Upload
ananth-shandilya
View
188
Download
7
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Promotion of Benchmarking Tools for Energy Conservation in Energy Intensive Industries in China
Pulp and Paper
A reference book for the Industry
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
1
Imprint
Contract: Promotion of Benchmarking Tools for Energy Conservation in Energy Intensive Industries in China
Contract No.: EuropeAid/123870/D/SER/CN
Contractor: The Administrative Centre for China’s Agenda 21 (ACCA21)
Room 609, No. 8 Yuyuantan South Road, Haidian District, Beijing, P.R. China, Postal Code: 100038
Partners: CENTRIC AUSTRIA INTERNATIONAL (CAI)
Beijing Energy Conservation & Environment Protection Center (BEEC)
Disclaimer
This publication has been produced within the frame of the EU-China Energy and
Environment Programme project “Promotion of Benchmarking Tools for Energy
Conservation in Energy Intensive Industries in China”. The EU-China Energy and
Environment Programme (EEP) was established to correspond to the policies of the
Chinese Government and the European Commission to strengthen the EU-China co-
operation in the area of energy. The project was formally started on the 1. September
2008. The total duration is 12 months. The contents of this publication are the sole
responsibility of the project team and can in no way be taken to reflect the views of
the European Union.
Beijing, 2009
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
2
Table of Contents
Summary and Acknowledgments.............................................................................. 4
1 Introduction ............................................................................................................ 6
1.1 Pulp and Paper ............................................................................................. 6
1.2 History of papermaking................................................................................ 7
1.3 Worldwide production - reference to China ......................................... 11
1.4 Pulp and paper manufacturing - Overview........................................... 12
1.5 Categories of pulp and paper mills......................................................... 13
2 Non-wood pulping .............................................................................................. 15
2.1 Non-wood materials and processes........................................................ 15
2.2 International best practice ....................................................................... 17
2.3 Energy use and energy benchmarks ...................................................... 18
2.4 Energy saving measures ............................................................................ 18
3 Kraft pulping ......................................................................................................... 19
3.1 Process flow.................................................................................................. 19
3.2 Consumptions and emissions.................................................................... 22
3.3 Energy use and energy benchmarks ...................................................... 23
3.4 Energy saving measures ............................................................................ 24
4 Sulfite pulping ....................................................................................................... 27
4.1 Processes ...................................................................................................... 27
4.2 Consumptions and emissions.................................................................... 29
4.3 Energy use and energy benchmarks ...................................................... 30
4.4 Energy saving measures ............................................................................ 31
5 Mechanical pulping............................................................................................ 32
5.1 Processes ...................................................................................................... 32
5.2 Energy use and energy benchmarks ...................................................... 33
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
3
5.3 Energy saving measures ............................................................................ 34
6 Recycled fibre mills.............................................................................................. 36
6.1 Processes ...................................................................................................... 36
6.2 Energy use and energy benchmarks ...................................................... 39
6.3 Energy saving measures ............................................................................ 40
7 Papermaking ........................................................................................................ 41
7.1 Processes - Overview.................................................................................. 41
7.2 Stock preparation ....................................................................................... 42
7.3 Paper Machine............................................................................................ 43
7.4 Energy use and energy benchmarks ...................................................... 47
7.5 Energy saving measures ............................................................................ 49
8 Integrated pulp and paper mills ....................................................................... 53
8.1 Processes ...................................................................................................... 53
8.2 Energy use and energy benchmarks ...................................................... 53
8.3 Energy saving measures ............................................................................ 53
9 Worldbest practice and energy benchmarks................................................ 54
10 Model case benchmarks............................................................................... 57
11 References and Links...................................................................................... 59
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
4
Summary and Acknowledgments
This reference book for the pulp and paper industry is a compilation of best available
technologies methodologies and future development in this industry. A very useful
source for this work was the “Reference Document on Best Available Techniques in
the Pulp and Paper Industries (BREF)” published by the Integrated Pollution
Prevention and Control (IPPC) Board of the European Commission (2001). Particular
reference is also made to the model case study on “Energy and Cost Reduction in
the Pulp and Paper industry – A Benchmarking Perspective (2002)”. Done by the
Pulp and Paper Technical Association of Canada, which is one of the leading
institutes for this sector. These documents and a number of further links can be
downloaded from the internet for free (see references and links).
As part of the BMT-Tool set (BMT = Benchmarking – Monitoring – Targeting) this
reference book provides sector specific information regarding the pulp and paper
industry in general, frequently used technologies, energy consumption of key
processes and other relevant aspects connected with the energy and environment
performance of paper making. Energy benchmarks are discussed as typical ranges
of energy consumption (MJ or kg standard coal) per production unit (ton of pulp or
paper). References are made to world best performances. A larger part of this
reference book is dedicated to describing the ample options for energy improvements
which exist for this industry, even within relatively modern and advanced plants.
The report is divided into a number of Chapters as follows:
• The first chapter provides an overview of pulp and paper production worldwide
and the increasing dominant role of China in this context; to enhance the readers
background a historical discourse of papermaking was inserted.
• The chapters two to eight provide detailed discussions of the frequently used
process lines of pulp and paper making; starting with non-wood pulping as a
special feature to Chinese prospects (chapter 2), followed by several more
conventional technologies of pulping such as Kraft pulping (chapter 3), Sulfite
pulping (chapter 4), Mechanical pulping (chapter 5), Recycled fiber mills (chapter
6); and completed by the distinct process of Paper making in stand-alone paper
mills (chapter 7) and a summary regarding Integrated pulp and paper mills
(chapter 8). Each chapter is structured in a description of the relevant processes,
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
5
and the related use of energy. Where applicable and available energy
benchmarks and energy saving measures are introduced.
• Chapter 9 provides an overview of selected energy intensity values drawn from
worldbest practices.
• Chapter 10 invites to further studying and reading along existing case studies and
a huge amount of references.
• Chapter 11 provides a number of selected links. The later include also
discussions of further important topics, which could not handled within the frame
of this reference book such as papermaking additives and chemicals, water
consumption and saving, and numerous further details to the various production
steps of pulp and paper.
Finally, it has to be noted that this reference book cannot answer all questions
related with energy efficiency/intensity in the pulp and paper industry. In fact, the
paper industry could be generally described as energy intensive. In Europe energy is
the third highest cost in the papermaking process, accounting for approximately 8%
of turnover. This is inconsistent with the fact that less is published on specific energy
requirement on process level than on water management for instance. Therefore, it is
rather difficult to find qualified information on energy consumption related to different
paper grades and product qualities, energy efficient technologies, and energy
practices and usage within the pulp and paper industry.
In many countries, information on energy balances of paper mills is poorly available
in public. Different reporting schemes, if any, for energy consumption are used.
Energy demand also depends on the product quality (especially in tissue mills) and
partly on local conditions. Therefore, it is difficult to present energy consumption
values associated with the use of BAT. The ranges of energy consumption of paper
mills shown in this reference book should only be taken as an indication about the
approximate need of process heat and power at energy efficient paper mills.
As it is in life, also for the pulp and paper industry and the specific operation, the truth
cannot be found in books but only in the practice by doing and self critic. Again it can
be found that besides external benchmarking the internal procedures of monitoring
and targeting are of prior importance. It is hoped that this reference book will be of
some guide towards this prospect.
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
6
1 Introduction
1.1 Pulp and Paper
Papermaking today is a large, capital-intensive industry, characterized by high-speed
machines and complex systems of control for manufacturing to close tolerances
thousands of products vital to education, communications, marketing, packaging,
construction, etc.
The pulp and paper industry comprises manufacturing enterprises that convert
cellulose fibre into a wide variety of pulps, papers and paperboards, such as:
• Newsprint
• Packaging paper boards
• Uncoated printing and writing papers
• Liner and fluting
• Coated printing and writing papers
• Tissue
• Packaging papers
• Speciality papers
Each of these categories demands specific properties of the product and the most
appropriate manufacturing route to these products may differ substantially. For
instance, newsprint is a product required in high volume on a regular basis but is only
required to have moderate strength, opacity, printability and a relatively short life.
Thus a manufacturing route which involves a high yield of pulp at the expense of
maximum achievable strength, brightness and texture can contribute to the efficient
use of raw materials.
In contrast, the critical quality of packaging papers is their strength if they are to be fit
for their intended use. In this case it is necessary to accept a lower yield inherent to a
different manufacturing route in order to achieve this strength. Printing and writing
papers need a different balance of brightness, texture and strength, and some can be
required to last for great many years. Tissue papers are made to have good dry and
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
7
wet strength for their weight and typically will be used once and not re-enter the fibre
cycle.
The raw material comes from wood (up to 95 % in Europe and North America) or
from straw and other plants residues, wastepaper and a very small quantity of linen
and cotton rags. The raw materials, e.g. wood, are reduced to fibre by mechanical
means or by cooking in chemicals. The fibres are then mixed with water, adhering to
one another as the water is removed by pressure and heat. This is the fundamental
principle of papermaking, discovered by the Chinese nearly 2000 years ago and
brought to Spain by the Moors, probably during the 12th century.
1.2 History of papermaking
Paper has a long history, beginning with the ancient Egyptians and continuing to the
present day. For thousands of years, hand-made methods dominated and then,
during the 19th century, paper production became industrialised. Originally intended
purely for writing and printing purposes, a wide variety of paper grades and uses are
now available to the consumer.
Of all the writing and drawing materials that people have employed down the ages
(since 3000 B.C.), paper is the most widely used around the world. Its name derives
from papyrus the material used by the ancient Egyptians, Greeks and Romans.
Papyrus, however, is only one of the predecessors of paper that together are known
by the generic term ‘tapa’ and are mostly made from the inner bark of paper
mulberry, fig and daphne. The fibres normally used for textiles, like flax and hemp,
also served as substitutes for bast. In later times, the fabric was replaced by fine
bamboo sticks, which freed the papermaker of the need to let the paper dry naturally
in the mould, since the poured or ladled sheet could be ‘couched’ off.
In AD 105, the Chinese court official, Ts'ai Lun, invented papermaking from textile
waste using rags. This can be considered as the birth of paper as we know it today.
Later, Chinese papermakers developed a number of specialities such as sized,
coated and dyed paper, and paper protected against ravages by insects, but they
had great problems satisfying the growing demand for paper for governmental
administration. They also used a new fibre-yielding plant - bamboo - which they de-
fibred by cooking in lye.
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
8
Chinese papermaking techniques reached Korea at an early date and were
introduced to Japan in the year 610. In these two countries, paper is still made by
hand on a large scale in the old tradition, preferably from the fresh bast fibres of the
mulberry tree (kozo in Japanese). Following the cooking process, the long, uncut
fibres are merely prepared by beating, which gives the paper its characteristic look
and excellent quality. The latter is due, among other things, to multiple, rapid
immersions of the mould, which results in a multi-layer fibre mat.
Very soon, knowledge of papermaking spread to Central Asia and Tibet and then on
to India. When the Arabs, in the course of their eastern expansion, neared Samarkan
they too became acquainted with the production of paper and paper mills were
subsequently set up in Baghdad, Damascus and Cairo, and later in Morocco, Spain
and Sicily. Owing to the lack of fresh fibres, the raw material used by the Arabs was
made almost entirely from rags: however, their defective and poorly designed
processing equipment (such as breaker mills) produced a rather inferior ground pulp.
But, by using this method, with screens made of reeds, thin sheets were made and
then ‘coated’ with starch paste. This gave Arabian paper its good writing properties
and fine appearance.
The export of Arabian-made paper, along with the secrets of its production, to
Europe, especially to Italy, has been well documented. From the 13th century
onwards, papermakers at two early Italian centres, Fabriano and Amalfi, tried to
improve the Arabian technique. Their efforts focused not on the raw material but on
its preparation and the actual papermaking process was improved. The Italian
papermakers developed: the use of water power; the stamping mill (derived from the
stampers and milling machines used in textile handicrafts); the mould made of wire
mesh (as a result of progress in wire production), which triggered the introduction of
couching on felt; the paper press (screw press) with slides for feeding in the material;
drying the sheets on ropes; dip sizing.
In the course of the rapid expansion of trade in the late Middle Ages, more and more
merchants dealt in the commodity called ‘paper’ that was growing in importance for
public and intellectual life. The Nuremberg councillor Ulmann Stromer (Stromeir)
mulled over the advantages of making his own paper and, with the help of skilled
workers from Italy, transformed the ‘Gleismühle’ by the gates of his home town into a
paper mill. The dates noted in his diary, 24 June 1390 (start of work on the
waterwheel) and 7 and 11 August 1390 (oaths sworn by his Nuremberg foremen),
are the first assured records of papermaking on German soil.
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
9
The advantages of this mill-based papermaking technique, which spread throughout
Europe in the 15th and 16th centuries far outweighed the disadvantage of
considerable outlays of time and capital for building and fitting out with new
machinery and equipment. However, the change in the production process, thanks to
the division of labour, boosted output and improved quality. And it could certainly
generate a profit, as some examples prove. On the other hand, there was a growing
risk of an imbalance between costs and earnings, a state of affairs noted in the
numerous reports of business failures among papermakers.
The tremendous upsurge in papermaking during the Reformation in the 16th century,
coupled with the introduction of printing with movable type, soon led to a serious
shortage of raw materials and to regulations governing the trade in rags. The
systematic search for substitute materials met with little immediate success. In the
early 18th century straw was certainly used as a raw material but failed to make
headway on quality grounds. Only the invention of groundwood pulp by Saxon Keller
(1843) and of chemical pulp (first patented in 1854 by Mellier Watt) solved this
problem.
During the 18th century there had been some concentration of craft activities in large
operations, the ‘manufactories’, which were dependent on skilled papermakers
organised into craft groups. The efforts made to step up production as much as
possible and to have many of the jobs done by machine (partly to get round the
constraining rules of papermakers' craft ‘usages’) culminated in the design and
construction of paper making machines. The initial model was the vat that was used
by J.N.L. Robert, who built the first flat-screen papermaking machine in 1798. This
was further developed in England, mostly by Donking and the Fourdrinier brothers.
Shortly afterwards other types appeared, like the Dickinson’s cylinder machine, and
machines which filled wire moulds transported on an endless chain and couched the
sheets on an continuous felt. Flat screen and cylinder machines, which were first
seen in the 19th century, were continually improved and extended to include a dryer
section. This soon led to a considerable widening of the paper web and to an
increase in production speeds. It also heralded industrialisation.
The history of the paper industry in the 19th and 20th centuries can be broken down
into five partly overlapping periods, each marked by definite trends. In the first stage
(from about 1800 to 1860), all work sequences previously performed by hand were
mechanised. This included the rag preparation, the use of fillers, pulp beating, the
paper machine with its various parts, and the machines required for finishing the
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
10
paper (the headbox, wire section, press section, dryer section, units for reeling,
smoothing and packaging). During the second stage (about 1840 to 1880), efforts
were made to obtain rag substitutes on an industrial scale (groundwood pulp and
chemical pulp) and appropriate industrial plants (groundwood and chemical pulp
mills) were developed. The third stage (1860 to 1950) was marked by the
enlargement of the web width, an increase in working speeds, the introduction of
electric drive and further improvements to various machine parts. Machines designed
specifically for the production of particular paper and board grades (for example the
Yankee cylinder and multi-cylinder machines) were also developed. The web working
width grew from 85 cm (1830) to 770 cm (1930), while production speeds rose from 5
m/min. (1820) to over 500 m/min. (1930). The fourth stage (1950 to 1980), which was
still dependent on the old methods as far as the mechanics were concerned, brought
unprecedented changes in papermaking. Alongside further increases in web width
and working speeds, there was the use of new materials (thermo-mechanical pulp,
deinked recovered paper, new fillers, processed chemicals and dyes), new sheet
forming options (e.g. by twin-wire formers), neutral sizing, greater stress on ecology
(closed loops) and, most of all, automation. The operational impact of these changes
was: specialisation in certain paper types; development of new paper grades (LWC -
lightweight coated paper); corporate mergers; company groups with their own raw
material supply and trading organisations; closure of unprofitable operations. 1980
onwards, the fifth stage leads into the future. The evolution of new sheet-forming
principles (with fluid boundaries between paper and non-woven fabrics) and chemical
pulp processes have been the main process improvements. However, the situation
on the global market (increased demand, above all in the Third World, trends in
chemical pulp prices, problems of location), are again raising capital intensity and
encouraging the formation of big company groups with international operations. At
the same time there are definite opportunities for smaller, local firms satisfying
specific needs.
The new Millennium is dominated by the tremendous progress that has been made in
computer science, thus triggering a complete change in our commercial and private
communication and information behaviour. Does this mean that the paper era will
come to an end? The answer is most definitely "No". Clearly there will be a huge
amount of data being generated electronically, but the issue is how to preserve it.
The difficulties of data storage over a long period of time are well known (for
example, the durability of disks; frequent changes of hard and software, electronic
breakdowns etc.). Once again, paper offers the most convenient and durable storage
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
11
option. The advance in technology will affect only the printing of items like short-lived
handbooks and encyclopaedias. Reading a book will remain a great pleasure into the
future and paper, as a ubiquitous material with its many uses, will continue to play an
influential role. Many artists will continue to express themselves by using this most
versatile material.
1.3 Worldwide production - reference to China
The global pulp and paper industry is dominated by North American (United States,
Canada), northern European (Finland, Sweden) and East Asian countries.
Australasia and Latin America also have significant pulp and paper industries. The
Asian region accounts for around 31% of the world’s consumption of paper. In Asia
Japan is the highest consumer of paper products per capita, followed by Singapore
and Malaysia. But both India and China are expected to be keys in the industry's
growth over the next few years. Accounting for over 50 % of the world’s overall
growth in paper and paperboard production since 1990, China is now the second
largest producer globally, surpassed only by the United States. In 2007 worldwide
paper production was 395 million tons. In this connection the USA was leading,
followed by China, Japan and Germany.
China’s unprecedented economic growth over the last 15 years has led to a sharp
increase in demand for paper and paperboard products. During this period, the
country’s aggregate consumption of paper and paperboard has grown by 9.6 nearly
10 % per year, rising from 14.6 million tonnes in 1990 to 48.0 million tonnes in 2003.
To meet this demand, domestic production of paper and paperboard has grown at a
similar pace, expanding from 13.7 million tonnes in 1990 to 43.0 million tonnes in
2003.
Baseline projections suggest that China’s aggregate demand will grow from 48.0
million tonnes in 2003 to 68.5 million tonnes per year in 2010. With domestic
production projected to reach 62.4 million tonnes per year, China is expected to
dominate global capacity expansion for most major grades. China’s annual demand
for fiber furnish across all grades is projected to rise from 40.2 million tonnes in 2003
to reach 59.6 million tonnes by 2010. Of this, approximately 58 % will come from
recovered paper, 25 % from wood-based pulp, and 17 % from nonwood pulp. This
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
12
rapid growth has far-reaching implications for forest sustainability and rural
livelihoods both within China and throughout the Asia-Pacific region. It will place new
strains on China’s domestic wood supply and may exacerbate forest conversion and
illegal logging in key supplier countries, in addition to providing both threats and
potential income opportunities for smallholder tree growers.
Consequently there is a trend towards the production of homegrown, waste based
material rather than imported virgin fiber kraftliner.
China’s paper industry is already unique in that; it is one of the largest users of non-
wood fibers. In fact, the share of wood fiber used in China has declined since the
1990s to about 7% of the input of the paper production, with recovered paper
representing 36%, and the remaining 57% covered by imported waste paper and
nonwood fiber. In the late 1990s there were over 5,000 pulp and paper mills in China,
of which over 70% used non-wood fibers, mainly straw. Most non-wood fiber mills are
small scale. In 1998 there were only 43 non-wood mills with a capacity exceeding
30000 t/year, and the vast majority produced less than 10000, or even 5000 t/year.
Since 2000, the Chinese government has started to close down the small polluting
and inefficient mills. In recent years modern large-scale paper machines have been
installed in China (e.g. Hebei Norske Skog Long 300,000 t/year plant, Dagang’s
paper machine 3 with a capacity of 1.1 million t/year). Non-wood fibers are expected
to continue to play an important role in China’s future paper industry.
1.4 Pulp and paper manufacturing - Overview
Paper is essentially a sheet of cellulose fibres with a number of added constituents to
affect the quality of the sheet and its fitness for intended end use. The two terms of
paper and board generally refer to the weight of the product sheet (grammage) with
paper ranging up to about 150 g/m2 and a heavier sheet regarded as board
(paperboard).
The pulp for papermaking may be produced from virgin fibre by chemical or
mechanical means or may be produced by the re-pulping of recovered paper (RCF).
In the pulping process the raw cellulose-bearing material is broken down into its
individual fibres. Wood is the main raw material but straw, hemp, grass, cotton and
other cellulose-bearing material can be used. The precise composition of raw
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
13
material will vary according to the type and species but the most important
constituents are cellulose, hemicelluloses and lignin.
Wood naturally contains around 50% water and the solid fraction is typically about
45% cellulose, 25 % hemicelluloses and 25% lignin and 5% other organic and
inorganic materials. In chemical pulping, chemicals are used to dissolve the lignin
and free the fibres. The lignin and many other organic substances are thus put into
solution from which the chemicals and the energy content of the lignin and other
organics may be recovered. The extent of this recovery is dependent upon the
chemical base used and the process configuration. In mechanical pulping processes
mechanical shear forces are used to pull the fibres apart and the majority of the lignin
remains with the fibres although there is still dissolution of some organics.
Pulps produced in different ways have different properties, which make them suited
to particular products. Most pulp is produced for the purpose of subsequent
manufacture of paper or paperboard. Some is destined for other uses such as thick
fibreboard or products manufactured from dissolved cellulose.
Paper produced by the use of recovered paper as fibre source will involve some
cleaning of contaminants prior to use and may involve de-inking depending upon the
quality of material recycled and the requirements of the end product the recycling
process. The fibres are reusable a number of times depending on the quality of the
recycled material and the purpose of the end product. The paper product may also
comprise up to 45% of its weight in fillers, coatings and other substances.
1.5 Categories of pulp and paper mills
As pulp and paper products are highly diverse and applied processes even for one
and the same product may vary greatly, many factors of production technology must
be taken into account to guarantee a high level of environmental protection. The best
techniques for the pulp and paper industry cannot be defined solely by describing
unit processes. Instead, the whole installations must be examined and dealt with as
entities
The process of pulp and papermaking consists of quite many stages. Besides the
fibrous material different chemicals and a great amount of water and energy in the
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
14
form of steam, fuel oil or electric power is required in the process. The wide range of
processes involved in the manufacture of pulp and paper can be broken down into a
number of unit operations for the sake of discussion. A sequence of operations can
be described from raw materials to product but individual processes will not involve
all the operations and some are mutually exclusive alternatives.
The following chapters discuss the main processes applied for pulp and paper
making, such as:
• Non-wood pulping
• Kraft pulping
• Sulfite pulping
• Mechanical pulping
• Recycled fibre mills
• Papermaking
• Integrated pulp and paper mills
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
15
2 Non-wood pulping
The pulp and paper industry converts fibrous raw materials into pulp, paper, and
paperboard. The processes involved in papermaking include raw materials
preparation, pulping (chemical, semi-chemical, mechanical, or waste paper),
bleaching, chemical recovery, pulp drying, and papermaking. The most significant
energy-consuming processes are pulping and drying. Globally, wood is the main fiber
source in the paper industry and most mills are quite large, producing over 300,000
t/year for typical paper mills.
China’s paper industry is already unique in that; it is one of the largest users of non-
wood fibers. In fact, the share of wood fiber used in China has declined since the
1990s to about 7% of the input of the paper production, with recovered paper
representing 36%, and the remaining 57% covered by imported waste paper and
nonwood fiber. In the late 1990s there were over 5,000 pulp and paper mills in China,
of which over 70% used non-wood fibers, mainly straw. Most non-wood fiber mills are
small scale. In 1998 there were only 43 non-wood mills with a capacity exceeding
30000 t/year, and the vast majority produced less than 10000, or even 5000 t/year.
Since 2000, the Chinese government has started to close down the small polluting
and inefficient mills. In recent years modern large-scale paper machines have been
installed in China (e.g. Hebei Norske Skog Long 300,000 t/year plant, Dagang’s
paper machine 3 with a capacity of 1.1 million t/year). Non-wood fibers are expected
to continue to play an important role in China’s future paper industry.
2.1 Non-wood materials and processes
It is well known that due to a plentiful supply and reasonable costs, the economics of
pulp and paper production in Europe and North America, and in most other industrial
countries, have favored wood as the fibrous raw material, in the past and up to the
present time. However, many of the developing countries, as well as a few of the
industrial countries, do not have adequate supplies of wood, but they do have large
quantities of non-wood plant fibers available. Fortunately, by choosing the proper
blend of non-wood plant fibers, almost all grades of paper and paperboard—ranging
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
16
from tissue to linerboard, including newsprint—can be produced with as much as
100% fibrous content of these materials. Furthermore, every type of reconstituted
panelboard - ranging from insulating board to hardboard, including medium-density
fiberboard - can likewise be produced, and is being produced, from non-wood plant
fibers.
Generally, nonwood plant fiber pulps can be grouped into two broad categories:
• Common nonwoods or hardwood substitutes such as cereal straws,
sugarcane bagasse, bamboo (shorter fiber species), reeds and grasses,
esparto, kenaf (whole stalk or core fiber), corn stalks, sorghum stalks etc.
• Specialty nonwoods or softwood substitutes such as cotton staple and linters;
flax, hemp and kenaf bast fibers; sisal; abaca; bamboo (longer fiber species);
hesperaloe etc.
As with wood, there are differing chemical and physical properties within the two
groups depending on the nonwood fiber raw material, and the current uses of
nonwood pulps include virtually every grade of paper produced.
Typically, common nonwood pulps or hardwood substitutes are produced in
integrated pulp and paper mills, and softwood kraft or sulfite pulp is added to provide
the strength requirements to the paper. However, specialty nonwood pulp may be
used instead of softwood kraft or sulfite pulp thus producing a 100% nonwood paper.
And, in some cases, wastepaper pulp may be blended in the furnish. The nonwood
portion of the furnish typically varies from 20 to 90% and can be even up to 100%
depending on the paper grade and required quality. The possible combinations are
endless and can be adjusted to meet market requirements.
Furthermore, it is possible to add small quantities (up to 20 - 30%) of common
nonwood pulps to primarily woodpulp-based papers without impairing paper
properties or paper machine runnability. This provides wood-based mills which are
hardwood deficient but located within a region with available nonwood fiber
resources such as cereal straw or corn stalks with the option of adding-on a nonwood
pulping line to supplement their fiber requirements.
Typically, the specialty nonwoods have physical properties superior to softwoods and
can be used in lower amounts in the furnish when used as a softwood substitute.
Specialty papers such as currency, cigarette papers, tea bags, dialectric paper etc.
may be made from a furnish of 100% nonwood specialty pulps. Specialty pulps also
may be used in combination with woodpulp to produce lightweight and ultra-
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
17
lightweight printing and writing papers.
Combinations of common and specialty nonwood pulps will permit the production of
virtually any grade of paper to meet any quality requirements demanded in the global
market. Adding possible combinations which include wood pulp, nonwood pulp and
recycled wastepaper pulp increases the possibilities for developing paper with
specific sheet properties designed to meet specific customers needs.
2.2 International best practice
International best practice energy use in pulp and papermaking technology is based
on wood-based fibers. Hence, the identified best practice technologies may not be
applicable to non-wood fiber based pulp mills. Most papermaking technology is
developed and manufactured in Europe (Metso and Voith) and Japan (Mitsubishi),
and specialized products from North America (e.g. felts). There is limited experience
with non-wood fiber outside of China and India, with the last mills in Europe closing
down (Dunavarosc in Hungary (1980s), Fredericia in Denmark (1991), and SAICA in
Spain (1999) due to tightening environmental regulations. Even though there is
increased interest in the use of non-wood fibers internationally, only a few best
practice technologies are available. Only one “non-wood” best practice pulping
technology outside China has been identified by a recent report (Ernst Worell at al,
1970). Other clean modern non-wood pulping technology has not yet been
demonstrated on commercial scales. Although the use of non-wood fibers may affect
the characteristics of the pulp (e.g. runnability, water retention), it is hard to evaluate
ex-ante the impact on the energy use of the paper machine. The energy use of the
paper machine is generally dependent on the pulp quality and paper grade produced,
and hence the best practice values apply to paper machines, indiscriminate of the
source of the virgin pulp (given a specific quality). Note that the variation of the pulp
characteristics and paper grades is so large, that it will affect the best practice energy
intensity values.
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
18
2.3 Energy use and energy benchmarks
The current international best practice is based on the Chempolis process developed
in Finland. It provides a clean process that recovers the chemicals. A first
demonstration plant with a capacity of 65,000 air dry t (ADt)/year has been designed
for construction in China, but construction has been delayed. The pulp has similar
characteristics as hardwood pulp, resulting in similar behavior (e.g. runnability, water
retention) in the paper machine (see below).
The design assumes a steam consumption of 5 to 6 t/ADt pulp, or equivalent to
approximately 10.5 to 12.6 GJ/ADt (358 to 430 kgce/ADt) pulp. These values vary
with the process lay-out. The above values assume conventional water treatment,
and exclude pulp drying (for preparation of market pulp). Electricity consumption is
estimated to be 400 kWh/ADt. Note that the process uses no fuel directly, as there is
no need for a calcination kiln (as with kraft pulping). The lignin generates steam of
about 7 to 9t/ADt pulp, depending on the lignin yield, required steam pressure and
feed water temperature. Hence, the plant can have an excess steam production of 2
to 3 t/ADt, equivalent to approximately 4.2 to 6.3 GJ/ADt (143 to 215 kgce/ADt) that
can be exported for use in the paper machine.4
2.4 Energy saving measures
For further measures to reduce energy consumption that are generally applicable to
pulp and paper mills it is referred to the references and links in chapter 11.
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
19
3 Kraft pulping
The kraft process (also known as kraft pulping or sulfate process) describes a
technology for conversion of wood into wood pulp consisting of almost pure cellulose
fibers. The process entails treatment of wood chips with a mixture of sodium
hydroxide and sodium sulfide that break the bonds that link lignin to the cellulose.
The process name is derived from German kraft, meaning strength/power; both
capitalized and lowercase names (Kraft process and kraft process) appear in the
literature, but "kraft" is most commonly used in the pulp and paper industry.
The sulphate or kraft process accounting for ca. 80% of world pulp production is the
most applied production method of chemical pulping processes.
3.1 Process flow
Woodchips are fed into vessels called digesters that are capable of withstanding high
pressures. Some digesters operate in a batch manner and some in a continuous
process, such as the Kamyr digester. Digesters producing 1000 tonnes of pulp per
day and more are common with the largest producing more than 3500 tonnes of pulp
per day. Wood chips are impregnated with the cooking liquors. The cooking liquors
consist of warm black liquor and white liquor. The warm black liquor is the spent
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
20
cooking liquor coming from the blowing. White liquor is a mixture of sodium hydroxide
and sodium sulfide, produced in the recovery process. In a continuous digester the
materials are fed at a rate which allows the pulping reaction to be complete by the
time the materials exit the reactor. Typically delignification requires several hours at
130 to 180°C. Under these conditions lignin and some hemicellulose degrade to give
fragments that are soluble in the strongly basic liquid. The solid pulp (about 50% by
weight based on the dry wood chips) is collected and washed. At this point the pulp is
quite brown and is known as "brown stock". The combined liquids, known as black
liquor (so called because of its color), contain lignin fragments, carbohydrates from
the breakdown of hemicellulose, sodium carbonate, sodium sulfate and other
inorganic salts.
One of the main chemical reactions that underpin the kraft process is the scission of
ether bonds by the nucleophilic sulfide (S2-) or bisulfide (HS-) ions.
The excess black liquor is concentrated in multiple effect evaporators to 60% or even
80% solids ("heavy black liquor") and burned in the recovery boiler to recover the
inorganic chemicals for reuse in the pulping process. Higher solids in the
concentrated black liquor increases the energy and chemical efficiency of the
recovery cycle, but also gives higher viscosity and precipitation of solids (plugging
and fouling of equipment).
The recovery boiler also generates high pressure steam which is led to
turbogenerators, reducing the steam pressure for the mill use and generating
electricity. A modern kraft pulp mill is more than self-sufficient in its electrical
generation and normally will provide a net flow of energy to the local electrical grid.
Additionally, bark and wood residues are often burned in a separate power boiler to
generate steam.
The finished cooked wood chips are blown by reducing the pressure to atmospheric
pressure. This releases a lot of steam and volatiles. The steam produced can then be
used to heat the pulp mill and any excess used in district heating schemes or to drive
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
21
steam turbine to generate electrical power. The volatiles are condensed and
collected, in the case of northern softwoods this consists mainly of raw turpentine.
The brown stock from the blowing goes to the washing stages where the used
cooking liquors are separated from the cellulose fibers. Normally a pulp mill has 3-5
washing stages in series. Washing stages are also placed after oxygen deliginfiation
and between the bleaching stages as well. Pulp washers uses counter current flow
between the stages such that the pulp moves in the opposite direction to the flow of
washing waters. Several processes are involved: thickening / dilution, displacement
and diffusion. The dilution factor is the measure of the amount of water used in
washing compared with the theoretical amount required to displace the liquor from
the thickened pulp. Lower dilution factor reduces energy consumption, while higher
dilution factor normally gives cleaner pulp. Thorough washing of the pulp reduces the
COD. Several types of washing equipment are in use: Pressure diffusers;
Atmospheric diffusers; Vacuum drum washers, Drum displacers; Wash presses.
In a modern mill, brownstock (cellulose fibers containing approximately 5% residual
lignin), produced by the pulping is first washed to remove some of the dissolved
organic material and then further delignified by a variety of bleaching stages.
In the case of a plant designed to produce pulp to make brown sack paper or
linerboard for boxes and packaging, the pulp does not always need to be bleached to
a high brightness. Bleaching decreases the mass of pulp produced by about 5%,
decreases the strength of the fibers and adds to the cost of manufacture.
A number of process chemicals are added to improve the production process:
Surfactants, Anthraquinone, emulsion breaker, defoamers, dispersing agents and
complexing agents, fixation agents
Pulp produced by the kraft process is stronger than that made by other pulping
processes. Kraft pulp is darker than other wood pulps, but it can be bleached to
make very white pulp. Fully bleached kraft pulp is used to make high quality paper
where strength, whiteness and resistance to yellowing are important. The kraft
process can use a wider range of fiber sources than most other pulping processes.
All types of wood, including very resinous types like southern pine and non-wood
species like bamboo and kenaf can be used in the kraft process.
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
22
3.2 Consumptions and emissions
In kraft pulping the wastewater effluents and the emissions to air including
malodorous gases are the centres of interest but in the next years it is also expected
that waste will become an environmental issue of concern. The most relevant
consumption of raw materials and emissions to water, air and soil (waste) as well as
energy aspects are covering the following aspects:
• Wood consumption
• Water consumption and wastewater emissions from different process steps
- Wood handling
- Condensates from evaporators
- Spillages
- Washing losses
- Bleaching
- Discharges of nutrients
- Discharges of metals
• Emissions to the atmosphere
- from the recovery boiler
- from the lime kiln
- from auxiliary boilers
- Malodorous gases
- Chlorine compounds from bleaching and bleaching chemical
preparation
• Solid waste generation
• Consumption of chemicals
• Use of energy
• Noise
Pulp mills are almost always located near large bodies of water due to their former
substantial demands. Delignification of chemical pulps released considerable
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
23
amounts of organic material into the environment, particularly into rivers or lakes. The
wastewater effluent can also be a major source of pollution, containing lignins from
the trees, high biological oxygen demand (BOD) and dissolved organic carbon
(DOC), along with alcohols, chlorates, heavy metals, and chelating agents. Reducing
the environmental impact of this effluent is accomplished by closing the loop and
recycling the effluent where possible, as well as employing less damaging agents in
the pulping and bleaching processes. The process effluents are treated in a
biological effluent treatment plant, which guarantees that the effluents are not toxic in
the recipient.
3.3 Energy use and energy benchmarks
The major part of heat energy is consumed for heating different fluids and for
evaporating water. Heat energy is also used to accelerate or control chemical
reactions. Electrical energy is mostly consumed for the transportation of materials
(pumping) and for the operation of the paper machine (only in integrated pulp-mills).
The manufacturing of bleached kraft pulp consumes about 10-14 GJ/ADt of heat
energy (steam for the production of electrical power not included). The consumption
of electrical energy is 600-800 kWh/ADt, including the drying of pulp. The energy
consumption for pulp drying is about 25% of the heat energy and 15-20% of the
electrical energy. Over 50% of the electrical energy consumption are used for
pumping.
The energy consumption depends on the process configuration, process equipment
and process control efficiency.
A best practice Kraft mill (as reported by Ernst Worrell et al, 2007) produces excess
electricity that can be exported. The export is the result of balancing the energy used
in the pulping process and the energy recovered from the black liquor recovery
process (combusting the lignin). The energy consumption of the process itself varies
between 10 and 12.2 GJ/ADt (341-416 kgce/ADt) pulp, while electricity use is around
610 kWh/ADt (75 kgce/ADt). The lime kiln uses 1.2 GJ/ADt in fuels and 30
kWh/ADt54 for total energy consumption of 11.2 GJ/ADt (382 kgce/ADt) in fuels and
640 kWh/ADt in electricity. However, the recovery process is a net producer of 15.8
GJ/ADt of steam. It is assumed that the steam is used in a back-pressure steam
turbine to generate electricity (around 655 kWh/ADt), resulting in a net export of
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
24
power of 15 to 20 kWh/ADt. This leads to a total overall energy consumption value of
11.1 GJ/ADt (380 kgce). Research and development in black liquor gasification has
not yet resulted in a commercially operating process, and is hence not included in the
best practice energy consumption figures. However, when this technology is
available it could result in significant energy savings, due to large amounts of excess
power production.
A similar conclusion is drawn by the BAT surveys of the EU: Chemical pulping plants
are energy-intensive installations that consume high amounts of energy but at the
same time produce steam and electrical power on site by use of regenerative fuels.
Thus, modern non-integrated kraft pulp mills are energy self-sufficient mainly
because of efficient energy recovery by burning 50% of the incoming wood in the
recovery boiler (strong black liquor) and the use of bark as auxiliary boiler fuel.
Furthermore, secondary energy from different process steps can be recovered as
warm and hot water (40-80o C). Fossil fuels are mainly used as support fuel (e.g. oil
in the lime kiln).
3.4 Energy saving measures
In order to reduce the consumption of fresh steam and electric power, and to
increase the generation of steam and electric power internally, a number of
measures are available.
• Measures for a high heat recovery and a low heat consumption:
- High dry solids content of black liquor and bark
- High efficiency of steam boilers, e.g. low flue gas temperatures
- Effective secondary heating system e.g. hot water about 85 °C
- Well closed-up water system
- Relatively well closed-up bleaching plant
- High pulp concentration (MC-technique)
- Pre-drying of lime
- Use of secondary heat to heat buildings
- Good process control
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
25
• Measures for low consumption of electric power
- As high pulp consistency as possible in screening and cleaning
- Speed control of various large motors
- Efficient vacuum pumps
- Proper sizing of pipes, pumps and fans
• Measures for a high generation of electric power
- High boiler pressure
- Outlet steam pressure in the back-pressure turbine as low technically
feasible
- Condensing turbine for power production from excess steam
- High turbine efficiency
- Preheating of air and fuel charged to boilers
In many European countries, information on energy balances of whole pulp and
paper mills is poorly available in public. In Europe, different reporting schemes are
used. Energy balances also depend to a certain extent on local conditions. Therefore
the ranges of energy consumption of pulp mills shown in the table below should only
be taken as an indication about the approximate need of process heat and power at
energy efficient Kraft pulp mills.
Type of mill Process heat consumption (net) in GJ/ADt
Power consumption (net) in MWh/ADt
Remarks
Non-integrated bleached Kraft pulp
10-14 GJ/ADt About 2-2.5 GJ/ADt can be used for power generation giving a heat surplus of 0.5-1.0 GJ/ADt.
0.6 -0.8 MWh/ADt Modern pulp mills are power self-sufficient
An integrated mill reported 10 GJ/ADT heat consump-tion in the pulp mill (pulp at 2.2% consist.) 1
Integrated bleached Kraft pulp and uncoated fine paper
14 - 20 GJ/ADt 2) There is a heat surplus of 4.0-4.5 GJ per tonne of pumped bleached pulp which is used in the paper mill
1.2 -1.5 MWh/ADt There can be a surplus power from the pulp mill of 0.1 - 0.15 MWh per tonne of pumped bleached pulp which is used in the paper mill
The surplus of electricity, if any, depends on if back-pressure turbines are installed
Integrated kraftliner, Unbleached
14.0 -17.5 GJ/ADt There is a heat surplus of 1.5-2 GJ per tonne of pumped unbleached pulp which is used in the paper mill
1.0-1.3 MWh/ADt There is a surplus power from the pulp mill of 0.15 -0.2 MWh per tonne of pumped unbleached pulp which is used in the paper mill
Integrated sackpaper, Unbleached
14.0 -23 GJ/ADt 1.0 - 1.5 MWh/ADt
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
26
The units can be converted from MWh to GJ according to 1 MWh = 3.6 GJ and 1 GJ = 0.277 MWh Notes: 1) including activated sludge treatment 2) Paper drying is more energy consuming than pulp drying
The effect of this energy saving measures can often not be easily been shown in
form of values because improvements depend on the situation of the mill before the
measures were implemented, which shows the importance of internal benchmarking.
For further measures to reduce energy consumption that are generally applicable to
pulp and paper mills it is referred to the references and links in chapter 11.
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
27
4 Sulfite pulping
The first pulp mill using the sulfite process was built in Sweden in 1874 and used
magnesium as the counter ion. Calcium became the standard counter ion until the
1950s. Sulfite pulping was the dominant process for making wood pulp until it was
surpassed by the kraft process in the 1940s. Sulfite pulps now account for less than
10% of the total chemical pulp production, and sulphate pulps are more used in
special purposes in papermaking rather than being an alternative market pulp grade
for kraft pulps. Mainly bleached sulphite pulp is made and the yield is a little higher
which can be attributed to the lower pH in the cooking.
The main reasons of the limited applicability of sulphite pulps are as follows:
• It is not possible to use pine as raw material in the acid cooking process
which limits the raw material base of sulphite pulping
• The strength properties of the pulps as measured by the papermaker are
generally not as good as those of kraft pulp, although for some speciality
pulps these properties may be equally good or even better
• Environmental problems have in many cases been more expensive to solve
and this has decreased the cost-competitivity compared to the kraft pulping
(e.g. pH-regulation of evaporation condensates, minimisation of sulphur
emissions and removal of organic compounds).
4.1 Processes
The sulfite process produces wood pulp which is almost pure cellulose fibers by
using various salts of sulfurous acid to extract the lignin from wood chips in large
pressure vessels called digesters. The salts used in the pulping process are either
sulfites (SO32−), or bisulfites (HSO3−), depending on the pH. The counter ion can be
sodium (Na+), calcium (Ca2+), potassium (K+), magnesium (Mg2+) or ammonium
(NH4+).
The sulfite process is acidic and one of the drawbacks is that the acidic conditions
hydrolyze some of the cellulose, which means that sulfite pulp fibers are not as
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
28
strong as kraft pulp fibers. The yield of pulp (based on wood used) is higher than for
kraft pulping and sulfite pulp is easier to bleach. Apart from printing and specialty
papers, a special grade of sulfite pulp, known as "dissolving pulp" is used to make
cellulose derivatives. Lignosulfonates are an important byproduct of sulfite bleaching.
These materials are used in making concrete, drilling mud, and drywall and so on.
The sulphite process is characterised by its high flexibility compared to the kraft
process, which is a very uniform method, which can be carried out only with highly
alkaline cooking liquor. In principle, the entire pH range can be used for sulphite
pulping by changing the dosage and composition of the chemicals. Thus, the use of
sulphite pulping permits the production of many different types and qualities of pulps
for a broad range of applications. The sulphite process can be distinguished
according to the pH adjusted into different types of pulping the main of which realised
in Europe are compiled in the table below.
Process pH Base Active reagent
Cooking temperature C
Pulp yield %
Applications
Acid (bi)sulphite
1-2 Ca2+ , Mg2+, Na+
SO2*H2O, H+, HSO3 -
125-143 40-50 Dissolving pulp, tissue, printing paper, special paper
Bisulphite 3-5 Mg2+, Na+ HSO3 -, H+ 150-170 50-65 printing paper, (Magnefite) tissue Neutral sulphite (NSSC)2
5-7 Na+, NH4 +
HSO3 -SO3 2-
, 160-180 75-90 Corrugated medium, semi-chemical pulp
Alkaline 9-13.5 Na+ SO3 2-, OH- 160-180 45-60 Kraft-type pulp sulphite
Table 5.1: Main sulphite pulping processes in Europe (according to Uhlmann, 1991)
The sulphite cooking process is based on the use of aqueous sulphur dioxide (SO2)
and a base - calcium, sodium, magnesium or ammonium. The specific base used will
impact upon the options available within the process in respect of chemical and
energy recovery system and water use. Today, the use of the relatively cheap
calcium base is outdated because the cooking chemicals cannot be recovered. In
Europe there is still one mill (FR) using ammonium as a base. The dominating
sulphite pulping process in Europe is the magnesium sulphite pulping with some mills
using sodium as base. Both magnesium and sodium bases allow chemical recovery.
The lignosulphonates generated in the cooking liquor can be used as a raw material
for producing different chemical products. Because of its importance in terms of
capacity and numbers of mills running in Europe in the following the focus is on
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
29
magnesium sulphite pulping.
Sulphite pulping consists of three main entities: the fibre line, recovery of chemicals
and energy (excluding calcium sulphite pulping where recovery is not possible but
where the spent cooking liquor can be evaporated and the components used for
other purposes) and external wastewater treatment. As in kraft pulping some
auxiliary systems like reject handling, manufacturing of bleaching chemicals and
auxiliary power generation are connected to the main departments.
In many respects the kraft and sulphite processes have similarities not least
regarding the possibilities of taking different internal and external measures to reduce
emissions to environment.
4.2 Consumptions and emissions
An overview of the raw material and energy input as well as the output of products,
by-products and the major releases (emissions, waste etc.) of the production of
sulphite pulp is presented in the figure below.
Using the mass stream overview, specific raw material, energy and water
consumption and specific emission per tonne of product can be calculated.
Because of the diverse and individual situation of each plant no general propositions
are possible to this topic. Internal benchmarking remains the only option.
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
30
4.3 Energy use and energy benchmarks
Information is generally much weaker for sulphite mills than for kraft pulp mills.
Therefore, from the limited information only a few techniques could be described to
the same extent as for kraft pulping. The process can be operated to produce a wide
range of specialty products, which will also result in a wide range of energy use.
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
31
Due to the variety of pulps to be produced, steam use is estimated to be 16 to 18
GJ/ADt (546 to 614 kgce/ADt) and electricity use to be 700 kWh/ADt.
4.4 Energy saving measures
The available data set is relatively small. This could be partly compensated because
of the inherent similarities between sulphite and kraft pulping. A number of
techniques for pollution prevention and control for kraft pulping are also valid in most
respects for sulphite pulping.
Energy can be recovered from the “green liquor”, similar to the black liquor recovery
process, producing about 15 GJ/ADt (512 kgce/ADt) pulp. The best practice assumes
optimisation of power use, state-of-the-art controls, efficient evaporation and
concentration of the green liquor.
For further measures to reduce energy consumption that are generally applicable to
pulp and paper mills it is referred to the references and links in chapter 11.
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
32
5 Mechanical pulping
In mechanical pulping the wood fibres are separated from each other by mechanical
energy applied to the wood matrix. The objective is to maintain the main part of the
lignin in order to achieve high yield with acceptable strength properties and
brightness.
5.1 Processes
There are several types of processes that can be used for mechanical pulping, i.e.
groundwood (GW), thermo-mechanical pulping (TMP) and chemi-thermo-mechanical
pulping (CTMP).
The earliest mills used sandstone grinding rollers to break up small wood logs called
"bolts", but the use of natural stone ended in the 1940s with the introduction of
manufactured stones with embedded silicon carbide or aluminum oxide. The pulp
made by this process is known as "stone groundwood" pulp (SGW). If the wood is
ground in a pressurized, sealed grinder the pulp is classified as "pressure
groundwood" (PGW) pulp. Most modern mills use chips rather than logs and ridged
metal discs called refiner plates instead of grindstones. If the chips are just ground up
with the plates, the pulp is called "refiner mechanical" pulp (RMP), if the chips are
steamed while being refined the pulp is called "thermomechanical" pulp (TMP).
Steam treatment significantly reduces the total energy needed to make the pulp and
decreases the damage (cutting) to fibers.
Some mills pretreat wood chips or other plant material like straw with sodium
carbonate, sodium hydroxide, sodium sulfite and other chemical prior to refining with
equipment similar to a mechanical mill. The conditions of the chemical treatment are
much less vigorous (lower temperature, shorter time, less extreme pH) than in a
chemical pulping process, since the goal is to make the fibers easier to refine, not to
remove lignin as in a fully chemical process. Pulps made using these hybrid
processes are known as chemi-thermomechanical pulps (CTMP). Sometimes a
CTMP mill is located on the same site as a kraft mill so that the effluent from the
CTMP mill can be treated in the kraft recovery process to regenerate the inorganic
pulping chemicals.
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
33
5.2 Energy use and energy benchmarks
Energy use in mechanical pulping is determined by the wood type used and the
“freeness” of the pulp. The “freeness” is an expression for the fiber quality and water
retention. Hence, energy use may vary widely on the basis of the desired pulp quality
given a specific wood type used.
Mechanical pulp mills use large amounts of energy, mostly electricity to power
motors which turn the grinders. A rough estimate of the electrical energy needed is
10000 mega joules (MJ) per ton of pulp (2750 kWh per ton) in international best
practice average.
Energy efficient mechanical pulp and paper mills consume heat and power as
follows:
• Non-integrated CTMP: For pulp drying recovered process heat can be used
i.e. no primary steam is needed. The power consumption is 2 - 3 MWh/ADt.
• Integrated newsprint mills consume 0 - 3 GJ/t process heat and 2 - 3 MWh/t
of electricity. The steam demand depends on the fibre furnish and the degree
of steam recovery from the refiners.
• Integrated LWC paper mills consume 3 - 12 GJ/t process heat and 1.7 - 2.6
MWh/t of electricity. It has to be noted that the fibre furnish of LWC consists
usually only of about one third of PGW or TMP the rest being bleached kraft
pulp and fillers and coating colours. If the production of bleached kraft pulp is
carried out at the same site (integrated) the contribution of the energy
demand of kraft pulping have to be added according to fibre furnish mix
manufactured.
• Integrated SC paper mills consume 1 - 6 GJ/t process heat and 1.9 - 2.6
MWh/t of electricity.
As mentioned there are several types of processes that can be used for mechanical
pulping, i.e. groundwood (GW), thermo-mechanical pulping (TMP) and chemo-
thermo-mechanical pulping (CTMP). The best practice assumes TMP. TMP allows
the recovery of heat from the process in the form of hot water and steam, as only a
fraction of the energy is actually used to separate the fibers. TMP allows the recovery
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
34
of 60-65% of the heat generated in the process (45% as steam, 20% as hot water).
However, a TMP mill consumes more power than a groundwood mill. The best
practice integrated TMP newsprint mill consists of a pressurized TMP mill consuming
about 2190 kWh/ADt and generating 1.33 GJ/ADt (45 kgce/ADt) of heat. For a non-
integrated pulp mill electricity use is estimated at 2420 kWh/ADt with generation of
5.5 GJ/ADt of steam.
5.3 Energy saving measures
In mechanical pulping and chemo-mechanical pulping the wastewater effluents and
consumption of electricity for the drives of grinders or refiners are the centres of
interest. The main raw materials are renewable resources (wood and water) and
some chemicals for bleaching (for CTMP also for chemical pre-treatment of the
chips). As processing aids and to improve the product properties (paper auxiliaries)
various additives are applied during paper manufacturing.
A lot of options for energy saving in many stages within the manufacturing process
are available. Usually these measures are linked with investments to replace, rebuild
or upgrade process equipment. It should be noticed that energy saving measures are
mostly not applied only for energy saving. Production efficiency, improvement of
product quality and reduction of overall costs is the most important basis for
investments.
In order to reduce the consumption of fresh steam and electric power the following
measures are available:
• Implementation of a system for monitoring energy usage and performance.
Based on reliable energy performance information appropriate action can be
taken. Energy management includes setting, controlling, reviewing and
revising energy performance targets.
• Upgrading of equipment. When replacing equipment less energy consuming
equipment with possibilities for automated process control instead of
conventional manual systems. Automated controlled systems are more
efficient to control and can result in more accurate processing and energy
savings.
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
35
• Minimisations of reject losses by using efficient reject handling stages and
reject refining. If fiber bundles (shives) and undeveloped coarse fibres are
removed from the main process line, the energy, which was already spent for
first grinding/refining would be lost. The reduction of reject losses after
grinding and mainline refining and the further refining of shives and coarse
fibres to develop the properties to the quality level needed thus decrease
specific energy consumption.
• Use of effective heat recovery systems (applies only for TMP and CTMP).
Large volumes of steam are generated in TMP refining because around two-
thirds of the refining electrical energy is transformed in thermal energy in the
form of hot saturated steam. The impurities present in the TMP steam make
the heat recovery unit necessary because the direct use of TMP steam is not
possible. The TMP steam is separated from the fibres in cyclones and then
condensed in the reboiler against vaporising clean steam. The clean steam is
normally used in the paper machine department.
• Application of co-generation of heat and power where the power/steam-ratio
allows it.
For further measures to reduce energy consumption that are generally applicable to
pulp and paper mills it is referred to the references and links in chapter 11.
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
36
6 Recycled fibre mills
Recovered fibre has become an indispensable raw material for the paper
manufacturing industry, accounting about one-third of the total raw materials because
of the favourable price of recovered fibres in comparison with the corresponding
grades of market pulp and because of the promotion of wastepaper recycling by
many European countries. In Europe there is an average utilisation rate of recovered
paper of 43 %. But is has to be taken into account that the maintenance of the fibre
cycle relies on the feed of a certain amount of primary fibres to ensure the strength
and other properties of the paper to be produced.
For effective use of recovered paper it is necessary to collect, sort and classify the
materials into suitable quality grades. Therefore, after collection recovered paper is
brought to the collection yards where it is sorted. Detrimental substances as e.g.
plastics, laminated papers etc. are removed before balling as well as possible. The
sorted recovered paper is usually compacted by baling machines. Industrial
recovered paper from large generators is usually delivered to and processed in
recovered paper yards integrated in the paper mill.
There are three categories of paper that can be used as feedstocks for making
recycled paper: mill broke pre-consumer waste, and post-consumer waste. Mill broke
is paper trimmings and other paper scrap from the manufacture of paper, and is
recycled internally in a paper mill. Pre-consumer waste is material that was discarded
before it was ready for consumer use. Post-consumer waste is material discarded
after consumer use such as old magazines, old telephone directories, and residential
mixed paper. Paper suitable for recycling is called "scrap paper".
Fiber recycling is an important option for reducing pulping energy use. China also
imports paper from other countries (notably the US and Europe) to provide its fiber
needs. Recycled fiber has become a global market in which China is an important
consumer.
6.1 Processes
The used fibers are pulped and (optionally) de-inked before being fed to stock
preparation for the paper machine. A concern about recycling wood pulp paper is that
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
37
the fibers are degraded with each and after being recycled 4-6 times the fibers
become too short and weak to be useful in making paper.
The recovered paper is put into a pulper together with hot water or fresh water, and
pulped with mechanical and hydraulic agitation resulting in their disintegration into
fibres. After repulping the recovered paper has a pulping consistency for subsequent
treatment. Some chemicals such as deinking agents and NaOH are often added as
pulping additives.
Deinking is the industrial process of removing printing ink from paperfibers of
recycled paper to make deinked pulp. The key in the deinking process is the ability to
detach ink from the fibers. This is achieved by a combination of mechanical action
and chemical means. In Europe the most common process is froth flotation deinking.
Ink removal is necessary in plants manufacturing paper grades where brightness is
important e.g. for newsprint, printing and writing paper, tissue or light top liner of
recovered paper based carton boards. The main objectives of deinking are
increasing of brightness and cleanliness and reduction of stickies. It should be noted
that the difference between de-inked and non de-inked grades is in the process and
not in the product itself. Depending on the quality of the recovered paper used,
market requirements or production needs, also packaging papers and boards could
be de-inked.
Contaminants and clusters are removed continuously during operation by a dirt trap
(e.g. screen plate) and are sent to a reject conveyor, in order to avoid the
contaminants breaking into small pieces or accumulating in the pulper. There is an
increasing use of secondary pulpers for further defibration, deflaking and cleaning
from heavy-weight (HW) and lightweight (LW) dirt. The installations trade under
different names but are based on similar functioning. Also screening drums are used.
Before entering a storage tower the pulp is often bleached by use of bleaching
chemicals. Generally hydrogen peroxide (P), hydrosulphite (Y) or formamidine
sulfinic acid (FAS) are used. Bleaching chemicals are added directly in the disperger
to maintain or increase the brightness. The reaction itself takes place in a bleaching
tower ensuring a sufficient dwell time. Any possible increase in brightness depends
on the raw material and on the pre-treatment of the stock. Hydrogen peroxide
bleaching is carried out in the presence of NaOH, sodium silicate and sometimes
chelating agents. For almost wood-free secondary fibre stock so-called
unconventional bleaching chemicals oxygen and ozone can be used.
Normally, the water for disintegration is totally re-circulated process water that comes
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
38
as white water from the paper machine. The figure below is a flow sheet of an
example for a stock preparation plant concept for processing recovered paper for
case making material (2-ply testliner). (HW = heavy-weight impurities; LF = Long
fibre fraction; SF = Short fibre fraction)
Various product characteristics require different cleanliness and brightness properties
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
39
from the RCF pulps and the process concepts vary accordingly. For example, de-
inking is not required in many board grades. On the contrary, a very efficient
multistage process is required for high speed paper machines, thin paper or for
grades where brightness is important. The degree of sophistication of the whole
process depends on the furnish used and the paper grade to be manufactured.
Therefore it is not reasonable to describe "one typical" recovered paper processing
system.
6.2 Energy use and energy benchmarks
Energy consumption is reduced by recycling, although there is debate concerning the
actual energy savings realized. The EIA claims a 40% reduction in energy when
paper is recycled versus paper made with unrecycled pulp, while the Bureau of
International Recycling, BIR, claims a 64% reduction. Some calculations show that
recycling one ton of newspaper saves about 4000 kWh (14 GJ) of electricity,
although this may be too high. This is enough electricity to power a 3-bedroom
European house for an entire year, or enough energy to heat and air-condition the
average North American home for almost six months. Recycling paper to make pulp
may actually consume more fossil fuels than making new pulp via the kraft process,
however, since these mills generate all of their energy from burning waste wood
(bark, roots) and byproduct lignin. Pulp mills producing new mechanical pulp use
large amounts of energy; a very rough estimate of the electrical energy needed is 10
gigajoules per ton of pulp. Recycling mills purchase most of their energy from local
power companies, and since recycling mills tend to be in urban areas, it is likely that
the electricity is generated by burning fossil fuels.
As a fact, paper and board mills require substantial amounts of steam for heating of
water, pulp, air and chemicals to the demanded process temperature and above all
for drying the paper. Besides, large quantities of electricity are required for driving the
machinery, pumping, vacuum, ventilation and wastewater treatment. In paper mills
energy is usually the main factor in operating costs. Because the secondary fibres
have already passed through stock-preparation equipment when the original paper
was made, RCF pulping require comparatively less total energy for processing then
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
40
is needed for chemical and especially for mechanical pulping.
Based on the performance of Swedish mills, the best practice is estimated to be 0.3
GJ/ADt (10 kgce/ADt) use of steam and electricity use of 330 kWh/ADt.
In many European countries, information on energy balances of paper mills is poorly
available in public. Different reporting schemes, if any, for energy consumption are
used. Energy demand also depends on the product quality (especially in tissue mills)
and partly on local conditions. Therefore, it is difficult to present energy consumption
values associated with the use of BAT. The ranges of energy consumption of paper
mills shown in the table should only be taken as an indication about the approximate
need of process heat and power at energy efficient paper mills.
Type of mill Process heat consumption (net) in
GJ/t1)
Power consumption (net) in MWh/t 1)
RCF based testliner and wellenstoff,
6.0 - 6.5 0.7 - 0.8
without de-inking RCF based cartonboard or folding boxboard, without de-inking
8.0 - 9.0 0.9 - 1.0
RCF based newsprint, de-inked 4.0 - 6.5 1.0 - 1.5 RCF based tissue, de-inked 7.0 - 12.0 2) 1.2 - 1.4 Explanatory notes: The units can be converted from MWh to GJ according to 1 MWh = 3.6 GJ and 1 GJ = 0.277 MWh 1) All data from [J. Pöyry, 1998]
2) In tissue mills the energy consumption depends mainly on the drying system used. Through air drying and re-creping consume significant additional energy. Tissue mills use primary fuel instead of steam in drying (most hoods are direct gas fired). Table 7.2: Indication for heat and power consumption associated with the use of BAT
for different types of recovered paper production per tonne of product
6.3 Energy saving measures
In order to reduce the consumption of fresh steam and electric power the following
measures are available:
• Implementation of a system for monitoring energy usage and performance.
• Upgrading of equipment.
• Use of effective heat recovery systems.
• Application of co-generation of heat and power.
For further measures to reduce energy consumption that are generally applicable to
pulp and paper mills it is referred to the references and links in chapter 11.
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
41
7 Papermaking
For the production of different paper grades either virgin fibre (chemical or
mechanical pulps) or recycled fibres or a mixture of fibrous materials are used as
main raw materials. The composition of raw materials used for paper manufacturing
(e.g. fibrous material, mineral fillers, coating) has a major effect on the total
production costs, the product quality and the environmental impact of the process.
The manufacturing of fibres used for papermaking has been described in the
previous chapters. In the following, paper and board manufacturing is described
independent from pulp manufacturing. This approach is considered to be reasonable
because the same unit processes around the paper and board machine are required
in every paper mill. The description of papermaking as part of integrated pulp mills
(see next chapter) would increase the complexity of the technical description. Finally,
many paper mills are non-integrated mills; they are stand-alone paper mills where
pulp is purchased as raw material from other factories (e.g. from stand-alone pulp
mills).
7.1 Processes - Overview
In the following the basic units of paper manufacturing are described. Although there
is a big variety of paper products and different process lay-outs in paper mills almost
all types of paper and board-making processes have the following basic units:
• Stock preparation
• Approach flow system
• A paper and board machine consisting of
- Head box introduces the suspension of fibres to the wire and creates a
uniform dispersion of fibres across the total width of the wire belt
- A wire section drains paper web to around 12 - 20% solids
- A press section removes more water out of the web by pressing down to
about 50% moisture content
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
42
- A drying section removes rest of moisture by heating the web with drying
cylinders
- A reeler reels the paper web into a roll
• Depending on the paper and board grade there are additional process units
(optional) like calenders, coaters, a coating colour kitchen, winders, rewinders
and a roll wrapping station.
7.2 Stock preparation
Stock preparation is conducted to convert raw stock into finished stock (furnish) for
the paper machine. The pulp is prepared for the paper machine including the
blending of different pulps, dilution and the addition of chemicals. The raw stocks
used are the various types of chemical pulp, mechanical pulp, and recovered paper
and their mixtures. The quality of the finished stock essentially determines the
properties of the paper produced. Raw stock is available in the form of bales, loose
material, or, in case of integrated mills, as suspensions. Stock preparation consists of
several process steps that are adapted to one another as fibre disintegration,
cleaning, fibre modification and storage and mixing. These systems differ
considerably depending on the raw stock used and on the quality of furnish required.
For instance, in the case of pulp being pumped directly from the pulp mill, the
slushing and deflaking stages are omitted.
Stock preparation is based on the removal of impurities, the conditioning of the
strength properties of the fibres (refining) and the addition of chemicals to aid the
process and affect the final quality of the paper sheet (resins, wet strength agents,
colours, fillers). In non-integrated mills the fibres are received dry. They are
suspended in a pulper to create a suspension that can be pumped. Then,
undissolved impurities are removed from the slurry by screening (screens) and
cleaning (centrifugal cleaners). The objective of screening is the removal of
interfering substances from the fibres. The fibre suspension is passed through a
screen with apertures in the form of slots or round holes, and the impurities to be
separated are rejected by the screen.
Cleaning is the separation of impurities from the fibre suspension in a centrifugal
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
43
field. Cleaning is carried out in centrifugal cleaners. A distinction is made between
heavy-particle and light-particle cleaners, depending on the purpose of separation.
Most cleaners are multistage systems (up to 5 stages).
To improve the bonding ability of the individual fibres of the finished paper refining
may be carried out (optional). The refining has the purpose of conditioning the fibres
to create the required properties of the finished product. Refining is carried out in
refiners equipped with e.g. a rotating disk that is pressed on a stator.
Complete stock preparation for a paper machine usually consists of several lines, in
each of which different raw stocks are prepared
7.3 Paper Machine
In the paper machine the paper is formed and most of the properties of the paper are
determined. The paper machine is actually a large de-watering device consisting of a
head box, a wire section, press section and dryer section. The most common
machine design still to recent times is the Foudrinier process in which the sheet is
formed onto a continuous wire or fabric onto which the suspension of fibres is
introduced from the headbox. Recently twin wire formers have been used for web
formation and they have become the state-of-the-art design. In twin wire formers, the
fibre suspension is led between two wires operating at the same speed, and is
drained through one or both sides. There are different types of twin wire formers (e.g.
gap formers. In gap formers the diluted stock is injected directly into the gap between
the two wires) and combinations of Fourdrinier and twin wires (hybrid formers).
Figure 7.2 shows the key features of such a paper machine.
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
44
Figure 7.1: Key features of a twin wire paper machine
The four main sections to the Fourdrinier:
Wet end
The first section is typically known as the wet end. Pulp may be delivered to the
Fourdrinier machine in a slurry form (a mixture of fiber and water) directly from the
pulping process. Alternatively, pulp may be supplied in dried sheets which are then
broken down in water to produce similar slurry, before being fed to the refiners in the
wet end where the fibers are subjected to high pressure pulses between bars on
rotating refiner discs. This action causes the fibrils of the fibers to partially detach and
bloom outward. After refining the pulp is mixed with some of the following: sizing,
fillers, colors, retention aid and waste paper called broke to a stock, and passed on.
Washing is done in pressurized screens and hydocyclones and also deaeration is
done.
The stock then enters the headbox, a unit that disperses the stock and loads it onto a
moving wire mesh conveyor with a jet from an opening called the slice. The
streaming in the jet makes some fibres align. This alignement can partly be taken
away by adjusting the speed difference between the jet and the wire. The wire
revolves around the Fourdrinier table, from breast roll under the headbox over the
couch to the forward drive roll, foils under the wire are creating low pressure pulses
that will vibrate and partly deflocculate the fibres while water is removed. Later on
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
45
Suction boxes below the wire gently remove water from the pulp with a slight vacuum
and near the end of the wire section the couch will remove water with higher vacuum.
Press section
The second section of the Fourdrinier machine (or any modern papermachine) is the
press section, which removes the most water via a system of nips formed by rolls
pressing against each other aided by press felts. This is the most efficient method of
dewatering the sheet as only mechanical pressing is required. Press felts historically
were made from cotton. However, today they are nearly 100% synthetic. They are
made up of a polyester woven fabric with thick batt applied in a specific design to
maximise water absorption.
Presses can be single or double felted. A single felted press has a press felt on one
side of the press, the sheet being exposed to a felt on one side and a smooth roll on
the other. Double felted is where both sides of the sheet are in contact with a press
felt. Single felted nips are useful when mated against a smooth top roll, which adds a
two-sidedness—making the top side appear smoother than the bottom. Double felted
nips increase roughness, as generally, press felts.
Conventional roll presses are configured with one of the press rolls is in a fixed
position, with a mating roll being loaded against this fixed roll. The felts run through
the nips of the press rolls and continue around a felt run, normally consisting of
several felt rolls. During the dwell time in the nip, the moisture from the sheet is
transferred to the press felt. When the press felt exits the nip and continues around, a
vacuum box known as an Uhle Box applies vacuum (normally -60 kPa) to the press
felt to remove the moisture so that when the felt returns to the nip on the next cycle, it
does not add moisture to the sheet.
Pickup roll presses are vacuum assisted rolls loaded against plain press rolls (usually
a roll in a centre position). While out of favour, these are generally found in machines
built in the 1970s–1980s. Pickup roll presses normally have a vacuum box that has
two vacuum zones (low vacuum and high vacuum). These rolls have a large number
of drilled holes in the cover to allow the vacuum to pass from the stationary vacuum
box through the rotating roll covering. The low vacuum zone picks up the sheet and
transfers, while the high vacuum zone attempts to remove moisture. Unfortunately,
centrifugal force usually flings out vacuumed water—making this less effective for
dewatering. Pickup presses also have standard felt runs with Uhle boxes. However,
pickup press design is quite different, as air movement is important for the pickup
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
46
and dewatering facets of its role.
Crown Controlled Rolls (also known as CC Rolls) are usually the mating roll in a
press arrangement. They have hydraulic cylinders in the press rolls that ensure that
the roll does not bow. The cylinders connect to a shoe or multiple shoes to keep the
crown on the roll flat, to counteract the natural "bend" in the roll shape due to
applying load to the edges.
Extended Nip Presses (or ENP) are a relatively modern alternative to conventional
roll presses. The top roll is usually a standard roll, while the bottom roll is actually a
large CC roll with an extended shoe curved to the shape of the top roll, surrounded
by a rotating rubber belt rather than a standard roll cover. The goal of the ENP is to
extend the dwell time of the sheet between the two rolls thereby maximising the
dewatering. Compared to a standard roll press that achieves up to 35% solids after
pressing, an ENP brings this up to 45% and higher—delivering significant steam
savings or speed increases.
Dryer section
The dryer section of the Fourdrinier machine, as its name suggests, dries the pulp by
way of a series of steam-heated rollers that stretch the web somewhat, removing the
moisture. Additional sizing agents, including resins, glue, or starch, can be added to
the web to alter its characteristics. Sizing improves the paper's water resistance,
decreases its ability to fuzz, reduces abrasiveness, and improves its printing
properties and surface bond strength. Some paper machines also make use of a
'coater' to apply a coating of fillers such as calcium carbonate or china clay.
Calender section
The calender stack is a series of rollers that the web is run between in order to
further smooth it out, which also gives it a more uniform thickness. The pressure
applied to the web by the rollers determines the finish of the paper, and there are
three types of finish that the paper can have. The first is machine finish, and can
range from a rough antique look to a smooth high quality finish. The second is called
a supercalendered finish and is a higher degree for fine-screened halftone printing.
The third type of finish is called a plater finish, and whereas the first two types of
finish are accomplished by the calender stack itself, a plater finish is obtained by
placing cut sheets of paper between zinc or copper plates that are stacked together,
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
47
then put under pressure and perhaps heating. A special finish such as a linen finish
would be achieved by placing a piece of linen between the plate and the sheet of
paper, or else an embossed steel roll might be used. The web is then wound onto a
roll after calendering, with a moisture content of about 6%, and stored for final cutting
and / or shipping. The environmental impact of (super)calendering is mainly the
energy consumption needed for running the machine and heating the rolls
7.4 Energy use and energy benchmarks
Energy use in the paper machine is determined by the specific grade of paper to be
produced and the fiber quality (e.g. water retention) in the pulp. Moreover, not all
energy efficient technologies are suitable for all paper grades. The best practice
values assume that an effective control system is in place, long nip (or shoe) press is
being used (not suitable for tissue mills), use of efficient motors, condensate
recovery, a closed hood for heat recovery, as well as integration of the various steam
and hot water flows in the mill. Note that small scale mills may have a steam
consumption that is 10-25% higher and an electricity consumption that is 5-20%
higher than the average figures of bigger plants.
The total demand for energy (consumption) in the form of heat (steam) and electric
power for a non-integrated fine paper mill has been reported to consume
• Process heat: 8 GJ/t (� 2222 kWh/t)
• Electric power: 674 kWh/t. 14
This means that about 3 MWh electricity and steam/ton product is consumed. When
considering the primary energy demand for converting fossil fuels into power a total
amount of 4 MWh/t of paper is needed.
The figures represent a modernised mill, like a mill built in the 1970s and since then
modernised. The values include all the stages from disintegration of fibre raw
materials to the final paper product and include also necessary service departments.
Energy consumption for the coating process is included in the case of the production
of coated paper (the mill is considered to have a capacity of 125000 t/a of coated fine
paper from market pulp. The paper has a pigment content of 39% and a moisture
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
48
content of 4.5%).
Table 7.4a shows the energy consumption in the form of heat and electric power for
this nonintegrated fine paper mill in a little more detail.
Department Process heat Electric power [MJ/t] [kWh/t]
Stock preparation 0 202
Paper machine 8000 350
Coating kitchen 0 118
Total paper mill 8000 670
Effluent treatment 0 4
Total consumption per tonne of paper 8000 674 Turbine generator 0
Total external supply 8000 674
Table 7.4a: Energy consumption in a non-integrated coated paper mill with a production capacity of 125000t/a [SEPA-Report 4712-4, 1997]; The external supply
figure shows the amount of the total demand that is purchased from external sources as fuel oil, coal and gas and electricity
Electricity (Power)
The electricity consumption depends to a certain extent on the paper grade
produced. The lowest values correspond to packaging paper or corrugated base
paper that consumes about 500 kWh/t, whereas printing and writing paper account
for about 700 - 800 kWh/t. The highest power demand, up to 5600 kWh/ADt, is
needed for some special paper grades. The power is mainly consumed by more
intensive refining.
Electric power in paper industry is mainly consumed for the operation of various
motor drives and refining in stock preparation. The motors are used for running fans,
pumps, compressors, stirrers, paper machines, presses, vacuum systems, various
conveyors, etc. For refining the electrical energy is primarily used to drive the rotor in
the refiner. The energy usage varies by product with filter and blotting papers
requiring least energy and tracing papers requiring the highest input.
Process heat
Heating of water and liquors, wood or pulp, air and chemicals to the process
demanded temperatures. Pulp and white water systems can often be kept warm
enough without addition of steam. It is essential to minimise the use of fresh water
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
49
and increase the use of white water from an energy point of view. In non-integrated
paper mills except addition of warm fresh water, circulation of the white water through
heat recovery is often necessary to keep the temperature at a sufficient level in the
white water system.
Evaporating water: In papermaking paper drying is the most energy demanding stage
during which the major amount of heat is consumed to evaporate water in the paper
sheet. It is important to minimise the amount of water to be evaporated by
mechanical measures (pressing). Development of the press section (use of twin-wire
and extended nip press) has resulted in somewhat lower moisture levels of the paper
entering the drying section (this does not apply to tissue paper). In the case of
surface sizing or coating the dried paper has to be dried again after adding surface
glue or coatings to the paper web. Higher concentration and temperature of these
chemicals result in reduced heat consumption.
Covering the heat loss to the surroundings: The major part of heat losses with the
humid exhaust air from the drying section is compensated by inlet dry air that has to
be heated again. The heat requirements can be reduced by reducing the airflow
through the drying section. This gives also a higher humidity of the outlet air, which
increases the value of air as a source of secondary heat. Heat recovery through heat
exchanger between the outlet humid air and the inlet dry air reduces also the heat
consumption.
Conversion into electric power: An increasing number of mills have installed co-
generation of heat and power plants.
7.5 Energy saving measures
As seen, the papermaking processes can be divided into the main areas: stock
preparation, wet end, dry end including pressing and coating (optional). These can
be further sub-divided into main process units. Table 7.5 shows the role of energy in
each process and the potential for energy savings in these stages.
For a non-integrated paper mill using chemical pulp, refining (as part of the stock
preparation) will represent the largest use of electrical energy (drying being the
largest use of heat). The electrical energy used in refining is usually in the range
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
50
between 100 and 500 kWh/t for most papers but can be up to 3000 kWh/t for
speciality papers. Practically all of the energy input to this refining will be turned into
heat and there is no option here for energy recovery although this heat generated
contributes to the elevated temperature sought in the process.
The potential for energy savings will be high in many cases. For example, many
refiners are incorrectly sized or not well maintained and this results in a high no load
power, which reduces refiner efficiency. Incorrect refiner fillings will cause an
increased use of energy to achieve a given property. New refiners with enhanced
efficiency can also save energy because of the very low no load power associated
with this type of refiner.
Main processes
Main process units Type and role of energy in each process
Potential for energy saving
Stock preparation
Slushing Up to 60 kWh power /t to break up dry pulp Moderate
Cleaning/screening The amount of pumping energy and stock heating depend on the number of stages required and they type of fibre (recycled fibre needs more than virgin); About 5 kWh/t is used for virgin stock
Low for virgin fiber
Refining Very energy intensive. Electrical energy is mostly used to drive the rotor in the refiner. Depends strongly on the paper properties to be achieved; 100 - 3000 kWh/t
High
Wet end Forming and draining
It uses large amounts of electricity for machine drive and vacuum processes. Energy efficient design of the headbox and twin wire machine leads to power savings; About 70 kWh/t is used for vacuum systems (varies with grade and porosity)
Moderate
Dry end Pressing It is not energy intensive in itself but efficient dewatering can give very large energy savings in the dryers
Moderate
Drying Apart from refining it is the most energy intensive process in papermaking. Mostly heat energy
Very high
Size press and 2nd dryer section
Heat energy for after size press drying low
Calendering Electrical energy for machine drives and pressing
low
Coating Coating and dryer Electrical and heat energy for re-drying low Table 7.5: Role of energy in the main papermaking stages and potentials for
improvement
Electricity
For a very detailed discussion on the consumption of electricity in paper mills and the
technical background that build the basis for improvements and the application of
energy efficient technologies it is recommended to study the relevant chapters of the
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
51
BAT report on pulp and paper industry of the EU (see list of references and links at
the end of this report).
Heat recovery
The purpose of the heat recovery system is to lower the mill's consumption of primary
energy by utilising waste energy from the process in an economically profitable way.
Nearly all the heat energy consumed in a paper mill is used for paper drying, making
the dryer section easily the biggest energy consumer in a paper machine. Roughly
80% of the energy needed in the dryer section is brought as primary steam to the
dryer cylinders, the rest coming as drying and leakage air and with the paper web.
Nearly all energy leaving the dryer section is exhausted with the exhaust air. About
50% of this energy i.e. something like 620 kWh per ton of paper can be recovered by
an efficient heat recovery system (at winter conditions).
Typical applications are using either air-to-air heat exchangers or air-to-water heat
exchangers both of plate design (some applications use also scrubbers). The former
is mainly used for heating hood supply air and machine room ventilation air. The
most common application for the latter is the heating of circulation water and process
water respectively. These heat exchangers are part of heat recovery towers. In
Figure 7.5 an example is given for combined heat recovery where first the hood air
supply and secondly the circulation water is heated.
Figure 7.5: Example for a heat recovery tower
Usually only part of the heat recovered is led back to the dryer section with the hood
supply air. Most is used outside the dryer section to heat process water, wire pit
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
52
water and machine room ventilation air.
For a very detailed discussion of this topic it is recommended to study the relevant
chapters of the BAT report on pulp and paper industry of the EU (see list of
references and links at the end of this report).
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
53
8 Integrated pulp and paper mills
8.1 Processes
An integrated pulp and paper mill is an operation where both main processes, the
pulping and the papermaking, are integrated at one production site.
In consequence the processes and technologies which were discussed above are
combined in various ways according to the specific raw materials in use and
manufactured products.
8.2 Energy use and energy benchmarks
Integrated mills can be more energy efficient than stand-alone mills, as no drying
energy is needed for the intermediate drying of the pulp. This will result in energy
savings at the pulp mill. Furthermore, process integration of the different processes
may result in a further optimization of the steam use on site. Finally, while stand-
alone pulp mills may have excess steam that cannot be used (due to black/green
liquor recovery or from heat recovery of the TMP), an integrated mill can use this
excess heat to serve the additional heat use of the paper machine.
8.3 Energy saving measures
Please refer to the distinct processes and technologies which have been discussed
before and which will constitute an integrated pulp and paper mill.
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
54
9 Worldbest practice and energy benchmarks
The following tables show the international best practice values of energy intensity in
the pulp and paper industry. The values have been compiled from mainly North
American and European experiences (taken from a study by Ernst Worrell at all,
2007). Energy values are given for final energy use only; for the adequate numbers
of gross energy (primary energy) the conversion factors for electricity generation
could be considered and self calculated.
The tables below respect the frequent practice and numbers are given separately for
• Integrated pulp and paper mills (comparing wood and recovered paper)
• Stand-alone pulp mills (comparing different technologies)
• Stand-alone paper mills (comparing different grades of papers)
Please note that these reported benchmarks are only indicating a direction of
potential improvements and that the individual conditions of a specific plant might be
very diverse from these numbers.
Table 9.1. World Best Practice Final Energy Intensity Values for Stand-Alone Pulp Mills (values are per air dried metric tons)
Raw Product Process Fuel Use for Steam Steam Exported Electricity Electricity Total
Use Produced Material
GJ/ADt kgce/ADt GJ/ADt kgce/ADt kWh/ADt kWh/ADt GJ/ADt kgce/ADt
Non-wood Market Pulp Pulping 10.5 358 -4.2 -143 400 7.7 264
Wood Market Pulp Kraft 11.2 382 640 -655 11.1 380
Sulfite 16 546 700 18.5 632
Thermo-mechanical -1.3 -45 2190 6.6 224
Paper Recovered
Pulp
0.3 10
330
1.5 51
Table 9.2. World Best Practice Final Energy Intensity Values for Stand-Alone Paper Mills (values are per air dried metric tons)
Fuel Use for Steam Electricity Use Total Raw Material Product Process
GJ/ADt kgce/ADt kWh/ADt GJ/ADt kgce/ADt
Pulp Uncoated Fine (wood free) Paper Machine 6.7 229 640 9.0 307
Coated Fine (wood free) Paper Machine 7.5 256 810 10.4 355
Newsprint Paper Machine 5.1 174 570 7.2 244
Board Paper Machine 6.7 229 800 9.6 327
Kraftliner Paper Machine 5.9 201 535 7.8 267
Tissue Paper Machine 6.9 235 1000 10.5 358
Table 9.3. World Best Practice Final Energy Intensity Values for Integrated Pulp and Paper Mills (values are per air dried metric tons)
Fuel Use for Steam Electricity Total Raw
Material
Product Process
GJ/ADt kgce/ADt kWh/ADt GJ/ADt kgce/ADt
Bleached Uncoated
Fine Kraft 14 478 1200 18.3 625
Kraftliner
(unbleached) and
Bag Paper
Kraft 14 478 1000 17.6 601
Bleached Coated
Fine Sulfite 17 580 1500 22.4 765
Bleached Uncoated
Fine Sulfite 18 614 1200 22.3 762
Newsprint TMP -1.3 -44 2200 6.6 226
Magazine Paper TMP -0.3 -10 2100 7.3 248
Wood
Board 50%
TMP 3.5 119 2300 11.8 402
Recovered
Paper
Board (no de-
inking)
8 273 900 11.2 384
Newsprint (de-
inked)
4 137 1000 7.6 259
Tissue (de-inked) 7 239 1200 11.3 386
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
57
10 Model case benchmarks
The Pulp and Paper Technical Association of Canada, which is one of the leading
institutes for this sector, performed in 2002 a model case study on “Energy and Cost
Reduction in the Pulp and Paper industry – A Benchmarking Perspective”. The
complete study can be downloaded from the internet for free (see references and
links).
The purpose of this study was to discus the motivation for developing an energy
efficiency program for the industry. In particular, it addresses two questions:
1. What is the potential for energy use reduction in pulp and paper mills?
2. How can this potential energy use reduction be achieved?
Benchmarking provides a means to determine the potential for energy reduction. A
benchmarking study is a comparison of the competitive situation among similar types
of mills producing the same product. The energy use for a particular mill can be
compared with that for similar mills or with that for a model mill representing the
current best practice.
To illustrate the potential to reduce energy consumption and greenhouse gas (GHG)
emissions, benchmarking studies were performed for the two largest production
segments of the Canadian pulp and paper industry:
• Kraft market pulp
The model kraft market pulp mill produces fully bleached market pulp from
wood chips transported from local sawmills. It utilizes the most energy-
efficient unit operations that have been proven technically feasible. The power
boiler uses hog fuel, and condensing-extracting steam turbines are used to
produce electricity. The total liquid effluent from the mill would be
approximately 35 m3/Airdried tonne (ADt).
• Newsprint
The model newsprint mill consists of a pulp mill and paper machine along with
an effluent treatment facility. The fibre furnish for a modern newsprint mill
would consist of thermomechanical pulp (TMP) and/or recycled fibre
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
58
depending on the fibre availability and market requirements.
In each case the energy consumption for a modern mill was determined using current
proven technology and compared with that for existing Canadian mills.
The authors draw the conclusions that there is considerable potential for energy use
reduction in pulp and paper mills.
• The model kraft mill can be operated with 9.9 GJ/ADt process steam, 1.2
GJ/ADt process fossil fuel and 578 kWh/ADt process electricity. The process
steam and electricity demands can be met by burning the spent pulping liquor
and the hog fuel associated with the chip supply. Thus, the only purchased
energy is the 1.2 GJ/ADt of fossil fuel needed for the lime kiln. The average
existing kraft mill, however, purchases considerably more energy: 5.99
GJ/ADt of fossil fuel and 272 kWh/ADt of electricity.
• The model newsprint mill had a fibre furnish of 80 percent TMP and 20
percent DIP. It can be operated with 0.2 GJ/ADt steam and 2430 kWh/ADt
electricity. The main steam demands are provided internally by heat recovery
from the refiner steam. The purchased energy is primarily electricity, 2430
kWh/ADt, with only 0.8 GJ/ADt fossil fuel needed for the continuous steam
demand of 0.2 GJ/ADt and to provide backup steam during upset conditions
in the TMP mill. The average existing newsprint mill purchases 2850 kWh/ADt
electricity and considerably more steam and fossil fuel, 4.46 GJ/ADt.
Pulp and Paper Industry – A Reference Book for the Industry
59
11 References and Links
BEST AVAILABLE TECHNIQUES FOR THE PULP AND PAPER INDUSTRY, CEMBUREAU 2000 http://www.cembureau.be/Documents/Publications/CEMBUREAU_BAT_Reference_Document_2000-03.pdf
"Environmental Comparison of Bleached Kraft Pulp ManufacturingTechnologies"
World Best Practice Energy Intensity Values for Selected Industrial Sectors - Ernst Worrell, Maarten Neelis - Environmental Energy Technologies Division, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, 2007 - http://ies.lbl.gov/iespubs/62806.pdf
Energy and Cost Reduction in the Pulp and Paper industry – A Benchmarking Perspective, Canada 2002 http://oee.nrcan.gc.ca/publications/infosource/pub/cipec/pulp-paper-industry/pdf/pulp-paper-industry.pdf
More information can be found by searching the cited links.
http://www.paperonweb.com/pmake.htm
http://www.paperonline.org/history
http://inventors.about.com/library/inventors/blpapermaking.htm#general
http://www.environmentaldefense.org/pdf.cfm?ContentID=1626&FileName=WP5.pdf.
http://www.hurterconsult.com/nonwood_uses.htm (non-wood pulping)
http://www.chempolis.com/index.html (non-wood pulping)