Upload
others
View
3
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
NMSWorks CygNet OSS v17 TM Forum - Frameworx R18.5
Copyright © TM Forum 2019
Frameworx 18.5
Product Conformance Certification Report
NMSWorks CygNet OSS v17
March 2019
Version 1.0
P a g e 1 | Copyright © TM Forum 2018
Table of Contents List of Figures ......................................................................................................................................... 3
List of Tables .......................................................................................................................................... 4
1 Introduction ................................................................................................................................... 5
1.1 Executive Summary ....................................................................................................................... 5
2 Product Functionality/Capability Overview .................................................................................. 6
2.1 NMSWorks Software Ltd’ CygNet OSS v17 – Product Overview ................................................... 6
2.2 Business Process Framework Level 2 Process Scope .................................................................... 7
2.3 Information Framework Assessment - ABE Scope ........................................................................ 9
2.4 Product Scope.............................................................................................................................. 10
2.5 NMSWorks CygNet OSS v17 Benefits .......................................................................................... 11
2.6 NMSWorks CygNet OSS v17 Products ......................................................................................... 12
2.7 NMSWorks CygNet OSS v17 Supported Installation Models ...................................................... 14
1 Business Process Framework Assessment Overview .................................................................. 15
1.1 Mapping Technique Employed .................................................................................................... 15
1.2 Business Process Framework Level 2 – Certified Process Scope ................................................. 17
2 Business Process Framework – Scoring Guidelines ..................................................................... 20
3 Business Process Framework – Process Mapping Descriptions .................................................. 21
3.1 Level 2: 1.4.4 – SM&O Support & Readiness ............................................................................... 21
3.1.1 Mapping Details & Supporting Evidence ............................................................................ 21
3.2 Level 2: 1.4.5 - Service Configuration & Activation ..................................................................... 22
3.2.1 Mapping Details & Supporting Evidence ............................................................................ 22
3.3 Level 2: 1.5.4 - RM&O Support & Readiness ............................................................................... 23
3.3.1 Mapping Details & Supporting Evidence ............................................................................ 23
3.4 Level 2: 1.5.5 - Workforce Management ..................................................................................... 24
3.4.1 Mapping Details & Supporting Evidence ............................................................................ 24
3.5 Level 2: 1.5.6 - Resource Provisioning ......................................................................................... 25
3.5.1 Mapping Details & Supporting Evidence ............................................................................ 25
3.6 Level 2: 1.5.7 - Resource Data Collection & Distribution ............................................................ 26
3.6.1 Mapping Details & Supporting Evidence ............................................................................ 26
4 Frameworx Conformance Result ................................................................................................. 27
4.1 Business Process Framework – Conformance Result Summary ................................................. 28
P a g e 2 | Copyright © TM Forum 2018
4.1.1 Service Domain – 1.4.4 – SM&O Support & Readiness ...................................................... 28
4.1.2 Service Domain – 1.4.5 – Service Configuration & Activation............................................ 29
4.1.3 Resource Domain - 1.5.4 – RM&O Support & Readiness ................................................... 30
4.1.4 Resource Domain - 1.5.5 – Workforce Management ......................................................... 31
4.1.5 Resource Domain - 1.5.6 – Resource Provisioning ............................................................. 32
4.1.6 Resource Domain - 1.5.7 – Resource Data Collection & Distribution ................................ 33
5 Information Framework Assessment Overview .......................................................................... 34
5.1 Mapping Technique Employed .................................................................................................... 34
5.2 Information Framework Assessment - ABE Scope ...................................................................... 35
6 Information Frameworx Conformance Result............................................................................. 36
6.1 Information Framework – Scoring Rules ..................................................................................... 36
6.1.1 Information Framework Adoption Conformance Scoring Methodology ........................... 37
6.2 Information Framework – Conformance Result Summary ......................................................... 38
6.3 Information Framework – Detailed Conformance Results ......................................................... 39
6.4 Information Framework - Adoption Conformance Result Summary .......................................... 40
6.4.1 Product Domain .................................................................................................................. 40
6.4.2 Service Domain ................................................................................................................... 40
6.4.3 Resource Domain ............................................................................................................... 41
6.4.4 Engaged Party Domain ....................................................................................................... 41
P a g e 3 | Copyright © TM Forum 2018
List of Figures
Figure 1 - Level 2 process coverage for NMS Works CygNet OSS v17 Assessment 8
Figure 2- Level 1 ABEs in scope for CygNet OSS v17 Assessment .................................................................... 9
Figure 3 CygNet OSS v17 Product Scope ........................................................................................................ 10
Figure 4- - Level 2 eTOM processes in scope for NMSWorks CygNet OSS v17 Conformance Certification 17
Figure 5- Level 3 process scope for certification ............................................................................................. 18
Figure 6- TM Forum Business Process Framework: Conformance Scoring Rules ......................................... 20
Figure 7- TM Forum Business Process Framework: Conformance Scores .................................................... 27
Figure 8- Conformance Scores for Service Domain - 1.4.4 – SM&O Support & Readiness .......................... 28
Figure 9- Conformance Scores for Service Domain - 1.4.5 - Service Configuraiton & Activation ..................29
Figure 10- Conformance Scores for Resource Domain - 1.5.4 – RM&O Support & Readiness .................... 30
Figure 11- Conformance Scores for Resource Domain - 1.5.5 – Workforce Management .......................... 31
Figure 12- Conformance Scores for Resource Domain - 1.5.6 – Resource Provisioning .............................. 32
Figure 13- Conformance Scores for Resource Domain - 1.5.7 – Resource Data Collection & Distribution . 33
Figure 14- Level 1 ABEs in scope for NMSWorks CygNet OSS v17 Assessment ............................................ 35
P a g e 4 | Copyright © TM Forum 2018
List of Tables
Table 1 - Business Process Frameworx Assessment Scope ............................................................................ 19
Table 2 - TM Forum Information Framework Adoption Conformance - Scoring Rules ................................ 37
Table 3 - Information Framework: Detailed Conformance Result ................................................................. 39
P a g e 5 | Copyright © TM Forum 2018
1 Introduction
1.1 Executive Summary
This document provides details of NMSWorks Software Ltd’ self-assessment and TM Forum’s Conformance Assessment of CygNet OSS v17 product, against the following Frameworx components:
• Business Process Framework Version 18.5
• Information Framework Version 18.5
The assessment included a review of:
• The methodology approach to process modeling against the TM Forum’s Business Process Framework Release 18.5 according to the specific processes submitted in scope for the Assessment.
• Conformance to the Information Framework Release 18.5 Domains/Aggregate Business Entities according to the specific ABEs submitted in scope for the Assessment.
P a g e 6 | Copyright © TM Forum 2018
2 Product Functionality/Capability Overview
2.1 NMSWorks Software Ltd’ CygNet OSS v17 – Product Overview
CygNet OSS v17 is a fully featured, vendor and technology-agnostic solution suite catering to carrier-grade
networks for Tier1 and Tier 2 Service Providers. It supports the complete Service Fulfillment and Service
Assurance capability, the cornerstone of which is the Inventory System. Standard REST APIs provide
integration with the BSS systems such as the Order Management system, Trouble Ticketing, Billing
component etc. and 3rd Party Applications in the Customer and Product Domains across Network
Operations Support and Readiness, Fulfillment, Assurance and Billing verticals.
Auto discovery is used to create the network data, while passive data is imported from various systems,
including third-party sources, via REST APIs. The network can be set up using the Plan Automation tool.
Upon successful completion of this stage, the corresponding network elements are auto-discovered,
resulting in the physical, logical, circuit, topology data being appropriately modelled and stored in the
Inventory database. Other inventory data such as location and customer information is imported from
other applications such as the CRM, GIS, Order Management System etc. Periodic Rediscovery and
Reconciliation ensure near real-time active inventory with a high degree of inventory data integrity.
The CygNet Service Fulfillment platform includes a comprehensive Service Fulfillment and Activation
system for Access, Aggregation and Core layers of multi-vendor and multi-technology networks. The
Order Orchestrator application provides the workflow and orchestration of the services across the
domains. The Design/Assign component of the Service Provisioning and Activation System is responsible
for automating the design of a service end to end, across Layer 1, Layer 2 and Layer 3 of the network, as
well as earmarking resources for this purpose in an optimal manner. This includes identifying the required
network resources, ensuring feasibility of service, and automatically computing the end-to-end path to
realize the service. The Service Activation Orchestrator interfaces with the Domain Controllers, enabling
fast deployment and provisioning of convergent services. The integrity of the inventory data, automatic
path computation and end-to-end automation are also enablers of smooth, efficient service fulfillment
to end-users, with minimal order fall-through.
The CygNet Service Assurance Platform provides Fault Management and Performance Management
capabilities, playing an important role in ensuring efficient operations. A key component in this is the
topology-aware Root Cause Analysis module, which in tandem with Service Impact Analysis, rapidly
identifies services that could be affected as a result of network outages. The Performance Management
System along with the Service Quality Management System provides an efficient framework for service
quality management and improved customer experience. The Performance Management system
provides APIs to the planning system and provisioning system to help the planning team augment
capacity of highly utilized network segments and improve network robustness.
CygNet Trouble Ticketing System is an ITIL v3 compliant Help Desk solution whereby an Alarm /
failure can be tracked from initial reporting till closuredriven approach to proactive issue
identification and time bound SLA driven problem resolution. The CygNet Order Management
System (OMS) coordinates the order fulfilment functions required to complete a customer order.
P a g e 7 | Copyright © TM Forum 2018
The system can capture direct orders or orders from ERP/CRM systems via web-based interfaces.
The Workforce Management System (WFMS) adopts a workflow-based approach and is used to
carry out physical installation/replacement of network and end user hardware while fulfilling a
service order (CFS or RFS) at end user location or communication node. It also used for preventive
maintenance.
The CygNet Reports Management module provides various Transmission and IP related reports for
Inventory, Fault, Performance, Service Provisioning & Activation and Trouble Ticketing.
The Web-portal provides a single sign-on for NOC users to access the CygNet OSS applications.
CygNet OSS can also be accessed via a Mobile based application.
2.2 Business Process Framework Level 2 Process Scope
The following figure represents the Business Process Framework Level 2 processes that were presented
in scope for the assessment, and the textual callouts represent the components of CygNet OSS v17 that
were assessed and support the corresponding Business Process Framework processes.
P a g e 8 | Copyright © TM Forum 2018
Figure 1 - Level 2 process coverage for NMS Works CygNet OSS v17 Assessment
P a g e 9 | Copyright © TM Forum 2018
2.3 Information Framework Assessment - ABE Scope The diagram in illustrates the Information Framework Level 1 ABEs that were presented in scope for the Assessment, and the textual callouts represent
the domain areas of CygNet OSS v17 that were assessed and support the corresponding SID ABEs.
Figure 2- Level 1 ABEs in scope for CygNet OSS v17 Assessment
P a g e 10 | Copyright © TM Forum 2018
2.4 Product Scope The diagram represents the CygNet OSS v17 product scope.
Figure 3 CygNet OSS v17 Product Scope
P a g e 11 | Copyright © TM Forum 2019
2.5 NMSWorks CygNet OSS v17 Benefits
• CygNet OSS v17 provides end-to-end Service Fulfillment as well as Service
Assurance capabilities and seamless integration with BSS solutions.
• The unique aspect of CygNet OSS v17 is the Inventory centric nature of Service
Assurance and Service Fulfillment components.
• The compute intensive Auto-Discovery and Reconciliation processes to run in near real
time, ensuring impeccable quality and integrity of the inventory data. • Operations efficiency and agility are achieved through automation of processes.
• The CygNet suite of BSS and OSS products have a high degree of convergence
• IT operations of the CSP can be implemented as closed loop end-to-end OSS/BSS
processes, reducing latency in service delivery significantly.
• Network Planning automation implements end-to-end automation of the
planning process, starting from the procurement of the order from the ERP
system, to the ultimate commissioning, decommissioning and augmenting of the
equipment, Links, Rings in the network. • The CygNet Service Orchestrator provides a framework to co-ordinate and
automate steps involved in designing, provisioning and activating convergent
services end-to-end in a cross-domain environment.
• The Fault Management system proactively detects potential outages, allowing
CSPs to take preventive measures and minimize service impact.
• The Service Assurance process is augmented by the Root Cause Analysis and
Service Impact Analysis modules which are in turn integrated with the Service
Quality Management system, thus ensuring speedy fault isolation, resolution
and customer service restoration.
• Key network metrics are monitored to ensure high levels of performance and
correlated with service and customer related information allowing CSPs to focus
on customer experience by delivering quality services.
• The CygNet Smart Predictive Analytics engine uses ML/AI techniques to identify
patterns of network behavior and provides critical insights about the network,
services supported and the impact on customers.
P a g e 12 | Copyright © TM Forum 2019
2.6 NMSWorks CygNet OSS v17 Products
The following is a list of CygNet OSS products that are accessible through the Web as
well as the Mobile;
• CygNet Auto Discovery & Network Inventory Management System
The Inventory System provides Auto Discovery capability, allowing the discovery
of devices either directly or through EMS/NMS. The auto discovery feature can
be scheduled to discover the devices based on schedules or on demand. This
enables running the process in a controlled manner. The discovered network
data will be modeled into the database designed basis SID. Once the modeling
of the device is done, the stitching process begins where L2 Topology, L3
Topology, Network Services, Customer Services are identified and modelled.
• CygNet Reconciliation System
The Reconciliation System identifies discrepancies in the discovered network
and reconciles any missing information with the Network Inventory (3rd Party)
Database and it provides Reconciliation reports that help compare the Network
Inventory before and after Discovery, understand the discrepancies etc.
• CygNet Fault Management System
The CygNet FMS Solution has a hybrid architecture in both polling the network
devices or vendor EMS/NMS and handling notifications on receiving faults from
them. The Fault Management System (FMS) along with the Root Cause Analysis
(RCA) and Service Impact Analysis (SIA) System provides a proactive and intuitive
way to handle faults/issues in the network. It is integrated with the Trouble
Ticketing system which allows operators to raise tickets automatically or
manually when faults occur, based on configurable rules.
• CygNet RCA and SIA System
The CygNet Root Cause Analysis (RCA) & Service Impact Analysis (SIA) System
identifies the exact cause of a fault/failure along with the impacted services that
were running in the network across multiple vendors and multiple technologies
in a span of few minutes.
• CygNet Performance Management System
The Performance Management System (PMS) provides Multi-protocol data
collection, Data processing as per KPIs from the network and provides
customized reports. The collected data are aggregated, condensed, processed
and stored. Visually impactful, intuitive reports including statistical summaries
P a g e 13 | Copyright © TM Forum 2019
are available that help the operator manage their Network performance
efficiently.
• CygNet SLA Management System
The Service Level Management (SLM) provides a comprehensive view of the level
of service actually provided to Subscribers vis a vis pre-agreed agreement. It is
based on the computation and aggregation of KPI and KQI metrics indicative of
the quality of service (QoS) for various services.
• CygNet Planned Event Impact Analysis
The Planned Event Impact Analysis tool simulates planned events and gives the
CSP a picture of its impact on Service and Capacity, providing valuable inputs to
the decision-making process of how and when the planned activity should be
carried out. A “What-if-analysis” context may be created and one or more events
of failures of differing natures can be simulated and their consequences
investigated.
• CygNet Service Provisioning and Activation System
The Service Provisioning and Activation System (SPAS) supports semi-automatic
and assisted circuit design for service order as per configured business rules,
reserving resources, and generating command-sets, assigning user command-
sets for execution on devices.
• CygNet Planning Automation Tool
The Planning Automation tool supports the Network Strategy & Network
Operations planning team across all domains i.e. a single user can use the tool to
plan across all technology domains. It allows for addition of new nodes, links,
augmentation of capacity to the existing or new topologies/locations and
upgradation or modifications of existing topologies across technologies.
• CygNet Technical Order Management System
The Technical Order Management System (TOMS) coordinates the order
fulfilment functions required to complete an order. REST APIs are used to
communicate with the CRM & Service Provisioning and Activation System.
• CygNet Workforce Management System
The Workforce Management System (WFMS) adopts a workflow-based
approach and is used to carry out physical installation/replacement of network
and end user hardware while fulfilling a service order (CFS or RFS) at the end user
location or communication node. It is also used for preventive maintenance.
P a g e 14 | Copyright © TM Forum 2019
• CygNet Customer Portal
The Customer Portal provides the CSP’s end customers with a portal to view and
visualize their end of the network i.e. monitor the usage, view faults,
performance related alarms/issues, raise tickets etc.
• CygNet Trouble Ticketing System
The Trouble Ticketing (TT) is an ITIL v3 compliant solution. It acts as a helpdesk
management system, provides issue tracking functionality to create new issues,
read existing ones, add details to existing issues or resolve issues. When a user
of the system makes a change, the system logs this, thus maintaining a history
of the actions taken. It handles incident, event & network tickets including
Customer Service SLA violation tickets.
• CygNet Reports Management System
The CygNet Reports Management System provides Transmission and IP related
reports for Inventory, Fault, Performance, Service Provisioning & Activation and
Trouble Ticketing. These reports can be accessed/viewed in various formats and
sent automatically by e-mail at pre-configured times.
2.7 NMSWorks CygNet OSS v17 Supported Installation Models
CygNet OSS v17 supports 2 installation Models;
• On-Premise Based
• Cloud Based
P a g e 15 | Copyright © TM Forum 2019
1 Business Process Framework Assessment Overview
1.1 Mapping Technique Employed
Business Process Framework Level 4 descriptions are analyzed by looking for implied tasks. (This is similar to how process decomposition can use Semantic Analysis). Each Business Process Framework process is supported by descriptive text. In many cases, each process is aligned and mapped to appropriate company documentation references solution, methodology or modeling material. Color coded text as highlighted below is used as part of the process mapping whereby highlighted text indicates the level of support for a Level 4 process implied task:
• GREEN is used to highlight key words or key statements that are fully
supported
• YELLOW is used to highlight key words/key statements that are partially
supported
• GREY is used to highlight key words/key statements that are not supported
• No highlighting is used for words/statements that are irrelevant, just for
reference or needed to complete the sentence.
As of February 2018, TM Forum allows mappings to be provided against Level-3 process elements when:
• L3s have relevant, consistent full detailed descriptions reflecting all L4 process
elements in their decomposition (usually implied tasks identified and separated
by bullet points)
• No decomposition to Level 4 processes was available for a particular L3
process, but the Level-3 mappings fulfil the condition described above,
therefore the score awarded hereafter is for the Level 3 process in its entirety.
Manual and Automated Support It is important to determine whether the implied task is supported by manual steps, automated steps, or a combination of both. In this document, “A”, “M”, or “AM” is used for each task to indicate that the step or steps is/are automated (A), manual (M), or both (AM). TM Forum Note 1: When process mappings are presented against Level 4 processes, the mappings are most often provided against the text in the “Mandatory” field for the process. In the event of the Mandatory field not being defined in the eTOM specification, the process mappings are in that case provided against the Level 4 Extended description. If an Extended description is not defined, then the mapping is provided against the Brief description.
P a g e 16 | Copyright © TM Forum 2019
TM Forum Note 2: Note that if a Level 3 process has not been decomposed to Level 4 processes in the Business Process Framework, in such cases the process mapping support is provided against the Level 3 process descriptions using the Mandatory/Extended/Brief description as per the guidelines explained for Level 4 based mappings in the previous note.
P a g e 17 | Copyright © TM Forum 2019
1.2 Business Process Framework Level 2 – Certified Process Scope
Figure 4- - Level 2 eTOM processes in scope for NMSWorks CygNet OSS v17 Conformance Certification
P a g e 18 | Copyright © TM Forum 2019
The following diagram depicts the number of Level 3 processes that were submitted for conformance certification, for each Level 2 process within the defined scope.
Figure 5- Level 3 process scope for certification
P a g e 19 | Copyright © TM Forum 2019
Table 1 - Business Process Frameworx Assessment Scope
NMSWorks Software Ltd
CygNet OSS v17
Product
24
Level 1 Level 2 Level 3
1.4.4 - SM&O Support & Readiness
1.4.4.1 - Manage Service Inventory In Scope
1.4.4.2 - Enable Service Configuration & Activation In Scope
1.4.4.3 - Support Service Problem Management Out of Scope
1.4.4.4 - Enable Service Quality Management Out of Scope
1.4.4.5 - Support Service & Specific Instance Rating Out of Scope
1.4.5 - Service Configuration & Activation
1.4.5.1 - Design Solution In Scope
1.4.5.2 - Allocate Specific Service Parameters to Services In Scope
1.4.5.3 - Track & Manage Service Provisioning In Scope
1.4.5.4 - Implement, Configure & Activate Service In Scope
1.4.5.5 - Test Service End-to-End Out of Scope
1.4.5.6 - Issue Service Orders In Scope
1.4.5.7 - Report Service Provisioning In Scope
1.4.5.8 - Close Service Order Out of Scope
1.4.5.9 - Recover Service In Scope
1.5.4 - RM&O Support & Readiness
1.5.4.1 - Enable Resource Provisioning In Scope
1.5.4.2 - Enable Resource Performance Management Out of Scope
1.5.4.3 - Support Resource Trouble Management Out of Scope
1.5.4.4 - Enable Resource Data Collection & Distribution In Scope
1.5.4.5 - Manage Resource Inventory In Scope
1.5.4.6 - Manage Logistics Out of Scope
1.5.4.7 - Manage Number Portability Out of Scope
1.5.5 - Workforce Management
1.5.5.1 - Manage Schedules & Appointments In Scope
1.5.5.2 - Plan and Forecast Workforce Management In Scope
1.5.5.3 - Administer and Configure Workforce Management In Scope
1.5.5.4 - Report Workforce Management In Scope
1.5.5.5 - Manage Work Order Lifecycle In Scope
1.5.6 - Resource Provisioning
1.5.6.1 - Allocate & Install Resource In Scope
1.5.6.2 - Configure & Activate Resource In Scope
1.5.6.3 - Test Resource Out of Scope
1.5.6.4 - Track & Manage Resource Provisioning In Scope
1.5.6.5 - Report Resource Provisioning In Scope
1.5.6.6 - Close Resource Order Out of Scope
1.5.6.7 - Issue Resource Orders In Scope
1.5.6.8 - Recover Resource In Scope
1.5.7 - Resource Data Collection & Distribution
1.5.7.1 - Collect Management and Security Information & Data In Scope
1.5.7.2 - Process Management and Security Information & Data Out of Scope
1.5.7.3 - Distribute Management and Security Information & Data Out of Scope
1.5.7.4 - Audit Management and Security Data Collection & Distribution Out of Scope
1.4 - Service Domain
1.5 - Resource Domain
TM Forum Frameworx 18.5 Assessment Scoping Document - Business Process Framework (eTOM)
Member:
Product:
Assessment Type
Number of L3 Processes in Scope: Overall Scope in the
certification
P a g e 20 | Copyright © TM Forum 2019
2 Business Process Framework – Scoring Guidelines
This section provides the Process Mapping output from NMSWorks self-assessment which was reviewed by TM Forum Subject Matter Experts alongside supporting documentation for NMSWorks CygNet OSS v17.
Figure 6- TM Forum Business Process Framework: Conformance Scoring Rules
Process Level Conformance Score
Level 1 Process Not applicable
Level 2 Process Not applicable
Level 3 Process
Conformance Score is
awarded between
3.1 & 5.0
Level 4 Process
Level of conformance
is calculated as input
to parent Level 3
Process Score
Note 2 - Level 2 processes shall be presented to define the assessment scope only. i.e. they shall not be assessed as self-
contained processes since the level of detail is not considered sufficient. A conformance level shall not be awarded for Level 2
processes. However, the Certification Report shall provide good indication of the coverage of the Level 2 process in terms of
number of contained Level 3 processes submitted in scope for the Assessment.
Note 3 - The Conformance Assessment shall be carried out at process level 3 (if there are no level 4 process elements defined for
a specific level 3 in scope) or at level 4 (if there are level 4 process elements defined for a specific level 3 in scope). For each Level
3 process (when there are no level 4 processes available), conformance shall be deduced according to the documented support for
the process implied tasks.
For each Level 4 process (when available), conformance shall be deduced according to the documented support for the process
implied tasks, as decomposed and described in the Level 4 process descriptions. The score awarded for a Level 3 process, is
deduced according to the support mapped to the Level 4 processes/Implied Tasks.
Note 4 - In evaluating conformance to the standards, manual intervention shall not impact the conformance score granted.
However, any level of manual support shall be noted in the Conformance Report and Detailed Results Report. This note
specifically applies to Product & Solution Assessments.
Note 5 - Processes that are supported via manual implementation only, are not considered in scope for the Assessment. This note
specifically applies to Product & Solution Assessments.
Levels of conformance are calculated for Level 4 processes according to alignment to the
individual implied tasks. Level 4 scores are summed and averaged to given an overall
score for the parent Level 3 process.
* In earlier Conformance Assessments, scores were awarded to Level 1 & Level 2 processes using values 1 through to 3. For this
reason, the Level 3 scores start from > 3.
Additional Notes
Note 1 - Level 1 processes shall be presented to define the assessment scope only. i.e. they shall not be assessed as self-
contained processes since the level of detail is not considered sufficient. A conformance level shall not be awarded for Level 1
processes.
The Conformance Score is awarded for each Level 3 process submitted in scope for the
Assessment.
The Conformance Score awarded can be a value between 3.1* & 5 depending on the level
of coverage & conformance to the Level 3 process based on the alignment to the level 3
Implied Tasks as decomposed in the Level 4 process definitions. If a Level 3 process has
not been decomposed to Level 4 processes, the Level score is awarded according to
alignment to the Level 3 defined Implied Tasks.
Business Process Framework - Conformance Certification Methodology
Qualifier
Conformance Assessment shall not be carried out at this process level.
A conformance level is not awarded to Level 2 processes in Frameworx Certification.
The Certification Report shall highlight the coverage within a Level 2 process submitted in
scope for an Assessment, in terms of number of Level 3 processes submitted for
assessment out of the total number defined in the Business Process Framework for the
Level 2 process.
P a g e 21 | Copyright © TM Forum 2019
3 Business Process Framework – Process Mapping Descriptions
This Section provides a summary of the solution mappings that NMSWorks Technologies provided in the form of self-assessment. The self-assessment was reviewed by TM Forum Subject Matter Experts alongside supporting documentation provided by NMSWorks Technologies.
3.1 Level 2: 1.4.4 – SM&O Support & Readiness
3.1.1 Mapping Details & Supporting Evidence
The documented mapping information for all Level 3 processes in scope for the ‘1.4.4 – SM&O Support & Readiness’ business processes are available from the following link: https://s3.amazonaws.com/tmforum-resources/Conformance+Certifications+/NMSWorks/NMSWorks-CygNet_OSS_v17-eTOM_Certification_Mappings_R18.5-SM%26OS%26R-1.4.4-V3RF.pdf Mappings and supporting evidence were presented for the following L3 processes: 1.4.4 - SM&O Support & Readiness
1.4.4.1 - Manage Service Inventory 1.4.4.2 - Enable Service Configuration & Activation
P a g e 22 | Copyright © TM Forum 2019
3.2 Level 2: 1.4.5 - Service Configuration & Activation
3.2.1 Mapping Details & Supporting Evidence
The documented mapping information for all Level 3 processes in scope for the ‘1.4.5 - Service Configuration & Activation’ business processes are available from the following link: https://s3.amazonaws.com/tmforum-resources/Conformance+Certifications+/NMSWorks/NMSWorks-CygNet_OSS_v17-eTOM_Certification_Mappings_R18.5-SC%26A-1.4.5-V3RF.pdf Mappings and supporting evidence were presented for the following L3 processes: 1.4.5 - Service Configuration & Activation
1.4.5.1 - Design Solution 1.4.5.2 - Allocate Specific Service Parameters to Services 1.4.5.3 - Track & Manage Service Provisioning 1.4.5.4 - Implement, Configure & Activate Service 1.4.5.6 - Issue Service Orders 1.4.5.7 - Report Service Provisioning 1.4.5.9 - Recover Service
P a g e 23 | Copyright © TM Forum 2019
3.3 Level 2: 1.5.4 - RM&O Support & Readiness
3.3.1 Mapping Details & Supporting Evidence
The documented mapping information for all Level 3 processes in scope for the ‘1.5.4 - RM&O Support & Readiness’ business processes are available from the following link: https://s3.amazonaws.com/tmforum-resources/Conformance+Certifications+/NMSWorks/NMSWorks-CygNet_OSS_v17-eTOM_Certification_Mappings_R18.5-RM%26OS%26R-1.5.4-V3RF.pdf Mappings and supporting evidence were presented for the following L3 processes: 1.5.4 - RM&O Support & Readiness
1.5.4.1 - Enable Resource Provisioning 1.5.4.4 - Enable Resource Data Collection & Distribution 1.5.4.5 - Manage Resource Inventory
P a g e 24 | Copyright © TM Forum 2019
3.4 Level 2: 1.5.5 - Workforce Management
3.4.1 Mapping Details & Supporting Evidence
The documented mapping information for all Level 3 processes in scope for the ‘1.5.5 - Workforce Management’ business processes are available from the following link: https://s3.amazonaws.com/tmforum-resources/Conformance+Certifications+/NMSWorks/NMSWorks-CygNet_OSS_v17-eTOM_Certification_Mappings_R18.5-WFM-1.5.5-V3RF.pdf Mappings and supporting evidence were presented for the following L3 processes: 1.5.5 - Workforce Management
1.5.5.1 - Manage Schedules & Appointments 1.5.5.2 - Plan and Forecast Workforce Management 1.5.5.3 - Administer and Configure Workforce Management 1.5.5.4 - Report Workforce Management 1.5.5.5 - Manage Work Order Lifecycle
P a g e 25 | Copyright © TM Forum 2019
3.5 Level 2: 1.5.6 - Resource Provisioning
3.5.1 Mapping Details & Supporting Evidence
The documented mapping information for all Level 3 processes in scope for the ‘1.5.6 - Resource Provisioning’ business processes are available from the following link: https://s3.amazonaws.com/tmforum-resources/Conformance+Certifications+/NMSWorks/NMSWorks-CygNet_OSS_v17-eTOM_Certification_Mappings_R18.5-RP-1.5.6-V3RF.pdf Mappings and supporting evidence were presented for the following L3 processes: 1.5.6 - Resource Provisioning
1.5.6.1 - Allocate & Install Resource 1.5.6.2 - Configure & Activate Resource 1.5.6.4 - Track & Manage Resource Provisioning 1.5.6.5 - Report Resource Provisioning 1.5.6.7 - Issue Resource Orders 1.5.6.8 - Recover Resource
P a g e 26 | Copyright © TM Forum 2019
3.6 Level 2: 1.5.7 - Resource Data Collection & Distribution
3.6.1 Mapping Details & Supporting Evidence
The documented mapping information for all Level 3 processes in scope for the ‘1.5.7 - Resource Data Collection & Distribution ‘ business processes are available from the following link: https://s3.amazonaws.com/tmforum-resources/Conformance+Certifications+/NMSWorks/NMSWorks-CygNet_OSS_v17-eTOM_Certification_Mappings_R18.5-RDC%26D-1.5.7-V3RF.pdf Mappings and supporting evidence were presented for the following L3 processes: 1.5.7 - Resource Data Collection & Distribution
1.5.7.1 - Collect Management and Security Information & Data
P a g e 27 | Copyright © TM Forum 2019
4 Frameworx Conformance Result
This Section details the Scores awarded to reflect Conformance for NMSWorks Technologies CygNet OSS v17 to the Business Process Framework components of Frameworx 18.5.
Figure 7- TM Forum Business Process Framework: Conformance Scores
NMSWorks Software Ltd
CygNet OSS v17
Product
24
Level 1 Level 2 Level 3
1.4.4 - SM&O Support & Readiness
1.4.4.1 - Manage Service Inventory 5
1.4.4.2 - Enable Service Configuration & Activation 5
1.4.4.3 - Support Service Problem Management Out of Scope
1.4.4.4 - Enable Service Quality Management Out of Scope
1.4.4.5 - Support Service & Specific Instance Rating Out of Scope
1.4.5 - Service Configuration & Activation
1.4.5.1 - Design Solution 5
1.4.5.2 - Allocate Specific Service Parameters to Services 5
1.4.5.3 - Track & Manage Service Provisioning 5
1.4.5.4 - Implement, Configure & Activate Service 5
1.4.5.5 - Test Service End-to-End Out of Scope
1.4.5.6 - Issue Service Orders 5
1.4.5.7 - Report Service Provisioning 5
1.4.5.8 - Close Service Order Out of Scope
1.4.5.9 - Recover Service 5
1.5.4 - RM&O Support & Readiness
1.5.4.1 - Enable Resource Provisioning 4.5
1.5.4.2 - Enable Resource Performance Management Out of Scope
1.5.4.3 - Support Resource Trouble Management Out of Scope
1.5.4.4 - Enable Resource Data Collection & Distribution 4.5
1.5.4.5 - Manage Resource Inventory 4.5
1.5.4.6 - Manage Logistics Out of Scope
1.5.4.7 - Manage Number Portability Out of Scope
1.5.5 - Workforce Management
1.5.5.1 - Manage Schedules & Appointments 5
1.5.5.2 - Plan and Forecast Workforce Management 5
1.5.5.3 - Administer and Configure Workforce Management 5
1.5.5.4 - Report Workforce Management 5
1.5.5.5 - Manage Work Order Lifecycle 5
1.5.6 - Resource Provisioning
1.5.6.1 - Allocate & Install Resource 5
1.5.6.2 - Configure & Activate Resource 5
1.5.6.3 - Test Resource Out of Scope
1.5.6.4 - Track & Manage Resource Provisioning 5
1.5.6.5 - Report Resource Provisioning 5
1.5.6.6 - Close Resource Order Out of Scope
1.5.6.7 - Issue Resource Orders 5
1.5.6.8 - Recover Resource 5
1.5.7 - Resource Data Collection & Distribution
1.5.7.1 - Collect Management and Security Information & Data 5
1.5.7.2 - Process Management and Security Information & Data Out of Scope
1.5.7.3 - Distribute Management and Security Information & Data Out of Scope
1.5.7.4 - Audit Management and Security Data Collection & Distribution Out of Scope
1.4 - Service Domain
1.5 - Resource Domain
TM Forum Frameworx 18.5 Assessment Scoping Document - Business Process Framework (eTOM)
Member:
Overall Scores
Achieved in the
certification
Product:
Assessment Type
Number of L3 Processes in Scope:
P a g e 28 | Copyright © TM Forum 2019
4.1 Business Process Framework – Conformance Result Summary
This Section provides a graphical view of the conformance levels granted to the Level 3 Processes presented in scope for NMSWorks CygNet OSS v17 conformance assessment. Each Level 3 process was measured using a Business Process Framework (eTOM) conformance score according to the level of Conformance – Full Conformance (Score = 5) or Partial Conformance (Score below 5)
4.1.1 Service Domain – 1.4.4 – SM&O Support & Readiness
Figure 8- Conformance Scores for Service Domain - 1.4.4 – SM&O Support & Readiness
P a g e 29 | Copyright © TM Forum 2019
4.1.2 Service Domain – 1.4.5 – Service Configuration & Activation
Figure 9- Conformance Scores for Service Domain - 1.4.5 - Service Configuraiton & Activation
P a g e 30 | Copyright © TM Forum 2019
4.1.3 Resource Domain - 1.5.4 – RM&O Support & Readiness
Figure 10- Conformance Scores for Resource Domain - 1.5.4 – RM&O Support & Readiness
P a g e 31 | Copyright © TM Forum 2019
4.1.4 Resource Domain - 1.5.5 – Workforce Management
Figure 11- Conformance Scores for Resource Domain - 1.5.5 – Workforce Management
P a g e 32 | Copyright © TM Forum 2019
4.1.5 Resource Domain - 1.5.6 – Resource Provisioning
Figure 12- Conformance Scores for Resource Domain - 1.5.6 – Resource Provisioning
P a g e 33 | Copyright © TM Forum 2019
4.1.6 Resource Domain - 1.5.7 – Resource Data Collection & Distribution
Figure 13- Conformance Scores for Resource Domain - 1.5.7 – Resource Data Collection & Distribution
P a g e 34 | Copyright © TM Forum 2019
5 Information Framework Assessment Overview
5.1 Mapping Technique Employed
The certification scope defines the list of Information Framework (SID) ABEs (Aggregate Business Entities) for which mapping support is reviewed during the assessment. For each of the ABEs defined in scope for the assessment, the organization undergoing the assessment must map their information model to the core entities and dependent entities and the required and optional attributes for each entity, as defined in the SID model, according to what is supported for the product/solution under assessment.
P a g e 35 | Copyright © TM Forum 2019
5.2 Information Framework Assessment - ABE Scope
The diagram in Figure 14 illustrates the Information Framework Level 1 ABEs (as highlighted in green) that were presented in scope for the Assessment.
Figure 14- Level 1 ABEs in scope for NMSWorks CygNet OSS v17 Assessment
P a g e 36 | Copyright © TM Forum 2019
6 Information Frameworx Conformance Result
This Section details the Scores awarded to reflect Conformance of the NMSWorks CygNet OSS v17 to the Information Framework components of Frameworx 18.5.
6.1 Information Framework – Scoring Rules
Between 2013 (Frameworx 14.0) and the end of 2017, TM Forum applied a combined scoring method based on two different categories of conformance scoring:
1. Information Framework Maturity
2. Information Framework Adoption
Starting on the 1st of January 2018, only one method has been retained instead of these two scoring methods (Maturity + Adoption). The use of two different methods made interpretation and understanding difficult and ambiguous for many of our members, on the ground of such experience, the TM Forum decided to keep only the “Adoption” scoring method and discard the “Maturity” scoring method. Adoption scoring ensures a good balance between qualitative and quantitative criteria on SID conformance criteria. The adoption scoring method consists of a range of scores from 1 to 10 which makes it intuitive and fair, it is also based on weighted criteria e.g. core element, dependent, required, optional, etc. This section provides further details about the Adoption scoring method.
P a g e 37 | Copyright © TM Forum 2019
6.1.1 Information Framework Adoption Conformance Scoring Methodology
As of Frameworx 14.0 based Conformance Assessments, to recognize the overall adoption of the Information Framework SID Information model, the Information Framework Adoption Scoring system was introduced to complement the Maturity Levels that have been used since the launch of the Frameworx Conformance Program. Information Framework Adoption scores are granted based on the detailed scoring guidelines outlined in Table 2 below. Adoption conformance is based on an accumulative scoring system - i.e. scores are awarded for each element of an ABE to give an overall total Adoption score for the ABE – with elements in this context defined by core & dependent entities and required and optional attributes for both category of entity. The scores for each element are calibrated according to relative weightings, according to the significance of each element e.g. core entity having higher weighting than dependent entities and required attributes having higher weighting than optional attributes. The relative weightings for each ABE ‘element’ are indicated in Table 2 - TM Forum Information Framework Adoption Conformance - Scoring RulesTable 2 below.
Table 2 - TM Forum Information Framework Adoption Conformance - Scoring Rules
P a g e 38 | Copyright © TM Forum 2019
Additional Notes on Information Framework Conformance Adoption scoring:
1. For each level, according to what is required, a value is calculated based on the
percentage of entities/attributes supported - as appropriate. This will result in a
decimal figure (rounded to one decimal place).
2. Adoption Scoring is based on the progressive scoring schema from the former
“Maturity” scoring, however it provides additional flexibility in-so-far as it allows to
score all attributes and entities in an assessed ABE. In the former “Maturity” scoring,
when not all required attributes of the Core Entity were supported, the Maturity Level
score would not progress to the next level, regardless of conformance to other
“subordinate” components of the ABE (e.g. dependent entities, optional attributes).
“Adoption” scoring fixes this constraint as it provides a weighting mechanism to score
all elements supported, regardless of the absence of the core entity or/and required
attributes.
3. A core business entity is an entity upon which other entities within the ABE are
dependent. For example, Service in the Service ABE. A model should strive to attain as
high a level of Information Framework (SID) conformance as possible. A core entity is
also an entity whose absence in the ABE would make the ABE incomplete.
4. A dependent entity is one whose instances are dependent on an instance of a core
entity. For example, a ServiceCharacteristic instance within the Service ABE is
dependent upon an instance of the Service entity.
5. The score values for each SID component are added together to get the overall
Adoption Conformance score.
6. If 50% of the required attributes of Core entities are not supported, scores for
following categories are not applied as Adoption Conformance requires conformance
to 50% of the required attributes of Core entities.
6.2 Information Framework – Conformance Result Summary
The following sections provide the summary results of the Information Framework Adoption scores granted to the ABEs presented in scope for the NMSWorks CygNet OSS v17 Frameworx Assessment. Each ABE was measured using the Information Framework (SID) conformance scoring guidelines as described in section 6.1.1 above.
P a g e 39 | Copyright © TM Forum 2019
6.3 Information Framework – Detailed Conformance Results
Table 3 - Information Framework: Detailed Conformance Result
Member:
Product:
Assessment Type:
ABEs in Scope:
Level 2 ABEs Level 3 ABEs Level 4 ABEs
Product Offering ABE Product Offering ABE 10
Service ABE Service ABE 10
Service Configuration ABE 10
Service Specification ABE Service Specification ABE 10
Service Test ABE 10
Resource ABE Resource ABE 10
Resource Specification ABE Resource Specification ABE 10
Resource Configuration ABE 10
Resource Test ABE 10
Party Order ABE Party Order ABE 10
Party Revenue ABE Party Bill ABE Party Bill ABE 10
Engaged Party Domain
Service Domain
Resource Domain
Product Domain
TM Forum Frameworx 18.5 - Assessment Scoping Document - Information Framework (SID)
NMSWorks Software Ltd
Conformance
Certification
Final Scores
Achieved
CygNet OSS v17
Product
11
Level 1 ABEs
P a g e 40 | Copyright © TM Forum 2019
6.4 Information Framework - Adoption Conformance Result Summary
6.4.1 Product Domain
6.4.2 Service Domain
P a g e 41 | Copyright © TM Forum 2019
6.4.3 Resource Domain
6.4.4 Engaged Party Domain