27
!"#$%" ’(" ")*+%$),")’ -$.%’ +) ’(" ,/’’"% $# "#$ %$&’()*$ +,-,.$/$-" 0*" 1221 /)0 +) ’(" ,/’’"% $# ,- 033$,4 (-5$) &$*"6’- 178 ’9 "#$ 0*" !"’1"") %$-( 2/’%+-3 4.55+*/) /667889:; /)0 -")’%/5 $’/<$ 0+4’%+-’ -$.)-+5 #=>?; %7?6@:A7:; /)0 $’/<$ %"<+$)/5 -$.)-+5 47B@:A %7?6@:A7:; /)0 ,"%+0+/) ")"%<C 5+,+’"0 /668=B9:; 4’/’",")’ $# "*+0")-" $# !%C/) 1+55+/, 5"C5/)0 $) !"(/5# $# %$-( 2/’%+-3 4.55+*/) "

National Wind Watch · 2011. 4. 8. · Exhibit 5 Carbon tax Calcs Lignite Coal Gas CCGT Annual generation 2357 2357 2357 GWh CO2 from thermal station 1.00 0.75 0.365 kg/kWh ! %!

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • !"#$%"&'("&")*+%$),")'&-$.%'&!

    +)&'("&,/''"%&$#! "#$!%$&'()*$!+,-,.$/$-"!0*"!1221!

    /)0&

    +)&'("&,/''"%&$#&! ,-!033$,4!(-5$)!&$*"6'-!178!'9!"#$!0*"!

    !

    !"'1"")! %$-(&2/'%+-3&4.55+*/)!

    ! /667889:;&!/)0! -")'%/5&$'/?;&%7?6@:A7:;!!/)0! $'/

  • DEF& GH98=I=B9;=@:?&9:A&"J67>=7:B7&&

    1:1! +;! 9(44! -,/$! 6&! $;4,-5:! ! ?-"64! @(-$! 788A! B! C,&! ,!

    D)6-*63,4! '9! E6-*4,6)! F-6.#"! +$)GH! ,! /(4"6I56&*6346-,);! $-.6-$$)6-.!

    *'-&(4",-*;! J,&$5! 6-! 0(*K4,-5:! ! B! #'45! "#$! L(,4696*,"6'-! '9! +,&"$)! '9!

    E*6$-*$!MD'C$)!E;&"$/!N$&6.-OH!,-5!B!,/!,!P$44'C!'9!"#$!B-&"6"("6'-!'9!

    Q4$*")6*,4! Q-.6-$$)&! M?:FOH! ,! P$44'C! '9! "#$! B-&"6"("6'-! '9! +$*#,-6*,4!

    Q-.6-$$)&! M?:FOH! ,! P$44'C! '9! "#$! B-&"6"("6'-! '9! D)'9$&&6'-,4! Q-.6-$$)&!

    MR:SOH!B!C,&!,C,)5$5!"#$!B-&"6"("6'-!'9!D)'9$&&6'-,4!Q-.6-$$)&!TE(3)$/$!

    U$*#-6*,4! 0C,)5V! 6-! 788WH! "#$! BDQRS! TX'//(-6*,"')! '9! "#$! ;$,)V! 6-!

    7881!,-5!"#$!B-&"6"("6'-!'9!Q4$*")6*,4!Q-.6-$$)&!E64Y$)!+$5,4! 6-!788W:!! B!

    C,&!,C,)5$5!"#$!Q4$*")6*6";!Q-.6-$$)&!0&&'*6,"6'-!T+$)6"')6'(&!E$)Y6*$!

    0C,)5V! 6-! 788Z! ,-5! C,&! /,5$! ,-! ['-'),);! >69$! +$/J$)! '9! "#$!

    0&&'*6,"6'-! 6-! 788W:! B! C,&! ,!N6)$*"')! '9! \$*"')! >6/6"$5! MR$C!S$,4,-5!

    4,).$&"!Q4$*")6*6";!N6&")6J("6'-!X'/3,-;O!9)'/!788A!I!788WH!!

    1:7! B!,/!,!+$/J$)!'9!"#$!X'//'-!](,46";!05Y6&');!^)'(3!'9!"#$!Q4$*")6*6";!

    X'//6&&6'-:!!U#6&!.)'(3!,5Y6&$&!"#$!Q4$*")6*6";!X'//6&&6'-!'-!9,*"')&!

    ,99$*"6-.! "#$!'3$),"6'-!'9! "#$!R$C!S$,4,-5!3'C$)! &;&"$/:! !U#$!.)'(3!

    #,&! ,! &3$*6,4! 6-"$)$&"! 6-! "#$! $99$*"! '9! 6-"$)/6""$-"! .$-$),"6'-! &(*#! ,&!

    C6-53'C$)!'-!"#$!'3$),"6'-!'9!"#$!R$C!S$,4,-5!3'C$)!&;&"$/:!

    1:A! B!C,&!,!/$/J$)!'9!,-!B-"$)-,"6'-,4!D,-$4!'9!Q_3$)"&!C#6*#!C,&!9')/$5!

    "'!65$-"69;H! 6-Y$&"6.,"$!,-5!&'4Y$!/,`')!$-.6-$$)6-.!3)'J4$/&!,"!,!7888!

    +=!#;5)'$4$*")6*!3'C$)!&","6'-!6-!B),-:!!

    1:Z! B!,/!,!/$/J$)!'9!"#$!Q_3$)"!05Y6&');!^)'(3!9')!"#$!W288!+=!F,43,&,)!

    "65,4!3'C$)!&*#$/$!-')"#!'9!+(/J,6! 6-! B-56,:! ! B9! "#6&!&*#$/$!6&!J(64"H! 6"!

    C644! J$! ,J'("! 1W! "6/$&! 4,).$)! "#,-! "#$! 4,).$&"! "65,4! 3'C$)! &*#$/$! 6-!

    '3$),"6'-:!

    1:W! !B! #,Y$! #,5! ,-! ,*"6Y$! 6-"$)$&"! 6-!C6-53'C$)! &6-*$! ,J'("! 12a8H!C#$-! B!

    #$43$5! C6"#! "#$! /$*#,-6*,4! ,-5! $4$*")6*,4! ,&3$*"&! '9! *'&"6-.! ,! 4,).$!

    C6-5! 9,)/! (&6-.! Y$)"6*,4! ,_6&!C6-5! "()J6-$&:! B! #,Y$! )$,5!C65$4;! '-! "#$!

    &(J`$*"!,-5!B!#,Y$!,! 4,).$!5,",J,&$!'9!,)"6*4$&!5$&*)6J6-.!"#$!*'&"!,-5!

    ! #!

  • 3$)9')/,-*$!'9!$_6&"6-.!C6-5!9,)/&!,-5!"#$6)!$99$*"&!'-!"#$!'3$),"6'-!'9!

    "#$!3'C$)!&;&"$/:!

    1:b! B! C,&! ,! /$/J$)! '9! ,! .)'(3! *,44$5! "'.$"#$)! J;! "#$! R$C! S$,4,-5!

    .'Y$)-/$-"!"'!.6Y$!,5Y6*$!)$.,)56-.!"#$!788A!$4$*")6*6";!')",.$:!!

    1:c! B!3)'Y65$5!,5Y6*$! "'!+$)656,-!Q-$).;!'-! "#$!'3"6'-&! 9')!*'--$*"6-.! "#$!

    3)'3'&$5!D)'`$*"!0L(,!#;5)'3'C$)!&*#$/$!"'!"#$!"),-&/6&&6'-!&;&"$/:!

    B! C,&! ,J4$! "'! 3)'3'&$! ,4"$)-,"6Y$&! "#,"! C'(45! #,Y$! )$&(4"$5! 6-! ,!

    *'-&65$),J4$!*'&"!)$5(*"6'-:!

    1:a! d-!&$Y$),4!'**,&6'-&H! B!#,Y$!,33$,)$5!,&!,-!$_3$)"!C6"-$&&!)$.,)56-.!

    "#$! &","$! '9! "#$! R$C! S$,4,-5! 3'C$)! &;&"$/H! "#$! -$$5! 9')! ,556"6'-,4!

    .$-$),"6-.!*,3,*6";!,-5! "),-&/6&&6'-! 46-$&!,-5!'"#$)!,&3$*"&!'9!3'C$)!

    &(334;!,-5!56&")6J("6'-!6-!R$C!S$,4,-5:!

    1:a! +;!3,)"6*(4,)! $_3$)"6&$! 6&! ,&! ,-!Q4$*")6*,4! ,-5!+$*#,-6*,4!Q-.6-$$)! 6-!

    3'C$)! &;&"$/! '3$),"6'-! ,-5! '3"6/6&,"6'-H! "),-&/6&&6'-! &;&"$/&H!

    56&")6J("$5!.$-$),"6'-H! #;5)'3'C$)! .$-$),"6'-H! "#$)/,4! 3'C$)! &","6'-&H!

    *'.$-$),"6'-H!,-5!3'C$)!&;&"$/!5$&6.-!,-5!3)'"$*"6'-:!!P)'/!1227!(-"64!

    788A! B! C,&! )$&3'-&6J4$! 9')! J6,--(,4! )$Y6$C&! '9! $4$*")6*6";! &(334;! ,-5!

    5$/,-5! 6-!R$C!S$,4,-5:! ! U#'&$! 5'*(/$-"&! ,)$! &"644! "#$! '-4;! 3(J46*4;!

    ,Y,64,J4$!*'/3)$#$-&6Y$!,-5!6-5$3$-5$-"!)$Y6$C:!

    1:2! dY$)! "#$! 4,&"! 969"$$-! ;$,)&! B! #,Y$! /,5$! /,-;! 3)$&$-","6'-&! ,"!

    *'-9$)$-*$&! ,-5! B! #,Y$! C)6""$-! ,)"6*4$&! 9')! -$C&3,3$)&! '-! 3'C$)!

    34,--6-.H!"#$!3)'J4$/&!9,*$5!J;!"#$!R$C!S$,4,-5!$4$*")6*6";!&;&"$/H!"#$!

    )6&K!'9!')",.$&!)$&(4"6-.! 9)'/!6-&(996*6$-"!.$-$),"6-.!*,3,*6";!,-5! "#$!

    )6&K!'9!J4,*K'("&!)$&(4"6-.!9)'/!,-!'Y$)4',5$5!"),-&/6&&6'-!&;&"$/:!!d-!

    /,-;!'**,&6'-&! B!#,Y$!J$$-! 6-"$)Y6$C$5! 9')! ),56'!,-5! "$4$Y6&6'-!-$C&!

    3)'.),//$&!'-!"#$&$!&(J`$*"&:!

    1:18! B! C,&! )$&3'-&6J4$! 9')! "#$! 'Y$),44! *'-*$3"! ,-5! 9')! "#$! 5$",64$5! 5$&6.-H!

    3)'*()$/$-"!,-5!*'//6&&6'-6-.!'9!/$*#,-6*,4!,-5!$4$*")6*,4!$L(63/$-"!

    9')! ,! ,! 2A8! K=! &/,44! #;5)'3'C$)! &*#$/$! 6-! ^'45$-!

  • ,)$#'45$)&!6-!"#$!&*#$/$:!d3$),"6-.!"#$!&","6'-!)$L(6)$&!"#,"!B!/'-6"')!

    $4$*")6*6";! 3)6*$&!,-5!$4$*")6*6";! 5$/,-5&!'-!,!/')$! "#,-!5,64;! J,&6&:! B!

    ,/H! "#$)$9')$H! Y$);! 9,/646,)! C6"#! "#$! 3)6*$! &36K$&! "#,"! ,33$,)! '-! "#$!

    &;&"$/!C#$-!#;5)'3'C$)!&"'),.$!4,K$!4$Y$4&!,)$!4'C!')!C#$-!"#$)$!,)$!

    3)'J4$/&!'-!"#$!&;&"$/:!

    KEF& ":L9L7M7:;!&

    7:1! B!#,Y$!J$$-!$-.,.$5!J;!"#$!033$44,-"H!%'*#!D,")6*K!E(446Y,-!"'!$_3)$&&!

    /;!'36-6'-!'-!"#$!46K$4;!*'&"!'9!.$-$),"6-.!$4$*")6*6";!9)'/!D)'`$*"![,;$&!

    ,-5! "'! *'/3,)$! "#,"! "'! "#$! 46K$4;! *'&"! '9! .$-$),"6-.! '"#$)&! 9')/&! '9!

    $4$*")6*6";:!

    7:7! B! *'-96)/! "#,"! B! #,Y$! )$,5H! ,-5! 9,/646,)! C6"#H! "#$!X'5$! '9! X'-5(*"! 9')!

    Q_3$)"! =6"-$&&$&! 6-! "#$! Q-Y6)'-/$-"! X'()"! &$"! '("! 6-! X'-&'465,"$5!

    D),*"6*$!R'"$!788b:!

    !

    7:A! B-!3)$3,)6-.! "#6&!&","$/$-"! B!#,Y$! )$Y6$C$5!,-5!#,5! )$.,)5! "'H!,/'-.!

    '"#$)!/,"$)6,4f!

    !

    M,O! U#$!

    &","$/$-"!'9!'33')"(-6"6$&!(35,"$5!788bhg!

    !

    M*O! Q-$).;!X$-"),4!R$C&4$""$)!M#""3fii$-$).;*$-"),4:*'/Og!!!M5O! %$3')"!J;!X,/J)65.$!Q-$).;!%$&$,)*#!0&&'*6,"$&!M72iWi8aOg!!

    M$O! U#$! E;&"$/! d3$),"')j&! /'-"#4;! )$3')"! "'! "#$! Q4$*")6*6";!

    X'//6&&6'-!'9!+,;!8ag!

    M9O! E(//,);! '9! P6-56-.&! RS! C6-5! 6-"$.),"6'-! &"(5;! 03)64! 788a! J;!

    E")J,*!$"!,4!,-5!+$)656,-!Q-$).;!!!

    ! %!

    http://energycentral.com/

  • M.O! R,"6'-,4!=6-"$)!^)'(3!788a!B-6"6,4!%$3')"!c!N$*$/J$)!788c!3(J46$5!J;!U),-&3'C$)!

    !M#O! U#$!X$-"),46&$5!N,",&$"!N\N!3(J46$5!J;!"#$!Q4$*")6*6";!

    X'//6&&6'-!!

    &NEF& -@?;&@I&9;=@:&&A:1! U#$! *'&"! '9! .$-$),"6'-! 9)'/! ,! C6-5! 9,)/! 6&! /,5$! (3! '9! ,! -(/J$)! '9!

    *'/3'-$-"!*'&"&:!!

    !

    -96=;98&-@?;&

    !

    A:7! U#$!/'&"! 6/3')",-"!*'&"! 6&! "#$!*,36",4!*'&"!'9! "#$!C6-5! 9,)/! 6"&$49:!U#$!

    *,36",4! *'&"! *,-! J$! J)'K$-! 5'C-! 6-"'! 3)$46/6-,);! *'&"&H! "#$! 'Y$)&$,&!

    *'&"&!'9!/,-(9,*"()$H!ᣀ-.! "#$! "()J6-$&!,-5!,&&'*6,"$5!$L(63/$-"H!

    ,-5!'-I&6"$! *'&"&! &(*#!,&!3)$46/6-,);! &"(56$&H! *6Y64!C')K&H! )',56-.!,-5!

    *,J46-.!J$"C$$-!"#$! 6-56Y65(,4! "()J6-$&!,-5!"#$!*$-"),4!3'6-"!C#$)$!"#$!

    C6-5! 9,)/! 6&!*'--$*"$5! "'! "#$!.)65:! !U#$&$!*'&"&!5$"$)/6-$! "#$!*,36",4!

    $_3$-56"()$!-$$5$5!"'!J(645!,!C6-5!9,)/:!

    !

    A:A! B! #,Y$!/,5$!(&$!'9! "#$!*'&"!$&"6/,"$&!.6Y$-! 6-!,! )$3')"! J;!D

    'Y$)&$,&! $4$/$-"! '9! "#$! *'&"! '9! ,! ";36*,4! C6-5! 9,)/! 6&! kRS! 7788iK=:!

    U#$;! ,4&'! $&"6/,"$! "#,"! "#$! R$C! S$,4,-5! *'/3'-$-"! '9! "#$! *'&"! 6&!

    J$"C$$-!kA88!,-5!kZ88iK=:!U#6&!.6Y$&!,!"'",4!6-&",44$5!*'&"!'9!J$"C$$-!

    k7W88!,-5!k7b88iK=:!!

    !

    A:Z! B! #,Y$! *#$*K$5! "#6&! $&"6/,"$! ,.,6-&"! )$*$-"! ')5$)&! "#,"! #,Y$! J$$-!

    34,*$5!6-!Y,)6'(&!*'(-")6$&!,-5!'"#$)!)$3')"&!'-!"#$!*'&"&!'9!C6-59,)/&!

    ,&! )$3')"$5! J;! Q-$).;! X$-"),4H7:! ! U#$! 9'44'C6-.! ,)$! )$*$-"! *'&"&! '9!

    'Y$)&$,&!C6-5!9,)/!5$Y$4'3/$-"&f!

    !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1!1D)$3,)$5!9')!"#$!Q4$*")6*6";!X'//6&&6'-!,-5!5,"$5!d*"'J$)!788b!

    7!TQ-$).;!X$-"),4V!B-5(&");!R$C&4$""$)M!#""3ii$-$).;*$-"),4:*'/O!

    ! &!

  • !

    A:Z:1! E(C,4*'!,-5!U;*#'C'!6-!D'4,-5!M71iZi8aO

    !

    0-!')5$)!Y,4($5!,"!,33)'_6/,"$4;!Q()'188!/6446'-!C,&!34,*$5!C6"#!

    E6$/$-&! 9')!AA! "()J6-$&!C6"#!,! "'",4!*,3,*6";!'9!cb!+=:! !U#6&! 6&!

    $L(6Y,4$-"! "'! ,! k?E! 7888iK=:! MkRS! 7bb8O! U#6&! *'Y$)&! "#$!

    .$-$),"6-.! 34,-"! '-4;! &'! "#$! 96-,4! *'&"&! C'(45! J$! *4'&$! "'! kRS!

    A888iK=:!

    !

    A:Z:7! 0",J(4,!=6-5!X$-"$)!6-!R')"#!N,K'",!?E0!MA8iZi8aO!

    !

    U#$! $_3$*"$5! *'&"! '9! "#$! Za! +=! 3)'`$*"! 6&! h/')$! "#,-! k! 171!

    /6446'-h:!U#6&!$L(,"$&!"'!k?E!7W78iK=!')!kRS!AA88:!

    !

    A:Z:A! R$C!%6*#/'-5!,-5!E"!\,4$-"6-$!6-!]($J$*H!X,-,5,!MWiWi8aO!!

    !

    U#$!$_3$*"$5!*'&"!'9! "#$!bb!+=!-$C!%6*#/'-5!3)'`$*"! 6&!k128!

    /6446'-:!U#6&!$L(,"$&!"'!k?E!7aa8iK=!')!kRS!Aa88:U#$!$_3$*"$5!

    *'&"!'9!"#$!W8!+=!E"!\,4$-"6-!C6-5!3)'`$*"!,&!k1b8!/6446'-:!U#6&!

    $L(,"$&!"'!k?E!A788iK=!')!kRS!Z788iK=:!

    !

    A:Z:Z! D,/3,!=6-5!3)'`$*"!6-!"#$!U$_,&!3,-#,-54$H!?E0!M1WiWi8aO

    !

    U#$! $_3$*"$5! *'&"! '9! "#$! 1H888!+=! 3)'`$*"! 6&! k7! J6446'-:! ! U#6&!

    $L(,"$&! "'!k?E!7c78iK=!')!kRS!Ab88iK=:! !0-!')5$)!#,&!J$$-!

    34,*$5!C6"#!^$-$),4!Q4$*")6*!9')!bbc!1:W!+=!C6-5!"()J6-$&:!

    !

    A:Z:W! %$3')"!J;!X,/J)65.$!Q-$).;!%$&$,)*#!0&&'*6,"$&!M72iWi8aO!!

    !

    U#6&!6&!,!)$3')"!'-!C6-5!3'C$)!6-!Q()'3$:!!! B"!&","$&!"#,"!h*,36",4!

    *'&"&!*'(45! )6&$!J;!78e! 9)'/!k?E!AWWW! "'!k?E!ZAZ7iK=! 6-! "#$!

    -$_"!&$Y$),4!;$,)&h:!

    !

    ! A:Z:b! [,44$""!=6-5!P,)/!0^>!Q-$).;!>"5!I!M1Aibi8aO!!

    ! '!

  • 0"!,!)$3')"$5!*'&"!'9!k07Ab!/6446'-!2W+=!"#6&!C6-5!9,)/!6-!

    E'("#!0(&"),46,!MZW!"()J6-$&O!$L(,"$&!"'!k0!7ZaZiK=:!MkRS!

    A888O!!

    !

    !A:W! B-! /;! '36-6'-! "#$&$! )$3')"&! ,)$! ";36*,4! '9! "#$! *())$-"! &","$! '9! "#$!

    6-"$)-,"6'-,4!/,)K$"!,-5!"#,"!"#$;!6-56*,"$!"#,"!"#$!kRS!7W88!II!7b88iK=!

    $&"6/,"$5! J;! D

    kA888iK=:!!MU#$!,Y$),.$!'9!"#$!,J'Y$!*'&"&!6&!kAZZ8:O!!^6Y$-!"#,"!R$C!

    S$,4,-5!6&!)$/'"$!9)'/!"#$!/,-(9,*"()$)&H!,-5!kA888iK=!6&!,"!"#$!4'C$)!

    $-5!'9!"#$!'Y$)&$,&!*'&"&H!,!*'&"!'9!kAW88iK=!/,;!C$44!J$!)$,46&"6*:!U'!

    *'Y$)! "#$! ),-.$H! B! #,Y$! (&$5! kA888iK=! ,-5! kAW88iK=! 6-! /;!

    *,4*(4,"6'-&:!

    !

    ,9=:;7:9:B7&B@?;?&

    !

    A:b! U#$!-$_"!/,`')!*'&"!6&!"#$!'3$),"6'-!,-5!/,6-"$-,-*$!*'&":!!d-!3,.$!78!

    '9!"#$!D

    'Y$)4,33$5H! B!#,Y$!,&&(/$5!"#,"! "#$!3$)6'5&!'(45!#,Y$!J$$-!1IWH!bI

    17H!,-5!1WI78!;$,)&!)$&3$*"6Y$4;:!!0"!kZ7iK=!M"#$!,Y$),.$!'9!A7!,-5!W7O!

    "#$! bA8! +=! [,;$&! C6-5! 9,)/! C'(45! #,Y$! ,-! '3$),"6'-! ,-5!

    /,6-"$-,-*$!*'&"!'9!k7b:W!/6446'-!3$)!,--(/:!!

    !

    #>7OH7:BP&Q776=:L&B@?;?&

    !

    A:c! U#$)$!,)$!*'&"&!,&&'*6,"$5!C6"#!9)$L($-*;!K$$36-.:!!U#$!3'C$)!&;&"$/!

    /(&"!J$!/,-,.$5!C6"#6-!,!-,))'C!J,-5!'9!"#$!^)65!9)$L($-*;!M-'/6-,44;!

    W8![GO:! ! B9! "#$! 9)$L($-*;!5$Y6,"$&! "''! 9,)! 9)'/!W8[G! "#$!C#'4$!&;&"$/!

    C644!*'44,3&$:!!P)$L($-*;!K$$36-.!$-&()$&!"#,"!"#$!,/'(-"!'9!$4$*")6*6";!

    .$-$),"$5! $_,*"4;! /,"*#$&! "#$! 4',5! '-! ,! /6-("$! J;! /6-("$! J,&6&:!!

    P)$L($-*;!K$$36-.!)$L(6)$&!"#,"!&'/$!&","6'-&!,)$!*'-&",-"4;!*#,-.6-.!

    ! (!

  • '("3("! "'!/,"*#! 94(*"(,"6'-&! 6-! "#$! 4',5!')H! 9')! 6-&",-*$H! "#$! 94(*"(,"6-.!

    '("3("!'9!C6-5!9,)/&:!

    !

    A:a! =6-5!3'C$)!&","6'-&! 6/3'&$!,556"6'-,4! 9)$L($-*;!K$$36-.!*'&"&!'-! "#$!

    3'C$)! &;&"$/! "#,"! ,)$! .)$,"$)! "#,-H! 9')! 6-&",-*$H! 9)'/! #;5)'3'C$)!

    &","6'-&:! ! P)'/! "#$! 3'6-"! '9! Y6$C! '9! &;&"$/! '3$),"6'-H! "#$! /,`')!

    3)'J4$/&! C6"#! C6-5! 3'C$)! ,)$! "#,"! 6"! 6&! (-3)$56*",J4$! ,-5! "#,"! 6"! *,-!

    94(*"(,"$! Y$);! ),3654;:! ! U#$&$! ),365! 94(*"(,"6'-&! /$,-&! "#,"! C6"#! C6-5!

    3'C$)! *'--$*"$5! "'! "#$! &;&"$/H! 9)$L($-*;! K$$36-.! J$*'/$&! /')$!

    56996*(4"!,-5!/')$!$_3$-&6Y$:! !0"! "#$!/'/$-"H! 9)$L($-*;!K$$36-.!34,-"!

    '3$),"$&!"'!/,-,.$!94(*"(,"6'-&!6-!"#$!),-.$!'9!liI!W8!+=:!!Q_3$)6$-*$!

    C6"#! 6-"$.),"6-.!"#$!'("3("!'9! "#$!+,-,C,"(!C6-5!9,)/!'C&!"#,"!C6-5!

    .$-$),"6'-!#,&!6-*)$,&$5!"#$!-$$5!9')!II!,-5!#$-*$!"#$!*'&"!'9!I!&;&"$/!

    9)$L($-*;!K$$36-.:!

    !A:2! U#$!(-3)$56*",J646";!'9!C6-5!.$-$),"6'-!/$,-&!"#,"!"#$!&;&"$/!'3$),"')!

    *,--'"!J$!*'-965$-"!'9! "#$!'("3("!'9!C6-5! 9,)/&!/')$! "#,-!,-!#'()!&'!

    6-"'!"#$!9("()$:!

  • !

    Z:8!! ,77;=:L&;R7!07M9:A&I@>&787B;>=B98&7:7>LP!

    !

    Z:1! =#$-! 5$"$)/6-6-.! "#$! -$$5! 9')! -$C! .$-$),"6'-H! &(996*6$-"! $4$*")6*,4!

    $-$).;! /(&"! J$! ,Y,64,J4$! "'! /$$"! "#$! 9')$*,&"! 3'C$)! 5$/,-5! 9')!

    $4$*")6*6";!'Y$)!"#$!*)6"6*,4!,("(/-IC6-"$)!3$)6'5!6-!,!5);!#;5)'!;$,)!C#$-!

    #;5)'I6-94'C&!,)$!1W!m!78e!4'C$)!"#,-!,Y$),.$!,-5!"#$!3'C$)!5$/,-5!

    6&! ,"! 6"&!/,_6/(/:! !U#$!,("(/-!,-5!C6-"$)&!'9! 122aH! 7881H! 788b!,-5!

    788a! ,)$! ";36*,4! $_,/34$&:! B9! 6-&(996*6$-"! $-$).;! 6&! ,Y,64,J4$H! "#$! 4,K$!

    4$Y$4&! C644! 9,44H! 3)6*$&! C644! )6&$! 5),/,"6*,44;! ,-5! ,-! $4$*")6*6";! &,Y6-.&!

    *,/3,6.-!/,;!J$!-$$5$5!"'!/6-6/6&$!')!,Y'65!"#$!)6&K!'9!3'C$)!*("&:!

    !

    Z:7! =6-5!9,)/&!.$-$),"$!$4$*")6*,4!$-$).;!C#$-$Y$)!"#$!C6-5!6&!J4'C6-.:!!B9!

    "#$!$-$).;!6&!-'"!-$$5$5!,"!"#$!"6/$!"#,"!6"!6&!.$-$),"$5H!6"!*,-!'9"$-!J$!

    &"')$5! 6-! #;5)'! &"'),.$! 4,K$&:!

  • "#,"! "#$! &()34(&! $-$).;! ,Y,64,J4$!C644! 5)6Y$! 3'C$)! 3)6*$&! 5'C-H!/,K$&!

    D)'`$*"![,;$&! 4$&&!$*'-'/6*,44;!,""),*"6Y$!"#,-! 6"!C'(45!J$! 69! 6"&!'("3("!

    C,&!,"!6"&!#6.#$&"!5()6-.!,("(/-!,-5!$,)4;!C6-"$):!!

    !Z:Z! B!#,Y$!,-,4;&$5!"#$!3(J46*4;!,Y,64,J4$!5,",Z!)$*')56-.!/'-"#4;!,Y$),.$!

    '("3("!'9!,44!"#$!R')"#!B&4,-5!C6-5!9,)/&!&6-*$!"#$!;$,)!7888:!P')!$,*#!

    /'-"#H! B! #,Y$! *,4*(4,"$5! "#$! *,3,*6";! 9,*"')! M"#$! *,3,*6";! 9,*"')! 6&! "#$!

    ),"6'!'9!"#$!,Y$),.$!+=!'("3("!5()6-.!,!/'-"#!"'!"#$!6-&",44$5!*,3,*6";!

    '9! "#$!C6-5! 9,)/&:O!U#$!34'""$5!5,",! 6"! 6&!'C-! 6-!Q_#6J6"!1:!U#$!*#,)"!

    'C&! "#,"H! 5()6-.! "#$! /'-"#&! '9! +,)*#! "'! 0(.(&"H! C#$-! "#$! #;5)'!

    &"'),.$! 6&!/'&"! '9"$-! ,"! 4'C! 4$Y$4&H! "#$! '("3("! '9! "#$! C6-5! 9,)/&! C,&!

    J$4'C!"#$!4'-.I"$)/!,Y$),.$!*,3,*6";!9,*"')!'9!8:A2H!6-!,44!/'-"#&!$_*$3"!

    @(-$:! U#$! ,Y$),.$! /'-"#4;! '("3("! 5()6-.! "#$! 3$)6'5! 9)'/! +,)*#! "'!

    0(.(&"! 6&! 9'(-5! "'! J$! 21:Ze!'9! "#$! ,Y$),.$! ,--(,4! '("3(":! U#,"! 6&! "'!

    &,;H! "#$! '("3("! '9! "#$! C6-5! 9,)/&! 6&! )'(.#4;! 2e! J$4'C! "#$! 4'-.! "$)/!

    ,Y$),.$! '("3("! 5()6-.! "#6&! 6/3')",-"! 3$)6'5:! 0&! ,! 5);! #;5)'! ;$,)! 6&!

    )$*K'-$5!"'!J$!'-$!C#$)$!"#$!#;5)'!3'C$)!'("3("!6&!1We!I!78e!J$4'C!

    -')/,4H! "#$! &6/(4",-$'(&! 2e! )$5(*"6'-! 6-! '("3("! 9)'/! C6-5! 6&! L(6"$!

    &6.-696*,-":! ! U#6&! 5,",! 5'$&! -'"! 6-*4(5$! "#$! C6-5! 9,)/&! 6-! "#$! E'("#!

    B&4,-5:! ['C$Y$)H! "#$! 5,",! 9)'/!=#6"$! [644&! C6-5! 9,)/! 9')! "#$! 96)&"! 96Y$!

    /'-"#&!'9!"#6&!;$,)H!6-56*,"$&!"#,"H!69!,-;"#6-.H!"#$!5)'3!6-!'("3("!5()6-.!

    "#$!4,"$!&(//$)!6-!,!5);!;$,)!6&!$Y$-!/')$!3)'-'(-*$5:!

    !Z:W! B!#,Y$!,4&'! 6-Y$&"6.,"$5! "#$!'("3("!'9! "#$!R')"#! B&4,-5!C6-5! 9,)/&!C6"#!

    ,-! 6-&",44$5! *,3,*6";! '9! 1a8!+=!5()6-.! @(-$!,-5! @(4;! 788c!C#$-! "#$!

    &;&"$/! 5$/,-5! C,&! ,J'Y$! WW88!+=:! ! U#$! ,-,4;&6&! C,&! *,))6$5! '("!

    (&6-.!3(J46*4;!,Y,64,J4$!5,",:!!Q_#6J6"!7!'C&!"#$!)$&(4"&!'9!"#6&!,-,4;&6&!

    $_3)$&&$5!,&!,!3$)*$-",.$!'9!"#$!"6/$!"#,"!"#$!'("3("!'9!"#$!C6-5!9,)/!

    C,&! J$"C$$-! 8! I! 18!+=H! 18! I! A8!+=H! A8! I! W8!+=H! ,-5! &'! '-:! U#6&!

    ,-,4;&6&!'C&!"#,"!"#$!'("3("!'9!"#$!C6-5!9,)/&!C,&!J$4'C!18!+=!9')!

    7We!'9! "#$! "6/$H! ,-5! 6"!C,&! J$"C$$-! 18!+=!,-5! A8!+=!17e!'9! "#$!

    "6/$:!D(""6-.!6"!,-'"#$)!C,;H!9')!Ace!'9!"#$!"6/$!"#$!'("3("!C,&!4$&&!"#,-!

    !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!%!+,-./0123,4!50.03,.!565!78/21!#99)!:/;./2>2.?!+;

  • A8!+=:!A8!+=!)$3)$&$-"&!1ce!'9!"#$!1a8!+=!6-&",44$5!*,3,*6";!'9!"#$!

    C6-5! 9,)/&:! P)'/! "#6&! B! *'-*4(5$! "#,"H! 5()6-.! "#$! *)6"6*,4! C6-"$)! 3$,K!

    5$/,-5! 3$)6'5! 6-! 788cH! 6"! C'(45! #,Y$! J$$-! /'&"! (-C6&$! "'! )$4;! '-!

    #,Y6-.!/')$!"#,-!18!+=!'9!C6-5!3'C$)!,Y,64,J4$!5()6-.!,!3$,K!5$/,-5!

    3$)6'5:!!!

    &SEF& -969B=;P&AH>=:L&?P?;7M&679Q&A7M9:A&67>=@A?&!W:1! B"! 6&!$&&$-"6,4! "'!#,Y$!&(996*6$-"!.$-$),"6'-!*,3,*6";! M34(&!,! )$,&'-,J4$!

    )$&$)Y$O! ,Y,64,J4$! ,"! "6/$&! '9! 3$,K! 5$/,-5! '-! "#$! R$C! S$,4,-5!

    $4$*")6*6";! &;&"$/:! ! d-! ,! ";36*,4! C6-"$)! 5,;H! "#$!/6-6/(/! 4',5! '-! "#$!

    &;&"$/!C644!J$!,J'("!Z888!+=!C#64$!"#$!3$,K!5$/,-5!C644!J$!6-!$_*$&&!

    '9! b888!+=:!0"! "#$!J$.6--6-.!'9! $,*#!5,;H! "#$! &;&"$/!'3$),"')!/(&"!

    5$Y$4'3!,!&*#$5(4$! 9')!.$-$),"6'-! "#,"!C644!$-&()$! "#,"! "#$!&;&"$/!*,-!

    /$$"! 3$,K! 5$/,-5:! ! =#$-! 5'6-.! "#6&! "#$! &;&"$/! '3$),"')! *,-! '-4;!

    &*#$5(4$!34,-"!"#,"!6&!188e!&()$!"'!J$!,Y,64,J4$:!

    !

    W:7! +,-;!6-Y$&"6.,"6'-&!#,Y$!J$$-!*,))6$5!'("!II!&(*#!,&!"#$!'-$!J;!E"),J,*!

    $"!,4! I! "'! ");!,-5!$&"6/,"$! "#$!$_"$-"! "'!C#6*#! "#$!&;&"$/!'3$),"')!*,-!

    )$4;! '-! C6-53'C$):! ! ?-9')"(-,"$4;H! )$*$-"! $Y65$-*$! 9)'/! "#$! ,*"(,4!

    '3$),"6'-!'9! "#$!R$C!S$,4,-5!3'C$)! &;&"$/!'C&! "#,"! "#$&$! &"(56$&!

    #,Y$! "$-5$5! "'! 'Y$)$&"6/,"$! "#$! C6-53'C$)! *,3,*6";! "#,"! C644! J$!

    ,Y,64,J4$!5()6-.!&;&"$/!3$,K&:!

    !

    W:A! U),-&3'C$)j&!&;&"$/&!'3$),"6'-&!/,-,.$)H!F6$),-!N$Y6-$!#,&!3(J46*4;!

    ,*K-'C4$5.$5!C6-5!3'C$)j&!')"*'/6-.&!5()6-.!&;&"$/!3$,K!5$/,-5!

    3$)6'5&:!!!B!)$9$)!"'!,-!,)"6*4$!6-!"#$!U,),-,K6!N,64;!R$C&!'-!=$5-$&5,;H!

    11!@(-$!788a:!,J'("!,!3)'3'&$5!C6-5! 9,)/! 6-!U,),-,K6:! !U#$! )$4$Y,-"!

    ,)"6*4$!)$,5&!,&!9'44'C&f!

    !

    "#$%&'()*+$! ','-+.! )(+$%-/)&'! .%&%0+$! 1/+$%&! 2+3/&+! '%,'! -4+!5)6&-$,7'!-4$++!.%8)$!9%$.':!5;6'-+$+)$0+:!'6((;/+

  • */&

    "'45!/$!"#,"!"#$!,*"(,4!*'-")6J("6'-!"'!3$,K!5$/,-5!9)'/!"#$!+,-,C,"(!

    C6-5! 9,)/&! 6-! "#$!;$,)&!788WH!788b!,-5!788c!C,&! 96Y$H!$6.#"!,-5!G$)'!

    +=! )$&3$*"6Y$4;:! ! [$! 3'6-"$5! '("! "#,"! "#$&$! "#)$$! C6-5! 9,)/&! C$)$!

    4'*,"$5!*4'&$! "'.$"#$)!,-5! "#,"! "#$)$!C,&!,! )$,&'-,J4$!3'&&6J646";! "#,"!

    "#$! 96.()$!C'(45!J$!#6.#$)! 69! "#$)$!C$)$!C6-5! 9,)/&!56&")6J("$5!,)'(-5!

    "#$!*'(-");:!

    !

    W:W! U#6&! 6&! *'-96)/$5! J;! "#$! ,"",*#$5! .),3#! M$_#6J6"! 2O! 9)'/! "#$! R,"6'-,4!

    C6-"$)!.)'(3!6-6"6,4!)$3')"!N$*!788aW:!B"!'C&!"#,"!C#$-!5$"$)/6-6-.!"#$!

    .$-$),"6-.! 34,-"! "#,"! C644! J$! ,Y,64,J4$! 5()6-.! *)6"6*,4! 3$,K! 5$/,-5!

    3$)6'5&!U),-&3'C$)!,&&(/$!"#,"!-'!C6-5!.$-$),"6'-!C644!J$!,Y,64,J4$:!

    !

    W:b! P)'/!1!@,-(,);!"'!A!@(4;!788aH!,!3$)6'5!C#$-!R$C!S$,4,-5!-$$5$5!,44!

    "#$! .$-$),"6-.! *,3,*6";! 6"! *'(45! .$"H! "#$! "C'! M+$)656,-! 'C-$5O! C6-5!

    !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!&[email protected];-01!B2-.,/!C/;D8!E-2.201!F,8;/.!#99)!:/;!G/0-38;H,/!

    ! "#!

  • 9,)/&! 9')!C#6*#!3(J46*!5,",! 6&!,Y,64,J4$H!.$-$),"$5! 4$&&! "#,-! "#$6)! 4'-.!

    "$)/!,Y$),.$!.$-$),"6'-:! B-! 9,*"H! 9')! 78e!'9! "#$! "6/$! "#$6)! '("3("!C,&!

    4$&&! "#,-! Z8e! '9! "#$! "'",4! 6-&",44$5! *,3,*6";:! P')! 78e! '9! "#$! "6/$! "#$!

    "'",4!'("3("!C,&!,J'Y$!W1e!'9!6-&",44$5!*,3,*6";:!!N()6-.!"#6&!3$)6'5H!"#$!

    ,Y$),.$!*,3,*6";!9,*"')!'9!=#6"$![644&!C,&!8:A1H!'9!U$!036"6H!8:AZ:!!B-!,-!

    ,Y$),.$!;$,)H! "#$! *,3,*6";! 9,*"')! '9!U$!036"6! 6&H! B! J$46$Y$H! 6-! $_*$&&!'9!

    8:Z:! ! U#6&! 6&! ,! &")'-.! 6-56*,"6'-! "#,"H! 6-! 5);! #;5)'! ;$,)&H! "#$! '("3("! '9!

    C6-5! 9,)/&! C644! ,4&'! J$! 4'C$)! "#,-! -')/,4:! ! 044! "#6&! /$,-&! "#,"! "#$6)!

    *'-")6J("6'-! "'!&(334;6-.!$-$).;!,-5! "'!&(334;6-.!$4$*")6*6";!,"! "6/$&!'9!

    3$,K! 5$/,-5! C,&! 4$&&! "#,-! C'(45! J$! ,*#6$Y$5! J;! *'-Y$-"6'-,4!

    &","6'-&:!!!

    !W:c! B! #,Y$! 'J",6-$5! "#$! 3(J46*4;! ,Y,64,J4$! 96.()$&b! 9')! .$-$),"6'-! ,"!

    +$)656,-n&! U$! 036"6! C6-5! 9,)/! 6-! "#$!+,-,C,"(! ,-5! ,"! "#$!=#6"$! [644&!

    C6-5! 9,)/! 6-!E'("#4,-5! 9')! "#$!3$)6'5! 9)'/!1!@,-(,);! "'!A! @(-$!788a:!!

    U#$&$! 96.()$&! ,)$! 9')! ,Y$),.$! 5,64;! '("3("! ,-5! #$-*$! "#$! 94(*"(,"6'-&!

    "#,"!'**()!C6"#6-!,!5,;!#,Y$!J$$-!,Y$),.$5!'(":!!E'!"#$!)$,4!&6"(,"6'-!6&!

    /')$! $_")$/$! "#,-! 6-56*,"$5! J;! "#$! 5,64;! ,Y$),.$5! 5,",:! ! U#$! "#)$$!

    *#,)"&!"#,"!B!#,Y$!5$)6Y$5!9)'/!"#$&$!96.()$&!,)$!'C-!,&!$_#6J6"&!AH!Z!

    ,-5!W:!!!

    !W:a! Q_#6J6"!A!'C&!"#$!,Y$),.$!5,64;!.$-$),"6'-!,"!U$!036"6:!B"! 6&!*4$,)!"#,"!

    "#$! '("3("! 94(*"(,"$&! *'-&65$),J4;! 9)'/! 5,;! "'! 5,;! ,-5! "#,"! 9)'/! "#$!

    /6554$!'9!+,)*#!"'!"#$!$-5!'9!"#$!3$)6'5H!"#$!'("3("!C,&!)$4,"6Y$4;!4'C:!B9!

    "#$!&","6'-!#,5!J$$-!'3$),"6-.!,"!6"&!,--(,4!,Y$),.$!*,3,*6";!9,*"')H!"#$!

    ,Y$),.$!'("3("!C'(45!#,Y$!J$$-!6-!"#$!Y6*6-6";!'9!Z8!+=:!B"!C,&!/(*#!

    4'C$)!"#,-!"#6&:!B"!6&!,!)$,&'-,J4$!,&&(/3"6'-!"#,"!"#$!4'C!,Y$),.$!C6-5!

    3'C$)!'("3("!6&!)$4,"$5!"'!"#$!>,!R6-,!C$,"#$)!C#6*#H!6-!"()-H!6&!,!9,*"')!

    6-! "#$! 4'C! ),6-9,44:! P()"#$)! 6-Y$&"6.,"6'-!/,;! J$! -$$5$5! "'!/,K$! &()$!

    "#,"!"#6&!6&!II!')!6&!-'"!II!";36*,4!'9!/'&"!5);!;$,)&:!

    !

    W:2! P)'/! "#$!5,",H! B!C,&!,J4$! "'! *,4*(4,"$! "#$!3$)*$-",.$!'9! "6/$! "#,"! "#$!

    !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!'!+,-./0123,4!50.03,.!:/;./2>2.?!+;

  • '("3("!'9!"#$!C6-5!9,)/!C,&!,J'Y$!,!*$)",6-!4$Y$4:!U#6&!6&!'C-!6-!"#$!

    "$_"!'-! "#$!56,.),/:! B"!'C&! "#,"! "#$!'("3("! 6&!,J'Y$!c1e!'9! 6-&",44$5!

    *,3,*6";!9')!'-4;!18e!'9!"#$!"6/$!,-5!6"!6&!,J'Y$!Ze!'9!6-&",44$5!*,3,*6";!

    9')!28e!'9!"#$!"6/$!,-5!,J'Y$!11e!*,3,*6";!9')!a8e!'9!"#$!"6/$:!!E6/34;!

    3("H! 6"!/$,-&! "#,"! "#$!C6-5! 9,)/! &$45'/!'3$),"$5! ,"! ,-;"#6-.! -$,)! 6"&!

    /,_6/(/! *,3,*6";:! ! 0"! "#$! '"#$)! $-5! '9! "#$! &*,4$H! "#$)$! 6&! #6.#!

    *'-965$-*$!"#,"!"#$!'("3("!C'(45!J$!,"!4$,&"!Ze!'9!6-&",44$5!*,3,*6";:!B"!6&!

    )$4$Y,-"!"'!*'/3,)$!"#6&!C6"#!,!*'-Y$-"6'-,4!3'C$)!&","6'-!C#$)$!"#$)$!

    6&!#6.#!*'-965$-*$!M6:$:!2We!')!/')$O!"#,"!6"!*,-!'3$),"$!,"!6"&!/,_6/(/!

    *,3,*6";!C#$-$Y$)!)$L(6)$5:!!B!,4&'!*,4*(4,"$5!"#$!*,3,*6";!9,*"')!5()6-.!

    "#$!1!@,-(,);!m!A!@(-$!3$)6'5:! B"!C,&!8:AZ!C#6*#! 6&!1We!4$&&!"#,-!"#$!

    8:Z!*,3,*6";!9,*"')!C#6*#H!B!(-5$)&",-5H!6&!"#$!4'-.!"$)/!,Y$),.$!9')!"#6&!

    C6-5!9,)/:!!U#6&!6-56*,"$&!m!J("!5'$&!-'"!3)'Y$!m!"#,"!"#$!'("3("!C644!J$!

    (-(&(,44;!4'C!5()6-.!,!5);!#;5)'!;$,):!

    !

    W:18! Q_#6J6"! Z! 'C&! "#$! &,/$! 5,",! 9')! =#6"$! [644&! C6-5! 9,)/:! ! U#$!

    *#,),*"$)6&"6*&! ,)$! &6/64,)! "'! U$! 036"6! $_*$3"! "#,"! "#$! '("3("! 6&! ,J'Y$!

    7:WeH! ),"#$)! "#,-! ZeH! 9')! 28e! '9! "#$! "6/$:! ! U#$)$! 6&H! "#$)$9')$H! 46""4$!

    *'-965$-*$! "#,"! 6"! C644! J$! .$-$),"6-.! ,! &(J&",-"6,4! ,/'(-"! '9! 3'C$)!

    5()6-.! ,! 3$,K! 5$/,-5! 3$)6'5! 6-! "#$! 9("()$:! N()6-.! "#6&! 3$)6'5! "#$!

    *,3,*6";! 9,*"')! C,&! 8:A1!C#6*#! 6&! 1be! J$4'C! "#$! 8:Ac! *,3,*6";! 9,*"')!

    "#,"H!B!(-5$)&",-5H!6&!$_3$*"$5!9')!"#6&!C6-5!9,)/:!

    !

    W:11! Q_#6J6"! W! 644(&"),"$&! "#$! $99$*"! '9! *'/J6-6-.! "#$! '("3("! '9! "#$! "C'!C6-5!

    9,)/&:! B! #,Y$! 5'-$! "#6&! "'! ,&&$&&! "#$! $_"$-"! "'! C#6*#! "#$! "C'! 9,)/&!

    &(33')"!$,*#!'"#$):!B9!"C'!C6-5!9,)/&!,)$!.$'.),3#6*,44;!&$3,),"$5!"#$;!

    $_3$)6$-*$!5699$)$-"!C6-5!*'-56"6'-&:!!B9!6"!'9"$-!#,33$-&!"#,"!"#$!C6-5!6&!

    J4'C6-.!,"!'-$!9,)/!C#$-! 6"! 6&!-'"!,"! "#$!'"#$)H! "#$-! "#$! 94(*"(,"6'-&! 6-!

    '("3("!C644!"$-5!"'!J,4,-*$!'(":!U#$!*#,)"!'C&!"#,"!"#6&!#,&!#,33$-$5!

    "'!&'/$!$_"$-"!J("!"#$)$!6&!&"644!,!*'-&65$),J4$!,/'(-"!'9!94(*"(,"6'-:!U#$!

    '("3("! "#,"! 6&!,4C,;&!,Y,64,J4$!28e!'9!"#$!"6/$!#,&!6-*)$,&$5!"'!2e!'9!

    "'",4!6-&",44$5!*,3,*6";:!!U#$!'("3("!"#,"!6&!,Y,64,J4$!9')!188e!'9!"#$!"6/$!

    6&!'-4;!7e:!!>''K6-.!,"!/,_6/(/!'("3("H!"#$!5,",!'C&!"#,"!"#$!'("3("!

    6&!,J'Y$!b8e!'9! 6-&",44$5!*,3,*6";! 9')!'-4;!18e!'9! "#$! "6/$!,-5!-$Y$)!

    ! "%!

  • $_*$$5&!aAe:!U#6&!/$,-&!"#,"H! 9')!,44!3),*"6*,4!3()3'&$&H!"#$!'("3("!'9!

    "#$!"C'!C6-5!9,)/&!"'.$"#$)!*'(45!J$!&,65!"'!J$!a2!+=!Mb8e!'9!1Za:a!

    +=O! ),"#$)! "#,-! "#$! 6-&",44$5! *,3,*6";! '9! 1Za:a! +=:! ! U'! 3("! "#6&! 6-!

    *'-"$_"H!6"!/$,-&!"#,"H!69!R$C!S$,4,-5j&!4',5!.)'C"#!6&H!,&!*4,6/$5H!1W8!

    +=!3$)! ;$,)H!/')$! "#,-!7W8!+=!'9!C6-5!34(&! &'/$!J,*K(3! *,3,*6";!

    C'(45!-$$5! "'!J$! 6-&",44$5! "'!/$$"! "#6&! 4',5!.)'C"#:!U#6&! 6&!-'"!C65$4;!

    )$,46&$5:!!B"!,33$,)&!"'!J$!.$-$),44;!J$46$Y$5!"#,"!,!1W8!+=!C6-5!9,)/!6&!

    &(996*6$-"!"'!/$$"!,!4',5!.)'C"#!'9!1W8!+=:!X4$,)4;H!"#6&!6&!-'"!"#$!*,&$:!

    !

    W:17! U#$!,J'Y$!,-5!Q_#6J6"!7!5$/'-&"),"$!"#,"!"#$!E;&"$/!d3$),"')j&!3'46*;!

    '9! ,&&(/6-.! "#,"! "#$)$! C644! J$! -'! '("3("! 9)'/! C6-5! 9,)/&! C#$-!

    &*#$5(46-.!.$-$),"6'-!9')!"#$!5,;H!6&!)$,46&"6*!,-5!3)(5$-":!!!

    !

    W:1A! B!,/!*'-965$-"!"#,"H!$Y$-!C6"#!C65$4;!56&")6J("$5!C6-53'C$)H!6"!C'(45!J$!

    )6&K;!"'!,&&(/$!"#,"!,&!/(*#!,&!78e!'9!"#$!*,3,*6";!C'(45!J$!,Y,64,J4$!

    5()6-.! &;&"$/! 3$,K! 5$/,-5! "6/$&:! ! 0&&(/6-.! "#,"! 18e! C'(45! J$!

    ,Y,64,J4$!C'(45!J$!4$&&!)6&K;!J$*,(&$!6"!C'(45!#,33$-!4$&&!'9"$-!,-5H!69!

    "#$! &;&"$/! '3$),"')! C,&!C)'-.H! "#$! *#,-*$&! ,)$! "#,"! "#$)$! C'(45! J$!

    &(996*6$-"!*,3,*6";!,Y,64,J4$!'-! "#$!&;&"$/!"'!&(J&"6"("$! 9')! "#$!/6&&6-.!

    18e:!!

    !

    W:1Z! B"! 6&!'9"$-!*4,6/$5! "#,"! "#$! )$&$)Y$!*,3,*6";!#$45! "'!*'Y$)! "#$! 4'&&!'9!,!

    4,).$!.$-$),"6-.!&$"!')!"#$!N6)$*"!X())$-"!>6-K!*,-!,4&'!J$!(&$5!"'!J,*K!

    (3!C6-5!3'C$)!69H!5()6-.!"#$!3$,K!5$/,-5!3$)6'5H!"#$!'("3("!'9!"#$!C6-5!

    9,)/&!6&!4'C:!!0&!)$&$)Y$!*,3,*6";!6&!-')/,44;!-'"!4$&&!"#,-!Z88!+=H!"#6&!

    3)'3'&6"6'-! ,33$,)&! "'! J$! L(6"$! *)$56J4$:! !

  • )$&$)Y$! *,3,*6";! 6&! (&$5! "'! J,*K(3! "#$!C6-5! 9,)/H! 6"! *,-! '-4;! *'Y$)! ,!

    )$4,"6Y$4;!&/,44!3$)*$-",.$!'9!"#$!C6-5!9,)/!*,3,*6";:!!U#$!6-$&*,3,J4$!

    *'-*4(&6'-!6&!"#,"!,!&(J&",-"6,4!,/'(-"!'9!.$-$),"6-.!*,3,*6";!C644!#,Y$!

    "'!J$!,44'*,"$5!3()$4;!"'!*'Y$)!"#$!)6&K!,&&'*6,"$5!C6"#!"#$!Y,)6,J646";!,-5!

    (-3)$56*",J646";! '9! "#$! '("3("! '9! "#$! C6-5! 9,)/&! 5()6-.! &;&"$/! 3$,K!

    5$/,-5!3$)6'5&:! !U#$!,4"$)-,"6Y$! 6&! "'!,&&(/$!"#,"! "#$!C6-5! 9,)/&!C644!

    3)'Y65$! '-4;! ,! &/,44! *'-")6J("6'-! "'! !/$$"6-.! 3$,K! 5$/,-5&! ,-5! ")$,"!

    "#$/!3()$4;!,&!,! &'()*$!'9! $4$*")6*,4! $-$).;! "#,"H!C#$-! 6"! 6&! ,Y,64,J4$H!

    C'(45! )$5(*$! "#$! ,/'(-"! '9! .$-$),"6'-! ,"! 9'&&64! 9($4! &","6'-&! ,-5H! ,"!

    "6/$&H!*,(&$!,556"6'-,4!&3$44!,"!"#$!#;5)'3'C$)!&","6'-&:!!B9!"#6&!6&!5'-$H!

    "#$-!"#$!'-4;!Y,4($!'9!C6-53'C$)!M,3,)"!9)'/!&/,44!*'-")6J("6'-!"'!3$,K!

    5$/,-5O!C644!J$!&,Y6-.! 6-! 9'&&64! 9($4&:! ! B-!/;!'36-6'-H! "#6&!C'(45!/$,-!

    "#,"! "#$!J$-$96"!'9! "#$!C6-5! 9,)/&!"'! "#$!3'C$)!&;&"$/!C'(45!J$! 6-! "#$!

    ),-.$! '9! A! *$-"&! "'! b! *$-"&iK=#! '9! "#$! $4$*")6*6";! 3'"$-"6,44;! ,J4$! "'!

    .$-$),"$5!J;!"#$!C6-5!9,)/&:!U#$!4'C$)!96.()$!)$3)$&$-"&!,-!,44'C,-*$!

    9')!"#$!9,*"!"#,"!L(6"$!,!#6.#!3)'3')"6'-!'9!"#$!C6-5!$-$).;!/,;!J$!4'&"!,&!

    #;5)'!&3644!')!,&!,!)$&(4"!'9!*'-&"),6-6-.!C6-5!3'C$)!.$-$),"6'-:!

    !

    W:12! 0&! $_34,6-$5! ,J'Y$H! 5()6-.! ,! 5);! ;$,)H! "#'&$! #;5)'! &","6'-&!C6"#! Y$);!

    46/6"$5!&"'),.$!C644!#,Y$! 46/6"$5!,J646";! "'!J,*K!(3!,!5)'3! 6-!C6-53'C$)!

    9')!/')$!"#,-!,!9$C!#'()&:!!E'/$!'9!"#$&$!#;5)'3'C$)!&","6'-&!/,;!-'"!

    $Y$-! #,Y$! &(996*6$-"! C,"$)! "'! ,44'C! "#$/! "'! )(-! ,"! /,_6/(/! '("3(":!!

    04&'H!/,-;!'9!'()!#;5)'!&","6'-&!#,Y$!)$&")6*"6'-&!'-!"#$!),"$!'9!*#,-.$!

    '9!5'C-&")$,/!94'C!C#6*#!&$)6'(&4;!46/6"&!"#$6)!,J646";!"'!6-*)$,&$!'("3("!

    ),3654;! 69! "#$! C6-5! 5)'3&! &(55$-4;:! ! U#$&$! "C'! 9,*"')&! /$,-! "#,"! "#$!

    ,J646";! '9! #;5)'! &","6'-&! "'! &(33')"! C6-5! 5()6-.! *)6"6*,4! 3$,K! 5$/,-5!

    3$)6'5&!6-!,!5);!;$,)!6&!L(6"$!46/6"$5!C#$-!*'/3,)$5!"'!,!-')/,4!;$,):!!

    !TEF& !9BQ&H6&9;=@:&&b:1! U,K6-.!"#$!9')$.'6-.!6-"'!,**'(-"H!B!J$46$Y$!"#,"!6"!6&!)$,&'-,J4$!m!,-5H!69!

    ,-;"#6-.H! .$-$)'(&! II! "'! ,&&(/$! "#,"! -'!/')$! "#,-!18e! Mob8!+=O!'9!

    "#$! 6-&",44$5! *,3,*6";! '9! D)'`$*"! [,;$&! *,-! J$! ,44'*,"$5! "'! /$$"6-.!

    &;&"$/!3$,K!5$/,-5!,-5!"#,"H!9')!,44!3),*"6*,4!3()3'&$&H!"#$!/,_6/(/!

    $99$*"6Y$!*,3,*6";!'9!"#$![,;$&!C6-5!9,)/!5()6-.!,!5);!#;5)'!;$,)!M"#,"!6&!

    ! "'!

  • *)6"6*,4!9')!34,--6-.!,-5!'3$),"6'-!'9!"#$!R$C!S$,4,-5!3'C$)!&;&"$/O!6&!

    -'!/')$!"#,-!W88!+=:!!U#,"H!6-!"()-H!/$,-&!"#,"!ZZ8!+=!'9!J,*K(3!C644!

    J$!-$$5$5! 69! "#$!C6-5! 9,)/! 6&! "'!J$!*'/3,)$5!56)$*"4;!C6"#!,!W88!+=!

    "#$)/,4! ')! .$'"#$)/,4! 3'C$)! &","6'-! M')! C6"#! ,! #;5)'! &;&"$/! "#,"!

    6-*4(5$&! &(996*6$-"! )$&$)Y$! "#$)/,4! *,3,*6";! "'! /,K$! (3! 9')! "#$! 1We!

    )$5(*$5!'("3("!6-!,!5);!;$,):O!!B-!/;!'36-6'-H!'9!"#$!ZZ8!+=!'9!J,*K(3!

    "#,"!6&!-$$5$5H!,J'("!28!+=!*,-!J$!3)'J,J4;!J$!3)'Y65$5!J;!"#$!3'C$)!

    &;&"$/!)$&$)Y$&!5()6-.!*)6"6*,4!3$,K!5$/,-5!3$)6'5&!,-5H!"#$)$9')$H!AW8!

    +=!'9!,556"6'-,4!J,*K(3!*,3,*6";!C644!J$!-$$5$5:!!

    !b:7! U#6&!J,*K(3! *,3,*6";!/(&"! J$! Y$);! 94$_6J4$H!/(&"! J$!,J4$! "'! &",)"! Y$);!

    L(6*K4;!,-5!/(&"!J$!,J4$!"'!'3$),"$!'Y$)!,!C65$!),-.$!'9!4',5&:!!P')!"#6&!

    5(";H! ,-! '3$-! *;*4$! .,&! "()J6-$! 6&! 65$,4:! ! ?-9')"(-,"$4;H! "#$;! ,)$!

    )$4,"6Y$4;! $_3$-&6Y$! Mk!1188iK=! ,**')56-.! "'! D

    MC#6*#!#,&!,!J'64$)!,-5!,!&"$,/!"()J6-$!,&&'*6,"$5!C6"#!,!*'-Y$-"6'-,4!

    .,&! "()J6-$:! !?-9')"(-,"$4;H!,!XX^U! 6&!/(*#! 4$&&! 94$_6J4$!,-5!#$-*$! 6"!

    *,--'"!J$!(&$5! "'!J,*K!(3!C6-5O:! !^,&! "()J6-$&!,)$! 46/6"$5! "'!J()-6-.!

    .,&! ')! 56$&$4! 9($4:! ! N6$&$4! 9($4! 6&! Y$);! $_3$-&6Y$! ,-5H! J$*,(&$! .,&!

    &(3346$)&!C,-"!"'!&(334;!.,&!*'-"6-('(&4;!),"#$)!"#,-!6-"$)/6""$-"4;H!"#$!

    .,&! &(334;! 9')! ,! .,&! "()J6-$! (&$5! 6-"$)/6""$-"4;! ,-5! (-3)$56*",J4;! 9')!

    J,*K(3! C'(45! ,4&'! J$! $_3$-&6Y$:! ! 0-! ,4"$)-,"6Y$! C'(45! J$! #;5)'I

    3(/3$5! &"'),.$! J("! ,&! B! B! K-'C! 9)'/!'"#$)! &"(56$&! B! #,Y$! *,))6$5! '("!

    "#,"!"#6&!C'(45!J$!$L(,44;!$_3$-&6Y$H!B!#,Y$!-'"!*'-&65$)$5!6"!9()"#$):!

    !

    b:A! U'! $&"6/,"$! "#$! 9($4! *'-&(/3"6'-! '9! "#$! .,&! "()J6-$&! B! #,Y$! ,&&(/$5!

    "#,"!"#$!.,&!"()J6-$!J,*K(3!*,3,*6";!C644!'-4;!J$!*,44$5!'-!5()6-.!@(-$H!

    @(4;!,-5!0(.(&"!C6-"$)!/'-"#&!C#$-!,44!,Y,64,J4$!#;5)'3'C$)!*,3,*6";!

    6&! '9"$-! -$$5$5! "'!/$$"! &;&"$/! 5$/,-5:! ! N()6-.! '"#$)! "6/$&H! B! #,Y$!

    ,&&(/$5!"#,"!#;5)'3'C$)!C'(45!J$!,J4$!"'!3)'Y65$!J,*K!(3:!!?-5$)!"#6&!

    ,&&(/3"6'-!,!.,&!"()J6-$!J,*K(3!C'(45!-$$5!"'!'3$),"$!4$&&!'9"$-!"#,-!

    69!6"!C$)$!"#$!&'4$!J,*K(3!9')!"#$!C6-53'C$)!&","6'-&:!!P')!"#,"!)$,&'-H!B!

    #,Y$!,&&(/$5!6-!/;!*,4*(4,"6'-&!"#,"!6"!C644!J$!6-!'3$),"6'-!'-4;!18e!'9!

    "#$! "6/$:! ! B! #,Y$! 9()"#$)! ,&&(/$5! "#,"! "#$! *'&"! '9! .$-$),"6'-! C644! J$!

    ! "(!

  • k8:78iK=#:! ! 0**')56-.! "'!/;! *,4*(4,"6'-&! "#$! -$$5! 9')! "#6&! ,/'(-"! '9!

    "#$)/,4!.$-$),"6'-!C644!/$,-!"#,"!"#$!C6-5!9,)/!6&!'-4;!aWe!)$-$C,J4$:!

    !

    b:Z! U#$!'C-$)!C644!$_3$*"!,!)$,&'-,J4$!)$"()-!'-!"#$!*,36",4!6-Y'4Y$5!,-5!6-!

    /;!*,4*(4,"6'-&!B!#,Y$!,&&(/$5!"#,"!"#$;!C'(45!)$L(6)$!,!)$"()-!'9!18e:!!

    B! "#6-K! "#6&! 6&! ,! )$,&'-,J4$! ),"$! '9! )$"()-! .6Y$-! "#,"! 469$! '9! "#$! C6-5!

    "()J6-$&! 6&!(-46K$4;! "'!J$!/')$! "#,-!78!;$,)&! M-'J'5;!K-'C&!C#,"! "#$!

    469$!6&!J$*,(&$!-'!C6-5!9,)/!(&6-.!/'5$)-!4,).$!/,*#6-$&!#,Y$!J$$-!6-!

    &$)Y6*$!9')!/')$!"#,-!9'()!')!96Y$!;$,)&:O! ! ! B"! 6&!,4&'!"#$!469$!(&$5!6-!"#$!

    D

    C644!(&$!"#$!4'-.!)(-!/,).6-,4!*'&"!J$*,(&$!6"!6&!56)$*"4;!$L(6Y,4$-"!"'!"#$!

    *'&"! B!#,Y$!,4)$,5;!*,4*(4,"$5! 9')!D)'`$*"![,;$&:! !U#$!#6.#$&"!*'&"!D

    D'C$)!#,Y$!*,4*(4,"$5!6&!18*iK=#!9')!,-!'3$-!*;*4$!.,&!"()J6-$!)(--6-.!

    '-!-,"(),4!.,&!6-!0(*K4,-5:!!!

    !

    c:A! d"#$)!*'&"&!,)$!a:7!*iK=#!9')!,!3'C$)!&","6'-!C6"#!Z88!+=!(-6"&!J()-6-.!

    E'("#4,-5!46.-6"$:!!0!1W8!+=!(-6"!J()-6-.!

    )$3')"O!

    !

    c:Z! D

    F,C$),(!&","6'-H!C#6*#!6&!,J'("!"'!J$!*'//6&&6'-$5H!"#$!$&"6/,"$!6&!`(&"!

    'Y$)! c! *$-"&iK=#:! ! P')! "#$! U,(#,),! &","6'-H! "#$! *'&"! $&"6/,"$! 6&! a:2!

    *$-"&iK=#:!

    !

    ! ")!

  • c:W! D

    "#$! &*#$/$&! "#$;!#,Y$! *'&"$5! ,"! 4$&&! "#,-!kA888iK=:! ! U'! .6Y$! ,! 9,6)!

    *'/3,)6&'-H! "#6&! -$$5&! "'! J$! *'/3,)$5! "'! "#$! *'&"! '9! D)'`$*"! [,;$&!

    "'.$"#$)! C6"#! "#$! AW8!+=! '9! J,*K(3! *,3,*6";! ! B9! C$! ,&&(/$! "#,"! "#$!

    $99$*"6Y$! '("3("! '9! D)'`$*"! [,;$&! 6&! W88! +=! ,-5! "#$! *'&"! 6&! k7H7cW!

    /6446'-H!"#$!$L(6Y,4$-"!*'&"!6&!kZWW8iK=!I!!W8e!/')$!"#,-!"#$!*'&"!'9!"#$!

    #;5)'! &","6'-:! ! 0! W88! +=! #;5)'! &","6'-! C'(45! '3$),"$! ,"! ,-! ,--(,4!

    *,3,*6";!9,*"')!'9!,"!4$,&"!W8e!&'!6"!C644!.$-$),"$!,J'("!7H788!^=#!3,!I!

    ,4/'&"! $_,*"4;! "#$! &,/$! ,&! D)'`$*"! [,;$&! "'.$"#$)! C6"#! 6"&! J,*K(3!

    .$-$),"6'-:! !U#$! 6-9')/,"6'-!,J'Y$!C,&!$-"$)$5! 6-"'!,! &3)$,5$$"! "'!

    *,4*(4,"$!"#$!*'&"!'9!.$-$),"6'-!9)'/!"#$!C6-5!9,)/H!"'!*,4*(4,"$!"#$!*'&"!

    '9!J,*K(3!&(334;!,-5! "'!*,4*(4,"$!,!Xd7! ",_! "#,"!C'(45!J$!-$$5$5! "'!

    J)6-.!"#$!*'&"!'9!.$-$),"6'-!9)'/!"#$!"#$)/,4!&","6'-&!$L(,4!"'!"#$!*'&"!'9!

    .$-$),"6'-!9)'/!"#$!C6-5!9,)/:!U#$!&3)$,5$$"! 6&!'C-!6-!Q_#6J6"&!c!

    ,-5!a:!

    !

    c:b! U#$!*'-*4(&6'-&!9)'/!"#6&!&3)$,5$$"!,)$f!

    !

    c:b:1! 0"! "#$! 3'6-"! '9! *'--$*"6'-! "'! "#$! .)65H! $4$*")6*6";! 9)'/! "#$! C6-5!

    9,)/!*'&"&!17:W!*iK=#!69!"#$!C6-5!9,)/!*'&"&!kA888iK=!,-5!1Z:A!

    *iK=#!,"!kAW88iK=:!

    !

    c:b:7! =#$-! )$,&'-,J4$! $&"6/,"$&! ,)$! /,5$! '9! "#$! *'&"! '9! ,! J,*K(3!

    .$-$),"6'-H! "),-&/6&&6'-! I! ,"! ,! *'-&$)Y,"6Y$!k! 188!/6446'-! I! ,-5!

    &;&"$/!'3$),"6'-!*'&"&!'9!kW!/6446'-!3$)!,--(/H! "#$!'Y$),44!*'&"!

    '9! .$-$),"6'-! 9)'/! "#$! C6-5! 9,)/! M"#$! *'&"! "#,"! "#$! $4$*")6*6";!

    *'-&(/$)&! C'(45! &$$O! 6&! 1W*iK=#! ,-5! 1b:W! *iK=#! 9')! "#$! "C'!

    *,36",4!*'&"&!,J'Y$:!

    !

    c:b:A! B9! "#$!J,*K(3!.$-$),"6'-! 6&!3)'Y65$5!J;!'3$-!*;*4$!.,&!"()J6-$&H!!

    "#$;! C'(45! .$-$),"$! A8c! ^=#:! ,-5! ,-5H! ,&! ,! )$&(4"H! "#$! C6-5!

    9,)/!'("3("!C644!J$!'-4;!aWe!)$-$C,J4$!$-$).;:!U#$!.,&!"()J6-$&!

    C644! $/6"! 1aZH888! "'--$&!'9! *,)J'-!56'_65$!$,*#! ;$,):! ! B9! "#6&! 6&!

    Y,4($5!,"!kW8i"'--$H!"#$!Xd7!",_!3,;,J4$!C'(45!J$!k2!/6446'-!3$)!

    ! "*!

  • ,--(/:! ! U#6&! 6-*)$,&$&! "#$! *'&"! '9! .$-$),"6'-! J("! B! #,Y$! -'"!

    6-*4(5$5!6-!/;!*,4*(4,"6'-&:!

    !

    c:b:Z! X,4*(4,"6'-&! "'! 5$"$)/6-$! "#$! J)$,K! $Y$-! Xd7! ",_! 'C! "#,"H!

    *'/3,)$5!"'!"#$!,4"$)-,"6Y$!46.-6"$H!*',4!,-5!.,&I96)$5!.$-$),"6'-H!

    "#$! ,--(,4! *'&"! '9! C6-5! 3'C$)! 6&! #6.#$)! J;! k1b8! /6446'-H! k1Z1!

    /6446'-!,-5!k1bW!/6446'-!)$&3$*"6Y$4;:! B-!3$)*$-",.$!"$)/&!3'C$)!

    9)'/!D)'`$*"![,;$&! 6&!ZWeH!A2e!,-5!Zbe!/')$!$_3$-&6Y$! "#,-!

    "#$! *'&"! '9! "#6&! "#$)/,4! .$-$),"6'-:! U#$!Xd7! ",_! -$*$&&,);! 9')!

    J)$,K!$Y$-!J$"C$$-!"#$)/,4!,-5!D)'`$*"![,;$&!6&!kbaH!ka8H!,-5!

    k127!3$)!"'--$!)$&3$*"6Y$4;:!

    !

    c:c! B! *'-*4(5$! "#,"! 69! D)'`$*"![,;$&! 3)'*$$5&! 6"! .$-$),"$&! Y$);! $_3$-&6Y$!

    $4$*")6*6";!*'/3,)$5!"'!"#$!,4"$)-,"6Y$&!,Y,64,J4$!"'!+$)656,-:!

    !!

    VEF& -@:B8H?=@:?W&

    !

    a:1! U#$! *'&"! $&"6/,"$5! J;! +$)656,-! 6&! C$44! J$4'C! *'&"&! $&",J46$5! J;!

    *'-"),*"&! 9')!&6/64,)!C6-5! 9,)/&! "#,"!#,Y$!J$$-!34,*$5!'Y$)&$,&! 6-! "#$!

    4,&"!9$C!/'-"#&:!!!

  • a:Z! U'! /,K$! "#$! *'&"! '9! $4$*")6*6";! 9)'/! ,! 46.-6"$! 96)$5! 3'C$)! &","6'-!

    *'/3,),J4$!C6"#!D)'`$*"![,;$&H!,!*,)J'-!56'_65$! MXd7O! ",_!'9!,"! 4$,&"!

    kbai"'--$!'9!Xd7!6&!-$$5$5:!

    !

    a:W! U'! /,K$! "#$! *'&"! '9! $4$*")6*6";! 9)'/! ,! .,&! 96)$5! 3'C$)! &","6'-!

    *'/3,),J4$!C6"#!D)'`$*"![,;$&H!,!Xd7!",_!'9!/')$! "#,-!k128i"'--$! 6&!

    -$$5$5:!

    !

    a:b! D)'`$*"![,;$&j! *'-")6J("6'-! "'! &(334;6-.! $-$).;! ,-5! "'! &(334;6-.! 3$,K!

    5$/,-5!5()6-.!,!5);!;$,)!C644!J$! 4$&&!"#,-!6-!,!-')/,4!;$,)!,-5!/(*#!

    4$&&!"#,-!C'(45!J$!,*#6$Y$5!J;!*'-Y$-"6'-,4!&","6'-&:!!

    !

    a:c! B9!"#$!bA8!+=!D)'`$*"![,;$&!C,&!J,*K$5!(3!J;!AW8!+=!'9!'3$-!*;*4$!

    .,&! "()J6-$&! 6"! C'(45! J$! )'(.#4;! $L(6Y,4$-"! "'! ,! *'-Y$-"6'-,4! 3'C$)!

    &","6'-!),"$5!,"!W88!+=:!!

  • ! "!

    Exhibit 1

    Exhibit 2

  • ! #!

    Exhibit 3

    Exhibit 4

  • ! $!

    Exhibit 5

    Carbon tax Calcs Lignite Coal Gas CCGT

    Annual generation 2357 2357 2357 GWh

    CO2 from thermal station 1.00 0.75 0.365 kg/kWh

    CO2 from thermal station 2,357,000 1,767,750 860,305 Tonnes

    Cost of power from thermal (PB report) 8.2 9 8 c/kWh

    Cost of power from thermal $193 $212 188.56 $m pa

    Cost of power from wind at 15 c/kWh $354 $354 $354 $m pa

    Premium paid for wind $160 $141 $165 $m pa

    Carbon price for breakeven 68 80 192 $/tonne

    Exhibit 7

  • ! %!

    Exhibit 9

  • ! &!

    Exhibit 6

  • !

    "

    !"#$%&'(&)*

    +",%

    -.-/

    /.

    01

    23

    45

    6/7

    //

    /.

    /0

    /1

    /2

    /3

    /4

    /5

    /6

    .7

    #$%&'(!)&*+,-

    ./01

    ./01

    ./01

    ./01

    ./01

    2201

    2201

    2201

    2201

    2201

    2201

    2201

    3101

    3101

    3101

    3101

    3101

    3101

    3101

    310145(6&78&9(:;5&5;9(5)

    <=9>)=?&$

    $%&'(!)!&&*6

    @A1BB11

    /30C

    /30C

    /30C

    /30C

    /30C

    /10D

    /10D

    /10D

    /10D

    /10D

    /10D

    /10D

    2@0D

    2@0D

    2@0D

    2@0D

    2@0D

    2@0D

    2@0D

    2@0D<=9>)=?&'(!)&*2111&E&321

    FG'(6;&H5(6&/1C1&I-J&*6&"

    /.83

    /CD02/CD02/CD02/CD02/CD02/CD02/CD02/CD02/CD02/CD02/CD02/CD02/CD02/CD02/CD02/CD02/CD02/CD02/CD02/CD02I-JK9(:;5&95>';+B111&'+,-J

    <=!J&H?(:&*6

    L@A1LBB11/2B0D/2B0D/2B0D/2B0D/2B0D/2@0C/2@0C/2@0C/2@0C/2@0C/2@0C/2@0C//10C//10C//10C//10C//10C//10C//10C//10C

    FMM

    B101/N

    O>!'(PG)&5=);

    B1011N

    Q)&*2C11+&,-R&9(:;5&'(!)&>!&B.02&';G)!

    S7T&/1&U5!

    */0BA*6

    9&(:;<,$=>';,*?;

    (%,*#@

    #&)*;"($

    /.

    01

    23

    45

    6/7

    //

    /.

    /0

    /1

    /2

    /3

    /4

    /5

    /6

    .7

    <=9>)=?&$

    $%&'(!)!&&*6

    @A1BB11

    /30C

    /30C

    /30C

    /30C

    /30C

    /10D

    /10D

    /10D

    /10D

    /10D

    /10D

    /10D

    2@0D

    2@0D

    2@0D

    2@0D

    2@0D

    2@0D

    2@0D

    2@0D<=9>)=?&'(!)&*2111&E&321

    8=',P9&2C1&%-

    B2C

    /C1

    210@

    210@

    210@

    210@

    210@

    210@

    210@

    210@

    210@

    210@

    210@

    210@

    210@

    210@

    210@

    210@

    210@

    210@

    210@

    210@2C1&%-&"&*BB11+,-&B1N&<4&*/11+%-J

    V5=G!6>!!>(G&=GW&!U!);6&(9;5=)>(G&'(!)

    /C

    @C

    C01

    C01

    C01

    C01

    C01

    C01

    C01

    C01

    C01

    C01

    C01

    C01

    C01

    C01

    C01

    C01

    C01

    C01

    C01

    C0145;XP;G'U&,;;9>GY&;)'

    FG'(6;&*6&Z/1C1&[21@&I-J\&

    /287

    2C2032C2032C2032C2032C2032C2032C2032C2032C2032C2032C2032C2032C2032C2032C2032C2032C2032C2032C2032C203I-JK9(:;5&95>';+B111

    <=!J&H?(:&*6&

    LAC1LB./C/AB0./AB0./AB0./AB0./AB0./A@0B/A@0B/A@0B/A@0B/A@0B/A@0B/A@0B/D10B/D10B/D10B/D10B/D10B/D10B/D10B/D10B

    FMM

    B101CN

    O>!'(PG)&5=);

    B1011N

    Q)&*2C11+&,-R&9(:;5&'(!)&>!&B30C&';G)!

    S7T&/1&U5!

    *@0.B*6

    <(69=5=]?;&'(!)&(H&^=U;!

    .CC1*+,-VJ>!&'(!)&;E'?PW;!&)5=G!6>!!>(G&=GW&!U!);6&(9;5=)>(G&'(!)!&];'=P!;&()J;5&95(_;')!&:>??&>G'P5&!(6;&'(!)!&(H&)J>!&)U9;

    A,%<)*;(,B;C)%;<,$=>';D"*"%,(&)*

    QGGP=?&<#/&&"&03,Y+,-J

    BD./11V(GG;!

    7;5';G)&5;G;:=]?;

    DCN

    <=5](G&V=E&"&*C1+)(GG;&*6

    *A

    EB:&<&(;5