2
Answer the following questions about your peer’s Prospectus draft then email this document to Prof. Manley by Thursday, May 28 at 11:59 pm. Be as detailed as possible in your review of their prospectus. What is the title? _______________________________________________________________ Is the title creative and non-predictable? ____________________________________________ Suggest two alternative titles the writer could use? 1. ____________________________________________________________ ___________ 2. ____________________________________________________________ ___________ What is the topic the writer will research? ____________________________________________ What is his/her research question? _________________________________________________ Can this question be answered with a yes or no? If so, suggest a new research question than cannot be answered in one word. ___________________________________________________ Why is this topic controversial? ____________________________________________________ Why do you think this writer is interested in the topic? _________________________________ What is the researcher’s purpose for writing about this topic? ____________________________

Peer Review 1

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Prospectus Peer Review

Citation preview

Answer the following questions about your peers Prospectus draft then email this document to Prof. Manley by Thursday, May 28 at 11:59 pm. Be as detailed as possible in your review of their prospectus.

What is the title? _______________________________________________________________Is the title creative and non-predictable? ____________________________________________Suggest two alternative titles the writer could use?1. _______________________________________________________________________2. _______________________________________________________________________

What is the topic the writer will research? ____________________________________________What is his/her research question? _________________________________________________Can this question be answered with a yes or no? If so, suggest a new research question than cannot be answered in one word. ___________________________________________________Why is this topic controversial? ____________________________________________________Why do you think this writer is interested in the topic? _________________________________What is the researchers purpose for writing about this topic? ____________________________Who is the researchers audience? __________________________________________________What is the plan for research? _____________________________________________________Do you think the researcher has a reasonable plan? ____________________________________Did s/he include possible primary and secondary sources? _______________________________

Give three suggestions to the writer/researcher to help make the overall topic and plan clearer:1. _____________________________________________________________________2. _____________________________________________________________________3. _____________________________________________________________________

After rereading the assignment sheet and rubric on the course website, what other suggestions do you have for the writer to improve his/her Prospectus before submitting the final draft?__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________