1
U(DF463D)X+[!%!#!=!/ A state that was struggling with a hous- ing squeeze now must find accommoda- tion for thousands of evacuees. PAGE A11 NATIONAL A10-14 California Fires’ Aftermath In a justice system built on the idea of choice, experts say the path to trouble may begin in childhood. PAGE A10 Early Trauma and Later Crimes President Trump’s outsize influence is a major factor in the closely watched Virginia governor’s race. PAGE A13 NATIONAL Not Running, but Looming Senator Robert Menendez is accused of corruption, but a recent Supreme Court case makes proving it harder. PAGE A16 NEW YORK A16-18 A New Definition of Bribery David Leonhardt PAGE A21 EDITORIAL, OP-ED A20-21 When North Korean hackers tried to steal $1 billion from the New York Federal Reserve last year, only a spelling error stopped them. They were looting an ac- count of the Bangladesh Central Bank when bankers grew suspi- cious about a withdrawal request that had misspelled “foundation” as “fandation.” Even so, Kim Jong-un’s minions still got away with $81 million in that heist. Then only sheer luck enabled a 22-year-old British hacker to de- fuse the biggest North Korean breach to date, a ransomware at- tack last May that failed to gener- ate much cash but brought down hundreds of thousands of comput- ers across dozens of countries — and briefly crippled Britain’s Na- tional Health Service. Their track record is mixed, but North Korea’s army of more than 6,000 hackers is undeniably per- sistent, and undeniably improv- ing, according to American and British security officials who have traced these attacks and others back to the North. Amid all the attention on Pyongyang’s progress in develop- ing a nuclear weapon capable of striking the continental United States, the North Koreans have also quietly developed a hacking program that is stealing hundreds of millions of dollars and proving capable of unleashing global hav- oc. Unlike its weapons tests, which have led to international sanc- tions, the North’s strikes have faced almost no pushback or pun- ishment, even as the regime is al- ready using its hacking capabili- ties for actual attacks against its adversaries in the West. And just as Western analysts once scoffed at the potential of the North’s nuclear program, so did experts dismiss its digital poten- tial — only to now acknowledge that hacking is an almost perfect weapon for a Pyongyang that is isolated and has little to lose. The country’s primitive infra- structure is far less vulnerable to online retaliation, and North Kore- an hackers operate outside the country, anyway. Sanctions offer no useful response, since a raft of sanctions are already imposed. And Mr. Kim’s advisers are bet- ting that no one will respond to a cyberattack with a military at- tack, for fear of a catastrophic es- calation between North and South Korea. “Cyber is a tailor-made instru- ment of power for them,” said Chris Inglis, a former deputy di- rector of the National Security Agency, who now directs cyber- studies at the United States Naval Academy. “There’s a low cost of entry, it’s largely asymmetrical, there’s some degree of anonymity and stealth in its use. It can hold large swaths of nation-state infra- structure and private-sector in- frastructure at risk. It’s a source of income.” Mr. Inglis, speaking at the Cam- bridge Cyber Summit this month, added: “You could argue that they have one of the most successful cyberprograms on the planet, not because it’s technically sophis- ticated, but because it has achieved all of their aims at very low cost.” It is hardly a one-way conflict: By some measures the United States and North Korea have been engaged in an active digital con- flict for years. Both the United States and South Korea have also placed dig- ital “implants” in the Reconnais- sance General Bureau, the North Korean equivalent of the Central Intelligence Agency, according to documents that Edward J. Snow- den released several years ago. American-created cyber- and North Korea Deploys Corps Of Hackers Bent on Chaos In a Nuclear Shadow, Kim’s Army Steals Millions and Wages Digital War This article is by David E. Sanger, David D. Kirkpatrick and Nicole Perlroth. Continued on Page A8 MOGADISHU, Somalia When a double truck bombing shattered the night in Mogadishu on Saturday, rescue workers be- gan the grim search for survivors that has become all too common as Somalia battles an Islamist in- surgency. They picked through burned-out cars and hunted as best they could in a collapsed ho- tel. But it was only on Sunday, as emergency workers pulled body after body from the rubble of a nearly leveled downtown street, that the magnitude of the latest at- tack came into focus. The num- bers of dead surged from 20 on Saturday night to more than 270 and counting, according to gov- ernment officials. More than 300 people were injured. “This is the deadliest incident I ever remember” since the 1990s, when the government collapsed, a shaken Senator Abshir Ahmed said in a Facebook posting. The attack came as the United States under President Trump has made a renewed push to defeat the Shabab, Somali-based mili- tants who have terrorized the country and East Africa for years, killing civilians across borders, worsening famine and destabiliz- ing a broad stretch of the region. While no one had yet claimed re- sponsibility for the bombings, sus- picion immediately fell on the group, which frequently targets the capital, Mogadishu. The Shabab — which once con- trolled most of the city — has lost much of its territory in recent years, the result of attacks by Afri- can Union forces, a fitfully strengthening Somali army and increasing American air power. But the group remains a potent killing force, despite years of American counterterrorism oper- ations. Some of the militants have pro- claimed allegiance to Al Qaeda, while others support the Islamic State. As the death toll grew Sunday, the Somali president, Mohamed Abdullahi Mohamed, declared three days of national mourning. He donated blood for the victims and asked his fellow citizens to do the same. “Today’s horrific attack proves our enemy would stop nothing to cause our people pain and suffer- ing. Let’s unite against terror,” Mr. Mohamed said on Twitter. “Time to unite and pray together. Terror Nearly 300 Die In Truck Blasts In Mogadishu This article is by Hussein Mo- hamed, Eric Schmitt and Mohamed Ibrahim. Somalis removed the body of a man killed in Mogadishu on Saturday. Two truck explosions in the capital left more than 300 injured. FARAH ABDI WARSAMEH/ASSOCIATED PRESS Continued on Page A8 SCOTTSDALE, Ariz. — Before Bob Corker, there was Jeff Flake. Mr. Flake, the even-tempered Republican senator from Arizona, has for months offered stinging critiques of President Trump’s character, demeanor and truthful- ness — the same message force- fully echoed a week ago by Mr. Corker, a Republican colleague from Tennessee, who warned that Mr. Trump’s reckless behavior could lead to “World War III.” But there is one crucial differ- ence between the two: Mr. Flake, unlike Mr. Corker, is running for re-election. And now he finds him- self in grave political peril. Mr. Flake is perhaps the most endangered Senate Republican, with an approval rating in one re- cent poll of just 18 percent among Arizonans. Mr. Trump has sav- aged Mr. Flake as “toxic” and a “flake,” and has encouraged a pri- mary challenge against him that has left the senator squeezed not only from the left but also the right. His fate is an object lesson for other Republicans who might con- sider voicing dire thoughts about the president’s fitness: Cross Mr. Trump, and your political career could well be over. Senator’s Re-election Struggle Shows Risk of Crossing Trump By SHERYL GAY STOLBERG After strongly criticizing President Trump, Senator Jeff Flake of Arizona is vulnerable to a Republican primary challenge. AL DRAGO FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES Continued on Page A12 WASHINGTON — The Justice Department has dispatched an experienced federal hate crimes lawyer to Iowa to help prosecute a man charged with murdering a transgender high school student last year, a highly unusual move that officials said was personally initiated by Attorney General Jeff Sessions. In taking the step, Mr. Sessions, a staunch conservative, is sending a signal that he has made a pri- ority of fighting violence against transgender people individually, even as he has rolled back legal protections for them collectively. The Justice Department rarely assigns its lawyers to serve as lo- cal prosecutors, and only in cases in which they can provide exper- tise in areas that the federal gov- ernment views as significant. By doing so in this instance, Mr. Ses- sions put the weight of the govern- ment behind a small-city murder case with overtones of gender identity and sexuality. Kedarie Johnson, a 16-year-old in Burlington, Iowa, was shot to death in March 2016. Family and friends told lo- cal newspa- pers that he was gay, iden- tified as both male and fe- male and occa- sionally went by the name Kandicee. Christo- pher Perras, a Justice Depart- ment lawyer, will serve as a county prosecutor in the case, ac- cording to court documents filed on Friday. “This is just one example of the attorney general’s commitment to enforcing the laws enacted by Congress and to protecting the civil rights of all individuals,” said Devin O’Malley, a spokesman for the Justice Department. Nine months into his tenure as the nation’s top law enforcement official, the nuances of Mr. Ses- sions’s civil rights policy are com- ing into focus. As a senator from Alabama, Mr. Sessions had spo- ken out against same-sex mar- riage and voted against expand- ing federal hate crimes laws to protect transgender people, and civil rights groups were livid when President Trump nomi- nated him to be attorney general. They predicted he would reverse policies on discrimination, police Defying Image, Sessions Aids Transgender Case By MATT APUZZO Kedarie Johnson Continued on Page A11 For decades the film producer Harvey Weinstein succeeded in hiding from public view complaint after complaint of sexual miscon- duct against him. But on the evening of March 28, 2015, at a ren- dezvous at the TriBeCa Grand, his longtime pattern of cover-ups was coming to a dramatic end. Meeting with him at the hotel was Ambra Battilana, a 22-year- old model from Italy, who had re- ported to the police the night be- fore that Mr. Weinstein had groped her during a business meeting. She was wearing a wire. As Ms. Battilana asked Mr. Wein- stein why he had touched her breasts at his office, undercover police officers monitored the ex- change, eager to capture his every word. “Oh, please, I’m sorry, just come on in,” Mr. Weinstein said as he tried to usher her into his hotel room, his tone alternating be- tween threatening and cajoling, according to the recording. “I’m used to that. Come on. Please.” “You’re used to that?” she re- plied. “Yes,” he said, adding, “I won’t do it again.” The investigation that unfolded over the next two weeks was per- haps the biggest threat ever faced by Mr. Weinstein, one of the most prominent figures in American entertainment. He immediately went on the attack. As the police and prosecutors investigated the model’s allega- tions, the movie mogul set in mo- tion a team of top-shelf defense lawyers and publicists to under- mine her credibility. They gath- ered court records from Italy about a previous sexual assault complaint she had filed and then dropped. Stories questioning her motives popped up in the tabloids with anonymous sources. Mr. Weinstein’s team even enlisted the help of a former Manhattan sex crimes prosecutor turned novelist with influential ties. For Mogul, Brush With Police, Then No Charges This article is by Megan Twohey, James C. McKinley Jr., Al Baker and William K. Rashbaum. How Weinstein Used Lawyers and Money to Evade ’15 Case Continued on Page A18 In the days after the shootings at the Route 91 Harvest festival in Las Vegas, many stories emerged of bystander courage. Volunteers combed the grounds for survivors and carried out the injured. Strangers used belts as makeshift tourniquets to stanch bleeding, and then others sped the wounded to hospitals in the back seats of cars and the beds of pickup trucks. These rescue efforts took place before the county’s emergency medical crews, waylaid by fleeing concertgoers, reached the grassy field, an estimated half-hour or more after the shooting began. When they did arrive, the local fire chief said in an interview, only the dead remained. “Everybody was treating pa- tients and trying to get there,” Chief Gregory Cassell of the Clark County Fire Department, said of his personnel. “They just could- n’t.” The experiences in Las Vegas have implications for the nation. Emergency medical services have changed how they respond to mass attacks, charging into in- secure areas and immediately helping the injured rather than standing back. Still, every minute counts, and bystanders can play a critical role in saving lives, as shown in the aftermath to the shooting on Oct. 1 outside the Man- dalay Bay Resort and Casino. “The city functioned as a trauma center,” said Dr. Sean Dort, a surgeon at Dignity Health- St. Rose Dominican Hospital’s Si- ena campus in nearby Henderson, Nev. “What really makes this unique is the volume.” What the Las Vegas shooting showed, trauma experts said, is that nascent efforts to teach and encourage the public to help the wounded in mass casualty emer- First Medics on Scene in Las Vegas: Other Fans By SHERI FINK Continued on Page A14 The reclusive transgender singer is a cult heroine. A new boxed set has re- turned her to the spotlight. PAGE C1 ARTS C1-6 Jackie Shane Re-emerges Iraqi forces were reported to have begun an attack on Kurdish-held Kirkuk and its oil fields. PAGE A7 INTERNATIONAL A4-9 Assault on Kirkuk Begins A Yukon Territory town has only 20 residents but two bars — and the own- ers are locked in a rolling feud. PAGE A6 ‘One Big, Unhappy Family’ As businesses chase market trends, young workers are being pulled into programs to give advice to the top ranks of their companies. PAGE B1 BUSINESS DAY B1-6 Millennial Mentors for C.E.O.s Despite an off-season of dizzying moves, there’s one constant: the War- riors, who are the heaviest favorites in decades, Marc Stein writes. PAGE D1 SPORTSMONDAY D1-7 N.B.A.’s 360-Degree Change Richard Wilbur, who in 1987 became the second U.S. poet laureate, was 96. OBITUARIES A19 Pulitzer-Winning Poet Laureate VOL. CLXVII . . . No. 57,752 © 2017 The New York Times Company MONDAY, OCTOBER 16, 2017 Printed in Chicago $2.50 Plenty of sunshine. Turning warmer. Highs in upper 50s to middle 60s. Mostly clear tonight. Lows in lower to middle 40s. Mostly sunny tomor- row. Breezy. Weather map, Page D8. National Edition

Of Hackers Bent on Chaos North Korea Deploys Corps · 16/10/2017 · C M Y K,Bs-4C,E2 1 ,00 6,A 1 0- 1 7- 1 Yxxx,20 U(DF463D)X+[!%!#!=!/ A state that was struggling with a hous-ing

  • Upload
    ngotu

  • View
    214

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Of Hackers Bent on Chaos North Korea Deploys Corps · 16/10/2017 · C M Y K,Bs-4C,E2 1 ,00 6,A 1 0- 1 7- 1 Yxxx,20 U(DF463D)X+[!%!#!=!/ A state that was struggling with a hous-ing

C M Y K Yxxx,2017-10-16,A,001,Bs-4C,E2

U(DF463D)X+[!%!#!=!/

A state that was struggling with a hous-ing squeeze now must find accommoda-tion for thousands of evacuees. PAGE A11

NATIONAL A10-14

California Fires’ Aftermath

In a justice system built on the idea ofchoice, experts say the path to troublemay begin in childhood. PAGE A10

Early Trauma and Later Crimes

President Trump’s outsize influence is a major factor in the closely watchedVirginia governor’s race. PAGE A13

NATIONAL

Not Running, but Looming

Senator Robert Menendez is accused ofcorruption, but a recent Supreme Courtcase makes proving it harder. PAGE A16

NEW YORK A16-18

A New Definition of Bribery

David Leonhardt PAGE A21

EDITORIAL, OP-ED A20-21

When North Korean hackerstried to steal $1 billion from theNew York Federal Reserve lastyear, only a spelling error stoppedthem. They were looting an ac-count of the Bangladesh CentralBank when bankers grew suspi-cious about a withdrawal requestthat had misspelled “foundation”as “fandation.”

Even so, Kim Jong-un’s minionsstill got away with $81 million inthat heist.

Then only sheer luck enabled a22-year-old British hacker to de-fuse the biggest North Koreanbreach to date, a ransomware at-tack last May that failed to gener-ate much cash but brought downhundreds of thousands of comput-ers across dozens of countries —and briefly crippled Britain’s Na-tional Health Service.

Their track record is mixed, butNorth Korea’s army of more than6,000 hackers is undeniably per-sistent, and undeniably improv-ing, according to American andBritish security officials who havetraced these attacks and othersback to the North.

Amid all the attention onPyongyang’s progress in develop-ing a nuclear weapon capable ofstriking the continental UnitedStates, the North Koreans havealso quietly developed a hackingprogram that is stealing hundredsof millions of dollars and provingcapable of unleashing global hav-oc.

Unlike its weapons tests, whichhave led to international sanc-tions, the North’s strikes havefaced almost no pushback or pun-ishment, even as the regime is al-ready using its hacking capabili-ties for actual attacks against itsadversaries in the West.

And just as Western analystsonce scoffed at the potential of theNorth’s nuclear program, so didexperts dismiss its digital poten-tial — only to now acknowledge

that hacking is an almost perfectweapon for a Pyongyang that isisolated and has little to lose.

The country’s primitive infra-structure is far less vulnerable toonline retaliation, and North Kore-an hackers operate outside thecountry, anyway. Sanctions offerno useful response, since a raft ofsanctions are already imposed.And Mr. Kim’s advisers are bet-ting that no one will respond to acyberattack with a military at-tack, for fear of a catastrophic es-calation between North and SouthKorea.

“Cyber is a tailor-made instru-ment of power for them,” saidChris Inglis, a former deputy di-rector of the National SecurityAgency, who now directs cyber-studies at the United States NavalAcademy. “There’s a low cost ofentry, it’s largely asymmetrical,there’s some degree of anonymityand stealth in its use. It can holdlarge swaths of nation-state infra-structure and private-sector in-frastructure at risk. It’s a source ofincome.”

Mr. Inglis, speaking at the Cam-bridge Cyber Summit this month,added: “You could argue that theyhave one of the most successfulcyberprograms on the planet, notbecause it’s technically sophis-ticated, but because it hasachieved all of their aims at verylow cost.”

It is hardly a one-way conflict:By some measures the UnitedStates and North Korea have beenengaged in an active digital con-flict for years.

Both the United States andSouth Korea have also placed dig-ital “implants” in the Reconnais-sance General Bureau, the NorthKorean equivalent of the CentralIntelligence Agency, according todocuments that Edward J. Snow-den released several years ago.American-created cyber- and

North Korea Deploys CorpsOf Hackers Bent on Chaos

In a Nuclear Shadow, Kim’s Army StealsMillions and Wages Digital War

This article is by David E. Sanger, David D. Kirkpatrick and Nicole Perlroth.

Continued on Page A8

MOGADISHU, Somalia —When a double truck bombingshattered the night in Mogadishuon Saturday, rescue workers be-gan the grim search for survivorsthat has become all too commonas Somalia battles an Islamist in-surgency. They picked throughburned-out cars and hunted asbest they could in a collapsed ho-tel.

But it was only on Sunday, asemergency workers pulled bodyafter body from the rubble of anearly leveled downtown street,that the magnitude of the latest at-tack came into focus. The num-bers of dead surged from 20 onSaturday night to more than 270and counting, according to gov-ernment officials. More than 300people were injured.

“This is the deadliest incident Iever remember” since the 1990s,when the government collapsed, ashaken Senator Abshir Ahmedsaid in a Facebook posting.

The attack came as the UnitedStates under President Trump hasmade a renewed push to defeatthe Shabab, Somali-based mili-tants who have terrorized thecountry and East Africa for years,killing civilians across borders,worsening famine and destabiliz-ing a broad stretch of the region.While no one had yet claimed re-sponsibility for the bombings, sus-picion immediately fell on thegroup, which frequently targetsthe capital, Mogadishu.

The Shabab — which once con-trolled most of the city — has lostmuch of its territory in recentyears, the result of attacks by Afri-can Union forces, a fitfullystrengthening Somali army andincreasing American air power.But the group remains a potentkilling force, despite years ofAmerican counterterrorism oper-ations.

Some of the militants have pro-claimed allegiance to Al Qaeda,while others support the IslamicState.

As the death toll grew Sunday,the Somali president, MohamedAbdullahi Mohamed, declaredthree days of national mourning.He donated blood for the victimsand asked his fellow citizens to dothe same.

“Today’s horrific attack provesour enemy would stop nothing tocause our people pain and suffer-ing. Let’s unite against terror,” Mr.Mohamed said on Twitter. “Timeto unite and pray together. Terror

Nearly 300 DieIn Truck Blasts

In MogadishuThis article is by Hussein Mo-

hamed, Eric Schmitt and MohamedIbrahim.

Somalis removed the body of a man killed in Mogadishu on Saturday. Two truck explosions in the capital left more than 300 injured.FARAH ABDI WARSAMEH/ASSOCIATED PRESS

Continued on Page A8

SCOTTSDALE, Ariz. — BeforeBob Corker, there was Jeff Flake.

Mr. Flake, the even-temperedRepublican senator from Arizona,has for months offered stingingcritiques of President Trump’scharacter, demeanor and truthful-ness — the same message force-fully echoed a week ago by Mr.Corker, a Republican colleaguefrom Tennessee, who warned thatMr. Trump’s reckless behaviorcould lead to “World War III.”

But there is one crucial differ-ence between the two: Mr. Flake,unlike Mr. Corker, is running forre-election. And now he finds him-self in grave political peril.

Mr. Flake is perhaps the mostendangered Senate Republican,with an approval rating in one re-cent poll of just 18 percent amongArizonans. Mr. Trump has sav-aged Mr. Flake as “toxic” and a“flake,” and has encouraged a pri-mary challenge against him thathas left the senator squeezed notonly from the left but also theright.

His fate is an object lesson forother Republicans who might con-sider voicing dire thoughts aboutthe president’s fitness: Cross Mr.Trump, and your political careercould well be over.

Senator’s Re-election StruggleShows Risk of Crossing Trump

By SHERYL GAY STOLBERG

After strongly criticizing President Trump, Senator Jeff Flake ofArizona is vulnerable to a Republican primary challenge.

AL DRAGO FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES

Continued on Page A12

WASHINGTON — The JusticeDepartment has dispatched anexperienced federal hate crimeslawyer to Iowa to help prosecute aman charged with murdering atransgender high school studentlast year, a highly unusual movethat officials said was personallyinitiated by Attorney General JeffSessions.

In taking the step, Mr. Sessions,a staunch conservative, is sendinga signal that he has made a pri-ority of fighting violence againsttransgender people individually,even as he has rolled back legalprotections for them collectively.

The Justice Department rarelyassigns its lawyers to serve as lo-cal prosecutors, and only in casesin which they can provide exper-tise in areas that the federal gov-ernment views as significant. By

doing so in this instance, Mr. Ses-sions put the weight of the govern-ment behind a small-city murdercase with overtones of genderidentity and sexuality.

Kedarie Johnson, a 16-year-oldin Burlington,Iowa, was shotto death inMarch 2016.Family andfriends told lo-cal newspa-pers that hewas gay, iden-tified as bothmale and fe-male and occa-sionally wentby the name Kandicee. Christo-pher Perras, a Justice Depart-ment lawyer, will serve as acounty prosecutor in the case, ac-cording to court documents filed

on Friday.“This is just one example of the

attorney general’s commitment toenforcing the laws enacted byCongress and to protecting thecivil rights of all individuals,” saidDevin O’Malley, a spokesman forthe Justice Department.

Nine months into his tenure asthe nation’s top law enforcementofficial, the nuances of Mr. Ses-sions’s civil rights policy are com-ing into focus. As a senator fromAlabama, Mr. Sessions had spo-ken out against same-sex mar-riage and voted against expand-ing federal hate crimes laws toprotect transgender people, andcivil rights groups were lividwhen President Trump nomi-nated him to be attorney general.They predicted he would reversepolicies on discrimination, police

Defying Image, Sessions Aids Transgender CaseBy MATT APUZZO

KedarieJohnson

Continued on Page A11

For decades the film producerHarvey Weinstein succeeded inhiding from public view complaintafter complaint of sexual miscon-duct against him. But on theevening of March 28, 2015, at a ren-dezvous at the TriBeCa Grand, hislongtime pattern of cover-ups wascoming to a dramatic end.

Meeting with him at the hotelwas Ambra Battilana, a 22-year-old model from Italy, who had re-ported to the police the night be-fore that Mr. Weinstein hadgroped her during a businessmeeting. She was wearing a wire.As Ms. Battilana asked Mr. Wein-stein why he had touched herbreasts at his office, undercover

police officers monitored the ex-change, eager to capture his everyword.

“Oh, please, I’m sorry, just comeon in,” Mr. Weinstein said as hetried to usher her into his hotelroom, his tone alternating be-tween threatening and cajoling,according to the recording. “I’mused to that. Come on. Please.”

“You’re used to that?” she re-plied.

“Yes,” he said, adding, “I won’tdo it again.”

The investigation that unfolded

over the next two weeks was per-haps the biggest threat ever facedby Mr. Weinstein, one of the mostprominent figures in Americanentertainment. He immediatelywent on the attack.

As the police and prosecutorsinvestigated the model’s allega-tions, the movie mogul set in mo-tion a team of top-shelf defenselawyers and publicists to under-mine her credibility. They gath-ered court records from Italyabout a previous sexual assaultcomplaint she had filed and thendropped. Stories questioning hermotives popped up in the tabloidswith anonymous sources. Mr.Weinstein’s team even enlistedthe help of a former Manhattansex crimes prosecutor turnednovelist with influential ties.

For Mogul, Brush With Police, Then No ChargesThis article is by Megan Twohey,

James C. McKinley Jr., Al Baker andWilliam K. Rashbaum.

How Weinstein Used Lawyers and Money

to Evade ’15 Case

Continued on Page A18

In the days after the shootingsat the Route 91 Harvest festival inLas Vegas, many stories emergedof bystander courage. Volunteerscombed the grounds for survivorsand carried out the injured.Strangers used belts as makeshifttourniquets to stanch bleeding,and then others sped the woundedto hospitals in the back seats ofcars and the beds of pickup trucks.

These rescue efforts took placebefore the county’s emergencymedical crews, waylaid by fleeingconcertgoers, reached the grassyfield, an estimated half-hour or

more after the shooting began.When they did arrive, the local firechief said in an interview, only thedead remained.

“Everybody was treating pa-tients and trying to get there,”Chief Gregory Cassell of the ClarkCounty Fire Department, said ofhis personnel. “They just could-n’t.”

The experiences in Las Vegashave implications for the nation.Emergency medical serviceshave changed how they respondto mass attacks, charging into in-secure areas and immediatelyhelping the injured rather thanstanding back. Still, every minute

counts, and bystanders can play acritical role in saving lives, asshown in the aftermath to theshooting on Oct. 1 outside the Man-dalay Bay Resort and Casino.

“The city functioned as atrauma center,” said Dr. SeanDort, a surgeon at Dignity Health-St. Rose Dominican Hospital’s Si-ena campus in nearby Henderson,Nev. “What really makes thisunique is the volume.”

What the Las Vegas shootingshowed, trauma experts said, isthat nascent efforts to teach andencourage the public to help thewounded in mass casualty emer-

First Medics on Scene in Las Vegas: Other FansBy SHERI FINK

Continued on Page A14

The reclusive transgender singer is acult heroine. A new boxed set has re-turned her to the spotlight. PAGE C1

ARTS C1-6

Jackie Shane Re-emerges

Iraqi forces were reported to havebegun an attack on Kurdish-held Kirkukand its oil fields. PAGE A7

INTERNATIONAL A4-9

Assault on Kirkuk Begins

A Yukon Territory town has only 20residents but two bars — and the own-ers are locked in a rolling feud. PAGE A6

‘One Big, Unhappy Family’

As businesses chase market trends,young workers are being pulled intoprograms to give advice to the topranks of their companies. PAGE B1

BUSINESS DAY B1-6

Millennial Mentors for C.E.O.s

Despite an off-season of dizzyingmoves, there’s one constant: the War-riors, who are the heaviest favorites indecades, Marc Stein writes. PAGE D1

SPORTSMONDAY D1-7

N.B.A.’s 360-Degree Change

Richard Wilbur, who in 1987 became thesecond U.S. poet laureate, was 96.

OBITUARIES A19

Pulitzer-Winning Poet Laureate

VOL. CLXVII . . . No. 57,752 © 2017 The New York Times Company MONDAY, OCTOBER 16, 2017 Printed in Chicago $2.50

Plenty of sunshine. Turning warmer.Highs in upper 50s to middle 60s.Mostly clear tonight. Lows in lowerto middle 40s. Mostly sunny tomor-row. Breezy. Weather map, Page D8.

National Edition