17
“Sometimes I think we're alone. Sometimes I think we're not. In either case, the prospect is staggering!” Arthur C. Clarke

ng!” “Sometimes I think we're alone. Sometimes I think we're ...astro.gsu.edu/~raghavan/astr1010/Class_37.pdfDetecting Exoplanets is Hard • If we lived on a planet around a nearby

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: ng!” “Sometimes I think we're alone. Sometimes I think we're ...astro.gsu.edu/~raghavan/astr1010/Class_37.pdfDetecting Exoplanets is Hard • If we lived on a planet around a nearby

“Som

etim

es I

thin

k w

e're

alo

ne. S

omet

imes

I th

ink

we'

re n

ot. I

n ei

ther

cas

e, th

e pr

ospe

ct is

sta

gger

ing!

”A

rthu

r C

. Cla

rke

Page 2: ng!” “Sometimes I think we're alone. Sometimes I think we're ...astro.gsu.edu/~raghavan/astr1010/Class_37.pdfDetecting Exoplanets is Hard • If we lived on a planet around a nearby

Wha

t We

Will

Lea

rn T

oday

•H

ow d

o w

e de

tect

pla

nets

aro

und

othe

r st

ars?

•H

ow d

o th

e di

ffere

nt te

chni

ques

w

ork?

•W

hich

tech

niqu

e(s)

hav

e be

en th

e m

ost e

ffect

ive

to-d

ate?

•H

ow w

ill w

e se

arch

for

Ear

th-li

ke

plan

ets?

Page 3: ng!” “Sometimes I think we're alone. Sometimes I think we're ...astro.gsu.edu/~raghavan/astr1010/Class_37.pdfDetecting Exoplanets is Hard • If we lived on a planet around a nearby

Pla

nets

Aro

und

Oth

er S

tars

•“E

xtra

-sol

ar p

lane

ts”

or “

Exo

plan

ets”

•T

he C

oper

nica

n re

volu

tion

rais

ed th

e qu

estio

n of

w

heth

er p

lane

ts o

rbit

othe

r st

ars

•B

ut, w

hat i

s a

plan

et?

–T

he IA

U o

nly

defin

ed a

pla

net i

n ou

r S

olar

Sys

tem

–W

e do

not

hav

e a

curr

ent d

efin

ition

of a

pla

net i

n ge

nera

l!

•S

tars

–F

use

Hyd

roge

n in

thei

r co

re d

urin

g th

eir

Mai

n S

eque

nce

phas

e

–A

t lea

st 8

0 M

Jup

•B

row

n D

war

fs–

Fus

e D

eute

rium

or

Lith

ium

in th

eir

core

–A

t lea

st 1

3 M

Jup

•P

lane

ts–

Bel

ow ~

13

MJu

p

–O

rbit

a st

ar

Page 4: ng!” “Sometimes I think we're alone. Sometimes I think we're ...astro.gsu.edu/~raghavan/astr1010/Class_37.pdfDetecting Exoplanets is Hard • If we lived on a planet around a nearby

Det

ectin

g E

xopl

anet

s is

Har

d•

If w

e liv

ed o

n a

plan

et a

roun

d a

near

by s

tar,

say

abo

ut

10 li

ght y

ears

aw

ay–

Onl

y 11

kno

wn

star

s ar

e w

ithin

10

lyfr

om th

e S

un

–T

he S

un w

ould

be

visi

ble

to th

e na

ked

eye

as a

sta

r

–E

arth

wou

ld b

e•

0.00

003

arcs

ecin

siz

e–

0.5

mm

pen

cil t

ip h

eld

over

200

0 m

iles

away

!

•0.

3 ar

csec

away

from

the

Sun

–0.

5 m

m p

enci

l tip

hel

d ov

er 2

mile

s aw

ay

•Le

ss th

an a

bill

iont

h as

brig

ht a

s th

e S

un

–Ju

pite

r w

ould

be

•0.

0003

arc

sec

in s

ize

–0.

5 m

m p

enci

l tip

hel

d ov

er 2

00 m

iles

away

!

•1.

5 ar

csec

away

from

the

Sun

•A

bout

a b

illio

nth

as b

right

as

the

Sun

•P

lane

ts a

re v

ery

hard

to s

ee n

ext t

o th

eir

brig

ht s

tars

Page 5: ng!” “Sometimes I think we're alone. Sometimes I think we're ...astro.gsu.edu/~raghavan/astr1010/Class_37.pdfDetecting Exoplanets is Hard • If we lived on a planet around a nearby

Dis

cove

ry o

f an

Exo

plan

et•

Ann

ounc

emen

t of e

xopl

anet

disc

over

y–

Oct

ober

6, 1

995

–M

iche

l May

or a

nd D

idie

r Q

uelo

z

–In

depe

nden

tly c

onfir

med

soo

n af

ter

by G

eoffr

ey M

arcy

& P

aul

But

ler

•S

tar:

51

Peg

asi

–50

ligh

t yea

rs a

way

•S

ince

then

, ove

r 20

0 pl

anet

s ha

ve b

een

disc

over

edht

tp://

exop

lane

ts.o

rght

tp://

exop

lane

t.eu

Page 6: ng!” “Sometimes I think we're alone. Sometimes I think we're ...astro.gsu.edu/~raghavan/astr1010/Class_37.pdfDetecting Exoplanets is Hard • If we lived on a planet around a nearby

Exo

plan

et D

etec

tion

Tec

hniq

ues

Indi

rect

met

hods

:•

Rad

ial V

eloc

ity•

Tra

nsits

•A

stro

met

ry•

Pul

sar

Tim

ing

•M

icro

lens

ing

Dire

ct m

etho

ds:

•D

irect

imag

ing

Page 7: ng!” “Sometimes I think we're alone. Sometimes I think we're ...astro.gsu.edu/~raghavan/astr1010/Class_37.pdfDetecting Exoplanets is Hard • If we lived on a planet around a nearby

The

Clu

e: P

lane

ts M

ake

Sta

rs W

obbl

e

•C

ente

r of

Mas

s –

The

Ear

th g

oes

arou

nd th

e S

un–

The

Moo

n go

es a

roun

d th

e E

arth

•M

ost m

etho

ds in

fer

the

pres

ence

of p

lane

ts b

y de

tect

ing

stel

lar

wob

ble

Ear

th a

roun

d S

un: 3

0 km

/s

Jupi

ter

arou

nd S

un: 1

3 km

/s

Sun

, due

to E

arth

: 0.1

m/s

Sun

, due

to J

upite

r: 1

3 m

/sT

his

can

be d

etec

ted!

Fig

13.

1

Page 8: ng!” “Sometimes I think we're alone. Sometimes I think we're ...astro.gsu.edu/~raghavan/astr1010/Class_37.pdfDetecting Exoplanets is Hard • If we lived on a planet around a nearby

The

Clu

e: P

lane

ts M

ake

Sta

rs W

obbl

e

•C

ente

r of

Mas

s –

The

Ear

th g

oes

arou

nd th

e S

un–

The

Moo

n go

es a

roun

d th

e E

arth

•M

ost m

etho

ds in

fer

the

pres

ence

of p

lane

ts b

y de

tect

ing

stel

lar

wob

ble

Ear

th a

roun

d S

un: 3

0 km

/s

Jupi

ter

arou

nd S

un: 1

3 km

/s

Sun

, due

to E

arth

: 0.1

m/s

Sun

, due

to J

upite

r: 1

3 m

/sT

his

can

be d

etec

ted!

Fig

13.

2

Page 9: ng!” “Sometimes I think we're alone. Sometimes I think we're ...astro.gsu.edu/~raghavan/astr1010/Class_37.pdfDetecting Exoplanets is Hard • If we lived on a planet around a nearby

Rad

ial V

eloc

ity: T

he D

oppl

er E

ffect

•M

easu

re th

e st

ar’s

vel

ocity

tow

ard

or a

way

fro

m

Ear

th

Fig

13.

3 a

Page 10: ng!” “Sometimes I think we're alone. Sometimes I think we're ...astro.gsu.edu/~raghavan/astr1010/Class_37.pdfDetecting Exoplanets is Hard • If we lived on a planet around a nearby

Ste

llar

RV

Lea

ds to

Pla

net I

nfo

Page 11: ng!” “Sometimes I think we're alone. Sometimes I think we're ...astro.gsu.edu/~raghavan/astr1010/Class_37.pdfDetecting Exoplanets is Hard • If we lived on a planet around a nearby

Rad

ial V

eloc

ity: S

umm

ary

•S

pect

rosc

opy

is u

sed

to m

easu

re

Dop

pler

shi

fts•

Mos

t pro

duct

ive

met

hod

so fa

r–

95%

of a

ll pl

anet

s de

tect

ed

•A

ll ar

e gi

ant p

lane

ts, d

own

to a

bout

N

eptu

ne’s

mas

ses

•N

eeds

a fa

irly

incl

ined

sys

tem

•R

equi

res

a ve

ry f

ine-

tune

d pr

oces

s to

det

ect p

lane

ts–

Spe

cial

ized

fie

ld (

3 m

/s p

reci

sion

)–

Ded

icat

ed lo

ng-t

erm

sur

veys

•C

an o

nly

obta

in m

inim

um

com

pani

on m

ass

–H

ow m

any

“pla

nets

” ar

e ac

tual

ly

stel

lar

com

pani

ons?

Fig

13.

3 b

Page 12: ng!” “Sometimes I think we're alone. Sometimes I think we're ...astro.gsu.edu/~raghavan/astr1010/Class_37.pdfDetecting Exoplanets is Hard • If we lived on a planet around a nearby

Tra

nsits

•R

emem

ber

any

Mer

cury

or

Ven

us tr

ansi

t ev

ents

?•

Pho

tom

etry

is u

sed

to m

easu

re c

hang

e in

ste

llar

brig

htne

ss a

s th

e pl

anet

pas

ses

in fr

ont

Fig

13.

7

Page 13: ng!” “Sometimes I think we're alone. Sometimes I think we're ...astro.gsu.edu/~raghavan/astr1010/Class_37.pdfDetecting Exoplanets is Hard • If we lived on a planet around a nearby

Tra

nsits

: Plu

ses

& M

inus

es•

Adv

anta

ges

–C

an g

et lo

ts o

f inf

orm

atio

n•

Rad

ii•

Incl

inat

ion

•E

ccen

tric

ity–

Can

pro

be p

lane

tary

atm

osph

eres

!•

Dis

adva

ntag

es–

Fav

ors

clos

e-in

pla

nets

, or

very

incl

ined

orb

its–

Har

d to

do,

spe

cial

ists

req

uire

d–

Sys

tem

s de

tect

ed c

an b

e fa

r, fo

llow

-up

obse

rvat

ions

di

ffic

ult

•F

utur

e–

NA

SA

’s K

eple

rM

issi

on–

Laun

ch: F

ebru

ary

2009

–W

ill d

etec

t Ear

th-s

ized

pla

nets

!

Fig

13.

8

Page 14: ng!” “Sometimes I think we're alone. Sometimes I think we're ...astro.gsu.edu/~raghavan/astr1010/Class_37.pdfDetecting Exoplanets is Hard • If we lived on a planet around a nearby

Ast

rom

etry

•P

reci

se lo

catio

n of

sta

rs•

Det

ect s

tar’s

wob

ble

in p

lane

of s

ky•

Adv

anta

ges:

Wor

ks fo

r al

l inc

linat

ions

–C

an g

et a

ll or

bita

l par

amet

ers,

incl

udin

g in

clin

atio

n an

d m

asse

s!

•D

isad

vant

ages

:–

Incr

edib

ly h

ard

to d

o: s

pace

-bas

ed in

terf

erom

etry

–W

orks

wel

l onl

y fo

r ne

arby

sys

tem

s

•F

utur

e–

NA

SA

SIM

Pla

net Q

uest

mis

sion

?–

Few

mic

ro-a

rcse

cond

reso

lutio

n!–

Can

det

ect n

earb

y E

arth

s

Page 15: ng!” “Sometimes I think we're alone. Sometimes I think we're ...astro.gsu.edu/~raghavan/astr1010/Class_37.pdfDetecting Exoplanets is Hard • If we lived on a planet around a nearby

Pul

sar

Tim

ing

•P

ulsa

rs a

re tr

uly

incr

edib

le o

bjec

ts–

For

mer

ly h

eavy

wei

ght,

now

dea

d st

ars

–A

tom

s cr

ushe

d by

gra

vita

tiona

l for

ce!

–S

ize

of a

city

, mas

s of

the

Sun

!–

One

teas

poon

ful w

eigh

s a

billi

on to

ns!

–V

ery

stro

ng m

agne

ts 1

014

G, E

arth

’s is

½!

•B

eaco

ns in

to s

pace

•B

est c

lock

s in

the

univ

erse

•P

lane

ts d

etec

ted

by s

mal

l var

iatio

ns in

tim

ing

•F

irst p

lane

ts fo

und

outs

ide

sola

r sy

stem

(19

94)

•P

lane

ts fo

rmed

afte

r st

ar d

ied!

Page 16: ng!” “Sometimes I think we're alone. Sometimes I think we're ...astro.gsu.edu/~raghavan/astr1010/Class_37.pdfDetecting Exoplanets is Hard • If we lived on a planet around a nearby

Mic

role

nsin

g

•G

ravi

ty b

ends

ligh

t–

Mad

e E

inst

ein

fam

ous

•A

dvan

tage

–C

an d

etec

t Ear

th-m

ass

plan

ets

•D

isad

vant

ages

–R

equi

res

a ra

re c

hanc

e al

ignm

ent

–N

ot r

epea

tabl

e–

Det

ecte

d pl

anet

s ar

e ty

pica

lly

very

far

•F

ollo

w-u

p ob

serv

atio

ns d

iffic

ult

•O

nly

a fe

w fo

und

so fa

r

Page 17: ng!” “Sometimes I think we're alone. Sometimes I think we're ...astro.gsu.edu/~raghavan/astr1010/Class_37.pdfDetecting Exoplanets is Hard • If we lived on a planet around a nearby

Dire

ct Im

agin

g

•V

ery

hard

to d

o•

Fou

r fo

und

so fa

r•

Wor

ks b

est f

or y

oung

, ho

t, m

assi

ve p

lane

ts

arou

nd w

impy

sta

rs•

Luck

y fin

ds v

ersu

s an

or

gani

zed

sear

ch