24
Protea PR & Crisis Advisors University of Cape Town BRAD SARAH JOY MARCIA – MAGGI NOODLES

ProteaPR&CrisisAdvisors - mbacasecomp.com€¦ · How%should%Maggi%noodles%proceed%to%regain%its%preQfiasco%market’share? ... Situaonal%Analysis%on%Maggi%Brand% ... instore$and$10%$price$

  • Upload
    ngocong

  • View
    234

  • Download
    6

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: ProteaPR&CrisisAdvisors - mbacasecomp.com€¦ · How%should%Maggi%noodles%proceed%to%regain%its%preQfiasco%market’share? ... Situaonal%Analysis%on%Maggi%Brand% ... instore$and$10%$price$

Protea  PR  &  Crisis  Advisors  University  of  Cape  Town BRAD     SARAH      JOY     MARCIA  –  MAGGI  NOODLES

Page 2: ProteaPR&CrisisAdvisors - mbacasecomp.com€¦ · How%should%Maggi%noodles%proceed%to%regain%its%preQfiasco%market’share? ... Situaonal%Analysis%on%Maggi%Brand% ... instore$and$10%$price$

IntroducBon BRAD  –  MAGGI  NOODLES

Protea  PR  &  Crisis  Advisors  

Page 3: ProteaPR&CrisisAdvisors - mbacasecomp.com€¦ · How%should%Maggi%noodles%proceed%to%regain%its%preQfiasco%market’share? ... Situaonal%Analysis%on%Maggi%Brand% ... instore$and$10%$price$

Your  Current  Situa-on  and  Our  Mandate  Protea  PR  &  Crisis  Advisors  

June  2015  

Aug  2015  

Oct  2015  

Nov  2015  

MSG  Found  in  Gorakhpur    Lead  content  exceeds  limits  Recall  in  U<ar  Pradesh  State  bans  FSSA  range  recall  

New  CEO  Nostalgia  Media  Campaign  

Court  led  lab  test  approved  

Relaunch  

Today  

EscalaEon  

How  do  we  return  Maggie  to  same  Market  Share  and  same  Margins?  

Take  Control:  Quick,  admission,  align  values  and  concerns.  Recall.  Provide  Eme  lines.    

24%  of  NIL  Business  $88  million  quarterly  loss  Net  Margin  decline  to  -­‐3.3%  

Page 4: ProteaPR&CrisisAdvisors - mbacasecomp.com€¦ · How%should%Maggi%noodles%proceed%to%regain%its%preQfiasco%market’share? ... Situaonal%Analysis%on%Maggi%Brand% ... instore$and$10%$price$

Key  Issues  Protea  PR  &  Crisis  Advisors  

Reputa-onal  Damage:  Trust  regarding  health  and  safety  

Consequen-al  Financial  Strain    

Compe-tors  Rising  

1  

2  

3  

Page 5: ProteaPR&CrisisAdvisors - mbacasecomp.com€¦ · How%should%Maggi%noodles%proceed%to%regain%its%preQfiasco%market’share? ... Situaonal%Analysis%on%Maggi%Brand% ... instore$and$10%$price$

Recommenda-ons:  Three  Pronged  Communica-ons  Strategy  

Protea  PR  &  Crisis  Advisors  

1.  B2C:  Customer  

2.  B2B:  Retailers   3.  Press  

Page 6: ProteaPR&CrisisAdvisors - mbacasecomp.com€¦ · How%should%Maggi%noodles%proceed%to%regain%its%preQfiasco%market’share? ... Situaonal%Analysis%on%Maggi%Brand% ... instore$and$10%$price$

Protea  PR  &  Crisis  Advisors  

Required  Responses  

How  should  Maggi  noodles  proceed  to  regain  its  pre-­‐fiasco  market  share?  

What  should  be  NIL’s  communicaEon  strategy  to  win  its  customers  back?    

How  should  NIL  address  the  challenges  posed  by  compeEtors  who  have  gained  ground  over  the  last  few  months?  

How  to  ensure  that  no  permanent  damage  is  caused  by  the  controversy?  

What  should  have  been  it’s  corporate  communicaEon  strategy  aYer  the  crisis  broke  out?  

Quality  control  or  crisis  control?    What  makes  more  sense  at  this  hour?  

1  

2  

3  

4  

5  

6  

Page 7: ProteaPR&CrisisAdvisors - mbacasecomp.com€¦ · How%should%Maggi%noodles%proceed%to%regain%its%preQfiasco%market’share? ... Situaonal%Analysis%on%Maggi%Brand% ... instore$and$10%$price$

Current  State  Analysis SARAH  –  MAGGI  NOODLES

Protea  PR  &  Crisis  Advisors  

Page 8: ProteaPR&CrisisAdvisors - mbacasecomp.com€¦ · How%should%Maggi%noodles%proceed%to%regain%its%preQfiasco%market’share? ... Situaonal%Analysis%on%Maggi%Brand% ... instore$and$10%$price$

Situa-onal  Analysis  on  Maggi  Brand  Protea  PR  &  Crisis  Advisors  

STRENGTHS   WEAKNESSES  

 Brand  

Convenience  Kids  love  it  Staple  food  

Brand  por[olio    

 Reputa-onal  damage  Financial  performance  Product  loss  write-­‐offs  

Ini-al  response  Damaged  retailer  rela-onships  

OPPORTUNITIES   THREATS  

 Rebuild  trust  New  CEO,  local  

 

 Compe-tor  ramp  up  

Customers  switching  brands    

Page 9: ProteaPR&CrisisAdvisors - mbacasecomp.com€¦ · How%should%Maggi%noodles%proceed%to%regain%its%preQfiasco%market’share? ... Situaonal%Analysis%on%Maggi%Brand% ... instore$and$10%$price$

Financial  Impact  on  Maggi  Brand  Protea  PR  &  Crisis  Advisors  

Before  (2014)  

90%  market  share  

24%  of  top  line  ($89m)  

AYer  (2015)  

??  on  market  share  (Yippee  &  Patanjali)  

1st  quarter  loss  in  17  years  

Top  line  fell  20%  Profits  loss  of  ($9.8m)    

Page 10: ProteaPR&CrisisAdvisors - mbacasecomp.com€¦ · How%should%Maggi%noodles%proceed%to%regain%its%preQfiasco%market’share? ... Situaonal%Analysis%on%Maggi%Brand% ... instore$and$10%$price$

The  Maggi  Customer  Protea  PR  &  Crisis  Advisors  

•  Purchasing  for  kids  •  Care  about  food  safety  and  trusted    brand  

•  Not  actually  the  consumer,  purchasing  decision-­‐maker  

The  Maggi  Mom  

•  Convenience,  on-­‐shelf,  accessible  •  Purchasing  and  consuming  Bachelors  &  

Students  

Page 11: ProteaPR&CrisisAdvisors - mbacasecomp.com€¦ · How%should%Maggi%noodles%proceed%to%regain%its%preQfiasco%market’share? ... Situaonal%Analysis%on%Maggi%Brand% ... instore$and$10%$price$

RecommendaBons BRAD  –  MAGGI  NOODLES

Protea  PR  &  Crisis  Advisors  

Page 12: ProteaPR&CrisisAdvisors - mbacasecomp.com€¦ · How%should%Maggi%noodles%proceed%to%regain%its%preQfiasco%market’share? ... Situaonal%Analysis%on%Maggi%Brand% ... instore$and$10%$price$

Recommenda-ons:  Three  Pronged  Communica-ons  Strategy  

Protea  PR  &  Crisis  Advisors  

1.  B2C:  Customer  

• Admission  and  Apologe-c  

• Align  values  • Tangible  health  “badging”  

•  In-­‐store  support  and  couponing.    

2.  B2B:  Retailers  

•  Leverage  power  of  Nestle  brand  

• Nego-ate  POS  and  Gondola  Ends  

3.  Press  

• Control  the  message  

• Detailed  and  forthright  about  opera-onal  quality  control  measures  taken    

Page 13: ProteaPR&CrisisAdvisors - mbacasecomp.com€¦ · How%should%Maggi%noodles%proceed%to%regain%its%preQfiasco%market’share? ... Situaonal%Analysis%on%Maggi%Brand% ... instore$and$10%$price$

ImplementaBon MARCIA  –  MAGGI  NOODLES

Protea  PR  &  Crisis  Advisors  

Page 14: ProteaPR&CrisisAdvisors - mbacasecomp.com€¦ · How%should%Maggi%noodles%proceed%to%regain%its%preQfiasco%market’share? ... Situaonal%Analysis%on%Maggi%Brand% ... instore$and$10%$price$

Implementa-on  Overview    Protea  PR  &  Crisis  Advisors  

0  to  1  Week   1  Week  to  2  Months  

2  Months  to  Six  Months  

1.  Press  Release  

2.  Consumer  led  brand  campaign  

         -­‐  TV  tag  on  

         -­‐  Instore  Ac-va-on  

         -­‐  Sampling  

         -­‐  Pack  Revisions  

         -­‐  Product  Bundling  

3.  Retailer  Brand  Campaign  

         -­‐  POS  

         -­‐  TV  Promo  

         -­‐  Cross  Category  Bundling  

Page 15: ProteaPR&CrisisAdvisors - mbacasecomp.com€¦ · How%should%Maggi%noodles%proceed%to%regain%its%preQfiasco%market’share? ... Situaonal%Analysis%on%Maggi%Brand% ... instore$and$10%$price$

Consumer  Brand  Campaign  Protea  PR  &  Crisis  Advisors  

Consumer  Brand  

Campaign  

TV  

Instore  Top  500  Stores  

Indian  FDA  

Approval  

Pack  Revision  

Product  Bundling  

We  value  your  family’s  health  as  much  as  you  do  

Sampling    Promotor  ladies  

Maggie  category  leaders  

Page 16: ProteaPR&CrisisAdvisors - mbacasecomp.com€¦ · How%should%Maggi%noodles%proceed%to%regain%its%preQfiasco%market’share? ... Situaonal%Analysis%on%Maggi%Brand% ... instore$and$10%$price$

Retailer  Campaign  Protea  PR  &  Crisis  Advisors  

Retailer  Campaign  

POS  

TV  Promos  

Product  Bunding  

Cross-­‐Merchandising  

Gondola  Ends  

DirecAng  consumers  instore  and  10%  price  discounts  

Kids  aFernoon  snacks  

Page 17: ProteaPR&CrisisAdvisors - mbacasecomp.com€¦ · How%should%Maggi%noodles%proceed%to%regain%its%preQfiasco%market’share? ... Situaonal%Analysis%on%Maggi%Brand% ... instore$and$10%$price$

Financial  ConsideraBons JOY  –  MAGGI  NOODLES

Protea  PR  &  Crisis  Advisors  

Page 18: ProteaPR&CrisisAdvisors - mbacasecomp.com€¦ · How%should%Maggi%noodles%proceed%to%regain%its%preQfiasco%market’share? ... Situaonal%Analysis%on%Maggi%Brand% ... instore$and$10%$price$

US$  0-­‐1  week   1wk-­‐2months   2-­‐6months  

Press  Release   X  Customer  messaging  Brand  campaign   2  000  000  TV  -­‐  tag  on   750  000  In  store  ac-va-on   1  350  000  Sampling   1  500  000  Supplier  QC   1  200  000  Product  bundling   650  000  Pack  revision   100  000  B2B  retailer  POS  in  store   500  000  TV  promo   1  500  000  

Total  cost   US$  9.5  million  

Implementa-on  Budget  

Page 19: ProteaPR&CrisisAdvisors - mbacasecomp.com€¦ · How%should%Maggi%noodles%proceed%to%regain%its%preQfiasco%market’share? ... Situaonal%Analysis%on%Maggi%Brand% ... instore$and$10%$price$

250  

270  

290  

310  

330  

350  

370  

390  

410  Mar-­‐15  

Apr-­‐15  

May-­‐15  

Jun-­‐15  

Jul-­‐1

5  

Aug-­‐15  

Sep-­‐15  

Oct-­‐15  

Nov-­‐15  

Dec-­‐15

 

Jan-­‐16  

Feb-­‐16  

Mar-­‐16  

Apr-­‐16  

May-­‐16  

Jun-­‐16  

Jul-­‐1

6  

Aug-­‐16  

Sep-­‐16  

Oct-­‐16  

Nov-­‐16  

Dec-­‐16

 

US$  m

illions  

Forecasted  Revenue  Recovery  

Page 20: ProteaPR&CrisisAdvisors - mbacasecomp.com€¦ · How%should%Maggi%noodles%proceed%to%regain%its%preQfiasco%market’share? ... Situaonal%Analysis%on%Maggi%Brand% ... instore$and$10%$price$

Conclusion BRAD  –  MAGGI  NOODLES

Protea  PR  &  Crisis  Advisors  

Page 21: ProteaPR&CrisisAdvisors - mbacasecomp.com€¦ · How%should%Maggi%noodles%proceed%to%regain%its%preQfiasco%market’share? ... Situaonal%Analysis%on%Maggi%Brand% ... instore$and$10%$price$

Key  Issues  Protea  PR  &  Crisis  Advisors  

Reputa-onal  Damage:  Trust  regarding  health  and  safety  

Consequen-al  Financial  Strain    

Compe-tors  Rising  

1  

2  

3  

Page 22: ProteaPR&CrisisAdvisors - mbacasecomp.com€¦ · How%should%Maggi%noodles%proceed%to%regain%its%preQfiasco%market’share? ... Situaonal%Analysis%on%Maggi%Brand% ... instore$and$10%$price$

Recommenda-ons:  Three  Pronged  Communica-ons  Strategy  

Protea  PR  &  Crisis  Advisors  

1.  B2C:  Customer  

• Admission  and  Apologe-c  

• Align  values  • Tangible  health  “badging”  

•  In-­‐store  support  and  couponing.    

2.  B2B:  Retailers  

•  Leverage  power  of  Nestle  brand  

• Nego-ate  POS  and  Gondola  Ends  

3.  Press  

• Control  the  message  

• Detailed  and  forthright  about  opera-onal  quality  control  measures  taken    

Page 23: ProteaPR&CrisisAdvisors - mbacasecomp.com€¦ · How%should%Maggi%noodles%proceed%to%regain%its%preQfiasco%market’share? ... Situaonal%Analysis%on%Maggi%Brand% ... instore$and$10%$price$

Protea  PR  &  Crisis  Advisors  

Required  Responses  

How  should  Maggi  noodles  proceed  to  regain  its  pre-­‐fiasco  market  share?  

What  should  be  NIL’s  communicaEon  strategy  to  win  its  customers  back?    

How  should  NIL  address  the  challenges  posed  by  compeEtors  who  have  gained  ground  over  the  last  few  months?  

How  to  ensure  that  no  permanent  damage  is  caused  by  the  controversy?  

What  should  have  been  it’s  corporate  communicaEon  strategy  aYer  the  crisis  broke  out?  

Quality  control  or  crisis  control?    What  makes  more  sense  at  this  hour?  

1  

2  

3  

4  

5  

6  

Win  back  consumer  trust  and  retailer  rela-onships  

Three  -er  communica-ons  strategy    

Brand  messaging  and  purchase  and  retrial  incen-vizing  

Take  control  of  press  messaging  

Discussed  in  introduc-on.    

Both  and  more.  Post  crisis  re-­‐messaging.    

Page 24: ProteaPR&CrisisAdvisors - mbacasecomp.com€¦ · How%should%Maggi%noodles%proceed%to%regain%its%preQfiasco%market’share? ... Situaonal%Analysis%on%Maggi%Brand% ... instore$and$10%$price$

Thank  you.  Q&A.   PROTEA  PR  CONSULTANTS  –  MAGGI  NOODLES

Protea  PR  &  Crisis  Advisors