Regina v. DUFFY Exhibit 1B, Tab 4

8/9/2019 Regina v. DUFFY Exhibit 1B, Tab 4

1/12

Prr

1 when

completed

'''\I

O f

E C O ~ O R Y

Senutvrs ·l.ivmg

Expens

es

1/te

f\

1110

11af

C

apiwf

Region

(

vC

R)

Pcriod coveredrrom Apri l l ,2 011 to March 3 1, 20 12

~ t v 3 0

Z 11

PRIMARY R

ES

fD

ENCF.

I.

the Honourable

l

- - - _ _ . . .

: V ~ . - f '

. . . 6 , . - , _ _ _ , member of the Senate for the province

Or territOI) of _

~ r ~ -

- - - - - - -

- - - - - - declare thal

0

My prim

ary

rc

si

cl

em·e is

i thin 100

kilome

tr

es fro m Pa rlia

mrnt llill.

0 My prirn11ry residence is more than 100 kilometres fro m

ra r

liament Hill.

Fo r the purposi.: of 1he

Twemy-Seco

11d Repor1 of

1'1c Sw

11d

/

g Se1101e Co ee on

111

e

rnal F co

vmy, B

ud

gets

and

Ad

s1ra 011, adopted in the Senate on June 18, 1998, 1hc address ofmy primary r e s i d ~ n c e in the province

or

1erri1ory

th3l

I represent is the

foll

owing:

.

Address:

l nil #:

Cit) :

rO\

in« :

k

Pos t

RI

Co de:

CE IN

THE

NCR

(10 be f//Jed o

nl

y by s

mulors wl1os

e primory residen

ce Is

more 1J1an

/()()kilometres rom P11rlia1n1m1 Hill

A.

0 I

do n

or

own or ren t

:1

secondary residence in the 'C R

A St•

nat

or h o ~ a

secondary residence

In

the

NCR w

ill be re

im

bursed 11 Oat

r:i

le,

as

dclermhm l by the

S/fmdlng Co nrm/l/ee on Infernal £co11onry, 8 1 1 d 1 1 u11d Allministralio11,

for each day such residence

is

s•·ailable

fo

r the enalor's occupancy, and providinJt that during such time it is not rented to another pt'rson

or c laimet llS< by

another

St

na1or. The

lbllowlni:

cundJlloos

apply:

Onl y on<

claim

per da ) for

accommodation

cosu nia} be

made

for that dwellmg, and

rl1c enator m ~ t s

ubmn

a proofofo\\11en.

h1p

o11 a r l ~ basis

li

roofanached

jSi:t I

O\\

n a secondRry· re' idrnn·

in

thr NCR

ll

nd meet the

b o H ~

conditions

C. .\ Se

nat

or

who

~ o r t 1ll

accommodations in lhc

l\Cf{ wi ll be

re.imburSed long h

ru

nds for its

monthly

CO)IS

remain ava ilable

fo

r t his purpose.

The

followl ni: conditions apply:

l he

Senator

musl

submit

a cop) of

he

lease

ugR-emcnl

and

proof

or

payment,

0

Lea

se

aua

ch

cd

l hc l i : s ~ o r

is

not a "

famil

y member

.

as defined in 1

he Se

11t1tq Adminis1ra1in > Rules,

Enteri

ng into the

l e ; i ~ e

will

no

t

further

the pnvnte

11tt

crcsts of the Senator or

1ho

sc or his or

her

" li11111ly member"· and

No Senator or Ins or

her

"famil y member" shal l have 1nten:st ma panner

sh1p

or

pri vate

corporation

1hal

1s a

pal1)

to such lease

under

which

the

panncrsh1p or

corporation receives

a benefit

.Rw. 0 I r ~ n t

a

~ e c o n d a l ' )

rnidcnct•

in

the \(.'R 11nd

meet the

abo,

•e conditions.

Ad

dr

ess:

l 'nit #:

C ity:

Pos1al Cod&/< >ff

La.ndlord:

(l/ ppltcabl

e)

SENATOR'S

OF.

Ct ARATION

I declare that

1h

c in fonna1ion pro vided above

1s

acc urate

as

or

th e

date

or

this declarauon a

nd Ihat a

ll re

cei

pts or

reimbursement r

i :qucst:.

arc compliant with the

Sena1

e

Ad

is1

u

1v11 I

and cnatc polic1cs and

guidelines.

I will advise

he F'

unediately

of

cl ·

t

n

f5U;f.'f2 I

Ou ·

Date· - - -

Signature

Su\>

11

duly

comptctcd lorm

10 l'm

ance and Procur.:menl

Ducc1o

roie

.

rt

g

1n S1ree1

, 11

lh

O

oor

. Onawa. Onrnno. i

I

AOA4


2/12

Lagace France

From:

[email protected]

Sent:

:

Thursday, May 26, 2011 :09 AM

Lagace, France

Subject:

Mike Duffy s Ottawa taxes

France:

This

is what I see

on my

bank account. I called the city and they say they send a written bill

in

July.

owever

because this is urgent, they will put

in

a special order and I should have a copy within a

couple

of

weeks_Barring a postal strike etc. As I mentioned

in

my phone message, lwill hold onto

the written bill, and send it

to

you. This is not going to be fast as I am usually in PEI

in

July, but you

will receive i t eventually. -Mike

PROPERTY

TAX

May

16

2

ll -CITY OF OTTAWA

HYDRO BILL

PMT

May

16• 2

l

I

-HYDRO OTTAWA

UTILITY BILL PMT

May

16

• ZOll

_OTTAWA WATER

478.00

97.50

63 02

1


3/12

l [

FIN NCI L O I R E T ~ R A T E


4/12

TAX BILL I

RELEVE D'

IMPOSITION

f Ottawa Revenue Bran

ch

tion des recettes Ville d'Ottawa

\Tel: 61 3-580-2444 Fax\Telecopieur: 613-580-2457

: 613-580-2401 ATS: 613-580-2401

I DATE DE FACTUR AT ION

JUN

/

JUIN

09 , 2011

ROLL NUl,'IBER I NUMERO DU ROLE

061 4.300.811.42805.0000

11

11

11

1

111 0 1 11111

111111

11111111w1 11 11

11

1m

1

1

DUFFY MICHAEL

DUFFY

HEA

TH

ER

FTP 291 5

PROP ERTY INFORMATION / INFORMATIONS FONCIERES

D

UFFY MIC

H

AE

L

4 7 MORENZ T

ERR

KAN A

TA ON K2K 3H2

DUFFY HEA

TH

ER

47 M

ORE

NZ T ERR

PLAN

4M65

1

PT BLK

127 RP

4R1 8263 PART 1 1/94TH INT

4R1

5507

PARTS 1AND

35

TO 40

IRREG 2854.18SF 29 .00FR 98.4

SSESSMENT/EvALUATION

MUNICIPAL I MUN ICIP

AL

E

- .r < ..

1•

EDUCATION I SCOLAIRE

ax Class I

Value I

Municipal Levies

Tax Rat

e%

Amount

Tax Ra

te%

Amount

rie d'imp0ts

Valeur

Prelevements Muni

ci

pal Taux d'imposltlon

%

Montant

Taux d'imposition %

Montant

384 ,500 CITYWIDE I VILLE ENTIERE

.562050

2,

161

.08

.231000

888.20

T

384

,500

TRANSIT/TRANSP. URS.

.178706

687.

12

384 .500 OTTAWA POLICE D'OTTAWA

.166392

639.78

F

SU

384.500

FIRE/INCENDIE SERV

.092515 355.

72

AL

384

,500 CONS AUTHORITY/AUT DE CONSERV

.006848

26.33

u

DIRECTION DES FINANCES

THE

S E ~ A T E

SEP

0 9 Z 11

LE

S ~ N A T

FINANCIAL

OIRt:CTORATE

I

Munic ipal Levy

3,870.03

Education L

evy

888.20

UX PARTIELS:

lm

pota m

unlcipa

ux

lmp

ota acolairea

SPECIAL CHAAGES CREDITS

.

-

.,

r

SUMMARY

-

fA 6 IS SPECIAUX I CREDITS SOMMAIRE

- SOLID WASTE CURBSIDE SERVI

CE

91 .00

Tax Levy

Su

b-total ( Municip

al+

Education)

4,758.23

HETS • BORDURE DE RUE

Total partlel des impots (municipaux + scolaires)

/UNITES 1@ 91.00

Special Charges /.Credits

91

.00

Frais speciaux

I

Credits

2011

Tax Cap Adjustment

0.00

Redressement d'imp6t de 2011 selon le plafonnement

Final

201

1 Taxes

4,849.23

imp6ts totaux de 2011

Less Interim Biii ing

Moins facturation interimaire

- 2,390.09

Past Due/Credit (as of JUN 09, 2011 )

- 477.91

Arrerages I Credit (au JUN 09, 2011)

:

91.

00

Account Balance I Solde du Compte:

1 981 .

23

E M E N ONLY I ET I.T DE COMPTE SEULEMENT

STA

TE

MJ:N

T ON

LY

/ t;TAT DE


5/12

LA DIRECTION

DES

FINANC

T H

E ~ -

T ~

CHEDULE2/ANNEXE2

EXPLANATION OF TAX CHANGES

I

EXPLICATION DES MODIFICATIONS D'IMP TS

2010 to

2011/de2010 a

2011

Property Class(es) I Cat6gorie(s) de blens:

Residential

R ~ s i d e n t i e l

Assessment Roll No / Numero du r61e 0614.300.811.42805.0000

S P

0 9 2011

Munlcipa ty I u n l c l ~ c:

N

T

CITY OF OTTAW

f l

/ l l i J E . l ( j ( J t f ~

T

OWNER(S) INFORMATION OU PROPRIETAIRE(S) PROPERTY INFORMATION/ INFORMATIONS FONCIERES

DUFFY

MICHAEL 47 MORENZ TERR

DUFFY HEATHER PLAN

4M651

PT BLK 127

RP

4R18263

PAR

T 1 1/94TH INT

Final 2010 Levies/ lmpc ts d6fln1Ufs de 2010 Final 2011

Levies/

lmp6ts deflnitlfs

de

2011

4,691

.18

4,758.

23

Total Year

over

Year Change I Modification totale d'une

ann•e

6

rautre

$67.05

EXPLANATION OF TAX CHANGES I EXPLICATION DES MODIFICATIONS O'IMPQTS

Final 2010

Levies/

lmp0ts definitifs de 2010

'2010

Annualized Taxes •1mp0ts annualises de 2010

2011

Local Municipal Levy Change

I

Modification des imp6ts locaux de 2011

2011 Provincial Education Levy Change I Modification des lmpOts scolaires provinciaux de 2011

Reassessment and/or Policy Changes I Changements • Reevalualion

eVou

decision strategiques

°Final 2011 Levies

I ..

mpots definilifs

de

2011

4,691.18

4,691.18

87.42

.00

·20.37

4.758.23

•An annualized tax figure i s used in this analysis to compensate for mid-year adjustments

in

lax treatment

or

assessment value.

II a property did not have any mid-year adjustments, the annualized taxes should equal the Rnal levies listed above.

··Final levy amount applies only to the property or portlon(s) of property referred to in this notice and may not Include some special

charges and credit amounts.

•Les impOts annualises servant ici a compenser les redressements en matiere d'lmposition ou d'evaluatlon qui ont ete apportes au

milieu de l'annee. SI un blen n'a pas felt l'objet d'un tel redressement, les impOts annualises devraient correspondre aux imp6ts

definiUfs

lnd

l

qulls

ci·dessus

Ce chiffre ne s'applique qu au bien

ou

a toute partie

de

celui-ci mentionne dens le present avis et ii

se

peut qu11

ne

comprenne

pas certains frais speciaux ou certalns credits.

Tax

Distribution by

Services

I

Distribution des taxes

par services

(See enclosed

Insert

I voir

piece jointe)

Provincial du

catio

n

Provincial

Mandated

Programs

Conservation Authorities

Transit & Para-Transpo

Police

Capital Financing

Roads & Traffic

Fire

General

Administration

Parks/Recreation/Culture

Garbage/Recycling•

Library

Paramedics

Planning/Economic Dev/Environment

TOTAL TAXES •

• Includes special charges

for solid

waste

TT-PTP-LETTER-03-2009

Amount/Montant

%

888.20 18.32%

533.79 11.01%

26.

.54%

$687.12 14 .17%

$639.78 13.19

$445.61 9.

19

$389.21 8.

03

$355.72 7.34

$305.57 6.28

$242.91 5.01

$145.46 3.00%

$92.93 1.92

$80.82 1

.67

$15.78 .33

duca

tion

provlncl

ale

Programme

s

pr

ovinciaux

obllgatoires

Office e protection de la nature

Tran

sport en commun et

Para-

Transpo

Police

Financement d'immobilisatlons

Routes

et

circulation

lncendies

Administration

generale

Parcs/Loisirs/Culture

Dechets/Recyclage•

B

ibliotheque

Services

paramedics

Urbanisme/Devel.

economique/Environnemen

$4,849.23

100.00% TOTAUX DES TAXES*

' = ~ ~

•

lnclus

les frais speciaux pour dechets

TB.FNL.PTP.MON.NONCAP.V

To

all

subscribers

to the

PTP

Plan:


6/12

WATER & SEWER

BIL

L

P.O. Box 3438, Sta,

J

on WA

ON

K1 p

6M9

FACTURE DES SERVICES

O'EAU ET O'EGOUT

C.P. 3438, succursale D

onAWA ON

K1 p

6M9

WBPC

l• lllllll

U

lll

l •llE

02041

DUFFY MICHAEL

&

DUFFY HEATHER

47 MORENZ TERR

KANATA ON K2K 3H2

il Deta il

T55 L)

revious Amount Owing Montant precedent

du

Debit Prelevement au tomatique 20 11/01 /

17

Charge

Redevance

d'eau: 15

m3

x 1.276

Surcharge Surtaxe d'egout: $1

9.14

x 116%

Supply Approvis ionnement pour incendies: 61 days/ jours@ $0.0869

Contact Us Contactez-nous

_

mai

l /Courriel : [email protected]

Telephone Telephone: 613-580-2444

Fax Telecopi

eur:

613-580-2457

TTY ATS: 613-580-2401

Billing code Code de facturation

B0225-0204

Estimate Estimee B

Service Address Adresse de service

47 MORENZ T

ERR

KANATA ON

K2K

3H2

Account Number Numero de compte

1002-0290-02

Billing Period Penode de facturation

from du to / a

2010/12/16 2011 /02/15

All dates are Year-Month-Day Format de la date . annee-mois

Amount Monlanl

74.03

-74.03

0.00

19.14

22 .20

5.30

are a pre-authorized debit customer. The Amount D

ue

will

be

withdrawn from

account on the Due Date shown. Paiement par prelevement automatique.

Montant du est automatiquement preleve

de

votre

compte

en banque a a date d echeance indiquee.

Consumption History I Historique de la consommatlon Meter Reading / Lecture du compteur

AMOUNT DUE

Service Date I

Read Type

Days Billed Consumption m • ~ Dally (m?i

Present

I

Previous

1

Consumption (mJ

Date du service Type de releve

I

Jours factures

I

Consommation (m

I

Quotidenne rn>)

Actuel

Prec8dent Consommation ( )

MONTANTOO

2011 /02/15 ESTIMATE EE 61 15 0.2 1557 1542 15

$46.64

2010/12/16 ACTUAL / REEL

59 25 0.4

2010110/18 ESTIMATE EE

61 4

0.6

DUE DATE

2010/08/18 ACTUAL / REEL 57 43

0.8

DATE D'ECHEANCE

2010/06/22 ESTIMATE

EE

61

70

1.1

2010/04/

22

ACTUAL / REEL

65 15 0.2

2010/02/16 ESTIMATE EE 63 16

0.3

Water and Sewer Account Fee Schedule Bareme des frais des compte d'eau et d'egouts

New

Account Nouveau compte 64.00 Returned Items

f

Effets retournes

Duplicate Bill / Double de la facture 32.00 ReminderNotice f Rappel de paiement en retard

Transfer to Tax Transfert au compte de taxes 32.00 Payment Distribution Repartition des paiements

Message: Fraud and Waste Hotline - Ligne directe de fraude et d'abus, 1-866-959-9309 www.ottawa.fraudwaste-fraudeabus .ca

2011 /

03

/

16

39.00

6.15

31.00

ETAIN THIS PORTION FOR YOUR RECORDS.

ARDEZ CETTE PARTIE POUR VOS DOSSIERS.

Page Number Nombre(s) de page

1 of 1

SEE REVERSE SIDE FOR MORE INFORMATI

VOIR

AU

VERSO POUR PLUS D' INFORMATI

H20 -INV (2010 -12- 13)


7/12

To:

CC:

From:

Dote:

Re

:

SENAT

emorandum

France Lagace

Mary

McQuaid

Mike

Duffy

20

May

2011

Ottawa residence

LA DIRECTION DES

FINANCES

THE SENATE

J u ~

13

1 11

LE SENAT

FINANCIAL DIREC

TORATE

As we dscussed this afternoon,we don t receive ~ tax bil

from

the

City

ofOttawa. As

pat

of their

geen

plm, Ottawa askspeople to pay their taxes electronicaly.Therefore we

don t get ~ nvoice.

When this

cane

1.4' last yea, I

called the

City id was

told

they o u l d ~ ~

doct.lment

for

a

fee of 30.00 aid scid it

would take to 8 weeks.

Our

home for the

past7yeas

slocatedat 7

orenz

Terrace, (Kmata)

K2K3H2

While the City

doesn

t

send

out paper

tax

bills, Ottawa Sewer and Water, and

Ottawa

Hydro send

lots

of

paper. I have enclosed two

of

their recent

invoices

made

out to

us

at ou r nata

add

ress as p roo f of our ownership.


8/12

SE

NAT

E S

EN T

C N D

L DIRE -.CES

emorandum

i .itJ 3 0

2 11

s we discussed this afternoon.we don't receive a paper tax bill from the City

of

Ottawa. As

part

of

their green plan, Ottawa asks people

to

p y their taxes electronical ly. Therefore we

don

't get a

paper

nvoice.

When this came

up

last year, I called the Cityand was told they could supply a paper

document for a fee of 30.00 and said It would take to 8 weeks.

Our home for the past 7 years is located at 47 MorenzTerrace, (Kanata) K2K

3H2

.

While the

City

doesn' t

send out paper tax

bills, Ottawa Sewer and Water,

and

Ottawa Hydro

send lots of

paper

. I

have

enclosed

two

of

their recent

invoices made

out to us at our Kanata address as

proof

of our ownership.


9/12

Account

Su

mmary •

S o m ' ~ i r e

de compte

Page

1 of/de 1

~ ~ a

Questions/Questions: 613-

738·6400

Power

Outage/Panne d'electricite :

613-738-0188

Service

For•

Service pour

47 MORENZ TERR

Account Number• Numero de compte

16867430004572026000

Meter Number• Numero de compteur

OTT657696

Account History

I Releve

de

compte

Date kWh

#

Days kWh/Day

du releve kWh # jours kWh/jour

- 03 - 31

2136

57 37 . 47

-

0?-07 14 '>0

63 ?3 . 01

-

12

- 01 1179 ?O . 3"1

10- 01 1529 60 2$ . 49

770 63

28 . 10

57 21 . 37

- 0

4- 01

1'.>32 64

r Reading

de

compteur

Consumption

en

kWh

40886

2065

.00

..ous Balance/Seide precedent

PaymenVPaiement

PaymenVPaiement

Electrici

ty

ChargelFrais d'electricite Winter/H

iver

From/Du 2011

-02

-02 To Au 2011-03-31 (57 Days/Jours)

2,000 kWh @ 0.0641kWh

136.04 kWh@$0.074/kWh

HST No. 863391363/No. TVH 863391363

Ontario Clean Energy Benefit/La Prestation ont. pour l'energie propre (-10%)

From Du 2011-02-02 To Au 20

11 -03·31

(57 Days Jours)

Delivery Frais de livraison

Regulatory Charges Frais reg lementes

Debt Retirement Charge/Reglement de la dette

HST No. 863391363 /No. TVH 863391363

Ontario Cl

ean

Energy BenefiVLa Prestation ont. pour l'energie propre (-10%)

·

usted

Consumption

Current Charges/Frais courants

2136.04 .

rajostee

Account Balance/Etat de compte

$175.94

$97.50

$97.50

$128.00

$10.07

$17.95

$15.60

$86.65

$15.18

$14.33

$15.10

$13.13

$258.55

$239.49

$195.

00

For your informa

ti

on • Au tres renseignements

The Ontario Government

has

taken

10%

off your electricity bill to

help

you with

the costs of

building a

clean

energy future. Learn

about the new Ontario

Clean

Energy Benefit: ontario.ca/energyplan or 1-888-668-4636.

Le

gouvemement

ontarien a allege votre facture d'electricite de 10

%

pour vous alder

acomposer

avec le

cout

superieur de l'energie

propre

. Plus sur la

Prestation

ontarienne

pour

l'energie propre : ontario.ca/planenergetique

ou

1 888 668-4636.

Hydro Ottawa offers

you a convenient way

to

pay your bill. Visit our

website

or

contact

us by

telephone for information about

pre-authorized

payments.

Hydro

Ottawa vous propose un mode de paiement pratique. Visitez notre site Internet

ou

communiquez avec nous par telephone afin

d'obtenir davantage de renseignements a propos des paiements automatiques.

Additional information

on

reverse. Please retain this portion. • Information

supp

lementaire

au

verso. Priere

de

conserver cette pertie.

• y ro

ttawa

c/o

PO

Box

4483

/ CP

4483

a/s de Station A

Toronto, ON

M5W5Z1

Tel./ Tel.: 613·738-6400

Fax . Tele c. : 613·738·6403

www

.

hydroottawa

.com

Service For • Service pour

47 MORENZ TERR

Account Number • Numero de compte

16867430004572026000

Due Date

15th

of

each month

Date d'echeance

IP 1


10/12

Pt d when

completed

DECLARA

TIO'I

OF

PRl\f AR\

0 SECO OA

R \

I O f . ' i ~

Senators' living Expenses m tile \ a11unol Cup11al

R«?:ton

(VCR)

Period co,·ered

from

April I

,

20 11 to 1\larch 31. 2012

PRJMA RY RES IDENCE

I, the Honourable

h

{

h

C,

R

J

_b

{ . , '

.

member of the Senate for the province

ortcrrilory of :J· n £ Ed .vr .. c\

{


11/12

WATFR

&

SEWFR

BILi

FACTURF DES

SERVICES

D'EAU n

O' fGO

l lT

Con l ;id IJ:<

I Contac

tc1 ruiuc;

na il /C ournel . revenue@o \lawa ea

l n t ~ p h o n c r

fclephone : 613-580

-2

444

f ' ( )

f ~ l l X

;'\J\;'lf\ ' j l t

(JI

IAW/\llN k PhM'l

(, r 14 I \

~ 1 1 c . c ,

. ' . . l I

on

\WI\ ( \N

I\

II'

t.M«J

wsPc u

02037

DUFrY

MI

CH

AEL

&

DUFFY

Ht:A

1H

f1R

47 MO

REN

Z TERR

KAN/\ [A ON K2K

3H2

....____---

06tall

T55

(E)

Previous Amount Owinq

I

Montant precedent dO

Pre Authori7ed Debit

I Pr

elevement

automa

tique 2011/03/ 16

Sub-To tal I Sous total

Water

Charqe

I

Redevance d'eau

21

m3 x

1.276

Sewer Surcharqe

I

Surtaxe

d'eQ

out

$26

80 x

116

%

Fax I Tetecnp1eur : 61 3-580-24

57

TT

Y

I

ATS : 613-580-2401

BtlhntJ

01dc• I Cnrh• d l.1n11mtron

47 MORE

N7

TFRR

KANA1A ON

1

2K 3H2

f r.n1111I N11111i M I I N11mNr1 11> complP.

1002

0290

-02

v >

Htl

hnq

1>1moct

I

Pllnode

de

1ac1ura11

0.2

Me

ter

Re;idrng /

l.cct

11ro

du complou

r

1

1

ro..e11t I

t"'v1 :

0111

ll20.tNV ( '>

011

l 1

>

13)

1

or

1

11.intl mt11r11 11u:. :


12/12

CANADA

emorandum

To

:

France

Lagace

Mary McQuaid

From :

Mike

Duffy

Date:

20 May 2011

Re

:

Ottawa

residence

s we

discussed this afternoon,

we

don't receive a paper

ax

bill from

the

City

of

Ottawa.

s

part

of

their green plan, Ottawa asks people to pay heir taxes electronically. Therefore we

don't get a paper nvoice.

When this

came

up last

yea

r, I called

the

City

and

was told

the

y could supply a

paper

document or a fee

of

$30.00

and

said it would take 6 to 8 weeks.

Our home for the past 7 years Is located at 47 Morenz Terrace, (Kanato) K2K 3H2

While the City

doesn

' t

send

out paper

tax

bills,

Ottawa

Sewer and Water,

and

Ottawa

Hy

dro send

lots of paper. I

have enclosed two

of

their recent invoices

made

out to

us at

our Kanata addre

ss as

proof of our

ownership.

Documents

Regina v. DUFFY Exhibit 1B, Tab 4