8/10/2019 PLAINTIFFS TRIAL MEMORANDUM
1/4
PLAINTIFFS TRIAL MEMORANDUM
Plaintif, through counsel, ost res!ect"ull# alleges$
STATEMENTS OF FACTS:
%& Plaintif is 'onna (ueno, )* #ears ol+, arrie+ an+ a
resi+ent o" - Little (aguioSt&, San 'uan .it#, Metro
Manila& She is an accountant& On the other han+,
+e"en+ant is /loria Su!erart, Inc&, locate+ at Ortigas
A0enue, San 'uan, Metro
Manila&
1& Plaintif has 2een a lo#al custoer o" /loria Su!erart,
Inc&, 2u#ing her groceries
an+ other stuf "or the !ast 13 #ears& Plaintif alleges that
her son sufere+
e4cruciating !ain 5hen he sli!!e+ on a 5et 6oor o" /loria
Su!erart 2# reason o"
gross negligence 2# 2oth the anageent an+ its e!lo#ees&
)& Aroun+ %3$33 a on Ma# %%, 13%3, !laintif together 5ith
Ric7#, her *8#ear ol+
son, 5ent to /loria Su!erart to 2u# toato sauce an+ other things
the# nee+e+ intheir house& 9hen su++enl#, a sall 2all rolle+
along the aisle, an+ Ric7# ran a"ter
it&
:& A"ter5ar+s, the !laintif sa5 her son sli!!e+ 5ith a hea0#
2ang on a 5et section
o" the aisle, shrie7ing "ro !ain in his right 5rist& She
ie+iatel# cae to his si+e
to hel! hi& A store cler7, 5ho she re"erre+ ;not
"rien+l#
8/10/2019 PLAINTIFFS TRIAL MEMORANDUM
2/4
"ro the shel" 5hen he ran 5il+ +o5n the aisle, chasing a"ter a
loose 2all& =e 5as
not there 5hen the inci+ent occurre+&
STATEMENT OF ISSUES:
%& 9hether or not +e"en+ant is guilt# o" Attracti0e Nuisance
o0er the inci+ent
occurre+ +uring the a2o0eentione+ case&
1& 9hether or not the !laintif 0ali+l# a2ate+ the nuisance
5hen she >les a
co!laint 2e"ore the Regional Trial .ourt
)& 9hether or not the +e"en+ant coitte+ negligence on their
!art o" allo5ing a
inor to sli! in their !reises&
:& 9hether or not +e"en+ant shoul+ 2e hel+ lia2le "or +aages
cause+ to the
!etitioner
ARGUMENTS:
%& The +e"en+ant is guilt# o" Attracti0e Nuisance o0er the
inci+ent occurre+ in their
!reises&
As +e>ne+ 2# the la5, Attractive Nuisanceis one 5ho aintains
on his !reises
+angerous instruentalities or appliances of a caracter li!el" to
attractcil#ren in pla", an+ $o fails to e%ercise or#inar" care to
prevent cil#ren
fro& pla"in' tere$it or resorting thereto, is lia(le to a
cil# of ten#er
"ears $o is in)ure#there2#, e0en i" the chil+ is a tres!asser in
the !reises
