28
PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order No. 8 The Tribunal’s decisions on Documents Withheld from Production Pursuant to Procedural Order No. 6 on the Basis of Privilege Priv. Log No. Date Author or Custodian Recipient(s) Summary Description Glencore’s Basis of Privilege Bolivia’s Comments Glencore’s Reply Bolivia’s Response Glencore’s Sur- Reply Tribunal’s Decision 1 9 March 2007 Litigation / Work Product; Common Interest Request denied 1

PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order …...Bolivia’s Comments Glencore’s Reply Bolivia’s Response Glencore’s Sur-Reply Tribunal’s Decision 1 9 March 2007 Litigation

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order …...Bolivia’s Comments Glencore’s Reply Bolivia’s Response Glencore’s Sur-Reply Tribunal’s Decision 1 9 March 2007 Litigation

PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order No. 8

The Tribunal’s decisions on Documents Withheld from Production Pursuant to Procedural Order No. 6 on the Basis of Privilege

Priv. Log No.

Date Author or Custodian

Recipient(s) Summary Description

Glencore’s Basis of Privilege

Bolivia’s Comments

Glencore’s Reply Bolivia’s Response

Glencore’s Sur-Reply

Tribunal’s Decision

1 9 March 2007

Litigation / Work Product; Common Interest

Request denied

1

Page 2: PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order …...Bolivia’s Comments Glencore’s Reply Bolivia’s Response Glencore’s Sur-Reply Tribunal’s Decision 1 9 March 2007 Litigation

PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order No. 8

1

3 Bolivia’s Statement of Defense, Section 4.4; Bolivia’s Rejoinder, Sections 4.4 and 4.7. 4

2

Page 3: PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order …...Bolivia’s Comments Glencore’s Reply Bolivia’s Response Glencore’s Sur-Reply Tribunal’s Decision 1 9 March 2007 Litigation

PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order No. 8

3

Page 4: PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order …...Bolivia’s Comments Glencore’s Reply Bolivia’s Response Glencore’s Sur-Reply Tribunal’s Decision 1 9 March 2007 Litigation

PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order No. 8

2

4

Page 5: PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order …...Bolivia’s Comments Glencore’s Reply Bolivia’s Response Glencore’s Sur-Reply Tribunal’s Decision 1 9 March 2007 Litigation

PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order No. 8

2 Litigation / Work

Request denied

5

Page 6: PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order …...Bolivia’s Comments Glencore’s Reply Bolivia’s Response Glencore’s Sur-Reply Tribunal’s Decision 1 9 March 2007 Litigation

PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order No. 8

Product; Common Interest

5

6

Page 7: PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order …...Bolivia’s Comments Glencore’s Reply Bolivia’s Response Glencore’s Sur-Reply Tribunal’s Decision 1 9 March 2007 Litigation

PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order No. 8

7

Page 8: PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order …...Bolivia’s Comments Glencore’s Reply Bolivia’s Response Glencore’s Sur-Reply Tribunal’s Decision 1 9 March 2007 Litigation

PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order No. 8

8

Page 9: PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order …...Bolivia’s Comments Glencore’s Reply Bolivia’s Response Glencore’s Sur-Reply Tribunal’s Decision 1 9 March 2007 Litigation

PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order No. 8

5 Legal Advice / Attorney- Client; Litigation / Work Product

Request denied

9

Page 10: PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order …...Bolivia’s Comments Glencore’s Reply Bolivia’s Response Glencore’s Sur-Reply Tribunal’s Decision 1 9 March 2007 Litigation

PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order No. 8

10

Page 11: PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order …...Bolivia’s Comments Glencore’s Reply Bolivia’s Response Glencore’s Sur-Reply Tribunal’s Decision 1 9 March 2007 Litigation

PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order No. 8

11

Page 12: PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order …...Bolivia’s Comments Glencore’s Reply Bolivia’s Response Glencore’s Sur-Reply Tribunal’s Decision 1 9 March 2007 Litigation

PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order No. 8

7 Litigation / Work Product; Common Interest

Request denied

12

Page 13: PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order …...Bolivia’s Comments Glencore’s Reply Bolivia’s Response Glencore’s Sur-Reply Tribunal’s Decision 1 9 March 2007 Litigation

PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order No. 8

6

7

13

Page 14: PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order …...Bolivia’s Comments Glencore’s Reply Bolivia’s Response Glencore’s Sur-Reply Tribunal’s Decision 1 9 March 2007 Litigation

PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order No. 8

8 Litigation / Work Product; Common Interest

Request denied

14

Page 15: PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order …...Bolivia’s Comments Glencore’s Reply Bolivia’s Response Glencore’s Sur-Reply Tribunal’s Decision 1 9 March 2007 Litigation

PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order No. 8

14 Litigation / Work Product; Settlement

Request denied

15

Page 16: PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order …...Bolivia’s Comments Glencore’s Reply Bolivia’s Response Glencore’s Sur-Reply Tribunal’s Decision 1 9 March 2007 Litigation

PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order No. 8

16

Page 17: PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order …...Bolivia’s Comments Glencore’s Reply Bolivia’s Response Glencore’s Sur-Reply Tribunal’s Decision 1 9 March 2007 Litigation

PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order No. 8

8

9

17

Page 18: PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order …...Bolivia’s Comments Glencore’s Reply Bolivia’s Response Glencore’s Sur-Reply Tribunal’s Decision 1 9 March 2007 Litigation

PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order No. 8

16 Litigation / Work Product

Request denied

18

Page 19: PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order …...Bolivia’s Comments Glencore’s Reply Bolivia’s Response Glencore’s Sur-Reply Tribunal’s Decision 1 9 March 2007 Litigation

PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order No. 8

19

Page 20: PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order …...Bolivia’s Comments Glencore’s Reply Bolivia’s Response Glencore’s Sur-Reply Tribunal’s Decision 1 9 March 2007 Litigation

PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order No. 8

20

Page 21: PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order …...Bolivia’s Comments Glencore’s Reply Bolivia’s Response Glencore’s Sur-Reply Tribunal’s Decision 1 9 March 2007 Litigation

PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order No. 8

21 Litigation / Work Product; Settlement

Request denied

21

Page 22: PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order …...Bolivia’s Comments Glencore’s Reply Bolivia’s Response Glencore’s Sur-Reply Tribunal’s Decision 1 9 March 2007 Litigation

PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order No. 8

22

Page 23: PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order …...Bolivia’s Comments Glencore’s Reply Bolivia’s Response Glencore’s Sur-Reply Tribunal’s Decision 1 9 March 2007 Litigation

PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order No. 8

10 Reply, ¶ 177 and footnote 479, ¶ 397 and footnote 967; Second Witness Statement of Christopher Eskdale, ¶ 55 and

footnote 48.

23

Page 24: PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order …...Bolivia’s Comments Glencore’s Reply Bolivia’s Response Glencore’s Sur-Reply Tribunal’s Decision 1 9 March 2007 Litigation

PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order No. 8

22 Litigation / Work Product; Settlement

Request denied

82 Litigation / Work Product; Common Interest

Request denied

24

Page 25: PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order …...Bolivia’s Comments Glencore’s Reply Bolivia’s Response Glencore’s Sur-Reply Tribunal’s Decision 1 9 March 2007 Litigation

PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order No. 8

25

Page 26: PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order …...Bolivia’s Comments Glencore’s Reply Bolivia’s Response Glencore’s Sur-Reply Tribunal’s Decision 1 9 March 2007 Litigation

PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order No. 8

84 Litigation / Work Product

Request denied

26

Page 27: PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order …...Bolivia’s Comments Glencore’s Reply Bolivia’s Response Glencore’s Sur-Reply Tribunal’s Decision 1 9 March 2007 Litigation

PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order No. 8

27

Page 28: PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order …...Bolivia’s Comments Glencore’s Reply Bolivia’s Response Glencore’s Sur-Reply Tribunal’s Decision 1 9 March 2007 Litigation

PCA Case No. 2016-39 Annex 1 to Procedural Order No. 8

28