12

Click here to load reader

Paradoxes of Awareness by O.G. Rose

  • Upload
    og-rose

  • View
    215

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Paradoxes of Awareness by O.G. Rose

7/23/2019 Paradoxes of Awareness by O.G. Rose

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/paradoxes-of-awareness-by-og-rose 1/12

Rcrcmjxas je CwcrakassJk Qkmarstckmhki, Hktakthjk, Rurpjsa, ckm tfa Rfakjoakjnjiy je Pacmhki (Nhea)

J.I. Pjsa

C wjrg hk tfa scoa ecohny cs „\jlhjnjihlcn-Cwcrakass‟ tfct cnsj mrcws erjo

„Axparhaklhki ]fhkghki‟ ckm „\ane-Manushjk, tfa ]jwcrm-kass je Avhmakla, ckm tfa Rcrcmjx je

Dumioakt‟, cnn `y J.I. Pjsa, tfhs pcpar whnn axpnjra jtfar ghkms je pcrcmjxas hk wfhlf‖cwcrakass je ‘ truklctas ‖mavanjpoakt je‘ (ckm/jr ‖trua cwcrakass je‘), ushki tfa axparhakla je

racmhki cs c ercoawjrg ejr axpnjrhki tfasa tjphls. Hk pcrthluncr, tfa pcpar whnn ejlus jk‖Qkmarstckmhki-Cwcrakass‘, ‖Hktakthjk-Cwcrakass‘, ckm ‖Rurpjsa-Cwcrakass‘, cnn je wfhlf

sfcra shohncrhthas whtf ‖\jlhjnjihlcn-Cwcrakass‘, ckm cnn je wfhlf cra hktaksheham hk jur \jlhcn

Oamhc ckm Ocss Hkejrocthjk Cia. Echnura tj `a ‖cwcra je tfasa hrjkhas je cwcrakass‘ (c ljohlcnkjthjk pjhkthki tj tfa eclt tfct ‖hrjky hs `ahki‘, cs criuam tfrjuifjut Hrjkhlcnny `y J.I. Pjsa)

whnn rasunt hk arrjrs je mhslarkoakt ckm pcrcmjxas, `jtf je wfhlf whnn hkerhkia upjk fuock

tfrhvhki. Cmohttamny, tfhs pcpar whnn aktchn parsjkcn clljukts ckm fhifnhifts je ‖wfct wjrgs ejr

oa‘, cs H tfhkg ht hs ukcvjhmc`na wfak macnhki whtf octtars je ‖fhif jrmar ljopnaxhty‘, hk wfhlftfa pcrthluncr lckkjt `a (racmhny) trcksnctam hktj tfa iakarcn. Eaan eraa tj tcga jr nacva oy

 parsjkcn clljukts cs yju saa eht.

H

Fjw mj yju racm c `jjg: Mjas jka racnny eunny ircsp tfa oackhki je avary saktakla

 `aejra ojvhki jk tj tfa kaxt: Jr hs ht ojra nhga c ghkm je ‖enjwhki‘, wfara c parsjk dust nats tfawjrms rusf jvar fho jr far, ircsphki tfa wjrms jk wfct hs c strckia ljkslhjus-ckm-yat-

su`ljkslhjus navan: He jka hs tjj ejlusam jk avary saktakla, tfa parsjk echns tj saa tfa pcrcircpf,

ckm he c parsjk ejlusas tjj oulf jk c pcrcircpf, tfa parsjk lck njsa shift je tfa lfcptar, ckm sj

jk. Hk racmhki, c parsjk fcs tj `jtf saa tfa ejrast tfrjuif tfa traas ckm tfa traas hk tfa ejrast. @utfjw hs tfct pjssh`na: Fjw lck c parsjk ejlus jk twj mheearakt tfhkis ct tfa scoa thoa: Hsk‘t

ejlus, `y maehkhthjk, c ‖ocghki hkvhsh`na‘ avarytfhki ansa `ut tfct wfhlf hs ejlusam upjk: He H scy‖H co ejlushki jk yju‘, co H kjt scyhki tfct ‖H mjk‘t saa ckytfhki jr ckyjka `ut yju‘: ]j racm hstj pcrthlhpcta hk c ghkm je pcrcmjx tfct he yju tfjuift c`jut tjj fcrm, yju‘m echn tj racm wann. He

yju ejlusam tjj fcrm jk ‖mj H ircsp tfct saktakla:‘, yju‘m echn tj ircsp tfa ljktaxt, `ut he yju

ejlusam tjj oulf jk ‖mj H ukmarstckm tfa ljktaxt:‘, yju‘m njsa shift je tfa saktakla hk erjkt jeyju.

Pacmhki hs strckia4 tfara hs sjoatfhki hkljoprafaksh`na c`jut ht, ckm yat racmhki hs ck

clt je ljoprafakshjk. Ckm sj tj csg tfa quasthjk ‖wfct hs ht tj racm:‘ hs sjoawfct c `cm

quasthjk, ckm yat ck hopjrtckt quasthjk tj csg. Ht saaos tj ukvahn tfct fuocks cra c`na tj ‖mucntfhkg‘, he yju whnn, ckm yat tfa clt je tryhki tj ljoprafakm tfhs ‖mucn tfhkghki‘ hs tj trckspjshthjk

ckm ramula ht hktj ‖shkina tfhkghki‘. ]fhs hs shohncr tj tfa pcrcmjx axpnjram hk „Axparhaklhki

]fhkghki‟ jk fjw tfa clt je tryhki tj ircsp ‖fhif jrmar ljopnaxhty‘ hs tfa vary clt wfhlframulas ht tj ‖njw jrmar ljopnaxhty‘ (ckm sj kjt tfct wfhlf tfa parsjk hs tryhki tj ircsp).Hrjkhlcnny, tfa clt je ircsphki hs tfa clt je wfhlf rasunts hk tfara `ahki kjtfhki tj ircsp (tfjuif

mj kjta tfct sjoa echnuras cra `attar tfck jtfars).

]j ljkthkua tj mrcw erjo „Axparhaklhki ]fhkghki‟, racmhki saaos tj fhifnhift fjwfuocks lck `jtf tfhkg hktakthjkcnny ckm ukhktakthjkcnny, avak mjhki `jtf ct tfa scoa thoa.

Qkhktakthjkcn tfjuift c`jut c pcrcircpf hk c `jjg lck `a tfa ljktaxt hk wfhlf tfa hktakthjkcn

tfjuift c`jut c saktakla jllurs. Hktakthjkcn ckm ukhktakthjkcn tfjuift saao tj `a akiciam hk c

Page 2: Paradoxes of Awareness by O.G. Rose

7/23/2019 Paradoxes of Awareness by O.G. Rose

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/paradoxes-of-awareness-by-og-rose 2/12

‖mckla‘ wfak c parsjk racms, ckm he tfa parsjk tfhkgs c`jut tfa mckla, tfa parsjk whnn echn tj racm

wann (nhga tfa lakthpama tfct lck ojva ukthn fa tfhkgs c`jut fjw fa ljjrmhkctas cnn fhs nais, tj

cnnuma tj tfa ecojus hocia). Pacmhki hs c `cncklhki clt, jka tfct lckkjt `a tfjuift c`jut ckm yatjka tfct kaams tj `a tfjuift c`jut sj tfct wa ocy ‖ukhktakthjkcnny tfhkg‘ wann (pcrcmjxhlcn, H

gkjw).

H whnn spacg erjo parsjkcn axparhakla4 H ehkm tfct wfak H racm c `jjg, aspalhcnny cljopnax ckm mheehlunt jka, he H try tjj fcrm tj ircsp wfct H co racmhki, H whnn echn tj ljoprafakm.Cs whtf Fahmaiiar ‘s wrhthki, ejr axcopna, H mj kjt try tj iat ‖tfa wjrms hktj oy facm‘ sj oulf

cs H try tj ‖nat tfa wjrms enjw jvar oa‘. H try kjt tj ahtfar ‖ljoprafakm‘ jr ‖kjt ljoprafakm‘ “  H

try kjt tj avak nat oysane tfhkg hk taros je tfct mhlfjtjoy. ]fa scoa ijas wfak H racm tfaoysthls jr wjrgs je Crhstjtna4 H nat tfa wjrms wcsf jvar oa, ckm tfak tfhkg c`jut wfct H

axparhaklam cetarwcrms. @ut avak tfak, H mjk‘t sj oulf csg tfa quasthjk ‖mj H ukmarstckm:‘ sj

oulf cs H csg ‖wfct hs trua:‘. Csghki tfct quasthjk, H hkavhtc`ny ehkm oysane ‖stuo`nhki upjk‘

wfct H racm, avak he H mhmk‘t pnck jk mjhki sj. ]fa saktaklas ckm wjrms dust ‖cppacr‘ hk oy ohkm,summakny ckm cnn ct jkla7 fjw tfhs fcppaks, H ljunmk‘t axpnchk. Kjt `alcusa tfara hs kj njihl tj ht,

 `ut `alcusa tfa clt je axpnchkhki ht hs tj ramula c octtar je ‖fhif jrmar lcuscnhty‘ hktj ‖njw jrmar

ljopnaxhty‘, cs tj axpnchk c octtar je parlapthjk hs tj axpnchk ht hk taros je tfhkghki (c pcrcmjxkjtam hk „Jk ]fhkghki ckm Rarlahvhki‟ `y J.I. Pjsa). ‖Fhif jrmar ljopnaxhty‘ lck `a ‖pjhktam

tj‘, `ut kjt ircspam ‖cnn tjiatfar‘ “  ht lck jkny `a ircspam hk ercioakts ckm inhooars tfct c

 parsjk lck ‖cslakt‘ tj cnn ijhki tjiatfar. C parsjk lckkjt ircsp avary wjrm jk avary pcia je c

 `jjg shountckajusny, `ut c parsjk lck, cetar racmhki tfao cnn, cslakt tj tfao cnn ijhki tjiatfar,avak tfjuif tfa parsjk ocy kjt `a c`na tj ircsp tfao cnn tjiatfar cs jka. ‖Njw jrmar tfhkghki‘

hs kalasscry ejr ‖fhif jrmar tfhkghki‘ ckm vhla-varsc4 tfara cra jkny prj`naos wfak jka trhas tj

rapncla jr mavcnua jka jr tfa jtfar.]j raturk tj parsjkcn axparhakla4 racmhki tj oa hs ck clt je natthki oysane kjt ukmarstckm.

Ht aktchns c trust tfct H whnn ukmarstckm wfct lck `a ukmarstjjm ckm tfct H whnn `a mhraltam tjwcrm

‖wfct hs trua‘ he H shopny gaap wjrghki ckm ‖enjwhki‘. He H trham tj ukmarstckm avarytfhki H racm

ckm tj raoao`ar avary hmac tfct lrjssam oy ohkm, H wjunm fcva ocma kj prjirass hk oy djurkaytj ukmarstckm tfhs nhea wa cnn nhva. H ehkm tfct he H trust, H summakny ehkm oysane dust ukmarstckmhki

wfct H racm, summakny ckm oystarhjusny nctar jk. H wjk‘t lncho H ukmarstckm avarytfhki eunny ckm

 parealtny, `ut H whnn scy tfct he H dust gaap racmhki Fahmaiiar, Crhstjtna, atl., ejlusam jkmatarohkhki ‖wfct hs trua‘, H ircsp oulf ojra je tfahr tfjuift tfck H mj jtfarwhsa. 

Cnn tfhs hsk‘t tj scy tfct ‖lnjsa racmhki‘ mjask‘t wjrg jr sfjunm `a cvjhmam7 ‖lnjsa

racmhki‘ hs vary hopjrtckt. Pctfar, ht hs tj scy tfct jka sfjunmk‘t nat ‖racmhki lnjsany‘ hopama‖racmhki‘. ]fhs ocy sjukm strckia, ckm cmohttamny, avarytfhki pcrcmjxhlcn oust sjukm strckia.

Fjwavar, H parsjkcnny fcva ejukm tfct wfct hs ojra hopjrtckt tfck tryhki tj ‖racm lnjsany‘ hs

tryhki tj ‖racm lracthvany‘, wfhlf oacks tfct H ‖racm jpak tj tfa pjssh`hnhty‘ je lracthki

sjoatfhki erjo wfct H racm. H mjk‘t racm avary `jjg sjnany ejr tfa hktakt je lracthki sjoatfhkijut je ht, `ut H mj cnwcys racm whnnhki tj tfhkg sjoatfhki kaw erjo wfct H racm. H ehkm tfhs jpaks

up oy ohkm ckm ocgas ht ojra enuhm ckm cihna, varsus rhihm ckm jvarny ejlusam. Cnn racmhki hs

unthoctany lracthva (avak he kjt tfjuift je cs sulf), ejr cnn racmhki ljo`hkas yjur ohkm whtf tfa

ohkm je tfa wrhtar , ejrohki ‖sjoatfhki kaw‘ (tfjuif jkny tfa racmar lck gkjw wfct ljksthtutastfct ‖kawkass‘). ]j ‖racm lracthvany‘ tfak, hs tj shopny racm hk c ockkar cwcra je wfct racmhki hs

hk assakla “  c lracthva clt. Rarsjkcnny, H fcva ejukm tfct he H racm tj lracta, H whnn c`sjr`, `ut he H

racm jkny tj c`sjr`, H mjk‘t c`sjr` kacrny cs wann. H saao `attar ct oaojrhzhki tfa hmacs je

Page 3: Paradoxes of Awareness by O.G. Rose

7/23/2019 Paradoxes of Awareness by O.G. Rose

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/paradoxes-of-awareness-by-og-rose 3/12

 pajpna tfct H hktaircta ckm parsjkcnhza hktj oy jwk tfjuift ckm pursuht je trutf tfck tfa hmacs H

shopny racm.

]j oa, racmhki, cs whtf ukmarstckmhki, hs nhga njva4 cs H dust ehkm oysane ‖hk njva‘, Hnhgawhsa dust ehkm oysane ‖hk ukmarstckmhki‘. ]fhs hsk‘t tj scy tfara hsk‘t cky wjrg hkvjnvam wfak

ht ljoas tj racmhki7 wjrgnass racmhki hs pjjr racmhki, cs njva whtfjut wjrg hs aopty ceealthjk.

]j njva ckm tj `a njvc`na, c parsjk oust wjrg ct `ahki mhslarkhki, aopctfathl, tfjuifteun, ckmsj jk. Hk c saksa, jka lckkjt mhraltny wjrg ct ‖`ahki njvhki‘, jkny wjrg ct `ahki `attar ct wfctocgas up njva, ckm sj wjrg ct ‖`ahki njvhki‘ (hkmhraltny) (sjoatfhki shohncr lck `a schm c`jut

‖`ahki fuock‘, ‖`ahki c ijjm wjrgar‘, atl.). Cs jka lckkjt `uhnm c fjusa whtfjut wjrghki ct

 `aljohki ijjm ct ncyhki `rhlgs, analtrhlcn wjrg, atl., sj wjrghki ct ‖ `ahki njvhki‘ aktchns ichkhkiaxparthsa jk njva‘s vcrhjus cspalts. Avak he jka mjask‘t kalasscrhny wjrg mhraltny ct ‖`ahki jpak

tj njva‘, hk c parsjk mavanjphki hk tfa cracs tfct ljksthtuta ‖`ahki njvhki‘, tfa parsjk wjrgs ct

‖`ahki jpak tj njva‘ hkmhraltny. @ut cs whtf ‖fhif jrmar lcuscnhty‘ `ahki jvarnjjgam hk ecvjr je

‖njw jrmar lcuscnhty‘, shkla tfhs wjrg hsk‘t ‖mhralt‘, tfa ohkm fcs trju`na ircsphki fjw wjrghkijk saaony ukranctam cracs je parsjkfjjm whnn rasunt hk tfa mavanjpoakt je jtfar cracs je

lfcrcltar. \hohncrny, wa struiina tj ircsp fjw Ahkstahk shtthki upstchrs njjghki jut c whkmjw whnn

nacm tj tfa mavanjpoakt je tfa ]fajry je Pancthvhty, cs wa struiina tj ircsp fjw ‖natthki c taxtwcsf jvar us‘ whnn nacm tj jur ljoprafakshjk je tfa taxt. Xat, erjo parsjkcn axparhakla, H whnn

lncho sulf hs tfa lcsa. Pacmhki hs nhga wctar4 he yju try tj ircsp ht, ht whnn ruk tfrjuif yjur

ehkiars, `ut he yju nat ht enjw jvar yju (wfhna jpak tj lracthvhty), ht whnn lnack ckm sjjtf yju. 

HH

‖Pacmhki-Cwcrakass‘, cs maslrh`am kcoanassny hk tfa ehrst salthjk, hs tfa stcta je `ahkigapt erjo ljoprafakmhki c taxt mua tj jka‘s ejlus jk ljoprafakmhki c taxt. \hohncrny, hk tfhs

salthjk H whnn axpnjra ‖Qkmarstckmhki-Cwcrakass‘, wfhlf hs tfa stcta je `ahki ehxam jk

ukmarstckmhki hk c wcy tfct truklctas ukmarstckmhki. Cs whtf racmhki, H ehkm tfct natthki

hkejrocthjk ‖wcsf jvar oa‘ iractny hklracsas oy lfcklas je ratchkhki tfa hkejrocthjk (ckmratchkhki tfa ojst hopjrtckt pcrts je tfa hkejrocthjk, ejr tfct octtar). H fcva ejukm sjoatfhki

shohncr wfak ht ljoas tj ljkvarscthjk4 he H co ‖Ljkvarscthjk-Cwcra‘, H try tjj fcrm tj ircsp

avarytfhki tfct sjoajka hs scyhki, ckm cs c rasunt, H ohss tfa pjhkt. Cs whtf racmhki, he H wjkmartfa wfjna thoa ‖hs tfct wfct tfa parsjk oackt:‘, ‖wfct mhm tfa spacgar oack:‘, atl., H njsa trclg

je tfa ljkvarscthjk. Cs `y ejlushki tjj lnjsany jk c saktakla, H njsa trclg je tfa ljktaxt, sj he H

ejlus tjj fcrm jk wfct c parsjk hs scyhki, hrjkhlcnny, H ohss wfct tfa parsjk hs scyhki. (]fhs hs tj `a axpaltam hk ck hrjkhl wjrnm, H suppjsa4 tj ao`rcla hrjky hs tj ao`rcla iakhus.)

Cs whtf racmhki ckm tfa parsjk wfj jvarny ejlusas jk racmhki lnjsany, tfa parsjk wfj

 `anhavas fa jr sfa hs tryhki tj ‖hktakthjkcnny‘ ircsp hkejrocthjk whnn tfhkg tfct fa jr sfa gkjws

ojra tfck tfa parsjk wfj dust nats tfa hkejrocthjk ‖enjw‘. Nhga tfa ‖fhif jrmar lcuscnhty‘-tfhkgartj tfa ‖njw jrmar lcuscnhty‘-tfhkgar (ckm nhga tfa parlahvar tj tfa tfhkgar, tj cnnuma tj „Jk

]fhkghki ckm Rarlahvhki‟ `y J.I. Pjsa), tfa parsjk wfj ‖nats tfa hkejrocthjk enjw‘ whnn saao tj

tfa parsjk wfj ‖ircsps tfa hkejrocthjk‘ cs he fa jr sfa mjask‘t ukmarstckm, ckm tfct fa jr sfa

mjask‘t lcra tj ukmarstckm. ]fa parsjk wfj ircsps whnn `anhava fa jr sfa gkjws ojra, wfak ht hs pralhsany tfhs `anhae tfct lck gaap tfa parsjk erjo gkjwhki. Hk jtfar wjrms, tfa aeejrt tj ircsp

Fahmaiiar lck `a tfa aeejrt tfct lcusas Fahmaiiar tj `a anushva, cs tfa aeejrt tj ircsp hkejrocthjk

lck `a tfa aeejrt tfct ocgas tfa hkejrocthjk hkljoprafaksh`na.

Page 4: Paradoxes of Awareness by O.G. Rose

7/23/2019 Paradoxes of Awareness by O.G. Rose

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/paradoxes-of-awareness-by-og-rose 4/12

Rnacsa kjta fara tfct oy pjhkt c`jut ‖natthki c taxt enjw jvar yju‘ hsk‘t c pjhkt c`jut

racmhki spaam sj oulf cs ht hs c`jut c lartchk mhspjshthjk wfhna racmhki. Pctfar tfck racm hk

taros je ‖ukmarstckmhki varsus kjt ukmarstckmhki‘, jka sfjunm nat tfa wjrms ‖enjw jvar‘, trusthkitfct wfct sfjunm `a ircspam whnn `a ircspam ckm tfct wfct sfjunm `a ukmarstjjm whnn `a

ukmarstjjm. ‖Enjw‘ hsk‘t sj oulf c `jut spaam cs ht hs c`jut c rancthjksfhp whtf tfa taxt htsane4 ht hs

ck ‖jpakhki up‘ jkasane tj tfa taxt rctfar tfck c ‖sfrhkghki tfa taxt‘ whtfhk tfa ljkehkas je jka‘s(prasat) hmacs ckm tfhkghki “  ht hs ejr c racmar tj oaat tfa taxt jk hts su`dalthvhty varsus tfaracmar ‘s su`dalthvhty “  tj oaat tfa taxt jk hts jwk ‖irjukms‘ (jr ‖fjrhzjk‘, tj usa c Icmcoar

taro), varsus tfa racmar ocghki tfa taxt oaat tfa racmar jk fhs jr far ‖irjukms‘ (ejr c parsjk tj

racm tfa @h`na cs c `anhavar varsus c kjk-`anhavar, ejr axcopna, tfjuif tfct hsk‘t tj scy c racmarlck‘t stap `clg ckm lrhthqua tfa @h`na cs ck Ctfahst). Ckm yat pcrcmjxhlcnny tfhs hs clfhavam `y

kjt `ahki jvarny ejlusam jk ‖ukmarstckmhki tfa taxt‘, ck ‖jvar ejlus‘ wfhlf ljunm parfcps

fcppak `alcusa c parsjk wckts tj oaat tfa taxt jk hts jwk ‖irjukms‘7 rctfar, ht‘s clfhavam erjo

trusthki hk jka‘s sane ckm ‖natthki mjwk jka‘s tfhkghki‘, tj c mairaa, ckm jpakhki jka‘s sane up tjtfa axparhakla je tfa taxt htsane.

]j fanp axpnchk tfa ‖enjw‘ pfakjoakjk axpnjram hk tfhs salthjk, wa sfcnn ravhsht ‖tfa

 pcrcmjx je dumioakt‘ (hktrjmulam hk „\ane-Manushjk, tfa ]jwcrm-kass je Avhmakla, ckm tfaRcrcmjx je Dumioakt‟). He H scy jr tfhkg ‖H mjk‘t ukmarstckm (hksart )‘, H fcva lractam c ‖naks‘

tfrjuif wfhlf H whnn turk pfakjoakc (‖tjwcrm‘ oa) hktj avhmakla ejr tfa lcsa tfct ‖H mjk‘t

ukmarstckm‘. Ljksaquaktny, H ocy clt hk sulf c wcy tfct (saaos tj) ljkehro tfhs lcsa4 ejr

axcopna, he H ljklnuma ‖H mjk‘t ukmarstckm‘ c lartchk `jjg, H ocy stjp racmhki ht, ocghki sulf tfalcsa7 he H ljklnuma ‖H mjk‘t ukmarstckm wfct tfhs parsjk hs scyhki‘, H ocy lfckia tfa tjphl,

rj``hki oysane je tfa lfckla tj ukmarstckm (ckm sj prjvhki, tj oysane, ‖H mjk‘t ukmarstckm‘). H

ocy, tj ljkthkua whtf tfa axcopnas, rchsa oy fckm murhki c naltura ckm tann c prjeassjr ‖H mjk‘tukmarstckm‘, lcushki tfa prjeassjr tj eraaza up ckm echn tj ocga saksa7 H ocy, murhki c

ljkvarscthjk whtf c erhakm, tann tfa erhakm ‖H mjk‘t ukmarstckm wfct yju‘ra iatthki ct‘, lcushki tfa

erhakm tj stuo`na jvar fhs wjrms, sj prjvhki tj oa tfct oy erhakm wcsk‘t scyhki ckytfhki tfct

ljunm `a ukmarstjjm jr tfct oy erhakm avak ukmarstjjm. H ocy scy ‖H mjk‘t ukmarstckm‘ erjo ciakuhka pncla je wckthki tj ukmarstckm, ckm yat oy clthjk ocy sthnn, vary wann, rasunt hk oa

 `ahki ukc`na tj ukmarstckm. Fakla, wa oust `a j`dalthva c`jut jur clthjks `ayjkm tfa hktakthjks

wfhlf ojthvcta tfao.]fa dumioakt ‖tfhs mjask‘t ocga saksa‘ (jr ‖H mjk‘t ciraa‘) lck `a tfa vary tfhki tfct

ocgas sjoatfhki kjksaksa (clljrmhki tj tfa (parlahvam) avhmakla), cs tfa mashra tj ukmarstckm

lck iat hk tfa wcy je ukmarstckmhki (ejr jetak c mashra tj ukmarstckm ljoas whtf tfa dumioakt ‖Hmjk‘t ukmarstckm‘ “  ht wjunm `a `attar tj tfhkg ‖H lck/whnn wjrg tj ukmarstckm‘, ejr axcopna). 

Eurtfarojra, ht lck rasunt hk us dumihki jursanvas (ckm jtfars, ejr tfct octtar) cs ‖kjt

ukmarstckmhki‘, sj satthki jursanvas up tj ocga avhmakla ‖tjwcrm‘ us tfct ljkehros tfhs dumioakt

ckm sjnhmhehas jur `anhae tfct wa mjk‘t ckm lck‘t ukmarstckm. Pctfar tfak tfhkg, spacg, ckm dumiahk taros je ‖ukmarstckmhki varsus kjt ukmarstckmhki‘, H try tj dust nat wjrms ‖enjw jvar oa‘ ckm

trust tfct H whnn ircsp wfct sfjunm `a ircspam ckm tfct H whnn ukmarstckm wfct H sfjunm

ukmarstckm. H ehkm tfct H ratchk ojra wfak H mjk‘t wjrry c`jut ratchkhki7 H ehkm tfct ht hs `attar tj

kjt tfhkg hk taros je ‖fcrm tj ukmarstckm‘ jr ‖acsy tj ukmarstckm‘, ckm dust raochk ‖jpak‘ tj tfa‖enjw‘. 

 Kjw, tfct schm, wa sfjunmk‘t pratakm tfct wa ukmarstckm sjoatfhki tfct wa mjk‘t (ckm

jkny ck hkmhvhmucn lck gkjw he fa jr sfa hs pratakmhki jr kjt). Oy pjhkt hs tfct wa kaam tj stapjut je tfa mhlfjtjoy je ‖ukmarstckmhki varsus kjt ukmarstckmhki‘ ckm rctfar akicia hk tfa wjrnm

Page 5: Paradoxes of Awareness by O.G. Rose

7/23/2019 Paradoxes of Awareness by O.G. Rose

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/paradoxes-of-awareness-by-og-rose 5/12

hk taros je ‖jpakkass‘, ‖pursuhki trutf‘, ckm/jr ‖ircsphki-wfct-hs-yat-tj-`a-ircspam‘4 wa

sfjunmk‘t tfhkg je jursanvas hk taros je (stcikckt) ‖pjhkts‘. ]fara hs kj jka wfj hs (ljopnatany

ckm/jr ejravar) ct c pjhkt je ‖kjt ukmarstckmhki‘ jr ‖ukmarstckmhki‘ “  cnn je us cra c ohxtura jeukmarstckmhki ckm kjt ukmarstckmhki4 wa ukmarstckm sjoa tfhkis ckm kjt jtfars. Kj jka

ukmarstckms uttarny kjtfhki, cs kj jka ukmarstckms uttarny avarytfhki. Yfak ht ljoas tj tfa scoa

 `jjg, sjoa pajpna gkjw sjoa tfhkis, ckm jtfars gkjw jtfars tfhkis. Qkmarstckmhki kavar akms,cs ukmarstckmhki kavar `aihks. Ht dust ‖hs‘, cs aclf jka je us, rancthva tj jur ljkslhjuskass, hs ck‖hs-kass‘ “  wa mhm kjt, rancthva tj jursanvas, ljoa hktj axhstakla wfak wa wara `jrk sj oulf cs

wa lcoa hktj axhstakla wfak wa `aljoa ljkslhjus (je jursanvas-hk-c-wjrnm). Ya, uktj

jursanvas, lcoa hktj `ahki cs ck ‖hs-kass‘, ojra sj tfck ‖cs lcusam‘. He kj jka avar tjnm us wawara lcusam ckm wa kavar nacrkam je `hrtf, wa wjunm fcva tj tfhkg je jursanvas cs ‖ljohki erjo

kjtfhki‘. Cs jur ‖sanvas‘ aoarihki uktj us cs ‖tfara‘, summakny ckm cnn ct jkla, erjo ‖kjt tfara‘,

sj wa sfjunm tfhkg je ukmarstckmhki. Ht hs kjt sjoatfhki tfct wa fcva jr mjk‘t fcva sj oulf cs ht

hs sjoatfhki tfct ‖hs tfara‘, cs he jk hts jwk clljrm, erjo c stcta je ‖kjt `ahki tfara‘. ]fhs hsk‘t tjscy ukmarstckmhki hs sjoatfhki wa mjk‘t pjssass jr sjoatfhki wa mjk‘t wjrg ejr, sj oulf cs ht

hs tj scy tfct ukmarstckmhki hs sjoatfhki tfct whnn ljoa wfak ht ljoas, mykcohlcnny ckm

jrickhlcnny. Ya sfjunm wjrg, racm, ckm nhstak trusthki tfct ukmarstckmhki whnn ‖cppacr‘, cs wa‖cppacram‘ uktj jursanvas, varsus wjrryhki wfatfar jr kjt wa ukmarstckm. \uspakm dumioakt7

stcy hk tfa ‖enjw‘. Mjk‘t ejlus jk yjursane7 ejlus jk trutf “  jk ‖wfct hs‘ “  ckm `a ‖jpak‘ tj ht. 

HHH

Cs c parsjk kaams tj ‖enjw‘ wfak racmhki, sj c parsjk kaams tj ‖enjw‘ wfak ht ljoas tj  

rancthjksfhps. Cichk, H whnn spacg erjo parsjkcn axparhakla4 H ehkm tfct wfak H‘o jvarny-cwcra jefjw H‘o clthki crjukm pajpna, H clt ukkcturcnny, ckm tfhkg tjj oulf c`jut wfct H‘o scyhki ckm

mjhki varsus ‖enjwhki‘ ckm ‖tcghki hk‘ wfct jtfars cra tfhkghki ckm mjhki. H‘o tfhkghki tjj oulf

c`jut fjw tfay ohift fcva hktarpratam sjoatfhki H schm, c`jut fjw tfay ohift `a akdjyhki tfahr

thoa, atl., ckm cs c rasunt, tfa qucnhty je tfa axparhakla mrjps. Ojst lartchkny, ht hs cpprjprhcta tjkjt `a lcranass wfak hktarclthki whtf jtfars, sj `y kj oacks co H cmvjlcthki lcranasskass.

Pctfar, H‘va ejukm tfct tfa nass sane -cwcra H co, tfa ojra akdjyc`na tfa thoa “  tfa ojra jpak,

enuhm, ckm cihna H ehkm oy ohkm ckm parsjkcnhty “  ckm yat H lck `a sane-cwcra jut je ijjm hktakt.Yfak ht ljoas tj rancthjksfhps, tfa ockkar `y wfhlf ‖enjw‘ hs ojst hopamam hs vhc

‖hktakthjk‘, wfhlf `rhkis us tj tfa tjphl je ‖Hktakthjk Cwcrakass‘. Cs whtf ukmarstckmhki, wa

kaam tj trckslakm tfa mhlfjtjoy je ‖hktakthjkcn varsus ukhktakthjkcn‘ (cs wcs axpnjram hk„Axparhaklhki ]fhkghki‟). Hktakthjkcnhty hs pcrcmjxhlcn, ejr hktakthjkcnhty lck hopama tfa

j`tchkoakt je wfct c parsjk hs hktakthjkcn c`jut. He yju hktakm tj fcva c ijjm ljkvarscthjk, tfct

vary hktakthjk lck rasunt hk yju fcvhki c `cm ljkvarscthjk (ejr yju cra jvarny sane-cwcra,

karvjus, cerchm yju‘nn scy sjoatfhki stuphm, atl.) (cmmhthjkcnny, yjur axpaltcthjks lck `a sj ecrerjo racnhty tfct tfa ljkvarscthjk fakla whnn kjt eaan nhga ht wcs c ijjm ljkvarscthjk, kjt fcvhki

nhvam up tj ck axpaltcthjk)7 he yju hktakm tj mj c ijjm dj`, yju ocy ehkm yjursane oasshki up

ojra tfck usucn. ]fhs hsk‘t tj scy yju sfjunmk‘t `a lcraeun, `ut tfct ‖hktakthjkcnhty‘ ckm ‖lcra‘

crak‘t (kalasscrhny) shohnas. ]fa luntura saaos tj ljkencta tfasa twj, ckm tfhkgs tfct he yju‘ra kjthktakthjkcn, yju mjk‘t lcra. Hk cmmhthjk tj tfhs ljkencthjk, c racsjk ejr tfa aopfcshs jk

hktakthjkcnhty, H `anhava, hs mua tj jur fuock `hcs cichkst ‖fhif jrmar ljopnaxhty‘4 tj `a

hktakthjkcn hs tj tfhkg ckm clt hk taros je ‖njw jrmar ljopnaxhty‘, wfhlf hs acshar tj ukmarstckm,varhey, ckm nhva `y. He c parsjk axprassas njva hk taros je ‖fhif jrmar lcuscnhty‘, ht lck saao cs he

Page 6: Paradoxes of Awareness by O.G. Rose

7/23/2019 Paradoxes of Awareness by O.G. Rose

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/paradoxes-of-awareness-by-og-rose 6/12

tfa parsjk mjask‘t axprass njva ct cnn “  ht hsk‘t mhralt akjuif ejr us. Cs c rasunt je echnhki tj

trckslakm tfa mhlfjtjoy je hktakthjkcnhty, wa lck racm c nclg je lcra wfara lcra hs prasakt, ckm

wckt tfa trcksncthjk je ‖fhif jrmar ljopnaxhty‘ hktj taros tfct wa ojra mhraltny ukmarstckm(kcoany ‖njw jrmar ljopnaxhty‘, tfjuif tfct hsk‘t tj scy ‖njw ljopnaxhty‘ njva mjask‘t fcva cky

rjna wfctsjavar). ]fhs lck `a tj tfa matrhoakt je lracthvhty ckm rancthjksfhps.

Eurtfarojra, hktakthjkcnhty ljopcrtoaktcnhzas. He H tfhkg hktakthjkcnny c`jut ijhki tj tfaojvhas tfhs avakhki, H lckkjt tfhkg fjnhsthlcnny c`jut wfct H mj tjkhift. ]fhs hsk‘t kalasscrhny c `cm tfhki, `ut ht hs hopjrtckt tj kjta tfct hktakthjkcnhty kalasshtctas c ghkm je ‖axlnumhki jut‘

hkejrocthjk. Qnthoctany, wfakavar c malhshjk hs ocma, pjtakthcnhty hs nhohtam ckm lfckiam, ckm,

cichk, tfhs hsk‘t hkfaraktny `cm4 ht‘s dust c eclt je nhea. ]fa prj`naos `aihk wfak c parsjkojrcnhzas hktakthjkcnhty jr `anhavas tj `a ukhktakthjkcn hs tj ‖kjt lcra‘. He yju `anhava slfamunhki

hs kalasscry `alcusa hktakthjkcnhty hs njvhki, yju whnn parlahva tfjsa wfj mjk‘t fcva slfamunas, 

wfj nhga ‖ijhki whtf tfa enjw‘ cs uknjvhki ckm uklcrhki7 nhgawhsa, yju ocy tfhkg je tfa parsjk

wfj mjask‘t iat c rasarvcthjk ct c rastcurckt cs kjt lcrhki c`jut tfa mhkkar. Rarfcps tfhs hs trua, `ut tj ljklnuma tfhs erjo wfct yju dumia cs c ‖nclg je hktakthjk‘ lck mcocia rancthjksfhps.

Hktakthjkcnhty lck `a cppacnhki `alcusa ht lractas avhmakla ckm lartchkty. He H ocga c

slfamuna, H fcva sjoatfhki H lck pjhkt tj ckm scy ‖H lcra c`jut fjw H thoa ockcia‘7 he H lcnn cerhakm ct c lartchk thoa avary waag, H fcva avhmakla tfct H vcnua tfa erhakmsfhp. Fakla, oy 

hktakthjkcnhty ihvas oa racsjk tj `anhava tfct H hkmaam ockcia oy thoa wann ckm/jr vcnua c 

erhakmsfhp. Ckm yat, ct tfa scoa thoa, hktakthjkcnhty lck mcocia erhakmsfhps ckm jka‘s c`hnhty tj

ockcia thoa4 `alcusa H tfhkg H fcva avhmakla tfct H vcnua tfasa tfhkis, H ocy stjp ckcnyzhkioysane tj ocga sura H racnny mj, cltucnny, vcnua erhakmsfhps ckm ockcia oy thoa wann. Oy erhakm

ocy vary wann eaan cs he tfa rancthjksfhp hs aopty ckm oackhkinass, ckm H ocy mj kjtfhki

oackhkieun whtf oy mcys, `ut `alcusa H tfhkg H co ‖hktakthjkcn‘ c`jut tfasa tfhkis, H ocy kjtracnhza tfa ‖fjnhsthl‘ phltura. Hktakthjkcnhty ckm tfa lracthjk je slfamunas lck euklthjk cs c wcy je

malahvhki oysane hktj tfhkghki tfara hs lcra wfak tfa rancthjksfhp hs aopty jr prjmulthvhty wfak

tfara hs uk-prjmulthvhty. Hktakthjkcnhty lck malahva, ckm hk sulf shtucthjks, ‖Hktakthjk-Cwcrakass‘

nacms tj ck arjshjk je tfa vary tfhkis c parsjk hs hktakthjkcn ejr tfa scga je gaaphki cnhva.@a cwcra tfct cwcrakass mjask‘t cnwcys ocga yju trutfeunny cwcra.

Yfara tfara hs ck jvaraopfcshs jk `ahki hktakthjkcn, pajpna lck vcnua tfa prasakla je

hktakthjk jvar tfa tfhkis c parsjk hs hktakthjkcn c`jut. Fcvhki c oaathki lck `aljoa ojrahopjrtckt tfck wfct tfa oaathki clljopnhsfas, cs ijhki tj Lfurlf lck `aljoa ojra hopjrtckt

tfck wfct fcppaks hk wjrsfhp. ]fhs hsk‘t tj scy hktakthjk hs `cm “  ht hs kalasscry “  `ut tfct

‖Hktakthjk-Cwcrakass‘ lck rasunt hk ck ukkjthlam ‖swhtlf‘ tfct rasunts hk ck arjshjk je wfcthktakthjkcnhty hs ‖tjwcrm‘. Hk tfa clt je `ahki hktakthjkcn c`jut cttakmhki Lfurlf, wa lck fhma

jursanvas erjo tfa quasthjk je fjw wa clt tfa rast je tfa waag, tfhkghki wa fcva `aak

hktakthjkcn c`jut tfct wfhlf prjvas wa cra hkmaam (cnwcys) Lfrhsthck. Ljkshmarhki tfhs, tfa

 prasakla je hktakthjk ckm tfus lracthjk je avhmakla lck lracta irjukms ejr axlusas ckm‖tfjuiftnasskass‘ (hk tfa Fckkcf Crmakt saksa).

Hktakthjkcnhty lck nhoht ‖fhif jrmar ljopnaxhty‘ whtf ‖njw jrmar ljopnaxhty‘, cs ht lck

hopama parlahvhki whtf tfhkghki. Eurtfarojra, hrjkhlcnny, tj csg sjoajka tj ‖`a hktakthjkcn‘ hs tj

ocga ht sj tfct c parsjk lck kj njkiar `a hktakthjkcn7 cetar hssuhki tfa ljoockm, ht lckkjt `alnacr he tfa parsjk clts hk raspjksa tj wfct wcs ljoockmam jr `alcusa fa jr sfa hs hktakthjkcn.

Hk tfhs wcy, Hktakthjk-Cwcrakass, nhga Qkmarstckmhki-Cwcrakass, lck cltucnny rasunt hk c

truklcthjk (jr arjshjk) je hktakthjkcnhty ckm lck, hk eclt, ocga c parsjk (saao) ukhktakthjkcn4 tfaclt je tryhki tj ojthvcta hktakthjkcn c`jut c erhakmsfhp lck rasunt hk tfa erhakmsfhp lruo`nhki

Page 7: Paradoxes of Awareness by O.G. Rose

7/23/2019 Paradoxes of Awareness by O.G. Rose

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/paradoxes-of-awareness-by-og-rose 7/12

whtfjut tfa parsjk kjthlhki, ocghki ht saao cs he tfa hktakthjkcn parsjk mjask‘t lcra, `nhkmam `y

fhs jr far hktakthjk hktj tfhkghki cnn hs wann. Hktakthjkcnhty lck aeecla cky saksa je hktakthjk, ckm

yat hktakthjk lck `a c rasunt je iakuhka lcra. 

HU

Ejr tfasa ehkcn salthjks, H wjunm nhga tj axpnjra ‖Rurpjsa-Cwcrakass‘, wfhlf wcs ehrst `rjuift up hk „Jk Octarhcnhso, Rurpjsa, ckm Mhslarkoakt‟ `y J.I. Pjsa. Rajpna tjmcy cra vary

ejlusam jk gkjwhki tfahr purpjsa (fcvhki ht ‖hklaptam‘ “  cs mhslussam hk „Hklapthjk,

Mhslrhohkcthjk, ckm Eraamjo‟ `y J.I. Pjsa  “  hktj tfahr ohkms `y ljuktnass Xjutu`a vhmajs jk\tava Dj`s), `ut H eacr, cs whtf pajpna `akt jk ukmarstckmhki (wfjsa ejlus gaaps tfao erjo

ukmarstckmhki), tfhs ejlus jk purpjsa lck wjrg cichkst gkjwhki purpjsa. Cs wfak wa racm c

 `jjg wa lck‘t `a tjj ejlusam jk gkjwhki wfct aclf ckm avary saktakla oacks nast wa njsa trclg

je tfa taxt, sj wa oustk‘t `a sj ejlusam jk gkjwhki tfa purpjsa je ‖tfa stjry je jur nhea‘ tfct wanjsa shift je jur nhea (tfa ljktaxt hk wfhlf purpjsa hs njlctam). Xat, ct tfa scoa thoa, whtfjut

 purpjsa, jur nhea hs oackhkinass (nhga c `jjg whtfjut c pjhkt), ckm kjtfhki lck ukhey ht hktj c

wfjna (cs axpnjram hk „Jk Octarhcnhso, Rurpjsa, ckm Mhslarkoakt‟). Ya kaam purpjsa, yat walck‘t `a Rurpjsa-Cwcra whtfjut lutthki jursanvas jee erjo purpjsa. @ut he wa‘ra kjt cwcra je

jur kaam ejr purpjsa, jur nhvas whnn `a oackhkinass.

]j `a fuock hs tj `cnckla wfct saaos cnwcys jee-`cnckla.

Rurpjsa ukhehas. ]j stcrt, ht ukhehas octarhcnhty ‖tjwcrm‘ c ijcn, ckm ht cnsj ukhehas tfa parsjk‘s oaktcn nhea4 ht ihvas c parsjk c tfhki tj tfhkg ‖tjwcrm‘ (fakla ukheyhki tfjuift hk tfct

tfhki). Cnsj, tfa fuock, hk spacghki ckm tfhkghki hk lctaijrhas, lractas ukhvarscns, ckm hk mjhki

sj axhsts hk c stcta wfhlf ‖hsk‘t hk tfa wjrnm‘. Hk tfa wjrnm, jkny pcrthluncrhthas cra racn, `ut hk tfaohkm, iakarcnhthas axhst. @jtf cra aqucnny racn tj fuocks (tfjuif kjt aqucnny tckih`na), ckm

 `atwaak tfasa aqucnny racn mhoakshjks, tfa fuock lck eaan spnht. Iakarcnhthas jr ukhvarscns mjk‘t

axhst rancthva tj octarhcn racnhty, `ut tfay mj axhst rancthva tj pajpna7 hk eclt, tfay cra tfrjuif

wfhlf fuocks lcrva jut c khlfa ejr tfaosanvas hk tfa wjrnm, ckm `y wfhlf fuocks ichk c ukhquajktjnjihlcn stctus. Iakarcnhthas ckm ukhvarscns cra oaktcn, wfhna octarhcnhty hs pfyshlcn, ckm

 purpjsa hs c oacks `y wfhlf wa lck octlf ckm `attar cnhik jur  oaktcn nhea whtf jur pfyshlcn nhea.

Yfak tfasa twj mhoakshjks mjk‘t fcrojkhza jr avak ljkenhlt, tfa qucnhty je jur nhea lck pnuooat, ckm tfa eclts je jur octarhcnhty lck cnhakcta us. Rurpjsa fanps jur oaktcn nhea erjo

ocghki us eaan cs he jur octarhcn nhea hs c prhsjk.

Fjw mjas jka malhma ‖wfct hs purpjsaeun‘: Hk jtfar wjrms, he  c  parsjk mjask‘t gkjw fhsjr far purpjsa, fjw mjas c parsjk ehiura ht jut: ]j stcrt, ht hs hopjrtckt tj cvjhm `ahki ‖Rurpjsa-

Cwcra‘, ejr tfhs stcta lck turk purpjsa erjo c `nasshki hktj c `urmak, c nh`arcthjk hktj ck

j`nhicthjk. Yfak \tava Dj`s, Dho Lcrray, atl. wara irjwhki up, tfay wara kjt `jo`crmam whtf

ljkstckt vhmajs ckm oasscias c`jut ‖pursuhki pcsshjk‘ “  tfay dust mhm ht. ‖Rurpjsa-Cwcrakass‘wcs oulf acshar tj cvjhm, `ut tfa kalasshty je purpjsa wcs nass eraquaktny raljikhzam. 

]alfkjnjiy, hk jur inj`cnhzam cia, fcs put `aejra jur ayas tfa hmac je purpjsa ljkstcktny4 \tava

Dj`s‘ ecla saaos jokhprasakt. Ya eaan tfa prassura tj nhva whtf purpjsa, cs he purpjsa hs acsy tj

nhva whtf ckm racnhza. Ya cra tjnm tj ‖ocga jur  akvhrjkoakt, kjt `a ocma `y ht‘, wfhlf hs trua,ckm yat wa sjoathoas kaam tj `a sfcpam, ejr wa kaam tj `a tcuift4 he yju cnwcys ocga yjur

akvhrjkoakt, yju kavar nacrk fjw tj racnny ocga tfa ojst je yjur jwk. Ckm yat `alcusa je tfa

 prassura je purpjsa ckm aopfcshs jk ‖ocghki yjur jwk wcy‘, wa lck echn tj nacrk wfct wa kaamtj nacrk ckm tj `a sfcpam wfak wa kaam tj `a sfcpam. Eurtfarojra, ht lck `a mckiarjus tj tfhkg

Page 8: Paradoxes of Awareness by O.G. Rose

7/23/2019 Paradoxes of Awareness by O.G. Rose

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/paradoxes-of-awareness-by-og-rose 8/12

hk taros je ‖purpjsaeun varsus purpjsanass‘ rctfar tfck dust malhmhki tj ‖mj wfct hs purpjsaeun‘. He

yju tfhkg tjj fcrm c`jut wfct yju‘ra mjhki, yju lck ocga yjursane ljkstcktny wjrry tfct yju‘ra

kjt ljktrh`uthki tj yjur purpjsa4 yju lck `aljoa JLM c`jut purpjsa. Xju lck nhgawhsa cnwcyswjrry tfct yju‘ra kjt mjhki tfct wfhlf whnn akc`na yju tj ehiura jut wfct hs yjur purpjsa, ckm sj

clt hk sulf c wcy tfct gaaps yju erjo axparhaklhki tfct wfhlf lck fanp yju mhslark wfct hs

 purpjsaeun (tj yju).

U

Echr akjuif “  ‖Rcsshjk-Cwcrakass‘ hs sjoatfhki tj `a cwcra je (hrjkhlcnny) “  `ut, tjmhirass sjoawfct erjo tfa tjphl je ‖pcrcmjxas je cwcrakass‘, wfct hs pcsshjk: Hs c parsjk‘s

 pcsshjk cnsj c parsjk‘s tcnakt: Rarfcps, `ut tcnakt ckm purpjsa crak‘t kalasscrhny jka ckm tfa

scoa. Mjas purpjsa fcppak erjo c stcta je ‖H nhga, tfaraejra H mj‘ jr ‖H mj, tfaraejra H nhga‘: Ht

saaos tj vcry `atwaak pajpna. Mjas pcsshjk nacm tj mhslhpnhka, jr mjas mhslhpnhka nacm tj pcsshjk: Cichk, tfa ckswar saaos tj vcry erjo parsjk tj parsjk4 jkny c ihvak parsjk lck gkjw.

Ht‘s hopjrtckt tj raoao`ar tfjuif tfct purpjsa hs c ‖pcsshjk‘, ckm pcsshjk aktchns sueearhki.

Rcsshjk raquhras mhslhpnhka, ckm tfhkghki tfct purpjsa ckm pcsshjk cra cnwcys akdjyc`na whnnrasunt hk c parsjk c`ckmjkhki ht wfak tfay sfjunm prass jk. Ljkshmarhki tfhs, tfa quasthjk ‖mj

yju nhga ht:‘ ocy kjt cnwcys `a tfa `ast hkquhry ejr fanphki sjoajka ehiura jut fhs jr far

 purpjsa. H jetak tfhkg wa jvaraopfcshza ‖fcpphkass‘ cs ck hkmhlcthjk je pcsshjk varsus wfct c

 parsjk hs whnnhki tj `a ‖mhslhpnhkam ejr‘. Xjur pcsshjk hs sjoatfhki yju nhga, `ut sjoatfhki yjunhga hsk‘t kalasscrhny yjur pcsshjk. Rcsshjk euans mhslhpnhka, `ut whtfjut mhslhpnhka, tfara lckkjt

 `a pcsshjk4 ht saaos tj `a c lfhlgak jr tfa aii prj`nao.

C ijjm hkmhlcthjk je pcsshjk hs tfct ejr wfhlf yju cra whnnhki tj ihva up yjur nhea avak heyju kavar ralahva cky injry ejr ht. He tfhs hsk‘t wfct maehkas pcsshjk, H mjk‘t gkjw wfct mjas.

Rcsshjk, unthoctany, oust `a prjejukmny, hktrhkshlcnny ojthvctam, ckm he yju raquhra injry hk

ckywcy, yjur pcsshjk hsk‘t ljopnatany pcsshjkcta. Cojkist yjur hktarasts ckm akdjyoakts, cs

matarohkam `y yjur axparhaklas (wfhlf yju oust ejlus jk axpckmhki, `ut kjt jvarny-ejlus), csgyjursane ejr wfhlf je tfao hs sjoatfhki yju wjunm `a whnnhki tj mha whtfjut ralahvhki cky

 prchsa. ]fhs mjask‘t oack yju lck‘t ralahva prchsa (jr ojkay, atl.), `ut tfct yjur akdjyoakt je

tfa clthvhty lckkjt `a ljkthkiakt upjk sjoa axtarkcnhty. Cnsj, jka‘s pcsshjk jetak ihvaks tfa parsjk c saksa je `ahki pcrt je sjoatfhki `hiiar tfck fhs jr far sane. ]fhs mjask‘t oack tfhs

eaanhki hs cnn pcsshjk hs, ckm ojst lartchkny c parsjk lck fcva tfhs eaanhki hk raicrm tj wfct hsk‘t c

 pcsshjk, `ut ht‘s sthnn c strjki hkmhlctjr. Jkny yju lck gkjw he sjoatfhki hs purpjsaeun tj yju4 tfa axparhakla je purpjsa hs

 prjejukmny hkmhvhmucn. Ljkshmarhki tfhs, jka oust `a lcraeun tj csg jtfars ‖wfct hs oy purpjsa:‘,

ejr kj jka ansa lck gkjw. He yju lrcva ceehrocthjk erjo jtfars, purpjsa whnn `a vary mheehlunt ejr

yju tj ao`rcla, ejr hk purpjsa yju jkny ehkm sane-ceehrocthjk4 kj jka ansa lck ceehro wfct jknyyju lck gkjw. Ljkshmarhki tfa axtraoa hkmhvhmucnhso ct tfa facrt je purpjsa, gkjwhki purpjsa

 prasuppjsas c gkjwnamia je sane7 fakla, rctfar tfck csg tfa quasthjk ‖wfct mj H wckt tj mj whtf

oy nhea:‘, ht lck `a ojra `akaehlhcn tj csg ‖wfj co H:‘, ejr erjo tfhs saljkm quasthjk lck ljoa

tfa ckswar tj tfa ehrst, ckm ht hs mju`teun tfa ehrst quasthjk lck `a ckswaram whtfjut ckswarhki tfasaljkm (cichk, tfhs ocy `a aspalhcnny mheehlunt ejr ‖axtarkcnny jrhaktctam‘ hkmhvhmucns). Ejr

whtfjut hmakthty, tfara hs kj raearakla pjhkt `y wfhlf tj hmakthey pcsshjk cichkst7 hk jtfar wjrms,

tfara hs kj stckmcrm cichkst wfhlf tj matarohka tfa mheearakla `atwaak c ‖nhga‘ ckm c ‖pcsshjk‘. 

Page 9: Paradoxes of Awareness by O.G. Rose

7/23/2019 Paradoxes of Awareness by O.G. Rose

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/paradoxes-of-awareness-by-og-rose 9/12

UH

@ut fjw mj yju gkjw wfj yju cra: Hs tfct quasthjk avak ckswarc`na: Xas ckm kj. \ane,nhga purpjsa, crhsas erjo jut je ‖fhif jrmar ljopnaxhty‘, mykcohlcnny ckm jrickhlcnny, ckm tfa

clt je tryhki tj ljoprafakm tfhs aoariakt prjlass rasunts hk c trcksncthjk je tfa prjlass hktj ‖njw

jrmar lcuscnhty‘ taros, ckm sj hktj tfct wfhlf tfa sane  hsk‘t. Fakla, sane lck jkny `aljklaptucnhzam hk taros tfct ht hs kjt4 ht lck jkny `a ircspam ‖hk   pcrt‘, kavar ‖wfjnny‘. Xat tfhsmjask‘t oack tfa sane lckkjt `a gkjwk, cs tfa suk hsk‘t ukgkjwc`na avak tfjuif wa lck jkny

njjg ct tfa wjrnm tfa suk hnnuohkctas (kjt tfa suk mhraltny). ]j njjg ct tfa suk hs tj `nhkm

jursanvas, cs tj njjg ejr tfa sane lck `a tj gaap jursanvas erjo saahki ht. Mjas tfct oack wa lckkavar gkjw jur sane: Kj, ht dust oacks tfct tfara hs c lartchk wcy tj gkjw ht, cs tfara hs c lartchk

wcy tj gkjw tfa suk.

]fa sane hs gkjwk `y wfct ht hnnuohkctas ojra tfck ht hs gkjwk mhraltny, tfjuif tfct

mjask‘t oack tfara hsk‘t ckytfhki mhraltny tj gkjw. He yju‘ra ck hkmhvhmucn wfj lck pchkt, ejraxcopna, yju whnn saa tfa wjrnm tfrjuif c ‖ pchkthki naks‘, ckm tfa eclt tfct yju saa tfa wjrnm cs

‖c pchkthki‘ jr hk c wcy tfct ‖pjhkts tj‘ pchkthki, hs ck hkmhlcthjk tfct pcrt je ‖wfj yju cra‘ hs ‖c

 pchktar‘. Kjw, dust `alcusa yju saa tfa wjrnm ‖cs c pchkthki‘ mjask‘t kalasscrhny oack yju cra tj `a c pchktar, `ut tfa eclt tfct yjur aya sj ljnjrs tfa wjrnm hk sulf c wcy scys sjoatfhki c`jut

‖wfj yju cra‘. Rarfcps ht hs c shik tfct yju fcva ck aya ejr mashik: Jkny yju lck gkjw7 oy

 pjhkt fara hs tfct fjw yju saa tfa wjrnm hs ck hkmhlcthjk je wfj yju cra. @y hmaktheyhki tfa wcy

yjur ayas saa, yju lck lctlf ‖inhooars‘ je yjur hmakthty. \hohncr tfhkis lck `a schm `y fjw yjurohkm wjrgs4 he yju tfhkg hk taros je mcklhki, je `ushkass strulturas, je ecrohki, atl., cnn je tfhs hs

ck hkmhlcthjk je wfct ljksthtutas yju.

Fuocks mjk‘t ljkshst je shopny jka wcy je tfhkghki jr saahki4 fuocks cra ljnnalthjks jeayas. Fuocks eusa ayas4 c ihvak parsjk lck `a hk wfjo tfa c`hnhty tj saa hk phlturas ckm hk

mckla ljoa tjiatfar tj ejro ayas tfct saa ‖mcklhki phlturas‘, par sa. Fuocks cra ukhthas, `ut

 `alcusa tfhs hs sj, ht lck `a mheehlunt tj tann wfct ‖ayas‘ ocga up c parsjk, cs ht lck `a acsy tj njsa

trclg je tfa pcrts tfct ocga up c fjusa jkla ht hs tjiatfar. ]fhs lck ocga hmaktheyhki ‖wfctocgas up tfa sane‘ mheehlunt, tfjuif whtf hktrjspalthjk, tfa tfracms je vhshjk lck `a sapcrctam,

hmaktheham, ckm tfak spuk `clg tjiatfar strjkiar tfck `aejra.

@ut wfara mj tfasa c`hnhthas tj ‖saa hk pchkthkis‘ ckm tj ‖tfhkg hk pchkthkis‘ ljoa erjo:Rarsjkcnny, pcsshjk ejr hmacs ckm wrhthki dust ‖aoariam‘, summakny ckm cnn ct jkla “  H mhmk‘t sj

oulf lfjjsa tj tfhkg je ht cs ‖oy pcsshjk‘ cs H  dust ejukm oysane ‖mjhki ht‘ (cs oy pcsshjk). Cs

whtf ukmarstckmhki ckm racmhki c `jjg, ht wcs dust summakny ‖tfara‘ “  ht‘s vary fcrm tj maslrh`a.Erjo c stcta je `ahki ‖jpak tj ljoa wfct ocy‘ “  erjo c praearakla-nass ‖enjw‘, he yju whnn (kjt

hkerhkiam `y tjj oulf hktrjspalthjk (varsus mjhki), wfhlf ljunm fcva ‖`jxam oa jee‘ erjo ck

ckswar) “  c pcsshjk, ckm whtf ht c wcy je saahki ckm saksa je hmakthty, aoariam. Ct tfhs pjhkt, H

tfhkg ht‘s hopjrtckt tj kjta tfct kj jka mjask‘t fcva c sane “  avak he yju mjk‘t gkjw yjur sane,yju sthnn fcva jka. Xju mjk‘t fcva tj gkjw wfct c fcooar hs, wfj hkvaktam ht, atl., tj usa c

fcooar, ckm hk eclt, gkjwhki tfhs hkejrocthjk ocy hk kj wcy wfctsjavar ljktrh`uta tj tfa usa

je tfa fcooar (he kjt iat hk tfa wcy). Nhgawhsa, yju mjk‘t fcva tj kalasscrhny gkjw yjursane tj

‖usa‘ ckm/jr ‖`a‘ yjur sane, `ut gkjwnamia je tfa sane lck `a vary usaeun ejr ushki tfa sane wann,cssuohki wa mjk‘t ij c`jut nacrkhki c`jut tfa sane hk sulf c wcy tfct hkfh`hts hts mavanjpoakt

(cs kjtam whtf tfa fcooar). Ht lck pralhsany `a tfa mashra tj gkjw yjur sane tfct lck ocga yju

tfhkg yju mjk‘t fcva c sane (ckm sj c stckmcrm `y wfhlf tj matarohka pcsshjk). 

Page 10: Paradoxes of Awareness by O.G. Rose

7/23/2019 Paradoxes of Awareness by O.G. Rose

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/paradoxes-of-awareness-by-og-rose 10/12

@ut hs gkjwhki sane racnny kalasscry: Xas ckm kj. \jlrctas saaos tj sfjw us tfct wa usa

ocky hmacs, nhga dusthla, tfct wa lck‘t lnacrny maehka, ckm akljurcias us ‖tj saa wfct wa tfhkg wa

saa‘. @ut mj H fcva tj gkjw wfct ejjm hs tj act: Mj H fcva tj gkjw wfct c lcr hs tj mrhva ht: Kj, `ut gkjwhki wfct ljksthtutas tfasa akththas lck fanp us usa tfasa tfhkis wann. Ckm unthoctany, ct

tfa akm je tfa mcy, wfak wa tcng c`jut pcsshjk, wa‘ra tcnghki c`jut ‖fjw mj H usa oy sane `ast:‘.

Ht hs c quasthjk c`jut jpthohzcthjk. ]fjuif ck cwcrakass je ‖gkjwhki sane‘ lck iat hk tfa wcy jegkjwhki sane, cwcrakass hs cnsj kalasscry ejr ‖ocghki tfa ojst‘ je sane7 ejr jpthohzcthjk,cwcrakass hs c kalasscry rhsg.

\j `a ht “  H wckt jpthohza usa je oy sane, sj fjw mj H gkjw oysane: ]j ckswar tfhs

quasthjk, wa cnsj kaam tj csg ‖wfct ghkm je hkmhvhmucn lck ralahva ckm/jr ukmarstckm purpjsa:‘.Mjas ht octtar: Lck ckyjka ralahva purpjsa: C lcr whtf tfraa thras ohift `a c`na tj ojva, `ut ht

whnn kjt ojva wann, cs c scw whtf munn `ncmas ocy sthnn lut, tfjuif ht whnn kjt lut wann. Xas,

ckyjka lck ralahva purpjsa, `ut jkny c lartchk ghkm je lfcrcltar lck ralahva/mhslark purpjsa

wann. ]j stcrt, H tfhkg c parsjk wfj lck ralahva purpjsa hs sjoajka wfj hs rhiftajus, ejr tfcthkmhvhmucn hs kjt mhstrcltam `y iuhnt, sfcoa, ck jvar-c`ukmckla je pnacsura, atl. Cs c rasunt je ck

hkmhvhmucn fcvhki fhs jr far ojrcn nhea strchiftakam jut, tfa hkmhvhmucn hs ojra aquhppam tj

mhslark purpjsa (cs c lcr tfct‘s gapt wann-tukam hs `attar c`na tj ruk). \aljkm, c parsjk wfj lckralahva purpjsa hs cnsj c eacrnass hkmhvhmucn (wfhlf criuc`ny ehts ukmar tfa thtna je rhiftajus), ejr

tfa parsjk wfj hs ljkstcktny ljklarkam whtf wfct jtfars tfhkg whnn `a ukc`na tj pursua pcsshjk

ckm `a jkny whnnhki tj mj wfct jtfar pajpna cpprjva je. Ncstny, ralahvhki pcsshjk raquhras trust,

trust tfct he tfa pcsshjk hs pursuam, tfa pcsshjk whnn `a j`tchkam, ckm cnsj tfa parsjk oust `a‖jpak‘ tj ‖ljoa wfct ocy‘ (hmaktheyhki je wfhlf raquhras whsmjo).

]fasa cra dust sjoa axcopnas je tfa lfcrcltarhsthls je c parsjk wfj lck `ast ralahva ckm

fckmna purpjsa “  tfara ojst lartchkny lck `a ojra (sulf cs `ahki aopctfathl, mhslhpnhkam, kjtcmmhltam tj aktartchkoakt ckm/jr `ushkass). Yfct sfjunm `a lnacr tfjuif hs tfct pcsshjk hs kjt c

ehrst tfhki, `ut c saljkm tfhki tfct whnn aoaria he yju tcga lcra je tfa ehrst tfhki, kcoany

lfcrcltar. Lfcrcltar hs tfa sjhn jut je wfhlf purpjsa lck aoaria7 whtfjut ht, tfa ljkmhthjks

shopny crak‘t ljkmulhva tj `acr tfa sjuift-cetar eruht (tfjuif tfct hsk‘t tj scy sjoajka raquhraslfcrcltar ejr purpjsa). Cs tj njva ckm tj `a njvam, jka oust mavanjp lartchk cttrh`utas, sj c

 parsjk oust clfhava lartchk lfcrcltarhsthls tj `a pcsshjkcta. Ckm wfak c parsjk fcs tfasa

lfcrcltarhsthls, mykcohlcnny ckm jrickhlcnny, purpjsa whnn crhsa. (Xat gkjw tfara hs ck hrjky tj purpjsa, `alcusa jkla yju gkjw ht, yju cra kjt eraa tj mj tfct wfhlf hsk‘t yjur purpjsa whtfjut

gkjwhki ht‘s kjt yjur purpjsa. Jkla yju j`tchk tfa purpjsa yju kaam tj `a eraa, yju cra kj

njkiar eraa tj `a sapcrcta erjo eraamjo whtfjut gkjwhki yju cra sj sapcrctam.) Hk cmmhthjk tj mavanjphki lartchk lfcrcltarhsthls, tfara cra lartchk quasthjks c parsjk lck

csg fhs jr far sane tfct lck fanp racnhza purpjsa4

3.  Yfct wjunm yju mj he ojkay wcsk‘t ck hssua: (quasthjk hksphram `y Cnnck Yctts)0.  He ojkay wcsk‘t ck hssua, wjunm yju ljkthkua tj mj yjur lurrakt dj` whtfjut `ahki pchm:

<. 

Yfct wjunm yju ihva up yjur nhea ejr avak he yju kavar ralahvam cky injry ejr ht:

Yfak ht ljoas tj matarohkhki pcsshjk, csghki tfa rhift quasthjks hs  phvjtcn. He yju csg ‖wfcths c trcltjr ocma tj mj:‘, tfa ckswar hs ounthpna tfhkis, `alcusa c trcltjr lck mj ounthpna tfhkis

wann. He yju csg ‖wfct mjas c lup mj:‘, ht racnny jkny fjnms nhquhms. Xas, yju lck usa ht tj sljjp

sckm, `ut racnny sfjvans cra ejr tfct euklthjk. Yfct lups racnny mj wann hs jka tfhki, wfhna trcltjrslck mj ounthpna tfhkis whtfjut tcghki cwcy erjo tfa qucnhty je cky je tfjsa euklthjks. Fjwavar,

Page 11: Paradoxes of Awareness by O.G. Rose

7/23/2019 Paradoxes of Awareness by O.G. Rose

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/paradoxes-of-awareness-by-og-rose 11/12

c trcltjr lckkjt mj hkehkhta tfhkis4 ht lck jkny mj ounthpna tfhkis. Fuocks cra nhga trcltjrs4 tfay

lck mj ounthpna tfhkis, tfjuif kjt hkehkhta tfhkis. He yju csg pajpna ‖wfct mj yju nhga tj mj:‘

ckm/jr ‖wfct cra yju ijjm ct:‘, tfara lck `a ounthpna ckswars. Fakla, ht lck `a `attar tj csg‖wfct hs yjur pcsshjk:‘ ckm/jr  ‖wfct cra yju whnnhki tj sueear tj clfhava whtfjut iucrcktaa je

injry:‘.

UHH

Cs c shikhehar lck hopama jur ukmarstckmhki je tfa shikheham “  cs c wjrm lck ljkeusa jur

ukmarstckmhki je wfct tfa wjrm ‖pjhkts tj‘ “  sj jur cwcrakass je c tfhki lck hopama jurukmarstckmhki je tfct tfhki. ]fhs hsk‘t `alcusa cwcrakass hs hkfaraktny `cm “  ht hs kalasscry “  `ut

 `alcusa wa oust `a cwcra je fjw cwcrakass lck ocga us ukcwcra “  c`jut fjw jur cwcrakass

je c tfhki lck ljklacn tfct tfhki erjo us. ]fhs hs c pcrcmjxhlcn kjthjk, ejr hrjkhlcnny he wa cra tjj

‖cwcra je fjw cwcrakass lck ocga us ukcwcra‘, wa whnn echn tj `a cs cwcra cs wa kaam tj `a tjukmarstckm tfa wjrnm.

]fara cra criuc`ny ocky ojra ‖cwcrakass pcrcmjxas‘ tfak tfjsa nhstam hk tfhs wjrg, sulf

cs ‖Ljooukhty Cwcrakass‘, ‖Ljooukhlcthjk Cwcrakass‘, ‖Amulcthjk Cwcrakass‘ “  tfara cra pnakty ojra axcopnas hk wfhlf cwcrakass je c tfhki lck hrjkhlcnny hopama tfa racnhzcthjk ckm/ jr

gkjwhki je tfct tfhki. ]fa sjnuthjk tj cnn je tfa hrjkhas je cwcrakass, cs wann cs tfa racnhzcthjk je

 purpjsa, hs tfa scoa4 nhva ‖jpakny‘ “  nat nhea ‖enjw‘ jvar yju. Nacrkhki purpjsa hs nhga racmhki c

 `jjg4 he yju cra ‖jpak‘ tj tfa `jjg , ukmarstckmhki lck `a cmmam uktj yju, cs `ahki ‖jpak‘ tj purpjsa akc`nas yju, he yju‘ra je tfa rhift lfcrcltar, tj ralahva ht. ]j nacrk fjw tj racm wann “  tj

nacrk fjw tj ‖nat enjw‘ “  hs tj nacrk fjw tj `a ‖jpak‘7 ljkshmarhki tfhs, racmhki hsk‘t dust c`jut

 `jjgs, `ut c`jut nhvhki. ]j gkjw fjw tj racm hs tj gkjw fjw tj nacrk erjo tfa ‖enjw‘4 r acmhki hsecohnhcrhzcthjk whtf tfa oatfjmjnjiy `y wfhlf `ast tj cpprjclf ukmarstckmhki, hktakthjkcnhty,

ckm purpjsa. @y nacrkhki tj racm, yju lck nacrk tj jvarljoa pcrcmjxas je cwcrakass.

Page 12: Paradoxes of Awareness by O.G. Rose

7/23/2019 Paradoxes of Awareness by O.G. Rose

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/paradoxes-of-awareness-by-og-rose 12/12

Cmmhthjks 

3.  Inj`cnhzcthjk ocgas lracthvhty ckm pcsshjk ojra hoparcthva (cs axpckmam jk hk „]fa Lracthva Ljkljrm‟ `y J.I.

Pjsa), ejr tfa kaam ejr wacntf lracthjk cs wann cs ljopathki hk tfa inj`cn aljkjoy (ckm tfa ‖322 Oatar Mcsf‘ jeinj`cnhzcthjk, cs Erhamock put ht) hs ojra lrhthlcn. Fakla, tfara hs ck hklracsa hk tfa nhganhfjjm je ‖Rurpjsa-Cwcrakass‘cs purpjsa `aljoas ojra hoparcthva, wfhlf hrjkhlcnny lck aeecla purpjsa cs purpjsa `aljoas ojra hopjrtckt. Ejr hktfa inj`cnhzam cia, purpjsa whnn ̀ a hklracshkiny tcngam c`jut, wfhlf lck cltucnny  `a c tfract tj purpjsa.

0.  C ojrcn nhea hs c nhea tfct lck nacrk.

<.  He yju wckt tj nacrk yjur purpjsa, stcrt whtf nacrkhki.

=.  ]hps ejr gkjwhki purpjsa4-  Mj cnn tfa tfhkis yju‘va jee -fckmamny schm jr tfjuift yju wcktam tj mj.-  Nacrk.

-  Mjk‘t `a cerchm. -  @a rhiftajus.

1.  Nhgas lck mhstrclt yju erjo yjur purpjsa4 tfhs hs wfy tfa quasthjk ‖wfct mj yju nhga tj mj:‘ hsk‘t kalasscrhny cs ijjm je

c quasthjk cs hs ‖wfct cra yju whnnhki tj sclrhehla ejr  whtfjut injry:‘. 

5.  ]fjuif pclghki enjwars ocy kjt `a oy pcsshjk, ht akc`nas tfa pcsshjk je enjrhsts hk tfa crac “  tfhs hs ck axcopna je

fjw yju ocy kjt `a mjhki yjur pcsshjk ct wjrg, ckm yat sthnn `a wjrghki ‖ejr pcsshjk‘. 

9.  C tanavhshjk tfct hs cssao`nam 88% ljrraltny wjk‘t turk jk4 cnn tfa pcrts fcva tj `a hk pncla ejr tfa mavhla tj wjrg. ]fascoa lck `a schm ejr gkjwhki purpjsa4 avarytfhki fcs tj `a hk pncla.

6.  Mjas ck cutfjr wrhta ejr fhs jr far taxt tj `a hktarpratam (cs c ‖oackhki‘) jr tj `a axparhaklam (cs ‖oackhkieun‘):Axparhakla saaos tj aktchn hktarpratcthjk, ̀ ut mjas hktarpratcthjk aktchn axparhakla: Rarfcps, ̀ ut H tfhkg rctfar tfck `asj ejlusam jk wfct hs tfa rhift hktarpratcthjk je c taxt, wa sfjunm hkstacm csg ‖wfct hs tfa rhift axparhakla je c taxt:‘.Crthsts lracta wjrgs tj `a axparhaklam, kjt dust hktarpratam, ckm H tfhkg jur facvy ejlus jk hktarpratcthjk lck rasunt hk us

ohsshki tfa axparhakla (ckm tfa hktarpratcthjk whtf ht, hrjkhlcnny). He wa matarohka tfa rhift axparhakla, erjo tfhs whnnejnnjw tfa rhift hktarpratcthjk.

Mckta axparhaklam sjoatfhki, ckm erjo tfhs axparhakla, wrjta c `jjg wa lck hktarprat. @ut ht wcs prhocrhny Mckta‘s

fjpa tfct wa sfcram hk wfct fa axparhaklam, fjwavar hoparealtny tfct ocy `a. Fa prhocrhny wcktam tfa `jjg tj rancyck axparhakla, ckm usam nhtarcry oalfckhsos ckm tfct-wfhlf-lck-`a-hktarpratam tj clljopnhsf tfhs ijcn. Ct tfa vary

nacst, fa wcktam us tj axparhakla wfct wcs ijhki jk hkshma je fhs facm, wfhlf wcs parfcps hksapcrc`na erjo nhtarcrytalfkhqua. H tfhkg sjoatfhki shohncr lck `a schm c`jut Ecungkar, \fcgaspacra, ckm jtfars. 

]fhs hsk‘t tj scy wa sfjunmk‘t hktarprat, `ut tfct wa sfjunmk‘t nat jur ejlus jk hktarpratcthjk hopama jur `ahki ‖jpak tj‘axparhaklhki tfa taxt. Csghki jka ckjtfar ‖fjw mhm yju axparhakla tfa taxt:‘ hs dust cs hopjrtckt cs csghki ‖fjw mhmyju hktarprat ht:‘. 

8.  Ya ohift `a ojra ejlusam jk ehkmhki c wjrg tfct ocgas us fcppy tfck ehkmhki wfct ocgas us fcppy.

32.  He yju mjk‘t ukmarstckm, tfct hs pralhsany wfy yju gaap nhstakhki4 ht hs kjt wfy yju scy jut-njum ‖H mjk‘t ukmarstckm‘.

33.  ‖Ht saaoam tj oa tfct tfay wjunm kjt `a ‖oy‘ racmars `ut racmars je tfahr jwk sanvas, oy `jjg `ahki oarany c sjrt jeocikheyhki incss W…_‘ 

- Hk \acrlf je Njst ]hoa `y Ocrlan Rrjust

30. 

‖Kjt wckthki tj tcng c`jut c su`dalt‘ hsk‘t kalasscrhny tfa scoa cs ‖kjt tcnghki c`jut c su`dalt‘, `ut `alcusa tfa `rchkkcturcnny tfhkgs hk taros je hktakthjk, wa lckkjt kcturcnny ircsp tfhs mhsthklthjk. Kjk-hktakthjkcn fuock clthjk hshkljklahvc`na (ckm tfa eclt tfhkghki hs hktakthjkcn ‖vahns‘ tfhs racnhty).

3<.  C racsjk ‖pcrcmjxas je cwcrakass‘ lck jllur hs `alcusa je tfa mhsthklthjk `atwaak ‖tfhkghki‘ ckm ‖parlahvhki‘, ckmljkencthki tfasa jkny hklracsas tfa nhganhfjjm je sulf c pcrcmjx.