZA GILKYSON Austin TX

J DAVID GILLANDERS

State University

AR Protect the ecosystem to keep the valuable commercial and recreational fisheries healthy.

JOSEPH GILLESPIE

Thornton CO

ABIGAIL GINDELE

Portsmouth NH

CLAUDIO GIOVINE

milan WV

CLAUDIO GIOVINE

peonian springs

VA

CARLA GLASER New York NY

ALLAN GLEASON Kingman AZ

DEKE GLIEM Dawson IA

LISA GOLDMAN Thorntown IN

CHARLES L. GOLDSTEIN

Carlisle KY We must protect these barely

Page 64: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

understood underwater regions and the systems they support! Thank You

ANITA GONCALVES

Ludlow MA

MARGARET GOODMAN

Glen Mills PA

ELLEN GOODMAN

Riverside RI

ROBIN GORGES Montpelier VT

SHANNON GORMLEY

Pine Bush NY

GERALD GOUGE Athens GA

REISA GOULD-DONATH

Saratoga Springs

NY

DAGMAR GRABSCH

Berlin Berlin

STEPHEN GRAFF Herndon VA

KEITH GRAGG Mount Gilead

OH

KAITLYN GRAVES

pittsburgh PA

JAMIE GREER West Orange

NJ

PENNY GREGORIO

Albany GA

TONY GREINER Albuquerque

NM

PAMYLLE GREINKE

Peconic NY

KELLEY GRIFFIN COATESVILLE

PA

CATE GRIFFIN southbury CT

JULIE GRIFFITH St Charles IL

MELANIE GRIFFITH

Key west FL

SUE GRIFFITHS SWANSEA, WI

SEYMOUR GROSS

Minneapolis MN

STACY GROSSMAN

Bexley OH

MARK GRZEGORZEWSKI

Tampa FL

JODI GUENTHER missoula MT

H. GUH Dallas TX

MARY GUILLET Winsted CT

KARLENE GUNTER

Rochester NY

SUSAN GUNTHER

Beacon NY

ELISABETH GUSS ny NY

MARCY GUSTAFSON

Chicago IL Yes, all the kids and I ask for these protections for the nature that saves our humanity.

DUANE GUSTAFSON

Cook MN

ELIZABETH GUTHRIE

Webster NY

WILLIAM HAEGELE

philadelphia PA Please help protect these forage fish!

ROBERT HAILE Hampton NH The only hope for the future is to make changes now that reflect the extent and rate of ocean warming.

SHERRY HALBROOK

Ballston Spa NY

SARAH HAMILTON

Canastota NY

LISA HAMILTON Schertz TX

PAULETTE HAMMOND

Baltimore MD

SUSAN HARDIN Little Rock AR

DONALD HARLAND

Candler NC It is vital that we protect the food chain including forage species.

TED HARRIS Lafayette IN

NANCY HARRIS Winston-Salem

NC

DENNIS HARTENSTINE

Birdsboro PA

Page 65: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

BRENDA HARTMAN

Reading PA we must manage the feeder fish so there is food for all

MICHAEL HASKELL

Scarborough

ME

MICHELLE HAYWARD

Bedford NY

JUDITH HAZELTON

Bennington VT

CHRIS HAZYNSKI Bordentown NJ

LINDA HEAGY Arlington TX

JAMES HEARD Homestead FL

JOANN HEDIGER Saint Louis MO Please protect forage fish as they are food for so many essential ocean residents. Please do not endanger their food source.

RICHARD HEINLEIN

Trevor WI

JEANNE HELD-WARMKESSEL

North wales PA

MICHAEL HELLER

Media PA

RODNEY HEMMILA

white bear lake

MN

KAREN HENDERSON

sudbury WY

RICHARD HENDRICKS

Webster NY

ERIC HENSGEN Tampa FL

ANNABELLE HERBERT

Tucson AZ

MARIA CELIA HERNANDEZ

Boston MA West Coast fishery leaders Dear Chair Lowman and council members, The time is now to start act to start a scheduled to place new protections on the little fish that are a big deal in a productive and healthy ocean ecosystem. The forage species such as saury, sand lance, and various types of squid are not managed or monitored. This is the time to protect all the species. To the Pacific Fishery Management Council , Please consider a smart approach: assessing the cost to the rest of the ecosystem before allowing fishing to begin. .Because every time this fisher man and

Page 66: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

their tools and trawlers are used they destroy the little fish and that hurts the growth of fish. Thank you for taking in consideration this view. Please protect the Pacific forage fish,the small fish other the species Sincerely Maria Celia Hernandez

ANNE-MARIE HEWITT

Bromsgrove NY

VALERIE HILDEBRAND

Parma OH

GINGER HILL Lyman SC

SUSANNA HINANT

Bean Blossom

IN

NORMAN HINES Simsbury CT

BRUCE HLODNICKI

Indianapolis IN

NATALIE HODAPP

Mankato MN

SARA HOLMES Chester CT

GREG HOLT HOuston TX

JANE HOPE Louisville KY

GREG HUDGINS Wading River

NY

ROBIN HUDSON Tarpon Springs

FL

MR AND MRS RICHARD N HUFF

Fort Wayne IN

KEVIN HUGHES Newtown CT

DOROTHY HUNTER

Spotsylvania VA

STEPHANIE HUNTINGTON

Denver CO

EMILE G. ILCHUK N. Catasauqua

PA

KAREN INGERMAN

Hartsdale NY This is so important. We must protect and conserve our resources on our beautiful planet.

SUSAN INMAN Elk Rapids MI

SHARON INTILLI Warwick NY All of this is critical to our own HUMAN SURVIVAL. We must protect these balances if we are to protect our own lives in the future, and do it in a sustainable way.

BRIDGET IRONS Philadelphia PA

ZARA IVANOVA Anchorage AK

GABRIELE JEFFERSON

euskirchen North Rhine-Westphalia

ROBERT JENKS Landisburg PA

BENJAMIN JOANNOU JR

Pinecrest FL

ERICA JOHANSON

Hopewell NJ

PHILIP JOHNSON Chapel Hill NC A very, very smart thing to do before it's too late.

PATRICE JOHNSON

Lubbock TX

RHONDA JOHNSON

Aylett VA

LAURA JOHNSON

Woodberry WI

RUTH JOHNSTON

Ha;es Corners

WI

AUDRONE JOKUBAUSKIENE

Vilnius CT

Page 67: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

MARK JOLLY-VAN BODEGRAVEN

Wilmington DE

HENRY JONES Columbus OH

JOSEPH JORDAN Philadelphia PA Protect Pacific Forage Fish

MARK JORDAN Philadelphia PA Protect Pacific Forage Fish

LOIS JORDAN Tucson AZ

WENDY JORDAN Washington DC

C K Lake Geneva

WI

ANN K Woodside NY

LINDA KACSER Rockville MD

TRACEY KATSOUROS

Waldorf MD

MELISSA KATTERSON

South Heights

PA

KAREN KAWSZAN

Spring TX

RAYMOND KEELING

Milford MI

PETER J. KEISER Manlius NY

JOHN KEISER New York NY

RENEE KELLER Minneapolis MN

MARCI KELLEY Saint Louis MO

ADRIENNE KELLOGG

Palmetto FL

CATHLEEN KELLY Calverton NY

PETE KELSO Princeton Junction

NJ

KATE KENNER Jamaica Plain

MA

DIANE KENT Phoenix AZ

RAMSAY KIEFFER

Milford DE

KENNETH KILEY Oregon city OH

JUDITH KING Vero Beach FL

JUSTINE KIRK Aspen CO We need to save our oceans and their biodiversity. Please protect critical forage fish.

R. KIRKPATRICK Espanola NM

ANNE Bradenton FL

KIRKWOOD

JAMES KLEIN Corpus Christi

TX

DONNA KNIPP New York NY

BRAD KNOPF Annapolis MD

JOANN KOCH Lebanon CT

DAVID KOELLER Shawano WI

ANNA KOLOVOU Woodside NY

JANINE KONDRECK

Denver CO

DON KOSAK Menomonee Falls

WI

STEVEN KOSTIS New York NY

BRANT KOTCH Houston TX

DANIEL KOZMINSKI

Solon OH

GAVIN KRAMER Ewing NJ

STEVEN KRANOWSKI

Blacksburg VA

DOUG KRAUSE Fargo ND

KAREN KRAVCOV MALCOLM

Scottsdale AZ

MILDRED KRIEMELMEYER

Waldorf MD Now, it's not too late to make the Arctic Ocean off limits to oil and gas drilling.

DEBORAH KRUPP

Huntingdon Valley

PA

PATRICIA KUSMIERSKI

Essex CT

KATHY KUYPER Green Valley

AZ Thank you for your fine work and please continue to protect forage fish from commercial fishermen.

ROXINIA LAFFITTE

southampton

NY

LAURIE LAGOE Alexandria VA

VéRONIQUE LAJOINIE

SAINT MAUR DES FOSSES

NY

Page 68: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

LESLIE LAMB Lynn MA

CATHY LAMBETH

Springfield MO

DAVID LAND Silver Spring MD

TORIE LAND Mankato MN

DOUG LANDAU St Petersburg

FL

DAVID LANDSKRON

Winter haven

FL We need to protect critical forage fish before our whole eco system falls apart for Good!!

LYNN LANG Randolph MA Let's keep fish where they belong in the ocean

MICHAEL LANGLAIS

West Warwick

RI what's more important. life or cash?

SHARRON LAPLANTE MD

tolland CT

DRENA LAPOINTE

Scottsdale AZ

KENNETH LAPOINTE

Ottawa Ontario

JENNIFER LASLEY

Alexandria VA

ANNIE LAURIE Dracut MA

RHONDA LAWFORD

South Wilmington

IL

MICHAEL LAWRENCE

Harrison City

PA

DEBI LAWSON Sterrett AL

MEAGHAN LEAVITT

Saint Petersburg

FL

LARAINE LEBRON

Utica NY

JINNY LEE Melrose FL We are obligated to protect all species that live on this earth.

BOBBI LEMPERT Paia HI

ANDREW LENZ Leverett MA

M LESZCZYNSKI Lapeer MI

MARIE LEVEN Flushing MI There has to be a limit of the amout of fish taken so that there are enough left for reproduction and for food for other species!

ALLAN LEVY Massapequa NY

PAUL LEWIS Roswell NM

DUDLEY LINDSLEY

Leonardtown

MD

AMY LINDSTROM

Lansing MI

WILBUR LITTLE Denver CO

RUTH LITTON South Yarmouth

MA

DOREEN LOCH Mauer AL

NICOLE LOH Singapore WI

JIM LONG Accokeek MD

MARGARET LOOMIS

Silver Spring MD

REEVE LOVE Albuquerque

NM

VANESSA LOWE Manor TX

NANCY LOWELL Tampa FL

CANDICE LOWERY

Mount Vernon

NY

LINDSAY LOWRY Hopewell NJ

HEIDI LUDWICK Papillion NE

WALT LUERKEN Seekonk MA

ANNA LUKASZEWICZ

Blasdell NY

KENNETH LUM Sacramento FL

DENISE LYTLE Fords NJ

BOB M hobbs NM

G M A MN

MEGAN M Merrillville IN

NILAH M. MACDONALD

Scituate MA

BONNIE LYNN MACKINNON

Georgetown TX

KENTON MACY Charleston IL

RENEE MADERA Southwest Ranches

FL

LILLY MAHANEY Leland MI

Page 69: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

HOLLY F. MALARNEY

Chelsea MA Forage fish are critically important to the life of the oceans and must be protected.

EUGENE MARIANI

Pittsburgh PA

VAL MARJORICASTLE

Inverness FL

GEORGE MARSH Tiffin OH

NATHALIE MARTEL

calgary Alberta

HOPE MARUZO Bozrah CT

JOHN MASSMAN

Antioch IL

FRANCIS MASTRI West Haven CT

SANDRA MATERI Casper WY

PATRICK MATRISCINO

Victor NY

GEORGIA MATTINGLY

Longmont CO

LISA MAZZOLA Tampa FL

BRANDI MCCAULEY

Des Moines IA

ANDY MCCOLLUM

Mount Vernon

IA History indicates that an unmanaged fishery is an unsustainable fishery, regardless of size or value of the species. Please act to sustain forage fish.

TONI MCCRAY Lanham MD

JAN MCCREARY Silver City NM

COLLEEN MCGLONE

New Port Richey

FL

ALICE MCGOUGH

Mashpee MA

RICHARD MCKEE Longmont CO

DON MCKELVEY Euclid OH

PATRICIA MCKENZIE

Atlanta GA Save our planet for the generations to come!

ANNIE MCMAHON

Clarkdale AZ

JOHN MCPEEK Fairfax VA Game fish and whales gotta eat, too!

STEPHEN MEAD Albany NY

MAUREEN MEDAGLIA

Natick MA

TONY MEDLIN Baton Rouge

LA

GINA MEGAY Mantua NJ

ELIZABETH MELLO

Rio de Janeiro

VA

CHRIS MENDEL Columbus OH We need. Leaders that have some foresight to see what needs to be protected. And monitored for future generations. Please be this leader. You may not be hailed as a hero but knowing you were the right leader for this decision should be worth something.

VINCE MENDIETA

Austin TX

ANA MESNER Ljubljana, WY

SUSAN MESSERSCHMITT

Biddeford ME

BONNA METTIE Paradise MI

DORI MILES Crown Point NY

STEVE MILLER portsmouth NH ecosystem

Page 70: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

first

MARTHA MILNE Fort Myers FL This is critical and cannot be delayed.

JOANNA MILOSZEWSKA

MA

DANIEL MINK Harrisburg PA

JUDE MISURELLI Hockessin DE

MJWL MJWL lis UT

JAN MODJESKI Murrells Inlet

SC

KENT MOLLOHAN

Helena MT I'll be alert this next Summer, looking for results of your actions. Thanks.

COREY MONDELLO

Boston MA

SHARON MORA whittier NC

PAULA MORGAN

Hollywood FL

DENNIS MORLEY Old Bridge NJ

KATHLEEN MORRIS

Columbus OH

KATHRYN MORSE

El Dorado AR

JEFFERY MORTON

Boulder CO We need to protect all that we have right now.

PAUL MOSS White Bear Lake

MN

JOHN MOY Acton MA

HELMUT MUELLER

Chapel Hill NC

D MURACO needham MA

MARINA MURPHY

BARROW IN FURNESS

NY

MONIQUE MUSIALOWSKI

Clinton Twp MI

ROSEMARIE MYERS

Papillion NE

SANDRA NAIDICH

Brooklyn NY

RAM NAIR Farmington Hills

MI

DIANE NASSIR, M.A.

Sandia Park NM

JESSICA NATHAN

Southlake TX

GREG NAVARRO Philadelphia PA

SUSAN NAVIDAD Little Rock AR

JOHN NAYLOR Makawao HI

DEBBIE NEIMARK

Chicago IL

GINGER NEIMO Adelaide Australia

ROGEREAU NELLYNA

Santenay OH

THOMAS NELSON

Lansdowne PA

DORIS NELSON Browns Mills

NJ

LYNDA NESBITT Stanfield AZ

LISA NESTE High Point NC

MARGARET NEWHART

Raleigh NC

F NO F No City CO

THERESA NOWACZYK

Iron Mountain

MI Humans are not the only beings who need to survive on this planet.

WILLIAM NUSBAUM

Saint Louis Park

MN

JUDY OAKS Las Vegas NV

REBEKAH O'BRIEN

New Port Richey

FL

EVELYN OCH Pittsburgh PA

ELLEN OCONNOR

Arlington VA Forage fish are vital to the health of our fisheries and oceans. Please use your authority to protect these essential fish.

JEN ODOM Lighthouse Point

FL

ROGER & GAYLE O'DONAHOO

Wantirna NY Please listen. This issue is vitally important to each & every one of us worldwide.

Page 71: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

We simply must cease our destructive ways and save, protect & preser these special fish now, now, now.

ANDREA OETTINGER

WÖRTH MT

ELIZABETH OLIVEIRA

Rio de Janeiro

VA

ROBERTO OLIVEIRA

Rio de Janeiro

VA

MARIANA OLIVEIRA

Rio de Janeiro

VA

ALLEN OLSON Minneapolis MN

SHYAMA ORUM new york NY

ALEX OSHIRO Honolulu HI

RHEA OSLAND Laurel IA

CHRIS OTTOSEN shell lake WI

BOB OTTOSEN shell lake WI

DALILE OUAI Paris NY

B P Rostock Ontario

D P F FL

ANDREW PAGEL Wauwatosa WI

KRIS PAGENKOPF

Gainesville FL

LAURA PAKALN Nyack NY

TAMI PALACKY Springfield VA

JENNIFER PALMER

Lexington GA

CHRISTOPHER PANAYI

Brighton NY

BRIAN PARADISE Ponte Vedra Beach

FL

ALICIA PARAVOLA

Chicago IL

BARB PATERNO recklinghausen

AK

ARLENE PATORAY

Paramus NJ

NADJA PAYNE Woodbridge VA

DANIELLE PAYNE Ft Wayne IN

GIANA PERANIO-PAZ

Hendersonville

NC

CARLA PEREIRA Union NJ

SARAH PETERS Rockville MD

KYLE PETERSON Sterling Heights

MI

ROBIN PETERSON

Jacksonville FL

NEZKA PFEIFER Scranton PA

JOE PHILLIPS Colfax NC

DAMON PHILLIPS

Alexandria VA

RICHARD PHILLIPS

Neenah WI

GEORGE PICCHIONI

Bronx NY

MONICA PICON merlo NY

CAT PIETRYKA Dearborn Heights

MI I honestly doubt with my whole heart, that I'll ever see such an amazing and brave rescue!

KAREN PIKE-ROBERTS

Rome NY

JOHN PINEZICH Longmont CO

SUSAN POIRIER Tallahassee FL

STEVE POLYDOROS

garden grove

CO

NICK PONOMAREV

Port Charlottle

FL

JUDI POULSON Fairmont MN

KAREN PRENA Chicago IL I fully endorse and support every word of this joint letter prepared by the Pew Trusts. In the 25 years that I have been an environ-mental attorney there have been profound negative consequences for forage species from

Page 72: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

commercial fishing. It is essential to reverse this trend.

MARY PRICE Houston TX

MARY PRICE Cleveland OK

LUCI PUGH New Bern NC

NORMAN PUGLIESE

Califon NJ

JOSEPH QUIRK New York NY

JULIA RADWANY Akron OH

LAURA RAFORTH

rochester NY

RITA RAFTERY Ridgefield Pk

NJ

SAPHIRA RAIN Raytown MO

DENNIS RAINES Currituck NC Menhaden depletion in the Chesapeake Bay has decimated our stocks of predator fish. Every ecosystem has a food chain to protect.

LISA RAMACI New York NY

JOANN RAMOS Iselin NJ We have to stop sacrificing the health of the oceans for the sole short term benefit of man.

CONNIE RAPER Durham NC

JANE READING Phoenix AZ

ROBERT M/CAROL G REED

Hardyville VA

LENORE REEVES Mokena IL

MR. & MRS. BRUCE REVESZ

Cedar Grove NJ

OSCAR REVILLA San Sebastian de los Reyes

NC

RONDA REYNOLDS

East Waterboro

ME

DEBORAH RICHARDS

Burns WY

JOHN RICHKUS Jersey City NJ

CHET RICK Minnetonka MN

CAROLYN RIDDLE

Austin TX

LINE RINGGAARD

Herning IN

SERGIO RIVERA Chicago IL

JACK ROBINS Iowa City IA

JANET ROBINSON

Boca Raton FL

WES ROC arivaca AZ

INGRID ROCHESTER

Elbert CO

DOROTHY ROEDER

Phoenix AZ

DENNIS ROGERS Hubbardston

MA

RYAN ROHRBAUGH

Sioux city IA

KEVIN ROLFES Austin TX

DEBORAH ROLLINGS

Colorado Springs

CO

DENISE ROMESBURG

Phoenix AZ

ANGELEASE ROSA

Philadelphia PA Ask west coast fishery leaders to protect critical forage fish

MATT ROSA Philadelphia PA Protect Pacific Forage Fish

KATHRYN ROSE Denver CO

TIM ROSE Lighthouse Point

FL

STEWART ROSENKRANTZ

Pompano Beach

FL

RICHARD ROTHSTEIN

Lakewood Ranch

FL

JULIANN RULE Avon MN

GALE RULLMANN

Youngsville NC

PAULA RUSTERHOLZ

Roseville MN

RICH RYAN Albuquerque

NM

Page 73: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

ROBIN RYSAVY Lake Winnebago

MO

CAROLINE SéVILLA

Champs-sur-marne

NY

OLIVIA SAACHI los angeles CO

CHRIS SAIA Brooklyn NY

NATASHA SALGADO

toronto MD

MANUEL SAN GABRIEL

Boston MA

MARC SANTORA Takoma Park

MD

ROBERT SARGENT

Salem NH

PAMELA SAUNDERS

St. George UT

WILLIAM SCHAFFER

Las Vegas NV Protect wholemarine ecosystems.

PHILLIP SCHAFFER

Kingman AZ

STEVE SCHILDWACHTER

Winter Garden

FL

SYBIL SCHLESINGER

Natick MA

OLIVIA SCHLOSSER

Mansfield Center

CT

EVA SCHMELZER Duesseldorf North Rhine-Westphalia

MICHAEL SCHMOTZER

York PA

CHRISTINE SCHNEEBELI

Geneva NY

CAROLINE SCHNETTLER

Le Chesnay MN

GORDON SCHOCHET

Edison NJ

EILEEN SCHOLL Charlotte NC

IRENE SCHROBENHAUSER

Moosburg AR

K SCHROEDER Tempe AZ Sounds like a good idea to me!

AMY SCHUMACHER

Beavercreek OH

JENNIFER SCOTT Fort Myers FL

J. DAVID SCOTT London Ontario

PETER SCOTT Knox IN

MICHAEL SECKENDORF

Carmel NY

KARYN SEDERBERG

Delray Beach

FL

GREG SELLS Austin TX

RUTH SERRA Clearwater FL

PEPA SGD fdsv FL

PRISCILLA SHADE

Boston MA

JOE SHAW Quakertown PA

CHARLES SHELTON

Grottoes VA

BRET SHER Vernon Hills IL

RUTH SHERMAN Ossining NY Need to do all possible to protect the health of our oceans,, our climate and planet depend on this.

ARON SHEVIS Brooklyn NY

KATHY SHIMATA Honolulu HI

NINA SHIRINA Moscow KY

ADRIAN SHIVA Trincity NC

DANIEL SHIVELY Greensburg PA

H. DENNIS SHUMAKER

Marietta PA

CHRISTIAAN SIANO

Austin TX

JOAN SILACO Queens Village

NY

RUDI SIMKO Fletcher NC We are connected to the world around us and need to protect ocean habitats for our future well-being.

TIA SIMON Gorham ME

SONNTA SIMON Parker CO

Page 74: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

LIZBETH SIMPSON

Pinellas Park FL

VIDYA SIVAN Boston MA

N. SIVIN Brooklyn NY

LESLIE SLATER Homer AK

ADAM SLOAN Denver CO

CYNTHIA SMALL Golden CO

MARI SMET Woodhaven NY

MARY ANN SMITH

Fort Washington

PA Thank you for consid-ering my views.

STEVE SMITH Washington DC

JANELL SMITH NEW DOUGLAS

IL

LOUISE SMITH Fort Worth TX

BARBARA SMITH Pinetop AZ

ELEANOR SMITHWICK

Atlanta GA

CAROLE SMUDIN

Bridgewater MA

DAVID SNOPE Califon NJ

ELIZABETH SNYDER~BALDONADO

Winston-Salem

NC

SCARLET SOBRANIE

Los Angeles CO Please protect these fish. If you don't protect them, the animals that need to eat them will die.

CAROLYN SOL Phoenix AZ

IAN SONGAN Sarasota FL

EILEEN SONNENBERG

Brewster MA

SALLY SORENSEN

Westerly RI

CAROL SOROOS Raleigh NC

MARTHA SPENCER

Brevard NC

DEBORAH SPENCER

Billerica MA

KAREN SPRADLIN

Jacksonville AL

ANDREA SREIBER

Schenectady NY

GEORGE STADNIK

Astoria NY

JOANNA STALKER

Margate FL

DENNIS STANSELL

Suches GA

CRIS STAUBACH Niantic CT

ALEX STAVIS New York NY

THEODORE STECK

Chicago IL

COURTNEY STEFANO

New Rochelle

NY

KLAUS STEINBRECHER

Angel Fire NM

LORENZ STEININGER

stafford VA

DOROTHEA STEPHAN

Winzer Bavaria

DAPHNE T STEVENS

Fiskdale MA Every living being is vital to the health of our interdependent web of life.

BETTY STEWART Newport News

VA

E STO passaic NJ

LAUREN STONE Northfield MA

W. ANDREW STOVER

Chambersburg

PA

MIKE STRAWN Warren MI

JACALYN STROUBLE

Pittsboro NC Thank you for your commitment and foresight in setting up protection for forage fish. They are a critical link in the ocean's chain of life. We cannot afford to let humans decimate their populations at the expense of other species! I

Page 75: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

would urge the strongest possible protections.

MORAIMA SUAREZ

Brooklyn NY

PAUL SULLIVAN South Glastonbury

CT

JOANNE SULLIVAN

Fresh Meadows

NY

RICH SURDYK Pittsburgh PA

THEA SURREY Melbourne FL

JOHN SUTHERLAND

White Hall AR

BARBARA SWEET

New York NY

REV CROW SWIMSAWAY PHD

New Marshfield

OH

T T t KY

TOM TAMPLIN Wallington TX

MILLS TANDY Austin TX There ain´t no such thing as a free lunch.

MARY TANOURY Grosse Pointe City

MI

YVETTE TAPP Santa Fe NM Creator's life forms are meant to be free and remain untouched by human hands. We are never to harm. Look at the original teachings and writings of most religions that are familiar, as well as those, thousands of years old, that have remained true to the VEGAN WAY

OF LIVING. These are the lucky ones that have not been taken over by those who prefer to kill and take whatever they come upon, as if all is their own, not creator's!

GARRY TAROLI Wilkes Barre PA

KEN TAYLOR Kapaa HI The great challenge Can you think of any problem, in any area of human endeavor, on any scale, from microscopic to global, whose long-term solution is in any demonstrable way aided, assisted, or advanced by further increases in population, locally, nationally, or globally? Prof. Albert Bartlett

TERRI TAYLOR Glen Burnie MD

TERRY TEDESCO-KERRICK

Phoenix AZ

JOHN TEEVAN Red Bank NJ

GAIL TEMPLE Brooklyn NY Everything is connected. The web of life needs every thread no matter how

Page 76: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

insignificant that may seem to humans.

MICHELE TEMPLE

Woodside NY

JUDY TERVALON New Orleans

LA Please protect the forage fish.

TEST TESTER Pasadena MD Protect our fish!

GARY THALER Revere MA

MARTHA THOMAE

Uwchland PA So-called forage fish are the vital element of food necessary for the ocean to continue to be a productive source of food for humans. To allow them to be destroyed only because humans don't eat them totally misunderstands the ocean ecology.

RICHARD THOMAS

Sarasota FL

CAROL THOMPSON

South Park PA

THERESA THORNBURG

Elkview WV

PETER TIJERINA Chicago IL

WILLIAM TONER Mc Graw NY

HELEN TOROSIAN

Fredericksburg

VA

CAROL TORRANCE

Voorthuizen ME

JENNIFER TOZZI TOMS RIVER NJ

FRANCINE TRANIELLO

Middleboro MA

LAURA TROLL Buzzards Bay

MA Please plan for the long term sustainability over short term profit for the good of all.

TRACY S TROTH Pearl MS

HAL TRUFAN Charlotte NC

JACKIE TRYGGESETH

Grand Marsh

WI

SAU TSANG las vegas NV

LAWRENCE TURK

Hendersonville

NC

PHOEBE TURNER

Kennett Square

PA

FREDERICK TUTTLE, JR.

Hooksett NH

FRANCINE UNGARO

Southington CT

SANDRA URIBE San Antonio TX

TERRY VACCARO NJ

DAVID VALENTINO

Morganville NJ

ROBERT VAN KOLKEN

Grand Rapids

MI

BRAD VAN SCRIVER

Castle Rock CO

JACOBA VAN SITTEREN

Austin, TX Start protecting the little fish NOW, so they and the predator fish will not become more endangered or extinct.

LISE VANDAL alma Quebec

MIKE VANLANDINGHAM

Shawnee KS

GEORGIKOPOULOU VASILIKI

rhodos AL

KEVIN VAUGHT Antioch TN

ILONA VAUPEL Willroth North Rhin

Wehe, dem Menschen - wenn auch

Page 77: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

e-Westphalia

nur ein Tier im Strafgericht Gottes sitzt.“ - hl. Franziskus von Assisi, Schutzpatron der Tiere -

ORDELL VEE Madelia MN

GIGI VENTOLA Montville NJ

BARBARA VIEIRA Staten Island

NY

SUSAN VOGT Fairbanks AK

ERIC VOORHIES Kapaa HI

DEBORAH VOVES

Anchorage AK

JANICE VRMEER Sedona AZ

LIU WAI LING N.T. Hong Kong

GA Please protect Pacific Forage Fish , right now , forage species such as saury , sand lance ,and various types of squid are not managed or monitored , so comm-ercial vessels can being fishing for these animals at any time no accounting for the potential effect on the rest of the food web , thank Dorothy Lowman , the council chair and

the other fishery managers and support their plan to protect pacific forage fish , Thank you

BIRGIT WALCH Hamilton Ontario

CAROL WALKER Winthrop MA

KEN WARD Gloversville NY

RALPH WARD Commerce TX

LEWIS WARD Newfield NY

DAWN WARD-DOMA

Keysborough

Victoria

ARILD WARUD Ericeira WV

MRS. P. D. WATERWORTH

Seabrook MD

DANUTA WATOLA

Kalety NY

SHAWNA WATSON

Winnipeg Manitoba

We do not own the earth, we borrow it from the future.

CHRIS WATSON Knoxville TN

ESTHER WEAVER Highland NY

ANNIE WEI Queensland Queensland

KRYSTAL WEILAGE

Butte MT

MASON WEINRICH

Glouceater MA

LISA WEISBERG New York NY Please take this proactive action now to protect the future of fish tomorrow. Thank you!

STUART WEISS Denver CO

JOSEPH WENZEL Maplewood MN

ERIC WEST Port Orange FL

BRUCE WHEELER

Savannah GA

CHARLES Colonial VA

Page 78: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

WHIGHAM Heights

JOHN WIENERT Atlanta GA

KIMBERLY WILEY

Rochester NY

BRIAN WILKERSON

Minnetonka MN

TANYA WILLIAMS

Collinsville MI Extinct is forever

FREDDIE WILLIAMS

benoni MA

DEBBIE WILLIAMSON

Mountain Home

AR

BEVERLY WILLIAMSON-PECORI

Mc Kees Rocks

PA

ALANA WILLROTH

White Bear Lake

MN

LUDGER WILP Bottrop IN

LINDA WILSCAM Vernon Rockville

CT

DOROTHY WOLKING

WEST ST. PAUL

MN

BARBARA WOOD

Philadelphia PA Protect Pacific Forage Fish

ROBERT WOOD asbury park NJ

JOYCE WOOD Bayfield CO

SANDRA WOODALL

San Antonio TX

HELEN WOODFIELD

OCEANSIDE CT Thank you for your proactive approach to protecting forage fish. I support your plan for active management of this critical resource.

CHARLES WOODLIFF

Cornelia GA

VIRGINIA WOOLRIDGE

Annapolis MD

TRIGG WRIGHT Spring TX

JOAN YATES Westbrook ME

DENNIS YEE Scottsdale AZ

ALLAN YORKOWITZ

Cplonia NJ

SAM YOU San Antonio TX

PAULETTE ZIMMERMAN

St. Louis MO

SANDY ZOUZANEAS

dover NH

BARRY ZUCKERMAN

Middletown NY

SANDRA ZUCKERMAN

somerset NJ

Page 79: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

In addition to those listed above on this petition, the Council office received the following similar or identical emails: From: Julia Harris <[email protected]> Date: Tue, Feb 24, 2015 at 4:22 PM Subject: Protect Forage Fish To: [email protected] Dear Chair Lowman and Council Members, I greatly appreciate the progress the Council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs and that seabirds, whales, and other marine life depend on forage fish as a vital food resource. I respectfully ask the Council to take final action in protecting unmanaged forage fish at the March 9, 2015 meeting by adopting the final preferred alternative (Alternative 2) that designates these species as ecosystem component species and prohibits new directed fisheries for these species without a full analysis. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the Council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Sincerely, Julia Harris 4045 SW Council Crest Drive Portland, OR 97239 From: Steve Altshuld <[email protected]> Date: Tue, Feb 24, 2015 at 4:48 PM Subject: Protect forage fish, Alternative 2 To: "[email protected]" <[email protected]> Dear Chair Lowman and Council members, I am one who greatly appreciates the progress the Council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs and that seabirds, whales, and other marine life depend on forage fish as a vital food resource.

Page 80: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

I respectfully ask the Council to take final action in protecting unmanaged forage fish at the March 9, 2015 meeting by adopting the final preferred alternative (Alternative 2) that designates these species as ecosystem component species and prohibits new directed fisheries for these species without a full analysis. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the Council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Respectfully, Steve Altshuld From: <[email protected]> Date: Tue, Feb 24, 2015 at 7:28 PM Subject: Protecting Forage Fish To: [email protected] Dear Chair Lowman and Council members, We greatly appreciate the progress the Council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs and that seabirds, whales, and other marine life depend on forage fish as a vital food resource. We respectfully ask the Council to take final action in protecting unmanaged forage fish at the March 9, 2015 meeting by adopting the final preferred alternative (Alternative 2) that designates these species as ecosystem component species and prohibits new directed fisheries for these species without a full analysis. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the Council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Sincerely,

Page 81: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

Luke Lowther and Debbi Robertson 4207 Douglas Way, Lake Oswego, OR 97035 From: Diana Lynn Kekule <[email protected]> Date: Tue, Feb 24, 2015 at 9:25 PM Subject: THANK YOU To: [email protected] Dear Chair Lowman and Council members, I greatly appreciate the progress the Council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs and that seabirds, whales, and other marine life depend on forage fish as a vital food resource. I respectfully ask the Council to take final action in protecting unmanaged forage fish at the March 9, 2015 meeting by adopting the final preferred alternative (Alternative 2) that designates these species as ecosystem component species and prohibits new directed fisheries for these species without a full analysis. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the Council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Sincerely, Kekule Bastron Family and Friends From: sara <[email protected]> Date: Wed, Feb 25, 2015 at 3:39 PM Subject: protect currently unmanaged forage fish To: "[email protected]" <[email protected]> Dear Chair Lowman and Council members, I greatly appreciate the progress the Council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs and that seabirds, whales, and other marine life depend on forage fish as a vital food resource. I respectfully ask the Council to take final action in protecting unmanaged forage fish at the March 9, 2015 meeting by adopting the final preferred alternative (Alternative 2) that designates these species as ecosystem component species and prohibits new directed fisheries for these

Page 82: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

species without a full analysis. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the Council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Sincerely, Sara Vonde Veld 3230 SW Upper Drive Portland, Oregon 97201 From: Kathy <[email protected]> Date: Thu, Feb 26, 2015 at 10:00 AM Subject: Comments on Forage Fish Protection Alternative To: "[email protected]" <[email protected]> Dear Chair Lowman and Council Members, I am requesting that the Council take final action to protect unmanaged forage fish at the 3/9/15 meeting by adopting the final preferred alternative (Alternative 2) that designates these species as ecosystem component species and prohibits new directed fisheries for these species without a full analysis. This final action is crucial to maintaining long term health of the marine ecosystem. This action will also fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan. Scientific studies have shown that forage fish are essential to the ecosystem food chain. Thank you in advance for your commitment to maintaining a healthy ecosystem and sustainable fisheries. Sincerely, Kathy Balogh Portland, OR From: Molly McAllister <[email protected]> Date: Wed, Feb 25, 2015 at 4:40 PM Subject: Please adopt alternative 2 To: "[email protected]" <[email protected]>

Page 83: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

Dear Chair Lowman and Council members, I greatly appreciate the progress the Council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs and that seabirds, whales, and other marine life depend on forage fish as a vital food resource. As a lifelong Oregon resident, the health of our oceans and its impact on the health of our coastal areas holds deep meaning for my family and me. I respectfully ask the Council to take final action in protecting unmanaged forage fish at the March 9, 2015 meeting by adopting the final preferred alternative (Alternative 2) that designates these species as ecosystem component species and prohibits new directed fisheries for these species without a full analysis. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the Council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Sincerely, Molly McAllister Portland, Oregon From: Joseph Bartolucci <[email protected]> Date: Wed, Feb 25, 2015 at 4:42 PM Subject: Protect Forage Fish and our Sea Birds that depend on them To: "[email protected]" <[email protected]> Dear Chair Lowman and Council members, I greatly appreciate the progress the Council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs and that seabirds, whales, and other marine life depend on forage fish as a vital food resource. I respectfully ask the Council to take final action in protecting unmanaged forage fish at the March 9, 2015 meeting by adopting the final preferred alternative (Alternative 2) that designates these species as ecosystem component species and prohibits new directed fisheries for these species without a full analysis. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management.

Page 84: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the Council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Sincerely, Joe Bartolucci [email protected] [email protected] via server8839.e-activist.com Feb 26 (4 days ago) to pfmc.comments Dear Chair Lowman and council members, I greatly appreciate the steady progress the council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows—and the public recognizes—that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs. As you know, the ocean off the West Coast supports valuable commercial and recreational fisheries, as well as ecotourism and other industries that are economic drivers for our coastal communities. Healthy populations of forage fish make all of this possible. I join thousands of fellow citizens in supporting the council‘s final action, due in March, to protect currently unmanaged forage fish. This action will designate them as ecosystem component species and ensure that adequate science and management are in place before new commercial fisheries can target them. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Forage fish protection has also received strong support from a variety of stakeholders involved in fisheries management, including commercial and recreational fishermen, processors, environmentalists, and the agencies themselves. Rarely has there been such widespread agreement on a management action, and the council should be applauded for its inclusive, deliberate, and scientific process. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Certainly, protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Sincerely,

Page 85: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

Anne Sheldon Sandy Oregon [email protected] [email protected] via server8839.e-activist.com Feb 26 (4 days ago) to pfmc.comments Dear Chair Lowman and council members, I greatly appreciate the steady progress the council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows—and the public recognizes—that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs. As you know, the ocean off the West Coast supports valuable commercial and recreational fisheries, as well as ecotourism and other industries that are economic drivers for our coastal communities. Healthy populations of forage fish make all of this possible. I join thousands of fellow citizens in supporting the council‘s final action, due in March, to protect currently unmanaged forage fish. This action will designate them as ecosystem component species and ensure that adequate science and management are in place before new commercial fisheries can target them. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Forage fish protection has also received strong support from a variety of stakeholders involved in fisheries management, including commercial and recreational fishermen, processors, environmentalists, and the agencies themselves. Rarely has there been such widespread agreement on a management action, and the council should be applauded for its inclusive, deliberate, and scientific process. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Certainly, protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Sincerely, MARGARET HASHMI BELLINGHAM Washington [email protected] [email protected] via server8839.e-activist.com Feb 26 (4 days ago) to pfmc.comments Dear Chair Lowman and council members,

Page 86: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

I greatly appreciate the steady progress the council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows—and the public recognizes—that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs. As you know, the ocean off the West Coast supports valuable commercial and recreational fisheries, as well as ecotourism and other industries that are economic drivers for our coastal communities. Healthy populations of forage fish make all of this possible. I join thousands of fellow citizens in supporting the council‘s final action, due in March, to protect currently unmanaged forage fish. This action will designate them as ecosystem component species and ensure that adequate science and management are in place before new commercial fisheries can target them. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Forage fish protection has also received strong support from a variety of stakeholders involved in fisheries management, including commercial and recreational fishermen, processors, environmentalists, and the agencies themselves. Rarely has there been such widespread agreement on a management action, and the council should be applauded for its inclusive, deliberate, and scientific process. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Certainly, protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Sincerely, David Linn Ocean Shores Washington Christine Steele <[email protected]> Feb 27 (3 days ago) to pfmc.comments Dear Chair Lowman and Council members, I greatly appreciate the progress the Council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs and that seabirds, whales, and other marine life depend on forage fish as a vital food resource. I respectfully ask the Council to take final action in protecting unmanaged forage fish at the March 9, 2015 meeting by adopting the final preferred alternative (Alternative 2) that designates these species as ecosystem component species and prohibits new directed fisheries for these

Page 87: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

species without a full analysis. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the Council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Sincerely, Christine Steele, MS Portland, OR Dear Chair Lowman and Council members, I greatly appreciate the progress the Council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs and that seabirds, whales, and other marine life depend on forage fish as a vital food resource. I respectfully ask the Council to take final action in protecting unmanaged forage fish at the March 9, 2015 meeting by adopting the final preferred alternative (Alternative 2) that designates these species as ecosystem component species and prohibits new directed fisheries for these species without a full analysis. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the Council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Respectfully, Lynn DeLorme, RN Suzan Hill <[email protected]> Feb 27 (3 days ago) to pfmc.comments Dear Chair Lowman and Council members,

Page 88: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

I greatly appreciate the progress the Council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs and that seabirds, whales, and other marine life depend on forage fish as a vital food resource. I respectfully ask the Council to take final action in protecting unmanaged forage fish at the March 9, 2015 meeting by adopting the final preferred alternative (Alternative 2) that designates these species as ecosystem component species and prohibits new directed fisheries for these species without a full analysis. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the Council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Sincerely, Rev. Suzan Hill 10632 SE Pardee St. Portland, OR 97266 [email protected] [email protected] via server8839.e-activist.com Feb 28 (2 days ago) to pfmc.comments Dear Chair Lowman and council members, I greatly appreciate the steady progress the council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows—and the public recognizes—that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs. As you know, the ocean off the West Coast supports valuable commercial and recreational fisheries, as well as ecotourism and other industries that are economic drivers for our coastal communities. Healthy populations of forage fish make all of this possible. I join thousands of fellow citizens in supporting the council‘s final action, due in March, to protect currently unmanaged forage fish. This action will designate them as ecosystem component species and ensure that adequate science and management are in place before new commercial fisheries can target them. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Forage fish protection has also received strong support from a variety of stakeholders involved in fisheries management, including commercial and recreational fishermen, processors,

Page 89: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

environmentalists, and the agencies themselves. Rarely has there been such widespread agreement on a management action, and the council should be applauded for its inclusive, deliberate, and scientific process. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Certainly, protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Sincerely, Linda Ethier Portland Oregon [email protected] [email protected] via server8839.e-activist.com Feb 28 (2 days ago) to pfmc.comments Dear Chair Lowman and council members, I greatly appreciate the steady progress the council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows—and the public recognizes—that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs. As you know, the ocean off the West Coast supports valuable commercial and recreational fisheries, as well as ecotourism and other industries that are economic drivers for our coastal communities. Healthy populations of forage fish make all of this possible. I join thousands of fellow citizens in supporting the council‘s final action, due in March, to protect currently unmanaged forage fish. This action will designate them as ecosystem component species and ensure that adequate science and management are in place before new commercial fisheries can target them. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Forage fish protection has also received strong support from a variety of stakeholders involved in fisheries management, including commercial and recreational fishermen, processors, environmentalists, and the agencies themselves. Rarely has there been such widespread agreement on a management action, and the council should be applauded for its inclusive, deliberate, and scientific process. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its

Page 90: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Certainly, protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Sincerely, cris courter friday harbor Washington Sharon Treadgold <[email protected]> Feb 28 (2 days ago) to pfmc.comments Dear Chair Lowman and Council members, I greatly appreciate the progress the Council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs and that seabirds, whales, and other marine life depend on forage fish as a vital food resource. I respectfully ask the Council to take final action in protecting unmanaged forage fish at the March 9, 2015 meeting by adopting the final preferred alternative (Alternative 2) that designates these species as ecosystem component species and prohibits new directed fisheries for these species without a full analysis. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the Council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. I am a lover of wildlife and supporter of Audubon. As a school teacher, I urge you to take action to preserve our natural gifts for our future generations. Sincerely, Sharon Treadgold [email protected] [email protected] via server8839.e-activist.com Feb 28 (2 days ago) to pfmc.comments Dear Chair Lowman and council members,

Page 91: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

I greatly appreciate the steady progress the council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows—and the public recognizes—that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs. As you know, the ocean off the West Coast supports valuable commercial and recreational fisheries, as well as ecotourism and other industries that are economic drivers for our coastal communities. Healthy populations of forage fish make all of this possible. I join thousands of fellow citizens in supporting the council‘s final action, due in March, to protect currently unmanaged forage fish. This action will designate them as ecosystem component species and ensure that adequate science and management are in place before new commercial fisheries can target them. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Forage fish protection has also received strong support from a variety of stakeholders involved in fisheries management, including commercial and recreational fishermen, processors, environmentalists, and the agencies themselves. Rarely has there been such widespread agreement on a management action, and the council should be applauded for its inclusive, deliberate, and scientific process. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Certainly, protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Sincerely, Carol Taggart Menlo Park California Bryan Brock <[email protected]> Feb 28 (2 days ago) to pfmc.comments Dear Chair Lowman and Council members, I greatly appreciate the progress the Council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs and that seabirds, whales, and other marine life depend on forage fish as a vital food resource. I respectfully ask the Council to take final action in protecting unmanaged forage fish at the March 9, 2015 meeting by adopting the final preferred alternative (Alternative 2) that designates these species as ecosystem component species and prohibits new directed fisheries for these species without a full analysis. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical

Page 92: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the Council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Sincerely, Bryan Brock [email protected] [email protected] via server8839.e-activist.com Mar 1 (1 day ago) to pfmc.comments Dear Chair Lowman and council members, I greatly appreciate the steady progress the council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows—and the public recognizes—that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs. As you know, the ocean off the West Coast supports valuable commercial and recreational fisheries, as well as ecotourism and other industries that are economic drivers for our coastal communities. Healthy populations of forage fish make all of this possible. I join thousands of fellow citizens in supporting the council‘s final action, due in March, to protect currently unmanaged forage fish. This action will designate them as ecosystem component species and ensure that adequate science and management are in place before new commercial fisheries can target them. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Forage fish protection has also received strong support from a variety of stakeholders involved in fisheries management, including commercial and recreational fishermen, processors, environmentalists, and the agencies themselves. Rarely has there been such widespread agreement on a management action, and the council should be applauded for its inclusive, deliberate, and scientific process. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Certainly, protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Sincerely,

Page 93: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

David Linn Ocean Shores Washington Laura <[email protected]> Mar 1 (1 day ago) to pfmc.comments Dear Chair Lowman and Council members, I greatly appreciate the progress the Council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs and that seabirds, whales, and other marine life depend on forage fish as a vital food resource. I respectfully ask the Council to take final action in protecting unmanaged forage fish at the March 9, 2015 meeting by adopting the final preferred alternative (Alternative 2) that designates these species as ecosystem component species and prohibits new directed fisheries for these species without a full analysis. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the Council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Sincerely, Laura Rose Portland, Oregon Lisa Hou <[email protected]> 3:16 PM (22 hours ago) to pfmc.comments Dear Chair Lowman and Council members, I greatly appreciate the progress the Council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. Unmanaged and wild forage fish are critical for a balanced and undisturbed aquatic ecosystem. I respectfully ask the Council to take final action in protecting unmanaged forage fish at the March 9, 2015 meeting by adopting the final preferred alternative (Alternative 2) that designates these species as ecosystem component species and prohibits new directed fisheries for these

Page 94: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

species without a full analysis. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Taking final action in March is essential to preserving the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Sincerely, Lisa Hou [email protected] [email protected] via server8839.e-activist.com 4:13 PM (21 hours ago) to pfmc.comments Dear Chair Lowman and council members, I greatly appreciate the steady progress the council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows—and the public recognizes—that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs. As you know, the ocean off the West Coast supports valuable commercial and recreational fisheries, as well as ecotourism and other industries that are economic drivers for our coastal communities. Healthy populations of forage fish make all of this possible. I join thousands of fellow citizens in supporting the council‘s final action, due in March, to protect currently unmanaged forage fish. This action will designate them as ecosystem component species and ensure that adequate science and management are in place before new commercial fisheries can target them. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Forage fish protection has also received strong support from a variety of stakeholders involved in fisheries management, including commercial and recreational fishermen, processors, environmentalists, and the agencies themselves. Rarely has there been such widespread agreement on a management action, and the council should be applauded for its inclusive, deliberate, and scientific process. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Certainly, protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Sincerely, Barbara Arlen

Page 95: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

Barbara Arlen Corvallis Oregon [email protected] [email protected] via server8839.e-activist.com 5:25 PM (20 hours ago) to pfmc.comments Dear Chair Lowman and council members, I greatly appreciate the steady progress the council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows—and the public recognizes—that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs. As you know, the ocean off the West Coast supports valuable commercial and recreational fisheries, as well as ecotourism and other industries that are economic drivers for our coastal communities. Healthy populations of forage fish make all of this possible. I join thousands of fellow citizens in supporting the council‘s final action, due in March, to protect currently unmanaged forage fish. This action will designate them as ecosystem component species and ensure that adequate science and management are in place before new commercial fisheries can target them. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Forage fish protection has also received strong support from a variety of stakeholders involved in fisheries management, including commercial and recreational fishermen, processors, environmentalists, and the agencies themselves. Rarely has there been such widespread agreement on a management action, and the council should be applauded for its inclusive, deliberate, and scientific process. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Certainly, protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Sincerely, Barbara Rosenkotter Deer Harbor Washington Stephanie Smith <[email protected]> 5:43 PM (20 hours ago)

Page 96: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

to pfmc.comments Dear Chair Lowman and Council members, I greatly appreciate the progress the Council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs and that seabirds, whales, and other marine life depend on forage fish as a vital food resource. I respectfully ask the Council to take final action in protecting unmanaged forage fish at the March 9, 2015 meeting by adopting the final preferred alternative (Alternative 2) that designates these species as ecosystem component species and prohibits new directed fisheries for these species without a full analysis. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the Council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Sincerely, Stephanie E Smith [email protected] 7:46 PM (18 hours ago) to pfmc.comments Dear Chair Lowman and Council members, I greatly appreciate the progress the Council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs and that seabirds, whales, and other marine life depend on forage fish as a vital food resource. I respectfully ask the Council to take final action in protecting unmanaged forage fish at the March 9, 2015 meeting by adopting the final preferred alternative (Alternative 2) that designates these species as ecosystem component species and prohibits new directed fisheries for these species without a full analysis. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the Council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its

Page 97: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Our environment and its multitude of dazzling ecosystems are our biggest treasures. Sincerely, Melody Owen Sherry <[email protected]> 9:01 PM (17 hours ago) to pfmc.comments Dear Chair Lowman and Council members, I greatly appreciate the progress the Council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs and that seabirds, whales, and other marine life depend on forage fish as a vital food resource. I respectfully ask the Council to take final action in protecting unmanaged forage fish at the March 9, 2015 meeting by adopting the final preferred alternative (Alternative 2) that designates these species as ecosystem component species and prohibits new directed fisheries for these species without a full analysis. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the Council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Sincerely, Sherry Reuter 2515 18th Avenue Forest Grove, Oregon 97116 Becky Tengs <[email protected]> 10:30 PM (15 hours ago) to pfmc.comments Dear Chair Lowman and Council members,

Page 98: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

I greatly appreciate the progress the Council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs and that seabirds, whales, and other marine life depend on forage fish as a vital food resource. I respectfully ask the Council to take final action in protecting unmanaged forage fish at the March 9, 2015 meeting by adopting the final preferred alternative (Alternative 2) that designates these species as ecosystem component species and prohibits new directed fisheries for these species without a full analysis. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the Council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Sincerely, Becky Tengs Eva Email <[email protected]> 6:17 AM (7 hours ago) to pfmc.comments Dear Chair Lowman and Council members, I greatly appreciate the progress the Council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs and that seabirds, whales, and other marine life depend on forage fish as a vital food resource. I respectfully ask the Council to take final action in protecting unmanaged forage fish at the March 9, 2015 meeting by adopting the final preferred alternative (Alternative 2) that designates these species as ecosystem component species and prohibits new directed fisheries for these species without a full analysis. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the Council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Protecting forage fish is a great first step.

Page 99: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Sincerely, Eva Conway-McGuire [email protected] 6:33 AM (7 hours ago) to pfmc.comments Dear Chair Lowman and Council members, I greatly appreciate the progress the Council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs and that seabirds, whales, and other marine life depend on forage fish as a vital food resource. I respectfully ask the Council to take final action in protecting unmanaged forage fish at the March 9, 2015 meeting by adopting the final preferred alternative (Alternative 2) that designates these species as ecosystem component species and prohibits new directed fisheries for these species without a full analysis. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the Council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Sincerely, Diane Rios Portland, OR Shannon Carson <[email protected]> 8:31 AM (5 hours ago) to pfmc.comments Dear Chair Lowman and Council members, I greatly appreciate the progress the Council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs and that seabirds, whales, and other marine life depend on forage fish as a vital food resource.

Page 100: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

I respectfully ask the Council to take final action in protecting unmanaged forage fish at the March 9, 2015 meeting by adopting the final preferred alternative (Alternative 2) that designates these species as ecosystem component species and prohibits new directed fisheries for these species without a full analysis. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the Council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Sincerely, Shannon Carson Moss Drake <[email protected]> 9:13 AM (4 hours ago) to pfmc.comments Dear Chair Lowman and Council members, I greatly appreciate the progress the Council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs and that seabirds, whales, and other marine life depend on forage fish as a vital food resource. I respectfully ask the Council to take final action in protecting unmanaged forage fish at the March 9, 2015 meeting by adopting the final preferred alternative (Alternative 2) that designates these species as ecosystem component species and prohibits new directed fisheries for these species without a full analysis. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Sincerely, Moss Drake

Page 101: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

Kari Luna <[email protected]> to pfmc.comments Dear Chair Lowman and Council members, I greatly appreciate the progress the Council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs and that seabirds, whales, and other marine life depend on forage fish as a vital food resource. I respectfully ask the Council to take final action in protecting unmanaged forage fish at the March 9, 2015 meeting by adopting the final preferred alternative (Alternative 2) that designates these species as ecosystem component species and prohibits new directed fisheries for these species without a full analysis. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the Council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. It’s here for all of us, and it’s our duty to protect it. Sincerely, Kari Luna [email protected] From: Ann Littlewood <[email protected]> Date: Sun, Mar 1, 2015 at 10:50 AM Subject: Forage Fish regulations To: [email protected] Dear Chair Lowman and Council members, Please protect unmanaged forage fish at the March 9, 2015 meeting by adopting the final preferred alternative (Alternative 2) that designates these species as ecosystem component species and prohibits new directed fisheries for these species without a full analysis. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the Council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Sincerely, Ann Littlewood Portland, OR

Page 102: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

From: Scott Carpenter <[email protected]> Date: Sun, Mar 1, 2015 at 8:13 PM Subject: Pacific Fishery Management Council - Comments To: [email protected] Dear Chair Lowman and Council Members, I am writing to ask the Council to take final action in protecting unmanaged forage fish at the March 9, 2015 meeting by adopting the final preferred alternative (Alternative 2) that designates these species as ecosystem component species and prohibits new directed fisheries for these species without a full analysis. Thank you for your time and consideration. Sincerely, Scott Carpenter 8405 SW Power Ct Portland, OR 97225-3427 From: Monica Drake <[email protected]> Date: Sun, Mar 1, 2015 at 6:13 PM Subject: Forage Fish To: [email protected] Dear Chair Lowman and Council members, As a life-long Oregonian, I love and respect the land, water and ecosystems. There's a reason I've stayed in this beautiful state. Please, take the necessary steps to do what we can to save the health of our oceans for future generations. I believe forage fish truly are a crucial link in ocean food webs and that "seabirds, whales, and other marine life depend on forage fish as a vital food resource." It's so very important. I'm taking time away from Sunday dinner with the family to reach out to you and to others, to everyone I know, asking people to speak up about this. I respectfully ask the Council to take final action in protecting unmanaged forage fish at the March 9, 2015 meeting by adopting the final preferred alternative (Alternative 2) that designates these species as ecosystem component species and prohibits new directed fisheries for these species without a full analysis. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the Council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its

Page 103: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Sincerely, Monica Drake From: Marty Wallauer <[email protected]> Date: Sun, Mar 1, 2015 at 5:08 PM Subject: Protect Fish Forage To: [email protected] Dear Chair Lowman and Council members, I respectfully ask the Council to take final action in protecting unmanaged forage fish at the March 9, 2015 meeting by adopting the final preferred alternative (Alternative 2) that designates these species as ecosystem component species and prohibits new directed fisheries for these species without a full analysis. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Thank you, Martha R Wallauer Oregon City Clare McClellan <[email protected]> 7:59 PM (13 hours ago) to pfmc.comments Dear Chair Lowman and Council members, I greatly appreciate the progress the Council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs and that seabirds, whales, and other marine life depend on forage fish as a vital food resource. I respectfully ask the Council to take final action in protecting unmanaged forage fish at the March 9, 2015 meeting by adopting the final preferred alternative (Alternative 2) that designates these species as ecosystem component species and prohibits new directed fisheries for these species without a full analysis. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the Council will fulfill the

Page 104: rMarch 2015 - Pacific Fishery Management Council · March 2, 2015 . Dorothy Lowman, Chair . ... DAVID ARNSON Los Angeles CA VANCE ARQUILLA ... DONNA CRANE Anderson CA

first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Sincerely, Clare McClellan From: Lucas Knowles <[email protected]> Date: Mon, Mar 2, 2015 at 4:30 PM Subject: Upcoming PFMC Meeting - for your consideration To: [email protected] Dear Chair Lowman and Council members, I greatly appreciate the progress the Council has made over the past three years to protect forage fish. The science clearly shows that forage fish are the critical middle link in ocean food webs and that seabirds, whales, and other marine life depend on forage fish as a vital food resource. I respectfully ask the Council to take final action in protecting unmanaged forage fish at the March 9, 2015 meeting by adopting the final preferred alternative (Alternative 2) that designates these species as ecosystem component species and prohibits new directed fisheries for these species without a full analysis. Establishing basic, precautionary management for these critical species makes sense and is an important step in the transition to ecosystem-based fishery management. Taking final action in March is essential to maintaining the long-term health of our West Coast marine ecosystem and all the benefits we derive from it. In so doing, the Council will fulfill the first initiative of its Fishery Ecosystem Plan, a visionary document intended to guide its implementation of ecosystem-based fishery management. Protecting forage fish is a great first step. Thank you for your continued commitment to maintaining a healthy ocean and sustainable fisheries. Sincerely, Luke Knowles