Reducing Risk:

Sustainability in theThird World

Session 40

Session 40 2

Session Objectives

Understand the impacts of disasters on developing countries and how these impacts also affect the U.S.

Understand the relationships between poverty and sustainability

Understand effects of international development and debt management programs on disaster vulnerability

Understand critiques of international development programs

Be able to place Third World risk reduction strategies in the context of an understanding of international development efforts

Session 40 3

Impact of Disasters on Developing Countries

Most deaths from disasters triggered by extreme events take place in the Third World

Most human lives lost in disasters are those of people living in Third World countries of Asia, Latin America, and Africa

The cost of these disasters is less in absolute dollar terms than in industrialized countries, but are large in relation to the size of their respective economies and set back development efforts

Session 40 4

Why Should the U.S. be Concerned with Reducing Risk in the Third World? Moral reasons

– Concern with saving lives

– Others are more likely to assist the U.S. if it assists others

Political reasons– Some of the countries are allies,

or are important to allies

– Sometimes there are international treaty obligations

– U.S. is concerned with regional security

– Large number of U.S. citizens with families live in many of the countries

– Citizen groups concerned with foreign interests in the U.S. constitute voting blocks

Economic reasons– U.S. corporations may have

facilities in the affected countries– U.S. may import an important or

strategic commodity from the affected country

– U.S. banks may have outstanding loans to business or governments entities in the affected countries

– U.S. engineering and other companies may find lucrative contracts in the process of recovery

Scientific reasons– Helps scientists understand how

to protect the U.S. from these kinds of extreme events

– The study of disasters helps protect the U.S. population

Session 40 5

Economic Effects of Disasters

Lower, and more erratic, yields of crops Lower weight gain by livestock Distress sales during bad years mean lower prices Economic distress means indebtedness at high

interest rates and potentially loss of land Little money for education of children Poor diet and health care Under nutrition and poor health reduce working

capacity More labor time (usually female) spent seeking water

and fuel Fewer environmental amenities and goods with which

to provide supplementary, non-farm income

Session 40 6

Health and Welfare Effects of Disasters

Disease transmission– Degraded or marginal

environment may harbor insect vectors of disease

– Isolated forest margin residence can expose humans to virulent retroviruses

– Lack of water can expose people to disease

– Exposure to unprotected sources of surface water can expose humans to disease

– Dust storms and low humidity is associated with spread of meningitis

Disease increases poverty, by:– Reducing the ability work– Increasing the amount of

money used for health care and funeral expenses

– Diverting labor time to care for the ill and disabled

– Encouraging frequent pregnancies to make up for high infant and child mortality, diverting women’s labor time from production and depleting their energy

Session 40 7

Poverty Decreases Sustainability Through Technology

Overuse of land reduces natural fertility Overuse of limited pasture allows erosion Limited land and pasture make it difficult to set aside land

as fallow Clearing of steeper slopes for farming or grazing allows

water erosion Reliance on limited wood fuel resources accelerates

deforestation Production of charcoal for urban markets accelerates

deforestation Inability to use production technologies that abate pollution Inability to afford disposal of solid wastes from production

Session 40 8

Poverty Decreases Sustainability Through Economics

Inability to afford more concentrated energy forms results in the poor using less dense, less efficient forms

Reliant on short-term crops for ready cash, farmers cannot afford to plant tree crops that would anchor the soil

Poor farmers lack investment of money or labor in soil conservation works

Poor herders cannot afford fencing to allow rotational grazing or improved seed for pasture improvement

Session 40 9

Placing Third World Risk Reduction Strategies in Context of International Development Efforts

Internal contradiction with large development agencies: some encouraging risk reduction, others encouraging investments which increase risk

Little connection between disaster risk reduction and “business as usual” development activities– “Normalizing” disasters make it hard to build into

development activities that kinds of projects that reduce risk

– “Complex humanitarian crises” drain away aid money from BOTH ‘normal’ development AND disaster prevention