Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    1/156

    To:

    From

    Submitted by

    Subject

    CITYOF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA

    Council Report

    November 5, 2013

    Honorable Mayor and Members o f the City Council

    Jason Stilwell City Administrator

    Susan Paul, Administrative Services Director

    Consideration of a Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year FY) 2013-2017

    Information Technology Strategic Plan

    Recommendation s) : Adopt the attached Resolution Attachment } adopting the City s FY 2013-2017

    Information Technology Strategic Plan Attachment II} .

    Executive Summary: In January 2013 the City Council adopted the development of an InformationTechnology and Interactive Government Project as one of its key initiatives for

    the year. To accomplish this initiative staff engaged in a Strategic Planning

    process that began in March 2013. The process included a series of interviews

    with elected officials and staff . In April the City s leadership team participated in

    a series of workshops to define how information technology can be used to

    effectively and efficiently support the City s daily functions, increase

    transparency and prepared the organization to meet changing services .

    The draft IT Strategic Plan Working Document Attachment Ill) was presented in

    a public workshop on September 9, 2013 was posted on the City s website andthree additional public workshops were conducted for the purpose of receiving

    public comment.

    The document presented for adoption reflects the results of the planningprocess and includes the City s vision for Information Technology IT), guid ing

    principles, definition of key goals, strategic objectives, and initiatives to be

    addressed over the next five years.

    Analysis/Discussion : The City s Information Technology {IT) has not been updated in many years .

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    2/156

    define the City s IT needs currently and into the future. Four public input

    workshops were conducted and the Draft Plan was po sted on the City s websitefor comment and feedback. The collaborative strategic planning process yielded

    important insight that led to prioritizing core infrastructure projects ahead of

    the more exciting web enabled app licants.

    The IT plan goals and objectives were developed using the Balanced Scorecard

    Methodology . The B ala nced Scorecard is a management system that enablesorganizations to clarify their vision and strategy and translate them into action.

    t provides feedback around bo th the internal business processes and externaloutcomes in orde r to continuously impro ve strategic perspective and re s ults.

    The 2013-2017 Information Technology IT) Strategic Plan provides a framework

    and road map to create alignment with the City s goals, the Adopted Budget and

    department needs.

    Key objectives o f the Plan include:

    Establishing a City wide direction for IT services

    Supporting open government through this transparency, accountability

    and collaboration

    Empowering everyone by providing access to IT so lution s

    anytime/anywhere

    Decreasing the City s environmental footprint

    Goals of the IT plan include :

    Easy access to information (anytime/anyplace)

    IT applications designed to encourage collaboration and communication

    between internal and external users

    Processes and procedures to manage and track the IT investment

    Streamlining business processes and enablingan

    outcome basedaccountable approach to service delivery

    Provide staff with tools and training that enable them to work

    collaboratively to provide internal and external customers the required

    level of support

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    3/156

    Key to the success of the Plan is its implementation and expert technicalassistance will be needed . Staff will return on a future Agenda with animplementation consulting contract.

    iscal Impact:

    Budgeted yes/no)Immediate infrastructure projects {financialsystem, payroll, HRIS, website updates and

    Granicus) were included in the FY 2013-14budge. -Estimated FY 2013-14 expenditure135,000-

    Previous Council

    Action/Decision History :

    Funding Source general fund, grant, state)General Fund

    In January 2013, the City Council adopted the development of the IT Strategic

    Technology Plan and Interactive Government Projects one of its key init iatives.

    Attachment:

    {Attachment 1 - {Attachment II)- {Attachment Ill)-

    Reviewed by

    City d m i n i s t r t o r [0

    Resolut ion adopting the City's 2013-2017 Internal TechnologyInformation Technology Strategic PlanIT Strategic Plan Working Document

    City Attorney Admin istrative Services

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    4/156

    ATTACHMENT ICITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE -SEA

    CITY COUNCIL

    RESOLUTION 2013-

    A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEAADOPTING THE CITY FISCAL YEAR FY) 2013-2017 INFORMATION

    TECHNOLOGY STRATEGIC PLAN

    WHEREAS, n January 2013, the City Council adopted the d eve lop me nt of an InformationTechnology and Interactive Government Project as one of its key initiatives for th e year; and

    WHEREAS, The FY 2013-2017 IT strategic planning process began with a technicalassessment of the City s IT infra struc ture with extensive internal int erviews and public review and

    co mment ; and

    WHEREAS , the plan is a living document responsive to changing ne eds and prioritie s and theavailability of funds; and

    WHEREAS , the plan identifies the estimated costs of the key initiatives /projects, each keyinitiative /project will have its own work plan and b e brought forward when appropriate through thebudget or capital planning proce ss; and

    WHEREAS , the 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan provides a framework androad map to create alignment with the City s goals , the Adopted Budget and department needs.

    NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED THAT THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OFCARMEL-BY-THE-SEA does hereby:

    Adopt the Information Technology Strategic Plan for City Fiscal Year FY) 2013-2017

    PASSED AND ADOPTED BY TH E CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CARMEL-BYTHE-SEA this TH day ofNovember 2013 by the following roll call vote :

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    5/156

    AYES:

    NOES:

    ABSENT:

    ABSTAIN:

    ATTEST:

    Daryl Betancur CMCDeputy Cit y Clerk

    COUNCIL MEMBERS:

    COUNCIL MEMBERS :

    COUNCIL MEMB ERS:

    COUNCIL MEMBERS:

    SIGNED

    Jason Burnett MAYOR

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    6/156

    ttachment

    CARMELBy the Sea

    2013 2017 Information TechnologyStrategic Plan

    November 5 2013

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    7/156

    : . : 1i t Message from the CityAdministrator,, -

    November 5, 2013

    Carmel-by-the-Sea recognizes Information Technology (IT) as a critical component in the delivery ofservices to the publicand , as such, includes the Information Technology Strategic Plan as a key component of the City s Policy Planning andManagement System. I am pleased to present the FY2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan. This Plan willguide the City s acquisition, management and use of information technology for the next five years . It should be noted thatthis is a strategic plan, not a work plan. Annually, an IT Work Plan willbe developed as part of the Annual Operating andBudget development process . Those projects identified later in this document as Year 1 projects are included in theFY2013-2014 Adopted Budget.

    IT s quicklybecoming the veh icle of choice for direct deliveryof many City services . Carmel-by-the-Sea has an opportunityto gain recognition as a leader in innovative governance through engaging new IT solutions . This Plan addresses improvingthe efficiencyof City staff while significantlyreducing the City s environmental footprint. Residents and customers of the Citywillbenefit from increased transparency , ease of conducting business with the City and new opportunities for participation incommunitydiscussions and forums.

    Initially, the focus willbe on shoring up the existing technology infrastructure through the replacement of aging ha rdware andsoftware followed by the acquisition of new software tools such as a modern financial system and a human res ource system.The goal is to improve the efficiencyof dailyoperations while preparing for new ways to deliverpublic services. At the sametime , we willbegin an upgrade of our web broadcast system used fo r City Council, Planning Commission and other publicmeetings by adding an Agenda Management system that willmake it easier for the public to followand participate more fullyin the legislativeprocess. The availability of information and documents , and the opportunityto be involved willbe morereadily available than ever before . Thus willbegin a new era of transparency from City Hall.

    Our challenge now will beto execute on the plans we have made . The City s ultimate goal is to successfully implement thePlan s initiativesin a planned and collaborative manner by followinga ormal, project managemen t methodology, adopting

    business process improvements and enhancing publicse rvice through technology.

    Resoectfullv.

    Jason Stilwell

    CityAdministrator

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    8/156

    The City s information technology implementation has fallen behind in recent years . Most business functions either are stillperformed manually or rely on outdated applications that are difficult to support . Access to data is extremely limitedresul ting in time-consuming manual processes to collect and aggregate data for analysis and reporting .

    The Cityhas a unique opportunity now to capitalize on new, integrated technologies to streamline daily operations, mprovetransparency and increase responsiveness and flexibility.

    The FY2013-2017 Information Technology T) strategic planning process began in March 2013 when Public ConsultingGroup conducted a technical assessment of the City s IT infrastructure. This was followed by a series of interviews withelected officialsand staff. Beginning in April, the City s leaders hip team participated in a series of workshops to define howinformation tec hnology ca n be used to effectivelyand efficientlysupport the City s daily operations, increase transpa rencyand prepare for future demands . Part icipants :

    Discussed the current state of the City s technology Defined the to-be state for technology keeping in mind the City s

    goals and objectives Developed a vision and mission for the City s IT implementation Identifiedand prioritized initiatives

    Subsequently, the draft Plan was presented to the City Council in apublic workshop setting, posted on the City s website and available atthree additional workshops held to receive public comment. Thecollaborative strategic planning process yielded important insight thatled to prioritizing core , back office infrastructure projects ahead of themore exciting web-enabled applications and seNices that havebecome the norm for seNice delivery in many jurisdictions. The latterwill follow the infrastructure upgrades and provide an opportunity for increased civic engagement in the governanceprocess .

    This document prese nts the results of the planning process: the City s Vsion for IT, Guiding Principles, identificationofGoals, Strategic Objectives and Initiatives to be addressed over the next five years.

    Methodology ApproachThe IT Stra teg ic Plan goals and objectives were developed using the Balanced Scorecard Methodology. The BalancedScorecard is a management system that enables organizations to clarify their vision and strategy and translate them intoaction. It provides feedback around both the internal business processes and external outcomes in order to continuouslyimprove strategic performance and results .

    The initiatives outlined on the followingpages are designed to answer the followingquestions from four perspectives :

    Customer: What needs to be done to meet cus tomer expectations and ach ieve their business requirements?

    Financial How will we effectively use and leverage taxpayer dollars ensuring good value for our technologyexpenditures?

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    9/156

    _;: I:

    ~ : : ._ Vision, Mission and Goals~ - .

    Technology planning is imperative for the City to meet service demands efficiently and effectively while ma intaining aconsistent focus on investment and improvement. The 2013-2017 Information Technology (IT) Strategic Plan provides aframework and roadmap to create alignment with the City s Goals , the Adopted Operating Plan and Budget and departmentalIT needs . Objectives in developing the Plan included:

    Establishing a Citywidedirection for ITservices Supporting open government through transparency, accountability, and collaboration Empoweringeveryone by providingaccess to informationtechnology solutions, anytime and anywhere Decreasing the City s environmental footprint

    ITVis io nStrategic Objectives

    To Achieve the Goals We Will:

    Carmel-by-the-Sea will be recognized as a leader where res idents ,businesses, visitors and government connect and work together forthe benefit of the community through innovative and engaging ITsolutions.

    Provide a secure. reliable and accessibleinfrastructureIncrease access channels

    Provide the information people need and want:when they want itEnable data sharing and exchangeImplement intuitive, easy-to-use applicationsImplement intuitive, easy-to-use collaborationtoolsDevelop an IT funding strategyDevelop an IT sourcing strategy

    Leverage publicfprivateand public/publicpartnershipsImplement applications to support routinebusiness needsImplement a performance management systemtied to C ty goals objectivesReduce the time it takes to access services andconduct businessStreamline and integrate business processesand workflowUnderstand custome r business needsPrepare for the future through research anddevelopmentIncrease technical expertise and proficiency

    T MissionBy embracing the core standards of quality service, accountability,efficiency and customer orientation, City IT will provide the highestlevel of professional services to its customers through innovativeinformation technology solutions aligned with the City's strategicgoals and objectives.

    Goa ls

    Residents, businesses , visitors and staff have easy access tothe information and transactions they need at their conven ience(anytime; anyplace ).

    IT applications are designed to encourage collaborat ion andcommunication among internal and external users.

    Processes and procedures are in place to manage and track ITinvestments to ensure they directly and measurably , supportbusiness priorities, nitiativesand outcome goals.

    The City's applications effectively streamline businessprocesses , improve information sharing and enable an outcomebased , accountable approach to service delivery.

    City staff are provided tools and training that enable them towork collaboratively to provide internal and external customers

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    10/156

    ~ ~ The Plan in a Nutshell

    T o day: Departments operate in silos with littledata-sharing and In some cases, no automatedsystems, which pr e vents everyone from seeingthe Big P i c t u ~\

    Th e Plan : Implement an Enterprise R es ou r c ePlanning system and associated to o ls to a utomatawof c ow and agg r ega t e data built upon a s ecureand modern e c . h n l a ~ l l n t r a s t r u c t : u r e :

    S c~ u r lt y . nd Pr lv aey

    :

    First Things First

    Th e Result : Online Citv Hall \Nhere Informat i o n andapplications become vai lable for the convenienc e tr e s i dents , business and visitors .

    O ntlno Co un cil g c n d ~s

    Before the C ty can emba rk on implementat ion of initiatives , it must ge t its technological brick and mortar City Hallfunctioning more efficiently. The City s technology is old and no longer serving the City well. The first step inimplementation of the IT Strategic P an is to modernize the current technology infrastructure. This will begin with a modes tNetwork Upgrade to increase capacity and strengthen network security. This will be followed by a Redesig n of the City sWebsite, and the implementation of a new Financial and Payro ll Human Resou rce (HR system to ens ure t he City caneffectivelyand efficiently process financial and HR transactions . At the same time , the City wll begin an Upgrade of theGranicus system , currently used to broadcast City Council and Plann ing Commission mee tings . This expans ion will includethe implementation of an automated Agenda Packet to streamline the creat ion, approval and public pos ting of City Council

    d Pl i C i i ti t i l ki th i f ti i t t i d

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    11/156

    ._ The Plan at a Glance___

    BSC Customer Perspective :

    Goal1 : Residents , businesses , visitorsand staff have easy access to the

    informationand transactions they needat their convenience (anytime;anyplace).

    Goal 2: ITapplications are designed toencourage collaboration andcommunication among internal and

    external users.

    BSC Financial Perspective :

    Goal 3: Processes and procedures arein place to manage and track ITinvestments to ensure they directlyandmeasurably , support business priorities,initiativesand outcome goals.

    BSC Internal Process Perspective :Goal 4: The City s applicationseffectivelystreamline businessprocesses , improve information sharingand enable an outcome-based ,accountable approach to servicedelivery.

    BSC Learning Growth Perspective:

    Goal 5: Citystaff are provided tools andtraining that enable them to workcollaborativelyto provide internal and

    t l t th high t lit

    Provide a secure, reliable andaccessible infrastructure

    Increase access channels Provide the information peopleneed

    and want; when they want it

    Enable data sharing and exchange Implement intuitive, easy-to-use

    applications Implement intu itive, easy-to-use

    collaboration tools

    Develop an IT funding strategy Develop an ITsourcing strategy Leverage public/p vate and public/public

    partnerships

    Implement applications to supportroutine business needs

    Implemen t a performance managementsystem tied to Citygoals objectives

    Reduce the time it takes to accessservices and conduc t business

    Streamline and integrate bus ines sprocesses and workflow

    Understand cus tomer business needs Prepare for the future through research

    and development Increase technical expertise and

    proficiency

    Online C ty Hall- Increase AccessChannels

    Business Continuity DisasterPreparednes s

    Technical Architecture IT Security Program

    Online City Hall- CitySource CivicEngagement

    Online C ty Hall-Web Enterprise Resource Planning

    Sys tem - Agenda Managemen tSystem

    ITGovernance

    Enterprise Resource PlanningSystem - Application Infrastructure

    o Business Process Re-engineering

    o Financial / Payroll / HRo Public Safety Applicationso F ee t/Facility/Tree/Fue l

    Managemento Permittingand Code

    Complianceo Contact Managemento Reco rds Man

    Online City Hall- Res identBusiness Outreach

    Using IT Effectively Program IT Sta ffDevelopment Program

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    12/156

    \

    : Initiatives- - - - - - ~

    Eight Strategic Initiatives and multiple projects were identified to help close the gap between where the City s informationtechnology implementation is today and where it needs to be in the future. Successfu l execution of these initiatives will helpthe City ach ieve its ITobjectives. Numerous projects fall under these initiatives. The following pages summarize initiatives.

    The Vis io n Onlin e ity Ha llThe goal of the Online City Hall is to create an electronic presence wherethe publlic can ind information and conduct business without having tophys ically come to City Hall. Most important it is a place where thecommunity and City government can come together to share informationand discuss important issues . There are five main components of theOnline City Hall initiative:

    Website EnhancementCity Source Civic Engageme ntResident I Business Outreach

    Increase Access Channels for Service Delivery

    Business Process IntegrationThese five lay the foundation which will ultimatelylead to a technology

    On l n e o neH Age n d u

    - .

    ~ ~ ~

    Colfl ' ' ity

    ~ t >ct: t ~ . . _ f ;~ th We:b

    . . by cr e dk c rd

    implementation designed to bring City government and the community closer together through shared forums and greate rtransparency.

    Website Enhancemen t is the backbone of Online City Hall providing a new design and supporting structure for the City sweb presence providingboth internal and external services . This includes:

    The techn ical infrastructure required to meet the City s online applications needs Utility-likeservices necessary to facilitateelectronic transac tions Links to other reg ional governments and organizations to provide a regional view or res iden ts businesses and

    visitors Taking advantage of cloud-based applications that make it easier for the public to receive and share information

    with the City Skills transference to City staff to enable the departments to fullyutilize this infrastructure moving forward

    Finally it includes the implementation of personalization capabi lity so that stakeho lders can se lect what information they areinte reste d in whether they want to retrieve that information themselves or have it sent to them automatica lly the requency ofwhen they would liketo receive it and how they would like to see it.

    ity Source Civic Engagement is the implementation of applications to provide information and se rvices to both internaland external stakeholders via the enhanced website. This includes services such as online business license and buildingpermit applications, the abilityto report problems or make a service reques t via the web and I or mobile devices providingcomments on City Council agenda items prior to the meeting and implementation of a community calendar. The goal is todeploy app lications des igned to enhance civic engagement and to implement applications des igned to recognize andsupport Carmel s unique village characteristics.

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    13/156

    ~ ~ -' = r:

    _ _ :_

    - \ rl ~ - .

    Finally, those business processes affected by this new approach to se rvice prov1s1on will be reviewed to identifyopportunities for Business Process Integration and information sharing to streamline business operations and improvecustomer service. Objectives include:

    Provide services bringing people together for the benefit of the community Provide the highest level of services to customers through innovative ITso lutions Streamline processes making it easier for the public to interact with Citygovernment Lowerthe cost of government while improvingservice Improve transparency into City government Present all the wonderful things Carmel-by-the-Sea has to offer to potential residents , businesses and visitors

    Enterprise Resource Planning ERP) System the Application InfrastructureThis initiativeis the foundational initiativeof the ITStrategic Plan. The goal is to replace current dispara te, outdated systemswith integrated systems built upon a shared database in order tostreamline and automate work processes and more easily share data.The scope is to define requirements , reengineer business processes ,se lect and implement systems and train staff on effective use of the newtools. Objectives include:

    Improve efficiencyof daily business operations Improve data accuracy and ease of reporting Enable internal and external customers to find and access the

    data they need to answer questions and make informeddecisions .

    The diagram to the right, a depiction of the City's desired ApplicationInfrastructure, contains many components ; some not traditionallyconsidered part of an ERP . Ultimately, these are the systems I modulesthe City envisions as necessary for full realizationof the ITvision. Not allwill berealized during the Plan s five-yearplanning window.

    urk r k u: : ~ ~.

    _

    ERP projects can be simple or complicated depending on the approach . Carme l-by-the-Sea has chosen to followthe lesscomplicated approach by focus ing initiallyon those core functions necessary for the provision of basic City serv ices .Initially, the focus will be on replac ing the City s aging Fina ncial system and implementing a Payroll I Human Resourcesystem . An Agenda Management system and Permitting system willfollow. These willbe implemented as hosted so lutionswith vendors providing support for the new systems rather than buying and/or deve loping City-specific applications. Animportant aspect of these projects willbe business process re -engineering -looking at how the City can streamline bus inessprocesses to take advantage of the new tools. Implementation of these systems will provide the first steps in increasedtransparency by making informationmore readily available to staff and the public.

    The FY2013/2014 Capital Plan contains funding to begin implementation of the Fnanc ial Human Resources , Agenda

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    14/156

    Ji

    Technical rchitecture

    c or

    I 4 ~Q t y E n t r p t t M t f t f ~ r

    _ . -J J

    -

    Enterprise Technical Architecture is the term used to descr ibe the variouscomponents comprising an organization s IT implementation as illustrated in thediagram to the left. The goal of this initiativeis ensure the City s IT components arealigned with the City s core goals and strategic direction. An upgraded technologyinfrastructure, capable of supporting the applications desc ribed n the Plan will enablethe City to provide services to meet the City s current and future needs.

    Objectives include: Develop a scalable and flexibletechnical infrastructure Leverage the City s existing hardware and software resources Develop a unding strategy to ensure the sustainability of the infrastructure Take advantage of newer technologies, such as cloud-enabled applications Develop a replace and refresh strategy

    IT Security ProgramResidents and businesses trust the City to safeguard their personal information and to protec t its IT investments . Thisinitiative includes developing a comprehensive informationtechnology security program to ensure the sa fety of sensit ive andconfidential information. Objectives include:

    Develop security policies and procedures to protect the City s informationassets regardless of technology platform Implement procedures to mitigate the impact of ITsecurity incidents Develop a securityawareness program Balance security measures with the need to get workdone

    Business Continuity and Disaster RecoveryThe Citydepends upon the use of information technologyfor service delivery, especially during times of eme rgency whenspeed and efficiency could affect lives. Working in conjunction with Public Safety, IT bus iness continuity and disasterrecovery plans will be developed based upon City and departmental business needs . An important goal is to balance riskversus cost when making recommendations . Risk measures willbe developed . Objectives include :

    Prevent and mitigatethe risks of ITdisastersReduce risk of partial failures

    o Minimizepotential of complete system failures Prevent and mitigate the risks of non-IT disasters on IT resources Leverage current and future technology investments Prepare for disasters via scenario deve lopment and drills

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    15/156

    Using IT EffectivelyA highly trained, flexible workforce is essential in achieving the vision set forth in this Plan . This initiative is des igned to

    enhance the technology skills of all City employees . The goal is to provide staff with theknowledge and skills needed to effectively utilize the City s technology tools to maximumbenefit. The Using IT Effectively initiativecons ists of developing and implementing an ITtraining program for all City employees. In order to maximize the value of the City sinvestment in IT, City employees must be able to take full advan tage of new au tomatedtools to increase their efficiency and effectiveness . We will accomplish this by trainingemployees in the use of the new tools so that IT investments res ult in productivity andefficiency gainsand by encouraging all employees to identifyways in which tech nology canassist them in day-to-day activities.

    Objectives include:

    Easy-to-use technologies are implemented to suppo rt business processes Employees understand how to maximize the technology tools provided

    IT Staff evelopment ProgramThe scope of this initiative is to identify the skills needed to support the City s IT needs and then develop plans andprograms to enhance, develop and maintain those skillsets.

    Objectives include:

    Provide the highest qualityservice with a well-trained staff Recruit, train and develop staff to support the City s nformation technology

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    16/156

    . ~: IT Governance\

    IT Governance is the framework for how IT decisions and policies aremade, administered and enforced . This framework includes anapprec iation for the critical im portance of personnel , organizations andbusiness processes affected by changing techno logies within a complexand rapidly evolving information centric environment. IT Governance isconcerned about two things:

    Ensuring IT investments deliver maximum value to the enterprise

    Mitigation of IT risks

    The goals of this initiative are to:

    Design , implement and institutionalize an IT Governance modelthat will provide guidance on the management of informationtechnology and a ramework formaking timelyIT decisions

    Clearly define the process , rules , agreements and standardsappropriate for the City s IT needs

    Objectives include :

    Ensure IT resources are deployed to deliver maximum value

    Ensure appropriate management of IT-related risks

    Ensure that IT investments are in alignment with and support theCity s performance management systems, initiatives and theannual budget process

    iscal Strategies

    As part of the IT Governance initiative, fiscal strategies will be developed.These wll include :

    IT funding strategies

    IT sourcing strateg ies

    These will be approached with a goal of developing and leveraging publicprivate partnersh ips as well as partnerships with regional governmententities.

    Gu ding ncip les

    The following P rinciples will gu ide ou rdecision-making :

    Informa tion technology decision-making willbedriven by the City s business need s andavailable resou rces.

    Quality Service, Accountability. Efficiency andCustomer Orientation will be the drivingconsiderations when selecting andimplementing IT solutions .

    We will make resource inves tments thatsupport the C ty s long-term vision and strateg icdirection .

    We willidentify. measure and track the value ofIT investments and increase accountabilityof ITexpenditures

    Strateg 1c partnerships will be estab lishedbetween stake holders and the City so that thebene fits of IT are leverage d to improvecustomer service and maximize the productivityof City employees .

    IT will facilitate the development of a businessdnven architecture that ensures departmen tscan effectively communicate with each other.and share and exch ange mformation asappropriate

    We will implement security policies andstan dards to protect systems. ne tworks.resources and da ta from loss and unauthorizedaccess . use . modification. destruction. anddisclosure

    Secunty will be the respo nsibility of every Cityemp loyee . Employees will be trained so thatthey can prevent secunty incidents fromhappen ing and de tect and mitigate suchincidents when they occur.

    We will partne r with neighboring junsdictionsand organizations when possible .

    We w ll use open source solutions whenfeasible.

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    17/156

    [ ~ Implementingthe Plan~ ~ \ -

    Following are the preliminaryhigh-levelcost estimates for Plan initiatives. Estimated costs are based upon experienceand/or research and the scope of work as envisioned during the planning process. Both a low and high estimate areprovided due to the uncertain nature of estimating at this level of detail. Costs willbe refined each year as part of thebudgeting process and/or when a given project is undertaken.

    I Beginningnline City Hall- Increase Access Channels FY13/14

    Business Continuityand Disaster Recovery FY14/15Goal

    Technical Architecture FY13/14

    ITSecurity Program FY13/14

    Online CityHall- CitySource CivicEngagement FY14/15

    Goal2 Online City Hall- Web FY14/15

    ERP - Agenda Management System FY13/14

    Goal3 ITGovernance FY13/14

    ERP - Business Process Reengineering FY14/15

    ERP - Financial/Payroll/ HR Management FY13/14

    ERP - Public SafetyApplications FY14/15

    Goal4 ER Fleet/Facility/Tree/FuelManagement FY15/16

    ERP - Permitting/Code Compliance FY14/15

    ERP - Contact Management FY15/16

    ERP - Records Management FY15/16

    Online CityHall - Resident Business Outreach FY14/15

    GoalS Using ITEffectivelyProgram FY13/14

    ITStaffDevelopmentProgram FY13/14

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    18/156

    _ ~:. Implementing the Plan.

    Implementing the PlanThe Information TechnologyPlan presents an opportunityfor the City to fundamenta y change the way it uses technology todeliver City services. The planning process iden tified five goals and eight associated initiatives to begin to deliver thesecha nges . As these span all departmen ts, successfu l imlemen tation will require a concerted City-wideeffort.

    The firststeps in the implementation process include:

    Communicating the Plan Communication with Citystaff and the public is key to its success .

    Sec uring Support for the Plan Commitment by the City Council and the City's Leadersh ip Team is the singlemost important factor in the successful implemen tation of the Plan.

    This is a five-year plan . As such , t is meant to be a iving documentresponsive to changes in priorites and the availab ility of funding.The evergreening process is composed of the followingsteps:

    Annually aligningITwith CityGoa ls and Objectives

    Developing an Annual IT Budget and Operating Plan

    Keeping the Implemen tation Roadmap current Quarterly management reviews with the City's senior

    leade rship

    Annual Progress Report to the Mayorand City Council

    These steps , complemented by implementat ion of projectmanagement best practices , IT Governance and performancemeasurement will ensure the Plan stays relevant and itsimplementation on track.

    Measuring Success

    f i t c ~ ~ l r o uJt ~ 1 4

    It is impossible to accurately predict every challenge and/or opportunity the City will face during the five-year planningwindow. Performance measures will be developed for each initiative and reviewed regularly and the course altered asnece ssary throughout implementation. Success willbe determined by the degree to which:

    The City supports open gove rnment: transpa rency, accountability and collaboration

    Stakeholders ca n conduct business with the City and access the information they need at their convenience

    The City s environmental footprinthas been decreased

    Investment decisions are tied to mission impact

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    19/156

    _ mplementation Road mapThe diagram below depicts the Plan s initiativesand projects. The timeline will beevaluated and adjusted over time takinginto consideration available funding staffing dependencies between initiatives and City priorities.

    Carmel by the Sea IT Strategic Plan Implementation Roadmap

    Goal

    Goa 1Easy, Reliable Secure

    Access

    Goa 2Collaboration andCommunication

    Goal3Measurable Outcomes

    Goa 4Process Improvement

    Goa 5Trained Staff

    2013/14 2014/15 2015/16 2016/17 2017/18

    1 1

    1-4 I13

    L 1-2 J

    A-1

    A-2

    [ A-3

    rI

    Initiatives I Projects

    Supporting Goa 11: Online CityHall Access

    1 2: Business Continuity13: Technical Architecture14: ITSecurity Program

    Supporting Goal 2

    A-1: Online C ity Hall - CivicSourceA-2: OnlineCity Hall- WebA3:ERP Agenda Management

    Sys tem

    Supporting GoalG-1: ITGovernance

    Supporting Goa 4Enterprise Resour ce Planning:

    E-1 :Business ProcessE-2: FinanceE-3: Payroll / HRE-4: Public SafetyE-5: Fleet/Fac ility/Tree/FuelE6: Permitting/CodeE-7: Contact MgmtE-8: Records Mgmt

    Supporting Goal 5T-1 :Using ITEffectivelyT2: IT Staff Deve lopmentT3: Residen t I Bus iness

    Outreach

    l l

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    20/156

    l ; l Implementation Roadmap- ,,

    The diagram below dentifies projects planned to beg in during the first year of the Plan .

    Carmel-by-the-Sea IT Strategic Plan Implementat ion Roadmap

    The follow ing diagram depicts init iatives and projects planned for Year 1 of the Plan.

    Goal1Residents , businesses, visitors and staff have easy

    access to the informationand transactions they need attheir convenience anytime; anyplace)

    Goal2IT applications are designed to encourage collaborationand communication among internal and external users

    Goal3

    Processes and procedures are in place to manage andtrack IT investments to ensure they directly and

    measurably , support business priorities , initiatives andoutcome goals

    Goal4The City s applications effectively streamline businessprocesses, improve informationsharing and enable an

    outcome-based , accountable approach to servicedelivery

    GoalSCity staff are provided tools and training that enablethem to work collaborativelyto provide internal andexternal customers the highestquality service and

    Jan 2014 April2014 July 2014 Oct 2014

    Webs ite Redes ign Deployment

    Network and Secur ity Upgrades

    Hardwa re and Software Updat es

    Automated Agenda Management System _ ]

    Oran1cus Update

    Website Redes ign

    Governance

    System

    Usi ng IT Effectively Us ing IT Effectively

    I - - . :iii

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    21/156

    I - . - . ::::iii: : . _ Carmel-by-the-Sea

    .: : :

    MayorJason Burnett , Mayor

    City CouncilVictoriaBeach

    Steve HillyardKen Talmage

    Carrie Theis

    City dministratorJason Stilwell

    Strategic P lan Workshop Part icipantsDeanna Allen, Finance Spec ialist

    Janet Bombard, City Librarian

    Heidi Burch, Assistant CityAdministrator Cty Clerk

    Mike Calhoun Public Safety Director

    Sharon Friedrichsen , Public Services Director

    Susan Paul Administrative Services Director

    Jason Stilwell, City Administrator

    Paul Tomasi , Commander

    Paul Wood Finance Manager

    Mark Wiener, Senior Planner

    ttachment

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    22/156

    1 9 2

    FY2013 2017InformationTechnology Strategic Plan

    Working DocumentNovember 5 2013

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    23/156

    1 9 3

    SectionExecutive Summary

    IntroductionVision and MissionGoals and ObjectivesStrategic InitiativesImplementation RoadmapInitialEstimated CostMeasuring Our SuccessIT GovernanceAppendices

    AppendixParticipants Appendix 8 -Interview Methodology

    Appendix C Definitions Appendix D - Projects

    ITStrategic Pla n - November 5 2013

    Page 2

    age3

    33

    396568758

    85

    88

    9

    99

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    24/156

    1 9 4

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    25/156

    1 9 5

    Technology planning is imperative for the City to meet service demands efficientlyand effectivelywhile maintaining consistent focus on investment and

    improvement.The City s technology implementation has fallen behind in recent years. Mostbusiness functions are either still performed manually or rely on outdatedapplications that are difficultto support.

    Access to data is extremely limited resulting in time-consuming manual processesto collect and aggregate data for analysis and reporting.

    The City has unique opportunity to capitalize on new, integrated technologies tostreamline daily operations, improve transparency and increase responsivenessand flexibility.

    IT Strategic Plan -November 5 2013

    Page4

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    26/156

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    27/156

    1 9 7

    The InformationTechnology strategic planning process began in March 2013, bybringing together the City s leadership team to define how information technology

    (IT)can be used to effectivelyand efficientlysupport the City s vision and goals.The collaborative strategic planning process yielded important insight that led toidentifyinga vision and mission, and priority projectand initiatives.

    Facilitated by Public Consulting Group, this document presents the resu lts of theplanning process: the City s Vision for IT, the Mission of the ITorganization andidentification of Goals, Strategies and Initiativesto be addressed over the next fiveyears.

    IT Strategic Plan- November 5 2013

    Page 6

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    28/156

    1 9 8

    Vision

    o Carmel-by-the-Sea willbe recognized as a leader where residents, businesses, visitors and

    government connect and work together for the benefit of the community through innovativeand engaging IT solutions.

    Mission for City ITOrganization:

    By embracing the core standards of quality service, accountability, efficiencyand customerorientation, City IT willprovide the highest level of professional services to its customersthrough innovative information technology solutions aligned with the City s strategic goalsand objectives.

    IT Strategic Plan- November 5 2013

    Page 7

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    29/156

    1 9 9

    We willhave reached our vision for information technology when we have achievedthe following results:

    Goal 1: Residents, businesses visitors and staff have easy access to the informationand transactions they need at their conven ience (anytime; anyplace) .

    Goal 2: IT applications are designed to encourage collaboration and commun icationamong internal and external users.

    Goal 3: Processes and procedures are in place to manage and track IT investments toensure they directlyand measurably support business priorities initiatives and outcomegoals.

    Goal 4: The City s applications effectively streamlinebusiness processes improveinformation sharing and enable an outcome-based accountable approach to servicedelivery.

    Goa l 5: City staff are provided tools and training that enable them to work collaborativelyto provide internal and external customers the highest quality service and support.

    IT Strateg ic Pla November 5 2013

    Pa ge 8

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    30/156

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    31/156

    2 0 1

    The followingGuiding Principles willguide our decision-making:

    Information technology decision-making willbe driven by the City s business needs and

    available resources. Quality Service, Accountability, Efficiencyand Customer Orientation willbe the driving

    considerations when selecting and implementing IT solutions. We will makeresource investments that support the City s long-term vision and

    strategic direction. We willidentify, measure and track the value of IT investments and increase

    accountabilityof IT expenditures. Strategic partnerships willbe established between stakeholders and the City so that the

    benefits of IT are leveraged to improve customer service and maximize the productivity

    of City employees. ITwillfacilitate the development of a business driven architecture that ensures

    departments can effectivelycommunicate with each other, and share and exchangeinformation as appropriate.

    ITStrategic Plan -November 5 2013

    Page 10

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    32/156

    2 0 2

    We will implementsecurity policies and standards to protect systems networksresources and data from loss and unauthorized access use modification destructionand disclosure.

    Security willbe the responsibility ofevery City employee. Employees willbe trained sothat they can prevent security incidents from happening and detect and mitigate suchincidents when they occur.

    We will partnerwith neighboring jurisdictionsand organizations when possible.

    We willuse open source solutions when feasible. We willuse integrated applications across departments to facilitate data sharing and

    minimize costs. We willmove applications to the cloud when it makes sense to do so. We willbuy rent rather than build.

    IT Strategic Plan- November 5 2013

    Page

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    33/156

    2 0 3

    Eight strategic IT initiativeshave been identifiedwhich are comprised of multipleprojects to move the City forward in achieving its goals and objectives. The focus

    initiallyis on shoring up the existing technology infrastructure through thereplacement of aging hardware and software. This includes:

    A modest Network Upgrade to increase capacity and strengthen network security.

    Redesign of the City s Website.

    Implementation of a new Financial and Payroll Human Resource (HR) system. An Upgrade of the Granicus system, currently used to broadcast City Counciland

    Planning Commission meetings.

    Implementation of automated Agenda Packet to streamline the creation, approval andposting of City Council Planning Commission and other public meeting materials.

    These lay the foundation which willultimately lead to a technology implementationdesigned to bring City government and the community closer together throughshared forums and greater transparency.

    ITStrategic Plan- November 5 2013

    Page 12

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    34/156

    2 0 4

    0 This graphic

    represents thetentative timelinefor implementingkey initiatives.

    0 It willbe adjustedover time takinginto considerationavailable funding staff dependencies

    between initiativesand City priorities.

    Goa l 2013 / 14 2014 /16 2016 /1 6 2016 / 17 2 017 18

    11Goal 1

    Easy Reli a ble Se cur e I ~ ~ IA ccess 1 14 J

    1 12- J

    A 1

    Goa lo a b o n ~t o nand r== A2 ICommunica t ion

    I A I

    Goa iJMeasurab le Ou tco m es @ ]

    Gol4P rocess Impr ov ement

    I e.a ~ ~ - j ... Ir - 1

    @ I

    GoISTraine d S ta ff 1 T 2 I

    I T 3 I

    IT Strategic Plan - November 5 2 13

    Page 1 3

    c .. I

    T 1

    Ini t iat iv es I P r o jec ts

    S upporting Go 11: Online City Hall - Access

    12 : Business Continuity3: Technical Architecture

    1 4: IT Security Progra m

    Sup p orting Go al 2A 1: Online City Hall - C ivic

    Sou rceA 2: Online City Hall - WebA-J:ERP Agenda Management

    System

    Supporting Goa/ 3G 1: IT Go vernance

    Supporting Go a / 4Enterp rise Resou rce Planni n g:

    E-1: Bu sin ess ProcessE-2 : Fin a nceEJ : Payroll HRE-4 : Public SafetyE-5: Fleot/FocilltyiTrooiFuelE-6: P o m ~ i t t i n g / C o d oE-7: Cont act MgmtE-8: Rocordo Mgmt

    Supporting Goal 5T 1 Us ing IT Effecti velyT 2 : IT St aff Deve lopmen tT- 3 : R eside n t I Business

    Out re ach

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    35/156

    2 0 5

    : This graphic

    identifies projectsplanned to beg induring the firstyear of the Plan .

    The follow ing diagram dep icts init iatives and projects planned for Year 1 o f the Plan .

    Go al1Resid e nts businesse s vis itor s and s taff have easy

    acce ss to the i nform ation and t ranu ctions they n eed atthe ir co n ve nienc e ( anyt ime ; a nyplace )

    G oal2IT ap pli cat ions a re dn lgned to en co urage collabo rat ionan d communicat ion among Internal and externa l us ers

    Goal 3Pr ocesses an d proce du res are In p lac e to manage a nd

    tr ack IT Inves tmen ts to en sur e they dire ctly andmeasu ra bly, su pport bus iness prlor lt ies , ln ltiatlve s and

    outcome go als

    Go al 4The City s app lications effect ively strea mline bu s inessproc e sses improv e infonnation shari n g and enable an

    outcomeb a se d accountab le app ro a ch to se rvicedel ivery

    Go al SCity sta ff are provid ed tool s and tr aining th at en ablethe m to work collab orat ively to p rovide inte rn al andex terna l c us tomers the highes t qu a lity serv ice an d

    su p port

    IT Strategic P an - November 5, 2 13

    Page 14

    Jan 2 14 A p r i l 2 0 1 4 J ul y 2 0 1 4 Oc t 2 14

    We b s ite R e d e s ign eplo ym e nt

    u l e l l t ct da an a g emen t ys te m

    y s . m

    U s in g IT E ff e c tiv e ly U si n g IT E ff e cti v ely

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    36/156

    2 0 6

    o Followingare the preliminaryhigh level cost estimates for planned initiatives

    Estimated costs are based upon experience and/or resea rch and the scope of work as

    envisioned during the planning process .

    Both a low and high estimate are provided due to the uncertain nature of estimating atthis level of detail

    Costs will be refined each year as part of the budgeting process and/or when a givenproject is undertaken .

    Legend

    0 - 25,000

    25,000 - 50 ,00050,000 - 75,000

    75 ,000 - 100,000

    > 100,000

    IT Strategic Plan - November 5 2013

    Pag e 15

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    37/156

    2 0 7

    Business Continuity Disaster Recovery

    TechnicalArchitecture

    IT SecurityProgram

    FY14 15

    FY13 14 II FY13 14 I

    ITStrategic Plan - November5, 2013

    Page 16

    I

    igh

    I

    egend

    0 - 25,000

    25,000 - 50,000

    50,000 - 75,000

    75,000- 100,000

    > 100,000

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    38/156

    2 0 8

    One-TimeCostEstmated Costs

    Timeframe Low High

    Goal2: ITapplicationsare designed to encourage collaborationand communicationamonginternaland external users

    OnlineCityHall-CitySourceCivicEngagement WebEOCDiscussionForums FY14/15

    OnlineCityHall-CityIntranetGISProgramERP-

    FY14/15FY13/14

    ITStrategic Plan - November5, 2013

    Page 17

    AnnualRecurringCost

    Low High

    Legend

    0- 25 ,000

    25,000- 50,000

    50,000- 75,000

    75,000- 100,000

    > 100,000

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    39/156

    2 0 9

    Low High m limlilGoal 3: Processes and procedures are in place to manageand track IT investments to ensure they directlyand measurably support business priorities initiativesand outcome oals

    [ ITGovernance -] FY13/14 l

    IT Strateg ic Plan - November 5 20 3

    Page 8

    Legend

    0- 25 ,000

    25,000- 50 ,000

    50,000- 75,00075 ,000- 100,000

    > 100,000

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    40/156

    2 1 0

    ifli i rnltluM High rr:l l:ll High

    Goal4: The City s applications effectively streamline business processes , improve information sharing and enable an outcome -based , accountable approach toservice delive

    B n-ocess Reenarneennn FY14/15

    ERP- Financiai/HRManagement FY13/14

    ERP- PublicSafetv Aoolications I FY13/14

    ent I FY15/16

    ERP- Perm ittina/Code Comoliance I FY14/15

    ERP - Contact Mana gement I FY14/15ERP - Records Manaaem ent I FY15/16

    Legend

    0- 25 ,000

    25,000- 50,000

    50,000 - 75,000ITStrategic Plan- November5 2013 I 75,000 - 100,000

    Page 19 > 100,000

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    41/156

    2 1 1

    FY 4 / 5

    FY 4 / 5FY 3 / 4

    IT Strategic Plan- November 5 2 13

    Page 2

    egend

    0- 25,000

    25,000 - 50,000

    50 ,000- 75,000

    75,000- 100,000 ,,

    > 100,000

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    42/156

    2 1 2

    It is impossible to accurately predict every challenge and /or opportunity the Citywillface during the five-year planning window. We willconduct formal and informal

    surveys regularly to measure our performance and alter course as necessary overthe next five years. We will knowwe have successfully implemented this planwhen our internal (employees, City Council members) and external (residents,businesses, visitors) stakeholders tell us:

    The Citysupports

    opengovernment: transparency

    accountability

    andcollaboration;

    They can conduct business with the City and access the information they need at theirconven ence;

    The City s environmental footprinthas been decreased ; and

    Investment decisions are tied to mission impact.

    IT Strategic Plan o vember 5 2013

    Page 2

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    43/156

    2 1 3

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    44/156

    2 1 4

    The City s technology implementationhas fallen behind in recent years. In March2013, Public Consulting Group (PCG) was retained to conduct a technical

    assessment of the City s information technology implementationand developan

    ITStrategic Plan to guide the City s IT investments for the next five years.

    PCG followeda structured approach which included documentation review, onsiteinspection, a technical assessment, interviews and workshops.

    18 people were interviewed.10 City staff participated in workshops.

    A summary of the Technical Assessment follows.

    ITStrateg ic Plan - November 5 2013

    Page 23

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    45/156

    2 1 5

    The condition of Carmel s IT infrastructure and applications has grown organicallyover several years.

    Configurations, policiesand operating procedures are large ly un-documented .

    The IT security posture does not appear to be in alignment with City priorities orindustry standards.

    The infrastructure is not prepared to recover from a disastrous event.

    The physical infrastructure is somewhat disorderly and includes retired cables andhardware intermingled with production equipment.

    The lack of documented configurations policies and operating processes ; the

    questionable security posture; the level of disaster preparedness; and the physicalcondition of the infrastructure present a risk to maintainabilityand ava ilabilityof theCity s technology platform.

    IT Strategic Plan -November 5 2013

    Page 24

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    46/156

    2 1 6

    I. )

    Ci n Q

    E

    z

    l

    N

    Q Olro

    a

    0:

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    47/156

    2 1 7

    Met with Executive leadership Identified project goals

    Established preliminary project scheduleReviewed relevant background material

    Budgets Plans

    Policies Network diagrams City s website

    Conducted interviews with elected officials, executives

    and staff 18 People were interviewed

    IT Strategic Plan - November 5 2013

    Page 26

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    48/156

    2 1 8

    We reviewed the City s current technology implementation:

    Physical inspection

    Documentation review

    Interviews with technical and non-technical staff

    Recommendations for immediate and longer-termimprovements were identified

    IT Strategic P an - November 5 2013

    Page 27

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    49/156

    2 1 9

    Developed the vision for the use of technology in the City Analyzed data and key findings

    Drafted ITVision and Mission Statements Drafted Goals and Operating Principles

    Conducted Workshop 1 Reviewed and discussed results of data gathering

    Reviewed and discussed draft Vision Mission Goals andOperating Principles

    Conducted Workshop 2 Developed Strategic Objectives for implementing each goal Identified Initiatives Projects

    Conducted Workshop 3 Prioritized Initiatives1 City staff participated in the workshops

    ITStrategic Plan o vember 5 2013

    Page 28

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    50/156

    2 2 0

    Developed Implementation Roadmap

    Created the InformationTechnology Strategic Plan WorkingDocument

    Presented the Draft Plan to the City Council for comment

    Posted the Draft Plan on the City s Website for Comment

    Held Three Workshops to Receive Public CommentFinalized the Plan

    Provided City withProject LibraryDocuments

    IT Strategic Plan- November 5 2013

    Page 29

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    51/156

    2 2 1

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    52/156

    2 2 2

    Vision

    o Carmel-by-the-Sea willbe recognized as a leader where residents, businesses, visitors and

    government connect and work together for the benefit of the community through innovativeand engaging IT solutions.

    Mission for City ITOrganization:

    o By embracing the core standards of qualityservice accountability, efficiencyand customerorientation, City ITwill providethe highest level of professional services to its customersthrough innovative information technology solutionsaligned with the City s strategic goalsand objectives.

    IT Strategic Plan- November 5 2013

    Page 3

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    53/156

    2 2 3

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    54/156

    2 2 4

    We developed the Strategic Plan goals and objectives using the Balanced ScorecardMethodology.

    The Balanced Scorecard is a management system that enables organizations to clarify theirvision and strategy and translate them into action .

    The Balanced Scorecard views the organization from four perspectives

    Customer

    o Financialo Internal Process and

    o Learning and Growth.

    It provides feedback around both the internal business processes and external outcomes inorder to continuously improve strategic performance and results .

    Five goals were agreed upon .

    IT Strategic Plan - November 5 2013

    P e 3 3

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    55/156

    2 2 5

    Financial Perspective

    {I I I

    Ob j e ct ive s Measures

    Business Process Perspective

    Strategic goalsIThe Vision fo r the

    Ci t y 's T e chnolog y

    Obj ec t ive s Me a s ur e s

    -.

    I is ..

    l )_Learning & Growth Perspective

    Whitt wt 1 ~ do to ensurf organ1ziJt tonperformaflc lm prov,_m,.flt , cllaflge ;tfld

    l ~ a r n m g

    Strategic goals

    Ob je ctiv es Me as u res

    \WIYt needs to e done to m t custom ere xpKflltlorls and achieve th e ir business

    requl . . . . .enr.7

    Strategic goals

    Obje c ti ves Me asures

    L.____.J

    J Balanced Scorecard Institute/\ d pt e:d f1o m th e Oa lan c ed S c o rc GJ r d b y Ro be r tS . K a p l ~ nan d Da v e P . N o r t on . Har v, r d Ousrnc s 'SGhoo l Pr es-s. 19 9 6.

    IT Strategic P lan - November 5, 20 3

    Page 34

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    56/156

    2 2 6

    We willhave reached our vision for information technologywhen we have achievedthe followingresults:

    Goal 1: Residents, businesses , visitors and staff have easy access to the informationand transactions they need at their convenience anytime; anyplace).

    Goal 2: IT applications are designed to encourage collaboration and communicationamong internal and external users.

    Goal 3: Processes and procedures are in place to manage and track IT investments toensure they directlyand measurably , support business priorities, initiatives and outcomegoals.

    Goal 4: The City s applications effectively streamline bus iness processes, improveinformation sharing and enable an outcome-based , accountable approach to service

    delivery. Goal 5: City staff are provided tools and training that enable them to work collaboratively

    to provide internal and external customers the highest qualityservice and support.

    IT Strateg ic Plan - November 5 2013

    Page 35

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    57/156

    2 2 7

    Sixteen strategic objectives designed to turn the goals into realityand achieve thevision were identified. Collectively, these objectives describe how the City s ITorganizations willachieve the City s informationtechnology goals.Each objective on the followingpages is identified as supporting one of the fourBalanced Scorecard perspectives: Customer, Financial, Internal Process orLearning and Growth and aligned with one of the five goals.

    IT Strate gic Plan - November 5 , 2013

    P e 3 6

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    58/156

    2 2 8

    To Achieve the Goals We Will: Provide a secure , reliable and accessible infrastructure Increase access channels

    Provide the informationpeople need and want; when they want it Enable data sharing and exchange Implement intuitive easy -to-use applications Implement intuitive easy-to-use collaboration tools Develop an IT funding strategy

    Develop an IT sourcing strategy Leverage public/privateand public/publicpartnerships Implement applications to support routine business needs Implement a performance management system tied to City goals objectives Reduce the time it takes to access services and conduct bus iness

    Streamline and integrate business processes and workflow Understand customer business needs Prepare for the future through research and development Increase techn ical expertise and proficiency

    ITStrategic P lan- November 5, 2013

    Page 37

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    59/156

    2 2 9

    Legend

    Goa l 1

    Res dena buai'n ss n

    . v isitors

    and staff heve u y cc n to thlnform Uon a nd r ~ t t ~ s o n

    th y nHd t h ir convenlnc onytlmo ; onyptac o

    GoalSCity staft' are prov ided tools andtra ining that enable them to work

    conabol llt tve ty toprovid

    eInte rnal and ext emal customersthe highest qualtty servic e and

    s upport

    Goal

    Goal2

    IT Apptk:at lons are des igned toen c ourag e c o l b o n ~ t t o nand

    commun tcet ton amo ng internaland eld e mal users

    Goal3Processes and pro ce dures are In

    place to manage and trac k IT

    tnveatments to ensure the ydlrectty and meaau ra bly, supportbu s iness p rtortt l l l nttla tlve s

    and outcome goela

    he C tty s app Hcatio n s etfe cttvelyst ream tlne bu si ness pro ce saes ,

    Impro ve Informat ion shanng and 14 ..

    enablean

    outcome..ba ae d.a cc ountable approach to s ervic edelivery

    IT Strategic Plan- November 5, 2013

    Page 38

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    60/156

    2 3 0

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    61/156

    2 3 1

    8 Strategic Initiativescomprised of multipleprojects were identified

    This section begins with a summary diagram of goals objectives and initiatives. Itis followedby narrative for key initiatives.

    IT Strategic Plan Novembe r 5 2013

    Page40

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    62/156

    2 3 2

    Online City Half- Web , Soe lalMed1 a

    IT Stan ~ p m e n t

    PrDtram

    Leg end

    Oool1Residents, u ~ n visitorsnd statr .,..,. ~ Y n o lh

    Information M d trwt see rlonth ty n hJr conven/tnc

    a n ~ o n y p la c o }

    Goal I

    Onl 1 tt City Ha ...City Sou rct

    Ooal2ITApplfcaflotla . . ha l gn f l l o

    tneour.g eoUborflon ttndcommunleffon among ntwnl t /

    and eJtfemal u s . .

    Ooal3

    CJ y t W f _ . . p rov l d ool1 ndfl alnln9 .. Htl lb l th .m ro w w t

    Processn . nd procedures . . .plee to maneg t t l h d TInv es tments to . . . . hy

    dlr.crJy nd m urably suppottbus iness prlorlries . lnlfJtlves

    . nd outcom. goals

    But 1na u Proc u Re . gtnn tln9

    coUabontlvf ly to pi OVIdeInternal and emtnal c u s t a . .ftl hlgiNst qu.Jity s . w l n and

    IUppOff

    Ooll41M City s applications effKflvelystnwnllnt bu l ln ess proc.sse s

    lmplovllnfonMtJon h nntl and. blan outcome-bal ld aecountebl epproch to a- rv in

    de l lv ry

    Document a n ~ t m f l \ tS ystam

    ITStrategic Plan - November 5 2013

    Page 4

    PubMc Sa ft ty Services

    FIH tl Fac:JIIty / T r F u~a n~ l mt t Sys.tt m

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    63/156

    2 3 3

    Onlln City Hall - Web; S odaM . o

    Legen d

    On l ln City Ha n -City Sou rc

    Gooll GooUR e ~ f n t s busitMsae vf.Jfonnd atafr t v a s yK c t U to lh

    r r r m ~ ~ t o nMd frwnue lfonathey need at th W e:onvnlnc

    IT Appllcetlona . . . dea l pNd oencowage e:ollabontlon and

    cotnmuttlcaflon among nt Hrtal

    11nyf/mo ; onyploco}

    OooUCity . _ . . p n w ld ed fool and

    . . . IMt ena ble...,. to worle:ollebonllv.,y o p r ov ff t

    lnt mal and extwn"' e:uetom.r1the,.,,.,.., quality .. mee end

    eupprxt

    Docu nMnt M.nagerMnt ~ t m

    OooUThe CJ Y eppiJcttJons etfectltlelya hamlhte u ln proce aae a,

    lmptweltrlomvllon andIINb/e . utcome-based.ae:e:ountable approach to ee M ce

    dollvory

    IT Strategic Plan -N ovembe r 5 2 13

    Page 4

    M d extemal unrs

    Pubic Safety S eM ces

  • 8/14/2019 Resolution Adopting the City Fiscal Year (FY) 2013-2017 Information Technology Strategic Plan 11-2013.pdf

    64/156

    2 3 4

    Today ; Departments operate In si los with l i t t ledata-sharing and in some cases , no automatedsystems, which prevents everyone f rom seeingthe "Big Picture".

    Library

    - lanning 8t Bui ld ing

    Public Safety

    j f = P u b l i c S e r v l I