13
Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials GCSE Design and Technology: Resistant Materials (4562) Name:

Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant ... Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant MaterialsName: ... 13. You need to keep this booklet

  • Upload
    ngonhi

  • View
    233

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant ... Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant MaterialsName: ... 13. You need to keep this booklet

Resistant Materials

Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant

Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials

Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials

Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials

Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials

Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant

Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant

Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials

Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials

Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant

Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant

Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials

Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials

Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials

Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials

Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant materials

Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials

Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials

Resistant Materials

Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials

Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials

Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant

Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials

Resistant Materials Resistant

Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials

Resistant Materials

Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant

Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant

Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials

Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials

Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials

Resistant materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant

Materials Resistant Materials

Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials

GCSE Design and Technology: Resistant Materials (4562)

Name:

Page 2: Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant ... Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant MaterialsName: ... 13. You need to keep this booklet

GCSE Design and Technology:

Resistant materials (4562)

Controlled Assessment Tasks and Guidance

Introduction to your Resistant Materials Coursework Your Resistant Materials project for GCSE counts for 60% of your final grade. This mark will be added to your final written examination, in order to produce your overall grade. The aim of this study guide is to introduce you to the Resistant Materials tasks available to you, as well as explaining how your work will be assessed and how you can earn your marks. To be successful at coursework tasks you need to be helped through the difficult process of managing your time during the final year of the course. You will already know from your experience of earlier tasks that you do not always allow yourself sufficient time for the making of the product. Your Resistant Materials tutor will encourage, and also require you to meet certain deadlines during the project in order to keep your work on target for the final submission deadline. This will be discussed with you at the review points during the year. This guide will help you to organise yourself by informing you of all the relevant points that are needed to complete your design folder.

GOOD LUCK

THERE ARE NO MORE REHEARSALS – THIS IS YOUR FINAL PERFORMANCE!

DO NOT BE AFRAID TO SEEK HELP

YOU MUST KEEP THIS STUDY GUIDE INSIDE YOUR DESIGN

FOLDER THROUGHOUT THE COURSE. YOU AND YOUR

TEACHER WILL NEED TO CONSTANTLY REFER TO THE

CONTENTS AND IT WILL ALSO BE USED WHEN WRITING

REPORTS TO YOUR PARENTS/CARERS.

Page 3: Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant ... Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant MaterialsName: ... 13. You need to keep this booklet

Resistant Materials Project Notes

1. All design folders must be A3 size, in order and securely held together at the end of the project.

2. You should design a front cover for your folder which should include your name, the

title of your project, candidate number, Arthur Mellows Village College 22315 and the context you have chosen.

3. You must integrate ICT into your project work wherever it is appropriate and try to

include CAD/CAM.

4. Spelling, punctuation and grammar will be assessed in the coursework project.

5. You are expected to produce a quality product which is related to current industrial and commercial practices. These include all relevant aspects of work that you do in school in order to complete your assignment which is similar to that carried out in industry.

Designing, Time and Work Planning

Use of computers – CAD/CAM – Internet Research

Design for manufacturing in quantity and be aware of commercial/industrial processes

Mind Mapping, Questionnaires and Surveys

Teamwork and Market Research

Modelling Prototypes and Planning

Use of tools /equipment and processes to produce quality products

6. You need to consider social issues including, managing resources, the environment, historical, cultural and value issues, health and safety and Sustainability.

7. Try to include how manufacturing processes such as jigs, templates, moulds and types

of manufacturing i.e. batch and mass will influence your design. Remember quality control and assurance.

8. It is important that all of your work is neatly presented, is well laid out and interesting.

Follow these simple tips:

Good quality graphics should be aimed for at all times.

A variety of graphics techniques should be used.

All work must be relevant to your project.

The results of research and investigation must be shown and analysed – include an explanation of why you have included the page and what you have found out.

9. Likewise, your practical work will be expected to be of the highest quality. You should

try to ensure that you:

Work carefully and safely.

Measure and mark out accurately

Use the correct tools

Make use of a range of processes and techniques.

Work to the highest possible standard.

Page 4: Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant ... Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant MaterialsName: ... 13. You need to keep this booklet

10. In your project you should identify a “client” - someone for whom you are going to produce the article. The best projects usually come from real problems which have been identified and can be solved. You also need to consider your target users of your product.

11. In addition to your coursework project you will take a written exam which is 2 hours

long and is the remaining 40% of your marks.

12. You are assessed on two attainment targets:

Unit 1: Written Paper (45601) 2 hours –120 marks – 40% Candidates answer all questions in two sections Pre-Release material issued Unit 2: Design and Making Practice (45602) Approximately 45 hours – 90 marks – 60% Consists of a single design and make activity selected from There is one tier of assessment covering grades A* to G.

13. You need to keep this booklet safe with your folder work. It tells you exactly what you need to include on each page and you will NOT be given a replacement copy.

14. Your teacher will ask for work to be submitted at interim assessment dates – shown at

the top of the next pages. Your work will be annotated with the improvements you need to make.

15. KEEP UP TO DATE WITH YOUR WORK!!!

Page 5: Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant ... Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant MaterialsName: ... 13. You need to keep this booklet

GCSE Design & Technology: Resistant Materials (4562)

STAGE 1: INITIAL RESEARCH AND INVESTIGATION Submit week ending – Friday 10th September 2010 DESIGN BRIEF, TASK ANALYSIS AND RESEARCH

ON EACH PAGE WRITE A

REASON FOR INCLUDING

THE PAGE AND WHAT YOU

HAVE FOUND OUT

DESIGN BRIEF AND TASK ANALYSIS

Write your Design Brief – a simple, short statement of what you

intend to do. Write your task analysis by answering these

questions:

Why did you choose this task?

Who is your client?

Why do you need to design your product?

What research will you need to do? Where? How?

How is the client going to be involved with your

project?

Draw a mind map to help organize your research – who, what,

where, when and how? Fill in your Gantt Chrat for your project –

a printed blank will be given to you.

CLIENT / TARGET USER QUESTIONNAIRE

Devise a questionnaire that will help you find out exactly what

your client wants. This could include colour, theme, price, size

etc.

You could also produce a survey for a group of people that

may use your product i.e. children at a play group. This will get

you a higher grade.

Analysis of results – you must say what you have found out. This

can be written or you could include graphs.

MARKET RESEARCH

Collect pictures, photos etc from magazines and the internet

of similar products to yours that are for sale. Think carefully how

you are going to present them on this page – DO NOT just cut

them out and stick them down.

You now need to analyse them – what are they, do you like

them, do they give you ideas for your designs, would they fulfill

what your client wants?

PRODUCT ANALYSIS

Find and analysis 2 products which are different and you would

be able to compare one against the other. Use the following

criteria to analyse each product:

CAFEQUE (Cost, Appearance, Function, Ergonomics, Quality,

User, Environment).

OR

ACCESS FM (Appearance, Cost, Colour, Ergonomics, Safety,

Size, Function, Materials).

MATERIALS

Find out what materials are available to you in school. Ask your

teacher for small samples that you could attach to this page.

Briefly describe each one and explain why they would be

good to use in your project. Try to find out how much they cost

– this could influence your choice. You could do this in a grid.

Also try to experiment with some of them.

TECHNIQUES

What techniques are available for you to use in school? This will

influence what you can make.

Write about the main ones that are relevant to your project,

draw diagrams and explain how you could include them in

your product. You could add some experiments and tests to

this page.

INDUSTRIAL PROCESSES

Find out about the different scales of production in industry.

What other processes do they use that you may not have

access to in school. You could do this in the form of a table.

Write a conclusion which links this with your project – if your

product was to be mass produced, how would it be done?

THEME / MOOD / PRODUCT BOARD

Some of the contexts have specific themes, others you will

need to decide on your theme (what did your client want)?

Collect pictures or make sketches, show ideas about colours,

shapes and anything else that links with this theme. Arrange

them in an interesting way on this page.

OTHER RESEARCH

For some of the projects you will need to complete other areas

of research that will help you with your design work. An

example of this is child development, ergonomics and safety of

toys.

At this stage re-read your context – have you remembered

everything it has asked you to do?

ANALYSIS OF SPECIFICATION

RESEARCH

Write a final analysis of

what you have found

out from your research.

How will this influence

your design work.

This is a list of points that you need

to consider in your design work.

You will have found these out in

your research i.e. time, sizes, colour,

theme, safety, weight, materials,

costs, production methods &

ergonomics.

Page 6: Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant ... Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant MaterialsName: ... 13. You need to keep this booklet

GCSE Design & Technology: Resistant Materials (4562)

STAGE 2: EXPLORING AND EVALUATING A RANGE OF IDEAS Submit week ending – Friday 15th October 2010 INITIAL DESIGNS, EVALUATING DESIGNS & DEVELOPMENT.

At the end of this stage you should have improved your design AND made sure you know exactly how you are going to construct your product.

INITIAL DESIGNS

You need to produce a wide range of design ideas, which are drawn freehand. They do

not have to be accurate and some may not work. Imagine you are doing a Mind Map but

in pictures. Make sure you have done the following:

Annotate (label) your drawings with notes on materials, processes that could be

used, problems that need to be solved etc. This will help to show your thinking.

Render your sketches with a range of media – coloured pencils, pens, pencil.

You must show evidence at this stage of ICT.

Try to model parts of an idea or a whole idea in card or using CADto see if it will

work.

At least

2 pages

EVALUATING DESIGNS

You can evaluate your designs either by writing alongside each of your initial designs or by

numbering your designs and evaluating them together on a separate page.

Each design needs evaluating, use these questions to help:

Does the design cover all the points in your specification?

How could it be improved?

Does it look good?

Has it progressed from your previous design?

What materials and equipment do you need? Are they available?

Are you going to develop the design? Why?

Are you going to reject the design? Why?

Finally get your client to comment on each of the designs – their views may differ from

yours!

At least

2 pages

DEVELOPMENT

You will have selected one or more or parts of your initial design ideas that could be

developed into a final design.

By sketching show how the design could be improved.

What are the different processes that you could use for its construction? Decide

which is best?

You may need to do some tests or make prototypes.

What are your client views – write these down.

Check that it still fulfils your specification.

How could your design be produced commercially?

Page 7: Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant ... Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant MaterialsName: ... 13. You need to keep this booklet

GCSE Design & Technology: Resistant Materials (4562)

STAGE 3: PLANNING THE CHOSEN DESIGN Submit week ending – Friday 12th November 2010

FINAL DESIGN

This is a quality 3D drawing, using a variety of techniques, of your

chosen design.

You may want to use ICT or CAD.

You may have to show your product from different angles if you

have detail on all sides.

TIME PLAN This may take more than 1 A3 sheet and it is best to complete this as you go through the making. Draw out your columns as below:

Process Tools/

Equipment

Time Explanation

(Diagram)

Comments Mass

Production

Quality

Assurance

Safety

Marking up Pencil, try

square, rule

30 mins I will draw the

shapes onto

the MDF

making sure

that my work

is accurate

This went OK

but I had to

redraw a

couple of

lines that

weren’t

square

A template

would be

used for

irregular

shapes

Ensure that all

the shapes

are drawn

out

accurately

and to the

correct size

Be careful

when

moving/

transporting

materials

around

Step by step The tools you

will use

How long it

should take

you

How it should

be done

What actually

happened

How it would

be done in

industry

Checks that

will be

carried out

Health and

safety issues.

Once you have decided on

what you are going to make,

you need to plan in detail so

that you know exactly how to

make your item.

ORTHOGRAPHIC PROJECTION

This should be to British

Standard scale in third angle

and should include

measurements and the

relevant symbols. If you have

forgotten how to do this, ask

your teacher. You could use

2D design tools to do this.

ENGINEERING DRAWING

An accurate drawing of the

product including dimensions

and sections.

CUTTING LIST

Name: Teacher: Project: Class:

Part Material Quantity

(No)

Length (L) Width (W) Thickness

(T)

Cost

You can also draw a diagram to show how the parts of your design

could be laid out on the materials for mass production. Wastage

should be the minimum.

FLOW DIAGRAM

This shows the correct sequence of making processes.

Make sure you include quality assurance ( setting

standards and meeting them) and quality control

(checking that you meet these standards)

You need to use the following symbols:

start/finish decision

Q.C.

process/action links lines &

columns

CONSTRAINTS, MODIFICATIONS and Testing

This is where you can record any problems that

you have during the making stage.

Explain how you solved the problems.

Record any testing that you have done.

You are now ready to begin your making!!

Page 8: Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant ... Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant MaterialsName: ... 13. You need to keep this booklet

GCSE Design & Technology: Resistant Materials (4562)

STAGE 4: SPIRITUAL, MORAL, ETHICAL, SOCIAL, LEGISLATIVE,

SUSTAINABLE, DEVELOPMENT, ECONOMIC AND CULTURAL ISSUES, AND HEALTH AND SAFETY CONSIDERATIONS

Submit week ending – Friday 26th November 2010 SOCIAL, CULTURAL, MORAL, ENVIRONMENTAL, SUSTAINABILITY, ECONOMIC ISSUES

SOCIAL, CULTURAL, MORAL and ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES

You need to recognise that graphical images and products should not offend minority groups.

Consider moral and cultural implications of graphic products.

Consider ergonomics and use of anthropometric data when designing products.

Understand symbols and signs which are essential information on packaging.

SUSTAINABILITY AND ECONOMIC ISSUES

You need to be aware of the 6 Rs rules – repair, reduce,recycle, re-use, re-think, refuse.

Consider environmental issues related to graphic products.

Show you understand the reasons for and consequences of the increased and reduced use of product packaging.

Be aware of the advantages and disadvantages of re-cycling and re-using materials.

Understand the materials and social costs of packaging;

Have an awareness of planned obsolescence.

Page 9: Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant ... Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant MaterialsName: ... 13. You need to keep this booklet

GCSE Design & Technology: Resistant Materials (4562)

STAGE 5: MAKING & EVALUATING Submit – Friday 18th March 2011

There will be no extension to this deadline!! Make sure you organise your time during this stage. If you can’t get on with one stage, is there something else you could be doing? DO NOT WASTE TIME.

You must make sure your work is accurate and of the highest possible standard.

You must use the correct tools, materials and processes correctly and safely.

Keep checking that your product is what you intended it to be.

Ask for advice where necessary.

Record as you go along, any problems that you have or changes that you make on your ‘constraints ‘ page.

Complete the ‘comments’ section of your time plan.

EVALUATION

1. Evaluate your product against your original specification! You can do this in a grid.

SPECIFICATION CRITERIA RESULTS AND EXPLANATIONS FULFILLED

My project needs to be completed by March 18

th 2011

I did complete my project by the deadline although I did have to spend time after school. . . . . .

2. Complete your evaluation report, approximately 500 words. Include photos taken during manufacture

and sketches of how your product could be improved. Test your product in action and include your conclusions.

3. Finally include a written evaluation from your client.

ALLOW YOURSELF

PLENTY OF TIME FOR

THE MAKING STAGE. IT

WILL TAKE LONGER

THAN YOU EXPECT.

EVALUATION REPORT

This should be approximately 500 words and should include photos taken during the making stages, conclusions of tests and a

written evaluation from your client.

Your teacher will give you a handout ‘A guide to writing evaluation reports’ which will help you through this process.

In addition you may find the following helpful:

Describe what it is you have made.

What research did you do and how did this help you with your designs?

Comment on the quality of your design work. Why did you choose your final design and reject others?

Describe 3 things you found difficult in the making. Explain how you overcame them.

If you had more time, what 2 parts of the project would you go back to either redo or spend more time on? Explain what

you would do and why.

Describe what it is about your final product that you are particularly pleased with and where the making went well.

Does your product fulfil your original specification?

How well did you work on your project? Did you work accurately and carefully? Do you feel you have produced your best

possible work?

List the skills you have learnt on this project.

Did you enjoy doing the work and are you pleased with the final product?

CAUTION When deciding what you are going to make you need to consider the size of the finished piece and

the time that you have available. You will need to read the following contexts and then discuss

your ideas with your teacher who will advise you as necessary.

Page 10: Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant ... Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant MaterialsName: ... 13. You need to keep this booklet

GCSE Design & Technology: Resistant Materials (4562)

SUMMARY OF CONTROLLED ASSESSMENT CRITERIA

The following is a summary of the assessment criteria for the controlled assessment together with an indication of how these marks relate to the assessment objectives.

Assessment Criteria Maximun Mark Allocation

1. Investigating the design context 8

2. Development of design proposals (including modeling)

32

3. Making 32

4. Testing and Evaluating 12

5. Communication 6

Total 90

Criteria 1 Mark Band

1. Investigating the design context

7-8 Discrimination shown when selecting and acquiring relevant research that will promote originality in designing

Excellent understanding and analysis of the design context

Detailed analysis of relevant existing products or systems undertaken related to design intentions

Comprehensive analysis of relevant and focused research undertaken

Clear and specific design criteria identified, reflecting the analysis undertaken

Target market identified and the intended consumer/user profiled

5-6 Good understanding and analysis of the design context

Good analysis of relevant products or systems undertaken

Good analysis of relevant research and context

Design criteria which reflects the analysis undertaken

Target market for product has been identified

3-4 Basic understanding and analysis of the design context

Some analysis of related products or systems undertaken

Made a superficial analysis of most of the research material and the context

Design criteria reflects most of the analysis undertaken

Some consideration has been taken of the likely consumer/user

0-2 Limited understanding or analysis of design context

Minimal analysis of other products or systems undertaken

Provided little evidence of research and analysis of context

Design criteria is very general and lacking in any detail

Limited understanding of the target market/user evident

Maximum Mark allocation

Page 11: Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant ... Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant MaterialsName: ... 13. You need to keep this booklet

Criteria 2 Mark Band

2. Development of design proposals (including modeling)

26-32 Imaginative and innovative ideas have been developed, demonstrating creativity, flair and originality. Further developments made to take account of ongoing research

A coherent and appropriate design strategy, with clear evidence of a planned approach, adopted throughout

The implications of a wide range of issues including social, moral, environmental and sustainability, are taken into consideration and inform the development of the design proposals

Excellent development work through experimentation with a wide variety of techniques and modelling (including CAD where appropriate) in order to produce a final design solution

Appropriate materials/ingredients and components selected with full regard to their working properties

Fully detailed and justified product/manufacturing specification taking full account of the analysis undertaken

19-25 Imaginative ideas demonstrating a degree of creativity, which are further developed to take account of ongoing research

An appropriate design strategy, with evidence of planning, adopted for most aspects

Development of design proposals take into account the main aspects relating to a variety of social, moral, environmental and sustainability issues

Good development work achieved through working with a variety of techniques and modelling (including CAD where appropriate)

Appropriate materials/ingredients and components selected with regard to their working properties

Product/manufacturing specification is complete and reflects key aspects of the analysis undertaken

12-18 Design ideas show some degree of creativity and further development

An appropriate design strategy, with some evidence of planning, adopted for some aspects

Developments of design solutions are influenced to some extent by factors relating to social, moral, environmental and sustainability issues

Adequate development work achieved through working with a range of techniques and modeling (including CAD where appropriate)

Materials/ingredients and components selected with some regard to their working properties

Product/manufacturing specification reflects most aspects of the analysis

6-11 Ideas show some variation in approach or concept

A limited design strategy, with minimal planning, is evident

Some consideration taken of social, moral, environmental and sustainability issue in development of design solutions

Development work is lacking in detail but makes reference to a number of techniques and modelling (including CAD where appropriate)

Materials/ingredients and components selected with limited regard to their working properties

Limited product/manufacturing specification which reflects most obvious features of analysis

0-5 Ideas are lacking in imagination with minimal development or further research

Little evidence of a logical approach being adopted, with no indication of planning

Development work shows little consideration of social, moral, environmental and sustainability issues

Basic development work undertaken using a limited range of techniques

Materials/ingredients and components selected with little regard to their working properties

Produced a simple product/manufacturing specification which is general in nature

Page 12: Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant ... Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant MaterialsName: ... 13. You need to keep this booklet

Criteria 3 Mark Band

3. Making

26-32 Final outcome(s) shows a high level of making/modelling/finishing skills and accuracy

Selected and used appropriate tools, materials and/or technologies including, where appropriate, CAM correctly, skilfully and safely

Worked independently to produce a rigorous and demanding outcome

Quality controls are evident throughout the project and it is clear how accuracy has been achieved.

The outcome has the potential to be commercially viable and is suitable for the target market

19-25 Final outcome shows very good level of making/modelling/finishing skills

Selected and used appropriate tools, materials and/or technologies including, where appropriate, CAM correctly and safely

Outcome demonstrates a high level of demand

Quality control checks applied in the manufacture of the product

The outcome is suitable for the target market and could be commercially viable with further development

12-18 Final outcome shows good level of making/modelling/finishing skills

Used appropriate materials, components, equipment and processes correctly and safely (including CAM)

Parts of outcome show high levels of demand

Applied quality control checks broadly but superficially

The outcome requires further development in order to be suitable for the target market

6-11 Final outcome is largely complete and represents a basic level of making/ modelling/finishing skills

Used materials, components and equipment correctly and safely (including CAM if appropriate)

Some aspects of outcome are demanding

Some evidence of limited quality control applied throughout the process

The outcome has some weaknesses which limit its suitability for the target market

0-5 Final outcome is incomplete or represents an undemanding level of making/ modelling/finishing skills

Used materials, components and equipment safely under close supervision

Worked with some assistance to produce outcome of limited demand

There is limited evidence of any quality control and levels of accuracy are minimal

The outcome has significant weaknesses which limit its suitability for the target market

Criteria 4 Mark Band

4. Testing and Evaluation

9-12 Detailed testing and evaluation as appropriate throughout the designing and making process taking account of client/user or third party opinion

All aspects of the final outcome have been tested against the design criteria and/or the product/manufacturing specification

Evaluate and justify the need for modifications to the product and consideration given as to how the outcome might need to be modified for commercial production

6-8 Appropriate testing and evaluation evident throughout the designing and making process

Most aspects of the final outcome have been tested against the design criteria and/ or the product/manufacturing specification

Evaluate and justify the need for improvements or modifications to the product

3-5 Evidence of some testing and evaluation leading to the production of the final outcome

Some evidence of testing against the design criteria and/or the product/ manufacturing specification

Some improvements or modifications to product suggested

0-2 Minimal testing and evaluation throughout the designing and making process

Limited or no testing of final outcome against the design criteria and/or the product/manufacturing specification

Limited mention of some improvements or modifications that could be made to the

product

Page 13: Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant ... Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant Materials Resistant MaterialsName: ... 13. You need to keep this booklet

Criteria 5

Mark Band 5. Communication

5-6 Design folder is focused, concise and relevant and demonstrates an appropriate selection of material for inclusion

All decisions communicated in a clear and coherent manner with appropriate use of technical language

The text is legible, easily understood and shows a good grasp of grammar, punctuation and spelling

3-4 Design folder shows some skill in choice of material for inclusion but includes some irrelevant content

Most decisions communicated with some clarity and with some use of technical language

There are a small number of errors in grammar, punctuation and spelling

0-2 Design folder shows excessive duplication of information and a lack of brevity and focus resulting in irrelevant content

Ideas and decisions communicated at a simplistic level with a limited grasp of the concepts involved and a limited use of technical vocabulary

Numerous errors in grammar, punctuation and spelling