Upload
others
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
1
FOR THE 52 WEEKS ENDED 30 JUNE 2019
2019 GROUP ANNUAL RESULTS
2
AGENDA
1. REVIEW OF THE PERIOD
2. FINANCIAL REVIEW
3. TRUWORTHS ACCOUNTS
4. STRATEGIC FOCUS AREAS
5. OUTLOOK
6. QUESTIONS
REVIEW OF THE PERIOD
4
SOUTH AFRICA TRADING ENVIRONMENT
Difficult trading environment.
GDP growth remained subdued throughout 2018/2019 – South African economy contracted by
3.2% in Q1 of calendar 2019, the biggest quarterly fall since Q1 2009.
Higher fuel and energy prices and volatile Rand.
Unemployment increased in Q2 of calendar 2019 to 29.0%, a 15-year high.
Consumer spending remains constrained.
Consumer confidence improved marginally in Q2 of calendar 2019, but remains lower than 12
months ago.
Business confidence at lowest level in two years.
Loadshedding in November/December 2018 and February/March 2019 impacted negatively on
trading.
5
UNITED KINGDOM TRADING ENVIRONMENT
Consumer confidence has been negative since announcement of Brexit in 2016.
Extremely tough retail environment.
March 2019 Brexit deadline postponed to end October 2019, uncertainty continues.
High street under pressure as growth in sales mainly contributed by online; textile, clothing
and footwear online sales grew 16.8% year-on-year for June 2019.
Continuing decline in retail footfall.
Nearly 1 000 stores affected by 27 retail failures for calendar 2019 to July, many more
impacted by rising number of CVAs.
UK GDP contracted by 0.2% in Q2 of calendar 2019 after 0.5% growth previous quarter and the
lowest since last quarter 2012.
UK unemployment rate lowest since Q4 of calendar 1974.
FINANCIAL REVIEW – GROUP
7
GROUP TRADING OVERVIEW
Non-cash impairment of Office intangibles – £97 million (R1.7 billion).
Improved retail sales growth (3.7%), second half momentum is encouraging.
Gross margin down to 51.6%, led by Office full price versus markdown mix; Truworths
unchanged at 55.5%.
Trading expenses remain well controlled.
Robust balance sheet, 6%* growth in net asset value per share.
Continued strong cash generation – net debt to equity at 7.2% (R663 million).
Healthy cash realisation rate of 93%.
Negotiations with Office lenders ongoing, expected to be concluded satisfactorily.
Bought back 3.75 million shares at total cost of R266 million.
Headline earnings per share down 7%*.
Dividend cover maintained at 1.5 times.
* On a comparable basis, i.e. excluding the Office impairment.
8
GROUP INTEGRATED REPORTING
The Group continues to strive for excellence in integrated reporting.
South African companies are renowned for their high quality of integrated reporting.
In a study by Oxford University Business School in March 2019, South Africa was ranked
first (scoring 2.85 out of 3) for quality of integrated reporting.
Five integrated reports from each of the following countries were assessed: Brazil, France,
Germany, Italy, Japan, The Netherlands, South Africa, South Korea, United Kingdom, and
the United States.
Truworths International’s 2018 integrated report won the JSE Top 40 category in the
JSE/CSSA Integrated Reporting Awards 2018.
The 2018 integrated report was also rated 10th overall (of the JSE top 100 companies)
in the EY Excellence in Integrated Reporting Awards.
Truworths International has been rated in the top 10 for 12 consecutive years, the
only company besides Sasol to be rated in the top 10 for more than ten years.
9
Jun 2019
Including
impairment
Jun 2019
Comparable*
Jun 2019
Targets
Gross margin (%) 51.6 51.6 51 – 55
Operating margin (%) 9.1 19.4 19 – 24
Return on equity (%) 9 23 23 – 28
Return on assets (%) 12 23 20 – 25
Inventory turn (times) 4.2 4.2 3.5 – 4.5
Asset turnover (times) 1.4 1.2 0.9 – 1.3
GROUP PERFORMANCE AGAINST TARGETS
* On a comparable basis, i.e. excluding the Office impairment and reclassification of interest in terms of IFRS 9 in the current period, as well as foreign exchange gains and losses in both periods.
10
Jun 2019
Including
impairment
Jun 2019
Comparable*
Jun 2018
Change on
prior period
%
Change on
comparable
prior period*
%
Sale of merchandise (Rm) 18 094 18 094 17 547 3 3
Gross margin (%) 51.6 51.6 52.4
Trading profit (Rm) 492 2 245 2 518 (80) (10)
Trading margin (%) 2.7 12.4 14.4
Operating profit (Rm) 1 653 3 512 3 946 (58) (10)
Operating margin (%) 9.1 19.4 22.5
Diluted HEPS (cents) 560.7 567.2 612.7 (8) (7)
Dividend per share (DPS) (cents) 384 384 420 (9) (9)
Cash generated from operations (Rm) 2 664 2 664 3 137 (15) (15)
Net asset value per share (cents) 2 156 2 569 2 421 (11) 6
GROUP FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE
* On a comparable basis, i.e. excluding the Office impairment and reclassification of interest in terms of IFRS 9 in the current period, as well as foreign exchange gains and losses in both periods.
11
GROUP DPS AND DILUTED HEPS
Compound growth rates:
DPS:
5-year 0%
3-year -5%
Compound growth rates:
Diluted HEPS:
5-year 0%
3-year -6%
405
452 452
420
384
592
666
621 613
561
-
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
Jun 2015 Jun 2016 Jun 2017 Jun 2018 Jun 2019
DPS Diluted HEPS
(cents) Office UK acquired
Dec 2015
12
GROUP RETURN ON EQUITY (ROE) AND RETURN ON CAPITAL (ROC)
Average:
ROE:
5-year 30%*
3-year 27%*
Average:
ROC:
5-year 44%*
3-year 40%*
(%)
35 35
31
27
23*
49 51
46
40
33*
-
10
20
30
40
50
60
Jun 2015 Jun 2016 Jun 2017 Jun 2018 Jun 2019
ROE ROC
* On a comparable basis, i.e. excluding the Office impairment and reclassification of interest in terms of IFRS 9 in the current period, as well as foreign exchange gains and losses in both periods.
Office UK acquired
Dec 2015
13
GROUP RETURN ON ASSETS AND ASSET TURNOVER
Average:
Return on assets:
5-year 27%*
3-year 25%*
Average:
Asset turnover:
5-year 1.1 times*
3-year 1.1 times*
Return on assets
(%)
Asset turnover
(times)
38 24 26 25 23*
1.2
1.0
1.1 1.1
1.2*
0.5
0.8
1.1
1.4
1.7
-
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
Jun 2015 Jun 2016 Jun 2017 Jun 2018 Jun 2019
Return on assets Asset turnover
* On a comparable basis, i.e. excluding the Office impairment and reclassification of interest in terms of IFRS 9 in the current period, as well as foreign exchange gains and losses in both periods.
Office UK acquired
Dec 2015
14
GROUP STATEMENTS OF FINANCIAL POSITION
Jun 2019
Including
impairment
Rm
Jun 2019
Comparable*
Rm
Jun 2018
Rm
Change on
prior period
%
Change on
comparable
prior period*
%
Property plant and equipment 1 780 1 780 1 726 3 3
Goodwill 346 1 611 1 629 (79) (1)
Intangible assets 2 616 3 171 3 227 (19) (2)
Other non-current assets 443 443 322 38 38
Cash and cash equivalents 777 777 982 (21) (21)
Trade and other receivables 4 934 4 934 5 110 (3) (3)
Inventories 2 108 2 108 2 072 2 2
Other current assets 352 352 423 (17) (17)
Total assets 13 356 15 176 15 491 (14) (2)
Total equity 9 175 10 929 10 369 (12) 6
Non-current liabilities 1 763 1 857 2 363 (25) (21)
Current liabilities 2 418 2 390 2 759 (12) (13)
Total equity and liabilities 13 356 15 176 15 491 (14) (2)
* On a comparable basis, i.e. excluding the Office impairment and reclassification of interest in terms of IFRS 9 in the current period, as well as foreign exchange gains and losses in both periods.
15
* Increase in Office’s net debt to equity ratio mainly due to the impairment of intangible assets.
Net debt
Jun 2019
Net debt
to equity
Jun 2019
%
Net debt
Jun 2018
Net debt
to equity
Jun 2018
%
Group Rm 663 7.2 968 9.3
Truworths Rm 245 2.8 605 5.9
Office £m 23.5 19.5* 20.1 10.2
GROUP CAPITAL MANAGEMENT
After share buy
backs of R266 million
16
Dividends
Final dividend of 135 cents per share (Jun 2018: 159 cents per share).
Total dividend per share of 384 cents per share (Jun 2018: 420 cents per share).
Financial position
Financial position remains strong with net asset value per share up 6%* to 2 569 cents.
Spent R266 million on repurchasing 3.75 million shares during the period.
Since the inception of the general share buy-back programme in 2002, 99.5 million
shares have been repurchased at a total cost of R3.2 billion at an average price of R33
per share.
* On a comparable basis, i.e. excluding the Office impairment and reclassification of interest in terms of IFRS 9 in the current period, as well as foreign exchange gains and losses in both periods.
GROUP CAPITAL MANAGEMENT (CONTINUED)
17
GROUP TRADING SPACE
Jun 2019
‘000 m2
Jun 2018
‘000 m2
Change on
prior period
%
Truworths 388 381 2
Office 15 16 (5)
Total 403 397 2
18
GROUP ONLINE PRESENCE
Strong year-on-year growth in followers on Facebook (>20%) and Instagram (>50%).
Truworths has nearly 4 million Facebook followers.
Majority of Truworths’ Facebook and Instagram followers are under the age of 34.
Identity’s Facebook followers increased nearly 20% over the last year.
Office London’s following on Facebook and Instagram increased by nearly 80% and 120%.
The truworths.co.za e-commerce website continues to register strong growth
• truworths.co.za is generating the turnover of a medium to
large-sized Truworths store.
• Website profitable from day 1.
• Brands available online include:
c 10% of
Group retail sales
Office online sales grew 10%.
Online sales comprising 34% of retail sales.
offspring.co.uk website has grown significantly with the expansion of product availability and growth in awareness, driven by effective use of social media and digital marketing.
“Click & collect” service expanded, comprising nearly 20% of orders, giving online customers access to stock already in store rather than just warehouse stock.
User journey enhanced including a more seamless checkout process.
New payment gateway offers new ways to pay including Apple Pay and Google Pay and a number of additional international currencies.
Customer database has over six million customers.
officelondon.co.za link to Office UK site launching this quarter, reinforcing strong brand association between OFFICE London in SA and Office in the UK.
19
GROUP CASH FLOW ANALYSIS (Rm)
2 930 (266)
1 152 8 (77) (968)
(92) 2 687 (1 766)
(373)
(266)
24 306 (422)
(116)
( 500)
-
500
1 000
1 500
2 000
2 500
3 000
3 500
4 000
4 500
CashEBITDA
Workingcapital
movements
Interestreceived
Dividendsreceived
Financecosts
Tax paid Capexmaintenance
Freecash flow
Dividendspaid
Capexexpansion
Sharesrepurchased
Other Net cashincreasebefore
borrowingsrepaid
Borrowingsrepaid
Net cashdecrease forthe period
20
80
89 91
109
93
-
20
40
60
80
100
120
Jun 2015 Jun 2016 Jun 2017 Jun 2018 Jun 2019
Group cash realisation rate
(%)
GROUP CASH REALISATION RATE
Average:
Cash realisation rate:
5-year 92%
3-year 98%*
21
GROUP NEW ACCOUNTING STANDARDS
IFRS 9 and IFRS 15 adopted with effect from the start of the period.
IFRS 9 Financial Instruments
Significant impact on doubtful debt allowance, increasing from 12.3% to 19.0% on transition
date (through retained earnings).
Doubtful debt allowance now based on expected credit loss model taking into account forward-
looking information.
Interest in respect of stage 3 debtors is recognised against trade receivable costs.
IFRS 15 Revenue from Contracts with Customers
Impact limited to accounting for sales returns (net impact on income statement is nil).
IFRS 16 Leases
New standard effective from 2020 financial year.
In process of finalising system changes and reviewing affected agreements and policies.
FINANCIAL REVIEW – TRUWORTHS
23
TRUWORTHS TRADING OVERVIEW
Retail sales increased 3%, gaining momentum in H2 (growing at 4%).
Gross profit margin unchanged at 55.5%.
Trading expenses remain well controlled, growing at 3%.
Profit before tax decreased 3%.
Continued strong cash generation – net debt R245 million after share buy backs of
R266 million.
Cash realisation rate of 97%.
Inventory turn unchanged at 4.8 times.
Active account growth of 3% – book remains healthy and performing in line with management
expectations.
Lay-bys and e-commerce sales contributing positively.
24
TRUWORTHS FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE
Jun
2019
Jun
2018
Change on
prior period
%
Sale of merchandise (Rm) 12 863 12 617 2
Gross margin (%) 55.5 55.5
Trading profit (Rm) 2 235 2 240 -
Trading margin (%) 17.4 17.8
Operating profit* (Rm) 3 392 3 667 (7)
Operating margin (%) 26.4 29.1
Profit before tax (Rm) 3 338 3 445 (3)
* Impacted by restructuring of funding arrangements in June 2018, as a result of which both investment interest received and finance costs decreased.
Excluding foreign
exchange losses in 2019
and gains in 2018, profit
before tax decreased 1%
25 25
TRUWORTHS RETAIL SALES GROWTH ANALYSIS
Retail sales
Rm
Retail sales
growth
%
LFL store
growth
%
Product
Inflation
%
Unit growth:
Comp stores
%
Unit growth:
Non-comp
stores
%
Jun 2019 13 517 3 1 0 1 2
Jun 2018* 13 115 1 (3) (1) (2) 4
Jun 2017# 13 061 (2) (5) 12 (17) 3
Jun 2016 13 264 14 7 9 (2) 7
Jun 2015 11 644 8 1 6 (5) 7
* Compared to weeks 2 to 53 of the 2017 financial period. # Jun 2017 retail sales weeks 1 to 52.
26
TRUWORTHS MERCHANDISE INFLATION TREND
(4.0)
(2.0)
-
2.0
4.0
6.0
8.0
10.0
12.0
14.0
16.0
2012
Summer
2013
Winter
2013
Summer
2014
Winter
2014
Summer
2015
Winter
2015
Summer
2016
Winter
2016
Summer
2017
Winter
2017
Summer
2018
Winter
2018
Summer
2019
Winter
2019
Summer
Inflation
(%)
27
TRUWORTHS DIVISIONAL RETAIL SALES
Jun 2019
Rm
Jun 2018
Rm
Change on
prior period
%
Truworths ladieswear 3 757 3 753 -
Truworths designer emporium* 1 396 1 383 1
Truworths ladieswear emporium 5 153 5 136 -
Truworths menswear# 3 675 3 663 -
Truworths kids emporium~ 1 097 925 19
Other† 1 443 1 309 10
Truworths emporium 11 368 11 033 3
Identity 2 149 2 082 3
Truworths retail sales 13 517 13 115 3
YDE agency sales 248 254 (2)
* Daniel Hechter Ladies, Ginger Mary, Glamour, LTD Ladies and Earthaddict. # Truworths Man, Uzzi, Daniel Hechter Mens and LTD Mens.
~ LTD Kids, Earthchild and Naartjie. † Cellular, Truworths Jewellery, Cosmetics, Office London (South Africa) and Loads of Living divisions.
28
Jun 2019
‘000 m2
Jun 2018
‘000 m2
Truworths 294 290
Identity 72 70
Other* 15 14
Total excluding YDE 381 374
YDE 7 7
Total 388 381
% change on prior period 1.6
TRUWORTHS TRADING SPACE
* Other comprises Uzzi, Loads of Living, Earthchild/Earthaddict, Naartjie, Office London, Naartjie/Earthchild and Kids Emporium.
29
TRUWORTHS TRADING SPACE (CONTINUED)
Continued focus on optimising space utilisation, consolidating space where
possible.
Leases are typically 5 years with option to extend for a further one or two 5-year
periods, providing flexibility in a changing retail landscape.
Successful rental negotiations during the period – occupancy costs up 2%.
Rental reversions, lower escalations or combination of both.
Lower average rental escalations.
Some stores on turnover-only rental.
30
TRUWORTHS NUMBER OF STORES AND DEPARTMENTS
Jun 2019 Jun 2018
Stores
Departments
within stores Total Stores
Departments
within stores Total
Truworths 350 - 350 346 - 346
Identity 258 - 258 255 - 255
Uzzi 44 247 291 48 233 281
Truworths Man 35 322 357 37 311 348
Earthchild/Earthaddict 34 135 169 41 90 131
Naartjie 21 60 81 26 49 75
YDE 20 - 20 21 - 21
Office London 15 - 15 13 - 13
Loads of Living 13 1 14 13 - 13
Naartjie/Earthchild 6 - 6 4 - 4
Kids emporium 4 - 4 2 - 2
Daniel Hechter 3 361 364 3 327 330
Ginger Mary 2 293 295 2 291 293
LTD 1 271 272 2 223 225
Total 806 813
31
TRUWORTHS CHANGE IN NUMBER OF STORES
Jun 2018
Stores
New
stores
Closed
stores
Jun 2019
Stores
Truworths 346 7 (3) 350
Identity 255 6 (3) 258
Uzzi 48 2 (6) 44
Truworths Man 37 1 (3) 35
Earthchild and Earthaddict 41 1 (8) 34
Naartjie 26 - (5) 21
YDE 21 - (1) 20
Office London 13 2 - 15
Loads of Living 13 - - 13
Naartjie and Earthchild 4 2 - 6
Kids Emporium (standalone) 2 2 - 4
Daniel Hechter 3 - - 3
Ginger Mary 2 - - 2
LTD 2 - (1) 1
Total 813 23 (30) 806
32
TRUWORTHS REST OF AFRICA CORPORATE STORES
Retail sales
Jun 2019
Rm
Retail sales
Jun 2018
Rm
Change on
prior period
%
Retail sales
Jun 2019
LC'm
Retail sales
Jun 2018
LC'm
Change on
prior period
%
Number of
stores
Jun 2019
Number of
stores
Jun 2018
Namibia 183 204 (10) 183 204 (10) 18 18
Botswana 106 100 6 79 78 1 8 8
Eswatini~ 100 94 6 100 94 6 5 5
Mauritius 23 21 10 55 55 - 2 2
Lesotho 23 23 - 23 23 - 2 2
Zambia^ 19 29 (34) 15 22 (32) 2 3
Kenya 9 9 - 66 73 (10) 2 2
Ghana# - 8 (100) - 3 (100) - -
Total 463 488 (5) 39 40
^ Closed 4 stores in May 2018 and a further 1 store in March 2019. # The Ghana stores ceased trading on 3 December 2017. ~ Formerly known as Swaziland.
33
TRUWORTHS SALES DENSITIES TREND
Compound growth rates:
Sales density:
5-year 1%
3-year -2%
R per m2
30 462
32 979
34 849 35 656
34 586 34 857
37 350 36 317
35 256 35 682
10 000
15 000
20 000
25 000
30 000
35 000
40 000
Jun 2010 Jun 2011 Jun 2012 Jun 2013 Jun 2014 Jun 2015 Jun 2016 Jun 2017 Jun 2018 Jun 2019
Sales density trend
34
TRUWORTHS GROSS PROFIT TREND
Compound growth rates:
Gross profit:
5-year 4%
3-year 0%
Average:
Gross margin:
5-year 55.3%
3-year 55.4%
6.2 7.1 7.1 7.0 7.1
55.2 55.3 55.2 55.5 55.5
-
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
-
1.0
2.0
3.0
4.0
5.0
6.0
7.0
8.0
Jun 2015 Jun 2016 Jun 2017 Jun 2018 Jun 2019
Gross profit Gross margin
Gross profit
(Rbn)
Gross margin
(%)
35
TRUWORTHS TRADING EXPENSES
Jun 2019
Rm
Jun 2018
Rm
Change on
prior period
%
Depreciation and amortisation 322 289 11
Employment costs 1 569 1 474 6
Occupancy costs 1 491 1 462 2
Trade receivable costs 1 037 1 099 (6)
Other operating costs 800 720 11
Trading expenses 5 219 5 044 3*
* Trading expenses grew 2% on the prior period excluding foreign exchange loss of R39 million in 2019 and foreign exchange gain of R29 million in 2018.
36
TRUWORTHS ANALYSIS OF TRADING EXPENSES
Depreciation and amortisation
Capital expenditure of R420 million (Jun 2018: R419 million) in the period.
Excluding non-comparable stores, depreciation and amortisation increased 2%.
Employment costs
Excluding non-comparable store costs and incentives, employment costs increased 4%.
Occupancy costs
A net 7 stores closed during the period.
Trading space increased 1.6% on the prior period.
11% INCREASE
6% INCREASE
2% INCREASE
37
TRUWORTHS ANALYSIS OF TRADING EXPENSES (CONTINUED)
Trade receivable costs
Excluding IFRS 9 stage 3 interest reclassification, trade receivable costs increased 4%.
Gross bad debts decreased 4%, recoveries increased 6% and debt sold decreased 31%, resulting in net bad debts decreasing 6% relative to the prior period.
The doubtful debt allowance increased from 19.0% (on an IFRS 9 basis, IAS 39: 12.3%) at Jun 2018 to 19.2% of gross trade receivables while the gross debtors book grew 4% since Jun 2018.
Collection costs unchanged relative to the prior period and other trade receivable costs decreased 3%.
Total cost of accounts of R1 211 million (Jun 2018: R1 278 million) exceeds total income from accounts (including notional interest) of R1 185 million (Jun 2018: R1 349 million), resulting in a deficit of R26 million (Jun 2018: surplus of R71 million).
Other operating costs
Excluding foreign exchange gains and losses from both periods (Jun 2019: R39 million loss, Jun 2018: R29 million gain) other operating costs increased 2%.
11% INCREASE
4%*
INCREASE
* Including the IFRS 9 stage 3 interest reclassification, trade receivable costs decreased 6%.
38
TRUWORTHS OPERATING PROFIT PERFORMANCE
Compound growth rates:
Operating profit:
5-year 1%*
3-year -4%*
Average:
EBITDA margin:
5-year 31%*
3-year 31%*
Average:
Operating margin:
5-year 29%*
3-year 28%*
3.4 4.0 3.8 3.6 3.5*
32 33
31 31 30*
31 31
29 29
27*
-
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
-
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
Jun 2015 Jun 2016 Jun 2017 Jun 2018 Jun 2019*
Operating profit EBITDA margin Operating margin
Operating profit
(Rbn)
Margins
(%) *Jun 2019 not comparable to prior years due to restructure of SA funding arrangements in Jun 2018.
The numbers in the graph below have been adjusted to exclude the impact of the funding restructure.
The reported numbers are operating profit R3.4bn, EBITDA margin 29%, and operating margin 26%.
39
TRUWORTHS CAPITAL EXPENDITURE
Actual
Jun 2019
Rm
Actual
Jun 2018
Rm
Change on
prior period
%
Committed
Jun 2020
Rm
Store renovations and development 252 320 (21) 291
Computer infrastructure and software 48 59 (19) 88
Land, buildings and refurbishment 113 31 265 151
Motor vehicles 4 4 - 4
Distribution facilities 3 5 (40) 3
Total 420 419 - 537
40
TRUWORTHS CASH FLOW ANALYSIS
2 758 (157)
1 149 8 (54) (917)
(80) 2 707 (1 766)
(340)
(266)
24 359 (302)
57
-
500
1 000
1 500
2 000
2 500
3 000
3 500
4 000
Cash
EBITDA
Working
capital
movements
Interest
received
Dividends
received
Finance
costs
Tax paid Capex
maintenance
Free
cash flow
Dividends
paid
Capex
expansion
Shares
repurchased
Other Net cash
increase
before
borrowings
repaid
Borrowings
repaid
Net cash
increase for
the period
(Rm)
41
TRUWORTHS CASH REALISATION RATE
Average:
Cash realisation rate:
5-year 91%
3-year 97%
80 83 84
110
97
-
20
40
60
80
100
120
Jun 2015 Jun 2016 Jun 2017 Jun 2018 Jun 2019
Truworths cash realisation rate
(%)
FINANCIAL REVIEW - OFFICE
43
“It’s worth bearing in mind that just about everything happening in Britain today seemed implausible just a few years ago. This situation is, as the pundits say, “fluid” and “dynamic”. About the only thing that can be predicted with confidence is that come November, Brexiteers will either be celebrating their victory, or mourning their destruction.”
John Rapley, Political Economist at University of Cambridge Sunday Times, 11 August 2019
OFFICE OVERVIEW
44
Retail sales decreased by 1% to £279 million.
Second half retail sales grew at 2% compared to a decrease of 3% in the first half, due to increased
markdown activity.
Decrease in gross margin to 42.3% (Jun 2018: 44.4%) primarily due to a shift in the full price versus
markdown mix.
Online retail sales increased 10% to £94 million (Jun 2018: £86 million), comprising 34%
(Jun 2018: 31%) of retail sales.
Store sales down 6%.
Trading expenses remain well controlled, growing at 2% (excluding the impairment).
Inventory turn unchanged from prior year at 3.2 times.
Net debt to equity increased to 20% (Jun 2018: 10%) following impairment of Office intangibles (11%
before impact of impairment).
OFFICE TRADING OVERVIEW
45
OFFICE FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE
Jun
2019
Including
Impairment
Jun
2019
Comparable*
Jun
2018
Change on
comparable
prior period*
%
Sale of merchandise (£m) 285.5 285.5 286.0 -
Gross margin (%) 42.3 42.3 44.4
Trading expenses (£m) 215.9 113.9 111.2 2
EBITDA (£m) (89.8) 12.2 21.8 (44)
Operating (loss)/profit (£m) (94.7) 7.3 16.1 (55)
Operating margin (%) (33.2) 2.6 5.6
* On a comparable basis, i.e. excluding the Office impairment in the current period.
46
OFFICE RETAIL SALES AND STORES BY COUNTRY
Retail sales
Jun 2019
£m
Retail sales
Jun 2018
£m
Change on
prior period
%
Number of
stores
Jun 2019
Number of
stores
Jun 2018
United Kingdom 254.3 256.7 (1) 124 138
Germany 12.7 13.5 (6) 8 8
Republic of Ireland 11.3 10.3 10 7 7
United States of America 0.3 0.5 (39) - 3
Total 278.6 281.0 (1) 139* 156*
* Including 24 concession stores (Jun 2018: 40 concession stores)
47
OFFICE TRADING EXPENSES
Jun 2019
£m
Jun 2018
£m
Change on
prior period
%
Depreciation and amortisation 4.8 5.6 (14)
Employment costs 35.3 37.0 (5)
Occupancy costs 48.4 45.1 7
Trade receivable costs 0.6 -*
Other operating costs 24.8 23.5 6
Trading expenses, before impairment 113.9 111.2 2
Impairment of intangibles 102.0 -
Total trading expenses 215.9 111.2 94
* Zero due to rounding
48
Depreciation and amortisation
Capital expenditure of £2.5 million (Jun 2018: £3.6 million) in the period.
Decrease due to assets becoming fully depreciated and lower capex spend during the period.
Employment costs
Store wages and salaries decreased £1 million due to lower headcount and hours paid, and lower commission due to lower sales.
Excluding once-off costs, employment costs decreased 4%.
OFFICE ANALYSIS OF TRADING EXPENSES
14% DECREASE
5% DECREASE
49
OFFICE ANALYSIS OF TRADING EXPENSES (CONTINUED)
Occupancy costs
Onerous lease provision increased £1.9 million.
Excluding once-off costs, occupancy costs increased 2%.
Trade and other receivables
Trade receivable costs amounted to £0.6 million due to House of Fraser entering administration.
Other operating costs
Excluding once-off costs, other operating costs increased 5%.
E-commerce costs increased £1.8 million as a result of increased marketing spend and increased distribution costs, which are directly linked to sales.
7% INCREASE
6% INCREASE
50
OFFICE CAPITAL EXPENDITURE
Actual
Jun 2019
£’000
Actual
Jun 2018
£’000
Change on
prior period
%
Committed
Jun 2020
£’000
Store renovations and development 790 2 338 (66) 993
Computer infrastructure and software 1 666 1 197 39 1 383
Distribution facilities 26 84 (69) 60
Head office refurbishment 10 2 400 22
Total 2 492 3 621 (31) 2 458
51
OFFICE UPDATE ON DEBT RESTRUCTURING
Office entered into debt restructuring negotiations with lenders in June 2019.
Office and lenders appointed advisors Alvarez & Marsal (A&M) and Deloitte
respectively.
An amount of c £42.5 million is owed to UK lenders, and Office has cash balances
currently of c £28-32 million (net debt levels are currently c £10-15 million).
Given current levels of profitability, cash generation, solvency and liquidity, no major
business restructuring is appropriate.
Management confident that lender negotiations will be concluded satisfactorily.
Truworths International as ultimate shareholder remains committed to the business,
and its board believes that Office’s fortunes will improve as the turnaround strategies
are successfully executed.
52
OFFICE CEO UPDATE FOCUS & PRIORITIES – STRATEGIC OPPORTUNITIES
PARTNERSHIPS OFFSPRING OXFORD STREET
Positioning
Strength of messaging – Win in
London and with Her
Activations –Physical, digital and
social. Online growth (10%) will
continue
New offerings and differentiated
ranges
Strong growth @+32%
Unique community position
Strengthening digital content
Increased brand positioning and
allocations
Selfridges partnership
New model trial store
Significant improvement
Agile and flexible elevated
format
Brand positivity – the physical
window to the Office brand
Test and learn
SEE TURNAROUND WORKSTREAMS
‘OPERATIONAL’
TRUWORTHS ACCOUNTS
54
SOUTH AFRICAN CREDIT ENVIRONMENT TRANSUNION SA CONSUMER CREDIT INDEX
The TransUnion SA Consumer Credit Index (CCI) increased marginally to 49 in 2019 Q2 from 48 in 2019 Q1.
The increase in the TU CCI signals the end to a declining trend for the past three consecutives quarters. Nevertheless, the index has now been below 50 since 2018 Q3, indicating consumer stress. This is corroborated by low consumer confidence and weak retail sales growth.
Overall, TransUnion consumer credit behaviour data shows stabilising consumer stress.
Accounts in early default (3 months in arrears) increased by 1% year-on-year in 2019 Q2. This is an improvement on the 6% in 2019 Q1.
Household cash flow fell marginally by 0.5% during 2019 Q2.
Household debt service costs did not change materially during 2019 Q2.
Household distressed borrowing (revolving credit utilisation) appears to be muted, falling 1% year-on-year. However, utilisation rates above 50% is the norm.
52 Q2 2018
48 Q1 2019
49 Q2 2019
Source: TransUnion
The index measures
consumer credit
health where 50.0 is
the break-even level
between improvement
and deterioration.
TransUnion Defaults &
Distressed Borrowing
50%
Household
Cashflow
35%
Debt Servicing
Costs
15%
DATA WEIGHTING IN THE TRANSUNION CCI
55
TRUWORTHS ACCOUNTS OVERVIEW
Strong demand for Truworths merchandise evidenced by record new account application volumes of 2.8 million.
Majority of applicants are under 30 years old.
Strict credit granting criteria maintained.
Sales growth from new accounts has been sustained with two years of double digit growth.
Truworths credit book quality has improved year-on-year, widening the gap to the retail benchmarks (Principa Credit
Compass).
Lay-bys are an attractive purchase option for customers who do not qualify for credit and a good incubator for future
account customers.
E-commerce is not only adding sales but enhances our credit account appeal to the online shopper.
Loyalty programme continues to attract and retain customers via tailored customer offers.
Shoppable accounts increased significantly on prior year.
Performance improvements driven by a combination of advanced predictive analytics that leverage our single-view of
the customer into omni-channel customer engagement.
56
TRUWORTHS ACCOUNTS TOTAL GOOD(0-1)/TOTAL BAD (2+) BALANCE RATIO
Source: Principa
Excludes Edcon
Au
g-17
Sep
-17
Oct-1
7
No
v-17
De
c-17
Jan-1
8
Feb
-18
Mar-1
8
Ap
r-18
May-1
8
Jun
-18
Jul-1
8
Au
g-18
Sep
-18
Oct-1
8
No
v-18
De
c-18
Jan-1
9
Feb
-19
Mar-1
9
Ap
r-19
May-1
9
-20%
-15%
-10%
-5%
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
Ye
ar-o
n-Y
ear
Ch
ange
Y-on-Y % Change Industry Excl. Truworths Y-on-Y % Change Truworths GROUP
Total Good (0-1)/Total Bad (2+) balance ratio for Truworths has improved by 7% year-on-year ,
while industry deteriorated by 13% compared to the same period in the prior year
Source: Principa
Dete
riora
ting
Im
pro
vin
g
57
-10%
-5%
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
Au
g-17
Sep
-17
Oct-1
7
No
v-17
De
c-17
Jan-1
8
Feb
-18
Mar-1
8
Ap
r-18
May-1
8
Jun
-18
Jul-1
8
Au
g-18
Sep
-18
Oct-1
8
No
v-18
De
c-18
Jan-1
9
Feb
-19
Mar-1
9
Ap
r-19
May-1
9
4+
Cyc
le B
alan
ces
Quarter
Y-on-Y % Change Industry Excl. Truworths Y-on-Y % Change Truworths GROUP
TRUWORTHS ACCOUNTS TOTAL 4+ CYCLE BALANCES
Truworths Total 4+ balances improved by 4% compared to prior year while industry deteriorated by 16%
Source: Principa (Excludes Edcon)
Imp
rov
ing
D
ete
riora
ting
58
TRUWORTHS ACCOUNTS NEW APPLICATIONS VS RISK APPROVED VS OPENED
-
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
20
08/2
00
9
20
09/2
01
0
20
10/2
01
1
20
11/2
01
2
20
12/2
01
3
20
13/2
01
4
20
14/2
01
5
20
15/2
01
6
20
16/2
01
7
20
17/2
01
8
20
18/2
01
9
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
No of Applications Risk Approval % Opened %
(%) High standard of credit granting criteria
maintained and improved
No. of account
applications
(millions)
59
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
2009/2010 2010/2011 2011/2012 2012/2013 2013/2014 2014/2015 2015/2016 2016/2017 2017/2018 2018/2019
Application Date
TRUWORTHS ACCOUNTS NEW ACCOUNTS OPENED
No. of new
accounts opened
(‘000) Record number of new accounts opened
60
TRUWORTHS ACCOUNTS NEW ACCOUNT APPLICATIONS BY AGE GROUP
18 – 24 years
25%
25 – 29 years
24%
30 – 34 years
19%
35 – 39 years
13%
40 – 49 years
13%
50+ years
6%
Almost half of all
applicants are under 30
61
Account sales growth year-on-year
Months
on book
Jun 2016
%
Jun 2017
%
Jun 2018
%
Jun 2019
%
1 to 12 months 11 (24) 21 14
13 to 24 months 15 6 (24) 13
25 to 36 months (3) 9 3 (23)
37 months + 14 4 1 3
TRUWORTHS ACCOUNTS ACCOUNT SALES GROWTHS
Affordability legislation impact on sales growth moving into the older account groups impacting the overall sales growth.
Affordability
legislation
impact on
sales growth.
Positive
future sales
growth.
62
TRUWORTHS ACCOUNTS SHOPPABLE ACCOUNTS
Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun
2018 - Shoppable 2019 - Shoppable
No. of
accounts
Shoppable accounts continued to improve in line
with increase in active customer base
63
TRUWORTHS ACCOUNTS STATISTICS
Jun
2019
Jun
2018
Number of active accounts (000's) 2 658 2 591
Change in number of active accounts (%) 3 2
Gross trade receivables (before doubtful debt allowance) (Rm) 5 898 5 663
Change in gross trade receivables (before doubtful debt
allowance) (%) 4 (3)
Account sales as a % of retail sales (%) 70 69
Qualifying payment (%) 90 90
Accounts opened to applications ratio (%) 22 25
64
TRUWORTHS ACCOUNTS STATISTICS (CONTINUED)
Jun
2019
Jun
2018
Active account holders able to purchase at period-end (i.e.
not in arrears) (%) 83 84
Overdue accounts as a % of gross trade receivables (%) 13 14
Net bad debt as a % of account sales (%) 8.3 9.2
Net bad debt as a % of gross trade receivables (%) 13.3 14.7
Doubtful debt allowance as a % of gross trade receivables* (%) 19.2 19.0*
Trade receivable interest as a % of gross trade receivables# (%) 18.8 22.7
* The June 2018 provision was 12.3% under IAS 39. The transition date increase in the provision was processed through retained earnings.
# Impacted by the IFRS 9 stage 3 interest reclassification. Excluding the reclassification, 20.6%
65
TRUWORTHS ACCOUNTS REGULATORY UPDATE
National Credit Amendment Act
Debt relief legislation signed into law on 13 August, announced by Parliament yesterday.
Regulations will need to be drafted and circulated.
Stakeholders will have an opportunity to comment on regulations.
Comes into effect on date to be set by the President on proclamation in the Government Gazette
Eligible to customers earning less than R7 500 per month, have unsecured debt of less than R50 000 and have been found to be critically indebted by the National Credit Regulator.
These accounts have in all likelihood already been written off or largely provided for.
In addition the doubtful debt allowance under IFRS 9 includes a provision for debt relief based on forward-looking considerations.
Studies will have to be undertaken about what the long term implications are for consumer behaviour.
NCRF is considering the legislation with its advisors.
STRATEGIC FOCUS AREAS
67
GROUP STRATEGIC FOCUS AREAS
Group focus areas
• Truworths and Office continue to collaborate
• Investigate strategic acquisitions
• Board transformation
Truworths focus areas
• Leadership and succession
• New store concepts
• Merchandise and supply chain
• Digital
Office focus areas
• Turnaround strategy
• Marketing, customer
engagement and loyalty
• Expansion and growth of e-
commerce
• Supply chain
68
GROUP BOARD TRANSFORMATION
Committed to transformation of the Truworths International Ltd board.
Medium-term target of 30% female representation on the board.
Cindy Hess appointed as independent non-executive director with effect from 1 May 2019.
Cross-industry experience predominantly in the FMCG sector.
Experience in the fields of risk management, restructuring and corporate finance.
Sarah Proudfoot appointed as executive director with effect from 23 May 2019.
21 years experience with the Group.
Appointed Director of Truworths Ltd Ladieswear Merchandise in 2016.
Experience in merchandise design, merchandise buying, planning, store design and marketing; strengthening the board's capabilities in all fashion retail functions.
Following these appointments, female representation on the board now 31%, in line with the Group’s medium-term target.
69
TRUWORTHS STRATEGIC FOCUS AREAS LEADERSHIP AND SUCCESSION
Succession is an important area of focus.
New divisional directors appointed with effect from 1 March 2019.
Cathy Kirkman appointed as Divisional Director: Merchandise Planning.
21 years experience with the Group.
Myles Apsey appointed as Divisional Director: Merchandise Planning.
18 years experience with the Group.
Peter Shackleton appointed as Divisional Director: Marketing & Merchandise.
21 years experience with the Group.
Zamira Mowzer appointed as Divisional Director: Internal Audit, Governance and Risk.
11 years experience with the Group.
70
TRUWORTHS STRATEGIC FOCUS AREAS NEW STORE CONCEPTS
Context
One of a kind EXPERIENTIAL concept store by TRUWORTHS.
Upmarket brand offering a collection of fashion, beauty and homeware.
Modern retail experience for the discerning female customer.
Aimed at capturing market share in the better-end segment by offering our higher LSM
customer a range of products with unique appeal.
Can be rolled out into better-end malls or more exclusive smaller retail environments.
First store successfully opened in April 2019 in the V&A Waterfront, Cape Town.
Fourways (Johannesburg) opening August 2019. Brooklyn (Pretoria), Loch Logan
(Bloemfontein) and Sandton (Johannesburg) to follow.
71
TRUWORTHS STRATEGIC FOCUS AREAS NEW STORE CONCEPTS (CONTINUED)
ID Kids
Successfully piloted ID Kids range in 26 Identity stores in summer 2018, rolling out to a
large number of stores for summer 2019.
Range is focused on the 2-8 year old age group and covers both girls and boys
collections.
Utilise the extensive in-house kidswear experience.
Look and feel aligned with the DNA of Identity and is “cool and fun”.
New Office London concept
Larger format footwear, apparel and accessories store.
Forward-thinking retail space, clean and clinical yet feels soothing and inviting for a new
take on futuristic design.
First store launching in Fourways Mall, Johannesburg.
72
TRUWORTHS STRATEGIC FOCUS AREAS NEW STORE CONCEPTS (CONTINUED)
New emporium concept
Launched refreshed emporium store concept in a number of large stores. Examples
include Gateway, Eastgate, Westville Pavilion, East Rand Mall and Westgate.
New store design elements
Introduced several new designs to ensure stores remain visually appealing and relevant,
including Loads of Living, Identity, YDE and Uzzi.
73
TRUWORTHS STRATEGIC FOCUS AREAS MERCHANDISE AND SUPPLY CHAIN
Product life-cycle management (PLM) system
Implementation of first phase successfully completed in April 2019.
Consolidation of fabric purchasing across departments
Drive improved margins and value offering through volume consolidation and bulk
negotiations.
Merchandise management system
Supply strategy review
New distribution center
74
TRUWORTHS STRATEGIC FOCUS AREAS DIGITAL
Integrated brand marketing
E-commerce
Data-driven decision making
75
Office turnaround strategy managed through three workstreams:
Trading alignment – focuses on merchandise performance and stock to reduce markdowns by
managing stock position.
Short-term essentials – aimed at prioritising Office’s operational and capital expenditure.
Marketing and brand alignment – focuses on the marketing/communication strategies, branding and
brand relationships.
Closure of poor performing stores remains a priority, while enhancing the e-commerce
offering to grow sales in a consumer environment trending towards online shopping –
footwear is highly conducive to online retailing.
OFFICE TURNAROUND STRATEGY
76
OFFICE STRATEGY – OUR VISION
We will focus on the basics to drive a more profitable business for all stakeholders: Look after our people, invest in our customers, harness our brand relationships and improve our product process
“ “ BACK TO BASICS TURNAROUND GROW
Morale
Costs
Capex
Trade
Inventory
Brand
People
Customers
Product
Stores
Space
Service
Digital
Offspring
Assortments
Supply chain
Our strategic priorities:
77
OFFICE STRATEGIC FOCUS AREAS
Marketing, customer engagement and loyalty
Customer research and analysis exercise in progress.
E-receipts
Expansion and growth of e-commerce
Ongoing enhancement of customer experience and transactional touch points
continues, supporting the popularity of this channel in the UK.
New payment gateway.
Same-day/nominated-day delivery and “click & collect” enhancements are progressing
well.
Supply chain
In-depth review of current warehousing and distribution model expected to improve
efficiency and reduce costs.
OUTLOOK
79
TRUWORTHS OUTLOOK
Consumer spending expected to remain under pressure in the short term – prolonged economic downturn and renewed demands on disposable income.
Labour market continues to weaken with unemployment at a 15-year high level.
Consumer confidence stabilised following the country’s national elections in May 2019 and the improvement in the power supply in recent months.
Consumer inflation remains steady.
Promulgation of debt relief act.
Stronger retail sales growth trend in the second half of the financial period is promising.
Sales momentum expected to be driven by:
Health of the account portfolio
Expanding e-commerce offering
Lay-by payment option
Customer response to new store concepts, including ID Kids and Context
Medium-term prospects will be supported by the health of the account portfolio, continued investment for growth, robust cash flows and strong balance sheet.
Retail sales for the first 6 weeks of the 2020 financial period increased relative to the corresponding
period in 2019, with lower markdowns. New Early Summer product started well – improved on last year. 1%
increase
80
OFFICE OUTLOOK
Trading conditions and consumer confidence remain under intense pressure ahead of the end-October 2019 Brexit deadline.
Retail sector will remain constrained in the medium term.
Turnaround initiatives implemented by management progressing according to plan.
Ongoing focus on inventory management to arrest gross profit margin decline and release working capital.
Real estate portfolio evaluation with a view to closing loss-making stores as leases come to an end.
Based on in-depth assessment by advisers, a major financial restructuring of Office is not being considered given its current profitability, liquidity and cash balances.
Retail sales for the first 6 weeks of the of the 2020 financial period increased in Sterling relative to the
corresponding period in 2019.
3% increase
QUESTIONS
DISCLAIMER
This announcement contains certain forward-looking
statements with respect to the financial condition and results of
operations of Truworths International Limited and its group
companies which by their nature involve risk and uncertainty
because they relate to events and depend on circumstances
that may occur in the future. Factors that could cause actual
results to differ materially from those in the forward-looking
statements include, but are not limited to: global and national
economic conditions; growth in trading space; interest rates;
credit and the associated risks of lending; merchandise
clearance rates; inventory levels and stock turn; gross and
operating margins achieved; and competitive and regulatory
factors. The Group does not undertake to publicly update or
revise any of these forward-looking statements, whether to
reflect new information or future events or otherwise.
APPENDICES
84
85