PLANNING & ZONING COMMISSION AGENDA

August 6, 2020 6:30 P.M.

PLANNING & ZONING AGENDA 1) Call to Order 2) Roll Call/Determination of Quorum 3) Approval of Agenda 4) Consent Calendar: 1. Plat of Aspen Harbor Addition Lot 2 Block 1 And Lots 14, 15 & 21 Block 2 (pg 3-5) 2. Plat of Brandon Park Second Addition Lots 31A & 32 Block 5 (pg 6-7) 3. Plat of Twin Rivers Crossing Addition Tract 2 (pg 8-9) 4. Plat of Westview Estates Lots 6, 7 & 8 Block 4 (pg 10-11) 5) Approval of Minutes of the July 16, 2020 regular meeting (pg 12-13) 6) Public Comments NEW BUSINESS 7) Home Occupation Permit Application 704 S. Nicholas Avenue (pg 14-19) 8) Stone Ridge Estates Preliminary Plan DISCUSSION ITEMS 9) Fence Ordinance – Chapter 15-14-6 (pg 20-21) 10) Building Permits for July – #20200257 - #20200306 (pg 22) ADJOURNMENT OF PLANNING & ZONING Board members unable to attend should please contact City Hall in advance for a quorum determination at 582-8987. Individuals in need of assistance in attaining access to the meeting, please contact City Hall at 582-6515 within 24 hours of the meeting time for special arrangements.

1

SUPPLEMENT TO AGENDA August 6, 2020 MEETINGS: 1) Thursday, August 20, 2020. Planning & Zoning Commission meeting at 6:30 p.m. in the Council Chambers Items on agenda: Nothing at this time

2) Thursday, September 3, 2020. Planning & Zoning Commission meeting at 6:30 p.m. in the Council Chambers Items on agenda: Nothing at this time

2

33

44

55

66

77

88

99

1010

1111

MINUTES PLANNING & ZONING COMMISSION The Brandon Planning & Zoning Commission met in regular session at 6:30 p.m. on July 16, 2020 at the Brandon City Council Chambers. Roll call was taken. Members present were Commissioners Brian Heidbrink, Brookes Noem, Chuck Parsons, Rob Schoeneman, Jim Starzl and Alica Thiele. Also present were Building Official Paul Clarke; City Administrator, Bryan Read and City Engineer Tami Jansma. Absent were Alderman Tim Jorgenson and Mayor Paul Lundberg. Vice-Chairperson Alica Thiele chaired the meeting. Commissioner Parsons moved Commissioner Heidbrink seconded to approve the agenda. Motion carried. Commissioner Noem moved Commissioner Parsons seconded to approve the consent calendar which contained the following items: a plat of Gehrke Addition Tracts 1, 2 & 3; a plat of Graff’s Subdivision Lot 10A; a plat of Heartland Business Park Addition Lot 8A & 10 Block 3 and a plat of Twin Rivers Crossing Addition Lot 8 Block 2 Motion carried. Commissioner Heidbrink moved Commissioner Starzl seconded to approve the minutes of the June 18, 2020 regular meeting. Motion carried. At 6:33 p.m. Commissioner Parsons moved Commissioner Schoeneman seconded to adjourn the Planning & Zoning Commission meeting. Motion carried. At 6:33 p.m. Vice-Chairperson Thiele called the Board of Adjustment meeting to order. Roll call was taken. Members present were Commissioners Brian Heidbrink, Brookes Noem, Chuck Parsons, Rob Schoeneman, Jim Starzl and Alica Thiele. Also present were Building Official Paul Clarke; City Administrator, Bryan Read and City Engineer Tami Jansma. Absent were Alderman Tim Jorgenson and Mayor Paul Lundberg. Commissioner Heidbrink moved Commissioner Starzl seconded to approve the agenda. Motion carried. A Variance Application for 1501 E. Rushmore Drive was presented. Applicant Joel McCulley, 1501 E. Rushmore Drive, was present for discussion. Joel is requesting a variance for the parking pad he recently installed on his property that does not meet the second front yard setback requirement. The required setback is 20’, the parking pad currently measures 16’ from the property line. Commissioner Parsons moved Commissioner Heidbrink seconded to deny the Variance Application as presented. Motion carried.

1212

At 6:58 p.m. having no further business, Commissioner Parsons moved Commissioner Noem seconded to adjourn the Board of Adjustment meeting. Motion carried. At 6:58 p.m. Vice-Chairperson Thiele reconvened the Planning & Zoning Commission meeting. I-90 Plaza Concept Plan was presented. Daryl Vierick, 7321 W. 65th Street, Sioux Falls and Pat Schwebach, 26779 Country Acre Drive, Sioux Falls were present for discussion. Daryl discussed his concept for developing the southeast corner of N. Splitrock Blvd. and I-90 into a commercial development. Plans to develop with fast food/steakhouse, movie theatre, bank, hotels, convention center, grocery store, convenience store, lake. Roads would be private, association would maintain, snow removal, etc. Want to begin construction in 2021. Would be an entrance off E. Birch Street, through the residential neighborhood. Concerns with increased traffic through the residential neighborhood. No action required at this time. Gaylene Mielke, 1616 E. Legacy Circle, was present for discussion. Gaylene expressed her concerns with increased traffic in this residential neighborhood. Joe Brock was present via Zoom and expressed his concerns with increased traffic through his residential neighborhood along E. Birch Street. Holly Park Sand Mine Concept Plan was presented. Harold Gate, 3501 River Bluff Road, Sioux Falls and Eric Willadsen, Willadsen Lund Engineering, 902 S. Cleveland Avenue, Sioux Falls were present for discussion. Harold wants to develop a portion along W. Holly Blvd. into a sand extraction operation as phase I, and then high density residential/commercial in phase II. Approximately 50-60 trucks per day, less during the winter months. Would like to start in 2021. Building Permits for June were presented – #20200189 - #20200247. No action required. At 8:07 p.m., having no further business, Commissioner Parsons moved Commissioner Heidbrink seconded to adjourn the Planning & Zoning Commission meeting. Motion carried.

Respectfully Submitted, _____________________________ ______________________________ Melissa Labahn Tami Jansma Recording Clerk City Engineer

1313

1414

1515

1616

1717

1818

1919

From: Paul ClarkeTo: Melissa Labahn; Tami Jansma; Bryan ReadCc: Patrick AndrewsSubject: P-Z meetingDate: Wednesday, July 22, 2020 10:37:44 AM

For the next P-Z meeting August 6th. I would like to have fencing as a “discussion” item.Specifically—about Item (I) smooth side outward.I have had {3} separate fencing companies call our office about that specific requirement.Thank you

Paul J. Clarke-CBO-CPCU-CCEOBuilding Official-Code Enforcement OfficerCity of Brandon, South Dakota304 Main AvenueP.O. Box 95Brandon, SD 57005Cell: 605-366-9226Office: 605-582-8987E-mail: pclarke@cityofbrandon.org

2020

15-14-6 FENCE REGULATIONS Fences may be erected in required yards, provided they meet or exceed the following requirements: A. No barbed wire fence shall be erected or maintained, except in LI or HI Districts.

In those districts, all barbed wire must be at least six (6) feet above grade.

B. Exposed electrical and other abnormally dangerous fences are prohibited within all zoning districts.

C. No fence shall be erected or maintained in such manner as to unreasonably

obstruct the view of others or their access to light or air.

D. R-1, R-2, R-3, or R-4: Fences may be erected or maintained, provided that no fence over four (4) feet in height shall be erected or maintained in any front yard. On corner lots and double frontage lots, fences shall be no more than four (4) feet in height in the front yards; however, fences no more than six (6) feet in height may be allowed in the second front yard. In no case shall fences exceed a height of six (6) feet.

E. CB, GB, LI, HI, or IN: Fences not exceeding eight (8) feet in height may be

erected or maintained up to the lot's property lines.

F. No fence shall be erected that violates Chapter 15-14-1. A fence may be allowed in the required site triangle if the fence is not more than thirty percent (30%) solid.

G. Chain link fences for public tennis courts, public basketball courts, public baseball

fields, or similar outdoor public recreational uses may be constructed to a maximum height of twenty-four (24) feet provided that the fence is not located within the required setback area.

H. Fences that are adjacent to alleys shall be set back five (5) feet from the

street/boulevard right-of-way.

I. The side of the fence considered being the face (facing as applied to fence post) shall face abutting property.

J. Any fence placed within an easement that impedes the access or intended use of

that easement may be removed by the City or the City's representative at its owner's expense. Fences permitted in a drainage easement shall be either ninety percent (90%) open or at least two (2) inches above grade. No fence is allowed in a drainage easement if the cumulative width of the easement is greater than twenty (20) feet.

Legislative History: Authority: Ordinance #291, 8/1/00 SDCL § Ch. 9 Ordinance #445, 5/27/09 SDCL § Ch. 11, 5, & 6 Ordinance #471, 7/20/10 Ordinance #474, 10/05/10

Ordinance #531, 5/10/16 Ordinance #533, 7/21/16 Ordinance #538, 10/25/16 Ordinance #546, 1/17/17

Ordinance #566, 9/25/18 Ordinance #584, 6/19/19

2121

1A B C D E F G H I

DATE PERMIT # PROJECT OWNER OWNER ADDRESS PROJECT DESCRIPTION CONTRACTOR CONTRACTOR ADDRESS PROJECT $ PROJECT ADDRESS3456789

1011121314151617181920212223242526272829303132333435363738394041424344454647484950515253545556

57

58

59

60

61

July

7/1/2020 20200257 Allegiant Builders 5728 E. Red Oak Dr., #6; SF, SD 57110 House/garage Allegiant Builders 5728 E. Red Oak Dr., #6; SF, SD 57110 $129,348.00 129 E. Birchwood Drive7/1/2020 20200258 Craig Nelson 104 S. 5th Avenue Front deck Owner Owner $1,480.00 104 S. 5th Avenue7/1/2020 20200259 Nylis Renschler 205 S. Oak Ridge Road Lawn shed Owner Owner $2,720.00 205 S. Oak Ridge Road7/2/2020 20200260 Casey Feuerstein 405 S. 2nd Avenue Reshingle Owner Owner $2,000.00 405 S. 2nd Avenue7/2/2020 20200261 Christine Manitz 417 N. Pasque Flower Trail Side yard deck Owner Owner $1,440.00 417 N. Pasque Flower Trail7/2/2020 20200262 Adam Bobzien 2804 E. Daybreak Circle Lawn shed Owner Owner $680.00 2804 E. Daybreak Circle7/6/2020 20200263 Ray Johnsen 1012 E. Magnolia Drive Fence Owner Owner $160.00 1012 E. Magnolia Drive7/6/2020 20200264 Michael Murphy 1016 E. Magnolia Drive Fence Owner Owner $800.00 1016 E. Magnolia Drive7/6/2020 20200265 Chad Olson 704 E. Elm Street Fence, garage addition Owner Owner $10,011.00 704 E. Elm Street7/7/2020 20200266 Mollie Calkins 436 N. Maple Avenue Fence Michael's Fence 3900 N. Potsdam Ave.; SF, SD 57104 $648.00 436 N. Maple Avenue7/7/2020 20200267 Joel Jorgenson 721 N. Splitrock Blvd. Tenant remodel Bowar Construction 25435 485th Ave.; Garretson, SD 57030 $6,000.00 721 N. Splitrock Blvd.7/8/2020 20200268 Margaret Lootens 812 E. Heatherwood Drive Lawn shed Owner Owner $680.00 812 E. Heatherwood Drive7/7/2020 20200269 John Murren 920 E. Birch Street Driveway addition Owner Owner $900.00 920 E. Birch Street7/8/2020 20200270 Brad Rotert 2909 E. Sunrise Court Front deck Owner Owner $814.00 2909 E. Sunrise Court7/9/2020 20200271 Troy Barthman 2516 E. Augusta Street Sidewalk 605 Companies, Inc. 700 E. 65th Str. N.; SF, SD 57104 $198.00 2516 E. Augusta Street7/9/2020 20200272 BV School District 700 E. Holly Blvd. Reshingle Guarantee Roofing 600 N. Ebenezer; SF, SD 57107 $105,000.00 700 E. Holly Blvd.

7/10/2020 20200273 Tyler Dolge 1400 E. Custer Parkway Basement finish Owner Owner $7,200.00 1400 E. Custer Parkway7/13/2020 20200274 Ryan Bailey 905 E. Keystone Circle Patio with pergola Owner Owner $441.00 905 E. Keystone Circle7/13/2020 20200275 Amy Ellsworth 504 S. Nicholas Avenue Rear deck Mike McClintock 48575 267th Str.; Valley Springs, SD 57068 $1,440.00 504 S. Nicholas Avenue7/13/2020 20200276 James Schobert 2200 E. Byrum Circle Reshingle Philbuilt Bldg Remodeling 402 Lovely Avenue; Baltic, SD 57003 $15,000.00 2200 E. Byrum Circle7/14/2020 20200277 Erika Andrews 208 W. Ponderosa Drive Reside Owner Owner $10,000.00 208 W. Ponderosa Drive7/14/2020 20200278 Char Fritz 100 S. 7th Avenue Fence Owner Owner $648.00 100 S. 7th Avenue7/14/2020 20200279 John Saarloos 512 S. Nicholas Avenue Reside Todd Drake Co. 47626 Slip Up Creek Road; SF, SD 57104 $15,400.00 512 S. Nicholas Avenue7/14/2020 20200280 David Baer 201 E. Seth Street Lawn shed Owner Owner $1,275.00 201 E. Seth Street7/15/2020 20200281 Howard Hedger 101 S. Main Avenue Attic access Fred's Home Repair PO Box 17; Brandon, SD $800.00 101 S. Main Avenue7/15/2020 20200282 Agape Counseling 700 S. 8th Avenue Sign Pride Neon 3010 W. 10th Street; SF, SD 57104 $1,525.00 700 S. 8th Avenue7/16/2020 20200283 Aspen Park Apartments 610 S. 2nd Avenue Reshingle Classic Homes by Mike Lewis 5808 S. Grand Prairie Drive; SF, SD 57108 $15,000.00 610 S. 2nd Avenue7/16/2020 20200284 Paul Honken 1820 W. Thomas Circle Fence Empire Fence 5400 N. Indiana Avenue; SF, SD 57104 $5,418.00 1820 W. Thomas Circle7/16/2020 20200285 Deb Bjelland 520 S. Nicholas Avenue Fence Owner Owner $2,016.00 520 S. Nicholas Avenue7/16/2020 20200286 Thunder Creek Homes 6236 S. Pinnacle Place, Ste 105; SF, SD House/garage Thunder Creek Homes 6236 S. Pinnacle Place, Ste 105; SF, SD $153,582.00 413 N. Woodland Court7/16/2020 20200287 Oakland Homes 312 E. Holly Blvd., #2; Brandon, SD House/garage Oakland Homes 312 E. Holly Blvd., #2; Brandon, SD $155,070.00 700 S. 4th Circle7/17/2020 20200288 DAK Storage 300 E. Linden Street; Brandon, SD Self Storage Bldg. Reaves Building Systems 4101 N. 4th Avenue; SF, SD 57104 $165,000.00 300 E. Linden Street7/17/2020 20200289 Doug Gingles 401 S. Lakota Avenue Deck Owner Owner $2,100.00 401 S. Lakota Avenue7/17/2020 20200290 Chris Rahn 424 S. 5th Avenue Basement finish Owner Owner $14,400.00 424 S. 5th Avenue7/20/2020 20200291 Nathan Timmermans 301 E. Meadowlark Court Deck Lacey Construction 909 N. Stone Circle $7,488.00 301 E. Meadowlark Court7/20/2020 20200292 John Neth 412 S. Lakota Circle Fence American Fence 47061 Charlotte Ct; SF, SD 57108 $318.00 412 S. Lakota Circle7/20/2020 20200293 Jeremy Morgan 501 S. 5th Avenue Reshingle Owner Owner $3,200.00 501 S. 5th Avenue7/20/2020 20200294 Chris Calhoun 305 W. Ironwood Street Deck Nelson Home Improvement 216 S. Yellowstone Drive $1,728.00 305 W. Ironwood Street7/20/2020 20200295 Christopher Husby 916 S. Nicholas Avenue Fence Empire Fence 5400 N. Indiana Avenue; SF, SD 57104 $648.00 916 S. Nicholas Avenue7/20/2020 20200296 OdeCo, LLC. 1804 W. Frontier Street Self Storage Bldg. Owner Owner $850,000.00 201 N. Heritage Road7/20/2020 20200297 Ben Simonson 1309 S. Lakota Avenue Parking pad Gerry's Concrete 1208 E. Redwood Blvd. $1,125.00 1309 S. Lakota Avenue7/22/2020 20200298 Andy Haas 2825 E. Daybreak Circle Lawn shed & fence Owner Owner $3,120.00 2825 E. Daybreak Circle7/22/2020 20200299 Patrick Lingor 305 E. Glenwood Drive Lawn shed Owner Owner $1,190.00 305 E. Glenwood Drive7/23/2020 20200300 Corey Christensen 1505 W. Meadowbrook Trail Basement finish Owner Owner $2,340.00 1505 W. Meadowbrook Trail7/23/2020 20200301 Red Rock Builders 47001 Mona Street, Ste 5; Tea, SD 57064 House/garage Red Rock Builders 47001 Mona Street, Ste 5; Tea, SD 57064 $154,318.00 1916 W. River Bend Street7/23/2020 20200302 John Whitelock 217 N. Pasque Flower Trail Deck Owner Owner $1,584.00 217 N. Pasque Flower Trail7/24/2020 20200303 Russell Dean 421 S. 5th Avenue Fence Owner Owner $2,079.00 421 S. 5th Avenue7/24/2020 20200304 John Nedved 504 S. 4th Avenue Driveway addition Owner Owner $940.00 504 S. 4th Avenue7/24/2020 20200305 Jordan Dockter 1408 E. Rushmore Drive Fence Empire Fence 5400 N. Indiana Avenue; SF, SD 57104 $1,958.00 1408 E. Rushmore Drive7/27/2020 20200306 Thomas Biever 409 S. Sunshine Avenue Lawn shed Owner Owner $680.00 409 S. Sunshine Avenue

New Homes to Date:

2020 - 27

2019 - 18

2222