MBSE and the Business of Engineering - ElysiumTitle: MBSE and the Business of Engineering Author: Terrence J. McGowan Created Date: 9/20/2016 10:39:31 AMelysiuminc.com/gpdis/2016/Tuesday-Presentations/... ·

BOEING is a trademark of Boeing Management Company

Copyright © 2016 Boeing. All rights reserved.

Copyright © 2014 Northrop Grumman Corporation. All rights reserved.

GPDIS_2016.ppt | 1

MBSE and the

Business of

Engineering

John SperlingVP Product ManagementAras Corporation

Global Product Data Interoperability Summit | 2016




GPDIS_2016.ppt | 2

My Background

Autonetics

Strategic

Systems

Division

Space

Systems

Division

Integrated

Defense

Systems

Y2K





GPDIS_2016.ppt | 3

Agenda

• The Business of Engineering

• Challenges of product complexity

• The Return of Systems Engineering

• Aras MBSE-PLM Reference Architecture

• Aras/XPLM Prototype

aras.com

© 2016 Aras





GPDIS_2016.ppt | 4

aras.com

Adapted from: Aerospace & Defense Industry PLM Value Gap Survey, CIMdata, March 2013

Legacy PDM has failed to meet the vision

Cap

ab

ility

/ V

alu

e

1990 2000 2010 2020 2030

Implementations

Technology

Vision

© 2016 Aras





GPDIS_2016.ppt | 5

The Science of Engineering

© 2016 Arasaras.com

MCAX PDM





GPDIS_2016.ppt | 6

• Electronics• Electrical• Software• Manuals• Packaging• Services• IoT• Manufacturing• Phase-Gate• Cost• BOM• Quality• Supply Chain• Compliance• Variants-Options

• Mechanical

Investment is not balanced with new reality






GPDIS_2016.ppt | 7

The Business of Engineering


Concept Development Manufacturing Field

Software

Mechanical

Electrical

Electronic

MCAX PDM

System

Product

Requirements, System Engineering

Configuration and Change Management – EBOM/MBOM/SBOM, Variants & Options

ECAD PDM,

Component Engineering

ALM

Manuf. Planning

Quality Planning

& Systems

Work Instructions

User Manuals

Service

Manuals

Catalogs

IOT Analytics

MBSE,

Simulation





GPDIS_2016.ppt | 8

“The PLM Underground”Where the work actually gets done

aras.com© 2016 Aras

Specs

Process

Plan

DFMEA

Work

Instr.Req’ts

Project

Plans

BOMs

Tech Pubs

PFMEA





GPDIS_2016.ppt | 9

Agenda






aras.com

© 2016 Aras





GPDIS_2016.ppt | 10

Product complexity is increasingAnd creating challenges

aras.com

Product Complexity

Time

Mechanical – 2D

Electrical

Electronic

Software

Systems

Connected

SE/MBSE

Product as a Service

Mechatronics

Mechanical – 3D

© 2016 Aras





GPDIS_2016.ppt | 11

aras.com

Managing design integrityAs role of software increases

© 2016 Aras





GPDIS_2016.ppt | 12

Coordinating outsourced activitiesAvoiding conflicts in design/manufacture/support






GPDIS_2016.ppt | 13

Ensuring operational safetyMaintaining context for IoT data and connected products

aras.com

Engine Health Management (EHM)Rolls-Royce uses EHM to track the health of thousands of engines operating worldwide, using onboard sensors and live satellite feeds

Over The Air Updates (OTA)OTA software updates will not only affect your infotainment system but also power train and vehicle safety systems

© 2016 Aras





GPDIS_2016.ppt | 14

Managing complianceConforming to regulations, managing risks and liability






GPDIS_2016.ppt | 15

Innovation without Limitation

Not just about building a faster mousetrap

• Packaging, Labeling, Compliance?

• Limiting Liability?

• Serviceability, Manufacturability, and Profit!

Innovation is not just about the Product!

The Business of Engineering needs Systems Level

Thinking






GPDIS_2016.ppt | 16

Agenda











GPDIS_2016.ppt | 17

SE spans many tools, domains, & data models

© 2016 Aras aras.com

Domain specific designs

Behavior part of every design step





GPDIS_2016.ppt | 18

Connecting MBSE to Design domains in PLM


OK, but how

?





GPDIS_2016.ppt | 19

Cross-domain Connectors

© 2015 Aras

MCAD – explicit

• MCAD file = PLM Part/Assembly (BOM)

• MCAD files mapped to PLM Parts

ECAD – extractable

• ECAD file PLM Part/Assembly (BOM)

• Components mapped to PLM Parts

Embedded Software – indirect

• IDE files PLM Part/Assembly (BOM)

• Released binary mapped to PLM Part(s)

System – TBD

• Requirements?

• Block diagrams (functional & logical)?

• Models as input, Reports as outputs?

Natural fit with PLM

Challenge with mapping files to PLM parts

Reference Architecture with Airbus & IBM

Similar to ECAD schematics?Explicit SysML data model?

It will take more finesse than this!

CAD

Connector

ECAD

Connector

ALM

Connector





GPDIS_2016.ppt | 20

“Holy Grail” of PLM


AS DELIVEREDAS BUILTAS PLANNEDAS ORDEREDAS DESIGNEDLOGICALFUNCTIONALREQUIRED AS SERVICED

R2

R7

R3

R8

R5

R6

R4

R9

R10

R11

F2

F8

F6

F4

F11

F10

F12

F9

F5

F7

F3

L2

L7

L3

L8

L5

L6

L4

L9

L10

B

C

FE

D

G

IH

K

M

O

L

J

B

C

F

D

G

IH

J

K

O

L

P1

C

F

D

P2

IH

J

K

O

L

G

T

C

F

D

I

J

K

O

L

G

T

SN #89

SN #44

C

F

D

H

J

K

O

L

G

T

SN #89

SN #44

C

F

D

H

J

K

O

L

G

T

SN #97

SN #44

R14

R13 F13

Q

R

S

Q

R

S

Q

R

SQ

R

S

R

S

QSN #53

AAAAA SN #6 SN #6

Q SN #71 SN #71

R

S

L11

F15

F14

F16

F1 L1R1

R12

AA SN #6





GPDIS_2016.ppt | 21

System Model structures in PLM


AS DELIVEREDAS BUILTAS PLANNEDAS ORDEREDAS DESIGNEDLOGICALFUNCTIONALREQUIRED AS SERVICED

R2

R7

R3

R8

R5

R6

R4

R9

R10

R11

F2

F8

F6

F4

F11

F10

F12

F9

F5

F7

F3

L2

L7

L3

L8

L5

L6

L4

L9

L10

B

C

FE

D

G

IH

K

M

O

L

J

B

C

F

D

G

IH

J

K

O

L

P1

C

F

D

P2

IH

J

K

O

L

G

T

C

F

D

I

J

K

O

L

G

T

SN #89

SN #44

C

F

D

H

J

K

O

L

G

T

SN #89

SN #44

C

F

D

H

J

K

O

L

G

T

SN #97

SN #44

R14

R13 F13

Q

R

S

Q

R

S

Q

R

SQ

R

S

R

S

QSN #53

AAAAA SN #6 SN #6

Q SN #71 SN #71

R

S

L11

F15

F14

F16

F1 L1R1

R12

AA SN #6

SysML

tool

connector

PLM manages evolution of physical

structures - with strong configuration

and change management control





GPDIS_2016.ppt | 22

Agenda






aras.com

© 2016 Aras





GPDIS_2016.ppt | 23

RFLP - Collaboration and Traceability


From/Toa SysML item

From/Toa physical part

Magic Draw Aras PLM SOLIDWORKS





GPDIS_2016.ppt | 24

System Models & PLM


Software

ALM

Mechanical

CAD

Electronic

CAD

System

Model

“Small” SEs

“Big” SE

SE/MBSE ALM/CAD/MBSEPLM – Product and Systems Engineering (SE & MBSE)





GPDIS_2016.ppt | 25

Add SysML structures

aras.com

SE

Logical

SE

Requirements

Created by

connector

© 2016 Aras

System

Model

Software

ALM

Mechanical

CAD

Electronic

CAD





GPDIS_2016.ppt | 26

Add Requirements decomposition

aras.com

SE

Logical

SE

Requirements

Each domain has its

own requirements

breakdown

MCAD

Requirements

ECAD

Requirements

© 2016 Aras

System

Model

ALM

Requirements

Software

ALM

Mechanical

CAD

Electronic

CAD

Referenced

automatically

or manually

via

connectors





GPDIS_2016.ppt | 27

Add Logical to Physical

aras.com

MCAD

Structure

ECAD

Structure

SE

Logical

SE

Requirements

MCAD

Requirements

ECAD

Requirements

Linked by connectors

or manually within

PLM

(a diagram-like visual

drag/drop process?)

© 2016 Aras

System

Model

Software

ALM

Mechanical

CAD

Electronic

CAD

ALM

StructureALM

Requirements

Not really “physical”





GPDIS_2016.ppt | 28

Add multiple models

aras.com

MCAD

Structure

ECAD

Structure

SE

Logical

SE

Requirements

SE

Logical

SE

Requirements

ALM

StructureALM

Requirements

MCAD

Requirements

ECAD

Requirements

Multiplicity of

SE models as

part of the same

PLM structure

© 2016 Aras

Software

ALM

Mechanical

CAD

Electronic

CAD

System

Model_1

System

Model_n





GPDIS_2016.ppt | 29

Add simulation data

aras.com

MCAD

Structure

ECAD

Structure

SE

Logical

SE

Requirements

SE

Logical

SE

Requirements

ALM

StructureALM

Requirements

MCAD

Requirements

ECAD

Requirements

© 2016 Aras

Software

ALM

Mechanical

CAD

Electronic

CAD

System

Model_1

System

Model_n





GPDIS_2016.ppt | 30

Add “System” properties (data/control flow)

aras.com

MCAD

Structure

ECAD

Structure

SE

Logical

SE

Requirements

SE

Logical

SE

Requirements

ALM

StructureALM

Requirements

MCAD

Requirements

ECAD

Requireme

nts

Created/linked by

connectors or manually

within PLM (a diagram-like

visual drag/drop process?)

© 2016 Aras

Software

ALM

Mechanical

CAD

Electronic

CAD

System

Model_1

System

Model_n





GPDIS_2016.ppt | 31

Properties are cross-domain negotiable “Contracts”

aras.com

Item A

Property x Property y

Item B

• Linked between any two structural items

• Value, range, enumerated list

• Units

• Fixed or a target (a budget)

• A domain owner

• On a structural item or accumulative for

an assembly

• Transformation function on a property link

• Created/linked by connectors or manually

(a diagram-like visual drag/drop process

within PLM?)

f(x) = y

f(y) = x

Makes Requirements

quantifiable and PLM

SE structures

behavioral

© 2016 Aras





GPDIS_2016.ppt | 32

Add Logical to Logical

aras.com

MCAD

Structure

ECAD

Structure

SE

Logical

SE

Requirements

SE

Logical

SE

Requirements

ALM

Structure

© 2016 Aras

ALM

Logical

MCAD

Logical

ECAD

Logical

Connectors extract

Logical block

abstractions per

domain

System

Model_1

System

Model_n

Software

ALM

Mechanical

CAD

Electronic

CAD





GPDIS_2016.ppt | 33

Enable Negotiations

aras.com

MCAD

Structure

ECAD

Structure

SE

Logical

SE

Requirements

SE

Logical

SE

Requirements

ALM

Structure

© 2016 Aras

ALM

Logical

MCAD

Logical

ECAD

Logical

Space to negotiate

“Contracts” on a

Logical block level

Software

ALM

Mechanical

CAD

Electronic

CAD

System

Model_1

System

Model_n





GPDIS_2016.ppt | 34

aras.com

Complex relationships via comprehendible views in context

SysML Graphs approach

© 2016 Aras





GPDIS_2016.ppt | 35

Agenda






aras.com

© 2016 Aras





GPDIS_2016.ppt | 36

Demo video






GPDIS_2016.ppt | 37

Business of Engineering

© 2016 Aras

aras.com

Continuous System & Product design process

PLMDigital Twin & Digital Thread configuration management





GPDIS_2016.ppt | 38

Partnering with

• TU Kaiserslautern: Proof of

Concept (MagicDraw)

• Airbus/IBM/Aras: OSLC-

based ALM/PLM integration

• XPLM/No Magic: MagicDraw

integration (MBSE/SysML)

• Aras/Altium: Bringing ECAD

into MBSE

© 2016 Aras

aras.com





GPDIS_2016.ppt | 39

Acknowledgements

© 2016 Aras

aras.com

• Airbus

• IBM

• Dr. Eigner, TU Kaiserslautern

• Dr. Zhang, AVIC

• Altium

• No Magic

• ProSTEP

• INCOSE

• OMG

• OASIS

• XPLM

Documents

MBSE and the Business of Engineering - ElysiumTitle: MBSE and the Business of Engineering Author: Terrence J. McGowan Created Date: 9/20/2016 10:39:31 AMelysiuminc.com/gpdis/2016/Tuesday-Presentations/... ·