MEMOIRS

NATIONAT ACADEMY OF' SOIET{OES

\folurne >(>(IgI:KTTf ] TX:T¿IOIIÙ

OF TEE

IINITDD STÄTESGOVERNMENT PRINTING OF'F'ICE

IüJ.SEINGTON1927

I{ATIOT{A'L ÀCA"DEMTT OF SCIEIVCES

Vohrm.e XXIgrxlnrf lltx:l\ltolFÙ

BIOGRA,PIIICAL MEMOIR GEORGE LINCOLN GOODALE

1A39 -L!/^2:ö_

'BY

B. L. ROBINSON

Psngpr,croo ro rEE Âclonuv å.T TEE Àutu¡rx Mnerrr're, 1924

' jri . \ ) i

$v 8¡,I-r.,,R9r¡ryqor

GEORGE ï,TNCOLN GOODALE-ROBTNSON '*"o'"",Ð***tDoctor Goodale's medical practice, though s¡tsnding through only threo yea,rsi, brought

considerable diversity of experience, for, in addition to private practico, ho held several officialpositions, being city physician in Portland, examining surgeon in the NaW, and contract surgeonin'the Army. He also tpught in the Portlá,nd MediA{ Ç,chgol,. .--, , ,. , ,

,

In 1866, being in ill health, he made the first of his longer journeys, going to Californiaby tho Pana,ma route, thus gaining his first.viow.€,tr.opical vegetation. His health \üa,s soonrestored and he extended his journey to several of úhe Western States.

On his return to Maine he married Miss IlenriettaJuell lfobson, to whom he had for somo

I.9&r9,:b-sep ;erlgaged: &nd ryhq' t-hro¡Bh',a lpng üfe¡ was his, .$eyrtçd.a+dr,sf-m,Pathstip ,,qompanion.

1.o¡,.lpclor,Goodalewpsinl86sappo,inted !qthe.Josiahtiitle.professorshipgf,nat¡¡¡g,I,gcipggggþBO.wdo,rp, Oollege,and there taught both in tþ9 medical qchggl ga{,il thc,coll.pg!4.ú,g prpfk, d¡i+g;t+.thg latüer .instruction in cþe-mis!¡y,."ti¡9r4logy,,,botany,1a,nd,,Z99IoSf, fqf tpþ,qut:fou¡it€,a{,ç,1h.;[g7¿'bevas,c¿lled,¡to:I{a,-tvard,¿s:univerqity.,le-q,tgrpr and,,instrqctgr,in þpta,ny*.:il+.lhp-rfg"hlowiûg.yeaü he ,w.as &dvqncod to. esFistent,,plofess,o4sþip,, and.,,in, ,'.1878:.:t9.,f,utl: B-ry-sfqq.s,,glçhip¡.1trJ

-,i:,,.,I1 w'a¡' biç:privilrego¡ as,wpll as one of his, oonsidgrgblg ,contriþutio¡s.rtoii$gigågg¿:te,4.-giievsD-r¡ Asø Gray' of .m¡rch, rou-ti49,.,¡üo"¡þ: i,n ipstnlçtior¡,;thus -frgeing, Doct-or iG.r-ey.'sr't-iue-fo¡ ùis.lsrig.-Brpjeçte{ Synoptical FIora of North A-m.erica, toward which þe had,boe¡rgg,þþ-ori.ag,dpriAgEßeqy,.y,g&rs aa, overwhelpi¡€,,8&Ês of uq,teri¡1, 'thqt

" only. :his trained ju{gment-icpp!{.-,h9,v,g

treatedtoequaladvaartage., , ." ' ;: , :,-..:,:,.:,¡; ; '; ;¡,,..r.;:;;i,.,Deptqx'Goodalgrs ÉrÞt,work at.-Ifarvard;wa,qhis,ge4e¡gtintroduc$oq¡;oo,r¡¡sgip.pþq,pe.rogeeigbe-t-anyr,, developed' ,çhie, fly , along ,the ,lings ;

gf, groqs. pq9rphqlory. wit¡ !{eqJs ' sin{q,¡ , t,o. .those . of

Ei-ob,ler¡r of ,saphsis Texrt'.bopki:re,4d pJ'Gray',q lucid;Struciq{al Bo,tøny",,, To.,pgorp,þolggyr.gf..,Pl}ch

Ealurp::he:.add9d:muchof-a;,phy¡iologioal Q.gd a¡,q4alqmical char..a,cterdçaJiug.;gfi.e4,iYsb,rri.tþ.the different vegetable,,tissu-es and ,!h.eir co4pone4t ele.pg¡tp,,yith.ass.i4ila-üip:r,,¡gçp¡¡,q!io.4,¡,tr.q¡rsptratio¡r,, geruþatioû; ,grnwjå, qnd, pleût noyemeBts, as.w,ell as.vdth.r.çpr:gd.uctlon,,v-aria-tio¡r; gnd. ev,olutiona¡y problems.:r,,,: ji-Itre,waÊ.a,finished lecture¡., , Digniffgd in¡prQsonco LTrd .q,greeablg in, ytice,.he hud ¡n rgpggs;siyp na.r1ner ,ryhip.h¡g&J,erweight to the i¡-formation he imparted. I{e;was.qeve_r,,huuied.rrù+,t,çþ,gse,,bis w-o¡ds,with.gryat care and passed,!9gi,call¡¡ fron poin!. to point. Hre was.a,giod,lfìF,tereporodraftsp@, ofter,gketchþ, g on,the blackbpard lp a few.well,-plpced,strplp.q',,!þe,ükiritstrl¡ctürBgor- an-aiqrnrcal detail.s h. e,wq,s dgeçtibing., , Eq,c.h dr¡wing was done with a-fti,9;{efqi,tetn-essrand ¡þe,mir.fÍpum.=^f .erasur^e.q,4d,oorrection.

.IIo never,heg!!q,þdito, omplof- 'the,.+o¡mperhaps,toq.,'generolly 'discardod.:meth-od iof ,,prpcige,dgfi4iFon ,of te¡ps ".o¡. st¡uc-tgres1,,¡,H-eê

-tbie,b-een done with.less,skill it rtigþå easiþ þq,vr tendçd tq t.he dogmatic,,bu.!,úhis.,;e,SQç{,h-n

LlevçrlJ av.oi{gd.,, IIis 'auditors.,w.ere carritd- away by the clea¡p9ps,of,,þis1pre9e¡ta!'ion.. ,$.qwas nsvor.tediousr Tever discursive, fhough, in a dignifed way, oftoa h¡¡florous. IIc þgd, bipp,itter .rre[ in, hand and therg \ila,g ng repetilio4, no tqJkiag qgainst time, no pauso tg ,assisT

4e,4ory., ,Not given to much theorizing nor to phiìosopþic gqneralizatiop, hþ slayed cl-os.e;,te

cqncrete fpcts and in stating thep. rì.ever confused hi-s hearers.by oveq-empha9is.,-o,f dou-bts .og

excoptig4s, Hundreds of students recall his lectures wit[ graiitude and .a'dmir+!ign.. It is tob" fämembered too that theso students were the same whó" dailv listened to such teachers q^É

|.Toiton, Shaler, tr'rancis C¡la, TVillia,m James, X'arlow, Palmer,l and Èoyce, lU of th"m mêngf greai oriþality and force, distinguished styEsts i¡ tneir respective figids. .

: :

t ' I n the l-a-boraio¡y Doctor Goodaló'was less successful than oä th" platform. , lHe *äsiþl#aiìi

-Uipily.uoa'"*"e"aiogty courteous to his students, but a ùrifle impersg+q,l, $ddilg.'tnaür'd¿it

wrth rather general diiections, which 'often left ihem in' some vaguenéss' as-r to:;his"'ìvishéÈiBéséarch in ihe concrete sense in which'it had taken form in thèlaboiiito¡iesiiä'tr'räncelàntlGermany had scarcely been transplanted to American botanical laboratories beyond the fietdof"taxônomy; and studelt publication of merit was exceptional before the' middle'eightieslttie :etective systg4 had not-long:been in 'vogue 'and' was lstilI in lts youth. ,'ùabora,tor¡r tãq"iement wds'as:yet scanty and very'imperfect. Its use'was'ahiefly,' to demonstrate' hoWn føcùsand processes, and almost never for student research. Graduato study wa,s,ra,re aidilittloorga,nized. There was much to change and to develop.

Ån¿or¡¡i oF ScrsNcDslNb.,6l

BTOGRAP}TY

. ,Doctor Goodale was keenly alive to,the nreed of inprovement'in'appa,latus;-increase;of

oqoipm.nt;, largor and better la6ofa,tories, more ðommodious auditoriums,' and' vasttry' increased'

and diversified collections of illustrative naterial, ' Toward'these'ends he planned'and worked

p"tf."Uf f"r:"o.. flu early realized _the impg*agce of 'pu-blicity"for scientific worki and with

his special gdt .ar n rúát"" äiqlruucn þr popït* tecturcã tro stirf-þsipublio to interes! in and

cordiality tãward s¿i"rrtifio work and ideals' , ' I ' j' '"':

.. ,l ff",äu*t several courses o lectures, atrtli'e Irowell.trnstitute in Boston, aü the 'Coopêr'Union

in New yo"k,, and.elséwhere. . TheÍ were well attended and aroused enthusiasm: Veggtabþ

pnv¡ia"gy *1" U in"-re"ãntie", "ijhder,

and earþ njnoties essentially novet in Ameriea and-t;À"

äodale had much skill'inlemonstrating and explaining, ovon to popular audiences,

thè,Ieading,facts and fundamental ,principlos ol"this subiect-"'He was' ingãnious in'devising

"fi*tio. iIÏushations and was.oo" oi'the

-first to give sui:cessfutilanç* pryig:tion to noving

ä¡J;;.h.es ;"*.";in p"otnpìus-, tl9 edcapeäf oxy.gen during the {¡iniþtio1'of'aquatioãil;;;ñ, Sn.h,vit"lpr9il".*, *no#o,in,acüón u-poniho,scrcen; naturally attrapted'nô.Tqlilt"*íi" days when the'electricÍanternwas still unhrown and,thqcinerrÌa'a thingund¡ea,med'of:

:. : . Doctoî ,Goodrilo wa* a,ve"y sucoessful'teacher in the ltrarvard'summerisahool, and'through

its -"¿lir-lu""iol*A.u wide influenco upon the methbds and'ideals of,ñirny'aloit'teaehers, both

men and women, young and middle "g^"d,

*ho took back t_o-th9ii:own work gr.eatly inci'e$etl

J"iu*i*.-¡¡of i..re# suarmer w""È* íhus spent,under,his'itimulating: ïnstruetiont They

ö;.J b¡**1'u,,,.,,i¡Ã6trs:parüs of tho,country,'t*q æn9*" came-'to'soek Tike opportulityi ' '

,,',.- . j[n, lg7g ,Dooto",.Good¿lu'"onsented, ,at ,the'solieitdtion of 'I)r; Asa'Gray, io'undertøke the

";";righ*i th;.¡I*y¿rd,got*oi" Ga,rdén, andwi*s appointed its direò'tor by th9.qræident'and

fello-wã of ,the, oitllege. , '

, tni. was ,a task'¡vhich'for Gãver¿l rea'sons'had much difficulty." :The

sarden was unendowed. Its expenses were, bonstãntþ increasing.' Tho'r¿pid deterioration

ãí-*nJrtä J*ãã"+*"-ed consärvatorios; the adverse'infuence's of 'dust'and'smokerfrom a

g¡owiog.city;.,the ca¡elessness and occasiånd'v¿ndalism',of:visitorsi tho'ìscarciüy of trained

ñä"oi*,,íùnø often conflicting ideas- oJ therrniversity boltrds, of'bottrnigal and horticultura,l

ã;lilrg""rl,¡æ'well ¿s of.the visitLg public, rôgardia. g the g,ppropriato aims for suc! ¿n establish¡

mentrand.,the liour."f ãu+Lfop-"iìt unorrl¿=te grien; 'tho'p"ãpe" afiu¡tment of its'ftuictioixi

to instructioo, "*"*ãh, op""i-"otation, and ocãtimatizabiÃ; its rcl¿tions to the;laborator'ies

;;t;il"--! .iùJ:Jt*""är,opoo theravail¿bte Éuppties'of'plänts and flowers'for-decoration

sÈ,oecasions of acu¿ã-ic celebra,tionJ¿Il 'thase,proËtem* w"tã superinposed upon the itiherent

aim"ùii* of keeping'a'host of, delic¿to'and,coitly exotics'heaftþ'i1 cra,mpe{ space 'aird url.¿

t L"¿ly Am*ta,r'.pãoio",Gfay, who had loog 9*p"yuoled,suoh trials,' once characteristically

¡ärr*Ë"¿ th¿t he did not *orrä1" that, Adamifell -if'h"'had'to

iivo'in Ð-gelde1. ' - ^ . .-. . Wih great patience, tact,'and,ovenness_9{ tempei nogtor_$oo_aale discharged foi'ma,li¡l

ye*, tn" ã"ti""^of thir,å*u"tiog position; 'The garden'under his directÒrshi,q wa¡.k"pj ?t Ii¡gh 1"""1 of efficiency. : ,It,functigned notably as, ¿n ,oo*ject,

Je¡so1 fui the great divêrsity of 'plant

life. No less than Z,OOO perenrúal speoies:wðro often in'cultivation there_ at _tfo'samo'time; as'

;tll ". ; "r"ia¿ u..u"i-"ät of annuais. llhe,conservatorios werg enlarged 11d im.proved;' ' The

;ñtlõ,Çui,.¡¡ven:"-ç"¡"ty "t horticultura,l.feaüures to attraót'the public: Drainage'and'g:ádiog"*oe Éettered;',.Anlendowment was started: A skillg!, 5"y-qii"",* gardener wasi

socrired, and a,tiberJplffãV i¡t"gri¡ated in supplying matoria,l not only for the diverse botanicol

;;triä-t" inu ooi"dt.iÇ,bot oiten'to neighlãring itrstitutions as'well. ". In,the later, seventíes and earþ eighties Doctor Gray, ¡slisted of h|l teaching ìby his

"o""g"ti" yot n'ger colleagues Qoodalg: qnõ F*lo*, and of hjs curatorial routine by the extra;or'

dinuäly'iåaurtäou. ãã':methodical Sereno' Watson,'.projected an ambitious coll¿borative

*o* *nl"n in fouî volumes,wris:to summa,rize the science'of botany. Vigwe$'þ retrospect¡

;il;;í";t"kt"¿ c"lr be clearly seen to have involved well-nigh impossible ¡lifficulties, and

there.can bu ^o

**pri'rJ ñ;d r;ained,u¡ftrished. The first-vohime wæ:a restatement'of

åïäääi-¡r"*"r*öú"r"gy by,Doctôr Gray_hims9lf. This subject wasrfaitly concretd 'rtn"l ¿a"J¿y,U"eo .+i"",t"ã"r"o*uf tiùes by"Doctor'Gray, whose masterly tucidit¡ and gogd

""Ã" of präportion had long,þsen recognizäd in Europe às woll'as America. ' Furthermore tlío

+ cEoRGE LrNCOLN, GOOD-AUE_ROBrNSON rMEMorEsråï:1HAf..............,

nubjeetr $hoqgh tJ no means coppletely investigatéd, had long beenpursued,and,was.relativelywell.ma-tured. Thus, without inorcìinetoidifficulty, Dogtor-Gra,y was able to.bring out håSúruptural isqtany a"s the first volume,of,th" p"oporéd rr"i*, " : , ,.; .,

- _ ,,- .-

- :,.r,: The seçoqd volqme, *.F:.h devolved upon ,Doctor Goodale, ì¡rasrtot give, si'nilap, summar5rof'the,a.natomipal and physiological aspects of the flowering pla¡ts. , gere tUe.otiditio* *u"ävery differenú. Inst_e1d of allanging a selective presentation of subject, mattor which had in& mê{i,sure,becgpe. defnite;'if, not, Ao,tqall} st4tic,,it¡,qas ,trssgssary,,to ,g¡ve, so to speak, aninstantpi¡eo-us ,vrew of a h¡qt,.of, facts;:intãrp¡etatíons, prooesses, ,uid tnão"iás,,whicd wero a.t-t-be, tiæo.rthgmqel.ves:lmovi q, .chan$n_g,,b,gAg multipligdi .anì rearranged. With astonishinelapidity,, " ,i .\.,,r,:,, Ptrant morphology, the,subject treated.by Doctor Gray, tpas,in great moa^suro an inde-peêdeu-t.o"n-ø , .Not "sq Flalt,physiology¡,wåg¡einyestìgartioo is iptim¡-{eþbouud upwjth,chem:istry' ,¿-qdi phygiæ, ,a¡rd .its succþBsi or.-, failure r m&Í,:, dopend upon concprrent. ,""go*"h- in so¡oer rémqte-ûeld,,such,as opúies;on'crystallogtaphy¡ theperfgction;ol staining

""ug";furr* unexpectêddiscovgxios.rega,rdingreloctrie.allpho4o¡q9lС-. , : . ., , ],,_.,-,:.':.:,-,:.i,:.,;;.,:¡i::r D.,ootor,Goodale'wrote, hi_s, v,olu".ne,fl¡rd, iú:.&ppeared,in,,.1885. ,fn ,tbe,spaee:of, a;bout 500pages. ho,go.mPre-gQad, & ye,st:a4qrlqt,o-t nattgr;, p¡lnrnarizingrhis Sübjeo1, proba.bly,as,ryqltr as: itE

,,.'ri.rThgreican:bslrflle.dopbt.that the¡rq¡kiproved disappoin¿ing,tq,its a¿trþs¡¡,.,.rt wasira,úher,too çonpendio¡¡s fo.rr a,'laborafor,¡r,,Sutdo,,a¡d.in,t-he rapid adva4ce of,..pla¡t an&¿o4¡i,,¿o¿physigìogy.pquld nqt'long,holdiits,owrÌras;a,trsrk¡ofrrefp¡ence.. , Neverth¿tessrit,haúsqm"y"*"of ,greatiusefqlness¡ and,thqre ca,n,beiûo,;dgubt w-hatever,that it, was aú,ifs døto.þy farrthe hesûwor. k on its subjqof y,hichþ,{, 1npeêred,i¡ A.qeriea.; ¡ X'urtler.m.ore, its iirflr¡9-4ceupö[subrequentedupa-bioual,wor.ks, inits'field hasrbee¡r:considerablg. .,. .:.. i . , :: ":t:,:::^.r, ,., jj r,..;j, .{ì

,, ', ,trtlhas,been;a ma,túer of wideiy.felt regret,thai the..tbjrd v.olume in lhe suriòsr"ìMhieh rou, iòhavo:been'an,iBtroduclion to cr¡rytogamic botany by Dr, llM., G., Farlowr,,wa,F,novpr oompletêd., .,r-r',,:Jt, is less generally,howl1',tha!-'a foirr¡h,,v,o.Io-g -¿r alpo,rprojecïed,,¡rhicb,Dopio" e*rjdesCribed,:4.ç':ia,rskotc-h; oJ,,the,;Na.turaii:,Ordors:qf,.,Phæoog*Jo,ÞIa¡1tÁ,.*o¿oi,th"lr,speoijiMorphology, Classifipation, ,Dìsiriþutroq,,Produets; &c;l' -This, by hisi:own, s:tatemont;,,íL:rya.shis'hope,r¿thor;thanhis,expectation,to;d¡aw,uphilnselJ,,.;:,,..,. .. . ::....,,.,..,.:,.. ..Ì:,. ;,,on.täe qompletionrof

lis,P,hysiologicat Boteny;,as:his;vofume was genorally called, DocioqGoodale turned his attentiqn: la¡gely,,to, cortq,in, pressing,matters somewhaú,eupheaigiicalljúo¡m-ed,"organization.l',,Tothosewho,rrorkininJtitgtionssuppolted,bygo*"r*o"ntJ;,Statð"orinunieþal appropriatigns" it,can,,sca,rçely bo ¡s¿li?ed whalðo-m¡liealiõris'ar,ise in.partiallyendowed instituúions ,g,4bitiorrsly expanding andjconsta,ntly fpreed,,to úakg on fu¡ction_r.,eq.Amq,intallr'. establishmentslof ino¡eaoing expeû$o., To:finq4c9rsqc,h,under,taþ¡gs;it. ig necessaryto,Þec,u¡e. the.,interest,oJ,pergong .of.:substaÃce inelined to eonstrqctive liberalitf. :Thq¡m¿üfu,;is,one requiring:consupm,¿te fact., ,There,must be the ability to aûtract faveiable,atteritiotg pres-en't,speciûe needs ilea¡ly,, to,com¡rand respeeô,.riqd to ingpire confidenoe-;. .,..;i , .1 ",ri,,.r , t'Inìa,lJ,,these.rcqufuem.ents,Doctot,Goodale w.as exceptionq,lly gifted,:and. h_s;secwed'thecordial:interest ofi an extended grorl-p of,persons,who;.te¡eatedly:aided h¡siruudprtaHng",,wiihliberalit¡r'and remained throughout life his de¡roted friends. IIis soliciljing,always haã a:fine._elignity.,'It was cleg,th,e! it was:,iupersonâl,in nature, for:high,p;ur.pose.aod.runselfish ends,IIis largest singlo uadertriking of ,tbis natule,ny'as úo,secure.the,needdtli.f:unds to huitd tho,botani-oa,l sectiqrr of the-university museun., , This was to furnish quarte¡s appropri4fg'tn th" existingneeds and.irnmediato expansion of the departmen!:of bqtanical inst-ruitiOn;:bot-h,as.,to,labora'-tories and;lecture:rooms. It was to have rooms also fon private gffi.ces, úfrary, cr,y.ptogamiocollections; and,amplo spaco for musoum oxhibits,of illustrahiv.e.boJanïq,a| *at""i¿,øti"ñ,,nuãloag beon, accumulating at,Ilarvqrd in a Fomewh¿l,t,desultory,lriaÍì4er,: and, which, thoughq,lready lipcluding¡m.pny. objects ,of ,rarity and- value, had.,n-ey,er,had prooer .organtzahioo., Tothis rnaterial.it waqlDpçtor Goodalefs,ambition to add objects far mo"" utiraetive.to,the,public,

This'building entprprise, 'of considerable magnitude ior its period, *ur "uoi"J

úx";gh 6tDoctor Goodale in a surrrrisingly short time, and was complete¿,i" rsgo. ,, o

.

: ÂcÁDsl4Y.or'. scrnNcEsl,;No.6l .

BIOGBAPITY

It proÌ,ided.for botany at:Harvard, quarters coordinato w1thllho¡g pt""io-l"l{ erected for

zootogy'and ethnology uod "úb."qo"ntly

addod for,geology and minerâlogy. ' It, thus qavg-the

;"i";; its proper plãco in tho comprehensive scheme initiatod rby.the Aqassþs; i The building

is of impreËsioe diLenrions,a,nd has many excollent features. , It is a serious businesslike-struc-

t're in ïni"n architoctural ombellisbme¡t nas been oompletoly eliminatod'and tho ends sought

huoe bueo simplicity, space, and durability. It was "mill Þoilú." It was a notable advance

upon what n"O p"#o*ly éxisted. . It must:not be judged by, standa,rds of constructioif only

at.a:later dato rendered iossible by uriexpected advances in steel,framing, reinforcod coúclete,

electric devices, or motal furnishing.Eaving thú" ,""*"d. for the university the needful hogsrng for a botanical museum, Doctor

Goodiile set.hjmself seriously about. tho task of ''assembling,exhibits appropriate to popular

illustration of his scienco.. Io thi" task he encountered dificulties of a'general and',psychological nature ,aÉ well'as

those of concrete detail. IIe wàs well awaro that previous attempts to mako a;botanioal

-o.u* a thing of popular intereþt had met with little success. Plant life itself ;lacks, nlüch¡

;;ù h"** uipuut *ñi"n can bo, aroused by ths clever prepa,rator who stages a'páil of nesting

biïds,,a b"uo"" ãiligently ongagod in feaß,ôf surprising construction, e lerPelt-charming itsp""y, o" an insect, u"rt""i.ni"gty- obscured þÍ protectivs mimi6ry. Nor do d¡'isfl'plant's com-

iu"ä * -"se¡m objects withîa,rie¿ minerals, precious stones or meteorites, nor yet with models

äf ""oyooS,

volcanäe", atolls, and other *urpri.ing ge9l9$c_d phenomena: . StP less are they

ãã-p"i*fá in poputai interest with archeolõgical exhibits dgnictinS primitive hrimanity in its

homely o""rrpuiio-o*. It was clear that, a botanical section in a general riuso-um, if it was,to

hotd its ownlm-ust includo,objects of much greater osthebic 1Pne4 than wood,sa,mplesn{b9"9,

,gu,os¡ o" g""ior, and far moré.i--ediate interest than dried fruits,'nuþ, or.corlês; Models

ä"rlá havo to be constructed which would glve lifelike representation of the plants themselves

with details of foru and color. This a,mbition \Mas noü a nsw ono, buü tbe results_attained, up

t" in"i dato, in plaster, wood pulp, or wax had been either extremely crudo and clumsy or else,

of a perishable naturo.W¡it" seeking a practicablo solution of this problem, Doctor Goodale was at'tracted about,

1gg5, by, soms excepïio"uny Efelike mo_dels in glass of marine invertebrates made by 1reopoìd

*lní¿Upn Blaschka. Óonceiving that the unusual talent thus shown might'attain,theJnri""¿ eodq U directed to plant structures, Doctor Goodale eltered into correspondence with

tn" gf"""hkás and not long*after visited them aü thei¡ home in Meissen, noar Dresden. They

wero at, first reluctant to r¡ldertake subjects so remots from thoir previous experience, but wero

soon induced to preparo some sa,mplo models of flowers and plants.

Theso,were färËarded to Camdridge, buü wero shattored in transit. Undiscouraged, Doctor

Goodalo saw even in tho fragmrnts such e¡ridenco.of ability on ths pa,rt of tho _artists that he

showed the pieces to severJinfluential friends. Among theso_wete.N[rs..Elizabeth C. Ivare,

of Boston, *¿ n." daughter,,Miss Mary Lee Wa{e, 'who took an immediate and gratifying

At"".*t in tne uo¿ertaËng and promisã¿ it th"i" support. Business details wero arranged

;"J th" B6.chkas, father "ld roo,-uotered upon a contract,extonding through a nunber of years

and securing to tho llarvard Botanical Museum their entire output'.

The noîable, indeed ¡nique, collection of glass models of ,plan1,s,-flowers, fruits, v.egetablo

structures, and anatomical details is too well k¡own to need description. _ It yas ent'irol¡l and

;*y [b";fuy financed by Mrs. and Miss Ware as a memorial to their husbaad and fatherr,Dt.

C-harles E. Wa¡e. Its success as a popula,r and drawing exhibit was immediate. Wit'hin a

few weeks oi its instatlation the attendance at the museum greatly increased and at times was

more than doubled.: Witn a central feature so notable, it was then possiblo to group attractively and with

telling effect in adjacent rooms exhibits of much cleverness to inform tho public regarding a

Stuutîu"i"iy of vegetable structures and productt. _ lo the most, telling disposition, prot'ectfon,

ãndlabelingoftheseDoctorGoodale.gave,painstakingattention.

,6 GEORGE LINCOLN GOODALE-ROBINSON [MsMorEs .NaEro-N,u,lvoL: xxl,

. ' Dffing his professional career Doctor Goodale'traveled much. IIe visited Europe ninetimes gnd, for. a, man who had not boen educatod thero, came to have a, very unusual tamitiarity_with th9 foreign laboratories and museuins. - He was a, linguist, of ,ability aind acquired a broaähowledge of foreign lite-ratures, public affairs, trade relations, colonial,,onterp;ises, tropicd,lagriculture, and a host of m.atters coatributing much to his powers as a,b"oad administiatorof a museum

In 1890 and,1891, in company with a cousin, Caþt..(later brigadier general) Greenleaf. Arrstin Goodale,.he madg a journey.of great length visiting Egypi, Ceilon, Au-stralia, Tasmania,New Zealand, Java, and the Straits Settlements, as well as several poinú fu.China and ,trapain.'-.- .lHis primary objecb was p_erscinally to'view the notable botanical establishments at pläceslikerPeradeniya,'Buiten-zorg, Melbourno¡ Syndey, and;Tokyo, to establish friendly rel'atioä"with their directors, and to securo by purchase or oxchange a choico selection of robjects,suitablb

: to:the firrther development.of ;the-Harvard Botanical Museum,and Garden:, fn ,these mattershe met,ryit'h gratifying sqccess; ,Among,the:exhibits obtained many were uhusual.and severaL-;such¿s,aliving specimen of the fern Todnea,b,arbina (tT:,aJrinanø) ánd,a giganüic,râta log, a lig-'¡rified aerial root somo'5 feet in diameter-were dou,btless at, their timo-unique, in Amãrica.,"

More ¿nd, more Ðoctór Goodale turned his,¿ttention to,the- ecolomie sfoe sf ,þ6f¿ay,¿1fltook much interest in the problems of tropicala,gricuiture. Arq,oog theso.was,the'improver{,ent'of'the sugarlcâ,rto¡,: Tdf.urther expeiimental'work,in this.fietd thðHarvard,Botaniäal Gardenwas able to establish, thlough the influence of Doctor,Go-odale and with.the generous financialsupþort:of Mr. Edwin n'. a{tkins, 6f Boston¡ a tropical garden and. expòrimenãs6¿tion in Cuba,atSoledad,near0ien;tuegos.' ,,,. ,i ..' .'.. ,

' IIerti not ,onlJz'mã,ny sugar canes, but'a'vanety of other tropieal plants of oconomio impor-tancé, were brought togethe,r for:observation'and experimental pirrposôs. Doctor Good¿lo 1¡adeseveral journeys to Cuba in the,interests of ithis enterprise, which is now being furútrer,devèlopedand alrèady forms a'notable instance¡of ,No¡t'h Amerìcan scientifio effort,brõught:to beai, uiontropical economic problems:

Doctor Goodale was a member of many societies botb scientific and social: IIe ,was apresiding officer of un-usual a-bility, managing:busi¡ess. with smoothness, speaking Uttf¿ ni-reU,but direcling cleverþ,the' discussions of othors. , 'Iris good.judgment, :reãdy,uid ,*y-puthedá'interest, and his.uniform courtesy. ma,de him a valued me11ibðr, Jn'many-;ss¡¡ùittees, 'H" .**'i9:l18s9'vice'president of the Am.ericaniAssociation'for the,Advaneemänt' ofiscieaoo,r and;.theio]]owing

-year its president. His retiring address, delivered at Washington, was entigêd'{Useful plants of the futrire.l',: ''IIe,was.Vice president ôf,the Boston Society-it Ñatural Histor5,from 1887 to 1890, and its president'during the yea¡ 1891-g2., He,rras one,of the founders Jfthe NêwEnglandiBotanïcâI'Clubiànd'was its presÍd,entifrom 1897,to,18gg; IIe received theþono1a1¡ìdegree.,oJ:A,' M¡ from Bowdoin in 1:869, and Of tL¡ D.,from Amherst in 1g90, fronBowdoià in'tag+, and from,'P.rinceton,in, 18g6. ; : . ,:,': i, ' , t, ,.,.. .: : ,,i..,.' ,,.,, ' 'TVith n¡r.nifold dutiés of instructión, ¿ad ¿dministratitrnithe care of the botanio gaiden,financing.ânel dovelopment of the museum, \Mith wide professi6nal correspondencs,¿i¿,¿6n,stant attention to the improvement of working conditions in his science, Doctor G""d;i; h"dlittle opportunity for personaf investigation. It is probablo he was right in judging,tþaf higspecial talents could be mirstefiectiveþ turned to otËer,ends, However, he had Jryåp;t¡"ã".interèst in the leseareh of others,'and many of his publicationsltook the form'df appreciativereviews:to give wider publicity to their results. , i'i,:^, ;:¡ ,. , ::

His writings, though numerous, wero'for the most part brief. Except for his PhysiologicalBotany, aìready discussed, he published but one rrork^of size, namely, The Wild Floweß ofAmerica. Ilis part il this was to supply appropriate letterpress of a popular scientific natureto accoùpany 5O'colored plates páinted by Isaao Spragué; the leading ,A.merican botanicalartist of the periôd- Tle þsk had,no grêat scope, but was conscientiousiy performed, and theresulting work.has be-en highly prized by many flow"" lovers and., toog anticçating thå nature=stucly pu'blications of the present day, gave popular instruction to tany re*det-s who couldenjoy its clearly written text and sf¡iking, colored plates, though they would have been unlikely

å.caDEuY oF gcrENcESlNo. Gl BIOGRÄPHY

to mako use of any work of moro t"chical charocter. Tho undertaking well illustrates DoctorGoodalo's confidence that science, for its own advancement and best intorests, must makopopular appeal.

His early rrritings covored a wide range of subject matter-chomical, medical, pharmaceu-ticol, horticultural, and agricultural, as well as botanical. In later years his publications weremostly roviolÍs, synopses for class uso, offr.cial reports, and addresses.

From 1888 to 1920 ho was an associato sditor of tho Âmerican Journol of Science, ancl to thisho contributod notes and roviervs in considerablo number. Many of his early rvritings rveroprinted in newspapors or in popular journals of a transient naturo, ancl in later years it is believedthat he from time to timo contributed by request to tho unsigned editorial matter of severalporiodicals, including the Nation.

For theso rea,sons it would bo weil-nigh impossiblo at this date to form a completo bibliog-raphy of his rvritings. llappily Prof. Robert Tlacy Jackson, whilo preparing his excellentsketch of Doctor Goodale for tho Harvard Graduates' Magazine, took great pains to familiarizohimself with his published output and to this end drow up e very full and as yet unprinted listof his writings. This he has gonerously contributed for uso in the present memoir and, withslight emendations, it is here appended. Tho portrait accompanying this memoir is hersreproducod by courtesy of tho editorial board of Rhodora.

In 1888 Doctor Goodalo was appointed to tho tr'isher professorship of natural history, achair long held by Doctor Gray. In 1909, after 38 yoars in the sorvico of llarvard Universityand no less than 36 years as professor, Doctor Gooclalo resigned an<l rvos thereupon appointed,by tho president and fellows of Harvard Collego, I'isher professor emeritus and honorary curatorof tho botanicol museum. To the extent that declining health permitted ho continued to givotho museum his care and thought for moro than a tlecado thoreafter, directing its growth, con-ducting its correspondence, and exerting influenco tolvard its financial support.

With social gifts of an oxceptional naturo, Doctor and Mrs. Goodale oariy gained anacquaintoncs of unusual oxtent ond rvoro ablo to make their home one of delightful hospitality,whore the guest at onco felt breadth of sympathy and rvhero conversaúion naturally turned tomatters of importance and themes of interest. They had five children, of rvhom only tworeached maturity, namoly, Joseph Lincoln Goodale, rvho has for many years been a distin-guishecl surgeon of Boston, and Francis Greenleaf Goodale, a larvyer of \Meston, Mass., practicingin Boston.

Doctor Goodolo's ûnal, illness w¿s of a gradual and at times painful naturo, but was bornepationtly ond. referred to, if at all, with char¡cterisüic humor.

It rrould bo impossiblo to summarizo in a ferv ntords tho achiovements of o life so full ofvaried, activities. It was ono of devoted and patient servico to science. Its ends were neitherspectacular discovory, nor detailed investigation, nor yet tho production of technical troatises.Its guiding motives rvere to improvo the conditions of tho student, to oxtend tho opportunitiesof the investigator, and above all to convey to a, wider public importont messages of scientiûctruth.

J I:: : ''-'.BIBIIOGRAPFIY .

. :; ,'., ,'

Compiled by RoaønoTn¡cv J¿crsoñ

1g62::'Botanical report [in thel Scientiûc Survey [ofi Maine]. Sixthrairnual:report.of'the secretqr5r of the Maine Boa¡d

of Agriculture, pp. 125-129 : ,' .. rl

Bcitanical.'notes''ori.the.newrlands. 'Ibid. þp:r 361-372, with B text ûgures. . ; : ,.'j :i.: ', :: ' .:'. ...

Chemic¿l report [in the] Scientific Survey fof Maine]. Ibid. pp. 443-456.A'catalogue Òf the'flóiVering plants òf Maine. Proc,.Portldnd Soc¡;Nat,l Eist. vol.,!,, pp: 37+63., [Continued,

in parü II of the same_volume published in 1869. See below.l. ... :; :.,: :._ ^. . .. .i., i

.. : .:' .i,:'a: .;.,-,. ì .t .1.ì . t, - , ...: .,.,, ,.1863.; t,,

Botonical report in the Scientiûc Survey of Maine. Secondgeology of the state of Maine, 1863. p¡i. 12G-128.

[On the geology of Yinal Eaven.] Ibid. pp. 264-266. . ,,

[Geological oþservations i¡ Maine.] Ibid. pp. 281-283.Recooooissaoce of tËe Schoodic Vallei. fÈia. pp. 313-328. :

'

[On the Pènobscot and St: John Valleys.] Ibid; pp. 333-843.[On iron.] Ibid. pp. 415-422.

1868 ' 'r' " ìi ' i: r"1 'j )r

r.,j:..i',: ::1. ..::.t.. r",ti

annuqrl ¡epofü ùpo¿,tlê''iatural lieiory anO

1867

Portland catalogue of Maine plants. [A checklist drawn with some chenges fromr.tþg palplpgpe,p.r,epafç4 by:..;:riD¡¡ G;;Ii,-, rGoodrile iand R.ev;" Jciseþh .,.Blake,a[dr,published ri¡ ,P.{qg.,; p-o¡tlgnd 'Soc3. rl{_at. Eistiivo! L pp,.:

37-63(1862)andpp. 127-138-(1869)¡],Por,tland...,Cover,Fp,,,l;-l?*- ,i'¡u,,,,i. ,, ,ì,;.:rr.! ..,j i'

...i.'. .,1 .i,. :: ...'!,.t.,:t .-...r r. .- .:,r.:i ,...r¡:.;.,,') :.:.r,',1!. 1., r:-,1) ,r:;., :..-:,:¡;..,,:i....-,' :' 1869 : , .,'.,, .,,,.,,-, .,,1,,, ,. .:.

A catalogqe of the flowering plants of Maine.' 'lWitn tn" collaboration oi'the Rev; Josepn Blaké¡ ': Pibb. Pört-i' 'ta¡dSoc.'Net.'Hist.'v;f. r, pp.'izz-tgg.-:[CòàclusÌon örïùe cbtâtoguii uéguii in.voi'.t,pf-37-63,'which,were published in 1862. See above.l "'":ii:- ,ìì:i;r'i':i'j'', r 'tÌil ì'li

1870:7872. .. :

tû¡¿Ë¡ '¡óint'âditorsn$''of 'Cyrû! i o..gg'iBrii:ôtett'and Geôrge Þinbolii Goôitilél"iÉòwd.öiiijrscÍertific,'RevieÌrliBrunswick, Maine, nos. 1;51, Feb. 15, 1870;rto Sept. fTjifaZZ. ' ' - ;'. ' ,". .

-,i..:;.',

[Review.] On a new method of observing the ¡ate of growth in plants; by E. AsrnuÁú¡...,,{ør,,{9u.rg*ScÍ.ser. 3, vol. 6, p. 231,

:

[Review.] On the general occurrence of starch in sieve cells; by:Ðr.r'Qnrgo-r. .,Iþid.,Ð. !3,1;,,;,¡1,, t. . ::, t.; .,. ,::.: ;..:[Review.] The influence of temperatrtfeì -on ithe .dèvelopment -:pf.-¡,F;eni;pi,l,l.iq'rc::g,løWVr.n¡t,blue mould.--!nor:1

lReview.l Normal formation of fatty strbstalrcgs in chlorophyJl;'.by :G¡,:BEro.sr..,: Iþi4.,p,¡890. . :;-^ ., t .,.

[Retiêw;], :p¡ysicilolical .reseàiches:inire'gard..to,,gerniination;, by':Pu.i.¡VA].I,:,TIEqgE¡4ì,,.,fbjd., pp,.,390-392.',., ,:: ,

lil- .:iì:: .Lr,: .:::,-:j :,::-'-1,j.':, --:.i .:l'ì'- --.trt.li:rìj::::..,,r ì,¡',: r,-i;. ì187Þ,,,,

Ibid. ser. 3,[Rgvrew,.l ,,P-,R"":l9Fgrl,e-t:?rv31io.3: :1,.c',e$elfi ¡v,,4, 49*,'"y.lJlt, .,Iþj9:, ?9il

[Note on a monstrosity in apple blossoms.] Proc. Bòston Soc. N¡t. Eist.,vpL l8,.p,3Þ4., ..r( !:,!,ì .,..j:fNotu oo vegetable parasitism.] Ibid. p. 359.

$Zg

V.e'getàfte";nistölógy.'r:'¡e¡osdd?s)NeÌ4riuriversbl-rcyclopæ¡lirí. "New.iYo¡k.. pÞr,,l189.1111Q.,;,jj,r.:::l ',.;,ti-¡.;1",1

[Review.] Transpiratlon inþlanlsìÌ .Wrn¡iN¡n: .,;Aa:,'Jd-ur¿:;Sci.. ser-¿-r3riìvo-l-. 1^5, p. ,1ã6.;, ,.,j .:1¡;:; 1;.,:,.-¡ ¡.., .. ':i

20rõ4"_26-.27 I

10

Ou¡ine of a course of four lectures on some relationg of botani to hgriiouitur* -.O"riv.$O U-y Pig¡,,Gr.oFg

L. Goo¡¿r,o of the University at Cambridge'ràfo¡g tþg Wgrgester'C.9¡¡gty.Eorticr¡ltural S¡cie!{, A'D-, I

1879.Trans.WorcesterCo.Eort.Soc.foryear1s79.12bp..Worcester,Mass.'..''j18S1

Concerning a few common plants. Boston Soò- Nat. Hist. Guides for scienêe teaching. 61 pp. I Gini, Eeath

& Co., Boston. Second ed. See above under 18,79': - -The Botanic Garden at Cambridge. Ilarvard Register, vol. 3, pp. 22-J5. lWith collaboration of Asa Grav'" and,{IexandêiAga,ssir.lt'''¡¿t:.rtt'881i 'r -'"' ' ';'"": " ': ::t::: 'ì'i" " ":':'i'' ' ':i""''

fn""i"iJi,;Bi¿¿iil;Ë;;tÉt";"a ae¡c"iptrYe.¿tla¡'of the:Eucalypts.ofi-Aüstralia:and,,the''oilioiiúng islands;

by Baron Fen¡, oo* Mtioor*. ain, "Joúrn.. sci, sèr. '3; vôli'2lr pp:i24С261,'; ' l ": ì '': ; ji:' 1 " ':- -'' ;

tn"ni.*.I 1'he flora of Essex County, Mass.;by Josw RosrNgo¡r' -Ibid' p' 251'

¡neview.Í Botany of California, vol' 2; by S¡npNo W¡isoN' Ibid' p' 251'

ôn tne origin of starch grains; by A. F. W" Scsr-uppn' Ibid: p'-3i0' , , , . r-

lnepo.t pJtn" sota,oiq Ë;iää.i" 4"". Rep. of. the Presiden! g,od T¡"*urer.of Haña¡d Còueset 1p7fr80: pp'

GEORGE LINCOT,N GOODA],E-ROBINSONÍMEMoTES NÀTIONÂL-

[Yor,. xxl,

atn. Rep. of thc President and Treasurer of l{arvard college, 1881-82, pp.

1883

: i,W.' P¡urrER;': VorlçiP,s,. Y.r,N Îr-Eetp!Ãi

Boston. 1r'. r ': i 'l: " "' :;

The floras of different countries. -tr,ibrary'of, Harvard:.tUniv¡;:Biþliog-,'Con-t¡iþ,'ng. 9.. .12 pp.r'Cam.tridgø;

Mass.':'..:.::i..':l.i,i,.l;,l-j:,.¡':.''.','-Guides:foi:scieiice.iteac,hi4þ,.no..Ili:-Co:rcêrning.a,fewcomtgnplants::. Publshedby'BoÞton:Soc"Nat'-Hist¡

Cover,pp. 1-61. ' ': ' : i -": : ' : ' ; : i

[Review.] 'ðuou-r,rgu" in early amber cane.-Professor Gonssì[A'Nl.T. Am. Journ. Sci. ser. 3, vol' 17, p' 488'

inevi"w.i On the causes of tle change in form of etiólated plants; by Professor Goor,pwsrr. Ibid. p. 494'-

[neoi"*.i The botaniqat tçrt-bqok (çixtn 9Ç.), Pa¡t I_. S!1au^ct31at botany, or oTganogxåphv on the basis

of morphologY... As¿GnÀv. Ibid'sei'3,vol'l8,pp,'!3-76' ..'. :. .: :,

[Published anonymouslY.]Cambridge, Mass.

::.:.::.',.".|,: 't. . .., . ,1879 :'1...ì I . ri i.11.1.i,;.;1,.:,.',,

ouuine notes [on botany].with titles of works of reference. cover, pp. 1-16. 16"

Recent reÅeaichès i'n'r,egbrd,to,seede. Tweñty:sixthr :Ann., Rep¡': $a¡is',Bo&¡d of Agrig. i for !878¡ pp- ?62-28't;

1880

95-99. Cambridge, Mass.lF8?: "

'r i ,,:- l:t

lReview.] Non-sexual outgrowths on fern prothalli. De B¡.nv. Ibid. p. 403.

inerri"w.i Absorption compared with transpiration. Vnsqur. Ibid. ser' 3, vol' 16, pp' 48É-486'

bn the causes of fhe abnormai shapes of plants grown in the dark' Ibid. p. 486.

lReview.] Davenport's notes on Botrychi'um símplen' Amer' Nat-'.vol' 12' p' 181

inuvi"*.i Ferns, in their homes and ours. .;I9u-lr.{,9uyr""1.,.Iþi$' pp' 624-625'

ìIybridization ia plants. Twenty-flfth Ann. i.i'èp.'Mass. Board òT?Agric. for 1877, pp. 156-159. Boston.

Ifild.4qwerstof .Ameripfi.. Witþ fifty qoloqedpþt9,q fr,om originatdravin-g¡b: Iqaac' S.prqgue.' ,T,,e¡t þ:,Georqg

,.*i;i:"ff:";""rl;?'å;3åÏi *"1¿åin?ru:¡3;t'"1""á *"',** or'luarvard coriege, r880-8r, pp-

96-101. Cambridge, Mass.

Report on the Botanic Garden.. 103-106.' Cambridge,''Mads.

õ¡:i-iJãã*rãp*¿"t:of,chlorophyil 'à'ú.d'cãior.grenr¡les,: :Ibiit. p::421-422¡;:'rr lir' 1 " ;''', ::i ''ri ; ;'.":rr ""i, i

tReview.l on the occurrence ãf io"-ic and acétic acids in plants, and their physiolo$icàlimpirttance'in'4etâ8ta-'---'.i.i''¡" õi. U,Br"u*^ñrv..t.AÌri,i"Jorirä.'Sci.:ser.'3, iol;i25¡'pp.i 161-tr62;r i" ':¿ :;" :'r'

-' l"r::'' ''i --!,r 1i '.ir;

tn"r"i#,1"-tÑ""¿lål¡¿iätiJ¡t"t.t.Ëermoveníentof:wäter,inplants:',:M.-,J:o¡,rpñv.¡sevrr;;r'rbid¿ ppi2?17-,2þ8;'

'

iñ""i"*.i Color and assimilation.-Tu. TV'' Erscnr'¡¡¿r'r¡r' Ibid' pp' 312-313'

[Review.] On the influence of sunny and shaded iocaiities on thË äevelopment of. foliage leaves; by E' Sr¡sl'rbid' pu'Ë!'3-3t4'1 ' ' ': '';r' ''ji't

o*i úo¿:¿À¡1n'¡ìroiu¿rêo'rvi,*ôùå,,o;Béfliå." iieod rr; 1883.'[Review.l Jab¡buch des K' Botanischen Garter

. Ibid. pp.479-480.fBeport of thel Director of the,Botanic Gprden'

1882-1883, pp. 11&:119. Cambridge, Mass'Am. Rep. of the President a¡¡d Treasurer of Earvard College'

fSS,i

.acÀDD!¡r or scrENcDslNo' 6l BIBT,IOGRAPHY

1887

11

[Review.] Die Pfla¡zenkrankheitén . . . B; Fn¿¡vr. Am' Jour. Sci. ser. 3, vol."27¡'pp' 4lffil6'in"rri"*.i The structure and function of lenticels.lllnrrqnrcs Kr,ns¿s¡{. Am, Jour. Sci. be¡. 3r vol. 28, p' 239'

[n""i"*.i The micrcichemical deteation of nitrates and nitrites in plants.-Mor,rsiir. Ibid. p. 239' L:' : ''

[Review.] on the structure and growth of pabns.-BnauNEB. Ibid. pp. 239-240.' ;"

[Review.] On the physiological signiûcance of water glands and nectaries; by-Wer,run G¿norNon. Ibid'. . .l

,""r,1å.itTå*"t;ation,and'transpiration:of.foogr.-Bor*ry¡nn aúd Merverlt- rbid. 241. : :

inu"i"*i Das-botanische Practiôum ; . ¡ SrRAsBUncnn. Ibid; pp.474-475.

iil"i;;.i Essenti¿l-sofbotanv....:'c.E'Bpsssv'r;:;on*tu , , , i .

,

vegetable histology, 8o 194 pp. illus. New York,. [advance reprint from Gray's Botanical Textbook, vol' 2'

Physi'ologicidlBotany. .,:. . ,. , r. ,,¡..praciieåt ut"r-"i.." ia bistologv and'physiology' '8o þp: 1212-3\,.Ibtd'. :'. - . --. * : , ,,'ili"rffi-t';;i;;ïr"",

"i:'äüiil"ã:;_-i th;.:rytJr"$r oi ,o1u""osu;..!i nrqnþ,_ ir: _Yegetable

phvsiorogv.

practicat exerciseb., -b'pp.;;i-

isg.lz)t ao, z1ã-gust.: Iuiuoo; B1ekeme;'& co,, New,York and Chlcagot

Gray's Botanical Textbook (sixth edition), vol' If'[RevievJReserve.""b:;iä;n,;"i"d:í';'Ë;;"^.Am.Jour.Sci.ser.3,vol'30,p.489.'l : . ,:.. . trr i i

T"ollå.to""" oo'pny.iologÌcal'botany,"delivered before the Women's Educatioual 4:sociatr-g $,Qæ),.renoiiàby E. s. Hatch. Nãw EngUnã Jgurnal of Education, Apr.-Ju'e, 1886.,v-ol 23, pp, 1Qft;1.917; 2L5;,,23t;

ias; zoz; 277; Bo9; 326, 342t 373" . ., '

-;.,, .' - ^ .

lReview.l ,pJasmQlV-tiÇ uto¿i"r . . . U"cò on Vmop, A-mr Jour'- !c!. ser. 3, v9!..31, Pf'. 157;1tái , ^^ '

,lt'^:Absorption of coto"iog Jäitir¡t Uy tn" üving prot'oþläim,of vegetabìe cgllst AU' Jgur Sci

1çr.' .3, vól' 32, p' 486'

A course of ten lectures on the pnàoo-l^u presented by ligneous plants. lÍith an account of ihe probable

origin, the classifcation, uod diut"ib.ttion of the shrubs and trees of New England' Delivered in March

and April, 1gg7, ¡"to¡_u in" W-ome4's..Edgcatipnal Assopiation. Repqrted for the Bgston Journ&l by Mjss

. I[atch....^ffitpcy.tng..,.,Ane¡tomyof atree.,.,Èostgn$emi;w.egklyJouraa¡,_Mu,1-18, 1887,,'vol. 54,'..o,22,, p.¡31.'.'

Seconit lecture. ph;riri"Cy of a iièe.' Bóston ioi"iai Suppl.'Mar. 19, i887, vol. 54, 19. 17693, p' [3];

tafsoinlBostonSemi-weeklyJournal,Mg'22,¡1887,vol'54,'no'!3,n'[3ì': ,.rtti7Q tec!y,re:.:, falmp- q.¡d !hei. arii-q,',. sqff;ilyËñË ;;il;1, lt-; '''iå,'t*,vol' 54' no" 176eI' p,''t11i

lalso in] Bosion Semi-weeklv Journa! Mal' 25, 18-87, vol' !4, o2'24, p' l2l'

i'r'"io]so'tooSemi-weeklyJ'ouinal,Ma,r'29,1887,vo1'54,no.25,p.|2]..---Filthlecture. our aþetatous trees. Bo*oí nlgríi1s fgurna!,]vtar-

29, !887, vol. 54, no' 17701, þ' [a];

,., Idqo,it],Þoston Selnj:qeetlv J-o.g.Tl-?,!,,Apr:,.l,,,t$sJ.1ot-¡!,,4o'.'?9rP''t3l' ' ' '-

'

siathtecture. Treeswithshowyblossomr.'Ë;iå;lï;;i"lS"¡OleT".'2,'1$87,vol-s¿,¡o.tzzos.r'tzl;þfroi"lBostonSemi-weeklyJournal,Apr.S, 18$7,voì'54rno'?7r,P1l[3]: :* .,;.:¿.'..'tt:.::1.: ' '|',,'i.)'::'

.,,.,,,; .ge.1¿ø,r.tth leckng¡ , Tþe qqrg..oj !"egl.: . F9.toa,[3i"ip,* I?lt"qtl]ï', 5, 188i, vol 54' iô:',17707' p' [2];'¡"rããîf Boston Semi-weekly Journal, Àpi' 9, 1887, vol' 54, no' 28,.p' [2]'

Eighth lecture. r'or"rirã¿ cünatå. ,

-ngoion Márning .Iournal, Apt' .12, I,ps7, ,y9! . 54,,tu 17713,'p' til;

¡rrr"i"f Boston Semi-weeklv Journqll;ÄPr' -1-5; 1q87,.vol' Í4:o',3-0, n' t2J" i''

,t{iplh tec.t,qe.,, noies-¡,prgauoter RestolJîoì"tr's",pft', Apr' ré,'ie'si iar'o,i;¡' noJloa se*i-wgffiJournal, Apr. 19, 1887, yoI.54t 9o.¡Q1;p¡ t3J. . -,-'" ,'r'. : i : . :" ', ' ,rr....::

. , .,Tenlhlecture. Hlnts aq lqitqeÌ+?q?epp,entolt*"9r¡asp,1¡1s'i-nlalagcapegardpni"g'.,,nþ$on Mornirig

Journat, Apr. 20, räöi,ï;1. -54:;;.=lil;6,'p.tlil.

lalso in]'Bostoo Semil"ãklv iournal, 'Lpr.'21,'18i87,

voI. 54, no. 32, P. [3]' '' - .';,. .

a method ót suþjeciins,iiviog prptgplaçm to the action of differeut liquids.

144-145. :

The Botanic Garden [including repo¡t on the'projected Bgta,nical-Museum]'

Treasurer of; Efarvard Couue", iàs5-86, ÞP' ll9-122' CBmbridge' I\{ass,

Obituary. Willie- Boott. Am, i.gul: Sci' sel' 3, vol' 34, p' 160' ,

1888

A.ddress of professor Goôdale: university of Michigan, r$7d887. , The semicentennial celebration'of the

äganiua+,ion of the U"iu"ttity of Micfiigan; June-26-30' 1887' pp' 190-191' Ann '{ibor' ì '

A.bÒurse of .lectures on fórests aid forest products, Lowbn Institute,Soston; X'eb' and"Mar','1888' [SyUabUs

oL l2lectures in 12 unnumbered sheets'l , r '':

am J.our, Sci,ser. 3, vgl. l3"PP,

. Ann. Rep. of the Presidegt a.gd

On a combination.o-f the a}r¡aTlqmeter with the clinostat. Am. Jogf. .Sçi.. ser; 3¡ vql',35, pp. 25&-259.. ' ,'. '., :

.Recent.coqtributiors to.opr;&ngwledge of ,the,yegetable:cell. Iþid' pp, élq=42Q. , r; ,,,:, : :,..., . i

Assimilation by colpred a4{.1v¿r.iegated leaves. ,Am. Jour. Sci; sgr.,3, vol. 88, pp' 159-16Q: '

I[ough'sAmericanWoods,Pqrt:I.Ibid.p;160.:,.Eteather in Townsend¡ Mass. Ibid. pp. 295-296. i '

Color granules in flowers and fruits. Ibid. pp. 472-474. .,, i, ): .r' .

List ofwritings of Asa Gray chronologically arranged. .[Prepared with'thq collaÞo-ratiqn,qf SerenqtWatson.andassistancã of 'lVilliam Gilson Farlolz, Cha¡Ies:sprague Sa¡gent ¿nd W-illiam fr4qcis Qanong:l Am. JouiSci.ser.3,vo1.36,Appendixpp.s-42.-Index,.prepar9d'.'byAr!hu1B1issSeym-gqr,pp.,11¡!5.

List of the writings of Asa Gray chronologieally arranged with an index. [Reprint of the preceding contin-uously paged.l cover, pP. 1-68.

sketqh of tþe life and wgrk of .Dr, 4*o g.uy:: Proc. Boston Soc.,Na!, H.is!. uol 24, pp. 191-198.

[Revien,.] Das pflanzenphysiologisòhe'Practikum . . . 'Dsrúon. Ain. Jour. Sôi. ser. B, vol 3{, pp. 8þ88.

lReview.] Gray's Elements of Botany., Garden and Forest¡ vol...1,,pp. 11-12'

[Review.] rheKansasr*ott."#äå;uËä¡îËu*;'"d,-irytrú;¡ç À K;uo¡ye¡.. rbid.p..12,r,r ,'-'[Review.] Resp-irator¡r'orþns of plants. ,: Lopwrc.Joglr 4a. Jo_u1sgi; sêr. 31 :91.-35' t j58. . .

[Review.] Die natürlichen Pflanzenfamilien, von a. Er.rcr,nn gld K. PRÂI{-T!. Ibid. p. 269, .

iRevi"w.l FIor¿ of the Ïrawaüa4 Islands; by 'W':r,r,rev H¡¡r,nsrleuo- ,I!id. pn. 501:-502.

[Review.] Dr. Spnpño ifl¡.rsow's Contiibutions io Ameriéan Boiany. -lå.ti""i, -S"i.t3e".

3, vol. 316,'¡.'392.

igeview.l Flora of Mid.dlesex County, Mass.; by L. L. D¡un and F. S. Cor,r,nrs. Ibid' pp. 392-393.

ine.,'iev¡.i A catalogue of plants growing without cultivation in the county of Nantucke_t, Mass.; by $enreL. Owpr.¡. Ibid. pp. 393-394.

12 GEORGE T,INCOT,N GOODALE-ROBINSON

[Review.] I'Io¡a ltaliana, vol. viii Professor C¿nupr,. Ibid. p. 417'

lReview;] 'Diagiosês'plantarum novarum âsiaticârum, VII.-C.-J. M¡xruowroz.[Review.J The orchids of the Cape Peninsula; by Hennv Bor,us. Ibid. p. 411,

[ReviewJ Eànðbook of the Amarylliderie,.including tbe $.lstroemerieae and Agaveae;p.418.

[MtrMOIEs NJ,TIONCI,' [Yot'xxr,

Ibid. p.417,

þy,I.G. Berpn. Ibi{.

[Review.] Catalogue of the flora óf Vermont; by Gnoncn I[. Ppnrr¡rs. Ibid. p. 394. ] ,,.r.

[Review.l Plants of Rhode fshnd; by J. II. BnrvNprr. IÞ¡d: pp. 394-395. . .

[Revie-w.] Catalogue of the flowering and leylJike ptagts.growi'og:without cuttivation in:t4e vicinity of thet Falli of Niaga=ra; 6y Devrn F. D¿v.' Ibid. p' 395 '

The Botanic Garden lincluding a repori on the projected Botanical Museum]. Ann. Rep. of the President andTreasurer of llarvard College, 1886-87. pp. t24-t26. Cambridge, Mass.

1889

Herbaririm of the late Rev. Dr. Joseph Blake. Am. Jour. Sci, ser. 3, vol. 87, p. 419.

Some recent investigatio¡s relative to cell-contents. Address before Am. Assoc. Adv. Sci. at Toronto meeting,

e"S: J-S8^9:^

Salem Press Publ. & Print. Co., p. 16. Salem: laSo'*1 Proø $.m. Assog: Adt. Sci. vol. 38,

' pp.259-272.WnaììsaphyIlodium?Am.Jour.Sci.ser.3,vo1.38|pp.495-497..,...''protoplasm and its history. Address delivere¿ . . . äs vi'ée $resident o'f' the Biological Si:ction oftthe .4. A.

A.S.atToronto,Äui.28, 1889. Bot.Gaz.vol. 14,PP..235'246'." ' :'''' ' :: : '

Princiþles of physiological botany as applied to horticulture and forêstry. "Garden and !'orest; vol.'2, pp. 8-9,zizr, zz-es, a4:.48, 56, os-qo, so-gr, 92, 104-105, ud-lu; l2&-l2g! 140-141,.153;'16+-lßõ,'177-178,

: 188, 2Ol:202, 213.-:214, 225, 249-250. : ' '

lReview.] ¡lg,r p;i"plasm'ars Éermen-torgapismus . . . A¡snRn WrsÂÑD.l .Am; Jou¡. Sci. qer. 3; vol. 37, pp.

77-79.[Review.] "Ringed trees." W. L. Gooowr¡r' Ibid. p. ?9. ; :

iReview.l e prolirio"at host-indef of fungi of the United stâtes; by W; G. F¡nr,ow a¡{ A.: B. Suvu'oun. Ibid.pp, 79-80.

¡¡.i, m""i"*.i C"ittio relations of tùê ôell wall.-Dr: Koirr,. 'Ibid"p.237:':r];.' 'â;'

igeview.l The chemjcal nature of assiinilation.:Ts. Boronnij 'Ibid: pþ' 237-288.

inerrie*:j' Improvement in the "iaces'i of the sugar beet.-:C. Vror,ro'rtp: and F- Dpspnpz. Ibid. p. 238.

lReview.] The primordial leaves of ,{bietineae.-Drcuu,lo¡t; ' Ibid.'pþ. 2ts8-239,

iil"i;;.j itiå ä"ur""¿lng water-current in plants and its physiologicai s'i!5nificance.-i. WrpsNon. Ibid. pp.

31È320. ì

lReview.] Certain coloring,matters in fungi. [, Zorr-. Ibid. p. 320.

fneview.i The bacterialïãimS fountt in noÍmal stomachs.-J. E. Aspr,ouÉ. Ibid. pp. 320-321, '' ' : ":| "

iReview.l The Botanic Garden at-Buitenzorg, Java.-Dr. Tnnus. Ibid. p. 322.

inurri"*.i The structuíe of 'the ,'crodq" of the_root.-LÉon F¡,or.' Ibid, p, 322. " t'. : .' ": : ':':

ine.rriew.j ContributionstoA-rrerican'botany,XVi; bySonrwo'W¿rson.' Ibid..pp.4L5-416i '' ' '

iReview.l Keytothesystemof Victorianpiants, I;'byBaronFpno.vowMunr,r,pn. Ibid:þþ.416-417.1 t'

igeview.l Revision of North American Umbelliferae; by J. M. Cour,rnn and J. N. Rosr. Ibid. p. 417.

AcÀDDMx,ön'selnicnsl -.'t. . ..i'No.6l- '

.BIBT.,IOCNAPÍTY

ll,riYlEw.l rY¡vuu6¡q¡,4¡av ¡ ge.v¡ vo-r-

.a, ."*¡qät b"g,A!""gypp,qq,Ç+qpa"tp, Du= cepner,r.4.,',Vo.l.,Sç*.!p4. ,.4qdropogspeae,;?ucl9Ä9,-EPqARP9EÀg5pÈ

¡¡sr¡iewJ ;*A'ngeyapd.te Pflanzenanatopie; by'iReview.l

- Die natürlichen Pflarizenfamilieq'-

.13

ïi

liii:1

Ìi

iiltiiit

l

t.

I

[Review.] Synoptical list of the North American speciài' of Ceanothus; by Wu. Tno¡,s¡gs . . . C. C. P¡Énv'

inérri"*.I -

On the multiplicaiion of Bryophyllum caJycinum. _,Er' B. 'W. BÀR. g{: JÞid,,n. 419' lgnsiened']

inerri"*.i Enumeratio f,lantarum guatepalepgium.i a.,,J9tI DpNxnr,r,.Sur- u' ' Jbidr,p. 419. ,;'r "rr'iii', : .Ì '

iñãJ;:i i"-"r"rt,.¡ eo4¡e.¡aiqnu-lrx 1.1Qft1i96 .,1,,' 9.,s. sêRcnryr.: .r.þi4.,p.419,' i',:i:'i: ""'i',- ,',:i':'

if.tote.l Annalsof Botany. Ibid.p.419._ .i. ,, ;i i . .'::':,,ì ,'':,',::-'--'. :'i"''';"tReview.l ,Ouuines qf lessqns iqboÎpn¡;' Parf !' :Ibo4:seg{ t9 leaf ; b¡r Jaryu trI' Næws'L!-É' ,I.þi4. n'r4-1-9t,,' .. r,'^;

iä;;;:ï i;;-b;;;huns und dachsthum âei zemàut;'E. z¡cs¿n¡¡s. Am. Jour. Sci. ser-',r;$,,vo-1. 38,

l$eyi,"f.l ..VClio4. :',..,I+;,Kr,prry,,1-Ib!{._n' ?{2' , . i '- ': , i:. "¡t ¿i'': :i i ':::;i)4.'r'::

iil#;:í Z,i" Xdooi"i.r'ãut'û*"o Lichtlaeé der Laubbl¡itter; by G. Kn¡sso. .'IþiÊ.9',?89'ì ,1,i iì1,j': :';

[ffqvr_eg,l ,,,,919.ra, ,q.Our,,atg"*é9rþpfq4iq"che zeillys, . [Noiei qn'iournal anri,q,$icleq þ-v 'sevèr$; s+,thorpd'- Ibid. p. 253. ^, " "

"'¡¡þyiew;l .The. utiligatioq b;,,plants ef,free:atmospnçriç,qrtfo8.e4¡,1,.. .-.,..!ro!,'-F'nelr5,¡, !i{,"'P.1'?ÞÐi: 'i. ',-,

'; f i;; r ì

t#;:i "nl";ãerrphüe pËanerogalmaþum Piodroq 1"1. continry,trg; nurc revisip 'Eêt!:ig1:1^nåq:11*-:

flì,eview.]lÀ"sçya+à,!eP{pnze"a3,ap¡op!e; by A.,Tscu¡rycn''.,..Ibj$';P'2õ4' r, ,: ¡',r:l'r'::,r',11';i"1'1.'tl':':::'"ii :' i''

iñ;ñ;:r,'oiJnattiriicnen'PflanzenfamiIieu.-Ä..E¡lo¡,ne?ids.P:^"To]I!id':|.^nlÍ:-in"uiu*.j Guide prøctique po¿r les travaux de micrographie, par Bt¡unnceno et G¿r,r,rppn. Ibid':p' 415'

i3;"i";.j Conhiúutions to the.physiology of growthl:j':'il: Wonr¡r¿¡w*. Ibid. pp. 415-416.

ü" eot'"io.câ¡q-ep tiqpr,rsss Lriry¡L;,!,o:'¡^!g$$ns of,.-!¡gf:J*"Xi!Y.t:iml, ii-+-,,$ep'191'!þe,þ¡i:Botanic.Garden linclud"]g a,. repo.¡t on l4g bgil$ng qf !þ.e, po-t1ni99l:!Ivlus-elÌm-lt:' qnn-', +leP' :o¡ !4q {resr'dent àiiat'Tieasurér'of Hariard Coilege;'f887-8pr' ,PP' 1q3:131rr Ca.pbridsel ivr'9ss:,'.,,¡, .,:ii t'i, .::; " .i

il

fi''1.

L"I

IL.

I

.'

t,

l,t.

I

bigþgical journal

. ,.,'Oãtrexì. i ilr

, ;.: .r, ,:":,¡ ,rti¡ .r¡,¡ ;'¡1¡:i:i:l

P',407.'', . ,,i.,. .::lrl::-,..1iìJ .rÌ"i'' :r''-i ri'':' j:..-,1: t:,!1.),t :rli,r.:;iì,-:

Am¡' Jour,¡,r SÇi. ¡ÊgD¡:i&.ì

.-ì ;"., ;,-r, l,' I r¡. 1 ¡ ¡.;:'i¡l:ì:.

P,lRfsx: ..'.' . ; V¿sr,¡r.;l : :,I-bidr;rPP;'': , l ., ,;"ì, ',i':i.i.,:t;ì1:'

ñ, L. BnrryroN,r:. Ibid. pp., :171:'172r.i :'rì'i . '.':'..:-.1 _-ì

Ann;.Rep. of .the"President'.arid Treagurer:9f, . ., :. :..,ii.- ...:

BnÀ¡iongun ,.

,,Ì

t4 GEORGE LINOOT,N GOODAT,Ð-ROBINSON lMÐuorBs NÀTroNÀr,' ' [Vor,. XãI;

Ibid. pp. 436-437. ,. *,-,t0,,..rì.:

[Review.] Researchesregardingthe.efrectgf'lea;f-removalin.the:daseof.giape-vines;:riA.,Mtiurz.',Ibid:,p:.437r[Revie¡i.].::Mubiferous Ëystem"of Laminariac€8,€,:by,Gu¡e¡ranù:.,:Am.:.Jour.,:Sêi. ser. 3] vol: 44,.,p- 5Q1,.','...,,ì:; j[Review.] Researches on multiple buds, by'W-. RussuLL. Ibid. pp. 501-502. .: i .,r .j,ii:l'[Review.] A¡tificial intracellular:clystallization;..8. Bpr,zvñc'r rlbid. p,"õOZ.;t .rr,;.i ..rj,ir.;ir,. r,rir ;r;:.:: i.,.,,;:;,-¡,r jìIReview,,l ,.Onth.eae¡&tionrrif'soli{tissues;,:Ilpxn¡, D¡v*úx.;Ibid;;pp;802-504. -j':.,.'r .Ìaì :.ì:.;'.':..i.,.jThe Botanic Garden [inclurling a report on the Botanical Museum]. Ann. Rep. of the Presiderit, a,ä!.Trea,surer

of Harvard College, 1890-91. pp.r 156-16ts:,, ,Caiúbridger'.Mass. ;,,...1. '¡..i ,¡:r .¡,:.,:- l:: ¡r, .i,;.,,',.. r'.;:¡-'r,l.f-i'..,' .,, .

,l 1gg,å:rf..ì .r. - , ';,:jj:: ,.aii..ì :ì,.;.ì._r..iii:i).irr.':1.í::: j..,,;ì.ti,,ij]

., .i '. . .. .: . .:. :: , .:l :,1,:, , .¡i; ¡ri ,ì i;,; ì: 1.,,:.':,'.,- .l:jl

Botany at the university. llarv¿rd Grad. Mag., vol.:l; pp. 29t-293,;: ', .' ' , | '.r;i-j

The Blaschka glass flOfer Côllection.. ,Ibid. pp.'602-606.:,' i.: ' ,.. . .. : j,-, i, r.'.i.r:r,' 1r:,ir:r .:i.; .i.: : ''.-r'..'.'.il;

Botanic Garden and Botanical Músèum' Earvard'G¡ad:"Mag., vol. á;,pp. 'll6-1L7,;"'';'i t':,"u .1' .i-.,: 'r-'':'-i'lìSêr¿ns :Fátson with a list of .his writings bt J. A. AIle¡;". Proc. Arä;.,A.caà.; vot,;zZ;'1B;.¿08-¿riti wh¿re,pubj

1891

Some of the possibilities of economic botany. Presidential address before the Am. A.ssoc. Advi Sci: at Wash-ington, Àug., 1891. Am. Jour. Sci. ser. 3, vol. 42, pp. 271-303. ì

The same reprinted separately at New Haven, 80 cover', pp. [2] 271-303j ' r''

The same published in Proc. 40thìmeeting An. Assoô. Adv. Sci.:1à92.' pp. 1-38 lunder title of] Useful'filanióof the future.-Sqme possibilities of economic botany, : ' L:'¡:l " 'r;'r ,¡: ¡1,"1'. " ;.¡:r'l .:

The sami!;:Pop, Sci. Mgnthly, 1892, vol.40, pp. 57'76,'2-07-220. \aityre (London), iol.44,'þp.:¿OS-470j: 58'O-SS6. :... ..: :. : , i' r .: : , . ,':.;::

Translations: Zuku'nftsfragen ueber Nahrungs-und Nü!-zpflanzen. Sond,erabdruck aus dei:Þharma-ceutischen Rundschau. New York. 1891. 80 pp. .2. Les plantès utiles'de l'¿vêuir: 'Rêüúe ßcÌenïificiìie¡5 Dec., 1891r.2'Jaií,, 1892. ' -.-, ¡i'r,-.1 -:..'.. ':.. r:ì :.: ¡::,::ì 'ì',! ,,.,:i,','r,';l '¡::i.!ì i.r',',ri'r?,'i:ii

:Botàiiìb'Gàidens'i¡ üió'equatorial belt and Ín' thri soùth éê¿s; "Ah;-Jóur. Sòi.,'ßèil S;r¡Or.'nO -p.'f7$-liii

260_264. .l :i .,í .i .:r:llsame contiiüè¿'u¡¿èr tittel Some museumd dnd'botiariical þardenb:in tliê eiiuatoiii¿:tbdtt'rindl _in thé'goü!_{

{Same lontinuedün¿¿r titlel "Botanic GardenÈ'iilthe:equatoriat belt'anä inÌthe'southiè;asrr'{5¡¿.;nf,¡,517:522.Gardenplantsof Ceylon. GardenandForest,,yol.4,p.62. [Seetableof contents,p,6¡:i'i:"1 .i:: r ':iThe Botanic Garden [including a report on the Botairica'l'Museum]. :A¡n::'Reþ:'of"tlici Pièiiidéút'á,úd TYeasuier

.of Ilarvard College; 1889-1890; pp. 16G-170. ; Cárhbridge;M¿¡sÉ. 'l'. :'';' ' : :l''r ,r":i:'j:-r '' .' .;:i-:. :' ¡.'';l :' r.;

-;. , .: ... .:,.., 1|892:r..:¡.:... . , -,.r ,,r., ;.:: .;i.ì :.1.i ,.1:ilriiti:.i,:;:jr',.':ì 1.r-.:ì.::fi]

[Mudeums'oT ÁuJtralia, tasmäliaiand.Ne¡r Zeahndl P¡oc, Bgeto-n.-Soc. Ng,!rU¡sü'ycjl, ?5, p. r16rr:.1;i] r; :1'

hemarksonthelifeofSahuelDóxter.Ibid]pp..364-365.'...'].'lReview.] On specific assimilation in Umbelliferae.:-M. GÉ¡rp¿,u op L¿¡¡enr,rÈnp. Am. Jour. Sci. ser. 3,

vol.48, p. 160.

IRevie¡¿],',Efests,ciÎ cert¡íin":poisoIrsi.onl,the,-gei.misation,of..seeds:.+-,CÉ:,:Oonxpvlñ'.Ibid:ì p.,,16L.;.:,',;.:.::',t:,.".,[:Review.l;'rProofs.lof llandlcommlnication.,bétiveen'Europe and Amerrioa,lduring,.thé.Í'nÍòdern'fr,age..,óf the

earth.-M. É¡¡rr,p Br,¡¡rcn¡no. Ibid. p. 161.

f8.eview:l' Coùparative'anatôuifof,plàn:ts.-+Ao. Cs¡rr¡r. nbid..:pp.',:1.6tr-162., : , ii ; í:, ì. ,,. .'i,,r;'ir,: :iir .:rì'

[Review.] M. Lucro¡t D¡.¡¡rnr, . . . Root-grafting. Ibid. p. 162. .rì. ', , ::: ','i:1 .r, ¡[Review.].' Pbysiolog¡r ..,,j,;:;LpcsÀnTr¡R;;:: ¡¡:IIÐNRI ,Boceuonæ¡.....trbid;pi,1621 ,.]i't..; .,:l .:-r.i : :,r.. : ; : t:[Reviewl BounQupr.or . Boletus. Ibid. p. 162. .;: .,rr .i.r¡ .;': r r r.' ,: .: - -:

,

lReview.] Die natürlichen Pflanzenfamilien . . Er.rcLpn and Pn¿lrtr;.1 trbid:p: 162., ì.. ii :r.r j, ::,:;rrr¡ii-. r.:.ri'.;.'

lReview.] Coniieroi'hg.príoéiples..whichJ.accôrñp6ny':chloiophy,If in.le¡ives:;-Ér.uió1 ;,Ibidi:þ¡1486¡'ri í.¡:::i:'iíilReview.] On the structriÍe.of ,thëovule andfhe development ofthe.embryo-sac.i¡,V;iricetoxicum:r;ÌiOuiuwÈ*rÌo;

lished anonymously. 'i:.ì ,,

Samé reþrinted'with portrait of' TV'aúson:and with mentio¡ of authorfs name. ,Oainbridgti;ì Mass,¡

ll I'r.,

i , ..f r:I :, f,l ,jli r.i. l

Thê genus Aster. Jour. Royal Elort. Soc., London, vol. 15, pp.4-L2. .ì'r'i.1.[Review.] The localization of the perfumês óf flowêrs,*MæsrvlnDr..Am..Iour. Sci;; ser,3; vol.,,äõ, pl;355¡;li[Note.] Botanical prizes of the trTench Äcademy. Ibid. pp.355-356, ,iri: ' ..' .i,''ii .'Ì r: r,: ,. ,¡r:::,.ilRevibw.]"Howblanchedseedlingscanbesaved.,-Conwúi.'Ibid;p.356'.')'.::i;:,.::::i:;. 'Ìrrr,,,rir:.,.,, : - ...,''r":[Review']rnfluenceofiiroistúre.onvegêtation.-E;lG.¡rx;'.trbid;pp;;356-35?.[Réview.l Reports of the Missouri Botanica] Garden, Annual Report. Many contribuúions in volume üteni

tionedanddiscussed. Ibid.pp.525-526.... ': .-r. .i, . . ':";;il ',:.;'[Obituaryl: Een¡y E]iasSeatoir: 'rtrbid:'pp.526-527:,.: i:--','::r'.: .,il :r... r.::,.i;i rr:

:r. ìl:ir: ¡" rÌ"1 :

lVPruUúry.1' uvutJ su4ù.ÞÞ4UUu¡ :lu¡u¡ I,l,. ¿aV¿Áa,1

lReview.] Plants of Onzaba . Snlrow. .-;A,m:, Jouí;.: Sôi., ser. 3ilío1:'46¡p. 76. :!":.i,a.' ,

[ReviewJ Die natürlichen Pflanzenfamilien . E¡vcr,nn. trbid. pp. 76-77.lReview.] Rainfall and leaf-form Srenr,. Ibid. p. 77.[Review.] Turgescence and transpiration in fleshy plants, by Éeunnaa Aunnnr. Ibid. p. 77.

BIBLIOGRAPHY L5ÂcaDEur oF ScrE¡¡c¡slNo. úl

[Reviewl on the origin of endogcns from exogens.-Rev. Gponou Hnwgr,ow. Ibid. pp. zz_zg.[Rqview.] Amount of rv¿ter in the soil after a period of severe drought . . Rprepn.' r¡i¿.ìp. r5z-15g.[Review.] Nitriôcaüion . . . Dosén¡rN. Ibid. p. 15g.[Review.] The action of the pyocyanio bacillus on plants.-M. C¡rannrN. Ibid. pp. l5g-15g.lObituary.l Alphonse DeCandolle. Ibid. pp. 2g6-289.The Botanic Garden [including a report on the Botanical Museum]. Ann. Rep. of the president ar¡d Trea,sr¡rerof Harvard College, 1891-92, pp. 168-169. Carnbridge, Mass.

1894

?he Botanic Garden ancl Boüanical Museum. Harvard Grad. Mag., vol. B, pp. 2g4-285,The Botanic Garden a'd ùIuseum. Harr,¿rd G'ad. Mag., vol. n, pi.'Bg5_8g6.Address at the dedication of ùhe Mary Fra¡rces Searles'sciencá Building, Bowdoin College, Sepü. 20, lgg4.80, pp. 32. Brunswick, Maine.[Review.] Flor¿ of IVIou¡rt Deserü . Rl¡¡o ancl Rsprror,p. Am. Jour. sci., ser. B, vol. 4g, p. 4BL.llÙevierv.] Researches in regard to the respiration of the Muscineoe.-8. Jti¡¡ésoN. i¡iã. p.-iar.[Review.] on the consüiüuüion of the atmosphere.-T. L. p¡rrpsoN. Ibi<t. pp. 4gL-.4g2.lRevierv.] vegetable resources of rndia . . . Kew Bulletin. rbid. pp. 511-512.lReview.] Grafting.-M. Luc¡pv D¡¡¡¡n¡,. Ibid. pp. 512-51g.[Review.] Inflorescenoe in descripüivo boùany , . .- M. F. Hy. Ibid. p. 513.[Revierv.] Researches on the süructure and affinities of the Terebiniliaceae . Jeor¡q. Ibict. p. 5rB.The Botanic Garden [including a report of the Botanical Museum]. Ann. Rep. of the presideni arrcl Treaeure"of H¿rvard College, 1892-gB, pp. lg3-lg7. Cambridge, Mass. l

'l'lre Botanic Garden and lVluseum, I{orv¿rd Grad. Mag. vol. 4, pp. 247_24g.The New York Botanic Garden. Science, n. s., vol. 2,-pp, l_i,,-'

1895

Review.l Lehrbuch der Botonik.-Dr. Fne¡vr. Am.]àur. sci. ser. B, vol. 4g, p. 75.Review.l . Lehrbuch der lloüanik.-Dr. I(. G¡sspNr{ÄcEN. Ibid. p.76.Review.l Lehrbuch der Botanik.-Dr. F. p¡,x. Ibid. p.25.ßeviow.l Lehrbuch der Boüanik.:srnes¡unonR, Nor,r,, bcnorvr, scRrurnR. Ibicl. pp. 75_26.Revierv.l A student'g textbook of boüany; by svonor H. vrves. Ibid. pp. 26-z2.!.eview.! Practical physiology of plants; by Ft,lwcrs D¡,nrv¡v and E. H¡¡*¡¡r,roN AcroN. Ibid. p. ZZ.Reviorv.l A praeticol flora-for schools and colleges; by o. R. wrr,r,rs. Ibid. pp. zz-zg.Revierv.l Pfl¿nzen-Teratologie, systernaùisch géordnet. Dr. o. pn¡¡z¡c. Ibìã. p. zg.Revierv.l Pracùic¿l botany for beginners; by F. D. Bowon. Ibid. p. ?g.Review.l Mechanism of the movê,¡îents of the süamens of Berberìs.-Cs¡uvp¿u¡. Ibict. pp. 166-166.

The Harva¡d Boùanical lVluseum. Ibid. p. 166.[Review.] on the amount of absorption of .water by roots.-M. Lu cor,¡¡n. Ibid. p: 162.The Ware collection of Blasclìka glass models of plants ancl flowers in the Botanical i4useurn of Harvarcl Univer-siùy. Ibid.pp. 242-246.lReview.] Field, forest, and garden botony. By Asa Gnav, revised by L. H. B¿rr,py. Ibid. p. 825.[ReviewJ A popular üreatise on the physiology of plants . . . p,rvi Son^rupn. Tronslaùed- ry n. n. wp¡ss.Ibid. pp. 325-326.[Review,l Cellrrlose. An outline of the chemistry of the structural elements of planùs, with reference to theirn¡tural hietory ¿nd industrial uses; by C. F.. Cnoss, E. J. Bnven, and p. Ileiorp. '

Ibiá. ñ. 4gz-4gg.[Review.] An inüeresting method of dissemination.-DusÉ¡r. Ibid. p. nda.[Review.] Ausùralian narcotics . . . J. H. M¿¡opl¡. Ibict. p. 4gB.[Review.] Die natürlichen Pflanzenfamilien. Eucr,pn. Am. Jour. sci, ser,. B, vol. 50, p. zg.[Review.] Familiar florvers or !9!a and garden, by F. scnorr,nn M¿rspwg. nia. p. fa.[Review'] Synoptical {1".? or North America; by Ase Gner and Spnp¡¡o Wamórv, couúinued a¡d edited byB. L. Ros¡ìrsoN. Ibid. pp. 4ZB-429.[Review.] Another example of chalazogamy.-Dr. s. N¡wlscs¡N. rbid. p. 42g.lReview.] The Misgouri Botanical Garden. sixth annual Report. rbid. pp. 502-50g.[Review.] fndex Kewensis. Ibid. p.50g.The Boù¿nic Garden [including a report on the Botanical Museurn]. Ann. Rep. of the presidont ¿nd Treasi¡rer

of Horvarcl College, 1898-94, pp. 188-1g?. Cambridge, Mass.

r896

Ths Botanicol G¿rden and Museum. H¿rvard Grad. Mag., vol. õ, pp. 2g6-2g2.Agricultural problems in plant physiology. Jour. Roya-l'Agric.'Sôc., ser. B, vol. Z, pp. 851-86g. London.Pleioùaxy in the androecium of Epidendrum cochleaüum, L. Ám. Jour. sci. ser. 4, vot.' t, p, zz.[Review.] Planü breeding. Being five lectures on the amelioration of domesüic ptat tr; uy f,. ¡1. B¡r¡,¡cy.

.Am, Jour. Sci, ser. 4, vol, l, p. 151.

16 GEORGE T,INCOI.,N GOODALE-ROBINSON

lBeview.l Tubercles on the roots of the soja bean . I(¡ncn¡qpn. Ibid' pp. 151-1õ2.

[Review.] Modifications of the cell-wall . V¡u Wrssn¡,r¡or¡ . . Me¡¡c¡¡t. Ibid. p. 152. .[Review.l On the accumulation of sugar in the root of the beet.-L. Mteup¡rnp. Ibid. 1õ2-1õ8.

[Review.] Propagation of the sugar-cane . . . J' H. W¡rxon. Ibid. p. 824.

[Review.] Lehrbuch der ökologischen Pflanzen-geographie . . . Eusp¡r W¿ru¡¡¡ls. Am. Jou¡. Soi. ser. 4,vol. 2, p.89.

lReview.] Missouri Bot¿nical Garden. Seventh Annual Report. Ibid. p.89.[Review.] The Botanical Gazette. Ibid. p. 396.

fReview.] The dualistic theory of descer¡t . . . S¿c¡¡s. Ibid. pp. 396-397.

[Review.] The timber pines of the southern United Staùes; by Cnenr,ns Mosn. Ibid. pp. 463-464.

[Review.] Richards on increase of activity in respiration after injury . . . Prprrsn. Ibid' p. 464.

[Obituary.] Baron Ferdinand von Mueller, K. C. M. G., Government Boü¿nist of Victoria. Am. Jour. Sci.ser. 4, vol. 2rp,464,

The Botanic Garden [including a report on the Botanical Mueeum]. Ann. Rep. of the President and Treasurerof Harvard College, 189{t-95, pp. 194-199. Cambridge, Mass.

1897

Bot¿nical Garden and Museum. Harvard Grad. Mag. vol. 6, pp. 237-238.

[Letter.] trYom Prof. George L. Goodale. [Presented at a memorial meeting for M¡. Thomas Tlacy Bouvé.]Proc. Boston Soc. Nat. Hisú. vol. 27,p,241,

lfieview.] An illusürated flora of the northern United States, Canada, and the British possessions from New-foundland to the parallel of the souúhern boundary of Virginia, and from the Atlantic ocean wests'ard to the102d meridian; by Nerne¡q¡s¡, Lono Bnrrro¡¡ . . . Aoo¡go¡r Bnow¡¡. Am. Jour. Sci. ser. 4, vol. 3' pp.76-77.

[Review.] Notes on the flora of Newfoundland; by B. L. Ro¡¡Nsou. Ibid. p. 77.

lReview.] The survival of the unlike. A collection of evolution esseys suggesüed by the study of domesticplonts; by L. H. B,r¡r,pv. Ibid. p.77.

[Review.] A. manual and dictionary of the flowering plants and ferns; by J. C. W¡¡,¡,¡s. Ibid. p' 353.

l$eview.] A practical botcny for beginners. [Notice of this and five other works by the following authors'JF. O. Bowsn, Vor,xor M. Sp¡r,o¡¡¡s, FneNcrs DenwrN, J. Y. Bnnonñ, WIr,r,tltrl A. Snrcnnr,r,, Tno¡r¡¡.s H.M¡cBnros. Ibid. pp. 490-491.

[Review.] Professor Van Tieghem's new systæm of classiûcation of Phænogamia. Am. Jour. Sci. ser. 4, vol. 4,

pp.7S-82.[Review.] The new series of Contributions from the Gray llerbarium of Ilarvard University, No. Xf, by Mn.

Gnpnr¡¡¡r¡r. Ibid, p. 249.

[Review.] Synoptical Flora of North Amerioø, Vol. 1, Parü f, Fascicle IL . Ae,t Gn,tx . . . Bpr¡¡¡¡¡rxLr¡¡cor,xRo¡¡¡¡gor¡... TÍ¡r,¡,r¡¡¡Tnp¡,segs. .. JorvM.Cou¡,rnn ..'r. L.H.B,r¡¡,n¡. Ibid'p.249.

lfteview.] An illustrated flora of the norùhern Uniùed States, Canada, and ùhe British possessions . . . N¡-1[EANrEr/ Lonp BnrtroN . . Aoo¡goN Bnorv¡¡. Ibid. p. 250.

lReview] Experimental morphology; by C. B. D,rvp¡¡ronæ. Ibid. p. 397.

lReview.] Descriptive cataloguo of useful ûber plonts of the world, including the structur¿l and economic

claseifications of ûbres; by Cnenr,rs R¡cs¡nos Doocp. Ibid. pp. 478-475,The Botanic Garden [including a. report on the Botanical Museum]. Ann. Rep. of the Presidenü and Treasurer

of Harvard College, 1895-96. pp. 20G-208. Cambridge, Mass.

Ttopical horticulture, with illusùratioo, oftn" n"r".r:::tu"ono-r. plants of hot climates. Trans. Masg. Hort.Soc. for 1897, pp. 13-19.

lReview.] Synoptical view of the various divisions of Embryophyta siphonogama; by A. Er.ro¡,pn. Am. Jour.Sci. ser.4, vol. 5, p. 156.

[Review.] Pflanzenphysiologie. Ein Handbuch der Iæhre vom Stoffwechsel und Kraftwechsel in der Pflanze;von Dn. W. Pnprrpn. Ibid. pp. 317-318.

[Review.] Permeability of úhe bark of tree-trunks to atmospheric gases. M. Hpl¡nr Dov.rux. Ibid. p. 318

lReview.] W¡r,rpn Gano¡r.¡pn . . Structure of the cell wall. Ibid. pp. 470-47L.

[Review.] The phytogeography of Nebraska: I. General survey; by R. PouNo. Ibid. p.471.[Review.] Text-book of botany; by Drs. Srnlg¡unoon, ScuIuron, No¡,r, and Scsn¡¡r. Ibid. pp. 471-472.

lReview.] Fossil plants: for students of botany and geology; by A. C. Spv.rno. Ibid. p.472.[Review.] Contribuüions to Japanese Characeae; by T. F. Ar,¡p¡¡. Ibid. p. 472.

The Botanic Garden [including a report on the Boùanical Museum]. Ann. Rep. of the Presidont and Trea¡urerof Harvard College, 1896-97, pp,2Lt-214. Cambridge, Mass.

[MEùrorRs N¡trox¡¡[Voú. XXI,

å,CADEMY oF Scr¡Ncrslñól6r- , :;: . :,-BIP.I-¡.. IQG.IiAI.EY,'; ï,;_ i1:,,.r ::l i

British and colonial army surgeons on the 19th 9i Aæ.if fl75. . Anaddrebþ defiveréa ontneldtå'*Áprilijissgbefore the Middleséx South DistrictliMedicit So": 'Pù¡UShed:'at the reiiuest of .thê'sciciety,;Cambfidge;

. Mass. -i:1:: í ":._:,: -.i,.1.: .:.1¡. .::.- '',. i:, .r¡:¡i:ij:,1¡i

got"Jíca¡¿en and'Bôtàiil¿at Museum.t'Harv:tGiad; 'Mägi'voi. 7,i pp: 419'420. 'r'r¡';'rr:: Ì '' :i::'ri '' :'r:r 'ir':ir :'' ':

[Review.] The poisonous effect exerted on living plants by phenols: t:. ' r]Rr1H. tnue; ,Adi.'Joúr. Sci: ser. 4,vol. ?, pp. 76-?7.

tReview;J ,,On the pecutiar iúode òf fonäation of .pollen4þains irÍ,,Magnoli¿e: . :. . Gurc¡r¡n¡. -.fbid:,Þ:ì77. ; ;

lReview.] Elements de botanique. P. v¡.¡¡ Trbeu¡¡¡,,,'Ibid. ftÈj"7?-78::i' i":.i':':.''¡:"', ,: i ..::'

[Review.] Die nattirlichen Pflanzenfamilien . . Ervcr,¡n. Ibid' p. 169.

[Review.] Experimental morphology, Part II; by C. B.'DevrÌNPoRr. Ibid. p. 474.

[Revíèwj] , Yrariations under,grafting;and thèr heredit¡rrof astr¡r,ed,pbaiact€ts;,by. L. D¡Nrp¿. 'rA¡o. J,our,,.Sgi;

ser. 4, vol. 8, pp. 8tl-85. .i';. ":i.[,Revie¡u:l .:Reseafches':coûccirniûg.-,eqtain. featur.esi io the.:appropnation'of 'nitrggen :byr,pJa¡ts.;:'þy 'L1,I's:0z:

Ibid. pp. 85-86. I.i:r. . :.: : ' j. -:r" r' .' .,',': .;,'. .¡;, it. -'- ¡.:: :-

.The,Botanic.r.Gárden,,.lincluding. â: re.p]crt, on lhe'Bo-tanica], Museuml, ; .Ann; rR.ep, ,of ..,the P¡-esidenti.qûd .the

Dêasurer of.Ilarvai'd,.Collegè, 1897t98.;'pp.; 23bZAí . Çambnidge; Mass,,:

New England plants seen by the earliest colonists. [R€åd 15 Jan..ii896'l;: T¡án¡:'.r'Colotidl'Soc',,:Mâ^ssi Vol. 3,

{HiSie¡ih,rks,on;thãdeath,of A.:Gould.l',Reãd.Dèor,1800.1, 'mi¿.;¡9pl',30e-307.,ì i,¡,;;-'rr,,: .ì';.i¡ ,.':'",: "ri:,

[Remarks on the death of General Walkêr.' Read'øt iíeeting<if :Jatdaiy., 1897.] ' Ibid. p.'315.' ;p :;¡ 1¡1.¡.:.;i

¡nevie#rì,''P¡dxis ùnd'Theorie der'Zellen:-tind'BèfruclitungJlehie.','l;':,r'!.:[46i16n.,"'Arn.',Jôur.'Sci.,ser.4,vol. 9, PP. ?7-78. ;' ::';:' .' : I .'

[Review.] The Missouri Botanical Garden. Ibid. p. 233.The Botanic Garden lincluding a reporù on the Botàltcal Museum]. Ann. Rep. of the President and the

Treasurer of llarvard College,,,l898:99r.pp..238-243;,.',Oapbridge,'Masd.,:,..,j.,::. .i.':;:.:: ..'1::,;,:. :,,;i.. i,: :

.1":',' .r i .'i: ri .:.','; ::.,,.'.. -;1 .ì- ,...:: . ::;"1:. : "-1901 '':' '

"'

¡tt'-¡1

The Botanical Department. Ilarvard Grad. Mag. vol. 10, pp. 254-255.

'the,méihòùâl þeênhouses at túê'Harïard':Botanic"Gâiâèdri:r:A'in: Joúr.'Sci. ser: 4, vol. 13, p, tp2.[Brief note on] The Botanisches Cent-¡alblatt. Ibid. p. 327. ' I

iReview.l The Galaþâgosifslánds-:"Ìmp'ofiaät'pap""; by Di. Robjpson, ilèäIing'with'thêir'þeóúlilâì "t¿"tàtiOi¡[Ulsigned.]-.NewYorkEierúng,Pòst,Dec.6,r902.,.:

[Rdviéw.]'rReseârchés on'cellulósé, 1895-1900; by C; F. Cnosd and'E. J. Bpve¡r. Am. Jour. 9¡gi.,,t"1i,,4,'oôL

'tn"-n¡tâñi" Gardéri lücludi-ns a reþort on thè Bãtatücát"Mú'ééù-1.' Ann- Rép: of''ihë'Piésident and tieTreasurerof HarvardCollege, 1900-01, pp.225-230. Cambridge, Mass¡ r' "'; : i'.' :I .ri'rj' :'r'

ì ^,::. .. . . ,....j .. ._,.: ...: : ì,i : ..;..,.. i

__:l::,'.;1..-r .lr:._ r: ,ai.' .:.' :'j. - ,"1 .i ,. : ,

An experimental garden in Cuba. Am. Jou¡. Sci. sèr. 4, voi. 16, pp. 105-106.The Botanic Garden [including a report on the Botanical Museum]. Ann. Rep. of the President and the

îreasurer of l[arvard College, 1901-02, pp..,242-2.46. , C1+b;1dS!1 Ma¡s. :, . 1 .:_.,.

; .. . ] . ,.i\ Ì i -i \ 1. .,i j .

Ila¡vard Experiment Station in Cuba, Ám. Jour. Sci. ser. 4, vol. 18, pp. 91-95.

.fl.e B¡tq,nic,Çardg¡ þçluding a ¡ep9rt gn."th9,þ9!agiqa,f,,\Iuqp¡¡nl, ,A"pp, Rep, of t.h9,P¡.es.idgqt aad.theTreasùiei of Elarvard College, 1902-03, pp.22t-229. Cambridge, Mass. , -,^ .,.,.:. ., - i: ,

' t,:::,;':l: i"''

i1906

.[Review.],'Themicroscop¡,of íegotabieìfoods;-rithspêcialrefei:enceto,the,deüeclion,of '¿dulterationjald.:thediagnosis of mixtures; by Arvonnw L. 'Wrnro¡r. Am. Jour. Sci. ser. 4, vol. 21, pp. 335-336.

À new fãrm of "container" for use in museumg of econbmic botany. Ibid. pp. 451-452.NotesfromtheHarvardBotanicalStatiqui.njCuba.:-:Ib-idr¿pp..475_470. :,r1 ,,:, i¡..r-j ,;.:::J. .

.LT

t.-It,'ì'I

i't,

t;i'

ì,iil\.

I

I

I.

I

i:l.I

i

It,l

[Review.] Plant response as a means of physiologicât iivestigation; by J¿eÄDrs Csu¡¡opn Bos¡. Ibid. pp.

Pl¡qte¡-plaques for museums¡ ..,AIn', Jour. Sci. ser. 4, vol,22, pp. 90--92.Ileatheiin Townsend, Mass: 'Íbia. p. 19ó.""' ) :rr:'" r ' "" :"-

The Botanic Garden tinlt^ujyn-g a,reporü,op thg Bolqnic. Mggeu.-ml. . Ren.,,9l.!,hg Þesi{gn! agd tþ Ïteaq"i"-t,9{.. Earvard Collgge, 1904-O5r pp;,24I-145-..,,,,,.

1902,, , . .,., ..,, ,., ,,,,,,.,.: .

, ,.,,

,r, j

The Botanic.Ga¡dQn lincluding a repeft on the'Botanica!,Museur!'!]., ,,Rep: of, the,-P¡esident and the Troasgrerof Harvard College, 1905-06,ppi'?30+23.4. .:Ca,mb¡idge,.Mpss¡,. .;. .:: ,,:: , ...: ..,:r , ,.,:r.:

18 GEORGE LINCOI,N :cooo*ræ-RoBINSoN i.] tMEMôìEdt$IoÀq-ffi

:i .. :- ,f9q8

[RtiviewJ ..îhe microsaopy,of technical products;',by,Dx. T., F.lH*u¡usnr. 'Au.'Jour. Sci, sei. 4; voft 25;pii;g7_gg. -.rr.r . ):. .:,j;.,,. 1,.. " .:..;.,

lReview;] , Gra¡¡'s lrlew'Ma,nu¿ilof Botáiy ,¡r¡',.; .Bnw¡Àurw. Lr¡vco¡Ñ Rò¡r¡¡soN,'{ind-Munnrrî:þy¡¡¡'1¡* Funlr*lóiThe Nation, vol. 87, p. 366. [Unsigned.] : .. : .) : ì'

[Êåview.] ,,.Girty'È New-manuiìl 6f, þef,¿¡y;i:.:$lhandbook of the flowering.plantó::aúd ferns'of;fhe:'ee¡tíãl .aädnortheastern United States'aiqd Caiáda-:. .' . Rèvigiid: by,Buñreuiñ .Lrrvcor,N'RosrñbctN and,.MríÈn¡rrLy¡rpo¡s Fnnv¡r,o. A.m. Jou¡. Sci. ser. 4, vol. 26, pp. 518-519.

[Review.] Systematic anatomy of the Dicotyledons. ' A'handbook for laboratories of pure and applied botany.

[Review.] A text-book of botany and pha,rmacognosy; by llnr'rnv Kn¡n¡¿on. Ibid. pp.,58G-l8[ . . :.:[Review.] Die Gestalts-und Lagever'änderlrng,der: P4a¡zçq:Cbro4atophoren; miteiner Bejlage; DiqLìght-

brechung der,lebe¡deqiPqawe+4eJle;ì:v,op.:GggîÀv,.Snlrv.,r,¡lbid..,p¡,587. :.. :- . -. .:i,:.r, ,:,r ::r: ;, r:..,.:.i,.:lThe,Botanic

'Garden [including; a repprt pn thrc.tsota¡ical.:Museum].,. ,ReÞ. of the F¡esiden-t apd. the Treasurefof fla¡vard College, 1906-07, pp,227-230. Cambridge, Mass. . . .: .,. ., i.; ,

The Harvard Botanical StatÍon in Cûba;' :Am. Jirur.iSci.jbeii..4¡.vdl::27;:¡ip.9rt-.96; . ,,: ':.'i: :^,r -',: ,

A convenient clearing and mounting reagent. Ibid. p. 96.[Review.] Handbuch der Blüten-biologie . . . P¡,ur, Kwurs. T¡anslated by J. R. A¡¡rswonrs D¿v¡s.

T[e: sotáiii¿;t "tViuseum:Cambridge, Mass.

Ibid.

lReview.] Jaarboek van het Department van Landb¡rüw in Niederlandsch-Indie, 1g07. Ibid. p. 192.[Review.] l-{.gfte,oi 1þ9!i+t¡t,e,tþ. Amazon¡and,Apdeg.r,., ,.;,&¡cg4nn, p.r-&g9-8.,. ....,..,,4:,p¡p9 B.u,gs.u-r,,.IÍ,¿¡

r,.A.cE. Ibid.'pp.266-267' -..;,.,.ì .:.t..,; :.: ,:r.1.1:j¡._:f 1 ;,.r.,:...,-,,1, i.r....r.1.l:,::_,,i.r.:i j.r:.:.:iì

[.Revigw,.,] !þ1,-C,op*9.cia]æe9d¡19!F, ofil-,+qig,.;i,by,:Srn Gponcr 'W'-err. .Ibi4.,ipp.,4ry1i18:-,,.ì ,.,i,t r -; ,¡.,.:ij::

lReview.] The forest flora of New South Wales; by_Jrl[.¡ M-*rppñ.,,.J.Þ!d^r,q..,:tl8.., , ì,' :.i. i ..,,,,._ , i

IFç"fy:l Tr99l,.I he+dbook of forest bo-tany {g¡"thewoodlan{s,.qn{¡1he.iabolqtory. U. Mansgü1, Wa4o,.Ibid. p. 491.

lRevierr.l Mendel's Principles 9f:bS^q9$tyj..by.;S. Qerpgor+,, ,Ib!$. pÞ: 4gL-\Qz¡ g¡{ CgL 2g, pp, br85. . .:..lRpvæW.J.,,Conlributfons f91_tne Gy_¡ Eerbqr.iu-m,9f.Ea¡vardU9-iyerqity,, .- ...,,[0.u *ort g{çè¡eratauthgqåì

Am.Jour.Sci'ser.4,vol'28,p.''8Þ....'''':[Review.] Elemente der exakten Erblichkeitslehre . . . w'. Jos¡-¡rxsnN. rbid. pp. ss-ó0.The Botanic Garden [including a report on the Botanicdl Museum.] Rep. of the President and the Tieasurer

p.96. ...,.:. ..,','. ,,.1,. rr: i.:: .....::.:," .:r;.:::rì t.,..-. ,: ., .)::-:lReview.] The forest flor¿ of New South Wales; by J. H. M¡rop¡r. Ibid. pp. 191-192.

of llarva¡d College, 1907-08,.pp, 737-241..,

C,.13b¡ids,3, Mass,

[Thesameforthefollowingyear.] Ibid. 190¡i:ô9i,,'pp.'lai:rìzs:t:"i ''' r.": '. 'r '' :: '" :':: : ' ': ;ì:'r:.[Review.] Physiologische Pflanzen-anatomie. . . . G. II*nnRrrÀNDT. Am. Jour. Sci. ser. 4, vol. 2g, pp. 195-196.

,,::,,:r. .,, ,r.. .t:,-; -,. -.;191.1:. ..rit¡ . ,.-ì. ; ; . : :. . :.;.:",: t....: :...:ì.:i.t.r.....,,¡;-:.,j.

Rep: of 'th,p Prep.id. agd !gq, T,teâsurú of-E-'aryard cq-Ilegôi lo09-r0r þp. lggirg4.L9t2

[The same for the following year.] Ibid. 1910-1911, pp. 185-186.Biographical memoire of Alexander Agassiz, 183F-1910...:Biógr, Memi,Natl ,Acad.,Sci.-vôl. Z;,pp;:ZSS-Cdd,

with portrait.1918

'The Botanical'Mriserin.: ReÞ.:of,:the,.Preside¡rt and:t:hq Trêasure¡,of .Ea¡vard Collegq, Tgl]*lzr,pp.'.18I:188."

.ii: . r ,,.. ,:,.._ .j'.:-: r,: i: _t " :ì.:. _

:ll,-

.1..,.. .. ..:.:. .... ì. , ,,1914., :.:., ..:,; ",,:., , .i... .. ... ....:,.; :.

[Thesamefortheacade-icyear1912-13j] Ibidl,.tr912!13,pp. 187-188.. r.1 :.i .. ::. , ,

.A.caDmMY os ScIENcDslNo.6l

[The same for the academic year 1920-21.]

[The same for the academic year l92l-22.7

BIBI,IOGRAPHY

1915

19

[The same for the academic year 1913-14.] 1913-14, pp. 198-200.The W'are Collection of Blaschka Glass-models of plants in flower. Cover [2], pp. 1-10. Cambridge, Mass.

IUnsigned.]1916

The Botanical Museum.Cambridge, Mass.

Rep. of the President and the Treasurer of Earvard College, 19141-15' pp. 218-216.

1917

[The same for the academic year 1915-16.] Ibid. 1915-16' pp.217-219.

1918

[The same for the academic year 1916-17.] Ibid. 1916-17' pp. 205-206.

The development of botany as sho\rn in this Journal [Development of botany since 1818.] Am. Jour. Sci. ser.

4, vol. 46, pp. 399-416'1919

The Botanical Museum. Rep. of the President and the Treasurer of Ilarv¿¡d College, 1917-L8, pp. 205-208.

1920

[The same foi the academic year 1918-19.] Ibid. 1918-19, pp. 162-163.The Ware collection of Blaschk¿ glass-models of plants in flower. Published by the Botanical Museum [of

Ilarvard Univ.l for gratuitous distribution. Cover., pp. [2] 1-11. [A later and slightly altered edition ofthe pamphlet issued in 1915.1

t92t

The Botanical Museum'Cambridge, Mass.

Rep. of the President and the Treasurer of Harvard College, 1919-20' pp. 205-207.

ls22

Ibid. 1920-21, pp. 242-243.

1923

Ibid. l92l-22, pp. 188-190.

BIOGR.APEICAL ÂND OBITUAR,Y NOÎICES CONCERNING DR,. G[OOD,A,I,E

1891

Sketch of George Lincoln Goodale. Popular Sci. Montbly, Sept. 1891, vol. 39, portrait and pp. 691-694.

lunsigned.l 1g2B

Prof. George L. Goodale dead. [Obituary.] Boston Evening Transcript, Apr. 12' 1923.

[Obituary notice.] Cambridge Chronicle, Apr. 14, 1923'

Professor George Lincoln Goodale. [Obituary notice.] Ifarvard Univ. Gazette, vol. 18, p. 146, Apr. 14, 1923.

M. D.'63. George Lincoln Goodale. [Unsigned obituary.] Ilarvard Alumni Bull. vol. 25,p.277, Apr.26,1923.

George Lincóln Goodale. lNote of his death.] Am. Jour. Sci. ser' 5, vol. 5, p. 524, June, 1923.

George Lincoln Goodale. [Obi(uary by W'rr,lrau Tnnr,¡,lse. Science, vol.57, pp.654-656, June 8, 1923.

Minute on the life and services of Professor George Lincoln Goodale. W. J. V. Osrnnuour, B. L. Ronrwso¡rand M. L. Fonrv¿r,o. Ilarvard Univ. Gazette, vol. 18, p. 198, June 16, 1923.

George Lincoln Goodale, lObituary,] Reprinted from the preceding. Am. Jour. Sci. ser, 5, vol. 6, pp.276-276.

George Lincoln Goodale. lObituary by] L. H. B¡r¡,py. Rhodora, vol. 25, portrait and pp. ll7-120. Aug.28,1923.

George Lincoln Goodale. [Obituary by] Ro¡onr Tn¿ct J¿crso¡{. I[arvard Grad. Mag. vol.32, portrait andpp.54-59. Sept. 1923.