Mykola Nykholat, A087 261 881 (BIA June 3, 2011)

8/13/2019 Mykola Nykholat, A087 261 881 (BIA June 3, 2011)

1/12

Cardinale, Caridad Pastor, Esq.525 E Big Beave Road Suite 206

Toy, Ml 480830000

Name:NYKHOLAT,MYKOLA

Dpam

Executive Oce r Immiation Review

Bd Immg AppOc h Ck

5107Leburg Pike. Site 2000Falls Church Vina 204/

HS/ICE Oice of Chief Counse DET333 Mt. Eliott St., Rm 204Detroit,Ml 4827

A087-261881

Date of this notice:6/3/2011

Encosed is a copy of the Board's decision and order in the above-rerence case.

Encosure

Panel Members:Pauey, Roger

Sincerey

Donna CaChef Clerk

Cite as: Mykola Nykholat, A087 261 881 (BIA June 3, 2011)


2/12

NKOAT MKOAA 087261881100 EAST SECONDMONROE Ml 48161

Name:NKOAT,MKOA

Dpam

xecutve Oce r mgraton Revew

Bd Immg AppOc h Ck

50 bug k, Su 2000as Chuch, Vna 2204

S/CE Oice of Chief Cousel DET333 Mt Eliott St. Rm 204Detoit M 48207

A087261881

Date of this otice:6/3/2011

Enclosed is a copy of the Board's decisio n the above-refeeced case. Ths copy is beigprovded to you as a cortesy. Yor attoey or repesentatve has bee seed with thsdecision psuat to C.F.R 1292S(a) If the attached decso odes that yo be emovedfrom the Uited tates or affrms a mmigatio Judges decso odeng that yo beemoved, any petton fo eview of the attached decsion mst be fled with ad eceived by theapoate cout of aeas wthi 3 days of the date of te decsion.

ncosure

Pane MebersPauey Roger

nlv

D C

Donna CaChe Cerk



3/12

US Department of JuiceExecuv Oc r Ingaon Rviw

Fas Chrch, Virga22 41

Fie: A087 261 881 - Deoit, M

I re MYKOLA NYKHOLAT

IN MOVA PROCEEDGS

APPEAL AND MOION

Dcison of th Board ofmgaton Appals

Date JUN 3 201

ON BEHALF OF RESONDE Cdad Pastor Crdinae, Esquire

ON BEHALF OF DHS

CHARGENoce: Sec

Brian C BurgtorfAsssant Chef Consel

23(a)(2)(A)(), I&N Act [8 US.C 1227(a)(2)(A)(] Convicted of wo or more crimes invoving moral urpitude

The respodent, a native ad citizen of kraine, hs appealed om te Immiato Jdge'sdecision dated eb 24, 201 On appea, he respondet moves to termnate proceedings or,ateatvey, to remd e record r her proceedings he Depent of Homeld Secydoes not oppose teation he moton to tenate w e anted

d y he Immiato Judge, he respodent was admted to he nted Sates as asdent on August 0, 2005, and is status w subsequenty adjusted to tat ofa codtoal residenton March 6, 2009 On ue 16, 2010, the respodet ws convcted of two cous o "rceny$20000 or more in vioao ofMicig Comped aws secion 750356( 4)(a) The Immiationdge detened that e respodets convictios were r two disinct cres nvoving moraurpude not rising out of a singe scheme of crimina isconduc, and hs und that herespondent was subject to remov as chged Te respondet has now sumed evdece to show

that he ws aowed to widrw is gui pea to the vioaions ofM.C 50356( 4)(a) d entera guly pea to two coun of msdemeor etering wihot permsson in violato o MCL 5015(1) e wo count under MCL 750356()(a) were dsmissed, eectivey vacaighis convctons r ceny The respondent gues hat his convctons r enterig cot be

considered convicion r crimes invovng mo iude ecause MC.L 5015(1) does otrequre he oense to e accompnied by itent to commt a morally utdous crme. Weee. See Matter of M &N Dec , 3 A 946 (an oene nvovng breg deterig or espass may e deemed to ivove mora rpude oy f accompned by the ntent tocot a moray tudinous act aer eny; Matter G 1 I&N Dec 403, 40-06 BA 193see alo Matter fLuiant, 24 &N Dec 75 (BA 2009) (dsngushng moray tupudousorda residenal burg sttute om New York burga satute in ater o



4/12

,

A08761 881

As moral ud cg s sol ound r rmova n s cas r now xss nobass r connung hs prc rr, moon o na procdngs wll bd

Accordngy, h llowng ordrs wll b nrd

ORDER moon s grand

URER ORDER procdngs nad

FOR T BO

2



5/12

. S. t: ARE OF JUSICEXCUIV OFF1E FOR IGRAION RVIW

IMMIGION COUR

Deroi Michigan

File A 87 26 88 Dae: Febrary 24 20

e Mtter o

MYOA NYHO

CHARG:

APPICAION:

APPCS

REMOVA PROCDIGS

Secion 237(a) (2) (A) (ii) o he Immigraionand aionaliy Ac as amended aeradmission conviced o wo or more crimesinvolving moral rpide no incldingpoliical oenses

None

O BHAF OF RESPODE O BEHF OF H DPARMOF HOMAD SECURIY:

Carrie PasorCardinale sqire525 . Big Beaver Road Sie 206roy MI 48083

Brian C. Brgorf EsqireAssisan Chief Consel333 Mon ElioDeroi MI 8207

O DCISO OF H IIGIO JUDG

he Responden is a male who is a naive and ciizen o

he Uraine. he Deparmen of Homeland Secriy HS) iniiaed

proceedings again Responden prsan o ahoriy conained in


6/12

Seion 240 o he Immigraion and Naionaliy A {hereinaer

"A) . he insan proeedings were ommened wih he Cor by

he iling o he Noie o Appear. See Exhibi ; 8 C. F. R.

003. 4(a) .

A a hearing beore he Cor he Responden has

admied reeip o he Noie o Appear rom he Deparmen o

Homeland Seriy and ha has been admied as noed as Exhibi

#.

he Responden hrogh onsel has admied as alleged

in he Noie o Appear ha he is no a iizen or naional o

he Unied Saes b raher a naive and iizen o he Uraine.

he Responden admied as alleged on he Noie o Appear ha he

ame o he Unied Saes a New Yor on or abo Ags 0 o

2005 as a nonimmigran sden who was admied or he draion

o his sas in he Unied Saes. Responden rher admied

ha on Marh 6 2009 his sas was adjsed o ha o a

ondiional permanen residen nder Seion 245 o he

Immigraion and aionaliy A

he Responden denied onviion on Jne 6 200 in

he 6h Ciri Cor in Mon Clemens Mihigan or he oense

o lareny nder $200 b more han $ 000 in violaion o

Mihigan bylaws (MC} 75. 564A he Responden rher dened

ha he viim in ha ase was a Fran DiMerrio. he

Responden rher denied ha on ha same dae in ha same

or he was onvied o a seond ofense o lareny of $200 or

A 8 26 88 2 Febrary 24 20


7/12

ore b less han $ 000 again in violaion o MC 750 3564A in

ha case involving a vicim Alexander Posis The Responden

denied reovabiliy nder Secion 237(a) (2) (A) (ii) o he Ac.

The Deparmen o Homeland Secriy has he brden o

esablishing removabiliy nder Secion 237 charges by clear and

convincing evidence. See Secion 240(c (3) In he insan case

he Deparmen o Hoeland Secriy has sbmied in sppor o

boh he acal allegaions and he charges o reoval cerain

docenaion o esablish he charges. See xhibi 2. The

Deparmen has sbied a Ceriied Record o he Macomb Cony

Circi Cor which esablishes ha by vire o he

docmenaion ha he Responden was senenced oowing a plea

o nolo conendere o wo cons nder MC 750. 3564A and or ha

oense was senenced o a er o imprisonen o one day wih a

year o probaion as well as he reqireen o coss and ees.

See xhibi 2 circi cor senence disposiion. The record

relecs ha he Responden on Jly o 2008 did comi he

oense o larceny agains a Fran DiMercrio. See xhibi 2

elony inormaion The inoraion binding he Responden over

rher esabishes ha a second oense was comied agains an

Alexander Posis and added Cons II wih a redcion o charge

rom he ore serios chages o larceny o 000 or ore b less

han 20 000 and aeped larceny agains he wo named

individals were redced prsan o agreeen. See xhibi 2

senence disposiion.

A 87 26 88 3 Febrary 24 20


8/12

The Governmen has he brden o proving ha he wo

separae crimes were no par o a singe scheme ee

Maer o C 9 I&N Dec 524 BIA 962 The Governmen rher

has o esabish ha boh crimes were in ac crimes invoving

mora rpide Hamdin v. IN 98 F3d 83 5h Cr 996 he

norma inerence o be drawn rom dieren crimes commied a

dieren crimes agains dieren persons is ha hey were

separae and disinc oenses and no par o a common scheme or

pan ness here is evidence o he conrary Maer o s- 9

I&N Dec 63 BIA 962 . In he insan case he Responden is

charged wih arceny agains wo dieren individas and whie

i appears ha hey invove simiar iems each o he crimes is

a separae and disinc crime ven hogh he ac ha hey are

simiar in characer and oowed cosey in ime makes no

dierence in consideraion where here are wo separae and

disinc crimes invoving as i does here separae iems o

separae persons Maer o D 5 I&N Dec 728 BIA 954

Becase an aien commis a crime and repeas he oense does no

oow ha he oenses were indeed par o a singe scheme even

hogh he crimes are simiar Repeiion o a paricar crime

wod no generay consie a singe scheme Maer o J 6

I&N Dec 382 BIA 954

Mora rpide does no have a cear deiniion and

individa cases ms be considered on heir meris in igh o

Board preceden as we as he appropriae circi cors he

A 87 26 88 4 Febrary 24 20


9/12

oard has held ha a crime involves moral rpiude when i is an

a o aseness vileness or depraviy in he privae soial

dies which man owes o his ellow man or o sociey . . . a

rime involves moral rpide when is nare is sch ha i

maniess pon he par o he perperaor personal depraviy or

aseness. Maer o E-, 2 I&N De. 34 (BIA A G. 944) ;

Maer o loan 2 I&N Dec. 84 (BIA 9; A. G. 98) ;

Maer o Awaijane 4 I&N Dec 7 (BIA 972) . he oard hasheld ha in deermining wheher a crime involves moral rpide

he Cor ms consider wheher he ac is accompanied y a

viios moive or orrp mind A crime y is very nare as

deined y he sae involve an evil inen eore a crime i

moral rpide is jsiied In oher words he crime ms e a

crime which is malm en se as opposed o malm prohiim.

Maer o E- 2 I&N Dec. 34 supra Maer o P 3 I&N De. 5(BIA 948) ; Maer o Awaijane supra.

he Responden has een charged wih a rime involving

moral rpide whih involves he oenses whih have een

radiionally ond o consie moral rpide. ee

Ooro v. IN 25 F. 3d 92 (5h Cir. 997) ; Maer o Alarcon 2

I&N Dec. 557 (IA 992) ; Maer o im 7 I&N De. 44 (BIA 977)

(arceny is a crime involvin mora rpide ; Maer o Grazley,4 I&N De. 33 (BIA 973)

he elemens o he oense involved nder MC 75. 354A

do involve ha he Responden commied he oense o larceny y

A 87 2 88 5 Ferary 24 2


10/12

seaing iems wihin e range o he vales expressed in he

sae The Cor hereore inds a oh crimes here involve

moral rpide and her inds ha he charge o removailiy

nder Secion 237(a (2) (A (ii o he Ac is ssained y clear

and convincing evidence.

The Responden has designaed he Ukraine as he conry

o which removal wold e direced. The Responden rogh

consel has indicaed ha ere is no ear o rern o ha

conry. The sole reqes or reie in is case is or a

coninance o prse a collaeral aack on he nderlying

convicions. The DHS opposes a coninance or a collaeral

aack on convicions. Whie a coninance may e graned or

good case and in he Cor's discreion he Responden in is

case has a his poin no nderlying relie availae o him. He

as expressed no rees or relie having wihdrawn his rees

or volnary deparre. The Cor is cognizan o he ac ha

he Responden has a Unied Saes ciizen wie pon which his

condiional residency was graned as well as a child orn o he

marriage. everheless despie ese eiies Responden has

wo very recen convicions or he oenses and he Cor will

decline o exercise is disceion o gran a coninance or he

sole ppose o a collaeral aack on nderlying conicions when

here is no evidence o a likelihood o a poenial sccess on he

meris. The reqes or coninance is hereore denied

For he oregoing reasons ased pon all he evidence

A 87 26 88 6 Ferary 24 20


11/12

[. -( .

of record whether specifically enumerated in this decision or not,

the folowing order will be enteed.

ORDER

IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that the Respondent shall be

removed and deported from the United States to the Ukraine on the

charge contained in the Notice to Appear

:

A 87 261 881

ELIZABETH A HACKE

Imigration Judge

7 Februay 24, 2011


12/12

CERTIFICATE PAGE

Documents

Mykola Nykholat, A087 261 881 (BIA June 3, 2011)