WORLD TRADE

ORGANIZATION WT/DS363/R 12 August 2009

(09-3798)

Original: English

CHINA – MEASURES AFFECTING TRADING RIGHTS AND DISTRIBUTION SERVICES FOR CERTAIN

PUBLICATIONS AND AUDIOVISUAL ENTERTAINMENT PRODUCTS

Report of the Panel

WT/DS363/R Page i

TABLE OF CONTENTS Page

I. INTRODUCTION ....................................................................................................................1 II. FACTUAL ASPECTS ..............................................................................................................2 A. MEASURES AT ISSUE...................................................................................................................2 B. TRANSLATION OF CHINA'S MEASURES........................................................................................4 III. PARTIES' REQUESTS FOR FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS.........................4 IV. ARGUMENTS OF THE PARTIES ........................................................................................5 A. FIRST WRITTEN SUBMISSION OF THE UNITED STATES ................................................................6 1. Introduction...............................................................................................................................6 2. Factual background..................................................................................................................6 (a) China's measures addressing trading rights ................................................................................6 (b) China's measures addressing distribution ...................................................................................8 (c) China's treatment of imported products compared to domestic products ...................................9 3. China's measures regarding trading rights are inconsistent with China's

obligations under the Accession Protocol and the Working Party Report........................10 4. China's measures regarding distribution services are inconsistent with China's

obligations under the GATS ..................................................................................................13 5. China's measures regarding product distribution are inconsistent with China's

obligations under Article III:4 of the GATT 1994 ...............................................................16 6. China's measures regarding product distribution are inconsistent with China's

obligations under the Accession Protocol .............................................................................18 7. Conclusion ...............................................................................................................................18 B. FIRST WRITTEN SUBMISSION OF CHINA ....................................................................................18 1. Introduction.............................................................................................................................18 2. Trading rights .........................................................................................................................19 (a) Motion pictures for theatrical release........................................................................................19 (b) Audiovisual products used for publication ...............................................................................20 (c) Reading materials and audiovisual products, including sound recordings ...............................21 3. Distribution services ...............................................................................................................22 (a) Reading materials .....................................................................................................................23 (i) Alleged discriminatory prohibitions .........................................................................................23 (ii) Alleged discriminatory requirements........................................................................................24 (b) Audiovisual products ................................................................................................................25 (i) The US claim under Article XVI of the GATS...........................................................................25 (ii) The US claims under Article XVII of the GATS ........................................................................25 (c) Sound recordings ......................................................................................................................26

WT/DS363/R Page ii

4. Product distribution................................................................................................................28 (a) Reading materials .....................................................................................................................28 (b) Sound recordings ......................................................................................................................29 (c) Motion pictures for theatrical release........................................................................................30 5. Conclusion ...............................................................................................................................31 C. ORAL STATEMENT OF THE UNITED STATES AT THE FIRST SUBSTANTIVE MEETING OF

THE PANEL ................................................................................................................................31 1. Introduction.............................................................................................................................31 2. Trading rights: films for theatrical release, unfinished AVHE products and

unfinished sound recordings are goods subject to China's trading rights commitments ...........................................................................................................................32

3. Trading rights: China's measures are inconsistent with its trading rights commitments and are not justified under any exceptions...................................................33

4. Trade in services: China's measures prohibiting foreign-invested enterprises from engaging in master distribution, master wholesale and wholesale of reading materials are inconsistent with Article XVII of the GATS .................................................34

5. Trade in services: China's services commitments cover the electronic distribution of sound recordings............................................................................................34

6. Trade in goods: China's measures regarding the distribution of hard-copy sound recordings intended for electronic distribution are inconsistent with Article III:4 of the GATT 1994..............................................................................................36

7. China's measures are properly before the Panel and are within the Panel's terms of reference ..............................................................................................................................36

D. ORAL STATEMENT OF CHINA AT THE FIRST SUBSTANTIVE MEETING OF THE PANEL................38 1. Introduction.............................................................................................................................38 2. Products/service at issue and applicable rules .....................................................................38 (a) The importation of motion pictures for theatrical release.........................................................38 (b) The distribution of motion pictures for theatrical release .........................................................39 (c) Audiovisual products used for publication ...............................................................................39 (d) Network music services ............................................................................................................40 (e) Distribution of sound recordings intended for so-called "electronic distribution" ...................41 3. China's right to regulate trade in cultural goods .................................................................41 4. Understanding of the Chinese legislation and regulatory framework applicable

to cultural goods and services ................................................................................................42 (a) No less favourable treatment for the distribution of imported reading materials under

Article III:4 of the GATT 1994 ................................................................................................42 (b) Distribution services of reading materials under Article XVII of the GATS ...........................42 (c) No market access issue or less favourable treatment for the distribution of audiovisual

products.....................................................................................................................................43

WT/DS363/R Page iii

5. Conclusion ...............................................................................................................................43 E. SECOND WRITTEN SUBMISSION OF THE UNITED STATES ..........................................................43 1. Introduction.............................................................................................................................43 2. China's measures regarding trading rights are inconsistent with China's

obligations under the Accession Protocol and Working Party Report ..............................44 (a) Goods versus services ...............................................................................................................44 (b) China's measures are not justified under its right to regulate trade in a manner

consistent with the WTO Agreement or Article XX(a) of the GATT 1994 .............................46 3. China's measures regarding distribution services are inconsistent with China's

obligations under the GATS ..................................................................................................47 (a) Reading materials .....................................................................................................................48 (i) Discriminatory prohibitions......................................................................................................48 (ii) Discriminatory requirements .................................................................................................... 49 (b) AVHE products.........................................................................................................................50 (i) Article XVI ................................................................................................................................50 (ii) Article XVII ...............................................................................................................................51 (c) Sound recordings ......................................................................................................................52 4. China's measures regarding the internal sale, offering for sale, purchase,

distribution and use of products are inconsistent with China's obligations under Article III:4 of the GATT 1994..............................................................................................53

(a) Reading materials .....................................................................................................................53 (b) Sound recordings ......................................................................................................................54 (c) Films for theatrical release........................................................................................................55 5. China's measures regarding the internal sale, offering for sale, purchase,

distribution and use of products are inconsistent with China's obligations under the Accession Protocol ............................................................................................................56

6. The Panel's terms of reference...............................................................................................56 7. Conclusion ...............................................................................................................................57 F. SECOND WRITTEN SUBMISSION OF CHINA ................................................................................57 1. Introduction.............................................................................................................................57 2. Terms of reference ..................................................................................................................58 3. Trading rights .........................................................................................................................59 (a) Motion pictures for theatrical release........................................................................................59 (i) The United States should not be permitted to change the subject of its claim..........................59 (ii) The Chinese measures should only be scrutinized under the GATS, not under WTO

disciplines on goods..................................................................................................................60 (b) Reading materials and audiovisual products, including sound recordings ...............................61 (i) China's right to invoke Article XX of the GATT to justify limitations on trading rights...........61

WT/DS363/R Page iv

(ii) The Chinese measures meet the requirements of Article XX of the GATT................................63 4. Distribution services ...............................................................................................................65 (a) The United States has put forward contradictory definitions and aims to broaden the

scope of the present dispute ......................................................................................................65 (b) The scope of "sound recordings distribution services" in China's GATS schedule is

limited to the distribution of sound recordings in physical form..............................................66 (c) Network music services are distinct from the distribution of sound recordings in

physical form ............................................................................................................................66 (i) Operational characteristics ......................................................................................................67 (ii) End-uses and consumers' perceptions ......................................................................................67 (iii) International classifications......................................................................................................68 5. Product distribution................................................................................................................68 (a) Sound recordings ......................................................................................................................68 (b) Motion pictures for theatrical release........................................................................................69 6. Conclusion ...............................................................................................................................70 G. ORAL STATEMENT OF THE UNITED STATES AT THE SECOND SUBSTANTIVE MEETING

OF THE PANEL ...........................................................................................................................70 1. Introduction.............................................................................................................................70 2. Trading rights: films for theatrical release, unfinished AVHE products and

unfinished sound recordings are goods subject to China's trading rights commitments ...........................................................................................................................70

3. Trading rights: China's measures regarding reading materials, finished AVHE products and finished sound recordings are not justified under its right to regulate trade in a manner consistent with the WTO Agreement or Article XX of the GATT 1994........................................................................................................................71

4. Trade in services: China's services commitments cover the master distribution of reading materials ................................................................................................................73

5. Trade in services: China's services commitments cover the electronic distribution of sound recordings............................................................................................73

6. Trade in goods: China's measures regarding the internal sale, offering for sale, purchase, distribution and use of the products are inconsistent with Article III:4 of the GATT 1994....................................................................................................................75

(a) Sound recordings intended for electronic distribution..............................................................75 (b) Films for theatrical release........................................................................................................76 7. China has not sustained its claim under Article 6.2 of the DSU with respect to

the Panel's terms of reference ................................................................................................76 (a) China's Film Distribution and Exhibition Rule, 2001 Audiovisual Products

Regulation and the Audiovisual Products Importation Rule are within the Panel's terms of reference .....................................................................................................................76

(b) China's discriminatory requirements and different distribution opportunities are within the Panel's terms of reference ........................................................................................77

WT/DS363/R Page v

8. Translation ..............................................................................................................................77 H. ORAL STATEMENT OF CHINA AT THE SECOND SUBSTANTIVE MEETING OF THE PANEL............77 1. Introduction.............................................................................................................................77 2. Terms of reference ..................................................................................................................78 3. Trading rights .........................................................................................................................79 (a) Motion pictures for theatrical release........................................................................................79 (b) China is entitled to put in place a system allowing it to review the content of imported

cultural products .......................................................................................................................80 4. Distribution services ...............................................................................................................81 (a) Zong Pi Fa no longer exists ......................................................................................................81 (b) Alleged discriminatory requirements........................................................................................81 (c) Network music services are not covered by China's commitments under the GATS...............81 5. Product distribution under Article III:4 of the GATT 1994...............................................82 (a) Reading materials .....................................................................................................................82 (i) Newspapers, periodicals, books and electronic publications in the "restricted

category"...................................................................................................................................82 (ii) Newspapers and periodicals in the unrestricted category........................................................83 (b) Sound recordings intended for electronic distribution..............................................................83 (c) Motion pictures for theatrical release........................................................................................83 6. Conclusion ...............................................................................................................................84 V. ARGUMENTS OF THE THIRD PARTIES ........................................................................84 A. AUSTRALIA ...............................................................................................................................84 1. Introduction.............................................................................................................................84 2. "Films for theatrical release" and "unfinished audiovisual products" .............................84 3. "China's right to regulate trade in a manner consistent with the WTO

Agreement" vis-à-vis "the right to trade"............................................................................85 4. The applicability and scope of the "public morals" exception of Article XX of

the GATT.................................................................................................................................85 5. China's GATS obligations......................................................................................................86 6. Article III:4 of the GATT.......................................................................................................88 B. EUROPEAN COMMUNITIES ........................................................................................................88 1. Introduction.............................................................................................................................88 2. Trading rights and China's WTO Accession protocol ........................................................88 3. China's commitments in the distribution sector under the GATS and its schedule

of specific commitments .........................................................................................................89 4. "Technological neutrality" under the GATS and the reading of China's

Schedule of Specific Commitments on Audiovisual Services..............................................89

WT/DS363/R Page vi

5. The classification on "videos, including entertainment software and distribution services"...................................................................................................................................90

6. Applicability of Article III.4 of the GATT 1994 to services ................................................90 C. JAPAN........................................................................................................................................90 1. Article III:4 of the GATT 1994 is applicable to the measures challenged by the

United States............................................................................................................................90 2. It is unclear whether China has demonstrated that its restrictions on trading

rights are "necessary to protect public morals" ..................................................................91 3. Commitments on "sound recording distribution services" include the

distribution of digital recordings over the Internet .............................................................92 D. REPUBLIC OF KOREA.................................................................................................................93 1. Introduction.............................................................................................................................93 2. Legal arguments......................................................................................................................93 (a) The challenged measures at issue seem to affect both trade in goods and trade in

services, and thus could be covered by both GATT and GATS ...............................................93 (b) The measures appear to constitute a violation of national treatment as provided in

Article III of the GATT and it is not entirely clear whether the measures can be justified under Article XX of the GATT..................................................................................94

(c) China's argument based on UNESCO Cultural Diversity Convention and its various domestic legislation is misplaced..............................................................................................94

(d) The challenged measure constitutes a violation of Article XVII of the GATS ........................94 VI. INTERIM REVIEW...............................................................................................................95 A. BACKGROUND...........................................................................................................................95 B. PARTIES' REQUESTS FOR CHANGES TO THE INTERIM REPORT ...................................................95 1. Terms of reference ..................................................................................................................95 (a) Comments by the United States ................................................................................................95 (b) Comments by China..................................................................................................................97 2. US claims regarding China's trading rights commitments .................................................99 (a) Comments by the United States ................................................................................................99 (b) Comments by China................................................................................................................110 3. Claims under the GATS .......................................................................................................116 (a) Comments by the United States ..............................................................................................116 (b) Comments by China................................................................................................................117 4. Claims under Article III:4 of the GATT 1994....................................................................118 (a) Comments by the United States ..............................................................................................118 (i) Reading materials ...................................................................................................................118 (ii) Sound recordings ....................................................................................................................119 (iii) Films for theatrical release.....................................................................................................120

WT/DS363/R Page vii

(b) Comments by China................................................................................................................121 (i) Sound recordings ....................................................................................................................121 (ii) Films for theatrical release.....................................................................................................122 5. Other changes to the Interim Report ..................................................................................124 VII. FINDINGS.............................................................................................................................124 A. GENERAL ISSUES .....................................................................................................................124 1. Burden of proof.....................................................................................................................124 2. Treaty interpretation ............................................................................................................125 B. PRELIMINARY ISSUES ..............................................................................................................126 1. Article 6.2 of the DSU ...........................................................................................................126 (a) Identify the specific measure at issue .....................................................................................127 (b) Provide a brief summary of the legal basis of the complaint..................................................128 (c) Sufficient to present the problem clearly ................................................................................128 (d) Relationship between the panel request and the Panel's terms of reference ...........................129 2. Measures China alleges are outside the Panel's terms of reference .................................130 (a) Whether the Film Distribution and Exhibition Rule is within the Panel's terms of

reference..................................................................................................................................131 (i) The narrative...........................................................................................................................132 (ii) Adequate notice.......................................................................................................................134 (b) Whether the 2001 Audiovisual Products Regulation and the Audiovisual Products

Importation Rule are within the Panel's terms of reference ....................................................136 (i) The narrative...........................................................................................................................136 (ii) Adequate notice.......................................................................................................................139 3. Certain requirements China alleges are outside the Panel's terms of reference.............141 (a) Distribution services for reading materials .............................................................................144 (b) Distribution services for AVHE products...............................................................................144 (c) Conclusion ..............................................................................................................................145 4. The US claim with respect to reading materials under Article III:4 of the

GATT 1994 ............................................................................................................................145 (a) The lack of consultations ........................................................................................................145 (b) Electronic publications............................................................................................................151 (c) Subscription requirements ......................................................................................................154 5. 'Measures' China argues the Panel should not examine ...................................................156 (a) The Several Opinions..............................................................................................................158 (b) The Importation Procedure and the Sub-Distribution Procedure ..........................................161 (i) Importation Procedure............................................................................................................162

WT/DS363/R Page viii

(ii) Sub-Distribution Procedure....................................................................................................164 6. Summary of conclusions.......................................................................................................166 C. US CLAIMS REGARDING CHINA'S TRADING RIGHTS COMMITMENTS ..................167 1. US claims of violation of China's Accession Protocol ........................................................167 (a) Paragraphs 1.2, 5.1 and 5.2 of the Accession Protocol ...........................................................168 (i) Paragraph 5.1 of the Accession Protocol ...............................................................................169 (ii) Paragraph 5.2 of the Accession Protocol ...............................................................................181 (iii) Paragraph 83(d) of the Working Party Report .......................................................................187 (iv) Paragraph 84(a) of the Working Party Report .......................................................................188 (v) Paragraph 84(b) of the Working Party Report .......................................................................189 (b) Consistency of the challenged Chinese measures with the cited paragraphs of the

Accession Protocol..................................................................................................................191 (i) Catalogue................................................................................................................................193

Paragraphs 5.1, 83(d) and 84(a) ............................................................................................................ 196 Paragraphs 5.2 and 84(b)....................................................................................................................... 198

(ii) Foreign Investment Regulation...............................................................................................198 (iii) Several Opinions.....................................................................................................................199

Paragraphs 5.1, 83(d) and 84(a) ............................................................................................................ 201 Paragraphs 5.2 and 84(b)....................................................................................................................... 202

(iv) Publications Regulation..........................................................................................................202 Article 43............................................................................................................................................... 204 Article 42............................................................................................................................................... 205 Article 41............................................................................................................................................... 214

(v) Importation Procedure............................................................................................................215 (vi) 1997 Electronic Publications Regulation ...............................................................................216

Article 8................................................................................................................................................. 219 Articles 50-51........................................................................................................................................ 220 Articles 52-55........................................................................................................................................ 223

(vii) Film Regulation ......................................................................................................................225 Applicability.......................................................................................................................................... 234 Consistency ........................................................................................................................................... 242

(viii) Film Enterprise Rule...............................................................................................................245 Applicability.......................................................................................................................................... 246 Consistency ........................................................................................................................................... 246

(ix) Film Distribution and Exhibition Rule ...................................................................................250 (x) 2001 Audiovisual Products Regulation...................................................................................250

WT/DS363/R Page ix

Article 27............................................................................................................................................... 254 Article 5................................................................................................................................................. 255 Article 28............................................................................................................................................... 260

(xi) Audiovisual Products Importation Rule..................................................................................260 Article 7................................................................................................................................................. 262 Article 8................................................................................................................................................. 264 Article 9................................................................................................................................................. 265 Article 10............................................................................................................................................... 266

(xii) Audiovisual (Sub-) Distribution Rule......................................................................................266 Paragraphs 5.1, 83(d) and 84(a) ............................................................................................................ 267 Paragraphs 5.2 and 84(b)....................................................................................................................... 267

(xiii) Summary of conclusions .........................................................................................................267 Catalogue (Articles X.2-X.3) and Foreign Investment Regulation (Articles 3-4) ................................ 267 Several Opinions (Article 4).................................................................................................................. 268 Publications Regulation (Articles 41-43).............................................................................................. 268 Importation Procedure (paragraphs 2 and 8) ........................................................................................ 268 1997 Electronic Publications Regulation (Articles 8 and 50-55).......................................................... 269 Film Regulation (Articles 5 and 30) ...................................................................................................... 269 Film Enterprise Rule (Articles 3 and 16) .............................................................................................. 269 Film Distribution and Exhibition Rule (Article II)................................................................................ 270 2001 Audiovisual Products Regulation (Articles 5, 27-28)................................................................... 270 Audiovisual Products Importation Rule (Articles 7-10)........................................................................ 270 Audiovisual (Sub-) Distribution Rule (Article 21) ................................................................................ 270

2. China's defence based on the "right to regulate trade" and Article XX(a) of the GATT 1994 ............................................................................................................................271

(a) Measures claimed to be justified by Article XX(a) ................................................................274 (b) Applicability of Article XX(a)................................................................................................276 (c) Application of Article XX(a) to China's measures .................................................................278 (i) Provisional justification of the measures at issue under sub-paragraph (a) of

Article XX................................................................................................................................278 Link between import entities, content review and the protection of public morals............................... 278 "Necessity" of the measures at issue to protect public morals............................................................... 284

(ii) Compliance with the requirements of the chapeau of Article XX ...........................................309 (d) Conclusion ..............................................................................................................................309 3. Overall conclusions ...............................................................................................................310 D. CLAIMS UNDER THE GATS .....................................................................................................310 1. Distribution of reading materials: claims under Article XVII of the GATS..................311

WT/DS363/R Page x

(a) Prohibitions on foreign-invested enterprises...........................................................................313 (i) Prohibition on the wholesale of imported reading materials .................................................313

Whether China has undertaken national treatment commitments with respect to the wholesale of imported reading materials through commercial presence (mode 3) ................................................ 314 Whether the measures at issue are inconsistent with China's national treatment commitments under Article XVII of the GATS........................................................................................................... 318 Conclusion............................................................................................................................................. 326

(ii) Prohibition on the "master distribution" (Zong Fa Xing) of books, newspapers and periodicals ..............................................................................................................................326 Claim with respect to wholesale trade services ..................................................................................... 326 Claim with respect to retail services...................................................................................................... 333

(iii) Prohibition on the "master wholesale" (Zong Pi Fa) and wholesale of electronic publications.............................................................................................................................336 Preliminary matter................................................................................................................................. 337 Whether China's commitments on wholesale trade services cover master wholesale and wholesale of electronic publications ..................................................................................................... 337 Whether the measures at issue are inconsistent with China's national treatment commitments under Article XVII of the GATS........................................................................................................... 338 Conclusion............................................................................................................................................. 344

(b) Discriminatory requirements applying to foreign-invested enterprises ..................................344 (i) Registered capital requirement...............................................................................................345 (ii) Operating term requirement ...................................................................................................348 (iii) Conclusion ..............................................................................................................................352 2. Distribution of sound recordings in electronic form: claims under Article XVII

of the GATS...........................................................................................................................352 (a) Whether China has undertaken GATS commitments for the distribution of sound

recordings in electronic form .................................................................................................. 353 (i) Services at issue ......................................................................................................................353 (ii) Sectoral scope of "sound recording distribution services" .....................................................354 (iii) Interpretation of GATS Schedules ..........................................................................................357

Ordinary meaning.................................................................................................................................. 358 Context .................................................................................................................................................. 360 Object and purpose................................................................................................................................ 368 Preliminary conclusion.......................................................................................................................... 368 Supplementary means of interpretation................................................................................................. 369 Other arguments – "technological neutrality" and "relevant factors".................................................... 376 Conclusion............................................................................................................................................. 379

(b) Whether the measures at issue are inconsistent with China's national treatment commitments (Article XVII)...................................................................................................379

WT/DS363/R Page xi

(i) Requirements of Article XVII ..................................................................................................380 Whether the services at issue are within the scope of services listed in China's Schedule.................... 380 Whether the measures at issue are "affecting" trade in services............................................................ 380 Extent of China's national treatment commitment for "sound recording distribution services" supplied through commercial presence ................................................................................................. 381 Interpretative issues on the treatment of like service suppliers ............................................................. 382

(ii) Measures at issue....................................................................................................................383 Coverage of electronic distribution other than through the Internet...................................................... 383 Specific measures.................................................................................................................................. 385

(c) Conclusion ..............................................................................................................................387 3. Distribution of AVHE products in physical form: claims under Articles XVI

and XVII of the GATS..........................................................................................................387 (a) Whether China has undertaken GATS commitments for the distribution of AVHE

products in physical form........................................................................................................388 (i) Services at issue ......................................................................................................................388

Sectoral scope of China's entry on "Videos, including entertainment software and (CPC 83202), distribution services"...................................................................................................... 388 Ordinary meaning.................................................................................................................................. 390 Preliminary view based on ordinary meaning ....................................................................................... 392 Context .................................................................................................................................................. 392 Object and purpose................................................................................................................................ 394

(ii) Conclusion ..............................................................................................................................395 (b) Whether the measures at issue are inconsistent with China's market access

commitments (Article XVI)....................................................................................................395 (i) Requirements of Article XVI:2(f) ............................................................................................395

Extent of China's commitments on market access for the services at issue........................................... 396 (ii) The measures at issue .............................................................................................................397

Audiovisual (Sub-)Distribution Rule (Article 8.4)................................................................................ 397 Catalogue (Article VI:3) and Foreign Investment Regulation (Article 8) ............................................ 401 Several Opinions (Article 1).................................................................................................................. 403

(iii) Conclusion ..............................................................................................................................404 (c) Whether the measures at issue are inconsistent with China's national treatment

commitments (Article XVII)...................................................................................................404 (i) Requirements of Article XVII ..................................................................................................405

Whether the services at issue are within the scope of services listed in China's Schedule.................... 405 Whether the measures at issue are "affecting" trade in services............................................................ 405 Extent of China's commitments on national treatment for the services at issue .................................... 405

(ii) Measures at issue....................................................................................................................406

WT/DS363/R Page xii

Measures limiting foreign equity participation ..................................................................................... 406 Measures requiring an operating term................................................................................................... 408

(iii) Conclusion ..............................................................................................................................409 4. Summary of conclusions.......................................................................................................409 (a) Distribution of reading materials ............................................................................................409 (b) Electronic distribution of sound recordings ............................................................................410 (c) Distribution of AVHE products ..............................................................................................410 E. US CLAIMS UNDER ARTICLE III:4 OF THE GATT 1994 ...........................................................411 1. Article III:4 of the GATT 1994............................................................................................411 (a) Like products ..........................................................................................................................412 (b) "[L]aws, regulations, or requirements affecting ... distribution".............................................413 (i) Laws, regulations, or requirements ........................................................................................413 (ii) "[A]ffecting"............................................................................................................................413 (iii) Distribution.............................................................................................................................413 (c) Less favourable treatment .......................................................................................................416 2. Reading materials .................................................................................................................418 (a) Like products ..........................................................................................................................418 (i) Traditional analysis ................................................................................................................418 (ii) The Imported Publications Subscription Rule ........................................................................419 (iii) Publications (Sub-)Distribution Rule .....................................................................................422 (b) Laws, regulations, or requirements affecting ... distribution...................................................424 (i) Laws, regulations, or requirements ........................................................................................424 (ii) Affecting ... distribution ..........................................................................................................425 (c) Less favourable treatment .......................................................................................................426 (i) Imported Publications Subscription Rule ...............................................................................427 (ii) Publications (Sub-)Distribution Rule .....................................................................................429 3. Sound recordings ..................................................................................................................430 (a) Like products ..........................................................................................................................431 (i) Traditional analysis ................................................................................................................432 (ii) Internet Culture Rule ..............................................................................................................432 (iii) Network Music Opinions.........................................................................................................434 (b) Laws, regulations, or requirements affecting ... distribution...................................................437 (i) Laws, regulations or requirements .........................................................................................437 (ii) Affecting ... ..............................................................................................................................438

Is "use" within the Panel's terms of reference?...................................................................................... 440

WT/DS363/R Page xiii

Distribution ........................................................................................................................................... 442 4. Films for theatrical release...................................................................................................451 (a) What creates the "duopoly" for the distribution of imported films for theatrical

release?....................................................................................................................................451 (i) Do China's rules and regulations create a de jure distribution duopoly?..............................454 (ii) Do China's rules and regulations create a de facto distribution duopoly? ............................457 5. Summary of conclusions.......................................................................................................458 (a) Reading materials ...................................................................................................................458 (b) Sound recordings ....................................................................................................................458 (c) Films for theatrical release......................................................................................................458 F. THE US CLAIM ON PARAGRAPHS 5.1 AND 1.2 OF THE ACCESSION PROTOCOL .......................459 1. Whether China's measures are inconsistent with paragraphs 5.1 and 1.2 of the

Accession Protocol ................................................................................................................459 2. Summary of conclusions.......................................................................................................460 VIII. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS..............................................................461 1. China's terms of reference objections .................................................................................461 2. China's commitments on trading rights in its Accession Protocol ...................................462 3. China's national treatment and market access commitments under the GATS.............466 4. China's national treatment obligations under Article III:4 of the GATT 1994 ..............468 5. China's national treatment commitments under paragraphs 5.1 and 1.2 of the

Accession Protocol ................................................................................................................469 6. Nullification and impairment...............................................................................................469 7. Recommendations.................................................................................................................469

WT/DS363/R Page xiv

ANNEX A

CONTENTS PAGE Annex A-1 Translation Differences in the Report – Summary Table A-2 Annex A-2 Short Title of Measures A-4

WT/DS363/R Page xv

TABLE OF WTO CASES CITED IN THIS REPORT

Short Title Full case title and citation

Argentina – Footwear (EC)

Panel Report, Argentina – Safeguard Measures on Imports of Footwear, WT/DS121/R, adopted 12 January 2000, as modified by Appellate Body Report WT/DS121/AB/R, DSR 2000:II, 575

Argentina – Hides and Leather

Panel Report, Argentina – Measures Affecting the Export of Bovine Hides and Import of Finished Leather, WT/DS155/R and Corr.1, adopted 16 February 2001, DSR 2001:V, 1779

Brazil – Aircraft Appellate Body Report, Brazil – Export Financing Programme for Aircraft, WT/DS46/AB/R, adopted 20 August 1999, DSR 1999:III, 1161

Brazil – Desiccated Coconut Appellate Body Report, Brazil – Measures Affecting Desiccated Coconut, WT/DS22/AB/R, adopted 20 March 1997, DSR 1997:I, 167

Brazil – Retreaded Tyres Appellate Body Report, Brazil – Measures Affecting Imports of Retreaded Tyres, WT/DS332/AB/R, adopted 17 December 2007

Brazil – Retreaded Tyres Panel Report, Brazil – Measures Affecting Imports of Retreaded Tyres, WT/DS332/R, adopted 17 December 2007, as modified by Appellate Body Report WT/DS332/AB/R

Canada – Autos Appellate Body Report, Canada – Certain Measures Affecting the Automotive Industry, WT/DS139/AB/R, WT/DS142/AB/R, adopted 19 June 2000, DSR 2000:VI, 2985.

Canada – Autos Panel Report, Canada – Certain Measures Affecting the Automotive Industry, WT/DS139/R, WT/DS142/R, adopted 19 June 2000, as modified by Appellate Body Report WT/DS139/AB/R, WT/DS142/AB/R, DSR 2000:VII, 3043

Canada – Dairy (Article 21.5 New Zealand and US II)

Appellate Body Report, Canada – Measures Affecting the Importation of Milk and the Exportation of Dairy Products – Second Recourse to Article 21.5 of the DSU by New Zealand and the United States, WT/DS103/AB/RW2, WT/DS113/AB/RW2, adopted 17 January 2003, DSR 2003:I, 213

Canada – FIRA GATT Panel Report, Canada – Administration of the Foreign Investment Review Act, adopted 7 February 1984, BISD 30S/140.

Canada – Periodicals Appellate Body Report, Canada – Certain Measures Concerning Periodicals, WT/DS31/AB/R, adopted 30 July 1997, DSR 1997:I, 449.

Canada – Periodicals Panel Report, Canada – Certain Measures Concerning Periodicals, WT/DS31/R and Corr.1, adopted 30 July 1997, as modified by Appellate Body Report, WT/DS31/AB/R, DSR 1997:I, 481

Canada – Wheat Exports and Grain Imports

Panel Report, Canada – Measures Relating to Exports of Wheat and Treatment of Imported Grain, WT/DS276/R, adopted 27 September 2004, upheld by Appellate Body Report, WT/DS276/AB/R, DSR 2004:VI, 2817

Chile – Price Band System Appellate Body Report, Chile – Price Band System and Safeguard Measures Relating to Certain Agricultural Products, WT/DS207/AB/R, adopted 23 October 2002, DSR 2002:VIII, 3045 (Corr.1, DSR 2006:XII, 5473)

China – Auto Parts Appellate Body Reports, China – Measures Affecting Imports of Automobile Parts, WT/DS339/AB/R, WT/DS340/AB/R, WT/DS342/AB/R, adopted 12 January 2009

China – Auto Parts Panel Reports, China – Measures Affecting Imports of Automobile Parts, WT/DS339/R, WT/DS340/R, WT/DS342/R and Add.1 and Add.2, adopted 12 January 2009, as upheld (WT/DS339/R) , and as modified (WT/DS340/R, WT/DS342/R) by Appellate Body Reports WT/DS339/AB/R, WT/DS340/AB/R, WT/DS342/AB/R

WT/DS363/R Page xvi

Short Title Full case title and citation

China – Intellectual Property Rights

Panel Report, China – Measures Affecting the Protection and Enforcement of Intellectual Property Rights, WT/DS362/R, adopted 20 March 2009

Dominican Republic – Cigarettes

Appellate Body Report, Dominican Republic – Measures Affecting the Importation and Internal Sale of Cigarettes, WT/DS302/AB/R, adopted 19 May 2005, DSR 2005:XV, 7367

EC – Approval and Marketing of Biotech Products

Panel Report, European Communities – Measures Affecting the Approval and Marketing of Biotech Products, WT/DS291/R, WT/DS292/R, WT/DS293/R, Add.1 to Add.9, and Corr.1, adopted 21 November 2006, DSR 2006:III-VIII

EC – Asbestos Appellate Body Report, European Communities – Measures Affecting Asbestos and Asbestos-Containing Products, WT/DS135/AB/R, adopted 5 April 2001, DSR 2001:VII, 3243

EC – Bananas III Appellate Body Report, European Communities – Regime for the Importation, Sale and Distribution of Bananas, WT/DS27/AB/R, adopted 25 September 1997, DSR 1997:II, 591

EC – Bananas III Panel Report, European Communities – Regime for the Importation, Sale and Distribution of Bananas, Complaint by the United States, WT/DS27/R/USA, adopted 25 September 1997, as modified by Appellate Body Report, WT/DS27/AB/R, DSR 1997:II, 943

EC – Bananas III (Article 21.5 – Ecuador II) / EC – Bananas III (Article 21.5 – US)

Appellate Body Reports, European Communities – Regime for the Importation, Sale and Distribution of Bananas – Second Recourse to Article 21.5 of the DSU by Ecuador, WT/DS27/AB/RW2/ECU, adopted 11 December 2008, and Corr.1 / European Communities – Regime for the Importation, Sale and Distribution of Bananas – Recourse to Article 21.5 of the DSU by the United States, WT/DS27/AB/RW/USA and Corr.1, adopted 22 December 2008.

EC – Chicken Cuts Appellate Body Report, European Communities – Customs Classification of Frozen Boneless Chicken Cuts, WT/DS269/AB/R, WT/DS286/AB/R, adopted 27 September 2005, and Corr.1, DSR 2005:XIX, 9157

EC – Computer Equipment Appellate Body Report, European Communities – Customs Classification of Certain Computer Equipment, WT/DS62/AB/R, WT/DS67/AB/R, WT/DS68/AB/R, adopted 22 June 1998, DSR 1998:V, 1851

EC – Hormones Appellate Body Report, EC Measures Concerning Meat and Meat Products (Hormones), WT/DS26/AB/R, WT/DS48/AB/R, adopted 13 February 1998, DSR 1998:I, 135

EC – Poultry Appellate Body Report, European Communities – Measures Affecting the Importation of Certain Poultry Products, WT/DS69/AB/R, adopted 23 July 1998, DSR 1998:V, 2031

EC – Trademarks and Geographical Indications (Australia)

Panel Report, European Communities – Protection of Trademarks and Geographical Indications for Agricultural Products and Foodstuffs, Complaint by Australia, WT/DS290/R, adopted 20 April 2005, DSR 2005:X, 4603

EC – Trademarks and Geographical Indications (US)

Panel Report, European Communities – Protection of Trademarks and Geographical Indications for Agricultural Products and Foodstuffs, Complaint by the United States, WT/DS174/R, adopted 20 April 2005, DSR 2005:VIII, 3499

Egypt – Steel Rebar Panel Report, Egypt – Definitive Anti-Dumping Measures on Steel Rebar from Turkey, WT/DS211/R, adopted 1 October 2002, DSR 2002:VII, 2667

Guatemala – Cement I Appellate Body Report, Guatemala – Anti-Dumping Investigation Regarding Portland Cement from Mexico, WT/DS60/AB/R, adopted 25 November 1998, DSR 1998:IX, 3767

WT/DS363/R Page xvii

Short Title Full case title and citation

India – Additional Import Duties

Panel Report, India – Additional and Extra-Additional Duties on Imports from the United States, WT/DS360/R, adopted 17 November 2008, reversed by Appellate Body Report WT/DS360/AB/R

India – Autos Panel Report, India – Measures Affecting the Automotive Sector, WT/DS146/R, WT/DS175/R and Corr.1, adopted 5 April 2002, DSR 2002:V, 1827

India – Patents (US) Appellate Body Report, India – Patent Protection for Pharmaceutical and Agricultural Chemical Products, WT/DS50/AB/R, adopted 16 January 1998, DSR 1998:I, 9

Indonesia – Autos Panel Report, Indonesia – Certain Measures Affecting the Automobile Industry, WT/DS54/R, WT/DS55/R, WT/DS59/R, WT/DS64/R and Corr.1 and 2, adopted 23 July 1998, and Corr. 3 and 4, DSR 1998:VI, 2201

Italy – Agricultural Machinery

GATT Panel Report, Italian Discrimination Against Imported Agricultural Machinery, adopted 23 October 1958, BISD 7S/60

Japan – Agricultural Products II

Appellate Body Report, Japan – Measures Affecting Agricultural Products, WT/DS76/AB/R, adopted 19 March 1999, DSR 1999:I, 277

Japan – Alcoholic Beverages II

Appellate Body Report, Japan – Taxes on Alcoholic Beverages, WT/DS8/AB/R, WT/DS10/AB/R, WT/DS11/AB/R, adopted 1 November 1996, DSR 1996:I, 97

Japan – Alcoholic Beverages II

Panel Report, Japan – Taxes on Alcoholic Beverages, WT/DS8/R, WT/DS10/R, WT/DS11/R, adopted 1 November 1996, as modified by Appellate Body Report WT/DS8/AB/R, WT/DS10/AB/R, WT/DS11/AB/R, DSR 1996:I, 125

Japan – Film Panel Report, Japan – Measures Affecting Consumer Photographic Film and Paper, WT/DS44/R, adopted 22 April 1998, DSR 1998:IV, 1179

Korea – Alcoholic Beverages Panel Report, Korea – Taxes on Alcoholic Beverages, WT/DS75/R, WT/DS84/R, adopted 17 February 1999, as modified by Appellate Body Report WT/DS75/AB/R, WT/DS84/AB/R, DSR 1999:I, 44

Korea – Various Measures on Beef

Appellate Body Report, Korea – Measures Affecting Imports of Fresh, Chilled and Frozen Beef, WT/DS161/AB/R, WT/DS169/AB/R, adopted 10 January 2001, DSR 2001:I, 5

Korea – Various Measures on Beef

Panel Report, Korea – Measures Affecting Imports of Fresh, Chilled and Frozen Beef, WT/DS161/R, WT/DS169/R, adopted 10 January 2001, as modified by Appellate Body Report WT/DS161/AB/R, WT/DS169/AB/R, DSR 2001:I, 59

Korea – Dairy Appellate Body Report, Korea – Definitive Safeguard Measure on Imports of Certain Dairy Products, WT/DS98/AB/R, adopted 12 January 2000, DSR 2000:I, 3

Korea – Commercial Vessels Panel Report, Korea – Measures Affecting Trade in Commercial Vessels, WT/DS273/R, adopted 11 April 2005, DSR 2005:VII, 2749

Mexico – Anti-Dumping Measures on Rice

Appellate Body Report, Mexico – Definitive Anti-Dumping Measures on Beef and Rice, Complaint with Respect to Rice, WT/DS295/AB/R, adopted 20 December 2005, DSR 2005:XXII, 10853

Mexico – Anti-Dumping Measures on Rice

Panel Report, Mexico – Definitive Anti-Dumping Measures on Beef and Rice, Complaint with Respect to Rice, WT/DS295/R, adopted 20 December 2005, as modified by Appellate Body Report WT/DS295/AB/R, DSR 2005:XXIII, 11007

Mexico – Corn Syrup (Article 21.5 – US)

Appellate Body Report, Mexico – Anti-Dumping Investigation of High Fructose Corn Syrup (HFCS) from the United States – Recourse to Article 21.5 of the DSU by the United States, WT/DS132/AB/RW, adopted 21 November 2001, DSR 2001:XIII, 6675

WT/DS363/R Page xviii

Short Title Full case title and citation

Mexico – Taxes on Soft Drinks

Panel Report, Mexico – Tax Measures on Soft Drinks and Other Beverages, WT/DS308/R, adopted 24 March 2006, as modified by Appellate Body Report WT/DS308/AB/R, DSR 2006:I, 43

Thailand – H-Beams Appellate Body Report, Thailand – Anti-Dumping Duties on Angles, Shapes and Sections of Iron or Non-Alloy Steel and H-Beams from Poland, WT/DS122/AB/R, adopted 5 April 2001, DSR 2001:VII, 2701

US – Carbon Steel Appellate Body Report, United States – Countervailing Duties on Certain Corrosion-Resistant Carbon Steel Flat Products from Germany, WT/DS213/AB/R and Corr.1, adopted 19 December 2002, DSR 2002:IX, 3779

US – Continued Suspension Appellate Body Report, United States – Continued Suspension of Obligations in the EC – Hormones Dispute, WT/DS320/AB/R, adopted 14 November 2008

US – Continued Zeroing Appellate Body Report, United States – Continued Existence and Application of Zeroing Methodology, WT/DS350/AB/R, adopted 19 February 2009

US – Corrosion-Resistant Steel Sunset Review

Appellate Body Report, United States – Sunset Review of Anti-Dumping Duties on Corrosion-Resistant Carbon Steel Flat Products from Japan, WT/DS244/AB/R, adopted 9 January 2004, DSR 2004:I, 3

US – DRAMS Panel Report, United States – Anti-Dumping Duty on Dynamic Random Access Memory Semiconductors (DRAMS) of One Megabit or Above from Korea, WT/DS99/R, adopted 19 March 1999, DSR 1999:II, 521

US – Export Restraints Panel Report, United States – Measures Treating Export Restraints as Subsidies, WT/DS194/R and Corr. 2, adopted 23 August 2001, DSR 2001:XI, 5767

US – FSC Appellate Body Report, United States – Tax Treatment for "Foreign Sales Corporations", WT/DS108/AB/R, adopted 20 March 2000, DSR 2000:III, 1619

US – FSC Panel Report, United States – Tax Treatment for "Foreign Sales Corporations", WT/DS108/R, adopted 20 March 2000, as modified by Appellate Body Report WT/DS108/AB/R, DSR 2000:IV, 1675

US – FSC (Article 21.5 – EC) Appellate Body Report, United States – Tax Treatment for "Foreign Sales Corporations" – Recourse to Article 21.5 of the DSU by the European Communities, WT/DS108/AB/RW, adopted 29 January 2002, DSR 2002:I, 55

US – Gambling Appellate Body Report, United States – Measures Affecting the Cross-Border Supply of Gambling and Betting Services, WT/DS285/AB/R, adopted 20 April 2005, DSR 2005:XII, 5663, and Corr.1

US – Gambling Panel Report, United States – Measures Affecting the Cross-Border Supply of Gambling and Betting Services, WT/DS285/R, adopted 20 April 2005, as modified by Appellate Body Report, WT/DS285/AB/R, DSR 2005:XII, 5797

US – Gasoline Appellate Body Report, United States – Standards for Reformulated and Conventional Gasoline, WT/DS2/AB/R, adopted 20 May 1996, DSR 1996:I, 3

US – Gasoline Panel Report, United States – Standards for Reformulated and Conventional Gasoline, WT/DS2/R, adopted 20 May 1996, as modified by Appellate Body Report WT/DS2/AB/R, DSR 1996:I, 29

US – Oil Country Tubular Goods Sunset Reviews

Appellate Body Report, United States – Sunset Reviews of Anti-Dumping Measures on Oil Country Tubular Goods from Argentina, WT/DS268/AB/R, adopted 17 December 2004, DSR 2004:VII, 3257

US – Section 337 GATT Panel Report, United States Section 337 of the Tariff Act of 1930, adopted 7 November 1989, BISD 36S/345

WT/DS363/R Page xix

Short Title Full case title and citation

US – Shrimp Appellate Body Report, United States – Import Prohibition of Certain Shrimp and Shrimp Products, WT/DS58/AB/R, adopted 6 November 1998, DSR 1998:VII, 2755

US – Shrimp (Thailand) / US – Customs Bond Directive

Appellate Body Report, United States – Measures Relating to Shrimp from Thailand / United States – Customs Bond Directive for Merchandise Subject to Anti-Dumping/Countervailing Duties, WT/DS343/AB/R, WT/DS345/AB/R, adopted 1 August 2008

US – Softwood Lumber IV Appellate Body Report, United States – Final Countervailing Duty Determination with Respect to Certain Softwood Lumber from Canada, WT/DS257/AB/R, adopted 17 February 2004, DSR 2004:II, 571

US – Superfund GATT Panel Report, United States – Taxes on Petroleum and Certain Imported Substances, adopted 17 June 1987, BISD 34S/136

US – Upland Cotton Appellate Body Report, United States – Subsidies on Upland Cotton, WT/DS267/AB/R, adopted 21 March 2005, DSR 2005:I, 3

US – Upland Cotton Panel Report, United States – Subsidies on Upland Cotton, WT/DS267/R, Corr.1, and Add.1 to Add.3, adopted 21 March 2005, as modified by Appellate Body Report WT/DS267/AB/R, DSR 2005:II, 299

US – Wool Shirts and Blouses Appellate Body Report, United States – Measure Affecting Imports of Woven Wool Shirts and Blouses from India, WT/DS33/AB/R, adopted 23 May 1997, and Corr.1, DSR 1997:I, 323

WT/DS363/R Page xx

LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS 1993 Scheduling Guidelines 1993 Guidelines for the Scheduling of Specific Commitments

under the GATS (Document MTN.GNS/W/164)

AVHE audiovisual home entertainment

CD compact disc

CNPIEC China National Publications Import and Export Corporation (Group)

CPC 1991 United Nations Provisional Central Product Classification

DSB Dispute Settlement Body

DSU Understanding on Rules and Procedures Governing the Settlement of Disputes

DVD digital video disc

EC European Communities

GAPP General Administration of Press and Publication

GATS General Agreement on Trade in Services

GATT 1994 General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade 1994

HS Harmonized Commodity Description and Coding System

ICP Internet Culture Provider

MCP Mobile Content Provider

MOC Ministry of Culture

MOFCOM Ministry of Commerce

SARFT State Administration on Radio, Film and Television

UNESCO United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization

UNOG United Nations Office at Geneva

UNON United Nations Office at Nairobi

US United States

VCD video compact disc

W/120 Services Sectoral Classification List (Document MTN.GNS/W/120)

WT/DS363/R Page 1

I. INTRODUCTION

1.1 On 10 April 2007, the United States requested consultations with the Government of China pursuant to Article 4 of the Understanding on Rules and Procedures Governing the Settlement of Disputes ("DSU"), Article XXII of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade 1994 ("GATT 1994"), and Article XXII of the General Agreement on Trade in Services ("GATS") with respect to (1) certain measures that appear to restrict trading rights with respect to imported films for theatrical release, audiovisual home entertainment products, sound recordings, and publications, and (2) certain measures that appear to restrict market access for, or discriminate against, foreign suppliers of distribution services for publications and foreign suppliers of audiovisual services (including distribution services) for audiovisual home entertainment products. The request was circulated on 16 April 2007.1

1.2 On 25 April 2007, the European Communities requested to join in the consultations requested by the United States.2 China accepted the European Communities' request.3

1.3 Consultations were held on 5-6 June 2007. Those consultations did not resolve the dispute.

1.4 On 10 July 2007, the United States requested supplemental consultations with China pursuant to Articles 1 and 4 of the DSU, Article XXII of the GATT 1994, and Article XXII of the GATS with respect to certain market access concerns related to the distribution of imported films for theatrical release and the distribution of imported sound recordings, as well as sound recording distribution services, specifically, (1) certain measures that appear to provide less favourable distribution opportunities for imported films for theatrical release than for like domestic films, and (2) certain measures that appear to provide less favourable opportunities for foreign suppliers of sound recording distribution services and for the distribution of imported sound recordings in physical form than are provided to like service suppliers and like products. This request supplemented the request for consultations circulated as WT/DS363/1. It was circulated on 16 July 2007.4

1.5 On 20 July 2007, the European Communities requested to join in the supplemental consultations requested by the United States.5 Further consultations were held on 31 July 2007, but these did not resolve the dispute.

1.6 On 10 October 2007, the United States requested that the Dispute Settlement Body ("DSB") establish a panel to examine the matters raised in the consultation requests, pursuant to Article 6 of the DSU, with the standard terms of reference as set out in Article 7.1 of the DSU.6 At its meeting of 27 November 2007, the DSB established a Panel with the following terms of reference:

"To examine, in the light of the relevant provisions of the covered agreements cited by the United States in document WT/DS363/5, the matter referred to the DSB by the United States in that document, and to make such findings as will assist the DSB in making the recommendations or in giving the rulings provided for in those agreements."7

1 WT/DS363/1. 2 WT/DS363/2. 3 WT/DS363/3. 4 WT/DS363/1/Add.1. 5 WT/DS363/4. 6 United States' panel request WT/DS363/5. 7 WT/DS363/6, para. 2.

WT/DS363/R Page 2

1.7 On 17 March 2008, the United States requested the Director-General to determine the composition of the Panel, pursuant to paragraph 7 of Article 8 of the DSU. On 27 March 2008, the Director-General accordingly composed the Panel as follows:8

Chairman: Mr. Florentino P. Feliciano Members: Mr. Juan Antonio Dorantes Mr. Christian Häberli 1.8 Australia, the European Communities, Japan, the Republic of Korea ("Korea"), and the Separate Customs Territory of Taiwan, Penghu, Kinmen and Matsu ("Chinese Taipei") reserved their rights to participate in the Panel proceedings as third parties.9

1.9 The Panel met with the United States and China (the "parties") on 22 and 23 July 2008. It also met with the third parties on 23 July 2008. The Panel met again with the parties on 23 and 24 September 2008.

1.10 The European Communities, Korea, and Japan presented third-party submissions before the first substantive meeting of the Panel. Australia, the European Communities, Japan, and Korea made oral statements during the first substantive meeting of the Panel.

1.11 The Panel issued its Interim Report to the parties on 20 April 2009. The Panel issued its Final Report to the parties on 23 June 2009.

II. FACTUAL ASPECTS

A. MEASURES AT ISSUE

2.1 This dispute concerns China's obligations under the WTO Agreement with respect to goods and services relating to reading materials (e.g. books, newspapers, periodicals, electronic publications), audiovisual home entertainment (AVHE) products (e.g. videocassettes, video compact discs, digital video discs), sound recordings (e.g. recorded audio tapes), and films for theatrical release.

2.2 The dispute arises over certain measures that affect (i) the importation into China of relevant goods, (ii) the distribution within China of relevant goods, and (iii) services and service suppliers in relation to certain of the above mentioned products.

2.3 More specifically, this dispute involves the US claims of violation with respect to:

(a) Chinese measures that are alleged to unjustifiably restrict the right of enterprises in China and foreign enterprises and individuals to import into China reading materials, AVHE products, sound recordings, and films for theatrical release by limiting trading rights to Chinese state-owned enterprises;

(b) Chinese measures relating to the distribution of reading materials, AVHE distribution services, and sound recording distribution services. More specifically, the United States is challenging Chinese measures that allegedly:

8 WT/DS363/6, para. 4. 9 Ibid., para. 5.

WT/DS363/R Page 3

- prohibit foreign-invested enterprises from engaging in the master distribution of reading materials, the master wholesale and wholesale of electronic publications, and the distribution of imported reading material;

- impose, on foreign-invested enterprises permitted to engage in the sub-distribution of reading materials, requirements that are more burdensome than those applicable to wholly Chinese-owned distributors. Such requirements relate to registered capital, operating terms, pre-establishment legal compliance, examination and approval process, and decision-making criteria;

- limit commercial presence for the distribution of AVHE products to Chinese-foreign contractual joint-ventures with majority Chinese ownership;

- as regards the sub-distribution of AVHE products, discriminate against Chinese-foreign contractual joint ventures by imposing on them certain requirements that are more burdensome than those that apply to wholly Chinese-owned enterprises. These requirements relate to operating terms, pre-establishment legal compliance, examination and approval process, and decision-making criteria;

- prohibit foreign-invested enterprises, but not wholly Chinese-owned enterprises, from engaging in the electronic distribution of sound recordings, e.g. through the Internet and mobile telecommunications networks.

(c) Chinese measures that allegedly do not provide national treatment for imported reading materials, sounds recordings intended for electronic distribution, and films for theatrical release. More specifically, the United States is challenging Chinese measures that allegedly:

- restrict distribution channels for certain imported reading materials by requiring their distribution to be conducted exclusively through subscription, by Chinese wholly state-owned enterprises, and only to subscribers that have been examined and approved by the Chinese government; unlike the situation for similar domestic reading materials;

- limit the distribution of certain imported reading materials (which can be distributed other than through subscription) to wholly Chinese-owned enterprises, while the distribution of similar domestic reading materials can be effected by other types of enterprises, including foreign-invested ones;

- discriminate against imported sound recordings intended for electronic distribution by subjecting them to more burdensome content review regimes than similar domestic products;

- discriminate against imported films for theatrical release by limiting their distribution to two state-owned enterprises, while similar domestic products can be distributed by any distributor operating in China.

WT/DS363/R Page 4

B. TRANSLATION OF CHINA'S MEASURES

2.4 Regarding China's measures at issue, the United States put forward its translations of the measures into English as part of the exhibits it submitted with its first written submission. China also submitted translations of some provisions as part of its exhibits attached to its first written submission.

2.5 At the second substantive meeting with the parties, the Panel identified a variety of provisions where the parties had provided different translations of China's measures or disputed the meaning of particular terms. The Panel requested the parties to attempt to bilaterally agree on a single translation of the provisions, and to provide, should the parties not be able to agree on the translation of all provisions, a joint suggestion as to the procedures that could be used to arrive at a single definitive translation of these provisions.

2.6 On 9 and 20 October 2008, the parties jointly communicated to the Panel that they had resolved a number of the translation differences by either agreeing on a translation or by agreeing that the differences in translation were not significant and therefore suggesting that the Panel might choose either one for the purpose of its work. With regard to the translation differences that could not be agreed, the parties jointly suggested, on 20 October 2008, that each party provide the Panel with a concise rationale explaining its views on each translation difference and that the Panel then seek translation of the outstanding provisions from an independent source.

2.7 On 22 October 2008, the Panel proposed to approach the United Nations Office at Geneva (UNOG) to assess its availability to serve as an independent translator in this dispute.10 This course of action was agreed to by the parties. On 14 November 2008, the Panel informed the parties that, due to current workload and resource constraints, UNOG would be unable to finalize the translations in the near future. On 20 November 2008, the US expressed concerns regarding delays to the Panel's work that might result from the use of translation services provided by UNOG. Should UNOG be unable to provide a revised, shorter timeframe, the US proposed that a private translation company be contracted to perform the relevant translations. On 24 November 2008, China expressed concerns with respect to the alternative put forward by the US.

2.8 On 12 December 2008, the Panel informed the parties that the United Nations Office at Nairobi (UNON) was able and willing to undertake the assignment sooner than UNOG. The Panel suggested that this avenue be pursued, and the parties did not object. On 19 December 2008, the Panel asked the translation services of UNON to provide the relevant translations.

2.9 The Panel and the parties received the translations from UNON on 10 February 2009. The parties then provided comments on the translations performed by UNON, and subsequently commented on each others' comments. Throughout this Report, the Panel will refer to UNON as the P