46
MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair Department of Radiation Oncology University of Lübeck, Germany

MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASESFocusing on radiotherapy

Dirk Rades, MD

Professor and Chair

Department of Radiation Oncology

University of Lübeck, Germany

Page 2: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

Limited number of lesions (1-3 / 1-4) ~40%

Multiple lesions (≥ 4 / ≥ 5) ~60%

In 20-40% of adult cancer patients

BRAIN METASTASES

Page 3: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

Median Survival Time:

Untreated ~ 1 month

Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

WBRT alone Mostly 3-6 months

► Short Overall Treatment Time

MULTIPLE LESIONS: PROGNOSIS

Page 4: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

20 x 2 Gy (4 weeks) or 15 x 2.5 Gy (3 weeks)

10 x 3 Gy (2 weeks)

MULTIPLE LESIONS:

FRACTIONATION OF WBRT

Rades D, et al., Cancer. 2007;110:1345–50

Overall Survival

p-valueat 6 months at 12 months

10 x 3 Gy (N=257) 33% 20%

Higher doses (N=159) 29% 18% 0.86

Local Control

p-valueat 6 months at 12 months

10 x 3 Gy (N=257) 39% 24%

Higher doses (N=159) 41% 30% 0.61

Page 5: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

10 x 3 Gy (2 weeks)

5 x 4 Gy (1 week)

MULTIPLE LESIONS:

FRACTIONATION OF WBRT

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1.0

0 5 10 15 20

Time to death (months)

10x3 Gy

5x4 Gy

P=0.29

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1.0

0 5 10 15 20

Time to death (months)

10x3 Gy

5x4 Gy

P=0.29

Reprinted from Rades D, et al., Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 2007;69:1509–13. Copyright 2007, with permission from Elsevier

Page 6: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

Mulvenna PM, et al., J Clin Oncol. 2015;33(suppl): abstr 8005.

Brain Metastases from NSCLC

Phase III non-inferiority trial

QUARTZ-TRIAL (N=538)

BSC alone BSC + WBRT

Median OS 57 days 65 days

Mean QALYs 41.4 days 43.3 days

Page 7: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

Wong J, et al., Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2009 Nov 15;75(4):1125-31. (N=129)

Symptom Relief:

Headache 41%

Discontinuation of Corticosteroids 51%

Komosinska K, et al., Acta Oncol. 2010 Apr;49(3):382-8. (N=91; KPS <70)

Improvement of Performance Status 57%

Van Oorschot B, et al., Breast Care (Basel). 2011;6(1):14-19. (Review)

Symptom Relief:

Headache 50-70%

Cerebral Dysfunction 40-50%

Paresis 30-40%

WHY WBRT FOR PATIENTS WITH A

POOR SURVIVAL?

Page 8: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

DOSES >30 GY FOR BRAIN METS

FROM MELANOMA

Intracerebral Control

Reprinted from Rades D, et al., Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 2010 1;77:537–4. Copyright 2010, with permission from Elsevier

Overall Survival

Page 9: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1.0

0 10 20 30 40 50

time to recurrence (months)

30 Gy/10 fractions

40 Gy/20 fractions

P=0.064

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1.0

0 10 20 30 40 50

time to recurrence (months)

30 Gy/10 fractions

40 Gy/20 fractions

P=0.064

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1.0

0 10 20 30 40 50 60

time to death (months)

30 Gy/10 fractions

40 Gy/20 fractions

P=0.007

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1.0

0 10 20 30 40 50 60

time to death (months)

30 Gy/10 fractions

40 Gy/20 fractions

P=0.007

Rades D, et al., Cancer. 2012;118:3852–9. Copyright © 2011 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

DOSES >30 GY FOR PATIENTS

WITH A MORE FAVOURABLE

SURVIVAL PROGNOSIS

Page 10: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

Gaspar L, et al., Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 1997 Mar 1;37(4):745-51.

1,200 patients from 3 RTOG trials (WBRT for brain mets.)

RTOG 79-16:

10 x 3 Gy +/- Misonidazole

6 x 5 Gy +/- Misonidazole

RTOG 85-28:

2 x 1.6 Gy / day

48.0 Gy vs. 54.4 Gy

54.4 Gy vs. 64.0 Gy

64.0 Gy vs. 70.4 Gy

RTOG 89-05:

15 x 2.5 Gy +/- Bromodeoxyuridine

RPA-CLASSIFICATION

(RECURSIVE PARTITIONING ANALYSIS)

Page 11: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

RPA-CLASSIFICATION

(RECURSIVE PARTITIONING ANALYSIS)

RPA I RPA II RPA III

Karnofsky PS ≥70 ≥70 <70

Age <65 years ≥65 years Any

PT controlled Yes No Yes/No

Extracranial

mets. No Yes Yes/No

Median OS

(months)7.1 4.2 2.3

Gaspar L, et al., Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 1997 Mar 1;37(4):745-51.

Page 12: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

1,200 patients from 3 RTOG trials (WBRT for brain mets.)

RTOG 79-16:

10 x 3 Gy +/- Misonidazole

6 x 5 Gy +/- Misonidazole

RTOG 85-28:

2 x 1.6 Gy / day

48.0 Gy vs. 54.4 Gy

54.4 Gy vs. 64.0 Gy

64.0 Gy vs. 70.4 Gy

RTOG 89-05:

15 x 2.5 Gy +/- Bromodeoxyuridine

RPA-CLASSIFICATION

HETEROGENEOUS TREATMENTS

Gaspar L, et al., Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 1997 Mar 1;37(4):745-51.

Page 13: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

1,960 patients from 5 RTOG trials (WBRT for brain mets.)

RTOG 79-16, RTOG 85-28, RTOG 89-05, RTOG 91-04, RTOG 95-08

RTOG 91-04:

10 x 3 Gy vs. 54.4 Gy (2 x 1.6 Gy / d)

RTOG 95-08:

15 x 2.5 Gy vs. 15 x 2.5 Gy + SRS boost

GPA SCORE

(GRADED PROGNOSTIC ASSESSMENT)

Sperduto PW, et al., Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2008 Feb 1;70(2):510-4.

Page 14: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

GPA SCORE

(GRADED PROGNOSTIC ASSESSMENT)

Reprinted from Sperduto PW, et al., Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 2008;70:510–4. Copyright © 2008 Elsevier Inc.

0 points 0.5 points 1 point

Age >60 yrs 50-59 yrs <50 yrs

Karnofsky

Score>60 70-80 >80

N

metastases>3 2-3 1

Extracranial

mets. Yes --- No

Page 15: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

1,960 patients from 5 RTOG trials (WBRT for brain mets.)

RTOG 79-16, RTOG 85-28, RTOG 89-05, RTOG 91-04, RTOG 95-08

RTOG 91-04:

10 x 3 Gy vs. 54.4 Gy (2 x 1.6 Gy / d)

RTOG 95-08:

15 x 2.5 Gy vs. 15 x 2.5 Gy + SRS boost

GPA SCORE

HETEROGENEOUS TREATMENTS

Sperduto PW, et al., Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2008;70:510–4

Page 16: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

Survival

at 6 months

(%)

Score

Age

≤ 60 years

≥ 61 years

43

25

4

3

Karnofsky Performance Score

< 70

≥ 70

8

53

1

5

Extracranial metastases

at the time of RT

No

Yes

51

24

5

2

Interval from tumour diagnosis

to WBRT

8 months

> 8 months

32

36

3

4

The score has been validated in

350 new patients2

SURVIVAL SCORE – WBRT ALONE

(N=1,085)1

1. Rades D, et al., Strahlenther Onkol 2008;184:251–5. © Urban & Vogel. With permission of Springer;

2. Dziggel L, et al., Strahlenther Onkol. 2013;189:364–6.

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1.0

0 10 20 30

Time (months)

A

B

C

D

p<0.001

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1.0

0 10 20 30

Time (months)

A

B

C

D

p<0.001

Time (months)

Scoring points

A

B

C

D

OS

at

6 ,p

mn

ts(%

)

Page 17: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

DISEASE-SPECIFIC GPA SCORES

(DS-GPA)

Melanoma / Renal Cell Cancer

Points 0 1 2

KPS <70 70-80 90-100

N brain mets. >3 2-3 1

NSCLC / SCLC

Points 0 0.5 1

Age >60 50-60 <50

KPS <70 70-80 90-100

N brain mets. >3 2-3 1

Extracranial mets. Yes --- No

Breast Cancer / GI Cancer

Points 0 1 2 3 4

KPS <70 70 80 90 100

Sperduto PW, et al., Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2010 Jul 1;77(3):655-61.

Page 18: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

NEW DS-GPA SCORE FOR

BREAST CANCER

Melanoma / Renal Cell Cancer

Points 0 1 2

KPS <70 70-80 90-100

N brain mets. >3 2-3 1

NSCLC / SCLC

Points 0 0.5 1

Age >60 50-60 <50

KPS <70 70-80 90-100

N brain mets. >3 2-3 1

Extracranial mets. Yes --- No

Breast Cancer / GI Cancer

Points 0 0.5 1 1.5 2

KPS ≤50 60 70-80 90-100 n/a

Subtype Triple (-) n/a HR+, her2- HR-, her2+ Triple (+)

Age ≥60 <60 n/a n/a n/a

Sperduto PW, et al., Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2012 Apr 1;82(5):2111-7.

Page 19: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

DISEASE-SPECIFIC SCORES:

WBRT ALONE

1. Rades D, et al., STO 2013; 2. Rades D, et al., STO 2013; 3. Rades D, et al., CNN 2013; 4. Dziggel L, et al., STO 2014; 5. Rades D, et al., ACR 2014

Tumour type Age Gender KPS N lesions Extracr. mets.

Breast cancer1 X X

Non-small cell

lung cancer2 X X X

Small cell lung

cancer3 X X X

Less

radiosensitive

tumours4

X X X

Esophageal

cancer5 X X X

Page 20: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

Survival

at 6 months

(%)

Score

(points)

Age

< 50 years

51-60 years

61-70 years

> 70 years

45

42

27

14

5

4

3

1

Karnofsky Performance Score

KPS < 70

KPS = 70

KPS > 70

8

36

60

1

4

6

Extracranial metastases

No

Yes

46

24

5

2

Systemic treatment prior to WBRT

No

Yes

24

33

2

3

Age, gender, KPS, PT, extracranial mets., N brain mets., interval FD to WBRT,

systemic treatment prior to WBRT, controlled PT

WBRT-30: WBRT WITH

10X3 GY ALONE (N=882)

Reprinted from Rades D, et al., Radiother Oncol 2013;108:123–7. Copyright 2013, with permission fom Elsevier

Page 21: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

Survival at 6 months

WBRT-30 – TEST GROUP VS.

VALIDATION GROUP

Test group Valid. group P

6 - 9 points 4% 3% 0.91

10 - 14 points 29% 28% 0.89

15 - 17 points 62% 54% 0.53

18 - 19 points 93% 96% 0.96

Rades D, et al., Radiother Oncol. 2013 Jul;108(1):123-7.

Page 22: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

WBRT-30 – COMPARISON TO

OTHER SCORES

Positive Predictive Value (PPV)

To die ≤ 6 mos. To live ≥6 mos.

WBRT-30 97% 96%

RPA 92% 75%

GPA 85% 64%

Rades 2008 96% 73%

Rades D, et al., Radiother Oncol. 2013 Jul;108(1):123-7.

Page 23: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

WBRT +/- SYSTEMIC AGENTS

(PHASE II/III-STUDIES)

Author N Agent Median OS

Verger, 2005 82 Temozolomide 4.5 vs. 3.1 mos. (n.s.)

Mehta, 2003 401 Motexafin-Gd 5.2 vs. 4.9 mos. (n.s.)

Knisely, 2008 183 Thalidomide 3.9 vs. 3.9 mos. (n.s.)

Neuhaus, 2009 96 Topotecan 2.9 vs. 3.1 mos. (n.s.)

Lee, 2014 80 Erlotinib 3.4 vs. 2.9 mos. (n.s.)

Zhuang, 2013 54 Erlotinib 10.7 vs. 8.9 mos. (p=0.02)

[Lin, 2013 (Phase I) 35 Lapatinib Feasibility criteria not met (tox.!)]

Page 24: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

Patients with a limited number of brain metastases may benefit from

Local Treatments

(Resection, Stereotactic Radiosurgery, Fractionated Stereotactic RT)

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1.0

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45

Ü berlebenszeit (Monate)

2

P < 0,001

3

>= 4

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1.0

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45

Ü berlebenszeit (Monate)

1

P < 0,001

2-3

>= 4

Survival time (months)

P < 0.001

SURVIVAL PROGNOSIS DEPENDS

ON THE NUMBER OF BRAIN METASTASES

Rades D, unpublished. Figure provided courtesy of Dirk Rades

Page 25: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

Pros:

1. Immediate mass reduction

(in particular for lesions >3 cm not suitable for SRS)

2. Confirmation of diagnosis (~5% of brain primaries = secondary tumours)

(new technologies reduce mortality to <2%, morbidity to <8%)

Cons:

1. Surgery (particularly in the posterior fossa) may cause leptomeningeal spread

[van der Ree, JNNP 1999, Siomin, JNO 2004]

2. Craniotomy = invasive, entails significant risks

3. Not suitable for all locations (brain stem etc.)

4. Improved OS only, if all metastases are removed => 1 lesion (2 lesions)

NEUROSURGICAL RESECTION:

PROS AND CONS

Page 26: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

Rationale for SRS vs. Neurosurgical Resection:

1. Treatment of multiple lesions in one session

2. Treatment of surgically inaccessible lesions (e.g. brain stem);

Fuentes, Neurosurgery 2006

92% LC of brain stem mets, only 2/16 patients died due to brain stem problems

“argument pro Surgery”: Rapid relief of symptoms, however: Hoshi, J Urol

2002: rapid relief in 80% of 42 RCC patients after GK-RS

STEREOTACTIC RADIOSURGERY

(SRS)

Page 27: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

Large Metastases (>4 cm)

and/or

Brain Stem Lesions (small therapeutic ratio)

Solution: Fractionated Stereotactic RT

=> 3-7 fractions

Better therapeutic ratio (EQD2)

Non-invasive fixation

Lesions >4 cm

Local control (1 yr.) 75-85%

Acute-toxicity ≤5%

Late-toxicity ≤3%

STEREOTACTIC RADIOSURGERY

(SRS): LIMITATIONS

© Dept. of Radiation Oncology, University of Lübeck

Page 28: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

Rationale for SRS / FSRT vs. WBRT:

1. Steep dose gradient: High dose to lesions, sparing of normal tissues

2. Higher dose per fraction => higher biological effective dose => higher tumour cell

killing potential

RATIONALE FOR SRS / FSRT VS.

WBRT

Page 29: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

EQD2 = GD x [(ED + /) / (2 Gy + /)] for tumour cell kill

RATIONALE FOR SRS / FSRT VS.

WBRT

Fractionation EQD2

10 x 2 Gy = 20 Gy 20 Gy

1 x 20 Gy = 20 Gy

(1x20 Gy ≈ 3x10 Gy)50 Gy

x 2.5

Page 30: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

1-3 METASTASES (RPA 1-2):

SRS VS. WBRT

Rades D, et al., Cancer 2007;110:2285–92

Local Control

p-valueat 6 months at 12 months

WBRT (N=91) 57% 26%

SRS (N=95) 84% 64% <0.001

Overall Survival

p-valueat 6 months at 12 months

WBRT (N=91) 59% 33%

SRS (N=95) 68% 52% 0.045

Intracerebral Control

p-valueat 6 months at 12 months

WBRT (N=91) 55% 23%

SRS (N=95) 74% 49% 0.005

Page 31: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

*new sites

1-4 METASTASES: WBRT+SRS VS.

SRS ALONE

Design Patients

1-year

overall

survival

1-year

local control

1-year

cerebral

control

Aoyama,

JAMA 2006RCT

SRS

SRS+WBRT

(N=132)

8%

39%

(P=0.42)

70%

86%

(P=0.019)

24%

53%

(P<0.001)

Rades,

STO 2008Retrosp

SRS

SRS+WBRT

(N=144)

53%

56%

(P=0.24)

66%

87%

(P=0.003)

51%

66%

(P=0.015)

Kocher,

JCO 2011RCT

SRS

SRS+WBRT

(N=199)

~71%

~84%

(P=0.040)

~57%

~70%

(P=0.023)*

Page 32: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

1 LESION: RESECTION + WBRT VS.

RESECTION

Design PatientsOverall

SurvivalLocal Control

Cerebral

Control

Patchell,

JAMA 1998RCT

Resection

Res. + WBRT

(N=95)

Median

~11 mos.

~11 mos.

(n.s.)

At 1 year

54%

90%

(P<0.001)

At 1 year

30%

82%

(P<0.001)

Smalley,

IJROBP 1987Retrosp.

Resection

Res. + WBRT

(N=85)

Median

11.5 mos.

23 mos.

(P<0.05)

at 1 year

15%

79%

(P<0.05)

Page 33: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

Single-arm Studies1

Local Control at 1 year: 71 - 93%

New Brain Metastases at 1 year: 39 - 64%

Overall Survival at 1 year: 50 - 69%

Comparative Study (N = 132)2: Surgery +WBRT +SRS

Local Control at 1 year: 83% 74%

New Brain Metastases at 1 year: 30% 52%

Overall Survival at 1 year: 56% 55%

SRS / FSRT FOLLOWING

RESECTION

1. Robbins JR, et al., 2012, Neurosurgery. 2012 Nov;71(5):937-43; Steinmann D, et al., J Cancer Res Clin Oncol. 2012 Sep;138(9):1523-9;

Connolly RP, et al., Neuro Oncol. 2013 May;15(5):589-94; Minniti G, et al., Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2013 Jul 15;86(4):623-9; Ahmed

KA, et al., Neurooncol. 2014 May;118(1):179-86; Ling DC, et al., Neurosurgery. 2015 Feb;76(2):150-6.

2. Patel KR, et al., J Neurooncol. 2014 Dec;120(3):657-63.

Page 34: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

Chang EL, et al., Lancet Oncol. 2009 Nov;10(11):1037-44. [N=58]

SRS vs. WBRT + SRS

Neuro-cognitive Deficits at 4 mos. 24% vs. 96% (p<0.001)

Intracerebral Control at 12 mos. 27% vs. 73% (p<0.001)

Aoyama H, et al., Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2007 Aug 1;68(5):1388-95.

WBRT + SRS vs. SRS

N=132 (total); N=92 (Follow up of MMSE)

NEURO-COGNITIVE DEFICITS

FOLLOWING WBRT

Preservation of neuro-cognitive function (MMSE ≥27)

12 mos. 24 mos. 36 mos.

WBRT + SRS 79% 79% 23%

SRS 53% 43% 43%

Page 35: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

WBRT + SRS vs. SRS alone for 1-3 brain metastases (<3 cm)

NCCTG N0574 (ALLIANCE):

PHASE III TRIAL (N=213)

Brown PD, et al., JAMA. 2016 Jul 26;316(4):401-9.

WBRT+SRS SRS alone P

Cognitive Deterioration at 3 mos. 91.7% 63.5% <0.001

Deterioration in Immediate Recall 30.4% 8.2% 0.004

Deterioration in Delayed Recall 51.1% 19.7% <0.001

Deterioration in Verbal Fluency 18.6% 1.9% 0.01

Intracranial Progression at 6 mos. 11.6% 35.3% <0.001

Intracranial Progression at 12 mos. 15.0% 49.5% <0.001

Page 36: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

LATE TOXICITY: WBRT+SRS VS.

SRS ALONE

Aoyama H, et al., JAMA. 2006 Jun 7;295(21):2483-91.

WBRT+SRS SRS alone P

Brain Necrosis 5% 1% 0.32

Leukoencephalopathy 11% 3% 0.16

Any Late Toxicity 17% 7% 0.19

Page 37: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

HIPPOCAMPAL SPARING

© Dept. of Radiation Oncology, University of Lübeck

Page 38: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

RTOG 0933; N=113 (42 analyzable at 4 months)

Hopkins Verbal Learning Test - Revised Delayed Recall (HVLT-R DR)

Decline from baseline to 4 months

7% with hippocampus sparing vs. 30% historical control (p<0.001)

Australian Experience

30 patients (26 with melanoma) with a total of 73 brain metastases

80% of evaluable metastases controlled (mean follow up = 3.5 months)

Median survival = 9.4 months, 1 patient with grade 4 toxicity

HIPPOCAMPAL SPARING

Awad R, et al., Radiat Oncol 2013 Mar 18;8:62.

Gondi V, et al., J Clin Oncol 2014 Dec 1;32(34):3810-6.

Page 39: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

WBRT: 37.5 Gy in 15 fractions

Memantine (20 mg/d, starting 3 days prior to WBRT for 24 weeks) vs. placebo

Hopkins Verbal Learning Test - Revised for Delayed Recall (HVLT-R DR) plus

other instruments

Decline in Delayed Recall at 24 weeks (N=149): 54% vs. 65% (p=0.059)

Decline in Delayed Recognition at 24 weeks: 2% vs. 13% (p=0.002)

MEMANTINE: RTOG 0614 (N=508)

Brown PD, et al., Neuro-Oncol 2013 Oct;15(10):1429-37.

Page 40: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

Number of brain metastases

N=1 70% 7 points

N=2-3 48% 5 points

Extracranial metastases

No 69% 7 points

Yes 56% 6 points

Primary tumour type

Breast cancer 80% 8 points

NSCLC 67% 7 points

Melanoma 54% 5 points

Others 57% 6 points

DISTANT BRAIN METS FOLLOWING

SRS ALONE (N=214)

Huttenlocher S, et al., Radiat Oncol 2014 Sep 20;9:215.

16-17 points 36%

18-20 points 65%

21-22 points 80%

Page 41: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

1-3 METS:

RESECTION+WBRT VS. WBRT+SRS

Design PatientsSurvival

at 1 year

Local control

at 1 year

Brain control

at 1 year

O’Neill et al.

IJROBP, 2003Retrosp.

Res. + WBRT: 74

WBRT + SRS: 23

62%

56%

(P=0.15)

42%

100%

(P=0.020)

Rades et al.

EJC, 2009

Matched

pairs

Res. + WBRT: 52

WBRT + SRS: 52

41%

56%

(P=0.08)

66%

87%

(P=0.021)

47%

66%

(P=0.13)

Page 42: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

RESECTION + WBRT ± BOOST

(RPA 1-2)

Rades D, et al., Cancer 2007;110:1551–9.

Overall Survival

p-valueat 6 months at 12 months

S+WBRT (N=99) 59% 41%

S+WBRT+Boost (N=102) 82% 66% <0.001

Local Control

p-valueat 6 months at 12 months

S+WBRT (N=99) 75% 54%

S+WBRT+Boost (N=102) 86% 78% <0.001

Intracerebral Control

p-valueat 6 months at 12 months

S+WBRT (N=99) 66% 43%

S+WBRT+Boost (N=102) 81% 71% <0.001

Page 43: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

SIMULTANEOUS INTEGRATED

BOOST (SIB)

© Dept. of Radiation Oncology, University of Lübeck

Page 44: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

Abbreviations: BSC = best supportive care; FSRT = fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy; S = surgery; SRS = stereotactic radiosurgery;

WBRT = whole-brain radiotherapy

1-3 (1-4) metastases

Complete resection possible

(single lesion)

Prognosis <3

months

WBRT

BSC

S + WBRT ± Boost

S alone

S + FSRT

FSRT ± WBRT

Complete resection not possible

Prognosis ≥3

months

S + WBRT ± Boost

SRS + WBRT

S / SRS alone

S + SRS/FSRT

Prognosis <3

months

WBRT

BSC

Prognosis ≥3

months

SRS + WBRT

SRS alone

FSRT + WBRT

FSRT alone

WBRT alone

>3-4 cm ≤3-4 cm >3-4 cm≤3-4 cm

Algorithm for treatment of 1-3 (1-4) brain metastases

Page 45: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

≥4 (≥5) metastases

High / intermediate radiosensitivity

Prognosis <3

months

5 x 4 Gy

BSC

10 x 3 Gy

Hippocampal

sparing ?

S and/or SRS

(selected lesions)

Low radiosensitivity

Prognosis >6

months

Prognosis 3-6

months

14-15 x 2.5 Gy

18-20 x 2 Gy

Hippocampal

sparing ?

S and/or SRS

(selected lesions)

Prognosis <3

months

5 x 4 Gy

BSC

Prognosis >6

months

Prognosis 3-6

months

15-16 x 2.5 Gy

20-22 x 2 Gy

Hippocampal

sparing ?

S and/or SRS

(selected lesions)

12 x 3 Gy

Hippocampal

sparing ?

S and/or SRS

(selected lesions)

Abbreviations: BSC = best supportive care; S = surgery; SRS = stereotactic radiosurgery

Systemic

agents?

Algorithm for treatment of ≥4 (≥5) brain metastases

Page 46: MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES · OF PATIENTS WITH BRAIN METASTASES Focusing on radiotherapy Dirk Rades, MD Professor and Chair ... Dexamethasone alone 1-2 months

Thank you!