1
U(DF463D)X+@!$!]!#!; ATUL LOKE FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES Protesters in Srinagar, in Indian-controlled Kashmir, on Thursday. The region has been on virtual house arrest all week. Page A6. Turmoil in Kashmir HOTAN, China — The muscu- lar young Uighur man sat uncom- fortably, glancing occasionally at three Chinese officials in the room, as he described his state- mandated salvation in a re-educa- tion camp. The man, Abduweili Kebayir, 25, explained how watching Is- lamic videos on his phone landed him in one of China’s notorious in- doctrination camps for Muslims for eight months — and how he emerged in January as a reformed man. “Now I know the error of my ways,” he said, as his wife and daughter shuffled nervously around the living room. The room, like the rest of the eerily sparse house where officials who ar- ranged the meeting said he lived, seemed almost staged, decorated with a family portrait, a potted plastic plant and a wall clock that had stopped. His words at times sounded as rigidly scripted as the govern- ment’s propaganda. “Now I know what is right and wrong, and what is legal and illegal,” he said. In late July, the government said most detainees had been re- leased from the indoctrination camps built to eliminate what it described as the threat of Islamic radicalism and antigovernment sentiment among the overwhelm- ingly Muslim population of Ui- ghurs in the Xinjiang region in China’s northwest. But reporters from The New York Times found, over seven days of traveling through the re- gion, that the vast network of de- tention camps erected by the gov- ernment of China’s authoritarian China Retains Secret Camps For Muslims By CHRIS BUCKLEY and STEVEN LEE MYERS Abduweili Kebayir, right, spent months in a detention camp. GILLES SABRIÉ FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES Continued on Page A6 SEATTLE The company called One Concern has the char- acteristics of a buzzy, promising Silicon Valley start-up: young founders from Stanford, tens of millions of dollars in venture capi- tal and a board with prominent names. Its niche is disaster response. And it markets a way to use artifi- cial intelligence to address one of the most vexing issues for emer- gency responders: figuring out where people need help in time to save them. That promise to bring new smarts and resources to an anach- ronistic field has generated ex- citement. Arizona, Pennsylvania and the World Bank have entered into contracts with One Concern over the past year. New York City and San Jose, Calif., are in talks with the company. And a Japanese city recently became One Con- cern’s first overseas client. But when T. J. McDonald, who works for Seattle’s office of emer- gency management, reviewed a simulated earthquake on the com- pany’s damage prediction plat- form, he spotted problems. A pop- ular big-box store was grayed out on the web-based map, meaning there was no analysis of the condi- tions there, and shoppers and workers who might be in danger would not receive immediate help if rescuers relied on One Con- cern’s results. “If that Costco collapses in the middle of the day, there’s going to be a lot of people who are hurt,” he said. The error? The simulation, the company acknowledged, missed many commercial areas because damage calculations relied large- ly on residential census data. One Concern has marketed its products as lifesaving tools for emergency responders after earthquakes, floods and, soon, wildfires. But interviews and doc- uments show the company has of- ten exaggerated its tools’ abilities and has kept outside experts from reviewing its methodology. In ad- dition, some features are available elsewhere at no charge, and data- hungry insurance companies — whose interests can diverge from those of emergency workers — are among One Concern’s biggest investors and customers. Some critics even suggest that A Tech Answer To Disaster Aid Is Falling Short By SHERI FINK Continued on Page A14 DES MOINES — The pack of cheering voters, sweating report- ers and snapping cameras sur- rounding Joe Biden made its way through the Iowa State Fair like a pulsating amoeba, consuming ev- eryone and everything in its path. “Do you like being the front- runner?” a reporter shouted Thursday afternoon. “What about calling President Trump a white supremacist, like Senator Eliza- beth Warren did?” “You just want me to say the words so I sound like everybody else,” Mr. Biden said, a flash of an- ger in his voice. “I’m not every- body else. I’m Joe Biden. I’m stay- ing the way I am.” This summer has been full of predictions about an early Biden demise as a presidential candi- date, be it from a poor debate per- formance or some gaffes, like his comment Thursday that “poor kids” are just as bright as “white kids.” But Mr. Biden has re- bounded repeatedly, maintaining a commanding, crowd-drawing position in the contest. Now, as he works to solidify that lead, a new political dynamic is energizing and clarifying the pur- pose of Senator Warren, Senator Bernie Sanders, Senator Kamala Trying to Catch Biden, Democrats Descend on Iowa State Fair This article is by Lisa Lerer, Syd- ney Ember and Reid J. Epstein. A kernel poll of Democratic candidates at the Iowa State Fair in Des Moines. The fair is the unofficial start of the fall campaign season. ERIN SCHAFF/THE NEW YORK TIMES Continued on Page A11 WEST END VILLAGE, Anguil- la — Sunset is as much a part of the package at the Malliouhana resort hotel as the warm face tow- els at check-in and morning yoga on the beach. Guests gather at plush patio sofas, tented cabanas, poolside lounges, bar stools and day beds, signature rum punches in hand, to watch a daily natural occurrence as if it were a block- buster show. But a violent death at the resort has rattled its tranquil rhythms and brought unwanted scrutiny to the resort, specifically to the door marked 49 and the bathroom within. What happened on April 13 has riled the small island’s population and has raised uncomfortable questions about class, privilege and the deference shown to tour- ists, who drive the local economy. At the same time, as the narrative of events unfolds, those very tour- ists are left reconsidering as- sumptions about personal safety once taken for granted in this idyl- lic setting. On a Saturday afternoon in April, a maintenance worker ar- rived at Room 49. He had not been summoned by the guest within the suite, a trader with UBS In- vestment Bank from Connecticut, on vacation with his wife, Kallie, and their three young children. The worker, Kenny Mitchel, 27, said he had come to fix a sink, and the guest, Gavin Scott Hapgood, 44, let him in. The two men almost immedi- Death at an American’s Hands Rattles an Idyllic Caribbean Isle By MICHAEL WILSON Continued on Page A18 WASHINGTON In 2013, Donald J. Trump said he sup- ported background checks for gun purchases to “weed out the sickos.” Two years later, as he pre- pared to run for president, he flip- flopped, telling Ammoland maga- zine that he opposed expanded checks because they don’t work. It is a recurring pattern. As president, Mr. Trump changed his mind again in 2018 af- ter the high school shooting in Parkland, Fla., insisting that stronger checks would be “fully backed” by the White House. But that position lasted only a few days, until a late-night meeting with the National Rifle Associa- tion in the Oval Office, after which he backed off his support and later threatened to veto a background check bill. On Friday, in the wake of massa- cres in El Paso and Dayton, Ohio, Mr. Trump presented himself now as a deal-maker eager to bring Democrats and Republicans to- gether behind tougher back- ground checks. On Firearm Checks, Support by Trump Comes and Goes This article is by Michael D. Shear, Maggie Haberman and Sher- yl Gay Stolberg. In a rare interview, President Emmer- son D. Mnangagwa defended his politi- cal and economic record against critics who say little has changed. PAGE A4 INTERNATIONAL A4-9 Zimbabwe, 2 Years After Coup The skyscraper’s observatory now has an official fragrance inspired by trees native to New York State. But not ev- eryone likes the smell. PAGE A16 NEW YORK A16-18 Eau de One World Trade Sarfraz Manzoor’s memoir about grow- ing up in a London suburb and finding salvation in Bruce Springsteen’s music is the basis for “Blinded by the Light,” which opens next week. PAGE C1 ARTS C1-6 A Movie Inspired by the Boss The outcry over a fund-raiser for Presi- dent Trump shows how even the gym has become a political space. PAGE B3 BUSINESS B1-7 Spin Class Gets Spun A special issue of the Travel section explores vacation spots like the Florida Panhandle, Cape Cod, Kauai, the Lake of the Ozarks and poolside Miami. THIS WEEKEND America’s Beaches The North fired two projectiles on Sat- urday, hours after President Trump said he got a letter from its leader. PAGE A7 More Launches in North Korea Documents offer disturbing testimony about what happened in Jeffrey Ep- stein’s Palm Beach, Fla., home. PAGE B1 Inside Epstein’s Mansion An Olympics dressage trainer at a riding stable in New Jersey was charged with attempted murder. PAGE A17 Arrest in Rider’s Shooting Amazon is trying to dethrone the king of streaming stand-up, starting with a new Jim Gaffigan special. So is HBO. And don’t count out YouTube, our critic Jason Zinoman writes. PAGE C1 Comedy Alternatives to Netflix Bret Stephens PAGE A20 EDITORIAL, OP-ED A20-21 People brought together by a police shooting five years ago in Ferguson, Mo., look back. PAGE A10 NATIONAL A10-15 Galvanized by a Tragedy The trainer Bill Mott remains unsettled by the disqualification that gave his long-shot colt the victory. PAGE B8 SPORTSSATURDAY B8-12 An Ambivalent Derby Winner The woman, grievously wounded in the mass shooting at a Walmart, lay on an operating ta- ble at the University Medical Cen- ter of El Paso as the chief of surgery, Dr. Alan Tyroch, turned her to clean the exit wounds. He knew what to expect, but it was still a horrific sight. She had two gaping holes the size of a man’s fist in her side and a third the size of a silver dollar where bullets had burst from her body. Those bullets had also shredded her intestine. Dr. Tyroch hooked her up to a colostomy bag and a feeding tube. And he reached into another wound to pull out a bullet lodged in her shinbone. It had been flattened by its violent im- pact into a disc the size of a quar- ter. The tragedy in El Paso on Satur- day, carried out by a gunman armed with an AK-47-style rifle, and another deadly massacre on Sunday in Dayton, Ohio, in which the gunman used an AR-15-style pistol modified to act as a rifle, can be measured in death tolls — 22 in El Paso and nine in Dayton. But the damage done by such weap- ons is witnessed most clearly by members of the medical staff who care for the wounded. The story of their lifesaving labors at the El Paso hospital, the only one in a 270-mile radius pre- pared to treat complex trauma pa- tients, is one of heroics in the face of violence, and of the doctors and nurses, who, once the adrenaline rush died down, struggled to live with the horror of what they had experienced. Some of the patients rushed to the hospital needed more than one operation, like the woman treated by Dr. Tyroch. On Saturday, sur- geons had quickly opened her ab- domen, cleaned out feces and blood, and sent her, with a tempo- rary patch over her open abdo- men, to intensive care, heavily se- dated and on a ventilator. They had to work fast, clearing the op- erating room to make way for other victims. Then on Sunday, Dr. Tyroch spent three hours operat- ing on her, repairing the damage as best he could. Six days after the shooting, doc- tors were still trying to repair ap- palling wounds in some of those who survived. The suspect in the El Paso massacre is a 21-year-old man from a Dallas suburb who told the police he was targeting Mexicans. Dr. Tyroch had seen wounds from military-style weapons be- fore, but he had never seen any- thing like the number of victims that showed up at his hospital on Saturday — 14 in all, most shot more than once. The back-to-back shootings in Texas and Ohio have led to re- Desperate Hour in El Paso As the Wounded Poured In Surgeons Describe a Scramble to Save Lives After a Mass Shooting at a Walmart By GINA KOLATA Continued on Page A13 Continued on Page A12 VOL. CLXVIII . . . No. 58,415 © 2019 The New York Times Company SATURDAY, AUGUST 10, 2019 Printed in Chicago $3.00 Periodic clouds and sunshine. Highs in upper 70s to lower 90s. Partly cloudy tonight. Showers north. Lows in 60s to middle 70s. Thunder tomorrow. Weather map, Page A22. National Edition

As the Wounded Poured In Desperate Hour in El Paso · C M Y K,Bs-4C,E2 1 ,00 0,A 9-08-1 1 Yxxx,20 U(DF463D)X+@!$!]!#!; ATUL LOKE FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES Protesters in Srinagar, in

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: As the Wounded Poured In Desperate Hour in El Paso · C M Y K,Bs-4C,E2 1 ,00 0,A 9-08-1 1 Yxxx,20 U(DF463D)X+@!$!]!#!; ATUL LOKE FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES Protesters in Srinagar, in

C M Y K Yxxx,2019-08-10,A,001,Bs-4C,E2

U(DF463D)X+@!$!]!#!;

ATUL LOKE FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES

Protesters in Srinagar, in Indian-controlled Kashmir, on Thursday. The region has been on virtual house arrest all week. Page A6.Turmoil in Kashmir

HOTAN, China — The muscu-lar young Uighur man sat uncom-fortably, glancing occasionally atthree Chinese officials in theroom, as he described his state-mandated salvation in a re-educa-tion camp.

The man, Abduweili Kebayir,25, explained how watching Is-lamic videos on his phone landedhim in one of China’s notorious in-doctrination camps for Muslimsfor eight months — and how heemerged in January as a reformedman.

“Now I know the error of myways,” he said, as his wife anddaughter shuffled nervouslyaround the living room. The room,like the rest of the eerily sparse

house where officials who ar-ranged the meeting said he lived,seemed almost staged, decoratedwith a family portrait, a pottedplastic plant and a wall clock thathad stopped.

His words at times sounded asrigidly scripted as the govern-ment’s propaganda. “Now I knowwhat is right and wrong, and whatis legal and illegal,” he said.

In late July, the governmentsaid most detainees had been re-leased from the indoctrinationcamps built to eliminate what itdescribed as the threat of Islamicradicalism and antigovernmentsentiment among the overwhelm-ingly Muslim population of Ui-ghurs in the Xinjiang region inChina’s northwest.

But reporters from The NewYork Times found, over sevendays of traveling through the re-gion, that the vast network of de-tention camps erected by the gov-ernment of China’s authoritarian

China RetainsSecret Camps

For Muslims By CHRIS BUCKLEY

and STEVEN LEE MYERS

Abduweili Kebayir, right, spentmonths in a detention camp.

GILLES SABRIÉ FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES

Continued on Page A6

SEATTLE — The companycalled One Concern has the char-acteristics of a buzzy, promisingSilicon Valley start-up: youngfounders from Stanford, tens ofmillions of dollars in venture capi-tal and a board with prominentnames.

Its niche is disaster response.And it markets a way to use artifi-cial intelligence to address one ofthe most vexing issues for emer-gency responders: figuring outwhere people need help in time tosave them.

That promise to bring newsmarts and resources to an anach-ronistic field has generated ex-citement. Arizona, Pennsylvaniaand the World Bank have enteredinto contracts with One Concernover the past year. New York Cityand San Jose, Calif., are in talkswith the company. And a Japanesecity recently became One Con-cern’s first overseas client.

But when T. J. McDonald, whoworks for Seattle’s office of emer-gency management, reviewed asimulated earthquake on the com-pany’s damage prediction plat-form, he spotted problems. A pop-ular big-box store was grayed outon the web-based map, meaningthere was no analysis of the condi-tions there, and shoppers andworkers who might be in dangerwould not receive immediate helpif rescuers relied on One Con-cern’s results.

“If that Costco collapses in themiddle of the day, there’s going tobe a lot of people who are hurt,” hesaid.

The error? The simulation, thecompany acknowledged, missedmany commercial areas becausedamage calculations relied large-ly on residential census data.

One Concern has marketed itsproducts as lifesaving tools foremergency responders afterearthquakes, floods and, soon,wildfires. But interviews and doc-uments show the company has of-ten exaggerated its tools’ abilitiesand has kept outside experts fromreviewing its methodology. In ad-dition, some features are availableelsewhere at no charge, and data-hungry insurance companies —whose interests can diverge fromthose of emergency workers —are among One Concern’s biggestinvestors and customers.

Some critics even suggest that

A Tech AnswerTo Disaster AidIs Falling Short

By SHERI FINK

Continued on Page A14

DES MOINES — The pack ofcheering voters, sweating report-ers and snapping cameras sur-rounding Joe Biden made its waythrough the Iowa State Fair like apulsating amoeba, consuming ev-

eryone and everything in its path.“Do you like being the front-

runner?” a reporter shoutedThursday afternoon. “What aboutcalling President Trump a whitesupremacist, like Senator Eliza-beth Warren did?”

“You just want me to say thewords so I sound like everybodyelse,” Mr. Biden said, a flash of an-

ger in his voice. “I’m not every-body else. I’m Joe Biden. I’m stay-ing the way I am.”

This summer has been full ofpredictions about an early Bidendemise as a presidential candi-date, be it from a poor debate per-formance or some gaffes, like hiscomment Thursday that “poorkids” are just as bright as “white

kids.” But Mr. Biden has re-bounded repeatedly, maintaininga commanding, crowd-drawingposition in the contest.

Now, as he works to solidify thatlead, a new political dynamic isenergizing and clarifying the pur-pose of Senator Warren, SenatorBernie Sanders, Senator Kamala

Trying to Catch Biden, Democrats Descend on Iowa State Fair

This article is by Lisa Lerer, Syd-ney Ember and Reid J. Epstein.

A kernel poll of Democratic candidates at the Iowa State Fair in Des Moines. The fair is the unofficial start of the fall campaign season.ERIN SCHAFF/THE NEW YORK TIMES

Continued on Page A11

WEST END VILLAGE, Anguil-la — Sunset is as much a part ofthe package at the Malliouhanaresort hotel as the warm face tow-els at check-in and morning yogaon the beach. Guests gather atplush patio sofas, tented cabanas,poolside lounges, bar stools andday beds, signature rum punchesin hand, to watch a daily naturaloccurrence as if it were a block-buster show.

But a violent death at the resorthas rattled its tranquil rhythmsand brought unwanted scrutiny tothe resort, specifically to the doormarked 49 and the bathroomwithin.

What happened on April 13 hasriled the small island’s populationand has raised uncomfortablequestions about class, privilege

and the deference shown to tour-ists, who drive the local economy.At the same time, as the narrativeof events unfolds, those very tour-ists are left reconsidering as-sumptions about personal safetyonce taken for granted in this idyl-lic setting.

On a Saturday afternoon inApril, a maintenance worker ar-rived at Room 49. He had not beensummoned by the guest withinthe suite, a trader with UBS In-vestment Bank from Connecticut,on vacation with his wife, Kallie,and their three young children.The worker, Kenny Mitchel, 27,said he had come to fix a sink, andthe guest, Gavin Scott Hapgood,44, let him in.

The two men almost immedi-

Death at an American’s HandsRattles an Idyllic Caribbean Isle

By MICHAEL WILSON

Continued on Page A18

WASHINGTON — In 2013,Donald J. Trump said he sup-ported background checks for gunpurchases to “weed out thesickos.” Two years later, as he pre-pared to run for president, he flip-flopped, telling Ammoland maga-zine that he opposed expandedchecks because they don’t work.

It is a recurring pattern.As president, Mr. Trump

changed his mind again in 2018 af-ter the high school shooting inParkland, Fla., insisting thatstronger checks would be “fullybacked” by the White House. Butthat position lasted only a fewdays, until a late-night meetingwith the National Rifle Associa-tion in the Oval Office, after whichhe backed off his support and laterthreatened to veto a backgroundcheck bill.

On Friday, in the wake of massa-cres in El Paso and Dayton, Ohio,Mr. Trump presented himself nowas a deal-maker eager to bringDemocrats and Republicans to-gether behind tougher back-ground checks.

On Firearm Checks,Support by TrumpComes and Goes

This article is by Michael D.Shear, Maggie Haberman and Sher-yl Gay Stolberg.

In a rare interview, President Emmer-son D. Mnangagwa defended his politi-cal and economic record against criticswho say little has changed. PAGE A4

INTERNATIONAL A4-9

Zimbabwe, 2 Years After CoupThe skyscraper’s observatory now hasan official fragrance inspired by treesnative to New York State. But not ev-eryone likes the smell. PAGE A16

NEW YORK A16-18

Eau de One World TradeSarfraz Manzoor’s memoir about grow-ing up in a London suburb and findingsalvation in Bruce Springsteen’s musicis the basis for “Blinded by the Light,”which opens next week. PAGE C1

ARTS C1-6

A Movie Inspired by the Boss

The outcry over a fund-raiser for Presi-dent Trump shows how even the gymhas become a political space. PAGE B3

BUSINESS B1-7

Spin Class Gets SpunA special issue of the Travel sectionexplores vacation spots like the FloridaPanhandle, Cape Cod, Kauai, the Lakeof the Ozarks and poolside Miami.

THIS WEEKEND

America’s BeachesThe North fired two projectiles on Sat-urday, hours after President Trump saidhe got a letter from its leader. PAGE A7

More Launches in North Korea

Documents offer disturbing testimonyabout what happened in Jeffrey Ep-stein’s Palm Beach, Fla., home. PAGE B1

Inside Epstein’s Mansion

An Olympics dressage trainer at a ridingstable in New Jersey was charged withattempted murder. PAGE A17

Arrest in Rider’s Shooting

Amazon is trying to dethrone the kingof streaming stand-up, starting with anew Jim Gaffigan special. So is HBO.And don’t count out YouTube, our criticJason Zinoman writes. PAGE C1

Comedy Alternatives to Netflix

Bret Stephens PAGE A20

EDITORIAL, OP-ED A20-21People brought together by a policeshooting five years ago in Ferguson,Mo., look back. PAGE A10

NATIONAL A10-15

Galvanized by a TragedyThe trainer Bill Mott remains unsettledby the disqualification that gave hislong-shot colt the victory. PAGE B8

SPORTSSATURDAY B8-12

An Ambivalent Derby Winner

The woman, grievouslywounded in the mass shooting at aWalmart, lay on an operating ta-ble at the University Medical Cen-ter of El Paso as the chief ofsurgery, Dr. Alan Tyroch, turnedher to clean the exit wounds. Heknew what to expect, but it wasstill a horrific sight. She had twogaping holes the size of a man’sfist in her side and a third the sizeof a silver dollar where bullets hadburst from her body.

Those bullets had also shreddedher intestine. Dr. Tyroch hookedher up to a colostomy bag and afeeding tube. And he reached intoanother wound to pull out a bulletlodged in her shinbone. It hadbeen flattened by its violent im-pact into a disc the size of a quar-ter.

The tragedy in El Paso on Satur-day, carried out by a gunmanarmed with an AK-47-style rifle,and another deadly massacre onSunday in Dayton, Ohio, in whichthe gunman used an AR-15-stylepistol modified to act as a rifle, canbe measured in death tolls — 22 inEl Paso and nine in Dayton. Butthe damage done by such weap-ons is witnessed most clearly bymembers of the medical staff whocare for the wounded.

The story of their lifesavinglabors at the El Paso hospital, theonly one in a 270-mile radius pre-pared to treat complex trauma pa-tients, is one of heroics in the faceof violence, and of the doctors andnurses, who, once the adrenalinerush died down, struggled to livewith the horror of what they hadexperienced.

Some of the patients rushed tothe hospital needed more than oneoperation, like the woman treatedby Dr. Tyroch. On Saturday, sur-geons had quickly opened her ab-domen, cleaned out feces andblood, and sent her, with a tempo-rary patch over her open abdo-men, to intensive care, heavily se-dated and on a ventilator. Theyhad to work fast, clearing the op-erating room to make way forother victims. Then on Sunday, Dr.Tyroch spent three hours operat-ing on her, repairing the damageas best he could.

Six days after the shooting, doc-

tors were still trying to repair ap-palling wounds in some of thosewho survived. The suspect in theEl Paso massacre is a 21-year-oldman from a Dallas suburb whotold the police he was targetingMexicans.

Dr. Tyroch had seen woundsfrom military-style weapons be-fore, but he had never seen any-thing like the number of victimsthat showed up at his hospital onSaturday — 14 in all, most shotmore than once.

The back-to-back shootings inTexas and Ohio have led to re-

Desperate Hour in El PasoAs the Wounded Poured In

Surgeons Describe a Scramble to Save LivesAfter a Mass Shooting at a Walmart

By GINA KOLATA

Continued on Page A13

Continued on Page A12

VOL. CLXVIII . . . No. 58,415 © 2019 The New York Times Company SATURDAY, AUGUST 10, 2019 Printed in Chicago $3.00

Periodic clouds and sunshine. Highsin upper 70s to lower 90s. Partlycloudy tonight. Showers north.Lows in 60s to middle 70s. Thundertomorrow. Weather map, Page A22.

National Edition