24
02/10/14 | Dominik Kraus | NIF and JLF User Group Meeting 2014 | 1 Probing matter at Gbar pressures at the NIF Dominik Kraus Department of Physics University of California, Berkeley T. Doeppner, A. L. Kritcher, D. C. Swift, J. Hawreliak, D. Chapman, B. Bachmann, P. M. Celliers, G. W. Collins, T. Darling, E. Dewald, J. Eggert, L. B. Fletcher, E. Foerster, D.O. Gericke, S.H. Glenzer, S. Hamel, R. Hemley, R. Jeanloz, O. L. Landen, H. J. Lee, S. LePape, T. Ma, E. McKee, D. Milathianaki, J. Nilsen, P. Neumayer, R. Redmer, S. Rose, S. Rothman, C. Keane, and R. W. Falcone 02/10/14 | Dominik Kraus | NIF and JLF User Group Meeting 2014 | 1

Probing matter at Gbar pressures at the NIF...temperature: - Fitting slope with LTE bremsstrahlung spectrum ~ exp(-hν/kT e): T e=400 eV- Fitting slope with Planck spectrum ~ ν3 exp(-hν/kT

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Probing matter at Gbar pressures at the NIF...temperature: - Fitting slope with LTE bremsstrahlung spectrum ~ exp(-hν/kT e): T e=400 eV- Fitting slope with Planck spectrum ~ ν3 exp(-hν/kT

02/10/14 | Dominik Kraus | NIF and JLF User Group Meeting 2014 | 1

Probing matter at Gbar pressures at the NIF

Dominik Kraus Department of Physics

University of California, Berkeley T. Doeppner, A. L. Kritcher, D. C. Swift, J. Hawreliak, D. Chapman, B. Bachmann,

P. M. Celliers, G. W. Collins, T. Darling, E. Dewald, J. Eggert, L. B. Fletcher, E. Foerster, D.O. Gericke, S.H. Glenzer, S. Hamel, R. Hemley, R. Jeanloz, O. L. Landen, H. J. Lee, S. LePape,

T. Ma, E. McKee, D. Milathianaki, J. Nilsen, P. Neumayer, R. Redmer, S. Rose, S. Rothman, C. Keane, and R. W. Falcone

02/10/14 | Dominik Kraus | NIF and JLF User Group Meeting 2014 | 1

Page 2: Probing matter at Gbar pressures at the NIF...temperature: - Fitting slope with LTE bremsstrahlung spectrum ~ exp(-hν/kT e): T e=400 eV- Fitting slope with Planck spectrum ~ ν3 exp(-hν/kT

02/10/14 | Dominik Kraus | NIF and JLF User Group Meeting 2014 | 2

Matter at Gbar pressure | Challenges and applications

ICF Plasmas at NIF!

Brown Dwarfs!

-  Interplay of Coulomb pressure and

electron-degeneracy pressure

-  Partial ionization, shell effects

-  Difficult description of compressibility and heat capacity

W. B. Hubbard et al, Physics of Plasmas 4, 2011 (1997)

Page 3: Probing matter at Gbar pressures at the NIF...temperature: - Fitting slope with LTE bremsstrahlung spectrum ~ exp(-hν/kT e): T e=400 eV- Fitting slope with Planck spectrum ~ ν3 exp(-hν/kT

02/10/14 | Dominik Kraus | NIF and JLF User Group Meeting 2014 | 3

Matter at Gbar pressure | Shell effects: heat capacity of aluminum

J. C. Pain, HEDP 3, 204 (2007)

Page 4: Probing matter at Gbar pressures at the NIF...temperature: - Fitting slope with LTE bremsstrahlung spectrum ~ exp(-hν/kT e): T e=400 eV- Fitting slope with Planck spectrum ~ ν3 exp(-hν/kT

02/10/14 | Dominik Kraus | NIF and JLF User Group Meeting 2014 | 4

Matter at Gbar pressure | Shell effects: Aluminum Hugoniot

J. C. Pain, HEDP 3, 204 (2007)

Page 5: Probing matter at Gbar pressures at the NIF...temperature: - Fitting slope with LTE bremsstrahlung spectrum ~ exp(-hν/kT e): T e=400 eV- Fitting slope with Planck spectrum ~ ν3 exp(-hν/kT

02/10/14 | Dominik Kraus | NIF and JLF User Group Meeting 2014 | 5

2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5

10−3

10−2

10−1

100

101

mass density [g/cm3]

pre

ssure

[G

bar]

SESAME #7592Cauble et al.Barrios et al.Ozaki et al.

Matter at Gbar pressure | CH Hugoniot & shell structure

PP0~ r−1

Page 6: Probing matter at Gbar pressures at the NIF...temperature: - Fitting slope with LTE bremsstrahlung spectrum ~ exp(-hν/kT e): T e=400 eV- Fitting slope with Planck spectrum ~ ν3 exp(-hν/kT

02/10/14 | Dominik Kraus | NIF and JLF User Group Meeting 2014 | 6

3.3-mm- diameter large LEH"

Solid  CH  or  CD  spheres  with  Ge  preheat  shield  

Streaked Radiography"

X-ray Scattering"

Zn foil"9 kev line emission"

Au shield "

"Au Hohlraum"(5.75 x 9.42 mm)"Fill: 0.96 mg/cc "4He "

Modified existing NIF platform (1D Convergent Ablator) Main diagnostics: -  Streaked X-ray radiography

(shock speed, mass density)

-  X-ray Thomson scattering(electron temperature)

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

0

10

20

-2 0 2 4 6 8 10 12

Laser pulse shapes for F_Gbar_Gbar_AAA

inner (TW)

total (TW)

outer (TW)

Backlighter (TW)

La

se

r P

ow

er

(TW

)

Ba

ck

ligh

ter B

ea

ms

(TW

)

Time (ns)

Laser    pulse  shapes  

Time  (ns)  Po

wer  (T

W)  

Experimental setup | X-ray radiography and scattering

Page 7: Probing matter at Gbar pressures at the NIF...temperature: - Fitting slope with LTE bremsstrahlung spectrum ~ exp(-hν/kT e): T e=400 eV- Fitting slope with Planck spectrum ~ ν3 exp(-hν/kT

02/10/14 | Dominik Kraus | NIF and JLF User Group Meeting 2014 | 7

Experimental setup | Target design

Zn backlighter foil

Au radiation shield

Rout = 1150 µm

CH (PaMS)

CH (GDP)

CH + 0.5% Ge

CH + 1% Ge

CH + 0.5% Ge

965 µm

capsule design with graded Ge dopant layer

Page 8: Probing matter at Gbar pressures at the NIF...temperature: - Fitting slope with LTE bremsstrahlung spectrum ~ exp(-hν/kT e): T e=400 eV- Fitting slope with Planck spectrum ~ ν3 exp(-hν/kT

02/10/14 | Dominik Kraus | NIF and JLF User Group Meeting 2014 | 8

Simulations | Parameter space

A. L. Kritcher et al., HEDP 10, 27 (2014)

Pressure  at  shock  front  

Page 9: Probing matter at Gbar pressures at the NIF...temperature: - Fitting slope with LTE bremsstrahlung spectrum ~ exp(-hν/kT e): T e=400 eV- Fitting slope with Planck spectrum ~ ν3 exp(-hν/kT

02/10/14 | Dominik Kraus | NIF and JLF User Group Meeting 2014 | 9

X-ray radiography | Raw data

N130701  N130103  

'me  

Self emission at 25.27±0.06 ns

January 03, 2013

July 01, 2013

radius  (mm)  

Time  (ns)  

6  

4  

8  

10  

2  0  0.5   0.5  1.0   1.0  

N130701  

22  

20  

24  

26  

18  

Time  (ns)  

radius  (mm)  0  0.5   0.5  1.0   1.0  

Page 10: Probing matter at Gbar pressures at the NIF...temperature: - Fitting slope with LTE bremsstrahlung spectrum ~ exp(-hν/kT e): T e=400 eV- Fitting slope with Planck spectrum ~ ν3 exp(-hν/kT

02/10/14 | Dominik Kraus | NIF and JLF User Group Meeting 2014 | 10

X-ray radiography | Analysis

-  Profile matching to infer µ(r) = ρ(r) σ(r)

-  Movement of shock front with time gives shock velocity

-  After shock passes marker layer, enclosed mass between shock front and marker layer is known

-  Assuming constant density and constant opacity for first time step after passing marker layer: simultaneous density and opacity unfold

-  As shock propagates: Using relative comparison to the first time step after passing the marker layer gives full density and opacity profile

D. C. Swift et al., in prep.

shock front

Ge marker

Page 11: Probing matter at Gbar pressures at the NIF...temperature: - Fitting slope with LTE bremsstrahlung spectrum ~ exp(-hν/kT e): T e=400 eV- Fitting slope with Planck spectrum ~ ν3 exp(-hν/kT

02/10/14 | Dominik Kraus | NIF and JLF User Group Meeting 2014 | 11

X-ray radiography | Results

T. Doeppner et al., in prep.

Inferred opacity

Hugoniot data

2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5

10−3

10−2

10−1

100

101

mass density [g/cm3]

pre

ssure

[G

bar]

SESAME #7592, 24 KSESAME #7592, 298 KNIF (24 K)NIF (298 K)Cauble et al.Barrios et al.Ozaki et al.

Page 12: Probing matter at Gbar pressures at the NIF...temperature: - Fitting slope with LTE bremsstrahlung spectrum ~ exp(-hν/kT e): T e=400 eV- Fitting slope with Planck spectrum ~ ν3 exp(-hν/kT

02/10/14 | Dominik Kraus | NIF and JLF User Group Meeting 2014 | 12

X-ray scattering | Temperature measurement

-  X-rays are scattered from

plasma electrons

-  Elastic (Rayleigh): scattering from tightly bound electrons or free electrons which dynamically follow the ion motion

-  Inelastic (Compton): scattering from free or weakly bound electrons, mirrors electron velocity distribution ! Te

Page 13: Probing matter at Gbar pressures at the NIF...temperature: - Fitting slope with LTE bremsstrahlung spectrum ~ exp(-hν/kT e): T e=400 eV- Fitting slope with Planck spectrum ~ ν3 exp(-hν/kT

02/10/14 | Dominik Kraus | NIF and JLF User Group Meeting 2014 | 13

Calibration shot

Zn  He-­‐α

Cu  He-­‐α Cu  He-­‐β

Photon energy 7.4  keV 10  keV

Bragg crystal (HOPG)

(10° offset from DIM- axis) Debris shield

Mounts to gated detector

High-efficiency, gated x-ray spectrometer (7.4 – 10 keV)

Filter pack

X-ray scattering | Spectrometer setup

T. Doeppner et al., in prep.

Page 14: Probing matter at Gbar pressures at the NIF...temperature: - Fitting slope with LTE bremsstrahlung spectrum ~ exp(-hν/kT e): T e=400 eV- Fitting slope with Planck spectrum ~ ν3 exp(-hν/kT

02/10/14 | Dominik Kraus | NIF and JLF User Group Meeting 2014 | 14

X-ray scattering | Raw data

time-resolved x-ray spectrum

Kme  

8.85 ns

X-­‐ray  ScaOering  Signal    

Photon  energy  

9.33 ns

Ungated  Hard  x-­‐ray  background  

X-­‐ray  conKnuum    emission  

Zn  source  plasma  and/or  gold  L-­‐shell  emission  

streaked radiograph

space  

Page 15: Probing matter at Gbar pressures at the NIF...temperature: - Fitting slope with LTE bremsstrahlung spectrum ~ exp(-hν/kT e): T e=400 eV- Fitting slope with Planck spectrum ~ ν3 exp(-hν/kT

02/10/14 | Dominik Kraus | NIF and JLF User Group Meeting 2014 | 15

8 8.5 9 9.50

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

Photon Energy [keV]

Sca

ttering in

tensi

ty

r=0.05mmr=0.1mmr=0.2mmr=0.3mmr=0.4mmr=0.5mm

X-ray scattering | Analysis: inhomogeneous sample

Different expected X-ray scattering spectra from different radii

0 200 400 600 800 10000

10

20

30

40

radius [µm]

mass

densi

ty [g/c

c]

mass density

0 200 400 600 800 10000

100

200

300

400

radius [µm]

ele

ctro

n tem

pera

ture

[eV

]

electron temperature

Page 16: Probing matter at Gbar pressures at the NIF...temperature: - Fitting slope with LTE bremsstrahlung spectrum ~ exp(-hν/kT e): T e=400 eV- Fitting slope with Planck spectrum ~ ν3 exp(-hν/kT

02/10/14 | Dominik Kraus | NIF and JLF User Group Meeting 2014 | 16

Kme  

Kme  

X-ray scattering | Analysis: scattering signal weighting

D. Chapman et al., in prep.

y  [µm]  

x  [µm]  

z  [µm]  

to  spectrometer  

9  keV  radiaKon  

Page 17: Probing matter at Gbar pressures at the NIF...temperature: - Fitting slope with LTE bremsstrahlung spectrum ~ exp(-hν/kT e): T e=400 eV- Fitting slope with Planck spectrum ~ ν3 exp(-hν/kT

02/10/14 | Dominik Kraus | NIF and JLF User Group Meeting 2014 | 17

Kme  

Kme  

Full analysis: -  Calculate radial

scattering spectrum for sample conditions

-  Apply weighting maps (3D)

-  Ray-tracing of weighted spectra to detector (3D)

-  Compare result with measured spectrum

X-ray scattering | Analysis: spectrometer ray-tracing

−8 −7 −6 −5 −4 −3 −2 −1 0 1−1

−0.5

0

0.5

1simulated detector image

x [mm]

y [m

m]

8600 8700 8800 8900 9000 9100 92000

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1lineout

photon energy [eV]

inte

nsi

ty [

a.

u.]

point source1 mm spherical plasma

Page 18: Probing matter at Gbar pressures at the NIF...temperature: - Fitting slope with LTE bremsstrahlung spectrum ~ exp(-hν/kT e): T e=400 eV- Fitting slope with Planck spectrum ~ ν3 exp(-hν/kT

02/10/14 | Dominik Kraus | NIF and JLF User Group Meeting 2014 | 18

Kme  

X-ray scattering | Results

8500 8600 8700 8800 8900 9000 9100 9200 93000

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

4x 10

5

photon energy [eV]

inte

nsi

ty

r < 0.12mmr < 0.20mmr < 0.30mmr < 0.40mmr < 0.50mmr < 0.60mmfull sample

8600 8700 8800 8900 9000 9100 92000

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

photon energy [eV]

inte

nsi

ty

measured spectrumcalculation

D. Kraus et al., in prep.

at r = 400 µm (Hydra + SESAME): Te = 60 eV ρ = 5.0 g/cm3 ZC = 3.9

Signal dominated by 300 µm ≤r ≤ 500 µm

Page 19: Probing matter at Gbar pressures at the NIF...temperature: - Fitting slope with LTE bremsstrahlung spectrum ~ exp(-hν/kT e): T e=400 eV- Fitting slope with Planck spectrum ~ ν3 exp(-hν/kT

02/10/14 | Dominik Kraus | NIF and JLF User Group Meeting 2014 | 19

X-ray scattering | Bremsstrahlung continuum

Photon  energy  

X-­‐ray  conKnuum    emission  

-  Slope sensitive to core plasma temperature:

-  Fitting slope with LTE bremsstrahlung spectrum ~ exp(-hν/kTe): Te=400 eV

-  Fitting slope with Planck spectrum

~ ν3 exp(-hν/kTe): Te=350 eV  

0 200 400 600 800 10000

100

200

300

400

radius [µm]

ele

ctro

n tem

pera

ture

[eV

]

electron temperature

7700 7800 7900 8000 810010

7

108

photon energy [eV]

inte

nsi

ty [a. u.]

measured spectrumbremsstrahlung fit

Page 20: Probing matter at Gbar pressures at the NIF...temperature: - Fitting slope with LTE bremsstrahlung spectrum ~ exp(-hν/kT e): T e=400 eV- Fitting slope with Planck spectrum ~ ν3 exp(-hν/kT

02/10/14 | Dominik Kraus | NIF and JLF User Group Meeting 2014 | 20

CD targets | Hotspot ion temperature via DD fusion

We attempted CD experiment with no ablator

solid CD

CH

1150

µm

Capsule design: CD with a graded Ge doped ablator

Rout = 1150 µm

solid CD

CH

CH + 0.5% Ge

CH + 1% Ge

CH + 0.5% Ge 96

5 µm

solid CD

<1um  RMS  

Outgassing caused wrinkles

Page 21: Probing matter at Gbar pressures at the NIF...temperature: - Fitting slope with LTE bremsstrahlung spectrum ~ exp(-hν/kT e): T e=400 eV- Fitting slope with Planck spectrum ~ ν3 exp(-hν/kT

02/10/14 | Dominik Kraus | NIF and JLF User Group Meeting 2014 | 21

CD targets | Hotspot ion temperature via DD fusion

Au  

CD  CD  

He  LEH  

DD  Rate  

Tion  

DD  ra

te  [a.  u.]                T

rad  [A.  U.]    

Laser  P

ower  [A

.U.]    

Time  (ns)  

Hohlraum Component

2   8  4   6  0  

Capsule Component

Page 22: Probing matter at Gbar pressures at the NIF...temperature: - Fitting slope with LTE bremsstrahlung spectrum ~ exp(-hν/kT e): T e=400 eV- Fitting slope with Planck spectrum ~ ν3 exp(-hν/kT

02/10/14 | Dominik Kraus | NIF and JLF User Group Meeting 2014 | 22

CD targets | Hotspot ion temperature via DD fusion

neutron  Time-­‐of-­‐flight  (ns)  

PMT  ou

tput  (V

)  

Preliminary  

Hohlraum: Tion=6(2)keV Yield=1.29(10)e10

Capsule: Tion=0.5(1)keV Yield=0.1(1)e10

n-­‐ToF  Data  2-­‐component  Fit  

§  neutron energy measured through time-of-flight over 18 m

§  neutron energy distribution is Doppler-broadened

Page 23: Probing matter at Gbar pressures at the NIF...temperature: - Fitting slope with LTE bremsstrahlung spectrum ~ exp(-hν/kT e): T e=400 eV- Fitting slope with Planck spectrum ~ ν3 exp(-hν/kT

02/10/14 | Dominik Kraus | NIF and JLF User Group Meeting 2014 | 23

Summary -  Developed and fielded an experimental platform for absolute Hugoniot

measurements up to the 1 Gbar regime -  Developed dedicated tools for data analysis for this very special and

demanding experimental geometry: -  Simultaneous density and opacity unfold of time resolved

radiography images -  3D analysis of X-ray Thomson scattering from inhomogeneous,

mm scale, multi-component dense plasma samples Posters M-15, T-10, T. Doeppner, D. Kraus

-  … -  First two Gbar equation of state experiments measured Hugoniot of

CH up to 720 Mbar Poster T-01, J. Hawreliak

-  Several approaches to experimentally constrain temperature: -  X-ray Thomson scattering (also sensitive to ionization state) -  DD fusion neutron yield -  X-ray self emission spectrum -  X-ray self emission absolute intensity Poster M-04, B. Bachmann

Page 24: Probing matter at Gbar pressures at the NIF...temperature: - Fitting slope with LTE bremsstrahlung spectrum ~ exp(-hν/kT e): T e=400 eV- Fitting slope with Planck spectrum ~ ν3 exp(-hν/kT

02/10/14 | Dominik Kraus | NIF and JLF User Group Meeting 2014 | 24

Outlook

-  Hugoniot measurements at lower pressure (connection to NOVA data)

-  Repeat of CD experiment

-  Further development of temperature diagnostics

-  Apply platform to different materials (HDC, …)

-  Development dedicated NIF platformfor X-ray Thomson scattering