Total possible points = 210 CSD14-020 - Appendix C

Item # Description Activa N Activa S CCM Fleming N Fleming S Hiawatha Kinsmen Northcrest Trent

1 Size of property - 40 marks

20+ acres = 40 marks 40 40 10 10 40 40 5 5 40

14-19 acres = 20 marks

7-13 acres = 10 marks

6 acres and less = 5 marks

Site - frontage and visibility - 10 marks 2 0 10 10 9 5 5 10 9

3 Ability to expand in future phases - takes shape of

property into consideration - 20 marks 15 20 10 5 20 20 5 5 20Great Potential - Multi-pad arena, additional

complementary facilities, supports (parking,

New Arena Site Review Scores

2

complementary facilities, supports (parking,

etc.) - 20 marks

Medium Potential - Twin Pad and some

complementary facilities - 10 marks

Limited Potential only a twin pad (no

complementary) - 5 marks

No Potential only a single pad - 0 marks

4 Zoning - and/or ease of re-zoning - 5 marks 1 1 4 5 5 3 5 2 4

5Availability of Utilities - broken down to sanitary,

gas, water, fibre, phone - 20 marks 0 0 20 10 10 5 20 20 10

Water 5

Sanitary 5

Gas 5

Fibre/phone 5

6 Cost/price for Land Acquisition - 20 marks 5 5 5 15 15 15 20 5 15

No cost for land 20 marks

No cost for land available through a long term

lease 15 marks

Price needs to be negotiated - 5 marks

Total possible points = 210 CSD14-020 - Appendix C

Item # Description Activa N Activa S CCM Fleming N Fleming S Hiawatha Kinsmen Northcrest Trent

New Arena Site Review Scores

7 Cost and/or Time to develop - 10 marks 0 0 0 5 5 0 5 3 0Low cost and time to develop 10 marks

(availability within 2 years, road access,

services, good grades)

Medium Cost and/or Time 5 marks

High Cost and/or Time 0 marks

8Timing in terms of availability of site - acquistion

timing, planning processes, etc. - 10 marks 4 0 0 7 7 4 0 0 4

Available immediately 10 marks

Available within 12 months 7 Available within 12 months 7

Available within 12-24 months 4

Over 24 months 0 marks

9 Displacement of other features/facilities - 10 marks 10 10 0 10 10 10 0 0 5Displacement requires relocation of other

features with costs - 0 marks

Some displacement with lower costs - 5 marks

No displacement -10 marks

10 Site topography - existing buildings, vegetation,

landscape, and/or other construction constraints -

15 marks 15 15 7 12 7 7 5 0 13

Flat and un-populated 15

Flat and populated 7

Grade issues, buildings and/or forested 0

11 Other Known Environmental Constraints - SWM 11 Other Known Environmental Constraints - SWM

issues, natural areas, wetland/habitats,

contamination - 20 marks 20 20 0 15 15 10 20 7 10

No constraints 20 marks

Some constraints 10 marks

Variety of constraints 0 marks

12 Public Road Access - 10 marks 3.6 3.6 7 5 7.6 10 10 5 7.6

Total possible points = 210 CSD14-020 - Appendix C

Item # Description Activa N Activa S CCM Fleming N Fleming S Hiawatha Kinsmen Northcrest Trent

New Arena Site Review Scores

Major Arterial - 10 marks

Minor Arterial - 7 marks

Collector road - 5 marks

Local road - 2 marks

No road access currently - 1 mark

13 Public Access by Transit - 10 marks 5 5 10 10 7 0 10 10 7

On existing transit route 10 marks

Easily adapted to be added to an existing route

7 marks

New route required - 3 marks

Not serviceable by City transit - 0 marksNot serviceable by City transit - 0 marks

14 Public Access - pedestrians or cyclists - 5 2 2 5 5 2 0 5 3 5

Existing route 5 marks

Potential for Route to be developed 2 marks

No route possible 0 marks

15 Proximity to other recreational and support

features- 10 marks 6 6 10 10 6 0 10 6 3

Within 2 km 10 marks

With 4 km 6 marks

Within 8 km 3 marks

Over 8 km 0 marks

Total Score 128.6 127.6 98.0 134.0 165.6 129.0 125.0 81.0 152.6

Ranking 5 6 8 3 1 4 7 9 2

Sheet1